Public Business. - Safeguarding and Developing Agriculture.
Contributions 143–278 of 278. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I could explain 101 things, but I want to get to the point.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not admit that if the supplies were larger the prices would be higher and better?
Comment on this
I think I am making my speech quite soundly and clearly.
Comment on this
I am not running away. You think no one has the right to run away but you.
Comment on this
Anyway, it comes down to this: the settled and considered policy of Deputies opposite for the relief of agriculture is to tax imports amounting to about £200,000, at a time when we have in the case of these imports an exportable surplus of something like £30,000,000. That is supposed to change the farmer suddenly from his present depressed condition into a condition of comparative opulence. That is seriously put forward in the Dáil. Of the other item, 1¾ million pounds, does the Deputy want to increase the price to the farmers by one penny? I will take you into my confidence and tell you if you do not want to increase the farmer's prices that he will pay no attention to your policy. Farmers are simple in some ways, but they are very shrewd in others. When they look for better times they mean better prices and nothing else, and I agree with them. You cannot improve the farmer's condition unless you help him to get better prices. Any tariffs that do not get higher prices are ineffective tariffs.
Deputy Davin asked me for my policy. Deputy Ryan and Deputy Davin afterwards took me into their confidence and told me that they wanted an embargo on the import of foreign oats and oat products, and the prohibition of the import of barley and barley products except under licence. The object of this prohibition is to increase tillage and to make it economic to grow oats and barley. There is this one point that I want to make on that. I am asked how am I to bring 360,000 acres back to tillage. Deputy Ryan pointed out that there are certain areas in this country where the land is unsuitable for grazing and only suitable for tillage, and it is suggested that the policy which I have been advocating tends inevitably to compel people to give up tillage and to go back to grass. It is equally suggested that this embargo is going to induce people to go back to tillage.
Let us examine that point for a moment in connection with oats. Leave out of account, for a moment, that what your policy amounts to is a tax on £30,000 worth of feeding oats in a country which at present holds close on £5,000,000 worth of oats. Leave out that and ask what is your object. Your object is to make it profitable for the farmer to sell his oats. That is a simple statement. You want to get the farmer a price which would pay him for his oats. How do you propose to do it? You propose to tax his competitors so far as that import of oats is concerned. Suppose you have removed the £30,000 worth, are you prepared to go further? Are you prepared to tax Indian meal, to tax £4,000,000 worth of feeding stuffs, and can you improve the price of oats or any other grain which the farmer grows for sale to any extent unless you prohibit not only oats but all imported feeding stuffs? Obviously you cannot. A small proportion of the oats of the country is fed to horses. No other grain is suitable for horses. Apart from that, oats is simply in competition with every other grain for live stock, for the production of bacon, eggs, butter, beef and mutton. Three-quarters of the oats of the country would be used in that way. All these imported feeding stuffs have certain food values, and the price of oats will bear a definite relation to the price of these feeding stuffs, making certain allowances for the food value of each. No one would buy oats at the present moment even for feeding cattle at 10/- or 11/- a barrel when they can get Indian meal delivered in Dublin at £5 10s. a ton. So that inevitably, if you want to provide a paying price for the farmers' oats or any other grain, you must tax not only the imports of oats but all feeding stuffs. If you do not, what does your policy come to? It comes to this, that you are asking the farmers of this country to grow oats and take a price corresponding to the wholesale price of palm nut cake or Indian meal. That is what he must take if he is a seller. He must take the wholesale price, whereas the policy which we advocate in order to encourage oat-growing or barley-growing is a policy of growing oats not for the wholesale but for the retail price. If a farmer feeds his own oats on his land to his stock he gets ultimately the retail price on it, and a slight profit. If he sells to his neighbour he must take the wholesale price of the oats. The difference between the wholesale price and the retail price, of course, varies, but it is, roughly, 2/- or 3/- a cwt. So that as opposed to the policy of the Government you are offering the farmers wholesale prices for oats and we are offering them retail. That is what it comes down to. There are enough people in this country endeavouring to deceive the farmers for political purposes.
For the past three or four years we have consistently told the farmers in the grain growing districts, though it was not popular, that there is no future for grain growing for sale. We have told them that if you grow grain for sale you must accept the wholesale price, and that the wholesale price will have relation to the wholesale price of other feeding stuffs, unless you break down the whole economy of the country by tariffing all feeding stuffs. I do not care at this hour of the day to take any action which would deceive the farmers further. My position is quite simple. I know that no tax on oats will make any difference to the price. It might make a slight difference. If you take 200 points and have immediate prohibition of oats it might affect the price for a month in two of the markets, but it would not have the smallest effect on the other 198, and it would have no permanent effect on the two. So far as I am concerned, a tariff on feeding barley or oats makes no difference. The only effect of placing a tariff on oats and barley, so far as I am concerned, is to still deceive the farmer and to still induce him to go on with an economy which is completely unsound. It is an attempt to bolster up an economy which is completely unsound and which is rapidly disappearing, and which you cannot bolster up. That is exactly what I want to safeguard against. There is no doubt that this campaign which has centred on oats for the last six months has been waged with the definite object of deceiving the farmer. I do not want to be any party to that by any action that we take. So far as I am concerned, if the Tariff Commission had examined oats, eggs, feeding barley, beef and mutton, and if the examination did not reveal some positive harm which I cannot see at the moment it would not make the slightest difference if these tariffs went on. Deputies know perfectly well that the real meaning of this resolution is not on the face of it. It is in what is absent from it. You have been deliberately deceiving the farmers for the last two years in the case of agricultural imports and what can be done by protecting the home market. When you gave them figures you always quoted 17 millions which included wheat and imported feeding stuffs.
Comment on this
When you specified them you came to talk of Chinese eggs and Russian eggs, and raised up all sorts of subsidiary anti-Chinese or anti-Russian prejudices with a view to deceiving the farmers in an illogical way as to the amount of the imports. I would like to call that bluff, and my position about these tariffs is that they make no difference, good, bad or indifferent. It might be that to take the 30,000 liquid eggs the Tariff Commission will have to examine the question of whether any drawback should go to some confectioner who is using liquid eggs for exportable toffee. Apart from considerations of that kind a tariff would make no difference. As far as I am concerned, if the Tariff Commission had examined them fully and had shown that they would not do positive harm, it would not make any difference to me or to the farmers of the country, but I do not want, and I shall not allow if I can help it, the farmers to be deceived on the issue.
Now as to butter, I want to say one word on that before I sit down. It is to be examined by the Tariff Commission and I do not want to go into it except to say this: My objection to agricultural tariffs is that they do not help the farmer. If they did I would be in favour of them. When I speak of helping the farmer, I mean they do not increase his price. I regard any tariff which does not increase the price as ineffective. I think it is the only raison d'etre for tariffs, with very rare exceptions. Speaking generally, the business of a tariff is to raise the price, and if I could be shown that tariffs would raise the price of agricultural produce then I would be in favour of tariffs. It is because I am convinced, with possibly the negligible exception of butter and condensed milk, that you cannot, that I am against this policy of agricultural tariffs for reasons which I will give later.
With regard to butter, I am extremely doubtful, although I have looked at this question from every point of view, as to the effect of a tariff for this reason: It is, of course, an obvious case, because it is the only item in which there is a shortage of home production for a short time. That singles out butter from every other article. But when you come to think of what the effects might be— of course, it can have no possible effect in the way of increasing production; we would want an increase of 7d. or 8d. per gallon of milk to get winter milk—but when you think that it might induce cold storage on a falling market I am extremely doubtful, and I should like it to be examined in the fullest possible way by the Tariff Commission. I will not say more on that now. I just want to add this: Deputy Ryan said in the beginning that certain industrial tariffs had been agreed to by the farmers in the hope that their products would also be protected.
Comment on this
I think you did. Of course I will take your version. I understood you to say that certain tariffs had been imposed and that the farmers had imposed and that the farmers had agreed to them, and were hoping that their products would be also tariffed.
Comment on this
I think I repeated three or four times that the farmers may have agreed for selfish motives, be- cause the home market was there for them.
Comment on this
I accept that. The point is this: the farmers have not agreed to the tariffs put on—they have not been consulted. The object of this resolution is not to benefit agriculture. It is to dispense with the Tariff Commission in the first instance. Secondly, it is to impose immediately, and without examination, certain agricultural tariffs which admittedly will have no real influence for good on our agricultural position. Having abolished the Tariff Commission, having put on these negligible agricultural tariffs, leaving out the big items, we can then go on and place indiscriminate tariffs on industrial imports; that is the real object of it. That is the reason why I put it to the farmers and everybody who is interested in farming to stand by the Tariff Commission.
It is an extraordinary thing that there should be any Party in this country that would suggest that tariffs should be imposed, as Deputy Lemass practically said yesterday—whole-hog tariffs, to use his own felicitous expression—without any examination by the Tariff Commission. That is a most extraordinary attitude to take up in view of the fact that it is practically admitted that none of these tariffs can help the farmer in any considerable way. There is no doubt about it that the object of this is to dispense with the Tariff Commission, and go on to indiscriminate industrial tariffs. Who will pay for them? I gave figures showing our exports of certain agricultural products, and our imports of the same products, showing that our imports were absolutely negligible, while our exports were comparatively enormous. That is the agricultural position. Take the industrial position in this country. For my own information I made certain groups—boots, shoes, apparel, textiles, vehicles, and so on—and I took the imports and exports to see what the position there was. I find that the imports of boots and shoes into this country come to just £2,000,000, and the exports £700,000. There is no exportable surplus there. In fact, there is a shortage of over £1,900,000.
Comment on this
Seven thousand pounds' worth, and our imports are £2,000,000 worth. There is no exportable surplus there.
Comment on this
It proves this: That even if there were no exports we still need to supply the Irish market with practically £2,000,000 worth of foreign boots and shoes. It proves that the effects of a tariff there, where there is such an enormous shortage of home production, is going to be quite different to the effect of a tariff where, on the contrary, there is an enormous export surplus. It proves that the farmers are paying well for industrial tariffs, and will continue to pay well for them. The very same thing applies to apparel and textiles, and to the other items. There is no export surplus.
Comment on this
The Minister has made an incorrect statement. He said the same position applies in the case of textiles. I assert that we export a larger quantity of the home production of woollen tissues than we use.
Comment on this
I assert that our imports are £4,663,000, and our exports £1,452,000. I am talking of the whole lot.
Comment on this
The Minister is comparing, I think, cloths that come under the exception with cloths that do not.
Comment on this
I have not taken these items because they have been tariffed. I have taken the general class of industrial imports.
Comment on this
Does not the Minister know that the greater part of the cloth that is imported is not tariffed?
Comment on this
I do not care whether these are tariffed or not. The point I make is this: that the effect of tariffs, whether they were imposed or are to be imposed, is quite different in a case where there is an immense shortage of home production, and, on the other hand, where there is an immense surplus produced at home. That is the position in industry. In every one of these items there is an immense shortage of home production and a necessity for importing. Any tax on imports will raise the price. Here are industrialists who want indiscriminate tariffs without examination where obviously they are going to raise the price, and they have the impudence to come to the farmers who have an export surplus and offer to give agricultural tariffs in exchange. They are going to be deceived. I am going to do anything I can do to see that the farmers are not deceived. I am no doctrinaire free trader. I am not against tariff reform because I dislike the word. My position is that because of the economic condition of the country tariffs cannot help agriculture except in a negligible way. If you can get any item where a tariff would increase agricultural prices, I shall see that the Tariff Commission examines that and that on it goes. It is because we cannot get such a one that we have to be careful, in a country where tariffs are bound to increase the price of industrial articles, that these tariffs are not imposed without examination, so as to put easy money into the pockets of industrialists at the expense of the farmer. The real object is to get rid of the Tariff Commission, to see to it that we shall have a spate of industrial tariffs at the expense of agriculture and under the cover of developing and carrying out a patriotic policy. I do not think it is a patriotic policy. I think our policy, which is much more humdrum, is a patriotic policy, and so far from this being any help to agriculture, I am of opinion that it is meant to deceive, and it would do more harm than good.
Comment on this
At the outset of his speech the Minister for Agriculture referred to what he thought was the origin of the resolution and spoke of party conferences and joint conferences between Labour and Fianna Fáil which had been held and of which this resolution is the outcome. He has no more right to say that they were joint conferences between Labour and Fianna Fáil than he has to say they were joint conferences between Fianna Fáil and Cumann na nGaedheal. So far as I know anything of the conferences which preceded this resolution, they were attended by Deputies from all parts of the House, and I think the Minister knows that. There were Deputies there from his own Party.
Comment on this
The suggestion was that this resolution was the outcome of joint conferences that had taken place between the two Parties in opposition during the Recess.
Comment on this
I want to disabuse the Minister's mind of that. It was not, no more than it can be said to have been the outcome of joint meetings of Cumann na nGaedheal and Fianna Fáil, because the conferences which took place were attended by members of all parties. So far as my information goes, members of all parties were represented on the particular Committee that was chosen to draw up the resolution to be put before the Dáil.
Comment on this
I do not know what happened. In any case, I want to say that so far as I am concerned I saw this motion for the first time on the Order Paper just as the Minister himself did. I think Deputy Davin made that quite clear.
