We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Business. - Local Government (Dublin) Bill, 1929—Recommitted.

Contributions 163–323 of 473. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Local Government (Dublin) Bill, 1929
Enacted

No. 51 of 1929 ›

If we are going to work Section 34 we must contemplate that a man may be registered for two or more premises, and we are simply stating in Section 33 that he may be so registered.

Comment on this

Then why need he be? That person must claim a vote on the commercial register. He puts in a claim and says: "I claim to be registered on the commercial register because I have property in the city of Dublin that has an aggregate valuation of so many pounds." His name need go on the register only once; it is not necessary for him to appear twice. It he appears twice on the register, can he be prevented from voting twice? He cannot. Obviously, the reason for putting his name there is that he may vote twice. This sub-section is unnecessary in view of Section 34.

Comment on this

I am not prepared to accept the Deputy's suggestion that it is unnecessary, but even if it were unnecessary, he cannot have more votes than are provided for in Section 34.

Comment on this

It is a question that I would like to see interpreted in a law court whether he can or cannot, because what Deputy Lemass says is perfectly correct. It appears to me that a person can apply to be registered in respect of one set of premises, the aggregate valuation of which would be £250, and can apply to be registered in a second case for another aggregate of valuations amounting to £250, and in respect of each entry would be entitled to cast six votes at an election.

Comment on this

I can assure the Deputy on the best advice that he would not.

Comment on this

I would like to hear the Minister prove that he could. I hold that Deputy Lemass's contention is a perfectly sound one, that it would be possible for a person to be registered twice in respect of two separate sets of qualifications.

Comment on this

The Bill provides that a person may be registered in respect of two or more premises, and that being so registered, where the aggregate of the valuation of the premises in respect of which he is registered reaches a certain figure he shall have a certain number of votes.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say why it is necessary that the person's name should be on the register twice if it is not proposed to let him vote twice?

Comment on this

I am not saying that it is necessary at all to have his name twice on the register.

Comment on this

Then why the sub-section?

Comment on this

Because the sub-section could be effective by putting down the man's name once and by putting the premises opposite. But I can assure the Deputies that there is nothing here that will allow a person to get more than the number of votes on the aggregate of the premises for which he is registered.

Comment on this

Has the Minister also considered the case of the multiple shops? They can be represented on the register by their managers, and in respect of each of them they would be able to cast six votes. What will be the position in regard to them?

Comment on this

It would apply in the case of a company owning three shops. They could possibly get more than six votes by having the managers' names registered in respect of each of them. Supposing that the valuation of each of them was £250, could they not register each of these premises in respect of the manager's name, and get six votes in respect of each?

Comment on this

No. If Deputies think that it will be possible to have that done, then in the machinery we will have to try to make arrangements by which it would be impossible for a company to pretend that their different shops belonged to a number of different individuals. That is a very different matter from what is here.

Comment on this

In any case, does the Minister not contemplate machinery by which a person will claim a vote on the commercial register in respect of property owned by him in the city area? In view of the fact that a person supporting his claim must state the property owned by him, he need only be entered once on the register. I cannot see the necessity for this sub-section. Its deletion will not interfere with the Minister's expressed intention. It would remove a doubt in my mind that, by permitting a person to be registered twice, we would be giving him power to vote twice.

Comment on this

The Minister understands that it is not necessary to be the proprietor of premises to be the rated occupier. It has often happened that people who are occupying certain premises merely for business purposes and perhaps paying a weekly rent for these premises are rated occupiers and have votes as such. At a time of great interest in municipal affairs it might easily happen that certain companies might desire to increase the number of their votes, and they could register the managers of their various premises in the city as rated occupiers, and secure duplication or triplication of the number of votes that would otherwise be available to them. That is what we want to avoid.

Comment on this

This would not prevent them if people wanted to do it. What I want to secure is that a person whose company may be registered in respect of two or more premises, and being so registered, on the aggregate of valuation, will have a certain number of votes. I secure that here.

Comment on this

Is the Minister sure of that? I think that the draftsman is at fault. It would, I think, be clear if the section was worded so as to read: "An individual who is registered once in respect of two or more premises." The Minister should consult the draftsman about it.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 18, Section 33, to add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

(7) Only one individual shall be entitled to vote in respect of any one set of premises whether the said premises are in the rated occupation of an individual, partnership, un-incorporated association or corporate body.

Comment on this

I think that this amendment is more or less in the same position as the previous one and if there is any point in it, it arises on the machinery of the Bill.

Comment on this

It was pointed out to me that in the case of a partnership, of property being registered in the names of two, three or more persons who jointly hold such property, there is no machinery to decide who would vote and that four people could, in fact, vote. It is to avoid giving two, three, or more persons votes, as they might be given if the Bill stands as it is, that the amendment is put down. Cases of that kind have occurred. Cases have been brought under my notice that occurred under Acts that no longer operate but which were in operation prior to the Local Government Act of 1898, certain franchise laws under which people claimed successfully that they were joint owners of property and had power to vote.

Comment on this

As the Bill stands, I do not think that it would be possible for a company to vote in that way. The machinery of the Bill will say what steps will have to be taken by which a company can vote.

Comment on this

Will the Minister see that that point will be covered?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

I move:—

"In page 19, Section 34, to delete sub-section (2) (d)."

We are anxious that whatever voting is to be done in the way suggested, should be done by the authorised person going to the polling booth and casting his vote in the ordinary way. If a person is authorised by a company or an incorporated body to vote, he should go to the polling booth and cast his vote the same as anyone else. We do not see why people who are given such great privileges under the commercial register should be given the additional privilege of voting by post. It could easily be arranged to have in every polling booth places for people who are on the commercial register to record their votes. That would probably be less costly than the proposed arrangement. It is a principle for which we certainly are not inclined to vote. We think that those who are given the privilege of being on the commercial register should be put to the trouble of going to the poll and casting their votes. If their vote is of such great value they should not object to doing that.

Comment on this

We think that there is no special virtue in putting people to trouble. This system will convenience the electors on the commercial register and will be cheaper. I am sure that the cost of providing separate ballot boxes and so forth for people on this register would be much greater than carrying out the ballot by post. Thus we save costs in the matter and convenience the electors. For these reasons I feel that postal voting on this small register should be allowed to stand.

Comment on this

If the principal reason for introducing this extraordinary proposal in relation to municipal elections is to meet the convenience of those whose names are on the commercial register, why not extend it to the general mass of the people? Why not permit everyone to vote by post? I am perfectly certain that the Minister would secure greater economy in that way than by conceding the privilege only in relation to commercial electors. I put it in another way. The Minister's contention is that these interests, because of the amount of rates they pay, are entitled to special representation in the Corporation. Let us see what value they attach to that. Does the Minister think that their interest in civic affairs is so slight that in order to induce them to cast their votes—even the six votes which the Minister gives them—and to exercise the undue influence in municipal matters, which under this Bill they will have attached to them, he is justified in granting them this special concession in regard to the special register and plural voting? I think that the argument put forward by the Minister in regard to postal voting is an argument against the whole commercial register. The least that might be expected of these people, who are granted special concessions and given undue influence in municipal affairs, is to give the same earnest of their interest in municipal life as the Minister exacts from the ordinary commonplace elector and ask them, like ordinary electors, to walk to the polling booth.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'Connell Labour Party

The Minister's proposal in this matter is a further evidence, if such evidence were needed, that he is creating a special privileged class. These postal voters are a very privileged class, and he will not ask such superior beings to walk like ordinary individuals to the polling booth. The objection, I suppose, that would be urged against making postal voting universal would be that such a system would be liable to abuse or that it would be impossible to keep a proper check on voting papers, etc. These special people, however, are so superior that the idea of their abusing the franchise would not enter into the Minister's mind. They are a privileged class who cannot be expected to go and register their votes like ordinary people. That is certainly in accordance with the whole idea underlying this proposed commercial register which creates a privileged class. The Minister may argue that because such people have not this representation already they are entitled to this commercial register. That, however, does not come in here. If there is anything good in the idea of postal voting it ought to be as good for the ordinary elector as for the commercial elector. There is no argument, so far as I can see, to justify differentiation of treatment in this manner of voting between a voter on the commercial register and an ordinary voter who has to cast his vote in the polling booth.

