Public Business. - Betting Bill, 1930—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–185 of 379. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 23 of 1930 ›
Deputy Flinn was speaking when the debate on this amendment closed. I feel that in putting the case for this amendment before the House our hands are greatly hampered by the extraordinary attitude which the Minister for Finance took in relation to the question I put to him to-day, because that question goes to the whole root of the matter. If Deputies will remember, the Minister in opposing the amendment devoted his whole attention to the question of what he called penalties in terrorem and altogether disregarded the issue which was definitely raised from these benches, namely, that the collection of the fines imposed under this Act should be entrusted to the Department of Justice in the ordinary way. I may say that excise penalties originated in the extraordinary circumstances which prevailed at the end of the 18th century. At that time you had an extensive smuggling trade in wines and laces with France, and those who, very often, were the instigators of the business were themselves the magistrates before whom the offenders would eventually be brought. The courts to which smugglers were summoned were often held in a harness room and even in the cellar, which the wines were intended to replenish, of a country squire. Naturally, in these circumstances the person engaged in running wine for the replenishment of his own table would take a lenient view of the offender when brought before him. These excise penalties were definitely fixed by the legislature in order to ensure that a conviction would be recorded and that an opportunity would afterwards be given to the ordinary officers of the law to apprehend the smuggler and imprison him.
Circumstances to-day have alto gether changed. Transport and communications have improved and a person cannot be brought now before a court held in a drawing-room in an obscure part of the country and allowed virtually to go free, particularly for offences against the revenue. Therefore, because circumstances have changed we say that there is no reason whatever why the extraordinary measures which then had to be adopted should be retained at present. These penalties were originally designed to prevent corruption, but in actual fact, if the information which has been conveyed to us is correct, they have now become a source of corruption.
Comment on this
I have already told the Deputy, first that there was no corruption, and secondly, that the matters which were the subject of disciplinary punishment had no connection with the question of penalties good, bad, or indifferent. No names have been mentioned, but nevertheless the Deputy in a sense is making a charge against individuals who can be identified—charges for which there is no foundation whatever.
Comment on this
If I have to make those charges and to repeat what I am going to say in this House it is merely because of the attitude the Minister for Finance took up. If the Minister will put the true facts of this matter, and all the facts, before the House, possibly my speech may be different, but if he refuses to give the House the information which we think it should have before it in order to determine this question, then I must repeat in this House what is commonly said outside. If what I say is inaccurate I regret it very much. If I do repeat an inaccuracy I want to make it clear that it is merely because of the extraordinary attitude taken up here to-day by the Minister for Finance. He has the option to put the true facts before the House in regard to this matter. I am simply repeating here what common, public rumour says in regard to these officials of the Inland Revenue. Before I proceed, does the Minister wish to speak?
Comment on this
Very well. In the discharge of the duty which I feel has been thrust upon us I must make the House aware of what is commonly repeated in the City of Dublin in regard to certain officials. I regret it should be so, but in the absence of the exact truth I have got to use what I believe is an approximation. Two officers of the Revenue Commissioners were, some time ago, connected with the administration of the Betting Act of 1926. For some reason or other we know that the conduct of these officers was the subject of a departmental investigation, and that whatever they were charged with must have been a serious matter because the penalty which, I believe, was inflicted upon one of them had serious monetary consequences for him. He lost, I understand, in salary and bonus something like £200 per annum and has been debarred from further promotion.
What were the offences? The Minister himself has admitted that, in the course of their duty, certain officers of the revenue are obliged to have betting transactions with bookmakers. It is said that these officers had betting transactions with bookmakers, not upon the public account, but upon their own private account, and that the returns made in the ordinary way by the bookmakers disclosed that these officers were in receipt of much more generous odds than the odds offered to the ordinary public. I do not know whether I should ask the Minister if that is true or not, or whether he is prepared to contradict me and say that it is not true. The fact that we do know is that these two officials were very heavily involved, and that apparently no effort was made by the bookmakers to get them to fulfil their obligations in regard to these transactions. That is the information which has been conveyed to me. I think it is serious. I am repeating it with every reserve. I am only repeating it because I feel that, in view of what has transpired already within the short period during which this Act has been in operation, there is a public duty upon me and upon the members of this Party to secure that henceforward the collection of monetary penalties from bookmakers will be dealt with in the ordinary way by the Department of Justice and not by the Department of the Revenue Commissioners.
The Minister has stated that he must have a maximum penalty. I have not yet had from him the information that I asked for on the last day, as to the exact amount of the penalties collected from bookmakers by the Inland Revenue Department where the fines were in sums of £500 and in smaller amounts. My information is that the amount accepted by the Inland Revenue Department has been very much less than the fine which the court was compelled by statute to impose; that not only were the amounts very much less, but that there were very serious differences in the amounts which the Inland Revenue Department accepted in discharge of the penalties imposed.
The Minister pleaded here for a maximum penalty. I want the House for a moment to leave that question aside and to consider whether the system of collection that at present prevails is to continue, because what happens is that though the penalty is imposed in open court the remission takes place in a star chamber. Take a case of a wealthy influential bookmaker. He is dealing in large sums, with perhaps a turnover of £50,000 or £100,000 a year, and he breaks the law. He goes, this man who is extremely affluent, to deal in private, in one room and without any witnesses, with an official of the State who is charged with the collection of a fine from him. Who can say what takes place between these two people? Who can say what is the consideration which is sometimes offered, and which we know has been offered, in order to secure a remission of the penalties which have been imposed by the court?
Comment on this
If the Deputy knows of any consideration having been offered, then he should give the information. No such information has ever reached me.
Comment on this
We are to a certain extent in the same difficulty as the Minister for Finance himself. He knows very well that though they had, shall we say, a suspicion almost amounting to a certainty, nevertheless they could not get any person to give direct testimony of what had happened. He knows that as well as I do.
Comment on this
I would like to know from the Deputy if he has any information whatever in support of the charges he makes.
Comment on this
I have asked the Minister to answer me and say whether the facts I have recited, the statements I have made are true —I do not know that one could call them facts, because they are only hearsay and common rumour, but we have examined them and believe there is some ground for them—that betting sheets furnished by the bookmaker did not disclose that certain officials of the Inland Revenue were in receipt of longer odds than the odds that were being offered to the public. Will the Minister also say was not that the reason why this investigation, which he has admitted took place, was held by his Department? I am prepared to sit down and give the Minister an opportunity of replying.
Comment on this
I told the Deputy already that I was not going to go into that—that in no way whatever did a question of the remission of penalties arise, and that no evidence at all reached us that would suggest that what the Deputy alleges now—that is, that inducements were offered for a remission of the penalties—took place.
Comment on this
Does the Minister say that there is no foundation for the statement made by Deputy MacEntee that these officials were, in fact, indebted to bookmakers, and that in fact they did get longer odds in certain betting transactions than the odds that were offered to the public, and whether that came before the inquiry?
Comment on this
I told the Deputy already that I was not going to deal with the subject matter of the inquiry further than I had done in my answer.
Comment on this
The Deputy is to take nothing of the sort. I am dealing only with what arises out of the question of penalties. I am not dealing with the matter further.
Comment on this
What we are dealing with here is a matter that touches the administration of the Act in some of its most vital particulars. If we can, shall we say, show that there is a strong suspicion that officials of the Inland Revenue Department have received concessions or privileges from the bookmakers over whom they are supposed to exercise supervision, can we not use that as an argument against permitting the excise penalties to continue, the excise penalty which carries with it this Star Chamber remission?
