Road Traffic Bill, 1931—Committee. (Resumed).
Contributions 1–134 of 266. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 38 of 1931 ›
I move amendment 4—to delete sub-section (3). I am not quite sure what purpose this sub-section is intended to serve. It seems to be a strange sub-section to insert in the Bill. It removes from the purview of the House or anybody appointed by, or acting under, this House the expenses which come under this section. They will not appear in any estimate and there cannot be any examination at any later time of the expenditure. I should like to hear what the Minister has to say in explanation of the sub-section.
Comment on this
The sub-section is an adaptation of Section 4 of the Roads Act of 1920. The position generally under that Act is that certain sums can be paid out from the Road Fund to the county council, to the police and under sub-section (c) "such part of the expenses incurred by and in connection with the Roads Department of the Ministry of Transport, including the salaries of the staff of that Department, as the Minister from time to time, with the approval of the Treasury, determine to be expenses so incurred in the administration of this Act."
The position generally with regard to that was that there was power to pay out of the Road Fund certain monies, including salaries, but the Roads Act of 1920 made no provision by which superannuation relative to the salaries so paid out would be payable from the Road Fund. This section reproduces the terms of Section 4 of the Roads Act, but simplifies accounting in certain respects. Officers of the Department of Local Government engaged on roads at present tend to do work proper to the Roads Department as contemplated in the Roads Act, that is work in connection with which the Road Fund is properly expended. They also tend to do other engineering work in connection with roads that are not part of the Road Fund. In practice officers, both clerical and engineering, of the Local Government Department engaged on roads are under the necessity to apportion their time between Road Fund work and non Road Fund work. That is very difficult from the point of view of accounting and is very often inconvenient in the matter of general administration. For that reason we provide in Section 2 here that the Minister may pay a certain percentage of the Road Fund, decided upon between the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Local Government, in respect of the expenses that are properly attributable to the Road Fund—it may be the expenses of Guards of a certain class on point duty work, expenses in connection with prosecutions, expenses in connection with licences issued by county councils, and general work under different Ministries which is properly attributable to the Road Fund. So that a certain percentage may be arranged to cover all the expenditure of the different Departments. It is also provided that the superannuation of officers whose salaries are attributable to the Road Fund would also be payable out of the Exchequer, but out of the Exchequer from moneys contributed under the percentage of the Road Fund handed over to the Exchequer. Deputies will see that in sub-section (5) we make provision to delete sub-section (c) of Section 4 of the Roads Act which gives power for the payment of salaries of staff directly from the Road Fund. Section 3 is put into this particular Bill to retain the power which already exists under that sub-section (c), and which the Department of Finance desire to retain to pay the money out of the Road Fund.
Comment on this
I think the Minister has missed the point of Deputy O'Kelly's query or else I misunderstood him. Sub-section (1) provides that these expenses are to be paid out of the Road Fund and says that for that purpose there shall be paid into the Exchequer from the Road Fund such sum as the Minister shall determine in consultation with the Minister for Finance. Sub-section (3) provides that this expenditure may be paid directly out of the Road Fund. There appears to be a certain conflict between the two. What we are anxious to get cleared up is, why it is desired that this expenditure should be paid directly out of the Road Fund when provision has been made in sub-section (1) for the payment of the expenditure out of sums paid to the Exchequer from the Road Fund.
Comment on this
The reason is that under Section 4 of the Roads Act already that power exists and the Minister for Finance is desirous of retaining that power in the present circumstances.
Comment on this
Will the Minister not give an idea of the circumstances under which it would be necessary to use the sub-section in question? Under what circumstances would it be convenient for the Minister for Finance to pay directly out of the Road Fund rather than transfer from the Road Fund to the Exchequer and pay from the general Exchequer? Is it anything more than merely an unnecessary elaboration of the law? Are there occasions when it will be an absolute necessity to have the power?
Comment on this
I have no proposal to make to the Minister for Finance for the operation of this section, but the Department of Finance desires to retain here in this Bill the power which they have under the 1920 Act.
Comment on this
Cannot the Minister give us any idea of the limit to which it will be used by the Minister for Finance or what proportion of the Road Fund will be so used? I think the Road Fund is at present £800,000 or £900,000 a year. Is the Minister for Finance likely to use this power to the extent of £200,000 or £500,000 or £800,000? This matter is very important because in so far as the Minister uses the power which this section gives him he can deprive the Public Accounts Committee of the chance of reviewing the expenditure which takes place. The Road Fund does not come under the Public Accounts Committee, consequently the Dáil will have no check on the expenditure of the Road Fund even to the extent of 90 per cent. of that Fund if the Minister for Finance chooses to sanction that that proportion can be spent directly.
Comment on this
As I say, I have no proposal to make to the Minister for Finance in connection with this. The Minister for Finance desires to retain it because he has the power there already. I cannot imagine myself circumstances in which the Minister for Finance would desire to use it to the extent of anything like that. I cannot myself from my own particular point of view visualise circumstances in which the Minister would use it at all.
That power is not used at the present moment, but so far as taking any transaction like that from under review by the House, though it is true it would take transactions like that from review by the Public Accounts Committee, but not from the review of the Comptroller and Auditor-General to whom the Road Fund accounts are presented annually; nor would it take it from the review of the House here, because it is the practice to discuss the Road Fund and its administration on the Vote for the Minister for Local Government.
Comment on this
The Minister tells us that the Minister for Finance says he would like to see the sub-section retained but he cannot give any reason himself.
Comment on this
Only that the Minister for Finance would like to retain the provision which is in the Road Act already.
Comment on this
The Minister says that the Minister for Finance desires to retain a power although he is not using it and does not know what he wants it for.
Comment on this
Would the Minister between this and the next stage endeavour to clear up the point put to him by Deputies on this side?
