We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Business. - Safeguarding and Developing Agriculture.

Contributions 1–142 of 278. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I beg to move:—

"That with a view to the safe-guarding and further development of the agricultural industry the Dáil is of opinion that the Executive Council should immediately take the necessary legislative action to provide for:—

(1) An embargo on the import into the Free State of foreign oats and oat products;

(2) the prohibition of the import of barley and barley products except under licence;

(3) (a) the imposition of an import duty of 20s. per cwt. on all bacon and other pig products; (b) the prohibition of imports of bacon and other pig products into the Free State after June 30th, 1932; (c) the marking legibly of all imported meat entering the Free State, so as to indicate the country of origin when such meat is exposed for sale; (d) the proper medical inspection of all imported meat entering the Free State;

(4) the prohibition of the imports of butter, condensed milk, dried and liquid eggs into the Free State."

I believe that it will be agreed on every side of this House that our object in discussing any economic subject should be to make our people as comfortable as possible and put them in possession of the means to buy the necessaries of life. Under present circumstances that appears to be possible only when people have work; in other words, there is no way that people could have the wherewithal to buy necessaries unless through their earning capacity. In approaching any subject of this kind, therefore, we should keep in mind the fact that the more employment we can promote the better it is for the country. Most countries have approached this subject through protection. In fact I believe that the Free State is the most free trade country in the world, including even Great Britain. I know that the Free State Executive Council will claim a good deal for their own common sense and wisdom, but I do not know that they will really claim that they are the only Government in this world that have any sense on economic affairs. They might, however, claim that, because they have had the audacity to claim even bigger things in the past. We have gone a certain distance towards industrial tariffs, and the farmers and other members of the agricultural community have agreed to these tariffs in the hope, I believe, that they in return would be protected in their industry. They have agreed to these industrial tariffs, perhaps for other reasons also, even, if you like, for selfish reasons, because they saw that if the people in the towns were fully employed they would thereby get a better market for their produce than they could get in a foreign market.

As a matter of fact not only was that belief inherent in the agricultural community, but it was proved by figures by the Department of Government which took the agricultural statistics in 1926. When these statistics were taken it was shown that the people living in towns in the Free State were, each and every one of them, purchasers of £10 worth of Irish agricultural produce per year, whereas the people in England, Scotland and Wales—countries to which we have been directed to turn our attention for markets by the present Government—were only purchasing 13s. worth per head. That only goes to show that the figures produced by the Government bore out what was the common experience of people in the agricultural community who knew the conditions prevailing in the local markets in their own districts, because the farmers have known for years, even before the present Government came into power, that the prices which they could get for their butter and eggs in local towns were always better than those they could get in the foreign market.

It is no wonder, therefore, that the agricultural community, even for selfish reasons if you like, were prepared to see our town industries protected in order that that home market might be increased. It does not appear, however, to be enough that that home market should be increased through industrial tariffs, that is, that the capacity of the market should be increased. It appears to be necessary also that the home market should be protected for the home producers and that the home producer will be either compelled or induced financially to purchase the home produced article. We will be told of course that there are certain articles that we should produce here and that we should not trouble about producing others, but we find, when we come to examine it, that there is no single article that the farmer is producing in this country in the production of which he cannot be beaten by foreign competition. We were told, for instance, that we cannot compete against Canada and America in wheat growing. We can be told now that we cannot compete against Russia and Germany in the production of oats. We can be told that we cannot compete against the Balkans and other States in the production of barley. We know—in fact the knowledge has made this motion necessary —that we cannot compete against China, America and other places in the production of bacon. We know we cannot compete against such places as Siberia in the production of butter. Hence when we come to examine the different products of the farmer in this country we come to recognise that we must some time or another protect practically every article the farmer is turning out.

The first item in this motion deals principally with tillage. I know that I am going to be tackled by such able advocates of tillage on the other side as Deputy Dr. Hennessy. The Minister for Agriculture has given us his views on tillage here on many occasions but it was surprising to find a disciple on the other side who could imbibe not only the ideas, but the very expressions and words of the Minister for Agriculture as Deputy Dr. Hennessy did in the letter which he wrote to the "Irish Independent" a few days ago. If the Minister himself were to write that letter he would have used exactly the same words.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan (Minister)

Do you suggest that I wrote or inspired it?

Comment on this

I would not suggest that at all.

Comment on this

The seed did not fall on stony ground.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

As that suggestion is here, may I say that I know nothing about the letter? I have not, in fact, seen the letter. I had nothing to do with the letter, good, bad or indifferent. Not having seen it I cannot say what it was like, but I have sufficient confidence in Dr. Hennessy to know that he wrote sound, common sense and in that way it would be rather like a letter which I would write.

Comment on this

That only proves what I said, that he was a disciple the Minister should be proud of. One reason why I think we should at least maintain the amount of tillage we have in this country even if we cannot agree to increase it—because I believe this motion is only going a small way towards solving the problem of tillage and it will not do more than maintain the present amount of tillage—is that we are importing into this country every year up to £11,000,000 worth of cereals which could be produced or substituted by crops grown in this country. If that figure is to increase, as it probably will increase under present conditions, because at present there is no option for the farmer except to go out of tillage, we cannot maintain even the present conditions with regard to our adverse trade balance of imports against exports.

There is another question to be considered. We all know that we have land in this country which is eminently suitable for the growing of oats, say, and we know that that particular land may not be suitable for the production of milk. We know that we have land that is eminently suitable for barley and that that same land may not be suitable for the fattening of cattle. I may be told by some speakers in the usual cynical way that "if that is so why not allow these farmers to grow oats and why not allow them to grow barley?" It may be a very good thing economically for the country as a whole to have oats produced on land that is best suited for oats and have barley produced on land that is best suited for barley and yet it may not be economically possible for the farmer to grow that oats or barley. I think that the House should consider the effect of making it possible for these landholders to do what is best for the country even though, for the time being, it may not be best for themselves.

Again we know that there is more wealth produced in tillage than in grass. Figures have been produced here before showing the food value of tillage as compared with grass. It was pointed out here that, taking the average tillage farms where you have so much oats, barley, potatoes, swedes and mangolds, the production of human food from that acreage was a good deal higher than the production of human food from grass. The practical farmers in this country know that in order to keep their land in good condition it is necessary, in practically all cases, to do tillage. In some land, what is known as the light tillage land, it is necessary to till oftener than it is in the case of land in the heavy grazing districts. In fact, in the case of this light tillage land when it is laid down into grass it does not remain in good pasture more than five to six years, after which it becomes necessary to till again. Again, if you compare Denmark with this country—it is the old comparison—we know that in Denmark they have 63 per cent. of their land in tillage, while in this country we have only 12½ per cent. tilled. Along with that, however, we find that in Denmark the output per agricultural worker is £196, while in the Free State it is only £96. That calculation is made after allowing for subtraction from the output of the amount of imported feeding stuffs that came into both countries.

I think that we should continue to till our land, because there is no use for the grass that will replace that tillage, considering the fact that the number of cattle that we have in this country has been steadily declining. We do not want any more land under grass at present to feed the cattle we have, but we do want more land under tillage in order to produce human food and animal foodstuffs that are required for this country. The farmer who is growing oats for sale is a very unpopular man in some quarters at present, but, at any rate, there are some farmers doing it. We have been told on other occasions that we should let the farmers do what they have been in the habit of doing and not ask them to change their farming economy. That farmer who is growing oats for sale is at a serious disadvantage. He is growing oats without any subsidy and he is trying to compete with oats coming to this country, oats that have been subsidised by the Russian Government or by the German Government. It is not fair to expect that that man should continue in the business he is engaged in. He should be helped out of his difficulties.

Another matter that is closely related to this is the question of imports and exports. The President, in speaking here yesterday, drew attention to the very good position of this country in having our adverse trade balance reduced. That would be a very welcome thing if it had been reduced by our importing less of the materials that we could produce here for ourselves, and by exporting more of the goods that we have been advised by the present Government to concentrate on for the foreign markets. But it is not so. As a matter of fact, our exports for the nine months up to the end of September last, the last returns we have, have increased by the very small sum of £193,000. But against that £193,000 we find that the exports of tractors and tractor parts have increased by 1½ million pounds. I suppose the Government will claim that it was their policy that brought Messrs. Ford to Cork. Probably they will. But if they had not succeeded in that policy, and if Messrs. Ford were not in Cork our exports would be down by 1½ millions. That shows that it is not through our agricultural policy that our exports have increased.

As a matter of fact, there is only one item in which our agricultural exports have increased. That increase has been in the matter of cattle. That has been increased by over £1,000,000. But the number of cattle that we have exported for the first nine months of this year, as compared with the exports for the corresponding nine months of 1929, has been increased by 72,000. I do not know if it is a good sign, or a sign that we have turned the corner, when we come to examine where these cattle came from. If any of us were watching the farmer who had, say, ten cows, and who was selling yearly ten yearlings at the fairs, and if in one particular year we found that that farmer had brought ten yearlings and two cows to the fair as well, we would say that that farmer had turned the corner, but it would be the corner into bankruptcy. That is what has been happening in the matter of this export of cattle.

We have increased our cattle exports by 72,000. After the first six months that export was increased by 36,000 as compared with last year's, and we found last June that we had 104,000 less cattle than in the previous June. That shows that we have increased our exports of cattle at the expense of the stock of cattle in the country. Included in that return of 104,000 cattle was 6,000 cows. If our farmers are compelled by economic circumstances to reduce the adverse trade balance by exporting their cows and leaving themselves with less stock to produce butter and young cattle in the coming year, it is hardly a matter for congratulation. We can hardly be congratulated upon the fact that we have reduced the adverse trade balance in that way.

We find that in the matter of finished product that our exports have decreased. If we take butter, bacon and eggs, we find that the three finished products produced by the small farmer who is going to get so much sympathy from the other side have decreased. If we look over the exports in the matter of these three products we find that the amount has gone down by 1½ million pounds. Now in the same period—that is, in the 12 months from June, 1929, to June, 1930 —the number of acres under tillage in this country has been reduced by 64,000. From that one can see that the free trade agricultural policy of this Government has led us to the position of throwing more land into grass and having less cattle to eat that grass. We see that our imports for that period have been reduced. In order to get this big reduction in the adverse trade balance, not only was there an increase in exports which was very small, but a decrease in imports which was large, amounting to £2,846,000. The biggest decrease in that item came under the head of cereals. The biggest decrease under that head of cereals was in the matter of wheat. We imported a good deal less wheat not only in value but also in quantity. But against that we imported more flour. Again, we decreased our imports of barley but we increased our imports of malt. Even taking wheat, flour and bread together, we find that for nine months we have made considerable savings in these imports. That considerable saving was made in quantity, apart from the price altogether. We did not grow any more wheat at home. We imported less for the nine months, and whereas our people were able to consume fourteen loaves in 1929 they got only thirteen loaves in 1930.

We have been told here by the Minister for Industry and Commerce—and we believe it—that the people who consume most bread are the very poor. If a man has any money to buy food the first thing he will do is to buy enough bread. If, therefore, people have bought less bread than in 1929, it must be the very poor people who have bought less bread and the only explanation is that they could not pay for what they wanted. We have reduced our adverse balance in two ways, first by getting rid of our dairy stock and cattle and, secondly, by leaving the people in the position that they cannot purchase their food requirements.

Of course there will be objections to this motion and I am quite certain that the Minister's old objection will be again brought forward—that it pays a man to produce grain for himself, but it can never pay a man to produce oats and barley as a cash crop. The Minister said that last year when maize was coming in at 8s. 8d. per cwt.; he will say the same now when maize is 5s. 2d., a difference of 3s. 6d. If that is the position, it must cost more than 3s. 6d. a cwt. to market oats in this country. Surely there is something wrong and something the Minister should have investigated before now in order to give the producers of oats and barley, who grow those commodities as a cash crop, some assistance. He should have made some effort surely to ease the position for them.

