We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Business. - Local Government (Dublin) Bill, 1929—Recommitted.

Contributions 324–473 of 473. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Local Government (Dublin) Bill, 1929
Enacted

No. 51 of 1929 ›

Is not Deputy Lemass assuming that the Manager is going to be a crank?

Comment on this

He might be. I do not say that Mr. Sherlock is.

Comment on this

I do not think such a Manager as the Deputy refers to would be kept. We must assume that we are going to be lucky and get the right man, and we must give him the right power and not tie his hands. I hope no Manager is going to indulge in a frantic orgy of litigation.

Comment on this

Surely there is nothing unreasonable in what Deputy Lemass asks. I think Deputy Lemass was not concerned about petty prosecutions for adulterated milk or matters of that kind, but about cases in which the Manager was inclined to involve the Council in large law costs. Surely there is something wrong there. If he is a Manager at all he is Manager for the Council. The Minister talks of the position of the council being prejudiced by public discussion. One could understand that if it was a public meeting, but surely any council knowing their business would not discuss a big law case in public, as they would have certain committees which would go into the matter. That is what happens. Even a municipal council would not attempt to discuss matters like that in public. There are committees for doing that work.

Comment on this

Discuss what?

Comment on this

Cases.

Comment on this

About what subjects?

Comment on this

There may be litigation with contractors, or things of that kind.

Comment on this

We are only theorising about it. If in the working out of things the Council require control over certain classes of litigation they can apply for reserved functions in respect of that.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 44, Section 50 (4), line 59, to delete the words "two-thirds" and substitute the words "one-half."

If the House would agree I would amend this amendment so as to make the section read, "for the passing of which more than one half of the members of the Council voted." That would mean, if the House is agreeable, instead of "not less than" we insert "more than" and instead of "two-thirds" we say "one-half."

Comment on this

I move:—In page 24, Section 50 (4), line 62, to delete the words "Town Clerk" and substitute the word "Manager." This is consequential on the abolition of the office of Town Clerk.

Comment on this

I move: In page 25, Section 52 (3), to delete all words after the word "Council" line 43 to the end of the sub-section. Sub-section (3) of Section 52 which deals with the appointment of the Manager says: "On and after the appointed day the appointment of a person to be a Manager shall be made by the Council and the office of Manager shall be an office to which the Local Authorities (Officers and Employees) Act, 1926 applies." I am against that section because it is a cod. It is so much camouflage, designed to deceive the public as to who has the appointment of Manager. If the office of Manager is an office to which the Local Authorities (Officers and Employees) Act, 1926, applies the appointment will be made by the Appointments Commissioners and not by the Council. It is only humbugging the Dáil and the Council to say that the appointment shall be made by the Council. I dislike humbug and that is why I propose this amendment. I think that the position of Manager can be filled just as well by the Council as by the Appointments Commissioners. The Commissioners may be useful in deciding between the relative claims of applicants for technical positions, but I dispute the contention that the position of City Manager is a technical one. It does not require technical training. It requires an amount of experience in general municipal affairs and an amount of general ability. The Council will probably be as good, if not better, than the Appointments Commissioners in picking out a man of ability. Judging by some of the appointments made by the Commissioners they could not have been worse.

Comment on this

It is not proposed to take the appointment of the Manager outside the scope of the Local Appointments Commissioners. If they are entrusted with the work of the selection of officers of local bodies throughout the country they can be entrusted with the work of selecting managers.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 55, Section 52 (5), lines 48 and 49, to delete the words "removed without the sanction of the Minister and shall not be."

Sub-section (5) provides that the Manager shall not be removed without the sanction of the Minister, and shall not be either suspended or removed by the Council except by two-thirds majority. The Minister told us some time ago that if the Manager did not do what the Council wanted in certain matters the Council could remove him. This sub-section, however, shows that the Minister was somewhat inaccurate. The Council cannot remove him. It can only recommend his removal. My amendment proposes to give effective control to the Council over the Manager. If they find that he is not doing his work, that he is making a mess of the job, and is refusing to carry out lawful orders, they should have the right to remove or suspend him. Power is given under the Bill provided the Council can muster two-thirds of a majority in favour of the suspension or removal of the Manager that suspension or removal should be effective without taking the Minister into consultation. I am inclined to think that the Minister for Local Government, especially the present Minister, will automatically side with the Manager, notwithstanding the merits of a dispute. That is why I think the inclusion of these words in the sub-section as it stands will mean that the Council will not be able to dismiss the Manager unless the Minister desires that he should go. That is not a satisfactory arrangement. It will be no easy matter to get two-thirds of the Council to recommend that the Manager be removed. It will not be possible unless there is grave reason for removing him. The fact that a two-thirds majority is against him should be taken as prima facie proof that there is grave reason for his removal, and his removal should be automatic.

Comment on this

Naturally very serious consideration would be given and it would require the Minister to make a very strong case to explain why he did not remove the Manager if two-thirds of the Council voted for his removal. It is the general administrative, statutory policy of the Department that an officer cannot be removed without the consent of the Minister. There are no adequate reasons for taking the Minister out of the picture in the case of the Manager. I do not think that Deputies should lightly run away with the idea that the Minister will very likely stand for the administration of a Manager where two-thirds of the Council consider that he is not fitted for the position.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 25, Section 52 (6), line 57, to delete the word "Minister" and substitute the words "Council with the approval of the Minister."

Sub-section (6) provides that the Manager shall be paid a salary which the Minister decides on. I do not think that it is asking too much to give the Council at least power, subject to the sanction of the Minister, to say what salary the Manager shall get. If he is to be the officer of the Council and not of the Minister, the Council should have the right to fix his remuneration. There might be a possibility that while under certain circumstances the Council might be unable to remove the Manager by a majority of two-thirds, they might by a majority vote force his resignation by refusing to pay his salary; but the inclusion of the words "with the approval of the Minister" makes that impossible because, unless the Minister approves of the salary which the Council proposes to fix, that salary cannot come into operation. It is only a shadow of power which the amendment seeks to give the Council, but even though it is only a shadow, let the Council have it. To set up a body presumed to be in charge of the City of Dublin and to take from it power to decide the salary of its chief executive officer is, in my opinion, a very foolish proceeding. The amendment is only a minor one, but I ask the Minister to accept it, seeing that the effective power of decision is left in his hands.

Comment on this

When we were discussing the previous stage, the House agreed that the experience of the Department was such that it was in the best position to judge what the salary of the person who gets this position should be. I do not think there is any reason for bringing in between the relations of the Council and the Manager the fact that the Council should fix the Manager's remuneration. It is unnecessary that it should be done. There have already been cases in which there have been serious disputes arising for one reason or another between the local body and the Minister in regard to the remuneration that should be paid to a responsible officer. Under the provisions of this Bill no such dispute is likely to arise, as a reasonable salary will be fixed. It will be fixed by the Minister who, in respect of many other officers, has power to over-ride the local authority.

Comment on this

I agree that the Local Government Department ought to have the over-riding authority the Minister speaks of, and ought to be in a position to rectify an injustice, as we do know that there are public boards, especially in the case of highly-educated and highly-experienced men, professional men, that sometimes are not anxious to pay a reasonable salary to these officers. That happened in one or two cases to my own knowledge that came under my notice in the last twelve months, but I do not think that would apply to a body like the Municipal Council of Dublin. As far as I know, the practice usually has been that they were inclined to be over-generous in the past, but even then I have known one or two cases where the generosity of the Council towards its officials—in the opinion of some of us, they were too generous—did not satisfy the Local Government Department. That was in the old days. I have known cases in which a salary of £1,700 or £1,800 was not thought sufficient for the office of town clerk, and the Local Government Department afterwards made it £2,000. Departments and their officials do not change very much. The tradition is carried on, and what happened then may happen again. The outlook of officials in regard to salaries is often very different to the outlook of public representatives. Apart from that, and recognising that the Department must have that authority to rectify abuses or injustices—I think that is right and proper—I do think it is a gross derogation of the dignity of a body like the Municipal Council of Dublin that it should not have power to decide what its own officials should have in the way of salary. I think that it is an unworthy suggestion to a body of that kind. There is no limited company or corporate body that I know of in the City of Dublin which would tolerate a position of that kind in regard to its own senior officials.

I remember when the representative of the Chamber of Commerce, who gave evidence before the Greater Dublin Commission—I have referred to this before—was questioned on the matter of the appointment, the control and, I think, the salary of the City Manager, that he declared definitely that the authority even for the selection of the Manager should lie with the Municipal Council. That is my recollection, and I think that, seeing the nature of the body, the least the Minister ought to do would be to accept this moderate amendment of Deputy Lemass. Taking the history of the Municipal Council as we know it, and of the councils that will now form part of the Greater Dublin Municipal Council, I think in general there has rarely been an instance in which it could be said that an inadequate salary was paid to a senior official. In case they were inclined to be too generous, which, I think, is unlikely, to this officer, the Minister could step in and rectify what he might think was an injustice either to the ratepayers or to the individual concerned. I think that the Minister's control is preserved by the wording of the amendment, and that he has all the power that is necessary, but that it is at least due to the dignity of the Municipal Council, if they are not to be allowed to select their own official, that they should be allowed to say what the salary attaching to the office may be.

Comment on this

I am entirely unmoved.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 26, Section 53 (1), lines 6 and 7, to delete the words "the Lord Mayor or Mayor of the Council (as the case may require)" and substitute the words "every member of the Council."

Comment on this

I accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 26, Section 53 (2), lines 12 and 13, to delete the words "The Lord Mayor or Mayor (as the case may be)" and substitute the words "every member of the Council."

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 26, Section 56, line 35, to insert in brackets after the word "discussion" the words "(other than discussions relating to the election of a member to be Lord Mayor)."

We are prepared to give the Manager certain wide powers to ensure that the work of the Dublin Corporation will be effectively carried out, but we do not think that these powers should necessarily include the right to criticise the person nominated for Lord Mayor. The purpose of the amendment is to compel the Manager to be silent when the election of Lord Mayor is under discussion at the Council. I do not think that is unreasonable.

Comment on this

Under the arrangement by which the Town Clerk becomes Manager, he will take the Chair at the first meeting until the Lord Mayor is elected and he will have to discharge certain functions. I do suggest that it is unnecessary to put in an amendment which practically says that the Manager shall not criticise, in presiding at the first election and only at the first election—that he shall by statute be prevented from saying what he thinks about the candidates for Lord Mayor.