Comment on this
I think that the Deputy should show that relevancy. The Deputy should show some relevancy between his charge against the two officials and the nature of an excise penalty.
Comment on this
It has been admitted that these particular officials had been charged in a particular way with the administration of the Act.
Comment on this
The administration of the Act does not entirely concern remission or imposition of penalties.
Comment on this
To a certain extent yes, because it is only when breaches of these provisions of the Act, which is administered by the Revenue Commissioners, have been made that the question of excise penalty arises. It is what is used—the excise penalty or the big stick, as Deputy Little says —to compel people to keep the law. The big stick may remain, but if the arms of the officials who wield it are tied by their transactions with the bookmakers I suppose the big stick will remain on the shelf or at least be whittled down. Now, I say that in the short time this Act has been in operation the things which have happened, not happened, mind you, to subordinate officials but to responsible officials in the Department, and the facts which, I am sure, are within common knowledge as to the conditions which used to prevail before 1926 in relation to the administration of the Betting Laws, should make us very chary about continuing a system which is, at any rate, likely to be easily and seriously abused. I said I did not want this point of the excise penalty mixed up with the question of the maximum penalty. I would suggest that the House should take a separate decision with regard to amendment 4. If the word "excise" is deleted from the section then the penalty would become one enforceable in the ordinary way by the Department of Justice.
If there are good grounds for making any remission with regard to these penalties those grounds can be stated in open court. The magistrate or judge sitting on the bench can determine in the full light of public opinion whether any mercy or remission is warranted, and if the remission is made I suppose public opinion would be satisfied. If, on the other hand, the maximum penalty is imposed public opinion will also be satisfied that the maximum penalty will be collected and that the law will be enforced with equal justice between them. Supposing that that is the issue we have at stake, we want, as I said before, to try and get every transaction under this Betting Act carried out, as betting is now done, in the full light of public opinion, so that the public themselves may form their own conclusions as to whether these penalties are warranted and as to whether the abuses which take place under the Act are such as to make it virtually impossible to regulate betting. Then they can come to a decision one way or another as to whether the present position of regularising betting is to continue.
Comment on this
I would like to draw the Minister's attention to the fact that apart from our having discussed the principle which runs through the Bill we must also pay attention to the particular clauses where the words "Excise penalty" occur. Whatever case the Minister may have later on in other clauses I would like to point out to him that in clause 2 you are not dealing with a matter which comes so much under the purview of the excise department as under the ordinary police. That is the clause prohibiting the non-licensed bookie from doing any business, and the detection of that particular crime is largely in the hands of the ordinary police. It is far more a matter of public order, and has less to do with the technical side of the collection of excise revenue, and it is an added reason in this case, whatever view the Minister holds with reference to excise penalties under other clauses, why he should allow the word "excise" to be deleted in this clause.
Comment on this
I want to refer again to the points raised by Deputy MacEntee, and I want to present back to the Minister the suggestion he makes that we are anxious on this side of the House to pillory or further punish officials who have been punished departmentally. We are not concerned with those officials at all—in fact, I feel very sorry for them—but we have to use this particular case to enforce the arguments and to show the reasons why we want to try and insist on all cases being tried through the District Justices. The Minister will not deny the assertions made or will not give us the information concerning the cases themselves. At the same time the Minister will not give us the information wanted to be able to form an opinion for ourselves as to whether the statements made to us from people outside the House are based on truth or are as near truth as possible. The Minister will not give us the particulars of the fines imposed on bookmakers from early after the administration of the Act. He will not give us particulars which I requested when last speaking on this particular amendment. As far as I can judge, and as far as my information goes from men in the bookmaking business, they are quite prepared to face the open court on whatever charge may be brought before them, but they are not prepared to stand over people who are fraudulently committing offences, and they are just as anxious as the Minister that those particular persons should be dealt with by the forces of the law. They agree that there is great injustice done to men who commit technical offences and are treated on the same basis as the Revenue Commissioners treat those who are fraudulent. It is all very well for the Revenue Commissioners if they bring certain cases that tend to fraud to the court, but they cannot deny that they themselves have on several occasions imposed a penalty on particular bookmakers who submit to a certain fine imposed on them.
Deputy MacEntee has given details of what is current abroad. The Minister has got to deny that all these suggestions are false and that the disciplinary action against these officials had nothing whatever to do with their intercourse with bookmakers in the administration of the Betting Act. I want to say, as far as I can understand and as far as I know on fairly good authority, these officials, prior to this, had records second to none in the Revenue Commissioners' Department. They were excellent and efficient officials, and their punishment now was a result of the position they were put in in administering that particular Act. Unless the Minister gives us the particulars of the cases of either of those particular officials, or unless the Minister can definitely deny that the circumstances had no connection at all with the offences they committed, I think he will either have to meet us on this or show us where we are wrong. The Minister answered the question put to him to-day by Deputy MacEntee, but he did not give us any new information. The only information that we have is information got from outside sources. The Minister stated that he wanted evidence from us. The Minister will not deny that in dealing with a particular bookmaker whom they had sent for, they pressed him very hard to give information against these particular revenue officials. I wonder would the Minister deny that his Department sent for a particular bookmaker and tried very hard to get him, as he said himself, "to squeal"? He refused to give that information, and he complained that his subsequent treatment was because he had refused to give the information that the Revenue Commissioners wanted. If that is not true, then, of course, the information I have been given is wrong; but I am inclined to believe, and, in fact, have good proof of it, that the information is true. If that is so, then the revenue officials themselves were looking for the information, or proof of the information, which is at our disposal now, namely, that these officials, in administering the Act in the way in which the Minister for Finance still wants it administered, were put in a position that might arouse a feeling that there was some attempt to corrupt the officials, and that the officials themselves had taken part in transactions which they were not allowed to do by the laws which governed their employment.
Comment on this
I have been listening with interest to the discussion on this matter. I might say at the outset that I know nothing whatsoever of these matters which form the main subject-matter of the two speeches we have heard to-day. I do not intend to deal with this matter from that point of view. I would like to be clear on this point: Before any penalty can be inflicted I take it that the bookmakers must be tried in open court and that the question at issue here is the right of the Revenue Commissioners to make certain remissions of the penalties inflicted.
Comment on this
To make a remission in secret and to conceal the grounds upon which the remission is made.
Comment on this
To make a remission, in any case. This practice of putting on this class of penalty for these offences is an old one, and it applies to a good many other matters relating to the collection of taxes as well as this one. I think Deputy Little suggested that it was for the police to prosecute in these cases. The same argument might be applied to other taxes, such as the entertainment tax. I do not think that that would be a proper matter for the police. In any case, what have we revenue collectors for except for the collection of taxes?
Comment on this
May I point out that this particular clause deals with the penalties which the person who has no licence would incur for betting at a street corner? It is a thing which would come under the notice of the police, though, of course, we are dealing with the general principle.
Comment on this
It is very likely that a circus man would not get tax tickets printed. As I say, it is the duty of the Revenue Commissioners and their servants to collect it. Deputy Briscoe has said that these men have stated that they are not afraid to face anything that may be brought against them in open court. How are the remissions to be made? Suppose the matter is handed over to the Department of Justice, how is it to be met by the Department of Justice, For instance, a sentence of imprisonment may be inflicted on a man for an offence that has nothing to do with revenue offences. The man is sent to jail; representations are made to the officials of the Department of Justice, and, in certain circumstances, they have the right to make a reduction in the sentence, to release the man or to inflict a smaller penalty on him, but that is not done in open court. I think it is a matter that could not be done in open court.
