We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance—Estimates for Public Services. - Vote 26—Law Charges.

Contributions 116–239 of 239. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Mr. Maguire

I have explained to the Deputy that I did not enter a nolle prosequi.

Comment on this

You withdrew it?

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

No.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The Attorney-General has left us all guessing by his failure to reply.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

The position is that if I wish to bring charges what has happened in the District Courts does not debar me, as the Deputy well knows, from preferring the charges now.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

It is open to the Attorney-General I know to charge those two Guards with assault. I am not speaking of them.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

No—to charge Gilmour and Ryan.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Oh, I see. Well why not do that first? Why not follow the invariable procedure? The invariable procedure was to proceed to the Court of first instance, have depositions taken there, and see is there a prima facie case made out. That normal, almost invariable, procedure was not followed. Why? Whatever the reason may be the Attorney-General, before he came to the conclusion that he should refrain from carrying out the normal procedure, must have practically tried the case himself. I put it to the Dáil that that is a very serious state of affairs, and that that is a new function for the Attorney-General. I go on to the third case that is the case of this man Dempsey. Dempsey was sentenced by a Judge. He was out in a few days. Why was he out?

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

I prosecuted Dempsey. He was convicted. Beyond that my jurisdiction did not go.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Well then it is your colleague. It is not the Attorney-General. We can refer to that again. I will leave out those two cases. I have outlined for the Dáil what has occurred. Now the principal facts are admitted. In fact the Attorney-General has had to admit them. I have not made a single statement of fact that is not admitted on both sides. I put it to the Dáil that what has happened is this: The high tradition which was laid down here at the beginning, of impartial and impersonal law, has, if you like unconsciously, been departed from—and that is the worst day's work that could be done—and that the Attorney-General and Minister for Justice are gradually allocating to themselves the functions of the Judges. It may suit the political exigencies to do this, but it will turn this State into a fourth-rate State, and a State in which there will be no liberty and no law no matter what form of Government there is.

Comment on this

A Leas-Chinn Comhairle: This has been a very valuable debate, but it has also been, on the part of the Opposition at any rate, a very badly stage managed debate, because the Opposition did not follow the precedent which it created last week and raise the issue, the so very-important issue which has been raised on this debate, in a debate upon the Adjournment. The Government now are in a position to examine the charges which have been made against them—the charge, in the words of Deputy O'Sullivan and Deputy Patrick Hogan, that in the administration of justice he had been governed by political influences. That charge was made last week. It has been repeated to-night. Apparently it is going to be one of the catch cries of the Opposition from this time forward—that we have been governed in the administration of justice by political influences. It is safe to make a charge like that when you feel you are going to have the last word.

It was noticeable on the part of some Deputies in this House when they were members of the Government that in a debate they preferred to follow feminine tactics—they wanted always to have the proverbial last word, and because they felt secure in that last week they launched the charge again, that we were governed by political influences in the administration of justice. This debate would have been as shameful as the debate on the Adjournment last week, when spokesmen of the Opposition Benches got up, knowing they had right behind them not merely in the case of Dullea but in the case of Levison, Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies who had gone on deputations to the Minister for Justice asking that they should be released.

Comment on this

We should have the names.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Neill's name was mentioned. What about Deputy Finlay in regard to Levison— Deputy Finlay who sat beside Deputy McGilligan priming him as regards the case he had to make, I am sure in the cause of justice, on behalf of Dr. Levison. That matter was raised on the Adjournment. It could have been raised on Notice of Motion if necessary. It could have been raised in such a way as would have enabled all the issues in it to be debated, and it would have been well for the Opposition if in raising the issue again to-day they tried to adopt the same tactics as last week, and have had a debate upon the Adjournment. We have heard Deputy Hogan speak. We have heard him again come forward, and, on behalf of the late administration, make a plea which the records do not substantiate, that they had established a high tradition for equal administration of the law in this country. I have heard the Attorney-General arraigned because a charge, which was I think a matter of summary jurisdiction, was preferred in the case of a man who is alleged to have broken into a house in conspiracy with some others, and who was wounded by the householder. I am not going to condone in any way what McWalter did. If I were to make any comment at all it would have been to commend the householder who defended his home. I do not know the circumstances of the case, but I am prepared to say from what I know of the Attorney-General that he took the right course, bearing everything in mind, and I rely on his judgment for that. My only regret is that the last Government, in much more serious circumstances which recently came to my notice, did not arraign people against whom there was conclusive testimony to prove that they were not merely guilty of house-breaking, but guilty of armed robbery, not only on one occasion but on three, and not merely of armed robbery, but of murder, and not of murder on one occasion, but on at least three.