Comment on this

It is not only at the first election. I agree that at the first election he should be allowed to speak—not necessarily to say what he thinks about the persons proposed for Lord Mayor, but allowed to speak. At subsequent elections of Lord Mayor, however, the outgoing Mayor would occupy the Chair and the Manager would be present and as the Bill stands would be entitled to stand up and criticise the individual who held office for the previous twelve months; to say that he found him an objectionable person to work with or that he had other faults which members of the Council might not have been aware of, or something of that kind. It would be obviously undesirable that the Manager should have that right. Whatever he might say at ordinary meetings of the Council, when normal routine business was under consideration, he should, I think, not say anything when the question of a Lord Mayor is under discussion by the Council. It only happens once a year; he can talk for the rest of the year provided he keeps silent for the five or six minutes the Council would be meeting to elect one of its members as Lord Mayor.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this

I move amendment 51:

In page 26, to add at the end of Section 56 a new sub-section as follows:—

(2) The Manager shall attend any meeting of the Council or of any committee of the Council at which he is requested by the Council to attend, and shall at such meeting give to the Council or such committee (as the case may be) such advice and assistance as shall reasonably be required of him by the Council or such committee, and for that purpose the Manager shall arrange for the attendance at such meeting of such of the officers of the Corporation as may be necessary, having regard to the business to be transacted at such meeting.

Comment on this

I move amendment 52, which is an amendment to amendment 51:

To delete in the proposed new sub-section all words after the word "Corporation" to the end of the sub-section and substitute the words "as the Council may consider necessary having regard to the business to be transacted at such meeting."

There is nothing in the Minister's amendment to indicate who shall decide whether it is or is not necessary that a particular official shall be present at a council meeting, Irrespective of whether my amendment is accepted or not, some amendment of the Minister's amendment is required, because it is undesirable that the matter should be left in the ambiguous state in which the Minister's amendment leaves it. It is obvious that it is the Council must decide in this matter. The attendance of the officials will be required because the Council wants them to be present and therefore it is the Council which should decide on the necessity of their being there and not the Manager. This is another reasonable amendment which I hope the Minister will accept.

Comment on this

I am opposed to the amendment to my amendment for the reason that I am not prepared to accept anything that would put the temptation before the Council to specify unnecessarily individual members of the staff whom they wanted to have at their council meetings. I submit that my amendment is quite adequate to do everything that may be required by the Council. It leaves the selection of the officers in the hands of the Manager, but the purpose of the Council is the purpose that is to be served, and if sufficient officers are not produced by the Manager to give the advice and the assistance that the council requires the Council will be dissatisfied and will want further advice and assistance, and I submit, therefore, that it is a reasonable amendment. But it must be the complete responsibility of the Manager to deal with his staff, and if the Council were in the position that they could nominate, for one reason or another, certain officials whom they wanted to see, I consider it would be an inadvisable position in which to put the staff, the Manager and the Council. We put on the Manager full responsibility for providing the information, and advice that the Council may want, and for that purpose providing whatever officials may be necessary.

Amendment to amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this

I move amendment 53:—

In page 27, Section 57 (4), line 4, after the word "exceeds" to insert the word "either," and in line 5, after the word "Council" to insert the words "or two-thirds of the members present and voting."

Section 57 provides that after certain procedure the Council may instruct the Manager to do a particular act, matter or thing, which normally would be the Manager's own proper function. I agreed to introduce an amendment which would make it clear that either one-half of the total Council or two-thirds of the members present could call upon the Manager to do that act, matter or thing.

Comment on this

On the section, I should like to draw attention to the words "as soon as possible" in sub-section (3). Would it not be advisable to put in something more definite there; to put in seven days, or three or four days, or whatever time the Minister thinks would be necessary? I think it would be better to have some definite phraseology rather than to leave it vague by inserting "as soon as possible." It might lead to members of the Corporation at some time or another feeling that they were not being fairly treated. If the Minister would put in some definite number of days it would be more effective.

Comment on this

"As soon as possible" here means immediately, and sub-section (2) provides that the meeting shall be held on a particular date; that is, the Manager cannot prevent the meeting being held at an early date, and I think the Manager would not do anything that would put the Council in the position of having a grievance against him. I shall look into the point which the Deputy makes and, if necessary, we can change it.

Comment on this

I have in mind something that happened in days gone by when the Town Clerk used whatever discretion he had to suit himself or certain interests in the Council at different times. It might happen in future. I do not think it would happen with the gentleman now suggested as Manager, but we are not legislating for individuals, but for the future, and we do not know who may occupy this office later. Having that in mind, I think it would be better to make that more definite.

Comment on this

I move amendment 58:—

In page 28, Section 60 (1), line 24, to insert after the word "him" the words "and countersigned by the City Accountant or the Borough Accountant (as the case may require)," and in sub-section (4), page 28, line 47, to delete the words "of the Manager" and substitute the words "and counter-signature mentioned in that sub-section."

This amendment is necessary in order to provide some countersignature. Now that the office of Town Clerk is abolished, it is proposed that there shall be a countersignature by the City Accountant or the Borough Accountant, as the case may be.

Comment on this

I move amendment 59:—

In page 29, Section 61, before sub-section (6), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(6) No part of the municipal fund or of any money under the control of the Corporation shall be applied for any purpose not authorised by this or any other Act or, in the case of money derived from trust funds, by the trusts affecting those funds."

There is a general provision of this kind in the statutes dealing with the handling of county council funds, and it is thought well to put in this amendment into this section so that the complete law dealing with the municipal fund will be embodied in the present Bill.

Comment on this

I move amendment 60:—

In page 29, Section 62 (3), lines 39-41 inclusive, to delete the words "and to the time within which payments may be made directly or indirectly out of the poor rate," and to delete all words after the word "Corporation," line 43, to the end of the sub-section, and before sub-section (4) to insert a new sub-section as follows:— (4) Sub-section (7) of Section 51 of the Local Government (Ireland) Act, 1898, shall not apply or have effect in relation to any debt, claim, or demand which is directly or indirectly payable out of the municipal rate.

Section 51 (7) of the Local Government (Ireland) Act, 1898, provides that payment out of the poor rate shall be made inside the six months in which it becomes due, or inside three months after that. It provides that if the payment is not made the sanction of the Minister for Local Government will be required for the making of the payment, and then the period can be extended for two years. This only applies to the poor rate and not to the ordinary municipal rate. After full discussion with the Corporation authorities we decided to remove this restriction, which would require payment within the particular time. There is adequate safeguard that the debts of the Corporation will be suitably paid, and paid in good time, and the restriction in this particular section is not required.

Comment on this

I move amendment 61:—

In page 29, before Section 63, to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) Where a tenement or hereditament situate in the city or the borough is held (whether together with or without other premises) under a lease which binds the lessor to pay or allow a deduction or set off against or indemnify the lessee against or otherwise to relieve the lessee from any rates (other than poor rate) payable in respect of such tenement or hereditament, all rent payable under such leave in respect of a period commencing on or after the 1st day of April, 1931. shall be reduced—

(a) in the case of an annual rent, by an amount equal to the amount of the rates (other than poor rate) in respect of such tenement or hereditament for the local financial year commencing on the 1st day of April, 1930, to which the relief afforded to the lessee by such lease lawfully extended, and

(b) in the case of any rent other than an annual rent, by an amount which bears to the rates (other than poor rate) in respect of such tenement or hereditament for the local financial year commencing on the 1st day of April, 1930, to which the relief afforded to the lessee by such lease lawfully extended the same proportion as the period by reference to which such rent is calculated bears to one year.

(2) In this section the word "lease" includes any contract of tenancy, whether in writing or verbal, whereby the relation of landlord and tenant is created, and the words "lessor" and "lessee" respectively include the landlord of and the tenant under such tenancy.

Under Section 52 (2) of the Local Government (Ireland) Act, 1898, the landlord is prohibited from entering into a contract under which he would pay the poor rate for the occupier. But there is nothing to prevent the landlord entering into a contract by which he would pay the other rates. This amendment is necessary in order, now that the occupier will be responsible for the whole of the municipal rate, that where cases exist where there are leases under which the landlord pays the municipal rate there shall be an adjustment of rent because of the fact that the occupier is now made responsible not only for the poor rate but for what were the other municipal rates by reason of the fact that he now becomes responsible for the municipal rate as a whole.

Comment on this

How is this affected by the Act passed recently by which the landlord pays when the house is under a certain valuation?

Comment on this

That is the Small Dwellings Act. We apply the Small Dwellings Act in another amendment, but it does not arise in this section.

Comment on this

I move amendment 62.

In page 29, lines 50 to 54, to delete Section 63 and substitute a new section as follows:—

The provisions of this Part of this Act abolishing certain rates shall not extend or apply to charges (commonly called contract water rates) made for the supply of water to particular hereditaments or tenements for purposes other than domestic purposes or to the supply of water under special contract to any person not otherwise entitled to such supply, and such charges shall, in the construction of this Act, not be included in the expression "rates abolished by this Act."

This is a re-drafting of an amendment which came up on the Committee Stage.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister to explain this further. It seems to me as if it might bring in in a double way houses brought into the city under the Bill from the county. Houses at present in the county may be getting their water supply through contract, and it would appear that if they are brought into the city they would be liable for the full rate in the city. It would appear under this amendment they would also be liable for the water rate that they were paying for a special supply when not in the city, and thus the Corporation would be getting at them twice over.

Comment on this

A contract made say with the South Dublin Rural District Council was a contract for the supply of water to the council, which they disposed of in their own way for domestic purposes and otherwise. So far as that contract lasts it will remain with the county council in respect of the area that remains outside the new city. But hereditaments that are receiving water from either the North or South Rural District Councils for domestic purposes, and which, normally, pay a domestic water rate will be simply regarded as ordinary domestic water users under the City Council. The contracts referred to are special contracts. I take it that if 5/- or 10/- is paid for the use of the garden hose that is a contract that a person will still be liable for, but it does not in any way refer to water supplied for domestic purposes.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that that is what is covered by the new section? At present the householder in the county enters into a separate contract on his own behalf if he wishes to get a water supply from the Corporation. He enters into a contract not only for the special purpose of a garden hose, but also for domestic purposes. He makes a definite contract to that effect in each case.

Comment on this

With the Corporation?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I am advised that the situation is quite sound, but I shall have the matter further examined and, if necessary, make a change.

