Private Deputies' Business. - Oireachtas (Payment of Members) (No. 2 Bill), 1928—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–128 of 249. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 51 of 1928 ›
The position with regard to this Bill is that Deputy Thrift made a speech on the Second Reading motion. An amendment was then introduced to refer certain matters to a Joint Committee and the Bill was postponed and comes up now. In view of the fact that just twelve months have elapsed since Deputy Thrift introduced the Second Reading debate, I think I might allow Deputy Thrift to make the motion again. There will, I think, be no objection to that.
Comment on this
I am obliged to the House for the permission given me. I did not expect that I would have an opportunity of speaking on the subject until the close of the debate. In view of the time that has elapsed, I think I should remind Deputies of the circumstances under which the Bill was brought forward, and of the reason for it. Deputies will remember that it came before the House rather in a hurry. It is as well that I should remind Deputies of the fact that it arose out of the last election for members of the Seanad. In view of the circumstances, it was thought advisable to circulate the Bill even before the result of the election was known, and that was done. That, however, had not the effect that was hoped, namely, that it would prevent various kinds of motives being suggested for the introduction of the Bill. That is not very material, because the simple fact is that the motive was one of economy. The Independent Deputies, for whom I am speaking in this matter, were looking round at the time for a way in which money could be saved and it seemed to them that the basis on which the allowances were made for members of the Dáil and Seanad was not fair and equitable, and that it left open an opportunity for saving a certain amount of money. That is the simple case for the Bill being brought forward by the Independent Deputies.
The proposal in the Bill would save the State 60 times £160—nearly £10,000. I do not think anybody would be prepared to say that the calls on Senators in any way, except the moral responsibility they have for the passage of legislation, are at all equal to the calls made upon Deputies, whether in the matter of time or in the matter of expense. The sum that is allowed both for members of the Dáil and Seanad is explicitly an allowance, not a salary, and the Independent Deputies are, on this point, quite at variance with many of those from whom they have received support in reference to this reduction of allowances. Their purpose is not at all to diminish the importance of the Senator's position or the sense of responsibility under which he holds office—quite the reverse. Their object is that the Seanad should continue to be an important part of this Oireachtas. If the introduction of this Bill does no more than awaken the Seanad to a more lively sense of their responsibilities in this matter and should lead to the result that the Seanad becomes a much more important part of the Oireachtas than it has been up to the present, it will have served a good purpose.
The allowances made to Deputies are to cover a variety of ways in which they suffer, both in loss of time and in actual expense. In the latter respect, they are in a very different position from Senators. Most of them have a very large constituency to look after and to cover if an election should arise, and their expenses in connection with elections are very much higher and ought to be very much higher than those of Senators. The Senator has no special constituency; he stands for the whole State and has no particular constituency to deal with. He has no claims to meet from his constituency. A member of the Dáil is in quite a different position, and most members of the Dáil have found that their expenses in dealing with their constituency come to quite a considerable thing. Many members of the Dáil, I understand, would say that their postal expenses, alone, are a very considerable item and absorb quite an appreciable part of the allowance they get. I do not say that Senators have not postal expenses—they have—but I say they are not on anything like the same scale as that of most Deputies.
The allowance is intended to make up, to a certain extent, to the members of the Dáil for the expense they incur in seeking election, and, further, to make up for the expenses they have to bear in attending to the wants and needs of their constituents and their repeated calls upon them. These are, as I say, very different from the calls made upon Senators. It seemed to the Independent Deputies that the basis of equality which was laid down as the basis on which allowances to Deputies and Senators are calculated is not an equitable basis and therefore, they introduced this Bill—a Bill which abandons that ratio of equality and makes a specific allowance to Senators on a given figure. The figure suggested is £200 a year which is a different figure from that on which the allowance to Deputies is calculated.
When any question of economy arises, of course, it has to be considered, not in itself, but in its relationship to what will accrue from it. The simple question always will be, and must be, is the economy worth while. What are you going to lose if you introduce this economy? I suppose there will hardly ever be a case, when a balancing of accounts has not to be made. If economy has to be made something will suffer. The only argument I have heard put forward in this connection is that what we shall lose is the possibility of finding Senators who will give up their whole time as Senators to the business. It does not seem to me that it can be contended that there is any kind of possibility of Senators' work being whole-time work, and that all that we should lose would be the occassional absence from the Seanad of somebody who would be prepared to devote his whole time to his responsible work as a Senator. Of course if we lost a single person of that kind it would be an extremely regrettable loss. The most desirable person to have would be one who would devote his whole time to his work. But the question is: Is that really going to be a practical point? How many, if any, are we going to have who will devote themselves entirely to their Senatorial work? It will be said that an odd case will arise. No doubt it will arise. There may be, even at present, one or more, not many, who could not accept the position of Senator unless the sum given at present, as an allowance, were continued. I do not know, but I think the case would be a very rare one. It is for Deputies to say whether they think that a saving of £10,000 a year is or is not a greater advantage than keeping open that possibility. Personally I think the losses would be very small in numbers—not small in importance, because as I said a single loss of the kind would be a matter of importance.
