Nomination of Ministers.
Contributions 182–362 of 519. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
Is it not correct to say that General Collins specifically asked that the question of the land annuities should be reserved for further discussion?
Comment on this
What is this agreement? I say that General Collins kept these land annuities in this country while he was alive.
Comment on this
I want to ask Deputy Lemass a question. He talked about giving Irish people the benefit of the doubt in regard to land annuities. Will he and his Party give the farmers who pay the land annuities the benefit of the doubt?
Comment on this
The Minister announced yesterday that I favoured Empire free trade. I said that I did not. He quoted an article by me advocating the imposition of tariffs for the development of Irish industries. He tried to distort it into an advocacy of Empire free trade. I never mentioned the word "Empire" in the whole article. That is the irresponsible individual whom this House is asked to appoint to the important office of Minister for Agriculture. Beaverbrook's colleague— his Irish prototype!
Comment on this
Lord Bedisloe is yours. You quoted from him last year.
Comment on this
You know that we cannot answer—that is the difficulty.
Comment on this
The administration of the Minister for Agriculture for the past eight years has been marked by continuous decline in agricultural production. He has only been a member of the Executive Council since 1927, and therefore is only responsible for its decisions since then. Before that he was recognised as irresponsible. But since he first did acquire the position of Minister for Agriculture there has been a decline in tillage, a decline in live-stock, and a decline in every form of agricultural production, with the exception, I think, of sheep. The number of cattle in the country is less than it was in 1922; the number of dairy cows is less; the acreage under every crop in 1929 was substantially less than in 1922. The greatest Minister for Agriculture in the world! If any other country had a Minister to produce similar results, there would have been a famine long ago. The only reason there has not been a famine here is because this advocate of Empire free trade has been able to arrange that we could purchase Canadian wheat instead of growing our own. He, of course, calls that free trade. It is only free at this end. As the Minister knows, the Canadian wheat pool has not sold any of the 1929 crop to us yet, as we were not prepared to pay the price.
Comment on this
I challenge the Minister to produce that one phrase, "free trade," as having appeared in any single sentence of the article.
Comment on this
Was the Minister serious when he told us that he advocated Empire free trade? It is impossible to know when the Minister for Agriculture pretends to be telling the truth or when he thinks we should know he is not. In that same speech he told us that he was in the Post Office in 1916. We know that is not so. Then he told us that he stands for Empire free trade. Are we to accept that as a serious contribution or not?
Comment on this
That I would be glad to follow you in that matter.
Comment on this
The Minister proceeded to tell us that it was the policy of the Government to maintain the Dáil as the supreme authority, and to assert that the Army has no right to take sides for or against any Government. Was he serious when he said that? I take it that was a serious contribution to the discussion. I am very glad to know that. I wonder could we get the Minister for Finance into the House before the debate concludes.
Comment on this
I may point out to the President that there is a very strong rumour in circulation to the effect that certain of the leading articles in the President's newspaper are either contributed or inspired by the Minister for Finance. If it is not correct that the Minister for Finance wrote the article entitled, "The Army," which appeared in the issue before last, I think that fact should be definitely stated. The attention given to that particular article and the uneasiness which was caused by it, were inspired by the fact that the current belief was that the author was the Minister for Finance. Was he or was he not?
Comment on this
You should never deny anything. It is a bad plan.
Comment on this
Then we cannot get a definite denial. We find that there is a split in the Cabinet already.
Comment on this
In the old Cabinet, which is to be reconstituted as a new Cabinet. The Minister for Finance holds that the Army is superior to the Dáil, and entitled to force its will on the Dáil, if ever it differs from the policy of the Executive which the Dáil elects. The Minister for Agriculture stands for democracy par excellence. He is going to defend the Dáil against the Army, when the Minister for Finance leads out his cohorts against the Fianna Fáil Government. We thank him for the offer of an alliance. I hardly think we will need it. I am inclined to think that the Army would refuse to follow the Minister for Finance. I do honestly think that in matters of this kind we will find a much greater volume of common sense in the rank and file of the Army than we will find in the Army Council or the Executive Council.
I do think, therefore, that the President should prevent irresponsible Ministers writing newspaper articles of that kind. I think that the Dáil should express its disapproval of these militant contributions, reminiscent of the old style, from the Minister for Finance by rejecting this particular motion. We have seen that the Government which it is proposed to re-appoint has practically failed to achieve anything in any sphere of its activities. The Minister for Finance, when he is not embarking upon these incursions into journalism, is merely marking time and doing nothing, either to ease the burden of taxation by effecting administrative economies or by embarking upon any project for the improvement of the financial conditions of the country.
I asked him some time ago if his Government was satisfied with the working of the Currency Act, or if they proposed to accept the recommendation, made by the official from the Department of Finance who was a member of the Banking Commission, that the whole question should be reconsidered at the conclusion of five years. It is just five years since the Banking Commission reported. The Minister said that it was not their intention, yet anyhow, to reconsider the findings of the Bankers' Commission on banking. The Minister for Defence sits idle and permits one of his colleagues to undermine the discipline of the Army. The Minister for Agriculture has produced nothing but decay, as I have said, in every sphere of agricultural activity. The outstanding achievement of the Minister for Local Government and Public Health since last elected has been the reduction of housing grants, following the publication of the figures ascertained in 1926 relating to the needs for housing. In any case, the individual who was responsible for devising the monstrous provisions of the Local Government (Dublin) Bill should not be in any Executive. As to the Minister for Education I have nothing to say. Nobody takes him seriously.
The Minister for External Affairs happens also to be the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I think that if the President wants to continue the Department of External Affairs that, at least, he ought to secure some person to fill that important position other than the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I am convinced that the work of the Department of Industry and Commerce has been seriously prejudiced by the fact that the Minister has been gadding around international conferences in Europe instead of attending to the work to be done in that Department. With 50,000 unemployed here, with 25,000 emigrants, and with our industries declining when they are not being bought out by foreign financial interests, the Minister for Industry and Commerce is more concerned with the question of naval parity between France and Italy than he is in the matter of bringing about an improvement in the situation in this country. The Minister for Justice I have already referred to. He has failed to instil discipline or to produce efficiency in the Guards. He has failed even to induce them to act legally. He is certainly the worst of all. If for no other reason, if every other person nominated in the motion was an archangel, while it includes Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, then, I submit, the House should not approve of the motion.
