We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1932—From the Seanad.

Contributions 217–430 of 430. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1932
Enacted

No. 11 of 1932 ›

The recommendation comes from the Seanad to delete Section 29. On that the Parliamentary Secretary finds himself incapable of any argument. The section is one which deals with the reduction of duty on certain mechanically propelled vehicles. This clause appears in a Finance Bill under the auspices of a Party which dubbed itself as the pro-railway Party. I think that is a correct description of them according to their professions, but whether these professions were sincerely expressed or not we do not know. At any rate the Seanad recommended that this section be deleted and the Parliamentary Secretary, without any argument, says it is regretted that this recommendation cannot be accepted. The argument cannot be used this time of loss to the Exchequer. The clause itself means a loss to the Exchequer. The Government are, therefore, deprived of the argument on which they mainly rely—that this would mean a loss to the Exchequer. There is no other way of recovering the money.

This is the Party that promised to recover £2,000,000 this year—to reduce taxation by that amount. Being a pro-railway Party, they have decided to reduce the taxation imposed upon buses. That is the main effect of Section 29. They do that while professing themselves to be a pro-railway Party. When any argument has been put up against this section we are told that this applies to all buses whether they are owned by the private hauler or by the railway company; there can be no force in any argument used that this is anti-railway. The people who use that contention have no appreciation of the railway situation as expressed by railway companies. I am not speaking of the transport situation, but of the railway situation. The contention of those who are concerned about railway matters in this country is that all goods and all passenger traffic carried by road, whether by rail-controlled buses or privately-controlled buses is a loss to the railways and is, therefore, another step on the road to the ruin of the railways and the disemployment of a certain number of railway men. It is, we are told, not a sound argument. That is countered by saying that this applies both to the railway-controlled buses and the privately-owned buses. If this diverts traffic from the iron road to the ordinary road it is a loss to the railway companies. They will tell you that the bus traffic which they run is run, in the main, at a loss and, in so far as traffic is diverted from the railway lines to their own bus companies, it means reduced revenue—reduced moneys for distribution amongst their shareholders and their employees.

The Government attitude on this recommendation shows distinctly that there is no appreciation of the railway situation and it shows that without any appreciation of the transport situation the Government have simply decided that they are going to remit taxation on buses. There has been no argument made that the taxation on the buses is inequitable, judged by any standard which we have upon which to base our judgment. It has not been argued that the taxation on motor traffic of all descriptions is heavier than what is warranted in view of the expense necessitated by the running of these vehicles upon our roads. An argument can be used that, as between the different classes of motor users, the private car owner is treated harshly in comparison with the heavy vehicles carrying passengers for hire or carrying goods at rates. An argument can be used with justice that the private car owner is paying more than he should and that the heavy bus for passenger use or the heavy lorry for goods use is not paying as much as those two classes of vehicles should pay if one takes into consideration the damage they do to the roads and the expense entailed in the upkeep of the roads for their benefit. No argument of that type has been used. We are simply told that on examination it appeared that this taxation was iniquitous and therefore was to be reduced. I should like the iniquity of the tax to be shown by figures. There must have been some examination made, if the thing was properly considered, and I should like to have the results disclosed. What, for instance, is the damage done to the roads by this type of vehicle? What money is collected for the upkeep of the roads from this type of vehicle in comparison with the private motor owner, who does very little damage to the roads? However, that argument is not being used. We are to make this leap somewhat in the dark for the amelioration of the bus and lorry traffic, and, to my mind, therefore, to the disadvantage of the railway companies who do not want to have either goods or passengers carried on the roads, but who want to have them carried on their own permanent way. There one comes up against a mentality in the railway companies which must be changed if transport is to be run properly here. It is not going to be changed, however, by this sort of reduction of taxation without proper examination.

The contention I was personally responsible for putting up to the railway companies was that they must show themselves capable of entering into the new situation. The new situation, as it appeared to me, and as I described it to them, was one in which the railways were to be kept as the main transporters of goods and passengers for long distances, but that they must be fed by road transport vehicles, and that I preferred to see these road transport vehicles, in the main, under the control of the railways because they had the advantage of terminal points, of knowing how the services of the railways were scheduled to run. They had the best situation of any company in the world to convey the combined types of transport necessary to us. One could demand from them a better degree of organisation and a better degree of efficiency in the running of this combined transport service. However, the railway companies previously, to my mind wrongly, concentrated upon talking about what they vaguely described as restrictions put upon their arrangements and upon their actions in regard to transport. It has been pointed out to them from time to time, and I think pointed out effectively, that under the system of the Railway Tribunal, as it holds at the present moment, the arguments that they put up with regard to restrictions are not of very much effect. They have their effect with regard to, say, hygiene in connection with the carriage of goods. But, at least a year ago, it was pointed out to them that arrangements were being made to ensure that the same hygienic regulations would apply to goods vehicles on the road as applied to goods vehicles on the rail. Why they have not been put into force recently I do not know, because I know they were on the point of completion and should have been promulgated and made operative months ago. Once that was done, the railway companies' arguments with regard to restrictions adverse to them and not to their competitors were considerably weakened.

On the other hand, I say that the new situation has gone very definitely against the railway companies from another point of view. Certain transport measures were introduced in this House and an administrative policy was outlined under these measures. That administrative policy had its relation mainly to passenger traffic. It was pointed out that the policy then was to throw all passenger carryings by road into the three big companies under the control of the Great Northern Railway, the Great Southern Railways, and the Dublin United Tramways Company. The situation, to my mind, has been worsened for three companies by the fact that the administrative policy outlined last autumn and winter has not been carried out under the new system of licences; that what was estimated to amount to an effective monopoly for the railway companies for passenger carryings by road has not in fact been brought about. A considerable number of private companies have been allowed to amalgamate and have been licensed for the carrying of passengers over certain routes. To that extent, the railway situation is worse than it was last year. In addition, we must bring to our consideration the present and the future effects of the policy that has been persevered in in this matter of the economic war. Carryings are undoubtedly going to drop everywhere, for passengers and goods. Under these circumstances, that we should have this foolish clause persisted in shows a complete lack of appreciation of the situation in which the railway companies were prior to the economic war, and the frightful situation into which they have now got.

This, in a sense, may be the salvation of the railways. I think a point has been reached where, if the railways are to be saved, the railway directors must be given complete and entire control of the transport situation. They should be given complete and entire control for about two years. They should be put on trial for two years. They should be told that they have the whole resources of the country; that they can tap whatever they like and charge whatever price they like for passengers and goods; that they are free from everything in the way of restrictions that applied to them in the past. If, at the end of two years, they have made their way they deserve our congratulations and deserve to be continued in existence. But if, in two years, they do not make good, then there has to be some change made in the method of direction of the railway companies. I hope we shall never come to the point in which we will have consideration of or giving in to the policy of nationalisation of transport in the country. But the situation has come to the point now when the railways are so badly hit by everything that it is no time to insist upon old-time regulations of any type. They should be wiped out. We have to trust the transport situation to the railway directors whoever they may be.

Comment on this

Why did you not do it last November?

Comment on this

Because the situation did not demand it.

Comment on this

Because you had not the guts.

Comment on this

It was not a question of the term used by the Deputy. It was a question whether the situation warranted it or not.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave would not allow you.

Comment on this

It was not a question of being allowed, but whether the situation warranted it. In these circumstances, when I get to the other leg of my argument, labour has to play its part. You cannot have a service that employs so many people, as railways do, continue, in the adverse situation they are meeting with at present, to pay labour what labour demanded at the height of prosperity of the railway system. The guaranteed week, the wages that are being paid, everything that appertains to the railway system comes down to us from the time when the railways were controlled, when they were under State auspices, and when it did not matter what the receipts were in comparison with the expenditure, because the cost in these days had to be passed on to those who had to utilise railway transport. Labour was able to fix its demand at a very high point. Apart from this question of wages, which is the last I should like to venture upon, the conditions should be revised. When you had a transport system in this country which was mainly founded upon railways, and when railways were all-important in the country's economic position, there was then something to be said for the labour people saying that they had a recognised position; one of considerable importance; one that therefore demanded attention from the railway managers; one which demanded certain regulations with regard to hours and wages, which could not have been demanded in the early days of railways when they were struggling concerns. We have now got into the position in which railways are again struggling, and if those who derive emoluments from railway services are going to persist in demands which were made in the days when railways were prosperous, or were in a position in which they could pay anything because the cost should be passed on to the transport users, then in the end they are going to kill this goose which lays the golden eggs for them.

They have got to readjust themselves to those new circumstances, and we, in this House, have got to readjust ourselves also to the new circumstances. The situation is such that if they persist in clause 29, this remission of rates to road vehicles which are destroying the railways, in face of the Seanad's recommendation, they are simply writing themselves down as having no understanding of the present position of the transport system of the country. I make an appeal, and I do not care whether the appeal is listened to or not, because the facts are going to bring about a situation so quickly that this appeal will have to be listened to before this year is over. The situation has now come to the point in which the railway companies will have to be empowered to use every weapon they find themselves capable of using against their main adversaries, and those are their competitors on the road. We cannot employ in this country through transport the number of men who at present find employment through the railway companies, and the number of men who also are finding employment through private buses, the goods carrying companies and the private omnibus passenger companies. Some one of those groups of employees has to go. The point now has been reached when inquiry has got to be made into arrangements being made to preserve the transport system of the country. I think, in the new circumstances, the only thing that can be done is to hand over to those who are in charge of the railway companies the complete control of transport in this country. You cannot hand it over to them immediately, but you can hand over to them liberty. You can give them freedom to operate their charges merely in order to do out their competitors. I abhor nationalisation, but I think the only thing that can be done is to set up some body like the Public Accounts Committee that will have the right every half-year to demand reports from the railway companies and have them discussed.

Comment on this

You disowned the Shannon scheme.

Comment on this

Not at all. There is no analogy between them—between a thing like transport and a new thing like electricity, because it was, to all intents and purposes, new. You may have to meet a situation in which you will have some board, like the Electricity Supply Board. If one had not painful experience that analogy of the Electricity Supply Board would strike me much more favourably. I wonder would anyone suggest taking it out of the hands of the people who are managing it at the moment, managing it with some degree of efficiency, and handing it over to a body selected by this House? Where would the personnel of the body be got from unless we are going to hand it over to completely inexperienced people? We would have to fall back on the present managers. I think transport has got to an extremely serious point, and no comparison of last November is going to unnerve me when saying that the circumstances are entirely different. If they are not entirely different we know that they are going to be completely different in a month or two when we get to this new economic situation or, at least, to the lag between the destruction of the present economic situation and the possibility of the dream of the new economic situation.

One of the agencies that is going to suffer in the interim is the transport agency. We cannot play fast and loose as between the two and there is more money in the railways, more people depending on the railways, and more employees working under better conditions and they deserve our support. In the circumstances, although it is a gamble, I do not believe there is any way out of it except to hand over control of transport to the three Boards of Management of the three main transport systems, to give them complete freedom from all restrictions and regulations, and judge them at the end of two years. If we are going to give any consideration to what I propose, I suggest that we get some access to those people and say that we make that suggestion to them on behalf of the trading community. It is a very delicate line to draw as between the other type of suggestion, to have what amounts to supervision over them. We can put up the suggestion to have access to them, to let us ventilate in our representative capacity points made by different trading agencies throughout the country, by farmers who want to have their stuff carried on the railways, by passengers who want to get from one place to another and the railway management can deal with these suggestions. To persist in present circumstances, and not merely in present circumstances, but in the circumstances we see inevitably developing in clause 29, reducing certain rates on mechanically propelled vehicles, convinces me in the clearest possible manner that there is no appreciation of the terribly dangerous point to which transport in the country has drifted.

Comment on this

I understand that Deputy McGilligan in my absence on more than one occasion has accused me of cowardice because of my alleged failure to be present on certain occasions when this section was discussed in Committee on the Finance Bill. If Deputy McGilligan will ask his colleague, Deputy Thomas O'Higgins, the reason for my absence on one particular occasion he will perhaps satisfy his curiosity on the matter.

Comment on this

On one occasion.

Comment on this

The policy behind the section of the Finance Bill as it originally stood is certainly wrong, wrong in principle from the point of view of the policy of this Party and to me is not quite clearly understandable. I have here copies or extracts from speeches made in this House by the present Minister for Industry and Commerce when he was in opposition and also by Mr. Lemass previous to the late general election in which he quite clearly indicated in plain English language that the Fianna Fáil Party was a pro-railway Party. No matter how much one may endeavour to explain the policy behind the section as it stands in the Bill it is impossible to persuade the railwayman, at any rate at the present time, that the section is not inserted for the purpose of propping up an uneconomic road transport system, a system which is making headway for the destruction of the railways of this country. I have been spoken to on many occasions during the short life-time of the present Dáil by members of the Fianna Fáil Party as to what could be done to try and save a certain section of railwaymen from being dismissed in different areas from which they come. I can only say here and now to the President and to those who may be anxious to preserve the railway system in this country that the destruction of the railways is being brought about fairly quickly at the present time by the policy that lies behind the section in the Bill. During the discussion in the Committee Stage, however, the leader of this Party criticised the policy behind this particular proposal.

