We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Deputies' Business. - Oireachtas (Payment of Members) (No. 2 Bill), 1928—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 129–249 of 249. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Oireachtas (Payment of Members)(No. 2) Bill, 1928
Defeated

No. 51 of 1928 ›

Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

It was done.

Comment on this

What was done? If you mean that the teachers' salaries were cut, of course they were cut all right, and the Deputy can take some credit for that.

Comment on this

And the old age pensions were cut.

Comment on this

The Minister has made great play with the name of a certain Senator associated with our Party. Senator Moore's position, in connection with this matter, is that he regards it as one primarily for the Seanad, that the Seanad ought to decide its own affairs. I dare say he believes that no such action should be taken with regard to the Seanad without corresponding action being taken in the case of the Dáil. The Senator is entitled to hold that view. I am sure that most members of this House would hold the converse proposition that an attempt at a reduction in the allowances of members of the Dáil should not be carried through without a similar reduction being made in the allowances of Senators. Senator Moore, in that matter, takes up the position that the Seanad is a body which is doing some work. That is his own personal point of view, and we are not going to bind him in that matter. If he thinks that the Seanad is doing good work, and that in the circumstances the members of it should get allowances, well in that he may have a different point of view to us. He speaks for the Seanad, and quite apart from the consideration that there are other Fianna Fáil members in the Seanad. Senator Moore has ideas himself about the Seanad, and whatever Deputies may say about him, he has done something to make the Seanad a place where live issues are discussed, and of preventing it from falling into desuetude.

The Minister also made great capital of the point that Fianna Fáil Deputies absent themselves. Undoubtedly a number of them were absent. For Deputies who have taken on responsibilities to their constituencies, who should be here but who are absent through their own fault, we are going to offer no excuse. We think that such Deputies should be here. But on this side, as well as in other parts of the House, there are times when Deputies have to absent themselves for health reasons, or on account of urgent business. This was a matter that was discussed at the Committee. I find that Deputy Lemass made the following proposition:—

That the Joint Committee is not satisfied as to the feasibility of any general scheme involving automatic diminution of allowances on account of non-attendance of Members of the Oireachtas, but thinks that the law should be amended to permit of each House establishing a procedure for dealing with special cases of protracted absence or irregular attendance of its members which may occur; that the Committee recommends that such procedure should make provision for the summoning by the House of the member to attend, failure to comply with this summons without adequate explanation being followed by withdrawal of allowance, either wholly or any part, for a specified period.

[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]

This was unanimously agreed to, that if members were persistently irregular in their attendance or showed protracted absences from the proceedings of the Dáil, steps should be taken to invite such members to give an explanation, and that if the explanation were not satisfactory to reduce the member's allowance accordingly. The Fianna Fáil organisation discussed the question of the attendance of their members. It speaks well for it that it was not ashamed to discuss the question. Fianna Fáil Deputies will have to answer their organisation—I can assure the House it is a pretty vigilant organisation—in this matter of their attendance here. If the Fianna Fáil Deputies are not able to argue their case and prove that they have carried out the duties they undertook when elected, then let the Cumann na nGaedheal Party make all the capital they can out of that at the next election. I say that the attendance in this House has improved, and that the general work of the House has improved by reason of the fact that the Fianna Fáil Party is here. Without referring at all to the individual capacity of the members here, the fact that this Party has come into the House has improved the position and improved the business. It has had the result of establishing a greater feeling of security. It has given the country the feeling that practically all shades of opinion are now taking a hand in shaping legislation, are giving voice to their different views and are trying to get those views embodied in the legislation passed here. That has been of enormous benefit to the country.

If the members of the Government Party are better attenders than the members of the Fianna Fáil Party, of course that is one of the misfortunes of the Party in office. For a period of four or five years the Government Party, when they had nobody in opposition except Senator Johnson, who did his best to carry on with a small Party of twelve members or so, it was comparatively easy for the members of it to absent themselves. There was no fear of the Government falling. During all that time it was only on exceptional occasions that the attendance went up to fifty or sixty. The average attendance in the House at that time would have been about forty. We are constantly being twitted with the statement from the opposite side that the legislation that was passed at that time, when our Party was not in the House, was much better than anything that we have contributed to. Therefore, I suppose we may take it that the quality of legislation does not depend on numbers. If you get forty good members in this House, fairly constant attenders, they will probably do as good work as seventy or eighty, or even one hundred and twenty, provided they apply themselves to the work to be done.

In connection with Deputy Gorey's point, with which I have some sympathy, that some allowances for their subsistence should be made for country Deputies who have to come up and spend several nights in Dublin, although it has been stated by Deputy de Valera that it would be better to have Deputies from country constituencies who live in those constituencies and carry on some kind of work there than that an increasing number of members of the Dáil should be persons like myself who do not happen to have any other business, it must be remembered also that members who live in the country have the trouble and annoyance of travelling up to and down from the city and they cannot apply themselves seriously to the work on hands. You cannot because of that get a sufficient number of persons to go through all the business before the Dáil carefully, produce the necessary amendments and carefully watch the proceedings if, as I understand from Deputy Gorey, their main work lies really outside the Dáil. If their main work lies on the farms or in businesses, and they find it impossible to carry on with substitutes, I do not see how they can continue to remain members of the Dáil.

The Fianna Fáil Party have achieved the result of increasing the attendance here considerably by virtue of the fact that the Government Party have to be constantly on the qui vive and the attendance has gone up from an average of 40 to 100. Whether legislation has improved or not the fact is that attendance is far better. The Minister has also forgotten in connection with the absence of the Fianna Fáil Deputies that very little important legislation has been brought before us during the past twelve months. With the exception of the financial business hardly any first-class measures have come before us. It is only natural that Deputies who, as Deputy Gorey says, have their farms or other business or personal matters to attend to would sometimes absent themselves for that purpose. Discussions on a Bill such as the Greater Dublin Bill would not be of much interest to them or to their constituents. Neither are they interested in the League of Nations and things of that sort. Their attitude on matters of that kind might be expressed in the words of Solomon: "The eyes of the fool are on the ends of the earth." Let the Minister sneer as he will about the wheat proposal, but when we have real legislation that will mean the building up of our industries and we have chiefly come into the House to participate in legislation of that kind—in which the country will take an interest, you will have as good an attendance from the Fianna Fáil Party as from any Party.

Deputy Gorey is concerned with a general reduction all round. We are in favour of it. We will take a general reduction as well as any others. The country desires economies to be made, and some gesture should be made by the people at the top.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

By the other fellow.