We will be told that we should advise the farmers to feed their grain to their own stock. There is not a farmer in the country who needs that advice if he could afford to do it. The advice, when it comes from the Minister or any member of Cumann na nGaedheal, is entirely gratuitous. Any farmer who can do it has been doing it for the last seven or eight years and he knows he is doing well on it; but we have to deal with the farmer who cannot do that. We know there are farmers who, when they produce oats and barley, have to sell the grain in order to pay their debts. They may owe money to the Land Commission, rates to the County Council, sometimes bank debts and sometimes shop debts. They have to pay those debts out of any money they may get for the grain. There may be farmers who can get over that difficulty, but them they may not have sufficient storage for their corn. Not every farmer has a large loft capable of keeping oats and barley so as to tide him over the winter. Even if a farmer had his debts paid and had sufficient storage, he might not be able to afford £150 or £200 to buy cattle to consume the grain. Even if a farmer could bring home the cattle he might not have a house to bring them into. Various difficulties of that sort confront men who grow oats and barley and these difficulties have not been met by members of the Government who talk glibly about a man feeding oats and barley to his own stock. Let us not waste time with such advice. Just consider the position of the man who is anxious to grow oats and barley but cannot do so.

It may be said that the quantities of oats that came into the country last year could not have made any difference in the price as the total amount came to only £30,000. Whatever the quantity was, it does not make the slightest difference; it is the question of the price that really matters. Would any Deputy in the habit of buying oats be prepared to buy Irish oats at 13s. or 14s. a barrel, knowing that at any moment within a week or a month, several cargoes of Russian or German oats would come in at a much lower price? It is the possibility of foreign oats coming in at a lower price that keeps the price of Irish oats down. I do not believe the quantity has the slightest influence on the matter.

Oats is a raw material, and we are advised that we should not tax raw materials. I hold that oats is the basis of a very important industry. Any Deputy who examines the agricultural output of the Saorstát in 1926 will find that the production of oats amounted in value to £4,950,000, almost £5,000,000. This industry is a most important one, as will be realised when that figure is taken into consideration. It should not be brushed aside by merely saying that oats form a raw material and must not be taxed.

We are told that it is right for the farmer who grows oats to feed them to his stock. Is it not just as reasonable to say that it is right for the farmer who wants to feed his stock to grow his oats? If he does that, a prohibition on oats coming in will make no difference to him. We will be told that the small farmer, especially in the West of Ireland, will be hit badly by this proposal. I do not know how, and I am hoping to find out. According to returns of the amount of oats grown in each county in 1926, the three counties mentioned in particular as likely to suffer under this scheme—Cavan, Galway and Mayo—are within the first eleven counties described as oat producers. Seeing that the amount of oats produced in the Free State is barely sufficient for our needs, I think that if we get three counties included in the first eleven as large growers, we can assume that they are at least producing sufficient for their own needs. These small farmers are the very people who sell a certain amount of oats after the harvest in order to pay their debts. They are the people who have to sell oats in order to pay their annuities, rates and shop debts; they have not bank debts as a rule.

If the prohibition of foreign oats has the effect of raising the level of the price of Irish oats here, it is going to benefit the very small farmers about whom we hear so much. The only oats these men buy as a rule is seed in the spring. Generally the man who sells oats sells more in quantity than he buys back in the spring for seed, and if we raise the level of prices he will benefit by the scheme. In any case this motion only refers to barley and oats. The price of barley and oats as feeding stuffs cannot go higher than the general level of other feeding stuffs. As long as we have not tackled the problem of maize, pollard and bran, the price of oats or barley to the consumer cannot go up very much. The only people who may suffer are those who have to buy oats, who cannot buy any other substitute, but they are not found amongst the small farmers. I would remind Deputies that there are other clauses in the motion which will have the effect of compensating small farmers who produce bacon, butter and eggs.

The motion next deals with barley. The value of our imports of barley and malt in 1929 amounted to £350,000. The value of the total production of barley in this country is £1,145,000. It is by no means an industry that should be neglected. But I want to speak particularly about malt. For the nine months of 1930, as compared with the same period in 1929, the imports of malt increased in value from £118,000 to £244,000. So far, I know of only one objection put up to the prohibition of the imports of barley, and that is that the brewers here require a certain proportion of foreign barley in order to make stout for export, it being necessary for the keeping quality of such stout. It is on that account we put in the proviso "except under licence." If these brewers have a good case to make they can make it before a competent tribunal, and if they can convince that tribunal, no doubt they will be allowed to import a certain amount of barley. But the import of barley should stop at that. I do not know any reason why malt should be allowed in. Surely we have people here who are able to make malt. We have the stores and the men, and we also have the barley grown here, so that there is no reason at all why we should allow malt to be imported.

Under the heading of both barley and oats a question may arise about seed. I think any Deputy who has been taking an interest in the Agricultural College in Glasnevin, and who has been following the experiments carried on there, will agree that those in the College are capable of producing and breeding good seed oats and seed barley, and that there is no reason why we should be paying so much money, especially for seed oats which are in no way superior but, in fact, are probably very much inferior to the oats we produce ourselves.

Coming to the next heading, the imposition of an import duty of 20s. per cwt. on all bacon and other pig products, it is hard to see why foreign bacon should be allowed in here in free competition with our own bacon, considering that we have a surplus for export. If we were to take over the home market for bacon we would still have about £4,000,000 worth of bacon for export. At present bacon valued for over £1,500,000 is coming in. There is no reason why the bacon producers here should not have their market enlarged, by giving them the market represented by that £1,500,000, as well as the market they have already in Great Britain. No reason can be advanced against the prohibition of foreign bacon. This foreign bacon is dearer, but it is not as good an article as the home product. By exporting our own bacon and importing a certain amount of foreign bacon, we are paying all the expenses of transport, handling, as well as those of the wholesaler, the retailer and others between China, America, Great Britain, Poland and Ireland. However, we recognise that the people of this country have developed a taste for a certain kind of bacon, and therefore we say immediate prohibition would not be fair, or perhaps feasible, but by giving notice both to the producers and the curers, that after 18 months the prohibition of foreign bacon would take effect, that would enable them to produce the pig and to have the bacon cured in the way the people desire.

We go further, and say that all meats coming into the Free State should be marked legibly with the name of the country of origin when exposed for sale. Meat is a most important food, and a certain amount is imported. So far we have taken no trouble to see that that meat is marked with the name of the country of origin. Only yesterday the Second Reading of a Bill was passed here, ensuring that people who drink port wine will get the genuine article. We think that people who eat bacon are in every way as important as people who drink port wine. If we go to the expense of inspecting meat that leaves the country, so as to ensure that it is in good condition for the foreign consumer, we should, at least, have as much consideration for home consumers, and see that no meat will enter the country unless it is inspected and found to be in good condition.

Under this motion the price of Irish bacon to the consumer cannot increase to any extent. Even when we confine our market to our own produce, we will still have a surplus for export, valued for about £4,000,000. The price of that bacon that we export to the foreign market will be regulated by the general world price of bacon in the foreign market to which it is sent, whether Great Britain or elsewhere. The people who export bacon from this country will get a certain price for their product in Liverpool or in London, and the price here will be fixed relative to that, allowing for expenses of transport, and so on. The price of Irish bacon here will not be increased to the consumer. To the producer this scheme will probably bring a small advantage, because he will have a bigger market than he has at present. If he has a market at the present time for five and a half million pounds worth of bacon in Great Britain, and if, in addition to that, we throw open to him the market here, worth one and a half million pounds, he will have a bigger market for his products, and he will either increase production or he will pick the very select part of that market for his own products. The price of foreign bacon will probably increase under this scheme, although there does not appear to be any reason why it should, considering that it is a good deal higher than Irish bacon at the present time.

Paragraph 4 deals with prohibition of imports of butter. There seems to be a growing belief that it would be a good thing for this country if all imports of butter were prohibited. A number of speakers, including the Minister, have expressed themselves more or less in favour of that. I do not know if it is necessary to go into the matter very deeply, if it is not going to meet with any opposition. As regards condensed milk, we have good equipment and the raw material to turn out any amount of condensed milk. We had condensed milk factories, and some of those who worked in those factories are now idle. We do not see why we should import condensed milk when we can produce it for ourselves and employ our own people.

With regard to eggs, the amount that comes into this country is small, but there is no reason why we should import any at all. We do not know what is in this liquid egg that is coming in. We do not know the country of origin or what is mixed with the egg or anything else. These liquid eggs are put into confectionery, which is consumed by the innocent people of this country.

The objection raised to these proposals is this: if we confine the market, say, for butter, to our own produce, what are we going to do with the rest of the supply? In his statement on Government policy yesterday, the President said we were exporting from this country £4,000,000 worth of butter and that we must continue to export that amount—that we must continue to export half our production in butter. The book I quoted before—the Agricultural Output of Saorstát Eireann— traces the output of butter, where it was consumed and so on. It shows that a certain amount of butter and milk was consumed by the rural population of this country, a certain amount by the town population, and a certain amount exported. A curious feature of those figures is that if the towns-people in this country had consumed per head as much milk and butter as the people in the rural districts did there would be none for export. So that if we must continue to export half our butter production, as the President stated, that is due to the fact that our town population is not eating as much butter or drinking as much milk as the people in the country are; and nobody claims that the people in the country are using too much butter or milk. The same thing applies to poultry and to eggs and the converse applies to mutton, sheep and lambs. If the people of the country could afford to eat as much mutton as the people of the towns did in 1926, we would have no sheep, lambs or mutton for export, and I do not know that anyone will claim that the people in the towns have gorged themselves with mutton. The Minister stated on one occasion that the home market for these commodities was negligible. The fact is that the home market is negligible because our people cannot afford to eat enough. We are advised to produce those articles for the foreign market and that we will eventually defeat our competitors in that market. We are up against the whole world in the British market for butter—not only the European countries but Canada, New Zealand, Australia and now, perhaps, a more serious rival still, Siberia.

We are advised that we shall beat all those competitors in the foreign market and, on the other hand, we are told that we cannot compete against the grain growing countries in our own market. If that is so—if we cannot protect ourselves in our own market— where does our fiscal autonomy come in or what is the use of it? It is admitted, I think, that for the last twelve months, at any rate, we have been producing butter at a loss to the producer and yet we are advised to continue to produce that butter for competition in the foreign market while we have land here suitable for grain growing which we are advised to leave derelict and not attempt to compete against the foreigner in our own grain market. We were told yesterday that we had a benevolent Government which saved this country from going into a wheat scheme. In saying us from going into a wheat scheme, they led us into a butter scheme which ruined this country and from which there is no going back. There is nobody on the opposite side who will claim that there is going to be a recovery from this butter position. They cannot foresee any future for the butter industry and no one will claim that there is any future for it. All that they can do is to throw it back at us that they saved us from a wheat, barley or oats scheme, but at least if we had gone into these commodities we would be growing them for our own market, a market that we could regulate and pay the producer for his cost of production. Four years ago butter was selling at 180s. per cwt. It is now selling at 122s.—that is Irish creamery salted butter—on the London market, I give that quotation from the "Irish Trade Journal." It is the price on the London market. What does the farmer get out of that? He gets 95s.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy say what is the cause of the decline?