I do not at all think that the proposal which is suggested is what could be called an undemocratic proposal or that it would tend to confine membership of the Seanad to one or more particular classes. It seems to me, in view of the actual time that is taken for sitting purposes by members of the Seanad, and of the probability, that in the future, their time of sitting will be very much smaller than the time of the sitting of members of the Dáil, that, even, if an allowance of £200 a year is made to Senators it would be just as much as and perhaps more open to what I might call the non-salaried class to assume the responsibility of Senator, in the future, than it was in the past. A man could spare the odd days required for the sitting of the Seanad, and the £4 a week, which £200 would give him would more than make up for the monetary loss he would suffer. So that I think the proposal is entirely clear of what I would call the slur thrown upon it that it is an attempt to limit the class from which the members of the Seanad can in practice be selected. It does not seem to me to have that effect at all.
I have no elaborate case to put forward in support of the Bill. The case is one that carries its own argument on the surface. It is simply and purely a way of looking for economy. There is no elaborate motive behind it despite the ingenious theories framed in that respect. It is for each member of the Dáil to decide for himself whether he thinks that economy worth while or not.
I am aware I am addressing the House after the report of the Committee has been issued with which this proposal did not find favour. Nevertheless the Independent Deputies for whom I speak think that the matter is one on which the Dáil itself, as a whole, should give its opinion and they have decided therefore to take the opinion of the Dáil upon it. I have no doubt, as I said before, that those who vote for the proposal will do so for very different purposes. Our purpose is to maintain the Seanad with all its dignity and responsibility and importance. I have no doubt that the support which the Fianna Fáil Party have promised to this proposal in what they said on the amendment is given for quite a different reason because they wish to get rid of the Seanad. That is not our purpose at all. In fact if we vote for this proposal together we vote for it from quite distinct and opposite reasons— as opposite as the Poles. I do not think it is necessary to go into the report any further because the arguments on this particular matter that came before the Committee seem to me to be very briefly those with which I have dealt already. On behalf of the Independent Deputies I propose that this Bill be now read a Second Time.
Comment on this
I think when introducing a Bill of this description it should have been based on justice, on service, and the cost of giving service. I think a broader view should have been taken by both Houses of the Oireachtas. I suggest to the mover that it would be in better taste if consideration was given to both Houses. The word used is "allowance" for members of one class and salaries for another class. To one class it is an income and to another class an allowance. Any Bill having an object such as this one has, should be based on service and the cost of giving that service. The original idea was to give allowances to Deputies and Senators, and a flat rate was struck. At the time, I opposed the flat rate on the ground that Deputies from the country should, to some extent, be compensated for the expense they were put to in coming to Dublin, leaving their homes and business, and finding temporary accommodation in the city. People who had their homes and their business in Dublin were in a different position from people who had to come up from the country. I hold that view more firmly now than I did then. We know that those who have to leave their homes and to live in Dublin for a portion of the week are under considerable expense. If they have a business they have to find a substitute and pay him, and there is the additional risk that their business will not be done as well by substitutes as by themselves.
If the Deputy was actuated by strict justice and the giving of service the Bill would be on much broader lines. An allowance for men coming up from the country becomes an income for those who live in Dublin, because the latter can live at home and attend to their business. I do not know if it were the intention to narrow it to a circle of people with means who could afford to come here as a hobby or as an amusement, and have a few letters attached to their names. The effect has been to narrow the circle to people living in the city of Dublin. We saw at the recent Seanad election the number of Dublin citizens anxious to serve their country. Numbers of them were around the corridors trying to serve their country, for a consideration. Very few people from the country came around lobbying.
I believe this Bill should contain a clause dealing with services given. I am prepared to support any Bill which will withhold money from Deputies or Senators who do not give service, who just qualify to be entitled to the allowance, and whose only function is to draw it. I will go a long way to keep that class of individual from drawing any money. I refer to the man who has no expense and who does not attend, whose only function is his connection with the Minister for Finance. That class of individual is receiving money under false pretences. The word "allowance" has been stressed by Deputy Thrift, but an individual of the description I have mentioned, who has no expenses, is receiving money by false pretences, and that is perpetrating a fraud on the public. I could understand a proposal based on service, but I cannot understand this Bill, which is supposed to be in the interests of economy. The Deputy seems to me to have blundered into this Bill without any consideration of the justice of the case or making a comparison of the two Houses. I know members of every Party who have to spend two or three nights in Dublin every week. They leave home on Tuesday morning and they cannot return until Saturday. Some of us can get home on Friday night late, but men from Cork and other places cannot get home until Saturday. I know that the allowances do not cover the expenses they are put to, not to mention the neglect of their business, which must suffer in their absence.
