In Committee on Finance—Estimates for Public Services. - Vote 26—Law Charges.
Contributions 1–115 of 239. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:—
Go ndeontar suim ná raghaidh thar £19,577 chun slánuithe na suime is gá chun íoctha an Mhuirir a thiocfaidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar críoch an 31adh lá de Mhárta, 1933, chun Costaisí Coir-Phróiseacht agus Dlí-Mhuirireacha eile maraon le Deontas i geabhair do Chostaisí áirithe is iníoctha amach as Rátaí Aitiúla do réir Reachta.
That a sum not exceeding £19,577 be granted to complete the sum necessary to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1933, for the Expenses of Criminal Prosecutions and other Law Charges, including a Grant in relief of certain Expenses payable by Statute out of Local Rates.
Comment on this
I am going to ask the House to vote against this Estimate, and I am going to ask the House to vote against it because this Estimate contains the salary of the Attorney-General. I am asking the House to vote against the Estimate because the Attorney-General, by his conduct in his office since he was appointed to that office, has shown himself unfitted to discharge the duties of that office.
The Attorney-General is the head of the Irish Bar. By reason of the position which the Attorney-General holds, he is head of the Irish Bar, and it gives me no pleasure, as a member of that profession, that I have got to stand here and make charges such as I am going to make to-night, such charges as it is my duty to make, against the man who is the head of the profession of which I am a member. I am perfectly aware that when he acts in an unworthy and improper manner, he drags not only himself down but he drags down the whole profession to which he belongs. It is no pleasure to me to show to the House and to show to the country how unworthily the Attorney-General has acted in the position which he holds.
The post of Attorney-General is a very important post in the administration of justice in this country. There is a tendency to consider that the Attorney-General is Law Adviser to the Executive Council and that he is nothing more. I want to point out to the House that the Attorney-General has other duties than that. I want to point out that it is by no means his sole duty and that it is not by any means his most important duty. The Attorney-General is responsible for the administration of criminal justice in this country. He stands in the position that is occupied in England by the Director of Public Prosecutions, and it is expected of him, and it is his duty, in carrying out public prosecutions, that he be swayed by no ulterior motive of any kind and that no political considerations of any kind shall enter into his mind when he is deciding what charges ought to be brought and against whom they are to be brought. For that reason the Attorney-General is made completely independent of the Executive Council. He is responsible by himself for the prosecutions which he brings and for the form of those prosecutions—for the persons he prosecutes or the persons he does not prosecute. He is perfectly independent. He is not under the control of the President nor is he under the control of the Executive Council.
The Attorney-General is absolutely independent of the President and of the Executive Council. The responsibility is his, and his alone, if wrong is done. He cannot be dismissed by the President nor by the Executive Council, and he has been put in that position deliberately by the laws of this State in order that he may be able to act uninfluenced by any political pressure of any kind. The Attorney-General cannot be dismissed. He stands there under nobody's control. He remains Attorney-General as long as the President who appointed him remains President. He cannot be removed from his office, and, as I say, the object and reason of that is that in the carrying out of the administration of the criminal law in this country he can be swayed by no individual, and he is under the control of no individual.
We must come to consider how the Attorney-General is carrying out, and has carried out, the duties of his post. I am going to give the House some concrete examples by which they can judge how the Attorney-General is acting. I am going to give the House some examples which are known to the whole public of how openly and bare-facedly the Attorney-General has acted in certain cases. The first case I am going to allude to is a case in which a charge was brought against a young man named MacWalter, for an attack upon the house of Mr. Patrick Gavan, who lives in the neighbourhood of Belcarra, in the County of Mayo. The facts and circumstances of the case are these: Mr. Gavan's house was attacked by a body of men on the night of Monday, 1st August last. This body of men came to his house and demanded that Mr. Gavan should come out to them, to be treated by them as their tender mercies should direct. Very properly, Mr. Gavan told them that he was not coming out, and that if they attempted to enter his house he would defend his house— that he had firearms, and that he intended to use the firearms for the defence of his house.
These men proceeded to break in the door of his house, and one man was coming in holding an electric torch extended in one hand. Mr. Gavan fired at that torch and the attackers decamped. Some little time afterwards he heard groaning outside his house, something that seemed like a human being in pain and suffering. He went out, and he discovered a young man named MacWalter lying some 30 or 40 yards outside his house, it being obvious that when he had fired at the hand holding the electric torch the scatter of the shot had penetrated his lung. That subsequently transpired. MacWalter was lying there in a very seriously wounded condition, completely deserted by his own comrades. Mr. Gavan then acted in a way which, I think, must have the approbation of every single Deputy in this House, no matter upon what bench he sits, because I do think that every Deputy in this House will admire the action of an extremely brave and Christian-hearted man. This body of persons who had attacked Mr. Gavan's house had decamped, as I have said, leaving their wounded comrade behind. Gavan's house is something like three-quarters of a mile away from the main public road, down a long, narrow road. Seeing a man there, who had come to injure him, in danger of death possibly, Gavan got on a bicycle and rode down to get a priest for the wounded man— the man who had come to attack him —not knowing where MacWalter's comrades were ambushed or what risk he was running. I think that a man, who, at his own risk, and knowing that those people had come to his house to attack him, knowing that those people had come to his house to injure him, a man who, at great personal risk to himself, goes out to help a wounded individual who had shown himself extremely ill-disposed to him, is certainly deserving of commendation by every person in this House.
Now, I come to the sequel, which I think will surprise the House very much. MacWalter of course was arrested. He was brought into Castlebar under arrest, but the House will be astonished to hear that no proceedings were taken against him for the attack upon Gavan's house. He was not proceeded against for conspiring with other persons to injure Gavan. The only charge brought against him was the very minor charge of having a revolver and having ammunition for that revolver in his possession. He was charged with precisely the same offence—nothing more—as if that revolver and ammunition had been found in his pocket as he was going along the road, or had been found in his house under his care and custody. The major crime of which he was guilty, the crime of attacking Mr. Gavan's house and of conspiracy with other persons to injure Gavan, he was not charged with at all.
I want to know from the Attorney-General why that attack upon that house and that conspiracy to injure Gavan were completely ignored by him. Is it, as it seems to be, that as a member of the I.R.A. he is to have the law against him administered differently from the manner in which it would be administered against any other person, or is it that the Attorney-General approves of the attacks by night of armed men upon the houses of innocent and properly conducted citizens of this State?