Comment on this
No, I think it is a small point to retain in a Bill like this power that already exists.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister for Finance will appreciate it if the Minister submits to the discussion that took place here to-day.
Comment on this
Question—"That sub-section (3) which was proposed to be deleted stand part of the Bill"—put.
Do you agree with this result?
Would it not be better if fees paid for public service vehicles were paid into the Road Fund?
Comment on this
All the fees paid with the exception of fees raised for parking attendants go into the Road Fund.
Comment on this
Sub-section (2) says the fees will go into the Exchequer and sub-section (3) says they go into the Road Fund.
Comment on this
At this point I would like to ask you, sir, for a direction regarding this section. The Donegal County Council is very much interested, as the Minister is aware, regarding the maximum weight of vehicles allowed on the roads. They are objecting, amongst other things, to having the maximum weight two and a half tons. My own personal view of the matter is that the question can be more appropriately discussed on Section 14 which gives the Minister power to make regulations both generally and in relation to particular areas. If you, sir, concur I propose to raise it on that section.
Comment on this
I move:—In sub-section (3), (b) line 46 to delete the words "one and a half tons" and substitute therefor the words "two tons." This amendment explains itself. The Bill mentions a maximum weight of one and a half tons for vehicles of a certain character and we suggest that the maximum should be raised to two tons. I believe there is a feeling amongst proprietors of that class of vehicle that one and a half tons is too small.
Comment on this
I am opposed to the amendment and my reason for opposing it is that under this sub-section Deputy O'Kelly is dealing with light motor vehicles. It has to be taken into consideration that if the weight is increased from one and a half tons to two tons the road will be damaged to a much greater extent. As Deputy Law mentioned, the matter was under consideration by Donegal County Council and they registered an emphatic protest against the damage that was being done to the roads by heavy vehicles.
Comment on this
I am afraid Deputy Cassidy does not understand the purport of the amendment. One and a half tons is mentioned in the Bill, for some reason that is not quite clear, seeing that the average light vehicle, such as the Ford ton truck weighs, I am informed, more than 30 cwts when unladen. The effect will be to class Ford ton trucks as heavy vehicles subject to the regulations for speed and otherwise that are imposed on heavy vehicles. This is a matter that affects a very large number of traders throughout the country because, of course, there can be no question that if the restrictions in respect of speed which apply to heavy lorries are to apply to Ford ton trucks the utility of these latter vehicles will be very considerably diminished. I cannot see how the driving of one of these Ford trucks at 30 miles an hour is any more dangerous at that speed than driving an ordinary Ford car which is built on the same chassis.
Comment on this
The point raised by Deputy Cassidy does not arise because a road or a set of roads can be closed to vehicles of two tons or say 35 cwts. and be open to everything under that weight, even though two different sets of vehicles might be classed as light vehicles. The only point that arises is the fact that the figures retained in Section 12 are the figures operating at present and until this amendment was put down, as far as I know, there was no suggestion that the present figures were not satisfactory. The only question that occurs, as Deputy Lemass says, is that of speed. I have no objection to accepting the amendment making the figure two tons. I can assure Deputy Cassidy that the matter does not affect what he has in mind. Section 144 will show that.
Comment on this
I move:—
To delete sub-section (7) and substitute the following sub-section:—
"(7) Every order made under this section shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas and shall not have effect until each House of the Oireachtas has by resolution authorised the making of such order with or without amendment of any of the proposed provisions of such order."
The reason for this amendment is fairly obvious. I propose to make it positive so that a rule or order made under this sub-section should be submitted to the House and voted upon before being made law. The Bill proposes to do the same thing in a negative kind of way, that the order is to be laid before each House and if there is no objection, that it will come into effect. I think it would be better that every such order should be brought before the House. Of course the House would have an opportunity of dealing with it but the proposal in the amendment is more positive, as it brings the matter under the notice of the House and the public, and is preferable to what is suggested in the Bill.
Comment on this
As regards orders I agree with the Deputy on the general principle. There is a point in the amendment and I would ask that it be left out as a matter of procedure. The Deputy's amendment asks that the order shall be brought before the House and shall not have effect until a resolution is passed. I would undertake to change the section so that the order will have to come before the House and be approved of before it comes into operation. A difficulty arises in connection with the amendment of an order in the House. If an order is not approved of it will be for the Minister to take cognisance of what has been said and to bring in an order that will be in concurrence with the wishes expressed. The Deputy has another amendment down giving the Minister power to annul an order. Under the Interpretation Act the Minister has power to make an order and has power to annual. I will undertake to look into the matter.
Comment on this
Would not the Minister give the Dáil power to make an amendment which might be an agreed amendment?
Comment on this
On the section, I merely wish the Minister to tell us the considerations which led him to depart from the recommendations of the inter-Departmental Committee with respect to the maximum weight of light motor vehicles. The Committee suggested two and a half tons and the Bill states three tons. I wish to know what were the considerations which induced the Minister to depart from the Report.
Comment on this
It was found that there were new cars on the road, passenger-carrying vehicles, whose weight was more than two and a half tons.
Comment on this
There were different types. The desire is that the ordinary private car shall be capable of being classed as a light motor vehicle.
Section 12, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.
SECTION 13.
Sub-section (4) and (6).
(4) Every person who uses a mechanically propelled vehicle in contravention of this section or who draws a vehicle by means of a mechanically propelled vehicle in contravention of this section or does any act (whether of commission or omission) which is a contravention of a regulation made under this section shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding ten pounds.
(6) Every regulation made under this section shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas as soon as may be after it is made, and if a resolution annulling such regulation is passed by either such House within the next subsequent twenty-one days on which that House has sat after such regulation is so laid before it, such regulation shall be annulled accordingly but without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done under such regulation.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:—
Before sub-section (4) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"Nothing in the foregoing sub-section shall operate to prevent the removal from one place to another for the purpose of repairs or alterations of vehicles which do not comply with the regulations made under this section."