I think the Deputy would be very well advised, at this stage, to withdraw the Bill, and if he is actuated by a desire to save expense, let us have a more fully-considered Bill, based on justice and on service, which will have the support of the House. Let a Committee sit down and try and hammer out a measure based on justice, and it will have support. Even if a general reduction in the present allowances is agreed on I will not oppose it. I will not stand, however, for picking and choosing. The Party that I belong to knows that there is a great difficulty in getting representative men throughout the country to come up and spend their time in the Dáil or Scanad. That is certainly the case in connection with the Dáil. It is very difficult to get men in the country to go forward for the Dáil, while hordes can be got in the city, knowing that it is a good job; that the money is an income. It is an income to the city man. There is no getting behind that. There are hordes of people in the city who want to represent country constituencies.
Comment on this
As Deputy Thrift explained, this Bill was originally introduced in November, 1928, prior to the election for the Seanad, which took place towards the close of that year, and when it became obvious that certain allies of the Deputy in the Upper Chamber, if I may call it so, were about to walk the plank. I do not want to attribute any motives whatever to the Deputy. He said himself that his only motive in introducing the Bill was to impose economy. I am prepared to take his word for that, although I think it extraordinary that the motive did not prove of longer duration than it did, as has been evidenced by the votes cast by the Deputy on the Special Committee which resulted. When the Bill was introduced a Deputy of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party moved an amendment referring the question to a Special Committee. That amendment was carried. The motion was considered in the Seanad, and was there amended, extending the terms of reference to cover not merely the remuneration of Senators and Teachtaí, but the remuneration of Ministers. The Committee met. I was a member of it. It seemed to me quite obvious from the beginning that the purpose for which the Committee was set up, and the main object of the Cumann na nGaedheal members of it, was not to discuss the proposal to reduce the allowances of Senators to £200 per year, but to devise a scheme for giving pensions to ex-Ministers.
Comment on this
I am not quite sure about that. The Committee was set up in consequence of the introduction of the Bill. The motion to set up the Committee was moved as an amendment to the motion for the Second Reading. It seems to me, therefore, that matters discussed at the Committee could be properly discussed on the resumed Second Reading of the Bill.
Comment on this
I do not think so. I think on this particular motion we could not go into anything further than the allowances to Senators and Deputies. If the report of the Joint Committee is to be discussed in general, I think another opportunity must be taken. If we were to go into all the matters dealt with by the Joint Committee, I think we will wander very far from the question of allowances to be paid to members of Seanad Eireann. I think the point made by Deputy Gorey must be deemed to be relevant, namely, the allowances paid to the different types of Deputies. I think the other general question dealt with by the Joint Committee must be discussed in some other way than on the Second Reading of this Bill.
Comment on this
I think it is likely that we will get an opportunity of discussing that particular proposal when Deputy Gorey's measure is introduced.
Comment on this
The Minister can attack from behind cover now. As Deputy Thrift pointed out, the Joint Committee rejected his proposal. Despite the valiant efforts of the Fianna Fáil-Trinity College combination, we were unable to get the Cumann na nGaedheal and Labour Members to see our point of view.
Comment on this
We do not reckon as being on our side those who have allied themselves with the enemy.
Comment on this
A member of your own hierarchy was on the Committee?
Comment on this
Not on our Committee. The fact remains that it was quite obvious the entire Seanad, irrespective of Party, was united in one solid block to defeat this proposal. Despite the efforts, however, of the Fianna Fáil-Trinity College combination the proposal of Deputy Thrift was rejected, but I am glad to say we were quite successful in restraining members of the Seanad from recommending an increase in their allowance. There was at one time considerable danger that the result of the Committee would be a recommendation that allowances should be increased all around. I grant you the proposal to do that was merely a preliminary manoeuvre in preparation for a subsequent proposal to increase the allowance of Ministers.
Comment on this
On the point of order that arose. When the Second Reading of this Bill was moved in the Dáil an amendment was moved. This was the amendment:
That it is expedient that a Joint Committee consisting of five members of the Dáil and five members of the Seanad be set up to consider and report on the question of the amount of the allowance which should be paid to members of Seanad Eireann.
The amendment moved here, therefore, had relevance only to matters in relation to this Bill, but in subsequent messages between the two Houses and at the instance of the Seanad, the Joint Committee was given wider terms of reference. Those wider terms of reference cannot be introduced here, and the Deputy will realise that if he introduces other matters besides the allowances paid to Senators or Deputies, other people will be entitled to reply. If other people are not allowed to reply, the Deputy is now taking an unfair advantage.
Comment on this
Deputy Gorey spoke mostly about Deputies. I submit that the question of Deputies' allowances only came into that Committee. It was not brought into the Bill. Therefore, I imagine it should not be relevant here, if the question of Ministers' salaries is not relevant. We have no objection to having Deputies' allowances discussed provided Ministers' salaries are discussed.
Comment on this
I criticised the Bill for what it did not contain, and I gave an indication of what I would support.
