We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Nomination of Ministers.

Contributions 363–519 of 519. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Vincent Rice Mr. Rice

I am prepared to say outside what I say now, that a solicitor of more experience than Deputy Little would be aware of this, that while counsel's opinions are private and sacred on private matters——

Comment on this

Are you, sir, not going to insist on Deputy Rice withdrawing the reference to Deputy Little's profession? That statement was obviously designed to injure Deputy Little in the practice of his profession.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us hear the explanation.

Comment on this
Vincent Rice Mr. Rice

When I was last interrupted I was observing that counsel's opinion on personal and private matters concerning the rights of property——

Comment on this

I protest against Deputy Rice being allowed to continue. I say that he should be asked to withdraw the statement he has twice made, and which he has not the courage to repeat outside the House. I say that he is a disgrace to his profession.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, order. What exactly is the statement which it is demanded should be withdrawn?

Comment on this

Were you not listening, and did you not hear it?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Mullins should not make the disorderly remark that he has just made. The Chair is listening very attentively to the Deputy. I am asking Deputy Little what is the remark which he demands should be withdrawn.

Comment on this

The suggestion that I am not a solicitor of experience.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The statement which I heard Deputy Rice make was that a solicitor of more experience than Deputy Little would not say something which the Deputy is supposed to have said.

Comment on this

Deputy Little was not elected to this House as a solicitor, but as a representative of the people, and a statement which might injure him in the practice of his profession should not be allowed.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy himself made personal reference yesterday evening to another member of the House, not as a Deputy but as to his profession. I suggest to the House that, so far as the Chair is concerned, if a Deputy states that a solicitor of more experience would not make a certain statement, I do not think that I have the right to demand that that statement should be withdrawn.

Comment on this

That is the second time that this statement has been made in the same form, and I say that it has been made with the intention that a definite slight would be put on Deputy Little in his professional capacity, and we are not going to stand for it.

Comment on this

Is it not obvious to the Chair that the remark was intended as a slight to Deputy Little? It was obvious to everybody else in the House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is perfectly obvious to the Chair that most of the remarks which are being hurled across the House are being made with the intention of slighting Deputies on all sides of the House.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Not in their professions.

Comment on this

Do you not know the reason? Deputies opposite are in a very venomous humour this evening because of the holy show that was made of them yesterday.

Comment on this

Mr. Shaw is always brilliant.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Now, now. The incident is closed. Deputy Anthony.

Comment on this
Vincent Rice Mr. Rice

I just want to finish——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I will not hear another word. Deputy Anthony.

Comment on this

I did not intend to intervene in the discussion, because I believe that other opportunities will present themselves when we are discussing the Estimates, and also because of the fact that I believe that we have occupied sufficient time already in discussing this motion. I was, however, provoked into becoming vocal by the rather disturbing speech of Deputy Tierney. Deputy Tierney has apparently cultivated a habit in this House of delivering himself of very disturbing speeches. On the one hand, he proclaims his wonderful solicitude for bringing about normality in this country, but at the same time he takes every opportunity, quite unintentionally perhaps, of making disturbing speeches, as disturbing as any made by the most bellicose member of Fianna Fáil. We have had an exhibition of it to-night. Deputy Tierney got us back—not so far back, I admit, as Clontarf or Brian Boru—to 1916, 1922 and 1923, and exhorted us at the end of his speech to forget all about 1916, 1922 and 1923. Surely we have left the nursery behind us, and we might just as well leave behind us also the period of 1916 and 1922—at any rate the Civil War period. There is a rather restless author behind my back, and he will, I am sure, have an opportunity later on of making a speech which, I trust, will be as well put together as some of the recent literature, the authorship of which I very much doubt. At any rate, I would like to know how Deputy Tierney justifies the blood-curdling picture which he envisaged for us a few moments ago, in which he told us that the Ministers who would take office would carry their lives in their hands. I say that nobody in this House or outside it, believes a word of that.

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

I do not. I will have something to say about that later on. I want to know how does Deputy Tierney reconcile that statement with the statement he made just a few weeks ago at Tullamore, in which he said that the last eight years were the most prosperous period in the history of the country? One cannot reconcile a period of prosperity with a period of civil war, or with a period in which Ministers have to go about the country with their lives in their hands and revolvers in their pockets.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Kevin O'Higgins.

Comment on this

I am reminded of the assassination of the late Kevin O'Higgins. I do not think it is right to be reminding us of that. We all regret that very much, and nobody has condemned it as much as I have. I will condemn conduct such as that as long as I live, and I am not afraid to do it either in public or in private. We had these disturbing speeches coming from both sides of the House. So long as you have this kind of recrimination, a ripping up of old sores of this description, so long will you have the necessity for some Party in this House which is dissociated altogether from these tragic events to take up the reins of office in this country and bring some kind of normality into the lives of the people. I have grave doubt about the suggestion that Ministers' lives are in danger, and I very much regret the speech made by Deputy Tierney. I gave him credit for more sense and a better sense of perspective than he has indicated in his speech.

Earlier in the discussion Deputy Fahy spoke about a vendetta conducted against certain people in the country by the Civic Guards or policemen not in uniform, C.I.D. men and others. I want to submit that there are also Civic Guards in the country, and members of the C.I.D. too, against whom a vendetta is conducted. Let us approach this question quite calmly and fearlessly. Let us put ourselves in the position of any of those men who entered the service of the police force at a time when the country was in a bad state, and who, because of their activities in maintaining law and order, have incurred the hostility of certain persons. Is there not a vendetta conducted against these men? It is not because they are in uniform that a vendetta should be conducted against them. As Sir Roger De Coverley said, a good deal can be said on both sides.

I could advance many reasons why some of the Ministers should not be elected. I could, for instance, speak about the Department administered by Deputy Mulcahy and show, notwithstanding his proclamations and possibly the proclamations of the President also, that a great deal remains to be done in the way of housing. I could take my own constituency in the City of Cork where no houses have been built for the poor man, none at all within the limit of the means of the ordinary working class man in the city. A certain number of houses have been erected and some are in course of erection, some on the purchase system and others rented at a rent that the ordinary working man cannot afford to pay. That is the case, and no sophistry of the Minister for Local Government or the President can get over that fact. I will have something to say at a later stage in reference to other Departments. I certainly could not let the statement made by Deputy Tierney in the Dáil pass unchallenged. When Deputy Tierney speaks about cross-road speeches made by the Deputies sitting opposite, he should not forget that he was a sinner himself in that direction. I have here a leaflect which contains an extract from a speech which Deputy Tierney delivered at an election in 1926.

Comment on this

Are you trying to pay off an old score?

Comment on this

It is not going back to Brian Boru.

Comment on this

You are paying off an old score.

Comment on this

We won that election.

Comment on this

Professor Tierney stated, dealing with the question of unemployment that it was not a question of unemployment. The trouble was—I do not like to use the word, but I suppose this is the product of our latest culture in the University—the "lousers," meaning the unemployed, would not work. That is an emanation of the professorial mind. I leave it to Deputy Dr. Hennessy to say whether that is the thing the University stands for or whether that is the kind of product that it will turn out in the future. We have had some evidence already of what it turned out in the past, but I do hope that it will not turn out any professors with that particular mentality in future.

Comment on this

What has that to do with the question before the House?

Comment on this
A Deputy

Just as much as Deputy Tierney's speech.

Comment on this

I could deal with other Departments, but as I have already indicated, I will reserve any remarks I have to make on them until the Estimates are brought forward.

Comment on this

As Deputy Anthony has stated, we shall have an opportunity of discussing the various Departments when the Estimates come before us. I would not have intervened in this debate were it not for certain remarks which were made by Deputy Davin. I am, I think, the senior member of the House, who has been working on the Public Accounts Committee. Deputy Davin presided for one year with great success and with a great sense of fairness over the deliberations of that Committee, but I regret to say that in the course of the debate Deputy Davin referred to a report of the Comptroller and Auditor-General which has not yet been submitted to the Public Accounts Committee, as for as I understand. I understand that he referred to the report for the year ending 31st March, 1929, which has not yet been submitted to the Public Accounts Committee. I, as one member of the House who served on that Committee, would like to object to that, and to say that it is not right that such reports should be discussed in the House before they are fully investigated by the Committee.

Comment on this

On a point of order, does the Deputy suggest that I am not in order in quoting an extract from a report of the Public Accounts Committee already circulated and from the Appropriation Accounts circulated about a month ago to Deputies by the Department of the Comptroller and Auditor-General?

Comment on this

I think the Deputy would be fully in order in quoting from the report of the Public Accounts Committee, but I think he should not have quoted from the report of the Comptroller and Auditor-General, which has not yet been submitted for examination by the Committee of Public Accounts.

Comment on this

On that point I quoted from the report of the Committee of Public Accounts, and I also gave a quotation from a public document. I expressed no opinion on what I quoted from the Appropriation Accounts. I certainly believe that I have a right to quote from documents once they are circulated from the Department to Deputies and have been published in the Press.

Comment on this

I agree that the Deputy has the right, but I do not think it is advisable.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is another matter altogether.

Comment on this

In the interests of the general procedure of the House we should not discuss the report of the Comptroller and Auditor-General until such time as it has been examined by the Committee.

Comment on this

I have much pleasure in supporting the re-election of the Ministers nominated by the President. I should like to take this opportunity of suggesting that the Government got a complete vote of confidence in this House yesterday, and that, in view of the unique opportunity provided by the fact that we have the lowest bank rate for the past seven years, they ought now to consider the advisability of tackling on a more extensive scale housing and other reproductive schemes. I know they were severely handicapped during the past year owing to the fact that we had a 7½ per cent. bank rate, and I think the Minister for Finance is deserving of the highest possible congratulation for having refrained during that period from floating a loan. We have now a 3½ per cent. bank rate in England, with the prospect of an immediate reduction to 3 per cent., and probably before next June a 2½ per cent. rate. I, therefore, say that this is the acceptable time, owing to the fact that we are able to procure money at half the previous rate, which will allow houses to be built so that they can be let at an economic rent. I certainly think that if the House devoted more time to matters of that kind, rather than to the balderdash we have been listening to for hours and hours during the past month, they would be better occupied.

I should like to say that if the Fianna Fáil Party think that their slanderous and venomous attacks on the Civic Guards are improving their position in the country they are under a very wrong impression. The Guards enjoy the confidence of the vast majority of the people and of all decent people. I have stated here before, and I repeat, that the Civic Guards are and always will be a living tribute to the memory of the late Minister for Justice, who was responsible for their establishment. The venomous attacks made on the Civic Guards come very badly from any Deputies. The Minister for Justice has a very difficult job in maintaining law and order, and it is an extraordinary thing to hear Deputies championing a person who was caught walking through Dublin with a live land mine and calling that person a patriot. I am not surprised at the bad humour that the Fianna Fáil Party are in to-day because they were made such a show of yesterday. Not alone was Deputy de Valera an "also ran," but the fact that he was beaten by 39 votes shows what was thought of him by the people here who have an opportunity of seeing and hearing him. I am sure Deputy O'Kelly must have been astonished and disappointed at the huge majority that trooped into the lobby to vote against Deputy de Valera. I should like to know what Deputy de Valera thought and what the people in America thought.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Yesterday's motion is closed, and a decision of the House was taken on it.

Comment on this

I have nothing further to say, only that I am sorry for any Deputies who make slanderous and venomous attacks on a body of men who are held in the highest respect in this country and who are the admiration of the world. An unarmed force, they have to stand up against men who are armed, and I certainly should like to pay the highest possible tribute to them.

Comment on this

I am afraid that a large percentage of the speeches this afternoon have dealt to a very great extent with personalities, with the result that the motion before the House has become somewhat obscured. The motion is "That the Dáil assents to the nomination of the following Deputies as Ministers, to be members of the Executive Council, and in charge of the Departments named hereunder." I observe that each of the outgoing Ministers has been re-nominated, which means, in effect, that the House is asked to dot the i's and cross the t's and acquiesce in everything that these Departments have done since the last election. I do not think there are any Deputies, irrespective of the Parties to which they belong, who would acquiesce in all that has been done by the various Departments.

Let us take, for instance, the question which gave rise to the political crisis, that of old age pensions. The House has been asked to endorse, on the one hand, the action of the Minister for Finance in refusing to give effect to a decision arrived at by a majority in this House. A majority of Deputies came to the conclusion that better terms should be given to the old age pensioners. The Minister for Finance, whose duty it should have been to introduce a money resolution to give effect to the will of the majority of Deputies, refused to do so. Still, we are asked to re-elect that Minister and to acquiesce in that policy and agree to let old age pensioners go as far as he is concerned.