I do not know whether there is any provision anywhere else in the Bill— there is not so far as I have seen—in respect to the matter for which this amendment seeks to provide. It seeks to provide that a vehicle that could not perhaps be brought under its own power to a place where repairs can be carried out can be moved. I think that there should be some arrangement under the Bill by which a car in that condition can be moved from one place to another.
Comment on this
This is an amendment which I will place in the third class, which I mentioned yesterday. I do not agree with it because of its being so wide. I think it opens the door too wide so that persons who are found without any brakes on their vehicles might say that they were on the way to the repair shop to have them repaired or to get something altered. If the Deputy thinks that there should be such a wide provision as this, and if he would put down his amendment for the Report Stage I will have the matter considered to see to what extent the smaller point which he has in mind might be met.
Comment on this
Does the Minister admit that this is the position as the section stands, that where a vehicle happens to get on a public roadway, if it does not comply with the regulations and is detected, the section prevents it from being moved from the place where it is detected to a garage? For instance, if a road inspector of any sort, whether a member of the Gárda or otherwise, points out that the regulations have not been complied with, it then becomes unlawful to move the vehicle on any public highway. It might be necessary to have the vehicle moved in order to get the defects, which have got the owner into trouble, remedied.
Comment on this
I have to consider whether the section is so tightly drawn as to deal with that. Deputies will realise at any rate that certain precautions are necessary even if you only impose a speed limit or the carrying of some kind of sign in the case of a car which has a serious defect. I have to consider whether the section is so tightly drawn as the Deputy suggests. I appreciate the point which Deputy O'Kelly has raised.
Comment on this
The Minister talks of the possibility of having an amendment submitted on the Report Stage. Do I take that to mean that the Minister is not going to have a second Committee Stage?
Comment on this
I move amendment (8).
Before sub-section (6) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"The Minister may by subsequent regulations vary or amend any regulations made by him under this section."
Comment on this
This amendment is really provided for in Section 12 of the Interpretation Act, which makes it clear that the Minister has power to vary or amend any regulations made by him.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9.
In sub-section (6) line 34, after the word "annulling" to add the words "or amending" and in line 37 to add after the word "annulled" the words "or amended".
Comment on this
The same point arises in connection with this as arose in connection with the Deputy's suggested amendment No. 7. That is, that Orders will not be amended in that particular way, they will be either subscribed to or disallowed. If they are disallowed it is a question of a new Order bearing such variations or amendments as the discussion in the House will suggest.
Comment on this
Would the Minister indicate how he proposes to introduce such an Order? Would it be introduced in such a way as that it would have to be withdrawn and that some time would have to elapse before it could be re-introduced? Supposing the Minister was rather anxious to get a particular Order without much delay and brought it to the House before the end of the session. He would have to call the House together for the purpose of carrying the Order or rejecting it altogether. Would the Minister consider some means of getting it considered in some way that would not be so rigid?
Comment on this
We have two classes of Orders, one Order under Section 12 and another under Section 13. The procedure in the case of an Order under Section 12 is that having made an Order and having put it before both Houses in the usual way by having the papers deposited on the Table, the House would approve of this Order and that would raise a definite discussion. That is an Order which would be absolutely changing the terms of the Statute here. Then under Section 13 we have the Minister making regulations putting a limit to the extent to which the hub-cap of a wheel may extend. In the case of that Order, it is proposed that it shall be put into operation from the time it has been laid before each House of the Oireachtas. If any member in either House wanted to raise any point in connection with it he would have to put down a motion to discuss the matter, otherwise the Order would automatically come into operation.
Comment on this
Does not the amendment suggest some way of getting the Order amended without rejecting it, of getting an agreed form on what the Minister may desire as an Order?
Comment on this
Reference to the Motor Public Services (Vehicle) Order of 1928, will show the kind of matters that will be dealt with in this Order.
On the question as to the insulation of certain parts, the question of whether locks or nuts should be used in certain places, details with regard to carburettors, fuel and things of that kind, there is a difference of opinion. These things are, in fact, settled with the technical men from the Motor Association, with the representatives of the motor owners, technical men from the Gárda and technical men even from the Dublin Corporation; and the details in regard to these matters are such as can only be satisfactorily settled in a conference like that. If there are things in the order that this House would disagree about, we ought not to be arguing here, for instance, as to whether screws should be turned in one way or another. It would be more satisfactory to see the whole order so that matters of that kind might be reviewed by the people technically most competent to review them. Then we should have a new order. But it would be asking the House too much to discuss these questions so as to arrive on these very difficult questions at the most perfect conclusion in the direction of amending orders like that.
Comment on this
On this section I want to press upon the Minister a matter to which I made reference during the Second Reading discussion that when he is considering the equipment which public vehicles should be obliged to carry, he should provide for automatic signalling arms which would indicate whether the vehicle is intending to turn to the right or to the left and some sign in the back of buses which will indicate when they are going to stop. These gadgets will greatly increase the safety of the public.
Comment on this
I beg to suggest a device on the same lines—that all motor lorries should be compelled to carry a mirror. I understand that light motor lorries are not at present compelled to carry mirrors, being light motor vehicles, though the heavy lorry is compelled to carry a mirror.
Comment on this
I should also like to support that and to press for a regulation for the provision of a mirror and that the size of mirror should be defined. Small mirrors would be of very little use. As to this power of making regulations by the Minister I would suggest that this is probably the best time in which one can press the importance of making such regulations. I had it in my mind to put down as an amendment a proposal that public service vehicles should be compelled to carry speedometers inside the vehicles in view of the passengers as some way of bringing into actual practice a restrictive effect upon their speed. I think that the proper way to carry that idea out would be by regulation. I want to impress on the Minister how best we can have such regulations considered as would provide for the necessary equipment of vehicles. I do not want to argue in favour of special regulations, but I think one such as I have indicated would have a very restrictive effect in tending to cut down the excessive speed at which these public service vehicles travel on our roads.
