Road Traffic Bill, 1931—Committee. (Resumed).
Contributions 135–266 of 266. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 38 of 1931 ›
Except there were people anxious to teach the Deputy a lesson, it would probably be taken into consideration that it was an oversight.
Comment on this
I move:
In sub-section (1) line 22, to delete the word "fourteen" and substitute therefor the word "fifteen."
This section raises a very debatable subject as to the age at which a boy has sufficient intelligence to receive a licence. The Bill suggests that a boy should not be under fourteen years of age to drive a motor cycle, not under seventeen years of age to drive a light vehicle, and not under eighteen years of age to drive a heavy vehicle. As to issuing a licence to a person under fourteen years of age I think there is very little doubt that that age is too low. While there may be some boys of abnormal development to which it would be safe to issue licences at fourteen the experience of most of us is that it would be wise in the general interests of road users to raise the age, certainly to fifteen, if not a little higher. While my amendment mentions fifteen if the House in its wisdom thinks that a higher age is desirable I would agree. I would not like to see licences issued to young persons under fifteen years of age.
Comment on this
I tabled amendments to Sections 21 and 22 and by an oversight I forgot to table a corresponding amendment to this section. I endorse everything that Deputy Good has said and I appeal to our medical colleagues for their views on the matter. After all a boy of fourteen is only a child. There are, of course, precocious boys. I am perfectly certain that when the Minister was fourteen he would drive an aeroplane. We are not dealing with prodigies. The average boy of fourteen does not possess the necessary nerve. He is too reckless, and if he gets into a traffic jam he might suffer from what could be described as traffic fright. In the interests of traffic control and in the interests of the boys themselves I hope the House will not allow the absurdities that appear in the Bill. I think this is the greatest defect in a Bill that is otherwise admirable.
Comment on this
I suppose it is a case of three great minds thinking alike, but when I was submitting my amendments I was not aware that Deputy Good had been thinking on the same lines. I agree with Deputy Good, and I am prepared to go further and say that the age of fifteen is too low. I think the physical ability and the mental control which a normal boy of fourteen or fifteen has would not justify a licence being granted at that age. The safety of the travelling public has to be taken into consideration and for the reasons given I would encourage the Minister to raise the age still higher.
Comment on this
I am entirely in favour of the amendment and in fact I would be inclined to raise the age to 16. I think the age of 14 is entirely too young for any boy to have a licence. We have been talking of boys but, as a matter of fact, if we were to examine the records, we would find that there are quite as many ladies driving motors if not more as there are boys and men. To let school children of 14 or 15 drive motors when they probably have not got the full nerve that they will have later on is an extremely dangerous thing. I certainly think that 16 is the earliest age at which a licence should be given. I think 14 is altogether too young, unsafe for the driver, and unsafe for the people whom he meets on the road. I hope the Minister will consider raising the age. It should certainly be not less than 15, but I would suggest 16.
Comment on this
When I saw those amendments I thought there was a split among the Independents, but apparently Deputy Good agrees with Deputy Alton that the age should be 16. I would like to support that suggestion. I think the last Deputy was confusing the provisions of this Section with another Section. This Section applies only to the driving of motor bicycles. If the Minister will make it 16, I think he will be very well advised.
Comment on this
Although my name is down in support of the amendment fixing the age at 15, I should prefer to have it fixed at 16. It was pointed out to me, however, with I believe some truth, that boys at the age of 18 or 19 are very much more dangerous, as far as driving in traffic is concerned, than at the earlier ages. It was only that aspect of the case that made me agree to put my name to the amendment by which the age is raised from 14 to 15. On the whole I would prefer to see the age 16 rather than 15. As I say, those who have greater experience and knowledge of the subject, have pointed out to me that there is greater danger and greater risk at the ages of 18 and 19. Boys at that age take great risks, whereas young boys are much more careful and much more likely to be careful. On the whole if the Minister is willing to accept the age of 16, I am willing to support it.
Comment on this
I think there is general agreement on all sides of the House that the age limit should be fixed at 16 rather than 14 as suggested in the Bill. That is my own view, and sounding the views of the Party with which I am associated, I have found that the majority seemed to be in favour of the age limit being fixed at 16. There were some who mentioned that from their own experience they thought that boys and girls of 15 could manage properly on a motor bicycle, but I think that the majority seemed to be in favour of 16. I certainly will stand for the minimum age being fixed at 16. There is one class of drivers of motor cycles to which my attention has been called —that is, boys who drive motor cycles for the Post Office. I would not like to do anything that would deprive these boys of their employment, if they are of a lower age than 16. The few I have seen on the street on Post Office work seemed to be boys over 16 years of age, but the point has been put to me. I do not think it is likely to interfere with the employment of boys in that Department. On the whole for motor cycles, certainly for high-powered cycles, 16 is as early an age as girls or boys should be allowed to drive these machines in modern conditions of traffic. Deputy Lemass has mentioned to me one class of motor attachment to bicycles that would not be of high power. It might be a disadvantage to deprive young people of the use of such attachments. There are small contrivances that are attached to pedal bicycles. There are not very many users of them, and it might not be worth while taking them into consideration in making these laws.
Comment on this
We could meet the point raised by Deputy Kelly in connection with boys from the Post Office by providing that the age of 16 should apply except in cases where boys are already in employment.
Comment on this
The position is that 14 has been the age limit up to the present. In support of what Deputy Sir James Craig has stated, I might say that all the information we have is that no traffic accidents occur arising out of the use of bicycles by boys of younger ages and as Deputy Sir James Craig stated 17, 18 and 19 are the dangerous ages. I would suggest that as 15 has been proposed in this amendment that we adopt 15 now. We can further consider the matter on Report and Deputy Alton can put down an amendment to fix the age at 16, if he wishes. There is in fact no complaint from the police authorities or any other side as to the misuse of motor cycles by boys of 14 to 16 years of age. The Post Office does not employ boys under 16 and I do not think that boys under 16 are employed in commercial work which would call for the use of motor bicycles. It has been put to me that there may be cases in some parts of the country in which motor bicycles are used by school children between the ages of 14 and 16 for the purpose of getting to a good school within motoring range. Considering how far flung in some parts of the country secondary schools are and considering the drive that is being made to have continuation education established, and to make things easy for young people who want to advance their education in that way, it would be a pity perhaps if persons actually using or likely to make use of higher educational facilities, were prevented from doing so by being forced to use pedal bicycles for a distance that was perhaps beyond their strength. That is the only point that has been made in that regard. I do not know whether the Minister for Education could be empowered to issue certificates to permit of the use of motor bicycles like that. We could for the moment make the age 15 but we are making the age 15 without any evidence except the idea that we think that boys of 14 and 12 are a bit irresponsible and reckless although the boys and girls of that age to-day are very different from those of the period in which, when you tried to ride a bicycle, one caught a grip of your back and pushed the bicycle up and down the road.