Comment on this
I am sure you were very annoyed with Deputy Davin.
Comment on this
We can afford to have our points of difference. In this Party we do not try to call members to heel to the extent that Cumann na nGaedheal does. If we have points of difference we can express them. I propose to express them here. When I came to view this motion I looked upon it just as I would upon a Bill which would be introduced in this House and which would come up for Second Reading. Looking at it from that point of view, I am more or less in agreement with Deputy Gorey. It is like the curate's egg—good in parts, but the parts which appeared good to Deputy Gorey are the parts which do not appear to be good as far as I am concerned. We do not agree as to the parts which are good.
In deciding what action I am going to take on the motion, I look to what I conceive to be the principle embodied in it and treat it just as I would a Bill on Second Reading. While I may not agree with everything in it, I ask myself if I agree with the principle. I should like to say that if I were putting down the motion I would not put it down in this particular form. I have, however, examined the principle of it. There are really two principles in it. One is the encouragement of tillage. I will not say going back to tillage. If you like, I shall put it as low as the maintaining of even the present position in tillage. The second is to secure all the home market for the home producer, and in so far as it embodies these two principles, and in my opinion it does embody these two principles. I am prepared to support the motion. I take the various propositions here. As far as the first and second go, so far as I heard the arguments against these by the Minister for Justice, by Deputy Bennett and, to some extent, by the Minister for Agriculture and by Deputy Gorey, they were all to this effect: it does not matter a straw whether you put on this prohibition or not, because the amount of foreign oats introduced into this country is so small that it does not make any matter. Granting that that is the position at the moment, we do not know what the position may grow to. Deputy Gorey's friends in Russia may take it into their heads to send greater quantities of foreign oats into this country. I think a country that does produce oats ought to take any steps necessary to preserve the home market, which it can control and keep and hold for the producers of grain. Deputy Gorey spoke of grain for feeding purposes and said that the cheaper the grain, no matter where it came from, the better for the person using it as feeding. But does he visualise the possibility in which all our feeding stuffs would be imported? I am sure Deputy Gorey would not say that that was a good economic position for the country to occupy. That is not an unlikely position; it is at least a possible position.
I look at the trade journal issued to Deputies this morning. I see items here which are very significant and serious, and despite all the Minister has said about the policy of agriculture which has been adopted we are faced with this position, that there is between this year and last year—I have not all the figures before me, but I think the thing has been going on for several years—there is a decrease of 101,336 acres of tillage or land under crops. I do not know how far the argument of the wet weather applies to that, and Deputy Gorey's fantastic proposal to put a glass roof over the country. Nineteen hundred and twenty-nine was a good season, and this year the spring was fairly good, too.
Comment on this
I do not think so. These figures were taken in June. Was the season so bad that the farmers till 101,336 acres less than last year after following a good and comparatively hopeful season? That was before the real bad weather set in, and before the big fall in prices, because I see the price of butter was 140/- in June but it is now fallen to 132/-. That is one side of the question. If that were followed by an increase in the number of cattle one would say there was shifting from one side to another. When I examine the live-stock returns I find an alarming decrease also. Deputy Dr. Ryan drew attention to this point. When he was speaking about the increase in the exports of cattle he showed that we were exporting our cattle and not maintaining our stocks in the country. That is borne out by the figures here.
Comment on this
Perhaps Deputy Gorey would examine them and explain them. There was a reduction in 1929 in the number of milch cows, two-year old, three-year old, and yearling cattle. These are the figures, and I am sure that Deputy Gorey will study them for himself. There is undoubtedly a decrease. That is a serious position, and, if that is the position into which the Minister's policy is leading us, I think it is time that there was a very serious examination of it in order to endeavour to find out whether we are operating on right lines or not. I think it is almost axiomatic that while we should do our best to maintain our position in the foreign market over which we have no control, we should secure to our farmers and producers the market which we can control and which we can hold. In my humble opinion the Minister always attaches too much importance to the question of price. There is the question of steadying the demand. That would have an effect on production. The farmer's life at present is too great a gamble. He is always gambling against heavy odds. He has no control over, or certainty about, the market in which he disposes of his produce. Even though it is a comparatively small portion of the market, in so far as it is the home market, everything possible should be done to reserve that to the farmer, as, if you like, a special preserve. I think if that were done, even though the market is comparatively small, it would be of considerable advantage to our farmers. It is for those reasons that I would be prepared to support proposals which would have the effect of preserving the home market, that is, in the matter of the prohibition of imported butter, condensed milk, dried and liquid eggs.
Comment on this
I am going to talk about bacon. I stated at the beginning that there were parts of the motion with which I did not agree. I have no doubt that the immediate imposition of a 20/- tax per cwt. on foreign bacon would have the effect of raising the price of imported bacon, and that that price would be paid, in the main, by the poorest members of the community, while the benefit that would be gained, and to which reference was made by Deputy Davin and Deputy Dr. Ryan, would not be such as would make up for the burthen that would be placed on the shoulders of the small farmers of the south and west and of the labouring community generally. You cannot change the fashions or tastes of a people in one or two years. As the Minister for Agriculture said, our small farming community, especially in the west and south, and the labouring community generally, in so far as they use any meat at all, use imported bacon. I am not saying that that is right or that it is sound economy, but we are faced with the fact that that is what they do.
Perhaps it would be better from many points of view, from a health and hygienic point of view, that women should wear home-knitted stockings instead of silk ones, but I do not think that anyone would propose the total prohibition of silk stockings and insist that women should wear home-knitted ones. We could not change the fashion if we tried, and I think it would be a very unpopular proposal. That, however, is the position we are faced with, and a tax of this kind on bacon would have only one effect. I doubt whether it would go very far towards inducing the present bacon-curers to put on the market the particular kind of bacon that is used by the poorer members of the community. It is a special brand, different entirely from that mainly produced by Irish curers, who go in for producing an excellent, first-class product which is sold at the highest price on the British market. They have shown no desire to produce the kind of article for which there is a demand here. I am sure that if a tax of twopence per pound were put on imported bacon the people who buy it now would still go on buying, even at a sacrifice of twopence per pound. They would have to do it. They would be forced to do it by the economy of their own families until a substitute, or something like it, was put on the market by the Irish bacon-curers.
In any case, before I would consider the imposition of a tariff I would insist that the position would be examined by the Tariff Commission or some other commission that would be in a position to go into the whole subject. There is no one in this House, I think, who can speak with an expert voice so far as bacon is concerned. One person will know one particular side of the industry, and somebody else will know some other side, but there are many different things to be considered in connection with this whole question of pig production. The fluctuations and their reactions, about which Deputy Bennett spoke, would want to be carefully examined before any proposal to put a tariff on or to prohibit the importation of foreign bacon should be agreed to. I have always objected to what are called indiscriminate tariffs. Before any tariff is put on, I believe that there should be a very full examination of every side of the case. I believe that not only the point of view of the producers but also that of the consumers should be taken into account. Therefore, I say, distinctly and definitely, that I am not in agreement with that particular portion of the motion which deals with a tax on imported bacon.
There are two other proposals here —(c) and (d)—to which I think there should be no objection. If meat is being imported into this country, we should know its source of origin. It ought to be so labelled and branded as to make it known where it comes from. We have heard of abuses, and we have heard some things that would lead us to believe that the stuff which we sometimes buy as Irish bacon was never raised on an Irish farm. I am not in a position to speak on that, but I am sure there are some Deputies who are. It is a question really whether the present agricultural policy of the Ministry is leading towards the better ment of the farmer's position, and of the agricultural industry generally. It seems clear to me, from every indication by which one can judge, that it is not, and as it has been said that the Government have made this motion a matter of confidence in their agricultural policy, I am not going to give any vote that will express confidence in the present policy of the Ministry.
Comment on this
At the outset, I want to express a certain amount of agreement with the Minister for Agriculture. It is quite true that the scope of this motion is very limited. It is very far, however, from being intended by us as a cure for the present economic condition of the farmers. I do not think that the proposer said anything that would give the Minister for Agriculture the right to infer that this was proposed by us as a cure for the present economic position of the farmers. This, as far as we are concerned, is only a small part of a general policy. Why did we begin with this part? We began with this for the simple practical reason that we found that there was a better chance of getting general agreement upon this, or we rather hoped that there was a better chance of getting general agreement upon it, than upon the bigger questions which we threshed out fairly completely with the Minister and his colleagues at the Economic Conference. The main reason why we began with this motion is that there was generally agreement amongst a large section of those who do not belong to our Party, with the proposals which it contains.
I said that it is very restricted in its scope. I find that the total involved, according to the figures for 1929, was £2,892,000 odd. That is practically £3,000,000. I quite agree with the Minister for Agriculture that that is only a small portion of the imports which we believe should be stopped and which should be replaced by our own products. The Minister seems to me to be rather inconsistent. He says it does not matter. I suppose I am wrong in saying he is inconsistent. At any rate, he says it does not matter. Very well, then. As far as we are concerned we are justified in starting with that, because there is less-opposition to it than there would be to other proposals. We believe it matters to this extent, that it would be the first step on the right road. I find it very difficult to deal with this question and to argue this matter piecemeal without reference to what the whole policy involved. It is very difficult when you are in a rut to get out of it without experiencing some jolt. Remember we have been forced into an economic rut in this country. There is nobody here who will not admit that a totally different economic system would have been adopted by our people here if they were free in the past to determine the fiscal policy which they were going to have. Certainly before the war, all those who were thinking nationally, all those who were associated with the movement that later became the national movement of Sinn Fein, were satisfied that the policy we were forced into was a policy that was intended for the benefit of England and was not working out for the benefit of this country.
The fruits of that policy were evident in the national life—quite evident. The one supreme test of whether the policy was a good one or a bad one for the country was the test of whether we were able to maintain our population and maintain that population in a reasonable standard of comfort. Applying that test, there is no doubt that the policy we were forced into, whatever benefit it was to the country across the water, was not benefiting us. During the years that followed the adoption of the free trade policy in England, we lost, as everybody knows, one-half of our population. That did not represent at all the total loss. We were cut down in eighty years by one-half. I am tired of repeating it, but I have to repeat it if we are to realise what is involved in these questions that are coming up and discussed constantly in connection with tariffs. We lost four and a half millions of our people, one-half of our population, at a time when every other civilised people were doubling their population. The loss was not merely four and a half or four and a quarter million of people. The total loss was far greater than that. The total loss could be ascertained by remembering that these other countries which had less productivity and which were less fertile than ours had doubled their population at the same time. Therefore, our true loss is represented by the difference between four and a quarter million and seventeen million people.
That loss, at any rate, was one of the things that we were hoping to make good as a result of getting our political independence or as a result of changing that policy that had been forced on us against our will. Very well. The question is whether we were right in that or whether we were wrong. Was that policy, adopted for the benefit of England, working out to the benefit of this country or not? I say the loss of population proved that it was not. Yesterday when the President was speaking as to how the Loan stood in New York, the Minister for Industry and Commerce taunted me that I did not take these figures and comment on their significance. I do not know, and I do not carry round in my head, the terms on which, say, the British War Loan was issued, when the coupons on it were due, when it was due for repayment, or any of these other matters on which the quotation might depend. I do not know exactly the conditions, whether, for instance, the Irish Loan is free from income tax or not at the moment. All these things have to be taken into account if we are going to judge at all what is the significance of our Loan being quoted at a higher price on the New York market. But even if all these had the full significance that the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the President wanted us to read into them, what does it prove?
I am sure every one of us has heard of the person whose credit in the publichouse was very good but whose family was starving behind that. We might have a very good position in the public eye and yet have a rotten position at home. I say that the position where you have 79,000 people in the City of Dublin compelled to live with one room to a family, the position in which you have 40,000 houses badly required in the country, the position in which our young people are forced to emigrate, and the general economic position which we all have experience of, is a far truer index of whether we have improved or whether we stand in a good position than is the fact that our stock is quoted a few points higher on the New York market. I refrain from discussing the significance of these figures because I have not got the assurance of the Ministers on the other side; I have not their audacity to comment upon figures until I have asked myself what is the real meaning of them, and whether the case they are intended to prove is really made by them.
Leaving these questions aside, there is one figure that nobody can deny. Our population, under the system imposed upon us from outside, has been cut down from 8¼ millions to 4¼ millions. Why have we been deprived of our population? The answer is that our people could not get a decent living in this country as compared with the standard of living that they were able to get abroad. We have to ask ourselves if that is inevitable. Must we simply throw up our hands and say we are doomed for all time to have a position in which we can only have a dwindling population, or have we a country and have we resources which, if properly managed, could support more people? As far as I am concerned, I believe we have. From the very first day that I had anything to do with the Sinn Fein movement I convinced myself that we could, under the policy of Sinn Fein—looking after ourselves—meet all our own requirements, and we could so develop our country that we would be able to retain the population here. I became a member of the Sinn Fein organisation because I believed, not merely in its political, but in its economic policy. There is no change in my mind as regards the economic policy yet. The economic and political policy go hand in hand, to my mind.