Comment on this
Deputy Gorey was absolutely relevant, and was, therefore, not called to order. He was relevant not because he alluded to matters which were contained in the Report of the Joint Committee, and which the Joint Committee considered, but because, as a matter of pure reason, the allowances to Deputies may be regarded as relevant to the allowances paid to Senators.
Comment on this
It is not abstruse; it is common sense. The question of allowances to Senators and Deputies may be discussed, but the question of salaries of Ministers is in a different category and must be discussed on another occasion. I have frequently told Deputies that rulings from the Chair nearly always contain the word "now." We cannot "now" enter into any discussion about salaries.
Comment on this
Did I understand you to say the allowances paid to various types of Deputies? You ruled that it was relevant to discuss the allowances paid to various types of Deputies. Therefore, it is in order to discuss the allowances paid to Ministers.
Comment on this
Therefore, I think it is quite relevant to compare the allowance made to a Deputy, from the point of view of the value given by a Deputy and a Senator respectively.
Comment on this
Why is it not in order to compare the allowance paid to Senators for their work in relation to the salary of Ministers for their work?
Comment on this
We will get back to the particular proposal in the Bill. The report of the Committee states that in arriving at the conclusion not to recommend any reduction in the present scale of allowances it was influenced by two main considerations. The first is that in a democratic State—they presumed that this was a democratic State—membership of either House of the Legislature should be open to citizens of every rank without undue sacrifice of private interests. That is a very high-sounding principle to which I am sure all Deputies and Senators subscribe. They went on to say that, secondly, having regard to the actual interference with such interests and to the expense inevitably incidental to their position as members of the Oireachtas. Senators and Deputies should discharge their duties conscientiously, giving full value to the State for the allowance now paid. It is on that second item that I join issue with the majority of the Committee. Deputy Gorey has given a very interesting contribution to this discussion. I am very much surprised to know that he considers an allowance of £200 a year too high for Senators. I thought that when Deputy Thrift proposed to reduce the allowance from £360 to £200 he would have met any possible objection which Deputy Gorey might be inclined to bring forward. That we should find Deputy Gorey unsatisfied and anxious to reduce the allowance further is, I must say, a complete surprise to us.
Comment on this
I am certain that the Deputy said that Senators should be paid in accordance with the value of the service they gave.
Comment on this
Some of them give no service at all and should get nothing.
Comment on this
It is, perhaps, news to Deputy Gorey to know that members of the Seanad are in fact required to do very little work. The Seanad meets on an average about forty days in the year and meets for the purpose of watching the Clerk stamp Government Bills and of discussing the advisability of adjourning for tea. Senators have no constituencies and are not bothered by voters who require matters to be taken up with various Government Departments. They have nothing to do except to meet in the Seanad Chamber forty times in the year and go home again. We, that is, the Trinity College-Fianna Fáil combination, suggest that having regard to the actual interference with their personal interests involved in such work the allowance of £200 a year should be adequate. Members of the Seanad were not, of course, prepared to subscribe to that particular proposal and they fought strenuously against it but were unable to produce any real arguments within the terms of reference of the Committee as to why the proposal should be rejected. So they threw the rules of order to the winds and brought in proposals which had nothing to do with the terms of reference to the effect that the amount of work entrusted to Senators should be increased. Whether it is or is not possible to increase the amount of work entrusted to Senators is a matter that has been discussed in this House previously in various forms. The view of Deputies on these benches is that if we want that work done well it should not be entrusted to Senators, but if it is of an unimportant nature which would be likely merely to waste the time of the Dáil it might safely be entrusted to the Second Chamber. I refer to such matters as the protection of wild birds and things of that kind.
Comment on this
Yes. I thank the President for bringing to my notice a type of work for which the Seanad is ideally suited—matters of no importance, matters of pure academic interest such as amendments to the Constitution.
Comment on this
That is a matter of much greater importance than amendments to the Constitution. As a matter of fact, I notice that an eminent medical man who was discussing that particular question in Dublin recently outlined the system adopted in America.
Comment on this
Oh, no. This report with which I was dealing stated that a minority contended that the allowance to Senators should be reduced because the Parliamentary duties and public activities which Senators are required to undertake are not so extensive as in the case of Deputies. The minority consisted, of course, of the Trinity College-Fianna Fáil combination, but that combination did not last long. The alliance between Cumann na nGaedheal, Labour, the McGillycuddy of the Reeks——
Comment on this
Yes. That combination defeated us on the particular issue of allowances to Senators, but then broke up, and Fianna Fáil was left to fight a lone battle against other proposals to effect economies to which Deputy Thrift alluded.
Comment on this
Perhaps Deputy Lemass would make it clear whether Colonel Moore was speaking as a Senator or as a member of Fianna Fáil Executive?
Comment on this
I could read the terms of reference. It appears from the resolution that the Committee was appointed by the Dáil and Seanad. Presumably Colonel Moore, not being appointed by the Dáil, was appointed by the Seanad. I may say that if my recollection is correct the gentleman mentioned owes his membership of the Seanad to the nomination of the President.
