Public Business. - Betting Bill, 1930—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 186–379 of 379. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 23 of 1930 ›
I think it would be quite unfair to penalise a citizen, and that because he is of another business he must be prevented from becoming a licensed bookmaker. We have a number of people in one business carrying on another business. I do not think that such a penalty should be put upon a decent citizen simply because he is in another form of business. If the Dáil accepts that principle it will have eventually to cover a great deal more ground and to rope in a number of other people who have licences and who at the same time carry on other business in a proper manner. I do not think the Minister should accept that amendment.
Comment on this
Deputy Little has not spoken on this, and I do not know what his views are, but what appealed to me was this: If you have licensed moneylenders also carrying on betting business it might occur that they would encourage persons to go into debt for the purpose of betting, and you might have people going a good deal further in the way of getting themselves into financial difficulties than they would if they were not dealing with people in a double business. If there was any great objection by the House to it I would not stand over it.
Comment on this
I think there is a very strong case as the Minister has put it. You come across a case where money has been lent particularly for the purposes of betting. It is the worst type of moneylending. This applies to the other cases also.
Comment on this
I submit that Section 6 would cover that particular type of person. We have a number of people carrying on business as pawnbrokers at the moment and these are licensed bookmakers. They are quite reputable people.
Comment on this
I do not know whether there is anybody, but there is always something to be said for exempting people who are existing licence holders. If the existing licence holders were people against whom there was nothing I would not see any objection to allowing them to continue to be eligible for the present. I do not see any objection to meeting the Deputy in that way.
Comment on this
I move amendment 19:—
In sub-section (4), line 64, after the word "name" to insert the words "and place of residence."
This is simply in reference to the issue of a bookmaker's licence to include as well as name, place of residence.
Comment on this
There is no objection. That is already provided for in the regulations made under the Act.
Comment on this
I move:
To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:
"The Revenue Commissioners shall forward a copy of such relevant portions of the register to the Clerk of the proper District Court within a reasonable time from the commencement of this Act, and shall from time to time forward a copy of all entries and alterations in such Register to the said District Clerk."
This is to secure that the District Court Clerk would have the register in the court for reference whenever a case would come before the District Court.
Comment on this
I had an idea that it arose out of certain other amendments that were rejected by the House.
Comment on this
No, because if the other amendments had been carried, the District Court records would then show everything as to the people who would have got certificates. This is a case where the matter is in the hands of the Superintendent of the Gárda and where it is necessary for the Gárda to have in their possession a copy of the register proper to the area.
Comment on this
Perhaps I misunderstood the purpose of the amendment. I would like to look at that again to see if there is a necessity for it. No representations have been made to me that there was a necessity for it.
Comment on this
It would be a great relief to Deputy Little if he lived down in Skibbereen. If he lived along with me in Skibbereen he would have no such thing as a betting shop at all. He would be relieved of a great deal of annoyance.
Comment on this
I move amendment 21:—
In sub-section (1), lines 37-38, to delete the words "superintendent of the Gárda Síochána" and substitute the words "District Justice."
Comment on this
It is similar, but it applies to the suitability of the premises, and the arguments which I offered before hold good now. The Minister seems to be adamant on the question, and it appears that we will have to leave what a distinguished member on the other side of the House has called "a barbarous antiquity" to continue. I am moving the amendment.
Comment on this
This procedure does not give the person who objects to the issuing of the certificate a right to appeal against the decision of the Gárda. I think it is just as important that he should have the right to appeal as that the applicant should.
Comment on this
I think this whole matter of the premises will have to be further considered. One of the things we were most anxious to do was to prevent the position arising where value would attach to the premises by reason of having a betting licence attached to them. If you want to deal with a house having a licence for the sale of liquor one knows how difficult it is to get a conviction for an offence, because it is said that you are destroying property. When we first brought in the licensing of betting houses we did not know whether this would be allowed permanently. We thought we might have to abolish licences. We do not want property to rise in connection with betting licences, and I want nothing to be done now which would seem to equate the premises licensed for betting with premises licensed for the sale of liquor, or to do anything that would give an idea that there was a property in bookmakers' licences. One of the ways in which we could keep down the number of shops is to have some increase on a graduated scale of tax. There are districts in which there are too many betting houses. That would be the better way to keep down the number. I would not like to deal with the problem of keeping down the number by treating it in the same way as ordinary licensed premises.
Comment on this
The Bill in another part meets this difficulty, because it extinguishes licences of bookmakers when anything happens to the person. When a person parts with the premises the licence is extinguished and any other person who comes along must get a fresh licence, so that in that way the value attaches not to the premises but to the person.
Comment on this
There, again, I would not like the position as to property to arise in one district where there are normal numbers and in another district where they are abnormally few. I am inclined to think that this matter will have to be dealt with along the line of some graduated house tax.
Comment on this
I move amendment 23:
At the end of paragraph (e), line 16, to add the words "or with any residence."
I would like to know whether the Minister thinks this is necessary or not. We want to prevent the premises connecting internally. What is meant is that the shop should be structurally separate from the residence to prevent the younger members of the family from having to pass through the shop in order to go to the residence part. That would be an easy thing to do, and it would prevent people escaping in the event of a raid on the premises. It would be better that the betting premises would be entirely self-contained and that it would not be possible for people to abscond by the back door with papers which the police may be looking for.