Comment on this
I rise to support the motion moved by the President. In doing so I should like to refer to some observations made by Deputy Lemass to-day and last night. You, sir, pointed out that the debate should be self-contained, but Deputy Lemass has repeated in a more emphatic form to-day the statement that he made last night. Deputy Lemass, in answer to questions put by the Minister for Agriculture and the President, said that they had the unanimous opinion of counsel on the question of the land annuities. I must assume, of course, that Deputy Lemass would not make a deliberate misstatement to the House, and I must assume, therefore, that Deputy Lemass is not aware of the facts. The Deputy gave a modest description of himself as not being a leader or anything like that in the Fianna Fáil Party. From the statements made by the Deputy, I must assume that he is not in the confidence of the Fianna Fáil Party at all. What I am now going to state to the House is a matter of common knowledge.
Deputy Lemass, Deputy de Valera and other members of the Fianna Fáil Party have gone around the country making statements. I say they have deliberately misled the people of this country on this question of land annuities, and all the legal advice that they have about them. Deputy Lemass has stated again and again at public meetings that they have the unanimous opinion of their lawyers on this question. Deputy de Valera stated the same thing in this House on at least one occasion. That has been repeated at meeting after meeting in the country. I make this charge against the Party opposite, that they are deliberately misleading the farmers and the people of this country on this matter. I see Deputy Lemass smiling. He will not smile so much after I have dealt with this a little further.
Comment on this
He will probably squirm as much as he did yesterday when the Minister for Agriculture was dealing with him. In May last Deputy de Valera in this House read a list of the questions that were put to gentlemen whom he described as eminent lawyers. Of course, they were questions that no solicitor would put to any counsel. They were questions framed deliberately to elicit certain information and a certain answer. The most extraordinary thing about this case which was submitted to these counsel was that, unlike every other case that I or any other barrister ever saw submitted to counsel, the general advice of counsel on the question was not asked. That was deliberately omitted, of course, because the general advice would have been to this effect, that there was no foundation for the case being made on the question of land annuities by Fianna Fáil. The questions were framed up for the purpose of getting the answer "yes" or "no," and no other kind of answer, on the specific question submitted. They were, if I may use the expression, framed up questions to get "yes" or "no," and to get no further information. Deputy Ruttledge, who, I am sure, is a competent solicitor, omitted the final and most important question that every solicitor puts to counsel when he wants to get advice.
Comment on this
Counsel's general advice on the question submitted. If that had been submitted, it would have elicited the advice which Deputy Lemass and his Party got in spite of it from, I venture to say, one of the most eminent members in my profession in the last two generations.
Comment on this
May I ask the Deputy a question? Is he reflecting upon the legal authorities who gave their opinion? Is he suggesting they allowed themselves to be made political instruments of a party?
Comment on this
Certainly not. I say that certain questions were put to counsel named in this House and outside to which obvious answers "yes" and "no" were given. I do say that they were not asked the questions which would have elicited their opinion on the real matter at issue. I do say deliberately—I am sorry that Deputy Ruttledge is not in the House at the moment, but his friends opposite will have an opportunity of consulting him—that the party opposite have in their possession, and have deliberately concealed from this House and from the country, the opinion of an extremely eminent member of the legal profession. That opinion, summarised in popular language, is that their case with regard to the land annuities is nonsense.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy asserting that he is one of the legal gentlemen whose opinion was quoted in this House by Deputy de Valera?
Comment on this
I said that every legal person whom we questioned answered in the negative the question, whether there was a legal obligation on the Free State Government to pay the land annuities to England.
[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]
Comment on this
The Deputy and his colleagues have stated again and again all over the country that they have the opinion of well-known lawyers on this question. I deliberately state in this House now that that statement is unfounded, and to the knowledge of Deputies opposite. I will tell the House something more about it.
I do not want to make invidious comparisons between one member of the profession and another, but I will say that the member of the profession whose opinion Deputies opposite have, as to the effect that their case for the annuities is nonsense, is not merely a more eminent member of the profession than the barristers who are quoted as having given their opinions to Fianna Fáil but is an even more eminent member of the profession than myself—I knew that would tickle Deputy Lemass—and a much more eminent member than any of the persons whose names have been quoted in this House, and quoted by Deputy Lemass, as having given an opinion on the matter.
Comment on this
I will give plenty of authority in a minute. I say that when the Fianna Fáil Party submitted the case to this member of the profession he turned them down and told them there was no case for the land annuities. After they got that opinion they went deliberately about the country misleading the people as to the state of affairs. I state, without the least reflection on other members of the Bar, that that opinion would carry more weight with the people of the country than the opinion of the six members quoted.
Comment on this
Yes. I want to help the memory of the Deputies opposite, in case it is failing, for I am sure Deputy Lemass would not deliberately deceive the House. I want to refresh his memory, and I want to do it to enable him to make the information public, for it is an opinion that would be extremely interesting to the people of the country.
Comment on this
If Deputy Rice's statement is true, unless he has permission to make the statement, he is guilty of a deliberate breach of professional conduct.
Comment on this
Deputy Rice ought to be allowed to make his speech, and Deputies who wish to reply to it can do so.
Comment on this
I will give every facility for finding the name. I will tell them where to find the name. I advise them to consult Deputy Ruttledge, who was the solicitor acting for the Fianna Fáil Party. Is that definite enough?
Comment on this
I do not wish to give Deputy Ruttledge any particular trouble. The date on which the opinion was given was 3rd May, 1929.