Towards the end of the debate he asked the Minister for Finance this question: Is the Minister prepared to assure the House that so far as that section of the Act is concerned—that is Section 29 of the Bill—he will not allow bus companies which pay very low rates to continue to work road services. The Minister for Finance in reply said:

I am sure the Minister for Industry and Commerce, from any conversations which I have had with him, would have no hesitation in giving that undertaking.

What is the position to-day? That assurance of a very definite nature was given by the Minister for Finance in this House on the 8th July. On the 25th July licences were issued under the Transport Act for buses which were supposed to ply under fair and reasonable conditions so far as the employees were concerned. I have made inquiries—I am not quite sure that the information I have is altogether reliable—but I have sufficient information in my possession and I can give the House a good deal of information to prove that certain bus companies which received licences on the 25th July and which are at present operating in and around the city are paying wages as low as 17/6 per week to their conductors. From a labour point of view we have to consider whether we are going to allow the railway industry which on the date of amalgamation on the 1st January, 1925, employed 17,224 men, to be wiped out by an uneconomic road transport system.

The Great Southern Railway Company on the 1st January, 1925, employed 17,224 men under trade union conditions. On the 1st January this year that number was reduced to 12,044. Since that date hundreds have been dismissed and hundreds have dismissal notices in their pockets at the moment. What is the position so far as the buses are concerned and what are, generally speaking, the rates of wages prevailing in these industries in which licences were granted on the 25th July? The Dublin Tramways Company pays its conductors £3 per week, which is a fairly reasonable rate of wages and which has been agreed to by the union which acts on behalf of the employees. Ticket examiners, which is the comparative position in the railway service, in Dublin City are paid 52/- per week. In areas like Bray, Dun Laoghaire, Howth, and other industrial areas of that kind the figure is 2/- per week lower, namely 50/- per week. What is the position so far as the bus companies are concerned? The maximum rate of wages at present paid to bus conductors in and around the city is 30/- per week. Up to the 25th July or up to the 1st August only two companies operating in and around the city were paying that rate of wages. The "Blue Line" which is supposed to be the model employer in and around the city only on the 1st August raised its conductors' rate from 25/- to a maximum of 30/-. Compare the maximum rate paid to these bus conductors with the 52/- paid to the ticket examiners and the 60/-a week paid to the conductors of the Dublin United Tramways Company and make up your mind as to what you think of that situation and how you can expect any body of trade unionists to justify a subsidy of £23,000 to these small bus companies who are carrying on that uneconomic transport war, carrying it on under these scandalously bad conditions.

I had a letter handed to me to-day in this House by the secretary of the Transport Workers' Union, which speaks and acts for the employees in the principal bus companies. I am informed that at the present time out of all the companies that received licences only the I.O.C., the Dublin United Tramways Company, the General Omnibus Company, and now the Blue Line Company, are paying trade union wages. Personally I do not look upon 30/- per week for a married man who has to live under the conditions we know here in Dublin as a reasonable wage—conditions where you have to pay 1/2 per dozen charged for eggs which are sold and which must be sold in the country at 4½d. and 5d. In my native town eggs have been recently sold at that figure while the retailers in the Dublin area were charging in or about 1/2 a dozen.

Comment on this

Eggs are being sold at 1/4 a dozen in the Monument Creamery.

Comment on this

I do not know anything about the Monument Creamery. I have not the pleasure of the acquaintance of anybody who is associated with it.

Comment on this

I merely mention it on the question of the price of eggs.

Comment on this

I do not want Deputy McGilligan to get away with the idea that all the responsibility for the present transport position lies upon the Fianna Fáil Government, a Government that has been only three or four months in office. I admit that Deputy Cosgrave, the leader of the Government which Deputy McGilligan ornamented as Minister for Industry and Commerce, promised everything but did nothing except to allow the railways to drift slowly towards destruction, towards the position in which they now find themselves. In November last they brought in a Bill when they now they were on the eve of a general election. They hoped by bringing in that Bill that they would be able to get hold of the votes of the shareholders of the Great Southern Railway and their friends in the country. I might also tell President de Valera that the pronouncement made by Deputy Lemass on the eve of the general election, in which he said that they were a pro-railway party, got him as far as I know a considerable number of votes from railway shareholders and I believe it is up to President de Valera and his Ministry to make good the promise they made on the eve of the general election and to put their transport policy into operation before the railway industry is destroyed altogether.

Deputy Cosgrave made a very serious charge against the Fianna Fáil Government when this matter was under discussion on the Committee Stage of the Finance Bill. He did not know that Deputy Anthony was going to call a division at the time on the section. He said: "No one is going to vote against this but it is a bad method of solving the problem, if there is a problem to be solved." Deputy Cosgrave was always a road hog. He never saw a problem outside the roads. He was a great friend of the roads and be made provision for their maintenance out of taxation and at the expense of the taxpayers of the country. Deputy Cosgrave never had his eye on the railways and never knew there was a problem in the railway industry. Therefore, not knowing that Deputy Anthony was going to call a division, he said: "Of course no one is going to vote against this method of solving the problem," but in a second speech when he knew Deputy Anthony was playing the Cumann na nGaedheal game, he announced that the members of his Party would march behind him against the section in the Bill. Deputy Anthony, of course, had a more intelligent view of the railway position because of the pressure brought to bear upon him by railway employees in the city of Cork and Deputy Anthony can be found somewhere in the city of Cork.

Comment on this

The same might be said of you in your own constituency. You are living very well outside it anyhow.

Comment on this

I will compare notes with the Deputy.

Comment on this

I can go to my constituency.

Comment on this

I can go to my home in my constituency, not like the Deputy. In discussing the question of the railways versus the roads I want to say, speaking as a railway man with twenty-five years' service, that I am not opposed to the extension of road transport in this country. I believe that the financial position in which the railways now find themselves is mainly due to the unregulated transport competition which Deputy McGilligan and his colleagues allowed to grow up during their period of office. I believe that if you had a proper transport policy in the country it would be possible to maintain the existing number of employees in the transport industry, by a proper system of co-ordination, by making it possible for the buses and the lorries who are stealing the cream of the traffic from the railways to feed the railways and so maintain a good industry. I have heard members of the House say that the railways are out of date and that they can be done without. I would ask President de Valera to find out, or to tell me, if he can, how 20,000 followers of football from Kerry can be brought from Dingle, Tralee or Killarney on the day of an All-Ireland final to Croke Park by any system of road transport or any alternative form of transport? I would ask Deputy Cosgrave, on the other hand, to inform me how it would be possible to transport four or five hundred head of cattle from a fair in Bantry to Cabra for the cattle market by any system of road transport?

Comment on this

You are solving that question.

Comment on this

These are things for which the railway industry has to be maintained. It has to be maintained for the purpose of carrying cattle traffic and heavy traffic which cannot be carried on the roads. The railway industry must be allowed to compete on equal terms with other forms of transport, and to compete on fair terms, but when you have a bus company that is allowed to employ conductors at 17/6, 20/-, or even 30/- a week, against a railway company that pays 52/-, I say that is not giving them a fair crack of the whip.

We are told about all the capital that has been invested in the road transport industry, and all the capital invested by people who at present own buses. I should be surprised to know that any capital has been invested by the people who own and run buses in this country at the moment. I got a copy of the first list of shareholders of the I.O.C. when it was originally started, and it had then a nominal capital of £5,000, and the I.O.C., like every other bus company, paid for its buses on the hire purchase system, out of revenue and not by the method by which the railway industry was established. When the Great Southern Railway Company was established it had a paid-up capital of £26,000,000, capital which was owned by purely Irish shareholders. The Leyland Motor Company of Lancashire supplied most of the buses here and most of the people operating buses for the last five or six years here paid for them out of revenue instead of out of their own capital. Therefore, let us get it out of our heads that there is any great amount of capital invested in buses plying for hire in this country. Deputy Cosgrave accused the Fianna Fáil Government, by their action in giving concessions, of bribery and corruption. At least he said it was tanta-mount to bribery and corruption. I wonder would he now enlighten the House, as he did not enlighten us then, what he meant by that? He just gave us a couple of words without any detailed examination.

Comment on this

It is too laborious.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave used to be looked upon by the railwaymen of this country as the leader of the pro-petrol party. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, who is not here, unfortunately, has promised to introduce a comprehensive transport measure in the autumn. He made that promise, I understand, to a deputation of employees of the Great Southern Railways Company who waited upon him. I think it is going too far, or that the Fianna Fáil Government are going too far, in throwing the fat in the fire by putting this bus tax into operation before that measure comes before this House and is passed by it. Apart altogether from that, I do not think that anybody who has any association with railway trade unions or with any other trade unions could possibly, in view of the promise given by the Minister for Finance on 8th July, oppose the Seanad recommendation. A definite promise was made by the Minister for Finance and to my knowledge it has not been carried out and I do not think that the bus companies who ply for hire in and around this city and who are going to get the benefit of this concession at the expense of the taxpayers of this country should be allowed any financial concession until they have carried out the conditions laid down by the Minister for Finance in this House.

Comment on this

What are you going to do about it?

Comment on this

I am not going to be dictated to by Deputy McGilligan or by Deputy Cosgrave on a matter of this kind. At any rate I have a far greater hope that the present Government will do more for the railwaymen of this country than Deputy McGilligan ever did while he was in office. While he was in office he forced 5,180 railwaymen out of a permanent position on to the streets and roads of this country and deprived them of the compensation to which they were entitled under the original Act of 1924. The Fianna Fáil Government would have to destroy the railways altogether before they would do as bad as Deputy McGilligan did. Deputy Seamus Moore is regarded by some of us as the transport expert of the Fianna Fáil Party. I believe that Deputy Seamus Moore knows much more about the transport problem than any Minister sitting on the Front Bench to-day or than any Minister during the period of office of the previous Government. Deputy Seamus Moore, however, is not always correctly informed. He said during the discussion on the Committee Stage, "I have had to get employment for a number of people and they were never paid as low a rate as £2 a week." That was in connection with a speech by Deputy McMenamin in which he spoke of bus conductors being paid a wage of £2 12s. a week. Does the Deputy know of a case where any bus owner is paying a rate in excess of 30/- a week in and around Dublin? There is no bus conductor in the city of Dublin earning a wage in excess of 30/- a week. The tram company are the best employers. They pay 30/- a week to their young members for a period of two years. In addition, they get certain holidays and certain overtime rates not paid to any other bus conductors and they get a uniform in addition, which is not supplied by any of the other bus owners. It is the best concern, so far as I know, from the point of view of wages and working conditions in the city of Dublin. I would like President de Valera, if he does read Deputy Seamus Moore's speeches, to know that the statement made by the Deputy to the effect that bus conductors were never paid as low a wage as £2 a week is incorrect.

Comment on this
Séamus Moore Mr. Seamus Moore Fianna Fáil

I was not referring to the bus conductors. Deputy McMenamin had mentioned £2 a week in another case. Was not that his comparison?

Comment on this

I should like to ask Deputy Davin, if 30/- a week is accepted as a trade union wage by the bus conductors in and around the city of Dublin, does he or his Party accept that as a fair wage?

Comment on this

I have already said, if the Deputy had been listening to me, that I certainly did not accept 30/- a week as a fair wage in Dublin or anywhere else either.

Comment on this

Why does it continue.

Comment on this

The uneconomic competition carried on by these bus companies, and particularly by the smaller bus companies, has had the effect in and around the city of Dublin of reducing the number of passengers carried per month between Bray and Dublin by anything between 3,000 and 5,000 passengers. If they are unable to remain in existence under these circumstances, how can they remain in existence if they are going to be compelled to pay—as I hope they will be—the recognised local trade union rate of wages?

I do not believe that it is possible for the Fianna Fáil Government to save these small bus companies from being exterminated within the next three or six months. Therefore I say that the policy behind the insertion of this section in the Finance Bill is wrong and is bound to fail.

Comment on this

Has Deputy Davin forgotten that the small bus companies do not employ conductors at all? How many of these small bus companies employ conductors?

Comment on this

When I spoke of small bus companies I referred particularly to the "Falcon," the "Blue Line" and so on.

Comment on this

The Deputy has already said that these companies are paying a certain rate of wages to bus conductors. There are not more than one or two of them who are employing conductors at all.

Comment on this

I do not want to go into detail. The "Blue Line" is paying 30/- a week to conductors; the "Blue Bird" 25/-; the "Gem" 25/-, the "Falcon" £1 to 17s. 6d. and then the "Grafton" and some others of them pay a lesser rate of wages. Deputy Moore is aware of the extent to which these small buses ply for hire in different parts of the city. These are the small companies to which the Minister for Finance referred in his Budget speech. He said he was making this provision for them for the purpose of maintaining them in existence. I do not think it is possible for these companies to be carried on. Deputy Moore knows well that the "Falcon" employs a small number of conductors. The Minister for Finance in his Budget speech said: "The particularly difficult position in which many small passenger carrying concerns have been placed by the imposition and increase of the petrol tax and by the seating tax on omnibuses has been brought under my notice. I have had the situation carefully investigated, and I am satisfied that, unless some relief be afforded, many of these concerns will be driven out of business and many people thrown out of employment." He subsequently stated that 1,000 men would lose their employment unless relief were afforded. I do not believe that that is so. He then continued: "The Government could not permit such a position to arise and, accordingly, have decided to reduce the seating tax in the case of buses by 33? per cent. as from the end of the current year. This concession will cost about £23,000."