Comment on this

Exactly. Some gesture should be made by the people at the top. If the Government Party think that the standard of taxation must remain for normal purposes at £20,000,000 a year, I cannot see where money will be available for housing or any other purposes. The Government are not able to borrow money. They have not finances, and they are not able to bring in legislation. They take up rather a petty attitude in this matter. We say we are more in touch with the feelings of the people in the country, because on every county council and local authority you have men of Deputy Gorey's stamp crying out for small reductions, crying out that no improvements are to be made out of local rates—no improvements in roads, sanitation or housing—because these things will involve an increase in the rates, but when they come up here they have quite a different story and they are opposed to the doctrines they preach to the local authorities. Let them have a little consistency and stand up for economy here sometimes.

Comment on this

The Report of the Committee appointed to inquire into the salaries and allowances of members of the Seanad and Dáil has come in for a good deal of criticism. Deputy Lemass has given a very entertaining description of the mentality of the Committee, but not the least interesting section of the Committee was the Fianna Fáil representation. They had their own little interests too. Some of them were interested in the salaries of Deputies and others were interested in the salaries of Senators. Both sections fought strenuously against a reduction in either, and there was no motion from Deputy Lemass for reducing salaries of members of the Dáil. The Seanad representative made a very good and strenuous fight for the salaries of Senators. I believe reductions could be made, especially in the cost of the Seanad, and the better way to make the reduction would be in the reduction of its membership. I do not know that you could apply the same rule to the Dáil for the simple reason that the more members you have returned to this House the greater will be your selection to get a decent standard of ability for your Ministers. I believe if the business of this nation is to be done well you must get men of capacity to do it, and I believe we have men of capacity at the helm. Many of them are in their position at great sacrifice to themselves and their future. They are men who have made their names in the Universities and elsewhere.

When Deputy Lemass measures the capacity of members on this side of the House he does it with a salt spoon, and the contents of the salt spoon is generally wormwood and gall, but when it comes to estimating his own services or capacity, and in estimating the capacity of those on his side of the House he does it with a hogshead—a hogshead of old wine. Deputy Lemass seems to think that capacity finds its equivalent in speech making. There are some members of his Party for whom I have the greatest respect who have never made a speech in this House. They are men of considerable ability. True enough, they have contented themselves with voting, and voting is far more important when it comes to making decisions than irrelevant and irreverent speeches. We often feel it our duty when a man—I do not like to use a common or vulgar expression—is talking through his hat to leave the House and give him as few of an audience as possible. That may cure him and his Party, and it may ultimately save the country. Deputy Derrig has made a speech which was, on the whole, a reasonable speech. It was a speech which showed that he has learned something since he came into the House. On the whole, I think the Fianna Fáil Party has learned a good deal, and that though their knowledge was a slow acquisition nevertheless it is there, and their experience will eventually come to something. A good deal of capital has been made from time to time regarding the salaries of Ministers, and that you should commence with those at the top. We have first to learn that their salaries are excessive.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think we ought to discuss Ministers' salaries.

Comment on this

Then I do not propose to say any more.

Comment on this

I feel in rather a difficult position, because I find myself in partial agreement with Deputy Gorey in some of his statements. In fact, I find myself so much in agreement with Deputy Gorey lately that, owing to the statement he made last night, I am getting nervous of myself. If I had my pockets tied up I would sit beside him. There is a lot in what he says about the expenses of members coming from the country and the expenses of those who live in Dublin. I also find myself in partial agreement with the Minister for Agriculture. The longer a member spends in this House the more he realises the futility of it. I suggest it should be seriously considered that after the general election the majority party should appoint an Executive Council and let the rest go home and stay there, and see what saving there would be. I suggest that, in view of the attitude of the Executive Council even towards the members of their own Party and towards the House in general.

Deputy Hennessy made a very wise remark when he said that the important thing was the voting. The more we realise that no matter how strong a case we put up it is going to be knocked out by a majority varying from 6 to 15, the more we will realise the futility of coming here at all. Of course, there is one good thing done by coming here, and that is that in spite of the attitude of the Press we manage to expose a few little jobs that are going on. I am surprised at the attitude of the Minister for Local Government in this matter. He apparently has very strange ideas in regard to the payment of members. For a far more important body than this or the Seanad he has laid down a mileage allowance for members of 4d. per mile one way.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

Yes, and the members must attend two-thirds of the meetings in order to get their allowance.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We are not discussing the expenses of county councillors now.

Comment on this

The Minister lays down the fees for one body, and, at the same time, tries to hold that whether a member attends here or not he is still to draw his allowance. I think that is a rather extraordinary attitude. In view of the position of affairs in the country, and the attitude adopted by the Ministry even towards their own Party, the House should seriously consider whether it would not be better to leave the Executive Council in charge of affairs altogether and clear out; have no salaries at all, frank members' letters to the Departments, give them £50 per year for travelling in their constituency, and let them stay at home. That would be far better from every point of view. The more you look into the matter the more you see the futility of it, in view of the attitude of the Ministry. As a matter of fact, I would seriously suggest that the Executive Council themselves should clear out and leave the six Independent members, who really rule this House, to come in and rule it. I make that suggestion in view of the famous occasion on which the Minister for Local Government introduced an amendment here, spoke on it for half an hour, and when he was opposed by the real rulers, immediately climbed down and voted against his own amendment, bringing his fifty or sixty lambs into the Lobby against it. That was the most striking example of the manner in which the country is ruled given during my time here. It was a very striking example of the mind of Ministers. Of course, I do not know if Deputy Good is yet prepared to take up office.

I must express myself as in favour of the reduction. I am in favour of any reduction that will succeed in getting rid of the Seanad. Deputy Thrift talked of a different class of people being brought in there. The more representatives there are in the Seanad of the class which is not drawn from the people, the better I shall like it, as the sooner that worthless and useless assembly is got rid of the better. Ministers here have adopted the attitude of dictators. There is no doubt about that. We had a striking example last night from the Minister for Justice of who the real rulers are. We have it every day in the week from the Minister for Local Government. Then we had the Minister for Agriculture who said that he had more important work to do for his £1,700 than listening to the drivel spoken here.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That has absolutely no relation to the Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture said no such thing. He talked of the drivel that Deputies speak from public platforms.

Comment on this

He spoke of the drivel and waste of time in this House in regard to private members' time being taken up on the wheat question. Perhaps the Minister for Local Government was not here, that he, too, was attending to more important business.

Comment on this

He spoke of that not as a waste of his time, but as a waste of the time of the House.

Comment on this

In view of the manner in which the Minister for Agriculture has gone against the officials of his own Department and of the changes that are occurring there lately, we do not know where we are.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I should like to hear the Deputy on the Bill.