Comment on this
Steps should be taken to provide that buses on the road should be in a proper state of repair both mechanical and otherwise. As far as the Six Counties of Northern Ireland are concerned such regulations do exist. In Donegal I have travelled on a bus that had been condemned as unfit as far as the Six Counties are concerned. Buses of this kind ran to the border and then the passengers were transferred to other buses and went into Derry city in them. There are buses in which people are travelling which are not properly equipped mechanically or otherwise. When the Minister brings in regulations under this section, I suggest that he pay particular attention to that aspect of the question.
Comment on this
I hope that in addition to these mechanical devices which indicate the direction in which the machine is going and when it is going to stop, the Minister will tighten up the regulations as to provide that these buses will not stop in the middle of the street. The way in which they do it now is perfectly scandalous. They do it in the eyes of the Gárda. They stop in the middle of the street and take up passengers.
Comment on this
I want to endorse that. I do not think there is anything that strikes one as being more likely to end in disaster than the way buses have of stopping in any place they choose in the street. They stop on the tram line or anywhere else they like without giving any indication that they are going to stop. As was pointed out by a Deputy on the other side, it is absolutely necessary that they should give some indication that they are going to stop. There must be some regulation by which it would be an offence if a bus stopped directly in the line of traffic instead of pulling into the side of the street. They are stopping at the present moment in the line of traffic under the eyes of the Gárda.
Comment on this
I think all these points are fully appreciated. The last point put up is a matter that has got to be considered in connection with another section. I do not know whether the section may not require modification in order to secure that the buses will not stop without pulling in to the kerb. On the other question of mechanical signalling and mirrors and arms, these are all matters that will get full consideration. We are all anxious to get the most effective and simple machinery so that the regulation and control should be perfect. The question of speedometers is one that has given a very considerable amount of discussion. The main point I think that has operated in not providing up to the present that speedometers shall not be attached to these vehicles is because of the case that is made for the unreliability of some of these things in large vehicles and the necessity for having them re-examined and re-wound very often. It is a matter that from my point of view at any rate deserves further and sympathetic consideration.
Comment on this
I move amendment 10—
Before sub-section (3) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"(3) Any regulation made by the Minister under the foregoing sub-section shall only be operative after the erection of suitable notices in conspicuous positions, indicating the precise nature of the restrictions, on the approaches to the roads or area to which the regulation applies."
The reason for it is that Section 2 says:—
(2) Different regulations may be made under this section in respect of different places or areas and in respect of different classes of vehicles.
The area which I represent has made a distinction in regard to the weight of certain vehicles which are allowed to travel on its roads. Our Donegal friends are pressing for the same thing so that there should be no excuse on the part of these people when they are crossing the boundary from one place into another; that is that there shall be some indication to the drivers that such an order is in force in that particular area. I know there is some reference to it in Section 144 but that section does not fully cover what we want.
Comment on this
Section 144 and also Section 43 provide for special speed limits. As far as Section 43 is concerned and as far also as Section 144 is concerned they provide that the councils responsible for the areas in respect of which these special limits are laid down will maintain the necessary signs. It would be impossible, I think, to have a section such as the section suggested by the Deputy's amendment inserted here. For instance a general regulation is made for the whole country restricting the weight of particular classes of vehicles, say to nine tons in respect of that area and to twelve tons in the city. You do not want to have the whole of Dublin City surrounded by notices saying that the particular class of vehicles passing out that road cannot exceed nine tons.
Where special speed limits are laid down or where special weights are laid down we will provide that signs will be put up. If we are to prevent the application of these by-laws and regulations until such time as the signs were put up—and even it might be argued until such signs are not put up in suitable places—you would lose control over the application of these to your area. If special speeds are made applicable on the particular area and a person is charged with offending against them, then the question will arise as to whether in the first place the necessary sign has been put up, and adequately put up, and whether it has been put up in a suitable place or not. All that will be taken into consideration in mitigation of or on the application of any penalties that might be imposed. That would be a matter for the courts dealing with the case to pronounce whether in the circumstances brought before it the local body responsible had made the necessary provision in the matter of the signs. What the Deputy has in his mind is therefore covered in the most practical way in which it can be covered. Covering it in the way he suggests would be impracticable.
Comment on this
We know of the unconscionable delay there has been in the erection of some of these signs. I know cases where the poles have lain on the road for months. If the regulations could not be made until these signs were put up that would make the law ridiculous. I am not asking more than that proper notice should be given to the driver and owner of the vehicle.
Comment on this
It cannot be charged against local bodies generally that they have not attended to the sign-posts on the road. So far as the particular point that the Deputy makes is concerned, I can only undertake that the road inspector will keep this matter under consideration and that a suitable standard for these things will be arrived at.
Comment on this
There are some members of the Donegal County Council in the House, and, therefore, I will not do more than direct attention to the matter raised by a resolution passed by the Donegal County Council on 27th October. I know that the Minister is fully familiar with the matter. The Donegal county is very mountainous and it has a great number of roads running across bogs. The council is anxious that there should be some strict limitation on the weight of vehicles running over the roads. They asked for an amendment of the Bill to give effect to their views. As far as I know and as far as I have read the Bill, it does not appear to me that any actual amendment is required, because in this Section 14, full power appears to be given to the Minister to make regulations prescribing the weights in respect of the various classes of vehicles passing over the roads; and not only to make regulations in respect of the weights of each class of vehicle, but also to make regulations with regard to the weight of the vehicles in any specified area. I do not know what my colleagues here think, but I do not propose to trouble the House any further with this. I deferred speaking on this until the clause was put, but I desire to press the point upon the attention of the Minister so that when he comes to make the regulations that are envisaged in this section he shall pay full attention to the views of the Donegal County Council with which I must say I entirely agree.