I contend that the policy and intention of the Minister is bound to fail and I do not think it is advisable for the present Government, especially in view of the promised transport legislation, to proceed any further in giving this concession to these bus companies until at any rate the definite pledge given by the Minister on 8th July last is carried out in the proper spirit and to the letter. I do not want on an occasion of this kind to talk about the merits and demerits of nationalisation. Later on a better opportunity will be afforded to Deputy McGilligan and others interested in the solution of the transport problem to deal with that matter. For that reason I am not going now to enter into a discussion of the nationalisation policy, into its merits or demerits.

Many members of this Party loudly applauded and supported Deputy McGilligan in his Shannon scheme policy which is still looked upon by the members of the Labour Party in this country as the greatest socialistic scheme ever carried out in this or any other small country. I do not see any difference between that and nationalisation except that you have a Board running the scheme not responsible to this House. Deputy McGilligan humorously talked about the failure of the Electricity Supply Board, forgetting the fact that Deputy Cosgrave and he were responsible for the selection of this Board, more especially Deputy Cosgrave. I would not suggest that the Railway Board should consist of men who would have no technical knowledge in the running of a railway.

The failure of the present policy of the board of directors of the railways is due to the fact that an overwhelming majority of these directors are men with no technical knowledge and these men with no technical knowledge of the running of a railway are dictating to men who have risen to the highest rank in the railway world as a result of their experience in railway work. Some of these directors would not know which end of a cabin to get into, but still they direct the working of the railways and make decisions on technical matters. These are the men who run, or perhaps I should say ruin, the railways. I hope that men of that class will not be put on any railway board that might be set up under a nationalisation policy.

I hope that the President will indicate to this House that the benefit of this financial concession will not be paid to bus companies who are not prepared to pay decent rates of wages and give decent conditions to their employees. I had an interview with the Minister for Finance on this matter and I was accompanied by two of my colleagues. I asked the Minister to let me know by what means he received the information which enabled him to say to the House that these small bus companies were on the verge of bankruptcy. I asked him to produce the balance sheet of some of the small companies. I did tell President de Valera—what Deputy McGilligan knows is a fact—that the method of working and carrying on business by some of these bus companies makes it impossible for them to produce a balance sheet. I have seen them carrying on where the fare is collected and no ticket issued. That kind of thing goes on wholesale as far as these small bus companies are concerned. I am satisfied that no proper balance sheet has ever been produced by these small companies.

Now to come to the railway companies and the I.O.C. I understand that the I.O.C., which was bought out of revenue provided by the Great Southern Railways Company, lost a sum of £70,000 last year. The shareholders of the Great Southern Railways will have to pay that loss and will also have to put up with the I.O.C. running buses parallel to the railways and stealing their traffic. That kind of suicidal policy cannot continue. Remember that this Party are prepared to give whatever experience they have acquired in helping the Fianna Fáil Government to bring before the House a transport measure which will help to put the whole transport system of the country into an economic position and preserve at the same time the great employment which the railways are giving to-day.

Comment on this

It seems to me that in considering the question of the concession to the bus companies there are three points that the Government have to establish. They have first to establish that the bus owners need the concession; next, that the bus owners deserve it and thirdly that it is in accordance with public policy. As regards deserving it we have had some interesting information from Deputy Davin who has told us the rates of pay paid to bus conductors. But something could be also said on the subject of the clerks and indoor employees. During the Trade Union Congress in Cork it was pointed out, I think, by Senator O'Farrell, that the clerks in the employment of the bus companies are getting normally £1 to 25/- a week and I understand that in many cases they are getting only 15/-. In one bus company the highest paid man in the office is getting £4 a week, one £3, and the rest from 30/- to 15/-with one or two exceptions.

Comment on this

Male or female?

Comment on this

Male clerks doing senior work are getting 15/- a week. The assistant accountant in one bus company who had been getting over £400 a year in the Ford business was only receiving 30/- a week and even then he was expected to do two men's work. Moreover, the clerks are not allowed to join trade unions. As against that the minimum salary for a railway clerk is £80 a year and at the age of 26 he goes to £210 a year without promotion.

There was a case quoted in the Seanad during the debate on this subject which deserves a little attention. It is a case that was heard in the Dublin District Court and it deals with a number of charges of driving buses at an excessive speed. This is the quotation taken from the Seanad debates:

Dealing with a number of charges of driving buses at an excessive speed, Mr. Little, D.J., in the Dublin District Court, said that in a case that came before him on Tuesday evidence was given that three boys, of about 17 years of age, were employed as cleaners by a Dublin bus company. They had to be out in the garage at 4 o'clock in the morning and they were paid 7/- a week.

"Of course, they stole something from the garage," commented the Justice. "That was only to be expected."

He wondered, however, how the railway company could possibly compete with that sort of thing. There was no common wage, age or skill limit, and the whole business was carried on in a ramshackle way.

The railway was becoming bankrupt, other people were becoming bankrupt, and soon they all would be bankrupt. When that happened they probably would turn around and say "Something has got to be done."

I just add these facts to what Deputy Davin has already told us about the merits of some of these bus companies as employers. Let us turn to the question of their needs. We were told the last time when the question was discussed here that unless this concession was given 1,000 men would be thrown out of work. I wonder if that estimate is persisted in? It was stated in the Seanad and not contradicted that the total bus employees in the Free State in the slack season was 2,500 and in the peak season 2,900. It, therefore, seems a very large order that 1,000 men should be thrown on the streets especially when you bear in mind that the largest bus owner is the railway company.

The railway company has not asked for this concession and has not threatened to throw anyone on the streets.

Comment on this

The I.O.C. employs 50 per cent. of the total bus employees in the country.

Comment on this

That means the railway-owned buses. We have not been told that the Dublin Tramways Company has threatened to dismiss anybody. If it has done so I have not heard of it. We have not been told that.

Comment on this

In fact, no serious effort has been made in this House to establish the case that the bus companies need this concession. No figures have been given to substantiate that claim. As Deputy Davin pointed out, we have had no balance sheets, and we have had no idea of how the figure of 1,000 men has been arrived at. This is a case where a great deal of explanation and proving ought to be called for. This Budget is imposing tremendous burdens upon everybody. Let us take the case of transport. We see the railways withering away under our eyes. One might say some tremendously strong case ought to be submitted to show that the bus companies need such a concession before it is given to them.

If some of the bus companies are on the verge of bankruptcy, I wonder why? I will take some of the figures quoted in the Seanad and not contradicted. They are to the effect that the bus services in the Free State in 1931 carried nearly 9,000,000 more passengers than in 1930 and over 12,500,000 passengers more than in 1929. It was also said in the Seanad and not contradicted that the receipts of bus companies were £94,000 more in 1931 than in 1930 and £133,000 more than in 1929. Therefore, it does look as if the road transport in itself was a flourishing and expanding business and one is naturally inclined to deduce from that that if some bus companies are doing badly it is their own fault and the result of mismanagement.

It was suggested a new situation was created by the tax on petrol. It was stated in the Seanad and not contradicted that the buses are not bearing the tax on petrol: that, owing to over-production of petrol all over the world, the price had not, in fact, increased substantially at all—only by ½d a gallon, and it is actually cheaper now than two years ago.

Comment on this

That was stated in the Seanad. It appears clear, however, that the cost of petrol has not increased by anything like the amount of tax. I suggest it is up to the Government to do a great deal more than they have hitherto done to establish the merits of this case, to show that the companies really deserve this extraordinarily generous treatment and, to show that they need it, and provided they conduct their business properly.

On the matter of general policy, it seems to me that it takes a lot of defending to introduce this Bill now. There is a comprehensive transport measure due and why should the situation be prejudiced any more than it is? To most of us the scales seem to be already weighted in favour of road transport as against rail transport. The road people seem to us to have the great balance of advantage and you are going further to increase that advantage by this concession. We are told the concession is purely temporary. Is it? What is meant by calling it temporary? There is nothing in the actual wording of the Finance Bill which shows it to be temporary; it appears to be as solid as it could be made. I know a comprehensive transport measure will be introduced and regulations can be made about rates of pay and other matters. Nevertheless, I do not think it is fair or accurate to call this a temporary concession. If it were temporary I should still consider it inadvisable, in view of the fact that a comprehensive Transport Bill will be introduced.

To any unprejudiced observer there seems to be no reason why the bus companies should not be called upon to take their chance until that measure is introduced. We have certainly not had the same softness of heart displayed in regard to other interests that might menace the Government with the possibility of dismissals of employees in large numbers. I doubt very much if the total dismissals that could arise, supposing the Government refused this concession, would have been as numerous as the total number of employees in Gallaher's factory. In any case, it is up to the Government to prove, what they have hitherto not attempted to prove so far as I have been able to see from the debates in this House and in the Seanad, that what they are doing is fair and equitable, or is called for by the needs of the situation, and that it will not prejudice, any more than it is already prejudiced, the permanent transport situation in this country.

Comment on this

I would not intervene were it not for the very interesting but amazing speech of Deputy Davin.

Comment on this

What is amazing about it?

Comment on this

It was interesting because of the Deputy's experience and technical training in the railway systems of this country and, in the circumstances, one would imagine that anything that he would have to say on a problem such as this would be worth listening to. His speech was amazing because of the fact that on one occasion when he could have been of positive service in this House—just a week or two ago when this subject was under consideration—he was absent from the Division Lobbies. I am wondering has he got the permission of his Party to raise this matter in the manner in which he raised it. I do not want to misquote, but I understood from Deputy Norton, the leader of the Labour Party, that certain assurances were given. I think the word "guarantees" was used.

Comment on this

Certain assurances, or guarantees, were given at an interview between representatives of the Labour Party and the members of the Executive Council.

Comment on this

Who told you?

Comment on this

That is the impression gathered both in this House and from paragraphs in the newspapers.

Comment on this

A "penny-a-liner."

Comment on this

Deputy Davin suggests that some "penny-a-liner" wrote these paragraphs. I know of very few "penny-a-liners" in the Dublin Press, and I think I know something about the Irish Press and the Dublin Press. These paragraphs appeared and were not contradicted either by the members of the Executive Council or by members of the Labour Party in this House. I feel that the difficulties shared by two Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party to-day, when they found themselves in the position that they could not vote according to their predilections, or feelings, or consciences, whichever word you wish to use, and had to make themselves vocal in the Dáil to explain their attitude in relation to another tax. I think Deputy Davin is in a somewhat similar position. Much though I want to see this Government continue in office, because I wish them to get a fair crack of the whip so that some of the things they stated they would do during the election will get a fair opportunity of being tried out——

Comment on this

How many times did you vote against them?

Comment on this

I shall do as I have done on election platforms, when I say to a disorderly interrupter, "When I am finished I will answer all your questions." Then I sometimes have to tell the fellow that if he does not shut up I will have to throw him out myself. I hope I will not have to do that with Deputy Davin. Deputy Davin has given us some figures relating to wages paid on the smaller buses operating in Dublin City and County. He has mentioned one company known as the Gem Line, which pays the very liberal wage of 21/- per week. That, I think, was the sum mentioned by Deputy Davin.

Comment on this

25/-.

Comment on this

25/- for the Gem Company. I suggest that Deputy Davin's song at the Labour Party Conference should be, "Shall I that Gem destroy?" I think I said previously in this House when discussing this question that I gave certain undertakings, not alone to railwaymen in Cork City, but to railwaymen outside Cork, that I would do anything that lay in my power to secure that at least the position as disclosed then, and that is some years ago, would not be worsened in so far as the position of the railway workers was concerned. I am not a railwayman and know very little about the working of the railway system, but Deputy Davin does know something. I have already paid him the tribute that he does know something about the operation of the railway system and the technique of railways in this country. I am concerned to elucidate if Deputy Davin has got the undertakings, or guarantees, suggested in these Press paragraphs that the railway system was to be looked into, that the conditions of these bus conductors and drivers was to be bettered in some way or another, or at least that they would not be worsened, and that those very low rates of pay which have been read out by Deputy Davin would no longer continue. The fact that the conditions are just as bad to-day as they were some months ago goes to show that these undertakings, or guarantees, have not materialised.

I feel that there is an aspect of the position which has not got the consideration of the Government, or if it has got any consideration it must have been very little. The multiplying of these small bus companies in the country is not for the good of the transport system. I feel, rightly or wrongly, that we are creating a number of small vested interests and if and when a system of nationalisation is introduced, if the Government thinks it is necessary—I am not saying it is necessary, but if the Government think it is necessary—I think they are doing a very injurious thing to their own policy, because these vested interests will have to be bought out. We had the spectacle in Dublin and in Cork in relation to these buses of a war of attrition between two or three small companies. We had a cut-throat policy carried on, one company operating against another, and vice versa, and lowering the fares until they were transporting passengers at a considerable loss to themselves. Everybody knew that that system could not continue. Here again we may have in Dublin and elsewhere a number of the smaller companies carrying on, with the subsidy now given to them by the Government, a war of attrition which in the end will be bad for the company and for the shareholders, and very bad indeed for those engaged as workers in these companies. If and when a system of nationalisation is put into operation by the Government, or if any other system of unification, let us say, for want of a better word, is proposed by the Government, I feel that they are building up very big obstacles indeed in the way of that policy, if they multiply these smaller companies. The greatest inducement is held out to smaller companies to multiply because of the reduction of this tax. As one who has given a promise to railwaymen to do nothing which will worsen their position, I do feel that this is in a positive way worsening the conditions of the railwaymen, because, as Deputy Davin suggested, these buses have stolen the cream of the traffic from the railway systems, namely, the passenger service, and the smaller parcel traffic.