Comment on this
I am not going to give the name in this House. The Deputy can get it otherwise, but I can give it through the Chair if the Deputy wishes. There is no necessity for all this hubbub about the name. Deputies opposite can get it from Deputy Ruttledge, who has it in his possession and suppressed it. I say it is not playing the game with the country when you get an opinion on four questions which do not deal with the general question and broadcast them, to conceal the real opinion you have, that there is no foundation for your case for the land annuities. I made this statement in the Sligo election last June. The Party with which I am connected circulated 10,000 handbills calling attention to the fact that the veracity of Deputy de Valera's statement was challenged on the question of land annuities, and no answer was received.
Comment on this
I challenge the Deputy's statement that there is any opinion that there is no case for the land annuities.
Comment on this
Let Deputy Ruttledge enter and deny it. I say he received that opinion on 3rd May, and that opinion has been deliberately suppressed.
Comment on this
We know something about Deputy Rice and the sources of his information. Let him prove his statement.
Comment on this
I do not intend to pursue this further, but I suggest that Deputy Ruttledge ought to be invited to return to the House and deny it. There is one further matter Deputy Lemass dealt with, and that is the attack on the Civic Guards' barracks at Newport. It was pointed out to him that that case was sub judice.
Comment on this
The Deputy stated that the Guards on the night the pretended attack was made on the barracks were drunk and went out. Deputy Lemass says he read the report of this in the newspapers, but it must have been in "The Nation" he read it, for the newspapers mentioned that four allegations made by the gunmen in the case against the Guards——
Comment on this
On a point of order, if the case is sub judice Deputy Rice has no authority or right to use the word "gunmen" in connection with the prosecutors or plaintiffs in the case.
Comment on this
I am not referring to the prosecutors. I only stated that the Deputy made the statement——
Comment on this
Can the Deputy prove that these men who brought forward the case were gunmen? I deny that.
Comment on this
I only wish to state that Deputy Lemass made the statement against the Guards, but he omitted to state this important fact, that the jury who tried that case locally in Tipperary found that the attack had been made on the Civic Guards barracks that night by gunmen.
Comment on this
I was told outside the Dáil half an hour ago that Deputy Rice was to controvert our attitude, or opinion, on the land annuities by a name, and that he would not give the name, as he could not. I would ask him the source of his information, if there is any such information existing, and whether he is guilty of dishonourable conduct or breach of confidence?
Comment on this
I am guilty of neither one nor the other. I had the permission of the member of the Bar to mention it.
Comment on this
I do not know whether that opinion exists, and I do not believe it does. I stated before, and I state it now, that all those who were consulted said there was no obligation to send the annuities to England, and I have no reason to believe that there was any opinion to the contrary.
Comment on this
I might be, but I saw the opinions. I asked Deputy Rice for proof, or the name, and he will give neither. He has sat as a judge on his colleagues on the Bar and he places them in the order of eminence. We are glad that at least there is one member of the profession as eminent as Deputy Rice, and I hope he will rise to as high a position. I do not want to go into the question of land annuities. It has been debated in many places and has been discussed sufficiently here to-day.
Comment on this
Before leaving the land annuities, will the Deputy explain the mystery why Deputy de Valera mentioned that seven opinions were given and he quoted only the names of six who gave opinions, and he did not say what opinion was given by the seventh?
Comment on this
I do not know that Deputy de Valera quoted that number of opinions here. I have no recollection of it.
Comment on this
But I state this, that I have seen the opinions given, and they are unanimous in this, that we are not obliged to pay these annuities to England.
Comment on this
That is all I know about it. I have seen the opinions, and the mystery, I think, exists in the imagination of the Deputy. I want to refer to the Department of Justice. Somebody says that we are all at it. It is very necessary, because it goes to the root of the matter. It is very important that a respect for law exist among the people of the country and that the Minister for Justice should try to inculcate a spirit of respect for the law. He frequently speaks here of civic spirit and of getting the proper regard for law and order, but it is my opinion that there is no Deputy in this House who is less likely to get that respect for law and order in the country than Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. He has been asked time after time to hold enquiries into the conduct of a section of the Guards called the C.I.D., and he has refused to do so. He has been asked by the public bodies in Clare to have such an enquiry, but he will not have it. I wonder why. Time after time matters were brought up here, and his reply was: "Well, the man got an epileptic fit and he was not beaten," though medical evidence proved that the man never suffered from anything like that. There is a kicking cow in Clare about which cow ballads have been written all over Connacht and in part of Munster. He has become famous for his kicking cows. That is not the spirit that the Minister for Justice should show if he wants to have regard for law and order. He challenges us to know if we want law and order and if we want the law enforced. I say that if he has a case against anybody he should get that person tried before a court and if he is found guilty he should be sentenced according to the law, but do not get men to persecute political opponents, people whom they suspect, often without reason, of having arms, to drive them out of employment and make it impossible for them to live in this country, for that is what is being done. Some of these people have gone to the courts, have got four definite verdicts against the C.I.D., and damages have been awarded. Other cases will come on, possibly with similar results, and I want to know what action the Deputy is going to take if he is appointed Minister, or if the President can tell us whether that campaign is to be continued, whether the same spirit is to actuate the Ministry.
Deputy Ruttledge briefly referred to the Gilmore case, and I am sorry that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney is not here, because I wanted to refer to it in more detail. In the lower court the case was so strong against the Guards that it was sent to the Circuit Court. In the Circuit Court a counsel was appointed by the State to represent Gilmore against the C.I.D. That counsel did not address the jury at the opening or at the closing of the case. Why? Was he not properly briefed? The C.I.D. had two senior and one junior counsel to represent them. Were they paid by the State? If they were paid by the State, what was the reason? Why was Gilmore given only one junior counsel—I am not animadverting against him personally—but why did he not address the jury at the opening or at the closing of the case? Was he not properly briefed? Did the State solicitor interview the witnesses and question them, or does the prospective Minister for Justice not think it is the duty of the State to protect the citizen and to see justice done, not at all costs to acquit the C.I.D., as if it did not matter to the ordinary citizen? That is a case on which I would like to have some more information, because the dice were loaded against Gilmore. What chance had he before a jury with two senior counsel and a junior counsel for the C.I.D., who were the defendants in the case, and one junior counsel for Gilmore—a counsel who did not, as I say, address the jury at the opening or at the closing of the case, and who was not, I submit, properly briefed? Would the Deputy also tell us why the counsel whom Gilmore had in the lower court were not retained in the higher court? That is the usual practice, and it is the ordinary practice in England. Why was it not followed here? That was but one sample of the spirit, and naturally the Guards and the C.I.D. take their cue from the Minister. He sets the headline for them, and they must necessarily follow. Everybody in this House knows that there is a certain section of the C.I.D., who vented political animosity against a certain section of their countrymen whom they are sent to persecute now. It was proposed in the Dáil once that a section of them who were prominent and who were bitter enemies of some of us in the civil war should be given other employment, and that people who had no connection with either side in the civil was should be put on such political work.