Deputy Shaw referred to the question of housing. I was very glad to hear him and other Deputies refer to this question, because the working classes cannot see eye to eye with the housing policy put forward by the Minister for Local Government. Under the 1925 Housing Act it was possible for a comparatively wealthy person in Dublin, Cork, Limerick, or elsewhere, who was able to put up £500 or £600, to obtain a free grant of £100 from the Government to help him to build a house. In addition to that, he was able to obtain a further free grant up to £75 to assist him in the building of the house. The result is that as far as the comparatively wealthy classes are concerned we find that quite a number of houses have been built. It would be very interesting if we knew how many of these houses have motor garages attached to them.

Let us compare, on the other hand, the manner in which the Local Government Department, acting through the Minister, have treated the working classes. The British Government during their régime in this country were responsible for doing one good thing, and that was for creating within the Twenty-Six Counties over 44,000 agricultural workers' cottages. Those cottages are let to labourers at a rent which their meagre purses can afford. At the same time, although there are over 44,000 cottages in the Free State, there is, and has been for quite a long time, a necessity for the erection of more cottages all over the country. I submit that while the Minister for Local Government is prepared to give a comparatively wealthy person, who has £500 or £600, a sum of £100 under the 1925 Act, it should be the policy of the Minister to give to boards of health for every agricultural worker's cottage they put up a free grant of £100 as well as a long-term loan. That is not being done. Consequently, we on these benches think that the Local Government Department have not done their duty as far as the agricultural workers' cottages are concerned.

Another Ministry that the House is asked to acquiesce in is that of Lands and Fisheries. It has been pointed out on numerous occasions that we believe that that Ministry has not done its duty in endeavouring to develop the fisheries and to put the fishing industry on a firm and solid basis, and in endeavouring to try and improve the economic position of the fishermen. We also believe that that same Ministry is not endeavouring to carry out the policy as enunciated in the White Paper, in connection with the Gaeltacht Commission in reference to rural industries. Many times when I looked into what this Department has done, or was endeavouring to do, I came to the conclusion that apparently the policy of the Department was to retard in many cases rural industries instead of endeavouring to improve them. These are a few reasons as to why we do not acquiesce in the policy carried out for some time past by the Minister for Finance, the Minister for Local Government and the Minister for Lands and Fisheries, and that could all be elaborated to a very great extent. For these reasons that I have advanced and many other reasons that could be advanced I believe it is the duty of Deputies not to acquiesce in the policy as carried out by these Departments whose Ministers we are called upon to re-elect to-night.

Comment on this

Nobody regrets more than I do that unpleasantness has crept into this debate both to-day and yesterday. If any Deputies in the House think that the Fianna Fáil Party had the intention, or the design, of introducing that unpleasantness they are making a mistake. It was our desire that this whole discussion should be carried on on a plane worthy of the subject. Once it starts it is almost impossible to end it, and I think that those who took advantage of renewing the general campaign of slander against Deputy de Valera which has been going on in the Press of this country for the past eight years have only themselves to blame. If they think that the effect of that campaign is to weaken Deputy de Valera in the position he holds on this side of the House and in the affection and esteem of his followers they are mistaken. Far from weaning away any support from him, they will only serve to enshrine him more firmly in our hearts.

We heard a number of statements made about Deputy de Valera. I want to refer to them on account of the fact that on repeated occasions references, like the reference by Deputy Rice to Deputy Little, and the reference by Deputy McGilligan to Deputy Moore, and by other Ministers to Deputy Aiken, that they were persons of mean intelligence, persons without experience, and all that kind of thing are, in my opinion, bad for this House. If people opposite, who have the experience of Government, and who claim that they are the only party fit and willing and able to carry on that Government, would turn their attention to controlling the utterances of some of the most prominent members of their party, we would all find it so much more easy and pleasurable to sit here and listen to speeches made in the House.

The Minister for Defence, whose nomination is before us with other nominations this afternoon, said yesterday, in spite of the fact that Deputy Fahy, who is recognised as one of the most moderate members of this Party, and who said this evening that he did not take any part in the civil war, made a categorical denial of the interpretation that the Minister for Defence sought to put upon his statement when he said it was a palliative of murder, still the Minister for Defence persisted in that statement. He then went on to say that Deputy de Valera was carrying on in America very dubious methods in connection with the raising of money for his paper. I found fault with the President of the Executive Council before for dragging that question of a daily paper —a business enterprise which has no connection with the business of this House and could be more fitly discussed outside if it is to be discussed at all—and for referring to that matter. I can only assume that the lead the President gave on that occasion was primarily responsible for his colleague's lapse in referring to Deputy de Valera's dubious methods.

The Minister for Defence said that if Deputy de Valera did in this country what he was doing in America he would presumably be open to an action under the law of the land. He made that statement, as other statements were made about Deputy de Valera, intending to injure him in his personal character and his honour, knowing that Deputy de Valera was not here to answer him and that no member of this Party, at such short notice, could get up the facts of the situation to controvert what the Minister had said. If controversy like that is to be indulged in no member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party has any right to object and the Press has no right to object if the whole question of the Treaty and that sort of thing is going to be discussed ad infinitum. So long as you have these personal attacks upon the character and reputation of members of a Party who have come in here I believe at any rate, and I frequently said so, to do their best to co-operate in carrying out a policy for the general benefit of the country and the general advancement of its interests, so long as that kind of campaign is carried on, co-operation will become very difficult and almost impossible.

It may be that one of the reasons that Ministers fall back upon that kind of argument is that they have no policy to put before the Dáil. The fact that the President, in proposing for renomination the members of his Cabinet to-day made no statement whatever with regard to his future policy would go to bear out my contention. As far as I can see there is no legislation before this Dáil out of the large number of Bills that have been promised in connection with agriculture, town tenants, fisheries and various other questions, except the Greater Dublin Bill. It is very significant that we have had no reference made in the whole course of the debate by any representative of the Government Party or by the President or by Ministers who now seek office as to the measures of legislation that they are going to put before the country.

Yesterday the Press was filled up with the usual argument about a bread and butter policy. Deputy MacEntee has said, and I am prepared to endorse what he has said, that we are prepared to face the future in the same spirit I hope as other members of other Parties in this House. But if on that question of bread and butter any futile discussion is going to be raised we are going to say in answer to that "go down the country, ask the traders and shopkeepers and farmers and labourers, where is the bread and butter that they were promised at every election whenever a political crisis arose since 1922" and they will tell you that they have not got it.

[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]

It is very significant that we hear a great deal about bread and butter when the Government is in any crisis, but as soon as the crisis is over we hear nothing about it, but only the campaign about the defeatist policy of Fianna Fáil and their anxiety to belittle the institutions in this country, and so on. If there is anything that is belittling these institutions it is the campaign that is being carried on of vilification in this House and elsewhere. That ought to be got rid of if we want people to look up to this House, to pay attention and follow the argument that takes place in it, and to believe we are all as serious as we would have one another believe. Deputy Shaw says that the Fianna Fáil Party are in a very bad humour because they have been defeated. The Deputy is under a misapprehension. The Fianna Fáil Party are in much better humour than they have been at any time since they came into this House. From Deputy Shaw, who was absent from the division on the Old Age Pensions Bill, it comes with singular inappropriateness that he should lecture us now as to what our feelings may be after yesterday's performance. The Deputy could not be found when the voting was to be recorded on the Old Age Pensions Bill. He was, by some miraculous dispensation of Providence, absent, but he was not absent yesterday. He turned up to put President Cosgrave back into office and to give him a majority which would try to make the country believe that he is quite safe for a few years more.

Deputy Shaw and the Irish Press are quite right to call attention to the attitude of the Fianna Fáil Party to the institutions of this State. As far as I am concerned, I have taken no part in the discussions in this House on either the Army or the Civic Guard. I want to say that the speeches of Deputy Ruttledge and of Deputy Fahy—I do not know so much about other speeches that were made, because I did not hear them—referred to definite incidents that took place down the country. The general demand of the Fianna Fáil Party in this matter is, I submit, a very moderate one. The refusal to agree to our request is doing far more harm to the Civic Guard force than the result of any inquiry, even if we admit that there are persons in that force as bad as the worst of those that have been described. If the Minister for Justice really wants to reassure the country in this matter, I think he would be well advised to have an inquiry and to finish up the whole question. Let us definitely get to the bottom of this matter. Let us, on both sides of the House, have the feeling that the Civic Guard force is above suspicion.

I believe that the Civic Guards are a body of men who are carrying out their duty well and are giving general satisfaction. I agree with Deputy Shaw that they are popular in the country. There are individuals, however, attached to the force, and I say, as I have said before, that these men have not a sense of responsibility. I have personal experience of that matter. I am not going to quote instances, but I simply say that a case has been made and that no effort has been made to answer it. There is no use in coming along with the argument that we are trying to besmirch the whole Civic Guard or that we are antagonistic to them. We are no such thing. We have definite charges made. We have the individuals who made them. We have court cases and we have the support of public bodies throughout the country. All we ask for is an impartial inquiry into these matters. Now if there is a desire at all to have what is called constitutional government or to recognise that this Party represents the opinion of the people who sent us here, I submit that if the Minister for Justice is faithful to his responsibility and takes a serious view of his office, he is certainly bound, in common decency and fair play, to examine this whole question.

We are told that the Executive is going to take up office with the assistance of the Independents. We are told by the organ of the Independents that a decisive factor in the control of the government of the country is this Independent group. It is quite patent, and no denial of it has been made from the Government Benches, that negotiations are going on between the Party opposite and the persons styled the Independent group by which, for the next two years, if the negotiations are successful, the Party in office will be under the thumb, the control and influence of what is called the Independent group. The members of that group are quite right to try and get their pound of flesh. They are quite right, as the "Irish Times" says, to hold the country to ransom, to drive a hard bargain and to see that they get a full return for the debt that is due to them for the support they have given the Government during the past number of years. But the country will be very anxious to know what is the quid pro quo in this case.

What is it proposed the Cumann na nGaedheal Party shall give to the Independents in return for their renewed allegiance and for the promise of their further support? We read that one of the things that the Independents will look for, and that it will be their duty to force upon the Government an acceptance of, will be the promotion of the special interests of that minority, and respecting the sentiments and traditions which are very dear to it. Does that mean that the members of that Party who, on a celebrated occasion in this House found themselves in a minority of fifteen against the combined vote of the other Parties on the vital issue of the Irish language, are going to be in the position in this House where they can dictate a policy of retrogression in carrying the Irish language not alone through the schools, but through the offices of the public Departments, the public bodies and general institutions of the country into universal and general use until it becomes the spoken and common language of the people? Does it mean that the national sentiments which Deputy Seán T. O'Kelly rightly stressed in his address yesterday, which the founders of this State and the signatories to the Treaty have held and declared it was their purpose and object to carry out, are going to be scrapped in order that the Cumann na nGaedheal Party may secure the support of this minority?

We are told that every man has his price, and the Independents may become cynical if they are not paid their price. The one refreshing thing about all this discussion, the one thing that must rejoice the Independents and their supporters, is that while this campaign of slander and vilification has been going on in this House, and which is giving so much joy to the English Press, they are a calm, detached, uncynical and philosophical Party which can wait quietly until the time comes to strike, and then when it sees the occasion arise to drive a bargain, it will drive a bargain. Let the Government Party put their cards upon the table and state whether they are going to stand by the national aspirations of the men who accepted the Treaty as a stepping-stone to freedom, as a foundation to work out the full national aspirations of this people, or are they going to go back as they have gone back on minor issues—for instance, on the City of Dublin Bill and on the Poor Relief Bill—at the behest and at the dictation of this minority? Are they going to force the whole national position backward by giving in now to the dictation that the "Irish Times" proposes to impose upon them?

Comment on this

I did not intend to take part in this debate only that Deputy Derrig seems to attribute all sorts of sinister intentions to the Independents. I think he said that negotiations were proceeding between the Government Party and the Independent group. That is not correct. As far as I know there are no negotiations proceeding between the Independents and the Government Party. I think it would be impossible for the President to select an Executive which would be pleasing to everyone. At the same time. I am sure he has done his best to select the most suitable Deputies for the different positions. There are one or two things I would like to criticise, if I may. One affects the President. Some time ago there was a Commission on the supposed grievances of ex-Servicemen. The Report of that Commission suggested that certain things might be done. The President, perhaps from lack of time, or otherwise, has not given the Report that consideration to which it was entitled. There is one other matter—I am not sure what Minister is concerned with it—and that is the Report on the Control of Motor Traffic which was issued on 1st September, 1928. Time and time again we have been promised legislation to deal with motor traffic, but it has been put off, and accidents have been multiplying in the meanwhile. The Government have spent a great deal of time on other measures, such as the protection of wild birds, and I think they might also try and do something to protect human beings as well.