Comment on this
I support what Deputy Law has said. As the Deputy has pointed out, this matter was discussed by the County Council, who have made recommendations with respect to the weights of vehicles on three classes of roads. They recommend that the weight of these vehicles should not be more than 2½ tons, 4 tons and 5 tons, respectively. I understand that so far as this Bill is concerned the maximum weight can be up to 7¼ tons.
Donegal is a mountainous county and these roads were not built in many cases for heavy traffic. At present unfortunately the heavy traffic is not being carried by the railways of Donegal. These railways have had to dispense with large numbers of their staff. The people who pay for the roads for these heavy vehicles are the ratepayers of the county. Now these ratepayers are paying for the upkeep of the roads for the benefit of the competitors of the railways, that is to say, the owners of the heavy buses and heavy lorries. On the other hand the railway has also to pay for the upkeep of their own permanent way. I hope something will be done as far as this Bill is concerned to remedy that matter. Perhaps the Minister would agree to an amendment on the second Committee Stage or on the Fourth Stage on the lines suggested by the County Council.
Comment on this
I am satisfied that this Bill gives the Minister sufficient power to meet the wishes of the Donegal County Council. It has already been put up to the Minister to make regulations covering the points raised by the County Council. I am perfectly satisfied with what the Minister has said on the matter. The matter is provided for in Sections 14 and 144.
Comment on this
The Bill does contain powers to deal with any matter that the Donegal County Council wishes at the present moment to deal with. I would ask the Deputies to realise that in respect of main roads and as to the weight main roads are expected to carry my Department must pursue a policy that will require uniformity in the different parts of the country in respect of our main roads. This is a Traffic Bill and nothing that could impinge upon the transport situation is intended to be covered by this Bill. As to whether particular roads in Donegal are to be set aside for particular vehicles because the railway companies in Donegal are in difficulties is a matter that should not enter into the minds of the Department or the Minister in framing regulations in regard to weights.
Comment on this
I would remind the Minister that it is Deputy Cassidy and not the Donegal County Council who is arguing in the opposite direction.
Comment on this
I know that, but Deputy Cassidy talked about it, and I want the Deputies to appreciate that point. The Minister for Local Government has had his hands completely tied in dealing with transport matters, and I want to suggest that 40 per cent. of the maintenance of the main roads is paid to the Donegal County Council from the Road Fund in the same way as it is paid in the other county councils in addition to the money paid for improvements of their main road system. I have been over some of the Donegal roads and I have not felt any more shaky on them than on some other roads in the country. My idea of the Donegal County Council is that their main roads ought to be able to stand up to the same type of traffic as the ordinary main roads of the country so far as the weights of vehicles are concerned. It would require definite demonstration before I would accept that these roads were being injured by the present traffic. I would require more confirmation of that before I would feel inclined to discriminate in respect of the main roads of Donegal.
I think that is a reasonable frame of mind in which to approach the matter at this stage at any rate.
Comment on this
I do not say that the Minister is unreasonable, but I think he is a little bit academic. It is easy to classify roads in a certain way but you do not, by reason of calling a road a main road or saying that it is a main road in the natural sense of the word that is to say, it is a main road leading from one point to another, make it necessarily a road capable of bearing heavy traffic. That, I think, is a substantial point. I do not know what roads the Minister has been over, but I have been over a road which must certainly be classified as a main road. It is practically the only road leading from Dunfanaghy to Gweedore and Burtonport. I know that road this summer became almost impassable through the ordinary bus traffic going on it and it was not very heavy traffic. I am not a technical expert, but I do not believe that these roads are capable of being made suitable for heavy traffic without colossal expenditure. Most of them are narrow. Of course they can be broadened here and there, but there are also roads the foundations of which are as bad as they can be. I do not believe that without colossal expenditure you can really make them carry heavy traffic or such traffic as would not be excessive.
Comment on this
Donegal occupies a very peculiar position in what I might call the life, blood and body of the Free State, but the roads of Donegal and the circumstances of the ratepayers of Donegal and the opportunities which should be given to those who license motor buses and lorries in Donegal are in no way different from those of any other county in the Free State. Although I have a life interest in the railway service I am not going to suggest and never did suggest here or anywhere else that the hands of the clock should be put back, and that there is not room in this Free State for a lorry and motor bus system. What I want the Minister to bear in mind is that he should not, by any regulations under this section of the Bill, allow one of these lorries to wear out portion of the foundations of the road themselves and thereby to impose an increase in charges on the ratepayers for which they get no satisfactory service in return. What was the rate paid in 1914 by the ratepayers in Donegal or any other county for the maintenance of these main roads? What is the percentage increase over the 1914 figure paid by these ratepayers to-day? What is the freedom given to the ratepayers to-day compared with the freedom they had in 1914?
I do not want this House to give power to the Minister for Local Government who, in my opinion, is a road hog and does not want to see railways occupying any position in this country. I do not want this House to give the Minister power to put on the roads lorries of a weight which will destroy the roads and which will compel the ratepayers to pay a charge which is not justified by reason of the return they get for those alleged services. What is the number of motor lorries of different weights plying on the main roads of the Free State compared with what it was three or four years ago? What is the additional revenue we receive in motor taxation from the people now using these roads in increased numbers? Not very long ago I was shown a photograph, if you like a transport photograph, of the position in County Cork so far as it was affected by the number of lorries plying for hire and the amount of destruction they had done to the railway services there. They were plying in the county of Cork at uneconomic rates not because they had the ordinary economic advantages over railway companies, but because they did not pay for the damage done to the roads. A motor driver buys a lorry and maintains it as long as it will live and when the lorry is at an end the driver goes out of existence. That is a dangerous policy and in my opinion by giving the powers asked for under Section 14 of the Bill you are giving the Minister more power than I would like to give him.