Comment on this
I did not participate in the Civil War, neither did the Deputy, and I suggest to the Deputy that if he is elected—and I hope that he will not be appointed to the Ministry of Justice, on account of the general tenor of that Department— that men in the C.I.D. who took a prominent part in the Civil War, who have political animosity against certain sections of their fellow-countrymen, should be given alternative employment, and that men with no such records should take their places.
Comment on this
I notice that Deputy Patrick McGilligan is nominated as Minister for Industry and Commerce, and it is quite meet that we should get some expression as to what is to be the policy of that Minister on the very important matters that confront the country at the moment regarding industry and commerce. It is very important that we should know what he proposes to do, and whether he proposes rather to create more unemployment than to give employment, as one would expect in connection with some of the measures he proposes to introduce. It has been hinted that there is an intention to carry out full development of the Shannon Power Scheme. What is the Deputy's policy regarding the people who will be thrown out of employment by the full development of that scheme? If we are to take it that he will continue the policy that he has carried out up to the present in that connection, we will get some idea of what he proposes to do if he develops it in full and throws other people out of employment. I am in full sympathy with the partial and full development of the Shannon Scheme in so far as it helps the nation, and it is helping the nation at the moment. There can be no question about it that it is a scheme that deserves support and that has proved fruitful for the welfare of the country. But when we consider that in various places people are unemployed because of its operations, we are entitled to ask the Deputy if he is going to throw other people out of employment without compensation if he goes on with the full development. I have in mind some forty or fifty people in Killaloe who are unemployed owing to the development of the Shannon Scheme. I have in mind the fact that I brought a deputation of these people to the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I have in mind the fact that the case was stated in full to him, and I have in mind the fact that, not alone these people themselves, but their fathers and forefathers, earned their living by a certain occupation on the Shannon. Not alone has the Minister refused compensation, but he has told me that he will not make an investigation on the spot in order to find out whether these people are entitled to compensation or not. He has definitely and deliberately turned down their application, and if we are to have a full development of the Shannon Scheme, we are entitled to know whether this is going to happen to the same people who follow this occupation on the Shannon.
The fishing on the Shannon is entirely disorganised. I have been told, and I believe it is true, that from Ardnacrusha to the source of the Shannon, only four salmon were caught as the fishing is thoroughly disorganised. I pass over his callous indifference to unemployment. The Deputy seems to have no policy and no intention of formulating a policy on the distress consequent on the unemployment that exists. There is no use endeavouring to try to induce him to formulate a policy. He is callous and indifferent on that matter, and I do not think, on that account, that Deputy Patrick McGilligan is a fit and proper person to be nominated for the position of Minister for Industry and Commerce.
In the matter of local government I notice that Risteard Ua Maolchatha is being nominated as Minister for Local Government and Public Health. I think no more unsuitable person could be nominated for that position, no person with less knowledge of local government administration, and if there is any position in which it is necessary to have a background of administrative knowledge, it is in local government. If there is one person in the Executive Council who would be fit for that position, and capable of doing something in it, it is the President. As for the rest, not one of them has any knowledge or any administrative background in local government. Certainly, Risteard Ua Maolchatha has no knowledge of the administration of local government. His only policy seems to be to concentrate, to draw everything to Dublin, to control it from there, and to centralise everything. That seems to be his entire policy, and thereby to create unemployment by the dismissal of officials from employment they held in the various activities of local government.
I would like to know if the Deputy has a housing policy. What does he propose to do towards providing houses for the thousands of people who at present need houses? No doubt the President can tell me that thousands of houses have been built within the last five or six years as a result of the Government policy; no doubt he will tell us that thousands of necessary houses were erected because of the Government policy. But have houses been erected for the people who were in need of houses? If he came down the lanes and byways in any town he would see the people housed in wretched hovels that they should not be in. Can anyone go round his own town and say that within the last five or six years there has been any appreciable diminution in the hardship caused by the wretched housing conditions? The money that has been expended by the Government in housing in nine cases out of ten has gone astray; it has gone to the speculative builder who erected houses for sale at a high price or for letting at a high rent. It has not provided houses for the poor people at present living in wretched hovels. In order to examine that closer one has to examine the situation in each town or district. I have here a report from the medical officer of health for the town in which I live —Ennis. I know the town pretty well. I have often gone around it, because I have canvassed it fairly extensively when looking for votes, like everyone else in public life. Here is what the medical officer of health reports regarding the position of housing in Ennis urban district: "The number of houses in that district which are not, and cannot be made, fit for human habitation is two hundred." No doubt, houses have been built in that town, and no doubt also there has been no rule made in connection with the erection of these houses to enable people to come out of the back lanes and slums and live in these houses. That money will continue to go astray until the Government takes up the problem and enables the public authorities to build houses for these people. The way the money is going now is not relieving the slum problem or the housing shortage.