Comment on this

It does not matter what the cause is, but the Government led us into that scheme of competition on a foreign market where we have no redress, instead of encouraging us to grow for our own market where we could regulate the price and pay the producer for his cost of production. To go into the cause would only lead to an academic discussion. It does not matter what the cause is. If we follow the Government policy for the last nine months, what has it led us to? In the case of bacon and pig products that we export, they decreased in quantity by 20 per cent. and in value by 22½ per cent. In the case of poultry—I am dealing with the finished products—they decreased in quantity by 11 per cent. and in value by 14 per cent. Eggs decreased in quantity by 2 per cent. and in value by 18 per cent. As regards butter, with all our Dairy Produce Acts and so on, we have succeeded in increasing our export of that commodity by 4 per cent., but the decrease in value has been 17½ per cent.

That is the Government policy—increased production for the foreign market, where the more you produce the less you get. You are competing on that market against countries all over the world. We are going in for increased production of all these commodities while we find that the price for them is being driven down on the British market. We are told to compete against those countries, to run our heads against a stone wall, at a time when we are getting less for our commodities. The advice that we have given is: "Turn your eyes on the home market," and if you produce an article for the home market, whatever it be—barley, wheat or oats—we can at least make a law here that will regulate the price of that article and give the producer what is due to him for producing it. But what law can you pass here that will compel the British people to pay more for their butter, eggs or bacon? That is the difference between the two policies. I have no doubt whatever that when the Deputies on the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches, who have been talking to the farmers of this country during the recess about the foreign goods that have been coming in here, who have been telling the farmers in Leix, Offaly, Kilkenny and in other places that the only hope for this country is protection for agriculture, come up here to vote on this motion they will see things in a different light and show that they do not believe at all in agricultural protection. We will see, at any rate, what they will do at half-past ten to-night. I do not intend to say anything more now except formally to move the motion.

Comment on this

I second.

Comment on this

I welcome this motion. It provides an opportunity for a debate on this question of the improvement of agriculture by tariffs or prohibition. Deputies will have the opportunity here of debating the question freely, and I hope, sensibly. This House is the only place, I think, at the moment where that question could be debated freely or sensibly. There has been an attempt made to stampede the farmers of the country into the position that they are going to be relieved by this policy of tariffs or prohibitions. The farmers of the country are not yet educated enough into the realities of the position, and that is one of the reasons why I am pleased that the debate is taking place in this House. Of the four heads with which the motion deals, I propose to take the third. dealing with bacon. The consideration of the others will arise on the debate on the bacon question. The Minister for Agriculture, I think, fully and fairly explained the case for bacon and for other products in his recent speech at Carlow.

Comment on this

But the Cumann na nGaedheal farmers did not agree with him.

Comment on this

The Minister dealt so fairly with the question that to a large extent the leader of the Opposition, Deputy de Valera, agreed with him. Referring to the question of bacon, the Minister for Agriculture said that neither import duties nor prohibitions would benefit the farmer, because there was an export surplus, and that there would be no increase in price in the home market. I agree. So, apparently, does Deputy de Valera. The Minister also contended that there would be no increase in production because of tariffs, that the increase in home sales would be balanced by the reduction in exports. Deputy de Valera said that this was a demonstrable fallacy, and he proceeded to demonstrate the fallacy by saying that there would be at first a reduction in exports, but if the price of bacon allowed a margin of profit, that there would be an increase in output. Everyone, I think, agrees with that. He forgot, however, to tell us why there should be an increase in price to the farmers because of a tariff. I am quoting from the speech that the Deputy delivered at the Ard Fheis in Dublin.

The Deputy said the producers would increase their output until they could provide the needs of the home market and have a sufficient surplus to supply the demands abroad. If the price showed a margin of profit there would be an increase in production. I ask Deputies to mark the words, "If the price showed a margin of profit." The Deputy did not tell us how or why there should be an increase in the profit to the farmers. He forgot to tell us that. If there is a surplus, as there undoubtedly is, in the production of bacon, and if the farmer, say, at the moment has a market for the home supply and for the British market, and if for this 1½ millions extra of the home supply which the proposer of the motion proposes should be tariffed, and that imports of foreign bacon to this amount should be prohibited, what happens? You transfer the farmer's market for the portion of that commodity he exported to the local market. The Deputy does not agree with me that that is what happens.

The farmer's position, to put it in a very plain way that any honest farmer can understand, is, say, that at present he produces three pigs. One is sold in the home market and two go into the foreign market. There are two men in the public market buying pigs, one for the English market and one for the home market, and the home man who is buying the pigs pays the same price as the man who is buying them for export. Deputy de Valera's argument appears to be that instead of exporting two pigs and keeping one, if we kept two and exported one, that would change the position of the farmer altogether, but the position is that you have as before two men buying, one for the English market and one for the Irish market, but the man who is buying for the home market will not pay 1d. more than the man who is buying for the export market. He would be a fool if he did, and I think there are very few fools in this country amongst the commercial community.

Comment on this

Is it in order for a Deputy to deal with a speech that has not been delivered in this House, and which I have not read?

Comment on this

I pay Deputy de Valera the compliment that his address to a great gathering in this city has at least been read by the prominent members of the Labour Party. As far as I am concerned, and I believe so far as the majority of Deputies in this Party are concerned, there can be no possible increase to the farmer because of the imposition of a tariff on bacon. Deputy Ryan in dealing with his motion made several statements in reference to bacon, but he did not make the least attempt to prove, or to show in any way whatever, that there would be any increase. Talking of bacon he said we could enlarge the farmer's market by giving him an extra home market. To enlarge his market does not necessarily mean that that is going to increase his price. Deputy Ryan as far as I know did not follow up his argument by proving how it would enlarge his price. He said: He will either increase his production because of that or collar the select portion of the market. He can do either of these things now. He can increase his production if he is satisfied with the prevailing price, which is in fact the British price. That will not be altered one whit by the imposition of this tariff or by prohibition. Neither Deputy Ryan nor Deputy de Valera has argued that the price will be altered by the imposition of a tariff. The only thing Deputy Ryan suggested was that the farmer could collar an enlarged market. He can collar that now. There is nothing to stop him from doing so. He can increase his production now if he is satisfied with the prevailing price received in the British market. There has been no argument put up that the price of a pig on four legs, irrespective of the price of the bacon, could be in the least improved by the imposition of this or any other tariff. I defy any Deputy on the opposite side to get up and prove that it can be. Deputy de Valera in quoting the Minister for Agriculture said further——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

It would be better to deal with the speech made in the House.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy read the whole speech.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Oh, no.

Comment on this

If the Deputies like it I would not mind doing so. He said that we dare not permit outworn economic theories to intimidate us in our task, and he suggests that we should set up some kind of tribunal to buy oats and barley from the farmers and sell them to those who need them for consumption at a profitable price, so that the proposition Deputy de Valera made at the Ard Fheis was that the Government in office—I hope it will not be our Government—should start buying oats and barley from the farmers at an augmented price that is going to make it clear to them that they will have a profit for the growing of them, and which they (the Government) could re-sell to their neighbours at an economic price. Very sound finance is all that I can say about that. I hope somebody will devise the means of putting it into operation. I cannot conceive any means of doing so. Take the question of oats. Deputy de Valera said that in relieving the English market of the amount of bacon that would be needed to supplant foreign bacon in this country, and consequently reducing the quantity in the British market by so much, that the quantity would be so infinitesimal that it could not possibly have a reaction on the British market. It could only absolutely bring about the same reaction as the small quantity of oats which comes into this country could have on the position of the oat market, and we are asked to put a prohibition on the small quantity of oats that comes into this country—a quantity so small that it is insignificant and could not possibly interfere with the commercial price of oats in this country. No argument has been made, or could be made, that it could interfere with the current price of oats in this country, and the Minister is asked to step in and stop the importation of oats. We can all stand up in this House and make vague statements to the farmers, statements that we know are inaccurate and can carry no weight.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin says "Hear, hear!" I hope Deputy Davin will go down the country and tell the farmer that the stoppage of the small quantity of the Russian or German oats that come into this country will make any material difference to the price he gets for his oats. I hope he will go down the country and preach that to the farmers and prove it to them.

Comment on this

It is not necessary, as your own colleague did it.

Comment on this

Did you read Deputy Gorey's speech?

Comment on this

Yes, and other speeches, but they did not influence me one whit. Speaking of oats, Deputy Ryan suggested that as long as we did not touch the problem of maize, oats do not matter, and in that I agree with him. As far as Deputies on this side of the House and, I hope, the Executive are concerned, there is no possibility that we would touch the price of maize. Deputy Ryan thinks that oats do not matter.

Comment on this

I do not like to have that attributed to me, that oats do not matter.

Comment on this

I took Deputy Ryan as saying it. The report will verify it. I took Deputy Ryan as saying that as long as we had tackled the problem of maize, oats do not matter. If he did not say that I will withdraw it. If he stands by that statement it does not matter. I hope the Executive will never be persuaded to tackle the question of maize. If there is going to be any increase in the production of bacon or pigs in this country it will be because of two reasons, either because of the increase of the price in the English market or because we can produce pigs more economically than we have been producing them. One of the ways by which we can produce them is by cheap feeding, and the cheaper maize and the other products become the cheaper we can produce bacon. I do not believe the farmers of this country who rear pigs and feed them on maize, with the addition of barley, perhaps, and other little things such as potatoes, will stand for a tax put on the main raw materials for their product. I am quite content to leave that in the hands of the farmers of this country as far as maize is concerned. Deputy Dr. Ryan tells us that if we did not tackle maize, then we need not tackle oats.

Comment on this

You are going further now. Surely I said we should tackle oats.

Comment on this

Does the farmer in Mayo or Roscommon want a tax on maize; does the farmer in West Cork want a tax on maize, does the farmer even in Limerick want a tax on maize?

Comment on this

On a point of order, is the Deputy discussing the resolution?

Comment on this

Not quite, I apologise, but Deputy Dr. Ryan made a particular point in this question we are discussing of oats that if we do not tackle the question of maize we need not tackle oats.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I take it that maize is an agricultural import, and is relevant to this resolution. If we stray no further from this resolution this evening than to talk about maize the Ceann Comhairle will be very much surprised.

Comment on this

I hope when the debate goes further some of the Deputies on the opposite side will get up who have been quoting outside the benefits that will accrue to poor farmers for whom a stranger might assume there was no sympathy in this House beyond the Opposition Benches. We heard last night the President's statement; we heard the wails of sympathy; some of the Deputies were moved to tears almost at the position of the unfortunate farmer. There appeared to be on this side of the House no sympathy for the farmer, and yet possibly on this side of the House there are a greater number of independent farmers than on the other side. We, who are making our living by farming, have no sympathy for farmers, but Deputies like Deputy Lemass, who is making his living in the city, have every sympathy for the farmer!

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Would it not be better that we should discuss agricultural products rather than Deputies?

Comment on this

I am sorry, but Deputy Dr. Ryan even went out of his way to taunt us with want of sympathy for the farmers. We do not go about proclaiming our sympathy for farmers; we are ready when the time arrives to help farmers in a sensible and a logical way. We do not want to bamboozle the farmers by proposing motions which in our hearts we know to be unsound, and from which we know no conceivable relief to the farmer could possibly come, and in this set of resolutions, from start to finish, from the question of oats, barley, bacon, and all the other items, with the possible exception of butter, there can be no relief. I think Deputy Dr. Ryan will possibly quote me as imitating the Minister, that I am taking my cue from the Minister. When I say a possible exception, I do not take my cue from the Minister or from Deputy Dr. Ryan. There is the possible exception of butter. It is one of the only articles the farmer produces in which, for three or four months, there is no export surplus. There are three or four months of the year when the farmer does not export butter, and there is just a possibility that interference would increase trade for these three or four months. In other words, putting in a prohibition might help the farmers. To my own mind it is very doubtful, but I would not have any objection to seeing it put into effect. I think the results will eventually be very doubtful.