Comment on this
A Deputy

You ought to give us the names.

Comment on this

In November, 1923, a civilian was murdered in the streets of Dublin, a civil servant was murdered in the streets of Dublin.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow this——

Comment on this

I am dealing with the issue raised by Deputy Hogan, the last speaker, who said the administration of which he was a member had established, on his own words, "a high tradition for equal law."

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow this. We are discussing the administration of the Attorney-General's Department and we must confine ourselves to that.

Comment on this

I suggest that, as the matter has been raised, and as this matter has been raised, in substantiating a charge against the present administration, I am entitled to examine that argument, and discuss that argument——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Hogan said the late administration set up a standard of justice which was very high. That was merely a passing reference to the administration of which he was a member. He did not go into details.

Comment on this

I am not going into details.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow a discussion on the late administration—it is not at all in order. We will never get anywhere if this is allowed.

Comment on this

I suggest, A Leas-Chinn Comhairle, in view of the wide range of this debate, Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney was allowed to perverse the reason for the setting up of the Kilrush Tribunal——

Comment on this

With great respect I mentioned I was not going into the Kilrush Tribunal, or anything about it, except in so far as the Attorney-General is concerned.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I dealt with two cases —deal with them you.

Comment on this

Deputy Hogan asked why the usual custom is not followed. He said the usual procedure, when evidence came before the Attorney-General and those who were responsible for the administration of justice, was to have information sworn. I want to show that up to the present Government came in office that was not the usual procedure. I think I am entitled to show that——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

On that reasoning we could open up every case from 1921 up, obviously that could not occur on this Vote. I have had the advantage, or disadvantage, of hearing Deputies Hogan and Fitzgerald-Kenney, and they did not go back on these cases.

Comment on this

I want to show that, in a case where detectives in Court identified men who committed two crimes informations were not sworn, and that instead of that instructions were sent out from headquarters that no action was to be taken.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This is not a discussion on the administration of the late Government. We are concerned now with the administration of the Attorney-General's Department on this Vote and we must confine ourselves to that.

Comment on this

The question of the usual procedure was discussed by Deputy Hogan.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is a matter of law.

Comment on this

No, what was the usual procedure is very often a matter of precedent, not a matter of law.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not for me to determine what is the usual procedure.

Comment on this

I submit that when you are debarring me from discussing this you are debarring me from the usual procedure. You accept Deputy Hogan's definition of what is the usual procedure. I submit what he alleges in regard to the procedure of the late Government is not proved.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister is trying to raise an issue with which I am not concerned at all. I am concerned with the administration of the Attorney-General's Department.

Comment on this

I submit that the most that could possibly be revelant is, what was the usual procedure in the year 1931, not in the year 1923.

Comment on this

Deputy MacDermot does not occupy any position of honour in this House. He is responsible to his own constituents and possibly they will deal with him later. At this moment I suggest that I am entitled to show what the usual procedure was in this case.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister is not entitled to show that what the late Administration did in 1924, '25, '26 or up to now, is right or wrong. He is entitled to show that what the Attorney-General did in the administration of his Department is right during the year under review or not, and nothing else.