Comment on this
If the Deputy would leave that over to the Report Stage I would look into the matter.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 24:—
Before paragraph (f) to insert a new paragraph as follows:
"that the annual rateable value where the premises are situated within the Dublin Metropolitan District is less than £15, or where the premises are situated elsewhere than within the Dublin Metropolitan District is less than £5."
Comment on this
This amendment goes with the section relating to the annual valuation. This supplies the machinery for getting the shop valued separately from the rest of the premises. Its real aim is to try to prevent sheds and undesirable places in an unsanitary condition in slum areas—premises which are of no valuation—from being used for the purpose of betting shops. It would be to the detriment of the health of people going there, and this amendment will help to raise the status of the business as far as it is possible to do so. I have fixed on a valuation of £15 because I find on looking up valuations in different streets— I do not mean the main traffic streets or other places where the valuation is high—that £15 would be about the average valuation. I rather think that £5 is high for a country town, and perhaps £3 would be sufficient there. I suggest that this would have a very good effect and would ensure that the premises would be in a good condition and that the business would be carried on in a reputable manner. I think that would be the result if some such standard of valuation as I suggest were fixed.
Comment on this
I would not see very much objection to this proposal if we could find a suitable level. I would not be prepared to say that the level the Deputy suggests is right. The whole thing is being tightened up. I do not know whether this is necessary, but it is one of the matters which I am looking into. I would not be prepared to accept the amendment. I would rather if the Deputy left it over.
Comment on this
Perhaps Deputy Little would be prepared to go a little further. The Deputy knows as well as I do that it was the declared opinion of the majority of those on the Betting Committee that it was a desirable thing to make it as difficult as possible for a certain class of the population to spend money on betting that they could ill afford. I suggest that Deputy Little should go the whole hog and raise the valuation in each case. We are all agreed that a large amount of money is spent in betting that should not be so spent, and it is spent by a class of person who can least afford it. If Deputy Little is sincere in this matter he should go the whole hog when he is discussing it with the Minister.
Comment on this
There are other sections which serve the purpose the Deputy has in mind. There are other sections in the Bill which deal with the desirability of premises. I do not think that one could deal with the matter in the way the Deputy suggests. It must be remembered that there are numbers of respectable persons, quite honest people, carrying on this business. They are not well enough off to take premises which would have a valuation of, say, £50, although I admit that that would be an exclusive figure. To raise the valuation would throw the whole business into the hands of one or two extremely rich persons, and I do not think that is the object of the Deputy on the Labour Benches.
Comment on this
The Deputy is aware that there are many of these premises in slum areas, and he must know that all this business is dangerous and bad for the country.
Comment on this
Quite so, but is it not clear that portion of this Bill relates to a residential area, a place where workers reside? Unfortunately, a great many of the workers reside in the slums.
Comment on this
It would appear that the Deputy is therefore anxious to afford facilities for betting.
Comment on this
I will refer Deputy Anthony to paragraph (c) of Section 11. If he reads the Bill he will see that one of the grounds for refusing a licence because of unsuitability of premises is that the premises are situated where large numbers of persons congregate, or that they are situated in a residental area. I take that to mean a slum; otherwise I was going to move an amendment somewhat on the lines of Deputy Anthony's remarks. I do not take a residential area to mean a place like Merrion Square; I rather think it means the place where the poor people or the workers reside. The place where they reside, to my mind, is the residential area set out in the Bill.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Anthony's point is met by the terms of Deputy Little's amendment. I do not know of any slum area where, in the case of a shop and dwelling-house, the shop alone would be valued at £15. I think it is essential, in order to set up a premises for betting, that it should be on a main thoroughfare.
Comment on this
Is it the intention of the Minister to remove the sheds at the back of residential or slum districts? He stated he had no knowledge of these premises. It is very difficult to fix a definite valuation figure, because you might get a place in a slum area which would have a valuation of £15. There may be cases where you might have to increase the valuation from £15 to £20.
Comment on this
I move amendment 25:—
In paragraph (i), line 40, before the word "cause" to insert the words "permit to loiter in."
Comment on this
I move amendment 26:—
To delete paragraph (1) and substitute the following paragraph: "that the applicant is the holder of a liquor licence, a pawn office licence or a moneylender's licence."
Comment on this
The Committee made a recommendation that those who already held a licence might be allowed to remain.
Comment on this
The trouble one experiences in connection with this Bill and the amendments is that unless one goes back and reads the report of the Commission it is impossible to get the proper meaning of sections of the Bill. That applies particularly to paragraph (1). If you read that without referring to the report of the Commission it is extremely difficult to understand it. There is ground for objection in the case of a person who holds a licence and who carries on a bookmakers' business as well.
Comment on this
The Committee recommended that those who had already a bookmaker's licence might be allowed to continue, but that new publicans should not be allowed to acquire premises licensed for betting. It is the same point that Deputy Hennessey raised in connection with pawnbrokers' and moneylenders' licences.
Comment on this
Is not the Minister doing a thing he does not like to do— creating a monopoly value in these premises? I think the Minister ought to reconsider this matter.
Comment on this
With placing a pawn office licence or a moneylender's licence on the same terms as are already contained in paragraph (1)— I go that far.
Comment on this
Would the Minister devise some means of differentiating between the premises? I quite see his point in regard to a person who holds a licence already, but the Minister might see Deputy Little's point in regard to a publican or pawnbroker whose premises are adjacent to those in which he conducts his ordinary business.
Comment on this
The practice, I understood, was that a good deal of betting used to be carried on long ago from the publichouse.