Comment on this
Oh, I do not think so. Please relieve me of that responsibility.
Comment on this
The President cannot possibly be relieved of that responsibility. The majority of the Committee contended that the existing allowance should be regarded as a minimum for members of both Houses. That particular sentence in the report brings us up against Deputy Gorey's proposition. Apparently Deputy Gorey, in asking that members of the Seanad should be paid in relation to the value of the service which they give, did not contemplate any reduction in the existing allowance. It is obvious that his purpose is to ensure that certain Senators who give some service should have their allowance increased as a token of the Dáil's appreciation.
Comment on this
I did not mention anything about increase. I think they are paid enough, both here and there.
Comment on this
The Deputy gave me the impression that he was dissatisfied with the existing arrangement. I am glad to hear that he is not. Perhaps he is only dissatisfied with the existing arrangement in regard to the Dáil. Surely this altruism on the part of Deputy Gorey is worthy of great praise. If Deputies are to be paid in relation to the value of their service Deputy Gorey's self-sacrifice should be recorded in the official records of the Dáil.
Comment on this
If you mean by serving giving away all the gas, I know what service you give.
Comment on this
The Deputy mentioned that it was very difficult for the Cumann na nGaedheal Party to get representative men from the rural constituencies. That fact is not to be attributed to the arrangement regarding allowances. The members of Fianna Fáil Party are paid the same allowance, but we have no difficulty in getting representative men from the rural constituencies. I suggest that the Deputy should seek the cause of the inability of Cumann na nGaedheal to get such representative men in the policy of his Party and not in the system of paid allowances. Apparently, however, according to the Deputy, they have no difficulty in securing hordes of representative men in Dublin. "Hordes" was the word actually used by the Deputy, but he did not explain how representative men——
Comment on this
If hordes of representative men in Dublin are anxious to become members of Cumann na nGaedheal how did certain members from Dublin come to be selected by that party? Surely if they had no difficulty in getting hordes of representative men they would not have selected Deputies like Deputy Dr. Hennessy, Deputy Peadar Doyle and Deputy J.J. Byrne.
Comment on this
Surely the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies for Dublin compare very favourably with the representatives of Fianna Fáil for Dublin?
Comment on this
Deputy Byrne is quite entitled to his opinion. It is quite obvious that Deputy Byrne, having been a member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party for quite a considerable time now is suffering from a superiority complex. That is the particular feature most noticeable amongst members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. I agree, A Chinn Comhairle, that the Cumann na nGaedheal Party does not properly arise on this Bill. The methods of payment of members in different countries were considered and it was agreed unanimously that the present system of payment at a fixed rate is the most satisfactory arrangement. Deputy Gorey can be quite satisfied that the method which he had in mind was considered by the Committee and unanimously rejected by the Committee and the Committee included certain prominent members of his Party—I mean the Party to which he is now attached. The majority of the Committee then went on to make a most foolish remark. They said that a member of the Oireachtas—and I would remind the Deputy that the term "Oireachtas" included both Seanad and Dáil—must be prepared to devote much of his time and attention to Parliamentary business in general. I think that that is a fallacy. I think it is well known that there are amongst members of the Dáil and Seanad many who devote very little of their time to Parliamentary business in general. In fact I would say that 90 per cent. of the members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party outside the Executive Council have no interest in Parliamentary business other than the interests of the Chief Whip.
Comment on this
The Deputy is now departing from his opening statement, that the Cumann na nGaedheal Party is irrelevant.
Comment on this
The Deputy said that they were irrelevant. I agree most heartily. I agreed with him on the same point about Fianna Fáil last night.
Comment on this
I take it that we will be allowed to give a number of examples, having regard to the examples which the Deputy has quoted.
Comment on this
I think I am entitled to an increased allowance having regard to the Deputy's remarks.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is certainly entitled to an increased allowance. He is probably the most useful member of Cumann na nGaedheal to his Party.
Comment on this
There is no reason why this debate, having started in a good-humoured vein, should develop into the old familiar wrangle which will not carry us anywhere.
Comment on this
Deputy Thrift having given us his reason for introducing this Bill, that reason being to effect economy, went on to say that the Seanad should be made an important part of the Oireachtas. It is quite noticeable from the particular phrascology used by the Deputy that he does not consider the Seanad an important part of the Oireachtas at present. Nobody can.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy misunderstood me. I said I wished to make it even a more important part of the Oireachtas than it is at present.
