Nomination of President of the Executive Council.
Contributions 195–393 of 585. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
The skunk does run, and well you know it. We ran you and chased you before in this House, and if necessary we shall do it again. "Oh, we were all in the Post Office," he says. The President was there. All credit to him for it. The Vice-President was there.
Comment on this
I beg pardon. The Minister for Defence was there, and all credit to him for it. I wonder where was Deputy Hogan on that occasion? He was jeering and jibing, probably, at the men who were there. All credit to the men who were there. I do not want to take one jot from any man on any side of politics who went out and did his duty when there was danger to be run. I did not want to drag this thing in, but I object to these jeers, and we object to them very much coming from the source that they did come from. I think they are unworthy of a man who, as I say, has reaped such benefit from the blood and sacrifices of those men and the dangers risked by them.
Comment on this
I think that is the most unwarranted attack upon Deputy Lemass.
Comment on this
I did not interrupt the Minister. I think our political attitude is definite and clear. We do not accept the Treaty as a final settlement of Ireland's claim to nationhood, of Ireland's national aspirations. We did not accept it in 1921, nor in 1922, nor do we accept it now. Is that definite and clear? The Minister for Finance, in a discussion on the Central Fund Bill, on the 22nd March, 1928, as reported in columns 1645-6 of the Official Debates, said:—
"With regard to the point as to whether we are aiming at the establishment of an Irish Republic, we are not."
That is definite and clear. He said further:—
"We believe this country as a member of the British Commonwealth of Nations can enjoy greater freedom and greater security than she could outside the great British Commonwealth of Nations, and our policy within it is really to remove anomalies that exist in the relationship between members of it."
That is a clear statement of policy, but at the same time it is a repudiation of the authors of the Treaty. It is a repudiation of Griffith and Collins, and of all the other men who accepted the Treaty. It is a definite and clear repudiation. I ask any of the Deputies on the other benches—not on ours—who were members of the Dáil that accepted the Treaty whether that is not a repudiation of the men who were responsible for having that Treaty accepted in the Second Dáil. There are others listening to me who can say whether that is or is not correct. I believe it is absolutely correct: Deputy O'Connell, when he said that the Labour Party, having accepted unequivocally the Treaty, does not accept it as the ne plus ultra of the march of the Irish nation, was interpreting what I believe was, and what those in the Second Dáil, or the vast majority of them, accepted as the real interpretation given to the acceptance of the Treaty by Griffith and Collins and others who spoke in favour of it at the time. The issue, therefore, on the political question is definitely and clearly knit. I would say you have on the one hand a definite statement: no further shall we Irish Nationalists or Irish Republicans go. We have gone into the British Empire, as some pro-Treaty people said, with our heads up, and the Minister for Finance tells us we are going to remain there. I ask anyone with a spark of real nationalism left in him is he content with that position? We are not, at any rate.
I did not intend to occupy much time in replying. I would not possibly have replied at all were it not for the grossly improper statements of the Minister for Agriculture. Our economic policy is well known. Deputies on the Government Benches pretend that they do not know and understand what it is. Deputy O'Connell, the leader of the Labour Party, knows it so well that he says there is no very considerable difference between their economic policy and ours, and I agree. There are some differences, but I do not think they are fundamental differences. In connection with the economic policy, let me say again that while we are here to use the machinery of this Free State to the fullest for the political advancement and the advancement towards freedom of the Irish people, we are not going to remain here idle and dumb when economic questions arise. Every opportunity that has arisen here has been made use of to the fullest by us to advance the economic and social interests of our people. I defy anybody to deny that.
Take the issue on which the Government was brought down, that of old age pensions. That is one of the numerous questions that we have raised here, and we have had many debates here in endeavouring to advance the social, economic and industrial interests of our people. It is not fair to suggest, as, to my mind, Deputy O'Connell suggested, that our intention was to remain idle and quiescent, hands in pockets, watching and waiting perhaps for political advancement and letting people starve and rot and die of hunger in the meantime. Deputy O'Connell ought to know, and I am sure he does know, that there is no Party in this House that has bent its earnest endeavours more often than we have in the direction of securing better housing, better conditions of livelihood, the development of industries and progressive development generally on economic lines, so that the people in this country may have an opportunity not alone to live, but to improve their standard of living. We have not remained idle; we do not intend to remain idle. Every day that we sit here a political question may arise, but certainly economic questions frequently arise, and on these economic questions we will in the future, as we have done in the past, devote the best of our energies and abilities to securing everything that it is possible to get, within our limited resources, inside the Twenty-six Counties, for the ordinary, plain, common people of the country.
I do not think I have much more to say. The question of the army and their position towards the army and the control of the army arises here. To my mind, going back over the past, it comes with ill-grace from Ministers who were in the Government in 1923-4 to charge us with having doubts as to what attitude we should adopt towards an army that attempted to over-ride or threaten or dictate to the Government. We have definitely before our minds the attitude the Ministry adopted when a real mutiny was attempted in the Free State Army. The mutineers were bought off. They were paid and pensioned and kept by money out of the taxpayers' pockets. Although they were mutineers and had threatened the State, they are kept and every possible position into which their leaders—not all their leaders but some of them—could be put by the present Government they were put. They were put into every soft job in the State and they are still in them. Those who were not lucky enough, as there were not jobs enough to go round, got fat pensions. They are still drawing—some of them at any rate—generous doles out of the pockets of the poor taxpayers. Now nobody can charge us with ever having said to any body of men or to individual men who stand for disorder in this country that when we come into power you will get the best jobs the State can afford or the biggest pensions we can rob from the Exchequer and that we will not submit to the Comptroller and Auditor-General any of the details of evidence on which the pensions are granted. Before they make charges of that kind against us about suborning disorder or threatening a government with arms, the Ministers should look into their own records. Not alone did they not properly control their own army but they cannot to-day control their own police or, at any rate, their own C.I.D. In the recent past, many verdicts have been given against the Ministry of Justice for breaches of the law committed by their own peace officers. What respect can anybody in the country have for law and order when you have the paid peace officers of the country encouraged, clapped on the back, and when everything is done that is possible to be done by the Ministry to show that the men who broke the law, men who are daily committing crimes against the person, who are committing assaults against peaceful citizens are not to be brought to justice? Heavy fines are imposed on them in the Court and yet not one step is taken so far as we know, to see that these men are taught and made to obey the common law of the land like any other citizen.
Comment on this
I cannot understand Deputy Redmond saying that the proposition I move here to-day that Deputy de Valera be made President of the Executive Council was an insult to this House. Deputy Redmond was a long time a member of the British House of Commons. "The Mother of Parliaments," I think, those who have a great admiration for that Parliament call it. In that Parliament and in that country the procedure is when a Government is defeated that the leader of the next biggest Party in the House is then asked to form a Government. In recent years we have seen developments where even a Party that was not the Party next strongest numerically was called on to form a Government, a minority Party. I merely give that one case of the British House of Commons as an example. Similar things have happened recently in France. No later than last week a similar thing has happened in Germany. It is not an improper suggestion, to put it mildly, that the man who is leader of the next biggest Party in this House should be put forward for nomination as head of a group that is prepared, ready and willing to form a Government.
Of course, we realise that we are a minority in this House, but we realise that although we are a minority we have in our ranks a number that is not very considerably lower than the Party that holds and has held power for the last seven or eight years. There is not a considerable difference in number between us. They only hold power because they have the assistance of other Parties. Would it not be in accordance with constitutional practice and procedure if those other Parties felt like it to give the Party next numerically strong, after the defeat of the Government, if they felt like it, an opportunity of taking the reins of Government and continuing to govern until such time as the people would properly be consulted? That would not be an unheard of thing in constitutional practice and usage. It was, bearing in mind that the Government had been defeated last week on an important and major issue, that we decided to put forward the name of Deputy Eamonn de Valera, head of the Fianna Fáil Party, the second largest Party in the House. Why the doing of that should be called an insult to the House I do not know.
I was surprised when I heard Deputy Redmond use such words. I know that he did vote before when Deputy Johnson in 1927 was put forward for election as President.
Comment on this
I beg your pardon. I was thinking of the vote of no confidence. He certainly voted at that time on the vote of no confidence when some of us had in mind that if the vote was carried it would have been Deputy Johnson who would have been put forward, I think, by the majority in the House to form a Government.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy tell the House and the country what his grounds for that statement are?
Comment on this
None. I said probably the majority would have done it. I know there was a great deal of talk among Deputies and certainly a great deal of discussion in the newspapers at the time and the name of Deputy Johnson, or Senator Johnson as he now is, was freely used. This is the point I wanted to bring out. Deputy Redmond certainly voted no confidence in the Free State Ministry at the time. He voted against their holding power. It was accepted that the party that would come into power would be composed in the majority of Deputies on the Fianna Fáil benches. If that were so and if he was even prepared at that time to elect to be a member of the Government that would be brought into power by the votes of the Fianna Fáil people, I wonder how he thinks it would be such an awful insult now to elect Deputy de Valera. I wonder if the fact that Deputy Redmond has recently been appearing for the Government and the Department of Justice in certain cases in the courts has anything to say to his change of mind.