As I have said, MacWalter was not alone. There were a considerable number of men in company with him. They came in a motor vehicle from the town of Balla. That is known by every single person in the neighbourhood. The names of the men are known by practically everybody in the neighbourhood. It is common knowledge. I want to know if the names of those men are not known to the Guards. I want to know why no proceedings against those men were ever taken, or why no attempt to make those men amenable to justice was ever made.
I come now to deal with a very curious and a very sinister aspect of this particular case. As I have told the House, this outrage against Mr. Gavan's house was carried out on Monday, 1st August of this year, and this conspiracy was hatched in the town of Balla and in its neighbourhood. It was carried out on a Monday evening, and President de Valera had spent the previous night and the morning of that particular Monday in the neighbourhood, and had only left it that afternoon. Now I want to make this perfectly clear—I do not want anybody to put any implication upon my words; I do not want anyone to come to the conclusion that I am in any way suggesting that President de Valera was aware of this outrage, or approved of this outrage, or did anything else except disapprove of it. I want to make that perfectly clear, but it is a fact—and a fact of very considerable significance—that it is the night of the day upon which President de Valera leaves this particular neighbourhood that these men choose to carry out their outrage. Why did they choose that particular day? I think there are two reasons which can explain it. The first reason is that evidently the I.R.A. accompanying President de Valera during his tour through Mayo possibly thought that this was a way in which they could earn his esteem. As I have said, I believe they were wrong in that, but I think they had another idea in their minds as well. I think they thought that they could bring influence to bear upon the Executive Council and upon the Attorney General, which would prevent any prosecution of them if they carried out their raid successfully. Subsequent events have shown that they were right.
McWalter, of course, who was arrested on the spot, had to be charged with something. He was charged, not with being on the dwelling-house, not conspiring against Mr. Gavan; he was charged with the mere offence of having firearms in his possession. He had to be charged with something. But if he had not been caught there on the very spot, is it not perfectly plain that no proceedings would have been brought against him, or against any single member of that party? I want to know from the Attorney-General, has influence been brought to bear upon him; have persons spoken to him about this case? I have said that he, and he alone, is responsible. Nobody should be able to influence him— neither the Executive Council nor anybody else should be able to influence him. I want to know if people have approached him.
President de Valera, when he stopped in this particular neighbourhood, was the guest of a particular family. I should like to know from the President why, as the whole County Mayo knows, the Chief Superintendent of the Guards, and a member of that particular family, had a very, very long consultation on the following Tuesday, early in the morning. I should like to know what was the reason of that, and as to whether influence has been brought to bear on the Chief Superintendent by a member of that particular family to have these proceedings cloaked up, and to prevent proceedings being brought against persons who were implicated with McWalter in this outrage. I believe that this outrage was carried out on this particular day because the individuals who carried it out believed that they could get the family who were President de Valera's hosts to bring such influence to bear that prosecutions would not be brought against them and the law would not run in their case. A member of that family was, last autumn, a member of the I.R.A. and a member of Saor Éire. Last autumn he informed the Guards he resigned from both those organisations and he did not intend to rejoin them. I do not suggest, for one moment, that he has broken his undertaking, but I do think that the persons who carried out this outrage might consider he was very frendlily-disposed towards the persons who had joined with him in these organisations, and that his family could bring, if he could not himself, influence to bear on the Attorney-General and Executive Council. I should like to know if the Attorney-General was approached, either directly or indirectly, either by any member of that family, or through any member of the Executive Council by that family, to lessen the charge which was brought against McWalter, and let the other people go scot free.
I hope the Attorney-General will be able to stand up in this House and say that he was not approached by anybody, that he did not consult with anybody, but that he decided himself as to what should be done, and that he was not influenced by anybody. I sincerely hope the Attorney-General will be able to stand up in this House and tell us that, and tell us the reason why he directed that only a minor offence should be charged against McWalter showing that influence had been brought to bear. We know, of course, the Executive Council does what the I.R.A. tell it to do. We had a good example of that some time ago. We had the case of Dempsey, a man who was sentenced to a term of imprisonment by a Judge in Dublin because he refused to recognise a Court properly and lawfully sentencing him to a term of imprisonment. We then had meetings held outside demanding his release; we had a trial of strength between the I.R.A. and the Executive Council, and we know it was the I.R.A. won, and that after they held their protest meetings this man, properly sentenced to a term of imprisonment for refusing to recognise the court, was released. But the Executive Council may be under the thumb of the I.R.A.; the Executive Council may do what the I.R.A. tells them, but that is no excuse—no sane excuse—for the Attorney-General. The Attorney-General has his own responsibilities and he cannot shield or hide himself behind the Executive Council, and no matter what the Executive Council have done, no matter what the President said to him, it is the moral duty of the Attorney-General to carry out the duties of his post without fear of the I.R.A. or affection for the I.R.A. or favour to the I.R.A.
That is one case. I am coming on to another, a still more shocking case. I am coming on to the scandal which is connected with the Kilrush affair. I think the House is pretty familiar with the Kilrush affair. Two gentlemen, Mr. Gilmore and Mr. Ryan, whose names are well known to this House, were in Kilrush and an encounter took place between them and the body of men who were with them, and two members of the Civic Guard. Two different accounts have been given of that encounter, one the account given by Mr. Ryan and his friends, saying that they had been wantonly fired at, wounding them both, the other the account given by the Guards that shots were fired at them; that a body of men was there about to attack them, or actually attacking them, and that they used their revolvers in self-defence—in necessary self-defence—having, as an eminent judge puts it, "a reasonable apprehension of serious bodily violence." They said they were attacked, and fired at, and they said, also, that they were being otherwise attacked and that they had a "reasonable apprehension of serious bodily violence" when they fired.
Now, that is a matter for inquiry, and they arrested and brought a charge of attempted murder, and two other charges, against Mr. Gilmore and Mr. Ryan and another man. Then we come to a very interesting sequel. We have, of course, courts in this country; we have courts set up to administer the criminal law, and we have courts of criminal jurisdiction, and if a charge was brought by Guards against Mr. Ryan and Mr. Gilmore, or against anybody else, or if there was a counter-charge to be brought against two or three members of the Guards by Mr. Ryan or by Mr. Gilmore, there was one place, and one place only, in which that charge and counter-charge should be investigated, and that place was the courts having criminal jurisdiction in this State.
