We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1932—From the Seanad.

Contributions 1–216 of 430. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1932
Enacted

No. 11 of 1932 ›

Hugh Victor Flinn Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Flinn) Fianna Fáil

I move: That the Committee do not agree with the Seanad in recommendation No. 1:

Section 7, sub-section (2). To delete in line 27 the word "public."

It is regretted that we cannot agree with this recommendation. This refers to the proposal in the Finance Bill to give certain discriminatory relief in the matter of income taxation to Irish capital invested in Irish enterprises. It was confined in the Bill to new issues of public companies. In the Seanad it was very strongly suggested indeed that this should be extended not merely from public companies to private companies, but from private companies to individuals. While the Government is very anxious to recognise the co-operation of the Seanad, and their desire to have that principle of discriminatory taxation developed for the purpose of concentrating Irish industries, if possible, in the hands of Irish owners, it is regretted that in this particular form that extension cannot be accepted. It is found that to apply in that particular form, the relief which is given to public companies to private companies would not carry out its purpose. The difficulty is that the proprietorship of the private company is frequently practically the property of an individual and practically anything can be done in relation to the shareholders. It is not in any way for the purpose, or with the desire of limiting the application of this principle, as desired by the Seanad, but merely because the administrative difficulties of attempting to do it in this particular form, at this particular time, would be very great. For that reason, the Government is not able to accept this recommendation.

Comment on this

I move: That the Committee agree with the Seanad in recommendation No. 2:

New section. Before Section 12 to insert a new section as follows:—

"12. Whenever the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister for Industry and Commerce, is satisfied that any articles charged with import duty under this or any other Act are essential to the process of any manufacture carried on or intended to be carried on in Saorstát Eireann and are not obtainable or likely to be obtainable in Saorstát Eireann and are required to be imported by a manufacturer for use in Saorstát Eireann in such process the Revenue Commissioners may by licence authorise such manufacturer, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, to import without payment of this duty the said articles either, as the Revenue Commissioners shall think proper, without limit as to time or quantity, or either of them, or within a specified time, or in a specified quantity."

This is an omnibus clause put in to cover a series of clauses previously in the Bill. In relation to certain commodities which were taxed, power was given to the Minister when satisfied that particular things that were being taxed were themselves the raw material or for some reason were necessary for manufacture, that he could by licence import them. It was first thought that this would apply only to certain limited articles but experience has shown that it applies to a considerable number of articles. Therefore, we are accepting this recommendation which was moved in the Seanad and which represented the original policy in relation to the Bill, that is, to give the Minister power to admit under licence taxed articles which are themselves an essential portion of the raw material or are otherwise necessary for manufacture in the Free State.

Comment on this

I move that the Committee agree with the Seanad in the following recommendation:—

Section 21, sub-section (8). After the word "foods" in line 62 to insert the words "or non-alcoholic drinks."

This was a case where it was put forward that certain foods were admitted which were supposed to be principally for the consumption of invalids and children. The case was put forward in the Seanad that there were certain non-alcoholic liquids which came under the same heading. I must say that it was not known that there were such liquids. They really are such things as lime juice, ginger ale and things of that kind in which the normal sugar content has been greatly reduced especially for the use of diabetic patients. It is a perfectly reasonable amendment and it is accepted.

Comment on this

I move that the Committee do not agree with the Seanad in the following recommendation:—

Section 24, sub-section (3). To delete in line 23 the word "or" and after the word "Ireland" in line 24 to insert the words "the Irish Rugby Football Union, the Football Association of the Irish Free State, the Irish Hockey Union, the Irish Lawn Tennis Association, the Irish Amateur Swimming Association, the Golfing Union of Ireland, the Irish Ladies' Golfing Union, the Irish Amateur Rowing Union or the Irish Amateur Boxing Association."

This is a recommendation to exempt a whole series of outdoor athletic sports from the entertainments duty. No one wants to tax that kind of thing but the position, quite simply, is this: that a certain amount of money has to be found under the Finance Bill to do the work which the Finance Bill sets out to do specifically. A sum of £25,000 has to be found from this particular source. The Government are unable to find a source which they regard as most desirable from which they can get this money, nor are they prepared to eliminate from the work set out in the Budget, the amount of work represented by £25,000, which would have to be eliminated if this particular provision were not made. It is one of those taxes which nobody wants to put on and which I hope the future state of the finance of the country will enable us to get on without. At the moment we cannot fit the acceptance of the recommendation into the Budget.

Comment on this

I think that the Government ought to reconsider this matter and make up their minds to accept the recommendation, or to substitute it, as I suppose they can still, by another amendment in even more general terms, to give the same result. Whatever force the argument which the Parliamentary Secretary has now used may have had when it was used a few weeks ago by the Minister for Finance, the circumstances which have intervened have very much reduced that force. We have before us to-day an estimate for a large sum which was certainly not ostensibly provided for in the Budget and in the revenue to be raised by the Finance Bill. The amount involved here is very small. I have no doubt that many things are now going to be done by the Government in which sums of much greater than £25,000 will be absolutely wasted and I think that the Government ought to make up its mind to forgo one of these wasteful and useless measures which it appears to have in contemplation and that it should allow these outdoor sports to be free from tax. Even when the Finance Bill was before the House, it was difficult to believe that the reason put forward by the Minister for Finance was the real reason for this tax. It was difficult to see, when other concessions were given of substantial amounts, why the Government had to stand on this and it looked as if they were yielding to a particular sort of pressure to which I think they ought not have yielded.

I, personally, am in favour of giving some slight encouragement or some slight preference to native games because of the special difficulties that attend games which are practically purely national and have not the advertisement that international forms of sport have. That particular preference was already in existence before this Finance Bill and had been confirmed by this House on several occasions. It was, I think, enough. Native games are not in a bad condition and they were able to carry on and be strengthened. I think that the House has put a sufficient seal of approval on them by giving them the preference that was already in existence. Now we are not merely relieving a particular association from income tax but we are definitely going to put a tax on other forms of sport. I think it is going beyond all reasonable limits to say that because a football is kicked in a particular way, those who are engaged in that sport and choose to attend and watch it, must make a contribution to the revenue which people who watch a football being kicked under another code of rules are not called upon to pay. It looks to me, from all the agitation in the matter, that this particular association does not take up the patriotic attitude in the matter of making a contribution to the revenue. It really did not base its appeal for remission on grounds on which they ought to have been based or on which they might have been based; it has not merely demanded that it be free from tax but through members of the Fianna Fáil Party demanded that there be a definite discrimination against all other forms of sport. I think that the question of the rules under which a football is kicked is not of sufficient importance from the national point of view to justify this taxation of a sport that after all is followed by people who are the poorest people here in the city of Dublin. When such big sums are being thrown about by the Government it is really impossible to believe that the £25,000 which is involved is the real reason for objecting to this amendment.

Comment on this

When this matter was before the House on the last occassion I appealed to the Minister to allow the matter to be decided as a non-Party question. I again voice that appeal. I ask the Parliamentary Secretary does he seriously believe that there is any possibility whatever of obtaining a sum of £25,000 from this tax. I have been told by people who know this matter pretty intimately, people engaged in the sport, that the utmost the Minister can hope to obtain is something between £6,000 and £7,000. It was entirely useless for the Parliamentary Secretary to plead that he must find £25,000, when he knows in his heart of hearts that he will never get £25,000 out of the imposition of this tax. At the present moment, I see Deputies on the opposite benches —I see Deputy Oscar Traynor from North Dublin who got a great number of votes in any election in which he stood simply because he was recognised as a man who would stand up for a sport—the Soccer code—of which he was once an ornament. Is Deputy Oscar Traynor going to swallow all his principles or is he going to give the vote which those who elected him expect?

Comment on this

Do you know what he has done?

Comment on this

I know what he has done in the last vote. He voted in favour of the imposition of this tax.

Comment on this

On this question at the moment, do you know what he has done?

Comment on this

If Deputy Traynor did not vote in favour if the imposition of the tax, I will be glad to withdraw the statement, if he corrects me. If he did not vote for it, it is all to the good. I hope he will vote against it now. I see other Deputies on the opposite benches. I see Deputy Briscoe of South Dublin who also got a great number of votes because he was looked upon as a person who would support the Soccer code in this city. I suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary that the game of Soccer is a poor man's amusement and he will find the greatest difficulty in getting the small amount of money which he hopes to get. It is a healthy amusement and I am sure that the President himself will regard it as a game in the interests of the general populace. Those who attend these games get a great measure of help from their attendance. They are kept out of pernicious practices in which they might spend a great deal more money than they spend for the game. I believe that the President himself ought to intervene in this matter and wipe out this tax altogether. If he can find £2,000,000 for an emergency matter, there is no reason, no justification in the wide world for calling for the imposition of a sum of this sort. There is no possibility whatever of the Minister obtaining this sum of £25,000. I should like to remind the Minister also that the Rugby code alone have spent £30,000 in giving employment. Surely he ought to take matters like that into consideration. He must know that the country is against him in this matter. I know that there are men on his side of the House who feel that if they had a free vote they would not go into the Lobby and vote for this tax. I appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary purely on non-Party grounds to reconsider his attitude with regard to this tax. It means a great deal to the ordinary working class people and I think that he should take off the Party Whips and allow it to be a free vote.

Comment on this

I agree also that there is really no validity in the argument put forward by the Parliamentary Secretary. I agree with the last speaker and I am satisfied that the Estimate of £25,000 is entirely beyond what will result from the imposition of this tax. If we assume that it will be produced, the Budget statement that was produced by the Minister for Finance suggested that the margin of safety would be about £65,000. Whether you take that as a surplus, or whether it is £65,000 or £40,000, £20,000 or even £10,000 it is, to my mind entirely immaterial. The Minister himself, in putting forward his Budget figures, admitted and stated that many of the figures had to be estimated on problematical figures. I do not think that the Parliamentary Secretary will make the statement that the margin of safety allowed for by that £65,000 is affected one whit by a reduction of £25,000. It is entirely a problematical difficulty and the possible errors in many of the other figures in the Budget are of a magnitude far beyond the figure represented by this £25,000. I submit to the House that there is nothing whatever in the argument put forward by the Parliamentary Secretary and that the substance of his Budget will not be affected by a trifle of that kind at all. I would urge the Parliamentary Secretary to satisfy himself definitely as to the likelihood of this figure of £25,000 being secured. I do not believe that it will be secured, and I believe that real damage will be done to the youth of the country and to their athletic training by the imposition of this tax.

Comment on this

When I spoke on this question before, I made an appeal to the Minister, based on the broad grounds of sportsmanship, as there had been introduced into this debate matters entirely irrelevant to the question, such as the question of foreign and non-foreign games, that we should address ourselves to the important fact that these games are necessary for the development of the youth of our country and that a tax of this nature is a tax on the health of our people. It is putting a tax on God's fresh air and a tax on the proper use of outdoor sports. I suggest also that the Government's attitude is inconsistent, because we have given a grant for the maintenance of the Tailteann Games and for the bringing out of our athletes to the Olympic Games. With regard to the latter, I am sure it is a great pleasure to all members in the House to know that we have covered ourselves with glory in the performances of Tisdall and Dr. O'Callaghan, both of whom have won events in forms of sport which are not necessarily purely Irish games. I suggest that we should do nothing that would discourage sport in the slightest way. A lot has been said about Soccer football. Football itself is not a native game. Rugby football is a game which has been taken up, particularly in the schools and colleges, chiefly on account of the manner in which it develops character. Many of the schools have taken up Rugby football, not because it is a foreign game or through any snobbery, but because they recognise that there is no game in the world that brings out the mental qualities of character and self-control and self-discipline in the way that Rugby football does. I appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary to forgo any small pecuniary advantage which he may be likely to derive from the taxation of these games, so that we may develop nationally on our health side. I think that if the matter got a little consideration it would be found that the amount of revenue likely to be derived from this tax will be very much smaller than the Minister anticipates. The tax was based on the assumption that the attendances at the football matches would be the same as in the past. As a result of this tax, the attendances will be very much lowered and the benefit to the Government in the form of revenue will be very small indeed. I am not in favour of foreign games myself, but speaking on behalf of games in general, I feel that it is no matter what particular code a man takes up so long as he plays the game to the best of his ability.