Comment on this
I have nothing further to say. I hope that I have made clear what our political attitude is and what our political object is. Any quotations from any speeches that have been made have not taken away in one jot from the clear and definite statement of political or economic policy that I have made here to-day as acting-leader of the Fianna Fáil Party. It is clear and definite, anyway, to the country. We are satisfied as regards what we are out for and what we propose to do in this House if a majority decides to vote for the motion that I had the honour to propose.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
I desire to move that Deputy Tómas O Conaill be nominated President of the Executive Council. I think the House will agree, and I am satisfied that when the country tomorrow gets an opportunity, as I hope it will, of reading the speeches which have been made in this House from the two big Parties on the question of the nomination of Deputy de Valera, that the country will agree that there is a necessity to get a sane man elected as President, a man who can forget and leave behind him what has happened for the last eight years in this country. On the motion moved by Deputy O'Kelly, we were treated to what many of us in this House and most of the people in the country would wish to forget—the Treaty issue, the constitutional issue and the civil war.
Comment on this
I said on the motion moved by Deputy O'Kelly. I did not say that Deputy O'Kelly said it.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Connell did not want to know what was the position of Fianna Fáil in 1922 or 1928 or 1929. He wanted to know what is their position to-day towards the fundamental issue. We are not concerned with what the attitude of Fianna Fáil or the attitude of Cumann na nGaedheal was to the Treaty before to-day. But we are entitled to know, and the country is entitled to know, what is their attitude here and now on the question that is to be decided by the Deputies of this House as representing the people of this country. That is the question which Deputy O'Connell asked, and that is the question which, I submit, he was entitled to ask. So far as we in the Labour Party are concerned, I want to repeat what Deputy O'Connell has stated that we accept the Treaty and the institutions we have under the Treaty in the same spirit and in the same way in which that Treaty was accepted by the late Arthur Griffith and the late Michael Collins; and we propose, if Deputy O'Connell is elected here to-day, to get for the Irish people the last ounce out of that Treaty. We propose to give that Treaty a really Irish interpretation. I was glad to hear from Deputy O'Kelly, in his concluding speech, that in that he differs very little from the Labour Party.
The question of the Army was introduced, and so was the question of the control of the Army. I want to say that if this House in its wisdom decided to give the Labour Party an opportunity of forming a Government, we would see that the Army would be the servant of the people and the servant of any Government appointed and elected by the people. We were told by the Minister for Agriculture that his Party, if President Cosgrave were re-elected, would govern. I want to say that if Deputy Tomás O Conaill is elected President of this House both he and the Executive he will submit to this House will govern as well as, at least, and perhaps much better than, the Cumann na nGaedheal Party governs. The Labour Party would insist and would see to it, no matter what the consequences were, that any laws passed by the representatives of the people in this House were obeyed in the country. What is the position to-day? I want to put this seriously to the members of this House. On Thursday last, on a major issue, an issue which the President considered called for the resignation of his Government, that Government was defeated by a majority of this House. The President refused to obey the will of the people as decided by a majority in this House. I put it to members of all Parties here that if they do not vote for Deputy Tomás O Conaill, then the only honourable course left to the House is to dissolve and go to the country.
Comment on this
For this reason. On last Thursday the House decided that Deputy Ward's Old Age Pensions Bill should be passed. The principle of the Bill was agreed to by a majority of the House. The Government then in office and having the confidence of the House refused to implement that Bill by introducing the necessary financial motion. If Deputy O Conaill is not elected as President here and now, it means that President Cosgrave will be re-elected on stating clearly to the House that he is not prepared to carry out the decision of this Parliament. The Deputy who does not vote for Deputy O'Connell and who voted for the Old Age Pensions Bill on Thursday last is going back of the vote which he then gave.
Comment on this
The Deputy who introduced the Bill explicitly explained that it was not Fianna Fáil policy.
Comment on this
I did not say what has been attributed to me by the Minister for Local Government and Public Health. I did say that the Bill was not intended to represent the ultimate policy of the Fianna Fáil Party on the matter of old age pensions.
Comment on this
That does not arise at all. I want to say that no matter by whom the Bill was introduced when it was introduced it became the property of the House. It did not belong to any particular Party. I want to put it to Deputies here and now, that if Deputy O'Connell is not elected, who is going to give effect to the Bill and how are the old age pensioners to benefit by the decision which this House came to on Thursday last?
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy that the House must either vote for Deputy O'Connell if there is any regard for the honour of this House or dissolve and go to the country. But Deputies know very well that if Deputy O'Connell is not elected there will be no question of going to the country, no question whatever. I think it is necessary for me in this House of which Deputy O'Connell has been a member for close on eight years, to say that he is a Deputy who is suited in every way to fill the honourable position of President of the Executive Council. I cannot claim and I would not dream of claiming for Deputy O'Connell all the superior qualities which have been claimed for Deputy de Valera. I would not insult him by doing it.
Comment on this
I would say this, that Deputy O'Connell is a man of the people of Ireland, one of the Irish people coming from the farming stock in this country, he is a man of intelligence who knows the people, knows what they want and who is prepared to give effect to their wishes.
Comment on this
I decided a good many years ago to leave that Deputy very severely alone. I do say this, that I think it is unfortunate and not at all desirable that these interruptions should be made in the very serious matter under consideration.
Comment on this
Quite serious. So serious is this proposition which Deputy MacEntee says is not serious at all, that Deputy Lemass stated publicly on Sunday last that he and his Party were going to vote for it. Why did they consider it serious on Sunday and ludicrous yesterday?
Comment on this
The trouble is that the Deputy is always joking. I put this to the members of Fianna Fáil and to the members of the Independent group who voted for the Bill on Thursday last, and with particular force I put it to Deputy Redmond, that on their attitude and on Deputy Redmond's own statement in the House to-day they all must vote for Deputy O'Connell. Deputy Redmond told us the reason he would not vote for Deputy de Valera was because Deputy de Valera would not state where he and his Party stood with regard to the Treaty and the Constitution.
Comment on this
He stated also another reason why he could not vote for Deputy de Valera. That reason was because the Deputy was more concerned with getting a Republic in our time than he was with dealing with the economic ills of the country. We say that there are thousands of people unemployed, thousands of people who require houses and who require food and clothing, and we state clearly and emphatically that we are satisfied that within the Treaty we have all the freedom which we require for the full economic development of this country. We are satisfied on that point and if we find at any time there is anything in the Treaty which will prevent us from giving full effect to our economic policy and our social policy, then we propose to get the best brains of this country—the best intellects that the country can produce—the very best men—to go across to England and have it out with the English people on the question of the Treaty.
Comment on this
I said that the Labour Party, if they found there was anything in the Treaty which would hamper them in giving full effect to their economic and social policy, were prepared to get the best brains of the country, go across to England and meet the other party to the Treaty in ordinary negotiations and use the machinery used by every civilised country in the world and so try to arrange our differences in that way. That is our policy, and unless we are able to do that in the ordinary way, having the best brains of the country employed in order to put our case against whatever case England may put up, I do not believe there is any other same way of doing it. That is the way we propose to do it, and I believe the country will agree with us in that policy. I do not want to go further into the matter now, but I say that if Deputy O'Connell is elected to-day, within twenty-four hours he will put before the House a Government which I believe will command the confidence not only of Deputies here but of the country. In conclusion, I want to say that so long as we are sent here by people who want the Treaty and who want us to get the last ounce out of the Treaty —which we are prepared to do—we have no right to endanger that Treaty either directly or indirectly, and we are not going to do it.
Comment on this
The redeeming feature of the events of the last few days, since the resignation of the Government, is the fact that the people as a whole have kept their heads cool, even though the Free State Government resigned on Friday morning. The citizens of this State have at least come to the conclusion that they must continue to work and earn their living—those of them who have the satisfaction of getting work, regardless of whatever government may be in power. The only thing that matters to the people, in so far as they are concerned with the Government, is whether the Government that has gone out was a better Government than the one likely to be put in as a result of to-day's vote. The so-called political crisis which led to the resignation of the Government on Friday morning was created by the weakness of those who normally support the Government. About thirteen or fourteen Deputies—I am not quite sure of my ground in this matter—who normally support the Government, suffered on last Thursday night from what I call a temporary nervous breakdown, and they failed to respond to Deputy Duggan's whip to vote against the Bill moved by Deputy Ward. I suggest they suffered from a temporary nervous breakdown because they were afraid they could not face their constituents and justify their vote against the Bill.
Let the country recognise and realise that the so-called crisis has been created as a result of the weakness of the supporters of the Government in this House. What is the good of our Ministers going around this country and boasting about the independent status of this State and the democratic nature of our Constitution if the majority of the Deputies here will re-elect the Government that has flouted the majority decision of this House. It is for that reason that I have very great pleasure in seconding the nomination of Deputy O'Connell. He will maintain the independent status of this State and interpret the democratic spirit of the Constitution.