Comment on this

I have said all I have to say on the Bill. I do not know, whether the Minister for Local Government has any conscience left or not, but if he will consider that famous occasion when he spoke for half an hour on an amendment and, a quarter of an hour afterwards, voted against it with 50 or 60 members of his Party, and will graciously vacate his position and let some of the real rulers take his place, then he will be doing some good.

Comment on this

I want to say why, after a good deal of hesitation, I have decided that I cannot support this Bill. There are two considerations which inclined me in favour of supporting the Bill. I am rather inclined, in the first place, to agree with Deputy Derrig in one of the observations he made, that at a time when economy is of importance, it is desirable that the example of that economy should come from the top, and the top in this matter, as I conceive it, is really the Oireachtas and, in particular, that Chamber of the Oireachtas which is charged with the special duty of finance—that is the Dáil. There is another consideration which, I think, is too often forgotten. We talk constantly of salaries paid to members. We tend sometimes to forget that the real basis of the thing is not a salary, but an allowance for expenses. From that point of view, I should, in the first instance, be very much inclined to say, looking at it in the abstract, that there is considerable ground for holding that the allowance paid to Senators should be less than the allowance paid to Deputies, because it is, I take it, notorious that, with the exception of certain individual Senators, whose expenses are unusually heavy, it is true that the expenses of Senators are considerably less than those of Deputies. Therefore, looking at the matter in the abstract, there would be a good deal to be said for putting the Seanad on a somewhat different basis. To that extent, I should be inclined to favour the Bill. But there are two other counter considerations which, to my mind, completely overweigh these particular ones. In the first place, we have had quite recently a committee upon this whole matter. I was not a member of that committee and I am not aware of the considerations they had before them, but, rightly or wrongly, that committee came unanimously to the conclusion that the allowance paid to members of the Oireachtas, whether of one House or the other, should not be reduced. That being so, I find it difficult, in the absence of any fresh evidence, to go against the conclusions of the committee.

Comment on this

Not unanimously.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

So far as the Dáil is concerned.

Comment on this

Secondly, and this weighs very much more. I do not like to be a judge in my own court. The chief value of the reduction is not going to be the amount of money you are to save. As a matter of fact such reduction in the allowance as the Bill proposes to Senators would be a trivial matter in itself. The value, if any, as a moral value—the example which Deputy Derrig has spoken of as the value of the reduction—would in my judgment be negatived by the encouragement given to that meanest kind of parsimony only too prevalent in this country which consists in jealousy at the advantages enjoyed by the other fellow. I do not like the idea. If this were a Bill of a general scheme for the reconsideration of the whole matter then certainly my feeling would be entirely engaged in support of it. But I do not like the idea to be a party here, without further and more claborate consideration of the whole matter from top to bottom, than is afforded by this Bill, to taking money away from my neighbours while I claim to retain myself in full possession of the emoluments appertaining to membership of this House.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'Connell Labour Party

I wish to say that though I happen to be a member of this Committee whose findings were discussed often in this debate I was unfortunately not able to attend the meetings of the Committee except in the early stages, when the really controversial points had not arisen, and so far as important decisions have been come to by an actual vote of members of the Committee I regret I was not present and took no part in the proceedings. I am sorry I had not an opportunity of being present when Deputy Thrift made his case this morning in favour of the Second Reading of the Bill, but I listened carefully to Deputy Lemass and he told us that Deputy Thrift gave as his reason for introducing this Bill the question of economy. I intend to oppose the Bill and my case has been made already, perhaps more strongly, than I could make it, by Deputy Lemass on the occasion, just twelve months ago, when this Bill was before the House.

During the course of the discussion on the Second Reading of that Bill on 22nd February, 1929, Deputy Lemass spoke as follows:—

I believe that the members of the Independent Group who acted primarily in this matter came together prior to the election of a number of Senators some time ago and decided to introduce this Bill. Their main desire was to find some means by which the privilege, if it is a privilege, of membership of the Seanad would be retained for that particular section of the community which they represent. Under the system of election which prevailed before the change there were a number of people who secured membership of the Seanad who could not possibly have got that membership if popular opinion or popular vote had any influence in the matter. A change was effected—a change with which in some respects we disagreed, but it resulted in the elimination of a number of people who, in my opinion, were undesirable in the Seanad, even though it did not make the utility of that body any greater. I believe that the motive which actuated the Independent Group here, and I think the motive which actuated certain members of the Seanad who also moved in this matter, was to ensure that it would be possible for those only to seek election to the Seanad who were provided with independent means of livelihood; in other words, that membership of that body would become the exclusive privilege of the moneyed class.

Again he said:—

We think that if the Seanad could possibly at any time serve a useful function in the Government of this State, then its members should be provided with an allowance which would make it possible for the poorest member of this community to fulfil all the functions of membership. Whether £200 a year or £360 a year is an allowance adequate to that end, I am not going now to express an opinion, but I would like to point out that it is possible for a shopkeeper or a professional man to carry out the functions attaching to the Dáil or the Seanad without any serious diminution of his income from his profession or business. There are very few working men earning a weekly wage who could, I think, persuade their employers to permit them to be absent from their work while the Dáil or Seanad was in session, and to return to their work during the recess. A working man, therefore, who becomes a member of the Dáil or Seanad is practically compelled to devote all his time to it. He is certainly not in the position to find any source of income to augment the allowance which he receives here. It was, I think, to exclude possibly all persons without private incomes becoming members of the Seanad that this Bill was originally introduced.

[Parliamentary Debates, columns 381-82, 22nd February, 1929.]

These are Deputy Lemass's actual words.

Comment on this

He has learned sense since.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I say no Deputy on these benches could be more cloquent on the effect of this measure than Deputy Lemass then was. I failed completely, and still fail, to understand why Deputy Lemass, who professes to have the interests of democracy and the working man so much at heart, should seek thus to exclude him from any right that any other member of the community possesses. So far as I am concerned this is all I have to say on the matter: that although there may be questions of the utility of the Seanad, or the value of the amount of service it gives, yet, while the Seanad is there and is an essential part of the Legislature in this country no vote of mine will be given which would have the effect, as this Bill would have, of confining it to members of the privileged or moneyed classes. That is all I have to say on the matter. I shall vote against this Bill.

Comment on this

As a member of the Committee, I want to say that I disagree completely with the view of the Labour Party as regards the allowances paid to Senators, and as regards any attempt towards preventing any member of any class becoming a member of and serving in the Seanad. I think this talk of democracy on the part of the Labour Party is so much eyewash.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'Connell Labour Party

You ought to be a good judge.