I want to get an assurance from the Minister such as Deputy O'Kelly got in the case of Section 12 that before the regulations under this section are put into operation they will have to be submitted to and approved of by this House. Does the Minister agree to submit an amendment on the next stage of the Bill in the form put down by Deputy O'Kelly to Section 12? If the Minister is prepared to go that far I think a good case could be made for it, a better case than could be made under Section 12.
Comment on this
I desire to support Deputy Davin's argument in this. Undoubtedly the Minister apparently is prepared to ignore two very definite facts in this matter. The first fact is that these roads are built out of the ratepayers' pockets and have been maintained up to two or three years ago out of the pocket of the ordinary farmer in the country. With his 40 per cent. of a refund he has deprived the farmers of those roads. They were not treated the same as the electricity owners were treated in this country. They got no compensation for the roads which were taken from them, for those roads which the Minister states the ratepayers are getting 40 per cent. of a refund. Those roads are taken completely out of the hands of the ordinary ratepayer and are useless to him. The ordinary ratepayer drives his horse and cart on them at definite danger to himself. I have seen the Minister's system in operation in Cork County and I have seen the result of it. I have seen people induced and cajoled into spending more money than the ratepayers can afford on these main roads on the principle that if you are going to spend £100 you are going to get £40 back. More main roads were made completely impassable for farming traffic. Not alone are those roads in the first instance the property of the ratepayers and are built out of the ratepayers' pockets, which the Minister completely ignores when he says that the ratepayers are paid £100,000 for building a road, but we are going to hand them over to the motor owners. That is bad enough. I am not prepared like Deputy Davin to allow the Minister to have the right to fix what weight of vehicle shall pass over that road. I have seen those roads built at from £1,200 to £1,500 a mile, and I have seen them completely torn up by individuals six months afterwards for the sake of whatever few pounds go into the Road Fund. The amount received in Cork County out of the Road Fund in one year would not build five miles of these roads. I think the Minister ought to give an opportunity to this House to fix the weight of the vehicles that will pass over these roads. I think we are entitled to that.
Comment on this
It is impossible to separate from the general power to make regulations with regard to maximum unladen weights of different types of vehicles the power to make these regulations in respect of specific areas. I think it would be a very difficult prospect if this House dealing with the special circumstances of Limerick Cork, Waterford or Dublin were to discuss each of these regulations in sub-section (2) for different places and different vehicles. I think the House would be taking on a lot more than Deputy Davin appeared to realise when he asked that such a regulation should not come into operation until the two Houses had approved of it. Where the Minister has power to make regulations in these particular matters, he will, under most circumstances, hold the particular type of inquiry of which I spoke yesterday. He will publish notice of such inquiry and there will be full opportunity for everybody locally interested to come and deal with the matter in the proper arena— at the local inquiry. I take it that Deputies are particularly interested in the local circumstances and not in the general circumstances.
Comment on this
On such short consideration of the matter, I should not like to give any undertaking to Deputy Davin which would place orders of this kind in the position of orders under Section 12. I think further consideration of the matter will bring home to the Deputy that that would be unreasonable.
Comment on this
Perhaps I may suggest a way to reconcile the differences which exist between Deputies and the Minister. Under this section, I agree with Deputy Myles that the Minister is taking sufficient power to deal with the questions raised by the Donegal County Council.
Comment on this
In passing, I may mention that Deputy Davin, with his usual childlike blandness, switched this discussion off from Donegal and carried it down to Cork, where he made a connection with Deputy Corry. I shall have nothing to do with that unholy alliance. I wish to bring this discussion back to the point raised by Deputy Law. I wish to point out to the Minister that since he visited certain roads in Donegal the roads which are now classed as main roads and which were referred to by Deputy Law are incapable of carrying more than two or three tons. I suggest to the Minister that a way of getting over the difficulties of places like Donegal would be to bring about a different classification of the roads in conjunction with the local councils. If the main roads of Donegal which are complained of are unable to carry the traffic which this Bill will allow them to carry, why not make them third-class roads and thus make it impossible for traffic of that nature to use them. My purpose in getting up was to suggest a way out of the difficulty.
Comment on this
The Minister states that uniformity must be maintained, so far as the regulations are concerned, for heavy traffic. While uniformity should be maintained, I suggest that it should only be maintained up to a particular point. The geographical and economical condition of certain counties should be taken into consideration.
Comment on this
I submit that a case has been made why the request of Donegal County Council should be granted. One of the reasons why it should be given special consideration is that it is surrounded by Derry, Tyrone and Fermanagh. Many heavy lorries, which pay no taxation and come across the Border, use and abuse the roads in Donegal. I disagree with the Minister that the roads in Donegal are as good as the roads in any other county in Ireland. The roads of Donegal are not capable of bearing as heavy traffic as the roads of Dublin, Meath, Kildare, or Wicklow. One of the reasons the roads there are not capable of bearing as heavy traffic as the roads of some other counties is that the Minister refused to allow Donegal County Council to pay more than twenty-six shillings a week to the road workers.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy suggest that because of that the road-workers of Donegal are not giving a full output.
Comment on this
I suggest that the road-workers are giving good work for the wage but the Minister cannot expect boulevards to be built on coolie wages. There is another matter to which I would like to refer. I do not know whether or not it is in order.
Comment on this
This is the case of the Derry and Lough Swilly Railway and that is out of order on this Bill.
Comment on this
They diverted the traffic from the railways to the roads, with the result that what should be a national charge had to be borne by the ratepayer. We suggest that the maximum weight for heavy vehicles under the Bill is too much for the roads with which we are concerned. Donegal County Council suggest that the maximum weights for the three classes of roads respectively should be 2½, 4 and 5 tons.