What was the reason given for the resignation of Deputy Cosgrave and his Government? I will quote from the report of the short speech which Deputy Cosgrave read on that occasion: "Last evening the Dáil passed the Second Reading of a Bill entitled the Old Age Pensions Bill, 1929, by a majority of two. In the course of the debate the Government, through the Minister for Finance, indicated their opposition to that measure, which proposed to impose a burden of some £300,000 per annum on the taxpayer. The cost of old age pensions to the State is already two and three-quarter million pounds sterling per annum, and the Government, having given the matter the most careful consideration, are not prepared to take the responsibility in the present financial situation of providing a further large addition to that sum which, while imposing a heavy burden on agriculture, trade and industry." and so on. Now I will, with the permission of the House, make an endeavour to draw up a balance sheet of the Government's financial administration concerning this State since they came into office. On the one side I will endeavour to picture what the Government did on behalf of the working-class people; the injury they did to the poorer section of the people in the interests of national economy, and, on the other side, I will endeavour to show the people of this country how the savings effected at the expense of the poor were handed over to the rich.
On the one side we have the Government, a couple of years after it was elected, coming in here and, as the first example of the fruits of freedom, introducing an amending Old Age Pension Bill which brought about a cut of 1/- in old age pensions, but which in reality when put into operation had the effect of making an average reduction of 4/- per week to those entitled to draw the pension. Subsequently they came along and cut the pay of the Civic Guard only a couple of years after that force was formed by themselves. They then came along and made a cut of 10 per cent. in the teachers' salaries. They subsequently came along and in the name of national economy took off the boot allowance of 1/6 which the Civic Guards hitherto drew. Next they cut down the Estimates for social services, which provide work by means of Land Commission improvement schemes, rural drainage schemes, and other schemes which provide work from State sources at the lowest standard of wages provided for any section of the community.
On the other side of the balance sheet we find that the money which they saved, or pretended to save, by cutting the old age pensions, by reducing the allowances of the Civic Guards, by cutting down teachers' salaries by 10 per cent., and by cutting the Estimates for the social services by 50 per cent., was handed over to the British Government, in the first place by way of a financial settlement signed by the late Minister for Finance. They subsequently came along, and, through what is known as the Compensation Property (Amendment) Act, 1926, provided a sum of between £350,000 and £400,000 of the taxpayers' money to be handed over to the people whose property was destroyed in the civil war, over and above the sum granted by the judges in the courts set up by themselves. That was, in the words of President Cosgrave, a gesture of friendship to the monied classes in this country for the purpose of enabling him to retain the consistent support of Deputy Thrift and Deputy Good in this House. They subsequently reduced income tax and supertax, pretending, as far as I can remember, to help the development of industry. Is there any Minister who will get up and show in what way the reduction of income tax and supertax has helped to create employment and develop industry since that reduction was put into operation?
They came along not very long ago, against the wishes of the Comptroller and Auditor-General and against the advice of the Public Accounts Committee, and handed out the sum of £216,000 over and above the amount voted by this House for gratuities to Army officers. These gratuities ranged from £3,000 per man downwards and on an average were about three times the amount given to officers who held similar rank in the British Army on their return to civil life after serving in the European war. We remember that on a recent occasion, notwithstanding the fact that the country is too poor to bear the cost of the Old Age Pensions Bill, that they voted a sum of £3,000 to the Irish Automobile Club so that the swanks in this country could hold motor races in the Phoenix Park. We have a proposal, moreover, by the Chairman of the Economy Committee, Deputy Heffernan, in the Estimates which are to be discussed in the near future to provide a sum of £48,000 for the broadcasting station, not, so far as one can judge from the conditions in the country at any rate, to amuse the old age pensioners. Looking at that review of the Government's financial history since they were elected in this House, how can any self-respecting man with any sense of responsibility to the democracy of this country vote for the re-election of that Government?
Comment on this
I stated at the beginning that the only alternative to the nomination now before the House was the re-election of the Government that resigned.
Comment on this
That the Government could not be worse than a Labour Government. That is what the Deputy means.
Comment on this
The President can tell the House and the country what he means by refusing to accept the majority verdict of this House and how he can justify it in view of the many plausible speeches which he has made in the last seven years about the democratic nature of the Constitution.
Comment on this
There are many people in this country, outside those who normally support the Labour Party, who believe that the only way out of the difficulty is to find some man outside those who have been actively associated with the civil war period. In putting forward the name of Deputy O'Connell we believe that we are endeavouring to find a man who, if elected, will bring us away from the associations and bitterness of the civil war period and who will nominate an Executive Council who will govern in accordance with the wishes of the plain people of the country. On that matter I hope Deputy Redmond will pardon me for reminding him of the speech he made in favour of that particular proposal. On the 16th August, 1927—I quote from the Official Debates of that date, columns 1686-7—Captain Redmond said:—
"We can hardly wonder, however, if the plain people of Ireland, tormented between the rival extravagances of President Cosgrave on the one hand and Deputy de Valera's on the other, are tempted to cry aloud ‘A plague on both your houses.'"
He meant, of course, a plague on the houses of Fianna Fáil and Cumann na nGaedheal. He proceeded to say:—
"I am thus brought to the proposition that we are not content to dethrone President Cosgrave in order to put Deputy de Valera in his place. Nor are we content to outlaw and expel Deputy de Valera in order to secure the throne in permanence for President Cosgrave. We want to see this wretched vendetta that is bedevilling the fair name of Ireland ended once and for all."
He suggested that we might find the President and Ministry from the Centre Parties, comprised as they were at that time of the Labour Party and the National League Party, and I suppose he also meant such of the Independents as might be acceptable to a President nominated by the Centre Parties. I would like to hear from Deputy Redmond what is the change in the situation, if any, which would justify him in withdrawing any of the words I have quoted.
Comment on this
No, but I suggest that his constituents are entitled to know if he has changed his mind. We had a trunk call from Nenagh the other day from the Minister for Finance and Deputy Séamus Bourke. In the speeches published in the newspapers last Monday they charged members of the Labour Party with being the most inconsistent body of Deputies in this House. We are, I admit, inconsistent in so far as we have failed to support consistently the policy of the Government in reducing the purchasing power of the people and in degrading the standard of living of the workers. I will make the Minister a present of that. What is their position? They have, as I have shown from the figures quoted, responded to the demands made upon them by Deputy Thrift and Deputy Good and of the people for whom they speak in every issue of policy that has come up during the last four or five years. Notwithstanding that fact, the Independents, I understand, are not satisfied with the attitude of the present Government. Here is a quotation, if I may be pardoned for quoting it again, from the "Irish Times," of the 29th March:—
"The outstanding moral of Thursday's accident is the need of new relations between the Government and the Independent Party. In plain terms, the Government must recognise its debt to the Party that keeps it in office. If it continues to ignore that debt the Independent members must begin to realise their duty to their constituents and must school themselves to use bravely the only weapon that all Governments fear."
Will any Independent Deputy tell us whether they have been able to get the new conditions which the Editor of the "Irish Times" wants them to impose on the Government, and will he tell the House what they are? I think that the Independent Party, which claims to represent seven per cent. of the people, have been treated far more liberally than the 30 per cent. Nationalists who have been ground down by Lord Craigavon and his Government in the North. Let us hear from the Independents whether they succeeded in getting the things to which the "Irish Times" claims they are entitled. The Government, by their conduct and actions, during the last five or six years have proved themselves capable of governing only in the interests of bankers, landlords, slum owners and gombeen men. Their policy has been guided on these lines, and there is no Labour Party, even though small in numbers, which would be worth its salt if it voted for the re-election of nominees of any such Government. I understand from the Press—and I readily recognise that Fianna Fáil do not always admit that reports in the Press are accurate—that some words of mine uttered at a public meeting in Malahide the other night have caused offence to some of the leaders of the Fianna Fáil Party. I want to say frankly and fairly that I am not prepared to withdraw one word of what I said on-that occasion. I am not prepared to qualify or modify one word, even for the purpose of getting support from Fianna Fáil for Deputy O'Connell's nomination. We are not asking for the votes of any Deputies under false pretences. Deputy O'Connell stated the position of this Party, and I hope it will be made clear for all time to the leader-writers of the different newspapers and to the leaders of other Parties who would like to create scares regarding our position on issues of fundamental importance. I submit to the supporters of the Fianna Fáil Party in the country, that if their Deputies refuse to vote for the nomination of Deputy O'Connell as President, they will be making it absolutely certain that some other person will be elected who will refuse to put into operation the Bill brought forward by Deputy Ward. The only thing for them to do is to vote for the nomination of Deputy O'Connell, and Deputies may take me as not begging for votes.
Comment on this
Even if I were on the border of starvation I would not like to beg from the Deputy. If Deputy O'Connell is elected as President he will, I admit, be unable to get a Ministry drawn from our universities, but, so far as I know his intentions, if he gets the confidence of the Dáil he will select as his Ministry a body of men who have experience in the workaday world, who will recognise the rights of their own country and who will govern it in accordance with the wishes of the people.
Comment on this
I wish to congratulate Deputy Davin on the very eloquent speech which he has just made. With that portion of it in which he criticised the economic policy of the Government I am in complete agreement. This Party, however, is not able to bring itself to take the proposal now before the House seriously. That a Party of thirteen Deputies should aspire to form a Government in a House of 153 Deputies seems to us to be ridiculous. Such a Government would be unable to follow any independent policy, and would be at the beck and call of Cumann na nGaedheal, which controls a majority in the House. It is, however, a matter of indifference to us whether Cumann na nGaedheal governs openly through Deputy Cosgrave or otherwise through Deputy O'Connell. If anything, we would prefer the former.