Coming to my friend the Minister for Justice, I would not like to leave the motion without having a word to say about him, or he might take it ill of me. I want to put the position to him in quite a different fashion from that which was put from the Fianna Fáil Benches. The Minister was good enough at one time to suggest that I would not look like a fish out of water on the Fianna Fáil Benches. I want to say to the Minister that the way I want to put the position regarding the ill-treatment of citizens by the C.I.D.—the Criminal Investigation Department, or whatever is the proper name—is quite different from the way in which it was put from the Fianna Fáil Benches. I want to rehabilitate these men in the confidence of the citizens. I want citizens to be able to say: "Well, we have trust in these men." I want the citizens to be able to say: "Well, you have been charged with certain things, you have been charged with beating someone, taking him into a field and beating him black and blue. But the Minister for Justice ordered an impartial investigation into the matter which has disproved these statements, and we can trust you because no real evidence has been brought against you." I suggest that the Minister does not charge even Clare with an epidemic of perjury. I have affidavits which were made by responsible people who are prepared to repeat what is in them on oath. Yet, the Minister has not ordered an inquiry into them. They are matters of some importance. I have underlined a few statements in them—I will not give the Guards' names, I am particularly careful about that—and I will tell the Minister that I do not want to make any political capital out of this charge against the Guards. As a matter of fact, it may cause me to lose some support. There are personal friends of mine in the Guards boys I would trust in any circumstances; men that I do not believe would be guilty of any despicable, mean or cowardly conduct.
As for the men in uniform whom I meet in Clare and in the streets of Ennis, I know nothing bad of them. I know that they are carrying out very difficult duties with a minimum of inconvenience to the citizens. I have nothing to say to them in any event. But when a public representative gets affidavits of this kind to the extent of perhaps a score, and when these affidavits are submitted to public bodies, and that these public bodies through the mouthpieces of the representatives that come from the areas concerned say that these affidavits are worthy of consideration and investigation, when public representatives get these documents, and come to the Minister and privately and publicly suggest that an inquiry should be held, the Minister flouts the demand by saying there is no case. He said on the last occasion that I raised the matter that the persons named in my question were known to be engaged in a conspiracy to overthrow the State by arms. If they are known to be engaged in a conspiracy to overthrow the State by arms, there was a very definite and proper course for the Minister to take, and I suggest that he should take that course. If I come to the Minister in a fortnight's time and put down a question asking him why A, B and C, who are known to the Minister to be engaged in a criminal conspiracy to overthrow the State by arms are not arrested, what answer will he give me? He says they are known to be engaged in the overthrow of the State. If I put down their names and ask him why they are not arrested what answer will he give?
Comment on this
I answered you fully the other night and you asked me to stop because I bracketed you with Deputy Cooney.
Comment on this
We had better be clear on that point. I have no objection to being bracketed with any Deputy of this House. This House is a collection of the representatives of the people and each Deputy in this House is within his right and is entitled to speak and to be heard as any other Deputy. To suggest that I refused to be bracketed with Deputy Cooney is not a statement of the facts.
Comment on this
Did the Deputy not say that the very argument he put to me now and which was put at question time on that particular day was put in an argument against Deputy Cooney? I said I will answer the argument of Deputy Hogan and Deputy Cooney together and Deputy Hogan got up and said: "I wish to be left out of it." That is my recollection.
Comment on this
If the Minister says that is his recollection, I will accept it as his recollection, but I will remind the House that this is what has happened. He proceeded to answer Deputy Cooney's charges, which were quite different charges from the charges made by me.
Comment on this
No, the charges were quite different. I was not allowed to make may case on that particular occasion. There was notice given that certain matters would be raised here on the adjournment with reference to particular people in Clare who, it was alleged, were ill-treated by members of the C.I.D. For some reason or other that matter was not raised, and on the following evening the Minister for Justice proceeded to answer me on a case which I had not made. I think the Minister will recollect that is what happened.
Comment on this
The Deputy's facts are right, but the question which the Deputy put before to me and which the Deputy put again within the last two minutes is precisely the question which Deputy Cooney put the other night, and which was answered in the Deputy's presence.
Comment on this
I am not objecting to that, but the Minister for Justice elect has stated that I declined to be bracketed with Deputy Cooney on the matter. I declined to be bracketed with no Deputy, not even with the Minister for Justice elect. I am quite prepared to act with any Deputy, but I refuse to have a case answered by any Minister which I did not make. I am not beholden to Deputy Cooney to make my case any more than I am beholden to the Minister for Justice elect. I make my own case, and when I make it let the Minister for Justice elect in fact answer it. Let there be no confusion. I did not refuse to be bracketed with any Deputy. Let that not be done in the future. When I read a few extracts from the affidavit, I am sure that any independent-minded Deputies, even those Deputies sitting behind the Minister elect, will agree that they are matters for investigation. It says here: .... "Then searched my sister's room, and abused her, and pushed her about in an attempt to seize her private letters." Does the Minister for Justice elect think that it is right for any members of a police force to pull a girl about and try and seize a girl's private letters? It goes on: "I'll do whatever I like within the four walls of this house.... The police party got on their bicycles and forced me by threats and pushes to travel at the same pace. When I refused I was pushed along, struck in the back, and the bicycles of the police were run against me.... I was taken from the cell to the orderly room, there placed on my back on a table by C.I.D. man So-and-so—got up on his knees on my stomach, placing his thumbs in my throat and pressing them into it. until I was on the verge of suffocation. I tried to free myself as best I could. I was then taken to the back yard, and there my arms were severely twisted.... I was again taken out and placed on the table, and Guard So-and-So repeated the assault committed before, this time being helped by Guard So-and-So, who held down my legs to prevent me escaping from the other Guard."
I have refrained from mentioning the Guards' names, but I suggest to the Minister for Justice elect that if he wants the ordinary citizens to have confidence in these men he ought, in justice to these men themselves, have an inquiry ordered, and he ought to have that inquiry ordered immediately, and made as full and impartial as possible. I am not approaching it by assuming that these men are guilty in advance, but if the citizens are to have any confidence in them they must be rehabilitated in the confidence of the citizens by an inquiry.