Comment on this

I think we have gone too far with that kind of talk. It seemed to me that the Minister for Agriculture in discussing the report of the Committee, and no other member who was part of the majority of the Committee, attempted to compare the work done by members of both Houses. When I was asked to go on the Committee I accepted the invitation of my Party, and I was delighted with the opportunity of serving on any committee that would set out to reduce the salaries and allowances paid to members of the Seanad. We are told, of course, that under the Constitution membership of that body is given to people who have rendered distinguished services to this country. It is on that condition we are supposed to believe that people are appointed to the Seanad, but I know some gentlemen in that assembly masquerading around with monocles, and God knows I am at a loss to know when they gave service either to the people or to the country. If I had my way I know where I would put some of them who distinguished themselves. I would give them a term in Mountjoy instead of in the Seanad.

I have not spoken here very often, but I hope I was one of the Deputies Deputy Hennessy referred to. I hope he had me in mind, and I want to say that on the Committee or in this House I have not seen any appreciation by the Front Bench opposite, by the Committee or by the Government, of the real position that exists in the country. I do not know whether I have given service for the cheque, as the Minister says, I am cashing, but if I am not going to give service I do not want to come here. I have come here with good intentions, but if my services are not worth what I receive then I am prepared to stay at home and give these services in some other way. I think flippant attacks get us nowhere, and that the Minister for Agriculture would be much better employed in giving more consideration to some of the serious problems that confront the people, who are absolutely clamouring for relief of some description. In this debate, I am sorry we are not allowed to discuss the question of Ministers' salaries, because I would like to have a word to say on that with special reference to our friend, the Minister for Justice.

Comment on this

I am glad to know we are friends.

Comment on this

I would like to have something to say about the Ministry as a whole, but I would love to say something about the Minister for Justice, and what he does for £1,700 yearly, coming in here well tuned up at 10.30, and making his defence up to 11 o'clock, perhaps once or twice a month, bringing in his kicking cow, and being paid at the rate of £1,700 per annum. I would love to say something to that Minister.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

You have succeeded very well.

Comment on this

We would just love to hear him.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Minister for Industry and Commerce said. He has been employed recently on foreign affairs, but unlike other Deputies I am not going to touch on that subject. Foreign affairs and the truce that has been referred to have no interest for me or for the people I represent. All the talk about democracy, about a democratic Constitution, and about co-equality has no meaning for me if it does not mean a decent standard of comfort and work for every man. If it does not mean that, it means nothing to me. This Committee, when considering the question of salaries, wages and allowances of members of the Oireachtas, failed to look at the question in relation to the ability of the people to pay, and for that reason I am going to vote for the Bill.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Smith must be labouring under some delusion. Is he aware that he is practically repudiating his leader, Deputy Lemass? Deputy O'Connell simply quoted a speech made by Deputy Lemass in this House on 22nd February, 1929; I want to quote it again for the benefit of Deputy Smith. Deputy Lemass said:—

I believe that the motive which actuated the Independent Group here, and I think the motive which actuated certain members of the Seanad who also moved in this matter, was to ensure that it would be possible for those only to seek election to the Seanad who were provided with independent means of livelihood; in other words, that membership of that body would become the exclusive privilege of the moneyed class...

On the assumption that that was a speech made by Deputy O'Connell a case was built up against the Labour Party. I hope members of the Fianna Fáil Party will take the castigation delivered by Deputy Smith seriously to heart. So far as the Bill itself is concerned I want to say that I am opposed to it for very different reasons to those advanced by Deputy O'Connell. I believe Deputy Thrift made out a very good prima facie case, at any rate, for revision and review. Revision and review do not necessarily mean a reduction. Deputy Thrift pointed out that, in his opinion, the work done and the value given by Deputies in this House was somewhat more important to the State than the work done in the Seanad. I think he found an echo in Deputy Gorey, though Deputy Gorey did not intend it that way, as he suggested that the allowance should be based on service, and that the allowance to Deputies should be somewhat greater than that for Senators. If that is true the obverse is also the case. In other words if less service be given by Senators than by Deputies the allowance paid should be less for Senators than that paid to members of the Dáil. I think Deputy Hennessy mentioned that there were irrelevancies spoken here from time to time, and I think the word "piffle" was mentioned. I think I never heard worse piffle in my time than I heard coming from Deputy Corry a few moments ago. If we have to listen to this sore of drivel I say it would be far better for most of us to absent ourselves for many a session after a general election.

I want to put it to the commonsense of anyone, and I put it to the members of Fianna Fáil, or to any person who has any pretensions to seriousness, education or enlightenment, not to mention culture—because I think that is absent—and to ask if they suggest that in a Parliamentary institution of this kind, after a general election, once a particular Party gets a majority, and is thereby enabled to set up a Government, that the Opposition should withdraw. If that is the mentality of Fianna Fáil I really sympathise with them and their leading spokesmen. There would be an end to Parliamentary institutions if such a grotesque suggestion was ever attempted to be carried into effect. I need hardly dilate any further on that most ignorant suggestion. I repeat most ignorant suggestion, and I suggest that it should not be made in any representative assembly. It is one which, I am sorry to say, has been made in this House, and it reflects very little credit on those who made it, and it says very little for the intelligence even of members prepared to listen to it without shouting it down.

There is something to be said for the Bill. A good prima facie case has been made out, but in my view a case is made out for revision. In that connection it might be well perhaps to stress the point made by Deputy Gorey. There is no doubt that in any revision or review of allowances to members of the Oireachtas that may take place in the future, due regard must be paid to the proximity or otherwise of members to Leinster House. I know that there are members of the Labour Party and members of every Party in the House whose absence in Dublin during the sessions of An Dáil, and whose duties take them over their constituency, losing very heavily. I am aware of the circumstances of more than a dozen members of this House which go to show that they are losing considerably financially. If there is to be an inquiry, I think that in common justice to these members, now would be the time to point that out, for the satisfaction of the mover of the Bill, though I believe he is, in this regard, very just and has a sense of equity. I feel, however, that in any revision or review that will take place, due regard must be paid to the circumstances mentioned by Deputy Gorey, which I would like to emphasise. I am sorry that the Bill was such a short one, and that it was not a little more comprehensive. Then perhaps I would be able to vote for it, but it has not gone far enough. It simply confines itself to a suggested reduction in the allowances of members of the Seanad.

