We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Nomination of President of the Executive Council.

Contributions 394–585 of 585. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

As far as I can understand, there are a good number of Deputies on these benches who should like to speak on this proposition. It was mentioned to me yesterday by Deputy Boland that in conversation with the Ceann Comhairle and, I think, Deputy Duggan, it was tentatively agreed that the debate on the election of the President should be concluded to-night, but, I think, on the understanding that the speeches on the earlier propositions would be very brief and short. So far as our side is concerned, we have kept to that arrangement. With regard to brevity on the two propositions which have been before the House already, there is no fault, I think, to be laid on our shoulders that we have taken up a considerable amount of the time of the House, but I do not think it is possible, from what I have been told of the number of people who wish to speak, that we can conclude the debate even by 12 o'clock.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Does the Deputy suggest any other hour?

Comment on this

Is it necessary that it should be concluded to-night?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Deputy O'Kelly was in a great hurry last week to have the matter decided.

Comment on this

Certainly, I am still of the same opinion that it should be concluded early, and if Deputies on the President's own Front Bench were less long-winded we would have concluded it earlier.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

The palm is with Deputy Lemass, who took three minutes more than anybody else.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Kelly took eleven minutes, Deputy O'Connell twenty-one minutes, Deputy Desmond Fitzgerald thirty-one minutes, Deputy Lemass thirty-four minutes, Deputy Hogan thirty-one minutes, Deputy Redmond thirteen minutes, and Deputy O'Kelly twenty-nine minutes in reply.

Comment on this

Go on to the next debate. I only spoke for one minute.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Can we not have tabloid speech?

Comment on this

Will the President guarantee that we will have tabloid speeches from his side? We have given some examples.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

It is not usual for the Ceann Comhairle to intervene on questions of this kind, but the nomination of a President is a special matter. There is, I think, something in the proposal that the House, when it meets to nominate the President, should, if at all possible, conclude the business in the one sitting, and by agreement. Under the Standing Orders, technically the motion to sit late should be moved before 6.40, but now, as we usually sit until 10.30, that must be considered to be 8.30.

Perhaps it could be agreed that this debate should be continued until 10.30 and, then, that objection would not be taken on technical grounds if it is proposed to sit longer, because after the debate has gone on for another two hours the House will be in a better position to decide whether it wants to sit later or not.

Comment on this

I agree, and I am quite willing, and our Party are willing that the debate should be concluded as early as possible. But the matter is a most important one. If there are a number of Deputies on this side who think they have something to contribute to the debate they ought not to be closured on an important matter like this. I am quite willing to waive any technicalities at 10.30 to a motion that the House should sit on till 12 o'clock.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

We will postpone the consideration of the motion then until 10.15.

Comment on this

I cannot understand why, first of all, the acting Minister for Finance had not the manners at least to rise in the House before I began my speech and give intimation of his motion. I can quite understand that this has been an opportune interruption for the Minister, because I notice that a number of Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies to whom I was going to put the same series of awkward questions, including the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, have taken the opportunity to leave the House. Very well, let them carry their shame with them. I am quite well aware that the Minister did not want to hear the excuses and the arguments that were used for the acceptance of the Treaty in 1922.

Comment on this

I wonder would it be consistent with the invitation to deal with this matter from this side of the House in tabloid fashion, to ask us to outline in a speech on this motion the splendid consistency and logic which exists in some of our actions, extending over a number of years—to deal in one speech with our speeches on the Treaty in 1922.

Comment on this

It was the President asked for the tabloid speech, not we.

Comment on this

I quite agree that the Minister has been consistent ever since he became pro-British, and that he has become firm and almost Cromwellian in his mentality and consistency.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

As to the Treaty debates, will the Deputy explain what quotations he proposes to give from the Treaty debates?

Comment on this

I am going to leave them but only to point out that ex-President Cosgrave's Party have deliberately abandoned the line of advance from the Treaty; they have renounced whatever possibilities of constitutional development there may have been in the Treaty. They have disembowelled and mummified it. They keep it now as an object of superstitious reverence, a sort of political fetish, so that whenever any member of their Party becomes a little restive it is trotted out by the President or the Minister for Finance, or the Minister for Agriculture, or the Minister for Local Government, who say: "Hush, hush, the Treaty! The bones of our fathers! The blood of the dead!" And at once the restive members of Cumann na nGaedheal are quelled.

Comment on this
Timothy Sheehy Mr. T. Sheehy (Cork) Cumann na nGaedheal

You are sneering at the Treaty which brought you in here.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I want to know from the Deputy what use he proposes to make of the Treaty debates.

Comment on this

I shall make no more use of them now. At once the spirits of Cumann na nGaedheal are quelled and fall down to adore Deputy Cosgrave as the keeper of the constitutional cold mutton. That is what the Treaty has become—dead mutton—something to be kept in cold storage, as Deputy O'Connell says. Cumann na nGaedheal has no longer any use for the Treaty. It has become an embarrassment to them, because, in view of the circumstances surrounding its acceptance in this country, it imposed upon those who sponsored the Treaty the obligation of working for independence in this country. But Cumann na nGaedheal statesmen have now a much wider field than an island offers them. Their ambition has outgrown their insular environment. They are anxious to posture as Dominion statesmen. The whole wide world will henceforth be the range of their activities. They want to be leaders in Dominion affairs, real bigwigs in Buckingham Palace. A "thriftless ambition that will ravin up thine own life's means" compels them to destroy whatever there was in the Treaty which might enable that instrument to be used as a weapon to secure the independence of this country, and instead of the Treaty they are now substituting the vague and ambiguous declarations made at the Imperial Conference.

[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]

Now, with regard to that, we come to another point, because it seems to me that there has been a deliberate change of policy in the Cumann na nGaedheal Party since 1926. The Report of the Imperial Conference of 1926 was not submitted to this House, but the Report of the Conference held in 1929 was submitted to this House, and for a very definite reason. Prior to 1929 British statesmen had admitted the right which Dominion statesmen claimed that the Dominions could, if they wished, peaceably, and of their own volition, secede from the British Commonwealth of Nations. Paragraph 60 of the Report of 1929 is designed to deprive members of the British Commonwealth of Nations of the constitutional right to secede which they previously possessed, and the reason why that document was submitted to this House was in order that the House, by ratifying it, might deprive itself of this constitutional right.

Now I do not wish to be misunderstood. The natural right which we possess to be independent is one thing. The constitutional right which the statesmen of other Dominions had won is another. If the people of this country desire to secede they have a perfect right and liberty under God to do so. Furthermore, they were in this strong position, that Great Britain had already admitted that right in the case of those with whom they were supposed to be co-equal. The point in regard to the Imperial Conference which I wish to make is this: that the late Government, under the Presidency of Deputy Cosgrave, got this House to renounce voluntarily that right which had already been conceded to the Free State. The House when it approved of that report, did wrong. It has the opportunity to-night of undoing that wrong; it has the opportunity now of retrieving that position because the person who was responsible for submitting this document to the House and for securing approval of this document, particularly paragraph 60 of it, is no longer in office, and the House can exercise its right and refuse to put him back in office. Having done that, the previous ratification of this document will be cancelled.

I have referred to the effect of paragraph 60 of the Report of the Imperial Conference. I would like to read that paragraph in order that the House may be fully aware of its implications:

Inasmuch as the Crown is the symbol of the free association of the members of the British Commonwealth of Nations, and as they are united by a common allegiance to the Crown, it would be in accord with the established constitutional position of all the members of the Commonwealth in relation to one another that any alteration in the law touching the Succession to the Throne or the Royal Style and Titles shall hereafter require the assent as well of the Parliaments of all the Dominions as of the Parliament of the United Kingdom.

I have already referred to the constitutional implications of that passage so far as they relate to our right to secede. I ask the House to consider a further implication. It will be noted that, if the existing law relating to the succession to the Throne or the Royal Style and Titles, as they are called, be hereafter altered or amended the assent is required not only of the Parliament of the United Kingdom but also of the Parliaments of all the Dominions. Now what is one of the major implications of that passage?

As you all know, the present succession to the Throne of Great Britain and, according to the theory of Deputy Cosgrave and his associates, to the Throne in the Irish Free State, is regulated by the Act of Settlement. The Act of Settlement was passed in June, 1701. It is not a dead letter. It regulates to the present day the succession, as I have said, not only to the Throne in Great Britain, but also, according to the theory of Deputy Cosgrave and the members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, the succession to the Throne in the Irish Free State. That Act of Settlement settled the succession to the Throne upon the descendants of Sophia, the Dowager Duchess of Hanover and the heirs of her body being Protestants. It further provides that all occupants of the Throne shall be in communion with the Church of England. That is the law at the present moment. It regulates the succession to the Throne, and again I emphasise that, according to the theory of Deputy Cosgrave, it also regulates succession to the Throne in the Irish Free State. The occupants must be Protestants and must be in communion with the Church of England.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Was not this Report fully discussed on a previous occasion?

Comment on this

This implication?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Was not this Report fully discussed previously and a decision on it come to by the House? I suggest to the Deputy that he cannot now discuss that Committee's Report on the Motion before the House.

Comment on this

I am not discussing the Report of the Committee. I am discussing the policy of the Party of whom Deputy Cosgrave is the nominee. I think I am perfectly entitled to discuss that policy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Perhaps the Deputy will listen to me. The Deputy has been discussing that Report and the implications of the Report for the last seven or eight minutes. I suggest to him that he cannot discuss that Report on the Motion now before the House.

Comment on this

I submit, A Leas-Chinn Comhairle, that that is very unfair ruling. I hold that I am entitled, on a Motion of this sort, to the fullest liberty of discussion and that I ought to get it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will get all the liberty to which he is entitled, but surely he is not entitled to go back and discuss every decision come to by the House during the lifetime of the present Government?

Comment on this

I am entitled to discuss every decision come to by the House for which the present nominee, Deputy Cosgrave, was responsible. The name of Deputy Cosgrave has now been submitted to the House, and I am entitled, I believe, to discuss and to criticise every decision of the House for which Deputy Cosgrave accepts responsibility.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has suggested that not only is he entitled to take the Report of the Imperial Conference, but that he is entitled to take any Act passed by this House and go back on it section by section. The Deputy is not entitled to do that.

Comment on this

I am not taking the Report section by section, but I am taking one vital paragraph in the Report.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is not entitled to discuss any particular paragraph in the Report.

Comment on this

I am.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am telling the Deputy that he is not.

Comment on this

If that is so, then the best thing to do is to conclude the debate.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I have no wish whatever to do that.

Comment on this

That is what it amounts to, if you insist on that ruling.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I have no wish to conclude the debate. It is not for me to conclude the debate, but it is my duty to keep the Deputy or any other Deputy in order.

Comment on this

I am not out of order.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I say that the Deputy is out of order, and he will have to accept that.

Comment on this

If the Deputy is showing that the policy of the late Government——

Comment on this

Opinions need not necessarily be expressed in words, and it does not matter.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy explain what he means by that?

Comment on this

I am not going to explain. My objection is there.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy wants to challenge the ruling of the Chair, then I suggest he ought to do it in an open manner or not challenge it at all.