Comment on this

I should like to make a final appeal to the Minister to accept the recommendation. If he cannot personally see his way to do that, I would suggest that he allow it to go to a free vote of the House. In these days of financial stringency, it is difficult for people in ordinary businesses to carry on, and it is even more difficult for people to carry on sports or to extend them or even maintain the standard already attained. There is nobody, I think, who would not wish, if they were richer, to offer pecuniary help to sport in this country as they do in other States. If we cannot do this, we certainly ought not to put hindrances in the way of sports. Very many of the amateur sports in this country have had to exist on contributions from the outside public.

The outside public latterly have had their resources restricted for various reasons and they are now unable to contribute in their usual manner to enable sports to be carried on. If the last resort that is left to sport, "the gate," is to be taxed then very many sports will cease to exist. Take one sport, rowing. Rowing has kept its head above water in this country for many years largely by private subscriptions. Deputy O'Neill a moment ago spoke about the Irish successes at the Olympic Games. I do not think there is an Irish heart that was not thrilled by the successes of our representatives at the Olympic Games and I do not think there is an Irish heart that would not be thrilled by the success of an Irish Rugby team or an Irish Soccer team in international contests no matter what it represented as long as it was Irish. We ought all to be anxious to help any number of people to combine to make sport more popular in this country and to induce the boys and girls in this country to engage in sport of any description, but preferably Irish sport.

We all of us here prefer Irish sport. The President of the Executive Council and I are Deputies who engaged in both forms of sport, Irish and international. So long as our engagement in international sport is concerned none of us lost our Irish mind. If we prefer Irish sport there is no reason why we should hinder other sports that are of an international character. The mere engaging by young people in any form of sport is all to the good. It expands even their intelligence. It gives them that true and real spirit of comradeship which is not perhaps possible in other ways. We see in various forms of sport a coming together of people who are opposed to each other in other ways. We see these sports representative of political thought of the most diverse type. I am not now referring to political divisions amongst Deputies in this House, but to people, North and South, who forget their differences when they engage in these sports. Now this tax, instead of helping that development, will much hinder it. I would appeal to the Minister to leave this recommendation to a free vote of the House or, better still, to accept the recommendation and so put all sport on an equal footing so that it would be possible for any boy or girl to engage in sport, preferably Irish, but, at all events, some sport.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary must have some skeletons in his financial cupboard that he is more afraid of than he is of this House. He can hardly have the nerve to tell this House that he cannot spare this £25,000. Since this Bill was last before us the Minister for Finance made very considerable advances to his prospects of revenue by the additional taxes he has put on. We are told that there is going to be no revenue from these taxes. In the President's Press this morning we read his warning to the people that they must not buy British coal. Anyone in this country who is influenced by the President's Press will not buy anything for the remainder of the year but British cement. There is to-day a large advertisement in his Press, advising the readers to buy British cement. I submit that there is to be more of an increase in revenue from the taxation on British cement than will very much more than cover the £25,000 that is supposed to be involved in this recommendation.

We read in this morning's paper a protest and more or less an appeal on the part of the Chairman of the Dublin County Council with regard to the position of physical training in the schools of this country. We have had gradually growing and becoming more perfect a system of medical treatment of the school children. Adenoids are taken out but nothing has been done to set up the children in a proper way. The recommendations of the primary schools programme conference some years ago made very definite recommendations. The difficulties which lay in the path of progress were such as arise out of the difficulties in the schools. I am convinced that certain difficulties arise in certain places, but some schools throughout the country have shown in the most magnificent way what can be done even without a State subsidy. I have been one who in normal times argued that if a thing could not be done in the way that we thought, there ought to be a tax put on outdoor sports. That would radiate its influence through the schools and give us a properly set up people.

I would not in the circumstances in which we now are argue that there ought to be a tax on sport because we, at this particular moment, are suffering under the most crushing burden of taxation that it is possible to bear, a burden so crushing that it is going very much to interfere with employment. Deputy Byrne has spoken of things in North Dublin constituency. I take one small corner of North Dublin constituency and in that corner of the city, Clontarf, we have employment given by residents there who get up yacht races, lawn tennis sports, swimming sports, golfing championships, rowing and other sports. With the amount of taxes that people are at present called upon to pay there is undoubtedly the jeopardising of the employment of a number of people employed there and elsewhere in connection with sport, organised in that particular way.

In the face of employment being jeopardised these additional taxes on sport should not now be imposed. I would imagine if we link up taxation on outdoor sports with the proper development of physical culture, that our national organisation would be the first people in the van to assist that. We are completely opposed to discrimination as between different forms of sport. Putting taxation on any organised form of sport in the country is going to prejudice its development and it is also going to jeopardise the position of the unemployed. The Minister has been made aware by deputations from many sports associations of the very considerable amount of money that is involved in the matter and the considerable amount of employment that is given. I cannot understand how the Parliamentary Secretary can have the nerve to come here and tell us that he cannot spare this £25,000, if it is £25,000. I find it difficult to realise that he is giving an Estimate here to-day without presenting a new budgetary statement to us, when very remarkable changes have been made in taxation since we last saw the Finance Bill in this House.

Comment on this

On many occasions in this House I have protested against discrimination in sport. While I do not begrudge any advantage that the Gaelic games have and are receiving from this House in successive Finance Bills, yet I do appeal now, as I have appealed on other occasions when I stood up in this House to protest against what I will term as unfair discrimination in the matter of sports. I do not want to labour the arguments made by other speakers and I do not want to repeat what I have already said, but I do feel that a man should be allowed to play any game he likes without undue interference by the State. Undue interference is here exercised in discriminating between one form of sport and another. We have had all the games mentioned. I am supporting the amendment sent from the Seanad for the reasons I gave on previous occasions and also for the reasons now advanced by Deputies who have spoken in favour of the amendment.

Let us take the case of rowing clubs. Most, if not all, Deputies have received circulars from the secretary of the Irish Rowing Union. I mentioned here before that I have been intimately associated with Irish rowing for very many years. I can produce, if necessary, for the Parliamentary Secretary, evidence that should really satisfy him or anybody else that in nearly all cases these clubs are run at a considerable loss. We have had the sad spectacle here a week or two ago when the Metropolitan Regatta in Dublin, at the annual fixture, received something like £25 in gate receipts. There are other clubs that hold regattas all over the Free State and I am sure the amount of gate money received by them is frequently less than half of what the Metropolitan Regatta got. In sport, just as in trade, competition is certainly the salt of the business.

These rowing clubs, as most Deputies are aware, in order to keep going and in order to encourage the pastime for which they are established, have frequently to travel long distances. Anybody who knows anything about transporting a rowing club and a team of oarsmen or, for that matter, a team of sportsmen anywhere, must be aware of the considerable expense involved. Oarsmen travel to regattas if they have funds sufficient to take them there. Frequently they have to travel with a four-oared or eight-oared outfit. We know that the cost of transporting those boats over long distances is relatively high. In no case can it be said that the ordinary subscriptions of members are sufficient to cover the expenses involved. The clubs have to rely for support on public subscriptions and money obtained through whist drives and dances. It is my experience that at the end of every financial year these clubs find themselves in difficulties. I do not know of even one rowing club in the Free State which can say it is solvent.

I do not want to travel as far as Northern Ireland, but I know a somewhat similar state of affairs exists there, with this difference, that in Northern Ireland they do not tax rowing, nor do they tax football or other forms of sport. I suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary, if he has ever kicked football, and I believe he has, that he might put it to the Minister that it makes no difference to a man what games he plays so long as he plays the game, as Deputy O'Higgins pointed out. The Parliamentary Secretary must admit that there is nothing better for building character, for building brawn and brain, than a fair indulgence in various forms of physical exercise. Why it is that this Government should make itself ridiculous, as the last Government made itself ridiculous, by an unfair discrimination in the matter of sport, I cannot say.

It has been said that many Deputies have developed a kink in favour of one form of sport. I am aware that the ex-Minister for Finance, Deputy Blythe, developed that kink and even to-day he cannot get away from it. He suggests that even now he does not object to Gaelic games getting more support as against other forms of sport. I disagree with him there. I believe no game should be taxed in this country. I am not going to refer to the present state of affairs; I do not want to touch on that; but if we had a normal condition of affairs here there is no reason at all why any young boy, who is a boy, who wishes to indulge in games should be deprived from doing so. There is no reason why these games should be taxed in any way. Gaelic games are exempt from this tax. Why? No reasonable case has been made for allowing Gaelic games to escape while other games are taxed. I support and I watch Gaelic games, but I am not going to be a party to discriminate between one game and another. If I have a bias at all it is in favour of rowing and Rugby football.

Comment on this

And fishing.

Comment on this

Fishing is tariffed enough, so far as I know. I have had to pay for my licence to fish and I do not object because I get good sport for the money. I suggest that the Parliamentary Secretary should ask the Cabinet to reconsider this matter. It is, in my view, a disgrace to our country to say that we have to tax certain games and that we allow other games to go scot free. Tax the lot or tax none. Perhaps I should have reversed that statement and say tariff none or tariff the lot. That is the way I feel. I do not want to see Gaelic games handicapped in any way. I want to see them encouraged. There are some persons who will make better Gaelic players than Rugby players and the obverse is also true. It is ridiculous to discriminate in this unfair way. I will support the amendment in the hope that the Minister will leave this matter to an open vote. It would seem as if this matter has really developed into a political issue. I do not want to make it a political issue. I have challenged the last Government on the matter; even now, I challenge the attitude of mind of the ex-Minister for Finance. It cannot be said that it is because this Government is in power that I am opposing this proposal. I opposed it also in the last Parliament.

Comment on this

I should like to join in the appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary to accept the recommendations of the Seanad. There are several reasons why this method of taxation should not be proceeded with. Possibly the first is that the Minister does not really want this type of revenue. If, any day or night, the Minister for Finance and the Cabinet considered that this country is being deluged with British games, they can fall back upon another Act and they can demand an excise duty on the financial returns received from these games. We have now come to the pass in this country that we are arguing at great length over the possible revenue from sport. Someone said the returns would reach £20,000. I think the Parliamentary Secretary mentioned £20,000 or £25,000. Somebody else suggested that the amount would scarcely reach £7,000. I will ask the Parliamentary Secretary for God's sake to say: "Yes, I agree with the suggestion; cut it out altogether and we can tax games later if we like."

In this country, at the present moment the important question is, not whether we can collect £20,000 or even £7,000 off one form of outdoor sport or another. The important question is whether anybody can indulge in any sport whatsoever. I am sure that when I appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary I do not appeal to him as an 18 ct. gold Celt or a 100 per cent. Gael or anything of that sort; I appeal to him as a man who knows what he is talking about. I say that all this talk about a tax on games is a futile waste of time, the most futile we have ever had here. We are discussing whether a person going to a Soccer match should pay a 2d. tax or a person going to see a regatta should pay a tax of 6d., while if one goes to a hurling match he pays nothing. That is the type of discussion we have when really it is not £7,000 or £20,000 we are concerned with. Our main concerns at the moment have to do with millions. We have in office at the moment a Government which has power at night—it is always at night they do these things— to place any tax they like on anything. The President laughs. He knows very well that that is the power he has. We are really only wasting time talking as to whether Soccer, Rugby, rowing, etc., should be taxed as against hurling and Gaelic football. I speak for a part of the country which is interested in rowing, Soccer, Rugby, etc.—the County Dublin. These games are supported, not by paying money to see them, but by voluntary subscriptions from persons who are really keen on them. I have a special interest in asking the Parliamentary Secretary to consider the importance of that matter.