There is an aspect of the whole question which I do not think has been touched on up to the present, and it is this: So long as you have a Second Chamber, and that that Chamber acts in a revising capacity, or in some other capacity, entailing as it does on a particular section of its members absence from home and a break in their relations with either their businesses or their employers, there should be some consideration extended to them by way of allowances. As Deputy O'Connell has pointed out—I think it was in quoting from the speech of Deputy Lemass made here last February— many of those Senators may have to give up their employment altogether, because their employers, in the majority of cases at any rate, would not be able to facilitate them in allowing them time to attend meetings of the Seanad. Undoubtedly, if the Bill were passed here it would inflict injustice on a number of persons, potential members of the Seanad. For that reason amongst others, though I might say it is not my main reason, because there is a case for revision, I oppose the Bill. That case for revision does not necessarily mean a reduction.

Amongst other things that Deputy Gorey suggested might be taken into consideration is the question of allowances based on service, but, of course, I recognise that that is a rather vague expression, and that service in the long run might mean service to Party instead of service to State. So that whilst I can see something good in what Deputy Gorey suggests its vagueness does not make a strong appeal to me. If Deputy Thrift or others think economy should be effected let them bring in another measure. I will reconsider my attitude and possibly support it, but as some Deputies have already said, some of these reductions must come from the top. I believe there is room for some reduction taking place at the top, but, again, I do not want to be taken as suggesting that the Minister for Agriculture, for instance, is not worth £1,700 a year. In my view he is worth twice that amount. As far as the Minister for Industry and Commerce is concerned, the only Minister present——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We are not discussing that question.

Comment on this

On a point of order, will we be entitled to take individual Ministers and to say they specifically are not entitled to their salaries, if a member of the House is entitled to say a specific Minister should have his salary doubled?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Perhaps the Deputy would listen to me for a moment. Did the Deputy not hear what I said to Deputy Anthony?

Comment on this

I did. The difficulty is that Deputy Anthony has stated that one Minister should have his salary doubled.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The difficulty with the Chair is, that Deputies sometimes get out very undesirable statements before the Chair is in a position to stop them.

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that Deputies have an opportunity every year of discussing the salary of each Minister on the estimates?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is so.

Comment on this

Before I was interrupted I was going on to talk about the suggestions made by some speakers here this morning that reductions should come from the top and that if any economies were to be practised they should begin at the top. I say that there is something to be said for that, but I say that no case has so far been made out for having the salaries of certain Ministers reduced.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has been told that it is not in order to discuss the salaries of Ministers.

Comment on this

Of course, I understand that there is some relation between the top and Ministers and I want to dissociate myself from this petty, mean talk about the reduction of Ministers' salaries.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

There has not been a word said about it. It is out of order.

Comment on this

I do not think that you were in the Chair when it was said. Anyhow I suggest to Deputy Thrift that he should withdraw this Bill and amplify it along the lines I have suggested. Perhaps then we might have a clearer and better case made for revision. I noticed that in the very temperate and well-reasoned speech of Deputy Thrift he was careful to suggest that he did not intend to cast any slur or to belittle the activities of members of the Seanad. As I have said, while we have the Seanad and while it is part of our Constitution I believe that its members should get a reasonable allowance. I hope on some future date that if a Bill is introduced it will be along the lines of revision and along lines which will not mean reduction.

Comment on this

Deputy Anthony has attributed a statement to me which I did not make. I have not, of course, had the national education which he had. He stated that I said that after a general election all members should remain at home. What I said was that in view of the attitude of the Executive Council towards members of this Party, the Labour Party, and even their own Party, it would be well if all members stayed at home.

Comment on this

That is all right.

Comment on this

And I gave instances of that attitude which bore out my statement.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Deputy Anthony should be compelled to stay at home.

Comment on this

I am sorry that Deputy Anthony did not listen to my speech.

Comment on this

I was here all the time and I do not think that I have misquoted Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

In their support of this Bill Deputies appear to have lost the point of view regarding the difference between the expenses of a Deputy and those of a Senator. We have been informed on a point of order that what we are discussing is the question of allowances, that these allowances are in respect of service, and that we should bear in mind the larger amount of service rendered by Teachtaí than by Senators. A Senator has to spend very little time in Dublin, comparatively speaking, and he is under no expense in his constituency. He has not to get around. The House to which he is elected is the creature of this Dáil, and he has not to keep in touch with his constituents. In consequence of the short time which he spends on parliamentary duty and the fact that he resides practically all his time at home are reasons why the £200 fixed in this Bill should be regarded as a reasonable allowance and why this Bill should consequently be supported by the House. The Minister for Agriculture, having turned to the multi-millionaires and the philanthropists on his back benches and having told them how wonderful they were to be here and how condescending they were to come here, pointed to the time-serving politicians on this side of the House and asked us whether we were prepared for a reduction in the allowances to Deputies for their parliamentary duties. We say that if it is necessary —and it is necessary in the public interest—for economies to be made at our expense, then by all means make them.

I believe that the Oireachtas is a costly institution and that it could be run at much lesser expense. The travelling expenses of Deputies amount to quite a large sum in the year. We meet here on Wednesday, Thursday and on Friday morning, but I can see the same amount of work being done in half the time here if we sat, as the British House of Commons sits, from Monday to Friday and if we sat every alternate week. In the amount of travelling expenses which we would save and in the consequent cuts which we could make in travelling allowances there would be considerable saving but, if it is advisable, and I contend it is, and if it is necessary, and I believe it is, in the public interest to cut down the parliamentary allowance then by all means cut it down. During debates of this kind we get lectures about the drivel which we speak in this House and also about education, culture, intelligence and so on. That is part of the campaign, of course, to discredit Fianna Fáil, part of the campaign conducted by the Press, which has redounded on its authors by bringing parliamentary institutions into discredit—so much so that parliamentary institutions are on their trial and the public verdict is very much against them. If the Minister for Agriculture belives that by entering this House any of us have become opulent because of our parliamentary allowance we wish to inform him that, if as a result of this campaign to discredit parliamentary institutions which had its authorship in the campaign to discredit Fianna Fáil, we return to the wilderness, we will not heave any sighs for the supposed flesh pots, the parliamentary allowances. Labour Deputies have contended that it would be impossible for anybody to be elected to the Seanad who has not a private income and that it would be impossible for him to carry out his duties as a Senator unless the allowance remains as it is. If we were to take a census of the number of people in this country with incomes of £200 and under we would find that the vast majority of the earners of this country have a salary or wage of £200 and under and have to exist upon it. In view of that fact, and in support of this Bill, we contend that a man would be adequately remunerated for the duties he has to perform in the Second Chamber by being paid an allowance of £200, along with the travelling allowance which he gets.

I think it would be far better from the point of view of debates and the conduct of debates if we had not repeatedly this ignorant lecturing about the want of education, the want of intelligence, and the want of common sense which we get on every measure on which we choose to speak.