Comment on this

There is only one matter I should like to refer to and that is the statement of Deputy Davin that licences have been given to bus owners paying 17/6 per week to conductors, contrary to the undertaking given by the Minister for Finance on July 8th. I only heard of that to-day. I have not had an opportunity of having the matter investigated.

I can promise that I shall see that the matter is investigated at once. I do not know how it could happen that such licences would be given. If there is no means of taking immediate action with respect to them, we shall certainly have an opportunity of dealing with them when the time for renewal of licences comes, which will be in October at latest.

Comment on this

Perhaps the vote can be taken without any statement from me —unless the House wants me to speak on the subject.

Comment on this

This is an important matter and should be discussed.

Comment on this

Somebody has said that if the devil were, perchance, to occupy the pulpit, he would make a far better case for himself than those whose professional duty it is to attack him are prepared to admit. That is very much the position so far as we are concerned. The way to assist the railways is not to attack the buses. The buses are portion of the transport system of the country. The railways are portion of the transport of the country and, so far as I can envisage it, these two, in some form of ordered co-operation, will continue to exist, and must continue to exist, side by side, performing a certain service. The business of the Government is to find that method by which the best use can be made of both in the interests of the community. That is the purpose which the Government has in relation to the transport legislation which it will introduce and which any fair-minded member of the House recognising the amount of work —wise or unwise—which the Government has had to do since it came into office, will admit it had not time to introduce yet. We are told that vested interests are being built up in these buses. These vested interests were built up before we came in. It is said that the number of buses is increasing. As a matter of fact, the number of bus companies is, rightly or wrongly, decreasing by amalgamation. Whether that is going to make the problem more difficult, or less difficult, is a matter of opinion. It has been suggested that no other industry has, in a moment of necessity, been relieved of tax or benefited by variation of a tax. That is not quite accurate. If you look back a bit, you will find a time when there was no tax on buses, as such. The late Minister for Finance went down the country and announced that there was going to be a tax of £100,000 put upon buses as part of a policy which he would not disclose. He said it was not as part of the policy of saving the small towns but that it was as part of policy and not merely as a matter of revenue. There, you had within our experience a tax of £100,000 put upon this form of transport. Outside that, you had the petrol tax. On the contrary, and following that, you had an announcement, preluded by a very excellent address by Deputy McGilligan as to the relief of £75,000 in rates on railways, with prohibition of appeal by any county council against that. Deputies will see that the position has not been allowed to remain static. There has been a £100,000 tax, and the petrol tax in respect of buses and there has been a £75,000 relief of rates upon railways as compensation.

There is another parallel case, as the House knows. That is in relation to race meetings. A very eloquent plea was made by a Deputy who sat about three seats above where I stand now. That appeal was made to the Minister for Finance at that time. It is well worth while for anybody who wants to speak of the moralities, or otherwise, of a tax to look up the speech of Deputy Blythe in which he gave way and relieved the racing industry of taxation, although he said there was no merit whatever in the application. Still he did it. We are not without precedent where industries are in difficulties——

Comment on this

I think the Parliamentary Secretary is in error. I think the Deputy stated that that remission was sought, so far as racing was concerned, because it would give an impetus to the horse-breeding industry.

Comment on this

I am not questioning that at all. I am not suggesting for a moment that there were no merits in the case. I am making the contention that there is a precedent for the relief by taxation of an industry which says it is in difficulties. It happened in this particular case that the Minister who did give the relief felt that there were no merits in the application when actually giving it.

The discussion on this particular recommendation was broadened by Deputy McGilligan to the widest possible point. One of the reasons why I did not make any protest against that was because I was very interested to hear what Deputy McGilligan would say on the subject and what Deputy Davin, with knowledge on the subject from another side, would say. I thought a broad discussion on the point would be valuable and I would like that, in this House or outside it, in some atmosphere in which we were not either defending or attacking buses and not having one industry or another industry in our mind, we could really come down and ask ourselves: what is the solution of the transport problem as a transport problem, as distinct from a mere matter of polemical discussion? The rather amazing speech which Deputy McGilligan made contained a good deal of material which is well worth consideration, because there are different points of view. This transport problem is not one of the things in respect of which one can lay down mathematical laws and say that this solution or that solution is the right one. Deputy McGilligan suggested that the railways should have for three years the absolute right to do what they liked.

Comment on this

The present Boards.

Comment on this

That did seem to me to be an amazing statement. I remember, four or five years ago, when this discussion was on before, saying that I was 100 per cent. railway, that I was anxious to see the whole transport system co-ordinated and that I would not object to its being co-ordinated under the control of the railway company if I were satisfied that the railway system was being run by people who had the broad interests of the community, as a whole, at heart. But that is a very different thing from saying that the railway companies should be allowed to do whatever they like for a period of two or three years. I do not want to misrepresent the Deputy, but we understood his attitude in relation to the transport problem, when we pointed out the growing danger and difficulty of a position which has now become acute, to be "let the dog-fight continue." If the suggestion is that the dog-fight should continue for another two years in the hope that the remnants and the wrecks will be more easily dealt with, I disagree. We do not want any such solution. We recognise that, at the end of ten years, the administration of the railways and the whole transport system is acute. We have had the statement of Deputy Davin that the directors of the Great Southern Railways are in conflict——

Comment on this

That is not exactly what I said. The majority of them have no technical knowledge of the running of a railway.

Comment on this

I was at a meeting of Cork shareholders at which statements made about the management of their railway would justify any anticipation of failure. We have had it stated, too, that all the bus companies are in the same state of chaotic management. The statement that the railways are being managed in that particular way does not furnish a case for going to the assistance of the railways. The statement that the buses are being badly managed is not a justification for going to the assistance of the buses. It merely shows that, after ten years of the growth of these two systems, things are very bad and want pulling together. The intention of the Minister for Industry and Commerce is, in the next session, to go into the whole question of the existing transport systems of the country and try and co-ordinate them. We recognise the position as it is and that position is being allowed to remain static until we are in a position to deal with it. You have to recognise the fact that the buses at present are carrying nearly 60,000,000 passengers. They have not taken those off the railways, because they were never there.

Comment on this

Yes, they were.

Comment on this

I am not saying this in any polemic spirit. I want to be fair.

Comment on this

Would you be surprised to know that in the suburban stations between Dublin and Bray, during the last seven months, 27,000 passengers have gone to the buses as compared with last year.

Comment on this

I would not be surprised but I cannot divide 60,000,000 into 24,000,000 and get unity. The total number of passengers carried on the whole railway system — the Great Southern and the Great Northern— has not been more than 24,000,000 since 1913 or 1914. That means that these people are now carrying for every passenger they took from the railways, if you assume they took them from the railways—I do not believe, and Deputy Davin does not believe, that all the passengers taken off the railways went to the buses——

Comment on this

Some went off the trams.

Comment on this

A huge number went off to private motor cars. It was the first-class passengers going off the railways that did the damage. If you take the total amount of traffic which the railways have lost, the buses are carrying fifteen extra passengers for every one they are supposed to have taken off the railways. The only plea I am putting to the House is to recognise the importance of these two great transport enterprises and to cooperate, so far as we possibly can, in a spirit which is not in any way partisan, with a view to seeing that we get the best solution of that complicated transport problem under the new Bill. The Minister for Finance is asking, after that £100,000 tax on buses and the 8d. petrol tax, also affecting buses, with the countervailing £75,000 of relief in rates given to the railways, that temporarily—until he is in a position to establish co-ordination upon some sound lines—a transport system which is to-day, with all its defects, carrying 58¾ million of our people, should have this relief.

Comment on this

I have rarely listened to a speech so inadequate to the points made as that which has just been delivered. The confession of the Parliamentary Secretary—which is, in fact, no argument to justify this remission— is that he is keeping the position static, to use his own words. He is not doing that. The status quo was the position with this tax on. He is reducing it. When he sought for his analogies, I was delighted to find that, in the last resort, he quoted one in respect of which the then Minister for Finance said there were no merits. I think the phrase could well be applied to this remission. There have been no merits urged for the remission. What are the other analogies? The imposition of taxation on buses and the remission of rating on railways—two matters on which arguments were advanced to this House and which were not flung at the House with the statement—an exaggerated statement as clearly shown by Deputy MacDermot—that so many men are going to be put out of employment if this remission is not granted. Further, we have the Parliamentary Secretary turning his whole attention, so far as transport is concerned, to passengers. I think that anybody with any appreciation of the transport situation in the country knows that the passenger side is not the important side and that it is not on the passenger side the railways are losing. It is not from the passenger side, at all events, that their destruction is going to come and, certainly, it would not be from the passenger side their destruction would come if the administrative policy contained in the last two Bills had been carried out as then announced. When the latter of these measures was introduced, the comments made from all parts of the House —by railway shareholders and railway directors—and by the Press were that, so far as the passenger situation was concerned, the Bills had done all that could be expected. There was unanimity on that. Where it was alleged they failed was on the goods side.

Comment on this

The lorries.

Comment on this

This proposal deals only with buses and look at the way it deals with them. To keep the position static, we are to give a remission of taxation. We are told that that is because there is a transport measure in the offing. Surely that is the very reason why we should keep the position as we find it unless a good case can be made against it. We are told, further, that this proposal is based, in its entirety, on the probable, or possible, loss of employment to 1,000 men. One thousand is a ludicrous figure. We are told that 1,000 men might be put out of employment on the passenger-carrying side of the road vehicles if this were not done. That is a ludicrous figure to those who know the number of persons employed on the passenger side of the road transport system. It is particularly ludicrous to those who know the numbers employed by the three main road auxiliaries. These three companies have not, so far as I am aware, threatened to dismiss any of their men or, if they have, it is because the administrative policy outlined in the last two Bills has not been carried out. We were told that 1,000 men were likely to be put out of work. During the discussion, that figure was reduced somewhat. There was talk of hundreds as a possibility. We must talk in hundreds and not in thousands.

Take the other side. We are to remit £23,000 or £25,000 of taxation this year. That money used to go into the Road Fund. It will not go into the Road Fund this year. How was the money spent when it did go into the Road Fund? In the remaking of roads, the maintenance of roads and the making of new roads. Let us take 30/- per week as the average wage paid to an employee and let us take it that this £23,000 remission is going to keep men in employment who otherwise would have to leave this transport agency—about 300 men at 30/- per week. Is 30/- a week the ordinary wage paid to those who are engaged in the maintenance and making of the roads in the country? If it is, does this not mean that 300 men are this year going to be taken off road work?

Comment on this

If not, where is the £23,000 to be got?

Comment on this

There is an extra million pounds going to the roads.

Comment on this

An extra million which is only a forestalling of other spending. What we are going to do this year is: bring in for payment to men employed on the roads a certain amount of money which, in the ordinary course of events, would be spread over four, five or six years. That is a proper thing to do when roads have gone out of repair and when you want them overhauled. Will the Parliamentary Secretary argue that that is the position at the moment. No man used be more eloquent about the "velvet roads" of this country. He complained that, driving at fifty miles an hour, he was passed by buses which could travel at a greater speed because of the velvet roads. Yet, we are to bring in £1,000,000 as a forestalment of spending which ought to be done over four or five years. As far as this £23,000 is concerned that must be taken as an item in itself. If that £23,000 is to be given to the bus owners to keep 300 men in employment, if it goes in wages, then, in so far as it disappears from the Road Fund, it means that 300 men who are employed on the roads are going to lose their employment. They may be substituted by the other men, but, so far as I am concerned, it cuts both ways.

There is a Transport Bill in the offing we are told; we must keep things static, but surely we are not doing that. We are making a change when we are told the position should be kept as it is and that a Transport Bill is in the offing. Most people who talk of transport and look forward to transport legislation have their position clearly revealed from those who look forward to legislation which will mean the dismissal of a certain number of the buses from the roads. We are told there are too many agencies employed in transport at the present moment. Sometimes the phrase is used by downhearted people in order to hide the obvious result of disemployment. We are told there is going to be regulation and co-ordination. I have not made enquiry in any way, but I hold that that will give us better transportation so that if there is to be transport co-ordination opposition will disappear or alternately the railway system is going to be weakened. Supposing that is the position that will stand. We have buses at certain points, at the moment, earning something. Some people say most of them are bankrupt, that they are not making any profit. Others say they are, but their accounts are kept in such a lax fashion that the profits cannot be discovered. At any rate there is this: We are handing them back a sum of £23,000. They will have its use and experience for three, seven or eight years before transport will be adequate. Do we not enhance the price of buses that will have to be bought off the roads, and do we not make it more difficult if we are knocking off any company for those that will have to remain? Do we not make it more difficult for the surviving agencies to meet the expenses of getting the others off the road. That is the situation, as it stands at the moment when we are told that a Transport Bill is in the offing and calls to us. Deputy Davin talked about the general transport situation as affecting the railways, and he made the astounding statement that, after a certain number of years 4,300 men, previously employed in the permanent way, were forced out——

Comment on this

No, I said that 5,480 men were forced out and I did not say they were employed in the permanent way.

Comment on this

No, not employed in the permanent way but people who regarded themselves as in permanent occupation.

Comment on this

That is quite right.