Comment on this

The reason that I touch upon this point is that I must make it clear to the House what the present policy of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party is—that one of the sheet anchors of the Party is to preserve the Protestant succession in this country. Henceforth the King, the Constitution and the Protestant succession are going to be the sheet anchors of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party in this country. By an understandable coincidence, in view of the complexion of this House, those principles of the King, the Constitution and the Protestant succession happen also to be the fundamental principles of the Orange institution.

I understand that during the last few days the Cumann na nGaedheal Party have had some difficulty with the Independents who support them in this House. I understand also that the difficulties have been easily resolved. One cannot be astonished at that when one realises that the members who sit on the Government Benches have exactly the same principles in regard to the Constitution and the King and the Protestant succession as Deputies who sit on the Independent Benches. I am sorry that Deputies Haslett and Cole are not here in order that I might congratulate them on the success of their missionary labours. It has been awe inspiring. In less than three years they have converted Deputy Cosgrave and the heads of the Cumann na nGaedheal organisation, as I said before, to the fundamental principles of the Orange Order. It only remains for him and the leading members of his Party to make a pilgrimage to Belfast on the coming Twelfth in order that this new alliance may be solemnised in an appropriate manner.

I must confess though that I became a little uncertain of my ground to-day when I heard the Minister for Defence open his speech with a quotation from an encyclical letter from Leo XIII. I began to ponder in my own mind how Deputies Haslett, Cole and Myles might take that particular quotation. However, apparently Deputy Haslett has also advanced a little, and he is now prepared to support the Government whose political existence is based on the encyclical letter of Leo XIII. Whether his constituents in Co. Monaghan will be as wholehearted as he in support of that Government is a matter I leave to him to settle with them.

I would now ask the House to consider the economic effects of that proposition. The House, by a majority, approved of the principle of the Old Age Pension Bill which was introduced by Deputy Ward. The cost of giving effect to the proposals of the Bill would be something like £250,000 or £300,000. I would ask those who supported the Bill to bear in mind that if they now vote in support of the nomination of Deputy Cosgrave they are throwing their former vote to the winds, and that the Bill will not proceed further, but will remain on the Order Paper until it is removed by a vote of the House.

They will vote to put in office a man who refused to find £250,000 for the aged poor, while the country, in the Estimates which this House is considering, will be asked to make provision for £1,991,000 in respect of pensions for able-bodied people. If you vote for Deputy Cosgrave you are voting for a man who, while he refuses to meet the needs and assuage the wants of the destitute poor, has piled burden upon burden upon the whole tax-paying community until the people are staggering under the load. Last year the Government extracted from the taxpayers £21,470,000. If the Estimates which the late Government submitted are approved of, as they will be approved, if you elect Deputy Cosgrave, an extra £400,000 must be found in taxation next year. The simple thing in the figures which have been published recently giving the returns for the year 1929-30 is that without exception every significant tax has shown a diminished return, a sure proof and certain indication that the country is already overburdened. It is due to that fact that instead of having prosperity and progress in the Free State we have industrial and economic stagnation and decay. To vote for Deputy Cosgrave to-night is to vote to accelerate that process of decay. Any Deputy who feels any uneasiness in relation to the present economic condition of the country, if he wishes to allay that uneasiness, if he wishes to ensure that the country will be given a chance to pull around and recuperate, must vote for someone other than the Deputy whose name is before the House.

There is another question, a question of law and order. A great parade was made in the House to-day about the equivocal attitude of Fianna Fáil in regard to men with guns. I think, before the Independent Deputies vote in this House, they have a right to expect from Deputy Cosgrave some statement with reference to an article which appeared in the "Star" on March 23rd. I think I had better read to the House the significant paragraph from that leading article:

"The members of the Government are the servants of the people. If it were apparent that they were not obedient to the people, it would no longer be necessary that the Army should be obedient to them. In these circumstances the Fianna Fáil Government would be only a tyranny. It is difficult to destroy a tyranny, except with sword and rifle."

A Fianna Fáil Government, being the Government elected by the people, the Government elected with the approval of this house and responsible to this House, would be only a tyranny.

"It is difficult to destroy a tyranny except with sword and rifle. If it should become a duty to destroy a tyranny in the Saorstát, it would be the duty of the soldier to move first, as he is best equipped for the work. Thus, the position is: Fianna Fáil has nothing to fear from the Army if they are good boys; but if they are bad boys, the Army will be highly dangerous to them."

Who is to be the judge as to whether the Fianna Fáil Party are good boys or bad boys? Is it to be the majority in this House, which will ultimately put the Fianna Fáil Party in power, or is it to be a junta of Cumann na nGaedheal sitting outside through its personal contacts with officers and men of the Army? I want to know who was responsible for writing that article, and who was responsible for the paper in which it appeared. Is it true that Deputy Cosgrave has a part ownership in that paper? Is it true that the Acting-President wrote that article? I think the House before it votes on that issue should have an answer to this question, as to whether Deputy Cosgrave is a part owner of the "Star," in which the article inciting the Army to mutiny in a certain eventuality was published. If he is part owner is he a fit person to be President of the Executive Council of the Free State? Who are the men and what Government and Party are now appealing to the men with guns? The Acting-President has come in. I hope if he intervenes in the debate he will say whether he is responsible for the article or not. We know that other articles which have appeared in the editorial columns of that paper have been written by him. If he did not write them did the Minister for Defence? The Minister for Defence has a peculiar personality. Not only is he Minister for Defence but also an amateur theologian. One of the most dangerous things, and one of the sources of the greatest evils which have afflicted mankind have been amateur theologians in charge of armies. Did the Minister for Defence write that article?

Comment on this

I would ask the Deputy to quote the article in the language in which it was written.

Comment on this

I am quoting it in the language which Deputy Esmonde and most of the Independent Deputies in this House understand. At any rate, I am making the speech in my own way, and if Deputy Esmonde has any intelligent contribution to make to the debate I would suggest that he would have the manners to sit down and listen politely until I have finished.

I may not have exhausted the possible sources of authorship. Did General Mulcahy write that article? It bears traces of his mentality. We remember a former mutiny in the Army. We remember a former Minister who was prepared to use the Army in order to make the Government good boys. We remember a certain incident which ended in the exit from the late Government of the then Minister for Defence, and I would like to know whether Deputy General Mulcahy was responsible for this article or not. At any rate, I say it shows traces of his mentality. We all know that he is not averse in certain circumstances to playing the Army off against the Government of the State. He did it in, I think, 1923. I am perfectly certain that he would be equally capable of doing it in 1930 or in 1931, if it happened to suit what he thought were his particular needs or his particular interests.

Comment on this

Ar aon chuma, d'fheadfadh sé é sgri sa teanga 'nar sgriobhadh é.

Comment on this

I am asking the Deputy to answer my question. I am not asking him to put questions to me.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We are not discussing the Minister for Local Government and Public Health; we are discussing Deputy Cosgrave.

Comment on this

I am discussing the associates of Deputy Cosgrave, the men with whom he was associated in the last Government, and the men, I presume, with whom he will be associated in the next Government if he is elected by this House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest to the Deputy that he might defer his criticism of other Ministers until they are put before the House. The Deputy should now discuss the only person whose name is before the House.

Comment on this

I must submit that I could understand that ruling if, when Deputy Hogan, Acting-Minister for Agriculture, had been criticising Deputy Lemass or Deputy O'Kelly, who, he held, were associated with Deputy de Valera, you had stood up in your place as a private Deputy and protested.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

There is no comparison whatever.

Comment on this

I suggest that there is. We members of the Fianna Fáil Party have had to bear the brunt of criticism from that Party on the motion to nominate Deputy de Valera.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not suggesting that the Deputy would not have a right to criticise Deputies on the other side, but I am suggesting that this is not the appropriate time to do it. The Deputy will get an opportunity, as I am sure he knows. The motion before the House is that Deputy Cosgrave be nominated as President of the Executive Council.

Comment on this

Exactly, and if Deputy Cosgrave is nominated as President of the Executive Council it will be too late for me to put before the House the reasons which I am now advancing as reasons why he should not be nominated. Therefore I am entitled to deal with those with whom Deputy Cosgrave has been associated in the past and with whom he is likely to be associated in the future.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

So long as the Deputy is clear that he cannot anticipate the Cabinet which may be put before the House if Deputy Cosgrave is elected President, then I am perfectly satisfied.

Comment on this

Well, I am dealing with those with whom he was associated——

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

He is not dissatisfied with me but with my associates.

Comment on this

As Deputy Aiken reminds me, "Show me your friends and I will tell you who you are." Now, I think the House is entitled to a show-down on this matter; I think the House is entitled to have from Deputy Cosgrave a clear, categorical statement as to what his attitude towards the Army is going to be; furthermore, what his connection with the "Star" is, and whether any member of his late Government was responsible for the article of which I have complained. I think the House is the more entitled to that by reason of a statement which was made by the Acting-Minister for Defence in the debate upon the proposition to nominate Eamon de Valera as President. We have heard a great deal about the right of the people, about majority rule, and a good deal of the criticism of the Fianna Fáil Party has been based upon a slanderous and lying statement that we at any time denied the right of the majority of the people in this country to determine for themselves their own affairs. But what are we to think of the statement made by the Acting-Minister for Defence, Deputy Desmond Fitzgerald, in the debate this afternoon? Referring to the proposition to nominate Deputy Eamon de Valera as President we had this astonishing dictum from the Acting-Minister for Defence:—"The Irish people have no right to elect him because that would be a denial of their own right." I am not responsible for the logic, but there is a statement made by a man who was a responsible Minister in the late Government—that the Irish people have no right to elect Eamon de Valera. Is that the attitude which Deputy William Cosgrave is going to take up in this matter—that if at any time the people of this country give a mandate to Eamon de Valera to form a Government, that the Acting Minister for Defence, General Mulcahy, Deputy Cosgrave and the rest of them will go out and, in the spirit of the article in the "Star," will tell the Army that the Irish people have no right to elect Eamon de Valera?

Comment on this

They have a right to do wrong.

Comment on this

I wish that the Deputy would make sober-minded interjections. This question is too serious to have a trifler like Deputy Esmonde butting in and interrupting by that sort of unseemly argument.

Comment on this

The right to do wrong.

Comment on this

I am asking Deputy William Cosgrave whether the people have or have not the right to elect Eamon de Valera, and if he declares to the House that they have a right to elect Eamon de Valera as President of the Executive Council, will he take into his Cabinet a Deputy who has already declared in this House that the Irish people have no such right? "The primary and fundamental function of government is to preserve social order," said the same Acting Minister. Now, on a number of occasions during the regime of the late administration Deputies on the Fianna Fáil benches brought before the notice of the House and before the notice of the late Minister for Justice a number of cases in which it was alleged that the forces under the control of that Minister were violating the law and outraging the rights and liberties of citizens, and the invariable reply from the Minister was to refer the Deputies to the courts, and to say that any possibility of redress lay there. Some people took the Minister at his word; they brought some cases to the courts; they have been heard there before a judge and jury, and in every single case in which the facts were submitted to a judge and jury the members of the police forces under the control of the late Minister for Justice, and therefore under the control of the Deputy who is proposed as President of the Executive Council, were found to have been guilty of outrages and assaults upon the citizens. In every single case that was found to be a fact, and I ask the Independents, whose position in this matter is peculiarly liable to attack, whether they can afford to vote to put in power a Deputy who, when formerly in a position of control and responsibility, permitted forces of the State to be guilty, as I have said, of outrages upon the rights and liberties of the citizens? Can they afford it? Can, they, in view of their responsibilities to the people who sent them here, cast their votes for that Deputy, because if they vote for Deputy William Cosgrave, they vote for the continuance of that violence, or will they vote for the constitutional and legal rights of the people who sent them here. "The primary and fundamental function of government is to preserve social order." Because the verdicts of the juries before whom the whole facts were placed have shown that the late Government, headed by Deputy William Cosgrave, failed in that primary and fundamental function of government, to preserve social order, I ask the House to vote against the proposal which Deputy Mongan has put before it.