[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]

Comment on this

I do not know if any other Deputy approves of Deputy Corry's suggestion, but if nobody is prepared to stand by him, at any rate I will. I think his proposal has much to commend it. I know it is a proposal which was adopted in a very great country in Europe a few years ago. The exact nature of the proposal was not made very clear by the Deputy, but he suggested, I think, that after election Deputies should retire and stay at home. In Italy, I understand, a special law was brought in that the majority party——

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, what I said was: "while this Executive Council is in office." I did not mean, of course, that every Executive Council is going to be the same as the present dictatorship. The Deputy can understand now. We have a dictatorship at present. I am sorry that the Deputy's intelligence did not grasp that before.

Comment on this

I am not very enamoured of Parliamentary institutions. I think perhaps that they are out of date and that they are a very unscientific method of governing a country, but at the same time I realise that it would be quite impossible to abolish the Oireachtas for many years to come. That may be a misfortune for us, but it cannot be helped.

Comment on this

Because in this State the Oireachtas is a very valuable safeguard for our national independence, and secondly, if we abolish the Dáil and the Seanad our neighbours in these oceans, British Newfoundland, New Zealand, Canada and America, would all jeer at us and say that we were too uneducated to produce a proper Parliament which was capable of carrying on the government of the country without disaster.

Comment on this
A Deputy

They have never jeered so much at us as since you set it up.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'Connell Labour Party

What are you doing here so?

Comment on this
A Deputy

Trying to improve it.

Comment on this

It would be impossible to keep the country going without Parliamentary government. I must say, in spite of what Deputy Thrift has said, and in spite of the statement of the Minister for Agriculture, the time and the circumstances of introducing this Bill did strike me, although I do not wish to be suspicious, as being suspicious. It seemed to me that the Independent members were trying to play politics and to embarrass the State at that particular moment. I may have been completely mistaken, but certainly I did get that suspicion, and nothing that has happened since has completely removed that suspicion from my mind.

Comment on this

May I ask the Deputy to explain why he was suspicious? I would like to know.

Comment on this

The time, the circumstances and the fact that the constitution of the Seanad changed, that the atmosphere of the Seanad changed, that the Seanad was previously, during the chairmanship of the previous Chairman, looked upon as——

Comment on this
A Deputy

Homogeneous.

Comment on this

Not so much homogeneous but as a brake on the more national elements of the country, and seeing that a change took place and that this Bill was introduced at the same time, I could not help associating the two circumstances, particularly in view of the fact that although the Independent members have always consistently been in favour of economy, they never brought in this Bill during the many years before, since the Dáil and the Seanad were established. That struck me as being suspicious, and the combination of the Independent members with those members who belong to the I.R.A., and those members who are associated together for the overthrow of the Constitution, was to my mind very remarkable, although we have noticed signs of this combination on previous occasions. For myself, I think that all the members of the Oireachtas should be considered as equal and that this differentiation between certain members of the Oireachtas and others is wrong so long as we have an Oireachtas.

Deputy Gorey's point, that members of the Oireachtas should be paid for their services, is also one with which I do not agree, because it tends to lower the dignity of the members of the Oireachtas and to imply, to some extent, that they are criminals who have to be watched and forced to do their duty. It is to a certain extent a confession of the failure of democracy that it cannot produce public representatives by election, who could be trusted to do their duty and to earn the moneys which they get by way of allowance except by stringent measures of discipline. I do not think this Bill will pass, but I hope the Government will give more consideration to the recommendations of the Committee which was set up as a result of the Bill being introduced.

Comment on this

I am in favour of the reduction of the salaries of members of the Seanad as at present constituted. I think to pay any member of the Seanad £360 a year for the particular services we get is a charge which the State should not be called upon to bear. I am not taking the line that £360 a year is too much for a Senator. I can imagine a Seanad in which I would be prepared to pay very much more than £360, just as in the same way I can imagine a Dáil in which I would be prepared to pay members very much more than £360 a year; but at the present moment there does not seem to be either in the personnel or the composition, in relation to interests or in the amount of work which is required to be done or is done, a justification for the total expenditure which is now made on the Seanad.

If we had a Seanad of very much smaller numbers selected upon an entirely different basis and made up of men who, whatever their political opinions were, would be chosen because they were experts in particular branches of Irish life, and if that Chamber was used for the purpose of revising intelligently for the information and further consideration of this House legislation which came through this House, I personally would not object to £360 a year, or to any sum above £360 a year, being paid. At the present moment the Seanad is purely and simply a piece of machinery for registering votes. I regard the Seanad as constituted as a Dublin endowed affair, and it is very rapidly becoming an organisation for the purpose of rewarding services performed by politicians for their parties. I am not now separating one party from another, nor am I aiming at the Opposition or at any other party, but. I cannot see any justification for the Seanad.

We had two elections for the Seanad, from one of which the vast majority of the people deliberately abstained. The election lasted for weeks and it must have been an infinitely humiliating experience for every man whose name went up. I know the case of one man who, during the previous elections of the Seanad, went out of the country and stayed away while day after day and week after week they were adding one more contemptible vote to his number on the 31st revision of votes. I think if people will honestly envisage what happened at the first public Senatorial election they will be satisfied that the result was an expression of contempt and an expression of derision by the country for the very Senators who were elected. Why members elected under those conditions in face of an electorate, 75 per cent. of whom deliberately abstained from taking any part in the election. should be regarded as people who are to receive £360 a year. I do not know. If you take the method of appointment of the original Senators, when there was no possible suggestion of any sort or kind that there was democratic sanction behind it, can anybody justify upon democratic grounds the payment to these gentlemen of £360 a year?

We all know what happened in the last election. Parties organised as parties in caucus did elect certain people. It was purely and simply a question of parties putting in their nominees. It made no difference whatever to the effective power of the Seanad that that election took place. It did not alter its composition in any effective way. Does anybody suggest that the election to the Seanad of people either under the original method of selection, the intermediate method of electing them, or the last method of caucus nomination constituted a Seanad of 60 people to whom £360 a year ought to be paid?

As to their work, I am not going to say anything unkind about them with any intention. I went through the list the other day, and I formed the opinion that there were about 15 and possibly 20 men in the Seanad who might claim to be people who would be selected for the Seanad under its constitution as laid down in the Constitution. Why there should be super-added to that 40 people to obstruct their activities, 40 people to give a party and a partisan colour to their decisions, I do not know. Why these 40 people should be paid for obstructing them, I do not know either. If someone were to come forward with a proposal for a Seanad made up of 15 people, those people to be experts in their own particular branches of Irish life, I am not going to quarrel if you offer them £1,000 a year; but I am going to object to 60 people being put to do none of the work but just to divide upon party and interested lines and to carry on the camouflage of a legislative chamber.