Comment on this

He said that these people were not paid the compensation to which they were entitled under the 1924 Act. That is entirely nonsense. The Deputy himself knows that there was more controversy over the compensation to be paid under the 1924 and 1926 Act than on any other point of railway work or management. And he knows further that I met the trade unions and agreed with them on a certain model case and agreed further with them that if this model case presented to the railway arbitrator did not get the compensation to which we agreed they were entitled then the Act would have to be amended.

Comment on this

Was not that prejudicial to the men.

Comment on this

I said that under the 1926 Act we would agree that certain cases should be put before the arbitrator and if he found himself coerced against that we would bring in an amending Act. And by implication I understood the railway unions to agree also. A case went before the arbitrator and compensation was given and under these circumstances to say that there were three or four thousand people thrown out of employment and got no compensation to which they were entitled is mere rubbish.

Comment on this

I said under the original Act of 1924.

Comment on this

The only two points under which that was amended were that a man was not going to get two kinds of compensation—superannuation from the fund, and compensation from the Railway Board—and consequently that the burden of proof was increased upon the employee. The second point on which I was approached by the union and on which we hammered out agreement eventuated in compensation being given.

Comment on this

What about the words "for economy causes"?

Comment on this

These were the words upon which the case turned and the arbitrator found himself coerced to give compensation. After these words were introduced we had our test case and the union never again approached me about the matter.

Comment on this

Because it was hopeless or useless.

Comment on this

Though all the facts of the case went to them. We agreed upon a certain case—upon half a dozen cases. These were presented to the arbitrator and we awaited the issue. I agreed these were cases for arbitration. It does not follow that the Act is bad.

Comment on this

I suggest, a Chinn Comhairle, that the debate is getting wide of the issue.

Comment on this

I am only following the point made by Deputy Davin in answering some of Deputy Moore's objections. We are told that there are a certain number of people out of employment who previously regarded themselves as permanent owing to certain Railway Acts and that these Railway Acts changed and the railway situation changed.

Comment on this

Do you deny that these people were permanent?

Comment on this

I am not denying that. The railway employee generally looks upon himself as permanent.

Comment on this

With the consent of the company.

Comment on this

In ordinary times railway employment is permanent. At one time people employed on the old stage coaches were regarded as permanent but in the course of time they were beaten by the railway and now the railways find themselves up against the motor vehicles.

Comment on this

That is a good comparison.

Comment on this

It is a good comparison. You cannot close down the wheels of progress.

Comment on this

The same as employment in the service.

Comment on this

I do not see how that is appropriate. There must be reaction to the changed situation in the transport world. We are told it is coming. But I object, and Deputy Davin objects, to what is being done here. We are told that a decision has been taken where a remission of £23,000 is to be given to the owners of road vehicles without any case having been made for it.

May I return now to where I started. I understand, and I state here, for contradiction or agreement, that the last Bill as introduced so far as passenger traffic was concerned on the administration as announced, would have put an end to passenger traffic. I was driven to this conclusion between the different transport agencies. It is not coming in any case to be a new policy. The new policy has been to diffuse traffic over all agencies. A bus owner here or there may pay scandalous wages or they may be single man concerns, and cannot give the proper service required. But as far as transport stages or concerns go, the last Bills were intended to meet the situation and would have with proper administration. This is a new situation in which a remission of £23,000 is given. The railways stood on one side, they were not coming in, they had their agreement though as far as the passenger was concerned the Bill if administered properly would give them what they wanted. They are still left with a grievance about goods. They have a new grievance about passengers and £23,000 is thrown mainly to their competitors and mainly because they do not want it.

Comment on this

It is not mainly to their competitors.

Comment on this

The benefit is mainly for their competitors. The remission of money is the same to all companies.

Comment on this

And half of it going into their own pockets.

Comment on this

Obviously, if you give a man £1 as £1,000, and if you give a man £1 as 5/-, the £1 has a difference in each case. The remission is mainly to the competitors of the three companies. At any rate, put it to the test—ask the three companies do they want it or would they prefer to see this remission not given and let us have a vote on that, guided by the three companies. I do not think there will be much difficulty in getting a statement from them that they would prefer not to see Section 29 in this Bill.

Comment on this

Naturally.

Comment on this

Naturally; they must have some reason and the only reason is that they believe that this is for the benefit of their competitors.

Comment on this

The fact remains that it is not mainly given to their competitors.

Comment on this

The fact remains that the benefit that accrues from it is mainly for their competitors. It is the same amount of money, if the Parliamentary Secretary likes to put it that way, but it is more needed by the smaller bus companies than the larger. The others are prepared to do without it. There is the transport situation as we now find it—the passenger side that was supposed to have been advanced, now worse than before because the programme is different to what was outlined, and, secondly, because of this remission, and, on the goods side, we have no advance at all. In fact, so far as the Parliamentary Secretary is concerned here to-day, he does not even give us a hint that the matter is being considered. All he put forward was the plea that the Government had so much work to do, all it has done in the last few months, that they could not have attended to the transport business. If they could not have attended to it, they might at least have left it as they found it. If we are going to have a plea made for keeping the status quo, let it be recognised that it is not being kept. This is making a change and it is because it is making a change that objection is being raised at the moment.

There is one last point. Deputy Davin raised the question of the analogy of the Electricity Board, and, from that, went on to criticism of railway directorates. I say that the analogy with the E.S.B. does not hold. The Deputy himself knows, because he was in the House at the time, that the Shannon scheme would never have been capitalised privately. It had to be done under State auspices or not at all. The Deputy knows further, that, owing to circumstances surrounding the growth of electricity, it had always been looked on as a service that lent itself to municipal management and control. What has happened with regard to the E.S.B. is that you have changed the municipal ownership, or municipal trusteeship, into national ownership or trusteeship. The circumstances were entirely different with regard to electricity and transport. We find transport in the hands of private agents, as it has always been.

Comment on this

What was the Electricity Department that was taken over in Cork?

Comment on this

There were a few private companies, but, in the main, they were municipally owned.

Comment on this

Confiscation!

Comment on this

Confiscation? I remember when that point was being argued——

Comment on this

Might I suggest to the Deputy that we should not widen the discussion too far.

Comment on this

The point has been raised again and the analogy cannot be made. On the question of directorates, the Deputy has declared that all that is wrong with railway management is that a very big number of those on the directorates do not know anything about technical railway business. What are we faced with, and what does the Deputy look forward to with equanimity?—the programme outlined by the Parliamentary Secretary, that we are going to have these transport agencies as they are run at the moment, with directorates mainly of men who do not know anything about the technical side of railways, and, quite properly, do not know anything about it, and this House, which certainly cannot say that it knows anything about the technical side of railways, are going to be asked by the Government in the autumn, or some time, to look at the whole transport situation, and to say whether we are going to have another body without any knowledge of the technicalities of railway working, sitting upon the railway directors and deciding whether they are to be allowed to continue in their posts, or whether we, in our lay wisdom, and ignorant of the technicalities of railway working are going to establish some new system.

Comment on this

Who said that?

Comment on this

That is what is suggested. Is this House going to consider transport?

Comment on this

Will one matter which it has to consider be whether private ownership, with directors as at the moment, is to be continued, or whether there is to be some change? We are going to have two bodies sitting on this business. Does the Deputy believe that railway managers ought to be technical? Does not the system work excellently elsewhere, the same system as we have here, the system of men who have a good outlook of a business type, who know accounting and the general lines of policy? They take their technical advice from their technical people and they rely on it. Surely that is the system that prevails in the main and why should we get away from it? Because of what? Because the railways are suffering? Does that mean every industry that suffers from world circumstances must be adjudged to be bankrupt in management? Would you say that the coffee industry in Brazil has been badly managed because it is suffering at the moment, or that the nitrate, or silver industries in South America were badly managed, because they are now in difficulties because of world circumstances? We should hesitate before passing judgment in that casual way on people who have done good work in railway management up to the time they met with circumstances entirely outside their control. We find ourselves faced with this recommendation from the Seanad, abolishing Section 29, and the only defence made for Section 29 is that made by the Parliamentary Secretary, that we should preserve the existing position. My answer is a simple one—we are not preserving the existing position. What the House is mainly pleading for is a preservation of the existing position until such time as a transport policy is properly thought out and brought before the House and that is the issue contained in the recommendation from the Seanad.

Comment on this

I was very glad to hear the promise made by the Parliamentary Secretary that legislation would be brought in in the near future to bring about an altered condition in respect of the transport facilities in this country. Quite recently, I attended in my constituency two meetings brought about by the threatened closing down of branch lines of the Great Southern Railways Company. At one of these, a representative of the railway company pointed out that, in the last four years, 3,000 employees had been dismissed but that 12,000 remained. Of these 2,000 were in County Cork and were paid annually £300,000 in wages. The company's revenue for 1931 showed a decrease of £330,000 and, for 1932 to date, there was a further decrease of £150,000. In 1911, they paid a dividend of only 10/- per cent. and they were now approaching the position of being unable to make any return to the shareholders. That condition of affairs exists at present and is likely to be intensified if further facilities are given to competing methods of transport. It must be apparent to everybody in this country who has any knowledge of economic conditions at all that if anything occurs to bring about the breaking down of the railway facilities in this country for the carriage of cattle or heavy goods, we will practically be reduced to the position that existed 100 years ago.

Once we lose the facilities which we enjoy our last stage is very much worse than the first. You are striking a blow by reducing taxation on the buses against a company that gives ordered and regular conditions of employment and in favour of irregular conditions of employment for other employees of transport systems. I feel that it will be a national calamity if there is not in the immediate future an effort made to preserve what is absolutely necessary for us to carry on the economic conditions which govern agriculture in this country. There is a very serious menace to the taxpayer by the increased traffic which is on the roads. In the parish in which I reside, in a line running from Cork to Ballycotton, there are about 24 single journeys of buses by two companies competing with each other and chasing each other on the road to catch whatever traffic exists. It is very advisable that buses should be given an opportunity of opening remote parts of the country, but they should not be allowed to cut up roads that were not made to carry these heavy buses. The contributions which the owners of these vehicles make are in no way adequate to maintain the roads over which they run. The cost of road keeping is becoming more and more appalling. We have the very finest roads in the country, so far as they have been built up during the past nine or ten years, and very high praise must be given to those who had charge of that particular side of the administration. I have heard visitors to this country who have motored over those roads speak in the highest words of commendation of the roads that have been built up, but you are simply carrying on a method of transport over them which is a menace to the work that has been carried on and which will undoubtedly pull down whatever work we have done.

I feel, having regard to the enormous amount of employment that is given by the railways and to the very large vested interests at stake, that legislation in the near future is absolutely imperative and I certainly welcome the news that such is contemplated. Whatever slight disappointment may take place with regard to buses that are not able to take on, it is simply pandering to inefficiency to reduce the taxes which they are called upon to pay. I certainly support the recommendation.

Comment on this

There is one aspect of this question, with regard to the further closing down of branch lines, which I am afraid has been lost sight of and it is a matter which concerns the Labour Party very much. If the railway companies are permitted to close down certain branch lines they may substitute the railway services by buses which under the new conditions they can run very cheaply, particularly when we hear that 30/- a week is accepted as a good trade union wage, and in that way the men who enjoy legislative conditions at the present time will be put out of work, and a number of organised workers will be disemployed if it is allowed to go on. I put it to the Parliamentary Secretary that that is an aspect that ought not to be lost sight of. Whether it is a matter that must wait for the new Transport Bill I do not know. I think it is a question of serious importance from the point of view of labour. In the years that have elapsed since the amalgamation of these lines more than one-quarter of the total number of employees of the railways have found themselves out of work. In the last few months the position has become more serious than ever. I do not say deliberately that the growth in the gravity of the situation has synchronised with the advent of the pro-railway Party to power. But it is very significant and we must face the facts that since the accession of the Fianna Fáil Party to power there has been an alarming decline in railway traffic and increased disemployment. There was a horrible expression used here the last day, something about political bribery. I do not think it has been sufficiently explained. I saw that the Parliamentary Secretary in the Seanad said that there was no truth in the assertion. The Seanad accepted the explanation. I am sure everybody else would, too. At the same time, there was some reference to the fact that during the last election these small buses conveyed Fianna Fáil voters to the polls, to the exclusion of the supporters of every other Party. It is a suggestion that has not been clearly explained.

I do not want to waste the time of the House in referring to the bankruptcy of policy of the pro-railway Party. Deputy Norton, on the last day on which we discussed the matter, used a very sonorous and ponderous expression in regard to this matter. He lashed himself into a heated protest against the conditions prevailing in these services, but still Deputy Norton walked into the Division Lobby to vote for this section in the Bill. A nice bit of play-acting went on. He asked for an understanding from the Minister for Finance. They bowed to each other. It was a very nice bit of acting. In the intervals Senator Johnson appeared in the House; perhaps he had intervened—I do not know—but I think it is a matter that ought to be brought to the issue to-night. I ask the Labour Party, are they going to vote for a bankrupt railway policy or are they going to make a show of protest in support of the Trade Union members that they are supposed to stand for?

Comment on this

I do not want to add very much to this debate, except to refer to certain matters which were discussed on the last day. Deputy O'Neill wants the Labour Party to make up its mind as to what it is going to do in connection with transport matters. Long before Deputy O'Neill took an interest——

Comment on this

Not transport. This particular matter under discussion is the remission of taxes.