Comment on this

You have either to provide special ballot boxes at all the places where polling is taking place and provide registers there, or you have to confine the commercial electors to a smaller number of polling booths. That is, you have to add to the present difficulties of getting polling booths.

Comment on this
A Deputy

They can all vote together.

Comment on this

You would give this additional trouble to the voters on the commercial register which ordinary voters have and you would also be entering into a certain amount of unnecessary expense in providing boxes and printing registers. You would have to provide ballot boxes for them at each of the stations at considerable expense.

Comment on this

What about providing different coloured ballot papers?

Comment on this

Or you can provide postal voting under which the electorate will be convenienced and expenses spared. I am not prepared to say now whether I have examined postal voting as compared with the present system to see whether it might not be in the general interests of the people, and convenience all the electorate to change the whole system. I do not think, however, that that arises now. What does arise is this: whether this is a simpler more convenient and less costly method of carrying on the election under the commercial register or not. I say it is, and on these grounds I ask that it should stand.

Comment on this

As far as economy is concerned, the argument was advanced that it would be necessary either to limit the commercial electorate to a smaller number of polling stations than was employed for the election of the ordinary members of the Council or that it might be necessary to provide duplicate ballot boxes at the polling stations. I think a way out of that might easily be found if the Minister would consider the question of having ballot papers of different colours. The candidates on both ballot papers would be absolutely different, and there would be no possibility of confusion arising in the minds of any of the electorate. It would be simply a matter of sorting out the papers when the ballot boxes were opened.

Comment on this

If the item of expense is the only one that is agitating the Minister's mind, I can assure him that that will not arise, as the Corporation happens to possess a larger number of ballot boxes than will be required for the election of ordinary members of the Council.

Comment on this

I do not see the use of making the commercial electors walk there and of putting them to certain inconvenience. That is apart from the question of the use of ballot boxes.

Comment on this

The Minister is overlooking the fact that they will have to walk in any case, if they are good citizens—that in addition to having a vote on a commercial register these super-citizens will have votes on the ordinary register, and they will have to walk to the polling stations to exercise these votes in any case.

Comment on this

What about a corporate body? There would be great difficulty in arranging for it to vote in any way other than by post. The vote would have to be given under seal.

Comment on this

A corporate body can select one man to vote on behalf of the body. I do not think that it is even necessary to print a special register. There only needs to be a special column on the existing register just as in the past persons were recorded as being Dáil electors, Seanad electors and jurors. That only needs another column on the existing register.

Comment on this

Can the Deputy suggest anything more simple than postal voting?

Comment on this

My point is that postal voting is, in this case, designed to ensure that there will be a 100 per cent. poll in the case of the commercial representatives and that similar precautions are not being taken in the case of the ordinary electorate.

Comment on this

Votes are far more likely to be lost in the postal election.

Comment on this

I am aware that the result of the last University elections may be easily explained on that account.

Comment on this

The Minister of course, I know, is one of those who believes that personation should be put down. Will he tell the House what precautions he proposes to take in connection with the postal election to ensure that the person who appears on the register is the person who fills the form and determines how the votes are going to be cast? That is one of the dangers I see in this—that the system lends itself easily to abuse.

Comment on this

How?

Comment on this

Because some person other than the person whose name appears on the register may get possession of the ballot paper and fill it up.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Somebody may get your letters in the morning.

Comment on this

That is quite possible.

Comment on this

Will the paper not be signed by a responsible person?

Comment on this

Who is going to test the signature? The Minister knows it is not difficult to ensure that all the postal votes will be cast, but we have some experience of the postal voting in connection with the Dáil and we do not want to have it repeated in connection with the municipal elections. It is quite easy to forget the voter's name in these cases.

Comment on this

The Deputy is speaking from his own experience.

Comment on this

No, but any person with common sense can see the dangers in this proposal. Apart altogether from having experience, he has only to have a sufficient imagination to see what can be done.

Comment on this

If the Minister will remember, I raised the matter in 1927 that a large number of our supporters in the University election had not received their ballot papers at all. They were intercepted somewhere in the post.

Comment on this

I do not remember that.

Comment on this

I remember I raised it here in the Dáil. Their votes were lost.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 45
·
Níl 67
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 20:—

In page 19, Section 35 (1), line 29, to delete the word "two" and also to delete the word "members" and substitute the word "member," and in line 31 to delete the word "aldermen" and substitute the words "an alderman."

Under this amendment where there are five electoral areas there will now be six aldermen and a council of 35, and that is sufficient.

Comment on this

I move amendment 21:—

In page 19, Section 36, before sub-section (3), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(3) At the first meeting of the City Council the business to be transacted shall be such business as the City Council is required by or under this Act or otherwise by law to transact at such meeting, and also any other business arising under this Act which, in the opinion of the City Council, it is necessary or desirable to transact at such meeting, and no notice, whether by notice of motion or otherwise, shall be required for the transaction of any such business."

This gives power to the Council to transact at the first meeting any business that they may consider requires to be done and which is of an urgent nature. It is just a precautionary measure.

Comment on this

I move amendment 23:—

In page 20, Section 38, before sub-section (3), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(3) All fees and emoluments which are payable by or under any statute (whether passed before or after this Act) to town clerks of county boroughs or in particular to the Town Clerk of the City, and are received by the City Manager by virtue of his being the Town Clerk of the City, shall be paid by the City Manager into the municipal fund and be accounted for accordingly."

The practice of the Department recently has been to give inclusive salaries to persons such as the secretaries of county councils and of boards of health, and in all cases practically where there are old statutory fees and emoluments to arrange that these fees shall be paid into the public treasury and that the salaries paid to the officials shall be inclusive salaries. In accordance with that policy, which I think will be accepted as a sound and satisfactory one, it is proposed that all fees normally paid to the Town Clerk will now be paid into the municipal fund, so that there will be an inclusive salary for the City Manager and for the Town Clerk.

Comment on this

I move amendment 25:—

In page 20, Section 39 (3), line 62, after the word "may" to insert the words "with his consent."

Deputies will remember that under Section 86, in connection with the Committee dealing with the expenditure under the Poor Law and the Grangegorman Mental Hospital Committee it is proposed that the Manager may be a member of these bodies. This amendment secures that he shall not be appointed a member of these bodies contrary to his own consent. I think Deputies will agree that all we desire to do is to make it permissive to have the Manager a member of either of these bodies, but that if the Manager in his discretion considers that he has not time in the circumstances to spend as a member of these committees it would be within his power to decline to act.