Comment on this

The President, who the other day deliberately flouted the will of this House, now starts coming back into office with the old campaigners. Deputy Derrig has asked the price paid to the Independents. I do not think there is any occasion to put that question. We had it demonstrated here to us on other few occasions who are the real rulers in this Dáil. It was clearly demonstrated on one occasion by the Minister for Local Government when he introduced an amendment, spoke in favour of it for twenty minutes, but when the Independents said "No" he walked into the Lobby followed by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party and voted against his own amendment.

I was anxious last night to appeal to the President that in view of the condition of affairs in the TwentySix Counties he would, at least, put his cards on the table and tell us exactly what he is giving this Independent group. Of course, we can realise from the manner in which he has carried on here in the last few years what price he is paying those gentlemen. We have no doubts as to the position of the Farmers' Party. They have remained absolutely dumb during the past two days. Not a word has been heard from them about de-rating or the present position of farmers. They are quite willing to let the farmers carry on in hunger, starvation and misery so long as one of their number occupies a decent post at the price of the votes of the other five. That is the position of affairs with regard to them, and they make no secret of it. They came in here and voted against the vesting of holdings, the retention of land annuities, and against everything which would be of any benefit to the farming community.

I think the price paid to the Independents is very clear, and if the President even to-night has the pluck to cast them aside and tell them openly here that no longer is he going to be not the head of the Government but the tail of the Freemason party in this country then we would be prepared to do something with him. A few days ago a couple of them broke away. They did not get their price, of course, but they have got it now. I am not going to go back to 1922. I do not consider that the late Minister for Local Government should be re-elected. I think he is absolutely incapable of filling that position. He has proved that he has no knowledge whatever of the present position of the ratepayers who have to foot the bill. His attitude here, and the replies he gives to questions here, is nothing but the attitude of a dictator throughout. Some time ago I had occasion to raise some questions in this House on combined purchasing, and the Minister proved that he knew nothing about it, or that he did not wish to reply to the queries put. I pointed out that under the Combined Purchasing Act the present Department is more corrupt than it was even under the worst rural district council in Ireland nine or ten years ago. I repeat that statement to-day, and even more cause can be shown.

I pointed out that where a local body ordered 2,000 yards of material from a contractor from whom they were compelled to order it under the combined purchasing scheme, a portion of the material was sent up to the Trade Department to test. Eight or nine months passed without a reply being received, and the material had to be taken into stock and used without knowledge as to whether it was up to sample or not. On another occasion, when the material was not up to sample, one of the officials of the Trade Department went down to the local body, saying: "We know the material is shoddy and not up to sample, but take it all the same." You have the position where a body of contractors can turn around and tender for material of a certain quality, and can then supply material which is not up to that standard, or anything near it, and it is accepted on the instruction of the Department to the local bodies. On a former occasion I gave examples of the state of affairs that prevailed from 1927 to 1929. There has been a new development since. Some two months ago the South Cork Board of Public Assistance sent a sample to the Trade Department. A short time afterwards they got a query down asking for the name of the contractor who supplied the material. In other words: "We want to know whether we have got palm-oil from this contractor or not, or whether the stuff is so bad that he should give a little more." That is a position of affairs which I think can no longer be tolerated. Was there any reason why the Department, or the Minister for Local Government, should look for the name of a specific contractor in regard to the sample which was sent up? I gave instance after instance here in November last of the manner in which the Trade Department has been working. Here is a statement which is a fair example of the rest:

"This complaint of Messrs. Usher & Co. is a legitimate one. Payment is held up because only a part delivery of the goods has been approved and taken into stock. One delivery each of Grey Drugget and Bengal Stripe still awaits decision under test. One sample of these materials was sent on March 7th. Another was asked for and sent on May 1st. No decision has yet been received from the Trade Department."

That is a sample of the manner in which the Minister's Department is conducted. After seven or eight months no reply has been received from the Department, which is waiting quietly until the material is taken into stock and used. In another case the storekeeper states: "The handling of samples of clothing material for test continues to be hopelessly inefficient. We are now awaiting reports on samples sent forward May 1st—two samples (second lot), June 5th—six samples," and no report received until July 10th. As I said, there has been a new development. The Department now looks for the name of the contractor before they decide whether material is up to sample or not. Could there be anything more ridiculous? The Minister has shown on several occasions during the past two years that he has no idea whatsoever of the capacity of the ratepayers to pay. On one occasion when a doctor was appointed to a local hospital at a salary of £70 a year, the Minister insisted that the appointment should be made by the Appointments Commission and that the salary should be not £70 but £250. I do not know how the Minister can justify that squandering of public funds while at the same time he cannot find any money for the old age pensioners. His old age pension department is being conducted much on the same lines as the C.I.D. force. When an old age pensioner applies for a pension the forces are sent out immediately, enquiries are made to find out whether he earned 2/- a week from some farmer in the district during the past twelve months or two years. If he did, that is followed up by a visit to the farmer to find out whether he got his board, whether he got an ounce of tobacco, if he had a little house, and to find out whether the hens were laying and how many eggs fourteen hens laid in four years. There is a squandering on the one hand and false economy on the other, and that is an indication of the work of the Department during the past two years. Deputy Mulcahy has given himself over soul and body to the motor owners, who now absolutely dictate the roads policy of the Department. Farmers in the Co. Cork have roads over which they cannot drive a horse. The Minister made a statement here a short time ago which I found myself compelled to contradict and in which further information proves there is no truth whatsoever. He said that it was stated at a meeting of the Cork County Council that the farmers were enjoying a reduction of 50 per cent. in their travelling costs owing to the fine roads that they had in Cork.

According to the Public Bodies Order I think an audit of accounts is supposed to be carried out every twelve months by the Minister's Department. I would like to know in how many public bodies this audit has been carried out during the past four years. I know that in the case of the Cork County Council, which is a rather important body, there was an audit a short time ago covering two and a half years. The last year's audit is due since last September. Of course, the Minister knows that he will get through all right with the votes of the Independents. Those business men who stand for looking after the business interests of the community will walk solemnly into the lobby and will vote for that kind of thing. I do not know if any of these business men are contractors under this Department or not, but it is time that somebody was put at the head of the Department who would act in a straight manner and would put an end to the condition of affairs that is going on at present. It is worse and more corrupt than the old rural district councils, and they, I believe, were bad enough for anything.

Statements were made about the Minister for Justice here to-day. I do not want to say anything more about him. I think there has been quite enough said about him. The Minister for Justice has proved an absolute travesty of justice; as a matter of fact, his appearance here as Minister for Justice has been enough to shock this Assembly and anybody who sees this Assembly. I do not like to say anything more about it, but I had hoped that the President would not have put that gentleman on the Front Bench again. But unfortunately I see his name on the Order Paper to-day. If the President would take one bit of advice from me it would be that he should move that gentleman from the Front Bench, or else close down the bar. A question was raised on the adjournment three weeks ago, and when I saw that Minister there I left the room rather than be insulted by having him reply to it. The President should take his Front Bench to the Dominican Fathers and have them given the pledge.

We have also the Minister for External Affairs. The manner in which public money is being squandered in that Department is a scandal under this travesty of freedom. In order to show that we are free and independent, we spend £59,820 a year on that Department. We have gentlemen circusing around foreign countries. I do not know what they are doing there, and I think the House does not either. Before that Minister is re-elected, I think we should hear something from the President or from somebody responsible as to what these men are doing for the money. They are being paid £59,000 odd out of the public purse by a Government which states definitely that it has no money to spend on the old age pensioners, whose Ministers are being re-elected to-night after turning down a deliberate vote of the Dáil. They are going to climb back into office devoid of honour, devoid of all decency, for if they had either honour or decency they would do one of two things; they would either put the Bill that has passed its Second Reading into operation and find the money for it, or they would get out and let somebody else find it. They are prepared to do neither. They are getting back to-night devoid of honour and of decency, but some day they will go to the country and very short work will be made of them. I can promise them one thing, that the Freemason vote will not hold them in office always, that there are not enough Freemasons in this country to keep them in office. We are having Ministers elected to-night who have declared definitely that they are going to do nothing what soever for the next twelve months in the way of de-rating agricultural land. The Minister for Finance stated here within the past three weeks that he will do nothing, that there will be no reduction whatsoever in rates this year. He is going to do nothing towards finding finances for de-rating, and I hope that the farmer Deputies of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party will remember that. I know that the other farmers there are not going to remember it. They had their price and they got it, and it does not matter to them whether the farmers of the country are hungry or not, or what position they are in. They do not care. But I appeal to the farmer Deputies in the Cumann na nGaedheal ranks to see that the Minister for Finance is not returned to office in view of the statement that he has made about de-rating.

Every Deputy who comes from a rural constituency knows that the farmers in that constituency cannot carry on in the present condition of affairs. They know very well that there is a limit to it just as well as I do. Still they are going to trot around here and remain dumb in the House while this debate is going on, and trot round like lambs after the Minister for Finance, who says he is not going to find one farthing for de-rating this year. I do not know what position the people have got into. Apparently they are prepared to put up with anything. Can the representatives of rural constituencies trot around here after electing the Minister for Finance and say: "We have put him back all right, although he told us he is going to do nothing for de-rating of land this year"? The Minister for Finance made a speech on 24th May last in which he pointed out that he would have to find finances for de-rating. We are now approaching a new Budget in which we will have the statement that no money can be found for de-rating. That is the gentleman who can afford to throw £3,000 to the motor races, but who can find no money to finance the farmers so as to put them in, at least, the same position as those with whom they have to compete in the markets. I suppose that position will have to be put up with until these gentlemen are before their constituents who, I hope, will deal property with them. I hope there is enough public spirit left in the country to deal with them. At one time I hoped there was enough public spirit left in those on the benches opposite to deal with them. Apparently there is not; apparently the benches opposite have been whipped to heel, but no matter what smoke screen may be thrown by those on the opposite benches, about 1922, about 1914, or even 1014, when they come back to bedrock they must examine the present economic position of this country.

We heard a great deal from Deputy Tierney to-night about the great work that the Government has done. When the Deputy was asked to point out that work he could not point to a single item. The Minister for Finance made one allusion to that in his Budget speech last year when he stated that they had gone into debt to the extent of £20,000,000 since 1923. That is £20,000,000 expended in keeping up this affair here and in keeping all the Departments, envoys-extraordinary and ambassadors abroad. In order to keep keeping these gentlemen going he borrowed £20,000,000. That is the position of affairs. If that condition is to continue much longer it needs no financial expert to see what the result will be. Not one single industry that the Minister can point to has been started since 1923. Such industries as were there are broken up. The £20,000,000 has not gone in starting industries, but has gone over to John Bull. Every two years we have a new loan of £10,000,000 being borrowed, while we hand over five and a quarter millions of money to John Bull. That is the financial position of this country at present; that is the great work which Deputy Tierney says the Government has done. I regret that by some means or other the Party opposite are not going to the country now. Even if they are re-elected I hope their period of office will be very short, until we get them to the country and let it judge them. I have no fear of what the result will be. I do not think that anybody sitting on the Front Bench will be re-elected.

Comment on this

I do not intend to delay this prolonged debate. I do not think I would have intervened except for the statement made by Deputy Davin, that the Minister for Finance had acted in defiance of the Public Accounts Committee and the Comptroller and Auditor-General. As a member of the Public Accounts Committee that is a statement I cannot listen to in silence. There may have been at times little differences between the Comptroller and Auditor-General's Department and the Department of Finance, and perhaps at times little differences between the Public Accounts Committee and the Department of Finance, but so far as I know there has never been any defiant attitude on the part of the Minister for Finance with regard to the Comptroller and Auditor-General or the Public Accounts Committee. Deputy Davin was, of course, within his right in quoting what Deputy Esmonde said a few moments ago, that he should not have quoted the Public Accounts Report and the Appropriation Accounts for 1928-29. The particular item that he raised of £216,000, and in which he says the Minister defiantly acted in opposition to the Public Accounts Committee and the Comptroller and Auditor-General, is an item providing for gratuities to resigned officers, and it arose mainly because the Ministry decided to put into practice the promises of economy that they had made on previous occasions, and because there was an abnormal reduction in the Army services of that year that could not possibly, perhaps, have been foreseen when the Estimates were prepared. This expenditure of £216,000 in allowances is met in the same account by savings in other departments consequent on the reduction in the Army forces that I mentioned.