Comment on this
The one point that remains to be considered is in regard to a publican, say, in the country, who has spent a good deal of money on reconstruction to cut off the betting premises from his ordinary premises. We would have to see whether we should knock him out and allow that money to be wasted.
Comment on this
No; I was going to treat the amendment as if it were not moved. Is the Minister going to consider it?
Comment on this
There are two points concerned. I am considering one point favourably and I will look into the other point. I do not want Deputy Little to take it that I am going to agree with him, though I may do so.
Comment on this
I move:—
To add at the end of the section a new paragraph as follows:—
That the premises are not fronting on a public thoroughfare and are not structurally separated from any other premises.
This amendment, if carried, would deal with very small streets which might be in slum areas. If the premises were in such small streets they would not be suitable as premises to be licensed. The same would apply to premises in a cul-de-sac.
Comment on this
I agree that premises must be structurally separated, but whether we should insist on them being in a public thoroughfare is a matter about which I am not so sure. For instance, premises in a slum street might be fronting on a public thoroughfare. I do not know that much would be effected by this. People have complained that betting offices were on public streets and were temptations to people to bet. There may be something in that. I have seen notices at the end of a lane indicating that there are betting offices at the far end. I do not know if they are proper offices, or if it would be better in the interests of the public to force them to come out and put up notices in the street.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister knows that there is a greater attraction to go into a speak-easy than into a publichouse?
Comment on this
I did not. Perhaps it could be arranged that we would have some provision about the sort of premises. I would suggest that the Deputy think over this amendment. If we inserted a provision about the premises being of a specified valuation and being structurally separated, I do not know that we could insist on their being in a public thoroughfare.
Comment on this
I move:—
In sub-section (2), line 37, after the word "such" where it first occurs, to insert the words "or any other."
Comment on this
In regard to Section 17 and in reference to the term "joint proprietors," I notice that there is a definition which makes a man a joint proprietor. If there are several people who are joint proprietors they become under the definition clause the proprietor. I just refer to the matter, as it is one of drafting.
Comment on this
There are some amendments in my name to Sections 17 and 18, and I would like to know whether the Minister will bring in an amendment on the Report Stage to deal with the matter.
Comment on this
I move:—
To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
"The registered proprietor shall not allow newspapers containing lists of horses nor other lists of horses to be displayed in such premises."
I was not quite clear whether Section 19 actually dealt with newspapers containing lists of horses, because higher up in the Bill there is a prohibition regarding any lists or statements, but it seemed to me that it was not sufficiently complete, so I put down this amendment as a further precaution in order to make sure that the proprietor shall not allow newspapers containing a list of horses or other lists to be displayed inside his premises.
Comment on this
Under the other section nothing can be displayed inside which can be seen from the street, and if there is a newspaper inside it can be seen only by a person who has gone inside the premises for the purpose of betting. I have not much experience in the matter, but I can conceive a person making a mistake if he has not a newspaper in front of him. When I go to vote in a proportional representation election, for instance, I would probably be in great difficulty if I had not the party list in my pocket.
Comment on this
The person coming in to bet must have his party list with him. One of the causes of loitering is the display of newspapers which those inside consult before making their bets. It is only when they go in and see the newspapers that they make up their minds as to what horses they will back. I think that the bookmaking community would welcome this amendment, as it makes it easier for them to keep their premises clear of loiterers. It is clear that the intention of the Bill was not to prevent these lists or newspapers being in the shop.
Comment on this
If the Deputy feels that it would not create a hardship among the betting community I will accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I think that the intention of the Committee was to prevent either newspapers or cards of any description containing the names of horses being displayed in a window. It would not be fair to handicap a backer by depriving him of getting information, such of it as there is in the newspapers, once he goes inside the shop.
Comment on this
I do not think that the amendment should be accepted. If it would prevent a growing evil it would be all right, but it would not do so. It would deprive the wretch who is so unfortunate as to frequent these places from having the best available information. I hope the Minister will not accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I have to take Deputy Anthony as having more knowledge of the betting community than Deputy Little. It is really a matter of any abuses that are to be rectified, and I am afraid that people might bring newspapers and hand them from one to another. We then might have some difficulties in administration.
Comment on this
If they bring in newspapers and hand them about it will not cause loitering. It is these newspapers hanging in the shops which cause loitering.
Comment on this
It does not always happen as Deputy Anthony states. If the Minister wants to get the behaviour in these premises that he desires he will not allow these newspapers to be exhibited. The ordinary man entering a betting shop buys one paper, but he would not be satisfied with one paper in the betting shop. These bookmakers have been forced to pin up in their places a whole series of newspapers. A man perhaps sees a poster of a newspaper stating "we gave seven winners yesterday." He immediately wants to see what are the seven selections for to-day. If you want to do away with loitering on the premises bookmakers will not object to removing these newspapers off the notice board. They give the selections of the various tipsters. Deputy Anthony is quite right in talking about a poor wretch looking at his paper, but at the same time some bookmakers have made a regular practice of hanging up all the racing papers—the "Racing Chronicle," and the racing news of the "Irish Independent" and "Irish Times." People look at these papers and they tempt them to bet.
Comment on this
I propose to get the views of the police and perhaps of certain representative bookmakers, and find out what is the opinion generally.
Comment on this
My reading of Deputy Little's amendment is that it does not prohibit a man reading his own newspaper. It merely prohibits the displaying of them in betting shops.