Comment on this

During the course of this debate I took a few stray notes, and I find that we have been discussing Popes, Kings, Fianna Fáil, Cumann na nGaedheal, Labour, Independents, I.R.A., I.R.B., the Orange Order, the Masonic Order, the Army and the Civic Guards. We got to the stars, but no one yet has mentioned anything about the sun and moon. Probably that omission will be repaired before the debate is over. What is all this about? For the past six or seven weeks rumours have been current that a political crisis would be precipitated here before Easter. We are now in the throes of that crisis. The ostensible cause has been the defeat of the Government on the Old Age Pensions (Amendment) Bill. The reason for that defeat has been stated by the late President to be the fortuitous and unavoidable absence of some of his followers. I question very much whether the President's explanation of the absentees was quite correct; I question very much whether this crisis was not deliberately brought on. In my opinion it was, and the defeat of the Government served more than one purpose. First of all, it was taken on the Old Age Pensions Bill, and, by the way, in all this welter of oratory which we have had to-day I have not heard one word about the unfortunate pensioners who have been deprived of what we held were their rights, and which I voted for as their rights on the last occasion—not one word about the poor pensioners who are going to be denied what the House voted them.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation. The Deputy's statement is not correct. It was mentioned from these benches by more than one speaker.

Comment on this

He was not here.

Comment on this

I apologise. I must have been out of the House then.

Comment on this

On a point of order. I think the Deputy was inaccurate in saying that the President stated that the cause of the defeat of the Government was due to the absence of a certain number of his followers.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is certainly not a point of order.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Hanlon.

Comment on this

I think I am perfectly correct in stating the reasons given by the President for his defeat.

Comment on this

You stated them inaccurately.

Comment on this

If I stated them inaccurately I will repeat what I said. The President stated that the cause of the defeat was the fortuitous and unavoidable absence of some of his followers.

Comment on this

I am not arguing the point with the Deputy any longer. I am not going to delay the House very much longer than to explain my position. I voted for the Old Age Pensions Bill because I believed it was the correct thing to do, because I believe the administration of the Old Age Pensions Acts was not in sympathy with the pensioners, and that a necessary change should be made in the administration and tightening up of the Acts. We are asked now to elect a President. All the possible candidates with the exception of myself have been removed from the scene, and I was seriously thinking of proposing myself as a probable. I can assure the House that if I did I would have the wholehearted support of my Party. We are quite unanimous on the question, and I do not know if the candidate now before the House is defeated but that I will not step into the breach and form a Pooh Bah Government of my own. I think I could function as Minister in all the Departments myself, and no doubt I would have a very good try. I want to say here and now that I am not going to vote for the late President's return to office. I am not stating that for the reason that he is not qualified for the office, but from the fact that if I did so the vote I gave here last Thursday for the pensioners would be nullified, and I would be stultifying myself. I am not going to do that. I took no part up to this in the Divisions for either of the other candidates. I believe that the whole proceedings here to-day have been staged, for what purpose the Government know best. Perhaps, as some Deputies stated, it was time to have a show-down. We have heard a lot about show-downs here for the last three or four weeks, and people who asked for them—the late Government and possibly the future Government—can go to the country and underline the words: "There you are; there is no alternative in the country. We are back in power and we can do what we like for the next twelve months." It is not, in my opinion, a very creditable thing to have this crisis going on, except possibly for a display of the sort I mentioned. In any event, for the reasons I have stated—and I could say a lot more which I do not wish to say—I intend to keep intact the vote I gave for the old age pensioners and not to vote for Deputy Cosgrave.

Comment on this

I rise to oppose the motion that Deputy Cosgrave be elected President, and in doing so I may say that it is not my intention to endeavour to emulate the tactics that have been adopted by the majority of the Deputies who have spoken. Personally I believe, and I think I am voicing the sentiments of the man in the street when I say that there has been by far too much mud slinging by some of the Deputies whom we have listened to to-day. The front bench of the Government Party are not immune from that criticism. I noticed that many bricks were thrown from the Government Benches. I think it is a great pity that the Government cannot lay bricks as successfully as they can throw them, because if they did so during past years we would not have the housing scarcity that now exists.

I propose to advance briefly a few reasons why I am going to vote against the nomination before the House. In the first place the present Government have been in power for a number of years with Deputy Cosgrave as the head of the Executive Council. During that time many laws had been passed by this House, but I believe that the majority of those laws that have been passed during the time when the Government were in office have been in the interests of the wealthy classes of the people and detrimental to the poorer classes of the community. Deputy O'Hanlon has pointed out, and I agree with him when he says, that the crisis has been staged. What has been referred to as a crisis has been brought about by the action of the Government in refusing to abide by the will of the majority of the Deputies in this House to increase the old age pensions. Now, in passing I might say that Deputy Cosgrave, whom we are now asked to re-elect to the position of President, was a member of the first Dáil, and as a member of the first Dáil I would like to ask him, or any of the Deputies sitting in the benches supporting him, what steps has he taken to put into operation what was known as the democratic programme of the first Dáil. What steps have been taken by the Executive Council, by President Cosgrave to endeavour to remedy what we, on these benches at any rate, believe is one of the greatest problems facing this country at present, namely, the problem of unemployment?

Let us just examine the democratic programme of the first Dáil in regard to this question of unemployment. We find the democratic programme to which General Mulcahy, Minister for Local Government and Public Health, and Deputy Cosgrave subscribed, stated: "We affirm the duty of every man and woman to give allegiance and service to the Commonwealth, and declare it is the duty of the nation to assure that every citizen shall have opportunity to spend his or her strength and faculties in the service of the people. In return for willing service we, in the name of the Government, declare the right of every citizen to an adequate share of the nation's labour." It goes on further in the programme to state: "While undertaking the organisation of the nation's trade, import and export, it shall be the duty of the Republic to prevent the shipment from Ireland of food and other necessaries until the wants of the Irish people are fully satisfied." Has President Cosgrave, during the number of years he has been in office, lived up to that programme? I believe that if the Government had lived up to that programme we would not have the same amount of poverty and hunger existing in this country to-day. We would not have the same number of emigrants going away in the emigrant ship from the country. As I say they have not even endeavoured to live up to that programme, because it was re-affirmed in that programme that one of the first duties of the Government should be to look after the people. We allege that the Government have looked after the wealthy classes of the people much better than they have endeavoured to look after the interests of the poorer classes of the people.

Another question which has not been faced up to by the Government or by the outgoing President has been the question of housing. It is well known that not alone in Dublin City, or in the towns and the villages, but also in rural Ireland, there is a great housing scarcity at present. We believe that housing should have been met by President Cosgrave, President of the Executive Council, as a national problem, that a national housing council should have been set up in order to deal with this question of housing in the rural areas, cities and towns in a national way instead of endeavouring to deal with it through private enterprise in a piecemeal fashion.

Again, one of the reasons why I intend to oppose the nomination before the House is owing to the fact that the Government have, since the time they were put into office, endeavoured to reduce the social services of this country. For instance, what was the policy, what was the programme of Deputy Cosgrave as a member of the first Dáil in regard to social services? We find that as far as the democratic programme of the first Dáil was concerned, it reiterates that: "The Irish Republic fully realises the necessity of abolishing the present odious, degrading and foreign poor law system, substituting therefore a sympathetic native scheme for the care of the nation's aged and infirm who shall not be regarded as a burden, but rather entitled to the nation's gratitude and consideration."

Has that declaration to which President Cosgrave subscribed been carried out? We have, it has been pointed out, those crises or alleged crises at the present time, due to the fact that Deputy Cosgrave would not even carry out in a small way that declaration which he made in the year 1919.

Again, we have the question, as pursued by Deputy Cosgrave and the Executive Council, of their failure to deal with other social matters. This Party some time ago introduced a motion in the Dáil calling on the Government, through Deputy Cosgrave, to introduce a system of widows' and orphans' pensions. We find that the policy of the Government Party was at that time—acting, I presume, through the President—that they would not put into operation a system of widows' and orphans' pensions.

Again, the policy of the present Government, acting through Deputy Cosgrave, has been, and still is, to endeavour to lower and reduce the wages of the working-class people. Shortly after they were returned to power we find them reducing the Post Office workers' wages. They followed that up by reducing the teachers' salaries. They followed that up by a circular to the surveyors of all the county councils in the Free State, asking them to reduce the road workers' wages. I hope Donegal Deputies will pay particular attention to this—that even yet the Government, through the Minister for Local Government has refused to allow the county councils up there to pay to the road workers this very small wage of 30/- per week. He thinks 26/- per week is sufficient, and evidently the nominee put forward to-night must acquiesce in that. Otherwise he would instruct the Minister for Local Government to withdraw his ban and allow that particular county council to pay an increase on the 26/- per week. I hope, at any rate, that the Donegal Deputies on the Government Benches on this occasion will have the courage of their convictions, and not cast their votes in a machine-like way, because if they do, I believe it will be a vote in favour of a lower standard of old age pensions and a lower standard of wages than we have to-day. General Mulcahy, when Deputy MacEntee was speaking, made an interjection in Irish. I only wish that General Mulcahy had been so active when the Report of the Gaeltacht Commission was before the Dáil. When the White Paper that the Government issued, and which they refused to live up to, was before the Dáil, I only wish that General Mulcahy had been verbal to put up a fight for the Irish speakers.

Reference has been also made to the Government's policy in regard to the question of partition. I believe that the neglect of the Government in not having at least as good social conditions in the way of old age pensions, unemployment insurance and widows' and orphans' pensions, is doing a big lot to keep back the day when we will have unity in this country. I would point out in conclusion that the House is now asked to elect a nominee of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party—a Party that sacrificed the interests of the minority and agreed to the partition of this country, and upon that issue, if upon no other, I ask the House to vote against the nomination of the President.

Comment on this

I rise to oppose the nomination of ex-President Cosgrave. Deputy Cosgrave declared in intimating that he was tendering his resignation that he would not take responsibility for financing the Old Age Pensions Bill that received a majority of the votes of the Deputies in this House. Deputy Cosgrave apparently intends to slip out a side-door and to come in by another door and evade the responsibility placed upon him by a majority of this House to give effect to a Bill that was passed here. In the course of his statement here on Friday last the then President stated that the Bill would not benefit the most deserving classes. The fact that a majority in this House registered their votes in favour of the Bill is all the proof that Deputy Cosgrave should require to satisfy him that that Bill should be financed. I would like to know if the Deputies who believe that that Bill is desirable and necessary and who voted for it are now prepared to go back on that vote and allow ex-President Cosgrave to evade his responsibilities to the poor and to refuse to finance that measure. If any of these Deputies who believe that the Bill is a necessary one and that it would benefit the most deserving classes of old people in this country support the proposition to re-elect Deputy Cosgrave President of the Executive Council I think their interest in the old age pensioners will be apparent to the blind.