Comment on this
It is a matter on which we have no very strong opinions and, therefore, we do not propose to take any part either in this discussion or this division.
Comment on this
I am very glad to have the opportunity afforded me by Deputy Davin of explaining my attitude on this vote. Deputy Davin stated that on a similar occasion in the year 1927 I took a certain attitude. He did not say whether it was going to be a different one to the one I am about to take because, possibly, he does not know, and he did not say in what way the occasion was a similar one. Let me recall to the House the occasion on the 16th August, 1927, which is the one to which, I think, he referred. On that occasion there was a question of a Vote of Censure on the then Government. That vote was proposed mainly upon the grounds of opposition to what was known as the Public Safety Bill, afterwards the Public Safety Act. In supporting that Vote of Censure I made it perfectly clear that the main reason for my opposition to the Government at the time was my utter dislike of their proposals in the form of a Public Safety Act. To make that clear I used the following words: "The real gravamen of the case against the Government is the Public Safety Act." I then went on to describe the Act as being to my mind a complete abrogation of the constitutional rights of the citizens of this country. Whether I was right or wrong in my opinion as to the effect and nature of that Act the fact remains to-day that the Act has been repealed.
If Deputy Davin wants to know my reason for not opposing the election of the present Government Party on this occasion, it is because the Public Safety Act has been repealed, and I believe that the only Party that can successfully propose and constitute a Government in this House is the Party which is the largest in number and which can command the support of the majority of this House. I am aware that that is perhaps rather entering into what will possibly be the subject matter of our next debate, but Deputy Davin asked me my attitude and has suggested that it is a change of attitude. I merely desire to say that, having pressed for the repeal of the Public Safety Act, and the Government having for one reason or another—I am not claiming to have been the means of doing it—repealed the Act, I feel that I am entitled, as an independent Deputy, to support that Government now, which is the only Government that can possibly command a majority of the votes of the House.
I do not know whether Deputies remember the statement made by the late Mr. Kevin O'Higgins when Minister for Justice, on 23rd June, 1927, when there was a proposal made to elect the President of the Executive Council. He said that the motion of the Government Party to elect President Cosgrave would be withdrawn "if there is anyone in the Dáil who is prepared to form a Government and gives us reasonable prospects of securing sufficient support for that Government." I desire to support that statement to-day. What reasonable support is there for the election of Deputy O'Connell? Could he maintain a Government? It has been said he leads a small Party, and neither his proposer nor his seconder has in any way indicated how he is going to get the support of Deputies in any other quarter of the House. On the contrary, we have heard from Deputy Lemass, on behalf of the second largest Party in the House, that they will take no hand, act or part in the debate or in the division, and much less will they support Deputy O'Connell, if he is elected to the position of President.
I agree, to a large extent, with a great deal that has been said by the proposer and seconder with regard to Deputy O'Connell's personal qualifications for the position. That, however, does not enter into the matter at all. The question is whether he can, in his present position, command a majority of elected representatives in this House and whether he would in any conceivable way be able to carry on such a Government. I cannot see how he possibly could. The suggestion was made by Deputy Davin that if Deputy O'Connell was not elected it therefore followed that the Cumann na nGaedheal nominee must necessarily be elected. I do not follow that line of reasoning at all. I do not see why some member of the Independent group should not be proposed. I do not see why someone should not propose Deputy Coburn or myself for that matter.
Comment on this
We would be in absolutely the same position as Deputy O'Connell would find himself. When he would be elected to the position of President he could not command a sufficient majority in this House to carry on the necessary public work and the affairs of the State.
Comment on this
Therefore, I feel that it is out of the question to expect anyone at this stage to support the election of a Deputy, no matter how qualified personally he may be, for the conduct of the affairs of the House who is not able to carry on the affairs of the House by a majority of Deputies. Again, I desire to thank Deputy Davin for the opportunity he has given me to say now, as I have said elsewhere, for a considerable time, that my chief and main opposition to the Cumann na nGaedheal Government in 1927 was their introduction and passage of the Public Safety Act, and that because that Act has been repealed, on all main issues, especially those in connection with the safeguarding of the Constitution and the government of the country, and in the carrying out of our international and contractual obligations with others outside, I am at one with President Cosgrave. When the time comes to vote, if he is proposed, I shall support him, and I hope what I am saying now will be taken as meaning that I will not have to inflict any further words upon the House upon this subject at any other time this evening, which subject I think should be disposed of as quickly as possible in order to let us get on with the business of the country.
Comment on this
It may be sometimes for the public good to entrust a minority Party with the formation of a Government. That may occur when efforts to form a Government which had a firm majority behind it have failed, or it may happen when it is only desired to have a group to carry on the Government for a week or two, or a month or two, pending a general election. But I can hardly imagine any circumstances in which it would be justifiable to entrust the formation of a Government to a Party as small as the Labour Party now is. There are 11 Departments of State, and there are two sub-Departments which have been recognised as requiring a Parliamentary head, namely, the Land Commission and the Board of Works. It is, therefore, necessary, apart altogether from the question of a Whip, to have 13 members in the Government. There are just 13 members in the Labour Party, so that they would be all generals and there would be no rank and file. We are assuming for the moment that every man will make an excellent Minister. The position would be that all the members of the Labour Party would be Ministers. They would be carrying out the policy of the Labour Party. I think it is recognised that all Governments really should have people in the Parliament to support their policy who are not in office, because a Government which had no support of this kind in the House would be very liable, I think, to find it impossible to ascertain what a Labour man not in office would think about any particular matter that would come before them.
I believe that even if we had to spend two or three days here voting upon various propositions and failed to elect a President it would be still undesirable to elect Deputy O'Connell unless Deputy O'Connell was in a position to assure the House that he had got promises of support from outside groups that would at least give a rank and file for his Government. I gathered from the speeches of Deputy Morrissey and Deputy Davin that that had not been done. We are asked simply to put the Labour Party into office. I am sure An Ceann Comhairle would not allow me to answer, at least at any length, remarks made by Deputy Davin with regard to the economic policy of the Government. It seems to me that the economic policy of the Labour Party is to increase the social services irrespective of the capacity of the country, in its present state of development, to pay for them without forfeiting the prospects of further development; and secondly to depend to an undue degree upon State action for getting economic results. The view of the Government which has held office for some time, has been that while probably social services will continue to increase for a long time to come in all countries we cannot expect in a country which is economically undeveloped to have social services on the scale of countries that have made considerable progress and have a much greater accumulation of wealth to draw upon and, therefore, have much greater productivity to enable them to meet the charges that will fall upon them. We believe that while the whole question of social services must be sympathetically viewed, an eye must be kept, on the other hand, on the sources of production, and everything must be done to allow those sources of production to increase. We also believe that there are definite limits to the utility of State action by way of increasing productivity and bringing about economic prosperity. If the State tries to do too much it only prevents individuals who can venture more than the State from undertaking enterprise that they ought to undertake. The sketch that Deputy Davin gave of the economic policy of the Government was, of course, a travesty of that policy. I think it would be more in order to deal with it at a later stage of the present proceedings. I do not want to scout the proposal for the election of Deputy O'Connell simply because it seems to be a foregone conclusion, but I wish to oppose it because I think even if the House practically saw no other alternative it should hesitate before putting an entire Party into office.
Comment on this
I am glad that the Government, through the Minister for Finance, overcame their evident reluctance to take part in the debate on this motion. Being asked to intervene in this debate in support of the nomination made by the Labour Party, is to me, personally, a very high honour. In the very brief contribution to the debate made by Deputy Lemass he asked us to regard this nomination as a joke. I would like to say that the greatest joke in the recent political history of this country that we remember was the excuse made by Deputy Lemass's Party when they entered this House. It seems to me now from their declared attitude on this motion that they are going to repeat the policy that they recanted when they came into the House—that is, abstaining from having any responsibility for decisions come to on national matters.
This unquestionably is a serious nomination. It is important, and very important, because of the fact that the Party that makes it, in all seriousness to the House, is on the threshold of big developments in the life of this country—developments that we are sure will mean that they will be given a bigger responsibility and a wider invitation to take a bigger part in the life of this country in the future than they had been able to take in the past. Though we are not, perhaps, in a position to dispute the view of the Minister for Finance, that this motion is going to be negatived proof is not wanting that there are signs available that a motion in some what similar terms might be made in this House at no very distant date in very different circumstances. I am sorry the Minister for Finance did not elaborate more than he did, in another place, on the incapacity of the Labour Party to govern.