Comment on this
I wonder is the Deputy really considering the Dublin metropolitan area or has he country districts in mind at all? I understand that there are a number of betting shops in country districts. People in the country are much more occupied than in the city, and they do not spend a considerable amount of time in reading newspapers. They may occasionally desire to put on a bet, and surely when they go into the office of the bookmaker they are entitled to ask: "Have you a newspaper until I look up the runners?" If we accept this amendment we are inflicting a hardship on people living outside the Dublin metropolitan area.
Comment on this
I move:
In sub-section (1), line 2, to delete the word "eighteen" and substitute the word "twenty-one."
This amendment has for its object the raising of the age from 18 to 21 on the ground that it is an internationally recognised age. In Monte Carlo the age fixed is 21 and not 18. As one anxious to prevent young people going into betting shops, I hope this amendment will be accepted. It does not prohibit them from actually betting, because somebody else can place a bet for them, but it does keep them away from the atmosphere of these betting shops.
Comment on this
I am always afraid of raising the age too high and of making the law difficult to enforce, because generally it does not carry the support of everybody concerned. I think we ought to carry it as far as it can be done. There have been varying opinions as to the age. Certain witnesses were willing to allow betting up from sixteen because that is the age in the Children Act, but I think the age of 18 is as high as we would have real support for. It is as high an age as we would have the full support of public opinion for the enforcement of. It is always bad to go too far in these matters, because everybody tries to take an easy view of the thing if you make the law too extreme.
Comment on this
There is a difference of opinion in regard to this amendment in all sections of the House. Personally I agree with the Minister that the age of 18 is as high as would be practicable. I do not think we could carry public opinion any further on the matter. Deputy Little feels very strongly on this question.
Comment on this
Had the Minister accepted this amendment I would have opposed it and put it to a division, because I think the age of 18 is high enough.
Comment on this
The police have a certain duty in regard to this matter, and their view is that the age of 18 is high enough. I think it is the best that can be done.
Comment on this
It is very difficult to fix an age at which you can enforce the law, but still I am inclined to think that as between the ages of 18 and 21 it is just as easy to enforce it up to 21 as it is up to 18. After all, that is the age at which people get the vote. Generally speaking, there is supposed to be a legal distinction after a person has reached the age of twenty-one which was not there before.
Comment on this
The Deputy is aware that in the British Racecourse Betting Act the age is seventeen. I think we would be going higher than is usual with this sort of age restriction if we went up to 21.
Comment on this
Betting has, unfortunately, increased so much in the city that I think we ought to do something to make it a little harder for young people. Many cases have come to my knowledge in which young people about the ages of eighteen and twenty-one have been indulging in betting. We have seen many cases reported in which young people have been charged with stealing and embezzlement. The explanation given in almost all cases was that these young people had taken to betting.
Comment on this
If you are going to impose a penalty upon a bookmaker for having betting transactions with a person aged nineteen or twenty, a person who has misinformed him as to his or her age, then I think that is unfair. If you are to put an additional restriction of that kind upon the bookmaker I think you are going to keep him sitting up all night thinking out how he is going to carry on his business. This Bill proposes that it is the person who takes the bet and not the one who makes it will be made liable. I think you are putting too much responsibility on the shoulders of the bookmaker. How is the bookmaker to judge whether a person is eighteen or not? In regard to more serious matters the law only gives protection up to the age of eighteen. I cannot see why, in regard to the minor offence of betting— if it can be called an offence at all— the age should be put up to twenty-one. Even if the age is fixed at eighteen, that is not going to keep people who want to bet from betting. They can get some other people to put on the bets for them. I am afraid you are not going to reform the morals of people by a regulation of this sort. I think the age of eighteen is sufficiently high.
Comment on this
I have a great deal of sympathy with the view expressed by Deputy Alton. I also think that the point of view put forward by Deputy Briscoe is well worth considering. I am of opinion that the age of eighteen should be allowed to stand. When we inquired into this matter we found that even schoolboys at the age of fourteen were betting. We all know the demoralising effect all this must have on young people. We found that schoolboys gathered their pennies and their twopences together in order that they could gamble. We also found that a number of persons in or about the age of eighteen were engaged in bookmakers' offices where bets were put on. In many cases they were engaged in the collection of bets, and we felt it would be wrong to inflict an injustice on that particular class of the community. This is a matter that should be considered by Deputies without regard to Party affiliations. It is a great evil—a canker that is eating into the heart of the whole community. In my opinion it is a thousand times worse than ever the drink evil was, and that it has done a tremendous lot to demoralise the whole country. I am not a pious person, but I feel strongly on this, and I agree that this is a great evil. Of course the popular thing would be to be on the side of the angels, but I have the habit usually of not being found on that side.
I feel that the Minister should not be pressed to alter the age from eighteen to twenty-one. The age suggested in the Bill meets, I think, the views of those who acted on the Committee to consider this matter. They had the advantage of examining a great number of witnesses such as bookmakers and their clerks, and representatives of all the Churches. When the age of eighteen was suggested I do not think there was one dissentient. I suggest to Deputy Little that he should withdraw his amendment and leave the age at eighteen.
Comment on this
In reply to Deputy Briscoe, my sympathy is altogether with the young people. I have no sympathy with the bookmaker obliged to sit up all night, as the Deputy said. In my opinion we have made betting too easy already. I think it is better that it should have been legalised than have it carried on as it was before, but at the same time I do not think we should make it too easy for people. You cannot walk along the streets to-day without seeing how betting is encouraged. It is spreading amongst every class and every age.