I have no doubt whatever about the result of the other proposed tariffs. There might possibly be some results from the prohibition of butter imports during the winter months. If we to-morrow, the day after or next week impose a prohibition, what would happen? It would almost inevitably raise prices and possibly there would be increased prices for butter this winter all over and some of the creameries in the country who hold up their stock would get better prices. The milking season is over, and the farmer would not materially benefit by it. There is a possibility of some good coming from it, but if we put in force the prohibition of butter what is to happen next winter? We have got to look before we leap or leap and look long. What will happen? There may be more butter held up than we can consume in this country, with the result that in March and April there will be put on the market an amount of cold storage butter which will have to enter into competition with the freshly produced grass butter and be sold at a loss. I am not saying that is certain to happen but there is the danger of it happening and it is one of the dangers of rushing hot-headed into any scheme of tariffs in farming. It is the one possible exception in that there is not an export surplus all the year round. No matter how our opponents polish their arguments this side, that side, upside, downside, they cannot eventually argue that the price to the home producer will not be regulated by the export article. The resulting price to the farmer for what he produces if he is producing a surplus will eventually be regulated by the export of the exportable article. There is no other conceivable way out of it as far as I can see. It may be that our intellect is deficient, that we cannot see two sides to any story, but to me it appears conclusive that there can be no possible advantage to the farmer from any imposition of tariffs. If as this debate goes on some enlightened Deputy on the other side gets up and proves to me conclusively that there is going to be an immediate or prospective increase to the farmer for the goods he produces because of this tariff I may alter my mind with regard to it. At present I do not see my way to do it. I do not think any Deputy is going to prove it to me. Six or ten months hence prices may for some other reason have gone up here and there. The prices of butter, bacon and many other commodities may jump up 50 per cent. during the next six months but if they do it will not be because of tariffs; they will jump up, if at all, irrespective of tariffs. It is a question of supply and demand.

It is a question for us, however little or much we may like it, of the demand in our neighbouring country, England. As far as the farmers' produce is concerned at the moment, England is our only market and the price that England is content to pay us will be the best price that we can get for our produce. If that price is good enough and economically sound enough to make it profitable for us to produce more we will produce more.

As regards bacon, the price will now and then be greater. Possibly there is no other farm produce the price of which varies so much as that of pigs. It is possible that in a few months' time the price of bacon will be much better than it is now. If a tariff was put on bacon at the present moment possibly it would be used as an argument then that the price of bacon had gone up, but it would have gone up irrespective of the tariff. It is almost certain that the price of bacon will be better than it is at the present moment and it will be better because the price in the English market will be better. No tariff or no prohibition of foreign imports that we can set up will make it better. The price will and must be governed by the export price. The same thing applies to eggs and other produce. Eggs are not mentioned in this motion, but Deputy Ryan, I think, said that the farmer could get a bigger price for his eggs in the local market than he could get in the export market. I deny it. The small farmer or the big farmer who would enter into the huckster business and bring his eggs from door-to-door might get a better price, but to do that he has to put himself in the position of a huckster as well as that of a farmer. He would not get a better price in the local market than in the export market. Agriculture will be improved in this country when the position of agriculture in other countries is improved. The farmers of this country are hard up at the present moment. There are difficulties in every branch of their business, but there are greater difficulties in the position of the farmer in any other country and I use the word "any" deliberately.

I had a good deal of experience of Canada many years ago. I get the Canadian papers and I know that the position of the farmer in Canada is much worse than the position of the Irish farmer. I have not seen where any Deputy in the Canadian House has preached that the farmer in Canada is down and out, or that the country is down and out. A number of years ago when I was in Canada, we had a period of the greatest depression in Canadian farming. Wheat was selling at half the present price, and the position with some of us was almost hopeless. I remember a farmer saying to me, and it left an impression on me that has still remained: "It looks as if we are down and out, that we cannot go on, but I tell you, and you will live to see it, this is going to be a hell of a great country." It was that spirit that made Canada, the spirit of the men who said, "this is and must be a great country," and not the spirit of decrying our country, and saying that we are down and out. Our financial position, thank God, is sound; our credit is sound. We stand at the moment, I do not say half-way up the ladder, but at the top. Our position is such that some of the greatest countries in the world—England and others —envy us. We are in the position that a country like Australia, which is so often quoted in debates, would give much to be in. Australia has been quoted as one of the countries that have been saved by tariffs. What is the position of Australia? The farmer's position in Australia is lamentable, and because of tariffs what has happened? The Australian loan is at 80, and if Australia wanted to borrow money to-morrow to help the farmer or anybody else, they could not borrow at much less than seven per cent., while our credit at the moment is so good that we could almost certainly borrow at four and a half per cent. There can be no question whatever that there cannot be any material gain from the imposition of a tariff or prohibition on the import of farming products into this country, with the one exception of butter, and that is problematical, and perhaps a small other item which Deputy Dr. Ryan mentioned, condensed milk. Except for these two there is no possibility, as far as I can see, that tariffs would benefit the farmer one way or the other, and I hope that Deputies in this House have intelligence enough to reject the motion.

Comment on this

As nobody else wants to speak, I do not want the motion to fall through. They say that fools rush in where angels fear to tread. I suppose I am a fool on this occasion, because I know nothing whatever about agriculture, but I think the great question as regards tariffs is whether tariffs are going to benefit a minority at the expense of the great majority. I also think that the proper place to discuss tariffs is not in the somewhat heated atmosphere of the Dáil but in the Committee Room where experts will sift any evidence that is put before them and then come to a conclusion. It is quite conceivable that tariffs on agricultural produce may be wise. I also think that there are some years when a tariff is good on an agricultural product and other years when it is bad. The Minister for Agriculture seems to have definitely set his face against any tariff on agricultural produce. In fact from the way he speaks the word tariff with him is like a red rag to a bull. He is definitely opposed to tariffs in an established industry such as agriculture. On the other hand, apparently he is in favour of tariffs to establish industries here, as I presume he must have consented to the tariff on boots which has given employment to a few hundred people at the cost of the great majority of the country. Free trade and tariff reform has been a subject that has been discussed on several occasions. I remember once discussing the matter with a professor of economics who was a great free trader. The subject was before England at the time. He told me that if he got on a tariff platform he could make as good a case for tariff reform as he could for free trade.

The first part of this motion asks for an embargo on oats. This morning I was speaking to a very prominent miller. He told me that his firm had been looking for 10,000 barrels of oats locally for the purpose of making oat-meal and that so far he had been only able to get 4,000 barrels of oats that were suitable for that purpose. It may be a bad year for oats—I do not know whether the rain affects oats or not—but that is a fact. Barley is a subject I know less about than oats, but I would not like to do anything which might interfere with the brewing industry here. My information is that the brewing industry gave a very fair price for barley this year—£7 or £7 5s. per ton. I cannot vote for the Motion because I prefer that this question should be investigated by the Tariff Commission and I hope that the Tariff Commission will be able to report in a short time and not keep us waiting as they have done on previous occasions.

Comment on this

Deputy Bennett was so good as to concede that we were right in at least one item. He has practically admitted that butter is one of the commodities on which a tariff or prohibition might be useful. Butter production is one of the fundamental industries of our country, whether it be butter produced by the farmer or by the more up-to-date method of creameries. The butter produced by the farmer is greatly in excess of that produced by the creameries—the quantity would be about three times as much. We are really a sort of large factory for the production of fat. We produce beef, butter, bacon and eggs. For the production of beef we depend altogether on the creameries and on butter production. If the price of butter falls, either on the home or foreign market, there is hardly a doubt but that store cattle will become scarcer and therefore the price will become higher. Butter production also affects the pig industry. It is fundamental to that industry.

The present system that we adopt in order to produce all these fats is one of importation. We practically import the greater part of what is fed to the animals. In one case, that amounts to £4,000,000, and the total would be something around about £11,000,000. The object of this motion is to try and change that, and have the farmers of this country, who have suitable land for the purpose, producing those foodstuffs as far as possible. Some of us, of course, are convinced free traders. We cannot see any hope whatever in tariffs. But when we consider the position of the greater number of countries, especially agricultural countries, we find that they are highly protected countries. Here we have been brought up under the wing of a country which is pre-eminently free trade, and I daresay on account of that many of us are more or less traditional free traders—buying in the cheapest and selling in the dearest market. I believe, however, that we ought not to allow that to impress us unduly. Because England is free trade it does not follow that we should be free trade. England's principal means of income was industrial production. Our principal means of income was agricultural production, in order to feed the workers in England. We were compelled to produce exactly what was wanted in England, and also to produce it at exactly the price they wanted it there. We had not then any power to develop even the smallest portion of a home market; in fact, we did not know we had one. Now when we have an opportunity of developing a home market, and making use of the different resources that we have, I see no reason why it cannot be done.

There is not the slightest doubt that large counties like Wexford and other counties cannot rely on the system of dairying or of feeding cattle. The land there will not long remain out of tillage. If it is left for any undue length of time it grows moss, whereas the land in Co. Meath is peculiarly suitable for the feeding of cattle, because it does not grow moss and will remain out of tillage. If we do not agree to help production in such counties as Wexford and other counties which are not able to follow what is generally pursued, we are wrong. I think that these counties should get a fair opportunity. I am quite sure that men from Wexford will admit that their county is peculiarly suitable for the production of grain—both oats and barley. Not alone that, but there is a tradition there. If it was not suitable for that purpose, it would be at present engaged either in dairying or in the production of beef, but it is quite evident that the people, through their own experience, discovered the fact that that county and other counties like it were suitable for that purpose and that purpose only. What I want to know is: Are we giving the people of these counties a fair chance? Have they as fair a chance as the people of other counties? Really, from the point of view of the industrial organisation of the country, Co. Wexford, so far as means of communication is concerned, is almost as far from Meath and Westmeath as Buenos Aires. It is a much simpler process to get Indian meal into the Co. Meath than to get barley from Wexford. It is necessary to have that matter developed before tariffs could become a success. Inter-county trade must be developed through a saner outlook on the question of transport. It has to be dominated, and if it is not the railways will become useless. That is a preparation for this question of tariffs. Tariffs would not have a fair trial except under these conditions.

If we take the County Limerick, for example, it is a pre-eminently dairying county. It has been that for years past. It was not the dairying scheme that made Limerick a great dairying county. It has a tradition in that way. Limerick does not till very much. The people of Limerick have been accused on and off of doing more or less the same as the people of Co. Meath— taking it easy.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Dairying is not taking it easy.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

They have been accused of that.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Not except by Meath men.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

It is quite possible. At any rate, Limerick does not till much, and has perhaps the densest cow population in any country, denser even than Denmark. Limerick does not go in for winter dairying. Why? Winter dairying is more expensive, and naturally the price of winter-produced butter must be something in excess of the ordinary price. Foreigners, having discovered that fact, have come in here in such strength with their butter that at times they have actually lowered the price of winter butter and made it cheaper than the summer production. I think that that is definitely a case where a tariff on butter would be useful. I think that hardly anyone in this House could disagree with that. I firmly believe that that is the case— that they are in a position any winter to keep the price of butter lower than it is in the summer.

As regards a tariff or embargo on oats, that is a commodity which is grown in every county. Galway, Mayo, almost all counties grow it, but in different counties they have different methods of using oats. For instance, Galway and Mayo sell earlier, and they have reasons for that, because before the general threshing there is a fairly good price, and they buy in what they want later. But they have another reason. Generally it is rather difficult for them to store oats. Rates went up on barns and places like that, and the farmers found it cheaper to pull them down than to pay the rates on them. It is a question of storage with these farmers. They cannot easily store their oats, and so on account of having it a little earlier than others they sell it and at a later period buy oats in. They are users, to a large extent, of foreign feeding stuffs.