Comment on this
I think Deputy O'Connell has misunderstood either Deputy MacEntee or myself. There is no suggestion that the mitigation of penalties shall take place in open court. The complaint is that the District Justice has no power but to inflict the minimum penalty, and even if on the merits of the case a man may appear to him to have committed only a technical offence he has no power to inflict the minimum penalty. The Revenue Commissioners themselves may deal privately with the matter.
Comment on this
If I understand the thing properly, the minimum penalty is fixed in the Act.
Comment on this
Then it becomes the minimum penalty. He must inflict the minimum penalty. I do not see anything wrong with the principle of having a minimum penalty in any Act. As a matter of fact, it is found in a great many cases that if a man is convicted of a definite offence a definite minimum penalty must be inflicted on him. That is quite a common thing in our Acts of Parliament.
I am coming to the question of remission. It is not done in open court. If the thing is referred to the Department of Justice, how is the Department of Justice to get the information on which it is going to act in giving a decision as to whether or not the penalty ought to be remitted? It seems to me that they will be forced back again to the position that is being complained of here, that they will have to go to the Revenue Commissioners and inquire generally as to what particular type of character the man who is applying for a remission is. Is it the kind of case that ought to get favourable consideration from us? Is this the man's first offence? That is the sort of thing that is done where anyone makes a recommendation to the Department of Justice to have a reduction of a penalty inflicted in open court for an ordinary offence. It strikes me that where there is a question of remission the Revenue Commissioners cannot be kept out of it and that their considerations must be taken into account.
I cannot see what advantage there is in bringing the Department of Justice into it. I am not speaking of open court, but of what is being done in the Department of Justice and in the Department of the Revenue Commissioners which is intimately connected with it, and generally knows the sort of thing that is going on. I think that the question of remission would be more fairly and justly decided by the Department that has the greater knowledge of the particular kind of offence than the Department that has to get its information in the long run from the Revenue Commissioners. That is the way I view it, and I cannot see that there is any point in the objection that has been made. I stand, of course, for the infliction of the penalty by the court. That is a principle that all are agreed on. But as to the rights to remit, I do not see that any great point has been made in what has been suggested by the other side, as to whether the minimum penalty is to be great or not; that is a totally different question.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy hold that the proper person to exercise a power of judgment in this case should be the Revenue Commissioners? That is the issue.
Comment on this
You suggest that it should be the Department of Justice.
Comment on this
The words of Article 64 of the Constitution are: "The judicial power of the Irish Free State shall be exercised and justice administered in the public courts established by the Oireachtas by judges appointed in manner hereinafter provided."
Comment on this
May I ask Deputy Little whether he would allow any power to rest with the Minister for Justice? It is not the judge who reduces the penalty which is inflicted by the court.
Comment on this
There is always the prerogative of mercy, which is not in any way analogous to the power of the Revenue Commissioners. The prerogative of mercy is there and must be there. It is embodied in the State. It is obvious that under the ordinary functions of the law the judge is the person who gives judgment and decides the penalty. If there is any remission of that it is abnormal, and a complete exception to the ordinary course and current of law, whereas in the other case the power of judgment is in the Revenue Commissioners, and it is normal and the current of law that they should be the deciding voice in what the penalty is to be. The function of a judge in the matter is purely that of a recommendation of mercy which may be accepted or rejected by the Commissioners. If Deputy O'Connell wants to leave that power in the hands of the Revenue Commissioners he should, in some way or another, explicitly amend the Constitution, as otherwise you are simply making new ground for doubts and litigation in future.
Comment on this
In so far as there may be danger of corruption, that danger will not arise in connection with the mitigation of penalties. It will arise in connection with detection and proof in court. The bookmaker who wants to corrupt anybody will try and carry out the corruption before the conviction has been recorded against him in court, and he will not wait until afterwards. As a matter of fact, so far as the bookmaker is concerned, in the ordinary way, the damage is done when he has been convicted, because there are grounds for the refusal of his licence when he applies for it afterwards. So that all this talk about the great danger of corruption of the public service because of the penalties being remitted by the Commissioners is without any foundation whatever and can only be based on views that have not sufficient regard to the facts.
I have already stated the case. There must be stinging penalties in revenue cases. The minimum penalties must be made rather high. They must have a terrorising effect, because you have not the same public opinion and you have not the same working of the individual conscience in regard to revenue offences that you have in regard to ordinary offences. Therefore, you must contemplate that on many occasions there will be a need for a remission of penalties. Somebody must remit, as Deputy O'Connell stated—either the Department of Justice or the Revenue Commissioners. One does not hear of these charges in connection with smuggling. For instance, exactly the same thing exists in regard to smuggling. There is a minimum penalty and then sometimes there is a remission, if a case is made for it. It is done by the same machinery. This only arises because a great many more bookmakers are inclined to break the law than you find in any other profession—and that is due to the fact that they were carrying on illegally before the Betting Act was passed—and because they carry on an enormous amount of propaganda.
Comment on this
We are all ready to admit that there is considerable difficulty in this case to secure, on the one hand, that those who try to evade their legal obligations with regard to paying taxes and so on will not find it easy to escape, and, on the other hand, to do justice to the individual and to prevent corruption. I do not agree with the Minister that there are not great opportunities for corruption in the case of mitigation of penalties. It is obvious that if a very heavy penalty is imposed the person who hopes to get off a large fine will have a direct incentive to corrupt the person who may be sent to negotiate privately with him. I think the Minister has not made his case.
Comment on this
There is nobody sent personally to negotiate with him. He undoubtedly makes representations to some person, but the whole matter is put on record on paper and goes up through several stages.
Comment on this
The initial stages, anyhow, as far as we can see, are those of direct personal negotiation.
Comment on this
It seems to me, anyhow, that you ought to change the procedure in that respect, and there is either of two courses open to us, so far as I can see. One is that the ordinary judicial procedure should obtain and the case be brought before an open court and liberty given to the judge, having heard all the evidence and all the circumstances, to impose the penalty that he thinks proper in the case. It is obvious that there must have been fairly good reasons for departing from that, as that departure has actually been made and it is not the custom. The next thing is to set up a special tribunal to deal with the mitigation of penalties, not necessarily a public court but somebody sitting in a judicial capacity who will hear all the evidence that is capable of being put forward by the Revenue Commissioners on the one hand and whatever evidence the person fined can put forward.
I do not know how far the present procedure actually approximates to that latter idea. Is there, in fact, some sort of tribunal that sits on these cases and considers, as a judicial tribunal should consider, what the amount of the remission should be, if any? It seems to me, at any rate, that the present system is particularly bad. There are opportunities of favouritism; there is danger of corruption and a number of other dangers that anybody can see. In any case, it is not right that the individual citizen should be left at the mercy of the Executive in a case like this. The functions of the judiciary, as I understand them, are to stand between the Executive on the one hand, who administer the law, and the individual citizen and protect him within the law against any unfair power that might be assumed by the Executive. Apart altogether from the dangers of corruption, you have not these safeguards here at all. Consequently, my opinion is that either you will have to go back definitely to the open court and leave it to the judge, having heard all the evidence that can be put forward by the Revenue Commissioners, to impose the penalty and sacrifice whatever there may be by having this high penalty, which is to be the minimum, or you will have to set up some independent tribunal to hear these cases of remission in private, and to decide in a judicial manner upon them. Perhaps the Minister would give us an indication of the present procedure.