Comment on this

If Deputy O'Neill will read the speeches that were delivered from the Labour Benches on the last day and if he will read the division lists he will see perfectly clearly what the Labour Party did on that occasion. If there is any one thing that it is easy to make up one's mind about it is this particular matter and it is rather late in the day for Deputy O'Neill and his Party to display an interest in transport problems and in the conditions of railway employees because during the years that Deputy O'Neill's Party was in office—during the years that they sat on these benches—we had the spectacle of the railways and of the road services getting into a hopelessly tangled condition. The failure of the ex-Minister for Industry and Commerce to take any effective steps to regulate the transport services, both rail and road, in a large measure has produced the difficulties that the railway companies are experiencing to-day. During the past ten years—this may be news to Deputy O'Neill—over 5,000 railwaymen have been driven out of their employment on the railways. Why did not Deputy O'Neill and his Party who are so much concerned about the condition of the railway employees and who make frequent allusions to the duties of the Labour Party stand up on those benches and protest against the failure of the ex-Minister for Industry and Commerce to take effective steps to regulate the transport system.

Comment on this

I was not on the benches then.

Comment on this

There were other Deputies here and we know that not a member of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party did during the past ten years any of the things on behalf of the railway employees that Deputy O'Neill wants us to believe he is genuinely concerned about doing to-day. I do not believe that there is any sincerity in any of the speeches or in any of the tears that have been shed from the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches about their concern for the railway employees.

On the last occasion when this Bill was being discussed in Committee Deputy Cosgrave made a speech and it is worth adverting to the speech. Referring to this particular matter Deputy Cosgrave at the conclusion of his speech said according to the Official Reports of the 8th July, Col. 529:

I say no one is going to vote against this but it is a bad method of solving the problem if there is a problem to be solved.

On the Committee Stage of the Finance Bill Deputy Cosgrave was not going to vote against the remission, but Deputy Cosgrave with his usual Parliamentary skill thought that he had the Labour Party in a difficulty and after making the declaration that no one was going to vote against this, which of course meant that Deputy Cosgrave was not going to vote against it, he proceeded to take advantage of certain circumstances in order to vote against this. Of course his vote on that occasion was just like Deputy O'Neill's speech here this evening, playing to the gallery, shedding crocodile tears for the railwaymen, 5,000 of whom were marched out of the railway service during Deputy McGilligan's period of office. I say that altogether in selfdefence and in answer to some of the ill-informed criticism that has come from the Cumann na nGaedheal Benches.

I want to say further in connection with this proposition that we do not look with enthusiasm on this proposal to remit the taxation on buses. While one can overlook many things done in a hurry, I regret that the whole Executive Council should have deliberately gone down before this clamour on behalf of the bus companies. The Minister for Finance on the last day said that he believed 1,000 people were likely to lose their employment unless this were done. The Minister who would believe that in existing circumstances would believe almost anything. I did not believe and I do not believe there is any more chance of 1,000 people losing their employment in the bus services this year than there was last year. That was the attitude of the Minister and I think it is a very unwise attitude indeed. I think at the same time that the Minister might have found a better case to justify this proposal than the plea that 1,000 people might lose their livelihood. I do not believe they would have lost their livelihood.

Our main concern in connection with this matter is to see that this remission of £23,000 should not be used as a means of subsidising companies who pay scandalously low wages and whose employees have to work long hours. On the last day I asked the Minister for Finance for an assurance that when issuing licences under the Transport Act he would not allow bus companies to ply for hire if the employees of these companies were paid low rates of wages or worked long hours, and the Minister for Finance gave a very definite assurance that, so far as he could speak for the Minister for Industry and Commerce, he had no hesitation in giving that undertaking. It was given very definitely and very explicitly and there was no haste about it so far as one could judge. What do we find happening in the meantime? I have got some information to the effect that these bus companies have got licences under the new Act and the employees of these bus companies are being paid rates of wages which are not only scandalously low rates but reflect upon all decent Christian conditions of labour. That has been done notwithstanding the very explicit assurance given to me. I think if assurances are going to be given in that manner then these assurances must be kept. While I did not hear the opening statements of the Parliamentary Secretary in connection with the matter, I do want to ask this question very definitely: Is this assurance going to be honoured? Are we going to take it that it is the policy of the Government not to issue licences to bus companies plying for hire if the wages paid by these companies are scandalously low wages and if the hours and conditions of labour generally are inhuman conditions of labour?

The other matter, of course, which has been introduced into the debate is the general question of the transport problem of the country as a whole. I believe that in the short time which the Government had at their disposal, it was not possible to deal with the matter in a comprehensive way or to deal with it in the way in which the Labour Party believes it can only be dealt with effectively. The example of having Deputy McGilligan ten years in office and doing nothing for these ten years is a very bad headline so far as the present Government is concerned. I would appeal to the President that there is a railway problem and a transport problem in the country. Both problems are inter-related. One problem cannot be solved except by co-ordination with the other. The problem has been allowed to drag on for many years. The transport services of the country to-day are in a chaotic condition. There is an enormous amount of wasteful cut-throat competition going on. Unless that competition is ended and some effort made to introduce ordered regulation into the present backward condition of the transport industry, then the prospect before that industry is going to be a very dismal one indeed.

I put it to the President that this is a matter of very vital importance not merely to the transport services but to the industry of the country as a whole. One cannot conceive an efficient industrial position unless one has an efficient transport system. Our transport services and our communications are the handmaidens of our agricultural and industrial position. Something must be done and done quickly to introduce order and regularity in our transport services. I would earnestly appeal to the President to give the House the assurance that he regards the regulation of the transport problem, which is the problem of the road services and the rail services, as an important problem and as one which will be tackled by the Government during the Recess so that the Dáil may be presented with proposals for legislation in the autumn which will put the transport services of the country on something like an ordered basis.

Comment on this

Might I intervene just for a moment? I quoted some figures when speaking earlier in the discussion showing the returns of bus companies for the years 1929, 1930 and 1931. I said that I took these figures from the reports of the Seanad debates. I just want to say now that I have ascertained that the figures were taken from the official records of the Department of Industry and Commerce as published in the Trade Journal in March. Might I also say that I discovered another statement in the Seanad debates which was not contradicted, that the results of the working of the bus companies during the first six months of 1932 showed that they earned record profits? I do not know where that information was taken from but I know that statement was made in the Seanad and was not contradicted.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Parliamentary Secretary a question which he did not answer in his reply? Might I ask whether the Minister for Finance before he took this decision and before his colleagues in the Executive Council agreed to it, had presented to them for their consideration and examination, the balance sheet and figures of the bus companies, to prove the financial position of the companies who are getting this concession? Was that done?

Comment on this

I cannot answer that directly but I do know that the Minister for Finance has stated here that he was aware from the figures of the financial position of the companies and that certain of them were not in a position to pay the tax which was then due. I cannot answer the question explicitly, but if the Deputy wishes it I will go into the matter and find out for him.

Comment on this

I submit that a concession of this kind given on a day when the Minister was putting his hands in the pockets of every class of taxpayer could not be done with a proper idea of the financial position.

Comment on this

He did not do it without a full and complete examination.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied that some of the smaller bus companies could not present a proper balance sheet to any Minister or Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

Are we to understand that the Minister for Finance took a decision on a matter of such importance without consulting the Executive Council?

Comment on this

No, the Executive Council would be consulted. I am anxious to avoid controversial statements in this matter. I do not want to get into a controversy, and if I alluded to anything that has been said it was certainly not in a controversial spirit. Deputy McGilligan misunderstood the measure when he thought that we were spending money on the same kind of roads as he spent money on. Some £6,000,000 of the State moneys were spent on what they called a State road system which was a duplication of the fan which has its handle in Dublin and of which all the roads stretch out over the country parallel to every railway in Ireland. That money was spent on duplicating the road transport system by a method which enabled it to be used as a direct competitor with the railways. The money which we are spending on roads this time, with very great difficulty I may say that we are keeping off that method. We are using the money, as far as is humanly possible, on the county roads for the purpose of being feeders to the central system as opposed to competitors with the central system. The whole object is, if the railway system is to remain as a backbone, then the roads must be used as feeders to that backbone. Frankly, I did not understand the amazing argument of Deputy McGilligan in relation to this House as a body to consider the subject of transport. The suggestion seems to be that this House was incompetent to deal with the matter: how could we here attempt to envisage the transport system as a whole? That may be so, but if it is so, then the whole democratic principle of Government breaks down. Ex hypothesi we are as competent or incompetent in relation to specialised items such as transport as in relation to other things. Another extraordinary thing was the statement of Deputy MacDermot to the effect that any statement made in the Seanad and not contradicted becomes the truth. Really, there is a limit on the Senatorial licence which we are prepared to submit to.

Comment on this

Does the Parliamentary Secretary contradict anything I have said?

Comment on this

I do not accept as necessarily correct a Senatorial statement as correct because somebody did not contradict it.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Even when it is made by the Labour Party?

Comment on this

Even by the Independent Party.

Comment on this

And even in face of the statistics of the Department of Industry and Commerce?

Comment on this

Yes, even so. If Deputy Norton had been here at an earlier stage he would have found that I made his speech and that the part of his speech that I did not make, Deputy Davin had already made. It may be a shock to him to know that.

Comment on this

I want somebody to act the speech—not to make it.

Comment on this

If Deputy Norton had been in he would have found that the assurance previously given had been repeated and that everything that it is humanly possible to do will be done to carry out these assurances.

Comment on this

That is, that they will not be allowed to ply for hire if there are low wages and the workmen have to work under bad conditions?

Comment on this

That is the policy of the Government. In every case we will try to carry out the assurance.

Comment on this

Can I have an assurance then that, to the extent that that policy has miscarried in the issuing of licences, it will be righted?

Comment on this

How will it be put right?

Comment on this

Will the Parliamentary Secretary say why the Department concerned did not take the proper steps to get the information from the bus companies who were looking for licences regarding their conditions of labour?

Comment on this

I should like to know have any wages been raised or conditions been improved?

Comment on this

How, if a licence has been issued, is it proposed to withdraw it?

Comment on this
Division

The Committee divided:, Tá,

Tá 64
·
Níl 52
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move: That the Committee agree with the Seanad in Recommendation No. 6:

Section 42. After the word "shall" in line 5, to insert the words and figures "as from the 12th day of May, 1932."

Agreed.

Comment on this

I move: That the Committee do not agree with the Seanad in Recommendation No. 7:

First Schedule. To delete Ref. No. 5, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 and 4.

This recommendation deals with the import of metal door frames. It is recommended that these should be free from import duty and we are unable to advise the Committee to accept that recommendation.

Comment on this

I move: That the Committee agree with the Seanad in Recommendation No. 8:

First Schedule. Ref. No. 16. Second column. After the word "catalogues" in paragraph (e) to insert in brackets the words "(other than catalogues consisting only of samples of wall-paper)."

This refers to the import of catalogues of wall-paper.

Comment on this

Will the Parliamentary Secretary explain? We cannot hear him here.

Comment on this

I am sorry. The recommendation was that sample books of wall-paper should be permitted in free of duty. We are accepting that recommendation.

Comment on this

I move: That the Committee do not agree with the Seanad in Recommendation No. 9:

First Schedule. To delete Ref. 21, including relevant references in columns 2, 3 and 4.

This refers to superphosphates, and we are unable to accept it. The Seanad recommends that superphosphates should not be taxed. We are unable to recommend the Committee to accept that.

Comment on this

Does that apply to superphosphates purely? Does it take in ground phosphates?

Comment on this

Ground rock phosphates or manufactured phosphates. It does not refer to the raw material phosphates unground; they are already free.

Comment on this

I understand this recommendation is being accepted?

Comment on this

No, it is not.

Comment on this

It is very difficult to hear the Parliamentary Secretary. Are you rejecting it?

Comment on this

I will put it more clearly. The Finance Bill set out that phosphates as a raw material would be admitted free, but superphosphates and ground phosphates would be subject to a tax. The Seanad recommended that superphosphates should be free of duty. We are unable to recommend to the House that they should accept that.

Comment on this

I submit to the House that the Seanad acted wisely in making this suggestion that superphosphates coming into this country should not be taxed. There can be no question about it that if superphosphates are taxed the farmer will have to bear the entire amount of the duty. It is a matter of common knowledge that manure manufacturers are comparatively few in number, that they are able to make a ring and that they are able to put any price upon phosphates, indeed upon any class of artificial manure. Between manure manufacturers in this country there is, for practical purposes, no competition. The only thing which can keep the price of superphosphates or, indeed, any other class of manure, from soaring is the existence of external competition.

I think it is of general knowledge amongst farmers that there was a very strong manure ring in this country some years ago, and that that manure ring was only broken down at the time co-operative societies were started. One particular firm manufactured for co-operative societies, the other firms refusing to do so. The co-operative societies, being able to sell manure at a cheaper rate than was being demanded elsewhere, succeeded in bringing down the price of manures for their customers. Through rivalry with other retailers, they succeeded in bringing down the price of manure to reasonable limits. I am talking now of what happened some 30 years ago, or thereabouts. Now, if you have only one or two firms in this country, there is nothing to prevent them putting up the price of superphosphates to any figure they like which will enable them to sell upon the same terms as the foreign or external manures can be sold.