Comment on this
If a young man is allowed to decide for himself at the age of sixteen as to whether he will fight for his country or not, if a young man can be hanged at the age of sixteen, and if the law does not give protection in the case of certain offences beyond the age of eighteen, I think we would be making a laughing-stock of ourselves by making it an offence for a bookmaker to accept a bet from a person under twenty-one.
Comment on this
What weighed with me in the matter is the fact that boys, when they come to 21, are earning a little money. It is more a town problem than a country problem. At that age boys have more money and more freedom. Their habits are unformed between 18 and 21. They get in with people who are interested in betting and go to these shops. There is nothing in public life to tell them that that is a thing they should avoid. If they are addicted to betting they can get some one else to do it for them. Nothing is going to prevent them doing so, but we should establish a standard and make a beginning in the interests of those who are learning to use their freedom, so that they might be kept from developing the habit of betting. I think there is nothing so important as the training of youth and character, especially at a formative age.
Comment on this
I think the age of 18 should stand. That is as far as we ought to go in this Bill. I was wondering if we are not imposing a great hardship on bookmakers by asking them to decide whether a person is 18 years of age or otherwise. We are throwing the onus on the bookmakers, who will have to decide in each case. Deputies can realise how difficult it is to say whether a person is 18 years of age or not.
Comment on this
And some of the men nowadays. I would like to suggest that the Minister should bring in an amendment on the Report Stage prohibiting a bookmaker from accepting bets from persons 18 years of age or over, who are in receipt of public assistance, unemployment insurance, or help from charitable organisations like the Society of St. Vincent de Paul. It is appalling at present to see people who are unemployed——
Comment on this
This is a matter upon which everyone is going to have a personal opinion. I do not think the arguments in favour of one age or another will carry very much conviction with our opponents. For practical reasons I feel that 18 is about as high a limit as you could have. What struck me most in Deputy Little's speech was the fact that whether the age was 18 or 21, those who want to bet will be able to do so by getting someone else to act as messenger. In view of that I do not see that there is much of a case for fixing the age limit below 18. I suppose that 18 marks a fairly definite stage in a boy's career. Most boys are thrown on the world at that age and they have to make their way in life. Even though they are not nominally regarded as fully-fledged men, nevertheless, as far as maintenance is concerned, they have then to fight their own battles. I do not think there is much to be gained by hedging them around with a great many restrictions which would meet with the support of public opinion, and which is the only thing that counts. I do not know whether public opinion would enable the age to be made 21, or whether in every-day life it would be practicable to enforce that age. In view of that I think 18 is as high as we can go.
Comment on this
I would like to point out that a great many of the workers in factories and restaurants are between 18 and 21 years of age. If the age is raised the Bill would be setting up a new type of individual, a kind of commission agent, to collect the bets for the bookmaker while the bookmaker himself would be free. As it is I think you will have that state of affairs arising, where an outsider will act as agent and will collect the bets while the bookmaker will be free from committing an offence.
Comment on this
As Deputy Briscoe says, I think there is a real danger that we would set up a new kind of subterranean organisation.
[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]
Comment on this
Might I revert to Section 21 and draw the Minister's attention to the fact that the minimum bet suggested is 1/-? I do not know whether the Minister would make that 1/- win or 1/- each way? I know that there is a great deal of objection on the part of bookmakers to 6d. bets. A shilling might mean two 6d. bets.
Comment on this
As the Minister is improving legislation I think he might improve the grammar. There is no such word as "lesser."
Comment on this
I move:—
At the end of sub-section (2) to insert the words "For the purposes of this sub-section any member of the Gárda Síochána or any officer of the customs and excise must obtain a warrant in the prescribed form signed by the District Justice."
This amendment deals with the power of entry and investigation. Under the former law the police had always to get a warrant to raid premises. Under the present law they do not require a warrant to raid premises which are licensed premises. It is undesirable that the police should be given power to raid premises other than licensed premises without a warrant of some sort.
It does not mean publicity for a policeman to get a warrant. It only means that he applies in the District Court, gets his warrant as a matter of course, and then goes and raids the premises. In almost all other kinds of legislation of a semi-political nature a warrant is required, and I think in this case it is very undesirable that police should have the power of raiding premises which may have nothing whatever to do with betting business without a warrant.
Comment on this
It would make the detection of offences almost impossible. There might be cases down the country where it would take a day before people would find a District Justice and get a warrant, and the evidence would be gone. There is no sort of offence in which it is more difficult to get a conviction than betting offences, where it concerns the altering of documents or the preparing of faked documents and destroying the originals, and it must be possible to raid as soon as suspicion is aroused. It is even more necessary than in other cases.
Comment on this
Is the Minister addressing himself to sub-section (2)? I presume the offence that section is designed to guard against is a continued practice of making a book on unregistered premises. It is only in relation to premises which are not registered that the warrant is requested. In that case, there would be time for the officer to get the warrant from the District Justice. It would only be a warrant to raid the premises where he suspected betting was carried on. Normally that would mean that it was carried on over a period of time.
Comment on this
There is very great difficulty. The stuff may not be on the premises, and it is moved to and fro. There are extraordinary difficulties in connection with these. For the moment I thought the amendment was referring to licensed premises. There is the likelihood with the restrictions put on licensed premises that there will be more unlicensed bookmakers' premises than there have been. Up to the present, when there was less difficulty in getting licences and less restriction on the premises there was not the temptation that might be anticipated to carry on unlicensed betting, but I believe there is likely to be more danger in the future, and unless you have speedy action you might have much of the old difficulties of the past.