That was not done in the Kilrush case. That would have been fair and just. That would have been to put before the magistrate, whose sense of justice or fairness could not be impugned, both sides of the case, and if he considered that the case was worthy of being sent for trial the men would have been sent for trial before a jury. That course was not adopted here. Another procedure was adopted. We are told that the Minister for Justice set up a Commission. He set up a Commission to inquire into the conduct of the Guards. I am aware that I cannot go very deeply into that, because the salary for the Minister for Justice is not on this Vote, but I can go into it to a certain extent because the Minister for Justice could not have set up this Commission, the Minister for Justice could not have denied fair play and a fair hearing to those two members of the Guards, unless the Attorney-General had conspired with him to prevent the Guards having justice and fair play. The Minister for Justice set up this Commission—a very curious Commission, a Commission which had as one of its members a solicitor who was standing counsel to the I.R.A. in Kerry. They were determined that the Guards would not have a tribunal which would be fair and impartial, that there would not be a tribunal that could do anything else except find against the Guards. They set up a tribunal the findings of which cannot carry conviction to the mind of any fair-minded man. They set it up in circumstances which must shock and horrify any individual in this State who has any sense of justice.
As I say, they set up a very carefully chosen Tribunal. I am not going further into that, but in order that that Tribunal should function at all, that that Commission should go into evidence at all, it was necessary that the Attorney-General should be consulted and that the Attorney-General should come in. As I have told you, there were charges brought against Mr. Gilmore and Mr. Ryan, the charge of attempted murder with other charges. Those are not investigated. They are not even charged until this precious Commission has been set up. If the Attorney-General had any sense of justice, any idea of how the criminal law should be administered, then the Attorney-General would have insisted that these matters should be investigated by the ordinary court, having competent criminal jurisdiction in this country. If the Minister for Justice wished to satisfy himself as to the conduct of the Guards, after the criminal prosecution had been closed and finished and all criminal proceedings terminated, then and then only should the Minister for Justice, in any fairness, have set up a Commission and set it up only for his own knowledge and his own information. That has not been done.
The Attorney-General not only takes away this case from the seisin of the ordinary District Court, not only tells the world at large that in a case where two important leaders of the I.R.A. are concerned, the courts are not to function, he not only attacks that particular District Court, but attacks the whole system and administration of our District Courts. He attacks the whole administration of criminal law in this country when, by his conduct, he says these courts are not fit to try and cannot be trusted to try cases of this nature. Mark you, he does not ask that these cases should be adjourned, that these cases wait over until the precious Commission's report is received, and that then criminal proceedings shall be taken. Not at all. He withdraws the charges and offers no evidence. In other words, in order to make assurance doubly sure, in order to make perfectly certain that the Guards will not get a fair show before the Commission, he, as plainly as he can, says to the Commission: "The charges which the Guards are bringing against Mr. Gilmore and Mr. Ryan are faked charges." That is the only meaning which can be put upon his action.
There was another matter, small possibly, but a little significant. The Attorney-General was represented by counsel before the District Justice. Mr. Gilmore and Mr. Ryan were also represented by counsel. Counsel on behalf of Mr. Gilmore and Mr. Ryan stated that it had been his intention to apply for cross-summonses against the Guards, but in the circumstances he would reserve the right of bringing any charges of a criminal nature his clients might like to bring against these Guards. He would reserve those and then he proceeds to read out a long series of affidavits, apropos of nothing, in order that the public mind may be prejudiced against the Guards. While he is reading out these affidavits he is not making any application. He reads out these affidavits perfectly irrelevantly to anything that is before the court. The Guards are not represented, and counsel representing the Attorney-General has got such a sense of fair play that he makes no protest against this very unusual procedure. The Attorney-General is anxious that every single thing should be done which would prevent that Commission from going into the trial of these Guards with a fair and impartial mind. He did every single thing he could do to prejudice that Commission, and, as a matter of fact, that Commission was a Commission as much—indeed more— trying the Attorney-General as it was trying the Guards, for if that Commission—and of course it would not, that was pretty well known—found, as it should have found, on the evidence reported in the newspapers, in favour of the Guards then, by the consent of everybody in this State, the Attorney-General would have proved himself absolutely unsuited to his office because he would have withdrawn charges against men who the Commission believed had been guilty of a criminal offence.
He was more on his trial before that Commission—of course the Commission knew it—than the Guards were on their trial. He held evidently some Star Chamber inquiry or, perhaps, held no inquiry at all and made up his mind entirely against the Guards and that he would not allow their case to go into court, would not allow them to state their case. He deliberately stops the proceedings against men who, they were ready and willing to swear, had attacked them. He does that before even this Commission has sat in order that he might prejudice the minds of the members of the Commission. It could have been for no other purpose. Deliberately to prejudice the minds of the Commission—that was the only object that could have been in his mind. I say he was as much on his trial as they were on their trial because, if the court decided that the Guards were attacked then the Attorney-General would be guilty of this offence: He would have been guilty of stopping proceedings against guilty men. He would be guilty of interfering with the administration of justice because he is seemingly afraid that certain gentlemen who refused to recognise our courts would be brought before those courts. After all, I think that the majority of the people in this House, and outside, really, in their heart of hearts, believe in fair play, and like to see fair play and to see even-handed justice administered by any persons administering justice. They do not see it here. They see the very opposite here. They see men who, if charged with any offence, should be brought before the ordinary lawfully-constituted courts set up by the laws of this country. They certainly should not be denied that right. Instead of that they are brought before a Commission, and they are to be condemned on the finding of a Commission, which, at most, is an inquiry into a disciplinary offence. The men who attacked them are to go entirely scot free and that very Commission is itself to the prejudice of the Attorney-General, and to the prejudice of all his actions.