I do not intend to go into a discourse on the subject. I am merely alluding to the matter because of the accusations that Deputy Davin thought fit to make against the Minister for Finance that he had acted in defiance of the expressed declaration of the Public Accounts Committee and the Comptroller and Auditor-General. I do not know how Deputy Davin arrived at that conclusion. I cannot find any paragraph in either the Public Accounts Report or in the report of the Comptroller and Auditor-General accusing the Minister of this attitude. I shall not prolong the debate further. I thought it right as a member of the Public Accounts Committee that I should intervene.

The administrative capacities of the Deputies nominated by the President are well known to this House, and I do not think that any Deputy will have any difficulty in making up his mind as to whether they should be entrusted for a further period to administer their different offices.

Comment on this

May I ask the Deputy whether he is, by his speech, repudiating the report which is signed on his behalf by the Chairman of the Committee in 1927-28?

Comment on this

That is all right. Then the speech is wrong.

Comment on this

There is a very beautiful Chinese proverb which I personally appreciate very much and which I would commend to the consideration of the House. It is to walk slowly passing a lame man. It is rather in that spirit than the spirit in which one would deal with a masculine organisation that I approach the consideration of the present Ministry. The position rather seems to be that of a housekeeper who, having thrown out the withered flowers of the vases, and having gone around the whole of her garden, comes back and sticks the withered flowers back into the vases again. It is extraordinary to say that the President, having the opportunity to review the quality of his team, and having looked abroad amongst the something like 65 members whom he has on his benches, and the 15 who own him, that he has not been able to find any even good second-class material with which to replace these outworn and decayed goods. I would have thought that, say, Deputy Daly would have leaped to his mind as a possible Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

What about yourself?

Comment on this

I will take over later when I am ready.

Comment on this

If you are returned.

Comment on this

Deputy Daly, for instance, in preparing a budget, would undoubtedly do justice to that trade which, in the words of his colleague, Deputy Sheehy, has put a necklace of glory around the world of Guinness's stout and Jameson's whiskey. He would undoubtedly have done justice to the poor child that he told us so pathetically of on another occasion. I do not see why the President, when looking around through his team, should have ignored talents so outstanding. Why has the President ignored the future Lord Chancellor? What has Deputy J. J. Byrne done to deserve this, that in a team made up of Deputies Lynch, Fitzgerald-Kenney, O'Sullivan, Hogan, McGilligan, Mulcahy, Fitzgerald and Blythe that he is to be accused of being unfit to replace any of them?

As to Deputy Osmond Grattan Esmonde, if we were picking film stars of course there would be no question, but surely his wide knowledge and deep study of foreign affairs and the amazing eloquence he borrows from an intermediate progenitor should find some recognition, some place in this extraordinary collection of intellectual and Ministerial rubbish. Let us have a look mentally along that Bench for a moment. It is a lot better now when it is empty but, envisage for a moment its disgraceful and discreditable fullness.

Deputy Fionán Lynch, Exhibit No. I, Minister for Fisheries. Is there any single member in this House who has any personal knowledge which would enable him to say that one single penny of the finances of the Ministry of Fisheries under the administration of Deputy Fionán Lynch has been effective to the conditions of livelihood of deep-sea fishermen on the Irish coast? Somebody in the House ought to have that knowledge. If something like forty or fifty thousand pounds have been spent by a seventeen hundred pounds a year man all these years on fisheries, somebody ought to be able to point to some place in Ireland in which some deep-sea fishing industry has prospered as a result of that expenditure. I personally do not know of any. One thing I will say for the credit of Deputy Fionán Lynch, Minister for Fisheries, is that if he does not know anything about his Department and does not do anything in his Department, at least he never pretends to do anything in his Department. All I have ever heard from him is that a scheme is in preparation. If our function is to find a half dozen really good schemes that are guaranteed never to hatch out under any conditions whatever, there would be something to be said for Deputy Fionán Lynch but there is nothing to be said for Deputy Fionán Lynch, for the Ministry of which he was a part or for the Government which appointed him or the Party which has robbed this country by allowing him, a dud, to preside over a dud department all this time. Nothing whatever to be said for Deputy Fionán Lynch as Minister for Fisheries, nothing to be said for the Government who appointed him, and nothing to be said for the Party which has exploited the country by allowing that Department which might in the possession of somebody with knowledge, industry and brains have delivered some goods to the people in return for the money which has been wasted.

Exhibit NO. 2—Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, the Minister for Justice. Of the largest sins and iniquities of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney I do not propose to speak at any considerable length. I am of opinion that he has been the deliberate inciter to crime for the benefit of his Party and the tool of his Department from the time he took office to the present day. The fact that he is a heaven-sent Minister for Justice, judged by the function which he was required to perform and is still required to perform by the Ministry to which he belongs, is no reason whatever why this House should insult the country which sends us here by leaving him longer in that position. The Minister for Justice has, as one of his functions, the supervision of the administration of the licensing laws. I am not going to deny that actual knowledge of the condition, places and people at and by whom liquor is sold is outside the knowledge of the Minister for Justice, but if that was the only qualification that was required surely the man whom I have previously mentioned as a possible occupant of the position of foreign affairs, Deputy Osmond Grattan Esmonde, possesses those qualifications also, and possibly even in a higher degree. I want you to conceive anything funnier than the Minister for Justice rebuking a drunken constable. I want you to conceive anything more ludicrous, any pretence more shamefully dishonest than the attempt of the Minister for Justice to insist upon any decent administration of the licensing laws. The Minister for Justice has the supervision of the administration of the licensing laws in the Leinster House bar.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

He has not.

Comment on this

It is time somebody had. Is it suggested that we have a Minister for Justice here and that he has no supervision over those whose business it is to deal with what is going on in the Leinster House bar?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

None whatever. He has no function in the matter.

Comment on this

Then it is time somebody had.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy can proceed now to be relevant. That point is settled.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy accuse the Minister of being responsible for the conduct of the Deputy's own colleagues?

Comment on this

I do not care who is responsible, and I do not care whose conduct it is that is making a disgrace of this House.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will the Deputy sit down? He has been told that the Minister for Justice is not responsible. He must go on now on that basis.

Comment on this

I am going on, on the basis that we have a Ministry in which somebody must be responsible for what is going on.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Nobody in the Ministry is responsible for whatever may be going on. This is not the occasion for raising that matter. The Deputy, I am sure, can deliver himself of sufficient personal abuse outside that subject.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Is not the Deputy's Party represented on the Kitchen Committee that control it?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Absolutely.

Comment on this

They might as well not be on that committee.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is a matter that does not arise now.

Comment on this

The Minister for Justice, who is in charge of something like 6,000 Guards, has picked out for commendation to this House as a good public officer a man who has assaulted an ordinary civilian and who has been cast in damages in a civil court to the extent of £40. Is that a man fit to be Minister for Justice? Is that a man who is entitled to hold up the standard for the whole of those who are concerned with the administration of justice in this country? Is the man whom the courts of this country have told that the people whom his officers have taken into custody illegally are entitled to destroy Government property deliberately and openly in order to call attention to the conduct of the Minister for Justice and his minions—is that the kind of man who should be Minister for Justice in this House?

Exhibit No. 1, the Minister for Fisheries with a wasteful, extravagant, idle Department wasting the public money. Exhibit No. 2, the Minister for Justice with a Department which he does not control, but a Department which, under his name, is deliberately inciting to violence, to crime and to illegality in this country those who ought to be the guardians of the law; the man who is deliberately using his Department for a Party purpose to savage, to bedevil into uproar and disorder the men who differ from him in politics in order that he may steal a little advantage of the pretended strong man. Is that a man whom we are to appoint as Minister for Justice?

It has been agreed to regard the Minister for Education as an innocuous and inoffensive element in the calculation. I think he could be substituted either inefficiently or efficiently by practically any backbencher on the Cumann na nGaedheal side. You would not notice if he were not there. All I know of his record of an outstanding character is that he issued for the use of school-children a book in a language possibly he did not understand, which had to be withdrawn, which would not pass the censorship of the Minister for Justice. An innocuous, .001 Minister.

The Minister for Local Government, the one unteachable man in the House, the man who borrowed from the great brains of the founder of the Cork Rotary Club a new and splendid conception of the dignity of local government in Ireland, described, when introduced upon the more intimate and familiar stage of the City of Dublin by the great, strong man, Deputy J.J. Byrne, as the machinery for the setting up of a collection of marionettes. That is his contribution to local government. And with a year of experience of its utter futility and sterility that unteachable man has the effroutery to offer it in its Dublin version to this House What would this House do on a free vote with the Minister for Local Government and his Bill? What would his own Cabinet do with the Minister for Local Government and his Dublin Bill on a free vote? A pinch-beck, painted, cardboard Massolini, incapable of learning through any experience but the experience which is coming to him and his colleagues soon of being thrown into outer darkness with the thought how little of importance he is when he fails to have behind him the fifteen Deputies with which Cumann na nGaedheal is linked in an alliance of contempt.

It has been suggested that in dealing with that fifteen we are dealing with strong men keeping their own castle. You are dealing with two organisations which are mutually, openly and publicly in contempt of one another, but which have to hang together in their sin lest they hang separately. The fifteen are in the position of men all dressed up and nowhere else to go to, eating cold mutton and mashed potatoes in ball dress and all their diamonds. Nobody wants them but those who have got them, and they do not want what they have got. But these two bedfellows have to lie quietly together because the bed is not large enough to hold either of them if they are active.

I have heard of mutual admiration societies. This is not a mutual admiration society. It is an institution of mutual contempt. The jackboot—the credit to Deputy Ernest Blythe for saying it—"the jackboot and two jackboots," he said, "for everyone of you," and immediately after he said it, with your money, your votes and your ears you had to go out and vote for him in South Dublin.

Comment on this

On that occasion Deputy Flinn voted for him. Think of the Legal Practitioners Act. The Deputy voted for him, using the jackboot still.

Comment on this

Something funny has happened. I do not know what it is. There has been an eruption.

Comment on this

Using the jackboot still.

Comment on this

Yes, since I have been asked about it, on that occasion a solid national block of 110 faced 15 who were hostile to the national principles involved in that vote. And that same fifteen alone, and everyone of that same fifteen form the majority by virtue of which President Cosgrave nominates his Ministry to-night. Yes, we did not vote with Deputy Blythe on that occasion, and we will vote with him again, and they know that on every occasion on which those fifteen dare to stand up and yowl they can count upon fifty-six or fifty-seven, or whatever may be our total strength here, to say to that fifteen that while on the road to national advancement we would rather they would go with us, at the same time we, with them, through them or over them, will go forward.

I now come to Exhibit No. 5, this bold, unbiddable child, this playboy of the western world, this man who— and within the period in which he has acted as Minister, we are entitled to review his conduct—is, by a court and a jury of his own fellow-countrymen, certified to be a slanderer. He is certified by a jury to be a slanderer, this Minister using the authority and the prestige of his office to slander an ordinary individual, and because he is that type of man he is properly in position in a Ministry in which he is Exhibit No. 5. He would be a disgrace to any Ministry which would not be a disgrace to any portion of this country. A good, loyal Cabinet comrade; a really nice person to sit with on the benches; a man who publicly exhibited in this House the Minister for Defence as a fraud; a man who sat here and heard the Minister for Defence describe as an army the thing for which this country is paying nearly two millions a year, and, having heard him describe it in detail, got up and said that it was all damn nonsense, that it was not an army, it was no damn good as an army, that it could not survive a minute as an army, and that it was nothing but an armed adjunct of the C.I.D.

Exhibit No. 5 is put in the same Cabinet with Exhibit No. 7, Deputy Desmond Fitzgerald, the Minister for Defence. Here you have upon those benches two men paid out of public funds, one of them administering a Department which costs this country, roughly speaking, six times the amount of the old age pension money that the Government could not find, and you have a fellow colleague, another Minister sitting by him, telling him he does not even know the name or function of the thing which his Department administers. Whether they exeunt collectively or whether they exist individually, the sooner the duds go the better. At least until they do go they ought to agree not to accuse each other in front of this House either of deliberate lying or of privative ignorance of the things which they ought to know. Either one or the other of these men should go out. Deputy Hogan or Deputy Desmond Fitzgerald should not be in the same Cabinet. I think neither of them should be in any Cabinet. One thing is perfectly certain, and that is that the two of them ought not to be in the same Cabinet.

Now, let us come back again to Exhibit No. 5, this strident Mussolini, the man whom I once did believe was the greatest, if not the only asset, of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, the man whom to-day I believe to be the greatest asset of the Opposition. This good young man, in a moment of enthusiasm, went down to Cork and told us that the purpose of his Department was to increase the price of agricultural produce. After he had watched the effect of some of his own activities on the price of agricultural produce he went down to Cork again and said that he could not, and nothing could, increase the price of agricultural produce; that the only way to do it was to decrease the cost of production. He is not, like Deputy Mulcahy, unteachable. He learns at a very great cost, at a great expense of reputation and at expense to the population bearing the cost in this country; but he does learn. He is in the same Ministry as Deputy Ernest Blythe, who provides out of the funds of this country in the relief of agricultural rates and in other directions something like two millions of money. Deputy Ernest Blythe knows, unless he is as privatively ignorant as Deputy Fitzgerald or Deputy Hogan, what is going on in the Department of Deputy Hogan from the point of view of using all the money which he gives him. He sees large schemes of improvement of one kind or another. He provides the money for them.