Comment on this
In asking the Dáil to assent to the President's nomination of his Cabinet, I should like to point out to both the Dáil and the country that the task which that Cabinet has been asked to take up is no light task, and is a task for which very little thanks have been given in the past, or are likely to be given in the future. We are asking men to-day to continue to devote the best years of their lives to the service of this country, of continue to devote to the public welfare, and to the well-being of the Irish nation, years of youth and years of vigour which they might well, if they were different men, be glad to devote to their own well-being and their own advancement. We are asking the men whom the President is calling on to assist him in the task of governing this country—and I would like the House and the country to remember this fact—still to take their lives in their hands, because it is, perhaps, the salient fact about the political position of this country at present that we have not yet arrived at the period in our history when the lives of Irishmen, acting as the spokesmen of the majority of the Irish people, are safe in this country. The President and his colleagues are taking on again to-day a task in the execution of which they will be called upon daily to risk their lives.
Comment on this
The people whom we are putting into office by this vote would be carrying their lives in their hands day by day. We have listened to the attacks made on the President and the Executive Council. I would like the House and the country to bear that fact in mind. They are going into office because it is the will of the majority of this House and of the majority of the representatives of the people, and because it is the will of the people that they should go into office. They are being asked not alone by this House, but by the vast majority of the citizens of this country, to take up again the task that they have performed so successfully for the last seven and a half years. They are being asked because it seems abundantly clear to the Dáil that there is not likely to exist, for many days to come, any alternative Government to the Government of Deputy Cosgrave and his Cabinet.
We heard a great deal from Deputy Lemass last night and from other speakers in this House about the prevalence of poverty in this country, about squalor, starvation and so on. It is easy for any citizen who is not blinded by political prejudice, who has not his brain distorted and disordered by political propaganda, who is grown-up enough to look back for fifteen years and look at the changes that have taken place up and down the country during the past seven or eight years of these fifteen years, to realise for himself the difference that the freedom of this country has already made to realise the progress that has been made, in spite of every difficulty and every obstacle, during these years in making Ireland an Irish and a prosperous nation. I thought I heard a voice murmuring something about the Six Counties. That is the kind of talk we have to listen to in this House from one day to another. There is not one Deputy in this House who can afford to throw stones at the Government on the question of the Six Counties. There is not one Deputy who can produce any policy or any shadow or adumbration of policy by which anything more can be done to unite the Six Counties with the rest of Ireland than is being done by the Government at the present moment.
Deputy Lemass talked last night about squalor, about how we had only to go around the country to realise the depth of the squalor and poverty to which it has sunk. I could not help thinking when listening to Deputy Aiken that Deputy Lemass must have drawn upon his experience of his own Party, because the mind displayed by the speech of Deputy Aiken could only be described as a squalid mind, as a slum mind, the mind of a child distorted and perverted by some kind of misfortune. He is incapable of looking at any question straight, and incapable of taking a generous or a decent point of view about any political matter.
Comment on this
I have no wish to cross swords with Deputy Davin, but I am quite prepared to if he wishes. There are some arguments to be put forward as to why we should understand the distortion of Deputy Aiken's mind, but it is very difficult to find any reason for the distortion that Deputy Davin sometimes betrays in this House except the exigencies of local politics.
Comment on this
I do not object in the least to your not supporting the Government. I do not ask any Deputy to support the Government. If the support was to be similar to the Deputy's attacks on the Government, I would much sooner that the Government would do without it, not only his attacks on the Government, but his utterances in general. The Labour Party is constantly lecturing the other Parties in this House because we, according to the Labour Party, are keeping the Treaty issue alive in this country, because we are going back to 1921 and 1922. I notice that there is a certain amount of coyness on the part of the Fianna Fáil Party in recent weeks to go back to 1922. Apparently the word has gone forth from their leader that we are going to go back to 1014 for the future.
Comment on this
The House has already agreed this evening that in this debate we would not go back beyond 1927.
Comment on this
I am just as ready to go back to 1916 as Deputy Dr. Ryan. I have nothing to be ashamed of about 1916.
Comment on this
I would like to make this one statement. I think it is not fair that Deputy Dr. Ryan and other members of his Party should be allowed to get up and make accusations against me about 1916 without my being permitted to say where I was in 1916, if necessary. I do not think there is any reason why I should give any explanation to Deputy Dr. Ryan or anyone else. But I was at home on my holidays in 1916 for the reason that the people who made the rebellion did not think me sufficiently important to tell me that there was going to be a rebellion. I could say a few things about the Deputy's leader and what he was doing in 1916 that might astonish him.
I would like to point out to the Labour Party and to the country generally that this controversy on the Treaty about which so much complaint has arisen, and has justly arisen, is not being kept alive by the Government Party. We do not wish to continue debating about the rights and wrongs of the Treaty for one day longer than is necessary. It is not we who are anxious to go back, it is not we who want to rake up the past. Aided by Government organisation, we have spent the last seven and a half years in trying to build up the future. They are the only Party in this country who can claim any real progressive work towards the future of this country. While every other Party in the country was trying to eat away the foundations upon which the future could be built the Government Party are the only Party that can claim to have done anything towards that future. No other Party can throw stones at them for the work they have done. They can, at least, show some claim for work done on behalf of the country.
Comment on this
The Deputy always reminds me of a kind of noise which physicists say exists but which is so loud that you cannot hear it. I never can hear what the Deputy is saying. I have repeated several times in the country and I want to repeat it here again that it is not now and it is not within the next ten years even that the country will realise the immense work that has been done here by President Cosgrave and his Government during the last eight years. It is not this generation but future generations that will turn back to honour and to thank the men who stood with President Cosgrave in the breach in this country during these years, some of which were terrible years. I have said several times that in days to come historians will relate that under President Cosgrave the Irish people enjoyed the best Government that this country has seen for many hundreds of years. I know that Deputy Lemass and his Party have scoffed at me for saying that, and the Labour Party, who are always prepared to give a better Government than any other Party, are prepared to scoff at that. But I maintain the Government that this country has been enjoying for the last seven and a half years is far and away a better Government than any Government this country has seen for many hundreds of years.
Comment on this
It is better than any English or any Irish Government that existed for many hundreds of years.