Comment on this

I do not think that the Minister has made any case for the amendment. Surely if the Manager is the servant of the Council, the Council should have the right to say that he shall act as their representative on these committees and that the question of his consent shall not enter into it. It seems to me that the purpose of the amendment is very largely to make the Manager superior to the Council, to give him a veto over the Council's decisions. Undoubtedly, the proposal that the Council should have power to nominate the Manager as a member of one of these committees, in the same way as they would nominate one of their own members, is right and justifiable under the circumstances, but that the Manager should have the right to refuse to act when the Council wants him to act, seems to me absolutely unjustifiable, unless it is the Minister's intention to go back upon the ground he has already covered and make the Manager again the master of the Council instead of its servant. I am quite certain the Council would not be unreasonable in that matter.

Comment on this

I am quite certain the Manager would not be unreasonable either.

Comment on this

If he said he had not time the Council would not insist, but if the Council thought its interests required that the Manager, with the special qualifications he has, should be a member of one of those committees he should not have the right to refuse to serve on such committees.

Comment on this

We are aiming at having these committees composed of persons who voluntarily undertake to go on such committees and to discharge their duties there. The Council will nominate a certain number on the Mental Hospital Committee. If the Manager undertakes to go as a member of the Committee he could simply acquiesce and need not go. There is nothing incumbent upon him to put in an attendance there. Even if he did go it would not be incumbent upon him to take part in any way in the discussions there. As the Deputy said, the Council will not be unreasonable, but the Manager also will not be unreasonable. It was not our intention, and it should not be our intention, that the Manager could be asked by the Council to act in the capacity of a public representative if, in his judgment—and as City Manager he would have a very wide outlook, and his judgment would be entitled to be regarded as sound— he ought not so to act. It ought not to be a matter of that particular kind to lead to a dispute between himself and the Council. I think it is quite sound to leave it permissive, and that if the Council and the Manager agree in the matter he may act as a member of the Grangegorman Mental Hospital Committee. It was because of the drafting of this thing in regard to the Mental Hospital that there is this doubt that he might be coerced. The drafting of Section 86 is such that there is no danger of his being coerced, and there is nothing to coerce him to act, and I do not think he should be coerced, and the temptation should not be put into anybody's hand to coerce him to act. We assume normal harmonious relations, and we assume sound judgment on the part of the Manager, and I think we may well accept this amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 26:—

In page 21, Section 40 (2), to delete all from the word "and" in line 29 to the end of the sub-section.

This is really a drafting amendment. While the statutory committee is being abolished we do not want to introduce anything here that would suggest that the Council could not set up a special committee to deal with anything concerned with any of these matters or with the waterworks.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 27:—

In page 21, section 42 (1), lines 47 and 48, to delete the words "fifteen" and "six" and substitute therefor the words "twenty-five" and "nine" respectively.

I move this amendment to enable the Council to be more representative of the general community than it is likely to be if it only consists of fifteen members. The population of the new borough consists of very diverse classes. You have some of the most prosperous elements in the community there; you have more of the prosperous elements of the community in that area, and in greater proportion than in the City of Dublin. On the other hand, you have a very large percentage of the poorer people and the workers there. It appears to me that as the Council is at present proposed to be constituted the more democratic sections of the community will not be adequately represented there, and that refers particularly to those who live in the smaller townships of Dalkey, Killiney and Blackrock. Furthermore, there is the fact that having the Council constituted of fifteen members practically compels the Minister to have only one electoral area. The process of election with a ballot paper containing fifteen names will become unwieldy and practically unworkable. For that reason, and in order to ensure that each district will have its own special representatives, we would like to increase the number of members on the council in order that we may also increase the number of electoral areas.

It was argued that one of the reasons why Blackrock, Dun Laoghaire, Dalkey and Killiney could not be included in the City area was because if they were so included these particular districts would not secure that special attention which their affairs demanded would be given to them by the Council. I think that the arguments which the Minister used to exclude these areas could also be applied now to ensure that the size of the Council shall be such that each particular district shall be first of all constituted an electoral area and that it shall have a certain quota allocated to it. I do not see how that can be very well done unless the size of the Council is increased. With a view to ensuring that it will be done and, at the same time, that in every electoral area due representation will be given to all the interests in that area, I propose that the size of the Council be increased from fifteen to twenty-five members. We are not wedded to three electoral areas. If necessary, there could be a sub-division of Dun Laoghaire and possibly of Blackrock, leaving Dalkey and Killiney as a separate electoral area.

Comment on this

I am very much wedded to one electoral area for this borough.

Comment on this

Is it a sacramental marriage—is there any divorce in it?

Comment on this

I think it is very necessary that you get the borough mind established in the area and that the division that at present exists arising out of the fact that you have four urban districts looking at different sections should be got away from at the earliest moment. The area is a comparatively small area. You will have a manager and you will have a council. My own idea originally was that a council of eleven members would be sufficient. I adopted the number fifteen in this measure because, after discussing the matter with the members of the urban districts throughout the area, I came to the conclusion that I would not object to a council of fifteen, if fifteen would satisfy them better. I think I may say that a council of fifteen was accepted generally as satisfactory by the parties representing the different townships with whom I discussed this.

Comment on this

Can the Minister envisage a ballot paper with fifteen vacancies and with say, forty-five candidates upon it? Has he considered how the electors are to mark a paper like that?

Comment on this

I can envisage such a ballot paper. It is a small compact area where the different men will be pretty well known from one end of the constituency to the other. I think if the Deputy works it out he will see that, with the average person voting for the average type of public man, the single transferable vote will be a vote that will exhaust itself by the time the voter comes to the end of his preferences. I am satisfied that electing in one electoral area fifteen members of the council by the single transferable vote arrangement gives you a not unsatisfactory form of getting a council for a small urban area like that. As I have already said, fifteen is the figure that I adopted in order to meet local opinion and, even if there were some difficulty in the matter of electing fifteen members, the thing that is very necessary there is to get the unified mind in the borough area itself. It is well worth any little difficulty in the ballot paper to secure that the persons elected there will be persons elected by the borough as a whole, and persons who will look on the borough as a whole as their constituency.

Comment on this

We will not press the amendment to a division.

Comment on this

I move amendment 29:—

In page 22, Section 44 (2), lines 35 and 36, to delete the words "Town Clerk of the Dun Laoghaire Urban District" and substitute the words "Borough Manager," and in lines 37 and 38 to delete the words "the said Town Clerk."

This is a drafting amendment arising out of doing away with the position of town clerk.

Comment on this

I move amendment 30:—

In page 22, Section 44, before sub-section (3), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(3) At the first meeting of the borough council the business to be transacted shall be such business as the borough council is required by or under this Act or otherwise by law to transact at such meeting, and also any other business arising under this Act which, in the opinion of the borough council, it is necessary or desirable to transact at such meeting, and no notice, whether by notice of motion or otherwise, shall be required for the transaction of any such business."

This is analogous with the amendment just passed and its object is to enable business to be transacted at the first meeting of the Council which the Council may consider urgent.

Comment on this

Before Section 44 is put I wish to comment upon the position of mayor. I think it is undesirable that we should have a mayor in the new borough. While I say that, I think at the same time that it is desirable that it should be possible for the Council to grant remuneration to the person who is acting as chairman of the Council. I was unable to devise an amendment which would meet both points. Sub-section (3) of this section is the only item in the Bill that provides for the remuneration of the mayor. That sub-section relates to the remuneration of the mayor and the mayor only, whereas I was anxious to get rid of the mayor and to have a chairman and to have that chairman capable of receiving remuneration so that he could give a fair amount of his time to that work. I think the Minister is prepared to sacrifice the mayor if sufficient pressure is put upon him by the House. I would ask now that that pressure should be exercised. There is no need for a mayor at all. There is no need to build up an association of that kind in the coastal borough.