Comment on this

I move amendment 63:—

In page 30, lines 35 to 64, to delete Section 66 and substitute a new section as follows:—

(1) The following limitation shall have effect in respect of the assessment of a municipal rate to which this sub-section applies on a hereditament or tenement situate in either of the areas which at the passing of this Act constitutes an added urban district, that is to say, so much in the pound of any such rate as is raised for purposes other than the excepted purposes as hereinafter defined shall not exceed the total amount in the pound of so much of all rates (other than the police rate) assessed on the urban district in which such hereditament or tenement was situate for or in respect of the year beginning on the 1st day of April, 1929, as was raised for purposes other than defraying the expenses of performing the duties of a board of guardians.

(2) The following limitation shall have effect in respect of the assessment of a municipal rate to which this sub-section applies on a hereditament or tenement situate in the added rural area, that is to say, so much in the pound of any such rate as is raised for purposes other than the excepted purposes as hereinafter defined shall not exceed the total amount in the pound of so much of all rates (other than the police rate) assessed on hereditaments and tenements (other than agricultural land) in the townland in which such first-mentioned hereditament or tenement was situate for or in respect of the year beginning on the 1st day of April, 1929, as was raised for purposes other than defraying the expense of performing the duties of a board of guardians.

(3) The following limitation shall have effect in respect of the assessment of a municipal rate to which this sub-section applies on a hereditament or tenement situate in the area which at the passing of this Act constitutes the urban district of Killiney and Ballybrack, that is to say, so much in the pound of any such rate as is raised for purposes other than the excepted purposes as hereinafter defined shall not exceed the total amount in the pound of so much of all rates (other than the police rate) assessed on the said urban district for or in respect of the year beginning on the 1st day of April, 1929, as was raised for purposes other than defraying the expenses of performing the duties of a board of guardians.

(4) Sub-section (1) and (2) of this section shall apply to every municipal rate made in the city for or in respect of a year prior to the year beginning on the 1st day of April, 1936, and sub-section (3) of this section shall apply to every municipal rate made in the borough for or in respect of a year prior to the year beginning on the 1st day of April, 1936.

(5) The following purposes shall be excepted purposes within the meaning of this section, that is to say:—

(a) defraying the expenses of performing the duties formerly performed by a board of guardians;

(b) meeting a demand by the Dublin Port and Docks Board under section 27 of the Dublin Port and Docks (Bridges) Act, 1929 (No. 2 (Private) of 1929);

(c) defraying expenses incurred or meeting a demand made under any Act (other than this Act) passed by the Oireachtas after the 31st day of March, 1930, whether before or after the passing of this Act.

(6) Nothing in this section shall apply to a rate assessed on a hereditament or tenement mentioned in the Second Schedule to this Act.

This is merely a re-drafting of the section.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 64 in the name of Deputy Lemass.

In sub-section (4) of the proposed new section to delete the figures "1936" wherever they occur and substitute the figures "1932."

It is an amendment to Amendment 63 which the Minister has moved, and its object is to alter the figures 1936 and to substitute the figures 1932. It appears to us that there is no special reason why those bodies that are being brought within the bounds of the City of Dublin should be given the advantage that this proposes to give them. I do not understand why there should be a limit put to their rates when such a limit is not put to the rates of the other parts of the new city. There is no special reason for it. It is not intended evidently as an inducement to bring them in, because they are being brought in whether they like it or not. They are now practically within the city, or they will when this Bill is passed, and why this distinction should be made in their favour we cannot see. What reason is there for it? Neither is there any justice in this. As a matter of fact these bodies and the citizens in these and other places around the City of Dublin ought to have been charged their portion of the rates for the upkeep of the City of Dublin for many years. They have not borne their share, and the fact that they have not done so might seem to some people in the City of Dublin a reason for asking them to bear a greater burden now. That is a thing I would consider unjust, but they certainly ought to bear an equal charge with every citizen in Dublin under the new boundary arrangement. I do not see any reason whatsoever why the ratepayers in the old part of the city should not be allowed the privilage which it is proposed to give to these new areas.

Comment on this

On the broad basis I agree that there is not very great justice in stabilising these rates, if you look at the matter from the city point of view, in the areas that are being added to the city. The fact is that these areas have lower rates at present than the City of Dublin, and for a particular period it is desirable to avoid an immediate definite increase in the rates for these areas. The arrangements that have been made in connection with the new government of the city will bring about efficiencies and economies that will prevent any very serious jump of the rates on either Rathmines or Pembroke. It may not be very just in the case of areas that, according to public opinion and according to the general circumstances, should long since have been part of the city that they should now have their rates stabilised. Nevertheless the fact is their rates have been less than the city rates for some time past, and they are less than the city rates now. It has been the practice generally when new areas are added to the city to stabilise the rates for a particular period, and there does not seem to be any very strong reason for departing from that practice when bringing in Rathmines and Pembroke into the city area now. I feel rather justified in the proposal when I take into consideration how very little criticism there has been in regard to this proposal either from the city area or from the areas proposed to be added——

Comment on this

Criticism of this proposal or criticism of the amalgamation?

Comment on this

Criticism of the proposal in the Bill.

Comment on this

The proposal to limit?

Comment on this

The proposal to stabilise the rates on the new areas for five years.

Comment on this

There has not been very much opportunity to do that until now. If we had wished to deal with this principle on the Second Reading we would not have been allowed to deal with it. The closure would have been moved.

Comment on this

I am speaking of general public criticism. I was referring to criticism by the citizens of Dublin and the citizens of Pembroke and Rathmines.

Comment on this

Their eyes were fastened on the major defects in the Bill. The attempt to introduce this principle is a very damaging thing. The only justification for it is that the Bill is so unworkable that the economies hoped for will not be realised, and that, therefore, Pembroke and Rathmines being the new areas will not get what they had hoped for. I do not think that will be the case, and I believe that as a result of the inclusion these areas will share in the economies to be secured and they will benefit from them. I do not think that it is reasonable if they are to secure any benefit from the amalgamation that they should be absolved from bearing any of the burdens that the reorganisation of the city may, at the outset, entail. If the benefits are going to be shared mutually by the amalgamated city—that is, the old city and Pembroke and Rathmines— then I do not anticipate that there will be any increase in the rates. Nevertheless, in justice to the citizens of the existing city and to the citizens who will be brought in, I submit that Deputy Lemass' proposal should be accepted. It is an attempt to meet the Minister. In the very early stages, in the first couple of years, it is possible that there may be a slight increase in the rates, and we are prepared to concede something to Rathmines and Pembroke, but I certainly think that practically four years more than what Deputy Lemass suggests is much too long.

Comment on this

It is a concession for five years. As well as I can recollect, when the city was taking in other areas the rates were stabilised for ten years.

Comment on this

The bad old days.

Comment on this

Deputy Good would not say now if the city was taken in by those other areas?

Comment on this

If I start on that line I might say more than the Deputy would like to hear.

Comment on this

I would enjoy listening to Deputy Good's statement on it.

Comment on this

I know that Deputy O'Kelly had a long experience of the old Dublin Corporation, and I tell him that the sooner we forget all about it the better. One reason why there has been so little discussion on this matter, although there was opportunity, is that this particular section is evidence of reasonableness on the part of the Ministry and on the part of the Dublin Corporation. This section stabilises the rate in existence in 1929 for a period of five years. If the Deputy takes the average of the previous fifteen or twenty years of the rates in the two areas mentioned and the rates in the city he will find that the difference is a very marked one. I hope the difference will be much less in the future, but I am certainly not sufficient of an optimist to consider that the city rates will ever be down to what they are in Pembroke at the moment. I hope that, as this Bill has been more or less accepted on the basis of the assurance contained in this clause, the Minister will now be no party to going back on that assurance.

Comment on this

If there has been little talk about this particular section I think the reason is because the Pembroke and the Rathmines ratepayers felt that they were getting such a good bargain that the less they said about it the better. They would not raise a whisper of any kind about it in the Press or on the public platform.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Deputy must be out of touch with opinion in both Rathmines and Pembroke.

Comment on this

I am not very much out of touch with those areas. I live near enough, and I am a small ratepayer in one of the outlying areas. To some small extent I am affected by it. I see the point of view of the old city, and I think the Minister would have acted more justly if he had not made those provisions in regard to the areas now being taken in. I speak as a small ratepayer in one of the outlying areas, and I think it would be better if he had put an additional tax of some kind —not an inconsiderable tax—on Pembroke and Rathmines so as to help to make good the deficiency in relation to what they owe to the old city. If he had done that he would have been acting more justly to all concerned. Knowing, as I am sure they do know, and as Deputy Good knows, what they owe to the old city, the ratepayers of Rathmines and Pembroke have taken care that no one of their public men, and, indeed, nobody in the area, was so indiscreet as to call attention to this particular section in the Press or on the public platform. I think if the Minister puts Rathmines and Pembroke and the other sections that are now being joined to the old city on the same footing as the old city he will not be doing an injustice to Pembroke and Rathmines, and he will not be doing an injustice to the old city, but if he allows this proposal to go through he will certainly be doing a grave injustice to the old city.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Deputy's memory is not serving him truly on the present occasion when he speaks of what Rathmines and Pembroke owe to the City. I do not know if the Deputy is aware that there is in existence at the moment such a thing as a body dealing with the equalisation of rates. That body meets every ten years to adjust relations between the township and the city. At the moment under the Equalisation of Rates Act, Rathmines pays as its contribution to the city a sum of approximately £10,000 per annum.

Comment on this

Not half enough.

Comment on this

Pembroke pays £6,000 per annum. That is adjusted by an independent authority every ten years. In the face of that it is not quite correct to say that Rathmines and Pembroke have not paid their dues to the city in the past.

Comment on this

I ask the Minister not to accept this amendment. I am prepared to substantiate what Deputy Good has said. I am a member of the Pembroke Council and it is not quite correct for Deputy O'Kelly to say that the townships have made no protest because they are getting such a good bargain. I can assure him as a member of the Pembroke Council that the outlook there is, that if the people had their way they would prefer to be left alone. That has been the cry all the time. There were public meetings held in Rathmines Town Hall to protest against this Bill. I ask the Minister not to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

May I suggest that one of the Committee Rooms should be set at the disposal of the Dublin Deputies so that they can carry on their conversation in peace?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is a most disorderly suggestion.

Comment on this

We are nearly finished now.

Comment on this

I wish to goodness you were finished.

Amendment 64 put and negatived.