Now, before children are able to walk, they use a scooter and then they get on to fairy bicycles. Afterwards you have youngsters of very irresponsible years, carrying all kinds of loads on the back of their bicycles until they become regular acrobats as far as bicycles are concerned. If we make the age 15 we do so without any evidence. I have no objection to making it 15, but if Deputy Alton would wish to make it 16 he can move to do so on the Report Stage. There is no use in perhaps cutting off facilities to people when there may not be any reason they should be cut off.
Comment on this
Has the Minister any knowledge in regard to accidents to boys of fourteen, fifteen or sixteen? I am only speaking of my own experience. I was in the position of being in charge or quasi charge of youngsters recently, and I was struck by the number of accidents from motor bicycles to boys who suffered permanent damage. One is short of a leg and another has damaged his arm. The ages of these boys range from sixteen up to nineteen. Sixteen and seventeen seem to be the ages most dangerous.
Comment on this
I agree with the Minister that we may take fifteen at present. When we come to hard facts this is a matter to which the parent has something to say because he has to provide the money.
Comment on this
I move:
In sub-section (1), line 26, to delete the word "fourteen" and substitute therefor the word "fifteen."
Comment on this
I move:
In sub-section (2), line 41, after the word "that" to insert the words "I am a competent driver and."
This amendment deals with the issuing of licences and with the form that has to be filled up before the licence is granted. On that form there is no declaration whatever to the effect that the person enquiring for the licence has any knowledge at all of driving. Well, I think it is essential that the person to whom a driving licence is issued should have some knowledge of driving; and with that object the form of the licence is here suggested. The point has been raised that if the person who is asked to sign that particular form says that he has not done any driving then a licence could not be issued to him and that there would be no way out of the difficulty.
Comment on this
He could not become a driver until he had a licence.
Comment on this
To get over that difficulty it has been suggested that beginners' licences should be issued to such persons and that drivers' licences should not be issued to those persons until they had some knowledge of driving. Of course tests are provided in the case of persons making application for licences to drive passenger vehicles, but we are all agreed that it would be very undesirable and a very troublesome task to put all persons who want to drive motor bicycles or light motor vehicles to a driving test. That would be a cumbersome method and in order to get over that difficulty it has been suggested that these words should be added to the licence and that furthermore beginners' licences should be issued for a short period of say three months or a shorter period if necessary in order to qualify for drivers' licences. That would get over the difficulty I think. In this connection there are possibly other difficulties, but this is not the time to discuss them. But it does occur to one that in connection with the issuing of licences in the North of Ireland it is necessary to have a photograph of the driver on the licence in order to identify him. That is a matter that can be subsequently considered. It does not arise in connection with any of the amendments.
Comment on this
I am only dealing with the question of issuing licences and I am asking that these words I have proposed should be added to the particular form which the person is asked to sign before the licence is issued.
Comment on this
It is a demand that nobody will get a driver's licence unless he is a competent driver, but that he can get a beginner's licence. As to the kind of licence which a man has obtained, what difference will it make to the pedestrian who has been injured whether the driver of the car has a beginner's licence or a driver's licence.
Comment on this
I have not entered at all into the question of the beginner's licence because that is a matter for the Minister to consider. But I think that in the present state of road traffic it is highly necessary that some protection should be given to the road users, and that the person who has no knowledge of motor driving should not be allowed to go on the public highway to the danger of other road users. That is a thing that this House ought not approve of. At any rate some protection is necessary. This is a limited form of protection, but some precaution is necessary before a licence is issued.
Comment on this
I have given as much consideration to this matter as I could give. I quite agree that the suggestion is impracticable, because if you start and give beginners licences then the question arises when the beginner ceases to be a beginner and when he becomes competent.
Comment on this
You have simply to take a man's word for it. And you are driven to consider who it is exactly who teaches people to drive cars. I am not really quite clear that what Deputy Good has in mind is really achieved by what he proposes. If it would make him feel any more comfortable about the matter it may be possible to arrange that a licence issued to a person for the first year should be indicated by a red line or by a blue line—something that would show that this is his first year of driving.
Comment on this
I must say that I do not sense any feeling of great difficulty in this House in the matter and I hesitate to make a proposal that there should be any distinction between the first licence issued to a person and any other licence. It might involve a difficulty and I do not see any necessity for it. I am not at all clear that there is any real necessity for it or that what is in Deputy Good's mind arises out of any practical experience in the situation that we had up to the present.
Comment on this
Would the Minister suggest the provision of a skating rink and let the learners qualify there?
Comment on this
Would the Minister make inquiries as to how this difficulty is met in other countries?
Comment on this
Perhaps it would meet the situation if the Minister could keep the learners off the main roads. I think that is the principal thing. All people must learn and you must give them a certain amount of licence in order to learn. The risk is that before they learn sufficiently that they are allowed to go on the main roads.
Comment on this
Then you would want something like overhead wires to take the car from the person's residence until he comes on to the by-road or else make provision that the learners shall not drive without a competent driver in the car. I do not know where all that would lead us to.
Comment on this
I am sorry I must disagree with Deputy Sir James Craig. I would ask the Minister to take those learners off the quiet residential roads where they are making life miserable for me and send them on to the rural roads so that they would be executed at once.
Comment on this
I move amendment 20.
In sub-section (1), (b), line 52, after the word "vehicle" to insert the words "not carrying passengers for reward."
I put this down because I believe there ought to be some age-limit below which a person should be deemed not to be competent to drive passengers for reward. Without this amendment there would be an inducement to owners of vehicles to employ boys. There would be an inducement to the owners of motor vehicles to employ—as they should not be allowed to employ in the face of the fact that there were such large numbers unemployed—boys below the age of 17. I do not think that sort of thing should be encouraged, and I put down this amendment to prevent owners from employing boys under 18.