Comment on this

Deputy Hogan has asked us why not adopt an invariable procedure, I took a note of his words. Why not adopt an invariable procedure. In adopting an invariable procedure, I want to show the procedure was not invariable—that in fact it varied. I think I am entitled to show that.

Comment on this

Deputy Hogan is referring to the procedure adopted by law, not by the Government.

Comment on this

Why was the usual procedure altered? I want to show that there is no established procedure, that it is a matter of fact so far as precedents go and precedent determines procedure, just as law. There are precedents on both sides and I want to cite one example where informations were not sworn.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It has no reference to the administration of the Attorney-General's Department.

Comment on this

Oh, yes, it has, because the allegation is that we have been remiss in the prosecution of justice, and I want to show that in certain serious matters there have been long intervals, so long that no action has been taken, and I think I am entitled to show that at any rate the late Government did establish a certain procedure, not an invariable procedure, but a procedure which they departed from on occasions which suited them.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister is entitled to make these statements. He is entitled to say the late Government did this, that or the other, but I am not going to allow this Dáil to debate matters that the late Government did as far back as 1923, or any year prior to the year under review, but what is under discussion on this Vote on the administration of the Attorney-General's Department. Otherwise we would never get anywhere.

Comment on this

I am not asking you to permit the Dáil to discuss it. I want to repeat again that there is no such thing as invariable procedure——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister will proceed on the lines I have already indicated.

Comment on this

I think the Government, being attacked, should at least be given an opportunity to defend itself. We have heard the most shameful allegations made by the late Minister for Justice, the late Minister for Justice who will go down in history as the author of the story of a cow which kicked with both legs at the same time.

Comment on this

The Minister ought to be a little more accurate. Mr. Ryan was not kicked. He was knocked off a stool by a cow. He should be a little more accurate with his facts.

Comment on this
A Deputy

The kicking cow will live in history.

Comment on this

I do not mind.

Comment on this

Oh, yes, it is the invariable procedure. Why was the usual procedure altered?

Comment on this

If a cow knocks down a man and the Guards are charged——

Comment on this

Informations are always sworn! Well, they were not sworn at any rate, I know, in February, 1924. What was the usual procedure? I do not know what the Opposition had to complain of in regard to McWalter. It may have been a fact that no accomplice of his was arrested. Possibly because an accomplice was not arrested and had not confessed to his complicity in the crime and had not by his confession implicated Mc. Walter——

Comment on this
A Deputy

He did.

Comment on this

—— that accomplice not having been brought to trial on a charge of attempted murder, and not having been remanded on bail, as an accomplice to a murder in 1923 was in 1925 under the late Government— possibly what Deputy Fitgerald-Kenney has been complaining of is the fact that when this hypothetical accomplice to McWalter was allowed out on bail in this fashion, he and his accomplice in the crime were not permitted to abscond, as three men who were guilty of two murders and three armed robberies were in 1923 under the late Government. That is how justice was invariably administered !

Comment on this

Nobody minds the Minister.

Comment on this

That is how justice was invariably administered under Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney and his predecessors. That is the high tradition which they established for equal administration of the law. Possibly what Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney had to complain of in regard to the Kilrush inquiry was that the Civic Guards had not received instructions from their headquarters when they identified men alleged to have committed crime, when they could have easily have apprehended these men, not to take any action until ten months afterwards when two of them got an opportunity of fleeing the country. Possibly that is what Deputy Fitgerald-Kenney has arraigned the Attorney-General for. Of course if we had done that, if we had so perverted the machinery which has been established in this country as to permit self-confessed criminals to escape, simply because they happened to belong to one or other of the forces under our control, then we would have been following the high tradition established for equal law by the late administration. But because whether the accused be guilty or not, whether the complainant be in uniform or out of uniform, we are going to examine the evidence that will be made available to the Court to satisfy ourselves that a charge justly lies before we put a man upon his plea, we are attacked in this fashion. When after a searching investigation into the evidence we set up a tribunal which will approach the issue without any bias in favour of one party or the other, and when the findings of that tribunal vindicate up to the hilt the action which we have taken we are attacked as we have been attacked by the Opposition, but that attack has recoiled like a boomerang on the head of the man who launched it.