If you were to have instead of the Seanad as at present constituted a chamber which was frankly and openly what it will gradually become, a creature of the Dáil, there would be a different aspect. What I mean is that if you had a body to advise the Dáil, to review Bills which might hastily go through here and which might have gaps and slips and things of on kind or another, its usefulness would be apparent. I have in mind a body which would have no power of legislation and no power of delaying legislation; which would be able to carry out a full examination of a Bill, and if that body were authorised to send the Bill back to this House with the comments of the fifteen experts for the information of Deputies, I am not at all sure that they would not be very valuable servants of this State even at £1,000 a year. If you had a body so constituted it would not matter what were the politics of the men selected. In selecting them I would rather choose men who would differ from me in politics and in outlook than choose people with whose opinions I would agree. What I would want from that assembly would be the criticism which I myself was not capable of evolving. If such a Chamber so constituted were established, then there would be some case to be made for a Seanad. There is a considerable case for a highly paid body acting as a Seanad, but there is nothing whatever to be said for the Seanad as at present constituted. Deputy Esmonde says that he is not enamoured of Parliamentary institutions. I am perfectly certain that this Parliamentary institution is not enamoured of Deputy Esmonde, nor has it any reason to be.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is a purely personal point.

Comment on this

I also would be prepared to deal with this House by some method of the same kind. I do not object to £360 being paid to any Deputy in this House who delivers the goods. I do object to 152 presumably responsible people being withdrawn from their ordinary activities and brought here to hang about the division lobbies and to wait for the call of the bell, merely to be engaged in neutralising each other's activities. This House today, sparse and scaree as the members are, indicates a long way above the average attendance. Time after time I have taken down here the attendance of members. Often at 5 o'clock, 7 o'clock or 8 o'clock there is not a Committee of the House present. Unless some machinery can be devised under which Deputies will actively attend to the work of the House then there is no reason whatever why the country should be put to the expense of paying 152 men to neutralise each other's efforts. The only thing that counts is the difference between our numbers. You can certainly get that difference without spending 152 times £360 a year.

If after the next election we could agree on the point of sending one-third of our number here and allowing the other two-thirds to go home, we would have exactly the same position from the point of view of the majority in the division lobbies. You would have, at any rate, under that scheme the material out of which you could get a very much better average attendance than you are getting now. We would besides save the State the salaries and expenses of about 100 members. It is not altogether a question of the amount of money that you pay to Senators and Deputies; it is the amount of work which they are prepared to do for it and the efficiency with which they do it. You can afford to pay and pay highly if the work is done, but it is pure folly to have 152 Deputies here and 60 Senators in the other House engaged in neutralising each other's efforts and not even attending in the House while the work is being done. As for the question of arranging the salary at £200 or £360, that is an arbitrary figure. There was a perfectly legitimate difficulty put forward by the Labour Party that there are men on the Seanad who could not afford to be there if they did not get a salary.

Comment on this

I think that point was made by Deputy Lemass, Deputy Flinn's own leader.

Comment on this

I am not complaining at all about it. I think it is a perfectly legitimate point. It is not past the intelligence and ingenuity of the House to find some arrangement by which cases of that kind could be dealt with. It is always difficult to make fish of one and fowl of another. But if sixty people are paid £360 each because there are half a dozen who cannot afford to be there at £200 each, it is a difficulty which I think we can find some machinery to get over and it is a difficulty in the solution of which or, in securing a way out of which I would be prepared to co-operate.

If I may sum up I would say this —I do not object to £360 for any Senator who is doing effective work. I do not think that the sixty Senators in the Seanad are doing anything like effective work. I think their numbers ought to be reduced, their powers ought to be altered and their functions in relation to this House should be changed. Their personnel ought be radically altered and sifted; then the question of what they are paid will simply be a question of their value and their efficiency, and not merely a question of some arbitrary figure of £200 or £360.

Comment on this

Accustomed as I am to diatribes from Deputy Flinn, I must say that I have never listened to a more unctuously self-sufficient speech than that which he has just delivered. On a Bill concerning the question as to whether members of the Seanad should be paid a certain sum by way of allowance, and whether that should be reduced to £200, Deputy Flinn has given us— and he has taken up a very lofty standpoint—his opinion of the Seanad, the members of the Seanad and their value for doing the work of this country. He has touched upon the way in which they got elected and one of his phrases was "the contemptible vote" by which certain people got returned. I would like to have an examination made in order to find out how many Senators were returned by any of the three methods to which the Deputy has referred with a more contemptible vote than that given to the Deputy himself as a first preference at his election, taken according to numbers. That is so much for one point.

The second point deals with the value of the Seanad, or the present members in the Seanad, viewed, as the Deputy said, from the point of their capacity to deal with various aspects of Irish life. There has been too much talk about the Seanad and about the incapacity of Senators to deal with matters from different viewpoints of Irish life. There are men in the Seanad who bear names honoured in this country for their endeavours in industrial matters. There are others there who are experts in finance. There are men in the Seanad who have worked for the country in a variety of ways. There are some who have helped this country in its cultural aspects, and there are some who have added to its fame in art and literature. There is hardly one man there who has not spent the best part of his years in this country, a country which Deputy Flinn left of his own accord. To bring him back it took that big catastrophe, the great World War, and he returned here because of the terrors that might possibly follow that great World War if he were in England. We have members in the Seanad, taking them simply from the point of view of how they can survey matters as Irishmen, to whom I would give £1,000, while I would be prepared to reduce Deputy Flinn's salary from the £360 that he at present gets. There are men in the Seanad who serve this country in a variety of ways, men who possibly do not speak as often as Deputy Flinn, men who do not parade themselves before the public as often as Deputy Flinn, and men who never suffer the humiliation of having one little bit of their hypocrisy paraded before the public as one little bit of Deputy Flinn's hypocrisy has been paraded. The Deputy thinks it is a scandalous thing to have 152 members in this House paid each £360 a year for the sake of neutralising each other's activities. It is a pity he was not here for the speech made by a member of his own Party, Deputy Derrig, a speech that was described by the Deputies who came afterwards as one of the most moderate that Deputy Derrig has ever delivered.