Comment on this
A light motor vehicle is simply a taxi, a street service car, or a private hiring car, one or the other. If we take the school-leaving age we find that the school-leaving age for the primary schools is at 15. Perhaps in Dublin it runs along to 16. Under Continuation Education, the compulsory age is 16, and the principal difficulty people always have with regard to boys is their employment just after they leave school. Numerous cases occur by reason of the fact that the boy does not get into an occupation at the time he leaves school. His character is destroyed and his value in business or in the industrial world is prejudiced by reason of the time he has been unemployed. If the taxi-driver has a son, this amendment would prevent his son at the age of 17 years becoming a taxi-driver. It would prevent the son of a hotel proprietor taking out the car belonging to the hotel and driving some of the hotel visitors for hire. I think that we ought not to close down a case like that when we should take into consideration that any young person driving either a street service vehicle or a private vehicle must be a person who has been tested for competency under the Bill. Deputy Davin, I take it, has only in mind the driving of buses?
Comment on this
Taxis and motor cars would come under the description of light motor vehicles, but buses would not.
Comment on this
I would ask Deputy Davin not to press his amendment. He must know that in the circumstances under which boys are brought up nowadays they are looking forward from the time that they are ten years of age to becoming drivers of motors or taxis. It is their biggest ambition in the world. At the age of 15 a boy is very often competent to drive a motor-car and many are specially competent at the age of 17 because they have grown up in a motor atmosphere. Unless we are prepared to offer alternative employment to a boy of 17 it would be unjust to forbid him to get a licence to drive a car. There are not many alternatives open to them, and boys at the age of 17 who cannot drive motor vehicles are in fact suffering a tremendous disadvantage. They will not get any employment. You have perhaps 40,000 vehicles classed as light motor vehicles and if you are going to say that a boy of 17 must remain idle though he is competent to drive a motor vehicle you are putting him under a great disadvantage. This is a dangerous amendment and I ask the Deputy not to press it.
Comment on this
I am putting it to the Minister that every Deputy knows that there is a considerable number of unemployed drivers in this country. While we have a situation of that kind it should not be made easier for the owners of motor-cars plying for hire to employ comparatively young boys at a small wage while married men with families are unemployed. That is the point of view from which I am considering the matter. If you allow the section to stand you are putting it in the power of owners of motor-cars to employ boys before they are physically fit, thereby depriving unemployed married men of a livelihood. I ask the Minister to reconsider the matter from that point of view, that is, of the married men and their dependents. It is far more necessary to provide an opportunity for employment for them than to pass this Section enabling boys under 17 or 18 years of age to be employed.
Comment on this
The Deputy is asking us to take away here a power which exists at the present moment with regard to persons of that age.
Comment on this
This Bill is reviewing the whole road traffic regulations which are, I suppose, fifty years out of date. I cannot say for certain how many thousand unemployed there are in this country including hundreds of motor drivers. We should not make it possible for these people to be left out of employment longer than the time in which they can secure it. By passing the section as it stands, we are allowing young men to pass a test and secure employment as motor drivers who are perhaps not as well qualified as the older men who are out of work.
Comment on this
I would like to say in this connection that every corner of every village in this country is filled with young boys of from 17 to 20. It is the aim of a number of labour representatives at the moment—I do not say it is Deputy Davin's aim—to try and keep young people out of employment. If people do not get the opportunity of making good early in life, the time passes when they can be trained for any useful occupation. I would urge in the interests of those young people that it is just as important that they should get employment as that the older people should get it. I think we ought to try, in the interests of the whole State, to do something towards breaking down the different barriers which are preventing those young people from getting into useful occupations and from being as good citizens as they would be if they got employment. From that point of view I am with the Minister, and I think that these young people ought to get the opportunity that is denied them in several walks of life.
Comment on this
I want to say there is no such intention in my mind as to deprive any man from getting employment and I shall join in co-operation with Deputy Good and with all other parties in this House to attain that end, but I want to take the men who are getting relief off the rates and you should do this before you create new avenues for employment for people not so well qualified.
Comment on this
Deputy Good has alluded to the fact that there are a large number of young people who are driving buses.
Comment on this
Light motors. While Deputy Davin and the Labour Party do not object to young people getting employment we claim that the first to get employment should be the married men and I venture to say to Deputy Good that one of the reasons why married men are passed over and employment given to the young men is that employers in Dublin city and county in many cases endeavour, as far as light vehicles are concerned, to take advantage of the situation by employing young men at a low rate of wages. We say that preference should be given to the married man with a family and if employment is to be given to young men it should be at trade union rates.
Comment on this
I move amendment 21:
In sub-section (1) (b), line 52, after the word "vehicle" to insert the words "or motor cycle."
There appears to have been an omission in the drafting of this Section. This amendment proposes to remedy that omission. Section 19 provides that no person shall hold more than one driving licence at a time, whereas Section 22 lays down that every driving licence granted shall operate to licence the person to whom it is granted: "(a) if or when such person has attained the age of 14 years and is under the age of 17 years to drive a motor cycle. (b) if or when such person has attained the age of 17 years and is under the age of 18 years to drive any kind of motor vehicle" and "(c) if or when such person has attained the age of 18 years and is under the age of 21 years to drive any kind of mechanically propelled vehicle except a heavy motor vehicle or a locomotive actually carrying passengers for reward." This would allow persons over 18 to drive light motor vehicles or motor cycles but, as drafted, the Bill would not permit a person licensed to drive a light motor vehicle to drive a motor cycle. I submit that that is unreasonable and my amendment is intended to provide that a person who has attained 17 years of age but is under 18 and who is entitled to drive a light motor vehicle shall be also entitled to drive a motor cycle.
Comment on this
I move amendment 22:
At the end of sub-section 1, to add a new paragraph as follows:—
"(e) if or when such person has attained the age of eighteen years and is under twenty-one years and has been at the date of the passing of this Act in three months' continuous occupation as the driver of a heavy motor vehicle, to drive any kind of mechanically-propelled vehicle."
There are in Dublin, and there probably are in other places, young persons under 21 years at present driving heavy motor vehicles and driving such vehicles which apply for hire. I believe it would be a hardship if such young men, having been in continuous employment for a number of months and having given satistion, should be deprived of their employment by the passage of this Bill. It is for the purpose of meeting that position that I move this amendment.