Comment on this
Is the Minister prepared to say that for other offences against the excise laws that the excise officers or the Gárda have the same power, for instance, as in the case of shebeening, and that they would have the right to go in? Is the Minister in a position to answer that question?
Comment on this
If they have not the right under the existing law would it not be unfair and unwise to make it specially for these cases?
Comment on this
The powers under the sub-section are very general and virtually give the Gárda or revenue officers power to enter any premises merely on the plea that they believe they are being used for the purpose of carrying on the business of bookmaking. It gives such wide powers of entry that I do not think the House should assent to it.
Comment on this
We had the powers of entry before, and I do not know that any abuse has arisen in connection with them. Shebeening is very easy to detect as compared with bookmaking offences. It is far more difficult to hide a quantity of stuff. In the other class of cases often detection has to be made by special officers, and there are all sorts of difficulties. In many of these cases nothing can be done by a local officer, and there are all sorts of difficulties connected with any delay. You would not have any delay in Dublin, because you could find a District Justice easily. But in a country place it might be a different matter, and there must be prompt action. While I do not promise to agree with the Deputy, I am prepared to examine the point again with reference to our experience during the past few years. I have grounds for thinking that there is greater danger of having unregistered bookmaking in the future than there has been in the past, and that will increase every time we tighten up the law with regard to registered premises.
Comment on this
First of all, in districts where District Justices are not easily available or where it is not easy to get a warrant, it is just as likely that the number of people engaged in betting would be very limited and that there would be very little attraction for a bookmaker to carry on.
Comment on this
In practically every big country town you have a licensed bookmaker. The principle involved is too serious to be bartered away for the benefit of the Revenue Commissioners and I feel that we will have to press this amendment. The Minister also stated that as compared with shebeening, on the one hand, and bookmaking, on the other, the greater evil was that of the bookmaker. I contend that if the House were to decide it that they would come to the conclusion that the effects of shebeening are a far greater evil than those of the man making a book illicitly. The Minister admits that in the metropolitan area he does not have that excuse. I think he should be inclined to sacrifice the little outlying districts in the interests of maintaining a big principle. Anybody's house could be entered or examined on the grounds that it was suspected that the person was using it as a bookmaker. A person might ring a bookmaker on the 'phone and put on a bet. Somebody might overhear the conversation, and the Gárda would have the right to enter because of it.
Comment on this
I was glad to hear the Minister say that he was prepared to examine this particular section before the next stage of the Bill. I do not think the House ought to give such wide powers either to the Revenue Commissioners or the Gárda Síochána as are proposed under this Bill. It is quite possible that any Deputy in the House, even the Minister himself, might be in the company of a bookmaker and probably that evening find the Revenue Commissioners raiding his house. I do not think the Revenue Commissioners have sufficient evidence to warrant a provision of this nature. If there has been such abuse of this Act as to warrant it, I would be prepared to accept it, but I would be very much surprised to hear it. There may be one or two abuses, but that is no reason why we should penalise the community. These are extraordinary powers, and I would like the Minister to examine them before the Report Stage, and provide that either the Revenue Commissioners or the Gárda Síochána, on entering a private house, would be provided with a warrant.
Comment on this
Having heard the Minister, I do not think these powers are necessary at all. As he has indicated, for the detection of certain offences under the Act it will be necessary, in the case of the smaller towns, to bring down a special officer. Did I understand the Minister to say that?
Comment on this
He could not apply for a warrant until he has something to swear before the justice. When he gets something to swear before the justice he has to lose a day or two.
Comment on this
Even in connection with that, I do not think that the Minister has succeeded in making a case. He has admitted that the difficulty of procuring a warrant is confined almost entirely to towns other than boroughs and county boroughs, but in those towns there will be one or two licensed bookmakers, and, therefore, the opportunities for carrying on a business as unlicensed bookmaker with profit will be decidedly limited. I suggest that they could be further limited if the Minister would inflict a penalty on people found on those houses. So far as I see, there is nothing in this section that makes it an offence to be found on premises conducting the business of an unlicensed bookmaker. If it were made an offence there would be no inducement for any person whatsoever to enter the premises of an unlicensed bookmaker for the purpose of making a bet. Therefore, there would be no inducement to any person to set up the business of an unlicensed bookmaker, and there would be no necessity for the powers which the Minister seeks in this sub-section. I cannot see what would call for the prompt action which the Minister considers is justified, and the only justification for these extraordinary powers. In view of that, I think that the Minister ought seriously to consider whether he cannot withdraw his sub-section or insert the safeguard that we ask, that the Revenue Commissioners can only enter a premises under the warrant of a District Justice.
Comment on this
I am prepared to consider the section, to see if there are any safeguards that could be introduced if they are necessary. I think there has been no suggestion of any abuse at all. I have not heard the slightest suggestion of one, and I do not think there is any likelihood of an abuse. But, leaving that aside for the moment, I am prepared to consider whether there are any restrictions or safeguards that we could introduce that would enable detections to be made and that would prevent the bare possibility of unjustified raids, and at the same time not make the detection in cases very difficult.