Deputy O'Connell stated here to-day in the course of the debate that we must choose a Government that will, without equivocation, give legislative effect to the expressed will of the majority. I think it is rather a pity that Deputy O'Connell did not see the wisdom of supporting the nomination of the majority Opposition Party in this Dáil, and the Party who introduced this measure and were responsible for having it carried through its Second Stage. Timid people are suffering, according to Deputy O'Connell, by being reminded of the effects of the defeat of the Danes at Clontarf. I do not know exactly what that has to do with it, but it makes one more or less sorry for Deputy O'Connell, because he must be having a very anxious time at present, and I think, from Deputy O'Connell's attitude in this debate, that one must class him amongst the timid.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

He did not refuse, like others, to cast his vote the way he thought he ought to cast it.

Comment on this

It has been suggested by Deputy Cosgrave that the Bill that brought about the defeat of the Government would not confer benefits on the poorer classes. A solitary argument has not been advanced, and cannot be advanced, in substantiation of that contention. A majority of this House sought to secure that charity would not be estimated as means against an old age pension claimant. Deputy Cosgrave refuses to admit that people who live on charity and who have no means whatever in their own right are amongst the poorer classes, and Deputy Cosgrave refuses to provide the money to secure that people who are living on the goodwill or charity of their neighbours, or who are dependent on some charitable organisation to keep body and soul together, and who are over seventy years of age, should get a miserable old age pension. I hope that the Dáil will not acquiesce in that, and that if Deputy Cosgrave is to be elected to-night, or whenever the vote takes place, that at least he will give some undertaking that if he is allowed to take over the reins of government again he will give effect to the majority will of the people as expressed by the majority of Deputies in this House.

He has said that the poor would not benefit by the Bill. The people who are already in receipt of old age pensions, who have nobody to look after them and have to enter a poor law institution as paupers, are not deserving people according to the spokesmen on the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches. If people who cannot live outside an institution, even with an old age pension, are not poor enough for Deputy Cosgrave and for the Minister for Finance, well they are poor enough for the majority of this House, and that should be sufficient for Deputy Cosgrave. Deputy Cosgrave is not prepared to accept responsibility for financing a Bill that aims at securing that a poor woman who becomes a widow after she is seventy years of age should not have the pension that she enjoyed as a married woman taken from her. That person is not poor enough for Deputy Cosgrave, the man who is now proposed as President of the Executive Council. According to the Minister for Finance, if effect were given to the Bill £125,000 would be spent on farmers, farmers whose valuations range from £10 to £13 10s. These people are not sufficiently poor for the Minister for Finance. They are not sufficiently poor for Deputy Cosgrave, but, again, they are sufficiently poor for a majority of the Deputies in this House, and they ought to be accepted by ex-President Cosgrave as being sufficiently poor for him.

Deputy Morrissey lamented the fate of the old age pensioners if Deputy O'Connell were not elected. I do not like to characterise that as hypocrisy, but it appears to me to be approaching very near to it. If Deputy Morrissey was so anxious about the old age pensioners that legislative effect should be given to the Bill that was passed here last week, I think the obvious course for Deputy Morrissey would have been to support the leader of the majority Opposition Party in this House and the leader of the Party who introduced it.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

That is the best yet.

Comment on this

The President is like Humpty-Dumpty. All the king's horses and all the king's men cannot put Humpty-Dumpty together again.

Comment on this

I am glad that tickles Deputy Cosgrave's sense of humour.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

It did undoubtedly. It was a great effort on the part of Deputy Ward.

Comment on this

It is a great effort on the part of the ex-President to be humorous this evening. Of course, it was a snap division! The whips of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party were caught out and the very unpleasant fact had to be faced that the Cumann na nGaedheal Government had been defeated. It was a snap division! A full week before last Thursday it was announced in this House that that day would be given to Private Deputies' Business. Everybody in the House knew that the first business to be disposed of on last Thursday would be the Old Age Pensions Bill. It was debated in this House from about 3.20 to 6.35 p.m. Yet it was a snap division. The Government was taken unawares. A mean advantage was taken of them. The poor unfortunate innocent Cumann na nGaedheal Government was thrown out. I wonder would Deputy Cosgrave or somebody on his behalf tell us in what way would they spend this £300,000 that they say the Bill will cost to put into operation—in what way would they spend that £300,000 that would give the best return? One would gather from the statement which Deputy Cosgrave made when he was indicating his intention to resign that he was prepared to expend £300,000 on old age pensions and that there were at least half a dozen ways in which that could be done. But not one of these ways has been indicated by the spokesmen of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. If Deputy Cosgrave is to be re-elected President, we should at least hear of some of these schemes for the relief of old age pensioners and we should hear definitely whether it is proposed that they should get any relief at all. We used to hear a lot throughout the country and in this House about majority rule. We hear nothing about majority rule now. When majority rule decided to give effect to this Old Age Pensions Bill that majority rule was evaded by a trick. At least an attempt was made to evade it, and I think it would be an eternal disgrace to this House if that attempt to evade the majority mandate of this House succeeded.

Comment on this
Richard James Mulcahy Minister for Local Government and Public Health (General Mulcahy) Cumann na nGaedheal

I think the Deputies on the far side of the House will remember my saying from time to time that the Deputies here on these benches contain the people who were the business part of the movement, who rallied the Irish people after 1916, put their feet down on solid ground from which to work out their national destiny as far as they could; and put their feet on solid political ground in 1921 and as far as the Deputies on the far side are part of the nation, they subsequently put their feet in here on the only ground on which they can do anything for themselves or anything for the country. What Deputies in this House and what people outside have to take from this debate as far as the members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party are concerned is that just as we put the people's feet down on solid national ground after 1916, and as we put the Deputies' feet on solid political ground later, we are going to put the feet of the country down on solid, financial ground now.

Comment on this

A Daniel come to judgment! Buying at £7 and selling for half.

Comment on this

The people here have a certain amount of money to spend on social services and it is because we are not prepared at the present moment to spend £300,000 additional on old age pensions on any account, that the House here was offered to-night an opportunity of setting up a Ministry that would do that if after mature judgment they consider that it ought to be done. The Deputies on the Fianna Fáil side and on the Labour side have spoken of the tremendous amount of work that is required to provide more satisfactory social services for the country. And if we can understand them, one of the first things they would do would be to give another £300,000 to old age pensioners. At least, that is what we are asked to-night to believe that they would do. We have given the House as a whole an opportunity of saying whether they will do that or not. And I think that we are facing a House a majority of which, at any rate, will come to the conclusion after mature deliberation that they are not prepared to do that. I think that the Deputies both in the Fianna Fáil Party and in the Labour Party must be quite convinced in their hearts that if they themselves were responsible for the government of the country they would not do that. If the Fianna Fáil Party came in as a majority and got the confidence of the majority of the House to-night I doubt if they would give an additional £300,000 to old age pensioners. At any rate, we are not prepared to do it and we are not prepared acting as a majority Party in this House or acting as responsible leaders of any kind, whether in a majority or minority operating as responsible leaders before the country—we are not prepared to expend money in a direction in which we think it ought not to be spent.

Deputies want more money for child welfare; they want more money for the clearing of slums and for the building of houses. Deputies want more money for all classes of things. It is because we know that more money is required for these matters that we are not prepared now to spend £300,000 additional on old age pensioners. It has been explained already that there are £2,750,000 spent on old age pensions. I told the House some time ago that on the whole of our poor relief services including medical charities in the country, including hospitals, including county homes and including outdoor relief, we were spending £1,647,000. That is much less than we are spending on old age pensions. In addition to that, we are spending £720,000 on mental hospitals. When we take the services on child welfare, school medical attendance, the treatment of school children, school meals, treatment of the blind, treatment of tuberculosis, the treatment of venereal diseases and so on there is being spent, whether through rates or taxes, a sum of £290,000. So that if we take the poor relief, mental hospitals and all these miscellaneous social services together that are only being developed we are spending in all a sum of £2,662,000, or a less sum than we are spending on old age pensions at the present moment. And we are asked to vote another £300,000 for old age pensions. We are not prepared to do that. In addition to the services I mentioned Deputies want additional homes for the people. Probably, at the present cost of housing and by the present housing want in our urban districts alone it will take £250,000 for thirty-five years from both the State and from local rates to provide these houses. I wonder would Deputy O'Connell, if he had £300,000 for one year, put it to old age pensions, or would he put it to the building of proper schools in some parts of the country? I think the Deputy has an idea of the amount of money that would be required to make up the arrears for the provision of proper school-buildings in the country. I think the Deputy has an idea as to the amount of money that would be required to keep up the normal wastage in the country in the matter of school-buildings. I wonder would the Deputy consider that that matter should be left out of consideration entirely when dealing with the question of the expenditure of more money on old age pensions. We have to think not alone of the people in their old age but we have to think of the sick poor, the ordinary poor, the poor who are old and infirm, people in the country generally who are infirm, the mental and physical defectives among the youth of the country.

We have a limited amount of money to spend, and we want to apply it to those things that will give us the greatest possible constructive returns. That is the note I would like to strike over this debate. People may talk about their political sovereignty, their hopes of Republics, their hopes of sovereign independence, and all these glorious things that are flag-wagging, and nothing but flag-wagging to some people, because it does not seem to bring them down to constructive work of any kind. They may talk of those things, but unless they make proper use of their resources, men and money, they are not going to achieve the great things that they would like to achieve.

On the question of pensions, most Deputies have spoken of Deputy Murphy's motion in November, 1928, in relation to pensions for widows. I take it that Deputy Murphy and the people who spoke about pensions for widows considered the family burdens of widows who require relief. One would think that they ought to be dealt with at least as generously in the matter of pensions as are the old age pensioners to-day, even without an additional £300,000. The county from which Deputy Cassidy comes will serve as an example. The average old age pension paid in Donegal is £22 10s.; the average payment from the local board of assistance to widows in Donegal is £11 10s.

Comment on this

Does the Minister mean to infer that we on these benches are responsible for that, or does he forget that in the democratic programme of the First Dáil the intention was expressed to do away with the foreign Poor Law system?

Comment on this

Certainly. I have said here before, apropos of widows' pensions, that you cannot wipe out the poor relief system; that is, a system of relief based upon local taxation. If you do, responsibility in these matters goes at once. If the representatives of Donegal were paying the old age pensions in Donegal, I doubt if they would pay higher pensions than the amount of money now being paid to widows in Donegal.

Comment on this

They are paying their share of taxation for the sugar beet factory in Carlow, and other things for which they get no benefit.

Comment on this

I am talking of their probable action in matters over which they have full control and responsibility. As I have said, they pay widows in Donegal £11 10s. a year. In Monaghan, where the average old age pensions payment is £21 8s., the average payment to widows is £15 4s. To summarise it, there are only two counties in the country in which the average payments to widows are higher than the average payments to old age pensioners in these counties. There are eleven counties in which the payments to widows on the average are less than two-thirds of the payments to old age pensioners, and there are two counties in which the payment to widows is less than one-half the average payment to old age pensioners.