Comment on this
An attempt is made to deal with them in as judicial a manner as possible. I have occasionally seen certain files in connection with them. Some person is deputed to examine the case and to make a submission, and either all the Revenue Commissioners or at least two of them sit and read the appeal and the case put in by the person; read any evidence that is available to them; read the submission that is made by the person who has more particularly considered it, and they come to a decision on that. Two or three things have to be taken into account: (1) You have to take into account the previous record and all that is known about the particular person—whether he is a hardened offender; whether he is a person whom they are always having difficulties with; whether he is a person who in fact has broken the law on many occasions but has not been caught. That will be one aspect. The other aspect is really the question of ability to pay. A penalty that might be very light on one particular person who is a wealthy bookmaker might be very heavy on a poor bookmaker, and there has to be an attempt made to meet the circumstances of a man who is poor. I have seen cases dealt with in the Department of Justice, as I once operated there for a short period during the illness of a Minister. Very much the same procedure is followed there, except that, instead of having two Commissioners, they have the Minister and the Secretary of the Department finally considering all the documents that may be brought up in connection with the matter. I assert that no abuses have occurred in connection with this matter, that the same procedure is being followed in connection with customs and many other things, and that this is all due to the extremely good propaganda carried on by a number of people who feel sore at being subjected to any penalties.
Comment on this
The existing Commissioners are the chief executive officers in charge of the collection of revenue. There are none of these set aside—independent, so to speak, of the Executive side—and sitting as Judicial Commissioners. The same Commissioners who are charged with the collection of the revenue are the people who will sit and decide on any question of remission. Is not that so? However well they may do it, is it not perfectly obvious that the protection ordinarily given to the citizen is not provided for here?
Comment on this
The protection ordinarily given to the citizen is given by the courts. If the citizen does not break the law he would not come before the Commissioners at all. He must have broken the law and must have been convicted before he comes before the Commissioners. I repeat, in spite of what Deputy Briscoe has said, that there was no such thing as bringing anybody forward for a technical offence unless so many technical offences have been committed as give very good ground for believing that the technical offence is a part of some sort of a regular campaign.
Comment on this
Will not the Minister admit that there is this difference between that system and the ordinary administration of the law in open court: that the judge is at liberty to impose ordinarily a generally suitable penalty for the offence having taken all the facts into account? In regard to the Department of Justice there would be relatively, I am sure, very few cases of remissions, whereas it is an every-day fact, and part of the general procedure of the Revenue Commissioners. I may be wrong about that, but it seems to me in the one case every one knows there are likely to be offences occurring which will lead to penalties being imposed that in fact the offender cannot pay, and that it is more or less part of the every-day procedure of the Revenue Commissioners that they deal with remissions. The occasional case that goes to the Department of Justice is not to be compared with that. Probably the existing machinery is good enough for the remissions of the ordinary course, but it is not good enough for the case of every-day affairs of the Revenue Commissioners. Whatever attitude the Minister may take up, upon this particular section I would suggest that he should carefully consider the possibility of having in addition to the ordinary Revenue Commissioners some sort of a court established of Commissioners to deal with the judicial side, meaning by that the question of the possibility of remission.
Comment on this
I want to contradict the Minister for Finance on one definite statement he has made. If he examined the circumstances I do not believe he would have made it. The Minister said first of all that every case was brought into court and that it is only after the court has inflicted the penalty that the question of mitigation starts. I say that is not true. The Commissioners have themselves imposed penalties when the defendant was never brought before the court.
Comment on this
There was a well-known case brought to the court, and for certain reasons the Commissioners compounded and obtained very substantial penalties of £9,000, but in that case they compounded on legal advice.
Comment on this
I am not talking of that case. I know of my own knowledge there have been cases where the Revenue Commissioners imposed penalties without bringing the defendants to court.
Comment on this
That is because the person himself chooses, as it is within his option. If he does not like to go to court, and have a conviction, there is power to compound with him.
Comment on this
I am glad to have that admission, because the Minister said there was no mitigation until after the defendant was brought to court.
Comment on this
Penalties have been imposed upon people not brought to court, and mitigations have subsequently followed.
Comment on this
The Minister will find I am correct. The Minister has on several occasions in this debate given the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners as to the bookmaking fraternity. He speaks of them as men likely to be engaged in defrauding the Revenue Commissioners because, prior to this Act, they were engaged in an illegal business and, therefore, they are always going to be practising illegality. I say that is one reason, if there was no other, why these men should be given a chance in a court of justice, for the judge or justice, having heard the facts of the case, to inflict a penalty and not to have it inflicted by a prejudiced body of Commissioners who believe that they are men engaged in illegality and who are out to defraud the Revenue.
I want to draw attention to the fact that the whole method of finding out evidence against these people is based on a principle that we all hoped had long since been disregarded, namely, the principle of felon-setting. He described how a man disguised as a corner-boy hangs round betting shops and gets into the good graces of betting men, and if they make a bet with him without putting it on the book he turns on them. The Minister should know in his own experience that in pre-truce days it was the bookmakers we went to to help us out of serious difficulties. They put their hand in their pockets and we did not ask them where they got the money, and he should not turn upon these men now and call them a bunch of rogues and thieves.
Comment on this
The Minister called them rogues. The Minister is prejudiced against these men, and his Department is prejudiced against them, and it is nothing short of felon-setting to get his men to get friendly with these men and to go round the premises of these men, as they have done. It is like a man going to a publican for years and then getting the publican to give him one drink after hours and immediately reporting him to the authorities. It is the same means that are employed to get the bookmaker into trouble. The Minister has not given the House the true fact of how the Commissioners' men act with regard to these men. It is absurd to have minimum penalties of £125 when a man is likely to be fined on ten different counts, and when the justice knows that a man has not so many pence.
The Minister will not deny this: that in many cases men have submitted to certain penalties on agreement on the understanding that they would not be sued for other penalties, and these were wiped out. I am not out to aid the men who want to defraud the Revenue, but to see that the man who is entitled to justice should have it. Take a man at Fairyhouse Races, where there are big crowds and hundreds of people betting with him. He may make one or two slips, but because they occur twice the Commissioners say they are calculated offences. That man may have two thousand bets, and he may have made a slip in two cases, and I am not asking the House that this man should be let off, but I suggest that he should be given an opportunity of coming before a judge or justice to answer his case. Let the Revenue Commissioners come forward and state their facts. Let the defendant put his case and let the justice inflict his penalty. If he thinks it is below the penalty of £125 he should have the power to do so. In that way you would avoid all these appeals for mitigation of penalties. The Minister has not answered the main question. He did not give the particulars he cited the other day. Nor has he disputed the fact that what was very nearly corruption arises out of the very thing we are objecting to.
Comment on this
I have not any sympathy with the bookmakers. It is a long time since I made a bet, and I have not any personal contact with any of them. What we are concerned with is that we think the present procedure, apart from the Department of Finance and the general administration of the law, is very undesirable. Deputy O'Connell said that the Revenue Commissioners cannot be kept out of this. We agree. But we think that the Revenue Commissioners ought to come into it in open court. They have either to make a case for or against the remission of the penalties in open court before a justice. But if that would not meet with Deputy O'Connell's views, and if we were to consider the proposition he put before us to the effect that the Department of Justice was to be the remitting authority, it would certainly be better than the present situation, because we think that at least the Department of Justice, before it made any remission, would consult the Revenue Commissioners, and the Revenue Commissioners would have to take the responsibility of recommending the remission to another Department, or otherwise oppose that remission. They would probably have to give grounds upon which they would base their attitude. That is a safeguard which does not exist at the moment. There would be the certain safeguard that before any remission would be made two Departments would have to be involved. As the debate develops I can see that amendments 5 and 6 are really complements to amendment 4, and, though I did think otherwise, I can hardly think now that they could be discussed separately.