Comment on this

I am afraid that the Deputy did not try very hard to devise an amendment which would meet the points he wants to have inserted, and I do not think that the Deputy is serious in that matter or that he meant it because a word or two would amend that part of the section. I cannot take the Deputy as being serious.

Comment on this

I am very serious. At first, I thought it was quite easy to amend the sub-section. If, however, the Minister thinks it is easy to amend it he can do so now. It seems to me that if he deleted the word "mayor" and substituted the word "chairman" he would have provided for what I want. So far as I know there is no law at present in force relating to the remuneration of the chairman of a borough council.

Comment on this

I do not believe that remuneration is necessary in this case.

Comment on this

I could hardly submit an amendment which would reconcile the two outlooks that have just been given expression to.

Comment on this

I would like to see the person acting as mayor or chairman receiving remuneration so that he would be able to devote his time to looking after the work of the Council and supervising the work of the Manager. To have an unpaid mayor or chairman would be more or less to give the Manager a free hand. I dislike also the idea of creating a new mayor in the country. We have historical reasons for retaining Lord Mayors in places where they exist, but no case can be put forward for establishing a new mayor.

Comment on this
Timothy Sheehy Mr. T. Sheehy (Cork) Cumann na nGaedheal

I see no reason why there should not be a mayor in Dun Laoghaire. There is nothing wrong about that.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

Or about giving one to Skibbereen.

Comment on this

I expressed an opinion on this matter when the Bill was being considered on the Second Stage. I am inclined to agree with Deputy Lemass. There is good reason for retaining a Lord Mayor in Dublin because of the historic associations attaching to the post. Besides, it is the capital city. I think that if you create a rival to our Lord Mayor you are rather apt to diminish the glory of our Lord Mayor. There will be, too, a certain amount of friction at social gatherings and things of that sort which will not lead to the harmonious working of the two bodies. If you want a chairman why not call him a chairman. I think, perhaps, that he might get some remuneration. Taken purely from the point of view of sentiment, I am against the appointment of this mayor.

Comment on this

I can hardly take Deputy Lemass as serious when he proposes this. As far as the question of having a mayor in Dun Laoghaire is concerned, I am very open-minded about it.

Comment on this

Then drop it.

Comment on this

I would like the Minister to drop this proposal if he has an open mind upon the subject. There is a great deal in what Deputy Alton says. This might be the cause of friction and social jealousies. Little points of that kind would arise and they would not tend to harmonise the working of the two bodies. From that point of view alone I think it would be advisable to drop the proposal about a mayor in Dun Laoghaire. A chairman would be quite an efficient person and a mayor is quite unnecessary. There are historical reasons for keeping mayors in other parts of the country, but there are no reasons why we should begin to establish new mayors. If we begin in that way now there will be other applications. I see no reason why we should establish any new posts of this nature. I think it would not add anything to the dignity of the position, and it would not help efficient working on local bodies. I think it would be an advantage to the capital city if there was no mayor appointed in Dun Laoghaire.

Comment on this

I am prepared to meet the House in this matter, and, as an amateur's shot at drafting, I will make this suggestion: I am going to change the word "mayor" and the section will then read:—

(1) The borough council shall at their first meeting...elect one of their members to be chairman.

(2) The chairman shall continue in office...until his successor shall have been elected at the next quarterly meeting of the borough council at which a chairman is to be elected...and such successor shall have made the declaration accepting office which is required by law.

(3) Subject to the provisions of this Act, the law for the time being in force in relation to the election, tenure of office, powers, duties, privileges, and remuneration of a chairman of a borough shall apply to the election, tenure of office, powers, duties, privileges, and remuneration of the chairman.

If the House is prepared to accept that I would be prepared to accept such a proposal from Deputy Lemass.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The amendment would read "In lines 50, 51, 54, and 61, to delete the word "mayor" where it occurs and insert in lieu thereof the word "chairman."

Comment on this

There will be consequential amendments necessary in other parts of the Bill.

Comment on this

Is it too late for me to raise one small voice in protest against this procedure? To me it would seem that this whole thing smacks of silliness. We propose to put in an amendment which does away with the mayor, but we suggest that the chairman who is to be set up instead shall be just the same as a mayor. What is the point of it at all? If you are to have an officer who is to be the same as a mayor, why not call him a mayor? There seems to be some kind of semi-Republican sentimentality under this whole proposal.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

What are the reasons that render it desirable in certain places to keep on a mayor because of historical associations and to oppose the setting up of a mayor in other places when it is equally desirable that there should be one? I must confess that I cannot see any great amount of reasoning in the whole atmosphere in which this little discussion has been carried on. I do not propose to call for a division on this matter but I certainly would like to register a protest against the whole tenor of this debate.

Comment on this

The Deputy would be an excellent man if he did not allow these anti-Republican bees to buzz in his bonnet.

Comment on this
Timothy Sheehy Mr. T. Sheehy (Cork) Cumann na nGaedheal

I am not anxious to divide the House on this matter, but I do think that it would add considerably to the dignity of the whole thing if a mayor were established in Dun Laoghaire.

Comment on this

If the amendment I have suggested is adopted it will be necessary to make alterations in other parts of the Bill.

Comment on this

It will be necessary to make consequential changes in the definition section.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

These could be taken as verbal amendments on the Fifth Stage.

Comment on this

Amendment 31, which is as follows, is purely a drafting amendment. It is not proposed to appoint a town clerk under this Act, and the other things arise out of the fact that the office of town clerk is abolished:—

In page 23, Section 46 (1), line 2, to delete the words "by or," and in line 3, after the word "Manager," to insert the words "and town clerk," and in lines 7 and 8 to delete the words "including the town clerk but not including" and substitute within the brackets the words "other than."

Comment on this

Amendment 32 is also a drafting amendment, and it deals with the doing away of the town clerk's position:—

In page 23, before Section 46 (2), to insert two new sub-sections as follows:—

(2) For the purposes of every enactment (including enactments passed or made after the passing of this Act) relating to town clerks of boroughs, the Borough Manager shall, on and after the appointed day, be the Town Clerk of the Borough, and have, exercise and perform all the powers, functions and duties for the time being conferred or imposed by any such enactment or otherwise by law on the Town Clerk of the Borough.

(3) All fees and emoluments which are payable by or under any statute (whether passed before or after this Act) to town clerks of Boroughs and are received by the Borough Manager by virtue of his being Town Clerk of the Borough, shall be paid by the Borough Manager into the municipal fund and be accounted for accordingly.

Comment on this

I move amendment 33:—

In page 23, Section 49 (1), lines 53 and 54, to delete the words "as soon as conveniently may be after the occurrence thereof" and substitute the words "after due notice at the next meeting of the Council after the expiration of one month from the occurrence of such vacancy or as soon after that meeting as circumstances will permit."

I think amendment 33 meets the point with regard to the time in which casual vacancies will be filled.

Comment on this

I move amendment 34:—

In page 24, Section 50 (1), to add at the end of the sub-section a new paragraph as follows:—

"(n) the appointment of representatives of the Corporation to attend any such conference or meeting as is mentioned in Section 2 of the Public Health and Local Government Conferences Act, 1885, and the exercise of the power conferred by that section in relation to the payment of the expenses of the attendance of such representatives at such conferences and meetings."