We are not asking you to support the election of President Cosgrave as President. We are asking you to take it from us that we want to keep your feet here and the feet of the people in the country down on solid financial ground. It is because we are awake to the matters that require the application of money to increase the social betterment of our people that we are not prepared to give another £300,000 to old age pensioners.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance stated down the country during the week-end that the Fianna Fáil Party were responsible for this cut in the old age pensions in 1924 which Deputy Ward's Bill proposed to amend. The Minister for Local Government and Public Health now tells us that the only anxiety of the Government in this matter is that the feet of the people in this country should be placed upon solid financial ground. I think if the people of this country examine the financial ground which the Minister tries to assure the House is so very solid, they will probably find that it resembles more a moving bog, and that if the expenditure on other matters not nearly as important to this country as the welfare of the aged poor is allowed to continue in its present proportions, then the country will find itself where it has been prophesied it would find itself, in a morass of insolvency. The Government Party, I am informed, have had sufficient finances available, although they can find no money to finance this measure, to put the large sum of £50,000 at the disposal of a body called the Investment Trust. The whole of that amount has been lost, just like another £50,000 which was placed in a glass bottle factory here in the city. Furthermore, whatever might be said about the enterprise in connection with the glass bottle factory wherein £50,000 was lost—perhaps it was some kind of effort to give employment here—the £50,000 invested in the Investment Trust was lost as a result of speculative enterprise in foreign film companies. I am told that corporation, the Investment Trust, has lost something like £70,000 as a result of these speculative deals. That is the way in which the Irish Free State Government spends the taxpayers' money. That is how they find firm financial ground for the Irish people, but they cannot find anything for the old age pensioners.

Deputies have referred in this debate to some of the items in the Estimates upon which money is being spent. I do not propose to do more than mention these items. I leave out of consideration the Army and the Civic Guards, which are costing £1,500,000 and £1,600,000 respectively. I say that out of those large sums some economy ought to be possible—some economy better than the cheese-paring economy which was initiated and carried into effect by the Deputy who now seeks re-election to the Presidency.

He says that that economy was necessary and should be made at the expense of the old age pensioners so that we might stand on solid financial ground. This House if it is honest will at least assure itself that if that cut is to be made, if this Bill which attempted to make up for it is going to be thrown aside, that similar economies will be insisted on when the new Estimates will be brought before this House within the next few months. You have a Governor-General costing £27,000, a Broadcasting Station costing £84,000, and a Ministry of External Affairs though nobody knows what it is doing. No report has been received from its foreign representatives or ambassadors. I say that the whole Department ought to have been scrapped in order to provide money for social services such as the service which would benefit under Deputy Ward's Bill. We have a sum of £3,000 spent on the Phoenix Park motor races and, in addition, we find —and I call the attention of the House specially to it—that under the Treaty, about which we have had so much talk to-night, this State is permanently committed to a payment of something like one and three-quarter million pounds annually for pensions, a great deal of which money is not even spent here and gives no benefit to the people. In all, we are spending something like two millions on pensions. Included in that is a sum of £208,216 for the present financial year for military service pensions.

I would ask the House to compare the conditions, to which this House is now going to give its sanction and to carry into law, under which these able-bodied men throughout the country are being treated and the manner in which the aged poor are being treated. A pensions officer can question old age pension applicants and just by looking at them say whether they are of the requisite age and, possibly, disallow their claims although they have produced the best evidence available. Further, the pensions officer can come along and arbitrarily estimate an income which is perhaps charity, as Deputy Ward pointed out, and can say that that charity is worth so much during the year, thereby depriving the claimant either of that charity or of his pension, as he cannot have both. That is going to continue in future.

The speeches of Ministers, I submit, show that they are absolutely out of touch with the situation in the country as regards the administration of old age pensions. Their back-benchers were not, however out of touch. They knew how rigidly and ruthlessly this law was being operated to the detriment of old age pension claimants. I say that it is up to those Deputies, if they are convinced that it is necessary, as the Minister for Local Government says, to hang up the Bill in order to find ourselves on solid financial ground, to assure their constituents that if money cannot be spared for that that no money shall be spent on less worthy purposes. Old age pension claimants are being treated in this manner, and, no matter what appeal is taken, and no matter what the local committees do, it all goes by the board because the Minister and his minions in Dublin will decide, as they have decided in the past, that these people are to be disqualified on some technical point. The whole of the £200,000 to be spent annually on military pensions is, however, to be spent without year or nay, even without allowing the Comptroller and Auditor-General, who has been appointed under the Constitution, to look into the matter.

Are the Party opposite satisfied that that is fair play, that the country will stand it, or whether, if there was a dissolution to-morrow, the country would not state quite clearly that the money should be found for old age pensions if it can be found for military service pensions? If the Government intend to persist with the Bill for the abolition of the powers of the Comptroller and Auditor-General, would the country say that these military service pensions are to be above investigation and that no court of appeal is to be allowed to investigate whether these claims are good and what evidence has been brought forward in support of them? The Government ought, at least—when it protects its own pets in that manner, saves them from the State, and is prepared, by even uprooting the Constitution, to shelter them —to have a more generous policy when dealing with the aged poor to whom Ministers on the opposite side openly acknowledged their responsibility and agreed, with others on this side of the House, that the care of the aged poor was to be the primary responsibility of this Government or of any Christian Government of which they might be a Party.

You have all that money spent. You have large funds which were at the disposal of the Exchequer, like the two millions held by the Intermediate Education Board and the £900,000 by the old Congested Districts Board, which have been absorbed into the Exchequer and have since disappeared. The Exchequer is empty and if you go through all the different Departments you will find that all the resources which ought to be there for reproductive work have been drained and exhausted. You find a merciless campaign for the collection of annuities and income tax. Where is all that money going? The people have a right to ask that question. They have got no answer but the best answer which the country can get and which it will appreciate most is the fact that throughout the whole discussion on Deputy Ward's Bill no serious argument was advanced against it, and the Government who were defeated on it, and who would have been defeated by a larger majority if they left the matter to a free vote of the House and to the generous instincts of their own Party, are seeking by discreditable methods to penalise the aged poor who cannot defend themselves. When they have spent money on purposes which are not really necessary for the good of the country they take every opportunity of saying, when suggested savings are pointed out, "Oh that does not count. That saving would not mean anything." They always protect the pensioners who are able to look after themselves and they always protect the officials but whenever they get an opportunity of jumping on the underdog they keep jumping on it until nothing is left except the parasites who are always battening on its dead carcase.

Comment on this

This discussion has been going on since 3 o'clock and I think we were asked to come here for one purpose, namely, to elect a President. The Fianna Fáil Party put up a Deputy for election and he was turned down. The Labour Party put up a Deputy and he was turned down. Without expressing an opinion on the merits of these candidates, may I ask is there any alternative left but to elect a representative of Cumann na nGaedheal?

Comment on this

What about the Farmers' Party?

Comment on this

What about the Redmond Party and the Independents?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I suggest that the Independents are not in the field. If we go on talking like this we will never finish. We have been listening to speeches which we have heard on every occasion when the Central Fund Bill was discussed. I suggest that there is no alternative but to elect a representative of Cumann na nGaedheal and, if that is so, there is no one to elect but Deputy Cosgrave. In that case we should shorten the proceedings because we are only wasting time.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy allow his name to go forward?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy O'Kelly.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will allow his name to go forward as the representative of a great business party, of great business interests——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Is the Deputy going to make a speech?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I have already called on Deputy O'Kelly.

Comment on this

There are one or two matters that, despite the protest of Deputy Murphy as to the length and, perhaps, the variety of speeches, I would like to refer to before a vote is taken on the motion before the House. I desire to ask the President if he will state, before the vote is taken, that the policy of the Executive Council, the policy of himself and his colleagues, the policy that they now accept and in future intend to carry out, is the policy that was outlined very briefly by the Minister for Finance when he spoke on the 22nd March, 1928, on the Central Fund Bill. I have referred to it already this evening. I do not know whether the President proposes to speak on this debate, perhaps he does not, but as the Minister who spoke for him just now did not refer to the matter, although it was raised this afternoon, and as the Minister for Finance is now present, perhaps we could have a definite answer in regard to that matter of policy before the debate ends. The Minister for Finance said: "With regard to the point as to whether we are aiming at the establishment of an Irish Republic, we are not." The language is not as clear as it might be, but I think that everybody will understand what the Minister for Finance meant to say. "With regard to the point as to whether we are aiming at the establishment of an Irish Republic, we are not. We believe that this country, as a member of the British Commonwealth of Nations, can enjoy greater freedom and greater security than she could outside the British Commonwealth of Nations, and our policy within it is really to remove anomalies that exist in the relationship between the members of it." It would be well if it is the policy of the Executive Council, and if it is in future to be the policy of the new Government, for the House and the country to know definitely where we stand in the matter. Has the Government definitely thrown over, so far as it can, the old ideal of the Irish people down the centuries for absolute separation from England? Are they now, or are they not, a party that stands for separation?

Deputy Cosgrave was once a prominent man in the movement for separation between England and Ireland. The Minister for Finance was likewise fairly prominent. So was the Minister for Local Government, who has just referred rather lightly to those who stand for a Republic as flag-wavers. Well, he did not always think that. But perhaps the Minister for Finance now expresses his mind on what the attitude of his Government is, and his own attitude is, on the old ideals as he used to understand them.

Comment on this

What I tried to make clear was that they were not doing anything to-day except flag-wagging.

Comment on this

You did not make it clear anyhow. You referred to Republicans as flag-waggers. You were a flag-wagger too at one time.

Comment on this

I wagged more than flags.

Comment on this

But when the temptation of the fleshpots came your way you fell very quickly. You put the flag-waggers on one side, who were prepared to walk the hard road, and put up with hard knocks—and we got them freely, from nobody more freely than from our former colleagues. However, when the fleshpots came your way, you jumped quickly for them, more quickly, I must say, than I expected.

Comment on this
A Deputy

I am sure you would jump yourself, too.

Comment on this

I did not jump.

Comment on this
A Deputy

If we gave you the chance you would.

Comment on this

I was certainly offered the fleshpots, as my former friends were, but I can say that, for either good or ill, I did not take the bait. I am here, and God knows I have got kicks enough from my former friends and colleagues. I do not complain of that; not a bit. What I do complain of is that these gentlemen are now sneering and jeering and gibing at those who stand, for good or ill, for the old ideals and the old movement of which they were once the leading lights.

Comment on this

And did nothing for.

Comment on this

The country is the best judge of that.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

If we did nothing for them we would not be here speaking for them. We are speaking for just as many people, just as many voters, as the three gentlemen and their Party who spoke already. However, it is not worth speaking about. They would not be here for the last seven or eight years in power, and they will not be in power here to-night unless they get the backing of the gentlemen in the centre of the House who stand for the Union Jack, who represent the old garrison of this country, who stand for the British alliance and keeping the gentlemen opposite in power, while the "Irish Times" rubs it in and lets them know where they are and, as the Americans say, where they get off. The "Irish Times" reminded them on Saturday last of their miserable position as a Government, their subordinate position in this House as a Government, the tail wagging the dog. As a matter of fact it really is the tail of whatever the number of Independents is which is wagging whatever kind of four-footed animal one can call the Cumann na nGaedheal Party opposite. The "Irish Times" says: "On the other hand, the Government has received a warning which should be salutary."