These men are being treated with gross injustice. Of course, there has been a finding against them. Everyone who saw the personnel of the Commission knew that there would be a finding against them. Everyone knew that the Commission was set up for the purpose of finding against them. Does anyone think the Attorney-General would have taken the risk he did take if he did not know, before-hand, what the Commission would find. He took a great risk when he set up these proceedings. As I say, if the findings of the tribunal were against him, he would have to resign his office and if he did not, if he had declined to resign his office, I believe the voice of public opinion would make him resign. He took the risk because he knew, as well as everybody else knew, that the Commission was a Commission set up to find against the Guards and in favour of Ryan and the Gilmores. I have mentioned things done in the open and brought to light, things done in defiance of public opinion. These are things that were done in the greenwood. What is being done in the dry? How many cases come up against the Guards about which the public know nothing, and in which there ought to be prosecutions, but in which the Attorney-General is advising against such prosecutions, knowing it would be bad for the Fianna Fáil Party if he did his duty as Attorney-General? I wonder how many such cases are there? We cannot know that. We do not know the files that come before the Attorney-General. But from the manner in which he acts in public we may form a very fair conclusion as to how he acts in those cases which never meet the light of day. If he braved public opinion, in the cases I have mentioned, how is he going to act when there is no need to brave public opinion, when all his acts are completely secret and unknown? Of course, it may be and, I suppose, will be, that the Attorney-General will have the support of his Party in his conduct here. And, of course, if he has the support of his own Party he will have the support of the Labour Party as well. We know that perfectly. But outside this House there is a body of public opinion that hates to see injustice done. There is a body of public opinion that believes the Guards have a right to fair and just treatment, and it is to that public opinion and not to the Fianna Fáil Party or the Labour Party that I speak now. I speak not to the Parties who do not care whether justice is done or injustice is done if it happens to suit their political purpose. It is to the great body of public opinion outside, that hates to see the law administered as the Attorney-General is administering it, that I speak. There is a body of public opinion outside this House to which I am confident I can appeal and which I hope will be strong enough to make the Attorney-General, if he survives this debate, act in his position as an honourable man ought to act.
Comment on this
The Deputy has lashed himself into a wonderful fury. I never saw him in such a fury before, and it would not be good for him, or even for the Attorney-General, if he continued to keep himself in such a fury for any considerable length of time. He criticised the Attorney-General and the Commission. There is no man better qualified to talk of what is done in the greenwood, and what is done in the dry, than Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. Of course Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney never did anything in the dry. It was always done in the greenwood. He never prevented a charge from coming before a Court of Justice while in office.
Comment on this
I rise to a point of order. The Deputy has said that I prevented, when in office, cases coming before a Court of Justice.
Comment on this
The Deputy stated to the House, in very clear language, that I had stopped prosecutions being brought, and I submit that the Deputy must name the particular case in which I acted in that fashion.
Comment on this
The words used by the Deputy were: "Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney never did so." With the tone in which the words were said I have nothing to do; moreover, we cannot discuss the administration of a previous Government on the Estimate for this year.
Comment on this
May I ask, a Chinn Comhairle, whether you would not say that there was a clear suggestion that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, as Minister for Justice, prevented prosecutions from taking place? Surely there was a clear suggestion to you and to everybody else. Are you going to allow that to pass? Will you not compel the Deputy to give fair play to Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, and ask him to name a case?
Comment on this
I distinctly said, and emphasised it, that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney in his office did nothing in the dry wood.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Seeing the innuendo in Deputy Cleary's remarks, surely Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney may ask him to cite a single case? If he cannot name a single case he should say so.
Comment on this
The Deputy is quite entitled to ask Deputy Cleary to name a case, but I have no power to compel him to do so.
Comment on this
Do the Opposition feel so guilty in certain cases without being mentioned by me at all?
Comment on this
Deputy Cleary made a charge, he has run away from the charge, and I am perfectly satisfied.
Comment on this
I emphasised the fact that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, while Minister for Justice, never prevented a case from coming before the Courts. Does Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney feel so guilty that he put the other construction on it?
Comment on this
Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, ex-Minister for Justice, Deputy Hogan, ex-Minister for Agriculture, and one of the legal advisers of the late Government, Deputy O'Sullivan, gave it a construction that seems to suggest that they know cases. They should not display the guilty conscience so quickly.
Comment on this
I deliberately emphasised the fact that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney never did prevent a case from coming before the Courts. I will say it again for him if he wants me and emphasise it further. He has criticised at length the setting up of a Tribunal to inquire into certain incidents that happened in County Clare. That Tribunal was set up by virtue of power given under an Act of Parliament passed by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government while in office. What was it passed for? Was it because a case might arise when a demand would be made for setting up a Tribunal? Did they do it for the purpose of pushing it aside in the Fitzgerald-Kenney fashion of dragging in a kicking cow to account for the hammering of a certain person? Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney does not like things of that kind. When a Tribunal was demanded to inquire into that case, a kicking cow was discovered.
Comment on this
There were the Courts of the country to hear everything. That is the line I took and always will take.
Comment on this
When Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney criticises the Tribunal, what he is really doing is criticising the Cumann na nGaedheal Government while in office. He should have thought over it more. I really think, if he had not lashed himself into such a fury, he would have thought of it in that fashion. Some of the findings of that Tribunal have been published I understand. Nobody in this country is more satisfied because of that inquiry in the County of Clare than the really decent body of the Gárda Síochána—none prouder or happier or more satisfied. If that attitude was taken up by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney while in office, some of the members of the Garda Síochána would be given much more respect throughout the country, because the black sheep would have been weeded out long ago and not replaced by kicking cows, as they were by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney while in office. The Deputy lauded at length the action of a Mr. Gavan, in County Mayo, because he defended the sanctity of his home against people who tried to break in during the night —a very laudable thing, a very praise-worthy thing. There is only one other precedent in recent history for such bravery. When that action was taken, however, and the man defended the sanctity of his home, what was Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney's laudation? What did he do? He sent his agents to South Mayo with placards giving it a construction of I.R.A. marauders. When that unfortunate tragedy took place in County Leitrim, and a man defended the sanctity of his home in broad daylight against gunmen, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney would turn against the man who defended the sanctity of his home, call him a black-guard, an ex-I.R.A. man, a man that should not be given any place in this State—one attitude towards one man who defends the sanctity of his home and another attitude towards another. I admire the attitude of Mr. Gavan. I think it is a praise worthy thing he did and a manly thing, but I do not admire the attitude of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, who will laud one man who defends the sanctity of his home and turn his rage against another who defended the sanctity of his home, because the armed men who went to that other man had political affiliations which were not Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
What case is the Deputy referring to? I am told I lauded a particular individual who defended his home.
Comment on this
Do you mean the man who shot Deputy Reynolds and a Guard, who got twelve months for shooting Deputy Reynolds? Is that the man?