Comment on this
Things that are equal to the same are equal to one another. I agree with the Deputy that the opportunities for increasing the importance of the Seanad are unlimited. Let us consider that particular suggestion if it is not irrelevant. Is it desirable that the importance of the Seanad as part of the Oireachtas should be increased? We have had one suggestion put forward by the President to-day, namely, that the Seanad might be utilised for the purpose of discussing amendments to the Constitution. Is it necessary to amend the Constitution? Surely the Government were never restrained in their activities at any time by the difficulties arising out of an Article of the Constitution? They just ignored it, and, having ignored it, sometimes they felt bound in conscience to amend it, and no particular difficulties ensued in consequence of that decision. A Bill was introduced, the closure was applied, it went to the Seanad, it was stamped with the rubber stamp by the Clerk, it went to the Governor-General, and then became law. Is it necessary to keep the Seanad in existence in order that amendments to the Constitution might be effected? I do not think so. If that is the only purpose for which the Seanad is required, the case for its abolition is overwhelming, and I would remind Deputies that that is the only reason which the President gave for its existence.
The Deputy hoped to awaken Senators to a sense of their responsibility by this Bill, but these hopes are doomed to failure. I think it would be impossible to secure that end by any act of this House. If the reduction of the allowance from £360 to £200 a year would have that effect, then there is a case for the Bill stronger than anything which the Deputy has advanced heretofore, but the Deputy must realise, I am sure, that the task of awakening Senators to a sense of their responsibility is not likely to be achieved in a generation. I agree with the Deputy that there is no possibility in present circumstances of the Senators' work becoming whole-time work. There is consequently no need why Senators should be granted an allowance upon the same scale as members of the Dáil, who are expected to give a much greater amount of time and attention to the work that comes before them. It is impossible under present circumstances for anyone seriously to recommend an increase in the allowances paid to members of the Dáil. If the unfair balance between the Dáil and the Seanad is to be rectified it can be done only by reducing the allowance of Senators. That proposal, I agree, is not undemocratic. It will merely prevent a form of extravagance to which the Government is particularly prone. I would like to remind the Executive Council that the £10,000 a year saved in consequence of the passage of this Bill could be put to a very useful purpose. We had a discussion last week or the week before on the great services rendered to the country by the holding of motor races in Dublin.
Comment on this
If it is not possible to mention the direction in which money saved in consequence of the passage of this Bill can be spent, I would ask the House to consider this proposal. There are serious grounds for adopting it, and no serious grounds have been advanced against it. I do not think we are likely to get them, certainly not from the Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
This proposal has been put forward quite seriously by Deputy Thrift, but I regret that it has not been considered seriously by Deputy Lemass. I am decidedly of opinion that it will not be considered seriously by the House. I intend to vote against the proposal for that and other reasons. Deputy Lemass is quite right in stating that this particular proposal has a rather interesting history. His historical knowledge, however, is always at fault. It is too recent. It began in 1916. In other matters, and even in this matter, it is a little bit too recent. This has a longer history than the Deputy thinks. It is true that Deputy Thrift introduced a Bill dealing with this question, and it was agreed upon that that particular Bill should be sent back to a committee to consider not only the question of Senators' allowances but also allowances to Deputies, Ministers' salaries and other similar questions. We all know what happened to that committee.
Comment on this
The report and evidence are here, and, as I understand the ruling of the Chair, I am relevant now in dealing with not only the question of Senators' allowances but also Deputies' allowances. This particular proposal has a most interesting history. I remember 1924 and 1925, before the Deputies opposite came into the Dáil. I listened then to many Fianna Fáil speakers down the country for want of other occupation, and while I was waiting for an opportunity to speak and talk sense to the people. I remember at that time the trend of their speeches, and I am glad to pay this tribute to the Fianna Fáil Party—they are still consistent. They were strongly of opinion then that the Seanad was useless, that it was a waste of money to pay Senators a penny; but they were equally strong in the opinion that the Dáil was useless, and that every single penny of the £360 that a Deputy draws was a waste of money.
Comment on this
Quite so. They were absolutely clear on that point. I heard Deputies in my own and other counties explaining to the people at great length that every penny paid to Deputies was a pure waste of money.
Comment on this
The Deputy will later have an opportunity of making one of his eloquent—
Comment on this
—and lucid speeches. Deputy Lemass talked about the sacrifices on the part of Deputy Gorey and said that they should be put on the records of the House— that they should be recorded here. I heard them telling people whom they alleged were down-trodden and over-taxed that the day they would go into the Dáil they would see that Deputies' allowances were cut down, that Deputies were paid commensurate with the services they gave and that they would be paid much less than £360 a year. In fact, some of the more patriotic and less scrupulous Deputies suggested that they would work for nothing, that they would do everything for pure love of country, for love of Kathleen Ni Houlihan.
Comment on this
I assure the Deputy that I did not go to the trouble—
Comment on this
I have something better to do for my £1,700 a year than taking down the drivel, the dishonest drivel, that has been talked by Deputies on the other side on public platforms. Do the Deputies deny that they made those statements time and time again?
Comment on this
I must intervene here. Deputies are under the impression that they are entitled to make speeches but that their opponents are not. It is a melancholy fact that their opponents are so entitled.
Comment on this
The Deputy will have every opportunity of speaking later.