Comment on this

I spoke at length on this matter when it was before the Dáil previously, but I should like to make a last appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary to remit the tax. There is something petty about this tax. I do not think that the Parliamentary Secretary, who is a master of logic and of the good phrase, can defend it or put a reasonably decent look upon it. That is the feeling of every sportsman in the House. I only want to speak of this from a sporting point of view. I agree with Deputy Anthony that you should tax no sport or tax all. I would be sorry to think that all were taxed. It is this note of discrimination that is particularly galling to many of us who know we are Irish and who play games which are stigmatised as non-Irish. We should encourage all sports. We want sports in this country, at this moment above all. There is a story as to how draughts were invented. In a time of trouble in Asia Minor, when there was a war on for ten years, the people diverted their thoughts from unpleasant things by this wonderful new game. It would be well if the Ministry would devote their attention to inventing some more games—untaxed games—rather than new taxes. We were asked to find an alternative, some other source from whence this petty sum—because it is, comparatively speaking, a petty sum— of £25,000 might be derived. Some sources were indicated to the Minister for Finance during the last debate on this matter and I could think of some more. I do not care from what source it comes or whether there is any source. I do not care if you tax tall hats or political meetings to get the money, or if our Budget is out £25,000. I would appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary, in the interests of the country and the mental health of our young people, to drop this tax and never let us hear of it again.

One of the reasons given for levying this tax on these so-called foreign sports is that the people who play them are best able to pay—that they are the aristocrats, the plutocrats of our country. I know Rugby clubs where the hat has to be sent round to buy the ball or to provide a jersey for, say, the crack player. If it is an aristocratic or a plutocratic game, there are aristocrats and plutocrats in the ranks of the Government. I make an appeal to them as sportsmen to drop this tax. I appeal to the President himself. He will forgive me for reminding him of the fact that he was a very good Rugby player. I have seen him playing many times. In fact, I think I umpired a game in which he played. He played with characteristic Irish vigour—he was a good player.

Comment on this

A good tackler.

Comment on this

I think I saw him scoring. I appeal to him as a sportsman and an old Rugby player, even if he is an aristocrat or a plutocrat, to drop the tax. There is a frightful lot of nonsense talked about it. It is absurd to talk of these games as non-Irish or stigmatising the people who play them as bad Irishmen. I can hardly speak with patience when I think of some Irishmen who have played these games and afterwards done honour to their country in many other directions and in distant fields. I make this eleventh-hour appeal and I hope the President will take the matter up himself.

Comment on this

I think the Parliamentary Secretary will fully realise that the reactions of this imposition are about as inevitable and as unfortunate as they could possibly be. No matter what the Parliamentary Secretary or the Minister may say, the general feeling is that certain sports which are indulged in by good Irishmen are being discriminated against. In fact, so far as I am aware, the only member of this House who took the view that the sports were not being discriminated against was Deputy Hogan, of Clare, who took up the rather "Alice-through-the-Looking-Glass" point of view that if you put the tax on all first and take it off some of them, you are doing the same thing as putting it on some and not putting it on others. The finesse does credit to the poet's mind, but I do not think it would appeal to the point of view of the mundane populace who are interested in Rugby and Soccer. I turn with special confidence to the distinguished members of the Fianna Fáil Party, like the President, who are protagonists of Rugby, and also, with even greater confidence, to the Parliamentary Secretary, because he has said to-day that their only difficulty is that they cannot find revenue wherewith to accept the recommendation. I think Deputy Thrift, on grounds mathematical, disposed of his difficulty. I suggest another way of disposing of his difficulty. If he looks at recommendation No. 13, he will see that the Seanad there propose to provide him with just enough money to make the concession that they ask him for in recommendation No. 4.

I would turn with special confidence to Deputy Davin to lend us a hand here, in order to kill two birds with the one stone—to support the abolition of the principle of discrimination amongst Irish sportsmen and to provide revenue by withdrawing the subsidy from bus companies which at present is being granted to them, to the grave detriment of the railways of this country, as a result of which the number of employees has been greatly reduced. One could go round the House at length. We have already referred to one distinguished Deputy from North Dublin who found it possible to swallow this proposal when it first came before the House. Deputy Briscoe had even a better digestion; he is equally distinguished, or more distinguished, if that can be, than Deputy Traynor, in Soccer circles. Deputy Norton is also a distinguished person in Soccer circles. I think I am right in saying that Deputy Briscoe is Vice-President of a Soccer institution in this city. They conferred on him every honour, every distinction with complete confidence. I hope when they come to renew that honour their confidence will not have suffered such a shock as to deprive Deputy Briscoe of the distinction which sits so graciously on him.

I put this to the Parliamentary Secretary in all seriousness, that a feeling has been created by the tax quite out of proportion to the value of the tax to the Exchequer. The majority by which the Minister carried this tax on a division in the first place indicates that the sense of this House is against it, because I think the Government had never a smaller majority since the Dáil sat than on the question of this particular tax. It was only by a majority of five that they carried it in Committee. Deputy Professor Thrift has made manifest that the argument that the Exchequer cannot spare the money is not a sound one. I have made a suggestion which provides the Parliamentary Secretary with a way out if he wants to collect revenue. I ask him now to take the sense of the House on this recommendation, to allow a non-Party vote and let us record our feelings in this matter in the confidence that if the Exchequer drops this £25,000, they will collect a great deal more in good will.

Comment on this
Dr. Thomas Hennessy Dr. Hennessy

Like most members of the Opposition, I am entirely against discriminating against any particular sport in this country. When this tax was first being imposed, the Gaelic Athletic Association, so far as I remember, was included, but the Government's agents throughout the country discovered or it was made known to them in very definite terms, that if this tax were persisted in, the Government would find a day of reckoning, with the result that the G.A.A. is no longer included. I do not think that is clean politics. Two great Irishmen within the last two days have distinguished themselves at the Olympic Games. They have brought Ireland a great deal of fame. These two men, Mr. Tisdall, of Nenagh, and Dr. O'Callaghan, from the County Cork border, have expressed themselves as being very thoroughly against discrimination in the taxation of games. I think the opinion of these two men should carry some weight in this country, and I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will give their views some consideration, although I must say I am not very hopeful. Is the Parliamentary Secretary so sure as to the amount of money he will derive from the taxation of these games? There is such a thing as the Six Counties in Ireland. I think the bulk of this money will have to come from international games and there is nothing on earth to prevent the promoters from arranging to have international games held in Belfast or some other town in the Six Counties, thus depriving Dublin not only of the taxation but of a very big expenditure of money by the people who come here to see these games. I think it is clearly a case of chopping off your nose to spite your face. Deputy Alton reminded the President that he was a good Rugby player. I am aware of that, too. Deputy Jordan, I think, expressed his admiration for his powers as a great tackler in the rugby field.

Comment on this

I never saw him in the rugby field.

Comment on this
Dr. Thomas Hennessy Dr. Hennessy

He specialises also in another part of the game and that is in giving the "dummy." President de Valera gave the "dummy" in the rugby field and he has been giving the dummy ever since, but he has never crossed the line.

Comment on this

If you got him, he would be a great man in the serum.

Comment on this
Dr. Thomas Hennessy Dr. Hennessy

President de Valera's nationality, in the minds of his admirers, at least, has not suffered by his playing Rugby, and I do not think that Rugby will make any man in Ireland anything more unnational than if he never played it. I think the whole thing is spiteful. Rugby and Association are both good games and the amount that you will derive from them in the way of taxation is negligible. For the sake of encouraging games generally, I think that the Parliamentary Secretary might very well abandon this taxation.

Comment on this

I rise to support very strongly the remarks made by Deputy Anthony. In his speech I think he mentioned every reasonable argument that could be adduced for having no discrimination with regard to games. There is no need for me to go back on anything he has said, but there is one point that I should like to stress very much and put to the President and to the Government. That is that I do not think I am in error when I take it that the object of this preference for Gaelic is really to encourage that game in this country. Taking sport as a whole, there are two great reasons to my mind which ought to encourage everybody in giving it support. One is the physical benefit which is to be derived from all forms of games or sports. There is another element to which I personally attach very great importance and that is the spirit of good fellowship and goodwill which all sports and games carried on in a proper manner ought to induce amongst those partaking in the games or people watching them. That goodwill cannot be expressed in terms of £s. d. The amount of good these games can do is immense. I look upon the Government's action in giving this preference to Gaelic, whether they intended it or not, as making the game of Gaelic, political. The mere fact of Gaelic having a preference over all other games must cause irritation, to put it very mildly, amongst the people who go to watch those other games. I take it that the main idea at the back of the Government's proposal is to promote Gaelic. They want to see that game developed. If that is their object, the best way they can set about it is to secure goodwill for Gaelic all over the country. They should get the goodwill of everybody. I have always supported cricket and Rugby. I play cricket myself, but I have never said one solitary word against Gaelic. I hold that people should be entitled to play the game they prefer to play. They should have perfect liberty to do that. I want to impress upon the Government that by putting this tax on other games and putting no tax on the Gaelic game, they must of necessity raise a spirit of animosity against that game. I think that is not what they want and that it would be a terrible pity. I think that even if they were to lose £25,000, the goodwill that they would get from everybody for the game of Gaelic by dropping this tax would be well worth it.

Comment on this

I feel that while there have been very many honest speeches on this question of taxation as a whole, there have been very many vitriolic outpourings from the benches opposite such as always follow practically everything that emanates from these benches. Why Deputy J.J. Byrne should have introduced his speech in the way he did makes me wonder and makes me wonder for this reason, that for the past week there has been going on in the Press a campaign of letter writing in which I have been the Aunt Sally so to speak. There has been a similarity between these letters and Deputy J.J. Byrne's remarks that makes me wonder does he know anything about this campaign.

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy will give Deputy Byrne credit for having the courage of writing letters over his own name.

Comment on this

Cumann na nGaedheal letters never appeared over the names of those who wrote them.

Comment on this

I do not want to do the Deputy any injustice. I just remarked the similarity between the letters and the statement made here by the Deputy. I have played Soccer football and I believe I have played it well and I make no apology to anyone in this House or outside for playing that game. The members of the Party of which I am a member know my views on this question. Deputy J.J. Byrne asked a question that has also been asked in this letter writing campaign. He wondered at my silence. It may be that I am a bit green in political circles and that I do not make enough of what I do and of what I have done. What I have done I have done behind the scenes and I have done it well, so much so that any little amelioration that has been made in this tax has been made, though I may say it egotistically, at my request and on my insistence.

I, like Deputy Mulcahy, have certain views on this question. If I were able to enforce my views I would have a Ministry of Sport which would direct the young idea into the channels in which it should go, and which would teach them to play all games, not one, two or three games and would teach them to play them well. Further, so far from taxing sport I would subsidise it. I would subsidise all sports of Irishmen. I believe that the Irish nation can be built up from the health that can be derived by participation in athletics. However, Deputies on the opposite side know, equally as well as I do, that members of a Party have Party pledges and, just as members of a team have got to give their loyalty to the team, so members of a Party have got to give their loyalty to the Party and it is my intention to do that however it may offend my friends in the athletic sphere. I might mention that in the last couple of days, as Deputy Dillon has stated, I have received notification that I have been elected vice-president of two branches of Association football in Dublin. I am very proud to have been elected but I also know that the necessity for taxation is there and that the necessity is not of the making of this Party. While that necessity is there I believe it is the duty of every association, whether athletic or otherwise, to do what it can to help the nation in this time of crisis. I pointed that out as a member of the deputation that went to the Minister for Finance. I pointed that out to the deputation on their way to interview the Minister and the deputation agreed with me that that was so. What they did object to and what I objected to was that any particular unit should have been selected for preferential treatment.

Comment on this

I join in the plea voiced by Deputy Dillon and other Deputies for a free vote on this recommendation. The Parliamentary Secretary must have realised how very unpopular this tax which is going to raise a very small amount of money, is going to be amongst those who have any connection with athletics and sports in this country. The Parliamentary Secretary resides in a portion of the County Cork where sports are carried on in a very marked degree. Cobh Regatta is one of the most popular fixtures I know in the country and Cobh Sports are also being revived. There is hardly a townland which is not affected by this tax. It seems to me that it is very unfair to tax the youth of the country who are really the people who will have to pay this tax in order to get revenue for the services of the State.

The last speaker has, with admirable patriotism I must admit, said that he deplores the tax but that it is necessary. Does that not point to the fact that all games should be taxed and that no particular section should be exempt for patriotic reasons? If there is any particular section who desire exemption in these circumstances they cannot be said to be unduly patriotic. I think I am right in emphasising the views expressed by other members that there should be no discrimination, no abhorrent discrimination because it is abhorrent to everybody, and that it should be withdrawn. The Parliamentary Secretary stated that he cannot do without the money which will be raised by this tax. He must expect very little benefit from his own tariffs if that be so. Almost everything that one buys nowadays is tariffed. It would be interesting to know if there is one single item that is not taxed in some way at the moment. I would appeal to him to remit this small amount of taxation because it is certainly a very unpopular tax. I was interested to hear Deputy Alton refer to the President's activities in Rugby and other games. Surely when he and other members of the Government have engaged in this game, it must be realised that it cannot be a very bad game to play. I would urge very respectfully that this is a tax which is imposed on a section of the people who are least able to bear it.