What does Deputy Blythe say about Deputy Hogan? After Deputy Hogan has spent all the money that Deputy Blythe's torturers have by various means extracted from the community, Deputy Blythe goes up to Monaghan and says that the land can support no more people. After all the money has been spent by Deputy Hogan, in spite of all the activities of the whole Department of Agriculture and the greatest Minister for Agriculture in the universe, notwithstanding all the activities of this bold, unbiddable child, the land is bankrupt from the point of view of its primal function. It can support no more people. Was there ever a more blasting indictment offered by one Minister to another than that single sentence? What are you spending all the money on, the money that is being spent by the Minister for Agriculture, if, as the result of the whole of it. Deputy Blythe knows what he is talking about when he says that the land under the administration of Deputy Patrick Hogan, of Clare. I mean Galway—it would be a very different proposition under the administration of Deputy Patrick Hogan, of Clare——

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'Connell Labour Party

Why did he not get it?

Comment on this

What are you going to say? Is the Minister for Finance as privatively ignorant of what is being done with the money he supplies to Deputy Hogan as Deputy Desmond Fitzgerald is of the Department of Defence which he is supposed to administer? If Deputy Ernest Blythe is telling the truth, then the sooner Deputy Hogan, of Galway, goes to join Deputy Finian Lynch, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, Deputy O'Sullivan and Deputy Mulcahy the better.

Exhibit No. 7, Deputy McGilligan. Deputy McGilligan is one of the best debaters whom it has been my privilege to meet. Deputy McGilligan has what I call a leader writer's brain. You have to know a good deal about the subject with which Deputy McGilligan is dealing in order to know that Deputy McGilligan does not know anything; in other words, that he has got up his case well from the books. What are the actual achievements of Deputy McGilligan? Mind, Deputy McGilligan is probably the only man in this bunch of whom one could say that he has something approaching a good second-class brain. He is the best of the bunch from that point of view. What are the actual accomplishments of Deputy McGilligan as Minister for Industry and Commerce? Just think. You have had seven or eight years' experience. What are the actual accomplishments of Deputy McGilligan?

Comment on this

The Shannon scheme.

Comment on this

Right. We will come to the Shannon scheme. Let us start with sugar beet. What does this House think of the business ability of anyone who was connected with the finances of the sugar beet scheme? Is there any man in this House who would like to take responsibility for putting over a spoof of that kind on the country again? Is there any single man in this House who would like to make that bargain and say that he was responsible? Mind, Deputy McGilligan, no doubt, was working through his Department. He was dealing with his officials. He was working on information, but, after all, Minister for Industry and Commerce even in a Cumann na nGaedheal Government is not expected to be purely a figure-head. He ought to be able to connote and co-ordinate. He ought to be some judge of men. He ought to be able to understand a financial proposition. This is the actual financial proposition of sugar beet. You can buy sugar to-day at either 8/3 or 8/6 f.o.b. at Hamburg. Under our scheme the sugar beet factory in Carlow has an actual preference of over 30/- on an article which can be bought f.o.b. at Hamburg under 9/-.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Would the Deputy tell us the subsidies behind the German sugar?

Comment on this

Yes and I can tell the Deputy the name of Queen Anne's grandmother.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Can he answer the question or not?

Comment on this

I would be very glad some day to get a legal opinion, a really high-class legal opinion, on the annuities question from the Lord Chancellor.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

One which you would not publish anyhow.

Comment on this

Certainly not. That is the proposition. Yet the Carlow sugar beet scheme cannot complete in the city of Cork with sugar which has that handicap. They have not been selling any sugar in Cork. What are we to think of the business organisation, the business brain of the best man, from the point of view of brains in Cumann na nGaedheal, if, in order to do that, he has rendered this country liable to a sum of two or three millions to enable it to be unable with a preference of about 30/- to sell sugar in Cork which can be bought f.o.b. at Hamburg under 9/-? That is probably his greatest achievement. For anyone responsible for that criminal waste of something approaching three millions of money in a country that cannot afford to find £300,000 for old age pensions, a bath in boiling oil would be just about the proper appreciation of an achievement of that kind in a country as poor as this is.

The future Minister for Finance, Deputy Daly, has reminded me of the Shannon scheme. The Shannon scheme has been a hobby of mine for the last thirty years. It has been one of the things which I have tried to believe in during all that period. It is a thing about which I actually read a paper before an engineering society more than a quarter of a century ago. I am not at all prejudiced against the Shannon scheme. If I could believe in the Shannon scheme, as a sound financial enterprise in this country, in its present condition, there is no man here who would be more anxious to do so. I want this House to compare the Shannon scheme as it was offered to this House with the Shannon scheme as it is in reality. The Shannon scheme was founded on the idea that there should be a network covering the whole of the Free State fed from the Shannon and distributing to every town of 500 inhabitants and over. It was to supply in bulk. It was to be self-supporting. It was to cost £5,200,000. It has already cost £6,000,000 visibly. Do not mind that; that is a perfectly reasonable variation in the estimate. I would not have been surprised, nor would I have blamed the Minister, if there had been considerably more divergence between the actual estimate and the actual cost, but it also contained, when we got it in its naked beauty in the 1927 Act, the fact that it was going to take over from the citizens of Dublin, without paying them anything, a property that was worth 1½ millions of money. That is not recorded in the £5,200,000 or the £6,000,000. I am a little bit doubtful about the figure, but it took an average of about £15,000 of income tax which up to the present day has been paid by the City of Dublin to the Minister for Finance and which will have to be found from some other source. There is a capital charge there of £300,000.

Unless the Act is changed—and the Act would not be changed unless this subterfuge had been shown up—it contains a provision by which the citizens of Dublin this year are out of pocket and would be, in perpetuity, milked of £30,000 a year in rates—£600,000 of capital not included in the £6,000,000. It contains the fact that the whole of that property spread over the whole of Ireland and representing probably £80,000 in rates is hidden in that scheme and represents, deducting the £600,000 for the Dublin rates, another £1,200,000. It contains the fact that this organisation is specifically prohibited from paying income tax, and the Electricity Supply Board can go to the courts and can claim back from the Minister for Finance the whole of the income tax paid by the holder of that portion of National Loan—the £6,000,000, and the £2,800,000 in addition which is used on the distribution network. There is another £45,000, or another £900,000 added to the £6,000,000, £2,800,000, £300,000, £600,000, £1,200,000, and the £900,000 hidden in the 1927 Act.

For the Shannon scheme to be a sound scheme financially it has got to pay interest and sinking fund not merely on its visible expenditure but upon its hidden expenditure also. It has not been suggested up to the present that it will do that. That is not really the gravamen of the charge. Mind, I am speaking as one entirely prejudiced in favour of the Shannon scheme development, as one who would hope to see not merely the Shannon scheme development but the development of the Liffey and other subsidiary water powers in Ireland, and who would be prepared to make considerable financial sacrifices over and above what was actually immediately profitable to have that done. I challenge any engineer to say that, given as common ground an electrical network covering the whole of the Free State, you cannot put down a steam station at the nodal points and feed the whole of that network cheaper than it will be fed from the Shannon.

Of course, we have the philosophy of Deputy McGilligan in what he once said in relation to his Patents Department. We pointed out the fact that it was hopelessly extravagant from the point of view of the State, that in order to get a patent here in Ireland you had to pay a cost which would be equal to the cost of getting that patent in England, in America and in the Free State, and that of the total charge which was put upon the patentee, the amount which the State received was probably not ten per cent. When that case was put to Deputy McGilligan here was his answer: "The total expenses of the Department are X. The total revenue of the Department is X plus Y. That is perfectly satisfactory." In other words, "So long as I can get more revenue than cost, the cost does not matter a damn to me." The Shannon scheme could undoubtedly have been substituted by a steam-station system, feeding into that common network, providing electricity for the Free State cheaper than the Shannon could do it. That may be an achievement for Deputy McGilligan.

I want now to put, in a few words, the other side which he is entitled to put up against that charge. He is entitled to put up against that total capital cost the whole of the money over and above unemployment allowance to the same people who are paid for unskilled labour. He is entitled to put up against it whatever political advantages, and I am afraid they are not very great, are involved in the fact that he will not have to import the quantity of coal which would be used by a steam station. Certainly, if Deputy McGilligan's record is to rest upon the Shannon scheme and the sugar beet scheme alone, though he may be the best case that they can put forward for that Front Bench, it is not the case to justify that Front Bench.

The Minister for Defence has already been adequately dealt with by Deputy Hogan, and I shall leave him there. According to the Minister for Agriculture, the Minister for Defence is a fraud. He is deliberately misleading this House. He is coming here and telling them that he is spending one and a half millions or so of their money on an army, and he has not got an army. If there is any reason for the continuance of Deputy Desmond Fitzgerald in the position of Minister for Defence, they can justify anything.

I now come to the last, Deputy Blythe. I have suggested a substitute for Deputy Blythe. In so doing I certainly was suggesting that something active should be done in his Department by his successor. It is not necessary, if the Department is to continue to carry on as it has been carried on, to substitute anything masculine. Any office boy could obey the orders of his Department with the same amount of inspiration and efficiency with which Deputy Blythe obeys the orders of his permanent officials. It is a Department without the shadow of imagination, without the shadow of inspiration, with no grasp of the big primal problems which have to be faced in relation to this country if it is to be rebuilt from the foundations up, as it has to be. Deputy Blythe, with the exception probably of the Minister for Justice, has probably less control of and less knowledge of what goes on in or less capacity to deal with his Department than any Minister on that bench of duds.

I simply now deliberately recall the list: Deputy Finian Lynch, Minister for Fisheries. Is there any man who would stand for him individually, any man who would employ him with his own money to carry on business of that kind? The Minister for In justice! Our 001 Deputy O'Sullivan. The unteachable Deputy Mulcahy. That bold, unbiddable child, Deputy Hogan. Our leader-writer, Deputy McGilligan. Deputy Desmond Fitzgerald, whose Army, according to the greatest Minister for Agriculture in the universe, is not worth a damn. And Deputy Blythe, who could be substituted by any person of ordinary elementary education in performing the actual functions which he does perform. At least it is coherent; at least it is consistent. They are on a level. They are on a level with the President, who draws his power from the fifteen whom he regards with contempt and who regard him with contempt. They are worthy of the President who is upheld by the Farmers' Party, whose leader he has described as bankrupt of intelligence, bankrupt of initiative; bankrupt of every thing of use and value in Ireland. It is worthy of the President under whose administration national principle in this country fell to the lowest level which it has touched in human memory, when they exploited the blood of a murdered comrade and tried to coin it into votes in a stunt election on the Public Safety Act. It is worthy of the President who, meeting the country in that stunt, had his power broken in his hand and was sent back here to wait for the day of his final dismissal, without the courage to destroy the child he had engendered which, under the name of the Public Safety Act, will be a lasting shame and disgrace to this House and to the country over which this House is supposed to be the sovereign Assembly.

Comment on this

I rise to support the motion standing in the name of the President. There has been a lot of time wasted on this motion. One would imagine that the people sent Deputies here to make all these bitter speeches, speeches which are not constructive or helpful to the country. We have listened to speeches with nothing in them but hostility to the President and the Executive Council. A great man, who has now passed away, said on the Treaty debate: "You on the anti-Treaty side may take all the glory and we will take all the blame, but let us save Ireland." I should think that that should be the motive in the mind of every Deputy sent here to do the best he can for his country and for the people. It is for that purpose the people sent us here and it is a pity to see the valuable time of the House wasted on speeches such as we have heard from Deputy Flinn and other Deputies. Is it not about time that we set to work and took some pride in our country and in our fellow-countrymen? Surely the hundred per cent. patriots and the hundred per cent. brainy men who sit on the Opposition side of the House might examine their consciences and say, "This is our country equally as well as it is theirs, and we have been sent here by the Irish people to do the work of the country."