What standing has Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney at the Bar of the country to attack a man with the record of Mr. Patrick Lynch? What record has he in the country's service except for the fortuitous fact that he happened to be available in the House in 1927 when a Coercion Bill was being rushed through by the late Government, when trafficking in the murder of Kevin O'Higgins, they tried to crush every element of constitutional liberty in this country? They rushed a Treason Act through the Dáil, and when they were looking round for a worthy successor to Buckshot Forster, to Arthur Balfour, to Hamar Greenwood, they picked Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. Who in this country would ever have heard of him? But we have heard of him. History has heard of him and he will go down in history. He will go down in history in the same category as these others, as one of the great instruments of Imperialist coercion in this country.

Comment on this

I did not intend to intervene in the debate were it not that my name has been mentioned by the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I regret to have to interrupt Deputy Finlay, but the proceedings of the House have been disturbed day after day by outrageous demonstrations in the Gallery. If members of the House are to be intimidated by guests of other members, the proceedings of the House cannot go on, and I confidently appeal to the Chair to take whatever action may be necessary to put an end to these disgusting outbursts.

Comment on this

I think it would be more convincing if Deputy Dillon had raised this matter with the Ceann Comhairle without waiting to consult his so-called colleague, Deputy MacDermot.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think the Ceann Comhairle has already indicated that the responsibility rests with each Deputy as to the visitors he introduces into the Gallery. The Gallery is not the place for demonstration either for or against anything said here, and each Deputy is responsible for the conduct of visitors he introduces into the Gallery. It is within the discretion of the Ceann Comhairle to close the Gallery to visitors, and I think the Ceann Comhairle is so minded if these demonstrations continue. He will be forced to take drastic measures to relieve the House of these demonstrations.

Comment on this

As I said, I did not intend to intervene in this debate were it not that my name has been introduced in the course of a speech by the Minister for Finance. I want to hear from him here and now, does he state to the Dáil that I at any time advocated the release of Dr. Levison from prison or any reduction in his sentence?

Comment on this

He stated that.

Comment on this

He did not, but he tried to state it in an oblique way. At no time did I advocate the release of Dr. Levison.

Comment on this

I have not said that the Deputy advocated the release of Dr. Levison but I said, and I think I am right, that he interested himself in the case.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Anyway, it does not arise on this Vote.

Comment on this

If I am wrong in that opinion I withdraw it, but I believe I am right.

Comment on this

Am I not to be allowed to discuss this matter? In all fairness I should be allowed to clear it up.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I shall allow the Deputy to clear it up in so far as his name has been mentioned but it cannot be discussed further.

Comment on this

I do not want to discuss it except to make a personal explanation. I state here and now that if anybody makes the statement in the House that I at any time advocated the release of Dr. Levison he is stating a deliberate falsehood. The only reason I intervened is that if a person with the mind of the Minister for Finance is put up in this House to justify the actions of the Government on these various matters at the very outset by stating a deliberate falsehood——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow that to pass. The Minister for Finance did not state a deliberate falsehood. That is tantamount to saying that the Minister had stated what is a lie.

Comment on this

What is incorrect?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will have to withdraw the words "deliberate falsehood."

Comment on this

I withdraw that statement.

Comment on this

Do I understand the Deputy to say that he did not interest himself, in the case of Dr. Levison, because if I understood him to say that I would accept his word, and be prepared to withdraw the statement I made?