Comment on this

I move amendment 65:

In page 32, to add at the end of Section 60 two new sub-sections as follows:—

(2) When a rate is made by virtue of this section on the owner of an unoccupied hereditament or tenement and such hereditament or tenement is subsequently let by or on behalf of such owner and such rate or any part thereof is in arrear and unpaid, the rate collector by whom such rate is collectable may, in addition and without prejudice to any other remedy for the recovery of the amount of such rate so in arrear and unpaid, serve either personally or by post on the occupier of such hereditament or tenement a notice stating the said amount so in arrear and unpaid and requiring such occupier to pay to such rate collector or his successor in office all rent then due or thereafter to become due by him in respect of the said hereditament or tenement until the said amount is by such payment or otherwise discharged, and, upon such notice being so served, such rate collector or his successor in office shall have the exclusive right to recover, receive, and give a good discharged for all rent required by such notice to be paid to him.

(3) A rate made by virtue of this section on the owner of an unoccupied hereditament or tenement shall not be invalidated by any error or defect in the statement of the name of such owner or by the use of the description "the owner" without any name or addition, and every such rate shall be recoverable from such owner notwithstanding such error or defect or the use of such description.

This is designed to meet the case where the owner of an unoccupied tenement does not pay his rates and afterwards rents the tenement. It makes provision for the collection of the rates from the occupier.

Comment on this

I move amendment 66:—

In page 32, Section 70 (1), line 10, after the figures "1861" to insert the words and figures "as amended by Section 91 of the Dublin Corporation Act, 1890."

This is a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 67:—

In page 32 to delete Section 70 (2) and substitute a new sub-section as follows:—

(2) Any hereditament or tenement in the city which, in the opinion of the City Council, is suitable for use as a dwelling for and is occupied by an artisan or a labourer shall, if the City Council so resolves, be deemed to be a small dwelling within the meaning of the Local Government (Rates on Small Dwellings) Act, 1928 (No. 4 of 1928), and that Act shall apply to such hereditament or tenement accordingly, but subject to the modification that in relation to such hereditament or tenement Section 10 of the said Act shall have effect as if the expression "eight-tenths" were substituted for the expression "nine-tenths" in sub-section (1) of that section.

Section 75 of the Dublin Corporation Act of 1890 empowers the Corporation to compound with the owner of certain classes of cottages occupied by artisans by which, on the payment of their rates inside a particular period, they get a reduction of 20 per cent. The section as at present drafted would prevent the Corporation giving the same facilities to new houses in future. The amendment gets rid of that, and it also makes an arrangement by which the houses are regarded as small dwellings within the Small Dwellings Act. They will be entitled after agreement by the Corporation to the same reduction for prompt payment as is secured under the Dublin Corporation Act of 1890 for the other houses.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 68:—

In page 33, Section 74 (2), line 13. and also in sub-section (3), page 33, line 16, to delete the word "fourteen" and substitute the words "twenty-one."

This amendment provides for the statement of expenses, the annual budget, being in the hands of members of the council twenty-one days instead of fourteen days before the rates meeting so that more adequate time can be given for an examination of it.

Comment on this

I move amendment 69:—

In page 33, before Section 75, to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) Whenever the City Council or the Borough Council considers that it is expedient that any particular matter relating to the administration of the city or the administration of the borough or to the administration of both the city and the borough should be referred to and discussed by a committee (in this section referred to as a joint committee of reference) appointed under this section, such council may resolve that such matter shall be referred to such committee accordingly.

(2) A joint committee of reference shall consist of—

(a) such number (not exceeding three) of members of the City Council as shall be nominated for the purpose by that council, and

(b) such number (not exceeding three) of members of the Borough Council as shall be nominated for the purpose by that council.

(3) Whenever the City Council or the Borough Council resolves that a matter shall be referred to a joint committee of reference, the following things shall be done by the said councils respectively, that is to say:—

(a) the council by which such resolution was passed shall nominate such members of such committee as it is entitled and thinks fit to nominate, and

(b) the last-named council shall communicate such resolution and nomination to the other of the said councils, and

(c) such other council shall at the next meeting after such communication is received by it nominate such members of such committee as it is entitled and thinks fit to nominate.

(4) When the City Council or the Borough Council has resolved that a matter be referred to a joint committee of reference and the several things mentioned in the foregoing sub-section of this section have been done, such matter shall be deemed to have been duly referred to the joint committee of reference nominated in pursuance of that sub-section, and such committee shall, as soon as conveniently may be, meet and discuss such matter and report the result of such discussion to the said councils respectively.

(5) All meetings of a joint committee of reference shall be held in the City Hall or other convenient place to be provided by the City Manager.

(6) It shall be the duty of the City Manager to provide from amongst the officers of the City Corporation all such secretarial assistance as may be required by any joint committee of reference.

(7) The City Manager and the Borough Manager respectively shall, whenever so required by a joint committee of reference, attend the meetings of such committee, and each of the said Managers shall be entitled to attend meetings of a joint committee of reference (whether he has or has not been required by such committee so to do) and to take part in the discussions at such meetings.

(8) All expenses (other than the provision of a place of meeting and secretarial assistance) incurred by a joint committee of reference shall be defrayed in the first instance by the City Corporation, and shall subsequently be apportioned between the City Corporation and the Borough Corporation in proportion to the rateable valuation of the city and the borough respectively, and so much of such expenses as is so apportioned to the Borough Corporation shall be paid by that Corporation to the City Corporation on demand.

This amendment is my contribution to that particular type of suggestion that says that there are matters of common interest between the city and the borough. It makes provision by which the council, either of the city or the borough, having come to the conclusion that a particular matter is a matter of common interest and ought to be discussed by the council of the city and borough, by the passage of a resolution can automatically bring about a situation by which an ad hoc committee would be set up, consisting of three members of the City Council and three members of the Borough Council, to report on the matter referred to them for consideration. It makes arrangements by which the expense of that particular committee will be borne and by which the secretarial work could be arranged for and premises provided.

Comment on this

I am well satisfield with the form in which the Minister has drafted this section. I quite approve of it.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

There are two points of objection to this proposal. I think it does not go far enough. I do not see why it should be an ad hoc committee. I think there are very good grounds for having something in the nature of a permanent committee and I think it should not be confined to the borough and the City Council. I think there is a good argument in favour of taking in the county council and the Howth Urban Council as it will be. I had amendments down—I must congratulate Deputy Lemass for taking them and putting them down in his name—about the joint services board on the last occasion.

Comment on this

I think he only put them down after consultation with one of your members who told him he understood that you did not intend to put them down.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I did not hear anything about it. In any case it does not matter. So long as they are there it is all right. But the same idea which Deputy Lemass had was down for the Committee Stage. Now, as I say, the northern borough has disappeared but we have Howth Urban Council and the county council. It was plain from the discussion that took place here to-day that especially on the northern coastal area there will be matters of joint concern as between the Howth Urban Council, and the county council possibly and the city and the borough, new developments for instance in the Portmarnock area. Those would be matters that it would be well should be considered by a joint body of this kind. Therefore I think the county council and the Howth Urban Council might be taken in on this joint committee.

The second point I wish to suggest is that the body ought to be a permanent body set up under the Act not simply an ad hoc committee set up more or less haphazard when any matter would arise which would call for joint consideration. It should be a permanent joint committee to be set up at the beginning of the life of each of the councils. Such a body would take a wider interest in the affairs and there would be more co-ordination with the work they might do on this occasion and the work they would do on a future occasion. There would be more thought and more time to have a settled policy in their joint action than if a committee were set up to do one thing to-day and possibly a different committee set up to do something else another day. There would be no continuity of policy in the joint body and I think continuity of policy would be justified. I suggest to the Minister that these two points should be met in his proposals. He does go some distance to have joint action but I think if he amended his proposals in the way I suggest it would be more advantageous than the proposal he has here.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Can we not discuss amendment No. 70 (a) and amendment 70 (b)?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I think they are all the same.

Comment on this

70 is different from 70 (a) and 70 (b).

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This is an amendment to amendment 69.

Comment on this

Let us deal with 69 alone.

Comment on this

This amendment the Minister has drafted goes a long way to meet the objections I voiced on the Second Reading. I am sorry that I differ from Deputy O'Connell. I really think that a committee ad hoc is more likely to have results than a permanent committee. A permanent committee with no object is likely to become a dead letter. A committee ad hoc with a definite purpose is very likely to be carefully set up to answer a definite demand from one or the other, and we would be more likely to get good fruit from the work of such a committee.

There is one thing Deputy O'Connell suggested which seems to be very attractive, and that is if we can bring in in some way the Howth Urban Council. I foresee that there will be a conflict of interests in that direction. There is a rather remarkable development on the North side. I think perhaps the Minister might consider that suggestion of Deputy O'Connell. It certainly seems an attractive and a wise one to me.

Comment on this

Would not the county council also be interested, as it surrounds all those districts? Apart from that—if I, as a rank outsider, may be allowed to refer to a Dublin Bill at all; I thought it was a special preserve from all the discussion I heard—if one body nominates will the other be compelled to nominate? Suppose a matter does arise which is really of importance to both, and that the Borough Council nominates a committee and the City Council refuses, what happens then?

Comment on this

Nothing in the world can happen.

Comment on this

The matter will not receive any joint consideration then.

Comment on this

I will deal with that matter when replying.

Comment on this

According to paragraph (c) of sub-section (3): "Such other council shall at the next meeting after such communication is received by it nominate such members of such committee as it is entitled and thinks fit to nominate."

That is to say, it is left optional to the other authority to refuse to participate in this joint reference to a committee by refusing to constitute a committee. I think if that situation is going to arise it will only arise in matters which seriously are of common concern to both or which are likely to be, because in a matter which so seriously concerns both authorities there is likely to be a very great conflict of interests. For that reason I think if one body decides that the matter is a subject for joint discussion the other body ought to be allowed to constitute a committee simply for the purpose of hearing what is to be said by one side on the matter, if for no other reason.