Comment on this
The Minister, I think, said that his hands were tied in respect of anything which might cut into the Transport Bill. Surely this is cutting into the Transport Bill. If the Transport Bill is to make any arrangement as to the proper division of traffic between railways and roads, surely the Minister is not going to take power to license vehicles on roads that will be affected.
Comment on this
The function of the Minister under this Bill, as I conceive it, is to fix maximum weights in relation to the capacity of the roads to bear them—assuming a particular standard of road that would not go beyond our requirements for provision and maintenance and upkeep, a suitable standard of maximum weights.
I have no feeling that in considering maximum weights at this particular stage, without the Transport Bill, that might by its provisions make direct reference to this particular matter, I am completely excluded from considering whether there is a train knocking about or not. I hope that Deputy Cassidy has completely demonstrated to the House the undesirability, when maximum weights are to be laid down as a base line for the country as a whole, that the condition of roads in Donegal, or in some particular part of Cork, should be introduced into the discussion in such a way as to bring about a situation in which we would fix in our base-line order maximum weights that were not reasonable for the country as a whole. The section makes provision by which in special areas regulations can be made to meet special road conditions, and only can be made after a local inquiry, in which there will be the usual procedure of advertisement and publication and the public hearing of what it is proposed to do and why it is proposed to do it, and any interested party can come to that inquiry and deal with the matter there.
Comment on this
Under Section 14 (2) regulations may be made in this matter in respect of different places or areas. I suggest that you want your standard for the country as a whole and that regulations of this particular kind are only intended to be a modification of a general standard in respect of a particular area.
Comment on this
It seems to me that there is a serious omission from the Bill. There is very little use making regulations for maximum weights unless adequate machinery is established for enforcing them. At present I understand local authorities have power to establish weighing machines and through their own officers may require heavy motor cars and locomotives to be brought to these machines for the purpose of being weighed. The InterDepartmental Committee drew attention to the fact that there is a very inadequate number of these machines throughout the country, and that confining the power to require cars to be driven to machines for weighing to the officers of local authorities was not satisfactory. The Committee recommended that members of the Civic Guard should have the power to require a lorry to be taken to weighing machines for the purpose of ascertaining the weight. I would be glad to know if it is the intention of the Minister to give effect to that recommendation.
Comment on this
That is a matter that must come up for review and careful consideration. Facilities do exist in some places for dealing with this particular matter, but there are other places in which this provision does not exist. That is a matter that will have to be reviewed and the necessary steps will have to be taken to see that there is adequate provision for seeing that regulations made under this Bill are adhered to.
Comment on this
The Minister has very diplomatically evaded the real issue which I raised in regard to this section. He has already given an undertaking to Deputy O'Kelly that the regulations which he is given power to make under Section 12, dealing with the classification of mechanically propelled vehicles, will be submitted to and approved of by the House before they will be put in operation. My contention is that we should not give to the Minister under Section 14 any more power than he has asked for in Section 12, and that the Minister should not ask the House to give him that power. If there is justification for the submission of the regulations he is given power to make under Section 12, the very same case can be made for his submitting the regulations made under Section 14.
I would be very reluctant to give any Minister for Local Government unlimited power. The Minister is asking for unlimited power under Section 14 to prescribe the weight of laden and unladen lorries which will be allowed to ply on the roads. The Minister will save himself a good deal of trouble and a considerable amount of discussion here if he will lay down the maximum weight for the best made roads and reducing that weight in accordance with the classification or carrying capacity of roads that are not as good. If he does that he will serve a useful purpose and meet the views of the general body of ratepayers who will then know where they are and what they are expected to pay for damage done by these heavy lorries to the roads. If he does that it will be much easier also to make the regulations which will have to be made under this section. I suggest again that he should apply the principle of the amendment which he has accepted from Deputy O'Kelly dealing with Section 12 to Section 14. I should like to hear what Deputy Moore has to say on this matter.
Comment on this
I suggest that the proper authority to fix the maximum weight of any vehicle is the local authority and that the county council should be the authority for dealing with vehicles running over the roads built out of the pockets of the ratepayers. The Minister talked of special areas and said that because there were bad roads in Donegal or in portions of Cork that was no reason why a specified weight should not be fixed for vehicles all round. I suggest that the power should be given to the local authorities and not to the Minister who only travels down the country at election time and then comes in a first-class railway carriage or something of that description. He takes very good care anyway not to get bumped on any bad road. Such a Minister should not have the fixing of the weight of vehicles travelling over by-roads in Co. Cork. I suggest that the county council would have far more knowledge as to the weight of vehicles which should be allowed to travel over the roads.
Comment on this
Are you prepared to give them that power? Our objection is that you are looking for the power yourself and are not prepared to give it to the county council.
Comment on this
It is you are going to do it and we have too much experience of your dictatorship in Cork already.
Comment on this
The Minister said with the consent of the local authority. Is it not laid down in the Bill that the regulations when made will be submitted for the approval of the House and can be annulled within a certain period?
Comment on this
Why not submit the regulations and have them approved the same as you agreed to under Section 12?
Comment on this
I suggest to Deputy Davin that this whole question is in a sort of transition stage at present. As a good many Deputies are aware, there is a transition from the type of petrol-driven vehicle to the Diesel vehicles which are now coming in. There are a number in Northern Ireland and there are one or two in our own part of the country. There are a good number in England. It is forecasted by a distinguished Irish engineer that before many months are passed that type of vehicle will be the standard type. The effect of that will be to save the country a very big bill in the way of fuel, because the Diesel is run on crude oil and uses very small quantities of it. In face of circumstances of that kind it might well be that the Minister would in order to secure the advantage of these vehicles for the country have to agree to a much heavier type of vehicle than any we are accustomed to. That type of vehicle may not be made in different sizes. As a matter of fact it is not so made at present. It may not be made in the number of types to which we are accustomed. For that reason I, for one, cannot get excited about this debate. I think it is very likely that within the next six months we will be faced with altogether different circumstances and find that a lot of this debate has been rather futile.