Comment on this
The Deputy did not wait for the decision of the court or for a tribunal to find out what happened in Leitrim until he sent out his election agents to get votes for him by giving it a complexion of Republicanism.
Comment on this
I shall get down to what happened in the last two or three days. The Minister for Justice was attacked the other night because of a certain man that he released. It is strange that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney did not mention that this evening, that a Mr. Dullea was released after very heinous charges were made against him and after he had been sentenced. Why did not the Deputy bring that in?
Comment on this
He was released after being sentenced. The Minister for Justice was charged here with releasing a man from jail who committed a serious crime, one of the ugliest of crimes, and it was insinuated by Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies that he released him because he was a Republican and a Fianna Fáil follower. Deputies opposite made these insinuations, while the real facts of the case were that the person who approached the authorities to have the man who committed that terrible crime released was Deputy O'Neill of Cumann na nGaedheal.
Comment on this
Of course I know Deputy Cleary's form. He is one of the Deputies I have most contempt for. That statement would not be made if Deputy O'Neill were here.
Comment on this
You did not make the statement the other night when he was here. You waited until he was gone. It is just your form.
Comment on this
That particular case does not come within this Vote. It is a matter for the Department of Justice.
Comment on this
Sit down. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney insinuated party politics and everything else about these charges. I say they are just as well founded or as likely to be as well founded as the charge made in the case of Mr. Dullea, after influence being brought to bear on the authorities by a Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy to get him released.
Comment on this
The Deputy has been told that that case comes under the Department of Justice. We are now discussing the Attorney-General's Department.
Comment on this
The discussion on this Vote is really very serious for the members of this House. We may disagree as to what is the best system, economically or politically, for this country, but there is one thing on which, I think, all persons and all parties should agree, and that is, that the law should be administered in a way that would have the confidence of every person in the country of any and every political party. I think that it was at the time of the Boer War that Kipling said: "Love to live by no man's leave underneath the law," and there is no Party in this House that should not stand for that, should not stand over it, and fight for it. Of the matters that have been raised by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney this evening, the most serious case, which happened to arise in County Mayo, was replied to by another Deputy from the same county, and that does lead, as the House will agree, to constituency political notions of what the law is. There is nobody in this House who should realise more clearly the importance and the necessity that we should not argue matters of principle on the basis of what happened in this constituency or that constituency, or what the political affiliations of this or that person were, than the Attorney-General.
The two or three cases that were raised by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney were serious and they do require serious consideration from this House. It really does not matter, as I say, in the discussion of this affair, what our notions on the uneconomic war are or what our notions on political affiliations with other countries are, but we, at least, must accept this, that we must stand for a sense of law and a standard in the administration of law whatever Party may be in power at the time, and it is on that matter that I would like to hear the Attorney-General or whoever will reply—and I take it that the Minister for Finance will reply for him. I would also like to draw the attention of the House to the sneering of the persons most affected, or the persons who pretend that they represent the persons most affected, namely, the Labour Party in this House, on this discussion.
Comment on this
I would like to assure Deputy O'Sullivan that I think he is doing my colleagues an injustice in saying that they were sneering at remarks made by him.
Comment on this
I did not suggest that they were sneering at me. They would not do that. I think that they were likely sneering at the suggestion.
Comment on this
The Deputy will try to have it both ways as usual but it has nothing to do with the particular case.
Comment on this
It has nothing to do with the particular case we are discussing at the moment, namely, the administration of law in this country. I want to refer to two of the cases raised by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. The first was the McWalter case, and, in this regard, I must say that I am speaking only from the newspaper report. A man's house is attacked, and a battering ram is used to break in the door and shots are fired, after midnight. A number of persons are there; they disappear. The man in the house hears groaning and, finding one of the men wounded, he goes down for the doctor and the priest, and reports the matter to the Civic Guards. What do all the great heroes who attacked his house do? They run away and leave their wounded comrade to die or to be killed, whichever may happen to him.
Comment on this
Is the action of these people, who are alleged to have attacked this House, an issue in this debate, or does it arise on this Vote?
Comment on this
Of course it does not! The action of people who came to a house and said they would break it in and murder people, does not arise on this Vote! Of course, it arises on this Vote. They were in conspiracy with the man who was accidentally caught, shot by this man whose first act was to attend to him because he was wounded, and to go for the priest and doctor.
Comment on this
One of the questions arising on the Vote is the legal action taken in connection with this particular criminal offence, the criminal offence being breaking and entering and conspiracy to murder.
Comment on this
If the Minister wants to apologise for their running away, let him have it. If he is ashamed of their running away, so am I.
Comment on this
No friend of mine ever ran away, but I know people who did. This is a matter which concerns not the County Mayo alone, and that is why I regret that the ex-Minister, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, and Deputy Cleary happen to be the persons who, so to speak, discussed this matter. It is a matter that is outside any constituency, county, province, party or anything else. It is the administration of law outside of all political parties, and that is why I support Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney's motion that the House refuse to pass this Vote. There are several other things which could be said with regard to the particular action, or inaction really, as the Minister reminds me, in County Mayo. I should not refer to the inaction of the heroes of the charge of Balaclava, or Balla, or wherever it was, but I should refer to the inaction of the Attorney-General in not having a criminal prosecution instituted against the persons who ran away, not because they ran away—the Minister is quite right in saying that I should not refer to their running away—but because they were in conspiracy with the person who was there caught in flagrante delicto on the job of attempting to murder this man.
Another matter referred to by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was the Kilrush affair, as it is called. The organ of the Government was very lucid and eloquent on this subject. It said that there was a Tribunal against whom there was no suggestion of partiality. I would like to say that if an offence is committed there are judicial institutions to deal with them. As was stated by Deputy Cleary, the last Government did institute a system by which judicial, or semi-judicial inquiries could be set up to inquire into charges against the Guards. Perhaps the Minister, or the Attorney-General, will tell us whether there will be laid on the Table of the House the findings of that Court of Inquiry. There are different courts in this country, District Courts, Circuit Courts, High Courts and the Supreme Court, and this is the High Court of the land; but there is still a higher court—the court of the people outside.