Comment on this
When a Deputy is speaking and gives way to interruption, well and good; but there are different kinds of interruptions. Constantly the position is created here that a Minister is not to be allowed to speak at all without constant interruption. Apart from that being disorderly there is to be considered the ordinary element of fair play. It is constantly happening, and Deputies ought themselves to realise it.
Comment on this
As the President has said, so far from Deputy Lemass being interrupted when he was speaking, we helped him. Deputy Smith loses his nerve on the slightest provocation. Deputy Lemass is the one who spoke, and he got plenty of latitude. I am speaking the truth, and what every Deputy knows to be the truth, when I say that it was the gospel of Fianna Fáil up to the time they cashed their first cheques, or lost their first cheques, that they would cut all Deputies' salaries. Some of them said that Deputies should not be paid at all. All, however, were clear that Deputies were overpaid, and they declared that when they had anything to do with the state of affairs they would see to it that Deputies' salaries and allowances would be reduced within proper limits.
What happened? We heard a lot at that time about the sweets of office, how people became corrupt the moment they got a little money and position. What happened? The Deputies came in; they got their first cheques at the end of the first month and they cashed them, reluctantly, I am sure. I am perfectly certain there was the greatest reluctance among Deputies, whom I do not see on the benches opposite now. But they took them all the same. I suppose they found it a little easier the second time, and at the end of the year they were taking their money like the rest of us. Deputy Lemass said something about the motives of Deputy Thrift and why he had not introduced this proposal long ago. The Deputies were a year in the Dáil and they did nothing except cash their cheques. I might add that to a great extent, so far as the members of their Party are concerned, they failed to attend the Dáil or to do any work. We set up this Committee and after long deliberation they failed to come to any decision on any question but the one.
Comment on this
Any unanimous decision. They decided unanimously that one thing was quite certain, and that is that every one of us, patriotic or not, Republican, Labour or Cumann na nGaedheal, should draw his £360 without a single penny being deducted. That is just one good example of Fianna Fáil consistency. Take the history of this question since 1923. Remember all the protestations that we heard from Deputies on the other benches and their predecessors. They come into the Dáil and sit tight for a year. They draw their cheques. When a Committee is set up—not by them— to go into this whole question, it is unanimous that whatever else happens—even though the sky might fall—Deputies must get every copper of the £360.
Comment on this
The Minister said that was the only unanimous decision of the Committee. It was not. There was another decision on a motion proposed by myself and recorded on page xiv.
Comment on this
Are we agreed that that was a unanimous decision? If I have not stated the particular position properly let some Deputy from the opposite benches tell me where I am inaccurate. I have not read the whole of the report because I have not had time.
Comment on this
I take it that it is common case that there was a unanimous decision, and that is the history of all the heroics of the last three or four years. Moreover, when it comes to Senators' allowances, the only representative of Fianna Fáil from the Seanad on this Committee was also clear that Senators' allowances should not be touched. You have there a rather interesting position. Once the Fianna Fáil Deputies tasted, we will say, British gold —perhaps I should have said accepted—they got to like it and they want to continue to take it.
Comment on this
As the President says, thirty pieces of silver. The Fianna Fáil Senator was corrupted in the same way. I suggest to Deputy Lemass that when he is President, which, of course, is certain to happen shortly, he will change his mind about Ministers' salaries also. I think that all the indications point to that, but in any event the history of this matter shows that it is a question that has not been considered seriously. It has not been considered on its merits by the Deputies opposite. They will vote for it for entirely different reasons to the reasons put forward by Deputy Thrift. It is a typical piece of Fianna Fáil eye-wash and the whole history of the matter shows that. Deputy Gorey made suggestions about making allowances corresponding to the expenses of the particular classes of Deputies and Senators. I do not think that that is practicable at all. I do not think that you can do more than approximate in this matter. But Deputy Lemass was very facetious on that question. He asked what should Deputies be paid and what should Senators be paid. That is a very interesting question— what should Senators be paid? Equally interesting it is to consider what Fianna Fáil Deputies should be paid.
Comment on this
What happens here? There is a Party opposite with nothing to do, nothing to do except politics. The Party on the Government benches are mainly men with other interests, mainly men who have to work hard at home. On the Fianna Fáil benches—there are exceptions—a very large proportion of the Deputies on the Fianna Fáil benches have nothing to do except politics and draw their cheques. What is the experience here? The Party opposite on any important issue have more absentees from the Dáil than any other Party in the House. That is notorious, and the case was so bad and it had got to be so publicly noted that they had to be hauled over the coals by their own organisation. Yet Deputy Lemass has the impudence to come here and to make suggestions as to how the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies are neglecting their duties. I have a certain amount of interest in Deputy Lemass. He is promising. If he did but develop his sense of humour it would help him. If the Deputy developed a sense of humour he could not take the line that he has taken. A sense of humour would be very useful to the Deputy.