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy Haslett I should like to point out that the amendment in his name is practically the same as the amendment moved by Deputy O'Kelly. Without the amendment of this clause, a person who has driven a particular type of vehicle for substantial periods before the Act comes into operation will be disqualified for the driving of that type of vehicle. Apart from the injustice to the owner-driver, this may seriously affect many young persons whose living may depend upon their being permitted to drive. You are going to create a period of unemployment and bring about all the disadvantages pointed out by Deputy Moore by allowing under this section a period to elapse which would seriously affect these drivers. A case has been put up already dealing with the men who are fairly competent to drive and have been driving.
Comment on this
The ideas in both of these amendments are acceptable, and I shall get something drafted to meet them. I should just like to say what I have in mind. I feel that we have to discriminate between the person who has a driving licence simply by reason of the fact that he is in employment that requires it.
I think we have to take the date of the passing of the Act and that a person holding a licence issued more than six months before the passing of the Act should continue to be allowed to hold a licence although he did not conform to the ages in the Bill. That would include a motor cycle licence. But, in the case of a person who, at the passing of the Bill, was in employment and had a licence which was necessary to his employment, I think we would have to shorten the period in respect of the licence for that. It would be, to some extent, unreasonble that persons should take people into their employment and get them a driving licence while the Bill is actually before the House, and I should like to give further consideration to that. Where, on the passing of the Act, there is a person in employment having a driving licence and his employment depending on that, where that licence has been issued more than two months before the passing of the Act, I think it might be reasonable to continue a licence to such a person although he did not come into accordance with the age limit, rather than that a person who obviously had been two months in a particular employment should be thrown out of that employment for a period, great or small. Deputies may have some comments to make on approaching the position on these particular lines and I shall be glad to hear them.
Comment on this
If a licence had been two months in force at the passing of the Act, will that be taken as implying that the owner had been in employment during that time, that there would be no proof of employment required?
Comment on this
No. If it was proved to the satisfaction of whatever authority is responsible for recalling that licence, if it were not properly in existence, that the person would be deprived of his employment if the licence was not continued, then that licence, although it was less than six months in existence, say, in two-and-a-half or three months, would be continued.
Comment on this
On the section, I would like to draw attention to sub-section (c) line 55, where I think the failure to put in a comma at the end of the word "vehicle" leaves the sub-section open to a wrong interpretation. Perhaps some poor taxpayer will be put to the expense of having to pay lawyers to interpret that later on.
Comment on this
I shall have that examined, although I understand these things are supposed to work without commas.
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy Haslett I move: "To delete sub-section (2)." The effect of the section as it stands is that though a licence has been obtained and a fee paid for it would have no affect till signed. If the section were to remain as it stands it would mean that a person could have two summonses issued against him for the one offence. I am sure that the Minister does not mean that a man should be prosecuted on two counts for one offence.
Comment on this
If a man is found without having his licence signed under sub-section (1) he can be summonsed for not having signed his name to it, and under sub-section (2) for having in his possession a licence that is not signed. I suggest that the two subsections should be run into one by taking out the word "notwithstanding" and substituting the word "and" so as to make it one offence.
Comment on this
There is nothing in the section to make it one offence. What is in the section is that a person is without a licence until he signs it. The purpose of requiring a licensee to sign his licence is to provide simple machinery for identification. Deputy Good was speaking of the necessity for attaching a photograph to every licence. That is more simply and satisfactorily met by requiring the licensee to sign the licence. I see no difficulty in the licensee signing the licence immediately after he gets it.
Comment on this
Why keep two subsections in the Bill that will allow of two charges being made against a man for one offence?
Comment on this
There is nothing here to make failure to sign a licence an offence. There is nothing to make anything under Section 23 an offence, but if a person has not got his licence signed, then under the section which requires him to have a licence he can be punished.
Comment on this
I move Amendment 25:—
In line 31, after the word "twelve" to insert the word "calendar."
This amendment is consequential on an amendment we were discussing on the definitions. I suggested that the definition of the word "year" should be twelve calendar months and this is consequential on that. The Minister might consider this along with the other.
Comment on this
Some adjustment will be made on the other one, but here it is covered by 1 (1) d of the Interpretation Act and is unnecessary.
Comment on this
I move amendment 25A on behalf of Deputy O'Kelly:—
In sub-section (1) (a), lines 46 and 47, to delete the words: "if such mechanically propelled vehicle is a public service vehicle," and to delete paragraph (b).
The purpose is to make the penalty for any person charged with drunkenness the same, whether it be a public service vehicle or a private vehicle. The opinion we have formed on this question is that if anybody should be penalised more than another it is the private motorist. The weight of the law should not fall upon the driver of a public service vehicle, or rather should not fall with more emphasis on the driver of a public service vehicle than of a private vehicle. There is no good attempting to discriminate as to which would be the greater danger on the road. Everybody knows that when a motor accident occurs there are generally two parties involved, and that it is as often the private motor driver as much as the public vehicle driver that is to blame. To make it a less offence for the driver of a private motor car to be drunk in charge of his car than for a driver of a public service vehicle to be drunk in charge of his vehicle, is if anything reversing what appears to us to be the natural order. A private motorist is supposed to be a more substantial man and to be a man of position generally speaking. Consequently, he ought to be a more educated man with more sense of responsibility than the driver of a public service vehicle. Then again a fine means a great deal less to him than to the driver of a publice service vehicle. A fine of £50 to many private motorists would not be a very great punishment, but to the driver of a public service vehicle it would be a very big punishment. We realise that it is very important in the case of drivers of public service vehicles that every possible means should be adopted to prevent them running the risk of being drunk in charge of vehicles over which they have control. When the Minister is looking at it from the point of view that the driver of a public service vehicle is in charge of, and responsible for a larger number of passengers, he is taking what seems to us to be a rather narrow view.
The private motor driver who is drunk on the road has similar responsibilities to every other motor vehicle on the road, and for that matter to every pedestrian and cyclist as well. The driver of a private motor car who gets drunk can cause any amount of damage. He could cause the upset of a bus completely full of passengers and we can see no real reason for making this discrimination in the Bill.