This is a tax which, essentially, will fall upon the consumer. I do not think anything can be more unfair to the farming community of the State, especially the small farmers, than to put a tax upon a thing which is absolutely necessary for the correct carrying on of their business. There is no artificial manure so neccessary to the ordinary farmer as superphosphate. Superphosphate is really a key manure. You may have nitrogenous manures, and they are of a useful character, and potash manures are useful on different sorts of land, but superphosphate is required for every crop on every class of land. The only alternative which you have to superphosphate, the only other manure which will give you phosphates to a considerable extent, is basic slag. That, though not really a manure, is suitable for all classes of crops on all classes of land.

When the Government have been putting up steadily the cost of living, when they have been killing the markets for the farmers, when they have been putting the unfortunate agricultural community into a condition worse than the agricultural community has been in within living memory, that is scarcely the time in which the Government would be justified, nor would this House be justified, in adding an extra burden. We had a debate here before upon superphosphates. We heard no arguments put forward and no real excuse put forward for the imposition of this tax. It is a perfectly wrong tax, and it is a tax which, if imposed by this House, will do a very considerable amount of injury to the Irish farmer. Not only will it impoverish the Irish farmer, who will pay the extra tax if he buys manures, but it will prevent great numbers of farmers from giving to the land the manure that the land needs.

You can do nothing worse at a time like this, when the agricultural community is going through a period of stress and hardship, largely through the action of the Government and its supporters. Nothing can be worse than to force, as you practically are forcing, the agricultural community to waste their land, to let their land run down. If they are not able adequately to manure their land, their land must run down. If you allow land to run down, it will take years to pull that land round again. It is very easy to run land down, but it is very difficult indeed, and will require a very big capital expenditure, to make land which has once run down fertile again. I cannot for my part see what reason can have prompted the present administration to impose this very unfair tax. It is very unfair to the farming community and to agriculturists of every kind. Every single one of the farming community is hit by the imposition of a tax of this nature. This is a time in which, instead of adding to the burdens of the agricultural community, it should be the duty of the Government to come forward and help them. I should have imagined that if the Government wished to deal with this question of manures at all they would deal with it in a completely different fashion; that there should rather be a bounty to the person purchasing manures than a tax upon manures which cripples his power to purchase and, in consequence, compels him to impoverish his land and to get less return than he ought to get from his labour. I say less return than he ought to get, because if he works and tills a soil inadequately manured the return which he gets will not be commensurate with the efforts he makes to produce his crop. A tillage farmer cannot farm without superphosphates. They are a necessity. By putting this tax on superphosphates, by cutting down, in consequence, the consumption of superphosphates in this country, you are doing a considerable amount of harm to the agricultural interest and to the tillage interest in the State.

We have been told by the Parliamentary Secretary that the Government will insist on the imposition of this tax. It does not surprise me in the least. It is what I expected. It is perfectly obvious that this is a Government which takes no interest in agriculture, or the agricultural community: that this is a Government which does not care whether a man upon the land lives or dies, flourishes or starves. That is perfectly obviously the policy of the Government, because it is the policy which they have shown through every single one of the taxes which they are imposing upon the agricultural community. Therefore, it has not come as a surprise to me that they are persisting in the imposition of this duty. It is very little use, therefore, to point out to them the injury they are doing, because it is plain they do not care whether they injure or whether they do not injure. At any rate, I appeal to the House to see that they are not successful in imposing this tax upon a section of the community which is not fit to bear this burden or any further burdens.

Comment on this

I support the recommendation from the Seanad. This duty has been discussed on several occasions in the Dáil and every possible argument that could be used against its imposition has already been used. The Seanad, in my opinion, acted wisely in making the recommendation. There is no doubt that if the Government persist in imposing the duty they will inflict very serious hardship upon the farmer. There is no artificial manure so commonly used as superphosphates. It is indispensable for the production of grass and in the production of crops. This tax will inevitably mean, under existing conditions, that farmers will be compelled to use a lesser quantity of this exceedingly necessary manure. In debating this duty on a previous occasion, it was pointed out by Deputies who are themselves engaged in the manure business that for years past the Irish manufacturers have waited to fix the price of superphosphates until the foreign firms importing superphosphates into this country had fixed their price. That has been the custom of the Irish firm—because there is practically only one firm in this country engaged in the production of superphosphates—for many years past. They have always waited until the foreign firms had fixed the price of their superphosphates and then the Irish firm fixed their price. It follows quite clearly from that that the competition, small and all as it was from outside had the effect of keeping down prices. There is no doubt that this tax will have the effect of removing that competition altogether and thereby giving to the Irish firm engaged in this particular business a complete monopoly of the Irish market so that they will be free to fix any price they like for the superphosphates used by Irish farmers. Everybody who has any experience of farming in this country knows well that when this competition is removed the price will inevitably go up.

I cannot understand why the Government should impose the duty at this time on artificial manures. If we are to judge by their own Press, they propose very shortly to embark on a very big tillage policy. If they hope to make that policy a success, they should make it possible for farmers to secure the raw materials of their industry at the lowest possible price. One of the most essential raw materials that the farmers require for tillage purposes is artificial manure. Surely if the Government had any foresight or vision, or if they were really interested in the welfare of the farmers, they would have hesitated before imposing a duty on artificial manure. It has been the custom of the Department of Agriculture to encourage the use of superphosphates for many years past. Their inspectors have encouraged farmers to use superphosphates and have themselves actually facilitated farmers in procuring large quantities of superphosphates at comparatively low prices. It was stated, I forget at the moment whether it was by the Minister for Finance or the Minister for Industry and Commerce, that the officials of the Department of Agriculture were consulted before imposing this tariff. I am perfectly certain of one thing, that the Minister was not advised by the officials of the Department of Agriculture to put a tariff on artificial manures. I think if he had discussed the matter thoroughly and exhaustively with the officials of the Department of Agriculture he would have learned that the use of superphosphates at present in this country is absolutely necessary and that they themselves were encouraging farmers to use larger quantities of superphosphates year after year.

I do not propose to go over the arguments I used, when discussing this duty, on previous occasions in the Dáil, but I appeal to the Government, if there is to be any consistency at all in the Fianna Fáil Party or their policy, to, at least, drop this duty on artificial manure. Surely they will recognise that the farmer, at the present time, has got to bear a burden heavy enough for his shoulders. Judging by present appearances it looks as if the burden, at the present moment, is comparatively light compared to what he will have to bear in the near future. If the Government is not prepared to drive the farmer out of business altogether, then, surely the tax on superphosphates, and other raw material of the farming industry, should be eliminated completely. I do not know whether there is any use appealing to the Parliamentary Secretary. I am convinced if the Parliamentary Secretary was acquainted with agricultural conditions in this country at the present time he would have no hesitation in recommending the Minister for Finance to remit this taxation on superphosphates.

Comment on this

When this tax was debated here some time ago I think it must be admitted that no effective defence was put up for it by the Government Party. If there is any use in an Opposition, if an Opposition is to be effective in any way whatever then I say the opposition we offered to this tax was certainly effective. On this side of the House we had farmers, business men and those engaged in manufacture getting up, one after another, making a case against this tariff. No Deputy on the other side, and no Minister made any attempt whatever to refute these arguments. It was admitted by the Minister that the manure firms in this country produced four-fifths of the needs of this country as against the importation of artificial manures of all other sorts. The manufacturers have control of four-fifths of the trade. They are paying good dividends and are solvent in every way, not because the Government has gone to meet them, or that they expect any help such as this tariff proposes to give them. It would be useless, at this stage, to reiterate the arguments that have been used in this House against this tax. Some Ministers said that practically no artificial manure was used on grass lands at all, thereby showing that they know nothing whatever of the very subject upon which they proceed to instruct the House. There are numerous farmers of grass land for whom artificial manure means more even than the annuities about which all parties are concerned at the moment. There are farmers who, previous to the universal use of artificial manures, had, perhaps, from one to four cows on their land, and who were able to double the capacity of their farms by the use of artificial manures. Whatever arguments are used to the contrary the cost of artificial manures must rise and the price must rise as a result of this tariff. It is inevitable that the additional expenses of this tariff will put the farmer in the position that he was in before effective land purchase ever came his way.

There was no real defence made for this tariff. Practically the only thing that could be said, if it was the case, was that the Irish manufacturers were prepared and able to produce all that was necessary for this State and, that it followed, that the price of these artificial manures would not go up. It was said that with a 20 per cent. import of the total artificial manures used there was no need at all for the price to go up. Any school boy, with even limited intelligence, knows that if you eliminate even a very small portion of the supply, as in this case, the price will go up. We had manufacturers and business men like Deputy Dillon and Deputy Davis and others pointing out the absolute nonsense of the contrary argument in the last few years. They gave illustrations that when for any reason the small quantity of imported manure was stopped the price of the home stuff went up, but immediately that the importation began again the increased price dropped. A small competitive tariff on artificial manures coming in was enough to keep prices down, but if the importation is eliminated there is no doubt whatever but the manufacturers of this State will increase the price of farm manures to the farmers. It may be that during the next few months farmers will be asked to bear greater sacrifices than they ever anticipated. The President himself painted a picture bad enough, that we were to tighten our belts and make sacrifices. God knows the farmers have now got to a position when there is no other hole left in the belt to take in, they are squeezed as tight as that. Every tariff introduced into this State, and now the retaliatory tariffs imposed by our neighbours, fall upon the farmers of this country. The whole burden of tariffs, offensive and defensive, falls upon the farmers. Ninety per cent. of the economic fight will have to be borne by the farmers.

Comment on this

By the farmers of England?

Comment on this

Is there no sympathy amongst farmer Deputies on the benches opposite, for the plight of the farmers of this country. I do not want to be drawn into a discussion of matters that are outside the question before us. We are nearing a time when any further burden will be impossible for the farmers to bear. We may be reduced to a position when we may have substitutes for artificial manures. Many of the commodities the farmers are at present preparing for markets will be reduced to manure before the winter is out. Many of us will have to reduce to manure the agricultural commodities we are now producing. We may have to reduce our cattle to bone manure and other products to other forms of manure. Any increased price in the artificial manure we use is beyond our capacity to bear. This House having failed to induce the Minister to remit this tax, if the Seanad did not insist on putting forward these recommendations I, for one, would say the Seanad failed in their duty. The Seanad, by this recommendation, is endeavouring to help to save the agriculturists in this country just as we, the farmer Deputies, attempted to save them. I hope on second thoughts the Government will consent to accept this amendment. In these days, when large amounts of money are found for purposes not quite so necessary, it should not be difficult for the Minister to find from some other source the sum that he hopes to get out of this tariff on superphosphates. I would ask the farmer Deputies on the Government Benches to raise their voices for once, since they became Government Deputies, on behalf of the people who need their help now more than any other section of the community.

Comment on this

We are about sick of the wail from the new supporters the farmers have got. I never saw such a change of front in my life as has occurred in the Opposition Benches during the last three months. It required the putting of them into opposition to make them friends of the farmers, or pretended friends of the farmers, and they still carry on the same old dictum that was preached here repeatedly by the now defunct Farmers' Party, namely, that the policy of the farming community should be to give all the employment they could to the foreigners, but to look to the Irish people to buy their produce. This tariff has not been put on for the sake of the amount of money that is to be got from it. The tariff has been put on to give employment in this country to 1,000 men who are being driven out of employment by the importation of this stuff. The least said by the barrister-farmer-Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney the better. We have enough of that class in the country.

Comment on this

If the Deputy makes ridiculous statements, he cannot help people laughing.

Comment on this

Down in my constituency, during the last fortnight or three weeks, there was a meeting of your class——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will address the Chair and not Deputies across the floor.

Comment on this

There was a meeting of that special description of farmers held in County Cork recently and the farmers of the constituency had to come in to disown them—the Colonial sheep ranchers, the retired British Army Majors and retired brewers and barristers who came in to speak for the farmers of Cork County. It is time that that thing was put an end to once and for all. This tariff, as I said, is being put on to ensure that, in this country, employment will be given to our own people. It was pointed out here, when this matter was debated before, that the imports of superphosphates in the first three months of this year increased by 5,000 odd tons as compared with the amount imported this time 12 months. Why? Because there was a tariff put on by Britain on the import of superphosphate into Britain to protect her own industry and, immediately that tariff was put on, the supplies that used to go into Britain were diverted here. I have no love for these manufacturers at all. They probably subscribe more to Cumann na nGaedheal funds, as is very well known, on the same lines as Messrs. Ranks, but this Government is not going to stand idly by and see the manure manufacturers of this country put in the same position as the flour millers. It is rather amazing to hear Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney and Deputy Roddy coming along now to wail about the position of the farmers. They have told us that the farmers found themselves in a position in which their belts are as tight as they can be. I admit that. I know the thousands of writs that were lying waiting until the general election was over to be sent out by the Land Commission if the Party opposite came into power for another five years. We know the sheaf of writs that were waiting to be shoved out and they were shoved out.

Comment on this

How many are waiting now?

Comment on this

The first thing the Minister for Lands had to do was to stop the bailiffs and sheriffs from operating on the unfortunate farmers of the country after the policy of the Deputies opposite. It is all very well for Deputy Hogan to sit smiling now. He increased the farmers' rents by 25 per cent. in my constituency, over and above what they were paying the landlord, by a so-called Land Purchase Act——

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am not smiling.

Comment on this

——in order to give more loot to the British landlords who were getting out. Of course, we know very well that that Bill was not Deputy Hogan's production. It was produced by the British Government.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It has nothing to do with this recommendation.