In this matter we have to choose very clearly between the policy of continuing in the rut into which we have been forced against our will, or getting out of it. Most people know that it is easier to keep in a rut than to get out of it. Every person who proposes to get out of it must be prepared to ask the people to face the necessary jolt in order to get out. When we argue these questions piecemeal, the fact that a jolt is necessary to get out is pointed out to us, but the advantage of getting to the plain open road is hidden away. I am coming down more particularly to the motion. I have been dealing with it generally. I agree that, considered in isolation from the general policy, it is not a very big thing; but when considered in connection with the whole policy, it is valuable, because it is a beginning at getting all Parties in the House to come together on some policy which will get us out of the rut into which we were placed against our will, because we were not in a position, in the past, to determine our own fiscal policy. I am quite willing to grant the Minister that the biggest item in this matter is the item of bacon. I have tried to get the Minister, in the past, to show why it is that we could not have the foreign market, with whatever advantages there are in it, and the home market as well. I have never got any reason from the Minister. I was trying to follow Deputy Bennett in order to find out his view, but I was not quite able to do it. I thought I discovered one particular point in his reasoning which I had not discovered before. At any rate, taking the whole situation, and with the arguments we have heard from the Minister and from Deputy Bennett, I am still not convinced that we cannot secure the foreign market and the home market at the same time.
Comment on this
My point was that you cannot secure it by tariffs or by prohibition.
Comment on this
The point is that you will have a demand at home for bacon. Are our people who used Irish bacon in the past going to give it up?
Comment on this
It is possible, and it could be profitable, assuming the price would be the same. The Minister was talking about wholesale and retail. I take it the extra difference is the cost of handling, transport, and so on. It seems to me there is an advantage, and it ought to pay the producer to sell his bacon at home somewhat cheaper than on the foreign market. I admit the margin might be slight. On the other hand, it is not quite the same type of trade. It has been admitted that the bacon used in the farmer's house in this country generally, with cabbage, is not quite the same class of bacon as is sent across the water. The question is whether we can produce that bacon cheaper for our home consumption. If there is a prohibition on the foreign bacon there is a possibility of an increased price. My anxiety is not concerned with the increased price; it is rather to see that the price would not be increased unduly. In this matter I am not considering, like the Minister, one section of the community alone. I think we ought to consider the interests of the community at large. I believe this policy works out to the interest of the community at large.
It might be necessary, as Deputy O'Connell said, to watch that there was not advantage taken of a monopoly. I do not believe there would be. I believe the internal competition would be quite sufficient to keep prices down. It is not a case where you have one big ring dealing with it. I believe internal competition would bring down prices, and ultimately, once we got our people into that particular trade, catering for the home market reserved for them, I believe prices would compare very favourably with the prices that would obtain under existing conditions, and we would have a better article for practically the same price, if not a better price.
It does not always follow that the imposition of a tariff means an increase. It may or it may not. I admit that at the start, while things are adjusting themselves, the presumption is that it will mean an increase; but with good organisation and with the cutting down of the overhead costs of production it might very well lead, not to an increase, but to a lowering of the cost. I am willing to concede, however, that there is a certain presumption at the start of an increased price.
I regret that it is necessary to deal in the first part of the motion with a tariff. I would prefer the prohibition, but the Minister would be the first to admit that you cannot close the door suddenly; you must have a transition period, and it is to provide for the transition period that the tariff is proposed. The ultimate policy is to exclude the importation of foodstuffs which can be produced here. The fact that we can produce them in surplus is, to my mind, the safeguard which the community at large has that prices will not go up. Therefore, if there is an appeal made by the Minister for Agriculture to the agricultural community, on the one hand, on the ground that prices do not go up, there is, on the other hand, the safeguard to the other consumers that they will be treated fairly and that the tariff will not mean a rising of the prices.
I say again I am not urging one policy specially for the farmers. I suppose the Minister for Agriculture regards it as his immediate duty to look after that section of the community. I will admit that they are the largest section and that they deserve the greatest consideration and care. But we have to forget a particular section and think of the community as a whole. I think it is very bad policy on the part of the Minister for Agriculture to try to put some antagonism between the manufacturing and industrial sections of the community and the farming section. I believe that the farmers of this country would benefit immensely if they had a home market that would save them somewhat from their present dependence on the foreign market.
The question of butter has been mentioned. I have got some figures here showing the relation between Irish and Danish butter in the British market. I do not know why this difference in price should be. It is something that I cannot understand. There is one explanation of it to my mind, and that is that we have no winter dairying here, and that we spend five months getting a market and seven months in losing it after having recovered it. I do not know whether that is an adequate explanation or not, but it seems the only one as to why our butter should show such a discrepancy in price as compared with Danish butter. I have here some tables which show that in October, 1927, Irish butter sold at 180/- and Danish butter at 184/-; that is a difference of 4/- per cwt. In October, 1928, Irish butter sold at 182/- and Danish at 198/-; that was a difference of 16/- per cwt. In 1929, in the month of October, Irish butter sold at 186/- and Danish at 202/-; that was a difference of 16/- per cwt. also. In October, 1930, Irish butter was 122/- and Danish 150/-, showing a difference of 28/- per cwt.
I think the Minister for Agriculture ought to admit his error on one point that if, instead of having an export market of £2,700,000 odd for our bacon, if we were to increase that amount of Irish bacon on the British market by half we would not change the price. The Minister for Agriculture will probably talk of £50,000,000 as the total amount of bacon sold on the British market. But you are not adding one and a half million pounds to the £50,000,000. Irish bacon has held its price relative to foreign competitors—relative to the Danish and other importers into England—better than Irish butter or Irish products of other kinds, simply because the amount is comparatively small and there is a special market for it. If you increase that export of Irish bacon I am not satisfied that Irish bacon will hold the position it holds now. I do not mind when the curers say: "Oh, if I had twice as much I could sell at that price." It is all a big "IF." My own conviction is that if instead of £2,700,000 odd worth of bacon which you are sending into England, you were to send in £4,000,000 worth, you would not get as good price per lb. as you get for the amount now exported. The Minister tells us that if we had £9,000,000 worth of bacon we could still get the same price for it in the British market. I do not believe it. But suppose we should, why not capture both?
Comment on this
The Minister is very anxious at times to try to show the big contrast there is between our policy and his. Perhaps we do the same on our side. I do not want to say that that is not done. I am willing to admit that the natural tendency for the advocates on both sides is to exaggerate the position taken up by the opponents. We have got to have all that sort of thing, I suppose. When we are asking to consider the home market and concentrate upon it, it is not right to accuse us of being blind to the foreign market. We are not blind to it, but we recognise its limitations. We know there is world competition. There are a number of other factors and these factors are all operating in the case of our butter. These are factors over which we have no control. When we can show, as in the case of bacon, that you can practically add to the existing market fifty per cent., why not go and take it? Is it not obvious that the overhead expenses will remain the same? With the increased production there is bound to result a certain amount of increase in profits. An increased volume of production makes that very certain. If we can increase the market which the farmer has for his products, then to that extent we are increasing the farmer's profits, even though the price per lb. did not seem to go up at all.
I am satisfied that it is good policy for the farming community and good policy for the nation to capture this home market for Irish bacon. It exists, and it is not really exactly competitive with out foreign market at all. I believe it has features of profit that the foreign market has not got for us. We would be saving on the cost of transport and so on. I believe that the bacon that would be produced would be a fatter kind of bacon. I know that when I was doing agriculture in school long ago I learned this much, anyway, that you will at the last stage in the fattening of animals find it much more profitable than at the earlier stages. We do not want to know very much about agriculture to recognise why that should be so. The fat that the animal puts on is relatively more in the later stages than in the earlier stages. I say that there are elements of profit in this particular industry of which we should take advantage.
We hear people talk about the matter of taste. I wonder how many people in this country, if they were given Irish-cured bacon such as we saw in the farmers' houses long ago, would not take Irish bacon in preference to foreign bacon? I do not know of anybody. I do not think this is a question into which the matter of taste enters at all. I believe that 99 out of 100 people would take Irish bacon in preference to imported bacon at the same price. I am convinced that as far as bacon is concerned there is a very good case. There are no grounds for the fears that Deputy O'Connell has given expression to, on account of the fact that there is unlimited power of production here and that the moment there is a demand there will be production to meet that demand provided it will be an effective demand in the sense that the people who want to buy Irish bacon will be able to pay the price and make it worth while for the farmer to produce it.
Then, again, I am perfectly convinced that it is sound economy for the nation and for the community as a whole to make it a paying proposition for the farmer to produce the article that pays the community as a whole. I tried to give an example of that in the case of wheat, and I have got to go back to that example. In the case of wheat, I pointed out that the national economy would be benefited if there were a higher production from wheat than there would be if the land were used otherwise. I restrict that, of course, to suitable wheat growing land. We have got enough suitable wheat growing land to produce our requirements. I said that the figures showed that the wealth of the community was being increased by this by, roughly, £2 an acre. That was the figure we had at that particular time. If the community as a whole is benefited to the extent of £2 an acre by the growing of wheat, I said that it would pay the community to give the farmer anything up to that amount to induce him to grow wheat. I said that the community could afford to subsidise the farmer. If you were able to prove that the community benefited by the production of wheat to the extent of £2 an acre, then the community would be well advised, if there was no other way of effectively dealing with the matter, to give the farmer £1 10s. out of the £2. I said that you would be justified in giving him even up to the full £2. I said that, in certain circumstances, and taking other considerations into account, you would be justified in giving him more than the £2.
In dealing with questions of this kind, we are of necessity compelled to think of the national economy as a whole, and the part which it plays. The difference between us, on these benches, and our opponents opposite is that they are simply trying to continue in the old rut, and trying to improve it somewhat if you like. We say that the old rut means national decay; that it is leading to the destruction of our people and our importance and strength as a nation; that it is leading to a decrease in the standard of living for our people, and that, because it is, it is high time we should consider going in a direction where that will be changed.
The question for us is: Are we going to make the change or are we not? Our country relatively is an undeveloped country. If we take advantage of our position, we can relatively be better off than any of the countries that I know anything about. At present we are very far from being in that position. If we are going to change our position, we will have to produce more wealth. When you look at the figures, what do you find? You find, for instance, that in the Free State area you have only an agricultural output per person of £86. In Denmark, the output in agriculture is £196 per person, or more than twice as much as ours. If we are to change the present position we must increase that output. To increase it, we must get a market. The Minister for Agriculture says: "Go into the world market and try and fight Denmark and the others there." The moment you do, down come the prices. I do not want to go into the figures in relation to our prices and Denmark's again. The Minister gave us figures yesterday on eggs. I tried to check them, and, taking the British reports, I find a very different state of affairs from that which he tried to make out.
I believe you can increase home production by 50 per cent. If you try to get that 50 per cent, increase in the foreign markets, I believe the prices are going to tumble down. The big question for us is: Are we going to change this policy and get out of this rut into which we have been driven, or are we not? The Minister tries to increase production in one way. We say: "By all means take these steps." But we do not see as much hope in that way as we see in steps which might be taken to capture the home market. This resolution is only a first step. There is also the question of wheat and the question of maize to be dealt with.
The question of maize, I admit, is a ticklish and a difficult question, but we have to face these questions if we are going to benefit to the full by the policy of Protection. Half measures are worse than useless in these cases. We are really at the parting of the ways, so to speak. We have to make up our minds whether we shall go in for protection of the home market and for being as self-sufficient as possible, or whether we shall continue this competition in outside markets. At present, we have got 672,000 persons employed in working upon the land. In order to get anything like the same rate of production per person as obtains in Denmark, we shall have to cut down our numbers by half. The agricultural industry can only carry half the number of workers which it is carrying at present if we try to get the same amount of production per head as Denmark. If you do that, where are the 300,000 people who will be taken out of agriculture to go? We have got to find other industries for them. In the other industries there are only 186,000 persons employed at present. Do you think it is possible for these industries to absorb suddenly 300,000 extra people? You know it is absurd. I admit that a tremendous amount can be done on the land, but each person you draw into industry other than agriculture is a double advantage, because you are providing an extra market for the farmer by doing that. I would be twice as anxious to get new industries other than agriculture established as to see extra people employed in agriculture. I hope I shall not be misunderstood in that. I simply mean that agriculture is more than saturated at present, that we are carrying far more on the land than the land can afford to carry with our present economy. The only hope of the land carrying anything like that number is to change our economy—to go definitely in for the policy of protection our home market, getting our other industries set up side by side and becoming, as far as possible, self-sufficient. If that does not commend itself to any Deputy in the House, I expect the Deputy will vote against this motion. If the policy of making ourselves self-sufficient, of getting ourselves out of this rut into which we have been forced against our will to the national detriment—if that policy commends itself to any Deputy I do not see why he should vote against this motion. This is the thin end of the wedge, if you like—the first step. It is the step on which we hope to get the greatest amount of agreement in this House. I hope that Deputies who were vocal a short time ago, when this question was before the country and before they came to their Party meeting—I hope that these Deputies, having apparently failed to convince the Minister for Agriculture in their Party meetings, will endeavour to make him see reason in this House.