Amendment 34 meets the point, I think, which is contained in Deputy Byrne's amendment No. 36, that the Council shall have reserved the powers of appointing persons to attend conferences.

Comment on this

I move the following amendments:—

35. In page 24, line 44, to add at the end of Section 50 (1) the following paragraph:—

"the decision as to the types and rents of houses in housing schemes and the alterations or modifications of same."

37. In page 24, line 44, to add at the end of Section 50 (1) the following paragraph:—

"the approval of all contracts of £500 and upwards."

38. In page 24, line 44, to add at the end of Section 50 (1) the following paragraph:—

"the use of Irish manufactured goods or materials and the granting or giving of preferences thereon in all or any corporate requirements or schemes."

39. In page 24, line 44, to add at the end of Section 50 (1) the following paragraph:—

"the sites and forms of public buildings, and public sanitary conveniences."

40. In page 24, line 44, to add at the end of Section 50 (1) the following paragraph:—

"the fixation of prices for corporation services relating to cattle markets, food markets and abattoir."

I have been anxious, during the whole course of this debate, if possible, to give the control of contracts to the Municipal Corporation as apart from the Manager or in conjunction with the Manager. The Minister has gone a great part of the way to meet objections urged against the Bill as it stood in its original form. He has given the Council powers to deal with procedure, reception and examination of contracts rather than examination of tenders, but still the power of contract is vested absolutely in the hands of the Manager. Speaking with some knowledge of business affairs, I think the whole exercise and placing of contracts should not be in the Manager's hands exclusively. I know from past experience that the door of corruption is very frequently thrown open when contracts have been placed. I know of such a thing as commissions being offered in the placing of contracts from 2½ per cent. to 10 per cent., to those in whose hands the placing of the contracts rested. I feel we have been lucky in obtaining the services of a particularly efficient Manager who will guard us against things of that kind, but we may not be always so lucky in the Manager which the Corporation will appoint, and if it so happens that a corrupt individual will have the sole placing of the contracts as the Manager appears to have under the Bill it would be a get-rich-quick job for that particular Manager. It has been urged that, more or less, matters of that kind in the State are left in managerial hands, but anyone who has any idea of why these things are left in managerial hands knows perfectly well that it is a foregone conclusion that these contracts will be placed in the hands of the party to which the Manager belongs. That is a well-known fact in American life. I might also point out that in large firms like the English Cooperative Society the same thing exists to my own particular knowledge in connection with large contracts for tea and sugar. I have heard it frequently stated that certain firms need not apply for contracts simply because they were not prepared to give the men who had the placing of the contracts a commission.

I am asking the Minister to go a little step further and remove any ideas or thoughts that anything in the nature of corruption may exist in the Dublin Corporation in the placing of contracts. If the Minister can see his way to allow the Council to have a deciding voice in the placing of contracts he is going to have a useful factor in seeing how these contracts are going to be placed. He is going to have a double check. In the first instance, you will have the contract dealt with by the Manager. Then it will have to come to the Council in order to receive the approval of the Council for any contract that is placed. That gives a dual control over every contract which the Dublin Municipal Council will place, whereas under the present system it is almost entirely in the Manager's hands. There is no check on the Manager except the auditor. Anyone reading the daily papers for the past few weeks would see how corruption has been going on in local bodies in England for a number of years. The setting up of a special committee to go into the affairs of the councils has only enabled those things to be brought to light. Under my amendment you will have a check on the Manager. If the Council can do anything wrong as far as their small functions are concerned they can be reported to the Local Government Department. On the other hand, if you have the Council reviewing these contracts you will have a dual check on the Manager. At present you have no check except the auditor, and anyone versed in municipal affairs knows that the work of the auditor is very heavy and it is quite possible for irregularities to occur in the placing of contracts if things are left entirely in the hands of the Manager.

I would urge the Minister to go a little step further to meet the views that are held by a great many business people in the city as far as the placing of contracts are concerned. I urge it particularly on the Minister, because the placing of contracts is purely a matter of policy. It has absolutely nothing to do with administration. I make that statement with no fear of contradiction, even though the Minister may disagree with me. It is an absurd thing, in view of the amount of money that may be given away yearly in the placing of contracts that the Council proper should have no control.

The Ceann Comhairle has asked me to take the amendments together and therefore I would ask the Minister to consider the question of rent and the type of houses. I would like to point out to the Minister that since the war a certain class of house has been erected at from 16/- to £1 per week. This has made no provision for the ordinary labouring man. I should say that the Manager himself as an individual should not have the right to determine what particular class or type of houses is erected in various parts of the city. If one looks across the Channel to see what has been done there you can see that a very considerable advance has been made in the housing of the poorer population in places like Leeds, London and Glasgow. Large amounts of self contained flats have been erected and let at a rental of 9/6 and 10/- and even at a rental as low as 7/6 a week. We have done absolutely nothing in Dublin as far as that is concerned. Are we to go on in the same manner and leave the things in the Manager's hands? It appears to me that if you send in certain individuals representing their own areas that these particular councillors will know the wants of their own districts a great deal better than any Manager can hope to know them. I certainly think that a councillor, representing his own area, if particular wants exist in his own district, should have some deciding voice in seeing that the wants should be attended to. I am of opinion that it is not going to interfere in any way with administration, that it is not going to infringe in any way on the managerial powers and that it should be productive of a great deal of good for the poorer people of this city. I have met day after day people who ask me when is a house to be erected at a rent which an ordinary working man can pay. We have rents on houses at 16/- a week. A man with 50/- a week cannot look at those houses. These are questions of policy and in connection with them the Council should have some voice in their decision. I need not speak on the point of nomination of members of the Council. The Minister has met that.

I want to say one word about giving power to the Council to have a voice in giving preference to Irish goods. A great deal of controversy has gone on amongst the thinking element in this city as to the large imports of foreign goods to take the place of Irish goods where Irish goods could only be supplied at a higher price. In the housing schemes which have been carried on in Dublin we have been using a substitute in the shape of a Belgian slate. A great many people ask if the money would be better spent by using Killaloe slate instead of Belgian slate. These are also questions of policy and the Minister is leaving every one of these questions of policy entirely in the hands of the Manager.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

What check has the Council over him? The Minister of course may tell me that they have the check or power of the purse, but if you put a body of councillors up to accept a certain scheme of housing and the Manager will not depart from a partcular scheme the Council will be put in the position of having to accept the scheme rather than have no scheme at all. If a large body like the Dublin Corporation do not do everything humanly possible to encourage the use of Irish material and purchase Irish manufactured goods I say it is a very bad example to the country and one that the Minister ought seriously to consider. The question of unemployment, as we all know, is one that is agitating the city of Dublin, particularly at the present time. We have to pay £121,000 arising purely out of the question of unemployment. This is one of the means by which this question could be partly dealt with and very efficiently dealt with. The Dublin Corporation should have some say in seeing that Irish manufactured goods receive a reasonable preference. I would put it to the Minister, is it fair or reasonable to place decisions of such importance entirely in the hands of the Manager? You may very easily make the position of the Manager impossible, if such questions of outstanding importance as these are left entirely to his own decision. I feel, as I have already said, that we have succeeded in obtaining an exceedingly efficient Manager. At the same time on important questions of policy like these the Council should come in and take some responsibility. If the Council do not discharge their duties or functions according to the wishes of the people they can be very easily removed, but the people have no power or say over the Manager if he carries out a line of policy that is not in keeping with the wishes of the people. They have no remedy over him. I would earnestly appeal to the Minister to meet me on these questions which I call purely questions of policy entirely apart from the question of administration.