The Deputy said that there would be no carrying on of unlicensed bookmaking in a country town where there are one or two licensed bookmakers. You may have somebody whose licence becomes disqualified and who does not readily turn to anything else. He has not to pay any personal licence or any licence in respect of these premises, and he does not pay the 5 per cent. on the bets made with him. Such a person may be able, in certain cases, to offer terms that would induce a certain number of people to bet with him. Apart altogether from the mere personal support he may get from old clients if he were still able to serve them, there is a very definite danger, and, as I say, a danger that increases with every tightening up of the procedure, that you will have people carrying on as unlicensed bookmakers. The detection of these is extremely difficult, and it is not a good thing to put any unnecessary difficulty in the way of enabling evidence to be got against them if they are carrying on this business. It is for that reason that I do not want delays. Perhaps we can find something that will provide some safeguard against the mere possibility of abuse, and at the same time not occasion these delays. I am willing to look at the whole thing with that object in view.
Comment on this
In view of the Minister's undertaking to reconsider the matter, I am willing to withdraw the amendment for the time being, with the power of reintroducing it on the Report Stage. I would remind the Minister that it is a very important principle that people should not be in a position to be raided without some authority in the form of a warrant. It is a principle that people have always been very careful about, and the whole law has been very careful to see that they are protected in that respect. A warrant must be issued before the police can enter the private house of any individual. As it stands at present, this drives the coach-and-four through that principle.
Then, again, in any ordinary district in Ireland a policeman or excise man can easily get in touch with the District Justice with a motor car within an hour. Certainly it would not take him more than two or three hours to get his warrant in any part of Ireland that I know of. This thing is not going to happen in the wilds of Donegal or Connemara, but in the ordinary districts, where it is likely that you will have the type of case that the Minister has mentioned. It is ten to one that the District Justice will be at hand within half an hour with a motor car.
Comment on this
In connection with this section, how about the persons who are being employed in these establishments at the date of the passing of this Act? Is this going to apply to them? You may have at the present moment people employed as bookmakers' assistants who are under the age of 18. What is the position going to be in relation to these?
Comment on this
Does the Minister not think that it would be wise to consider, on the Report Stage, that anybody who is in the position of a manager of a premises should have a licence? A person may have multiple shops. The person who is actually in control of the shop is not the proprietor. Does not the Minister think that he ought to have a licence?
Comment on this
We considered that carefully and we came to the conclusion that it was better not, that it would be easier to enforce the law by having the responsibility rest on the owner of premises, and leave him to get the right persons.
Comment on this
Have not representations been made to the Minister that where a man has more than one premises he has no remedy against the manager who does an act for which he may probably lose his licence? Is the Minister not prepared to make that person liable for the offence as well as the bookmaker? Representations have been made to the Commissioners that in some cases where a penalty was imposed on bookmakers for a fraud on the Commissioners the fraud was actually committed by an employee, who himself benefited by it. The bookmaker was made responsible unless he proceeded to swear an information against the employee. The Minister may not have heard about that, but representations have been made to the Commissioners. Will the Minister, therefore, not consider the imposition of penalties on the persons who are the managers of these branches?
Comment on this
What we want to avoid is a person being able to employ people who would act as scapegoats for him. That is why we want to keep the responsibility on the proprietor. I do not know whether it would be right to carry out the suggestion of Deputy Briscoe, that is to say, without relieving the proprietor of responsibility to make the employee also responsible. The difficulty is that it might tend to lighten the responsibility of the proprietor and, as I say, enable him to escape conviction, and have the employee convicted, and used as a scapegoat.
Comment on this
The Minister might introduce an amendment providing that where an office is managed by a manager, in the event of an offence being committed not only will the proprietor have a penalty imposed upon him but also the manager. The bookmakers are anxious to get protection against the lackadaisical methods of some employees. In the way I suggested you would not be releasing the proprietor from the full penalty, but, at the same time, you would be lessening the opportunities for the employees.
Comment on this
I shall think of that, but I could not give the Deputy any indication now.
Section ordered to stand part of the Bill.
SECTION 27.
Comment on this
In connection with this section, I suppose the same proviso in relation to persons employed at the date of the passing of the Act will apply?
Comment on this
Yes, we will have to look at it.
Section ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Section 28 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
SECTION 29.
(1) Every person who stands or loiters outside or near any registered premises after he has been requested by a member of the Gárda Síochána to move on shall (whether such standing or loitering is or is not an obstruction to traffic) be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding twenty pounds, or, at the discretion of the court, to imprisonment for any term not exceeding two months.
Comment on this
I move:
In sub-section (1), after the word "loiters," line 3, to insert the words "inside or."
Perhaps the Minister will consider this amendment.
Comment on this
I would be rather inclined to be against this, because the proprietor's business is to put them out and not allow them to loiter inside. If they fail to go out, he could call in the police. We think it would be better to leave the responsibility as regards the inside of the premises entirely on the proprietor. If we were to adopt the amendment, it would seem to be at least partly the duty of the police to prevent people loitering inside, and we might have the old difficulty of the proprietor getting sympathy for the view that it was the duty of the police.
Comment on this
My point of view in regard to this was that it was to make it an offence for a person to loiter inside—not merely an offence after he had been requested to leave by the police, but to make it in itself an offence to loiter.
Comment on this
Whether he was requested to go out or not. One of the difficulties that bookmakers will have will be the fact that some bookmakers will be stricter than others.
Comment on this
I move:
To add at the end of the section, line 19, the words "Any person causing or inducing any person under the age of twenty-one years to commit an offence under this section shall be liable to the same penalty."