We say that in actual fact the minimum penalty for which the Minister is pleading in this House is really only a theoretical penalty and that it is very seldom imposed; even the mitigated penalty is very seldom made effective. We say that in the majority of cases a remission is made. In actual fact, the final adjudicating authority in this matter which determines the gravity of the offences of which a person has been convicated is not the judge who funds a person guilty, but the Revenue Commissioners, admittedly upon grounds which they themselves could not have produced and which could not have been accepted by the judge in open court. The House heard the Minister recount the extraordinary procedure which takes place. The Minister said that certain negotiations are entered into by the person involved or by his solicitor; that a remission is made, and that at least two of the Revenue Commissioners sit in private and these two ask the opinion of a third officer—very often the officer whose duty involves him in betting transactions with these people——
Comment on this
Can the Minister tell me what are the duties of the principal clerk of the Revenue Commissioners in relation to the Betting Act?
Comment on this
We have to make our case in the dark. Whatever reason seals the mouth of the Minister for Finance he will neither give us the truth nor the untruth in this matter.
Comment on this
The Deputy should be able to see that betting transactions are carried out by the outdoor staff.
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
The Minister said that in the case of one of them he was prepared to consider the matter.
An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.
Comment on this
As I told Deputy Wolfe, I intend to introduce a Bill dealing with Excise penalties for the purpose of bringing the law into relationship with the English law by limiting the time. That, however, does not arise at the moment.
Comment on this
The Minister indicated that he might possibly waive the question of Excise penalties in relation to one section.
Comment on this
I think that there are one or two sections in the Bill where I might waive the question of the penalty, but not on this particular section.
Comment on this
No, not on this one. If the Minister indicated the sections we need not move amendments. He might possibly do so when we come to the question again.
Comment on this
I move:
Before Section 3 to insert a new section as follows:—
"In all places, other than a registered premises, e.g., racecourses, sports field or anywhere where bookmaking is permitted, it shall not be lawful for any person to accept or solicit wagers except he be the holder of a bookmaker's licence in his own behalf."
I do not think that the Minister will take the same objection to this amendment as to the previous one. Perhaps he would indicate whether he accepts it.
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied that that point is covered, and that the object of the amendment, if not put in the Bill, will be carried out, namely, that nobody other than a bookmaker carrying a bookmaker's licence on his own behalf will be allowed to act in outside places?
Comment on this
Amendments Nos.8, 9 and 10 depend on the next amendment, No. 7.
SECTION 4 (1).
Any person (other than a body corporate or an unincorporated body of persons) who is ordinarily resident in Saorstát Eireann and desires to obtain a bookmaker's licence may, after publishing the notice hereinafter mentioned, apply in accordance with this section to the superintendent of the Gárda Síochána for the district in which he has or proposes to have an office registered under this Act or, if he has not and does not propose to have any such office, to the superintendent of the Gárda Síochána for the district in which he ordinarily resides for a certificate (in this Act referred to as a certificate of personal fitness) that he is a fit and proper person to hold a bookmaker's licence.
Comment on this
I move the following amendment:—
In sub-section (1), lines 19 and 22, to delete the words "superintendent of the Gárda Síochána," and substitute the words "District Justice" in each line.
This section deals with the certificate of the fitness of the person who is about to make application for a licence. The principle involved is really the same as that which was involved in the other amendment. If you examine the nature of the work of the superintendent of the Guards in this direction you will see that he has really to act as a judge. The Bill is quite explicit on the point, because when we come to sub-section (4) we see that the superintendent is to act in his discretion and shall decide the matter in his discretion. Those words are unusual, but whoever is the person to grant the certificate of fitness he must exercise an unusual amount of discretion, because, if you turn to the grounds upon which a certificate of fitness may be refused in a further section, you will find that one of them is "general character and known habits." That is a very vague and rather unsatisfactory limitation, but there does not seem to be any other way of dealing with it than to leave it to the discretion of someone acting in a judicial capacity. Another ground is "financial circumstances," but there again the exercise of a considerable amount of discretion is required, because it does not mean merely that a man may have a bank balance or not be bankrupt, but rather that he is in good credit. That is a matter that should be decided by some authority who constitutionally should have powers to act as a judge. Another ground of objection to the granting of a certificate is that the applicant has been carrying on business in a disorderly way or has caused loitering. That is a matter which a judge can decide. I would remind the Minister that this is very much on all fours with the case of the Master of the Court, which caused a great deal of difficulty to the Dáil owing to a decision of the courts, to the effect that the Master could not act, as previously, in a judicial capacity. Apart from the argument bearing on the constitutional point, it is also objectionable that a superintendent of the Guards should be a person to decide the question of fitness, because he is the person who has to carry out and administer the law in regard to the applicant afterwards from year to year when making his application. It places the police in a position in which they can bully people and in which they may be open to acting in an irregular manner.
Anyone who imagines that the law relating to bookmakers has been carried out in a perfectly regular manner in the past is not aware of the facts because, before this law was passed, it was known that the police winked at the practice of bookmaking. It was well known that superintendents of the police arranged amongst themselves as to how many raids they would have and how many fines they would secure. The particular bookmakers who were going to be raided were told beforehand about it, and the raid was carried out in a most polite manner. On some occasions when the magistrate imposed a fine much heavier than that which was usually imposed as a matter of practice, no one was more discomfited and amazed than the superintendents of the old police. In another case where an over zealous policeman managed to get the warrants before the superintendent, the usual practice was upset because one of the superintendents had more penalties imposed in his district than the superintendents in other districts. It is more or less inevitable that a practice of that kind arises from time to time in dealing with bookmakers. It is wrong, in my opinion, that the police, while administering the law, should be put in the position of acting as judges in regard to persons applying for a certificate of fitness of character.
Comment on this
Deputy Little is rather prone to raise far-fetched constitutional points. It seems to me that if the amendment is carried it will give a little extra work to the solicitor profession, but I do not see what other good it will do. What will happen is that instead of making application to a police superintendent the applicant will apply to the District Justice, and, if he is refused a certificate, he will then appeal to the Circuit Judge. It seems to me that the present machinery imposes no undue burden, and it gives no opportunity to the police of bullying. Everyone knows that the District Justice will not be afraid, if he thinks that a superintendent has done wrong. to reverse him and to grant a certificate if he thinks that the superintendent has refused the certificate on unsatisfactory grounds. I think that the real objection to the amendment is that it throws an unnecessary expense on a certain section of the public. I do not see any reason why they should have that expense thrown on them unless there are really good grounds for it. I do not regard the Deputy's far-fetched constitutional points as counting for anything.
Comment on this
Does the Minister think that these applications will be so numerous as to warrant extravagant expense on the community? Surely there will not be one thousand applications on any day.
Comment on this
Is the Minister going to use that as an argument against the amendment? Surely he can give us some figures as to how many applications would probably be made in a year. I do not suppose that it would go over hundreds. If the Minister has any further reason for objecting to the amendment I would like to hear more about it.