Sections 14 and 15 agreed to and added to the Bill.
SECTION 16.
Comment on this
It will be necessary in this section to change the description "Seating accommodation" to "Passenger accommodation".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11.
In sub-section (2) line 58, to insert the word "knowingly" after the word "person."
I think the sub-section as it stands is too wide. It is quite right that a person engaging a driver who is to do his permanent work should satisfy himself that such driver has a licence, but I think that in the case of a casual engagement it would be a very undue burden to put on a person who employed a person casually to make such inquiry. It would be quite absurd that a person taking a taxi should satisfy himself that the driver had a licence before hiring him. I think it is unnecessary also to insist that an employer should see that his driver has his licence paid up to date. He should be only obliged to satisfy himself that the driver has his licence when employed and not require him to see that the driver takes out a new licence when his current one expires. I think the section is far too wide as it stands and that by inserting the word "knowingly" after the word "person" it will meet the case.
Comment on this
I appreciate the point Deputy Thrift makes with regard to the hiring of a taxi or public service vehicle. I think there is an amendment down relating to that somewhere later in the name of Deputy Good. The position already in the Motor Car Act, 1903, is that it is an offence for an owner to employ a driver if that person is not licensed. That Act is in operation since 1903 and has not caused any serious grievance. I think that when you take into consideration the elaborate steps we have taken to tighten up the whole control of road traffic, it is not unreasonable to ask that persons who employ men to drive for them shall see that such drivers are in possession of licences in the proper way. That is the position since 1903, and it would open up a very serious difficulty if we departed from that position.
Comment on this
I admitted that at the time of the engagement the employer should take care to see that the driver is licensed. But to insist that he should be continually looking after the matter would I think be imposing too much on the employer. The amendment which the Minister suggested might cover my point.
Comment on this
Did I understand the Minister to say that the provision in the 1903 Act was that the owner of a motor car who employed a person would be liable? Does the Minister notice that this applies to every person who wants to employ a car for a short journey? It would no doubt be a public service vehicle but not of the type perhaps of a taxi or bus. Suppose a man employed his neighbour to drive him for a short distance, or if he employed a lorry, for instance, to take his goods, would he be liable under the provisions of this section? It appears he would. I agree with Deputy Thrift that such provision makes it very wide indeed.
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree to add at the last part of the section the words "licensing him to drive such vehicle of which he is the owner"? Would not that meet the case if such words as those were added?
Comment on this
The first part of Deputy Good's amendment to Section 133 is that "For the purposes of this Act any person hiring a street service vehicle shall not be deemed to be the employer of the driver" ...Deputies may wish on that basis to extend the class of street service vehicles, but I take it that Deputies will not wish that the ordinary regular employers of a driver, let us say shopkeepers or business firms, should be relieved from their responsibilities for seeing that the drivers of their cars have licences. In page 115 of the Traffic Report it was made clear, as follows: "Furthermore in Sections 3 and 20 of the Motor Car, 1903, Act, a person must not employ a person who has not a current licence to drive a motor car on the road."
Comment on this
But if Deputy Thrift's amendment were accepted the effect would be to relieve the employer altogether of that obligation, and I think we appreciate that he ought not to be relieved of that. Relief is apparently sought for the casual employer of a vehicle.
Comment on this
We can give further consideration to that and see what is involved in it. I shall consider it and if Deputies will do the same then on the Report Stage we shall see how the position can be safeguarded.
Comment on this
I take it the Minister will consider the amendment I have down. I think no matter what liabilities are resting or may rest upon the owner of a vehicle there is no doubt whatever that the unfortunate hirer of the vehicle knows nothing about whether a man should be licensed or should not be made licensed. It would be exceedingly unfair if that hirer of a taxi should find that he had incurred considerable liability.
My amendment is put down to ensure that the hirer of a taxi by the act of hiring will not incur any liability that may fall on the driver.
Comment on this
I was referring to the amendment that the Deputy has to Section 133. With the first part I agree but I will have something to say to the second part.
Comment on this
I submit that Deputy Thrift's amendment is absolutely unsuitable and that the sub-section might as well be deleted. It would necessitate a person proposing to employ a car saying: "I do not want to know if you have a licence or not."
Comment on this
I am withdrawing my amendment. I stated at the beginning that I stressed the matter for casual cases. I say that once a person engaging a car satisfies himself that the driver is licensed no liability should fall on him.
Comment on this
In connection with amendment 12 I will undertake to redraft it and to insert an amendment covering it.
Comment on this
The penalty in this section seems particularly severe in comparison with other penalties. The driving of a car without a licence is not such a serious offence as to warrant six months' imprisonment and a fine of £100. In my opinion offences which are much more serious are punished much more lightly in the Bill.
Comment on this
I would be glad to have some comments on the fines and punishments if Deputies have any to offer.
Comment on this
Take Section 25. A person driving so as to be a source of danger to the public is liable to a fine of £25 for certain offences. The man without a licence who drives a car carefully and who is not a danger to anyone becomes liable to a fine of £50 and to three months' imprisonment for a second offence. It seems to me these penalties are altogether out of proportion. The only reason there are licences is because it makes it easier to enforce the traffic regulations. Although it is desirable that there should be sufficiently severe penalties to induce everybody to obey the law, at the same time it would seem to be contrary to justice that it would be possible for a man who has merely omitted to provide himself with a licence at a particular period to be punished in the very severe manner indicated.
Comment on this
I would agree there is something to be said on that subject generally, particularly if we take the case of a person who has an insurance, while for some slight reason not having a licence. I have an open mind on a lot of these matters and I would like if Deputies would put down amendments which would suggest the conclusions they have come to for discussion on the next stage.