Comment on this

Other Deputies alluded to the condition of the farmers and I am stating the manner in which the farmers were brought to that condition. It is absolutely disgusting to listen to Deputies opposite who pretend a terrible love for the farmers and whom I saw here, when we were making appeals from those benches to them to stop the looting that was going on, and bringing in amendments to prevent the landlords from looting the farmers, trotting up after the tail that was leading the dog during the last five years—the little landlord independents who formed themselves into a party here, and leading the so-called farmer Deputies after them in voting for Act after Act to drag the last ounce of sweat from the farmer for the benefit of rack-renting landlords. They talk about the effect of all this to-day. We are sick of this kind of thing and it is about time they ended it. This tariff on superphosphates is a tariff definitely intended to provide employment for our own people. As Deputy Bennett admitted, the manufacturers here are in a position to supply all our needs and why should we allow one shilling to leave the country for something that can be produced here? We hear talk of profiteering. We are taking steps to deal with the profiteer and if the manure manufacturer turns out a profiteer, we will have just as little hesitation in shoving Mr. Goulding into Mountjoy as Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney had in putting decent men there. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney has now gone to sleep. He is resting from his labours.

Comment on this

The Deputy's voice is so soothing that it would put anyone to sleep.

Comment on this

I would like to think that my voice would soothe the Deputy to sleep, but, like the effect of the superphosphates on the grass he was talking about a while ago, I think that something else had a more stimulating effect than my voice.

Comment on this

I think that Deputy Corry, in common decency, should be made to withdraw that statement.

Comment on this

In common decency, it ought to be allowed to remain.

Comment on this

In common decency, we should not speak to him.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not know what the Deputy refers to.

Comment on this

Everyone knows what was meant.

Comment on this

I know that it is very bitter to tell the truth to the gentlemen opposite every time I stand up. It is about time they heard a little of the truth.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

And something about this question.

Comment on this

I am dealing with the tariff on superphosphates and I urge the Ministry to withdraw the preference which they are giving to British superphosphates. If any preference is to be given let it be given elsewhere rather than to people who are trying to finish the job that they very nearly succeeded in doing with the help of Deputies on the opposite benches. I certainly urge that upon the Ministry. The gentlemen who voted for this recommendation in the Seanad——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy cannot discuss the action of the other House.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, it is owing to the action of the Seanad that we are here.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy cannot discuss the actions of another House.

Comment on this

Deputy Bennett referred to the action of the Seanad in sending the recommendation back to the Dáil.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Bennett did not comment on the action of the Seanad.

Comment on this

Deputy Bennett said the Seanad was right. Surely I have a right to say that their action was a wrong one.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputies cannot discuss what induced the Seanad to do anything and cannot discuss their actions. Deputies can discuss the recommendation.

Comment on this

The way we must look upon this tariff is that we have to keep as much money as we can in this country. I see no reason whatever for paying the money of the farmers to foreigners for superphosphates when these can be produced here and the money kept at home. If farmers are in beggary now, it is definitely due to the policy of those in Opposition, who claimed to represent this country and handed over £3,000,000 a year to the British Government out of the hardearned sweat of the farmers. We are now endeavouring to get that money back. That was money which Deputies opposite robbed from the farmers and that is why they are now beggared. The difficulty about the annuities is due to the action of the Deputies opposite and to the manner in which they managed the Britishmade Land Acts that they shoved through here without any semblance of justice. We intend to provide employment here for our own people in spite of the action of the Deputies opposite.

Comment on this

When?

Comment on this

I have resisted this proposal at every stage of this Bill. I would like to refer briefly to one or two things that were said this evening. We were told that another 1,000 men were to be thrown out of employment if we did not dole out £30,000 to the buses. It was pointed out that of the total number employed on buses, 2,800, more than half were employed by the I.O.C. and a large percentage on the Tramway Company's buses, neither of which concerns had threatened to dismiss men. Of the remainder, 1,000 were to be sacrificed if we did not provide money to subsidise the buses——

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is it in order for the Deputy to discuss the buses or the number of men employed on the question dealing with a tariff on artificial manures.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must be aware that introductory remarks are allowed.

Comment on this

The Lord help us, if Deputy Corry is to call us to order. Having agreed to provide £30,000 in the name of the mythical 1,000 bus conductors who besieged the Minister for Finance at Leinster House to make the concession, that revolted the loyal heart of Deputy Davin and drove others into insurrection. Deputy Trainor stated to-day that party loyalty had a strong pull and a long pull, but that was the only thing that would drag him into the Lobby against the tax on Soccer football. I wish there was the same spirit amongst the farmers.

Comment on this

The farmers do not want advice from barristers.

Comment on this

And barristers do not want advice. I sympathise with a friend that I have on these Benches who was very vexed when he came and said to me: "You are trying to destroy the recommendation." Far from it. Knowing the President to be a reasonable and a conciliatory man, I have not the slightest doubt that if the question was raised on Thursday last at a meeting of the Fianna Fáil Party, and if members explained that they could not stand for this thing, he would be very glad to facilitate them.

Comment on this

The farmers do not want to be considered in that way.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt Deputy Corry. There is no impost in the Budget so manifestly unjustifiable as the impost on artificial manures, and particularly on superphosphates of lime. Deputy Corry stated that the imports of superphosphates increased by 500 tons last year as compared with the previous year. That was due to the fact that England had put on a tariff, and that the surplus from Belgium was sent to this country. Apparently the Deputy is also not aware of the fact that the officials of the Department of Agriculture have been going around the country for two years exhorting the people to use superphosphates. That is why you have increased imports. There has been an increase in the sales because the Department have exhorted the people to use superphosphates instead of other manures and to raise the ingredients on their own farms and save unnecessary costs. I suppose there is not much use in again appealing to the Government to make some concession in respect of manures required by the farming community.

At this juncture I would like to say that there is a growing practice in this House of hurling insults across the floor. I do not particularly refer to Deputy Corry, but I think it comes ill from the member of one Party, which has had a pretty rough time at the hands of another Party, in respect to subscriptions to suggest that Cumann na nGaedheal did this or Cumann na nGaedheal did that because they got subscriptions from this or that manufacturer. I heard a good many suggestions come from the other side which were equally deplorable, that Fianna Fáil did this and that Fianna Fáil did that because manufacturers gave subscriptions, and I saw the Minister for Finance get up and in great and justifiable anger protest. I say that such anger was justifiable as these are monstrous charges, to suggest that honourable men got subscriptions from this manufacturer or from that manufacturer, yet, on the same Benches, Deputies now get up and make the charge against the Cumann na nGaedheal Party that their own Minister bitterly resented as being out-rageous. I must say that I agree with the Minister for Finance there.

Comment on this

I did not say that members of Cumann na nGaedheal did anything for their own benefit. My statement was that Messrs. Goulding —and they are no friends of mine— probably subscribed generously to Cumann na nGaedheal. That has nothing to do with any benefits that they expect from Cumann na nGaedheal.

Comment on this

Deputy Corry made a reference to Ranks. I have heard him not once but several times make the same reference. It is time he came out one way or another.

Comment on this
An Leas Cheann Comhairle

I cannot deal with charges thrown across the floor of the House. That should be dealt with in some other way.

Comment on this

I obey your ruling—

Comment on this
An Leas Cheann Comhairle

There is a Committee on Procedure and Privileges and if any gross breaches of privileges have to be discussed, that is the proper place for it.

Comment on this

I bow immediately to your ruling, but I thought it well to refer to this matter lest somebody should suggest that I was getting bribes from somebody. I merely represent it to the Government that they are doing something now in the name of a thousand men who I suggest to them do not exist, the thousand who are going to be disemployed if we do not put a tariff on superphosphate of lime. I suggest that the farmers through the ordinary process of economic pressure during the last five or six years which has prevailed all over the world, perhaps less here than anywhere else, are having a very hard time. This added burden the agricultural community is not in a position to bear and the result will be, as I have said before, that if the price of manure is increased, as it certainly will be increased if Belgian and Continental superphosphate is kept out, that the farmers will use less of that commodity and the less the farmers use of that commodity the less production there will be in the country, and the less production there will be, the poorer everybody will be.

Comment on this

So much was said on this matter when it was before the House on a previous occasion and during the course of this evening's debate, that I do not intend to take up the time of the House at length this evening. I should like to point out to the Government that of all the tariffs they have recently imposed this is one that, in my opinion, is going to strike the farmer hardest—that is, the practical industrious farmer who is inclined to make the most of his holding. A twenty per cent. tariff imposed on superphosphate at a time like this, knowing the rings which we had to fight in that particular industry for years past, is the very thing that is going to hamper to a tremendous extent the action of the Government in trying to encourage or increase tillage in future. We are all prepared, at least I have always been and so have my neighbours, to give a preference to Irish manufactured artificial manures. I have paid £1 per ton more for Irish artificial manure in my native town than the price at which I could get Belgian artificial manure. If I paid that last year when there was no tariff, what shall I be expected to pay to the Irish manufacturer this year when he has the advantage of this twenty per cent. tariff?

I think that the Government at all events ought to give some undertaking to-night, if this particular tariff is passed, that there will be some control of manufacturers as regards the prices they will charge the farmers. If that guarantee is given it may go a considerable way to encourage those of us who have been doing our best in the line of production for some years and who will continue to do that on our farms in future. This tariff comes at a particularly bad time on the farmers, when we find it impossible to meet demands on us, to meet annuities, to meet local rates, to meet the shopkeepers. If I might throw out a suggestion—I do not know whether the Government would be prepared to consider it or not—I would ask them to consider this, that a ten per cent. tariff should be quite enough if they want to encourage manufacturers of artificial manure in this country. No figures have been given to us either on this occasion or on any previous occasion, to show that Messrs. Goulding and the other manufacturers of artificial manure cannot turn out artificial manure, superphosphate or any other classes, at a ten per cent. tariff. They should be able to do it or if not, they should go out of business. I wish to put that suggestion to the Government and I ask them seriously to consider it, if they are honest and sincere, in what we are told is their future policy, to encourage increased tillage amongst the farmers of the country.

Comment on this

Those who had the advantage of visiting the Departmental demonstration plots at the Cork Industrial and Agricultural Fair must have seen the enormous value of the use of artificial manure in our agricultural economy. I put it to the Government that they have made certain promises with regard to their tillage policy and it is certainly inconsistent with these promises to place upon farmers who will have to carry out that tillage policy any imposition which will add to the cost of agricultural production. If you look at the enormous advantage to the small farmer of being able to increase production by the use of proper mixtures of artificial manures it will be very apparent that the income of the country will be seriously curtailed by an imposition of this sort which far outweighs any slight advantage that may be gained in the shape either of revenue or increased production by the manure manufacturers in the country. It has been put forward that by restricting imports you will put a thousand men into employment. The fact is altogether overlooked that a tariff of this description will so increase prices as materially to restrict the use of artificial manure by farmers, particularly at a time when they are already so badly hit by tariffs in other directions and at a time when they cannot possibly stand up against the huge increase in the cost of their requirements.

I feel that this tariff will be a blow to the agricultural policy of the Government, a step that will certainly be most ill-advised and one that the agricultural community will seriously resent. When you take into consideration the fact that the farmers of the country are so heavily taxed that they will require a great deal more capital in carrying on their work, and take also into consideration the very serious example shown by the large amount of derelict land we have in the country showing how the farmers are being hit —that derelict land is increasing in area—you must agree that the Government would be well-advised not to add further burdens to those already borne by the agricultural community. I feel that this is the most ill-advised tax that could possibly be imposed and that it will hit the agricultural community when no recompense is being given them. It is true we have had the Butter Bill but it has yet to be shown that it is of any material advantage to the farmers. We have had also £250,000 given in derating small farmers under a valuation of £10, but I think that is a very small recompense indeed for the serious curtailment of production that is likely to ensue if the agricultural community are restricted in their activities or if the price of their requirements is increased.

It has been our experience in this country that when a tariff is imposed on any commodity the price of that commodity is increased to the full amount of the tariff. I am residing in a tillage country and I can see around me the needs of the tillage farmers. It is absolutely essential for these men to have a supply of superphosphates available. The tillage farmer is not able to keep a very large amount of cattle or to feed very largely, so he must have at his disposal a considerable amount of cheap manure, far and away larger than the ordinary rancher would have. In addition to that the value of superphosphate as top dressing for grass land is very apparent to anybody who has had experience of the work of small farmers. The agricultural economy of their farms would be very much enhanced and they would be able to carry a certain number of cattle which they could not carry if they were not able to increase production of their grass lands and their meadows. It has been the experience of farmer Deputies here that artificial manure is one of the chief essentials for the farmer. It has been emphasised that a very large quantity of home-manufactured manure is used by Irish farmers and I must say that that has redounded very much to their credit—the giving of a preference to a home-manufactured article. But the price of that is kept within reasonable bounds by the small amount of imported manure. The quantity imported is increasing. It is apparent to the agricultural community that if manures were not imported prices would go up very much beyond what they are at present. Co-operative employment also has been responsible for keeping prices down. Manure manufacturers have their own system of giving rebates in the shape of discount and that kind of thing to the trade, but if we are to abolish the one thing that is enabling us to keep manures down to reasonable prices for the farmers I have no hesitation in saying that it will have a very serious effect on our farming policy generally and on any constructive policy which the Government may bring in.

Comment on this