Comment on this
During the past few days we have heard epithets in connection with the Labour Party flung about like "inconsistency" and the term "ludicrous" was used. The term "incapacity" figured more than once in the contributions that have flooded the papers for the last few days. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance is absolutely convinced of the inconsistency of the Labour Party. In an extremely interesting address delivered in Nenagh on Sunday he ranged an attack over such interesting subjects as "race suicide,""divorce,""senile marriages," and proclaimed our inconsistency to his audience. My first comment on that would be this, that if Deputy Bourke had any regard for consistency, or even for public decency, he would refrain from talking about incapacity in connection with any Party or any individual. I say that because I doubt if there would be any serious contradiction of the fact that he himself presents the greatest example of floundering incapacity that this House has ever known since it was set up. Surely, in the course of the statement delivered, I have no doubt in the usual lucid fashion in which he approaches questions of this kind, the limit was reached when the superseded Minister for Local Government, who got what used to be termed an Irishman's rise in 1927 from his President, went on to talk about people of work-shy mentality. There, at any rate, I bow to the absolutely intimate knowledge he had of the subject. There is no question whatever about his right and qualification to speak upon that subject. I want to be merciful, and I only want to say a few words more. If Deputy Bourke has any capacity there was very little evidence of it manifested in this Chamber, and I want to say, in addition, that if a regrettable feature in the life of this country at present is the abnormal number of senile marriages, it is equally regrettable we should have the senile statements that Deputy Bourke has made. We give him credit for one thing, at least, and that is that he was endeavouring to make some atonement for his undoubted incapacity. Perhaps he was trying to make easy his lot for his absence here last week, and with an Executive which must be by now heartily sick of him indeed.
Deputy Heffernan, another lieutenant of the Minister for Finance, has no faith in our capacity either, but he has another fear, and it is this, that our policy would be dictated from outside. No doubt we recognise Deputy Heffernan's high qualification to speak of capacity to govern. We are also keenly conscious of his undoubted capacity for intelligent utterances both in this House and outside of it, and of course there are very few in this House better fitted to speak where the question of the independence and policy of a Party are concerned than Deputy Heffernan. Deputy Heffernan is very highly qualified in that respect indeed. In that connection, I think I could say safely that the chorus of highly hysterical utterances that have been given expression to about the Labour Party during the last three or four days would have been complete if we had had a contribution from such a highly constructive and consistent statesman as Deputy Esmonde. I think that the whole atmosphere, the whole chorus as it were, would have been absolutely complete if we had a statement of that kind from Deputy Esmonde also. I want to say this seriously, that this whole thing would be regarded as a capital joke if there were not still in the country a number of people who are inclined to take utterances of that kind seriously. There must be a large number of people down the country who do not know intimately the speakers whom I have referred to and who would be inclined to think, by reason of the position that they occupy, that they are capable of serious utterances. The fact that there are such people in the country renders statements of this kind somewhat more serious.
The Minister for Finance, when speaking on Sunday, was in a very different frame of mind to what he was in this evening. The howling lion on Sunday became the cooing-dove a few days afterwards. The Minister was certainly in his best jack-boot style on Sunday evening when he was tearing to pieces the jelly-fish Labour Party.
If there is any role that the Minister for Finance likes to shine in it is that of the man of iron. I always prefer to think of him as a tin-pot Bismarck, and I want to tell the Minister that I think he cuts a very poor figure indeed in that role. That was not the first historic statement that the Minister made in that county. Early in 1922 in this House he was reminded of a statement that he made in, I think, Thurles under very different conditions some years ago. The Minister was on that occasion on his trial by the British for his connection with certain phases of the National movement at that time. I would like to hear him contradict my assertion that his statement in his own defence was about the greatest exhibition of jelly-fish mentality that we could have or that ever has figured even in the annals of that movement.
Comment on this
Surely the statement is not relevant to this debate. The House is debating the motion that Deputy Tomás O Conaill be nominated President of the Executive Council.
Comment on this
And I am engaged, with all respect, in endeavouring to reply to lying charges that have been made about the incapacity of Labour to select a President and to govern as we think we ought to be governed. Perhaps it is inconvenient to remind the Minister of statements like that now, statements made at a time when his hectic newspaper articles and hectic speeches reached less cautious people to encourage them to do what the Minister himself was careful not to do. In more recent times, we had a clear exhibition of how strong and stern the Minister was on one of the things that perhaps would be termed fundamental. I refer to the period when the late lamented representative of this country on the Boundary Commission woke up suddenly and discovered that we had lost six counties, and when the Minister for Finance in his own constituency at Emyvale shook his fist at the British Government and at Mr. Justice Feetham and made the welkin ring with his uncompromising utterance. He is reported to have said——
Comment on this
Surely the Deputy is not demonstrating the capacity of the Labour Party at all. I do not wish to hamper the Deputy in demonstrating the capacity of the Labour Party, and particularly the capacity of Deputy Tomás O Conaill to be President of the Executive Council but the Deputy is demonstrating something quite different. There is really no connection between demonstrating the kind of person the Minister for Finance is, or was, and Deputy O'Connell's capacity to be President of the Executive Council.
Comment on this
I am proceeding to show that Labour is capable of governing. I think it would clear the air if I were to show how incapable other people are when they start to criticise Labour.
Comment on this
As I have said, I do not want to hamper the Deputy at all, but he is not demonstrating the capacity of the Labour Party to govern but is demonstrating, for example, that the Minister for Finance is in fact a jelly-fish.
Comment on this
I am not very anxious to pursue the matter. I have no doubt but that I will get another opportunity of getting it out here or elsewhere. Deputy Lemass, during the last few days, expressed the view that the idea of a Labour Government was ludicrous. In the most ludicrous manner possible the Deputy proceeded to change his whole policy with regard to the nomination of Deputy O'Connell to be President of the Executive Council. I have heard no indication, in the course of this debate, as to why the Fianna Fáil policy on this matter has been changed. I heard no serious objection to the position of Labour on the Treaty as defined by Deputy O'Connell to-day. I heard no serious objection to the economic policy of Labour as defined, and I want to know exactly where the snag is in the whole story?
The newspapers this morning contained the statement that the change of front that has taken place within the last day or two was caused by the statement made by Deputy Davin in Malahide on Monday night last. I have not seen a word in that statement in any way different to the statement the Labour Party has made on this question. I made statements like it on dozens of occasions in my own constituency. I stand completely over the position he has taken up. If there is any word in it that Deputy Lemass is anxious to take objection to it appeared to me it is the word "equivocation" in connection with the question of the acceptance of the Treaty. Does the Deputy want the equivocation that has surrounded this whole question to continue? I am sick of equivocation in this matter, and I think it is quite time it should be definitely settled, and that we should know where we are in regard to the whole question.
If the statement by Deputy Davin would do nothing else than clear up all the slush that has been written about alliances between one Party and another it will do a great deal of good, and if it will help to prevent the fairy tales that reach unfortunate people down the country about dark and sinister alliances made here, there and everywhere, from being repeated it will have done a great deal of good. If it took all this time for either or both of the political Parties to ascertain what our attitude on this major question was or is it is a very poor tribute to their intelligence, but it certainly is not our responsibility. I would be very much surprised if the policy of Deputy O'Connell, put into operation—if this motion were carried by the House—would not effect more in as many months than other policies have effected in years. If Deputy O'Connell would not be capable of tackling with more vision and capacity than the Executive Council who are charged with responsibility in the matter the question of unemployment, I would be very much disappointed, and if there is anybody here who wants a discussion on the question of what has happened the Labour Government in England then we can arrange a time to have it discussed. Interjections of the kind we have had will not get us away from this particular point at all. I believe that Deputy O'Connell would be able to tackle the job and bridge the gap between our social services and the infinitely better services of other countries, and that prevail in another part of this country.
I want to come back to what the Minister for Finance said about the economic policy of the Labour Party, that it was to enlarge the social services without the smallest regard to the source of production. The agricultural policy of the Labour Party was published some years ago. That policy is indicated in the clearest possible terms. It was laid down that it would be the duty of the Labour Party to exploit the natural resources of this country and to develop production. The essential standard of services we visualise could be met without imposing any heavy burden on the State. The Minister is not going to get away with the clever camouflage that Labour suggests that all the drain should come out of the services, and that the natural result would be that the country would be run into national bankruptcy. The Minister deprecated State action, which he says is the policy of the Labour Party. The Government has been responsible for more schemes involving State action in the last three or four years than the Labour Party if given office could put into effect for a long time. It has been responsible for State intervention in connection with the purchase of creameries, the Shannon scheme, the railways, and in many other directions. The Government, I have no doubt, does not wish to disown State action.
I do not think Deputy O'Connell could be accused, if he were given responsibility, of doing things that others could be accused of having done, or of things such as have been started recently by the present Executive. Deputy O'Connell, I am sure, would refuse to give effect to a proposal, seriously made in this House, to revive the worst form of the old landlord system by reserving a corner on the public boards for the privileged class of this country, and I feel certain that no Labour Government—certainly not a Labour Government in this country—would sanction local government being transformed in the way it is in this country at the moment. Other Deputies than members of the Labour Party have given expression to that view. The control of local government in this country is being transformed into a detestable tyranny, and the Labour Party would be definitely and determinedly against that policy. Under a Labour Government we would have had no strike in the Post Office, or trouble in other directions where we have evidence of dissatisfaction and irritation.
There is another consideration, and perhaps it is one of the most important. In the opinion of this Party, and in the opinion of a growing number of people in this country, one of the greatest needs at the moment is a Centre Party Government. Deputy Redmond, in his speech this evening, was afraid to give support to a minority Government. Deputy Redmond went perilously near accepting that position two years ago in this House. I think it would not be an exaggeration to say that Deputy Redmond accepted that position. I do not want to say anything more in connection with Deputy Redmond's attitude this evening. I repeat, there is a growing volume of opinion in this country in favour of a Centre Party Government, and the relegation, for the time being, at any rate, to an arena other than political of the big figures in the two big Parties in this country. I am satisfied, from the course of the debate this evening, that the number of people who are thinking in that direction will be very largely increased when they read their newspapers to-morrow. Certainly there was material in the debate this evening for a conclusion of that kind. The policy of this Party is one of peace. The record of this Party since its inception has not been marred by anything such as could be mentioned in other connections. There are no bitter memories to be wiped out in connection with the Labour Party.