Comment on this

This amendment confines the body to the borough and the city—that is, the two large urbanised populations here—and I think that in this particular way we are examining what services can be jointly organised or jointly controlled, or what can generally be done in a joint way to help the urbanised populations around the cities here. We must concentrate on the city and the borough. If we bring in Howth, or if we bring in the county council, then we extend very much the possibility of having the body called together. Howth may want the body called together to develop the amenities of the pier and argue that the citizens of Dublin use it, and all that. This is really intended for sound practical purposes. For that reason, acting on the theory that the kernel of the service for which there is any case for acting in a conjoint way lies in the services which supply our main urban population, we confine it to the borough and the city. An ad hoc body will, I came to the conclusion, give you a better body. If you set up a permanent body you may not set up the best possible body for dealing with any matter that may come up. But if you are discussing roads, water or cleaning as a conjoint matter the two bodies are in a position to select the best and most experienced people to consider the matter according to what the particular matter is. That is the reason for not putting up a permanent body. I think the very fact of setting up an ad hoc body will mean that only important matters really worthy of discussion will be considered, but if you have a permanent body you may easily have a position in which footy matters would be referred to them without very much result. What we are really after is to see what services there are that can be regarded as conjoint services.

In reply to the argument that one body may ask for this committee to be set up and the other body may refuse you cannot do anything if that happens. The body that wants to have it examined can naturally examine it themselves. All this conceives a joint understanding on the part of the City Council and the Borough Council. What has been said here so much and what has been said in the public Press is true, that there are possibly some things that are of joint interest. I cannot imagine either of the two councils refusing to discuss a matter. If the question does arise and there is a refusal to discuss it then the tribunal which is set up in a detached way by the Minister for Local Government, of which one will be for five years and another inside the five year period after that, can take cognisance of the case made by the council that considered the matter. They will take the whole situation into review and the matter can be settled there. I cannot conceive any machinery by which you can force an unwilling council to come into a committee and discuss a particular matter with any kind of a hope that you are going to get a harmonious arrangement out of it.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

I do not think the Minister's objections to including the Urban Council of Howth are very substantial. The only real objection that there would be in substance would be if he could say that there were no common interests on which they might meet on a joint committee. He did not attempt to say that. I do not think he could in view of the situation as we know it. I do not think it meets the situation to simply say that Howth may want to discuss some footy questions like the extension of the pier. I do not know why he should assume that Howth Urban Council would want to do something foolish and that the City Borough would be altogether above doing something foolish.

Comment on this

There is a Commissioner in charge of Howth.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

The council will soon be established. I do not think that is a sound objection. If there are matters of common interest between the Urban Council of Howth and the city an arrangement might be made whereby only those two bodies or three bodies that would have a common interest would meet to set up their committee. An arrangement might be made with the Urban Council of Howth and the City Council would want to discuss one particular thing in which the southern borough would not be interested or where the southern borough might want to discuss a thing in which Howth might not be interested. I suggest there is no good reason by which an arrangement could not be made whereby Howth and the city would discuss by means of a joint committee matters which are of common interest to both. As Deputy Fahy pointed out, there would be a case too in which the county council would have an interest in coming in.

Comment on this

Of course, my own approach to this matter is that this committee is unnecessary, because there is no reason why the council of the borough would not discuss with the council of the city, or vice versa, anything they wanted to discuss, apart altogether from this machinery, and there is no reason why Howth Council would not discuss with the City Council anything it had to discuss. We are putting the joint services idea on a special plane by setting up this particular committee, and it can only arise on a special plane as between the two very big urbanised populations here. There is plenty of other machinery for dealing with anything as far as discussion goes or as far as arrangement goes as between either rural area with the county council contiguous to the city and Howth.

Comment on this

I have not very much to hope for from this committee. I certainly do think if there is anything of value in it, it depends upon its constitution being compulsory if one of the bodies decide that there is a matter of sufficient importance and of common concern both to the borough and the city for reference to it. Therefore, I think, if the section goes through in its present form, and if it is still left optional to one of the bodies to take away the purpose of the section by refusing to nominate members of the committee, the section will be valueless. It is precisely in this case, where one of the bodies is indisposed to consult with the other, that the committee can be of any service, because it is only where there is that indisposition to meet that if the representatives on both sides can be brought together under a common chairman with the matter of reference before them before they start that any good result will arise from the committee. If the Minister is going to allow the proposal to go in its present form and permit one of the bodies to defeat the whole purpose of the section, then I think it will be better to withdraw it.

Comment on this

Does Deputy MacEntee suggest some other word for the word "shall" where the word "shall" is used in (a), (b) and (c)—"such other council shall at the next meeting after such communication is received by it nominate such members of such committee as it is entitled and thinks fit to nominate." The words "thinks fit" refer to members.

Comment on this

I thought it had reference to numbers. Suppose they think fit to appoint none. I think there is a fault in the drafting.

Comment on this

I think Deputy MacEntee is mistaken if he thinks it is possible to compel co-operation by legislation. It is possible to hope for co-operation and to do everything we can to make co-operation easy or possible. That is what this amendment sets out to do, but if the two or either of the two is dead-set against co-operation we cannot enforce it by legislation. I think, on the other hand, if we try to make this proposed board too wide, and hope to do too much, all we shall do is to prevent its doing anything at all. I think, as the Minister said, we have attempted to put this on a special plane whereby the southern coastal borough and the city can deal with these joint matters in this special way. If you do widen that you will spoil the whole idea.

Comment on this

I am of opinion that paragraph (c) will have to be redrafted. Does the Minister, by paragraph (c) intend to leave to either of these bodies the option of nominating members or not as they think fit, because, as the section stands, if they thought fit not to nominate any members they would be entitled to do that?

Comment on this

The drafting section is supposed to impose a statutory duty on them. It is possible that they could be mandamused into setting up the three persons, but whether that would lead to anything but a meeting and a burst-up I do not know. It is better, I think, to leave one council or the other in the position of failing to carry out a statutory duty than to force a meeting by means of a mandamus that would simply bring about a burst-up and prejudice the subsequent discussion of the matter. I do not think we need look for any unreasonableness either on the part of the city council or of the borough council on anything connected with the setting up of a committee arranged for by statute. That committee is supposed to deal with matters of common interest to both the city and the borough.

Comment on this

The difficulty that I see is, that at the end of a certain period the Minister proposes to review the relations between the borough and the city. I have a feeling that one of the effects of that proviso will be that the borough, in order to safeguard itself against subsequent absorption, will endeavour to differentiate itself as much as possible from the city: that, therefore, in a number of important matters, it may desire to evade any consultation with the city which might compromise the future existence of the borough. For that reason, I can see that there will be a certain urge on the part of the borough not to set up this committee: to keep itself as aloof as possible from the city. It is in view of the Minister's own proviso to bring the relations of the city and the borough under review at certain stated periods that I think this matter of the proviso should be made to compel consultation upon certain important matters to take place between the borough and the city whenever one or the other of these two bodies consider it necessary that such consultation should take place.

Comment on this

It does not appear to me that the amendment forces these bodies to co-operate. That, I think, is the fundamental weakness in Deputy MacEntee's proposal. You can compel a body to nominate representatives to meet another body, but to compel joint representatives to co-operate in some common object is hoping for too much. Even if they do not co-operate, but if they meet in accordance with this proposal I am quite satisfied that even that fact will be an advantage in this way: that when this other independent tribunal meets every five years and considers matters of common interest, to a certain extent a way will be paved, and public opinion will be formed on certain matters that will come before the tribunal. In elucidating these matters, and in drawing attention to them, this particular committee will serve a useful purpose. Judging from one's own experience, if one party to this tribunal refuses to proceed or to carry on the ordinary courtesies of debate, I think that in itself will have rather a damaging effect when the subject comes before the tribunal ultimately. In view of all the circumstances, I think it is unlikely that what Deputy MacEntee anticipates will happen.

Comment on this

What I would like to say with regard to this amendment—this is also for the purpose of discussing Deputy Lemass's amendment—is that we have to take it that both councils will be always ready to come together to discuss what one or the other puts up as matters of common interest. I expect they will always be ready to do that. I suppose we may take it that as representing the people of the city and of the borough they will take a very keen interest in these matters. The Lord Mayor of the city might think it very undesirable that he would go into committee to discuss the matter from the very beginning; that if he did so he might be driven to take up a particular line, and therefore to a certain extent might prejudice a detached discussion of the matter in committee. He might feel that he would be prejudicing the position of the council in discussing the matter in a detached way when the full result of the committee's investigations and decisions were placed before it. There is nothing to prevent the Lord Mayor of the city being appointed on the committee. I am sure if he were on the committee he would act as chairman. I think it inadvisable that he should be on the committee. It might easily arise, from the point of view of the council and of the borough, that it would be undesirable particularly for himself to have the Lord Mayor on the committee.

Comment on this

I must say that I cannot see the Minister's point of view at all. It seems to me that the Lord Mayor should be the natural link between the city council and the borough council in these matters relating to joint concerns, and in which consultation is necessary. My view on this matter is that the proposed consultative council will be of very little practical use. My agreement with it is because of the fact that I think it is advisable that the suggestion of joint interests between the two councils is being introduced into this Bill by this proposal and is not in the Bill otherwise. The idea to make the Lord Mayor automatically chairman of this committee means that the seniority as it were of the city and particularly of the Lord Mayor of the city is thus established. I hope to see the day when the two councils will be amalgamated into one. It is because I think that this committee sets the pointer in that direction that it is acceptable, and for that reason only, and not because, as I have said, that I think it will be of any practical use.

It is necessary also that the pointer should be set in the direction of the seniority of the city, and by the appointment of the Lord Mayor automatically as chairman. I cannot see how the appointment of the Lord Mayor could possibly damage the interest of the city or prevent useful work being done by any of these committees if set up. I do not think that the Lord Mayor should be detached on any question that concerns the interests of the ratepayers of the city, nor do I think that the city council should elect persons with a detached view on something affecting the interests of the ratepayers of the City of Dublin. I take it that we will have on that committee three individuals representing the interests of the ratepayers of the borough and three individuals representing the interests of the ratepayers of the city, and that their object will be to see how far common action can be taken by the representatives both of the city and of the borough to help the interests of both. In that matter the Lord Mayor should not be a detached person. He should be a partisan striving to do the best he could for the people he represents.

Comment on this

Certainly, detached as to the means by which that could be done.

Comment on this

He will not become any more or any less detached by reason of the fact that he would be a person who was presiding at the committee. I would not press the amendment if there is any serious objection to it, but I think it is desirable there should be somebody appointed who would automatically take the chair at these committees, and that representatives of the borough and the council should not come together and wrangle as to who should take the chair, and as to which was the more important body, and whether there should be an alteration in the chairmanship, or anything of that kind. It is desirable that somebody should be indicated as chairman, a senior representative of the council, or somebody of the kind. It seems to me the most desirable person is the Lord Mayor.