Comment on this

My advice to Deputy Byrne is that he is almost fully met on everything that he has done here. He talked of reserving to the Council the decision as to the types and rents of houses under housing schemes. I take it he does not mean that the Council shall be able to say that Johnny So and So's rent shall be 7/6 and not 9/6, like the rest of the people.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

No.

Comment on this

Section 50, sub-section (1) (a), gives the power of borrowing money for houses that have to be provided. I do not accept the Deputy's disparaging suggestion that as much has not been done in Dublin to provide houses at reasonable rents as has been done in any of the English cities.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

In the city of Leeds a man can get a three-roomed self-contained flat with sanitation and water for 7/6 a week. Can we offer anything like it in Dublin? The same thing obtains in Glasgow and London.

Comment on this

How many people in Leeds are looking for the same accommodation and cannot get it?

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

But there is none available here.

Comment on this

When the city Council decide on a housing scheme they ask for proposals to be put up to them as regards the type of house and they ask for estimates and all that sort of thing. They have to decide. They certainly are not doing their duty if they do not look at the site, at the lay-out of the house, and see what kind of houses are going to be provided for the money that they are going to borrow. Before they complete their borrowing they have responsibility, you may say, of looking at the financial side of the housing proposal. They have to see how much, as a council, they are going to give as a grant towards the carrying out of that housing scheme; they have to see how much they are going to get as a government grant, and how much they are going to get from the occupier generally in order to balance the finance of their scheme. In that way the Council have almost complete general control over the rents.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

May I put a concrete case to the Minister? Supposing a certain section of the Council want self-contained flats on the north side and the Manager says "no," what power has the Council got?

Comment on this

The Council need not provide him with the money to build whatever he wants to build. So that the section with regard to borrowing gives complete control over the general policy as regards the kind of house that the Council are going to allow the Manager to build. It gives the Council complete control over the general balancing of the scheme and it keeps them out of the very invidious position of saying that a particular rent shall be a particular sum.

On the question of contracts, as the Deputy remarked, I have put in a section that will enable the Council to frame regulations for receipt and examination of tenders. Giving that power to the Council I say that the acceptance of a contract is a managerial function. If the Council are going to be the body that is going to accept the contract then the Manager's responsibility is diffused. If the Council accept a contract for building a particular housing scheme and the contractor turns out badly or the houses turn out badly the Manager cannot say: "This is not my responsibility." If a drainage scheme turns out badly the Manager cannot wash his hands of that. I am quite satisfied that dishonesty in connection with contracts on the part of a manager, operating through his machine of officials and supervised as to the general lines of his policy and the general results of his work by a Council, would be much more impossible than dishonesty with the Council accepting contracts.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I would like to point out to the Minister that I have not asked for acceptance. I have asked for approval. There is a big distinction.

Comment on this

You must make the Manager shoulder his responsibility for accepting contracts. If you are going to hold the Manager completely responsible you cannot reasonably allow him to shed his responsibility by saying to the Council, if something turns out wrong, "You approved of this." We control the position from the point of view of examination of tenders. The Council can do that, but the acceptance of a contract, I want to argue, is a managerial function. I doubt if any Council would ask to be put into the position of approving of contracts when they are in the position of having a Manager who will shoulder full responsibility for them, and when they can completely supervise him in reference to his work.

As regards amendment 38, the Deputy, I think, will admit that even in the drafting of it he had a difficulty in meeting what he has in mind. I think it would be impossible to draft an amendment to meet what he has in mind. As the amendment stands, the Manager, I think, would hardly be able to wear a suit of homespuns, because, under it, the whole use of Irish manufactured goods is to be reserved to the Council. As I have said, I admit it is difficult to meet what the Deputy has in his mind. Local bodies, as a whole, have had this difficulty to contend with, that while a large number of them have been very anxious to support Irish slates, and some of them are actually spending more on houses than they otherwise would because they are using Irish slates, and while some more of them are spending additional money on houses because they are using locally-made bricks, in their endeavour to try to meet the want of houses for the poorer classes on the one hand and the scarcity of money on the other a very large number of them are driven to the position of not supporting Irish manufacture as much as they would like in this matter.

Comment on this

There is just a question I would like to put to the Minister. Taking slates as a typical example, how do the tenders received for Irish manufactured materials compare with the tenders received for foreign materials?

Comment on this

I think I can tell the Deputy that, on the ordinary reduced standard house that we are building in general throughout the country, it would cost about £18 more to roof in Irish slates than in asbestos slates.

Comment on this

I would like to know from the Minister how it is that the Glasgow Corporation, in the carrying out of their housing schemes, can afford to insist on the use of Irish slates while we cannot afford to do it though the slates are produced at our own doors.

Comment on this

I think I said on a previous occasion that the building technique here is probably responsible for it. For one thing, they use a smaller slate in Glasgow. The question of the Council and the Manager and their responsibility are, I suggest, involved enough without getting into a discussion now on building materials. What the Council have to do is to settle their general line of policy and then instruct their Manager. When they have settled their general line of policy they can, when sending out their specifications for houses, ask for alternative quotations for houses in which Irish windows, Irish slates, or Irish-made doors are used, but you cannot reduce to a section in a Bill that the Council shall be responsible for all that. The Council, in the effective review that they have over the plans and over the work that they propose to carry out, can quite easily institute a technique by which they can secure that their policy with regard to the use of any particular material will be carried out, their policy being, as must necessarily be the case, that when occasion arises they will consider the advantages nationally to be gained from using Irish materials. But no body is going to pass a resolution saying "henceforth we are never going to use anything but Irish materials," because they have to look at the interests of the Irish manufacturer and his employees, on the one hand, and, on the other hand, at their own interests and the interests of the city generally while making the best use of the national money.

The thing is not so simple, but I am quite satisfied that the Council, with the control they have through the money side of the thing, if they properly examine the plans, and all that, for the type of work they are going to do, can easily control the situation from the point of view that Irish manufacture shall be used along the general line of policy which they think reasonable. The remarks I have made with regard to housing generally apply to the sites and forms of public buildings, and public sanitary conveniences, which are dealt with in amendment 39. If public buildings are to be erected and sanitary conveniences, provided in any part of the city, there must always be plans of the sites and of the buildings it is proposed to put up.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Would the Minister say under what section of the Bill the Council has any control, say, as to where sanitary conveniences are to be erected?

Comment on this

Whenever work of that kind has to be done, and the money required for it has to be raised out of the rates or borrowed, it is simply common sense to say that when the Council is asked either to borrow money or to raise it from the rates for such constructional work, they would ask to see the plans of the proposed site and structure. We give them that power, so that it is entirely in their own hands to use it. With regard to amendment 40, which deals with the fixation of prices for Corporation services relating to cattle markets, food markets and abattoir, that is a purely administrative act. The financial aspect of it can be controlled by the Council, because the income and the outgoings of the market, and all that, are matters that affect the yearly budget of the Council. In dealing with their yearly budget they can make arrangements that a certain income shall be required from these markets in order to meet whatever general expenses they have in connection with them, so that the Manager is not in the position that he can fix any price he likes for services such as these.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Is the Minister aware that the present prices charged in the cattle markets are about 300 per cent. over pre-war, and that there is a feeling outside that these prices are more than the trade can bear? The Council have no power whatever to alter that state of affairs.