Comment on this
I would like to draw the attention of the House to the fact that a few years ago a duty of 50/- a ton was placed on oatmeal. At that time we expected it would benefit the farmer. As a dealer in oats and oatmeal I can assure the House that one-sixteenth of a penny has not gone into the farmer's pocket as a result of that duty. Any benefits that have accrued have gone into the pockets of the millers. That is a positive fact. What do we find at the present time? Speaking for the area of the Saorstát I represent, I find that flake oatmeal made in Belfast and retailed at 1/- per quarter stone, or £32 per ton, is being sold in the various towns. I inquired recently why the people will not buy the ordinary oatmeal that is made in local mills, and which they can purchase at about 1/10 per stone. The explanation given was that the flake meal can be cooked more quickly. Their time is so precious that they cannot see their way to cook oatmeal in the way that their fathers and mothers cooked it. Speaking from experience, I say that the 50/- duty that was placed on oatmeal in 1926 has neither benefited the farmer nor assisted in holding the home market.
I would like to bring another matter before the House, now that the growing and consumption of oats has been mentioned. I am perfectly certain that the horse population in the City of Dublin was very considerable ten years ago, both in respect of the hackney cars and carrying contractors. What is the position to-day? I am sure that there has been a reduction of 70 per cent. in the horse population as a result of motor traction. That has meant a big falling-off in the consumption of oats in the home market. If you go into the towns where there are carrying contractors it is the same story. The great bulk of the heavy traffic is done by motor lorries, while horses are only used for door-to-door delivery of parcels by the various railway companies and by other concerns.
Deputy Davin is an experienced railway man, and I want to draw his attention to the internal transport problem. If we in Donegal desire to purchase oats in Kildare, Wexford, Carlow or Kilkenny, what rates will the railway company charge for carrying them? I will tell the House what was my experience last spring. I purchased seed barley in Enniscorthy and I brought it to Derry, the rate being 42/6 per ton. I then paid 7/- to convey it from Derry to Carndonagh by lorry. That meant that barley from Enniscorthy to Carndonagh practically cost 50/- a ton. That is a matter that Deputy Davin might deal with, seeing that he is one of the most experienced railway men in the Twenty-Six Counties. In my opinion the transit problem is of great importance in connection with this question, but I have not heard a word about it from Deputy Davin. He should have enlightened the House on that aspect of the question when dealing with a tariff on grain, and the exclusion of foreign oats, so that we might be able to get a cheap rate from the grain-growing counties to Cavan, Monaghan and Donegal.
Comment on this
The motion before the House asks for "the marking legibly of all imported meat entering the Free State so as to indicate the country of origin when such meat is exposed for sale; and the proper medical inspection of all imported meat entering the Free State." It is principally with that portion of the motion that I propose to deal. It has been suggested by the Minister for Agriculture that the principal reason people consume foreign bacon is that in many cases the price is lower than Irish bacon. I propose to prove that at least 30 per cent. of the imported bacon is bought by consumers under the impression that it is Irish bacon. According to the trade and shipping statistics issued by the Department of Industry and Commerce for the year ending 31st December, 1929, there was imported pigs and pig products value £1,783,959. That was made up as follows:—pigs to the value of £8,480, bacon to the value of £1,610,119 hams to the value of £16,975, pork to the value of £11,424, pork sausages to the value of £17,943, pigs' heads to the value of £75,184, and other pig products value £43,834. It has been asserted by people employed in the bacon trade that not alone does imported bacon come into the Saorstát from the Six Counties and Great Britain, but also from Poland, China, Denmark, United States of America, Holland, Sweden, Madagascar, Latvia, and Ukrania. Deputy White gave the House to understand that he proposed to vote against the motion.
I believe Deputy White is not voicing the sentiments of either the small farmers or the wage earners of Donegal when he says that he would like to see this Ukranian bacon still coming in instead of the people using Irish bacon. I believe I am voicing the people's sentiments when I say that they would prefer Irish bacon to that coming from Poland or Russia. It has been asserted on very reliable authority that a big percentage of the bacon that comes from the countries I have mentioned is sold in the shops, not alone in Dublin, but right through the country as Irish bacon. According to the evidence given before the Commission on Prices in 1923, and again before the Commission on Prices in 1927, it was alleged by people engaged in the bacon trade that a large quantity of this foreign bacon went through an additional smoking process in Dublin, and in many cases was branched "Dublin mild-cured," sent to different parts of the Saorstát, and sold in the shops as Irish bacon. People purchasing such bacon were, in many cases, under the impression that it was Irish bacon. No doubt that may seem a rather far-fetched statement, but in order to prove that assertion I would like to quote for the House a few extracts from the evidence given before the Commission on Prices in the year 1923. During the examination of a witness before that Commission on 18th April, 1923, the Chairman said: "Foreign bacon was brought in and smoked and then sold as Irish bacon." Giving evidence at a public session of the Commission on 13th April, 1923, Mr. J. Ryan (Dublin) of the District Co-operative Society, Ltd., said: "I have known Dublin provision men to offer American smoked bacon to the public as ‘Dublin cured.' What is offered sometimes by the retail trade as ‘Dublin cured' is American bacon brought in in borax. It is washed in Dublin, dried and smoked." According to the evidence of Mr. W.H. Freeman, Hon. Secretary of the Irish Wholesale Provision Trade Association, the ratio of imported bacon sold in Ireland would be, roughly, as three to one, and the Dublin wholesale selling prices of imported bacon are based, as far as practicable, on the ruling Liverpool prices.
[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]
I would like to quote also an extract from a full-page advertisement which appeared in the "Irish Independent" on 13th January, 1930. It was signed by an ex-member of this House, Mr. James O'Mara, chairman of Donnelly's bacon factory. In that advertisement he stated: "Thousands of tons of Danish, Dutch, Latvian, Ukranian, Polish, and Chinese bacon are arriving in the Saorstát." It was further stated in the same notice that "Most of these countries are rife with foot and mouth disease." This evening in the course of this debate, I asked the Minister for Agriculture when he started to talk about the purity of this imported bacon, if it underwent any inspection, and he said no. Apparently one of the farmer Deputies, Deputy Gorey, was not satisfied. Deputy Gorey is now a member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, but he goes under the guise of the Farmers' Party, which does not exist at the present time.
At any rate, it is well known that, in regard to this £1,610,000 worth of bacon that is coming into the country, there is no proper inspection system. The Department of Agriculture do not insist on certificates with this bacon from foreign countries, with the exception of bacon which comes from the Netherlands. On 23rd November, 1927, I drew the attention of the Minister in this House to this matter. I pointed out what was going on, and asked him to see that a brand was put upon all imported bacon sold here, so that the people concerned would know the country of origin. The reply the Minister gave me on that occasion was that he had not the power to do that owing to the fact that the Merchandise Marks Act had not been passed by the Dáil. Three years have elapsed since then. The Minister knows that this is going on. He has read, I presume, the evidence given before the Food Prices Commission. There was a question on the Order Paper to-day by Deputy Hennessy, a member of the Minister's party, with reference to this, and he was told that the matter was under consideration. The matter has been under consideration for over three years, and yet nothing has been done. The question was discussed in 1923, and again in 1927, and up to the present nothing has been done. If any Deputies can afford the time to go down to the North and South Wall in Dublin, and to the Rotterdam sheds, they can see for themselves that large quantities of this foreign bacon are still coming in. They can find out for themselves, too, that portion of it goes to some of the curers in the Saorstát, when it is put through an additional smoking process, and is sold to the people as Irish-cured bacon.
I believe there is a big necessity to have all this foreign bacon branded. The Prices Tribunal in 1927 recommended that not alone should all imported bacon be branded, but that it should be made compulsory for all retailers to label bacon with the name of the country of origin. I think that such a regulation as that is necessary, when bacon is sold as rashers. I think it is unfair to the farmers of the Saorstát that their foreign competitors should be allowed to send this bacon in here duty free. The farmers in Poland, Denmark, Latvia, China and other countries from which this foreign bacon is coming pay no rates or taxes here, while these burdens have to be borne by our farmers. I think the latter should be protected against these foreign competitors. I believe if the Irish farmer was protected in that way, and if you had either prohibition against foreign bacon or a tariff on it, that a good opportunity would be afforded to him to capture a market which is worth approximately one and three-quarter millions a year at the present time, a market which at the moment is held by his foreign competitors. I appeal to the farmer-Deputies in the Cumann na nGaedheal Party to support the motion before the House and not to be led away by the false economics preached here this evening by the Minister for Agriculture. By doing so they will be helping the farmers of the country. I believe that the passing of the motion would have the effect of helping to develop the agricultural industry. In addition, its adoption would be of benefit to the consumers who, in very many cases, are hoodwinked into buying foreign bacon in the belief that it is Irish bacon.
Comment on this
I have listened to the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party making his case for the adoption of this motion. I must say that I found it somewhat difficult to understand clearly the policy which he advocated. In the opening part of his speech, Deputy de Valera said that the policy laid down in the motion before the Dáil is not to be regarded as the whole policy which he and his Party stand for, that it is only to be regarded as the beginning of that policy—the thin end of the wedge. I see that Deputy de Valera agrees with me there. If that be so, then I would draw the attention of other members of the House and of the farmers of the country who think they are supporting a policy which is not a political policy by a particular Party, but who think they are supporting a policy which might conceivably be supported by members of all political parties, to the fact that what Deputy de Valera is asking them to do is to support a policy which he believes is for the national benefit of this country but which, in reality, is the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party.
In other words, Deputy de Valera has asked the farmers to accept it that the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party is also a national policy for the benefit of the country. Deputy de Valera may think that is so, but I do not. I think we should clearly understand that so far as they are advocating that this is a stepping stone they are really advocating and standing over the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party. Deputy de Valera spoke of a national policy. He said that in dealing with an economic policy we should deal with it in national terms rather than in terms of a single industry. I accept it that Deputy de Valera is honest in his claim in that regard, but I want to say that I am always suspicious of the man who tries to justify an economic policy or doctrine by stating in the forefront of his argument that national interests are his first consideration. I am not going to argue that individual interests may not clash with national interests, and that it may be good policy to see that a national economic policy is carried out to the detriment of an individual industry, but I cannot see that it is good policy to carry out what is asserted to be a national economic doctrine if that is to be to the detriment of the most important and largest section of the community in the country.
It has not been shown so far, and I do not think the Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party has shown, that the policy advocated to-day, which is the beginning of the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party, is to the advantage of the farming community or that it would not be to their detriment. Deputy de Valera used the favourite argument which he has used over and over again, which he regards as the foundation of his whole economic policy, and the argument is that the population of Ireland has decreased from something about 8,000,000 to something about 4,000,000, and that if things had gone on as before the decrease of population started we would now have a population of 17,000,000.
Comment on this
I did not say "If things went on as they were." I said if we were perfectly free during the past 80 years to adopt a fiscal policy in our own interests.
Comment on this
Yes, and incidentally the policy under which the population grew up to 8,000,000 was a different policy to that which Deputy de Valera is now advocating. The population would have been, say, 17,000,000, but is round 4,000,000. At the same time the economic policy of this country was the policy of free trade. Therefore, the decrease in population is due to free trade. Who is going to accept that argument? That is simply a statement, and there is no proof of it. There are dozens of other factors, dozens of things that have happened in Ireland, and dozens or scores of factors in world development, which may have affected our population. No one can accept it as proved that the decrease in population has occurred because of our wrong economic doctrine. It may be so or it may not, but if it is so, or partially so, surely the policy of protection for agriculture, if feasible? Why should any Government be so senseless as to protect industries the number of workers in which must be a comparatively small section of the population and refuse to protect agriculture, if agriculture could be protected? If only from the point of view of simple political expediency, by protecting agriculture they could do it.
Looking at it from that point of view, surely the Government that which would refuse to give protection to agriculture, if it could be shown to be effective, would be doing a very foolish thing in their own political interests. In so far as he entered into an argument, Deputy de Valera dealt with the merits of the case made on Deputy Ryan's motion. He entered into the effect of an imposition of a tariff on bacon. I want to make it clear at this stage with regard to tariffs in general that I am not now, and never have been, a doctrinaire free trader. I concede, and I have always done so, that you can help develop a country by a policy of protection, but I agree that the general tendency of so helping industry is to increase the price of the article protected, and the effect of that would be to increase the cost to the farmers. I was very chary about advocating a policy of protection. I am not, as I have said, a doctrinaire free trader, and I would be the first to demand a tariff on agricultural products if I thought a tariff would be effective.
Comment on this
May I ask did the Parliamentary Secretary oppose the setting up of a part-time Tariff Commission?
Comment on this
Deputy Davin must give me the opportunity of making my statement. As to tariffs, I regard the effort to force the Dáil into a general tariff policy as simply political expediency and electioneering. If I were looking at my personal interests, as I believe some Deputies are, it would be to my interest to stand for a tariff on agricultural products, because I come from a county that appears to be affected by the various items in this motion. I come from a county that produces the second largest quantity of barley. I come from a a county that grows a good deal of oats—a county that is a large producer of dairy produce. If I was looking at my own interests I would go shouting from the house-tops or from barrels on street corners, for protection for the farming industry, but I have not done so, because I am not convinced that these items of agricultural produce can be protected. I am open to conviction on the matter. I have heard nothing here to-day to convince me that these items of agricultural produce can be protected. Take the question of bacon. That has been already effectively dealt with by the Minister for Agriculture, but I was not present to hear all of his speech on that subject. My attitude in regard to a tariff on bacon is, that I do not believe it will be of any benefit to the farmers, or that it is going to increase the price of bacon or pigs for the farmers. I am quite convinced that in using any argument that a tariff would increase the price of pig products you are trying to make a fool of the people.