Whilst I have been a Deputy, I have not yet heard a word of praise here for any Bill introduced by the Government. In the early days, when the first housing scheme was introduced, I was the Chairman of the Pembroke Council. The Government proposed a scheme that for every pound raised by any local body a free grant of two pounds would be given. The anti-Treaty element in that Council turned that down. They would give no help to the Treaty Party. I think the same hostility prevails all round. No cooperation or help is given from the anti-Treaty side of the House to the President and the Executive Council, no matter how good the Bill may be that is introduced. There is nothing but bitterness and going back on the past. Let us look forward. There are bright days ahead for the country. I have heard Deputies speak with hostility of their fellow-countrymen. It is only in this House you hear expression given to these wicked ideas. Did Deputies opposite meet with some fellow-countrymen in America or Australia they would be very friendly with them; they would agree to differ. Why not agree to differ here in this House, but at the same time to keep the welfare of the country in our minds and the welfare of the people who sent us here? I thought that early in the evening there would be a division on this motion instead of raising many questions on it. There will be plenty of time to discuss all the questions which we have raised to-night when they can be gone into in their proper place. We should go on with the nation's work and we should have a bit of patience with each other and not be suspecting each other of treachery all the time.

I say to the Fianna Fáil Deputies and also to Labour Deputies, that there are a great many good things that can be said for the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, but it is a very strange thing that if any Deputy gets up to say a good word for the Government he is immediately pounced upon and attacked. Deputy Tierney said a few kind words, and truthful words, about the Government Party. Immediately he sat down Deputy Anthony jumped up and attacked him about some frivolous thing he said in an election speech at a street corner. I think that is a very poor spirit to show. We should get away from that and let this party feeling die down to some sensible proportion. Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies have a perfect right to defend the Government Party. I have great faith in the members of the Front Bench in this House. I know them for a number of years. I know they love their country, and I know that there is nothing in their minds but the uplifting of the country.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Batt O'Connor know the Minister for Justice for a long time?

Comment on this

I believe it is in accordance with Parliamentary procedure that Deputies proposed for Ministerial rank are not supposed to speak in their own defence. That, to my mind, explains the valiant attempt of Deputy Hugo Flinn to assail them in his unmeasured language. Deputy Hugo Flinn is an orator, and he prides himself on the fact. He seems to me to have studied his oratory under a very great orator, apart from his other faults, and that was Horatio Bottomley. Horatio Bottomley was a great orator; he was fluent, he was eloquent, and he was impudent— traits which Deputy Hugo Flinn possesses in excelsis. Deputy Hugo Flinn has found his spiritual home amongst the Fianna Fáil Party. Well, I do not think so badly of the Fianna Fáil Party as to wish them luck of the day that Deputy Flinn joined them.

It is well known to mental specialists that people of third-rate mentality have an obsession that they cannot get over, in season and out of season, of belittling in every way men of first rate mentality, and that is also a little trouble from which Deputy Hugo Flinn suffers.

Comment on this

You show it sometimes.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Flinn was allowed to make his speech without interruption, and Deputy Hennessy ought to be allowed to reply without interruption.

Comment on this

I will not keep the House very long. The first time I ever heard Deputy Hugo Flinn was when he was addressing a body of hard-headed business men here in Dublin. He had some extraordinary panacea about income tax. Well, those hard-headed business men, after his grand eloquent discourse, simply laughed at him, and this House could also afford to laugh at him, and certainly the supporters of the Government Party can afford to laugh at him.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

He was Hugo Victor Flinn at that time.

Comment on this

I also heard a speech from his neighbour on the benches opposite. I would not undertake to reply to anything Deputy Aiken would say. I know he is the Beau Ideal, the Beau Geste, Beau Brummel and the Rajah Bhong of his own Party. I shall also make the Fianna Fáil Party a present of Deputy Aiken. Anything that has been said has not lessened the proposed Ministers in the estimation of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. We know some of the members of the Opposition well, and there are men in the Opposition of whom I would not like to say anything hard, and there are men that would never disgrace their country by making what Mr. Augustine Birrell once described as carrion crow speeches. We have had the greatest example of a carrion crow speech to-night, and that was delivered irrespective of the harm, financial or otherwise, that it might do to the country. That was Deputy Hugo Flinn's contribution to this debate, and I must say that I sympathise with the Party to which he belongs.

Comment on this

I just rise for the purpose of giving one reason why the Minister for Local Government and Public Health should not be in the Cabinet.

Comment on this

Only one?

Comment on this

One reason on this occasion. On the Estimates, we can give others. That one reason, I am sorry to say, is not in the House to-night. In my absence yesterday evening, I believe a Deputy delivered a little homily on my duty to my constituents, and the one reason why I think the Minister for Local Government should not be appointed is that he has not delivered a little homily to the gentleman who spoke here last night as to his duty in earning £1,000 per annum.

Comment on this

I must join with other speakers in expressing my surprise that, when the President got the opportunity, as he has got a very favourable opportunity on this occasion, of throwing some of his present team overboard, he did not take that opportunity. I do not want to go into the merits—because they have none—or the demerits of the men who are proposed for Ministerial positions. I only want to make a few remarks about things that have arisen in the debate. I noticed that when Deputy Tierney was speaking he made an appeal to the members of this Party to give up recriminations, personal attacks and so on, to cut them out altogether. I wish that advice would be taken. On that I would like to say this. I was speaking to some people from Greystones after the 1927 election and they said that the most abusive and the most scurrilous speaker they had ever heard in the town was Deputy Tierney, with one exception, and that was Deputy Doctor Hennessy.

Comment on this

I never made a speech in Greystones in my life.

Comment on this

Who said the speech was made in Greystones?

Comment on this

Greystones people heard it, but I do not know whether the speech was made in Greystones or not. Deputy Lynch is again being proposed for the position of Minister for Fisheries. Deputy Flinn asked if there was a member in the House who could point to one single good act which that Minister had done while in office, and the House remained silent. I believe the House would still remain silent if the question was again put. I do not know whether the President will also remain silent when replying to this debate. The Minister for Fisheries sleeps peacefully while the French and British trawlers raid the fish along our shores, leaving our own fishermen to go without any fish. The only thing that wakes the Minister up is when he is reminded by some official in his Department that there are annuities due by those fishermen who have to go without fish. Along the coast with which I am most familiar, the only thing the fishermen there ever hear from the Minister for Fisheries is that their annuities are due and that they had better pay up. When they make representations to the Department of Fisheries about the raids carried out along the coast by French and British trawlers they get no satisfaction. It would appear that the only class of fishermen who get satisfaction from that Department are the rod men, especially those who fish along the river Barrow. I do not know whether the same rule applies in the case of other rivers or not, but so far as the river Barrow is concerned, for two months after the ordinary fishermen, who earn their bread from fishing, are forbidden to fish in the Barrow the rod men are allowed to fish there for salmon. That bye-law is typical of the rules carried out by the Department of Fisheries. If Deputy Lynch is returned to that Department he will still, I suppose, carry out the old policy.

Since speaking here on a former occasion a little book has been published dealing with the agricultural output of Saorstát Eireann. Some very interesting facts emerge from that publication. Again and again we have pointed out here that Denmark, which is half the size of Ireland, is able to export £24,000,000 worth of butter per annum, while the Free State is only able to export £4,000,000 worth. When we have pointed to that we have been met with the reply that that is due to the fact that the Danish people use margarine and export their butter. To a certain extent that is true. That is referred to in this little book. We are told that the people of the Free State consume 30 gallons of milk per person per annum. That applies to the City of Dublin. Would any Deputy in this House who knows the north city constituency well, and is familiar with the conditions under which people live in Marlborough Street, Gloucester Street and other streets in that area, agree with this report, which says that every man, woman and child in these streets consumes thirty gallons of milk per annum.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Does the book state that?

Comment on this

It gives the consumption of milk in the Free State.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Is not that a different thing?

Comment on this

The consumption of milk in the Free State is given at thirty gallons per person per annum.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Is not that different to what the Deputy stated?

Comment on this

If it is true that they are not getting that quantity of milk and eating 38 lbs. of butter per annum, could you conceive it possible, if they are only getting a few pounds of butter each, that the big percentage of the population of this country are consuming twice that quantity, namely, 76 lbs. of butter each. I think that even a person with an abnormal appetite would find it hard to consume that amount. It has been pointed out to us that the reason why Denmark is able to carry on an export trade in butter to the extent of £24,000,000 a year, while the Free State can only export £4,000,000 worth of butter, is because the Danish people are content to eat margarine themselves—that is to say, that the Danish people are content to put up with an inferior article, because we all regard margarine as inferior to butter. This book also tells us that the output of agricultural produce per worker— that is including farmers and labourers—is £96 per annum in the Free State, whereas in Denmark the corresponding figure is £196 per annum. Why, therefore, do the farmers or labourers, as the case may be, in Denmark take margarine in preference to butter? It cannot be through any spirit of want or saving, as has been suggested here?

It has been suggested here again and again that one of the reasons why we are not able to carry on the same trade in butter as Denmark is because our people have a high standard of living, but when we look into these figures what do we find? That the average income of agricultural workers in this country—taking farmers and labourers together—is 37/- per week, whereas the average income of the corresponding class in the rural districts in Denmark is £3 15s. per week. The report goes on to say that the Danish practice of exporting the superior article and consuming the cheaper substitute at home is, therefore, akin to the Irish practice with regard to bacon. The Danes, the report states, manufacture the bulk of the margarine which they consume, while the cheaper bacon consumed in Ireland is imported. That may have something to do with it. The fact with regard to Denmark is that any article that they want is, as far as possible, produced at home. The remedy that has been suggested here by the Minister for Agriculture and speakers on the other side is, first of all, more production. But what incentive is there for more production at the present time, say, in the case of butter, the price of which has fallen to such an enormous extent over the last few months? The drop in the price of butter as compared with this time last year amounts to between 40/- and 50/- per cwt. If we take the total, which is given in this book, of butter as 1,491,000 cwts. per annum, the loss from falling prices amounts to £73,000 per week. That is an accidental loss over which we have no control, as we cannot control the British market.

The loss could be got over only by an increase in the milk yield of the cows of the country to the extent of 150 gallons per annum, so that even if the agricultural policy of the country succeeded in increasing the milk yield to the extent of 150 gallons per cow, that would have gone for nothing on account of the fall in prices for butter in the British market. That is a proof of the foolishness of trying to develop a line in a market over which we have no control, while we allow foodstuff to come into our market which we can control fully if we wish. The Minister for Agriculture said when speaking at Ballygar a few weeks ago "I advised the farmers last Autumn to keep their corn to feed their cattle, and now," he said, "if they had taken my advice look at what prices they would be getting for their cattle." The prices are good now, but the farmers he advised to do that cannot afford to keep their grain as they have to sell it to pay their annuities, or, perhaps, they have no storage for their grain, or no cattle to feed it to. If they had to buy cattle, what about the people who sold the cattle last autumn when they got as low a price for cattle as was got before the War? I know a man who kept his cattle and he fed them his own grain. About three or four weeks ago they broke into a field next his own farm and the bailiffs came along and took them to pay the other man's annuities. They were sold in public auction in Dublin, and the money went to the Land Commission to pay the annuities of the other man. There was some cash over and that also went to the other man. The cattle of this man, Hayes, were taken under a legal quibble. As I say, they had broken in for the first time to the other man's farm, Hayes alleges, and in that he is supported by local witnesses, and even by the Civic Guards; but it was known that a malicious informant from the district sent word to the Land Commission that these cattle had been habitually grazing on the farm upon which the annuities were due, and the Land Commission, therefore, took them for the payment of annuities for themselves.

That is the case of one man who took Deputy Hogan's advice to keep his cattle over the winter. Many other comparisons could be made between this country and other countries that have a higher agricultural output per head of the population. In this book, for instance, the output of this country is given as £96 per head; in England and Wales, £169, and in Denmark, £196. In Denmark, they have not, as we have, to send land annuities to England or anywhere else. I notice that Deputy Gorey and others only laugh at the annuities going out of this country, but when the speakers on Deputy Gorey's side were in Sligo and Leitrim they began to take this question rather seriously and they— Deputy Gorey amongst them—suggested that now that there was a new Government in England something might be done about the question. But that was to the electorate of Sligo-Leitrim. Neither has Denmark to send money across to England to pay pensions to ex-Danish police, or people of that sort. They keep the money at home for their own industries.

Comment on this

They do a little ploughing in Denmark, too.

Comment on this

They do 65 per cent. of tillage, and we do 12½ per cent. As a result, their agricultural output is £88,000,000, and our output is £66,000,000.

Comment on this

Is it the Minister for Agriculture who makes them plough there?