Comment on this
There are two points that I would like to make in connection with this before the discussion goes on. A public service vehicle as the section stands shall include a large bus, small bus, taxi, and private hired vehicle. We are considering the position of the driver of a private vehicle and driver of a goods vehicle on the one hand. The Bill suggests the offence of drunkenness should be more leniently dealt with so far as maximum penalties are concerned and minimum qualifications with regard to that particular class. There are three classes. The big and small bus, that is buses carrying from fourteen passengers upwards, and buses carrying from six up to fourteen. Then the small street service and private hire vehicles. Then persons running big and small lorries and persons running private cars. I am inclined to think there should be— and at any rate I want the opinion of the House as to whether there should be—greater penalties for any of these particular classes. Personally, I feel there ought to be a higher penalty in respect of the person driving a larger public service vehicle as distinct from what is in the Bill, that is a person in charge of a bus of from 20 to 36 passengers. That person, in a state of drunkenness, may do a lot more than run into another car. He may run into a wall or over a bridge with 32 passengers on board, and I think that greater strictness is required with regard to that particular class of vehicle. However, I would like to have the opinion of the House on that. We think that the taxi and the private hire car might be put into the normal class. Then, having come to a decision as to whether there should be any discrimination at all, I think on this section we will want some discussion as to whether the penalties imposed here on a public service vehicle—that is the higher penalties— are thought to be excessive or not.
Comment on this
I am rather inclined to agree with Deputy O'Kelly's amendment, I think there is a good deal of force in what Deputy Moore has said. The privately owned car can do a tremendous lot of damage if the man driving it is drunk. It can cause a bus to swerve and turn over, during which many passengers may be killed. I fail to see why the Minister thinks that the driver of a taxi should be treated differently from the driver of an ordinary car.
Comment on this
Personally I am prepared to forgo that, but in the case of buses or heavy public service vehicles I am not.
Comment on this
I am inclined to agree whole-heartedly with Deputy O'Kelly's amendment.
Comment on this
I do not think the punishment can be sufficiently great for a drunken man who attempts to drive a car. Since I sat on the Liquor Commission and heard the evidence given there I formed the opinion that we could in practice not inflict any punishment that could be sufficiently great upon such a man. In my opinion the punishment here is too slight. I think it is a dreadful thing that anyone drunk can drive a 'bus containing maybe 32 persons whose lives are depending upon him and run perhaps into another car or a ditch or anything of that sort. In addition there is the danger to the community. If I had my will I would increase, in every direction, instead of diminishing, the punishments for drunkenness while driving motor vehicles. Nor would I make any difference between a man who is driving a vehicle carrying five persons or a bus carrying thirty persons. There is as much danger in the one as there is in the other. I overlooked the fact that I wanted to say something about Section 25. I think that section is useless because of the words it contains, namely, "to his knowledge." No man is going to say that when he undertook to drive a car he was incapable. I think the words "to his knowledge" render the section practically inoperative. I would like to see the Minister tightening up Section 26 and to make the penalty greater. I could say a great deal about that if I wished. I have seen cases where life was lost because people were drunk in charge of vehicles.
Comment on this
I am inclined to agree with Deputy Sir James Craig and generally with those of his opinion. I am not taking that view on the immediate line of the amendment, but on the general principle. Long before a man is drunk he is a danger to himself and to society if he is in charge of a motor car. I am not speaking of the man who is obviously drunk. A man who will allow hiself to get into that state, a state of actual drunkenness, and then drive a public vehicle is a criminal. I have no hesitation at all in saying that. He has a lump of metal on the road with a momentum which is flying along the roads at 40 or 50 miles an hour. He is not fit to be in charge of such a lethal weapon and to be let loose on the public. I am taking the line that long before a man is in that condition he is a danger. This is a subject upon which I think most of us can speak with a certain amount of experience because most of us have been in a condition a good deal on the right side of being drunk, and yet in a position to recognise that we were not as competent as we ought to be. You have the man who goes to an ordinary house at night. He has dinner and he is coming away just a little bit "fresh." That man is dangerous. The man who knowingly goes out with a vehicle in that condition most certainly ought not to be treated with any consideration. As a result of knowingly going out in that preventable condition of incompetence and taking charge of a vehicle he becomes a danger to the public. In this particular matter I will uphold the most stringent treatment of any man either in a state of drunkenness or in an incipient state of incapacity, who while in charge of a motor car causes damage to other people.
Comment on this
If the amendment is put to a division I will support it, believing that the object aimed at is sound. I realise, as the Minister has pointed out, that a person who is charged with being drunk while in charge of a public vehicle, with the lives of 36 passengers at his mercy, is certainly a person likely to cause great damage and, if you like, to kill more people than a person who is in charge of a private car. I do not like the idea of fixing a maximum penalty, without at the same time putting in a minimum penalty for a first or second offence. I am entirely opposed to the imposition of a fine in the case of a person who is found guilty of drunkenness on a second offence while in charge of a private or a public vehicle. I think a person who is found drunk for the second time, whether in charge of a private or a public vehicle, should be in Mountjoy Prison.
I would like to see an amendment of the section so as to prescribe a minimum penalty for a first offence, and certainly imprisonment for drunkenness while in charge of a car for a second offence. Certain people are in a position to have more than one car and, to them, £20, £10, or £5 would only mean as much as 5s. would mean to the milkman who sells milk at 1s. 8d. a gallon, to which he has added 50 per cent. of water. A fine of £5, £10 or £20 to a man with £10,000 a year who can afford to get drunk means nothing to him as compared with a poor person who is driving a public service vehicle, but Mountjoy is a deterrent, and the Minister might amend the Bill so as to order detention in such cases.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy Flinn that the man who is half drunk, as we call it, is a much greater danger than the man who is wholly drunk. The latter will not encourage people to get into his bus. A man who is wholly drunk has sense enough to know that he is not able to get into the bus and to drive it. It is the man who is partially drunk, who has lost his judgment, who is the greatest offender, and the greatest danger. I agree with Deputy Davin and I would like to see such a man getting no option to imprisonment if convicted a second time.