Comment on this

In my view the discrimination in the imposition of this tax is not the main objection to it. The main objection is to the principle of the taxation of sport of any kind. If this were a provision to give a subsidy to Gaelic football and nothing else I personally would not have any very strong objection to it, but I do think that the whole principle of taxation of games is bad. I rose really to make one point which I have not heard made by any Deputy who has yet spoken. That is that since we last discussed the subject on the 8th July a situation has arisen that gives the Government a good excuse for taking a rather more kindly attitude. Since then we have entered upon an economic war. The country is going to pass through a time of great strain and stress. I venture quite seriously to make the point that there is nothing better than games to keep the people in a state of good humour and good nerves.

Comment on this

Like Deputy Traynor, I have no apology to offer for the support that I give in any way to games which may be considered by some people as not of a national type, such as Soccer. I want to say quite frankly that when this proposition to impose taxation on all games and sports was first mooted it was put to me, and I believe the position to be so still, that while we have to confront a situation where foodstuffs are taxed it should be the first duty of any Government to remove the taxation on foodstuffs before proceeding to remove the taxation on games. In that spirit I accepted the proposition as it was then made. Since then, however, of course a remission was made in connection with one particular class of sport. I cannot speak for sport to any extent outside the city of Dublin because I do not happen to know much about the sport that is carried on in other parts of the country. Certainly the members from outside the metropolitan area felt very keenly the taxation of Gaelic games. A remission in taxation on Gaelic games has been brought about and that is now being held up by most speakers as discrimination. I do not know whether it is fair to say that it is discrimination against rather than in favour of a particular class of sport. I feel that I would be very happy if the Government could see its way to remit the taxation on all sports. Like Deputy Oscar Traynor, however, I find that if the Government feels in its wisdom that it must go on with this particular tax and sees no way out of it, as a member pledged to support that party which is the Government, I naturally will have to take my place in the line in the division lobby alongside them. I do not know whether if it was left to a free vote, I would do the same, but I also feel that there are Deputies on the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches who would find themselves voting differently.

Comment on this

Why not try it?

Comment on this

I would ask that I might be allowed to make my own speech without any promptings from Deputy McGilligan. The House will remember when this discrimination in favour of Gaelic games was carried out previously, and there was a free vote in the House on that occasion in which the majority of the members voted in favour of discrimination for Gaelic games. I happened to be the only member of the Party who went into the Lobby against discrimination. My hope would be that a free vote would result in equal treatment for all sports, but I have my doubts about it and I would be anxious to challenge the Parliamentary Secretary to do what I say and leave it to a free vote of the House, because I believe that a great number of the Cumann na nGaedheal back benchers who are ardent supporters of Gaelic games would vote for discrimination in favour of Gaelic games.

Deputy Dillon did me the honour of referring to me in the sense that he had heard that I was recently elected as vice-president of the Soccer Association. In fairness to the Soccer Association that gave me that distinguished honour, I must say that they made no conditions. They did not ask me to vote in favour of a remission of tax on Soccer nor did they threaten me that if I did not do so I would be asked to resign. I presume that like Deputy Oscar Traynor I was selected on my merits in their estimation as a promoter of the game. In consultation with a number of these people I find that their grievance is that if there is to be taxation on sport all forms of sport should shoulder it. They say, and I want to say it to the House now, that if the followers of Gaelic games feel that they are entitled to national discrimination in their favour, they should be the first to show their national responsibility. They should be the first to make the sacrifice, and if a sacrifice is called for from any sporting element it should be from the Gaelic games. It appears however that if Gaelic games want to be looked on as the national games—and I have no objection to them—the others feel that they should not be asked to make the sacrifice by way of taxation when the national games are let off. We have our views on these things. I can quite follow and agree with the people, some of whom are members of this House, who, against all opposition have helped to nourish and foster the Gaelic games into something that is living and can be recognised as a part of our national life. I can understand them conscientiously and sincerely feeling that there should be discrimination in favour of the national pastime. I hope, however, that they will be sufficiently sportsmanlike to feel that while a person living in a metropolitan area has in his area what they might term a non-national game, but again which is a local game, that they might feel that some consideration is due to the person who is in favour of taxation being taken off Soccer or rowing or any game whatever. I do not know whether the Parliamentary Secretary will listen to appeals or not. As Deputy Traynor has pointed out, he has done his best privately and behind the scenes, without putting it in the paper every day, to get this thing done. Others also have done their best, but it is expected of us by the sportsmen of the country, no matter to what party they belong, that we should play the sporting game with our own party. If the Government thinks that it is in the interests of the nation to raise taxation in the way suggested, I would point out to the Minister that the amount involved is not so tremendous. £25,000 is not going to bring him out of the difficulties at the end of the financial year and I appeal to him to consider whether, if he cannot see his way to remove the tax altogether, he could leave it to a free vote of the House. I am prepared to leave it to that and I think that the sporting people of the country would then feel that they had no grievance. The last time that it was left to a free vote the ordinary Soccer people lost as against the majority of the House. That can happen again in the same way; but in the hope that it will bring about, not discrimination against—I object to the term discrimination being used—but discrimination in favour of a certain set of games, in the hope that it will do away with the discrimination in favour of Gaelic games, I would appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary to leave it to a free vote. Perhaps he would get the result that Deputy Traynor and myself hope for or we may get the results that the supporters of Gaelic games hope for.

Comment on this

This subject has been debated at some length and I wish to add just a very few words to the remarks that have been made. The recommendation which has come from the Seanad embraces practically the views of the supporters of every outdoor sport played in this country at the moment with one exception, and that is boxing, which is conducted at times outdoor but mostly indoor. I do not think that anybody will dispute that boxing from the standpoint of the youth of the country is a very fine sport indeed. The Parliamentary Secretary has sought to retain the duty of the tax on sport by reason of the necessity apparently for £25,000 this year. This £25,000 is comparatively a small sum when considered in relation to the amount which this Oireachtas is asked to budget for this year. Undoubtedly the principal interest of the country and of this House should be the welfare, health and above all the character of the youth of the country. In what way can the youth of the country best acquire first of all health and character? It is conceded generally on all sides here that the best way to obtain these is by participating in sport. If a man participates in sport, if he wants to be a good sportsman, he will first of all select for himself the sports that he wants to shine in or the game that he wants to shine in. He himself of course must be free to select the game that he likes best. He must be free to select the sport he is to follow. If the Oireachtas has the interest of the youth of this country at heart and if it wants to do that by promoting sport in the country we should place all sport on an equal footing. I am against discrimination. I do not care whether it is discrimination in favour of or discrimination against a particular sport. Every sport and every game in the country should stand on an equal footing and the people of the country should be free to participate in what sports they think fit. That should be the standard. It is conceded on all sides that a tax imposed on certain sports will interfere with these sports. It may be perhaps that we tax a certain number of them and if we do we are thereby cutting down facilities for sport which are open to the young people of the country. I would appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary to leave this to a free vote of the House. I quite appreciate Deputy Traynor's remarks that he is bound by his Party pledge and that he has to play the game with regard to his Party and that he must abide by that. But this is a question in which there has been a demand from all sections of this House irrespective of Party. I would appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary to keep sport clear of politics and not to bring politics into sports. He can do that by leaving this to a free vote of the House.

Comment on this

I would like to join in the appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary to let this matter go to a free vote. If the President were in the House I would appeal to him to do this. I remember the President perhaps better than any Deputy here in the days when he played Rugby. I saw him many a time playing Rugby. I am therefore all the more surprised that he should tax Rugby or that indeed he should put a tax on any sport. I again urge on the Parliamentary Secretary and on the Government to let it go to a free vote of the House.

Comment on this

I feel a certain pride that this amendment has come back as a recommendation from the Seanad because it was made first in an amendment moved by me in this House. It was an amendment which when put to the House only suffered defeat by the smallest margin by which any vote has been carried, a margin of five votes. A plea has been made to the Parliamentary Secretary to leave this to a free vote of the House. That is not the way the matter should be treated. It should be left to a free vote of the House if the Parliamentary Secretary was convinced that it would be defeated. That would not be a proper thing in a House composed as this is after the Seanad has made a recommendation on a matter that has been defeated in this House by only five votes that we can now have it accepted by a small margin of votes. If there is any feeling at all in the country it is shown by the vehement way in which this tax is opposed. These recommendations in the Seanad should be carried out by a huge majority here. Deputy Briscoe and Deputy Traynor make the plea that their Party ties will compel them to vote for this tax. Let them see how they became affiliated to their Party and how their Party became affiliated to the Government. We are told by the Parliamentary Secretary that this sum cannot be afforded. I am going again to read the advertisement which shows how it was that Deputy Traynor and Deputy Briscoe became associated with the Government. The case made by the people who made out that advertisement and spoke for the Government was that.

"Fianna Fáil has a policy which can and will reduce the burden of taxation by no less than two million per annum." Now £25,000 is a small sum in comparison with two million pounds, which that Party was to find this year in the way of saving. It will be objected that this year was not meant but the advertisement here will show that it was this year:

"Fianna Fáil is satisfied that substantial economies are feasible without reducing social services, without inflicting hardships on any class of Government servants or impairing in the slightest degree the efficiency of the administrative machine. It has examined with minute care the Estimate of Supply Services for the current year and is convinced that a saving of many hundred thousand pounds can be made not including such items as the sum of £152,500 paid to the British Government in respect of R.I.C. pensions and other similar payments not required by the Treaty."

And then they wind up with this appeal:—"The burden of taxation can be lightened by no less than £2,000,000 per year." That is the solution after saying that the estimate of supply services had been examined with minute care and that not less than £2,000,000 could be saved. What is the use now of bladdering to us about £25,000? Deputy Traynor has been appealing for his constituents in the matter of this tax.

Comment on this

I have not put in any appeal for my constituents.

Comment on this

If the Deputy has not done it the Party opposite has. But that is the Party to which Deputy Traynor tied himself—the Party that promised a saving of £2,000,000 a year. We do not ask for £2,000,000. Give us this £25,000 and let us off this tax.

Comment on this

What about the taxes the Deputy put on?

Comment on this

That is the sort of thing on which Deputy Corry got a lecture here.

Comment on this

And I will be elected again any day.

Comment on this

We need not talk about that now. We are talking in relation to this £25,000. It is ludicrous to be told that the Party that promised £2,000,000 saving cannot give us this £25,000 now off this tax. "After examining with minute care the estimate for the supply services for this year not less than £2,000,000 can be saved." There is another way that has been spoken of by Deputy Dillon, and again I am sorry that the great upholder and advocate of the railways is not in his place, as he has not been in his place whenever these matters of taxation are being discussed.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The railways are not now under discussion.

Comment on this

Yes, by way of analogy they are. There is a sum to be saved if another recommendation is to be accepted—a sum of £25,000. Let the Minister accept that recommendation and relieve Deputy Briscoe and Deputy Traynor from the embarrassing position in which they find themselves.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin is dealing with the case of the railwaymen at the present time.

Comment on this

I wish he could be brought here.

Comment on this

I am here; I am in his place.

Comment on this

The railways are certainly saved now.

Comment on this

Ask Deputy Peadar Doyle to save them.

Comment on this

I suggest another way for making revenue. Let us have drilling, as Deputy MacDermot suggested, considered as an entertainment. Why not tax drilling in the country? Will you get £25,000 in that way? Of course, you will. It is the law not to allow drilling, and, if you are not going to enforce the law, put a fine on those found breaking the law and on the Minister for Justice, whose duty it is to see the law enforced. Let us have the double fine. Let it be considered an amusement. It may be termed an outdoor game; it is mainly a game, and it is certainly out-of-doors. What about taxing the people who do not recognise the courts? That is another game, a complete and entire game in the present circumstances. It is a game for which there is not even the excuse that is offered in regard to outdoor games. They at least bring some benefit to the people who are playing them.