Comment on this

I do not know what the Minister does there, but I do suggest he would not be so foolish if there were farmers in Denmark who had derelict farms, and who owed money to the Land Commission, to the county councils and to the shops, and who do not know where they are going to get the next meal, as to tell them "The way you will get on is by buying another cow and another sow." We have suggested before, and we will keep on suggesting it until the people opposite see the error of their ways, that it would be much better to try and develop our own market here, and try and supply our own wants here, rather than export stuff to an uncertain market like the English market, which is at one time uncertain for cattle and at another for butter, and so on. If we were to develop our own market and employ more people in the towns, by protecting our own industries, we would be building up a market to a certain extent. For instance, on various occasions we have discussed here the question of a flour tariff. For the year 1929 we paid for flour coming into the country £2,438,000. That was 3,112,000 cwts. of flour. At the price of wheat last year, as it was bought by this country, the wheat that would produce that flour would cost £2,280,000. As well as getting the flour required, we would have got, as everybody knows, 30 per cent. of offals, and if these offals were to realise only £7 a ton, that would amount to £469,000. The difference between what the wheat could be got for and what we paid for the flour is £158,000. Therefore, the total gain to the country by importing wheat instead of flour would be £627,000.

I may be told by some of the efficiency experts on the other side that the flour mills do not give much employment, or they may tell me that we cannot have a tariff on flour until our mills are efficient—as the late Minister for Industry and Commerce said, well placed, well managed and well machined. If we had brought in wheat instead of flour last year we would have had £627,000 for distribution in the way of wages, profits, dividends, or in some other way; it would at least have been another £627,000 free for circulation and free for the purchase of agricultural or other produce.

Last year we had an item of £224,000 for bread and buns imported, principally from bakers in the North of Ireland. Those who read the Report of the Tariff Commission and the other publications on the flour and wheat question will know that at the rate of 93 pairs to the sack of flour, and taking 70 per cent. as the yield of flour from wheat, the cost of the wheat to produce that bread would have been about £60,000. We paid £224,000 for the finished articles of bread and buns which came in across the Border, but the materials to make them could have been imported in the form of wheat for about £60,000, and all the labour up to the time the bread and buns were produced could have been done in this country, so that we would have had, with that item alone, £160,000 free to spend in wages, dividends, and in other ways. The flour and the bread are only two items to show what a strong policy of protection could do in creating a home and a stable market for our own produce, not the sort of market that we have in England, where we get 180/- for butter one day, and a couple of months afterwards it is down to 124/-. The farmer who has spent perhaps the last six or seven years in trying to improve his herd of cows and in trying to get into good strain will now find that if these prices are to last—and we hope they will not—he has got into a stock which will be no use to him, and he will have to turn to some other form of farming.

I do not want to go into all the various other items of imports of articles which could be produced at home and that could be stopped from coming in. There are millions of pounds going out for wearing apparel, for leather, and for boots and shoes. All these things could be produced at home, giving a large, amount of employment here, and every single halfpenny that would be paid to the workers on the production of these articles would be available to buy the produce of our own market, which market could be regulated to the advantage of the producers at home and which would give the agricultural community at least a chance to know what line it could develop in the coming three or four years. The present policy is not the policy of the Minister for Agriculture alone nor of the Minister for Industry and Commerce alone; it is the policy of the combined Executive Council, a policy of free trade and free competition As a matter of fact, the policy of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, as he expressed it here on the Vote on Account with regard to the flour mills, was that there would be no tariff until we had efficiency. He then went on to say that the more British companies that came in to buy up the flour mills the quicker a tariff would come, which means that we cannot have efficiency until the British manufacturer comes in and buys the mills: then we will have efficiency and then we can have a tariff.

A threat was made outside by Deputy Blythe, who has been proposed as Minister for Finance. He told his audience that if Fianna Fáil succeeded in its policy of withholding the land annuities from Britain, Britain would strike back by putting a tax on cattle going into the British market. If Britain is going to frighten this country from her rights every time that this country has a right to claim by the bogey of a tax on our exports to Britain, then the sooner we drop this sham of independence the better. But how could Britain do it? If Britain puts a tax on our cattle, would we not be entitled to put a tax on articles that come in here from Britain? We are purchasing more from Britain than Britain is purchasing from us, and if there is to be a war of tariffs between the two countries we will have the best of it. There is no likelihood that Britain will try a tax on cattle or anything else, because, as I said, we are a larger customer for her produce than she is for ours; but if she does try it on, then let us retaliate. If this policy of free trade between Britain and this country is to continue and if this status which we have got of being a fully-fledged member of the British Commonwealth of Nations is to continue, can the President say what advantage has been brought to this country by the Treaty? If we are not to go ahead and try to be independent, both politically and economically, if we have no hope in front of us, can the President give any reason why we should remain as we are now, part of the British Commonwealth of Nations, having practically lost the desire, if not the power, to put tariffs on foreign articles coming into the country? If we are to be, as it were, not only politically but economically part of the British Empire, then can the President say what difference it would make if we were again to merge with and become part of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland? I would like to know what advantage there is in remaining like this if we are not going to push forward towards complete independence, not only politically but economically.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Might I take it that the debate will conclude to-night? I understood from Deputy Aiken that it would.

Comment on this

I think it will. I do not think that there are more than a couple of Deputies to speak.

Comment on this

I do not think I shall keep the President very long. I may say at the outset that I am rather disappointed at the manner in which the President has presented his proposed Executive Council to the House. After the adoption of the glorious principles of the Revolution to which Deputy Cole and Deputy Haslett adhere—the Revolution of 1690—I should have thought that at the opening of the session to-day the President and his nominees would have entered dressed in the appropriate scarves, beating the big drum, and garlanded with the lilies which commemorate the glorious victories of Derry, Aughrim, Enniskillen and the Boyne. It would have introduced a touch of colour into the dull and sombre proceedings of this House. I am certain that henceforward, thanks to the missionary zeal of Deputy Cole and Deputy Haslett, the meetings of the Executive Council will open with the toast of the glorious, pious and immortal memory of William III., Prince of Orange, who has saved us from the Pope and Popery, wooden shoes and brass money, But that is merely by the way.

I rose to ask the President to justify the inclusion in the Executive Council of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, the late Minister for Justice. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney has a remarkable claim upon posterity. We remember him in this House as the sole progenitor and the only begetter of a remarkable cow, a regular two-handed son of a gun of a cow, a cow who was able to kick with both feet, a phenomenon, I believe, which has not come within the purview even of a sportsman like Deputy Gorey. But what other claim has he beyond his capacity to improvise a cock-and-bull story whenever the exigencies of defending the policy of his Department in this House compel him? What other justification has Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney to sit as a member of the Executive Council of this State? None other, except that he is the centre of a conspiracy to secure the defeat of justice, a conspiracy which has been exposed, as Deputies on those benches have put it, in the courts of justice, a conspiracy which has been condemned in the courts of justice, a conspiracy, the instruments of which have been cast, as Deputy Flinn said, in damages in the courts of justice of this State, a conspiracy for which, in the Estimates, Deputy Ernest Blythe, who is to be Minister for Finance in the new Executive Council, will provide the sinews of war. In the Estimates for the current year the sum of £1,444,000 is to be provided out of the taxpayers' money for the Gárda Síochána. That is £30,000 more than last year, and a large part of that sum is to go as wages, salaries and allowances to the thugs and gun bullies who are the active instruments of the policy which was adopted by the late Minister for Justice, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, whose name is now one of those before the House.

Again, in Vote 26. dealing with law charges, sub-head G, which provides for the defence of public officials in actions taken against District Justices or the Gárda Síochána, I notice that for the year 1930-1931 the amount devoted to that sub-head has been increased from £200 to £800. What is the significance of that fact? Does it portend an intensification of this lawless campaign, for which Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was responsible, and for which he will possibly be responsible again if the House returns him?

I submit that there is one section in the House that has a particular responsibility in this regard, and that is, the section which has, like Pilate, hitherto washed its hands of the whole affair. If this Executive be kept in power it will be by the votes of the fifteen Independent members in this House.

Comment on this
Timothy Sheehy Mr. T. Sheehy (Cork, W.) Cumann na nGaedheal

More power to them.

Comment on this

I ask them, in view of the facts which have been brought before their notice this evening, in view of the facts which, I am sure, they have read for themselves in the newspapers, do they stand for an intensification of this campaign of lawlessness, which has been carried on under the leadership and at the instigation of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney? Does Deputy Good stand for that; does Deputy Haslett stand for that; does Deputy Cole stand for that; do the Deputies who represent Trinity College stand for that? Do they stand for this, continual and persistent sabotage of the civil liberties? That is the issue we are putting up to them. This debate has concentrated on the personality of the late Minister for Justice. We have recited to those members, in order that they may not vote in ignorance of the facts that have been published in the newspapers, the astonishing fact that members of the police force have been cast in damages in the courts of this State, and that instead of being suspended from duty, instead of being dismissed with ignomy from that force, they have, on the contrary, been commended for their action by the ex-Minister for Justice.

For a moment I would ask them whether, even though at this time this particular campaign may be directed against a certain section of the community only, do they think it is going to end there? Do they for a moment believe it is going to be against Republicans always and only? Let me remind them of an incident which. I am sure, is well within the recollection of every member of this House.

About two or two and a half years ago it was quite a common thing for a citizen of Dublin who possessed a motor car and who happened by chance to leave it outside his house at night to waken in the morning and find the motor car gone and the next day, or a couple of days afterwards, to hear that it had been found somewhere in the highways or bye-ways around the city. For a long time it was believed that this temporary theft of motor cars was the work of the Irregulars, but then a shocking and a startling thing occurred. There was a fatality at Bray in which three members of the Civic Guard, the force for which the Minister for Justice, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, was then responsible, were found to have taken a motor car, and in consequence of the fatality and the ensuing inquest, it then transpired that this temporary theft of motor cars had been the habitual and customary practice of members of the Gárda Síochána on night duty in the city. At the police court proceedings the surviving Guard I am glad to say was discharged. I think he was sufficiently punished for what had happened. I regret that the punishment was so drastic. But in consequence of the fact that it then became known that this practice of joy-riding by the Guards had not been condemned at once there was a regular epidemic of it through the city, so much so, that even Deputy J.X. Murphy, who I presume is going to vote for this motion, had to write to the papers protesting and condemning it, and asking that some appropriate action should be taken, either by way of an amendment of the law, or some other way to stop such proceedings. The Guards took the motor cars in the first instance and the immediate result was, as I have stated, that there was a widespread imitiation of their action in taking motor cars without the leave of the owners.

The Guards at the moment are conducting a campaign of lawlessness throughout the country. In the hands of the Independent members at this present moment rests the power of determining whether what the late Minister for Defence described yesterday as the primary and fundamental function of a Government, the preservation of law and order or the enforcement of the social order shall be undertaken seriously. In the hands of the Independent members at this moment rests the power to determine whether the Executive Council which is going to be constituted to-night will make that their primary and fundamental function and exercise it without regard to party advantage or party gain. The Guards have been, as I said, convicted of lawlessness. At the moment it is confined to them, but if they are allowed to go on, make no mistake about it, there will be widespread imitation of their action throughout the land. Lawlessness and disorder inevitably breed lawlessness and disorder, and if the Independents stand for peace, stability and progress in this country it is their duty and it is incumbent upon them before they cast their vote to-night to have from the President a statement that he will discard from his Executive Council Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney and instead will put in charge of the police forces of this country a man who has some conception of the duty of a Minister for Justice.

Comment on this

Before the President replies. I understand a statement was made to-day by Deputy Rice with regard to some counsel's opinion which was alleged to be in my possession. I do not intend to go into it or discuss what that opinion contains. I leave these matters to Deputy Rice's own sense of taste. I just content myself by stating that what he said was entirely inaccurate.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

This debate has gone on since 3 o'clock, and there has not been much reference to the particular incident which gave rise to the necessity for appointing a new Executive.

On this day week a Bill which would have entailed a Money Resolution was passed by this House, and it is obvious to everybody, more perhaps to Deputies on the far side of the House, the Fianna Fáil representatives, than any others, that if there were a firm decision of the House, if they meant business by reason of the passing of the Second Reading of the Bill introduced by Deputy Dr. Ward that some serious steps would be taken, some definite action should undoubtedly be taken which would emphasise the sincerity of those who voted for the Second Reading of the Bill. It is idle to say that what transpired here yesterday was a normal outcome of the proceedings which took place here on Thursday night last. Within the last three years the Deputies opposite came into this House for the first time and their first act was to vote against the continuance in office of the then Executive. I am positively certain that they had in mind then voting for a different Executive and that that Executive would not have come from their Party. There was something political about that particular decision, there was something economic, but I cannot say so about the decision that was taken here on Thursday night last. If they were really sincere in the vote they gave then they would, in my opinion, have voted for Deputy O'Connell last night.