I could put that a great deal stronger. I regard the proposal to elect Deputy O'Connell as President of the Executive Council as an attempt to get what was described by Deputy Morrissey as the last ounce out of the form of government under which we live, and to develop the economic life of the country under the Treaty as far as possible, to increase the social services in the country, to encourage production in the country, and, above all, to wipe out the memories, the bitterness and the hatreds that have disfigured the face of this country and marred any hope of real progress in it during the last five or six years. That particular aspiration may not be realised as a result of this motion this evening, but unquestionably the time is coming nearer, and I think when it does come that we, at any rate, will be given credit for having done something to bring it nearer, and having brought it nearer, for having done something to realise in the truest sense of the word the most urgent need and vital consideration that should affect the lives of the people in this country.
Comment on this
When I came into this House first I hoped to see some kind of an alliance between the Labour Party and our Party for the good of this nation, but by degrees, according as I got to know the personnel of that Party, I lost all hope. Some time ago, in this House, I called this place a circus. I was reproved on that occasion by the members of the Labour Party, who always stand for the dignity of the Chamber. But the solemness of this debate has been rudely intruded upon by the comic opera of the last half hour, the comic opera of 13 members out of 150 suggesting the formation of a Government. We have heard a lot about policy. The Minister for Finance tonight told us that there would have to be 13 Ministers out of the Labour Party. I wonder what the attitude of these 13 would be on such a matter as the land annuities? That question came on for debate in this House some time ago on Deputy de Valera's motion to withhold the land annuities. I find that five of the Labour Party voted in favour of withholding them and seven voted against, including Deputy O'Connell as one of those who voted against. There were also Deputy Davin, Deputy Anthony, Deputy Murphy and Deputy Morrissey. Surely Deputy O'Connell realises tonight that his Cabinet is split irrevocably on that question.
Comment on this
Whoever proposed this to-night will want a straight-jacket. Imagine, as Minister for Defence, General Mark Anthony with his wooden gun; fancy this nation being defended by such a stalwart military champion as Deputy Anthony. I do not want to follow that up, but when we hear statements about the last ounce out of the Treaty and the irreducible minimum from the Labour Party, and when we look at their vote on the matter of withholding three millions which would be of great assistance—five voted in favour of withholding and seven were against—one could really imagine Deputy Redmond being proposed as President to-night. I expected he would, but I suppose he could not find agreement within his Party. I notice they very often take different lines here. I am very grateful to the Labour Party for having created a lighter vein by this motion. I agree with most of what they have said about the Government Party, but the idea that enters into their minds seems to be "You have fought and suffered from 1916 to 1925 or 1926, the two sides of you. Now get out and we will reap the profit."
Comment on this
That is the idea that seems to be at the bottom of this proposal. I admit there is one Deputy in the Labour Party whom I might be prepared to support?
Comment on this
I think the country would welcome Deputy Hogan. Any Deputy who showed the self-sacrifice that Deputy Hogan showed here——
Comment on this
You are as far apart as the poles. Now, General, you will not get the budget this time.
Comment on this
The wooden gun. I am sorry you did not grow a meigeal. You would look better like a goat all right, but you could not grow the whiskers. Anyway, I do not think that the introduction of 13 members here as a Ministry would do any good. I notice that the Minister for Finance made an allusion here a while ago to the fact that he was going to have two new Ministries. One of them was to be the Ministry of Public Works. I suppose that was, as a result of the suggestion to the Independents in the "Irish Times" that they should get their price. I hope when he is giving out this Ministry for Public Works that he will not forget Deputy John Good.
Comment on this
I did not intend to contribute anything to this word-picture of all our heroes, but the proposer and seconder of this motion made certain allusions which I think need a reply. Deputy Morrissey, in proposing that Deputy O'Connell be nominated as President, offered some ready-made advice and gave a challenge; and we had the burlesque of Deputy Davin towards the Independents, especially those who voted for the motion on the Old Age Pensions Bill. As one of those, I want to say that I believe in what I did on that occasion. I advocated it before I came into this Dáil, and I feel consistent in continuing to advocate it. The other Independents can speak for themselves on that question, but, to my mind, both of these Deputies stopped short because they said if we want to put the Bill into operation we have got to vote here and now for Deputy O'Connell, while they gave us no indication of how Deputy O'Connell, with the best will in the world, was going to carry it out. As a great many of the speakers pointed out, the whole force at his command would be thirteen.
Comment on this
The Labour Party has gone to great pains to show us that they have no alliance with any other Party in the House. They have not even thrown a gesture to the Independents. I think if they had offered them at least two seats in the Cabinet there would be something to be said for them. Instead of that, they go round in a hostile manner and shout denunciations of every Party in the House, and then they say they can carry out this measure that passed the Second Reading the other day. I do not think that anyone could believe that they mean serious business, because they do not give us any indication of how it could be carried out. Deputy Davin went very far in his speech in denouncing the Independent group. He told us that we had already got far too much and that the people whom we represented in this case had got far too much at the hands of the Government, and that there were people in another State who had not got nearly so much. There are people in other places who can reply to that, and reply satisfactorily, I am sure. I can only say that since I came into this House I have been in the Independent group and, to my knowledge, that Independent group have never asked for or got any sops from the Government. They have acted, as far as I know, in an independent manner, without any reward being held out, and it comes badly from a Party that must admit that they have got a few crumbs from the present Government.
I say frankly and openly that I admire Deputy O'Connell in many ways. He has shown great ability in the leadership of his Party and in his work outside this House. He is a man that no one can cast a stone at. Up and down the country he has been praised for his work, and deservedly praised, but the Labour Party is asking an impossible thing in asking to have him nominated President at the present time. If he were nominated it would only create a situation that we would have to meet in a day or two again. We were told that if Deputy O'Connell were elected President in 24 hours he would have a Ministry to carry on the Government of this country. What would be the position before the 25th hour would be out? The Cabinet would be gone and we would be asked to elect another President. As one of those challenged in regard to our votes on the Old Age Pensions Bill, I cannot support this motion that Deputy O'Connell be nominated President, because it leads nowhere. The proposer and seconder have not told us that they can deliver the goods. If there is no alliance how would they get a majority to carry the Bill through the House? I must oppose the motion. That does not mean, as far as I am concerned, that the one section in the Old Age Pensions Bill which caused all this will be lost sight of. There will surely be another day to reckon with that, instead of electing a President from a Party of thirteen.
Comment on this
Having what I believe to be, anyhow, a slight appreciation of jokes, I would like to participate in this huge joke, the best joke of the evening, the nomination which is before the House. As Deputy Lemass has pointed out, we look upon it as nothing more or less than a joke. I want to reassure those in the country and in the House who have not the sense of humour which we claim to have lest they might misunderstand this hypocritical gesture on the part of certain Deputies in this House. First of all, we have Deputy Morrissey telling us that if Deputy O'Connell is not elected to the position of President of the Executive Council there is only one alternative and that is the election of President Cosgrave, and for those who do not agree with that there is an honourable alternative, namely, to dissolve and go to the country. He challenged those who supported the Old Age Pensions Bill which brought about the defeat of the Government and who are not prepared to support the implementing of it to go to the country. If there was any sincerity in that challenge why did he and his Party not take the only practical step which must be apparent to any intelligent member of this House and support the nomination made by the second largest Party in this House? I put that to any fair-minded Deputy. Deputy O'Connell's nomination I assert is nothing short of humbug. The attitude of his Party from the inception of this State has been one of humbug and neither he nor his colleagues ever intended to shoulder any governmental responsibilities in this country. Had they intended to do it they would have had the courage to nominate a sufficient number of candidates to give the people an opportunity of saying whether they wanted a Labour administration or not.
They did not do that on any occasion, and I am quite certain they never will. I hope to see the day that they will. Then we will know where the people stand in this matter. I want to make it perfectly clear that if I believed for one moment that the Labour Party represented real Irish Labour, that if we had as an alternative to the present administration a real Irish Labour Party, nothing would prevent me giving them my support and doing everything in my power to have them elected to administrative responsibilities in this State. In this connection I am referring particularly to the front bench of the Labour Party. The front bench of the Labour Party, as has been pointed out by Deputy Corry, was divided on a major issue some time ago, and quite recently on other issues. We had one outstanding issue which, to my mind, was in defence of a fundamental principle, the right of a Deputy to exercise his rights and privileges as a member of this House, and taking the only honourable course when he was denied that right, namely, to get out of the position which this House thrust upon him. What happened? His coleagues found a substitute on that front bench.