Comment on this
I would not like to accept the suggestion of Deputy Little that everybody in the service of the State who acts in a judicial way, except a judge, is really violating the Constitution. That would appear to be the conclusion to be drawn from Deputy Little's argument, but it would make administration impossible. Every executive officer and every higher administrative officer in the Service acts in a judicial capacity in one form or another every day. Lawyers may attach a special meaning which the ordinary man does not attach to the word "judicial" or to the exercising of judicial functions in ordinary administration. Surely Deputy Little knows that the higher officers in the various Departments must exercise these functions every day in making decisions as to what should be done in this, that and the other case. I think if you were to follow that argument to its logical conclusion you would have to take a great many other powers out of the hands of the superintendent of the Guards. Is the superintendent of the Guards who makes up his mind to oppose, say, the granting of a licence to a club or to an ordinary publican acting in a judicial capacity, or if he makes up his mind that he will not oppose it, is he acting in a judicial capacity?
I take it that if there is a question of the granting of a licence to a club or to an ordinary publican to be decided the police will decide whether or not they will oppose the application. In doing that the superintendent of the police for that particular purpose is acting in a judicial capacity. The same argument applies in the case of a gun licence. A man will apply for a gun licence and the superintendent may say: "This is not a proper person to have a gun licence." Of course, he has another remedy if he has a right to carry a gun, just the same as the bookmaker has in this case, but we would be going very far indeed if we accepted the suggestion of Deputy Little that all officers exercising a judicial capacity should be judges and only judges. I think it would make administration impossible if that were so.
Comment on this
I would like to point out that there is a considerable volume of opinion in favour of the amendment and that a considerable number of witnesses who appeared before the Joint Committee on the Betting Act were in favour of the procedure outlined in the amendment. It is not an extraordinary procedure at all. The same procedure is adopted in relation to publicans' licences and also in the case of licences for dance halls. My impression is that even the bookmakers themselves are not opposed to the procedure contemplated by Deputy Little's amendment. I have not heard anything justifying the new procedure first established under the Act of 1926, which I do not think is giving satisfaction to the bookmakers or to a number of the general public. Why should the procedure be different in this case from that which appertains to liquor licences and dance hall licences? That is the case which the Minister has to meet. That is, can he justify the departure which was made in the 1926 Act from the procedure then in force in relation to similar things? I do not know that there is the same feeling in regard to this amendment as we had in regard to the excise penalties, but there is too much of the Star Chamber procedure altogether. It would be much better that they should be held in open court, because, first of all, it would attract more public attention from the point of view of preserving the character of the applicant. It would be much better that bookmakers' associations themselves might have an opportunity of stating in open court the objections which they might possibly have to an applicant getting a licence and that others who might know something about a man's personal character might have an opportunity of appearing there. It is an extraordinary thing, one of the things which struck me in the evidence heard by the Joint Committee on the Betting Act, that while responsible people were quite prepared to go into open court and state generally their objections to an applicant getting a licence, they very much disliked the idea of writing a letter which would possibly be a privileged or confidential communication to a superintendent of the Civic Guards making these objections. They felt it carried with it the suggestion that they were acting as informers. The Minister says "No," but I was on the Committee, and every witness, that is, those who might be taken as representing general public opinion, was strongly of opinion that it would be much better if these applications were made before the District Justice, and if he had discretion to grant or refuse licences, rather than the superintendent of the Gárda Síochána.
Comment on this
There is no parallel to the certificate of personal fitness and the present machinery seems to me to be quite satisfactory. I do not pay any great attention to the statement that people would come into open court and would not lodge objections with the superintendent. Persons who have experience of the work of administration do not find that there are people who will rush into open court in that way. The amendment would simply throw business on the District Court when there is no need for it, business which is not of a character for the District Court. It would also throw business on the Circuit Court which should not go there. It is a minor type of business and I really do not see any reason why the superintendent of the Civic Guards should not have this power. I do not see why the procedure should be changed unless there is some good reason for it.
Comment on this
The way in which an unfair influence is brought to bear by having this power in the hands of the superintendent of the Gárda is this: A man makes an application for a licence and the superintendent refuses. He then goes to the District Court and gets the superintendent's refusal reversed and starts to conduct his business. An unfair discrimination is made against that man afterwards in the carrying out of the law. He may be raided. We have had examples of people being raided for certain offences while other people guilty of the same offences were not interfered with. It prejudices that particular applicant in the eyes of the superintendent that he has succeeded in reversing the superintendent's refusal on going to the District Justice. The object of the amendment is to make the law analogous to that in the case of applications for liquor licences or dancing licences. That is, it is made a matter of judicial decision. In answer to Deputy O'Connell, I would like to point out that the making of a decision is not necessarily a judicial decision. If a superintendent decides to oppose an application for a liquor or dancing licence in court the fate of that application will be decided by a Justice after he has heard all sides of the case. He has authority to make a final decision between the parties. That is very different from the decisions made by an officer when he is making up his mind to take a particular line of action. In this case the District Justice hears all the evidence and he comes to a judicial decision as between the parties. I do not want to do anything that is not done in principle already under the liquor or dancing laws.
Comment on this
I think that Deputy Little's fears as to the position in which a superintendent of the Gárda Síochána would be placed in connection with these matters are unfounded, because if the amendment were carried, presumably in the ordinary way some person must be in the position of opposing the application of a person who is unsuitable to obtain either a certificate of personal fitness or a certificate of suitability of premises as the case may be. The person who, in the ordinary course, would be placed in the position of having to oppose an application if, in the first instance, it was brought before a Justice of the District Court, would be the superintendent of the Gárda Síochána, so that if we say that the application were brought before the Justice and he refused to uphold the opposition offered by the superintendent, and that an appeal were brought to the Circuit Court from the decision of the District Justice, the very same results would flow as, the Deputy fears, flow from the present procedure. The present procedure, so far as I have had experience of it, works extremely well. In any case, where a superintendent of the Gárda Síochána saw fit to refuse a certificate of personal fitness the person aggrieved had the right to go before a Justice of the District Court. His doing so did not really bring an end to his remedies in the matter, because if the Justice saw fit, and if any question of law is involved, he has the power, a power which has been resorted to in the past, to state a case for the decision of the High Court on a question of law and fact.
Comment on this
Question put: That the words proposed to be deleted stand part of the Bill.
Do you agree with this result?
I move:—
In sub-section (1), line 48, after the word "resident" to insert the words "in Ireland but."
This amendment enables a certificate of personal fitness to be issued to a person who is resident outside Saorstát Eireann. The amendment is to this effect, that the certificate might be issued to a person who is outside Saorstát Eireann but who is a resident in Ireland. In other words, I think it would meet the Minister's real object, which is to provide for certain cases of persons living in the Six Counties who come in from time to time and act as bookmakers at race meetings. It does not deal with premises, but with persons who go on the course. I think it would cover all the cases that the Minister wants to deal with, and, at the same time, prevent the objectionable practice arising of bookmakers coming from across the water to get licences to go on racecourses in Ireland. I would like to know if the Minister is willing to accept our amendment.
Comment on this
There is not a great deal in it. In the past a certain number of English bookmakers of good standing came over, and I have been led to understand that their exclusion was a definite loss to the ring, as it is called here. Moreover, there is this position, that Irish bookmakers can and do bet in Great Britain. I do not think, if we pass Deputy Little's amendment, that they would be excluded, or that any steps would be taken to exclude them. Nevertheless, I cannot see any objection to allowing reputable English bookmakers come in here under present circumstances, and consequently I think it would be better to let the section stand. It is true that we are mostly aiming at admitting certain Northern Ireland bookmakers. I do not see any good reason for confining it to them.