The only good of a tariff on bacon or any other product to the farmer is if it increases his price. I cannot see that it does increase his price, and I think Deputy de Valera has agreed with the statement that it does not increase the price he gets, because of the reason that the farmer exports something like £6,000,000 worth of bacon. Whatever the farmer produces in bacon he certainly exports in or about £6,000,000 worth of bacon and bacon products, pigs, etc., and imports something like £2,000.000 worth. There is a big export surplus of bacon, and while that exists it is quite clear that the price which the farmer gets from his produce at home must be controlled by the price of the exportable surplus. I think that is accepted, and that the price of the farmer's pigs will not increase. But then it is stated that it does not matter about price. There is a wider market. Deputy de Valera says you increase the market of the producer of pigs and bacon products by 50 per cent., Deputy de Valera's calculation being founded on the argument that you export something like £6,000,000 and import something like £2,000,000. Really you only increase the market of the farmer for his bacon to the extent of £2,000,000 on a total market of £50,000,000. That is, if you do it at all, it is only as far as the whole market is concerned, not so far as the internal market is concerned. You increase it only about four per cent. and you must always remember, though you do increase it by four per cent., you drive out of the market of the Free State by your tariffs a quantity of imported American bacon, and you must drive it into some other market. You increase outside competition against you, with the result that to all intents and purposes the market is the same as it was. There is no harm done so far. Although you have not increased the price of the farmer's pig you have not done very much harm, but where the danger comes in is this: by putting on your prohibition you keep out of the country this quantity of imported bacon whatever it may be, American or Chinese, and force people who, because of their economic conditions, and because of the lower price of the product buy it, into doing one of two things, either into buying Irish bacon at a higher price than the imported bacon or doing without bacon at all if their economic circumstances will not allow them to buy at a higher price. You do harm to a section of the community and no good to the farmer. So far as the tariff has gone it has done no good but has done harm in forcing people to pay more for their bacon. You have not given a quid pro quo to the farmer. You have not increased the price of his bacon. There is another danger. This demand for American bacon is a demand for an inferior and cheaper product. It is stated that American bacon is dearer than Irish bacon. I do not believe it is.
If you compare the prices, retail with retail, and one part of the animal with another, you will find that American bacon is cheaper. If it is not cheaper in actual price it is cheaper because people buy it generally for the reason that it goes further. The small farmer will tell he buys American bacon for the reason that it goes further, that a half-pound will go as far as a pound of Irish bacon; it is greasier, not so palatable and goes further. You are going to stimulate a demand for a somewhat inferior quality of Irish bacon. Of a second-grade Irish bacon. Is that going to do the Irish bacon trade good? When a demand is made for secondgrade bacon the demand will be met with supplies, because it is much less trouble to breed an inferior pig than a good quality pig. The tendency will be in that direction if it is not countered. What happens then? We at present command the highest price for any imported bacon in the English market, and it is very important for the Irish farmers to continue to supply a good class and good grade Irish bacon. If you stimulate the production of an inferior pig——
Comment on this
Will you supply the same grade from the same litter? You are talking of something you know nothing about.
Comment on this
I am not going to argue with Deputy Gorey; at least I stick to my guns. Now the position is this: you are actually doing harm because you are preventing the Irish pig producer from holding the valuable market he has, a market which he can always extend. These are the opinions I uphold with regard to bacon. I do not profess to be infallible. I do not profess as the members on the opposite benches do profess they have examined this so fully that they do not want to refer to any Commission or Committee. Deputy Dr. Ryan can do here in an hour what it would take the Tariff Commission weeks to do. I have seen no indication of that ability in the case of the future Minister for Agriculture in the Fianna Fáil Party to think that he can do in an hour what it takes the Tariff Commission several weeks to do. I am sure I do not know all about it.
Deputy Gorey points out there are factors I do not know. I agree. I am willing to do this as I have been willing to do with every Tariff suggested. Deputy Gorey and those interested in the bacon trade can put up a case, and I am willing to abide by the recommendation of the Tariff Commission. It will not do us any harm to see an exhaustive and careful analysis of the situation, and it will not do the farmers in this case the least bit of harm to wait for a number of weeks. It will take a whole-time Tariff Commission to deal with a case of this kind quickly. As I see the situation at present, I do not believe there is anything in a tariff on bacon. I know, however, that this, being a political motion, the eye being on the electorate and not on the Dáil, no doubt I will be misrepresented and quoted out of my context. No doubt it will be used by the agents of the political parties throughout the country to my disadvantage, but I am prepared to stand by my, statement.
The situation that exists at the present time is no new situation at all. The demand for tariffs on agricultural produce is not new. I have been interested in this question for a very considerable time and have given a good deal of study and thought to it. I have been watching the machinations of the people that are associated with the question of tariffs on agricultural produce. I know that it did not begin with the farmer. The farmers had no thought for it. It was fostered and helped and, I believe, it was subsidised by people with industrial interests. As Deputies on the opposite side know, there has been the growth and quick disappearance of various kinds of associations called by various names. I would call them mosquito associations that bite and disappear. They have called themselves by nearly every conceivable name except that of the Farmers' Union. These are the associations that are calling meetings of the farmers and pretending that they are non-political, while off their platforms they are advocating a policy which is the policy of the Party on the opposite side. The names associated with these various associations are interesting. The associations are like a chain of interlocking companies with interlocking directorate. The prominent men are the same in every association.
Comment on this
You can trace them all back to the industrial associations that are advocating whole-hog tariffs, and from there to the Fianna Fáil Party and to the financiers of that Party, the people who stand to make fortunes if they can handle a political party and get the tariffs that they want.
Comment on this
It is a serious point. The Deputy is making an insinuation that behind this motion lie some financial interests or people financially interested in tariffs.
Comment on this
Not for a moment. I am not denying for a moment that there is a demand, and a strong demand, from the farming community for these tariffs. I do not believe that the demand will be nearly so strong to-morrow, because I believe the whole case has been exploded. I claim no credit for it. It was exploded before I touched upon it. The demand for tariffs is very strong among farmers, for the reason that we have passed through an unparalleled period of depression and the climatic conditions were such as would depress any man working on a farm. The farmers are feeling distress, and they are looking around to see how the situation can be saved. It is not easy to see how to help them. Their conditions are controlled by world conditions. Perhaps they are not as badly off as the people in other agricultural countries, but panaceas are offered to them by men who are professing to be serious politicians, and who say that they are offering something for nothing. That is the reason the farmers are looking for these particular tariffs, because they think there is some way by which they can get something for nothing. That is the kind of doctrine that is preached at the present time. It is the doctrine of defeatism. It is a doctrine that any party with a sense of responsibility should be very slow to preach. What we want at present is to put courage into our farmers and to assure them that their economic salvation must depend, to a large extent, upon their own efforts—not altogether, but to a large extent—and that this turning to the Government for help and for tariffs in their hour of need is simply leading them into a quagmire.
Deputy de Valera is impaled upon the horns of a dilemma in regard to bacon. He wants to do two conflicting things at the same time. He wants to improve the market for the Irish pig producer and he does not want to increase the price of bacon to the consumer. You cannot do these two things at the one time. I notice that though Deputy Davin and some other members of the Labour Party have seen fit to associate themselves with this motion, other members of the Party have reservations. The Leader of the Labour Party has a reservation about it. I do not like to suggest any motives that may not be correct, but I cannot help thinking that the Leader of the Labour Party has at the back of his mind the peasants of Galway and Mayo who live to such an extent on imported bacon, and no doubt he is aware of the impolitic effect of increasing the price of that bacon. Also the farmers of the west of Ireland who are, to a large extent, producers of poultry and pigs, are dependent, to a certain extent, for their feeding stuffs on the market. They do what Dr. Ryan says, produce a considerable quantity of oats. But Dr. Ryan did not mention that they sell practically none of that oats, that they actually go into other countries and buy oats, and that they are not concerned with the price which they get, but with the price that they have to pay.
Comment on this
That is very strange. They do not care what they get for it when they sell it. It is no wonder the Farmers' Party failed.
Comment on this
The Fianna Fáil Party was once very nearly defunct. Until they saw their way to put the Bible aside when they were kissing it they were nearly defunct. I kissed the Bible honestly every time I kissed it.
Comment on this
Deputy Ryan, the farming economist of the Fianna Fáil Party, as I said before, is endeavouring to convince this House that he knows more about tariffs than the Tariff Commission could possibly ascertain in the course of their inquiries. He spoke of a great number of economic policies which I regard as fallacies and which I believe would not stand the examination of any person having an elementary knowledge of economics. It is like Deputy de Valera's argument about the population. Deputy Ryan has developed an argument that he got from the agricultural statistics or some blue book of that kind, that the value of an Irish citizen as a customer is greater than that of an outside person. The Irish citizen as a customer for agricultural produce is worth a great deal more than a citizen of the British islands! Is that put forward as a serious argument?
A well-known statesman and economist in the British Parliament, dealing with the cotton situation the other day, pointed out that if the natives of China decided to add an inch to the tails of their shirts it would be more valuable to the industry than the whole trade of the Dominions. If the British consumers decided to take one pound of butter per head per year of our produce, it would be worth more to us than the home market Deputy Ryan spoke so much about.
If Deputy Ryan wants to carry the argument further, let him reduce it to an absurdity. This is the absurdity. We export not alone to England, but to the United States. Let him take the total exports to the United States and divide the population of the United States, which is about 110,000,000, into the total exports from here, and see what figure he would get. He might get the thousandth part of a farthing. That is the value of the United States consumers to us. That kind of argument is absolutely ridiculous—there is no sense or meaning in it.
Comment on this
With regard to the actual motion itself, it has been analysed very carefully, and I do not intend to follow the analysis of the speakers who have gone before me only to say that, in a general way, with the exception of bacon, in regard to which I think a tariff cannot be of any advantage to the farmer, and of butter, regarding which I think there is a possibility of a tariff being of immediate and short advantage, in so far as the other tariffs are concerned they are of no consequence. I agree absolutely with the Minister for Agriculture that they are of no consequence. They are simply window-dressing.
As to a tariff on imported oats, the keeping out of Russian oats would make practically no difference to the price which the Irish farmer would get. In the average year there is more oats exported than is imported, and the price of oats in the Irish market is controlled by the export price. The word "dumping" is used in a loose way. Dumping is sending in an article to be sold below the cost of production. It has been stated that Russian oats is selling here below the cost of production. If it is, I think it ought to be kept out, that is if it is feasible to do it, and if it is administratively possible. You might very well have to set up an immense machine which would cost more than the game is worth. In actual practice, there is very little oats imported into this country which is in competition with the kind of oats produced here. If Deputy Ryan inquired into it, he must know that the import of oats consists principally of seed oats, the special oats for racing horses, and a very inferior class of screened oats for feeding purposes. These do not enter into direct competition with ours. It seems quite likely that if we put a tariff or a prohibition on oats we must allow all these classes of oats to come in under licence. If we do allow them to come in, what is left will be a negligible quantity.
Deputy Ryan would prohibit the importation of seed oats. I wonder has he consulted the experts in the Department on that point? In the past it has been found essential to import seed oats to keep our stock healthy and strong. Deputy Ryan did not say whether he would keep out the special quality of dry Dominion oats with a low moisture content, which is fed to racehorses. The export of our horses is worth above one million pounds. It is not a negligible industry, and it is worth helping. I cannot say whether these men could feed their horses as well on Irish produced oats as on the imported oats. The fact of the matter is that if they see fit to import oats and pay a higher price for it because they say it is essential for the quality of the blood stock which they breed, I take it these men know their business best, and that I cannot teach them. I take it that if they find it essential they will still continue to import that special quality of oats. Then we have this quality of screened oats. It is well known that in such places as Canada, when they thresh and screen wheat, the wheat is not always pure. It is mixed up with a good deal of foreign seed and oats and other things—mostly oats. That is sent over here at a cheap price. It is excellent poultry-feeding, and is very cheap. If we produce no oats to enter into competition with them, all these classes will have to be allowed in under licence.
So far as the oats tariff is concerned, it is simply an appeal to the prejudices of the farmer. Farmers are not growing oats for sale as a cash crop in any quantity. I have personal knowledge of the farmers in my county and the number who are dependent upon the cash they receive from their oats crop to keep them going is almost nil. Generally the farmer simply grows oats for his own personal requirements and when he threshes, if he has a load or two too much, he probably sells it for cash, which will come in handy, but if he sold his whole crop at that price it might be an actual loss. I think there is nothing in the proposal for a tariff or embargo on oats, but I feel in the same way with regard to that as to the other items. I am willing to have it submitted to the Tariff Commission to examine into all the reactions and repercussions and to accept the general tenor of their report on the question. Deputy de Valera said this was only the thin edge of the wedge of the economic policy which his Party stands for. He mentioned that they stood for wheat growing. I heard Deputy Ryan and Deputy de Valera expounding the policy of wheat growing.