Comment on this

What does the "Nation" say about the Independents?

Comment on this

Wait until I get a chance in the next week or two and I will let you know. "It has discovered that phenomenon of natural history which, neglected, has ruined many Governments—the fact that even a worm will turn. Passive revolt may not be less dangerous than flagrant revolt." Remember that, Cumann na nGaedheal majority in this House, when next you dare to propose anything that the gentlemen of the Independent Party, for whom the "Irish Times" speaks, would not like. You will know where you will be. Imagine Deputy Wolfe as a backer of President Cosgrave waving a Republican flag around Kilkenny! What a delightful comedy it would be! If you had President Cosgrave, the Vice-President, and the Minister for Local Government holding the principles to-day which they held in 1921 and for a certain portion of 1922 the Independent Deputy for West Cork, for whom the "Irish Times" speaks, one of the old British garrison in the country, might not be so readily at their back.

He voted against them the other day and brought them down on this question of old age pensions. Beware now and keep well in with him and the British; well in with the old garrison, or you will not be long in office, even if you are put in again to-night. The "Irish Times" again says:—

The outstanding moral of Thursday's accident is the nature of the new relations between the Government and the Independent Party. In plain terms, the Government must recognise its duty to the party that keeps it in office.

They will do well to remember their friends or they will not be in the job long and well they know it.

Comment on this
Timothy Sheehy Mr. T. Sheehy (Cork) Cumann na nGaedheal

I never thought I would find you pinning your faith to the "Irish Times."

Comment on this

I am not pinning my faith to it and I am sure it has not much faith in me; I have about the same faith and love for it. When the Deputy knew me on public platforms long ago, we did not see eye to eye in politics any more than we do now. He was then on a different platform.

Comment on this
Mr. Sheehy

I was serving my country.

Comment on this

We have about the same political relations to each other now. Deputy Sheehy remained faithful to the British connection.

Comment on this
Mr. Sheehy

No. I was faithful to all the brave men from Parnell down all along the line and I never got a job. I was not even sent to Paris like the Deputy.

Comment on this

I am glad the Deputy referred to my going to Paris. Although I say it myself, it took a fit man to go to Paris to speak for the Irish Republic in those days. If there had been anybody else more fitting at that time, he would have been sent instead of me.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

We shall take the question of the late sitting now.

Comment on this

If there is any possibility of finishing by 11.30 or 12, I submit that we should sit on to do so.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

For this particular question only?

Comment on this

I think so.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Then we will say 11.30 p.m.

Comment on this
Mr. Sheehy

We shall stop until morning to elect him if it is necessary. Get ready for it now.

Comment on this

I submit, and I think I am borne out by these two leading articles in the "Irish Times" on Friday and Saturday last, that the change in policy that has been adopted, and which was announced last year by the Vice-President on the question of Irish national ideals, was brought about owing to the fact that this Government that has been in office for seven or eight years, and that possibly may be in office to-morrow, owe their place, and will owe whatever power they have in future, to the tail of the Independents, for whom the "Irish Times" speaks. Deputy Wolfe is one of those on whom the Government must rest to keep them in office. The Vice-President has declared, and must stick to it in future, if he is put into office: "With regard to the point as to whether we are aiming at the establishment of an Irish Republic, we are not." The "Irish Times" cracks the whip; the Independents, I might say, pay the piper, and the Government must play the tune accordingly.

There is one other matter to which I should like to refer, and which is, I think, particularly appropriate, and that is the question of our finances. The Government were defeated the other day, as Deputy Mulcahy has reminded us, because they refused to implement a Bill that got a Second Reading. The Government claimed that they could not, and said they would not find the £300,000 which they said would be necessary to finance the provisions in that Bill. I am not satisfied that £300,000 would be necessary—I believe that is an exaggeration. However, let it be £200,000 or £300,000, or any figure in between. They could not, they said, and above all, they would not, implement that Bill. While this Government let themselves be beaten and had to resign because of failing to implement that Bill, and find, let us say, £300,000, what have they paid to the British in the last seven years, and paid, I claim, without any legal obligation that I can find within the Articles of Agreement for a Treaty signed on 6th December, 1921?

Comment on this

That ought to finish it, if you could not find it.

Comment on this

You are quite right. I am glad you have such a high opinion of my critical faculties. Article X. of the Treaty states:—

The Government of the Irish Free State agrees to pay fair compensation on terms not less favourable than those accorded by the Act of 1920 to judges, officials, members of police forces and other public servants who are discharged by it or who retire in consequence of the change of government effected in pursuance thereof.

There is not one word in that Article that obliges the Government that has gone out or the Government that is to come in to pay pensions to people who were not in the service of the Free State Government, because the words here are "judges, officials, members of police forces and other public servants who are discharged by it or who retire in consequence of the change of government." During the eight years from 1st April, 1922, to 1st March, 1930, this Government has paid to the British Government the following sums: Land annuities, £25,000,000 odd; pensions for civil officials who had retired prior to the Treaty, £1,101,000; pensions to the R.I.C. for which there is no Treaty obligation, £9,882,000. These sums alone make a total roughly of £36,000,000 paid out of this country, whose resources are comparatively poor, in eight years to the British Government without any legal obligation on us to pay them according to the terms of the bond here. Still we cannot find what is, in comparison with this, the miserable sum of £200,000 or £300,000 to restore to the aged pensioners what they used to get from the British and which was filched from them by the Free State Government in 1924. I should like the Acting Minister for Finance, before this debate closes, to say whether before paying the annuities for the first time in 1922 the British Government made any demand for this money and, if so, was the demand made in writing. If there was such a correspondence it would be most interesting if the Acting Minister for Finance would let the House see it. I should like to know did Deputy Cosgrave, when he was Minister for Finance in 1922, obtain the opinion of his law adviser before paying the annuities or the pre-Treaty pensions or the R.I.C. pensions. If he did, I am sure the House would like to know what the nature of that legal advice was.

It is possible that the Government of that day handed over that money because it had been the habit of the officials who had been in power here before to send that money to England. I would like to know if Deputy Cosgrave, in 1922, did himself pay away that money without having received any demand from the British Government, or if he got an opinion from his law advisers, I would like to know what that opinion was. It is extraordinary that a Government can pay out of this poor country's resources a total, in eight years, of £36,000,000 of hard-earned money. Every Deputy in this House has complaints from someone or other amongst his constituents about the harshness with which the income tax is being collected, and that income tax, to a large extent, goes to pay the £36,000,000 to britain, and now we are told that two or three hundred thousand pounds cannot be found to keep the impoverished and destitute poor alive for a few months in this country.

Comment on this

If England is paid out of income tax, what becomes of the annuities?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy should not interrupt.

Comment on this

What became of the Crown Prosecutors?——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

You are worse.

Comment on this

The Minister for Local Government talked of putting the people's feet on solid ground. I would like to know if somebody would be kind enough to tell us from the Front Bench opposite whether the solid ground of Irish nationalism was no longer ground enough to stand upon, but that in future the people were to be encouraged and ordered, as far as the Government could order them, to forget about the past, to forget everything that generations of the people for centuries have stood for and sacrificed, and suffered for. We are to forget it, and to wrap the Union Jack round us, and to become good citizens of the British Empire, or the British Commonwealth of Nations, to give it its later name. If that is the policy it is just as well we are not in it. Is it the element of the Independent Party for which the "Irish Times" speaks that is to rule in this country? Are their ideals to prevail? Are the principles upon which these gentlemen opposite, or the major portion of them— they are a very mixed crew now— entered national life, when they pinned their faith to the old national traditions, to be forgotten? Is all they stood for to be cast aside? And are we in future to understand that a definite stage has now been reached in Irish history, with the country split in two, with our entrance into the British Commonwealth of Nations, otherwise the British Empire, and that we are to stand fast, and not to look for any progress towards the realisation of our national ideals, but thank God for the day that gave us the opportunity to walk into the British Empire, to reap the material fruits that our ability to swallow our principles enabled some persons opposite to gather?

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

When President Cosgrave was proposed as head of the Executive of the Free State in June, 1927, and again in September, 1927, we on these benches opposed his re-nomination and nothing has transpired since that would give us any reason to change the opinions we then held, and we propose to vote against the nomination of President Cosgrave to-day. When speaking against the nomination of President Cosgrave in September, 1927, I gave it as one of my main reasons that I regarded his action as a political manoeuvre to get out of his promised obligations to the country and this House. He is due for election to-night because of another somewhat similar manoeuvre. I shall only say, in that connection, that it reflects no credit on President Cosgrave or his Ministry and it will reflect little credit on this House if they implement the action of the President in what is nothing more than a subterfuge in his attempt to get out of his obligations to this House. I do not think that in any country there would be found an action of the kind to which we have been treated by the President and his Ministers in thus, as it were, dodging—and that is the only word I can get to describe it—the vote passed here on Thursday night. The opposition to the various aspects of the President's policy has been expressed from these benches and from other benches. On every occasion that has offered itself we have expressed our position by our votes and it seems likely that we will have other opportunities afforded us in the future of again expressing that position and explaining it.

I do not intend at this hour to go into any matters of detail in that regard. I wish to say, in a general way, that my main objection to the policy of the present administration is that no real effort has ever been made by them to tackle the social evils which we are all agreed exist in this country. Anything that has been done has been nothing more than patchwork efforts. There has been no recognition, on the part of the present Ministry, of the fact that the State is nothing more than a collection of individuals. There has been no attempt to organise these individuals for the production of the necessaries of life, no attempt to organise the resources of the country and no deliberate effort to see that the services of individuals who live in this State are used to the best possible advantage.

People require to be housed, fed, clothed and educated. These are the normal wants of the people, but, as I have said, no regular, organised, deliberate effort has been made at any time, or attempted in a big way, to see that the people of the country are set to work to provide these necessaries. The Government failed to appoint anybody whose specific work should be the encouragement and direction of economic development. We debated that point on more than one occasion in the House. We debated it on the Bill setting up the Tariff Commission, and on other matters relating to that Commission.

[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]

We, from these benches, put forward the idea that it is not enough merely to have a body sitting who, if they are asked by some people interested in a particular industry, will consider the question whether or not that industry should be helped. They would then look into the question, but unless that question is put up to them they will simply take no action whatever. As I have said, in a general way, no action has been taken by the Government, and that is the main line of our objection to the present administration. One might very well think of the inhabitants of a country as something in the nature of a well-organised or well-ordered army marching to a recognised goal. Instead of that, we seem to have merely an undisciplined mob marching along if they are marching at all. They are certainly not all marching in the same direction. They are simply marching backwards and forwards, getting in one another's way, and generally hampering one another's efforts. We think it ought to be the duty of the body that is entrusted with the control and powers of the State to make a deliberate effort to see that some kind of order be brought out of chaos of that kind.

It has often been said, from both sides of this House, that we on the Labour Benches have no remedy for the social evils that exist, except doles and schemes of relief. That is not the case. We have never proposed these except as mere temporary expedients, and that is all we have ever regarded them as. They are necessary as such, but as a permanent solution of our economic problem we do not regard them as effective. The object of a Government, with the powers that a Government possesses, should be to organise the resources of the country so as to secure increased wealth production and so make it possible to maintain our social services at the level which we all profess to wish they should be at.