What was the reason they refused to vote for Deputy O'Connell? There was one reason, and one reason only. They did not wish to see the leader of their Party placed in a larger minority than Deputy O'Connell. There was no anxiety about the old age pensions, not at all. We must keep up the prestige of our own chief. We must make it clear here in Ireland, and more especially in America, that the leader of the Fianna Fáil Party could not be placed in the lowest minority in this House. That is the whole sum and substance of it, and that is the explanation they have got to give to any person outside who, by reason of the non-passage into law of that measure, suffers a loss of 1/-, 2/6 or any other sum in connection with old age pensions.

That should have formed the basis of discussion here to-day. Not at all; other matters were brought up. We are living here under a Constitution more democratic than that of any other country in the world. In no other Parliament is the President of the Executive Council or the Prime Minister elected or nominated by the Parliament; in no other Parliament are the members of the Ministry submitted for consideration by the Parliament, and one would have imagined that on an occasion such as this an opportunity would be afforded, now that the House is full, of placing upon the records of the House something like a respectable discussion in connection with that procedure.

The selection of an Executive is perhaps the most important incident in the life of a Parliament, and on such an occasion one would look for some light and leading, some fair discussion, some decent discussion, some discussion that would be free from personalities and all the rest of it. Not at all. We are concerned with the actions of the Civic Guards and with various details all of which can be discussed on the Estimates. Some of them have already been discussed and passed by this House. Deputies will have some difficulty in explaining to the people of the country why it was when they were afforded an opportunity of putting an alternative Ministry in control of this country they would not vote for Labour. Not likely. They would let down the Fianna Fáil flag and the Fianna Fáil flag is the most important thing in this country to the Deputies opposite; not the prosperity of this country, not the independence of this country, but the success of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

It is the same thing.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

The same thing. This is an occasion upon which one would naturally expect policy to be outlined. Deputies occasionally ask for it. It is an unusual occasion; one might reasonably expect that such an expression of policy should fall from the lips of the President of the Executive in the nomination of the Ministry. I endeavour to save the time of the House and to avoid, as far as possible, any invasion of the time that should be devoted to really constructive work here in the Parliament of the people of this country.

The policy of the Government is well known; it is in the book of Estimates under each of the Votes that have been introduced since we first took up office. It is in the legislation which is passed through the Oireachtas and becomes law and we have, if we might say so, an alternative to it, all the wailings, the screechings, the pessimistic utterances, and the deplorable outbursts of pessimism that have come from the far side of the House. The second last speech is evidence of it. The price of butter is down. The Government policy is wrong. The Government should have foreseen, within the last few years, that in this year of Our Lord. 1930, in the month of March the price of butter would fall to 30/- a cwt. The Minister for Agriculture, having foreseen that, should have taken the necessary steps, should have an alternative policy in mind. I wonder how many people from over the Border, coming in here to this House or taking up the newspapers or the records of the speeches made in the last couple of days, would say that this is a place they ought to join.

Comment on this

Speeches from both sides.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I wonder do Deputies ever consider that.

Comment on this

Or Ministers?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Or Ministers? Ministers have it in mind at all times, not to-day or yesterday.

Comment on this

That explains the change in policy.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

There has been no change in the policy of the Government. It is unchanged. It is progressive. The advantages which the country has derived under its administration for the last eight years are to be seen on all sides. More might have been accomplished, more could have been accomplished, much better results would undoubtedly have ensued if the calibre of the Opposition was of a different character, if there was a conception of true patriotism, if there was an incentive to work, if there was not a continual cry of "What can we hammer out of the National Exchequer; what extra doles can be got; what new imposts can be put upon industry, upon agriculture, what further outcry can we make that will appeal to some one or other section in the country which for one reason or another is not particularly prosperous at the moment?"

Comment on this

That is every section.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

From that side have come pronouncements which would be undoubtedly a forerunner of national uneasiness, a shaking of public confidence, a feeling of unrest and insecurity, nervousness about investing capital in this country and nervousness about the future, a feeling that everything was not right. Is that a good policy to adopt? Is that going to lead towards progress in this country? Is it likely to make us more prosperous? Is it likely to increase industry and employment in the country? Deputies sometimes tax us with being unfair to them. I do not intend to be unfair to them. Taking that Party as a whole, what is its policy? The policy of this Government is seen in this House. It is seen outside in the better roads, the better streets, improved drainage, the improvement in the number of houses and in our agricultural produce, in the number of tariffed industries there are, and so on. What is the policy of the Party opposite? I have it under the name of their own leader.

"Irish Press Limited,

American Offices, Transportation Buildings,

225 Broadway,

New York City,

February, 1930.

"A Chara,

I have undertaken the task of establishing a daily newspaper in Ireland. I believe no more useful service can be rendered to Ireland at the present time."

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

A new industry.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

"No more useful service." Not even a change of Government.

Comment on this

Not even a change of Government.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The President must get an opportunity of replying. He must be given an opportunity to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

interrupted.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Shut up.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Did the Independents get their price?

Comment on this

Were there negotiations?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I have made no bargain and there have been no negotiations.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

And no bargain.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

None whatever. They are as free as the people outside. I was going to say as the Deputies opposite, but they are not free. They are bound to attend to the Party Whip, and Deputy Boland knows how to crack it. He was able to bring up four more here to vote for his leader than he was to vote for the old age pensioners last week.

Comment on this

That cuts both ways, too.

Comment on this

It is a pity that Deputy Duggan was not so zealous.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Yes, it is a pity, but at any rate it clears the air, and Deputies opposite are a good deal sorer to-night than they were this night week. That 39 will not be easily forgotten. It was something that was not expected and it was about time that it came. It shows this, that there are in the Labour Party people who are not afraid to give expression to their views and to walk into a Division Lobby. In eight years I never saw them remain in their seats during a division.

Comment on this

You saw them walk out when the Government was in danger.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

Never. That is not true. We would have put out the Government long ago if we had you to help us.

Comment on this

They do not want to put the Government out.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I will have to make peace between these two Parties. We have thrown in the apple of discord. There was one common policy between them, anyhow. That was, that between the two of them they intended to put us out, but there was this unfortunate thing lacking, and it is a primary consideration which Deputies opposite will sooner or later have to consider, that is, that when we are put out there must be something to put in our place; there must be an alternative Government. The country requires it. The country must be provided with a Government.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

They will be more careful in the selection of candidates next time.

Comment on this

You will not be here to decide.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

A good deal of play was made here this evening about the Guards. That is a matter that could be discussed on the Estimates. It is a matter that ought to be discussed on the Estimates. Let us for a moment, and without any heat, revert to the peculiar circumstances in which the Gárda Síochána were inaugurated.

The time in which they were formed was a time of grave disturbance in the country, regrettable disturbance, and what happened? In May, 1923, an order was issued by the leader of the Party opposite to cease fire. The pity about that was that along with that there did not come an order to surrender arms. They are through the country; they have not all been collected. Some of them are in the hands of young enthusiasts; some of them are in the hands of persons who, perhaps, do not take the same interpretation of the moral law as ecclesiastics and, in consequence, a very big responsibility was placed upon the administration and upon the new Gárda. Deplorable incidents have happened within the last few years. Many members of that Gárda have lost their lives within the last few years. It is not a normal situation. But listening to perhaps the most moderate speech which was made in connection with this matter this evening one thing struck me very forcibly. There were some decisions of the Courts recently against Guards. That is one assurance, if such were required, that there is impartial justice in the Courts. There were in addition to the convictions two or three acquittals. This most moderate of all the speakers centred upon some of the features of the acquittal, and I gathered if that was the view of a moderate Deputy on the far side that it would be hard to expect from a less moderate person any more impartial view. I gathered that as far as convictions were concerned they were bound to have been right, but that so far as acquittals are concerned there was something wrong about them. I have said before in this House in connection with another Party that one of the disadvantages we are at in this country is that people address themselves to public questions who are unaccustomed to the exercise of authority.

Although that pronouncement was made by a very moderate person on that Party, I was firmly convinced, having heard that person make that pronouncement, that that person was utterly and entirely unaccustomed to the exercise of authority.

There must be a change in the administration in this country sooner or later. Time alone will make that a necessity. I invite Deputies opposite not to consider isolated instances, however reprehensible they may be and however much they may condemn them, without having the whole picture before them, without considering all the circumstances, without bearing in mind some of the difficulties, some of the complexities and the troubles — the terrible troubles—with which these guardians of the peace, who have the confidence. If not of the Deputies opposite, of the vast majority of the people, have to contend. Such charges as that major crimes have not been detected and that persons have not been brought to justice do not form a fair accusation, having regard to the number of arrests and the percentage of convictions in connection with those cases. It is a subject which should be considered calmly, dispassionately and without any advertence to one's leanings towards the persons whom the people believe are suffering on one side or the other. The whole subject was not dealt with in this House this evening in the manner in which one would like it to be dealt with. Any stranger coming here and listening to the debate would form the impression that it was the best that could be provided in this Parliament of Dáil Eireann.

I said I was not going to keep the House long, and I do not intend to. The policy of the Government, as I have pointed out, is emphasised in the various Acts which have been passed through the House, the Estimates which have also come before the House, and the various Budgets which have been considered. The policy has been to make this country a place in which industrialists would have confidence, where the burdens on industry and agriculture would be made as light as possible. That was the main consideration which we felt compelled us to refuse to impose a tax on the people of this country in order to carry into law the Bill which received a Second Reading on Thursday last.

The credit of the country stands high, very high. It does not follow from that that it is possible for us in a short space of time, at a moment's notice, to float loans. There were some very sensible suggestions made here this evening. Yesterday evening there were some criticisms on the election of myself, which I expect referred also to the other Ministers. Some members of the Labour Party pointed out the democratic programme of the First Dáil. They said that it had not been carried into effect. Deputy J.M. O'Sullivan dealt with that to some extent last night when he said that it might be possible to do all the things which had been suggested by the members of the Labour Party and the Fianna Fáil Party, but that it might possibly entail the introduction of a £25,000,000 Budget. Could industry bear that? Could agriculture bear that? Are the people rich enough to bear it? On the Benches opposite there is a Deputy who at one time advocated a no income tax campaign. This was modified subsequently to a proposal that there should be no income tax on Irish investments at home, Irish industries, Irish manufactures, and so on.

Other Deputies went so far as to say that we were legislating entirely for the rich and that we were indifferent to the poor. That is not a true charge. There is no foundation for it. During the last seven or eight years—though I am only responsible to account for the future. I suppose—we have been responsible for as intensive a social programme as the country was able to afford. I invite Deputies to contrast the condition of affairs here with their ideals, to examine other countries much longer established than this, countries with greater opportunities and better traditions than we have got, to compare affairs in those countries with conditions here, and to bear in mind that it is easy enough to table a programme of houses for all, houses for everybody, but it is quite another matter to find out who can be taxed to pay for them. If during the last two days we had bent our energies towards considering what were the difficulties of the present situation, how they can be solved, how the production of the country could be increased, how it would be possible to get cheaper houses for a larger number of people, how we might induce industrialists to develop at a still further rate the existing factories in the country, it would have been much better than all this rámeis that we have heard at great length and thundering sound.

This morning I received from a friend of mine an extract from the writings of Thomas Davis, and I propose to conclude with these words. My friend writes:—

Let me write down here a passage in one of Davis's essays:—

It is not a gambling fortune, made at imperial play, Ireland wants; it is the pious and stern cultivation of her faculties and virtues, the acquisition of faithful and exact habits, and the self-respect that rewards a dutiful and sincere life. To get her peasants into snug homesteads with well-tilled fields and placid hearths; to develop the ingenuity of her artists, and the docile industry of her artisans; to make for her own instruction a literature wherein our climate, history and passions shall breathe; and to gain conscious strength and integrity, and the high post of holy freedom. These are Ireland's wants.

Comment on this

"Not a gambling fortune, made at imperial play."

Comment on this

I wish to raise a point of order. It is a matter for you to decide whether you will take it now or after this Vote is taken. During the course of the President's speech Deputy Corry interrupted and you said to him "Shut up." I do not think that is an expression which the Chair should use to a Deputy in this House. If a Deputy has offended against the rules of order there is a method by which he can be dealt with. I would like to draw attention to the fact that the expression used by the Ceann Comhairle on that occasion was one that should not have been used.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The expression was quite inadequate.

Comment on this

I would like—

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I am going to put the Question.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 80
·
Níl 65
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Good old fifteen!

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

In the course of the President's reply to the debate which has just concluded, Deputy Corry made an interruption and the Ceann Comhairle said "Shut up." The Ceann Comhairle thinks that is an expression which the Chair should not have permitted itself to use, and regrets having used it.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I move the adjournment of the Dáil until 3 p.m. on Wednesday, 9th April.

The Dáil adjourned at 10.20 p.m. until Wednesday at 3 p.m.

Comment on this