Comment on this
If there be any amendment of this section I would certainly like to see it in the way of tightening it up. I do not see why any distinction should be made between the driver of a public vehicle and the driver of a private car. It may be said perhaps that the driver of a public vehicle must be competent to carry the public safely, but in a number of collisions— and there was one a few days ago— the accidents to public vehicles have been caused by drivers of private vehicles who were incapable of driving cars. I think the position as between the driver of a public vehicle and the driver of a private vehicle can very well be left to the court trying the case. The court will have certain discretion, even though this section be tightened, as to the penalty that is to be imposed, we will take it for a first offence. The penalty which the court may impose will depend a great deal on the circumstance of the case. I can quite see that the maximum penalty for a first offence would, in certain cases, be decided upon by the court, in the case of the driver of a public vehicle, and at the same time the maximum sentence might be imposed by the court on the driver of a private vehicle, because owing to the action of that driver a number of people were injured.
With regard to the other matter mentioned by Deputy Sir James Craig, I think this section as it stands meets what was a defect in the existing law with regard to the charge of being drunk when driving a motor car. The usual defence in such cases—and I have come across a number of them— is that the onus is on anyone prosecuting a person for being drunk in charge of a car, irrespective of type, to prove that the person was drunk. I think sub-section 3 meets that, because the onus is not now on the prosecution to prove that the person was drunk, or was in such a state of intoxication that a Guard was arresting him irrespective of whether he was in immediate relation to the car or not.
Sub-section (3) provides that the real question to be decided is whether a person, by reason of the amount of intoxicating liquor he had consumed, is incapable of managing a car. That is going a great way towards remedying any defect which existed in the law in the past. It was a serious difficulty, a difficulty which gave an entirely unmerited defence to people prosecuted under the Act. I would impress on the Minister not to allow any change to be made in the section at all. From my own experience there has been an increase in the number of cases, certainly in Dublin recently. If there be any change in the section, I would suggest to the Minister that it should be on the lines of tightening it up and leaving it to the discretion of the court as to whether there should be any distinction made between the driver of a public and a private vehicle.
Comment on this
I hope that Deputy Finlay understands that our proposal is to tighten up the penalties.
Comment on this
Is any voice in the Committee going to be raised for differentiation? As far as I can see there is none. I take it, then, that we ought to accept the amendments which are before us. Deputy O'Kelly has made that particular point that there should be no differentiation as between different classes of vehicles. Then I ask the Committee to turn their attention to the punishments that are provided, and see if we can elucidate further what particular type of tightening up in respect of them is desirable. The position at the present moment is that a person convicted on the first offence may be fined £50 and sentenced to three months' imprisonment, and that he will be disqualified from driving for a period of not less than twelve months. For the second offence a fine of £100 may be inflicted and or six months' imprisonment, together with the minimum disqualification of three years from driving.
Comment on this
Amendments 27, 28 and 29 are consequential on that amendment.
The following amendments were agreed to:—
27. In sub-section (2) (a), page 15, lines 11 and 12, to delete the words "was committed in relation to a public service vehicle and".—Seán T. O Ceallaigh.
28. In sub-section (2) (b), lines 15 and 16, to delete the words "was committed in relation to a public service vehicle and".—Seán T. O Ceallaigh.
29. In sub-section (2), to delete paragraphs (c) and (d).—Seán T. O Ceallaigh.
Comment on this
I move amendment 26:
In sub-section (2), line 5, to delete the word "shall" and substitute therefor the word "may."
I may say that I would be the last Deputy in the House to wish to slacken any regulations that might be made under the section. I realise the danger that exists, and I endorse the words that have fallen from all Benches in regard to them. My amendment proposes to substitute the word "may" for "shall," because we all know that there are at times border-line cases. There have been cases that presented a good deal of difficulty to the justice trying them, where the person charged has been very technically in error. I do not want to minimise the fines or the punishment, but to leave some little discretion in the power of the justice who tries the case. A great deal can be said for that attitude, inasmuch as every justice, having the witnesses and the person charged before him, is in a very strong position to judge whether that person was negligent or whether it was a technical offence. It is only on that point that my amendment is proposed. I do not wish to minimise any of the punishments, but just to leave a certain discretion with the justice. It would seem to be mandatory if a technical offence is committed.
Comment on this
This amendment really involves the whole question of the general type of punishment. Deputy Haslett's amendment would put the section into the position that conviction for drunkenness in charge of a car would not invariably bring disqualification. The section as it stands means that conviction, whatever be the fine or other punishment inflicted, must bring disqualification for a minimum period of twelve months in the first instance, and three years in the second instance. As I say, the question at issue is the general type of punishment that should be inflicted for these offences.
Comment on this
I would also ask the Minister not to accept Deputy Haslett's amendment. I think that when there is a conviction for the offence of being drunk in charge of a motor car there should follow automatically disqualification for the period mentioned. Under the Motor Car Act of 1903 the justices have power at the moment— and it is a power which has been exercised in some cases recently—of disqualifying people for certain periods after an offence has been committed; but every time an attempt is made to have such disqualification imposed, as is now empowered by the Motor Car Act, the defendant immediately makes the case that it is a matter of particular hardship in his case—that it is really going to prejudice his business and perhaps deprive him of his livelihood for a certain time. Where an offence of this nature is committed I think it certainly merits the punishment of disqualification, and that it is not a matter which should be left to the discretion of the court, that when the court proceeds to a conviction, automatically flowing from that, as is provided by the sub-section, there should be the disqualification mentioned.
Comment on this
I quite agree with Deputy Finlay that the excuse of depriving an offender of his livilihood should not be considered when the offender runs the risk of depriving pedestrians and others of their lives. He should also be deprived of his licence automatically. It should not be optional. I would ask the Minister to consider, regarding a second offence, whether a fine of £100 is not too large. The man is then deprived of his licence for three years. Take the case of a wealthy man who can employ a driver. It does not matter very much to him to be deprived of his licence, and it looks like class legislation. I think that for a second offence there should be a term of imprisonment without the option of a fine.
Comment on this
On the section itself, I understand that the Committee desires that on the first offence there should be a minimum disqualification for twelve months, and that on the second offence there should be a mimimum disqualification for three years. Then there is the question in the case of the first offence of the maximum fine of £50 and a sentence of not more than three months; the three months sentence not to be obligatory. In the same way for a second offence the maximum fine is £100 and a sentence, which is not obligatory, of six months. I would like to have the opinion of the Committee as to the amount of the fines — £50 in one case and £100 in another. I should like to have all the information possible on the matter of the suggested imprisonment of three months for the first offence and six months for the second offence and all the information possible as to whether there should be an obligatory sentence of imprisonment for the second offence.