Comment on this

The Deputy says he does not want to press the amendment. I certainly do not want to press my view as against the view of the House, but I feel that an ad hoc committee set up to discuss a particular matter should examine the question in an absolutely detached way, that is, each section should bear the interests of the people as a whole in mind. That goes without saying. I feel that the presence of the Lord Mayor as chairman might easily bring the city council into a difficult position in the matter by bringing him into discussion at the earlier stages.

[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]

Comment on this

The fact that the committee will be meeting in the premises of the city council, and that its work will be facilitated by the staff of the city council, should, in my opinion, mean that the chairman of the city council should also be chairman of the committee.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Lemass is taking this matter too lightly. He is regarding the joint committee merely as a symbol and a safeguard of unity, and he wants the Lord Mayor to sit in the chair as representing the sovereignty of the city. It should be left to the discretion of the committee to elect their own chairman. The committee will have different questions coming before it, and it would be necessary to pick a chairman carefully. There is nothing as it stands to prevent the Lord Mayor from being chairman, but I think the fact of the Lord Mayor being always chairman would detract rather than add to his dignity.

Comment on this

I move:—

70b. In page 33, before Section 75, to insert a new section as follows:—

"The Conjoint Services Board shall consist of the Lord Mayor and three other members of the City Council, the Mayor, and one other member of the Southern Borough Council, and the Mayor."

70c. In page 33, before Section 75, to insert a new section as follows:—

"On a day to be appointed by the Minister for the purposes all the powers, functions and duties of the City Corporation and the Southern Borough Corporation, in respect of the following matters, that is to say:—

(a) water supply;

(b) drainage;

(c) housing,

shall become and be powers, rights and duties of the Conjoint Services Board."

70d. In page 33, before Section 75, to insert a new section as follows:—

"It shall be the duty of the Conjoint Services Board to consider and advise the Councils of the City and the Southern Borough upon any matter which appears to it to affect in any way the welfare of the City and the Borough in common and which is brought before the Board by any of its members."

70c. In page 33, before Section 75, to insert a new section as follows:—

"The Councils of the City and the Southern Borough may by resolution in equivalent terms agree that powers, rights and duties of the respective Corporations in addition to those hereinbefore specified shall become powers, rights and duties of the Conjoint Services Board, and upon the passage of such resolutions by the Councils the powers, rights and duties specified therein shall become powers, rights and duties of the Conjoint Services Board upon a day appointed for the purpose by the Minister."

I might explain that these amendments are identical in terms with the amendments which appeared in the name of Deputy O'Connell on the Committee Stage. I did not put them down with the intention of stealing Deputy O'Connell's ideas in any way. I was anxious that the projected Conjoint Services Board should be introduced in the Bill, and I waited until the last possible moment to enable Deputy O'Connell to table the amendments in his own name. It was only when I was informed that the time was running out yesterday evening I tabled the amendments, and even then I told the official responsible that if at the last moment Deputy O'Connell came in with the amendments mine should be withdrawn.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

I think these amendments were circulated yesterday.

Comment on this

No. These were only handed in yesterday.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

The earlier ones were.

Comment on this

No. The amendments circulated earlier in the day were my own amendments for which I take full responsibility. I want the House to understand that I am not responsible for the drafting of these amendments, and if there is anything wrong the fault is Deputy O'Connell's. The project outlined in these amendments is the establishment of a Conjoint Services Board. We have pointed out here in the discussions on the previous stages of this Bill that the ratepayers of both the borough and the city areas can secure substantial advantages by unification in the control of the three services over the whole area. There is in fact at the present time a unified water supply, the City Corporation selling water to the existing townships on the southern side at rates fixed by agreement or otherwise from time to time.

There are three drainage systems, in fact four, in operation in the area: the Dublin main drainage, the main drainage of Pembroke and Rathmines, the drainage of Dun Laoghaire and Blackrock, and the Dalkey system. The only improvement that could be effected in relation to drainage by the establishment of the conjoint board would be the saving that would result from unfied control, including the unification of technical staffs, equipment, and things of that kind.

It would, undoubtedly, be desirable to have one main drainage system for the whole area, but that could only be achieved at considerable cost. The existing drainage systems for Dun Laoghaire, Blackrock and Dalkey are, however, capable of very considerable improvement, which improvement could not be carried out by the new Southern Borough, because the cost on the ratepayers in the area would be very considerable, and, as far as I know, its borrowing powers are very nearly exhausted. The new Southern Borough will not be large enough in population to secure trustee status for its stock and, consequently, even if its borrowing powers were not exhausted or almost exhausted, it might find difficulty in raising money to effect improvements in a service of that kind.

In relation to housing we had a more or less prolonged discussion on the Committee Stage, and divergent views were expressed on both sides of the House. It seems to us that the housing requirements of the citizens in both districts could be more rapidly and more economically provided for if there was unified control. The Minister appeared to think that the housing requirements of the citizens of the Southern Borough might be neglected if control was exercised from the City Hall in Dublin. This is a matter upon which differences of opinion cannot be resolved by debate here. The main reason why we are anxious to get the Conjoint Services Board established is because it would obviously strike the high road towards the establishment of the one council for the whole area, which is the ideal that, in our view, should be aimed at. The main services of water supply, drainage and housing would be handed over immediately to this Board if established, and other services could be transferred to it from time to time, so that ultimately the need for the existence of the separate corporations would have ended, they could be abolished, and you would then have the one corporation for both areas. The original proposal, of course, proposed to include the suggested Howth Borough, so that in the long run we would have in operation the proposal of the Greater Dublin Commission for the whole of the suggested Greater Dublin area.

Apart from the fact that the establishment of this Board would make the ultimate establishment of one council for the whole of Dublin city inevitable, it would immediately confer undoubted benefits on the ratepayers of the areas concerned, inasmuch as they would probably get the essential services—the services handed over to the Board—conducted with greater efficiency and at less cost than with duplicated authority and duplicated control. It could be argued that the establishment of the Southern Borough would be a particularly futile proceeding if it was not proposed to give that Borough control over these services of water supply, drainage and housing, and I have no answer to that argument, because I think the establishment of the Southern Borough is futile in any case, and that it will not be very long before it will be abolished and the area included in the city. Apart altogether from that, whatever political reasons operated in the establishment of the Southern Borough will undoubtedly continue to exist. The ratepayers should not, however, be deprived of the advantage that would come from the establishment of the conjoint board. I confidently propose the first of these amendments, on which a decision will be taken, and I hope that the Dáil will see its way to accept it.

Comment on this

After setting up a council and arranging to appoint a Manager to deal with the affairs of the borough, and setting up a council and appointing a manager to deal with the affairs of the city, I can quite understand Deputy Lemass's want of anxiety to stand over these proposals, but I think the House will accept it that after doing that we will not, as a body, recommend the setting up of a Conjoint Services Board to take over the control of housing, drainage and water, and to tell the new Dublin Council anything else it might think of about the welfare of the city generally. I am very strongly opposed to setting up any body over the Council of the City of Dublin, and any conjoint board that would deal with these matters would have to be a conjoint board that would be devised and recommended by the Council of the City of Dublin specially, because I think that if the main control of local government development is taken away from the Council of the City of Dublin at this particular stage it would only lead to a terrible want of reality and create an amount of chaos.

The new City Council will have a very considerable amount of work to do in the city; the new Borough Council will have a very considerable amount of work to do in the borough, and if they have anything to say with regard to a conjoint board and the handing over of services to such a board later they will have five years to examine the matter, and they can make any representations they like to the tribunal that will go into the matter in five years' time. But certainly now is not the time to set up anything like this.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 34, Section 75, line 2, to delete the words "with the consent of the Minister."

This amendment relates to the deputy Manager. It is proposed that while the Manager is on vacation or is, through illness, absent from the city or the borough, or is suspended from the performance of his duties, temporarily incapable of exercising his powers and functions, a deputy Manager may be appointed for the duration of that period of incapacity, and the section says that he may with the consent of the Minister be removed at any time during such vacation or incapacity. The amendment proposes to delete the words "with the consent of the Minister." I think that the Council should at least be given the right to remove a temporary Manager. The Minister has refused to give them any right whatever over the permanent Manager, even to the fixing of his salary. It is unlikely that the power will ever be exercised, and therefore the Minister would be quite safe in conceding it.

Comment on this

This amendment 71 and amendment 72 are related to the same thing, because in amendment 72 the Deputy proposes that in any circumstances when the Manager is not available the power of nominating the deputy Manager should lie with the Lord Mayor. Our proposal is that if the Manager is going away on holidays, or in such circumstances as he can foresee his incapacity, he shall, after consultation with the Lord Mayor, nominate the deputy Manager. I think that is reasonable and I do not intend to depart from it. Amendment 71 proposes that the deputy Manager, having been appointed, whether by the Manager, after consultation with the Lord Mayor, or in the other circumstances where the Manager has not done that and where the Lord Mayor has appointed the deputy Manager, that he can be removed without the authority of the Minister. I think that if such a critical state of affairs existed that it was necessary to remove the deputy Manager, the Minister certainly ought to be made aware of these circumstances, and it would not be reasonable that even a deputy Manager should be removed without the circumstances being drawn to the notice of the Minister and the consent of the Minister obtained.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister why the Parliamentary draftsman clings to the word "incapable." It has got a sinister meaning in that respect. I suggest that the word he wants is "incapacity."

Comment on this

He might not be incapacitated if he was on holidays.

Comment on this

As I said before, it is a sinister and ambiguous word. A better word could be found.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 36, before Section 80 (b), to insert three new paragraphs as follows:—

"(b) the fourteenth day after the day which is the day of election for the purposes of this Act shall be substituted throughout the Act of 1927 for the 1st day of April, 1927, except where that date occurs in the expression ‘the local financial year commencing on the 1st day of April, 1927,' and

"(c) the local financial year commencing next after the day which is the day of election for the purposes of this Act shall be substituted throughout the Act of 1927 for the local financial year commencing on the 1st day of April, 1927, and

"(d) Section 10 of the Act of 1927 shall apply to the Council of the County of Dublin, and"

This is a drafting amendment fixing certain dates in connection with the application of the Acts of 1925 and 1927.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 36, to add at the end of Section 80 a new sub-section as follows:—

"(2) On and after the fourteenth day after the day of election the Secretary of the County Council shall act as and be the chief executive officer of the Board of Health."

