We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Thomas A. Finlay Snr.

Follow

Former member, 1932

Service

Dáil

In Committee on Finance—Estimates for Public Services. - Vote 26—Law Charges.

All I can say is that I have no recollection of these words, and I do not believe I could have used them, because my own state of mind was that I considered there would be a conviction. I recollect undoubtedly saying that the judge charged in favour of Dr. Levison. I now pass…

13 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Control of Manufactures Bill, 1932— From the Seanad.

I think the objections which the Minister has raised with regard to this amendment inserted by the Seanad are not at all well-founded. The main purpose of the amendment is to ensure uniformity of practice within which the Minister may exercise his discretion. The Minister has…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1932—From the Seanad.

This subject has been debated at some length and I wish to add just a very few words to the remarks that have been made. The recommendation which has come from the Seanad embraces practically the views of the supporters of every outdoor sport played in this country at the moment…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

Constitution (Removal of Oath) Bill, 1932 (From the Seanad).

I have listened to the remarks of the Attorney-General, and, discussing them purely as a lawyer, and not, as it were, in any political atmosphere, I fail to see that he has advanced, as yet, any answers to the criticism of the repeal of Section 2 of our own Constitution Act…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Finance Bill, 1932—Committee Stage (Resumed).

I also ask the Minister to reconsider this matter. Certain representations have been made to me-by coursing clubs. I agree with what Deputy Cleary has said that, in considering this matter, it is very difficult to divorce the position of the coursing club from the position of the…

5 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Additional Financial Motions by the Minister for Finance. - Finance Bill, 1932—Committee.

While this section is vicious in the way described by Deputy O'Sullivan, I would like to deal also, and, perhaps, at a little more length, with the point raised by Deputy Blythe. I think that the taking of power by the Minister to impose liability on particular citizens in the…

16 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Public Business. - Control of Manufactures Bill, 1932—Committee.

The Minister has given as examples why he cannot accept the amendments what I conceive to be entirely outside the scope of the Bill. He tells us what everybody knows, that in a memorandum or articles of association a manufacturing company may take power to do the business of…

5 contributions in this debate

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Constitution (Removal of Oath) Bill, 1932—Report.

Two arguments have been addressed to this House by the President of the Executive Council in support of Section 2 of the Bill before the House. The first argument is based on the relation of Section 2 of the Constitution Act, 1922, to the question of the removal of the Oath. If I…

12 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Financial Resolutions. - Financial Resolution No. 26—General. (Resumed).

The Minister for Finance, in introducing this Budget, at the outset of his speech, saw fit to describe the capital position of this country, and suggested that something like £115,000,000 was the amount of the National Debt. One would be at a loss to understand the reason for…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

Constitution (Removal of Oath) Bill, 1932.—Committee Stage (Section 1 Resumed).

I shall not move the amendment in my name until Report Stage.

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

Constitution (Removal of Oath) Bill, 1932—Second Stage (Resumed).

The President of the Executive Council in introducing this Bill said that it fell within a narrow compass and in his introductory remarks he invited this House to discuss it within a narrow compass. As I understood his opening statement he admits, for the purpose of his argument…

7 contributions in this debate

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Vote 34—Prisons.

Does the Minister say that the conditions of release of the man are such, that in the event of his conviction before any other court of competent jurisdiction, the ordinary provisions of law have been abrogated, so that he will not now have to serve any remnant of the sentence he…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

Road Traffic Bill, 1931—Committee Stage (Resumed).

With respect to the Minister, I cannot see how there could be an appeal to the Circuit Court under this section. Under the sub-section as it is framed, there is no proceeding whatever, no originating process, in the District Court between the person aggrieved and the person…

7 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Road Traffic Bill, 1931—Third Stage (Resumed).

I think the opinions expressed about the sub-section are unduly alarming. After all any court administering any branch of law practically every day has to consider the interpretation to be placed on the word "reasonable." It happens every day in ordinary common law actions and…

2 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Road Traffic Bill, 1931—Committee Stage (Resumed).

The section we are discussing is outside the scope of the ordinary private motor car and deals with the heavier type of vehicle, the principal one referred to being the bus. I think a very good case has been made out and in fact exists to prescribe a speed limit for buses. Deputy…

5 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Road Traffic Bill, 1931—Committee. (Resumed).

If there be any amendment of this section I would certainly like to see it in the way of tightening it up. I do not see why any distinction should be made between the driver of a public vehicle and the driver of a private car. It may be said perhaps that the driver of a public…

4 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Public Business. - Finance Bill, 1931.—Committee.

It would appear that objection is taken to this section on two broad grounds. First, by way of sympathy with executors, and secondly, owing to the effect on pending proceedings before the court. I should say, at the outset in regard to the income tax code that the length of time…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

Town Tenants Bill, 1930—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Everybody speaking on this amendment seems actuated by a desire that equity should be meted out to every person interested in houses, but apparently there is some confusion of thought in arriving exactly at a conclusion as to what is Deputy Thrift's amendment. Deputy Byrne, who…

3 contributions in this debate

Dáil

Supplementary Estimate. - Town Tenants Bill, 1930—Committee (Resumed).

Might I suggest to the Minister that the amendment of Deputy Lemass might be met in this way. I think there is a good deal to be said in support of the general principle at the back of the amendment. That is, that a tenant who finds himself dispossessed in pursuance of the…

1 contribution in this debate

Dáil

Public Business. - Civil Service Cost-of-Living Bonus.

I would ask the Minister to consider favourably this motion. As I conceive the position, the complaint made here on behalf of the lower grades of the Civil Service is that the present method of computation of the cost-of-living figure does not really show the true bearing of that…

1 contribution in this debate