There is one other remark I wish to make. It arises in connection with this election and what happened here to-day. The point I want to make is that the Government is elected from this House and not from a party. The action of the Labour Party to-day, which in some quarters was not treated as serious, was intended to show, among other things, that this House is not elected as, say, the British House of Commons is elected. It is elected under a system of P.R., and it is possible under that system to have a collection of groups in which no party will have a majority. It would be quite possible to have here five groups of thirty members each. If we had that, I wonder what position Deputy Haslet would be in?

Comment on this

Do not worry about him.

Comment on this

He would not be here at all.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I am not ruling out Deputy Lemass from that class. The people who think and speak and make the observations that were made here to-day are really thinking of the British Parliamentary system with two or, possibly, three big parties, and not a collection of groups representing various interests in the country. What, after all, is Cumann na nGaedheal except a collection of people representing various interests in the country. That is the real binding link between us in this House. Deputies who talked as some Deputies did to-day, were really thinking of a system which is altogether different from the system under which this Parliament is elected. I think it is right that should be said. There would be nothing wrong, although the suggestion was treated in a humorous fashion, if, for instance, Deputy Murphy was chosen by the House to form a Government. If he got the support of a certain number of people he would be entrusted by the House with the control of the nation's affairs, and would get support so long as, and only so long as, he and his Ministry carried out the wishes of the House as expressed by its votes here. The Minister for Finance spoke as if——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I want to hear the Deputy on the proposal before the House.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I think I have said all I want to say on the proposal before the House. I will take another opportunity of dealing with the matter you have been so good as to allow me to develop to the extent you have. I seriously suggest that this is a matter the President or some member of his Ministry should give us some indication on, as to whether or not they intend to go on as they have been going, just continuing what I might call a hand-to-mouth policy on economic affairs, or whether they really intend to attack seriously and deliberately the question of organising our resources. There is no reason why we should not take into account the resources and the population of the country. We have not the same problems as they have in the great industrial country across the Channel. Ours is a different problem. We are in a better position to solve our economic evils than they are. The object of the Government ought to be to make a determined effort to solve our economic evils along the lines I have suggested.

Comment on this

In supporting the motion before the House I will do so in very few words. One reason is, I think, the House has got an overdose of talking during the day and is anxious to know who is to be the President of the Executive Council to-morrow. It is not necessary for me to say many words in support of the proposal before the House, because the strength of Deputy Cosgrave's claim to re-election as President, and to a further vote of confidence in this House in his administration, depends not on words and formulas but on solid achievement. The evidence of his success, and the evidence of his policy, is to be seen in this very Chamber, and in our cities and towns outside, and in driving through the country. There have been changed circumstances right throughout the country in the last seven years. Deputy O'Connell spoke about social services. Throughout the country the land has passed into the hands of the people. Good decent houses have been built in the towns and cities. I regret that in this debate to-day the Fianna Fáil Party treated us entirely to another Treaty debate, forgetful of the fact that we are electing a President for 1930 and not for 1922. The real opinion of the people of this country is that what matters is what is going to be done to-morrow and not what people said or did in 1922. Deputy MacEntee asked us what we had done to achieve any measure of freedom for the people since 1922.

Comment on this

I did not ask that.

Comment on this

I may be misinterpreting the Deputy's meaning.

Comment on this

I asked did you still want the Crown, and still want enemy forces in your harbours, and still want partition.

Comment on this

The Deputy asked us what advantages we were taking from the Treaty.

Comment on this

Do you want the Crown?

Comment on this

I am sorry if I misinterpreted the Deputy. I apparently took him up incorrectly. I was proceeding to point out that we have freed the people from squalor and we have freed them from misery and darkness. These are solid measures of freedom which matter to the people of the country far more than phrases and formulas. Does Deputy O'Connell think the country is still in darkness? Does he think no houses have been built and no land purchased for the people?

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

He thinks enough houses have not been built.

Comment on this

With regard to our old age pensions, that question was discussed when Deputy Ward introduced his Bill. I was trying to confine myself to the proposition before the House, and the attitude of the Government on the old age pensions is that whatever money is there should go to the poor old age pensioners and not to the aristocrats among them, a select minority who have farms and people who have deposits in the banks. Deputy Cosgrave's policy is that whatever money there is should go to the poorest and not to the richest amongst the old age pensioners. Deputy MacEntee quoted from an article written in a journal in a language which I am sorry to say I do not understand, and I do not know whether or not it is understood by Deputy MacEntee, but the policy of the Government with regard to the Army was clearly expressed to-day by Deputy Hogan. This is the place for laying down policy and not the columns of a newspaper. Deputy MacEntee no doubt listened to that speech, in which Deputy Hogan outlined a policy which should satisfy all parties. It was a clear and definite pronouncement.

Comment on this

But it was not made by Deputy Cosgrave.

Comment on this

It was made from Deputy Cosgrave's Front Bench and not repudiated by him.

Comment on this

So was the other statement that the people had not the right to elect Eamonn de Valera.

Comment on this

When a Fianna Fáil Deputy is speaking, we take it he is speaking for his Party, and we expect that when a Minister is speaking on a matter of policy it must be accepted that he is speaking for the Government. Quibbles of that kind get us nowhere.

Comment on this

Then the people have no right to elect Deputy de Valera?

Comment on this

We hold that the majority of this country have the right to do wrong, but Deputy de Valera differs from us. We are democrats, but the Republicans are too democratic to accept that principle. They have not the right to do wrong. If there is one obligation greater than others on Deputies in this House, it is the obligation of taking a decision on a matter that arises in the House. I can respect a man who takes a decision even if that decision is contrary to mine. I can respect people whose opinion differs from mine, but I have no respect for an individual elected for a constituency, and who comes here like Deputy O'Hanlon, and takes a studiously negative attitude on a day such as this.

To do anything positive you must offend somebody, but to adopt a negative attitude, an attitude of abstaining deliberately all through a day, is not what is expected from public men. The only thing which Deputy O'Hanlon achieved to-day was, as far as he could, to disfranchise Cavan. If we all adopted that attitude our lives might be a bit more peaceful, but I doubt if we would be doing the duty for which we were elected.

In conclusion, I would like to say that I am proud and happy to have an opportunity of supporting the proposition to elect William T. Cosgrave as President of the Executive Council. He was the pilot of the people in the bad days; he was the leader in the dark days; he was the man who built up this State to a certain definite extent. There is no reason why the people should have lost confidence in him. The pilot that led us out of the wilderness is entitled to lead us now. We are in sight of prosperity, if we have not actually reached it, and I am happy to have this opportunity of supporting Deputy Cosgrave's nomination.

Comment on this

The proposer of this motion told us that the people's hearts would beat with joy when the announcement is made that Liam T. Mac Cosgair has been re-elected President of the Executive Council. I did not know why exactly——

Comment on this

Abair an rud adubhairt mé. Ná habair rud ná dubhairt mé.

Comment on this

I took a note of what the Deputy said, and I am quite certain that my note is accurate. I was proceeding to say that I did not know why the people's hearts were to beat for joy until Deputy O'Higgins got on his feet. We have now been informed that Deputy Cosgrave's administration has abolished squalor, has abolished poverty, has given the land to the people, and has produced an era of prosperity the like of which we never knew before. I do not blame Deputy O'Higgins for talking in that manner. He is prosperous; he meets none but prosperous people from one end of the day to the other; he drives through Dublin in a motor car, and he lives very well indeed, I am sure, like all those with whom he is associated. But when he talks about squalor being abolished and poverty being non-existent, he talks nonsense, as many Deputies in the Cumann na nGaedheal Party know. There are 68,000 people in Dublin living in houses unfit for human habitation. Is that squalor or is it not? There are 50,000 unemployed. A quarter of a million people have emigrated while Deputy Cosgrave was President of the Executive Council because they were unable to get a livelihood in this country. That is his record, and it is because that is his record that I think the House would be well advised to reject the motion which is before it.

We get a good deal of this prosperity talk from members of Cumann na nGaedheal, and particularly from members of the Executive Council. Deputy Blythe went to a meeting in Nenagh on Sunday last. There were forty people at that meeting, thirty-nine of whom arrived in motor cars and one in a pony trap. They were all prosperous, well fed, fat people. At that meeting there was the correct atmosphere in which the Minister for Finance could denounce this infamous proposal to spend another quarter of a million pounds on old age pensions. He did not propose to give that quarter of a million pounds to the poorest section of the community; he proposed to keep it in the Exchequer or to spend it on the reduction of income tax. At that meeting I have no doubt but that the Minister's speech got the most sympathetic consideration. There was not a single individual there who ever had or ever will have to study the qualifications to which a person must conform to get an old age pension. They were not concerned about old age pensions except in so far as they had to pay for them through taxation. All this prosperity talk occurs in a prosperous atmosphere, but if Deputies of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, including Deputy O'Higgins, will come for a walk with me through my constituency and see some of the squalor, some of the poverty, and some of the misery that exists there, they will not be so enthusiastic about the re-election of Deputy Cosgrave as President of the Executive Council.

The old age pensions was not the only matter that Deputy Blythe talked of at this select meeting in Nenagh on Sunday. He announced, on behalf of the British Government presumably, that if Fianna Fáil should attempt to assert its legal right to retain the land annuities England would retaliate by putting a tax of £1 per head on all cattle and other live animals leaving the country. No doubt the Minister for Finance was duly accredited by the British Government to represent it at that meeting, but we would like to be sure of that fact. We would like to have it definitely stated that he had the authority of any British Minister, or any British politician, or any Englishman of any sort to make that statement.

Comment on this

I will go further. I will remind the House that I recently challenged Deputy Cosgrave, when he was President of the Executive Council, to produce an independent legal opinion to the effect that there is a legal obligation under the Treaty on the Free State Government to pay to England the amount of the land annuities. We have had opinions on that matter from such individuals as Deputy Rice and others who are associated with the policy or in the pay of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. Since this land annuities controversy began there has not appeared one eminent legal man independent of the Government Party to give an opinion in support of that attitude. If Deputy Esmonde can produce one such eminent legal man we would be very interested, and particularly interested to note the progress in promotion that that individual will make during the next twelve months.

Comment on this

The Deputy will not——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Let the Deputy make his speech.

Comment on this

I want to get this matter of the threat made by the Minister for Finance at Nenagh cleared up. Was he authorised by the British Government to make that threat? I have noticed in English newspapers this year statements made by every British political leader to the effect that they would not agree under any circumstances to a tax being placed upon foodstuffs imported into Britain from British Dominions. None of these British political leaders thought fit to qualify that statement with a proviso that in the event of a Fianna Fáil Government being elected they would do what Deputy Blythe suggested—impose a tax of £1 per head on our cattle. Deputy Blythe has travelled a long way since 1922. There was one time when he would not have been intimidated by thoughts of that kind, much less inclined to come out into the open to encourage the British Government to take such action in the event of a Fianna Fáil Government standing up for the legal rights of this country. Let it be quite clear that that was the function which the Minister for Finance was fulfilling on Sunday. He was in effect saying to the British Government: "If you take that action you can rely on the moral support of members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party." He was fighting England's battle against Ireland; he was supporting the English claim against the Irish claim; he was throwing his moral authority behind the British Government. It is to support that policy that Deputies are asked to re-elect Deputy Cosgrave as President. If they are content to do that, then let us have no more of these protestations that they are as anxious as we are to preserve the sovereignty and to protect the interests of this country.