The County Cavan is another highly developed county, and produces an enormous amount of oats. It buys a great amount of foreign produce, and I believe that the farmers in that county buy it because there is no industrial machinery. There is nothing to assist the farmers from other counties transferring their surplus grain into that county; there is no encouragement for them to do so because the foreigner, being highly industrialised, puts in his commodities in very handy bulk. There is no danger of its heating or anything else. It may be got any day of the week, and has not to be taken to the mill. We have made no endeavour yet to attempt to commercialise barley and to put it on the market in that condition. And if people have made any attempt such attempts have been largely thwarted by the position of the railways. We ask for tariffs upon these commodities not for the purpose of making the farmers rich men or that they might be able to put money in their own pockets. What we really want is to stabilise the farmer's industry in order that at this time of the year he may be able to say to himself: "I shall sow five or six acres of barley and five or six acres of oats because I understand the Government have taken steps to prevent imports from Russia or East Prussia."

The Minister told us that it was only a matter of £35,000, and he is right. But that makes not the slightest bit of difference. What the farmer is afraid of is that it might become any day of the year £350,000. He has no outline; there is not the slightest indication of security. What we want to do is to give him some indication of security. We want to tell him that Russia or Prussia will not be allowed to come in here and put some impediment in his way. He will have a tariff which will give him a chance of cashing his oats if he wants to cash them. We do not want to grow all oats to sell for cash; it would not do, and if we wanted them to do it they would not do it. But there are certain districts in certain counties where they must sell. The custom and general routine and the land conditions are such that they have to sell oats and other grain as a cash crop.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Why not alter the custom?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

Because the land is suitable for that purpose only.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

The land would not allow them to buy a sow?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Reilly

Certainly that may happen. It is on behalf of such men that I, certainly, urge that some form of protection should be given, that something should be done to prevent foreigners from dumping huge quantities of food supplies into this market. I believe we have the greatest opportunity of any small country of becoming self-contained in that way, but, of course, we have not developed that industrial instinct that other countries have developed. But that will come; it must get encouragement, and we must try and bring back in some way confidence to the farmer. We have admitted it at times, and we have shown that oats can be grown here. I believe we ought not to allow the impression to grow abroad that it cannot be done. From time to time it was sought to be proved that we could not do it. It is now sought to make us throw up our hands and say we cannot grow wheat or barley, and even now it is sought to make us say that we cannot grow oats. I think it would be a pity to say that, because although the Argentine and other countries are producing Indian corn very cheaply, it is likely that they will produce at a much cheaper rate, but it is just as likely that they may not produce at all. We have no guarantee.

It would be well, as we are a fat-producing country, to take some steps to guard against being cut off in any way from foreign supplies, because we cannot supply these commodities ourselves in a year or two years. There is certain machinery necessary for the production of these things that we must keep in order, and not let them fall into decay. So I think it wise that this question of oats and butter—others may make a case for barley—should be seriously considered.

Butter production is all-important so far as the cattle and pig trades are concerned. It is only a matter of considering how we can supply what the Minister for Agriculture calls the raw material at an economic price. Under no conditions can I imagine our being able to produce any of these commodities within the reach of the price of Indian corn, which can be produced even cheaper than its present price. Its supply can, however, also be cut off, and there is nothing at all impossible in a falling away in that supply. As we are engaged in this particular industry, it would be wise to guard against any untoward incident of that description, and, above all, to keep our machinery in repair, and try to give the people of the country portion of that eleven millions which is almost altogether transferred to other countries.

Comment on this

I have listened to two speeches from the benches opposite, and they were made, I suppose, by the only two practical farmer Deputies who are likely to address the House from those benches. I must, however, confess that to me they were very disappointing speeches. I, at least, thought that the Deputies opposite would argue their case before this assembly, and I did not think that both would be satisfied with begging, as they have begged, the only question at issue here. Deputy Dr. Ryan told us that there should be tariffs on agricultural goods as a set-off against tariffs on industrial goods. That, however, is begging the entire question, because the question which they have set themselves out to prove is this, namely, that a tariff on those commodities specified in the motion is going to be of advantage to the farming community. That is what they set themselves out to prove, or rather should have set themselves out to prove, and that is the one thing which they have made no effort to prove. They have assumed it from first to last.

There was one thing which struck me very much in Deputy Dr. Ryan's speech, and that was his frank and fair admission that the policy which the Minister for Agriculture has been preaching in this House and outside is a sound policy for Irish farmers to follow. The Deputy admitted frankly that the policy of growing as much grain and other feeding stuffs as possible and feeding them to stock on one's own land is a wise policy for the people to pursue. He said, however, that that was a policy which every farmer could not pursue because he had not the capital. So, let us limit this discussion, or, rather, let us recognise that the discussion is limited, to this, namely, a discussion as to what should be done to assist farmers who have not enough capital to farm their own land in a proper way. That is what Deputy Dr. Ryan limited this discussion to. He admits that the policy of the Minister for Agriculture is the correct policy for those who have sufficient capital to farm their own land, but that it is not a policy for others because they have not sufficient capital.

We have no figures before us as to the numbers who have not sufficient credit to get capital, because it appeared to me that Deputy Dr. Ryan's speech was entirely one for further facilities from the Agricultural Credit Corporation. He has not, however, explained to the House how those farmers, whom he talks about, and who, he admits, ought to change their methods and grow corn, not as a cash crop but for feeding purposes, can go before the Agricultural Credit Corporation to borrow money to farm their land properly. It is gratifying to have an admission from the Deputy that the agricultural policy adopted here is a sound policy for the country. Now I come to look more narrowly into this motion. The first thing it deals with is foreign oats and oat products. We have heard a good deal of talk from Deputies on the opposite benches on the question of oats. Deputy O'Reilly told us that it has been said that we cannot grow oats. No one ever said that. No one said that we ought not to grow oats. No one ever said that the growing of oats should not be encouraged as much as possible, but that is the growing of oats for home consumption.

Deputy Dr. Ryan said that we have five million pounds worth of oats in the country and that only £35,000 worth is exported. That £5,000,000 worth is not marketed. That is the total estimated value of oats harvested, and of that a very trifling portion goes on the market. The market in this country for oats is naturally very small and restricted. Who can buy it? The miller for oatmeal, but who else? A few horse owners, comparatively few, because horse owners who do not till themselves, and who have not their own oats are not many, and a few farmers who have not grown as much oats as they require themselves. It is obvious that the market for oats in this country is very restricted. The Deputy wishes it to be thought that the price of oats would go up to an enormous extent if foreign oats were not imported. He wishes the farmer to believe that, and that if an embargo is put on oats the price will rise substantially for his benefit. He knows, as he must know, perfectly well that the amount which comes in is trifling and cannot affect the market to any great extent. He knows, as he must know, that an embargo upon oats will have no appreciable effect upon the price of oats in this country. It is exactly the same when you come to deal with the imports of feeding barley, because I take it the Deputy would allow in the imports of brewing barley. These are trivial things which cannot matter one way or the other. They cannot affect the market one way or the other, as the amount imported is too trivial. When we come to bacon, however, we come to a very important question indeed, a question to which, without any argument and, so far as we can gather, without any inquiry, the two Opposition parties in the House have tied themselves. They propose for a time an import duty of 20/- per cwt. on bacon and total prohibition after eighteen months. Deputy Bennett was right when he said that the price of bacon would not affect to any real extent the price of pigs to the farmer if you put a tariff on bacon.

You have got to prove in the first place that your tariff on bacon is going to increase the price of the pig. No attempt has been made to do so. The price of the pig to the farmer will always be regulated by supply and demand and, as Deputy Bennett pointed out, there is a large export of pigs from this country. It is the joint demand which will go, together with the supply of pigs available, to fix the price of the pig to the farmer. There is nothing to show that a tariff on bacon will increase the price of the pig to the farmer. On the other hand, we know that at the present moment we export to a very large extent the very high quality bacon. We also export the secondary class of bacon, but the bacon which comes in here, the bacon for which large sums are paid, is a lower grade of bacon, ordinary American bacon, which is the main food of the small farmer and of the workmen in the country towns. You are going to put upon that a tax of something that will be about 2½d. per lb. You are putting up the price of what has become a staple article of diet for the poor farmer, the small farm labourer and the workmen in the towns. You are doing that without any enquiry of any kind. You are deliberately attacking the weakest and most defenceless section of the population, and you are putting up the price, or wish to put up the price, of a staple article of diet for the persons who can least afford an increase, a substantial increase, in their cost of living.

Deputy Dr. Ryan declared that we were the most free trade country in the world. He went as far as to say, or if he did not certainly Deputy Murphy did, that we were opposed to tariffs and were a free trade Party. We are not a free trade Party. As a matter of fact, long before Deputies opposite came into this House, while the Deputies opposite were wandering in the wilderness outside, tariffs were imposed by this Party. These tariffs have been very useful indeed. In fact, the paper run by the Party opposite, instead of being a Fianna Fáil organ, has recently become a Cumann na nGaedheal paper, because week after week it is showing the success of the Cumann na nGaedheal protective policy. Our view, though, is that tariffs are dangerous things. A tariff may be a two-edged sword. A tariff must not be imposed without very, very careful inquiry. It is for that purpose that we have set up our Tariff Commission. We have set up that Commission so that every possible matter shall be taken into consideration before a tariff is imposed.

Deputies opposite are pretty frank in their policy. They say: "We will tariff every single article that comes into this country. We will tariff them indiscriminately, except such ones as are totally prohibited." That is really the policy that was announced from the Fianna Fáil Benches to-night. Allusion was made by Deputy Bennett to what is happening in Canada and Australia. He was challenged as to the accuracy of his facts. I happen to have here in my hand a cutting from to-day's paper dealing with the result of the Australian fiscal policy. It is a protest by the primary industries of Australia against the existing system of tariffs there. By the primary industries are meant graziers, sheep and stock breeders, wheat producers and fruit growers. Therefore, you may take it that the primary industries, as they describe themselves there, comprise the agricultural industries of Australia. The industries represented by the petition have accounted for more than 95 per cent. of Australia's total exports for the last ten years for which figures are available. The points made by the petition are:—

(1) Successive Australian Governments have increased the cost of production by means of high tariffs, subsidies, bonuses, guarantees, artificial industrial legislation. (2) Interference with shipping and high taxation. This policy has reduced the purchasing power of the £ sterling to the stage when it is impossible for any unassisted industry, primary or secondary, to carry on profitably in competition with the industries of the world. (3) The incidence of the Australian tariff policy on primary industries is peculiarly malevolent in that, being imposed in the interests of manufacturers, it taxes the requirements of the primary industries, raises the cost of living, and, therefore, the cost of service to these industries. As it restricts imports it necessitates higher freight charges on exports. The primary producers, that is to say the agricultural community, have to sell their products as to nearly half the total production overseas, at world prices, and, therefore, cannot pass on the price to the consumers. The petitioners urged a complete revision of the tariff policy.

That is followed by the signatures of different members of the organisation. So there in one country it has been shown that the indiscriminate and unwise use of tariffs can do an infinity of harm to the agricultural community. What do we find here? We find a certain Party, and possibly a smaller Opposition Party in this House, coming forward with a demand for indiscriminate tariffs, and with the assertion that tariffs must always and in all circumstances be wise and beneficial. If that is not their policy, what can be the objection to the policy that we have always put forward, the policy that a tariff should not be imposed until the case for and the case against its imposition has been carefully examined by an impartial tribunal?