Comment on this
For my part I think the measure of imprisonment set down is sufficient. I think it meets the case. I think it is a sufficient deterrent to anybody who might be inclined to run the risk, while intoxicated, of driving a motor car. On the question of fines, I mentioned here on the Second Reading, and I should like to bring it before the Minister again, the point of view that has been put to me, that the penalties set out here in this Section and throughout the Bill for offences of this kind do seem to suggest class legislation; that there are individuals who in the ordinary course of their business are employed as motor drivers who could not possibly pay a fine of £50, men to whom £50 would mean all that they had in the world, and that there are other persons who would be liable to be brought within the ambit of this Section and to whom £50 fine would mean nothing. Would it be possible to consider the putting into operation in this country of the system which I believe is in operation in other countries though I have not any personal knowledge of it. I am told that fines are imposed in this way: A man is asked what his wages are or what his salary is, and the fines are regulated by imposing penalties of so many weeks' wages or so many months' wages or salary, as the case may be. They are fined in proportion to their income. If that could be done it would be possible to arrive at a system that would be fair to all concerned. I do not want the fines to be any less drastic. I want the fines to be at least as drastic as they are set out in the Bill, but I want that they should be made to fit the income of the offender, so that they would be equally fair and just to all in proportion to their earnings and to their financial capacity and their position generally. I should be glad to know if the Minister has given any thought to that matter and whether he feels that it would be at all practicable?
Comment on this
There is a danger that we are letting our feelings run away with our sense of justice in this matter. There is a danger of the House taking on itself the functions of a court. The Section as it stands leaves it to the discretion of the court to say whether the penalty is to be without the option of a fine or not, and I think it would be a regrettable thing if the House took away from the court that discretion. In certain cases it would be wrong to give the option of a fine without imprisonment, because imprisonment would be the only thing that would be fair and just. But I do not think the House should say when that situation would arise. I am in favour of leaving the matter in the discretion of the court.
Comment on this
With regard to the penalty, I should think that the penalty certainly for the first offence is quite adequate, and with regard to the remarks of Deputy O'Kelly as to fines, generally the position is this: A fine may be imposed, but take the case of the Justice in the District Court. The District Justice in deciding when the fine must be paid must have regard in the first instance to the ability of the defendant to pay it. If he considers that the nature of the offence merits the imposition of a penalty of £10, then under the Criminal Administration Act of 1914 he always should have regard to the ability of the defendant to pay. Only in the case where the defendant is likely to abscond or leave the locality, which does not happen in most cases, does the justice order that the fine should be immediately paid, and as a matter of course when time is asked for the payment of the fine, time is granted to meet the circumstances of the particular defendant. So I think that under the existing law the court has ample scope to deal with the payment of penalties, having regard to the ability of the defendant to pay. With regard to the second offence, I think that a great deal can be said for having imprisonment in such a case, and not leave it in the discretion of the court to say whether there should be imprisonment or not. The very nature of the offence prescribed by this section is an offence of a most serious nature against the public generally. If a person has committed an offence once, I think it would be a very good thing for this legislature to declare by this Bill that if he is let off or dealt with at the discretion of the court, then if he commits it a second time there should be one, and only one penalty for the professional man, manufacturer, merchant or working man. I would ask the Minister to accept it as six months' hard labour at the discretion of the court.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Kelly in pleading for mercy for motorists drunk while driving a motor car for the first or second time, has unintentionally ignored the facts that the penalty is a maximum penalty; that the justice or the judge, or whoever would try the case, would have a discretion to make the penalty anything from 5/- to £50. The owner or the owner-driver of a private car may not have any difficulty in paying a fine of £100 for a second offence, while it would be absolutely impossible for the driver of a public vehicle earning £3 a week or so to provide the sum laid down in the section for the second offence. In the circumstances therefore, such a defendant would have to accept the hospitality of the State in Mountjoy. I am entirely in sympathy with Deputy Finlay's suggestion that there should be no discretion allowed to the justices to impose a fine in the case of a conviction for the second offence, and that the defendant, whether he be a well-to-do owner-driver of a private motor car or the driver of a public vehicle, should be imprisoned. The public would welcome his detention in Mountjoy at their expense, because he would be far safer there than to allow him out on the road to commit a third offence. I entirely sympathise with the suggestion put forward by Deputy Finlay, and I hope the Minister will amend the Bill on these lines.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy Thrift. I think the intrusion of the term "class legislation" has been a mistake. That is founded on a misapprehension. It is hard to make the penalty fit the conditions. I cannot find any formula that will meet the case and which would be strictly just. The best thing you can do is to give power to the judge to fix the penalty and not bring in an amendment like this which would take it out of his hands. The phrase used by Deputy Finlay is a very excellent one and I think it ought to dominate this discussion. The nature of the offence of a man driving a motor car is not at all the same as say the case of a man losing his temper.
In the case of a man driving a motor car while under the influence of drink there has been very definite conscious preliminaries. The man has deliberately put himself in the position of being a danger to the public. The man having once done so and having been convicted he has had his warning. He is putting himself in that position of being a danger to the public and under these circumstances I would say that he should have to take the consequences. Such a man is taking a serious responsibility in driving a public vehicle at all. When the man knows that he cannot keep off drink then it is for him to keep off the motor car driving. The one thing that I do object to in Deputy Finlay's argument is the six months. I think again that this is a question that should be left to the discretion of a judge. It is the mere fact of imprisonment that will matter and not so much the period of imprisonment. It is the fact that he has had to undergo imprisonment that makes the radical difference. I would make it certain on his conviction a second time for this offence that he would be imprisoned, but I would leave it to the justice to say what the maximum period of imprisonment should be.
Comment on this
I am in full support of what Deputy Finlay says. I do not understand what Deputy Flinn says. Is not that the maximum period in the Bill?
Comment on this
No; the suggestion was that the man for the second offence should automatically go to prison for six months. That was Deputy Finlay's suggestion.