Comment on this
I shall not discuss it beyond saying that if the policy which was expounded were carried out in the way suggested it would cost this country at the present time £4,100,000 in subsidy. If I had got up in this Dáil and advocated a policy which if carried out would cost that, I would never raise my head again in this Dáil as an advocate of agriculture.
I feel that I would be wanting in courage if I did not give voice to my opinion on this matter. I feel that I would not be doing justice to the policy which I stand for, and which I have always stood for, if I remained silent, I believe that if this policy is expounded clearly to the people and particularly to the farmers they will realise that it is not a policy which is meant for their good.
The tactics here are those that was sought to be adopted by the Tories when they wanted to dish the Whigs. This is an attempt by the Fianna Fáil Party to dish the Cumann na nGaedheal and the Farmers' Party. I do not believe that they will dish them. The farmers may be simple and uninformed, but they have a shrewd sense of what is at the back of all this. When they read some of the speeches made here to-day they will realise that this policy of Protection for agriculture is only a blind which is intended to deceive them and to bring them into the camp of the whole-hog Protectionists, and which will result in raising the prices of the articles they consume as Protection has already raised prices, and will continue to raise them until the farmer finds himself placed in an intolerable and hopelessly uneconomic position, and until he becomes what he has not been before, a serf. We have the most independent farmers in the world. If the Fianna Fáil policy materialised it would turn the farmers of this country into serfs of the economists and industrialists in this country who are controlling the Fianna Fáil Party by controlling its finances.
Comment on this
We are at present endeavouring to raise funds in order to fight a by-election so that I hope nobody will be misled by the statement of the Deputy that the Fianna Fáil Party is receiving any funds from the industrialists.
Comment on this
I believe it is an unsound policy to ask the Dáil to examine into and give a verdict on an elaborate policy of this kind dealing with agriculture, which is confessed to be only the first step in the general agricultural and economic policy of the Party opposite. If it is to be referred to the Tariff Commission set up to examine and report upon it I am prepared, although I do not believe, with the exception of butter, that anything effective or useful can come out of tariffs of this kind, to accept the report of the Commission and to give my support to the legislation necessary to carry it into effect.
Comment on this
I thought that the Leader of the old defunct Farmers' Party would have the grace to hold his tongue in this matter. Unfortunately he did not. He knows so much about the present-day agriculture that he has stated here that we export £6,000,000 worth of bacon. That was the statement by the responsible leader of the Farmers' Party. That shows how much he knows about agriculture. When the leader of the late Farmers' Party stands up in this House and protests against tariffs on agricultural produce coming into this country and at the same time votes in favour of tariffs on down quilts and margarine and old women's rosary beads, what can we expect from him after that?
I want to deal with what is more important still, namely, the prohibition of the importation of foreign barley and foreign malt. I think it is a contemptible thing if the country is going to be ruled by one industry or supposedly one portion of an industry, that is the brewing industry. We have here a list and statement of the imports of foreign barley into this country in the last few years. And examining the imports and exports of beer and comparing them with the imports of foreign barley and malt into the country I consider at least that there is no justification whatever for the large increase in the imports of foreign barley and malt in the last few years, even taking the statement of Messrs. Guinness on its face value that they have to import a certain amount of foreign barley to pander in the line of beer or porter to the taste of somebody. In the year 1928 Messrs. Guinness imported £110,000 worth of foreign barley, and in the year 1929 Guinness imported £220,000 worth of foreign barley. I see no justification in the figures of the exports of beer to justify that figure of imports. The story is far worse when we come to the question of foreign malt. I would like that somebody on the opposite benches would try to give the slightest bit of justification for the imports of foreign malt into this country. There may be some justification, taking Messrs. Guinness' statement on its face value, for importing foreign barley but I cannot see any justification whatever for the imports of foreign malt. During the past nine months, from January to September, 1929, taking the imports and exports I find that in 1929, 139,680 cwts. of foreign malt were imported. In the present year 319,000 cwts. of foreign malt were imported. That difference works out at 15s. 4d. per cwt. When we take the price of imported barley, it works at 7s. 1d. per cwt., so that we have 8s. 3d. per cwt. taken out of the pockets of the Irish workers by Messrs. Guinness.
Comment on this
There is no justification for it. If Messrs. Guinness could make their brew in Bristol, they would do it. It is not for our good they are here at all. There is no justification for taking out of the pockets of Irish workers the value of 139,000 cwt. in the last nine months. That is the position here with regard to the importation of foreign malt. That is more than onethird of the sum which the President throws as a sop to the unfortunate and starving workers of this country. That is greatly affecting the people of my constituency.
In the town of Midleton, where formerly there were 280 workers employed in the malting house, there are eight or ten employed to-day. Close on 200 families have been thrown out of employment through the importation of foreign malt. Whatever justification there may be for the brewers or one brewer who is importing foreign barley—I am glad to say there is only one importing foreign barley—there is no justification for importing foreign malt and throwing the workers idle. It is the duty of any Government not tied head, neck and heels to Messrs. Guinness to interfere and stop that, but they are bound to Messrs. Guinness by some unknown financial squeeze. We heard a lot from Deputy Bennett to-day about the importing of foreign produce and what can be grown here. Deputy Bennett has apparently kept clear of the circumstances. The circumstances are that the tillage land of this country has been valued as wheat land under Griffith's valuation. The unfortunate farmers living on tillage land have to pay rates upon that high valuation. The valuation of tillage land is higher than the valuation of land in the Golden Vale in Limerick, which is entirely grass land. Repeated appeals have been made in this House from 1927 upwards to the Minister for Finance for a revaluation of the land of Ireland, but his Party are not going to change their economic policy.
The tillage farmers are, at least, entitled to fair play. As Deputy O'Connell said, 110,000 acres went out of tillage last year. Is there any farmer who is prepared to grow oats at £4 10s. per ton with the dread always hanging over his head that there will be 400,000 or 500,000 tons of foreign oats thrown into the country at any moment? No farmer will till his land with that threat hanging over his head. That is the position as I view it. It is not so much a question of the amount of oats imported this year as the uncertainty which it creates in the market. As I say, the tillage farmer is entitled at least to the home market for his produce. It is all very well for Deputy Shaw and other racehorse owners to tell us that their horses will not jump high enough when fed on home-grown oats. Perhaps that is the reason they are sending oats from Russia here, perhaps they want our military horses to jump higher in Moscow or somewhere else. They must be acclimatised before they go. These horses are costing us between £5,000 and £6,000 per year.
Comment on this
We are discussing the reason for importing foreign oats. The Minister for Agriculture in March and April last would not listen to demands in this House for a tariff on foreign butter when it was being dumped into this country wholesale, but he is now flirting with the subject because he plunged the finances of this country into butter and the establishment of creameries. That is his child and he is prepared to adopt it.
Comment on this
I could learn from you how to spell margarine. It is time that something was done for our tillage farmers. We were told last night by the President that the position of the farmers is better than it was before and we were told a while ago by the late leader of the Farmers' Party that this was a political stunt on the part of Fianna Fáil. Another leader, Deputy Gorey, at a public meeting supported the proposal to prohibit the importation of foreign oats and the imposition of a tariff on foreign bacon. Then there are the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies—Deputies Dwyer and Aird. I do not know how they are going to vote, but I appeal to them to have the courage of their convictions for once. I hope to see Deputy Gorey walking into the same lobby with me.
Comment on this
In fact, in order to get him there I would be prepared to keep out of it so that he would not twist and turn again. This, however, is far too serious a matter to be treated in any jocose fashion. We have supported tariffs on foreign industrial articles coming in here because we believe that every man who is held in industry here is increasing our home market. We see no reason why foreign agricultural produce should be dumped here. The reasons put forward against this motion are absolutely false and no one knows that better than Deputies opposite. Any Deputy who has been through his constituency during the past five months knows that he is bound in justice to the farmers to come here and support this motion despite the opinion of the Minister for Agriculture and his colleagues. I hope that Deputies opposite who supported what practically amounted to the same motion as this at conferences outside recently will have the courage of their convictions and vote for it and not be dragged away by any whip from their organisation. I think that any Deputy who is not tied hand and leg to the brewers' organisation or any such organisation will support this motion.
Comment on this
I did not intend to intervene in this debate, but as Deputy Heffernan adumbrated such extraordinary doctrines I could not remain seated. The sum total of his speech was that this motion is wrong because it comes from Fianna Fáil. I suppose that if Fianna Fáil proposed to give a roast pig to every farmer in Ireland for his Christmas dinner Deputy Heffernan would say it was wrong because Fianna Fáil proposed it. He suggested that we must not consider the national position so much. I am sure that he was not serious in that and that he did not fully consider the implications of that statement before he made it. It is the reactions of such motions as this upon the nation as a whole that we must primarily consider. This motion was very necessary. It was very necessary to drag from the Government Party some statement as to what they intend to do, if they intend to do anything, to relieve the present state of our farmers. So far as one can gather from statements of responsible members of the Government Party, they seem to have adopted the policy of letting things drag. The Minister for Agriculture told us last night that the Tariff Commission was the sheet anchor of the farmers. I have no conception of what a sheet anchor is, but if it is something which would be likely to drag one into a current and leave one submerged there, I submit that the Minister is right and that it is the farmers' sheet anchor. The Tariff Commission has, in fact, been so slow in its actions that it is almost impossible to detect whether it has any motion at all. With the terms of this motion I am almost in entire agreement, but I must confess that there is one item about which I am not quite easy. In many parts of the country there is a certain domestic economy which has come down for at least decades and I am not at all convinced that you can alter a tradition of that kind in a short space of time or alter it so much by acts of a legislative assembly such as this. You may influence it to some extent but you must be careful as to what will happen during the period in which you are altering it. You may say that that economy is bad for that particular community who have adopted it, but, be it bad or good, it is there and you have to consider it. Item 3 of the motion proposes a tariff on imported bacon. It is, no doubt, intended to help the Irish pig producer, and if I saw that such would be the result of it I would heartily support it, but I am not quite happy about it.
Let us analyse the situation as far as we can, from the returns supplied to us. We are not supplying the Irish market at the moment. There is a large import of bacon. There is a big demand across the Channel that is not supplied, and if the proposed tariff on bacon is going to increase pig production, how is it, can anybody explain— and Deputy Dr. Ryan has certainly not convinced me, nor has Deputy Davin— going to increase production and preserve the Irish market for the Irish pig producers? If I could see a way by which that could be achieved I would certainly support the doctrine whole-heartedly, but right across the Channel there is a large demand, and there is no corresponding increase in pig production here to supply that demand. How are you going to increase pig production here in order to supply the home market, and yet hold your foreign market? That is the thing that is troubling me.
For the nine months ending September, 1930, we imported 293,512 cwts. of bacon. If you work that out in terms of pigs, it would come to something like 140,000 pigs. Are we in a position to produce, in a reasonably short space of time, 140,000 pigs to supply that market? I have not heard so far one argument that would convince me that we are going to supply that market. In 1929 we imported 357,812 cwts. of bacon. If that is worked out and expressed in terms of pigs, you find that we imported something like 180,000 pigs. Can we produce that much here in this country? That is just one argument that has not been developed either by Deputy Dr. Ryan or by Deputy Davin. We have to consider those people who have that domestic economy coming down through the decades. We have to consider where we are going to get these hundreds of thousands of pigs while the bacon industry of the country is being reorganised. If the bacon industry were reorganised to such a pitch that we could be sure that in the interim between now and when the Irish market could be capable of supplying it, that there would be no hardship on the consumers in the country, then we might say that it was something on which all parties could agree.
I propose to vote for the motion, because I agree with nine-tenths of it. I have no faith whatever in the economic policy of the Minister for Agriculture or the present Executive Council. This motion, as I said at the outset, is very necessary to force them to take some action. If it does force them to take some action, it will have achieved its purpose. If it forces them to make the Tariff Commission to do some work and to do it in an effective fashion, it will have served its purpose. Three-fourths of the motion is excellent, but there is just that one matter to which I referred, and which I would like to hear Deputy Dr. Ryan develop when replying.
Comment on this
I can give three very excellent reasons why, judged on their merits, these proposals should not be entertained. The first is that there is no volume of agricultural opinion behind these proposals. The second is that it is a decided attempt to short-circuit the Tariff Commission. Lastly, and perhaps most important, the proposals, I submit, are too absurd on the face of them to get the dignity of a full-dress debate. It is not the merits of the proposals before us, but it is what is not in the proposals that has made it important for this House to consider them. That is, if I might use the expression, it is a means of drawing the badger, and it is a means of extracting from the Government some definite idea of what the real policy is in regard to agriculture. I do not, and I never did since I came into the House, or for a considerable time before I came into it, believe in a tariff policy. We had yesterday an example from the Government Benches which to me, indeed, was a very pleasing thing to see. We had the Minister for Industry and Commerce making a kind of apologia for tariffs generally. I think he was one of the principal members of the Executive Council who was instrumental in bringing tariffs to this country, himself and the Minister for Finance.