Comment on this

I wish in the first instance to contradict the statement which has been repeatedly made in the Press, that this is a Fianna Fáil-Labour motion. It is a private member's motion, put down in the ordinary way, to which I have appended my name, and which I will give my reasons for supporting. I think it is far more honest for Deputy Ryan and myself to come into this House and back, in the only place where we can do so in an effective way, the demands which are contained in these proposals, rather than to go out in the country in the way some of the Minister's colleagues are doing, initiate these demands, and then come into this House and refuse to vote for them. I hope the Minister will take that as a satisfactory explanation from me for appending my name to this proposal. Deputy Bennett had the audacity to state that the farmers of this country were not educated enough to understand the implications of these proposals. I wonder will the farmers of Limerick, whom the Deputy claims to represent, congratulate him upon having made that statement?

So far as my own support for industrial tariffs is concerned, I have been very careful always in the House and outside it, and so have other members of the Labour Party, to make clear that tariffs alone are not going to make any great contribution to industrial development. The imposition of the boot tariff and other tariffs that could be named is quite sufficient to prove that statement. The failure of these tariffs to bring about the result which we all hoped for is due to the fact that Irishmen with money did not put their money into these industries. It is also due to the failure of the Government to make it certain that there would be a guaranteed market in this country for any article produced by a tariffed industry. We have made it clear always that any assistance given by this House in the shape of tariffs for the development of industry should carry with it a guarantee for a decent minimum wage to those employed in these industries. We differ with both the Fianna Fáil and the Cumann na nGaedheal Party in this matter, and, therefore, the Minister need not take so much delight in thinking that we and Fianna Fáil are as near to each other as he seemed to think.

The Census returns, apart altogether from the knowledge that Deputies have of the position in their own areas, prove that during the past eight or ten years there has been a considerable rush of the population from the land, from the rural areas into the towns and cities. There has been a rush out of the country altogether in the case of people who could find the means of getting out of it. That is mainly due to the fact that the people who found greater and more remunerative employment on the land up to the last eight or ten years are not now willing to remain on the land any longer, simply because they cannot make a decent livelihood out of it. We have also the information supplied to us by the Government returns that there has been a reduction in the acreage of land under tillage to the extent of 365,000 acres between the years 1921 and 1930. Assuming that the wealth production of that land when under tillage is £10 an acre, and assuming that out of that £10 there would be paid in wages the sum of £4 per acre, we have the fact that the amount paid in wages under that head alone would be equivalent to £1,460,000 a year. That is the loss in wages to Irish labour, and that loss is due to the fact that the land has gone out of tillage and is now in grass.

I would like the Minister, if he accepts these figures, to inform the House to what extent employment has been given on the 365,000 acres now under grass as compared with when it was under tillage. Has he any information at his disposal which would educate Deputies on that matter? The amount of £1,460,000 in wages—assuming that these figures are accepted as approximately accurate—would mean a loss of employment to 22,462 agricultural workers at 25/- a week. From the labour point of view that is a very serious matter. There is no possibility, as far as I know, of the people who have been deprived of their employment on the land securing alternative employment in the towns and cities.

Taking paragraphs (1) and (2) of the motion as it stands on the Order Paper, our position in regard to these particular proposals is that we propose, as we have already proposed, that a National Grain Control Board be set up and that that Board should have the right and power to fix the price, regulate the supplies, and to guarantee to the grain growers of this country an economic price for the grain they produce. That is my reason for supporting these two proposals. I hope, if the proposal is acceptable, that the necessary legislative steps will be taken, as they would have to be taken, to set up that National Grain Control Board.

A good deal of emphasis has been laid upon the proposal to impose an import duty of 20s. per cwt. on bacon and other pig products. Strange as it may appear to the Minister, that proposal and the proposal of prohibition have been put forward in the midland part of the country by Deputies who sit behind the Minister on the Government Benches. I attended the Conference convened by the Farmers' Association some time ago. At that Conference certain Government Deputies were present. I clearly recollect one Government Deputy, now behind the Minister, proposing that we should take steps to prohibit the import of bacon into this country.

Comment on this

I did not propose it.

Comment on this

If there is any difference between "proposing" and "supporting," the Deputy can have the benefit of it. At any rate, the Deputy concerned proposed that for the purpose of developing agriculture it was desirable that imports of bacon should be prohibited. The proposal appeared to me at the time to be rather a drastic one. I could plainly see, under the existing conditions of the bacon-curing industry, that the people who would happen to get a monopoly as a result of that proposal would be very likely to fleece the Irish consuming public, who would have to buy Irish bacon, if they bought any bacon at all, in preference to the bacon now being imported. The proposal to impose a duty of 20s. was put forward for the purpose of diverting the minds of the bacon-consuming section of the community to the fact that they can, if the bacon-curers of this country have any common sense, get Irish bacon in this country which will be as good as any bacon imported.

There may be a possibility that the price of imported bacon, consequent on the putting into operation of that proposal, would increase, but that would be all the more reason, and a very good reason, at any rate, during the short period such a duty would be in existence, for the Irish public to buy their own bacon in preference to the imported bacon. I admit, from what I have been informed on this matter by people who know more about it than I do, that Irish producers are not putting Irish bacon on the market at present in such a condition as would induce the poorer sections of the community to buy it. I believe that between the date of the imposition of a duty of 20s. a cwt. on bacon and June, 1932, that steps should be taken and legislation enacted which would help to reorganise the bacon-curing industry, and make it obligatory on bacon-curers to put on the home market the quantity and the quality of Irish bacon which would be equivalent to what is now being imported and purchased by our own people.

It is claimed by the Minister for Justice and by Deputy Bennett that the imposition of this duty and the adoption, in June, 1932, of the policy of prohibition would not increase the price of the pig to the farmer or the price of bacon to the curer. I hold the opinion that the new demand which would be created in the Irish market by the adoption, in June, 1932, of the policy of prohibition would certainly help to increase the price. I hold that a reorganisation of the industry on national and co-operative lines could make it possible for the farmer pig supplier in the future, under a reorganised industry, to get a better price for his pig than at present. The Minister, I am sure, will not argue that the bacon-curing industry is at present carried out on sound economic or national lines.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

An army of officials under Deputy Davin might help to improve matters.

Comment on this

I do not want to bother myself at this stage about Deputy Gorey's interruptions. Probably Deputy Gorey will explain later on in greater detail, so that it can be permanently on the records of the House, what he meant by a recent speech made in his constituency. Perhaps he will tell us his reasons for turning his coat inside out on these and other matters. The Deputy has turned his coat several times already, and he has found himself wandering into different benches in the House and from one Party to another. It is really difficult to know with what Party he is associated or what he stands for. In a recent speech in Carlow the Minister said that we would probably be getting a bigger price for our Irish bacon if our supplies were larger. Why are our supplies not up to demand in the export market? Is it due to any failure on the part of the people in the bacon-curing industry or is it due to failure on the part of the pig feeders and suppliers, or both?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

It is due to the prevailing prices.

Comment on this

At any rate, the Minister agrees, under certain circumstances, that there would be a better price for bacon in the export market if supplies of the right quality were obtainable.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Yes.

Comment on this

I take it that the Minister would also agree as a consequence that that would have an effect on the Irish bacon in the home market.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

No. I do not see the connection.

Comment on this

Probably the Minister will give an explanation later. I confess that unless and until we set up the Food Prices Control Commission that has been recommended, there is a danger of the possibility of an increase in the price of imported bacon. I believe we will be more than repaid for anything that may be done in that respect by the putting into force of legislation which will help to reorganise the bacon-curing industry, which will help to give more employment to people in that industry, and which will tend towards better prices to the farmers for their pigs. There will, I believe, be a demand for more pigs both for this country and for export purposes.

I do not think anybody will argue against the demands put forward in paragraphs (c) and (d) of the motion. I feel sure no one questions the necessity for taking legislative steps to enforce these particular proposals. The answer to these proposals so far is that we have now a permanent Tariff Commission which can examine the implications of all proposals of this kind. Up to the present, applications for tariffs, either industrial or agricultural, have been made by representative bodies of people engaged in a particular industry. When a proposal for an admixture was put before the Government, the Minister is aware that certain questions were put to the people who sent in that application asking them to what extent they represented the people engaged in grain growing, how many branches of the Grain Growers' Association were in existence, and how many members belonging to each branch were associated with the applying body.

The unfortunate thing about the farming community in this country is that they have no really sound organisation for industrial purposes. As a Labour Deputy, I will welcome the day when the farming community has the good sense to organise for industrial purposes. When that day comes the Minister, Deputy Bennett, and similar people, will have far greater respect for the opinions and demands of such bodies than they would seem to have at the moment. Whenever demands have been made by the farming community for measures which would be likely to develop and protect the agricultural industry, the people making them are told that they do not represent the farmers. It would seem that there is no organisation in existence which could claim to represent the farming industry.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Cumann na nGaedheal.

Comment on this

God help the farmers.

Comment on this

As far as I know, the Cumann na nGaedheal organisation consists of the principal graziers of the country, who, no doubt, approve of the Minister's policy in allowing into the country imported foodstuffs so that they can get them at the cheapest possible price.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The Deputy does not know much about the organisation.

Comment on this

I am not aware that there is a branch in existence in my constituency and, therefore, I might not know much about it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We are not discussing the Cumann na nGaedheal organisation.

Comment on this

Apart altogether from the merits or demerits of the proposals on the Order Paper, I had hoped that the discussion upon them would be carried out in a non-party spirit, that there would be no necessity for dragging in questions of party into a matter that should be free from party prejudice or bias.

Comment on this

You are a very innocent man.

Comment on this

Perhaps Deputy Carey will tell us how many acres of land he tills. I believe that in supporting these proposals I am speaking for a considerable number of small tillage farmers in my constituency. I support this motion because I am convinced the proposals it contains will help to put agriculture on its feet. I believe it will help to maintain, and increase, the acreage of land under tillage and thereby give employment to a greater extent than is being given under the Minister's present policy. The fact that 365,000 acres of land have gone out of tillage is proof of the inaction and the bad policy of the Government. We are entitled to know what steps the Minister proposes to take—if he proposes to take any—to prevent a further large acreage going into grass, thereby causing additional unemployment with consequent misery and poverty in different parts of the country.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I do not know that I am entitled to take part in this debate. My name has been frequently mentioned, however, in connection with these proposals. I am in the position that I cannot vote for or against the motion because of certain arrangements that have been made. The fact is that I happen to be paired, and, that being my position, I cannot and will not vote. I do not know if I am entitled to take part in the debate, but I will chance it. Deputy Davin is apparently very much concerned about land going into grass. Before I proceed with my speech I will make a suggestion that might help the Deputy. If he does not want the land to go into grass, the best way to prevent it is to put an embargo on all grass manures and so prevent them being imported or manufactured in the country. The use of grass manure is one of the reasons why there is so much grass in the country. To suggest that we should not have any bone manure or fertilisers would mean that there would be less grass.

With regard to this motion I would like to draw attention to the fact that it is only three or four weeks since this new programme, embodying half a dozen demands, has been adopted. Twelve months ago we had the great blending scheme. Up to three or four weeks ago that scheme held the floor. We heard nothing about it to-day, and there is not a word about it in the motion.

Comment on this

It is under consideration.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

We can get anything from £7 to £7 10s. per ton for barley to-day. We can buy maize at £4 10s. to £5 a ton. Because of that we have not heard a word about the blending scheme. The sails are trimmed to suit every breeze. The attitude is changed every day, so that what was good twelve months ago would not be considered good to-day. We find ourselves dealing with one class of motion to-day, while twelve months ago it was a different one. We would have had a different motion six weeks ago if the Dáil had been in session. We do not know whether these are the demands of the chief Opposition or of the Labour Party. Only three weeks ago bacon was put on the programme of the grain growers, and that was because Mr. McCluskey went into the Association, and his views swept the Board.