The age there should be 18 years.
Comment on this
This is making it an offence to induce a person to commit an offence. Take an employee in a certain business who is under 18 and whose employer tells him to go and make a bet. He goes to the bookmaker's office and makes the bet. The fact that he is under 18 may not be detected, or, even if it has been detected and the bookmaker is punished, surely some blame ought to attach to the person who induced the boy to make the bet?
Comment on this
The suggestion that was put to me was that the amendment would lead to abuses. People would send youngsters to a betting office and promise to accept the responsibility if the youngsters were accused and tell them that they would get off in that event. The point of view put up was that this would lead to people being able to say: "I will be the person who will suffer; go and do it."
Comment on this
I think you will have to consider the greater coercion that might be exerted by an employer rather than by an employee. It is well known that in certain businesses boys are often sent out to make bets, if not actually by the employer by a foreman or some superior, and I think some penalty ought to attach to them.
Comment on this
Probably it would be better to withdraw the amendment and bring it up in its new form on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move:
To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
"Nothing in the foregoing sub-sections of this section shall affect the right of a bookmaker to accept wagers in his registered office from persons outside Saorstát Eireann."
I do not think the Minister will refuse this amendment because it will bring him in more duty. I do not think he intended that a bookmaker should be prohibited from accepting cross-Channel bets.
Comment on this
I do not know if it is necessary, but if it should prove to be necessary I have no objection to putting in words to cover this point.
Comment on this
I have been informed that legally a bookmaker would be committing a technical breach of the regulations if this were not inserted. One of the bookmakers' associations, at whose request I move the amendment, have got legal opinion that that is the position.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:
"All such regulations shall be laid upon the Table of each House of the Oireachtas as soon as may be after it is made, for a period of twenty-one days on which such House has sat and if no notice of motion referring to such regulations is tabled in either House within the said period such regulations shall become operative."
The object of this amendment is simply to prevent what certainly happened on one occasion in reference to orders laid upon the Table of the House. If orders are laid upon the Table of the House they are open to be dealt with within twenty-one sitting days. That is the usual time; and if a motion is tabled in that time unless it is discussed under the present Standing Orders, it goes by the board. If there are several other motions before it in Private Members' time and it is not reached then the order comes into operation and the motion ceases to have effect. So in order to prevent that occurring I drafted this particular form to deal with regulations laid upon the Table.
Comment on this
Of course, the Deputy must see this would be quite unworkable. It might lead to regulations which are urgently necessary not coming into operation for a lengthy period.
As a matter of fact, there was one motion put down by a Deputy which was not reached. I do not know whether that was not his own fault. I am quite certain if any Deputy who put down a motion and wanted it discussed asked for time he would get time in this House. In fact, I think I heard in some discussion the Ceann Comhairle say that, whatever the Standing Orders might say, if a Deputy wanted a motion discussed he would be bound to give him time for it.
Comment on this
I am glad that Deputy Hogan (Clare) has come into the House, as it was he that had a grievance in connection with this matter. He put down a motion for the discussion of certain prescribed rules, and owing to the way in which the order of time worked out he never got an opportunity of moving it. I think some decision was come to afterwards by the Committee on Procedure and Privileges. Perhaps the Leas-Cheann Comhairle could tell us something about this.
Comment on this
I understand this matter was discussed some time ago by the Committee on Procedure and Privileges and that they came to an agreement which was satisfactory to all parties.
Comment on this
I move:
To delete the words and figures:
“10 & 11 Geo. V, c. 52. | Ready Money Football Betting Act, 1920. | The whole Act.”
I think it is a mistake to repeal the Ready Money Football Betting Act. It is purely an advertisement Act, and I do not know whether it is the policy of the Government to allow this football betting to go on by advertising and the circulation of coupons. The Minister already mentioned that he was going to reconsider a certain section where the Ready Money Football Betting Act is mentioned. I suggest he should also take into consideration now that that Act does not deal directly with the ready money football betting, but with advertisements and circulars issued which make them illegal. Perhaps the Minister would accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I do not profess to be very familiar with this system of coupon betting, but as far as I can gather it is rather illogical. You can bet on a football match, cash or credit, in a bookmaker's office, and the only thing prohibited is this particular system of betting on the result of a certain number of matches on a coupon. If a person writes out his own coupon and hands it in, it is all right. It is only illegal if he takes a printed coupon and makes his bet on that. The present position is illogical. It does not prevent betting on football. It creates an exception from the general principle that betting is really legal. I was approached very soon after the Betting Act was passed on this question, and suggestions were made that it should be amended. I promised to consider that when amending legislation was before the House, but no suggestion is made that any harm would be done by repealing this Act, which really creates rather an anomalous position.
Comment on this
I have the Act here, and it says: "any person in the United Kingdom who writes, prints, publishes or circulates any advertisement, circular or coupon." I suggest that that Act should be amended but not entirely repealed.
Comment on this
As far as I know, it has been operative only, shall we say, to hinder this particular form of betting.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not recognise that it opens up the gates to other kinds of advertisements as well as for bets on football matches?
Comment on this
If there is any avenue not closed by this Bill I am prepared to look at it, but I know that the object was not to have this big anomaly which exists in regard to one form of betting. I am prepared to look at it on Report Stage and see if there is any possibility of abuses arising.
Comment on this
Soon. I am delaying it for a short time, because there are a number of points that I promised to look into myself.