Comment on this
Perhaps it has something to do with going off the gold standard. There is that court, the highest court of all, to be reckoned with. There are thousands of people outside who want to know why two persons, who flagrantly flouted the authority of this House, were not dealt with. Those persons are not flouting the authority of the Government which sat here a year ago; they are flouting the authority of this House; they say to this House: "You have no right to govern this country." Why did the two leaders with ten or twelve others—the number does not matter—march, at 11 o'clock at night, towards a place where they knew there were two detectives protecting a house? That is what the people in the country would like to know, and that is why I suggest the Attorney-General, or the Minister, should lay on the Table of the House the findings of the Court of Inquiry. After that, perhaps the Attorney-General will tell us why it was he found it necessary to set up this Court of Inquiry; why it was he found it necessary that charges against persons who repudiate, not the authority of the Cosgrave Government, but the authority of this House, should not be investigated in the courts of the land. Is it not because he knew those persons would repudiate the courts; that they would say: "We refuse to recognise your courts; you are a usurping authority; you are only a pale pink edition of President Cosgrave?" Is that not the reason why he set up a special court and why he selected the personnel of his court?
Particular individuals were represented at that court by counsel. One of the most important statements made there was that these persons had spent the night before painting the streets of the town—I understand they painted them red. At any rate, they painted Nelson's Pillar white with the inscription "Boycott British Goods." That was described by their counsel as being not only a patriotic, but an excellent work. I used to take it that everything patriotic was excellent, but in this instance their work was not only patriotic but excellent. I suggest it is because of those declarations "Boycott British Goods,""Boycott Dáil Eireann,""Boycott President de Valera's Government,""Boycott the Attorney-General,""Boycott any type of Government set up in this country except that set up by the authority outside this House," that the Attorney-General felt compelled—I should say was compelled—to set up a Tribunal in order to give him an excuse to prosecute these persons. There were the Guards and there were the headquarters staff of the I.R.A.——
Comment on this
I would like to draw the Deputy's attention to the fact that it has already been stated that the Tribunal was set up by the Minister for Justice, the Vote for whose Department is not before the House.
Comment on this
I quite agree, sir, What I should have said was that the Attorney-General did not direct a prosecution against these persons. If he directed a prosecution against the Guards on the information of the headquarters staff of the I.R.A., he could have directed a prosecution against the headquarters staff of the I.R.A. on the information of the Guards. I should have put it that way. There is one thing upon which emphasis must be laid. Deputy Cleary said that they were proud of the Guards. It is only right that this country should be proud of the Guards. Quite a lot has been said about the plain people and it is but right to give a little credit to the Guards. We are very proud of the Guards, and I think the nation will not forget the fact that these two detectives arrested the whole headquarters staff of the I.R.A. and brought them into the barracks.
Comment on this
A considerable amount of play has been made about certain incidents in Kilrush and, as one of the representatives of the area, I would like to reply to the statements that have been made. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney referred to even-handed justice. I think that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney contributed more to the down-fall of his Party than any of his colleagues in the Cabinet of the former Government, and that was because of the sort of justice that, in the opinion of the people, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney meted out when he was Minister here. Nothing has happened recently that has given more satisfaction in the County Clare than the setting up of this particular tribunal. When that tribunal was set up it gave the people to understand that for the first time they were going to receive even-handed justice. It is the duty of the police to protect the people, not to attack them, and it would be a bad thing if the state of affairs were to continue where, no matter what charges might be levelled and no matter how truthful these charges might be, they would be met by the Government of the day with the argument of the kicking cow.
That position has changed. It has been changed by the highest tribunal in the land, by the court of the people. That was changed by the free vote of the people. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, and his Government, because of the sort of justice they meted out during their term of office, were found wanting by the people.
I do not know if it is in order for certain legal luminaries in this House to attack brother professionals at the Bar. I do not know if it is in order to make personal attacks on the eminent lawyers who formed this tribunal at Kilrush, one of whom is a distinguished Clareman, and a leading light at the Bar. I do not think it adds to the dignity of those who belong to the profession to make these personal attacks. Deputy Gearoid O'Sullivan has asked why the Attorney-General did not direct a prosecution. I hope he will. I hope it is not too late and that a prosecution will be directed in this case. What would have occurred if a Cumann na nGaedheal Government was in office when this thing happened? These unfortunate men would have been arraigned in court, tried for their lives, and, perhaps, under testimony that would have been forthcoming, might have paid the extreme penalty. That could easily have happened as it happened before, perhaps, on less evidence. Another case of a similar nature happened in Lisdoonvarna and I will just quote a statement, not from this tribunal, but one made by Circuit Court Judge McElligott.
Comment on this
October 15th, 1932. I am reading a quotation from the "Clare Champion":
His Lordship: Were there any Guards present in the barracks besides this ruffian?
These are the words of Judge McElligott. As Deputy Cleary stated, even the ordinary members of the Guards will be as well pleased with the action the Government has taken in that particular case as the ordinary public.
Comment on this
I think this is a most extraordinary procedure. Charges have been brought in connection with the administration of his office by the Attorney-General.
Comment on this
I shall waive the point. I think if it was seriously intended to raise these points, as I am not very conversant with the facts, it would have been more just to have given some intimation of the particular topics that were to be raised, as this discussion, at this late hour, finds me without any files to refer to. Although I have endeavoured to get the papers in connection with the cases that have been mentioned by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, I have been unable to do so, and I must rely on my memory for facts in connection with my handling of these cases.
Comment on this
May I make a suggestion? If the Attorney-General is incapable of answering, or if he feels himself at any disadvantage in replying to the charges which I have brought against him, on this side we are perfectly willing that the discussion should be adjourned until to-morrow, and that another estimate should be taken in its place.
Comment on this
I said that it would be more fair if I had notice. I am quite prepared to deal with the charges now. I accept entirely Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney's opening remarks as regards the position of the Attorney-General. I accept his statement that the Attorney-General is independent of control by the Executive, independent of control by the President, independent of any control whatsoever. He must act on his own independent judgment, and while I find it rather difficult to deal calmly with the charges which have been made against me by the Deputy, and by some people who are looked upon as responsible, I assure Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, and I assure the House, that not in one single case that has come before me, have I been swayed by political influence or influence of any kind whatsoever. At the end of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney's speech he made the unworthy suggestion that there are numbers of cases which have come up, and which have been stopped for political reasons. I say that charge is entirely and absolutely false. No case whatever has been stopped by me for political reasons. I have no reasons other than the reasons which the Attorney-General should have in mind when considering cases that are brought before me. It is his duty, and I accept it as such, to examine carefully the evidence put before him, and to examine only the evidence put before him by the responsible authorities, to decide whether a case is to be prosecuted and the nature of the charge to be preferred. I repeat that that has been my course of action in connection with the particular cases mentioned by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, and about which he made so much play. I assure Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney if he will accept my word—and his judgment seems to me to be unbalanced in this matter—that no one spoke to me in connection with this case. I spoke to no one and nothing was before me in my office save the police report.