I have heard it stated here in the course of the debate by the Minister for Justice that tariffs should not be imposed until they were very carefully considered. Were the first tariffs which were put on in this country very carefully considered? They were not. They were put on solely for the purpose, not of increasing our industrial employment, but purely and simply for the purpose of revenue, to delude the people into the belief that taxation was low, and having them pay it on their wearing apparel, shoes, and food. That was the sole object of tariffs when they were first launched in this country. The Government, I am glad to say, are finding—late in the day no doubt—that they made a mistake in being even half-hogged Protectionists, and the Minister for Agriculture might have frankly told us—he did not quite go the whole hog—that he was not in favour of tariffs in any shape or form.
Like Deputy Hogan, I did not intend to intervene in this debate, because I thought it was really too absurd. Deputy Gorey is in a rather peculiar position, and I would be glad to see him go into the slips with Deputy Corry, but he only comes in now to run a bye in the national produce stakes. On the merits of the case in regard to the question of the embargo on oats, I think that the House is convinced that such an idea is absurd, that the matter is not worthy of consideration. There is only one matter in connection with it to which I would like to refer, and that is the statement made by Deputy White, who stated that when the 50s. per ton duty was put on oatmeal, it was of no benefit to the farmer, and was a benefit only to the middleman.
Everyone with any experience will agree also with that. But he went further and he said that notwithstanding that, flake meal was being imported from outside, from Belfast and other places and sold at a very high figure per stone, something like £32 per ton. Do you know why that happens? Why that happens is because there are live people in the business in other parts of the world while we are asleep. There are people in Belfast and in other places getting money out of oats because they advertise the fact and the public know about it. Advertising is what sells foreign stuff in Ireland. We have the best stuff in the world and we will not advertise it ourselves. With regard to barley there is a lot of humbug being spoken by the members of the Grain Growers' Association on the question of barley generally. I will give you my own experience of the Grain Growers' Association. Some two years ago, a Deputy in this House was in a terrible state of excitement as to what was to happen to the barley grown in his district. He was a member of the Government Party. He put down a question on the Order Paper and got very little satisfaction. He asked me about it and I told him he was foolish. When he left the House I asked him, "have you any barley for sale and how much have you?" He told me what he had. I said, "I will sell it for you—what is your price?" He gave me his price and I could have sold every ounce of that barley. I asked to have it delivered in wagon-loads but he never delivered a bag of it.
That is a typical instance of the barley growers. They want someone else to look after their business for them. I could have sold every bag of that barley in the County Cavan to the Cavan pig feeders, but the gentleman who was so excited about the barley could not deliver one bag in Cavan for the pig feeders there. And then we are told they want an embargo on barley, and we are told they want prohibition of some sort to assist men who will not take steps to assist themselves. Truly, there is a question in this matter of barley growing with regard to transport, but the question did not arise about this particular barley. I left the question of carriage out. I could have sold it and paid the carriage. What really happened immediately afterwards was that in that district the price of barley rose 2s. a barrel a couple of days afterwards, and it was because it rose that couple of shillings and that they got that couple of shillings that they would not come into a competitive market with their barley. As long as men are satisfied to supply Messrs. Guinness's maltsters or anybody else at a tied price and do not look for competitive markets, there is always going to be a grievance in the barley-growing districts. These men have been doing this thing for years. They may be very good huntsmen but they are very bad barley-growers and barley sellers.
I just came across a little matter to-day which is rather interesting. The Department of Agriculture have, I think, their own breed of barley known as "145." It is a good malting barley, and I believe the Department is prepared to back it. I believe it is a good barley. A great number of people have grown "145" barley, but in some of those places the maltsters are refusing that barley to-day, and insisting upon other barley. They are giving a lower price of 2/- a barrel for that barley than for Archer's Spratt. Why? Because they know they will get that barley later on at a lower price. That is how the price goes down and the Grain Growers' Association do not see that. Let them come up into a competitive market in County Cavan and then there will be no question of the sale of their barley to be solved.
Comment on this
Can they not feed their pigs at home with this barley where it is grown?
Comment on this
With regard to the question of bacon I would say that this matter may be divided into two sections. There is bacon which we must continue to import, bacon which suits the taste and the palate. Deputy de Valera does not believe that they have any taste or that there is any question of palate in the agricultural districts. There has been a taste acquired for American bacon and there is something more than a question of taste in it. There is a question of palate attached to the matter of American bacon. If you put an embargo on American bacon where is the substitute to be got? You cannot substitute it. You cannot get the Irish pig producers to raise a bacon pig similar to the American bacon pig. How many years would it take to do it? You cannot get it. There is some reason in talking about the imports of other foreign bacon, such as bacon imports from Germany, Poland, Ukraine, Denmark and Holland. I have gone to the trouble of investigating it. I have had before me sides of bacon from Ukraine and other countries. I put Irish bacon alongside it, and I have no hesitation in saying that no man here could distinguish between Irish bacon and the imported bacon from these countries. I do not mean to say that the imported bacon is as good as the Irish bacon but to the uninitiated it appears to be as good. This foreign bacon that I am speaking about was branded. Here is what the motion says:—
"the marking legibly of all imported meat entering the Free State, so as to indicate the country of origin when such meat is exposed for sale."
I think that should be carried out because it is one item of the proposals with which I agree, but if it were carried out as it is, it would not meet the situation.
Bacon is imported and sold side by side with Limerick bacon in the various shops in the country but there is at least a difference of 4d. per pound to the wholesaler. It is sold, however, at the same price. I have seen a brand put on bacon but I know that that is not an indelible brand. When that bacon goes through the process of smoking, and it does go through that process, that bacon is turned out without the brand. If you are going to deal with the bacon question, what you must do is to get the people who smoke this foreign brand of bacon to brand it, not on the shoulder, but right across the side with not more than a certain space apart so that the buyer cannot help seeing the brand of the bacon. I agree with Deputy Cassidy when he says that something more has to be done. You must insist on the retailers displaying in their shops a notice stating that "Foreign bacon is sold here." When that notice is displayed the housewife will ask for Irish bacon. Most housewives will, undoubtedly, ask for Irish bacon. As matters stand it is not asked for.
A gentleman told me yesterday that he went into a shop, not in Dublin, but in a town within fifty miles of Dublin. While in the shop a woman came in and he heard her asking for four lbs. of Irish bacon. There was a side of Limerick bacon and a side of foreign bacon on the counter, and the shopkeeper cut the four lbs. off the foreign bacon and gave it to the woman. When the customer left the shop this gentleman asked the shopkeeper: "Is that Russian bacon?""No," said the shopkeeper, "it is Chinese." That woman went home in the belief that she got four lbs. of Limerick bacon, and what is more, she paid the price for it. The retailer did not tell her that that bacon was bought by him at a lesser price. The process of smoking bacon is a very cheap one and the profits that are gained by the retailer and the deception played on the consumer are certainly things into which the Government should look more carefully than they do at present. If this motion does nothing else but make the Government follow that up, without putting on any embargo at all, it will have done very useful work.
The Minister for Agriculture, when dealing with this question of bacon, let us into a few secrets. He stated that the price in England is fixed by four of the big wholesale people. They are big distributors, and they fix the price of the bacon. The price of Irish bacon is fixed, having regard to the price of Danish. The Minister stated further that we could increase our export of bacon in Great Britain by at least fifty per cent. With that I entirely agree. That statement by the Minister was made in answer to the proposals put up in this motion. Why has not the Minister seen that the exports were increased by 50 per cent. before these proposals were put to the House? I look upon it as an admission of failure by the Minister. He should have known from his advisers in London that we could increase our exports by 50 per cent., and yet that was not done. These are the questions that we have to consider, and not questions of tariffs.
There is only one matter in this country worth thinking about, only one question that the Dáil should concentrate upon for the next twelve months. If the Dáil did concentrate upon this one matter and left aside all the Bills about twopence-halfpenny things for at least twelve months, the country would benefit. We should concentrate upon the marketing of our produce. Our produce is the best in the world, and we should market it as it should be marketed. There is practically no need to legislate for the betterment of the farmers for the next five years. Our whole energies should be directed to marketing our products, and the farmers would derive immediate benefit. As it is, we are deluged with legislation and with blue books, and we get no further.
Any man who does not take an interest in the agricultural industry, does not deserve to be a citizen of the State. Agriculture is the only industry we have. People talk about developing the other arm. While they are talking about developing the other arm, and talking about an additional 13,000 people being employed as the result of tariffs, they are paralysing the agricultural arm that we all have to stand by. According to the Minister's own statement, the necessary nourishment is not being given in order to keep the right arm of the State going. Let us concentrate more upon the agricultural arm. There is no use in bringing up proposals for tariffs or tinkering with the question. This is nothing else but tinkering with the whole economic question. Anyone who has ever studied economic questions will realise that.
Is there a man in Ireland to-day who will say that there is an economist in any part of the world who is not talking nonsense? We are in the midst of economic chaos; every country in the world is economically unsound; every country is looking for some economist who will supply a panacea for its troubles. Where is America, the home of tariffs? She is in a hopeless condition and she is looking for an economist to show her the way out. We do not want any of your economists to intervene in our affairs. We see what is necessary. The Minister for Agriculture tells us that we can increase our exports by 50 per cent. If we do that we have no need for an economist. Is not that the whole situation in a nut-shell? Let us concentrate on that particular point. The fact is that we have the best country in the world mishandled.
In the course of this debate we had one Party throwing at another the suggestion of a coalition of Labour and Fianna Fáil. That may or may not be true. The men who make those statements are themselves in glass houses. Everything has a political colour in this country. It is time for us to drop that and to become aware of the economic factors that are controlling us. Economic factors are the all-important matter and it is time for us to decide once and for all that this country will divorce politics from economics. If we do that we can forge ahead; we can do what the Minister says we could do, increase our agricultural market by 50 per cent. Once we do that we have the whole question solved.
Deputy de Valera made a most extraordinary statement; it was extraordinary coming from him. I do not want to be unfair to any Deputy, but the statement seemed to me to be extraordinary. Possibly I may have a peculiar point of view. The Deputy said that agriculture was overcrowded; in other words, it was not able to maintain the number of people at present existing on agriculture. He used the word "saturated" and said that agriculture was what you might call saturated with population.
Comment on this
And you are going to increase the population by drawing off the surplus to the towns in order to develop the dead arm, an arm we never had. What is going to happen our principal industry, agriculture, while you are reducing the saturation? The Deputy mentioned that in agricultural Ireland there were 600,000 people and he described the position by saying that our principal industry was saturated from the point of view of population. If this country were properly developed——
Comment on this
Not on your basis. If the country were properly developed, we would have double the number of people on the land in Ireland and we could give them a standard of living much better than they are getting to-day. I do not care what position he may be in, but there is no person in the State to-day living on a lower standard than the people upon whom we are depending for our bread and butter. It is a reproach to the State that this position of affairs should exist. I know there are people in this country to whom the very name of farmer suggests something low and mean and actually beneath them. And yet these very men are the sons of farmers, but they forget that when they come to the City. These men are doing the greatest injury and injustice to the industry that put them into their professions or businesses. That is the type of intelligence that is prevalent in this country and the sooner it is got rid of the better.
I could say quite a lot on this subject, but I do not want to prevent other Deputies from taking part in the debate. There are, however, one or two other points to which I would like to refer. The Minister for Justice said that one of the ways of dealing with farmers in a bad way was to advise them to apply to the Agricultural Credit Corporation. That just gave me an inspiration. The Minister for Justice knows very little about the working of agricultural credit when he recommends a man who is in a bad way to go to the Agricultural Credit Corporation. When would that man get assistance and what are his chances of getting it? Even if his claim did go through more quickly than anybody else's, when would he have relief? The people in the country do not regard the Corporation as an assistance to agriculture.
When the Agricultural Credit Corporation, which was supposed to be for the benefit of the farmers, was launched, I remember making the complaint that an opportunity for investment was not placed before the small investors and that it was confined only to the better-off people. Even the very poor and badly-done announcements about the Corporation appeared only in the daily Press. The result of that was that the flotation, so far as the public was concerned, was a failure. I am perfectly satisfied that it was designed to be a failure. According to the Minister for Finance only £20,000 was subscribed by the public to this great scheme for the purpose of giving long-term loans to the farmers. There was a reason for that. I do not want to go back on it, but there was a reason and not a very creditable reason for that failure. The public were not meant to subscribe or allowed to subscribe because it was not intended that they should have any power of control over the Agricultural Credit Corporation. Had the public subscribed they would have power to nominate people on the Board and they would have availed possibly of that power. There was another flotation of bonds for the Agricultural Credit Corporation a short time ago, scarcely a month ago. Agricultural bonds were put on the market. The statement was made that the bonds were taken up in an hour. That statement is not true. That hour is just one hour of exaggeration. The issue was taken up before it was floated. It was actually subscribed before it was floated. What I complain about is this: The President said a great deal——
Comment on this
It is now past 10 o'clock, and it was agreed that Deputy Dr. Ryan should have half an hour for reply. I think Deputy O'Hanlon could get another opportunity to debate this question.
Comment on this
It is not often that I intervene in debates in this House, and I want to finish my speech.
Comment on this
There was an understanding that this debate would begin after Questions, and conclude at 10.30 p.m. It was stated from the Chair that Deputy Ryan should be allowed at least half an hour to conclude. That has been the practice, and I think it ought to be adhered to. Apart from that arrangement, I think Deputy O'Hanlon will agree, if he looks at the motion on the Order Paper, that the operations of the Agricultural Credit Corporation are outside its scope.