We are having all this nonsense about £25,000 talked of. This proposal to get £25,000 from sports of various kinds comes from a Party which pledged itself to find £2,000,000. That Party can find £30,000 by accepting another recommendation of the Seanad. That Party can find any amount if they only put taxation on the particular types of folly that are being prosecuted in the country at the moment with every appearance of zeal. Deputy Briscoe put forward the suggestion that if there is going to be any hardship in this National Budget it ought to be borne by the association which prides itself as being a national games association. I do not think it is fair to put on this tax. There should not be a tax on any of these sports. It should be on them all or none. If you are going to put a tax on sports put it on them all or, alternatively, on those that can afford to pay. Put a tax, if one is necessary, on the heavier-priced seats. I had an amendment down to exempt an admision fee of 1/- or less and I suggested that if any tax was to be imposed on higher-priced seats it should apply to all games. That suggestion was not considered a good one and we had to have this discrimination in favour of all games played under the auspices of two organisations.

The point was made that we in our time made certain discriminations. There was a discrimination of a very trifling type in regard to income tax. It had reference to income tax on profits in relation to Gaelic games. That was rendered exempt after a free vote of the House. I voted against the discrimination, such as it was and trifling as it was.

The third point is one that goes definitely to the merits of all these games. I make no excuse for repeating what I said on other occasions. I agree with what Deputy MacDermot said. Games are useful at all times. They are never more useful or have more beneficial effects than when the people are going to suffer in other respects. We are told that we are going to suffer. Sometimes we are not told that. If we are to believe every type of nonsense that the Minister for Defence talks it would seem as if he will have to get all our houses rebuilt and have the doors made higher and wider if we are to pass in and out because we are apt to get very much stouter and swell up as a result of all the food that will be available in the country. If that type of argument is persisted in we really should have more games. If that sort of folly is persisted in it will lead one to the conclusion that we should have more games. If we are to eat as much food as the Minister indicated we certainly would need exercise. All that sort of thing is the purest nonsense. We are going to have hard times. There was never any nation that in time of want and hardship did not specially cater by way of games for the people who were likely to endure suffering. I alluded to this matter before and I made reference to the games in Ancient Rome. I mentioned that whenever there was a difficulty in giving the populace bread, when times were hard, they organised gladiatorial combats, chariot races, and everything calculated to amuse a people who were living barely at the subsistence level. It was in this fashion that they carried their people through hard periods. We have hard times ahead we are told. The Party that promised to give us £2,000,000 cannot lose £25,000, even though that might be necessary as a tonic to keep people in the urban areas at a good point of enthusiasm. There has been talk as if the only discrimination that mattered was one against Rugby football. I am sorry there is a discrimination against Rugby football but it is not the only discrimination. Look at the Seanad recommendation:—

To delete in line 23 the word "or" and after the word "Ireland" in line 24 to insert the words "the Irish Rugby Football Union, the Football Association of the Irish Free State, the Irish Hockey Union, the Irish Lawn Tennis Association, the Irish Amateur Swimming Association, the Golfing Union of Ireland, the Irish Ladies' Golfing Union, the Irish Amateur Rowing Union or the Irish Amateur Boxing Association."

Why should all these games be discriminated against? I have said before that as far as enthusiasm is concerned that there is no game, Gaelic football or hurling included, which can give rise to such an exhibition of mass enthusiasm as does the International Rugby contest which takes place here from time to time.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not know what he is talking about.

Comment on this

I have been at them all and I can judge as well as the Deputy. If there is one game that started off in this country with a definite prejudice against it, it is Rugby. By its inherent good qualities it has won through to such an extent that to-day it is admired almost by everybody, even those most keen upon keeping a ban on those who either play or attend the national games. One must admit that Rugby football stands out pre-eminently as a game. There was a time when a national paper of a weekly type in circulation here never let a week go by without some criticism upon Rugby football. Does it criticise now? What is the change due to? Tennis used to be thought a namby-pamby sort of game, a game played by polite young men and polite young women. I mentioned before that if people would only go back upon the records of school contests in Dublin here they would find that the school that has made most headway and that stands out pre-eminently so far as lawn tennis is concerned is one of the Christian Brothers' Schools. Golf also has come into the category of games for the democrat although it started as being something exotic. There has been a controversy going on here for years, one that unfortunately has not come to a proper head, in reference to the provision of an artisans' golf course. Those are the games we are discriminating against. Can anybody say a word against swimming? Even Deputy Corry is silent on that.

Comment on this

I should like to see you swimming somewhere. You would want a lot of water.

Comment on this

There is a certain novelist of the present day who suggested that most people suffer a bath upon two occasions, once just after they are born, and once, after they leave this life, and that they derive as little amusement from the first as they do profit from the latter. But there are other people who bathe more often and who swim. I do not know that anybody in the House will be able to assert that swimming as a sport or recreation is a thing that should be discriminated against. Much the same case can be made for the other matters spoken of. The game I want most of all to make a plea for is Association football, probably the game that was most derided by the strong Gael at one time in the history of this country as being the predominantly English game. If beaten at all by Rugby from that point of view, it was only beaten because it was said that there was a more snob-bish class attached to Rugby than to Association football. What is the situation with regard to Association football now? No wonder the two Deputies who sit opposite feel a little acutely their position in regard to Association football. It is all very well putting on smiling faces, but they do feel it and will feel it much more acutely later. They should feel it, because if there is any game which, as I said before, destroys the tedium of work for the working man, it is Association football, the game to which he looks forward on Saturday and Sunday.

Comment on this

What is the feeling like?

Comment on this

He spends his time looking forward to a match at the week-end for the end of one week, and for the beginning of another week he looks back to that match and then looks forward to another, and that carries him through the winter, the most discontented period of the year. It does carry men through. It will be said that this tax will not stop Association football. It may not stop it entirely, but it certainly is going to take a considerable amount of variety out of it. The League that was in existence consisted of about a dozen clubs. You might say that about a dozen first-class teams took part in it. They have been weakened within the last fortnight by two. There is not going to be the same interest for the working man in Dublin, Cork or Waterford if there is not the same number of teams to see in a contest as before. That is the position we have got to, and that is all for £25,000. Really is it worth while, for £25,000, despoiling the men who have not really much else to look forward at the end of the week? They have no games they can enjoy in the sense of playing themselves, but they do enjoy a contest, seeing other men in the arena, talking about form and the performances afterwards. Everything that goes to create enthusiasm, to make a man look forward to the end of the week, to lighten his heart and to lighten his work is all inherent in this tax, and that is going to be weakened, if not killed, by the imposition of the tax.

There should be definitely some advertence to this point. There have been other nations before this and they adverted to it. They took the games that were popular and they fostered them and they never fostered them more than when the country was in a state of turmoil. Times here are going to come down perhaps rather harder on the people. Everything is pressing on them. Surely for the sake of £25,000 it is worth while to let them have their week-ends as they used to have them. That is all that is asked for. It is no satisfaction to people who are pressing this amendment merely to say briefly that the money cannot be spared. The money can be spared. If necessary, the money can be found elsewhere. It is the Government's duty, if the House does express the view that this money should not be found this way, to put up alternatives. When alternatives are put up, it is possible that the House may reject them and go back to the games. That has not been put before us. There are a considerable number of alternatives which ought to be tried before we come to impose a tax on the week-end sports. If I am asked what alternative I suggest, I say that the Minister should again examine with minute care these estimates and give us £25,000 of the £2,000,000 promised to us.

Comment on this

My reason for intervening in the debate is this: it has gone on for a considerable time and we had many speeches, but no one ventured to speak from the Government Front Bench up to this. Seemingly it is a matter of no importance and is regarded as such by the occupants of that Front Bench, which has only one representative on it at present. When I played football I played Gaelic football and nothing else. I understand that when the President played football he played Rugby and nothing else. When the President was Leader of the Opposition in the House I heard him stating here that if he had his way he would not tax any games. I wonder what is going to be his attitude with regard to the games of various kinds? I also listened to the Parliamentary Secretary in this House stating that Cumann na nGaedheal back benchers were so much slaves to the Party machine that they marched into the division lobby like dumb driven cattle. I wonder what is he at this moment? So far he has been dumb. Those who should be occupying the Government Front Bench are absent without explanation. I wonder why? Is there any reason for it? Deputies Briscoe and Traynor have given explanations. What part did they play when there was a vote taken in this House recently on this matter? Did they vote on that occasion? They are now present and I ask them why did they not vote? What is their reason? Had they the courage of their convictions then? They seem to have gained some courage since. It would appear that they are going to vote this evening. We are told that this £25,000 cannot be done without. It is not so very long since the Minister for Finance could afford to make a present of £23,000 to small bus owners. It was said that that was to avert the danger of 1,000 people being thrown out of employment. I am at a loss to understand how the Minister for Finance arrived at the conclusion that 1,000 people would be thrown out of employment. On that occasion I listened to Deputy Norton, the leader of the Labour Party, with some interest, because in unmistakable language he said: "I must condemn this." He criticised the proposal in these words: "These buses that are now to be relieved at the cost of the State are being relieved for people whose employees are scandalously underpaid and scandalously overworked." These are his words, and they can be found in the Official Report. What was Deputy Norton's attitude afterwards if he considered that the employees of these small bus companies were scandalously underpaid and overworked? What did he do when he went into the division lobby? Did he act up to his convictions? One would infer that he was in duty bound to these employees to go into the division lobby and vote against the remission of that taxation of £23,000.

That was remitted in these circumstances to which I have referred and of which I have a very distinct and definite recollection. But what did the Deputy do? Although he condemned it by his voice, he supported the remission of £23,000 taxes to these small buses, which I say are a very great danger to the travelling public. I suggest that there are reasons why that was done. I venture to say that the Parliamentary Secretary, now representing the Minister for Finance, was in full possession of these facts and has a sound knowledge of why that remission was made. My reason for mentioning this matter is that we can afford to remit £23,000, but we cannot avoid taxing sport, although we had the words of President de Valera that if he had his way he would not tax sport at all. I wonder is he having his way, is he under compulsion, and if so, where is the compulsion coming from now? That is a question that requires an answer. There is no use in talking sheer nonsense and saying that we cannot afford to do this or to do that. There is the matter of a supplementary vote which is coming before the House for consideration, when the President and the Parliamentary Secretary will be asking the House for £2,000,000, but they cannot afford to overlook a matter of £25,000 which is going to be a very serious consideration for sport. As I said in my opening remarks, I have played Gaelic and nothing else. I was always a supporter of Gaelic.

Comment on this

Will that appear in the "Western People"?

Comment on this

Possibly. I hope it will, and that the people will read it. Having read it, they will be able to judge my conduct then and now and to judge that I have never run away from anything I have done, and that my pledge is my bond.

Comment on this

The abolition of the Mayo County Council.

Comment on this

I supported one form of sport but I am not in favour of boycotting or penalising another. This is penalising sport and I have no hesitation in saying that it is being done for political considerations. The Parliamentary Secretary and those associated with him have been intimidated into the position they are taking up now. I wonder why it is that Deputy Briscoe, who is the vice-president of a Soccer Association, is taking up this attitude, and why Deputy Traynor, who is such a great exponent of the game as I am told he is, can vote for it. When it comes to voting we look to Deputy Briscoe to show how consistent he is in this matter. He will have no hesitation in doing his duty according to his convictions, and he will not be afraid that his actions in this matter will be the subject of criticism in the daily Press. I have no objection to his sending a report of my remarks to the "Western People."

I would appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary to leave this matter to an open vote. When Deputy Cosgrave was President there was no compulsion when this matter came to a vote before. The members of the Government Party then had absolute freedom to vote for or against it. Why does not this Government now take a like course? If members of the Opposition are willing to go round and support the tax let them do so by all means— the Cumann na nGaedheal back-benchers that the Parliamentary Secretary described on various occasions as dumb driven cattle who were slaves to a Party machine. I say here that the members of the then Government Party were not slaves to a machine with regard to sport. They had full and ample opportunity to exercise their own discretion and to vote according to their own wishes.

Comment on this

It is nearly one and a half hours since I heard Deputy Gearóid O'Sullivan saying that this debate was very dragged out and that it would have no effect whatever.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

I consider that this tax is absolutely justified.