Comment on this

I contend that they have. I contend that when they discuss their budget, when it is put up to them that a certain amount of income is going to come in from the markets and that the expenditure on them is going to be so much, that they can reduce the income from the markets if they want to.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

In other words, can they fix the prices?

Comment on this

They can fix the prices by fixing the amount of money that they will require to be got in from the markets, and by fixing the amount of money that they are going to provide, if necessary, to be spent on them. They have general control of the finances in that way. As regards the fixing of anything else in connection with them, that is a managerial matter, and just as in other matters the general policy of the Council can easily be put into operation, because, if necessary, on any particular point arising out of it the Council can apply the section that has been inserted in the Bill enabling it, after a particular class of notice has been given, to pass a resolution requiring the Manager to do a particular act even though it is not a reserved function. They have that safeguard.

Comment on this

The Minister has gone a long way to meet the views of the Dáil in relation to the powers of the Council, but I think he has succeeded in stopping short of doing anything effective in these matters. I want it to be made quite clear as to what powers the Council have exactly. It is true the Minister has told us the Council have control of the rates and control of decision on big matters of policy, but that is a purely negative form of control which does not give them an effective right to decide questions which are undoubtedly questions of policy, and which ought to be decided by the elected representatives of the people. Examples have been given by Deputy Byrne. He mentioned the building of self-contained flats as against the building of houses in the form in which they have been built in recent years. The Minister said the Council can decide on the building of self-contained flats if they wish by refusing to vote money for anything else. Is that the only power the Council have in the Bill as it stands?

Comment on this

No. If the Council required the Manager to carry out a particular scheme and he declined to do so he can be sacked.

Comment on this

Will the Minister accept an amendment I have on that particular matter that enables the Council to sack him?

Comment on this

I am personally not going to take the Minister out of the picture when the Manager is to be sacked.

Comment on this

The Minister said the Council can sack the Manager, but in fact they cannot. The Council can require the Manager to prepare estimates of the cost of schemes. If they decide on an undertaking they can, under Section 67, order the Manager to proceed with execution of any such scheme after estimates and plans have been prepared under Section 55, and for which they are prepared to vote money.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy mean that the Council can order him to proceed with such a scheme under the circumstances?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

In other words, if the Council want a block of flats erected in the centre of the city they can order the Manager to prepare plans, and under Section 57 to proceed with the execution of the plans?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

That seems to meet the point mentioned by Deputy Byrne in respect of Section 35. If I thought the Council had only negative power to refuse to vote money for certain purposes I would not be satisfied, but as they can decide that definite schemes can be undertaken it is a big improvement on the Bill as introduced. The Minister on the matter of contracts has gone a long way to meet the views of the Dáil, but he has again stopped short of doing what the Dáil wants him to do. The provision in Section 51 that the Council can determine the manner in which tenders are to be received and examined will in practice prevent the Manager from doing anything which would be seriously detrimental to the interests of the ratepayers, or carrying out any operation which might be described as corrupt, because the mere fact that the Council will have the opportunity of knowing the tenders which were submitted for the execution of any particular work will act as an effective safeguard over the Manager when he comes to decide which particular firm is to get a contract. The Bill as originally introduced gave the Manager, if he so choose, the power to receive tenders in secret and to award contracts in secret, which was an undesirable arrangement. Section 51 is a considerable improvement, but it does not meet the point Deputy Byrne was trying to provide for in amendment 38, which deals with one of the matters of policy which the Council should decide.

The actual awarding of the contract and the supervision of its execution are functions to be exercised by the Manager, but the Council should have the right to decide what preferences, if any, are to be given when contracts are under consideration, such as preference to local traders for the supply of goods, preference to Irish manufacturers for the supply of articles needed, and preferences of a kind such, for example, as are given in Northern Ireland to local firms in all contract work. As the Minister is aware from certain matters that arose quite recently, the Northern Ministry have instructed the local government bodies in the six counties to give a preference to Six-county firms, and have asked that if they cannot get a Six-county firm to do the work that they should get it done by a British firm rather than have it done by Free State firm. If the Council decide to give a preference to Dublin firms, or to Twenty-six county firms as against Six-county firms, they should be empowered to do so. Under the Bill as it stands, a decision of that kind will be taken by the Manager and not by the Council. These are obviously matters of policy into which the Manager should not be allowed to enter, if he is to be, as the Minister asserts he wants him to be, a purely executive officer to carry out policy decided by the elected representatives of the people. The wording of a section providing that the Council would have that power reserved to it would not be easy, but it certainly would not be impossible, and if the Minister is anxious to ensure that that matter, which is a matter of policy purely, will be reserved to the Council he could get it done. It has nothing whatever to do with the ability of the firms to carry out the contracts for which they have tendered, or matters of that kind, in which the Manager shall have the greatest say.

I take it that in deciding the sites and form of public buildings, and structures of that kind, the Council have power under Section 57 to arrive at decisions even if no such projects are in the mind of the Manager. The Minister when speaking on the matter seemed to indicate that the Council could only decide when an actual project was in contemplation by the Manager, that they could reject his plans and order him to substitute others. I take it that under Section 57 the Council can decide something the Manager had not thought of, and order him to prepare plans and execute them, when they are prepared to provide the money. Am I correct in that?

Comment on this

Yes. Sub-section (1) says quite clearly "Any particular act, matter or thing specifically mentioned."

Comment on this

The only matter that seems to require amendment in the Bill arising out of the amendments in Deputy Byrne's name is that in relation to the giving of preferences in the awarding of contracts. I do not see how the Minister can possibly argue that is a matter of administration. It is obviously a matter of policy and should be reserved to the Council.

Comment on this

I have said what I think of these two amendments. We have a provision in the Bill by which the Council in the actual carrying out of its business, and coming up against problems which Deputies say are involved in these matters, can make proposals to the Minister, and a Ministerial order can be issued giving them further reserved functions in specifically defined terms to deal with whatever they think additional is required to be reserved to them in respect of these matters. We therefore provide an amendment that instead of requiring a two-thirds majority of the Council to look for an order giving increased reserved functions we make it clear that a clear majority of the council can do that. If we have any confidence at all in the Council standing seriously over its business, accepting the idea of the City Manager and helping to administer the city on sound lines, I think we cannot say that there is any particular problem to be solved in this that they will not direct their minds to and see what best can be done and what ought to be done if reserved functions are necessary. I think the matter is not one that can most satisfactorily be settled here, but that it must work out in actual practice.

Comment on this

Would not the Minister put into Section 51 a provision that not merely should the Council have power to make regulations concerning the reception and examination of tenders but also the awarding of contracts, knowing as he does that under sub-section (2) of that section regulations cannot come into operation until he approves of them? That would enable him to limit the regulations in regard to contracts to the particular matters to which I referred.

Comment on this

I can imagine that that may require to be done in the handling of tenders when they come in, but I cannot imagine what is in the Deputy's mind with regard to the regulations for the acceptance of tenders. After all, when the tenders are brought to the final stage of handling a contract has to be entered into.

Comment on this

I mean that the Manager should be empowered to give, say, a five per cent. preference for goods of Irish manufacture. That is the class of regulation I have in mind.

Comment on this

The Manager will have that power. Deputies may say that he ought not to have it.

Comment on this

The point is as to what exactly is the power the Manager will have. Should not the Council have power to fix the preference, to say that it should not exceed ten per cent. or twenty per cent. or a hundred per cent.?