This amendment proposes that the Secretary of the County Council shall be appointed Secretary of the Board of Health when the Board of Health is appointed in the County of Dublin. It arises out of strong representations made by the County Council that this would give them a better opportunity of co-ordinating and controlling the general work of the county. I think it is an admirable suggestion.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 39, Section 87 (1), to delete all the words after the word "appoint," line 15, and substitute the words—"in accordance with the principle of proportional representation for the purposes of this section a Committee (to be known as the Rathdown Union Committee) consisting of such number of persons not being less than five, as the said council thinks proper."

The purpose of this amendment is to ensure that all sections of the council will be adequately represented on the Rathdown Union Committee. I think that owing to certain circumstances the practice has grown up of regarding boards of health, whose functions are to a certain extent analogous to those of the Union committees which are being established under this Bill, as the perquisite of the political majority of the members of the county council, and that every endeavour is made, on one side possibly as much as on the other, to pack these boards of health, because it is thought that a certain amount of political advantage is to be secured from the distribution of home help. I do not think that is quite a good practice. I do not see any way in which it can be prevented except by providing that these Union committees will be representative of the council as a whole, and that persons nominated to them will represent all the views of the members of the county council so far as they can in reason be represented. The principal purpose here is, first of all, to secure as far as this amendment is concerned—and also amendment 76, because there is a misprint in that— that the number of people nominated will be sufficient to ensure that representation will be given; and, secondly, that the method of nominating them is according to the principle of proportional representation, which will ensure that every section in the council would be represented on the Union committees.

Comment on this

At the present moment there is a board of guardians in Rathdown union area and a board of guardians in Balrothery union area, and the proposals in Sections 87 and 88 are to enable the council to appoint persons to carry out the duties of these boards of guardians in these areas, as a temporary measure, until the necessary legislation is introduced to deal with the general poor law situation in Co. Dublin, which must be before March, 1931, arising, I think, out of the last Act that was passed. For that reason we leave it open to the county council to select in any way it wishes persons to carry on this work in a temporary way. The fact that there are guardians there engaged in this class of work, and that some of them will not be members of the county council, but that the council may wish nevertheless to have some of them associated with their own representatives in carrying on this work, leads me to leave the matter the way it is. The county council is given complete discretion to select persons to act like commissioners, and for that reason I anticipate they will take some of the persons at present acting as guardians, if not the whole body, as the county council may easily require to do. I do not accept the idea of there being sections in the county council that want to be represented one way or another in Balrothery area or in Rathdown area. If there are such sections, it is open to the county council to make their selection by a system of proportional representation if they wish. But I do not think we should bind the county council by a system of election in selecting persons in the particular circumstances which exist in Co. Dublin. I am opposed to amendments 75 and 76, and I think Deputy MacEntee will understand that it may be very much more satisfactory if the county council should be given a free hand, in view of the fact that there are guardians there already that they will probably reappoint.

Comment on this

My opposition is somewhat changed and modified by the statement of the Minister that Sections 87 and 88 are temporary provisions, and in view of that I am perfectly prepared to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 39, before Section 89, to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) The secretary of the county council may from time to time amend any rate or assessment in any rate book kept by the county council by inserting therein the name of any person who ought to have been rated or by striking out the name of any person who ought not to have been rated or by raising or reducing the sum at which a person has been rated or by making such other amendment therein as will make such rate or assessment conformable to the provisions of any Act for the time being in force in regard to the making of such rate or assessment.

(2) Every person aggrieved by any such alteration shall have the same right of appeal therefrom as he would have had if his name had been originally inserted in the said rate or assessment and no such alteration had been made therein, and as regards such person the rate shall be considered to have been made at the time when he received notice of such amendment.

This is to enable the county secretary to do what the Bill arranges that the City Manager is able to do, namely, to correct in a simple way errors in the rate book where errors have arisen.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 39, Section 89, to delete sub-section (2).

This is not a very important amendment. The section refers to the amount that public bodies, particularly the Municipal Council of Dublin, can be charged by the Local Government Department for the annual audit and it puts a limit on the amount to be charged. The proposal in the Bill is that this section shall cease to have effect in the city and county. In that way, I take it, there would be no limit to the amount that might be charged by the Department for the annual audit. It has been represented to me by some of those connected with the Municipal Council that that might be interfered with, that it is always the practice in legislation like this to put a limit to the amount that may be charged. The abolition of the limit might leave it open to the Department to be unfair in this regard and the Council would have no redress. I think that if the Minister consulted his officials they would suggest a limit of some kind and have it agreed to in the Bill. Those concerned would be in a position to judge what would be a fair amount to charge for the time—I suppose considerable time—given by the Local Government Auditor in auditing the accounts for Dublin City. Additional time would be necessary in future in view of the extended nature of the work and I think that some limit could be agreed on and inserted in the Bill. To leave the matter in the air in future, as it would be if this section were adopted, might lead to unfairness to the city.

Comment on this

The position is that under the Act of 1898 a sum of £100 is placed as a limit beyond which a county council will not be charged for its audit. That was over thirty years ago. With the enlarged city the position would be changed. I think that it takes the auditor nine months to carry out the audit in connection with the Dublin Corporation. His salary would be about £700 or £800 and the intention is that the city ought to pay for the cost of the audit but no more than that. In the same way in regard to the county, the county should pay for the cost of audit but no more. I do not think that a safeguard is necessary in regard to the amount that will be charged. I could, however, consider that and, if it were necessary to put in an amendment later, it might be managed in the Seanad that the city or county should be charged the cost of the audit, but I think it is unreasonable that the standard of £100 fixed in 1898 for auditing the city accounts should operate now in connection with the extended city. I would like the section to stand and I can have the matter further considered and, if necessary, in the Seanad introduce a qualifying clause. I take it that the Deputy agrees that a sum of £100 is not reasonable now.

Comment on this

I quite agree that a figure fixed thirty years ago is not equitable now as values have changed very considerably, but at the same time I think that the Minister will agree that, as it has been the custom to limit the amount, the suggestion of those in authority that a maximum amount should be fixed is a reasonable one. As the Minister promises to consider the suggestion, I withdraw my amendment.

Comment on this

I move:—

In pages 39 and 40 to delete Section 90 and substitute a new section as follows:—

(1) Subject to the provisions of this section, every statute and every order made under statutory authority whereby, immediately before the appointed day, the City Corporation is required to supply water for use in the urban district of Dun Laoghaire, or whereby a price is fixed for such supply or whereby such price may be varied from time to time shall have effect, on and after the appointed day, with the substitution therein of the Borough and Borough Corporation for the said urban district and the council thereof.

(2) Every provision contained in any statute or order whereby, immediately before the appointed day, the City Corporation is required to supply water for use in any of the coastal urban districts other than the urban district of Dun Laoghaire shall, save as hereinafter otherwise provided, cease to have effect on and after the appointed day.

(3) The delivery of a supply of water by the City Corporation to the Borough Corporation for use in the Borough in pursuance of this section shall be made separately in respect of each of the several areas forming at the passing of this Act the respective coastal urban districts and such delivery in respect of each such area shall be made at the place at which the City Corporation is, immediately before the appointed day, required by law to deliver water for use in such area.

This is a redraft.

Comment on this

Does it bind the City Corporation to give any greater quantity than the aggregate of all the supplies now given separately to the coastal urban districts?

Comment on this

What it particularly does is to safeguard the position in regard to the point of delivery. I take it that it safeguards the supply up to the agreement that has been entered into.

Comment on this

Does it impose any further obligation on the City Council?

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 40, Section 91, line 11, after the word "agree" to insert the words "to do all or any of the following things, that is to say," and to delete the word "and" and substitute the words "renew or."

This is just to clear up the position and to make it clear that, as well as laying down and maintaining, the renewal of pipes can be undertaken.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 40, before Section 95, to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) The Minister shall, on such two occasions as he shall think proper within the limits hereinafter mentioned and also on such and so many (if any) subsequent occasions as he shall think proper, appoint by order such number of such persons as he shall on each such occasion think fit to constitute and be a tribunal for the purposes of this section, and shall by each such order nominate one of the members of the tribunal thereby appointed to be the chairman of such tribunal and appoint such person as he thinks fit to act as secretary to such tribunal and appoint a convenient day, hour, and place for the first meeting of such tribunal.

(2) The first appointment of a tribunal under this section shall be made within five years after the passing of this Act and the second such appointment shall be made not less than three years after the appointment of the first such tribunal and not more than ten years after the passing of this Act.

(3) It shall be the duty of every tribunal appointed under this section to consider, make recommendations, and report to the Minister with all convenient speed whether any and, if any, what alterations are then necessary or desirable in the boundaries of the City and the County respectively and in the several local administrative areas within the County, and also whether any and, if any, what general adjustments of the financial relations of the City, the County, and the several local administrative areas within the County are then necessary or desirable, and also whether any and, if any, what arrangements are then necessary or desirable for the establishment of joint local government or public health services for the common benefit of any two or more of the following areas, that is to say, the City, the County, and the several local administrative areas within the County, and for the joint control of such services by the several local authorities having jurisdiction in, the respective areas benefited by such services.

(4) Every report made by a tribunal appointed under this section shall be forthwith laid before each House of the Oireachtas by the Minister.

(5) A tribunal appointed under this section shall have all such powers, rights, and privileges for enforcing the attendance of witnesses and examining them on oath or otherwise and for compelling the production of documents as are vested in the High Court or a Judge thereof in respect of the trial of an action, and a summons signed by the chairman of the tribunal shall be equivalent to and have the like effect as a formal process issued by the High Court for enforcing the attendance of witnesses and compelling the production of documents.

(6) If any person—

(a) on being duly summoned as a witness before a tribunal appointed under this section makes default in attending, or

(b) being in attendance as a witness refuses to take an oath legally required by such tribunal to be taken, or to produce any document in his power or control legally required by such tribunal to be produced by him, or to answer any question to which such tribunal may legally require an answer, or

(c) does any other thing which would, if such tribunal were a Court of Justice having power to commit for contempt of Court, be contempt of such Court,

the chairman of such tribunal may certify the offence of that person under his hand to the High Court, and that Court may, after such inquiry as it thinks proper to make, punish or take steps for the punishment of that person in like manner as if he had been guilty of contempt of the said Court.

(7) A witness before a tribunal appointed under this section shall be entitled to the same immunities and privileges as if he were a witness before the High Court.