Comment on this
It is a historical statement of fact, for which some credit should be given. What assistance has President Cosgrave's Government got during these seven and a half years? For the first half of that they got civil war; for a third of that seven and a half years they got abstention. They got the famous speeches that Deputy de Valera so often gave similar to the one Deputy Lemass has now given. We would be down in our graves before we ever saw him taking any part in the work of building up this country. The Treaty issue and the miserable squabble about what happened in 1921 and 1922 have been kept alive, and are being kept alive, in this country by Deputy de Valera, and by Deputy de Valera alone, and the people should realise that.
Comment on this
On a point of order. It was ruled by the Ceann Comhairle early in the debate that this debate was being confined to the present appointment and the recent work of the Ministry. Now, the Deputy is going behind all that and, having talked about the civil war, he has left himself open to the challenge: Who started the civil war?
Comment on this
I do not think that the Ceann Comhairle ruled that exactly. I think the ruling was that it was undesirable, in criticising the proposed Ministry, that the House should go back beyond 1927. I think the Deputy ought to permit Deputy Tierney to proceed.
Comment on this
What I am saying is that the squabbling about 1921 is being kept up at the present moment in this country by Deputy de Valera and his Party.
Comment on this
The Government Party have been always willing to forget it. Their existence is based on that fact.
Comment on this
The Government Party have always been prepared to use what was done in 1921 for the building up of this country. They have been doing that for the last seven and a half years, while all the time their opponents have been doing their very best to drag them back and to begin again the old, miserable debate of which the country was pretty well sick in 1921.
Comment on this
The Deputy should try to tell us something about the wars of the Spanish Succession.
Comment on this
I want to put the blame for the present situation in the country where it properly lies. I want people here and elsewhere to realise that if all this squabbling is going to go on——
Comment on this
I want to say this to the Labour Party and to the main Opposition Party, that if we are never going to have a discussion here without some reference to 1916 or 1921, then the blame for that does not rest on the shoulders of the Government Party, who have been trying to turn their backs on 1916 and 1921 and go forward towards a better future for the country.
Comment on this
There really must be some order. Deputies can deal with all those points later by way of speeches.
Comment on this
In so far as we suffer, and nobody will deny that we do suffer, from economic disabilities and lack of progress in this country, that fact is due to the other fact, that we still keep on squabbling about political issues which do not matter. The Government Party have always been willing, and are willing now, to let these issues drop.
Comment on this
I would like to make an appeal in the name of the country to Deputies generally. I appeal to them to agree to let these issues drop. I appeal to them to do something more constructive than to be always harping back on what Deputy Hogan said in 1916, where I was in 1916, or what Deputy Lemass did when he was in his cradle.
Comment on this
We ought all be prepared to agree in this country that, having won a certain political status, we will use that status to the best advantage for the country; that, having got an opportunity and nobody can deny that we have got it—to make this nation again a progressive Irish nation, we will use that opportunity, and that such criticism as we may utter will be confined to seeing that the opportunities which we have got are better used. Let us be prepared to agree that instead of quarrelling about the basis on which we are working we will get together and determine that we will all use that basis in an effort to advance instead of going backwards, and instead of trying to dig up every piece of miserable propaganda that we can think of we will turn over a new leaf, get back to honest politics in this country, and cease squabbling about such things as land annuities. Then we will not have these faked statistics that we have had from Fianna Fail; we will not have the carefully cooked and drawn-up figures trying to prove a certain political thesis. We will all agree that we have a certain measure of self-government and that we can use it to make progress. It is not fair to the nation, instead of using that measure of self-government in order to make progress, to spend our time here squabbling about that measure and trying to minimise what has been done.
There is nothing more demoralising about the present position than the type of political propaganda which seems to have become the recognised and regular thing in this country during recent years. Nothing is too fantastic to put into a political paper or sheet. No invention is too wild so long as you think you can blacken your opponent. You cannot go too far to search out some kind of miserable make-believe, street-corner argument to throw at your opponents. You cannot descend too low, like Deputy Aiken did this afternoon. There is nothing too mean or miserable for you to think of so long as you think that some mud will stick somewhere. As one citizen, it is my belief that it is about time we began to examine our own consciences about that kind of political propaganda. It is about time that we began to realise that the country does not want that kind of political propaganda. The country wants a rest as far as that kind of mud-slinging is concerned. The country expects from politicians sound political work. Instead of spending our days in the Dáil, as we have been for weeks past, discussing pure rubbish to a very large extent, we ought to settle down, if we are capable of doing it, and make some effort for the betterment of the country. If we are not able to do that, then we should make place for others who are better able.
Comment on this
Sometimes when I hear the legal profession attacked, I wince. I have a great regard for that profession as a whole and when I heard Deputy Rice here to-day committing breaches of professional etiquette, I felt as if I would have to hang my head in shame as a person in any way associated with the law at all. In his speech Deputy Rice suggested that there were six lawyers of eminence and respectability, experts who could be relied upon by the layman, men who were prepared to tell the truth, and when they were called upon to give an opinion they became parties, according to the Deputy, to the answering of certain questions in such a way that they gave a dishonest opinion, that they gave an opinion contrary to the law, that they indulged in a view that no judge would tolerate— in short, that they misled the public as to what the law is.
Comment on this
Deal with the framed questions and do not mind the opinions.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the answers to the framed questions. What I say is that the lawyers would have to be parties to a political trick and they would be dishonest to their own profession if they were to have done what Deputy Rice suggested they did. Does he imagine that they were simply handed so many questions and asked to fill in their answers? Does he think there were no conferences concerning these cases and going into the full law on the matter? It was for the purpose of crystallising these opinions that the answers were put to certain questions.
Comment on this
Is the Executive Council blamed for these answers?
Comment on this
Another thing I want to say is that it is a strange bird that fouls its own nest, and that is what Deputy Rice did in this House as regards his own profession to-day. He suggested that a certain mysterious lawyer had committed a breach of confidence in handing over his opinion, paid for in the ordinary way as between lawyer and client, to a third party who is an opponent. That is the case, or else Deputy Rice does not tell the truth in this House. I will leave it at that. I am sorry the Minister for Justice is not here because I want to deal with certain cases that have occurred. The first case that I want to deal with is not a political case at all. It is a case simply of a very foolish blunder in the administration of justice, one which should not go without criticism in this House because it throws a considerable amount of disrepute upon the conduct of the Department of Justice and the Courts of Justice. I refer to the case at Stradbally and the mishandling of that case.