Comment on this

I think they had you, too, as regards bacon.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I will deal with that. I advocated a tariff on bacon five or six years ago, and I have never changed my attitude with regard to such a tariff. I want to explain my position now with regard to that tariff. Even though I am keener perhaps than anyone in the Dáil or outside it for a tariff on bacon, I am not going to stand for such a tariff without examination.

Comment on this

Examine it yourself.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

No. I do not care what view my colleagues or the Minister for Agriculture have. I have a distinct view. A tariff will be no good to me; it will give me 12 pence for a shilling. The English market as compared to the Irish market, is worth 12½d. as compared with 1s. in the Irish market. Unless a tariff on bacon means more production, and unless we are able to maintain our export trade, in addition to catering for the Irish trade, which is value for 1½ millions, an embargo is no good. If a tariff was put on, and if the response was not good, I would be the first to suggest to the Minister to revoke it. It would be no good to the producer unless we have the bacon value at present for 1½ millions produced in the country, in addition to what we produce for outside. Any other attitude would be the attitude of a fool, and would be dishonest. Cheap feeding-stuff here means cheap pork and bacon, and means that a profit can be made out of cheap foodstuffs.

A tariff on oats is of such little importance that I think it is not worth talking about. At the meeting in Kilkenny I did not know what was the extent of the import of oats. When I learned that for 12 months it only amounted to £30,000, an infinitesimal sum, I thought it was not worth talking about. Personally, I would not let one ounce of Russian oats or any Russian money into the country.

Comment on this

What about the Germans?

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I would let in the Germans. Comrade Cooney and Russia have no attractions for me. Nothing good comes from Russia. I would not put a tariff, but I would put an embargo on anything from Russia.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That seems to be the general objection to Russian oats. It is to Russia, and not to the oats, they object.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

The only thing that would enable us to compete with our rivals, and that has enabled us to do so for the last six months, is cheap feeding stuffs. If German or Russian maize was a serious competitor here with American and Argentine maize, then I would welcome it. Anything that makes our feeding stuffs cheap and that makes it possible for us to produce with profit is to our advantage. Any legislation that denies us that is cut-throat legislation. We have been able to carry on with profit during the last 6 or 12 months, which was the worst period the bacon trade of this country had, because of cheap feeding stuffs. The blending scheme has been abandoned now. Under the blending scheme we would have had to pay a price for barley which would mean that we could not produce——

Comment on this

On a point of personal explanation. I never said a word about the blending scheme since it was referred to the Grain Tribunal.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I know, but you are trimming your sails.

Comment on this

And so are you.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I am not referring to you; I am referring to other Deputies.

Comment on this

You will have to trim again when you go back to Kilkenny.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I never trim. What was claimed twelve months ago is abandoned to-day, and the same people will change in six months' time again.

Comment on this

You will not vote.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Imports are of no value to this or to any other country unless a profit can be made on them. If a profit can be made from imports they are a national asset. If the imposition of an embargo or a tariff on imports is so high as to make the use of home-grown grain and the tariffed imports an uneconomic proposition, that is, if a profit cannot be made on the use of the tariffed or home-grown foodstuffs, then tariffs would be a national curse and an embargo would mean national ruin. I do not think it needs much argument to prove that. What is the reason that the producer of home-grown grain is his own worst customer and, above all, is the worst producer of the finished article? He grows the raw material, the corn, but he will not use it. It may be said that home-grown grain is used in parts of the country, but it is only to a limited extent. The grain grower as such is not a pig feeder, or a cattle feeder. He does not feed young stock. He wants the State to set up machinery to take his grain to other parts of the country where the people are not afraid to do the disagreeable and dirty work, to feed pigs, calves and cows. Why does he not do it himself? There would be no freightage if he used the grain at his own door. These people want the Government to set up machinery to send the grain 150 miles away and to find customers. It is not customers these people want but victims, and they want to force the State to make the victims use stuff that they will not use themselves. The producer is either a fool or a rogue if he expects someone else to do a thing that he will not do himself. He is either a fool or a rogue who expects people to buy and to use grain at more than its economic value.

Comment on this

What is that?

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

What you buy the food-stuff for and what you have to sell the finished article at, that is what I call economic value. The worst day's work that has been done for home-grown grain was done by the Grain Growers' Association when they adopted the blending scheme. They de-graded barley to the level of foodstuffs.

Comment on this

The Grain Growing Commission has not yet reported, and I suggest that Deputy Gorey is trying to influence the Commission before they make their report.

Comment on this

He would not have any influence on them.

Comment on this

Perhaps he would reconcile his argument with the speech he made some time ago.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I will deal with that. That was largely in opposition to you and your friends, the anti-God crowd in Russia.

Comment on this

Clap yourself on the breast.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

With regard to the tariff on bacon, I want to explain my position. I stated in the beginning that if a tariff on bacon did not mean more production it would be of no use whatsoever. If there was not a sufficient response, I would vote for revocation of the tariff within a year or two years. I believe, however, that there is a chance of a response to a tariff on bacon. It is only a gambling chance. It is not anything like an even-money chance. It might be five or six to one, but the chance is there. Because the chance is there, and because I think a response would be given—not perhaps a hundred per cent. but an important percentage—I am prepared to take the chance. If nobody else will bring the matter before the Tariff Commission, the company with which I am connected will do so. I believe that if bacon is tariffed, or if there is prohibition of imports, the ordinary feeders will get a certain degree of confidence. What is more important still, the breeders—who in many cases are not the feeders—will have more confidence and will maintain the sow population. Without the maintenance of the sow population, we can never have high production in bacon. I believe that if you can induce a certain amount of confidence, and if the home market is placed at their disposal, the breeders will keep more sows and the feeders will feed some extra pigs. I know that the Irish market has been a steadier market than the English market for the last two or three years. It has unquestionably been a steadier market, and because of that steady market I see great possibilities of an embargo on bacon making it even steadier. The ordinary feeder, in my opinion, will produce somewhat more than he is producing to-day. It only needs a sixth or a seventh on what he is producing at present to fill the gap.

In addition, there are a considerable number of people who never feed a pig and who are largely consumers of American bacon. I believe that circumstances will force the majority of those people to feed sufficient pigs, at least, for their own use. Because the proposal contains all these possibilities, all these elements, not of certainty but of chance, I am prepared to urge it on the Tariff Commission and on the Minister. It might also induce those who are not feeders—the producers of corn, the people at the bottom of this agitation—to keep one or two pigs in the year. It might induce them to dirty their hands for once. It might induce their families to go with the times and it might pull them off the rock on which they were fixed one hundred years ago. Their attitude is: "We were tillage farmers always; our fathers did this before us and we will continue." That is the attitude of people I meet in the country. They will not adapt themselves to modern conditions. Because one man only got a certain price for pigs fifteen years ago, he never kept a pig since. He is a large producer of corn. These are the people we want to change, and we may induce them, of necessity, to feed a few pigs. I hope I have explained my advocacy of a tariff on bacon. That has been my attitude, and always will be my attitude.

With regard to the Russian oats, I think Deputy Cooney understands me, and I need not labour that question. There is no comrade whom I would not like to see standing out in the sea from the highest down to Deputy Cooney.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan Minister for Agriculture (Mr. Hogan) Cumann na nGaedheal

Deputy Davin asked me to say what is my policy in regard to bringing back into tillage 350,000 acres of grass. He is not entitled to be told that, because it is not my policy that is under discussion; it is the policy of the two principal Opposition Parties in the Dáil that is under discussion. The Dáil met, after five or six months' adjournment, yesterday, and the first motion that came in, signed by a front bencher of Fianna Fáil, Deputy Ryan, and by a very important Deputy, if I may say so, on the Labour Benches, Deputy Davin——

Comment on this

You can say it for the sake of argument.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

No. I am paying you a genuine compliment. Remember the circumstances. This is a very bad season. That is admitted. We are told that it has been a disastrous season. During the last three months, there have been Fianna Fáil and Labour conferences all over the country——

Comment on this

And Imperial Conferences.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Please do not interrupt. They have all met and considered the agricultural position. They have debated the situation, and have put up various proposals with the object of relieving the agricultural distress that exists at the present moment. There were five or six conferences, and they culminated, quite recently, in a joint conference in the Mansion House. After all that consideration, on the first day the Dáil meets we have this motion placed before us. I am not taking an unfair advantage when I claim that I am entitled to say that this is the policy of the two Opposition Parties for the relief of agriculture.

Comment on this

Are you aware that members of your own Party were in the Mansion House, and supported these proposals?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

It is extraordinary that Deputies on the opposite side seem to pay far more attention to what Deputies on this side say or think than they do to what their own members say or think. Whether that be so or not, there is no question that we are entitled to take this motion as the contribution of the two Opposition parties towards the relief of agricultural distress, which, they say, is extremely urgent and needs to be dealt with immediately. I think that that is a perfectly fair attitude to take up. We must take this as the best contribution they can make to this serious problem. I have, of course, a certain responsibility as Minister for Agriculture, and, year after year, and month after month, I am expected to produce new schemes out of a hat—schemes nobody need pay for—to relieve agricultural distress or help agricultural development. I am in a slightly different position now. We are supposed to have failed. The measures we have taken are insufficient, and here is the deliberate thought-out contribution of the two Parties opposite towards the solution of this urgent national problem.

Comment on this

Only part of it, and you know it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I will be glad to hear the rest of it. If it is anything like this I will be glad to debate it, but such as it is this is a considered attempt to deal in a big way, let us say, with a very urgent national problem. What does it amount to? Protection for agriculture. There are some extraordinary features about this motion. It deals with the imports of feeding oats and feeding barley, bacon, eggs and butter. When I look up the statistics I find that the total imports dealt with here amount, roughly, to £2,150,000. What about the real agricultural imports? What about the big items amongst agricultural imports that we used to hear so much about, especially from the benches opposite? We are told that protection of the home market is going to be the salvation of the farmers. But after the closest examination what protection are they going to give? Protection for £2,000,000 of the home market, and no protection, presumably, for the home market so far as wheat is concerned amounting to £6,000,000, and of feeding stuffs amounting to £4,000,000. These two items alone give a total of £10,000,000.

Deputy de Valera, no later than yesterday, stated that there were considerable agricultural imports into this agricultural country. He mentioned the figure of twelve or fourteen millions. That figure is the figure that is always mentioned. There are considerable agricultural imports, but it is never explained that these twelve or fourteen millions include one item of six millions for wheat and flour—that, roughly, is the figure—and another item of four million pounds for imported feeding stuffs. There you have a total of ten million pounds. After considering the whole position carefully, what does all this protection policy come to as set out here deliberately in this motion? It is concerned with two millions only out of a total of fourteen or fifteen millions for agricultural imports. Why is that? There was surely ample time to consider the merits of protection. The imposition of a tariff on wheat used to be a kind of King Charles's head with Deputy de Valera. We used to be told about all the maize that came into the country amounting to about £4,000,000 and about the cake substitutes for our own oats and barley. I had to listen to that for the last two years, but now after six months' consideration the two big items of agricultural imports amounting to £10,000,000 are thrown overboard.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

And on the first day of this Session a motion is deliberately brought forward by the Opposition Parties with a great flourish, with all the trumpets sounding, that is, to give relief to agriculture. When you look into it, what does it come to? It deals with three or four items that, in all, amount to about £200,000, and one item, bacon, which amounts to one and three-quarter millions. To cap the thing, the mover of the resolution gets up here and admits that even if the imports of bacon were taxed it would not increase the price which the producer receives for his bacon.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey contradicted me.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

As a general rule, I prefer Deputy Gorey's advice, but on the present occasion I agree with the Deputy. All these agricultural imports amount to about 2¼ million pounds. Take the one big item amongst them, namely bacon, and consider the attitude of the Deputies opposite. What is their attitude? It is this, that even if you tax these imports it will not increase by one penny the price which the producer receives for his bacon or his pigs. That is admitted. I ask the farmers of the country who are being deceived and rushed to note what all this protection policy for agriculture comes down to. Consider the debate that has taken place up to the present. There has been very much more time spent debating the question of oats than all the other items mentioned in the motion, and the value of oats imported amounts to £30,000. At the present moment, according to Dr. Ryan's figure, which I accept, there are £4,900,000 worth of oats in the country, and the value of oats imported amounts to £30,000. During the last three hours of this debate, at least two and a half hours have been given to this question of oats, and this is the tedious policy that is going to save agriculture at this time of acute depression. Deputy Ryan wasted a considerable amount of time in endeavouring to reassure the farmers as to the effects of a tariff on oats, eggs and feeding barley. It is rather curious to observe that there is no mention of beef or mutton in this motion, and we have some imports of both. My attitude on these tariffs is that they do not matter twopence.