Comment on this
I would like to know from Deputy Little, who is so keen on constitutional matters, whether he has adverted to the fact that it is inadvisable, to say the least, to set out in a Bill that the Six Counties are not part of Saorstát Eireann.
Comment on this
It will be set out if your amendment is carried. There are people who hold that Saorstát Eireann is not Ireland.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy contend that the Six Counties are inside the jurisdiction of Saorstát Eireann?
Comment on this
If he does I am quite satisfied. Until that time comes we have, unfortunately, to make a distinction.
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied that the section as it stands will permit the coming in of a desirable type of bookmaker, if there is such a thing, in the Minister's view? Will it also permit an undesirable type to come in?
Comment on this
I would like to point out that this is a new clause. It was not in the old Act. Under the old Act they were all excluded. We are doing no one a great injury.
Comment on this
That was owing to inadvertence. There was no intention to exclude them. An amendment was carried in the Seanad, and the proposer did not intend to exclude them. It was carried against my wishes. The Bill contained a provision that no one intended it should contain.
Comment on this
The present position is that for four years they have been excluded, and no great damage or injury has been done by continuing to exclude them. I do not see why we should legislate for people who are not resident in, or who have not a domicile of any sort in this country. It is rather against national principles.
Comment on this
Would the Minister tell the House how many people not resident in Ireland would be affected if Deputy Little's amendment were carried? I prefer the old name of Ireland, and the old Irish race, to the new nationality of Saorstát Eireann which Deputy O'Connell proposes to erect.
Comment on this
Bookmakers come in here, make a book and get away without paying those who bet with them It has occurred in many cases. Quite recently we have had cases of that.
Comment on this
I do not believe it happened recently. If it did he came in as an unlicensed bookmaker.
Comment on this
What do the Gárda Síochána know about foreigners? How would they make an investigation?
Comment on this
If they do not know anything and cannot learn anything, they cannot certify that he is fit.
Comment on this
Perhaps if I do not move the amendment now the Minister may consider the matter and give me an opportunity on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I would not like the Deputy to think that I would come to his point of view. However, I do not think the matter is very important, but still, as I say, a certain number of good bookmakers do come in from the other side.
Comment on this
No; but shall we say financially strong, bookmakers who could pay up when they were due to pay? There does not seem any reason why they should be excluded. As a matter of fact, Saorstát bookmakers are allowed to go and do go to racecourses in England, and there is no attempt to exclude them. The whole exclusion was a mere accident and not contemplated by anyone before.
Comment on this
I would prefer to withdraw the amendment now with power later on to move it on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment 12:—
In sub-section (1), line 51, to delete the words "Minister for Justice" and substitute the words "District Justice for the Dublin Metropolitan District," and in sub-section (3), line 62, to delete the words "the Minister for Justice may in his absolute" and substitute the words "the District Justice for the Dublin Metropolitan District may in his."
Now that the Minister has taken up the attitude he has about No. 11 I think it is all the more reason why the question of deciding the character of this person should be done publicly and by a judge, because it should not be in the hands of a Minister. If some extremely influential person comes to the Minister for this licence, or this certificate, he is always open to the charge of political influence, and it is a very serious matter to leave in the hands of the Minister. It is really a matter which should be decided by some authority publicly and in a judicial capacity as to whether this person coming into Saorstát Eireann should be entitled to such a certificate. It is really more serious than the last amendment, and I will move it. I think the Minister should consider carefully the accepting of it and allowing this matter to be decided by the District Justice of the Dublin Metropolitan District rather than by the Minister.
Comment on this
I think this is a kind of case most unsuitable to be dealt with by the District Justice of the Dublin Metropolitan District. Of course a man might not have any intention of carrying on any business in the Dublin metropolitan district. I cannot see any reason then in dealing with a foreigner who is being given a privilege subject to his complying with certain conditions. It is really more satisfactory to have that dealt with administratively than by some form of judicial procedure. I can imagine cases where it might be difficult to have any idea in advance of what line the courts might take. The court might take the line if something could not be proved against a man that he ought to get it. To be dealt with administratively only people of high standing would be admitted. If you left it to the court you might either have the Justice taking the view that he would demand certain proofs which would be impossible to give, or he might admit everybody. Everything would depend on his particular view of the matter.
I think because we cannot really control these in the precise way we can control people resident here that the matter should be dealt with by the Department of Justice along certain lines which, when the matter comes to be worked out, can be explained to the Dáil if necessary, or embodied in some sort of document, but I think it should be possible to keep the things tighter by dealing with them administratively.
Comment on this
I fail to see the Minister's point of view in this matter, because, first of all, there may be a considerable number of bookmakers with whom these people would be competing for business who may object to their getting a certificate. They may possibly, on publication of the notice provided for under sub-section (2), give notice to the Minister that they object to the application being granted, and nevertheless they are not able to substantiate that objection before any tribunal. If the Minister overrides their objection they are not able to carry the matter further. The final decision rests with him, and he makes that decision in secret. That is, I think, a very objectionable feature. After all, a number of people may apply for these licences which may be granted to them. They are all resident outside this country. I am speaking entirely impersonally in the matter. We may know nothing about them. They may be objectionable people to whom attention would be directed if they had to make application in open court.
Comment on this
We know the manner in which these notices are published, and very few people advert to them. I wonder how many people read the notices which a bookmaker publishes when he is applying for a licence. Fewer people even would take notice than in these cases of people who are living in their own locality and with whom they were acquainted. I think the procedure should not be purely administrative, but that application should be made in the court and that an opportunity should be afforded to people who might object to come into open court and prove their objection and have the case decided there once for all. After all, once these licences are granted they are to remain valid until they are removed for some offence under the Act. Therefore, since the number of applications necessarily are going to be small, since they are only to be made once, it would not cause an undue burden on the court to sit and hear applications of this kind and adjudicate upon them.
Comment on this
The Minister does not even specify in the section that the applicant must be a licensed holder in his own country.
Comment on this
We are not going to have any bookmakers from Russia. It is more than likely that the bulk of these people will be from across Channel or from the Six Counties, and nowhere else. They certainly have got to have licences in these places.
Comment on this
There are certainly licences in England. Even if the Minister stipulated that the man from across Channel must be already a licensed holder or that if he comes from a country where betting is licensed he must be a licensed holder, there would be something to be said for it. As Deputy MacEntee pointed out, these licences will hold good for twelve months unless the holder commits an offence that will deprive him of his licence. He can only be refused the renewal if he does not pay his debts. He may go a whole year without paying his debts, and the only remedy people have is that at the end of twelve months he will not get a renewal.
Comment on this
His licence cannot be revoked for non-payment of bets. On the application for a renewal his licence can be refused if it can be proved that he has not paid his bets, but he is going to be allowed to hold his licence for twelve months, and the public have no remedy, not even in open court.
Comment on this
That is a matter, of course, that applies to any applicant. If it were thought necessary on further consideration to put in any special provisions relating to outside bookmakers that could be done. I am prepared to look into that.
Comment on this
If the Minister would put in some further provision it might meet the purpose of the amendment.
Comment on this
If any man comes from across Channel it would be obvious that he would make his application in Dublin first. It is the most central position, and he would have greater information here about things of that sort.