Comment on this
That is the extent of the solidarity, sincerity and honour which this great Irish Labour Party boasts of. There is another aspect of it. If we are serious in looking for an administrative council, they have neither intellectual ability nor a national outlook sufficient to warrant us giving them such a thing as serious consideration. They have told us that if Deputy O'Connell were elected to the position of President he would send the best brains in this country to negotiate with the British signatories to the Treaty in order to revise it where necessary. Where are the best brains in the country? In the Labour Party. I presume Deputy Anthony would be entrusted with the office of Minister for External Affairs. We can imagine Deputy Anthony or Deputy Davin going over there to revise the Treaty in the interests of the Irish people. Let them, first of all, give us some indication that they have some understanding of the real needs and requirements of the Irish people. Let them, first of all, give us some indication that they have some allegiance to national ideals and to national fundamentals. These prominent members of that group have never given any indication that they had the slightest sympathy with the national ideals which, I think, should be placed in the forefront of every Irishman's activities, both public and private. Of course we can hear them on all matters where thimble-rigging is introduced.
On such occasions they are the loud speakers put up here, and we have Deputy Davin this evening going into hysterics about the terrible conditions of unemployment, poverty and suffering which obtain throughout the country. Deputy Davin has had many opportunities here in this House to demonstrate his earnestness in connection with those matters, and on every occasion he has refused to toe the line, whether with those who have not only indicated the methods but have demonstrated their courage and ability to find a solution for these difficulties. I want to assure Deputy Haslett, from what I know of the ordinary people of the country, that his excuse for not helping to implement the Old Age Pensions Bill which was sponsored by a Deputy from his own constituency, will not satisfy the ordinary average intelligent voter at the next election, and I am quite confident that the Deputy will fail hopelessly, just as this Labour Group will also fail. Their nomination here this evening is in the form of eyewash in order to hide the real reason for their refusal to take what I said was the only practical step if they were really serious in their professed desire to have this Old Age Pensions Bill passed. Deputy Davin says that the most pleasing feature of the political crisis is the manner in which the people have kept their heads cool. I have not such a low estimate of the intelligence of the mass of the people. I believe that they have, after the last eight years, come to realise the game which is being played by those who control the Majority Party in this country and their allies. They and their allies are well known despite the efforts of the Press, despite the efforts of every evil influence in the country, they are well known to the average person of intelligence, and when the day of reckoning comes, as it will come, the nomination of Deputy O'Connell will only serve as a good front page joke for "Dublin Opinion" in the near future, and afterwards it will become a mere memory.
Comment on this
I am sure the House has been rather amused by the speech of Deputy Cooney and the speech of Deputy Corry. Deputy Corry reminded us that at one time he had compared this House to a circus. I did not know until then how it was that Deputy Corry and Deputy Cooney became members of this House. But now I know. They strayed into the wrong house—into the Dáil instead of into a circus. As is known to most of us since the days when we were young boys when we had great pleasure in going to a circus in the country, what used happen was that when the principals left the ring, as the principals left the front bench of Fianna Fáil this evening, the clowns came on to entertain the house until the principals came on again. I take it that is the explanation of the intervention of Deputies Corry and Cooney in the debate this evening.
Comment on this
I want to know if the expression that has been used by Deputy Morrissey is in order?
Comment on this
I would say it is contentious but I would suggest to Deputy Morrissey that it is hardly parliamentary.
Comment on this
If you, sir, say it is not parliamentary I as being a person with some regard for decency and as one who tries to do the right thing in the House will withdraw it. I hope the Deputy will follow the same line whether he is an ordinary Deputy or Deputy Speaker, a position that I think he will never occupy. The Deputy has accused the Labour Party of not representing Irish Labour. I did not know when the Deputy delivered that speech whether he was delivering it under the instructions of his constituents in Dublin City North or whether he was following out the instructions of his friends in Russia to whom he gives his whole-hearted allegiance. I do know this, that the Labour Party decided a good many years ago that Deputy Cooney was no acquisition to them and they parted company—
Comment on this
I am certain the Deputy knows very well what happened and I can tell the House what happened.
Comment on this
Read the official reports of the Dáil during the civil war. Deputy Morrissey has deliberately stated an untruth, and he is not in order.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey is in order; I will check him when he is not.
Comment on this
I did not interrupt the Deputy. I did not think it worth my while to interrupt him. The 250,000 Irish workers affiliated to the Trade Union Congress and the Irish Labour Party have just as much contempt for Deputy Cooney's views to-day as they had in 1921.
Comment on this
The Deputy told us that Deputy Haslett's excuse about the Old Age Pensions Bill would not be accepted. Would the Deputy tell us what he meant? Deputy Haslett made no excuse except what the Deputy himself made. Deputy Haslett voted for the Old Age Pensions Bill in the same way as Deputy Cooney and Deputy Haslett, like Deputy Cooney, in refusing to vote for the only man who is prepared to give effect to that Bill——
Comment on this
Oh, now, Deputies know that very well. What is the use of saying anything else? He is the only one now. Of course, sir, all this is the usual face saving. Deputy Cooney said the Labour Party were not sincere in putting Deputy O'Connell forward. The Labour Party, he said, were never prepared to undertake their responsibilities! It is well known in this House and to the people of the country that the Labour Party undertook their responsibilities in 1922 and have carried them out since. Deputy Cooney said that our Party did not put forward a sufficient number of candidates at the last election. If the Labour Party were prepared to go for the money which would be required to put forward a sufficient number of candidates to the same sources as the Deputy and his Party went, then they certainly could put forward more candidates.
Comment on this
We got no money from the British trade unions, I am sorry to say. We would be very glad to get it.
Comment on this
I submit that it would be at least as honourable for trade unionists in this country to accept financial aid from fellow trade unionists in another country to give effect to a policy upon which they are jointly agreed as it would be to pursue Irish servant boys and servant girls in America who were forced to leave this country. If this Party were forced or compelled— though I do not believe they will be —to make a choice between accepting assistance from fellow trade unionists in Great Britain or anywhere else and going around cadging with the hat in America, then I would decide upon accepting the money from British trade unions.
Comment on this
It is the old trouble. I am saying this quite seriously, and I do not want to give offence to anybody.
Comment on this
If Deputies in certain seats of the House are allowed to state their views without interruption, they in turn should allow other Deputies freely to express their opinions. I take it that Deputy Lemass and his colleagues are in favour of freedom of speech.
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass informed us that he could not take this proposal seriously, that the Labour Party was a minority Party, that the whole thing was a huge joke and that it was ridiculous. I was waiting to hear the Deputy tell us what happened since the speech on Sunday last in Mayo, as to make him come to that conclusion. Was it because the Deputy overstepped his authority when he said in Achill that he and his Party would vote for Deputy O'Connell? Are we to take it that he was called to book by the acting-leader of the Fianna Fáil Party and had to make the speech he made yesterday when he said that he would now have to force his view on the Party to vote against Deputy O'Connell? I do not pretend to be quoting the Deputy accurately.
Comment on this
The Deputy said he would strongly urge or press his views on his colleagues so that they would not vote for Deputy O'Connell.
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass did not say that the Fianna Fáil Party were going to vote for Deputy O'Connell. He said they probably would, which is quite a different thing.
Comment on this
I am prepared to hear Deputy Lemass rather than Deputy Aiken. Deputy Lemass ought to know what he himself said better than Deputy Aiken.
Comment on this
The Deputy will remember, I am sure, the year 1927 when he and his colleagues came into the House. They took that step after five years' consideration. They took the step that Labour took in 1922 when they came to the conclusion that it was the desire of the Irish people that they should enter the Dáil. It was no joke then for the Deputy and his Party when they were prepared to vote, in the words of some of his colleagues, a denationalised and brass-hatted Labour Party into office and, if they could, into power in this country. What has happened since then?
Comment on this
I know that the Deputy and his Party have changed absolutely. So far as the Labour Party is concerned, our attitude towards the Constitution, the Treaty and the institutions set up under the Free State Government is the same to-day as it was in 1922 and in 1927. There has been no change whatever on our side. All the change has been on the Fianna Fáil side, and I submit that if it was not a joke in 1927 it is no joke now.
Comment on this
I can understand the Fianna Fáil Party agreeing to almost anything at that particular time. That Party realised that its members were in a rather difficult position. It was realised that it was necessary in the interests of the country that it should be made easy for those Deputies to come into the Dáil and to fall in line with other representatives of the people and do what they could to assist the country economically. I want seriously to disagree with the idea put forward by Deputy Lemass and by the Minister for Defence, the idea that the House as a whole is subordinate to a party. It is not. Remember there is no party in this House with a clear majority.
Comment on this
No; there is no party in this House with a majority. We have been carrying on without having any one Party in the majority. I would remind the Minister for Finance that since the second election in 1927 a minority Government has been kept in power by other groups in the House. We must remember also that in both of the big parties there are many members who could agree upon economic and social questions, and who, I have no doubt whatever, would, if a Labour Government were in office, come together on social and economic questions. The suggestion of Deputy Lemass and the Minister for Finance, which was continued in Deputy Haslett's speech, was that if you put a Labour Government in office within twenty-four hours, they would be out of office in twenty-five hours.
I would suggest to the Deputy that a Labour Government which would want to be defeated would have a good deal of difficulty in framing a proposal, unless of course it was a proposal under some protection measure to give a guaranteed rate of Trade Union wages, which would bring the two big Parties into the Lobby against us. As far as I recollect, the only occasions upon which the two big Parties have come together and have gone into the one Lobby against the Labour Party, were occasions when matters were being discussed affecting the workers or the poor.