Comment on this

The position with regard to Dr. Levison's case was this: I prosecuted, and Mr. Lupton, counsel, who defended, asked me if I would accompany him to the Minister for Justice, with a view to correcting him in anything he might say to the Minister with regard to the course of the trial. I told Mr. Lupton that out of courtesy to a brother at the Bar, I certainly would accompany him to the Minister and, also, out of courtesy to the Minister himself. On that occasion the Minister said to me "May I take you as petitioning on behalf of Dr. Levison?" And I said "Certainly not." In the interview I drew his attention to one matter, when Mr. Lupton was putting the matter before the Minister, and that was, that at the end of the trial Mr. Lupton asked for liberty to appeal on the ground, amongst others, that there was a miscarriage of justice and the trial judge said: "I will not accede because in my opinion there has been no miscarriage of justice." I pass now from that.

Comment on this

On a point of personal explanation: The House will recollect, when this matter was on a night or two ago, I said I would take the responsibility in both cases. But there is now the question of fact, and I would like to give Deputy Finlay every opportunity of conveying to the Dáil everything that is material concerning this matter. As Deputy Finlay has thought fit to intervene will he deny this: that he came to me in my room and told me that he had prosecuted Dr. Levison—that he did not expect he would be convicted, and that the trial judge did not expect he would be convicted?

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this

You deny you said that?

Comment on this

Certainly I deny it.

Comment on this

I have a perfectly clear recollection that Deputy Finlay said to me, in the presence of Mr. Lupton, that he did not expect a conviction, and went further and said the judge did not expect a conviction.

Comment on this

I would not deny that because I have not a clear recollection. If the Minister has a clear recollection I will not deny that.

Comment on this

I want to be perfectly fair——

Comment on this

I have no recollection of saying that I did not expect a conviction. What I said was that the judge in his charge certainly charged in favour of the defendant, and my recollection is that Mr. Lupton said he did not expect a conviction.

Comment on this

So that Deputy Finlay may have every chance I put it to him now, in the presence of the whole House, that he stated to me his own condition of mind. He can tell the House now his condition of mind but I put it to him now, and he can deny it if he wishes, that he told me specifically—and that influenced me greatly —that he, the prosecuting counsel, did not expect a conviction, and, furthermore, that the judge did not expect a conviction. That had tremendous weight with me.

Comment on this

All I can say is that I have no recollection of these words, and I do not believe I could have used them, because my own state of mind was that I considered there would be a conviction. I recollect undoubtedly saying that the judge charged in favour of Dr. Levison. I now pass from the matter. I did not desire to enter into it in this House because it places me in an invidious position, having prosecuted, and I would not have mentioned the matter if my name was not dragged into it in a most unjustifiable way by the Minister for Finance.

But to pass now to other matters. Let me say that the excuse given for the Attorney-General stopping the prosecution of McWalter in Mayo was upset by the evidence. As I understood, the offence was breaking into a house, or attempting to break into a house, with intent to commit a felony. The matter is entirely one of inference for a jury to draw from the surrounding facts in connection with a particular crime. In connection with McWalter, the position was this: The evidence showed that he attempted to break into a house. He was found outside in possession of firearms, and surely any reasonable person would come to the conclusion that there were facts established there, and that it was for a jury to say whether there was intention to commit a felony. The punishment for attempting to break into a house is more serious and greater than any punishment that can be given for an offence of having a gun without a licence, and I do suggest, while I accept the Attorney—General's word, that he examined this case bona fide, that there could be no doubt whatsoever that there were sufficient and ample facts before him to justify a prosecution for attempting to break into a house with intent to commit a felony. It was a matter for a jury. In this country, in cases of serious crime, the final arbitrator is a jury as to whether the offence was committed or not. It is for a jury to decide whether the offence was committed. The best place any person can find himself, if it is alleged that he committed a crime, is before twelve of his own countrymen. They are the best judges of the facts. No one can read or take a photograph of what was at the back of the person's mind at the time. He can only he judged by all the surrounding acts. I say this, no person reading these acts, as they were apparent to the Attorney-General, should take upon himself to decide that no reasonable jury would convict this man of breaking into a house with intent to commit a felony. That is the position of the Attorney-General. He decided, in the first instance, whether there was reasonable evidence to place the man on trial. And while I accept his word, that he considered this whole matter bona fide, I say it is, in these circumstances, regrettable that he did not let the law follow its ordinary course, in that there was abundance of evidence of intent to commit a crime, which should have been determined by a trial before a jury of the man's own fellow countrymen.