Comment on this

I want the Council to stand over their own work, to say whether they want any power like that. They have machinery for approaching the Minister if they want to do anything like that.

Comment on this

That is only putting it on the long finger.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 24, line 44, to add at the end of Section 50 (1) the following paragraph:—

"except where otherwise provided by law, the making of general regulations concerning the appointment, promotion and removal of officers and servants of the Corporation (not including the City Manager) and fix the maximum rates of remuneration to be paid to such officers and servants."

This is an amendment which I will not argue at length, because we have already argued it on the Cork City Bill. By it I seek to give the Council power to decide the general regulations that shall apply in the appointment, promotion and removal of officers and servants of the Corporation, and to fix the maximum and the minimum rates of remuneration to be paid to such officers and servants. It seems to me that it is obviously a matter of policy, and, therefore, a matter to be decided by the Council, as to what procedure shall be adopted in recruiting the staff of the Corporation and as to the scales of salaries which the staff shall be entitled to receive. I do not propose, nor do I think it right, that the Council should interfere with the Manager in relation to individuals, should say that A. B. is to be paid so much, that C. is to be promoted and D. sacked, or anything of that kind; but the Council should have the right to decide such questions as to whether or not clerical positions are to be filled by competitive examination, whether or not seniority is to apply in the promotion of officers, to fix scales of salaries that shall apply to particular servants, the minimum and the maximum rates of salary, and things of that kind. They are not points of administration; they are not matters that a board of directors of a company would entrust to the general manager. I suggest that a board of directors would insist on deciding such questions for themselves, and in our opinion the Council should also have power to decide such questions for itself. However, I do not think that there is much prospect of moving the Minister in the matter, so I have merely stated the case again. Perhaps we shall be able at some date to get the Council to demand that this power shall be given them.

Comment on this

There is just one point that struck me when listening to Deputy Lemass, and that was with regard to the appointment of the officers of the Council. I remember when the Greater Dublin Commission was sitting that there was a general feeling that there should be appointments by public examination.

Comment on this

In fact, that is the practice.

Comment on this

Can the Minister ensure that in the Bill? It is a very delicate question as to who will supervise the staff with regard to the question of promotion. If you are to make the Manager responsible I am afraid you must give him the necessary powers.

Comment on this

I do not object to that.

Comment on this

I think it would be better not to give them to the Manager.

Comment on this

On the question of appointments there is a very longstanding tradition that clerical appointments should be made as a result of a public examination. As far as technical appointments are concerned, there will be the Local Appointments Commission. I appreciate Deputy Lemass's appreciation of my attitude with regard to this amendment. We cannot accept this amendment, but we want to make it clear to the Deputy that the position of the staff and their general conditions are not in the completely exposed position to the Manager's will and whim that he suggests, because the Minister has very wide control over the general conditions of service of officers of local bodies, over their pay, over their superannuation, and over their dismissal, so that you have growing up quite a code of law administered by the Minister that will protect the staff against the whim of the Manager, and the Manager will not simply be a person who is given full control over the general conditions of employees.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 24, line 44, to add at the end of Section 50 (1) the following paragraph:—

"the making of decisions relating to the initiation or defence of any action or other legal proceedings, whether civil or criminal, in any court of law or equity other than prosecutions under any Act for the time being in force for the protection of public health."

This amendment is also designed to reserve to the Council decisions on matters which are obviously matters of policy—the initiation or defence of any action or other legal proceedings, except ordinary routine actions arising under the Public Health Acts and things of that kind. It might easily happen that a City Manager with a taste for litigation will be appointed at some time, and he could perhaps put the Council into such a position that they would have a considerable bill of costs to meet at the end of the year as the result of legal proceedings unwisely entered into. The Council should have some power of check over a Manager of that kind. It might be necessary to have some financial limit under which the Manager would have a free hand to take action if he thought fit, but over which the Council would have to be consulted before proceedings could be started or an action defended. I think it would be unwise to leave it absolutely to the discretion of the Manager to decide whether or not legal proceedings should be initiated or whether or not any action should be defended. In many cases it can easily be imagined that big matters of policy might arise, and the Council would be put in a very invidious position if, in its name, the Manager could proceed to take action without consulting them.

Comment on this

What kind of matters of policy? The position is that we are giving certain duties to the Council, and certain duties to the Manager, and the law is certainly the implement both of the Council in respect of their duties, and of the Manager in respect of his duties, to enable them in the ultimate to carry out their responsibilities. You cannot put a Manager in this very responsible position and then say: "You can have all the weapons in the armoury but you cannot have the law." It may be a case of noncompliance with a contract, or nonpayment of rates, but I think the Manager's armoury for carrying out his work generally would be very prejudiced if, in any particular case, before he went to law, he had to make an exposure of the whole facts to the Council in public, as he would naturally have to do, if he had to get the Council's approval to go ahead with the action.

Comment on this

Would not that apply in the case of a county council at present?

Comment on this

The county council is responsible, and does its work in its own way. I do not know if county councils go in for much litigation. I know that many things are threshed out in public at county council meetings that certainly do not improve the county council case, or do not improve anything for that matter. On the ground that the Manager is going to be free and effective he must know that he can, in an untrammelled way, bring the law into motion as part of his machinery for getting things done. Even in the interests of the Council, where the Council would agree that the law ought to be invoked, they might easily have their position prejudiced by having a public discussion of the lines upon which a dispute arises. That would furnish their opponents in law with a very considerable amount of material which it might be undesirable to furnish. I would ask Deputies to realise that if you give the Manager certain responsibilities he must have free access to the law. If the Manager is given to litigation, as well as spending his time at it and spending public money, that is a flaw in his general management, and the Council has machinery to point out the flaw, and if it cannot be eradicated in one way it can be eradicated in another.

Comment on this

I would like to distinguish between the two classes of prosecutions. There is the ordinary prosecution for selling adulterated milk, not paying rates, or routine prosecutions which the council should not have before them, and which the Manager could deal with as part of his duties. I was trying to think of a type of case that the Council should be consulted about, and the best example that came to mind was that in which the Dublin Union Commissioners were recently engaged, concerning the question of due relief of destitute poor people. In that case it was obviously a big matter of policy, and not a matter of administration that was involved, and if there had been an elected body in charge of the Dublin Union at the time, it would undoubtedly have been entitled to be consulted.

Comment on this

How does the Manager come into a case like that?

Comment on this

Under the Bill as it stands the Manager is the only person entitled to come in.

Comment on this

No. If anybody is going to be prosecuted for not giving due relief it would be the body dealing with the poor law.

Comment on this

I am not saying that this is identical of the type of case that would arise, but I think it is analogous. It might easily happen that a case would arise which the Council as a matter of policy would not defend, or that the Manager might embark on proceedings which the Council from the point of view of policy would not embark upon. In other words, the Council might be put in a position which, if left to their own discretion, they would not get into. There should be some provision by which the Manager would consult the Council at least before initiating proceedings in matters involving large sums of money, or in matters of public policy. The difficulty which the Minister mentioned—that the merits of the Council's case might have to be discussed in public before an action was commenced—applies to every other elected body in the country, except Cork Corporation, and I do not think it has proved to be altogether insurmountable in the past. But if, in the Minister's mind, there is an insurmountable difficulty, it can be got over by giving the Council power to make regulations providing that under certain circumstances a committee of the Council or the Lord Mayor or the Lord Mayor and the Aldermen should be consulted by the Manager before legal proceedings of that kind were initiated or defended.

Comment on this