Comment on this
I do not see why I should be ruled out of order for referring to the Agricultural Credit Corporation. Other speakers have referred to it. It was the Minister for Justice introduced the Agricultural Credit Corporation into the debate. I am only a private member, but I should get the same liberty as the Minister for Justice got in the debate.
Comment on this
I did not hear the Minister for Justice, but there can be no doubt whatever that the question of the flotation of loans by the Agricultural Credit Corporation is not relevant to this debate. I should be very much surprised if that question were already dealt with in this debate; I do not think it was. The Deputy would be clearly out of order in dealing with that question now, but another opportunity could be found to debate it.
Comment on this
The statement has been made that agriculture is in a most depressed condition. It is agreed that it is in a most depressed condition and there is a flotation of agricultural bonds. They were subscribed for—it does not matter by whom they were issued—before they were put on the market. It is stated that they were subscribed for an hour after issue. The public were informed, before they got an opportunity of subscribing, that the bonds had been already subscribed, and that if they liked they could go to the Stock Exchange and buy them at a premium in order to enable the underwriters—we do not know who they were—to make a profit in a day. That is not good business.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Hanlon has talked some of the most nonsensical platitudes that have been uttered in this debate. He talked about the two arms—the agricultural arm and the industrial arm. One arm he described as dead at one time and at another time as unborn. There are several countries in a prosperous condition as a result of developing the two arms of agriculture and industry at the same time. Practically all the European countries which have been recovering from a state of depression have worked in that way. If we take France, in which there has been a policy of pronounced Protection, we find that the French have found a market for their agricultural produce at home, and that they have also found a market for their industrial products at home. In that way, they have obtained employment for all their people in their own country. There is no necessity for emigration there, because they have developed the two arms. Deputy O'Hanlon would advise us to go out and compete in the foreign market against every country in Europe. He would advise us to spend money in advertising in the foreign market, money on foreign consuls, money on trade representatives, and money in attending economic conferences.
If we take the two big products which we are trying to develop in this country and which the Government believe we ought to push on the foreign market—butter and bacon— we find that on the British market the value of imported butter from 1927 to 1929 has increased from £48,000,000 to £54,700,000, while the amount that was exported from the Free State has remained static. Our rivals on the English market have been every year much more active, and we are trying to hold our own. The fact that we put on a little more butter in that market may not in itself have the effect of lowering the prices there, but the fact that every country is putting more butter every year on the British market will certainly have the effect of lowering the prices. There is, therefore, no hope that the prices for the exported article are going to increase. The same thing applies to bacon. For the same years, the value of bacon imports into Great Britain increased from £38,600,000 to £43,700,000, while our export of bacon from the Free State only increased by £400,000. It was not the fact that we increased our bacon by a small amount that brought down the price of bacon, but it was the fact that practically every other country competing against us increased its supplies to the British market that caused this. That brought the price of bacon down. Now we are advised by Deputy O'Hanlon—who gave us the impression that no economist in the world could solve this question, while he was himself endeavouring to solve it—that we should go more and more into this business of competing in the British market for bacon, butter and eggs, and that we should go in for advertising.
The Minister for Agriculture wanted to know to-day if we had dropped the other portions of our agricultural policy—if this represented our sole contribution. I think I stated here to-day at the outset that this motion, if passed, would only go a small way towards solving our agricultural difficulties. We have not dropped other parts of our agricultural policy and we are not afraid to say that we still believe that motions that were brought in here by us would be good for this country. We are not afraid to say that we still believe that this country should produce wheat for itself. We are not afraid to say that it would be a good thing for this country if it produced all the feeding stuffs required for our own cattle and stock. Deputy Heffernan said that if our wheat policy had been carried, when brought in last autumn, it would have cost the country this year over four million pounds. Our total wheat supplies, if the farmers were paid 40s. per barrel, would not cost four million pounds. I think we were told by practically every opponent on the opposite bench that we would never get our total requirements of wheat grown in this country. Now, when it suits him, Deputy Heffernan assumes that the total wheat supply would have been produced in the first year. That was concurred in by the Minister for Agriculture. That sort of talk is not going to do any good. The most we could expect to get would be 100,000 acres the first year and the most we would have to pay the farmers would be 30s. a barrel—and they would be well paid. I do not think anybody would deny that. On that calculation, the cost would be somewhere about £100,000 for 100,000 acres of wheat.
Comment on this
It was calculated that with 12 cwt. per acre of milling wheat the total requirements would be 800,000 acres. That would be perhaps £100,000 for 100,000 acres of wheat. But the people who condemned that policy are not afraid to admit that they have advised the growing of beet and have paid the farmer for doing so entirely out of public funds, handing the beet over as a present to a foreign company. But when it is a matter of growing wheat or of helping the farmer to grow it, making him bear a certain proportion of the cost himself, keeping Irish mills, owned by Irish capital working, then there is no sympathy from those on the opposite side. Deputy Heffernan may accuse us of being subsidised, bribed and financed as he put it by manufacturers in this country in order to support tariffs. Our opponents went back to the old argument that prohibition of oats could make no difference because the quantity was so small. Deputy Bennett was the first to mention that and the Minister for Agriculture used the same argument. How, they asked, could it make any difference when £30,000 worth of oats came in, considering that our total production was £5,000,000? It does make a difference and for Deputy Bennett's benefit I would like to put the case that I put here before. If there were prohibition of oats at present and if he were a merchant would he not be prepared to give as much for Irish oats as they are worth compared with any other feeding stuffs? But if there is a danger, and the danger is there, that Russian oats can come in at any time at 4s. or 5s. a barrel, is the Deputy prepared to give 11s. per barrel for Irish oats? He is not. He is afraid that Russian oats will come in and lower the price. There is a possibility that Russian oats will come in at a ridiculous price, thus keeping down the price of those who have Irish oats to sell.
It may be considered an offence for a man to grow oats for sale. Deputy Gorey will say that such a man never soils his hands. He has asked if such men are prepared to produce pigs, and if they are afraid to soil their hands in some sort of useful industry. I know a good deal about tillage farmers and about the men who produce pigs, and I am quite prepared to state that those who go in for tillage have a much worse time when it comes to hard work than any other farmer in the community.
The Minister suggests that they should feed their own stock with their own oats. He says that is their policy, and that our policy is to get the wholesale price of feeding stuff for oats as a cash crop. I have learned this, that as far as the Minister is concerned, it does not matter what we say, he will use his argument. It does not matter what we say, he will interpret it to suit his own argument. However, I will repeat what I said. The man who is able and who can afford to feed his own grain to his stock, is doing it. We are not concerned with that man. It is with the man who cannot do so that we are concerned. It has been argued by Deputy Bennett and by the Minister for Agriculture that a tariff will make no difference whatever in the price of oats. The Minister stated plainly that it would make no difference to the seller or to the purchaser of oats whether a tariff went on or not. Seeing that there is a large volume of opinion in favour of tariffs, as the Minister learned in Carlow, why does he not impose a tariff that can make no difference?
When coming to bacon, the Minister said that the Irish curers could buy many more pigs, and that they were prepared to do so. Perhaps that is so. If it is the case, why is it that the export of live pigs increased from 199,000 in 1929 to 269,000 in 1930? Why is it that the Irish curers, who are prepared to take twice as many pigs, allow so many live pigs out of the country? During the same time the number of pigs bought for curing in the Free State went down from 584,000 to 482,000. One thing is evident, either that the number of pigs going out of the country is on the increase or British curers must be in a position to give a bigger price than Irish curers. I think that is quite evident.
Comment on this
Most of the pigs in Cork and Kilkenny are fed up to 20 st., and go direct to Birmingham.
Comment on this
On the other hand if English curers are giving more for Irish live pigs than the Irish curers, why do they not take the lot? The point is that the demand for English bacon on the English market must be limited. In the same way seeing that the number of pigs in Ireland fluctuates and that the price fluctuates, the demand for Irish bacon on the English market must be limited to a small number. The Minister says that the price of Irish bacon is fixed in relation to Danish bacon. I do not know if he can stand by that. If the Minister traces the prices in the British market for the past two or three years, he will find that there are big fluctuations between the prices of the two articles. They do not follow on parallel lines. It is quite evident that there is a demand for a certain amount of Irish bacon on the British market, just as there is a demand for a certain amount of Danish bacon. The point is that we have a certain market in Great Britain for a certain amount of bacon, but we cannot go beyond that seeing that the demand is not there. If we do go beyond that the price comes down to a level at which it does not pay to produce bacon, and therefore we get out of pigs. Why should we not capture the home market in addition to the other market? We have been told that a tariff would increase the price to the poor consumer of low grade bacon. It is admitted that that bacon is of a low grade.
Comment on this
The Minister said that it was admitted by me and by others that the effect of a tariff on bacon would not get a better price for the Irish producer. What I said was this, that there were two choices open to the Irish producer if this prohibition on imports were carried, (1) that he could increase his production; that is, that he could supply the present part of the British market that he has and, in addition, supply the home market; or (2) I said that he could choose the most select part of the present market. If he chose the most select part of the British market, obviously what I meant by that was that he would choose the part where he would get a better price than he is getting at present. He has two choices, either to increase production at present prices or to remain at his present production and get a better price for what he produces. Deputy Gorey, I admit, made a better case for the bacon tariff than I made. He has more experience of that trade than a good many of us here have. He has also the experience that the home market is more stable, and in addition, the Deputy made the point that if the portion of my motion dealing with bacon were passed it would again induce people in this country to kill pigs for their own use. That is to say, people here would go in more for domestic killing, and that certainly would be a very good result if it could be achieved.
Deputy White spoke about oatmeal. I think from the figures given that the complaint the Deputy made on this is not as serious as he imagines. We find that in 1926, when the census of production was taken, we imported 219,000 cwts. of oatmeal and in addition to that we produced here another three-quarters of a million cwts., so that our total requirements of oatmeal at that time were about one million cwts. In 1929 the imports had gone down to 60,000 cwts., so that we have reduced our imports from 219,000 cwts. to 60,000.
Comment on this
It shows that the tariff on oatmeal has been a success. So far that has not done any good to the farmer. The only way in which it could be made of benefit to the farmer would be by prohibiting the import of oats because then the oatmeal mills would have to take the Irish oats. We were told by Deputy White that flake oatmeal was coming into the Free State from Belfast at £32 per ton.
Comment on this
I was going to remind the Deputy in case he did not know it that it could be got from a Free State source—Drogheda.
Comment on this
I do not know. I have not looked into that. The Minister for Justice quoted an interview on the deplorable state of things in Australia, and said that a tariff policy had ruined Australia. He quoted from a meeting held by all the primary producers responsible for 95 per cent. of Australian exports over the last four or five years. Is it not a peculiar thing that no matter what change of Government takes place in Australia that all the Governments there stick to a tariff policy, and that it should take a member of our Government to advise the Australian people as to what they ought to do? I hope they will hear of and take note of the advice which our Minister for Justice gives them. I have here a quotation from a speech made by Mr. Hughes, a former Prime Minister of Australia, and according to our Minister for Justice he is in error. But Mr. Hughes still believes in a tariff policy as the only policy for Australia. Here is what he says:—
"The only hope for the primary producer lies in the increasing consumption capacity of Australia through growth of population and higher consuming per capita....
Owing to the employment they provide and the wealth they create, the consumption powers of the home market have so increased that, out of the total wealth production in 1928 of £447,000,000, £350,000,000 were consumed in Australia, leaving only £97,000,000 for the depressed markets of the outside world."
That is what Mr. Hughes thinks of the outside world. We have met with a certain amount of encouragement for our motion from various elements. For instance, if you take the creamery districts of Tipperary and Limerick they will support a tariff on or a prohibition of butter. Deputy Heffernan and Deputy Bennett, who represent these creamery districts, are prepared to support the motion so far as it applies to butter. In the same way the Minister for Agriculture, who has staked his reputation on the butter industry, is prepared to consider butter. Those who are concerned with the butter districts are prepared favourably to consider that part of the motion dealing with butter.
Comment on this
Of course only in the event of the Tariff Commission giving a favourable report, but that applies only to what they are personally concerned in. Deputy Gorey agrees with the bacon proposals but not with the others. If the Deputies from Leix and Offaly were permitted to speak on the motion they would agree about barley——
Comment on this
Is the Deputy entitled to misquote every Deputy who has spoken from these benches? Every Deputy who has spoken from this side has said that he will agree to no tariff that has not been examined by the Tariff Commission.
Comment on this
I have said that as a matter of fact. The Minister for Agriculture need not have interrupted. I said that of course they wanted to put it to the Tariff Commission, but other matters with which they are not concerned they would not allow to go to the Tariff Commission.
Comment on this
On a point of correction, the Deputy is misquoting. He knows he is not telling the truth.
Comment on this
You know very well that you are misleading, and your Party knows it very well too, but it does not matter.
Comment on this
The only contribution to the debate from Deputy Shaw was an invitation to a Deputy on this side to spell the word "butter." The Deputy is very keen on that sort of interruption. The last time I heard Deputy Shaw making a similar interruption was at a meeting in Westmeath where he asked an interrupter to spell "Geoghegan," and he did spell it.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?