Comment on this

In the absence of the Parliamentary Secretary or of a Minister, I think the House should stand adjourned for a few minutes.

Comment on this

Words of wisdom from the Lord Mayor.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is no Standing Order on the point. It is for the Ministers or Parliamentary Secretaries to judge whether it is right or courteous for them to be in the House.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Then to whom is the Deputy addressing his remarks?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

To the Ceann Comhairle, as every Deputy should.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

For what purpose is the Deputy addressing his remarks in the absence of a Parliamentary Secretary or Minister?

The President and Mr. Flinn resumed their seats.

Comment on this

On a point of order. There is a convention that the Government Front Bench should always be occupied and that convention has always been observed except in particular cases. The absence of the Parliamentary Secretary, I take it, was accidental. I take it the Government does accept the convention that during the course of a debate in the House the Government Front Bench should be occupied.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is quite right in stating that there is such a convention. I presume that the absence of the Parliamentary Secretary is accidental and merely temporary.

Comment on this

I desire to apologise.

Comment on this

I am afraid that Deputy Flinn took another one of his periodical trips to London that the Press are so fond of referring to. We heard a lot of talk this evening about discrimination. We heard appeals against discrimination from Deputy Thrift, Deputy Alton and others. I wonder were these gentlemen as vocal as they are now when the G.A.A. was definitely banned in this country in 1920. Did they then protest against the game not alone being taxed but being absolutely banned or were they supporters of the policy of the people who banned it at that time—those people who are so vocal now against discrimination?

Comment on this

I suppose I was.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not worth answering. I wonder also why those Deputies are so anxious now for freedom from tax for one association at any rate that refused to recognise the national flag in places where its games were played. Those are the people to be freed from taxation. Deputy Davis told us that when they were on the Government Benches they were absolutely free to vote in any manner they liked. I wonder will Deputy Hassett bear that out?

Comment on this

As far as Gaelic games are concerned, we were.

Comment on this

What about the Land Commission? Were you free then?

Comment on this

Just as free as you are now.

Comment on this

Was he free before when he had to pay for 365 acres that a district justice got in Tipperary?

Comment on this
A Deputy

What has all this to do with a tax on games?

Comment on this

Can the Deputy say that he paid for his own farm?

Comment on this

I paid for it myself and worked to pay for it, and I had no pension to enable me to pay for it either. I paid for it in spite of all I was robbed of by Mulcahy's army.

Comment on this

For God's sake keep away from that.

Comment on this

I will keep away from it. Then we had a Deputy on the Opposite Benches, who always reminds me of someone who is suffering torture, telling us about the saving that could be effected. Undoubtedly, there could be an amount saved in other ways. I suggested several times to the Executive Council a way in which they could save a lot of money for this country. If the Executive Council took my advice they could have saved an amount of money. Undoubtedly, England would not be so anxious to fight and we would not have those votes that we have to meet to-day.

Comment on this

Could the Deputy explain the present policy?

Comment on this

Of what?

Comment on this

Of what he is talking about.

Comment on this

I should like to direct the attention of the House to the fact that we have been many times pulled over the coals for interrupting, but the interruptions from the opposite benches are worse than ever.

Comment on this

You are afraid of that now.

Comment on this

I should like to know is it in order or is it helping the proper discussion of this matter to discuss why certain members on these benches are not in Mountjoy Prison or under other conditions?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not in order, but if the Deputy is allowed to speak without interruption debate will be more orderly.

Comment on this

I like interruptions. Deputy O'Sullivan is so anxious to speak that sometimes he opens his mouth a little too wide. He opened it too wide in Galway the other day. Ask Deputy O'Neill about that?

Comment on this

My mouth is not big enough to open too wide.

Comment on this

Will you cease interrupting?

Comment on this

I will not be intimidated by Deputy Corry's or Deputy Jordan's just chastisement. Deputy Jordan has repeated it here and Deputy Corry has repeated it here. There is a threat that certain members on the Front Opposition Benches are being guarded and Deputy Corry has boasted here that £12,000 could have been saved by preventing that, and Deputy Jordan said in Galway——

Comment on this
A Deputy

Is this a point of order?

Comment on this

I am raising it as a point of order. Are you afraid of it? Deputy Jordan said "You will get it." I want to know is that right. He runs away now from his own threat that he can prevent these persons from getting their just chastisement for what they did for the last ten years.

Comment on this

What is your interpretation of just chastisement? You would be surprised at the way I would chastise you if I got the chance.

Comment on this

I had no protection.

Comment on this
A Deputy

You had it for ten years.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Corry —on the games.

Comment on this

Apparently, every time I speak here I succeed in getting a lot of gentlemen on the opposite benches angry. I definitely put those two points. I am sorry that Deputy Alton and Deputy Thrift are not here. I would like to hear from them on the subject of what protest they made when the G.A.A. was banned here, or were they assisting those who banned it? Now, when their turn comes, or a little of it at any rate, you have them squealing so loudly. Secondly, when the organisation that refused to respect the flag of this country and refused to hoist the flag of the country in Lansdowne Road, when they, or their representatives come into this House asking for relief of taxation, I would appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary not to yield one inch of that tax to them.

Comment on this

So much has been already said on this matter that I do not wish to speak at length. One thing, however, I would like to bring to the minds of the Deputies, and that is that when the Minister for Finance introduced his Budget he had in his mind the taxation of all games, which will go to prove that, so far as the Minister was concerned, he was of the opinion at that time that if games were to be taxed, the taxation should be of a general nature. The House will remember that after the Budget statement deputations on behalf of the G.A.A. waited on the Minister for Finance and as a resultl of those deputations the Minister for Finance allowed it to be published that the taxation as far as Gaelic games were concerned would be remitted. With that decision I fully agree, but my position here to-day is that I want the same remission given to all games. I think that if the Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches would look on this question from the point of view of sport, they would have very little difficulty in accepting unanimously the recommendation that has come back from the Seanad. I do not want to go into past history as regards the G.A.A., referred to by Deputy Corry. It is just as well that we do not go into these things or perhaps we could speak a lot about it; but I think it is very bad and un-Christian, even if the G.A.A. were banned in 1920, that we should adopt that old heathen principle of an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth. I myself have played all games, and the reason I am so much opposed to this discrimination is because I am convinced that this discrimination is injurious to the G.A.A. I have the honour to represent a county which for many years occupied a very high position in the G.A.A. world and as a result of this pernicketty policy of differentiation, this narrow-minded policy, that county has never appeared in a favourable light for the last few years, as far as senior football is concerned, at any rate. It would be in the interests of the G.A.A. that no differentiation should be shown between the games and it is for that reason that I am heartily supporting this recommendation of the Seanad. It is not a question of nationality or of preference of any one game over another. It is simply a question of justice and fair play, and I would appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary to have this recommendation carried unanimously. But if he cannot agree with that course, he can at least allow this Vote to be an open Vote. On the last occasion, as has been pointed out by many speakers, the late Government allowed their members to have a free Vote and every Party in the House was satisfied. I think the same procedure should be pursued on this occasion, and I have no doubt but the Deputies would vote according to their consciences. It is according to the minds and wishes of a good many of them that this recommendation be accepted, and that we would have no differentiation or discrimination in games.

Comment on this

I suggest to the House that the recommendations of the Seanad are very wise recommendations and the House should accept them. To my mind it is a very bad thing indeed to take any steps for the discouragement of athletics in this country. I believe that athletics do a great deal more than merely to develop the body. I believe that athletics have got a great deal to do with the formation of character. I believe that any step which the Government takes to check the growth of athletics in this country is a very bad step and one which should not be taken. I sincerely hope that the view which has been put forward by Deputy Corry in the course of this debate is not the view which commends itself to the Government Benches and I hope the view which he expresses stands alone even in the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

What view?

Comment on this

We have got his idea of the principles upon which taxation could be levied and we have got from him now an admission that he is voting for this taxation because he is going to get back from certain associations a little of what they gave him some time ago. In other words Deputy Corry is voting against the Seanad's recommendations because he wishes to take punitive action against certain associations and he wishes to hit these back——

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, what I said was that the reason for discrimination was because one definite association, namely, the G.A.A., had been taxed and has suffered severely during a certain period when other associations were enabled to make money.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

Therefore that association got into a worse position financially and is entitled now when there is a National Government in power to some share of fair play. That was the only reason I gave and I object to words being put into my mouth that I did not use.

Comment on this

When Deputy Corry talks about a National Government being in power now he talks a lot of balderdash and nonsense. There was never a less National Government in this State than the one now in office.

Comment on this

Well we know it is better than your Government.

Comment on this

Having now heard Deputy Corry's explanation we discover that we are in the same position as we were—that he is voting for this taxation in order that certain associations should be punished; that Soccer and Rugby games should be punished because of the fact that over ten years ago or thereabouts Gaelic football was not allowed to be played. That is now the attitude which we discover has been taken by Deputy Corry. I sincerely hope that that is not the attitude which is taken up by even one single Deputy in Deputy Corry's Party. Looking at this matter from the broad point of view I suggest to the Government that they are making a very bad mistake in putting this tax upon games and that in consequence they are checking the growth of athletics in this country.

In my opinion athletics are of great value to this country both physically and also for mental training. I think it a great mistake that anything should be done which will check that growth. The matter of football has been very fully thrashed out already. We are told that certain games are games that should not exist; that Rugby and Association should be squelched in comparison with other games. I do not agree with that view. I believe that a person should have the right to play any game he likes. I believe that every single person in this State should be free to play any games he likes.

Let us leave this question of football and come down to those associations which are being taxed here. Take the swimming association. What reason is there for taxing that? The consequence of that taxation is that a most valuable exercise is being discriminated against and discouraged. Why? Swimming is a very healthy exercise, and on occasions I should imagine that the Government would recognise, and that even the Parliamentary Secretary would recognise, that the acquisition of the powers of swimming has led to life-saving. I would imagine that the Government would encourage rather than discourage the learning of the art of swimming.

Then there is another form of sport —boxing. Upon what grounds can you differentiate between ordinary field athletics and boxing? Why should there be any tax upon boxing entertainments when there is no tax upon field athletics? I can, to a certain extent, understand why there should be a tax upon field athletics rather than upon boxing, because athletics do not require the same amount of coaching that boxing does. In consequence an athletic club can carry on successfully with smaller financial resources than a boxing club can. If a boxing club is going to be successful and to go along as fast as it ought to go along, it is almost a necessity that it should have a professional coach. Boxing is a sport which is increasing fast in this country. The game is being improved enormously, especially in country districts. Why the improvement in boxing has taken place in country districts is because, to a certain extent, good Gárda boxers happen to be stationed there. You have places like Wexford, Tobercurry, Sligo, and so on where boxing is going ahead, and if you examine that matter you will find it is simply because there happens to be very good Gárda boxers stationed in those districts. Those clubs all over the country should have professional trainers. The number of expert Gárda boxers is not unlimited, and they should be able to have coaches, professional trainers, who will teach them the art of boxing. That cannot be done, and, in consequence, boxing is not going forward as quickly as it should. Even at the present moment the boxing clubs are very short of funds.

I would like to know from the Government what income do they expect from this tax on boxing? How much per annum will they make out of it? There is no principle involved. So far as field athletics are concerned, they have given way. What loss to the revenue will it be? Remember, a trifling gain to the revenue will be a very serious loss indeed for the boxing association. £300 or £400 per annum to the Government is nothing. That amount raised by way of taxation on the boxing association would be very large indeed. For that reason I will press on the Government to consider seriously removing the impost in this instance. In the case of those associations where there is no substantial question of revenue involved, the Government should follow out the principle they established when they took the tax off field athletics. They should, at any rate, agree to take the tax off these small associations, such as the boxing and the swimming associations.