Comment on this
No. On the flour motion, the Deputy and his Party disagreed with the amendment to that motion which proposed that if there was going to be protection for the flour milling industry and the wheat industry there should be guaranteed wages, hours and conditions for the workers employed in that industry. That was the question of a fair wages clause. The next time we found the two big Parties ranged against the Labour Party was when the question of the reduction of the Civic Guard boot allowance was being discussed. On another occasion both the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies and the Fianna Fáil Deputies decided against the Labour Deputies that election to the Seanad by the people of Ireland was undesirable. Both Parties agreed in that. I am putting it in the light of what happened for the past two years, and I put it seriously to Deputy Haslett that it would be difficult for the Labour Government to frame any question which would get them defeated.
Comment on this
The Deputy's real objection against Deputy O'Connell's nomination—and in this he agreed with Deputy Redmond—was that we had not gone round seeking to buy votes, that we had not either offered Deputy Redmond, Deputy Haslett or somebody else a seat in the Cabinet if Deputy O'Connell were elected.
Comment on this
Oh, well! I have been pleasantly surprised that in this debate neither from Cumann na nGaedheal nor Fianna Fáil has there come any serious opposition to this proposal. Nobody has questioned the very clear and very explicit statement made by Deputy O'Connell this evening, a speech which set out clearly, without any equivocation, where the Labour Party stood both as to the fundamental political issues and so far as the main economic and social issues are concerned. The Minister for Finance and Deputy Lemass both fell back on the very lame plea that it was a joke. It is not a joke. It is put forward seriously. As Deputy Murphy stated in his speech a few moments ago, if Deputy O'Connell is not elected by this House as President to-night we are satisfied—and I believe both Cumann na nGaedheal and Fianna Fáil know this—that before we are very much older either Deputy O'Connell or some other Deputy of this Party will be proposed and elected President by the majority of the people of the country. When that happens, I am satisfied that a President put forward and elected by this Party will govern this country at least as well as it has been governed for the past seven or eight years.
Comment on this
Tá bród orm go bhfuil ainm agam-sa le cur roimh an Dáil mar Uachtarán ar an Ard-Chomhairle: fear tá mé cinnte agus atá me annso a toghfar—sin é Liam Mac Cosgair. O thainig an Dáil i réim, bhí an t-ainm sin faoi árdmheas ag an tír go léir. Tá raidhtigh ann "gur fearr an gníomh a cruthíutear ná an ráidhtigh bréige as béal na mbréagadóirí." Chruthuigh Liam Mac Cosgair an gníomh gach lá ó rinneadh Uachtarán de. Seacht mbliana ó shoin, toghadh é mar Chaptean ar an Saorstát nuair a bhí an long i measc maidhmanna agus fairrgí móra, stoirm agus gála. Anois, nuair a thug sé an long isteach ar an gciuineadas, tá daoine ag iarraidh an halamadóir do bhaint uaidh. Ach, sa tír seo, ar an gciuineadas féin, tá carraigreacha báidhte agus mara bhfuil eolas ag an gCaptaen ortha is contabharthach an rud é. Mar sin, ní maith an rud an Captaen d' atharú go mbeidh an long slán sábháilte feistithe sa gcéibh.
Anois, tar éis na mblian sin, chuaidh an tUachtarán go dtí an tír ag iarradh measa. Cuireadh air ais é. Chuaidh sé ann arís agus cuireadh air ais é, agus arís agus cuireadh air ais é, agus deirim-se dá dteigheadh sé go dtí an tír amáireach go gcuirfí air ais é dhá uair chó láidir. Nuair a hosclochas na daoine a gcuid páipéar amáireach agus nuair a fheicfeas siad go mbeidh Liam Mac Cosgair 'na Uachtarán ag stiúra na tíre arís beidh a gcroidhe ag preaba le spóirt go bhfuil sé air ais arís.
Ná ceapadh duine ar bith sa Teach seo gur amadáin an chuid is mó de dhaoine na tíre seo agus go meallfar le cáith iad. Ní meallfar. Teastuigheann an fíor-choirce uatha agus sé Liam Mac Cosgair atá in ann é d'fháilt dóibh. Ní choinneoidh mise moill ar an Teach ag iarraidh é do mholadh—tá a fhios ag an tír cé h-é féin. Tá a fhios aca céard a rinne sé ó thainig an Stát seo i réim; tá a fhios aca céard tá sé in ann a dhéanamh; teastuigheann sé uatha. Molaim-se é le bheith 'na Uachtarán ar an Ard-Chomhairle mar ní féidir linn duine chó maith leis d'fháil.
Comment on this
I would ask the House to consider the political, social and economic effects of the proposition which is now before it. I am perfectly certain that there are considerable numbers of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party who do not wish to have the full implication of Deputy Mongan's proposal analysed.
I know also that there are in the ranks of Cumann na nGaedheal a considerable number of Deputies who adopted in regard to the present Constitution the attitude which was taken up by those who sponsored the Treaty in Dáil Eireann in 1921, and who sponsored it to the country in the election which followed in June, 1922. I ask those members to consider what is the present position of Deputy Cosgrave in regard to that Treaty, and in regard to the promises which were made to the people in connection with it. We all of us remember the striking words of the late General Collins—that the Treaty gave not freedom, but the means to achieve it. What advantage have the late Government and Deputy Cosgrave taken of that opportunity? They have deliberately renounced and turned their backs upon the arguments and the principles which we understand animated the late Arthur Griffith and the late General Michael Collins. If these should linger in the minds of the Deputies of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, those of them particularly who have a national record, I would direct their attention to the statement made in this House by the acting Vice-President. Deputy Blythe, speaking on the Central Fund Bill on 22nd March, 1928, was reported in column 1645, volume 22, of the Dáil debates to have said: "With regard to the point as to whether we are aiming at the establishment of an Irish Republic, we are not." The Minister for Finance was the Vice-President in the late administration. I presume if Deputy Cosgrave is nominated President of the Executive Council that Deputy Blythe will again become Vice-President and Minister for Finance. Therefore, I am bound to assume that the policy which Deputy Blythe enunciated in this House on 22nd March, 1928, will be the policy of the administration which will be formed if Deputy Cosgrave is elected. We remember that we were told that the Treaty was to be used as a stepping-stone to the Republic. But now we have an authoritative declaration on the part of one of Deputy Cosgrave's colleagues that henceforward their advance is not towards the Republic but towards a closer association with the British Commonwealth of Nations. In Deputy Blythe's case possibly it is a case of political atavism. He has merely been thrown back to the political opinions and ideas of his forefathers. But in the case of Deputy Cosgrave it is something much more blameworthy. It is a deliberate recantation of the fundamental principles of Irish nationality. What a very far cry this declaration is from the days when the Treaty was put before the people. Then it was to be a stepping-stone to the Republic. Then it was, as I said, in the words of the late General Michael Collins, to be not freedom but the means to achieve freedom. Then it was in the words of Deputy Mulcahy: "None of us want the Crown. None of us want our harbours occupied by the enemy forces. None of us want what is said to be partition."
Comment on this
I am glad that Deputy Mulcahy was not shot. I am glad that he is here to answer the questions that I am going to put to him now. What has become of his protestations? He said in December, 1921, that he did not want the Crown.
Comment on this
He said in December 1921 that he did not want the enemy forces in our harbours. Does he want the enemy forces there now?
Comment on this
He said in December 1921 that he did not want this thing which is said to be partition. Does he want that thing now?
Comment on this
Except to connive at partition and acquiesce in the presence in our harbours of the enemy forces and to ask this Dáil to approve of a report which virtually saddles the Crown of Great Britain upon this State for all time? Deputy General McKeon is in the House and he was also in the Second Dáil. I am perfectly certain that in December 1921 he did not want the Crown. I am going to ask him does he want the Crown now? I am perfectly certain that in December 1921 he did not want the enemy forces in our harbours. Does he want the enemy forces there now? I am perfectly certain that in December, 1921 he did not want this thing called partition. Does he want that thing now? If he is prepared to answer these questions then I think he is in honour bound to say "no" to the proposition which has been put before the House.
Comment on this
I do not want to go back to the Treaty debates. At any rate, I pointed out then that the inevitable consequence of the acceptance of the Treaty would be the perpetuation of partition.
Comment on this
If Deputy Connolly wishes to make a speech I am quite prepared, after I have sat down, to listen to him, and I shall be glad to hear Deputy Connolly's defence of the merits of the proposition put before the House. I shall be glad to hear him defend as an Irishman the merits of the proposition put before the House.
Comment on this
I notice that Deputy Seamus Bourke is not in the House. He is also one of the people who were most strenuous in urging the acceptance of the Treaty on the grounds that it would be a steppingstone to the Republic. I want to know whether Deputy Bourke has gone hand in hand with the Vice-President and abandoned all desire to advance.
Comment on this
Just before 8.30 p.m. I should like to say that I think it was generally agreed the other day that it was desirable that the election of the President should be concluded as soon as possible, and I should like to move that, if necessary, the Dáil should sit until 12 o'clock for the purpose of concluding the business of electing the President.