Comment on this

Very serious charges have been made against the Attorney-General here this evening. Perhaps not the least serious of the charges was the charge made by Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney, that the Attorney-General, to use the words of the Deputy, conspired with the Minister for Justice in order to deny justice to the Guards who were concerned in the affray at Kilrush. It is not necessary to emphasise how grave that charge is and how necessary it is that it should be met by the Attorney-General, and should be met by anyone else in this House who is in any degree concerned in order to assist the House. I shall endeavour to avoid going into any ground covered already, or that is manifestly within the knowledge of Deputies in this House. It is only for me to say, in regard to these charges at Kilrush, that there were allegations made by Mr. J. Ryan and Mr. Gilmore and Mr. Lowe against certain members of the Garda Síochána, and that there were counter allegations by two members of the Garda Síochána—Carroll and Muldowney—against Lowe and the Gilmores.

In so far as charges were made against Gilmore, Lowe and Ryan, I had no very direct or immediate concern. The Courts of the country were available to deal with any serious charge, seriously supported, against Ryan, Gilmore and Lowe. With charges against the Guards of gross violation of duty, of an attempt to pervert the course of justice, of wounding citizens without rhyme or reason, I, as Parliamentary head of the Department of Justice, was intimately concerned. I was bound to answer to this House in respect of that force. It has been suggested here, very speciously, that the way to deal with these charges was to have recourse first to the District Justice and afterwards to a Judge and Jury for trial, because no one suggested that the District Justice had jurisdiction in this case. It was an indictable charge. He had merely jurisdiction to return for trial. If Gilmore, Ryan and Lowe were returned for trial, unlikely as it would have been, if they had been tried at Ennis before the Circuit Court Judge and a Jury, and if they had been acquitted by that Jury, which Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney suggests is the method to try them, and I was to come here and tell the House that because of the trial at Ennis before a County Clare Jury disciplinary action had been taken against Guards, what would be said in this House, what would be insinuated?

In discharge of my duty I did not adopt any novel or unheard of procedure. Section 18 of the Police Forces (Amalgamation) Act, Statute No. 7 of 1925, passed by the Parliament of this country, provided for the constitution of a Tribunal such as the Kilrush Tribunal. The section was not called in aid for the first time by me. My distinguished predecessor in the office of the Minister for Justice, the late Mr. O'Higgins, appointed a Commission of three members, presided over by a member of the junior Bar, with another member of the junior Bar as one colleague, and with a layman as the third, to inquire into much less grave charges made against certain detective officers in the County Waterford. Perhaps Deputies have only to have that drawn to their attention to recollect it. The suggestion now made against the Attorney-General is that he entered into a conspiracy to draw the trial of this issue away from a jury in the County Clare and to put it before some hole-and-corner Tribunal. Some Deputy on the Opposite side used, as I felt sure some one would before the debate concluded, the phrase, Star Chamber. What does the House think of that charge made against the Attorney-General? Pursuant to the Statute of 1925, the Tribunal was set up. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney said—I was amazed and I was pained to hear him saying it—"Every-one who knows the personnel of that Commission knew they would find against the Guards. The Attorney-General entered into a conspiracy with the Minister for Justice to set up a tribunal, and everyone who knows the personnel of that Commission knew they would find against the Guards." I was gratified that a member of the junior Bar, Deputy Gearoid O'Sullivan, did not associate himself with that. I may differ from Deputy O'Sullivan in many of his opinions, but I expected that Deputy O'Sullivan would have the pluck to stand aside from that charge. I was also gratified that a member of the other branch of the profession, the solicitors' profession, Deputy Hogan (Galway) not merely did not stand by it, but got quite away from it. These Deputies knew the indecency of the charge as well as its injustice.