On the figures that are available— figures which are available to anybody —and without having the benefit of an examination of the question by the Tariff Commission, I say that it would not make the slightest difference tomorrow to any farmer, be he a seller or a buyer of oats, a seller or a buyer of eggs, whether there are tariffs imposed on these articles or not. The value of feeding oats imported amounts to about £30,000, feeding barley to about £10,000, liquid eggs to £30,000 or £40,000, beef about £40,000 or £50,000. mutton about £30,000, giving a total for these imports of about £200,000. The export surplus in regard to these items in this country is over 30 million pounds. The two parties who put forward, at this stage, as a constructive contribution towards the relief of agricultural depression, that imports amounting to £200,000 should be prohibited in a country where you have an export surplus in these very items of £30,000,000 cannot be taken seriously. Bacon is one of the big items here in this motion. Deputy Davin, I could see, was a bit nervous about bacon. Everyone noticed that, I think.

Comment on this

About American bacon.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

About this proposal, and I do not wonder. I will be curious to hear Deputy O'Connell on this question of American bacon. He, like myself, comes from the west. He knows something about the conditions of the small farmers and about their economy, and I will be very curious to hear his views on a tariff on American bacon. I do not believe he is as enthusiastic, I will not say as Deputy Davin is, because his enthusiasm has obviously abated, but as Deputy Davin was. It seems to me that he is now becoming extremely doubtful about it, because he suggests the reorganisation of the industry. He thinks it is necessary for this prohibition to be imposed that there should be a reorganisation of the industry and that it should be followed by Governmental action in the way of compelling the bacon curers to produce a certain amount of bacon and, presumably, of compelling the retailers to sell at the old price.

I am satisfied, with Deputy Ryan and Deputy de Valera, that this tariff will not increase the price the farmer will receive for his pigs by one penny, or even stabilise the price by one penny. I believe, in addition, that it will increase the price of the low-grade bacon which the labourer and the farmer buy. Evidently Deputy Davin has some suspicion that I am right, because he suggests a control in price. I am not saying this so far as Deputy Gorey is concerned, but I am saying it so far as the people who brought forward the motion are concerned, what their policy comes to is: that if you leave out trumpery items, such as oats, feeding-barley, and liquid eggs, that for the sake of doing something and dislocating trade, we should without examination clap a tariff on American bacon, even though it will not increase the price by one single penny which the farmer receives for his bacon, and even though it requires a price fixing tribunal to control the price the poor man pays for his bacon. That is what the policy for the relief of agriculture comes to. I do not think I need argue the point that this proposal is not going to confer any direct benefit on the farmer by way of increasing his price, for that is admitted.

Comment on this

I do not admit that.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

It really does not matter.

Comment on this

No, but the Minister should not be making statements which are not correct.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Can you deny it?

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

You are alone. You will come to see the sense yet of that. The only point in the dispute is as to whether it will increase the price of the low-grade bacon which the poor purchase. Let us consider that for a moment. First, let me explain what I mean by low-grade bacon. It is low-priced fat bacon. Now, fat bacon is as healthy as lean bacon, and in fact healthier. There is a suggestion that imported fat bacon is diseased or unwholesome. That is nonsense. The only difference between the bacon the labourer and the farmer buy and the best Irish bacon is that the imported bacon is fat, and the best Irish bacon is lean. Do not let us discuss this as if the imported bacon was unclean or unwholesome.

Comment on this

Is it inspected?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

No. Everyone knows that American bacon is sound.

Comment on this

Does it come in with a certificate as to its fitness for use?

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Does a certificate go out with the Irish bacon?

Comment on this

It does.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Since when?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Sometimes a man working in the open has a preference for fat bacon, and as it happens that is cheap bacon, but I suppose there may be physiological reasons for that preference. That bacon will have to be supplied, if there is prohibition, by the Irish bacon curers, and what will happen is that the second grade Irish bacon will be taken over here from England and placed on the Irish market, and sold on the Irish market at the same price as could be got in the market in England, but at a higher price, in fact, than the farmers or labourers could have bought American bacon if it were on the market. The person who states that American is more expensive than Irish bacon is making a statement which is incorrect. It depends on the quality. Some of the imported bacon is of the same quality as the Irish. It is only the fat bacon which is less expensive than the lean Irish bacon, which fetches the highest price.

Comment on this

Surely at the present price the Minister does not suggest that it would be better to buy foreign than Irish pigs?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am not talking of the price of pigs. I am talking of the price of bacon, which is a different thing. I am stating that the quality of Irish bacon which is exported is higher than the quality of imported bacon. I am explaining that one is a low grade bacon and that the other is bacon which is used by rich people and there is a high price for it. I want to explain how it is, in my opinion, that the price paid for bacon by the poor here would go up even though the farmer received the same price for the pigs he sold as before the tariff was imposed. That would happen for this reason: A certain grade of bacon would be kept at home in this country and sold at the same price as in England— at the international price—but that price is, in fact, considerably higher than the price fat American bacon used to sell at. It is now admitted—No. 1— that it would not increase the price the farmer receives for his pigs, and— No. 2—it would increase the price the poor would have to pay for the bacon they like, American bacon, and American-cured bacon goes very much farther than Irish-cured bacon. The only case made is that it gives the farmer an extra market. I cannot understand that. The farmer sends his pigs, alive or dead, to the local market, where they are sold by scale to O'Mara's, Donnelly's, or Denny's. The price is the only thing he is interested in. It does not make the slightest difference to him whether the pig he has sold is consumed in Liverpool or Cork. He has not the slightest interest in that, and he does not care twopence about it. The price is the only factor that will induce him to keep more pigs. I think the way Deputy de Valera put it was that if the margin of profit is great enough more pigs will be produced.

What influences the margin of profit? On the one hand, the price of the finished article. That will remain the same. On the other, the cost of production. That will also remain the same, because that will depend entirely on the cost of the raw materials such as imported feeding stuffs or feeding stuffs produced on the farm. That would be only increased and thereby the margin lessened by any tariff on imported feeding stuffs. Assume that particular form of lunacy is now forgotten and that there is no question of putting a tariff on imported feeding stuffs, the margin of profit will not be affected in any way by a tariff on imported bacon, because it will not affect the price of the finished article and cannot affect in any way the price of the raw materials. Therefore, I cannot see why it is going to produce more pigs; I cannot as a farmer, and I am trying to think of it from the farmer's angle, see why it could.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

He will not produce one at all then.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The margin of profit that rules induces him to produce the amount of bacon that is produced at present. Nothing will induce him to produce more bacon except a bigger margin of profit, so a tariff will not affect that in any way, because it will not affect the price of the finished article and it will not affect the cheapness of the raw material.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Nothing will induce him to keep seven where he keeps six.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Unless there is a bigger margin of profit.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

He will keep six.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Speaking from experience of this country, the moment prices rise people go into pigs generally, but unfortunately too late, and every time prices fall they get out of pigs. In any case, we all have practical experience. We all know that it is if you like the price of the finished article or the margin of profit, as Deputy de Valera puts it. My point is there would be no inducement here. By reason of this profit there is the inducement at present that, even though the price of the finished article is small, the price of imported feeding stuffs like oats, wheat, barley, Indian meal and cakes is so extraordinarily low.

Now there will be a demand by the Irish market amounting to 1¾ million pounds if foreign bacon is prohibited. Will that demand be supplied if there is no inducement, by reason of the tariff to the farmer, to get more pigs? It will be supplied by withdrawing from the English market some of our six million pounds surplus and marketing it in Ireland. That is the only way if there is no extra inducement. Further, we are not short of an extra market. At present the British import £53,000,000 worth of bacon. I have not the slightest hesitation in saying that we can get exactly the same price for £9,000,000 worth of bacon that we get at present for the six we export.

Comment on this

Why do you say that?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Every bacon curer knows it. I will tell you why I say it. There are four or five houses handling Irish bacon in a big way in England at present. The same houses are handling Danish bacon in twice and three times the quantity. The price of bacon is ruled to a very great extent at the moment, not by the price of Irish but by the price of Danish bacon. When the big brokers meet every week in the markets to discuss the price of bacon, they do not dream of asking what Irish supplies are in; they ask what Danish supplies are in. These are big wholesalers not supplying customers but big organisations, chain shops, etc., who want to take big quantities week after week and who, if they do not take big quantities, will not buy in small quantities. I am assured by my own agents in London in the trade commissioner's office and by big wholesalers that if we had bigger supplies of bacon in the English markets possibly we could get a bigger price. I am assured of that also here on this side by representatives of two or three of the bigger houses on the exporting side.

Comment on this

It creates a slump when the market is flooded.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What Deputy Fogarty will have to learn is that business is not susceptible to simple analysis; it is a highly complex matter. In any event here is a market that absorbs £53,000,000 worth of bacon. Our bacon exports fluctuate year by year and have no effect on the prices of that market. As Deputy de Valera himself stated on a previous occasion, if the one and three-quarter million pounds' worth of foreign bacon were deflected to the English market it would not have the slightest effect on the English market.

Comment on this

Not Irish bacon.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am certain that two million pounds extra of our bacon would not be felt on the English market apart from the considerations I have put now.

Comment on this

Have you learned no lesson from the butter position?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I have. In regard to that there can be no doubt when you consider the vastness of the British market; there is over £60,000,000 worth of beef and mutton; over £53,000,000 worth of bacon; £54,000,000 worth of butter, and over £23,000,000 or £24,000,000 worth of eggs. There is not the slightest doubt about it, we could increase our exports to that market by £2,000,000 or £3,000,000.

Comment on this

Who is to blame?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am not on that. That is a different point, but we could increase our exports to that extent without bringing down the prices of our products in the smallest way. We have the market already, but we do not supply it. I will just quote one fact, and I ask is this denied? There is not one of the bacon-curers of the country who is not complaining week after week that he is not getting half his supply of pigs. There are people in the Dáil here connected with the bacon industry. Every single one of the bacon-curers are offering the same prices for twice the quantity of pigs, and they cannot get them. Is that denied?

Comment on this

What does that prove?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

It proves that they can afford to give the same price for a much bigger quantity and market it. There is no doubt about it.

Comment on this

A better price according to your statement in Carlow.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am not on that question. There is no question about it, the bacon-curers of this country, the exporters, can give the same price week after week, and are anxious to give it, for much bigger quantities of pigs. I know it from many sources, and know it from my own experience, and from the complaints I have received. Moreover, the position with regard to the bacon-curers at present is that they are carrying overhead expenses which are not warranted at all by their killings. Everyone who knows anything about the business knows that also. They are working at half-time, and carrying full overhead expenses. You can add 33 per cent. to your pig supplies, and not affect the price one iota. The proof is, bacon-curers are offering week after week the same price for twice the quantity of pigs, and are not getting them.

Comment on this

Would the Minister explain the reason that they are not getting them? Is it not owing to the present state of the farmers?

Comment on this