Comment on this
I am very glad to hear it. I said in my speech that I would be very glad if the Attorney-General would make such a statement.
Comment on this
That particular case gave me a considerable amount of worry both from the circumstances and from the absence of evidence upon which to lay certain charges. It has been suggested that there was evidence involving other people who were alleged to have been with McWalter on the night in question. I can only say to Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney that there was no evidence brought before me to identify any single person there on that night, and if any evidence is put before me, I will unhesitatingly prosecute. I have no sympathy whatever with the people who took part in the raid upon the house on the night mentioned by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. I am prepared to condemn that action, and the action of people who went there that night in as strong terms as Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney or any other Deputy, and I assure the House that if evidence is put before me identifying those people I shall bring a charge now against any of these people.
Now, as regards McWalter himself, he was so seriously wounded in the attack upon that house that he nearly died in hospital. He was under arrest in hospital. The moment that he was well enough to be arraigned before a court, that the Guards reported that he was well enough to be brought before a court, I had him brought before a court. Having regard to the evidence before me and to the whole situation, weighing it up as carefully as I could and without the slightest sympathy for McWalter, I decided that the best and the wisest course was to bring him up on a charge for the possession of firearms. He was speedily dealt with on that charge. He was sent to prison for six months, and as far as I understand his six months in prison have been spent between life and death in hospital. I assure the Deputy again that I dealt with the case without being influenced in any way. None of the persons who have been mentioned by the Deputy, or hinted at by him—no person whatsoever—spoke to me.
I may say at this juncture that when I came into office I did find that certain people thought that perhaps I might be swayed by representations made to me. Certain persons thought apparently that the Attorney-General was approachable. Since I came into office I have deliberately set my face against any interference whatsoever by any persons, Executive Council, or anybody else, with me in the discharge of my duty. I can say that there have not been three occasions in the last three or four months when even the slightest shadow of a hint has been made to me as to how I should deal with any case. In these circumstances I do resent and feel most keenly the charges that have been levelled against me by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. I feel it from his position as a member of the Bar. I feel, too, that there has been nothing adduced here to justify the suggestion that has been made.
Now, to deal with the Kilrush case: What I want to say in connection with it is that it was a very serious and troublesome case, as serious and difficult a case as ever came before a legal officer. The duty of the Attorney-General, examining such a case, was to weigh up the evidence put before him to see whether or not he was justified in taking steps to prosecute the charges suggested. I am sure that Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney will not for a moment deny me the right to use my judgment. I may have been wrong in certain cases in the action I took, whether or not to prosecute. I may have been guilty of an error of judgment, but surely Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney will not deny me the right to use my judgment. What I do resent is the Deputy's complaint that my judgment has been swayed or influenced by considerations which should not have influenced it. In the Kilrush case I deny that. In the action taken to drop the charges in that particular case, I had to assist me a leading member of the Irish Bar. I approached the case in the same way as I approached every other case, with the determination that if there was evidence to justify a charge being made that charge was going to be made, no matter who complained. Approaching the evidence in that way it was decided in all the circumstances that the particular charges referred to by the Deputy should not be proceeded with. In view of the fact that this Commission was about to be set up it was intimated clearly to the court that my hands were kept absolutely free to take whatever action I wished after the findings of the Tribunal. Had the Tribunal, as Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney suggests, found that these charges should be proceeded with, that the evidence justified the charges being made that were then formulated or that other charges were to be preferred, I would not have felt in the least bound by anything that had happened at the earlier investigation to drop the charges. I would have proceeded with the charges.
I take it that the Minister for Justice will now yield to the demand made from the other side of the House to lay upon the Table of the House the report of the Kilrush Tribunal. I can tell Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney and Deputy Gearoid O'Sullivan that when they see the report of the Kilrush Tribunal they probably will not be so pleased that they asked for it.
Comment on this
That Tribunal will convey nothing to my mind. I do not accept the verdict of that class of Tribunal.
Comment on this
I think it is a monstrous thing for a Deputy who, again I say, is regarded by some people as being responsible, to allow his judgment, his prejudices, to be so unbalanced that he should here, in a place where they are unable to defend themselves, make a slanderous statement about the men who sat on that Tribunal. No whisper or suggestion was made until it was made here in this House, that the men selected to sit on the Kilrush Tribunal were not eminently suitable men to investigate this very difficult and troublesome case. I listened with astonishment to the suggestion that Mr. Patrick Lynch, K.C., is a man who could be suborned and one whose judgment I am supposed to know in advance.
Comment on this
At the date of the dropping of the Kilrush proceedings, if my memory serves me, the Minister for Justice had not then nominated his Tribunal. It was only subsequently that the Tribunal was nominated by the Minister for Justice. It is being calmly suggested here—I should not say calmly because it was not calmly suggested—but it has been suggested, and the suggestion will go out through the country, that Mr. Lynch, the Chairman of the Tribunal, is incapable of giving an impartial verdict on evidence submitted to him. I say that is a monstrous charge for anybody who knows Mr. Lynch to make. What I have said about Mr. Lynch applies also to the other members of the Tribunal. I do not happen to know Mr. McGrath. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was very careful to make no reflection on either Mr. Lynch or Mr. McGrath by name. He only chose to attack Mr. Brown, one of the most prominent solicitors in Kerry, because he happens to hold certain political views, and then the suggestion is that he is incapable of giving a fair and impartial judgment.
Comment on this
He must have a most biased judgment. A man who has been solicitor to the I.R.A. for a considerable time must have his mind biased in favour of them.
Comment on this
It is very undesirable that the personnel of a Commission should be discussed in the House at all.
Comment on this
I only referred to it as it has been referred to by the Deputy. I can only hazard the opinion that the Deputy is seeking in advance to take away some of the weight which the public will attach to the findings of that Commission. It will be found when the Report of that Commission is laid on the Table that if I erred in connection with the Kilrush case at all it was in not preferring against the Guards the formulated charges in the first instance, charges in connection with their conspiracy to make false charges against Ryan and Gilmore. These charges, according to the findings of this Tribunal, should have been considered by me and not charges against Ryan and Gilmore. However, the report will speak for itself.