To my mind that was as good a speech as Deputy Derrig has ever delivered of a purely defensive character. What was the great claim that Deputy Derrig made for the party? That by coming here and sitting in the benches—he said distinctly not by talking—they got the Government benches better filled. He claimed as the very virtue of his party's presence here the point that Deputy Flinn makes against the whole House neutralising each other's activities. That was the essence of the claim made by Deputy Derrig—the value the country gets from the presence of the members of his party here:

Deputy Kennedy is in favour hypothetically—he always has a little barrier—of a reduction in allowances even to members of the Dáil. He thinks apparently that they can suffer a bit of a cut yet. That was not the point of view of the Joint Committee or of Deputy Lemass who led on that Committee for his Party. The following resolution was proposed at the Joint Committee by Deputy Lemass:—

[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]

That the Committee is of opinion that the duties attaching to membership of the Seanad do not necessitate the payment of an allowance equal to that paid to members of the Dáil; and also that the existing economic circumstances of the State do not permit of any increase in the allowance paid to members of the Dáil and recommends, therefore, that the allowance paid to members of the Seanad be reduced.

There is no mention there of any decrease in the moneys to be paid to the representatives attending here. In fact the Deputy was one who afterwards joined in an unanimous recommendation that, as far as certain other facilities that are given to Deputies are concerned, they should be extended, and that "The State should take up with the railway companies the possibility of providing full facilities for travel in all parts of the Saorstát at the minimum real cost, irrespective of the railway companies' existing scheduled charges." The Minister for Agriculture talked about the advances made by the party opposite in this matter of understanding what are the real expenses that fall on a member of the Dáil. He said, but it was denied, that previous to that party coming to the House the claim had been made that members should serve here for nothing. That claim was certainly made.

I had the experience of attending at a meeting where Deputy Killilea claimed that they as a Party had brought in a Bill to reduce the payment of members and that the Government Party had thrown it out. At the same memorable meeting—it was a meeting in connection with the Carlow-Kilkenny election— another member of the Party, Deputy Brady, describing himself as one of the mugs, also said that they had brought in a Bill to reduce the payment of members. That was the brazen claim the Deputy made.

Comment on this

In the presence of the Minister?

Comment on this

And reported in the Press?

Comment on this

I do not know about that. It was a small meeting

Comment on this

We have then just your recollection as proof of the statement?

Comment on this

That is all. Deputies, we have been told, came in here to save the country. We have what is now described as the Save the Country Fund, to which payments were to be made out of the surplus moneys that Deputies get by way of allowances. I queried the amount in that fund on one occasion. I think it was then £105 or £150.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

It is more now.

Comment on this

I am sure it is. There must have been additions to it since by at least the members of the Fianna Fáil Party who are now in the Seanad. We have this extraordinary position with regard to the Seanad. The Party opposite do not believe in the Seanad as at present constituted, but nevertheless they put up candidates for election to it. They do not believe that the members of the Seanad, as at present constituted, either do sufficient work or give sufficient value for the allowance they receive. Probably the seven or eight members of the Fianna Fáil Party who are now in the Seanad, being conscience-stricken that they are not doing sufficient work or giving sufficient value for the allowances they receive, are paying something into this Save the Country Fund. One of the Senators in question was a member of this Joint Committee, and he certainly tried to get everything he could for the Seanad.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

He was not conscience-stricken?

Comment on this

That particular individual is not one of the six or seven the Minister refers to.

Comment on this

That Senator has been in some way repudiated.

Comment on this

It was the President who nominated him for membership of the Seanad, and it is he who is now repudiating him.

Comment on this

That Senator has repudiated Fianna Fáil principles, if they are principles so far as payment of members of the Seanad is concerned. That is all. But there are five or six others. They were sent there by the Fianna Fáil Party though it believes that the Seanad is no good, and that the members of it do not do sufficient work or give sufficient value to the country for the allowances they receive. We must presume, however, that the Save the Country Fund is much stronger now, largely as a result of the contributions it has received from these six or seven members. It would be interesting to get some sort of audited accounts in regard to the moneys in that fund.

Comment on this

Let us have a showdown. We will undertake to publish the accounts in relation to that fund if the President undertakes to publish the accounts of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party funds. and the names of the subscribers to that fund?

Comment on this

If the President ever said that the Deputies in the Cumann na nGaedheal Party were getting paid too much for their attendance in this House I would repudiate him, but I do not believe he ever said it. Further, he never said that we would start a Save the Country Fund out of the extra moneys that Deputies get. We have no corresponding fund.

Comment on this

Does the Minister accept the offer that all parties in this House should disclose the whole of their financial resources and their sources?

Comment on this

That question does not arise.

Comment on this

Will you do it?

Comment on this

So far as the Deputy is concerned, I have got the best disclosure I could with regard to him and where his money is lodged, and that is all I want to know about him. I do not say that we are building up a fund. We never said we were. We always had the realisation that the allowances which are being paid are just barely sufficient to meet Deputies' out of pocket expenses. We believe that still.

Comment on this

Does the Minister deny that he tried to collect money from English millers?

Comment on this

I am not concerned with money collected from English millers. If the Deputy wishes to keep his money in an English Bank we do not care, but he should not lecture other people for doing it.

Comment on this

That is not the question.

Comment on this

What did Deputy Lemass propose before the Joint Committee? "That the existing economic circumstances of the State do not permit of any increase in the allowances paid to members of the Dáil." Is there an implication there that if the circumstances were better the allowances would be raised, or an implication that at the moment they are not excessive? We think they are not excessive either for Deputies or Senators.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

Nothing has been said with regard to the fund that was to be added to by contributions arising out of the excess paid to members, and which stood at £150 a couple of years ago, when the Deputies, in the height of their enthusiasm, thought that all work done here should be honorary, and when, as the Minister for Agriculture said, they were in a cross way receiving crossed cheques that came to them monthly. I would like to know a little bit more about the fund.

Comment on this

I have made an offer.

Comment on this

The last time I asked you about the fund there was no offer and I was given no information.

Comment on this

How did you get along in America?

Comment on this

I am afraid there is no fund.

Comment on this

I am prepared to produce my bank-book——

Comment on this

The Deputy is not prepared to do anything except what we disclose to the contrary against him. Otherwise, he will keep up the bluff.

Comment on this

What bluff?

Comment on this

We have no fund of that sort.

Comment on this

No, you get yours from the English millers, and you apply to them for it.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy say that I personally have got some-money from English millers?

Comment on this

No, but Cumann na nGaedheal over your name.

Comment on this

From English millers?

Comment on this

An English miller.

Comment on this

The Deputy will have to substantiate that.

Comment on this

What did you get from Guinness?

Comment on this

Does the Minister deny that he circularised the English millers for funds for Cumann na nGaedheal?

Comment on this

As such, yes?

Comment on this

But the Minister does not deny that he did it?

Comment on this

I do not know whether the English millers were circularised or not.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Perhaps the Minister would now move the adjournment of the debate.

Comment on this

I move.

Comment on this