Comment on this

The case for Rugby and boxing has been put up so well that I will not detain the time of the House by dealing with them at any length. There is one little point I would like to mention concerning Rugby. Only two or three years ago the Rugby Union were induced to spend close on £40,000 on the erection of a Grand Stand at Lansdowne Road in order to accommodate their patrons. There was the hope that as a result of that improved accommodation all the International matches would come to Dublin. On the occasion of an International at Lansdowne Road between 40,000 and 50,000 people are usually present. Anybody who has tried to get to Lansdowne Road between 2 o'clock and 3 o'clock on the day of an International will realise the amount of employment that is given to Dublin carmen and taxi drivers, to hotel waiters and waitresses, many of whom perhaps, had not been working for at least a month before. By bringing these matches to Dublin a good deal of money is spent in the City. Speaking for Dublin, I appeal to the Minister to consider that aspect of the matter. Were Deputies ever present at Lansdowne Road when Ireland scored in an International match? Whether the scorer was from the Free State or from Northern Ireland that was never questioned and we cheered as no other race would cheer, especially if the score brought us victory.

There are three fields in Dublin City in which the big soccer matches are played—Shelbourne Park, Milltown and Dalymount Park. On an average you will have 50,000 Dublin working men paying 6d. or 1/- to enjoy one and a half hours' sport in the sunshine. Even if there was a heavy downpour of rain, that would not damp their ardour in any way so long as they saw a good game. The people who patronise Soccer are the working classes. The tax is only 1d. on the 6d. seats and 2d. on the shilling seats, but nevertheless that will impose a considerable hardship. Take the case of two boys who possess one shilling and desire to see a Soccer match. They will have considerable difficulty in finding the extra penny or two-pence and the receipts suffer in consequence. I do not wish it to be taken that I withdraw my support in the slightest in the case of big matches or higher priced seats, but I do urge the Minister to withdraw the tax entirely in the case of the 6d. or 1/-seats. If he does that he will be granting a great concession to the working classes. He could fix a tax upon seats over one shilling. I will appeal to him, however, not to fix the tax in such a way as to take away the good patrons from the International Rugby matches that we all hope to see played at Lansdowne Road.

I will give an instance of what the Minister would get from last year's Soccer receipts. As regards senior football the sum he would have been entitled to last year would be £6,700. Is it really worth while, for the sake of £6,700, to endanger the future of any of the clubs that are providing an afternoon's amusement to 60,000 people who travel from Dundalk, Waterford, Cork and other places? I appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary to give them some encouragement. Let him meet the House reasonably on this matter and submit a suggestion that will relieve the situation in regard to the lower priced seats. It might be of interest to note that there are countries on the Continent that subsidise football. In some of those countries where football is subsidised —I am now speaking of Soccer— when our teams went to visit them they were met by the principal public men and entertained hospitably. On more than one occasion within the last couple of years the Irish Free State flag was raised to an honoured position. These young men enabled Continental countries to see for the first time the colour of our flag. I ask you to treat them as ambassadors from our State, if you like, ambassadors for our products, by getting people on the Continent to talk about the Irish Free State.

There are many forms of sport in which we all feel great pleasure. At the beginning of to-day's proceedings, a compliment was paid to our representatives, O'Callaghan and Tisdall, who had done so well. There are one or two others that should be mentioned. There is another young man who carries the Free State flag in his pocket everywhere he goes. During the past year he has been unbeaten when a hair's breadth of a mistake at a turn would endanger his life. Everybody feels proud when the flag is raised by Stanley Woods. Swimming has been mentioned. It is only yesterday that we read in the newspapers that a young man named Heron from the Half-Moon Swimming Club won the British championship. I ask that the State will recognise the services of these young men. Only this morning again we read in the newspapers of Ireland's victory in cricket. It shows you that there are Irishmen capable of rising to great heights, no matter where they go, in forms of sport other than those mentioned to-day. If any Deputy wants to see what the Dublin children think of Soccer let him go to Bohemian Park some day and see the youngsters surrounding Captain Cannon, the goalkeeper, and asking him for his autograph. They can see them at Milltown watching Bob Fullam or at Shelbourne Park trying to get hold of that veteran of football, Bill Lacey. In recognition of the very great work done by these, I appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary to adopt the amendment, or go some way to save these clubs and these sports.

Comment on this

If anyone wanted to be prophetic as regards the future of sport in this country, I think one might safely say that sooner or later a Ministry of Recreation, something similar to that which they have in France, will be established in this country. In France they recognise the tremendous moral urge and impetus that sport of every description gives to a nation. I remember during the Great War, when a division was fighting beside the 16th Irish Division, something was going wrong with them. Their resistance was weak; their attack was weaker still. The authorities investigated the matter and brought the division out and drilled and re-drilled them until ultimately they discovered that games and sports were being neglected by the general in charge. When the cause was revealed, sport was re-introduced and made an Order of the Day. Boxing was made one of the primary things in the training of that division. When that division went back again there was a complete change in the part of the line which they held. When I was with the American troops General Pershing insisted on the same thing. The same thing was done with the Italian troops. General Haig, when he was in charge of the British Army, insisted that the first thing after training and even before it, should be sport and games. If in war, when men are at one another's throats, games are so necessary in order to maintain the morale of the men, the same thing applies to a nation in peace, and especially to a nation which to-day is engaged in an economic war. Let all taxation be withdrawn from games. Let the people have their games of one kind or another. Let them go freely, whether they go to the left to Croke Park, or to the right to Lansdowne Road, or to Shelbourne Park and those other places where Soccer is played, and let there be no tax on one to the advantage of the other. Let people have their sport and their games, and then the nation will advance in the way it should advance, with fine moral strength and courage.

Comment on this

Personally I should like to see this question left to a free vote of the House. Whether it is or not, if a division is called, I intend to vote as I did on a former occasion. Hurling and Gaelic football are recognised by all nationalists in this country as national games, and, as members of the Parliament of this State we have an interest in the promotion of national games, we should mark out these national games for some distinctive preference. That is the only reason why I believe the Government are right in this matter. Deputy McGilligan, who is credited with the most elastic imagination in this House, I believe has again done me the honour of referring to me in my absence and to my attitude on this matter. I do not know that he knew very much about my mind on the matter and my likely attitude upon another matter that is to come up for discussion. One thing I remarked during the ten years of office of the late Government was that, while they were Ministers they were very seldom, if ever, found at Croke Park at All-Ireland hurling or Gaelic football matches. They could be found "hob-nobbing" with the lords and ladies at Lansdowne Road, but although they were Irish Ministers, they could not honour by their presence the national games of Gaelic football and hurling. That is the mentality with which they look upon this proposal to-day.

Comment on this

Are you quite sure?

Comment on this

I do not know whether it is a pleasure or not, but I never had the pleasure of looking at the pleasant face of the ex-Minister for Justice at Croke Park during the period he was in office.

Comment on this

I was in Croke Park many times and I never had the pleasure of seeing Deputy Davin there. I did see Deputy Corish, I must say, but never Deputy Davin.

Comment on this

I was actively associated with the G.A.A. for a very long period.

Comment on this

And kept away from Croke Park?

Comment on this

No. I do not believe I ever missed an All-Ireland football or hurling match any time I was in Dublin during the last 25 years.

Comment on this

I have spoken several times to Deputy Davin at Croke Park.

Comment on this

Whether I was there or not, I am not bigoted. Certainly I am not definitely opposed to those who play other games. The young people are entitled to play any games they like in any way they like. Let us look at the issue and judge it fairly and squarely. Deputy McGilligan painted a grand picture about the enthusiastic thousands who frequented some football matches at Milltown, Shelbourne Park and Dalymount Park. Who are the people who are responsible for or-ganising these games? Men who put their money, the same as ordinary speculators into business concerns, to buy and sell young men and make profits by getting gate money. That is not the position of Gaelic football.

Comment on this

The Deputy has now mentioned the grounds of three teams. One of them is an amateur team.

Comment on this

The seven or eight teams which Deputy McGilligan had in his mind were got up by speculators who put their money into them just as they would put money into any other profit-making business, to buy and sell young men. That is not the position of the G.A.A. Those who play hurling and football do so whether there is profit or not.

Comment on this

What about Rugby?

Comment on this

Or boxing?

Comment on this

As to the professional side of Rugby I am not competent to speak.

Comment on this

There is no such thing as a professional side to Rugby football and it should not be mentioned.

Comment on this

There is the Northern Rugby Union.

Comment on this

The Northern Rugby Union does not operate in this State.

Comment on this

There are two kinds of Rugby.

Comment on this

In Ireland there is only one.

Comment on this

There is the Rugby Union in the North of England.

Comment on this

I submit that any reference to the Northern Rugby Union in England is out of order in discussing the taxation of Irish games.

Comment on this

I am not going to provoke discussion or to prolong discussion on this matter. I say that I believe it is the duty of the Nationalist members of this House, who believe in the promotion of national games to show by giving a preference of this kind that these games are national and that they are not professional. I believe the Government is right in giving a preference on this occasion. Even by this taxation we are not going to prevent anyone from playing any game he likes.

Comment on this

Why not subsidise the national games rather than tax any game?

Comment on this

I should like to see this matter left to a free vote of the House because I believe, if it were left to a free vote, the House, although it is now different in complexion and character, would confirm the decision which was come to on a free vote of the House twelve months ago.

Comment on this

On a point of information. May I ask Deputy Davin did not the Labour Party vote for the self same amendment on a previous occassion?

Comment on this

Look up the records.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Your leader voted for it.

Comment on this

As I observe the Parliamentary Secretary is anxious to conclude, I am not going to detain the House at any great length. I wish to refer briefly to some of the points made by the previous speakers in support of the recommendation of the Seanad in regard to the tax on outdoor sports. Deputy Blythe stated that the members of the G.A.A. on the Fianna Fáil Benches not alone got their games relieved from the tax but insisted on this discrimination, on other games being taxed. I would respectfully suggest that the Deputy should be more careful in regard to the verification of statements of that nature in future. I should like to point out that the principle of discrimination has been there for years— since an Irish Government first took office, in fact I might say since the time of the first Dáil. During the days of the British regime the G.A.A. resisted attempts made to impose taxation on it. I would ask some of those interrogative Deputies on the Opposition side to apply some of their ridiculous questions to their own attitude. I would ask them to explain their attitude and statements on former occasions up and down the country and in this House with the vote they gave here on the amendment on the Committee Stage of the Bill.

Deputy O'Neill in asking the House to agree to the Seanad recommendations conveys the impression, in fact he states definitely, that Rugby football is a factor in discipline, in physical, educational and intellectual development in some of the schools and is superior to any other game, Gaelic football or the old Irish game of hurling. I should like to ask if the Deputy seriously means that. My contention is that hurling is the finest game in the world. It is generally admitted by those who have seen it played by first class teams that it is the finest game in the world, and many people who saw for the first time the epic struggles that took place in all-Ireland hurling finals were converted to Gaelic ideals as a result. There is no doubting the statement that hurling is out on its own. It is a distinctive game, going back to the dawn of history.

Comment on this

I should like to remind the Deputy that I made no comparison between Rugby and hurling. I quite admit that hurling is a game away on its own and I would not compare any game in the world with it.

Comment on this

I leave it to the official records to verify what I have said as to what was the Deputy's actual statement. That was certainly the impression he conveyed to my mind— that Rugby football is superior from the point of view of discipline.

Comment on this

I must correct the Deputy. I did not state that.

Comment on this

I will take the Deputy on the point as to whether he did not state that Gaelic football as compared with Rugby——

Comment on this

I think the Deputy should not be allowed to take Deputy O'Neill on another point before withdrawing the misrepresentation of which he has been guilty.

Comment on this

I stated very definitely, and I am satisfied that the official records of this debate will reveal——

Comment on this

Records or no records, I think that a personal explanation when made should be accepted by any honourable man in the House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If Deputy O'Neill states that he did not make a certain statement Deputy Gibbons will have to accept that.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Neill stated that Rugby was promoted and encouraged by those in charge of schools in preference to any other game.

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

I am positive. You said that Rugby was encouraged in preference to any other game.