The proposer of this motion said more than that the people's hearts were going to jump with joy when the motion was carried. He gave us one reason, at any rate, why we should re-elect Deputy Cosgrave—that he can deliver the goods, can bring corn instead of chaff. He has done so—Canadian corn, brought in here when the Canadian Wheat Pool thinks fit to let it in, and at prices which they think fit to charge. He can deliver the goods—British goods, delivered into towns where once factories existed for the production of the same goods. The history of his period in office has been one of stagnation and decline of industry. The story is one of unemployment and emigration, and I believe that the first step towards the revival of the prosperity of this country must be the removal of this Government from office. Deputy O'Connell, I think it was, remarked to-day that the people kept their heads remarkably well——

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

Oh, no, I did not say that.

Comment on this

Some Deputy on the Labour Benches said that the people kept their heads remarkably well when Deputy Cosgrave's administration was defeated on Thursday and when he resigned on Friday. It is a good thing to have it established that the earth did not stop revolving when Deputy Cosgrave ceased to be President. If this political crisis has produced no other result but to get that idea firmly fixed in the minds of the people it was worth while.

The members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party will not be able to go around foretelling earthquakes and other dire calamities if the Government is defeated at the next election. The Government has been defeated and nothing unusual has happened, except as has been remarked, a particularly prolonged debate. The Government's days are numbered. It is only a matter of a few weeks or a few months before their final exit from office. I think this House would be well advised to prepare the people for the day of prosperity that is coming by permitting a sample to be given now, by the election of some other Government. A minority Government in this House would not be able to do a great deal for the people in existing circumstances, but they could do something; they could break them in gently to the possibilities of prosperity, the prosperity that will come when a pro-Irish Government, with a pro-Irish economic policy, sets out to repair the damage they have caused. I think the greatest mistake this House could make would be to pass the motion now before us. If there was one thing more than another likely to destroy all hope of improvement in the future, to encourage increased emigration, and possibly a few suicides, it would be the re-election of Deputy Cosgrave.

When it was announced on Friday last that he had resigned a great wave of optimism and hope spread over the whole country, and people seemed to awaken as from a sleep, to view the prospect of brighter days in the near future. Now their hopes are going to be dashed to the ground. I appeal to you not to do that. At one time Deputies sitting on the benches opposite must have had some interest in the welfare of the Irish people. Let them search down into the bottom of their hearts now, and see if they cannot find there some justification, some motive for opposing this motion. If we reject the motion now before us we will have produced a position of stalemate. We can reconsider the matter to-morrow and possibly hammer out a means of carrying on an efficient government until the people are given a chance at the coming election to clear out the Cumann na nGaedheal Party altogether, as I have no doubt they will. The proposer of the motion and Deputy O'Higgins referred to Deputy Cosgrave as the captain of a ship, guiding it into port. The "Irish Independent" published a photograph of him at the wheel this morning. The ship is a long way from port still and there are many rocks in the way and if I know anything about Deputy Cosgrave we are bound to hit every one of these rocks.

Comment on this

As I understand this debate is going to conclude at 11.30, I have only a few remarks to make. Deputy Lemass spoke of the country waking up as from a sleep and seeing the great prospect that was before it, when it heard of the resignation of the President. Personally I would say that when I wake up every morning I wonder what new pronunciamento there is from Deputy Lemass as to what the new policy of the Fianna Fáil Party is. Hardly a day passes now in which we have not a full statement of what the policy is, not necessarily the same as the statement the week before, but, at all events, we have undoubtedly a rather long statement from him practically once a day.

The motion before the House is to elect William T. Cosgrave President of the Executive Council. I need not dilate on his qualities. The history of Ireland for many years past is, to a large extent, a biography of the candidate whose name is now before the House for election. He was called to look after the destinies of this country in a particularly troubled time, and, as far as he is concerned, I can say—and I think the majority of this House will agree—that there are very few people in any country that could have faced that particular task as well, as courageously, and as ably as he has done. It is easy to criticise, it is easy for one Deputy after another in the different Opposition Benches to get up and propose expenditure. What one of them will come down with the £30,000,000 Budget that would be necessary to carry through any of the policies, or half of the improvements, that they have outlined? It is very easy to demand money. The responsibility is not theirs for raising it. When it comes, as we have had occasion to point out again and again, to spending money we are faced in this House with opposition to anything in the nature of increased taxation. I heard the beginning of a speech of one Deputy on the Front Opposition Bench. I think he availed of the occasion immediately to start with the complaint that there was increased taxation. The same day that that complaint was made from the Front Opposition Bench, one of the members of his own Party proposed the Second Reading of a Bill that would increase expenditure to the extent of £300,000. It is easy to complain of high taxation on the one hand and to make various proposals for more and more expenditure on the other hand. Everybody would like to expend money on different social services. Nothing is easier than that. We have had many years' experience of that kind of demand from the different parties that will not accept the responsibility of imposing the necessary taxation on the people. This evening the Minister for Local Government pointed out the contrast there was between allowances paid to widows in certain counties and old age pensions. Why was there no agitation in these counties for increased pensions? The people who demand increased expenditure here know perfectly well they would incur unpopularity if they made any such demand, because in local matters the connection between expenditure and taxation is very clearly realised.

Deputy Lemass pretends—and how he could make the pretence after the speeches we have had to-day I do not know—that the Labour Party and this Party kept the 1922 issue alive. Not once was the 1922 situation referred to from these benches or from the Labour Benches. What we are insisting on is not the attitude of Deputy Lemass's Party to the Treaty in 1922; what we are insisting on—and we never got an answer to it—is his attitude to the Treaty in 1930. That is a question we would like to have answered. At all events, so far as our policy is concerned, it ought to be clear to the different parties in this House that not vague promises, not mere generalities, but the details of that policy is what is required.

Whenever the Parliament sits, practically every hour of parliamentary time is given to a discussion of the policy of the Government, directly or indirectly. Nothing else except an occasional Bill in which the Government is not interested one way or another is discussed in this House. So the one thing that ought to be clear in this House is the policy of the Government. I wonder have Deputies any conception at all of the extraordinary tasks undertaken by the Deputy whose name is now before the House for nomination and his Government for the last eight years? Have they any conception of the difficulties of taking a country that had emerged from different revolutions and wars and putting it on a solid foundation, putting it on the road to work out its own destiny in a sensible and orderly manner?

I know very few countries in which a similar problem was faced and solved with more skill and success than it has been solved in this particular country. I can only say that there must be extraordinary ignorance on the part of the Deputies who criticise the immense amount of work that has been done in a progressive way in the last eight years, very extraordinary ignorance of the difficulties one country after another that had been immersed in revolution had to face. The policy of this Government is clear. It is not now, and never has been, out for stunts. It does not intend to win the favour of the electorate by any stunt or by any promises. The President has had an extremely difficult task to perform during the last eight years. Remember, the measures that are now considered to be to the advantage of the country and are now accepted by everybody, when they were introduced by this Government and passed in the teeth of different types of opposition, received nothing but criticism from the people who now oppose this Government and who acknowledge that the schemes are good. I think we incurred, so far as the country is concerned, more unpopularity by the good work we did than we are incurring now for a great deal of the work we are doing or for our lack of enterprise in tackling various problems.

I remember perfectly well when the various Bills of the Minister for Agriculture came to be put into effect the country there was in the country. It was pointed out to us that there was no chance of people any longer supporting us, if we insisted in enforcing these Bills for the improvement of butter and cattle in the country. It was the same thing with the Shannon scheme. Every bit of good legislation that is now acknowledged by practically everyone in this country to have been for the good of the country was opposed with the same bitterness and the Government met with the same criticism that we have listened to here for the last two and a half hours. Let us realise this. A country that was kept in subjection as long as this country was kept in subjection, a country that, as I say, had been buoyed up with the hopes that are inseparably connected with revolution, entered into its new existence and it expects its Government to do a great deal more things than any Government is ever capable of doing.

There is no difficulty for Deputies to come in here, propose various remediable measures, or social legislation, leave the unpopular, the impossible task sometimes, of finding the necessary means for them to the Government and then opposing them when they propose the necessary means. We have been criticised—I think Deputy O'Connell criticises us —as indulging in a trick. I am surprised at a person belonging to a Party that always expresses a high respect for constitutional principles saying that. The Deputy had begun his opening speech by saying that the Government had done the right thing to resign and give the Dáil an opportunity. Now he looks on that right conduct as a trick.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

Not the resignation, surely.

Comment on this

We gave the House an opportunity of selecting various other Presidents.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

And took good care that they would not be allowed to select them.

Comment on this

We are bound to follow the Deputy's advice. We cannot exercise our own free judgment as to whether he is a proper person to take control of the Executive Council. Take the bodies that were opposed to the Government last week. Where is the unity amongst them? Deputy O'Connell said that the last man he would vote for would be Deputy de Valera, and Deputy MacEntee and the others would not go to the trouble of voting at all, either for or against Deputy O'Connell. What chance is there under conditions of that kind of any other body taking on the task of Government except the President who has taken it on up to the present? If there was such complete lack of unity between these two parties I suggest it is very unfair to throw the blame on this side.

Comment on this

But they coalesced when it was a question of voting against Deputy de Valera.

Comment on this

They had at least the courage to vote. They did not sit on the benches and take no interest whatsoever. Deputy MacEntee and the others profess great interest in the carrying through of the Old Age Pensions Bill. I suggest to them that it would be better if they had decided to support Labour. There was a much better chance, if they had supported Labour, because there was a possibility that some Independents who would not vote for Deputy de Valera would vote for Deputy O'Connell.

Comment on this

What a possibility.

Comment on this

We have had various policies put forward in the absence of the chief by the Deputies on the opposite side.

Comment on this
A Deputy

What are you giving the Unionists?

Comment on this

We are giving them nothing. Everybody who supports this Government supports them, I think, for the one reason because they think this Government and its policy is the best policy for the country. We have never entered into any arrangements with any party.

Comment on this

Does the Minister really believe that?

Comment on this

What about the Farmers?

Comment on this

They support us also because they believe, as was clearly expressed by the leader of the Farmers' Party, as the Deputy could have seen in yesterday's newspapers, that it is in their best interests to support us and oppose others.

Comment on this

Posts and Telegraphs?

Comment on this

Deputy MacEntee is disorderly when he makes his own speech. He is disorderly when anybody else is speaking. The habits of a schoolboy debating society should be kept out of this Dáil. As I say, we can urge on behalf of this nomination that of the different candidates proposed here to-day the one whose policy is known in detail and whose record can stand examination is the candidate who was proposed by Deputy Mongan and whose name is now before the House.

Comment on this

The Minister for Education tried to keep his face straight when he said that.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 80
·
Níl 65
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

William T. Cosgrave The President

I beg, sir, to return thanks to the Dáil for this great honour which has been conferred upon me. I propose, with the help of God, to carry out the duties of the office to the best of my ability. I move the adjournment of the Dáil till 3 o'clock to-morrow.

The Dáil adjourned at 11.40 p.m. until 3 o'clock on Thursday, 3rd April.

Comment on this