Comment on this
I am sure this Bill will go to a division. I am equally sure that the Fianna Fáil Deputies will troop into the Lobby in favour of it. They will do so under the very strict discipline of the Fianna Fáil whip. Fianna Fáil is the best regimented Party in the House, and the Deputies will troop in there in favour of Deputy Thrift's motion. They will do that for their own reasons, but clearly those reasons are not on the merits of the Bill. Deputy Thrift is in a difficult position. I admit that this is a sound proposal from this point of view, and it is put forward honestly. But I am not going myself to be a party to this Fianna Fáil eyewash, and that is what it will come to. I am with Deputy Gorey, for if ever this question is to be considered it should be considered on its merits. Not only should the allowances of Senators be considered, but the allowances of Deputies. And some consideration should be given to the services that these Deputies have been giving. We heard something from Deputy Lemass about the waste of time in the Seanad. They meet, we are told, to consider whether they will adjourn for tea and to put stamps on Government measures. Now when it comes to a waste of time there is far and away more waste of time in this House. Will Deputies, and especially Farmer Deputies, consider the amount of time that has been wasted during the last six months, and will they consider the amount of drivel talked on the question of wheat-growing here during Private Deputies' time when useful work could have been done for the country? I had to sit here and listen to Deputy after Deputy getting up and talking the most nauseating nonsense——
Comment on this
Time and time again I have listened to a futile discussion here. There is more waste of public money in the Dáil in a week, in my opinion, than there is in the Seanad in a month. The Seanad does more useful work in the same time, undoubtedly.
Comment on this
That is another slight weakness of his also and he has it in common with other members of his Party. The Deputy has got to realise that talk is not work. Many of them seem to imagine that to come here—many Deputies of his Party seem to be under this impression—that to come here and talk on every subject whether they understand it or not is doing the work of the country. I cannot agree with the Deputy that the Seanad is not doing useful work. I am satisfied that there is more time wasted here in the Dáil than there is in the Seanad. I put it to the Deputies here that this motion is not being considered on its merits, that the motion itself is not being considered on its merits. I say that this Bill should not be supported until some attempt is being made to meet the problems that arise not only in connection with Senators' but Deputies' allowances and until there comes realisation here that there should be some value for the allowances paid. I am sorry to notice that that realisation is not coming and there appears to be no sign of it on the benches opposite.
Comment on this
I can understand that a general feeling of irritation which may be attributed to the baser instincts of human nature should arise when the vexed question of salaries or the allowances of Deputies and Senators comes under consideration. If the Ministers feel that right is on their side and that wrong is on our side why not call in the Chamber of Commerce or somebody else and appoint a committee to go into the whole question? In that way we would be spared this discussion which generally engenders a lot of heat and, I am sorry to say, an amount of personal animosity. I do not think that the Minister, in spite of the fact that I find in him a slight improvement and that I find a more reasonable frame of mind running through his speech, helps his case, for which I admit there is strong support and a good deal of reason, when he falls back on the old jibe about cashing our cheques. If the consideration of cashing cheques was the paramount consideration it is extraordinary that, except for one or two errant sheep, that a larger number of Deputies could not be got to enter this House before the Fianna Fáil Party entered it. It is extraordinary that men could not be found to cash those cheques at an earlier period.
The Minister seems to forget in that connection a matter about which I have no hesitation in reminding the House. And that is that during the period when we were outside this House the Government in office had full power and complete patronage at their disposal. I for one have no hesitation in saying that they used that power to the full and that any plums that were going or any public positions that were going, naturally, and I suppose inevitably, in the circumstances, fell to their own Party and to their own supporters. If the Fianna Fáil Deputies were hard up and undoubtedly they were hard up I think that is no disgrace for them. I think on the other hand it is of some credit to them that they did come in at a time when they considered it necessary for the benefit of the nation that they should come. They estranged a good deal of their own supporters by doing so. They did that not because they were hard up and reduced to a particular condition, though I do not deny that. There existed amongst many of them very hard circumstances. Many of them had fled the country and a great many of them like myself had lost their positions because they had been dismissed by the Government opposite. I do not introduce that for any personal reason, but I want to answer the contemptible sneer that has been made that we came in here to cash our cheques. If we went to Chicago or any other city in America, at the very least we would get as good cheques as we are getting out of this place.
Comment on this
I did not make that point. I did not complain that Deputies had cashed their cheques. What I said was that they protested before that they would never do the like.
Comment on this
I say that the Minister cannot show where any Deputy on this side ever said that. I took a most prominent part in what may be called the extravagance campaign. Perhaps I may have modified my attitude or I may not, but I devoted my attention chiefly on the platform to the viewpoint that those at the top should reduce their own salaries before asking those at the bottom to do so. I was quite glad, however, to find Deputy Gorey, who is well known to his constituents as being a strong supporter of the policy that labour costs and wages should be reduced on every conceivable occasion in order to lighten the burden of taxation on farmers, getting up and adopting an entirely different policy and saying that members of the Seanad should have no reduction made in their allowances.