Comment on this
I should like to have one point cleared up. There is a difference between a certificate of personal fitness and a licence. When a certificate of personal fitness is granted the applicant has not to renew it every year.
Comment on this
I was not quite sure about that. I thought that once his certificate was granted he got his licence from the Revenue Commissioners every year until they had grounds for refusing a licence.
Comment on this
It may be possible that such a person would be allowed to carry on his betting here on certified returns. How will the Minister be able to deal with him if he commits an offence and goes abroad? The Revenue Commissioners cannot look him up if he is across Channel. In the interests of getting the most desirable class of bookmaker there should be proper and rigid control; at least we should have some assurance that the man is a bookmaker by profession on the other side. That should be stipulated in the Bill. Secondly, there should be some special regulations dealing with him, because he might defraud the public and also the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
The whole thing is brought up when you are bringing in licensed holders who are non-residents of the Saorstát. The whole Bill deals with penalties for various offences. None of these offences can be dealt with when a person is non-resident here unless you catch him when he is here.
Comment on this
No. I am just pointing out to the Deputy that he has been getting away from the amendment.
Comment on this
It certainly arises on this section. Deputy Little proposes one way of dealing with these foreign bookmakers which makes it more difficult for them in his opinion.
Comment on this
In his opinion. I would suggest that the Minister ought to look into the matter to see that the regulations with regard to the foreign bookmakers would be very much more stringent than in the case of people at home, because if they do commit an offence undoubtedly it would be more difficult to get at them.
Comment on this
I agree with that. I agree that there is matter for consideration there, as to what regulations should be put in for the protection of the public and for the more speedy ending of his career as a bookmaker here.
Comment on this
I understand that foreign bookmakers have already been effectively dealt with without any legislation. I have been told that for a rather long time after the war foreign bookmakers were reaping a rich harvest, but that by some accident they received a lot of bad money. They paid out this bad money, and since then foreign bookmakers are as rare as the dodo.
Comment on this
I do not think it is clear in the Act that the licence has to be renewed at the end of the year.
Comment on this
The licence expires, and the bookmaker has to present a new certificate to get a licence.
Comment on this
Question put: That the words proposed to be deleted stand.
Do you agree with this result?
I move:—
In line 13, at the end of paragraph (b), to add the words "or been convicted of an offence under the Street Betting Act, 1906, or in relation to the advertisement of betting whether under the Betting Act, 1874, or the Betting and Loans (Infants) Act, 1892; or the Ready Money Football Betting Act, 1920."
I am anxious, by means of this amendment, to learn from the Minister what is the policy of the Bill with regard to advertisements. Certain sections of the Bill prevent a bookmaker from advertising on his premises or putting out anything which would be an attraction, or anything, I suppose, which would constitute an advertisement. It is very difficult, however, to know what is the policy of the Bill, because at the end the Bill repeals the Ready Money Football Betting Act, which is purely an advertising Act—an Act preventing the making of bets through advertisements or coupons. That Act has been ignored for some time. There has been a considerable amount of duty paid and recognised as payable upon transactions of this sort carried out upon coupons. There have been recognised abuses of the law in the past, and the law in this matter has been administered in a partial manner. Some people have been raided because they have a particular political point of view, while others were not interfered with. I should like to know the Minister's attitude generally with regard to allowing any sort of advertisement under the Bill, or whether the Bill deals with it in any way.
Comment on this
I would have no objection on the Report Stage to put in a slight modification of this amendment, providing that where there was more than one conviction under the Ready Money Football Betting Act that should be ground for objection. The reason I would like it altered in that way is because after the Betting Act was passed many bookmakers genuinely believed that all kinds of betting on football was legalised, and, in fact, so did certain people in official circles. It was only after the point had been raised that it was ascertained definitely that this particular Act was still in operation and that it was not legalised. The question of whether that Act should be retained in operation can be decided later on on this Bill. Meantime, if the principle of this amendment were to be adopted it should be adopted with some modification. I would be quite willing to put that in on the Report Stage, with the modification I suggest.
Comment on this
What about the Act of 1874, which is to be read as one with the Act of 1853? A good deal of the Act of 1853 is gone because, of course, the houses are now licensed. At the same time, the Act of 1874 prevents advertisements, and yet you do see occasionally bookmakers' advertisements.
Comment on this
I move:
To add to paragraph (e), line 22, the words—"and in the case of an application for a bookmaker's licence by a person, who has not previously held a licence, that such applicant has not furnished as a reference either the names of two house owners or that a recognised Bookmakers' Association has not vouched on his behalf."
I should like to know if the Minister has given any thought to what is underlying this amendment. I am anxious to be assured that where a man who has never held a licence before applies he cannot be judged on the basis underlying the whole of this Bill. I should like the Minister to consider that aspect of the question.
Comment on this
Of course, a person must first have the signature of two Peace Commissioners. Therefore there is no reason to add two householders to that. Then, as far as recognised bookmakers' associations are concerned, I do not know yet whether we wish to give any sort of statutory or official status to the bookmakers' associations. Generally I think this amendment is unnecessary, because at present a person must have the certificates of two Peace Commissioners.
Comment on this
My purpose was to make sure that if a person of some respectability applied he would not be turned down. If the Minister is satisfied with two Peace Commissioners that would meet the point. I am not anxious to press the point about the associations, except to say that now that betting has been legalised the bookmakers' associations are interested in seeing that the members will conform to the regulations and they would have some knowledge as to the fitness of applicants. While it may not be advisable from one point of view to recognise the associations as statutory bodies, the Minister might consider giving them some say in the matter of an application for a licence.
Comment on this
I move:—
In paragraph (i), line 38, before the word "cause" to insert the word "permit."
The object is to tighten up the clause a little so as to throw the onus of proof on the bookmaker that he has not permitted persons to congregate or loiter in or outside his premises.
Comment on this
The difficulty is that it would be very hard if we put in the word "permit" with reference to loitering outside the premises, because the bookmaker really would not have any power to prevent loitering outside. If he caused or encouraged persons to loiter outside, that is provided for in the section.
Comment on this
I see that difficulty, but would the Minister consider if the section was so worded as to permit to loiter in the premises or to cause to loiter in or outside the premises.
Comment on this
I move:—
At the end of paragraph (j), line 44, to add the words "or for a person with no licence."
I think this fills a gap which requires to be filled up here. It really is to add at the end of sub-clause (j) if the applicant is acting as agent for a person whose application would be refused on several grounds set out in paragraphs (a), (b), (c) and (d), and to add as a further ground "or for a person with no licence."
Comment on this
Of course I believe under Section (e) that would be covered. If a person acted for a non-licensed bookmaker he would be objected to on the ground of (e), and that would be amply covered. Sub-section (j) is to cover a different class of case, where a person would not get a licence himself and puts up a dummy to get a licence but where he would be the real proprietor and perhaps nominally a clerk.
Comment on this
A man might get in for a year or two as a man of straw acting for somebody else outside unless you put in acting for a person without any licence.
Comment on this
I will see if there has been any case before, and whether it has been dealt with efficiently under sub-section (e).
Comment on this
I think the Commissioners will have knowledge of bookmakers refused on the proper ground, a renewal of their licences then proceeding to get an unknown person to apply for a bookmaker's licence whom they would finance.
Comment on this
I move:
To add at the end of the section a new paragraph as follows: "that the applicant is the holder of a pawn office licence or a moneylender's licence."