Comment on this
I understand that there are law proceedings pending in that case, and if that is so, I think it would be very unwise and very undesirable that the Deputy should refer to it now.
Comment on this
The way I was going to deal with that case would not bear on any new cases which have begun; but at the same time the difference might be too subtle, and I bow to your ruling in the matter. There will be plenty of opportunities later on.
Comment on this
My position is that I was rather going to deal with the manner in which the whole case was handled, and not the merits of the case. I intended dealing only with the manner in which it was handled.
Comment on this
At the same time I am entitled to get this on record, that I think the Minister should look into the matter and have an inquiry into the conduct of certain policemen who were concerned in that case.
Comment on this
The Deputy ought to be perfectly well aware that he should not make a statement like that.
Comment on this
Well, I withdraw the statement if you think it has any implication on the action that is going on. I am anxious that the law, in ordinary neutral matters, should be properly conducted. I have here a case that I want to bring before the House. I had almost given up hope of ever getting a satisfactory answer from the Minister in reference to wrong conduct on the part of the Guards in different parts. I have a letter here from Mr. Patrick Healy, who was raided by the police on Tuesday evening, the 25th February, 1930, at 5 p.m. He was raided by two Civic Guards, accompanied by a plain-clothes detective, who arrived at his home at Ballycurrane in a motor-car. He writes:—
I was myself absent from the house at the time. The sergeant from Clashmore was the first to enter the house. He said to my father, "I must search your house." My father replied, "You may." Before producing any sort of warrant this sergeant and the Guard rushed into my room and proceeded to search. Meanwhile the detective in the kitchen produced some form of warrant, and read same in the presence of the household. Not one of the family understood one word, as he mumbled the whole thing from start to finish, and when asked to explain what he had just read he ignored the question and proceeded with the search. The only clue they gave was when the sergeant asked my father to account for my movements on Saturday night, 22nd. A raid took place on that night in a lock-up shop in Grange, three miles from my home, and amongst the articles taken was a pair of boots the property of the sergeant in Ardmore. Supposing they were in quest of stolen goods, I am sure they did not expect to find same in my private correspondence or in my pocket. They first searched my bedroom, threw the whole bedding on to the floor, ransacked every press, closet and drawer in the room, and carefully persued all my private letters, as well as books, newspapers, and several periodicals—that is, "The Nation, "An Phoblacht" and "Honesty," which I read regularly.
They were looking for a pair of boots in "Honesty" and the "Nation."
.... They did the same ransacking in three other bedrooms, the parlour and kitchen, and left the whole place in a terrible state.
Is that the way to carry out a raid? Is that the way in which policemen should do their duty in a country? Supposing that someone in that house had committed the robbery? Supposing somebody had, is that any excuse for rushing into the house, as they did, just as if they were dealing with armed robbers? He read the document in such a way that no one in the house knew what was in it. This is a case in which there is at least evidence to show that it was because he was a supporter of the Fianna Fáil movement that he was being victimised. But supposing there was not any political aspect to it, supposing the case was as black as possible from the point of view of the individual, was that the way in which the Guards should carry out their duty? I suggest that this is not the work of the Guards themselves. The people at the top are responsible for it. The Minister does not seem to be able to keep his wooden-headed Mussolini under control. Everything must be done by violence and terrorism.
There are so many cases that it is really impossible to deal with them all. Deputy Hogan, from Clare, has already mentioned some cases where there were some twenty persons raided, arrested, and searched without any colourable excuse for doing so. They were treated in a manner in which no human being should be treated, even if they were murderers instead of being honourable citizens and supporters of the Republican movement. This is not the way in which to get respect for the Constitution. "Constitution" is a word that is greatly abused. I wish we could get some short word substituted for it. But this is not the way in which to get human beings to live in a small island like Ireland in conditions of civilisation and of agreement of some kind or another—to live in peace and self-respect.
The Department of Justice is more responsible for the continuance of a feeling of bitterness amongst Irishmen than any other Department in the State. It is even worse than Deputy Tierney's speech, though I was very glad to hear Deputy Tierney make a resolution in public that he is never going to refer to the civil war again. While we do not propose to refer to the civil war, there is a certain insidious attempt being made to get the big guns of morality and theology on the side of the Minister for Defence. The Minister for Defence is more interested in theological defence than he is in the defence forces of the country. I suppose his attitude is ruled by the fact that there is now a representative of the Pope in Ireland, and he wants to put us in a wrong position by quoting Leo XIII against us.
Now, it just happens that Leo the Thirteenth affords perhaps the best explanation of our attitude towards the Free State, because his attitude in the Vatican as a voluntary prisoner as a protest against the Italian Government, which he did not regard as the legitimate Government of the Papal States, is very analogous to our position. While we submit to conditions as they are and do not propose to change them by armed force, at the same time we hold, as the Pope did in connection with the Papal States, that the Free State is not the legitimate Government. Just as the case of the conduct of the Popes from the time of Pius the Ninth ended finally in a Treaty of agreement, so we may hope, by keeping our end up in regard to what we believe to be the legitimate authority, to get a final treaty which will be satisfactory from our point of view. It is not fair for the Minister for Defence to quote small pieces out of the Encyclical of Leo the Thirteenth when I could quote long passages, if anyone would take the trouble to read them, which would be a splendid defence of our case and of the case of any country struggling for freedom. I do not want to say more except that I hope that the House will seriously consider the matter before voting and declare that, at least, in the case of the Minister for Justice a change should be made before the present Cabinet is appointed.
Comment on this
On a point of personal explanation, I understood the Deputy who spoke last to suggest that there was some breach of confidence on my part or on the part of somebody else in mentioning the opinion which parties had got. I have full authority from the counsel concerned to mention the matter. A solicitor of more experience than Deputy Little would be perfectly aware——