(8) The costs and expenses incurred by or in relation to a tribunal appointed under this section shall, to such amount as may be sanctioned by the Minister, be paid to the Minister by such of the following bodies, that is to say, the City Corporation, the County Council, and the several local authorities whose functional areas are within the County, as such tribunal shall direct, and the proportion of such costs and expenses so payable by any such body may be recovered from such body by the Minister as a civil debt."

This provides for the setting up of the tribunal which we have discussed. It will be set up in five years' time, and then in not less than another five years, and after that, as occasionally required by the Minister.

Comment on this

I move:—

In page 42, First Schedule, to insert in their appropriate alphabetical positions in that portion of Part I. which relates to the North Dublin Rural District the following names of Townlands and of the District Electoral Divisions in which they are respectively situate, that is to say:—

Name of Townland. | District Electoral Division in which situate.

Bettyville | Howth Rural.

Charleville | Howth Rural.

Foxlands | Howth Rural.

Maryville | Howth Rural.

Raheny, North | Howth Rural.

Raheny, South | Howth Rural.

Sibylhill | Drumcondra Rural.

and to add at the end of Part II. the following paragraphs:—

That portion of the Townland of Harmonstown in the District Electoral Division of Drumcondra Rural and the Rural District of North Dublin bounded as follows, that is to say:—

Starting at a point on the boundary between the Townlands of Furry park and Harmonstown, in the District Electoral Division of Drumcondra Rural, where the said boundary intersects the northwestern fence of the Great Northern Railway, proceeding in a north-easterly direction along the said fence for a distance of 653 yards to the intersection of the said fence with the boundary between the Townlands of Harmonstown, in the District Electoral Division of Drumcondra Rural, and Glebe, in the District Electoral Division of Howth Rural, thence south-easterly, southerly, south-easterly, south-westerly, westerly, north-westerly, south-westerly and northerly along the boundary of the said Townland of Harmonstown to the starting point.

That portion of the Townland of Glebe, in the District Electoral Division of Howth Rural, and the Rural District of North Dublin bounded as follows, that is to say:—

Starting at a point on the boundary between the Townland of Harmonstown, in the District Electoral Division of Drumcondra Rural, and the Townland of Glebe, in the District Electoral Division of Howth Rural, where the said boundary intersects the north-western fence of the Great Northern Railway, proceeding in a north-easterly direction along the said fence for a distance of 370 yards to the intersection of the said fence with the boundary between the Townlands of Glebe and Ballyhoy, in the District Electoral Division of Howth Rural, thence south-easterly, southerly, south-westerly, north-westerly, northerly, and north-westerly along the boundary of the said Townland of Glebe to the starting point.

That portion of the Townland of Ballyhoy in the District Electoral Division of Howth Rural bounded as follows, that is to say:—

Starting at a point on the boundary between the Townlands of Glebe and Ballyhoy in the District Electoral Division of Howth Rural where the said boundary intersects the northern fence of the Great Northern Railway, proceeding in a north-easterly direction along the said fence for a distance of 532 yards to the intersection of the said fence with the boundary between the Townlands of Ballyhoy and Raheny South, in the District Electoral Division of Howth Rural, thence south-easterly, south-westerly, northerly, and north-westerly along the boundary of the said Townland of Ballyhoy to the starting point.

That portion of the Townland of Snug in the District Electoral Division of Howth Rural and the Rural District of North Dublin bounded as follows, that is to say:—

Starting at a point on the boundary between the Townlands of Snug on one side and Ballyhoy and Raheny South on the other side where the said boundary intersects the northern fence of the Great Northern Railway, proceeding in an easterly direction along the said fence for a distance of 225 yards to the intersection of the said fence with the boundary between the Townlands of Snug and Raheny North, thence southerly, westerly, and north-westerly along the boundary of the said Townland of Snug to the starting point.

That portion of the Townland of Kilbarrack Upper in the District Electoral Division of Howth Rural and the Rural District of North Dublin bounded as follows, that is to say:—

Starting at a point on the boundary between Raheny North and Kilbarrack Upper, in the District Electoral Division of Howth Rural, where the said boundary touches the Townlands of Foxlands in the District Electoral Division of Howth Rural, and proceeding in a northerly direction along the said boundary for a distance of 433 yards, and continuing in the same direction for a distance of 158 yards along the eastern boundary of the holding now occupied by Patrick Cullen, thence easterly for a distance of 476 yards, and north-easterly for a distance of 483 yards along the northern boundary of the holding occupied by the said Patrick Cullen to the centre of Kilbarrack Lane, thence along the centre of the said lane for a distance of 76 yards to the boundary between the said Townland of Kilbarrack Upper and the Urban District of Howth, thence south-easterly, south-westerly, north-westerly along the boundary of the said Townland of Kilbarrack Upper to the starting point.

This is to insert in the Schedule the townlands which form the corridor extending from the City boundary to the Howth boundary.

Comment on this

The purpose of these amendments is largely to ascertain from the Minister the principles upon which certain concessions in regard to rating have been conceded to certain bodies in the occupation of certain premises. I could understand to a certain extent why concessions are given to the Royal College of Surgeons, to the Royal College of Physicians and to the Honourable Society of King's Inns and, to a certain extent, possibly also to St. Patrick's Hospital, but I cannot understand why a concession in regard to rating has been extended to the Corn Exchange Buildings Company which is, I think, a purely commercial concern. Apart altogether from that, it appears to me that if the concession to the Royal College of Surgeons, to the Royal College of Physicians and to the Honourable Society of King's Inns is extended because of certain educational work done by these bodies or because of the professional control which they exercise, a similar case can be made out in connection with a considerable number of educational establishments in the city where the body of students is considerably in excess of any of those which come under the jurisdiction of any of the societies I have mentioned. I refer to premises occupied by other professional bodies such as the Institute of Civil Engineers of Ireland who also exercise a certain amount of professional control and jurisdiction over a professional body in Ireland. I am not putting forward a plea that these concessions should be extended to each of the cases I have mentioned. I am putting forward the case to the Minister and I ask him to justify it.— I think it will require, in the minds of the general public and the citizens of Dublin, a considerable amount of justification—as to why preferential treatment is meted out to most of the bodies I have mentioned.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is under some sort of misapprehension in connection with the matter. We are not here and now proposing certain exemptions for certain bodies. Deputies will remember that previously I stated that in having a consolidated municipal rate we were wiping away all kinds of rates of different names which were raised in different ways and with different incidence. The bodies here mentioned are the bodies' which of old had exemptions from certain rates. Some of them were exempt from the improvement rate, some from the domestic water rate, some from the grand jury rate, and so on. Others when exempted from, say, the improvement rate, had to pay a particular tax based on the number of square yards between the front walls of their premises and the middle of the street. We introduced a consolidated municipal rate for the purpose of simplifying rating and accounting. In doing that we had to make some kind of arrangement to safeguard the exemptions of people who up to the present had exemptions. These premises, as the text of the Bill shows, will be rated to the full municipal rate, but they will be rated to the full municipal rate only on a particular percentage of their valuations, that percentage being worked out so that the percentage exemption that has operated in the past will continue. It may be that a case can be made out against some of the bodies having exemptions, but this is not the Bill upon which to make that case.

Comment on this

Is the Minister not continuing these exemptions, and would it not be within his power, to reconsider this whole matter and to decide not to continue these exemptions? We are asking the Minister to justify his decision to continue the exemptions.

Comment on this

I justify my decisions to continue the exemptions because we are dealing with this matter in a public Bill. There are people concerned with this part who have private rights. These parties had no opportunity of coming forward to argue their private rights in this matter and I do not think it reasonable, when we are simply making a change for the general public good, to take away from these people the exemption which they have enjoyed up to the present and which they have enjoyed because of definite statutory authority.

Comment on this

I must say that I think the Minister is approaching this matter in a very haphazard way. I would have thought when he was recasting the whole municipal government of Dublin, he would have certainly considered the position of privileged bodies under that government, and would have seen whether, under the circumstances that now prevail, he was justified in continuing exemptions granted under another regime.

I do not know whether the Corn Exchange Buildings Company, which is the subject of one of my amendments, at the present moment really discharges in the same complete and full way which it might have done 60 or 70 years ago, the functions for which the company was originally formed. My own personal opinion, from the few occasions I was within the precincts of the buildings of the company is that they simply exist as office premises, and that so far as the corn trade of the country is concerned, the company does not fulfil any function whatever. It is quite possible it might have been granted a concession, because it had opened as a medium of exchange between the corn-growers, the corn factors and the corn merchants. I do not know whether that continues at the present day. I do not know whether it performs that function on such a scale as to entitle it to the very substantial concession in rates which the Minister proposes to grant. The Minister is going to assess the premises upon three-fifths of their valuation.

Again, in regard to the other bodies, the Royal College of Surgeons and the Royal College of Physicians, although they do exercise important functions in regard to the medical profession, nevertheless, their membership is very limited, and I do not know whether it can be said that they are, on the whole, representative of the medical profession in the country, and whether, taking into consideration the changed circumstances, the Minister is justified in extending them the privilege which he proposes under this schedule. I would like to hear the Minister, particularly in regard to the Corn Exchange Buildings. I think he should justify the inclusion of these particular premises in the schedule, because the concession not only relates to the present premises, but to any other premises which they might hereafter occupy in substitution for the present premises. If by any chance they were to remove from the premises at Burgh Quay and enter into the occupation of one of the most palatial premises in Grafton Street, by that very fact they would benefit very considerably financially, and the citizens of Dublin would suffer financially very considerably.

Comment on this

In the consideration of this Bill I have never heard a case suggested for doing away with the exemptions, and for that reason I can only repeat that the occasion of the introduction of a consolidated municipal rate for the more economic, efficient and satisfactory administration of the finances of the city is not the time to interfere in any way with any of the exemptions that are there.

Comment on this

The real fact of the matter is that the Minister has not considered this problem. That is what his admission comes to. He is asking the House to continue these exemptions for all time not only in relation to the premises at present occupied by the various bodies, but any other premises which they may hereafter occupy in substitution for these. He is asking the House to continue the privilege in perpetuity. He ought to justify that or else withdraw the schedule. If the Minister could put up reasons, we may not be averse to granting the concession in connection with some of the bodies on the schedule, but the particular one I have cited I do not think is justifiable. If the Minister cannot see his way to meet us in the matter, I am afraid we shall have to divide the House.

Comment on this

I have nothing to add.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I think we might take it that amendments 83, 84, 85 and 85a are not moved and put the question on amendment 86.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment 86 put.

Tá 48
·
Níl 59
Result _

Do you agree with this result?