Comment on this
Certainly it is coming to a nice pass when men cannot venture to go on a Tribunal like the Kilrush Tribunal without being slandered by men in this House who apparently do not know who they are or care.
Comment on this
I have dealt with the only two cases which were brought forward after the wild attack by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. The wild attack now narrows down to two particular cases and a hint that there were several more if they could only be uncovered. Since I came into office I have acted independently and have been to the best of my judgment actuated in every case by one consideration only, and that is what are the facts of the evidence which has been brought before me by the police. I think it is monstrous that I should be charged in the way I have been charged to-night by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney.
Comment on this
We accept the Minister's statement that he is acting bona fide, but the Minister knows that that does not dispose of these cases. The debate has lasted for some time and thanks to Deputy Cleary and the other Deputy who spoke the real points have been fairly successfully evaded. Even the Attorney-General has taken refuge in the question of whether the Tribunal in Clare was good or not, knowing full well that that was not the point of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney's charge at all. Deputy O'Sullivan said that it was a charge that ought to be taken seriously by the House and especially by the Labour Party. I feel that that is so, and that it should be taken seriously, especially by the Labour Party. What is the issue? What was said here by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was that the Minister, through political influence, either failed to make a charge when he should have made it or modified the charge he ought to have made.
There were two cases cited, and I would ask the House to attend carefully to the facts of those cases. Remember, you have the advantage that the facts are admitted. We are not disputing about the facts at all. We are not disputing the question of whether it was a good or a bad tribunal that was set up to deal with the Kilrush case. That is not in dispute and it should not be in dispute. Take the McWalter case in Mayo. It is admitted by the Attorney-General and by everybody else that an attack was made on the house of this man, Gavin, and that the attackers were armed. It is admitted that one of them was captured in the attack and that he was captured attempting to break into the house.
Comment on this
It was admitted up to this. It was published in all the papers that the man had a gun. He was actually charged with having a gun, surely?
Comment on this
I have no objection to the Deputy stating his version of the facts, but I do object to his attributing statements to me.
Comment on this
Those statements were made by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney and the Attorney-General has not helped us. Surely that was the charge? Surely it is not denied that there was an attempt to break into the house, and that McWalter was one of the men? What misstatements have I made or what have I said that was not admitted? I agree with the Attorney-General that it did not matter that this man went for the doctor or the priest. There is a bigger issue. That man was caught red-handed trying to break into a house with a gun. He was only charged with the offence with which I would be charged if I was found walking down the road with a gun in my pocket—having a gun without a licence. Is not that an extraordinary thing? Do the Deputies on the other side think that the Attorney-General has met the case when he says that he considered it on its merits. There was murder committed in this country before.
Comment on this
Never mind who did it—shut up for the moment. Houses have been broken into and murder has been committed. Supposing it happens again—they are not all Gavins—and murder is committed? That sort of thing is contagious and I must say that if such should happen the Attorney-General will have his responsibility. I do not care whether McWalter was wounded or not. There is no hurry about McWalter. He can get better. That is an appeal ad misericordiam and has nothing to do with this. The thing that matters is that he broke into a house with a gun and under circumstances which made it extremely likely that he was attempting to commit a felony. What charge was made against him? That of having a gun without a licence! I say that that is a most monstrous thing.
Suggestions have been made here by previous speakers on the lines of tu quoque—“You did as bad.” We never did. We never withdrew a charge from the magistrate or from the Court. They cannot suggest that any Minister for Justice or Attorney-General has ever done anything but prefer the charges that ought to be preferred. The late Kevin O'Higgins established a high tradition here, to start with. There is a high tradition in England, one of the few countries where there is a tradition, that of equal law. Ours was higher—equal law, equally administered—and that was carried on by every Minister for Justice and Attorney-General up to the last election. I put it to the Labour Party that from the point of view of the poor alone this is a most important question. The Labour Party may think that political influence is on their side at the moment, but taking any sort of a long view, it suits the poor that there should be an equal administration of law. I put it to them, and to anyone with a respect for the conception of law, that this thing should not be allowed to stop at this. One of the most serious crimes is breaking into a man's house. We know what it means in this country especially. It makes it more serious that it should have been done with a gun, and no mercy should be given to the man who did it, and it does not meet the case that he should be charged with the offence with which he was charged. If there is any real sense of real liberty in this House they will not allow this matter to remain where it is. They will not allow a man guilty of a foul crime to lie in jail for a short sentence for having a gun without a licence. I say that it is a disgrace.
Now I come on to the Kilrush case. I do not want to say anything about the Court——
Comment on this
I will not ask your leave for anything I say. I said that sentence in order to underline this:—That it is not the point whether the Court was right or wrong, good or bad. The point is this—that it must again be admitted that two Guards made a charge against certain persons of assault and of using firearms—revolvers. That charge was made. That charge might be wrong. That charge might be made by you or me and be wrong. The law is not powerless. The resources of civilisation are not exhausted.
When such a criminal charge is made, the usual procedure—the normal procedure—is that informations are sworn. Is not that so? Why were they not sworn here? Did the Guards refuse? The public should know that. The next step is to go before a magistrate. We need then have had no argument as to whether the Court was good, bad or indifferent, or the solicitor Fianna Fáil or Cumann na nGaedheal. The Courts are there. It is generally admitted here and elsewhere that our magistrates and our magisterial system are first class. We had the magistrates there. Why was not the charge brought before a magistrate? Why were not depositions taken? The facts could have come out that way. Why was the usual procedure altered this time? I am in a difficulty in all this. The Attorney-General acted bona fide, but it was most unfortunate that the usual procedure, the invariable procedure, was altered in a case where the two injured innocents were two well-known and dangerous characters, to everybody's knowledge, in the I.R.A. It is most unfortunate that that should have occurred—most unfortunate. I personally—I am not speaking now as a lawyer—have never heard of a case before —the Attorney-General may be able to quote one—where the Attorney-General entered a nolle prosequi, before depositions were taken. I thought that was an unusual procedure. All I have to say is that where you had two members of the Civic Guard, two esteemed members of the Civic Guard—but, again, that is neither here nor there—making definite charges of assault, and assault by people who had guns, it is most unfortunate——