Comment on this

I do not want to be misunderstood. I think I have made my position quite clear.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Neill in the course of his statement was very contradictory. He said he had no objection to some slight differentiation in favour of national pastimes. Further on he stated that it was a disgrace for any Government to make any exception whatever. He stated also that he was in favour of Rugby and rowing, so it has come to this that it is a disgrace for a national Government to favour distinctive games of their own. Things have come to a nice pass if we are expected by Deputies on the Opposition Benches to apologise for our adherence to things which are Irish and national and of which we are proud and of which we should be proud. It was stated by Deputy Coburn that the constituency which he represents in days gone by had been pre-eminent in the G.A.A. I feel it incumbent upon me to make this explanation. He said that there was a different picture now, that it does not hold that pre-eminent position which it did in the G.A.A. movement in days gone by. He attributes this falling off to the principle of discrimination in favour of G.A.A. games that has obtained for some time. I can assure the Deputy and other members of the House that Louth does occupy a foremost place in the G.A.A. It is in the forefront of our games. I have seen their football team give a great display against the redoubtable Kildare team this year and I believe their minor football team is going to win the national championship this year. I think the Deputy does not know very much about the G.A.A. in Louth when he makes that statement. Deputy Finlay makes the point as to the reasonableness of having freedom of choice extended to boys who wish to play any particular form of game. I should like to ask him is that freedom of choice recognised in many of the educational institutions of our country? I say it is not. I say that many boys going to them have to play foreign games or no games.

Deputy McGilligan has made reference to the mass enthusiasm at the week-end Soccer and Rugby matches in Dublin and suggested that that did not apply to any great extent to Gaelic matches. He must not have been present at an All-Ireland final where he would see the real Ireland, in miniature, and see enthusiasm that redounded to the advantage and the pride of everybody in the country. He made reference to the disappearance of some Soccer clubs and specified Waterford. Why has the Waterford club gone out of existence? It was unable to carry on before these taxes were introduced because of the introduction of foreign players. The Waterford team was composed almost entirely of professional cross-Channel players and the club were unable from the "gates" they received to hold them, so that professional Soccer has practically ceased to exist there, and these taxes have nothing to do with it.

I spoke at length on this matter on a former occasion, and I am not going to delay the House any further. But I do ask the Parliamentary Secretary to insist on having those games brought within the provisions of the taxation as outlined in the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

I think the idea behind this Bill is not discrimination as between games but as between associations governing these games. There is a big difference between the two ideas. The Gaelic Athletic Association is conducted on national grounds and is entitled to consideration from a national Government. It was formed to fit Irishmen better to win the freedom of their own country, not, as Deputy Minch would have us believe, to enable the 16th Division better to beat the Germans. On that ground alone they are entitled to preference from a national Government. If one association has any national virtues beyond the others I submit it is the Gaelic Athletic Association. If anybody in this House or in the country doubts that, I would ask him to conceive the things that happened on Bloody Sunday in Croke Park being enacted at Lansdowne Road. If he can, then he and I differ. I appeal to the Parliamentary Secretary to stand by the tax.

Comment on this

Deputy Gibbons objected to Deputy Blythe stating that members of the G.A.A. not only advised and urged the Minister that they themselves should be exempted but insisted on the taxation of their rivals. Deputy Gibbons suggested that Deputy Blythe was misinformed, but his very last words were to that effect. He asked that the Government should insist upon preserving the taxation against those other bodies. I do not know if he can have very much objection to Deputy Blythe's suggestion at the beginning.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, my heart is soft but my pocket is empty. That is the whole question. I am told that there is a surplus of £60,000. No one has taken into account the concessions that have already been made and every one of them was out of that £60,000. There is not any surplus of £60,000, and as regards the statement that the £25,000 can be done without the same thing can be said in relation to the proceeds of any other tax. These things, unfortunately, accumulate. If anyone thinks that we do not know that it is a politically undesirable expedient they must be simply mad. The people who are envisaging ten, twenty or sixty thousand of possible voters pouring into Soccer matches and who think that we do not see them and do not know that they are voters are very foolish people. We do. There is a whole lot of voters. There are roughly speaking 1,750,000 voters in this country who in one way or another are being asked in this Budget to face taxation in order to meet the necessities of the case and there is no particular reason why on broad grounds that proportion of them which we see going in in thousands to the football matches should be discriminated in favour of as a general principle. We are told that because we are asking for £2,000,000 here for emergency expenditure and another Supplementary Estimate for housing and the rest—because we are asking for more expenditure—we ought to throw away some of our income. That may seem a reasonable proposition. Deputy Mulcahy told us that he was in favour or had previously been in favour of a proposal, only it happened to be a proposal of this Government, that money might be exacted from those who look on at sports, for the purpose of benefiting the fibre and physical texture and the development of the race, but he is against it now when we are going to use the £25,000 as part of an expenditure that includes good housing, unemployment relief, public health works and £100,000 worth of free milk for the building up of the children. Why cannot they put this in proportion? The people who have been calling for that mens sana finance—which is about the only quotation probably they know—in this matter to aid them in attacking the money which is being paid for this particular Vote have voted against every tax practically that we have asked for—all the unpopular things that we have had to do. To make them more unpopular they voted against every taxation and in favour of every expenditure, not merely the normal expenditure but every abnormal expenditure that has to be met out of these incomes. They say scatter £25,000 here and there; it is not required. They speak of the pressing burden of taxation and go into a whole series of irrelevancies. Deputy Mulcahy for some extraordinary reason has read the “Irish Press” and he is not capable even of understanding it when it is put in the very simple way in which it is put. He does not know that “Portland cement,” for instance, is a trade term and even when a Belgian firm is engaged in advertising that it is prepared to supply——

Comment on this

Are we discussing Portland cement?

Comment on this

I quite agree.

Comment on this

I submit that the Parliamentary Secretary is completely out of order.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The matter was referred to by Deputy Mulcahy and the Parliamentary Secretary is entitled to make the point.

Comment on this

In this debate !

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy made a very concrete statement.

Comment on this

One ex-Minister may be even shocked by ex-Minister Mulcahy.

Comment on this

Does the Parliamentary Secretary suggest that Portland cement is called Belgian Portland cement?

Comment on this

But Portland cement is excellent cement, and those people are advertising damned good stuff as an alternative to the British stuff. That was the objection—excellent cement— in spite of the people on the opposite benches who are going around trying to find propaganda to the contrary. We are alluding to newspapers and their actions. What national newspaper was it that rang up a respectable and responsible firm in this city and asked to be put on to some competent expert person who would tell them that Belgian cement was no good?

Comment on this

You admitted it.

Comment on this

I should like to ask is it in order for the Parliamentary Secretary to ask a question of that nature about a newspaper not named and to make an imputation of that kind?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is better that he should not name it.

Comment on this

We will call it the national newspaper that is always accurate. We will be able to identify it then by its own columns. Deputy Byrne says that the total yield is only going to be between £6,000 and £7,000. Another Deputy Byrne says "Oh, no." Why they do not get together in a corner beforehand and come to an agreement as to what funny story they will tell or whether to contradict one another or not, is more than I can understand. Deputy J.J. Byrne says that the total yield will only be so much and Deputy Alfred Byrne says that we will get more from Soccer alone. All I am suggesting to them is that if there is to be any argument upon the indefiniteness of the yield, they ought to agree as to the amount of indefiniteness.

Comment on this

I know.

Comment on this

But then poor Deputy J. J. Byrne does not. The estimate which I have is founded upon the yield of these taxes when they were previously in existence. They are the estimated yield given to us by competent professional tax officials. They are not guesses either by Deputy Alfie Byrne or Deputy J.J. Byrne.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary mentioned——

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary will talk to you later on.

Comment on this

He mentioned the estimates from Soccer as distinct from other games.

Comment on this

It was given by that absolutely impregnable authority, Deputy Alfie Byrne.

Comment on this

What was the Soccer estimate?

Comment on this

I could not tell you the separate estimate for that or for ping pong or quoits either. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney says that they will get £300 or £400 from boxing.

Comment on this

You were told nothing of the kind.

Comment on this

Then I will withdraw it.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary is not very quick on the uptake. What I endeavoured to explain to the Parliamentary Secretary was that a sum of £300 taken from the Boxing Association would be a very large thing to them, but a very small item to the State. As to what the yield of the tax might be I made no suggestion.

Comment on this

Then what had the figures of £200 or £300 taken from the Boxing Association to do with it, if they were not intended to be the yield?

Comment on this

It was merely meant to give a plain, simple example of how a very small sum could be of much more importance to an association and of no importance to a Government. Seemingly, even with the simple example which a child could follow, the Parliamentary Secretary cannot follow it.

Comment on this

Then it was not relevant and had no meaning.

Comment on this

It was absolutely relevant. I thought the Parliamentary Secretary had something to do in the business.

Comment on this

Among all the counties mentioned by the Deputy, he left out Clare where he has taught the cows boxing. Deputy McGilligan discussed how many times some people took baths. He was wrong. They take them three times, at birth, at marriage and at death. Deputy McGilligan also said that the British imposed the tax, and another Deputy told us it was invented here. Why do they not get into a corner and agree as to what misrepresentation they desire to give? That is about all that was said really. The position is that this Finance Bill has to be passed by Friday. Is it suggested that any amendment could now be made, that it could go back to the Seanad and be approved, and that we could still get it done by Friday? Nobody on this side of the House desires to do that politically unpopular thing of taxing all those thousands of people for whose votes the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies have been appealing to-day. Because it is necessary that even from those people, in this unpopular way, this particular sum of money must be got in order to be added to all the other sums which are in the Budget to enable the expenditure of the State to be balanced by its income—for that reason we have to refuse to accept the recommendation of the Seanad in this matter.

Comment on this

Is it because of the inability of the Government to arrange its Parliamentary programme that this recommendation is being refused?

Comment on this

I should like to know whether, if the Dáil accepts a recommendation from the Seanad on a Finance Bill it is necessary for the Minister to put it through this House and send it to the Seanad for its acceptance of the recommendation.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Seeing that the Parliamentary Secretary is not accepting the recommendation, I do not see how the matter arises.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary put it forward as one of the reasons for not accepting it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not the duty of the Chair to tell the Parliamentary Secretary whether he is wrong or not. If the Parliamentary Secretary were accepting the recommendation it would be the duty of the Chair then to find out what action should be taken, but seeing that the Parliamentary Secretary is moving the rejection of it it is not the duty of the Chair.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary has made a statement on procedure. He said here just now that no reasonable political party should ask him at this stage of the financial business to introduce an amendment consequent on the acceptance of this recommendation from the Seanad on the ground that it could not possibly be got through before Friday. I challenge with all respect that it is necessary for a fresh amendment to be put through on a Finance Bill and I ask for your ruling, Sir.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair is not responsible for the correctness or incorrectness of a statement a Minister makes. The Parliamentary Secretary is opposing the recommendation; therefore, what Deputy Dillon is speaking on does not arise.

Comment on this

I want to ask the Chair to whom should a Deputy address a question on procedure of that kind if not to the Chair?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has the Standing Orders to which he can refer.

Comment on this

Well I challenge the Parliamentary Secretary from my reading of the Standing Orders. May I not ask the Chair to rule whether this is not within the Orders and whether it does not arise?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If the matter arises out of what the Parliamentary Secretary is doing? It arises out of what the Parliamentary Secretary says. That may be wrong or it may be right. If the Chair were to say whether the statements made on this side and on that side of the House were or were not correct the Chair would have a busy time of it.

Comment on this

With respect this is one of the grounds on which the Parliamentary Secretary indicated the intention of the Government to reject the Seanad's recommendation. I challenge that statement and I ask you to say is my interpretation or the interpretation of the Parliamentary Secretary of the Standing Orders the right one? Until the House has that explanation they cannot agree with the Parliamentary Secretary's motion to reject the Seanad's recommendation.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is labouring under a misunderstanding. There are two legs to this unfortunate thing. If the House were to accept a recommendation which reduces the revenue by £25,000, then the Government could not balance its Budget.

Comment on this

Oh!

Comment on this

That is not what the Parliamentary Secretary said a while ago.

Comment on this

That is what I did say.

Comment on this

I challenge the Parliamentary Secretary to repeat that that is what he did say.

Comment on this

I do repeat it.

Comment on this

Then I accept it.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: That recommendation 4 from the Seanad be not accepted.

Tá 68
·
Níl 54
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move:—

That the Committee do not agree with the Seanad in the following recommendation: Section 29. To delete the section.

It is regrettable that we are unable to ask the Committee to accept this recommendation.

Comment on this

For the reasons which the Deputy will find if he takes the trouble to read the debates which took place in this House. There has been no change whatever in the position since the debate took place.

Comment on this

We have the arguments summarised.

Comment on this

Go ahead.

Comment on this