Comment on this
I think that Deputy Davin has slightly misunderstood what Deputy O'Kelly was referring to. I want to support Deputy O'Kelly in this point, and I do so in spite of Deputy Flinn's fear that we might be discussing class distinctions. This is my point of view: it is not the first or second offence that I am concerned with; I am concerned, and we are all concerned, with trying to make it as impossible as it can be for any person driving a motor car to be under the influence of drink. Now there are people who have sufficiently large incomes to be able to laugh at a fine of £50. It seems to me that that fine for a first offence would not have the same effect on them by way of punishment as a fine of a few shillings would have on a defendant who is earning a small salary or who is a working man. Deputy O'Kelly mentioned that in some countries they measure the punishment by way of fine on the basis of the man's income. I would like to say that the justices here do that already. I have had professional men, agents and business men come to me and say: "How is it when I go to court for a tail-light charge the justice asks me what is my business, and when I tell him he says, ‘You are fined £2,' while another man comes along for the same offence immediately after and the justice says ‘5/-'?" I can see the sense of that. A fine of 5/- to an ordinary motor driver may be a far greater punishment than a fine of £2 to a professional man or manufacturer. I say that so far as the second offence is concerned, in the case of drunkenness in driving a motor car, no punishment is too severe. We should make it as difficult as possible for any man to take the risk of driving a car while under the influence of drink, hoping that he may escape an accident. There should be some way of thinking out a method of making an arrangement so as to have it that for the first offence the man who is able to laugh at a fine of £50 should be made to feel the punishment. Sometimes a wealthy man will no more feel that fine than some of us would feel a fine of 5/-. In the case of the first offender, unless there is a definite criminal activity on the part of the driver the Justice is not going to send him to prison. He is going to fine him the maximum. I join with Deputy O'Kelly in asking the House to consider that the punishment for drunkenness in driving a motor car should be made as severe as possible in the case of the driver of a car, taking into consideration that in inflicting the punishment the rich man will be made feel it just as severely as the poor man.
Comment on this
I want to say what impression the discussion has made on me. What I propose to do on the Report Stage is this: As the Bill now stands, there is no discrimination between the different classes of punishment. To some extent Deputy O'Kelly has been answered with regard to the point of means. £50 and £100 are maximum fines, and it is in the discretion of the justice to make the fine as low as he cares after having considered the merits of the case and the circumstances of the person charged. I propose to leave that £50 and that £100 there stand as maximum penalties for the first and second offence. If Deputies think that they would like to raise these figures, they can put down amendments embodying their views. In the same way the three and six months' imprisonment figures can be considered. I propose to leave these maximum penalties there. My judgment goes on the line of the matter that Deputy Thrift suggests— that we should leave it to the justice to say whether the case is such even for a second offence that imprisonment is right. If there are Deputies who consider that for a second offence there should be on conviction compulsory imprisonment they can think that matter over and put down an amendment. I would not propose from my side here to make it compulsory imprisonment for the offence, when the justice is there to give consideration to the matter, and to use his discretion.
Comment on this
Would the Minister consider that where the offender on his first conviction had been fined the maximum amount, and he had received the maximum punishment, that on a second conviction such an offender would be open to the maximum imprisonment?
Comment on this
The justice is there to deal with the whole circumstances on the second conviction, and he has the record of the defendant.
Comment on this
The Minister is aware that if it goes out that the House is considering this, and that a very serious view is taken by the House of drunkenness in charge of a motor car, it may have this effect, that persons will not take the chance of being convicted and imprisoned?
Comment on this
Will the Minister be prepared to leave it to a free vote of the House to say whether there should be compulsory imprisonment?
Comment on this
The House appreciates the spirit in which the Minister is trying to meet its views on this matter.
Comment on this
Before the section is put may I call the Minister's attention to some curious phrasing in sub-section 4, which reads: "Whenever a member of the Gárda Síochána is of opinion that an offence. ...has been committed in his view..." and so on. Is the intention there to say "within sight of the Gárda" or in his opinion? Is the phrase "in his view" an alternative for "in his opinion"?
Comment on this
On the matter of the point raised by Deputy Moore, let us take the case of a Gárda going down the street; the offence is one of driving a motor car while the driver is intoxicated, and the Gárda going down the street does not see the man driving the motor car but he sees him getting out of the car, he sees the condition of the man getting out of the car, and the Gárda has reason to believe that an offence has been committed.
Comment on this
The point was whether the phrase "in his view" means in his sight or in his opinion. If it means in his opinion it is tautology. There would be a redundancy there. The only meaning that one can read into it is that it is within his sight.
Comment on this
It is within his sight and I understand that the phrase has been used in previous legislation. We can take a note of the matter and have it made perfectly clear.
Comment on this
I move amendment 30:
In sub-section (2), line 25, to delete the word "three" and substitute therefor the word "five."
I submit to the Minister that the period specified here is rather short. The person might be some distance away. It is not a very serious point, but I suggest that the three days should be made five. He might be up in Donegal, and it might take a day even to get notice of the order. I suggest that the three days be altered to five so as to give a reasonable time for complying with the order.
Comment on this
It is the same principle as applies to Section 35. I have an amendment down dealing with the matter under Section 35, where we suggest seven days.
Comment on this
I am opposed to it on Section 35. A disqualification order can only be made when the applicants have been in court and application is made at that particular time. Normally you would expect a person charged with an offence in connection with this Bill to bring his licence to the court with him. A publican charged with an offence is bound to bring his licence into court for the inspection of the court. If we are in a position that a person can be disqualified, and that he is allowed a fairly long period to surrender his licence, abuses may arise.
Comment on this
Would the Minister explain whether disqualification comes into operation when made or when the licence is surrendered?
Comment on this
Otherwise a person could come into court charged with drunkenness, and could cheerfully drive away, after being disqualified, for a period of three years.
Comment on this
The disqualification order disqualifies him, not from driving a car, but from holding a driving licence.
Comment on this
I would ask the Deputy to put down his amendment again and give me an opportunity of considering it on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
Sub-section (3) allows the court to accept a good reason for non-production within the specified time, but in that case he must have been summoned for non-production beforehand.
Comment on this
Would the Minister also consider the question of tourists? We know that a good many of these people come to this country. They motor away to the West, and leave a considerable part of their luggage behind them, with perhaps the licence. Take the case of those men.
Comment on this
If a person is summoned for the non-production of a licence, then there is provision in the Act. If he is challenged by a guard for non-production of a licence it is not an offence. He can say, "I will undertake to produce my licence," mentioning any particular Gárda station in the country he wishes, "within three days." He has that protection, but this is a case where a person has actually been disqualified in connection with some particular charge from holding a driving licence. There are a number of cases in which this question occurs, and if the Deputy puts his amendment down on the Report Stage we will consider it again.