That Kilrush Tribunal was presided over by Mr. Patrick Lynch, a man of 42 years' standing at the Irish Bar, a leader of the Irish Bar, a member of the Bar that the late Government delighted to honour, and rightly delighted to honour. The late Government entrusted the conduct of some of their most serious cases to this gentleman and the Attorney-General is now accused of entering into a conspiracy to induce that gentleman to perpetrate an injustice on the police of the country. As late as 1931 the late Administration had Mr. Lynch as their leading Counsel in one of the heaviest cases of the year. Many times during the years they were in office, when they were in a tight pinch, Mr. Lynch was the man they resorted to. Not merely had they Mr. Lynch as an advocate, but when they appointed, pursuant to a Statute of this House, temporary Judges to hear the heavy arrears of Civil Bill Appeals, with all the powers practically of High Court Judges, they selected Mr. Lynch as one of these Commissioners and entrusted him with the trial of these cases. When some of these, including some who now sit on the benches opposite, had private litigation, we know from the public prints that they resorted to Mr. Lynch.

Comment on this

If that statement has reference to me, it is not true.

Comment on this

It has no reference to one in particular. Perhaps Deputy Cosgrave would like to associate himself with Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney in saying: "Every one who knows the personnel of the Kilrush Commission knew they would find against the Guards."

Comment on this

I am concerning myself with the statement made by the Minister.

Comment on this

I made no statement incidentally about Deputy Cosgrave.

Comment on this

"Some of the people sitting on the Front Bench opposite."

Comment on this

If I said the Front Bench opposite, I was not comprehensive enough. I should have said the benches. I think I did say the benches.

Comment on this

Perhaps the, to me, unknown Deputy on the back benches, would like also to associate himself with the statement that the Attorney-General entered into a conspiracy to procure a man to deny justice to the Guards. However, as I said, I am gratified that the two other members of the legal profession who spoke stood aside from that charge, and that even Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney had not the audacity to attack the third member of that Tribunal, a man whose success in the legal profession is eclipsed only by his success on the field of battle in the Great War. This is the conspiracy; these are the conspirators; these are the tools of the conspiracy, a conspiracy to wreak injustice on the members of the Guards. Deputy O'Sullivan challenges the Government to lay on the Table of the House the Report of the Kilrush Tribunal. I have before me the report of the Kilrush Tribunal. There is no mystery about the report of the Kilrush Tribunal and there is no attempt to keep back from the public the very valuable public document relating to the Kilrush Tribunal. The complaint is made that there are men who were denied justice, men whose complaint and allegation were not solemnly acted on by the Attorney-General, and a prosecution arranged against Gilmore, Ryan and Lowe on the strength of their word. The Attorney-General, who is one of the high statutory officials in this country, on whom the responsibility rests not to bring nonsensical prosecutions, foolish prosecutions, would have been prosecuting on the faith of the statement of two men in regard to whom the Kilrush Tribunal say—and I read from their original signed document:—

(1) From the evidence before us, we find, first, that Detective Officers Myles Muldowney and Michael Christopher Carroll and members of the party consisting of George Gilmore and others were guilty of jeering at and taunting each other at the Cappa Road, Kilrush, on the night of Sunday, 14th August, but that Messrs. Gilmore, Ryan and Lowe did not take part therein;

(2) that Detective Officers Myles Muldowney and Michael Christopher Carroll, followed the party consisting of George Gilmore and others, for a distance not warranted by the duty on which they were engaged, and that without justification they fired at and wounded Messrs. Gilmore and Ryan.

"Without justification they fired at and wounded Messrs. Gilmore and Ryan,"—and the attack on my friend here to-night is not an attack for failing to prosecute Carroll and Muldowney who, without justification, fired at and wounded Messrs. Gilmore and Ryan. He is not to be content with the wounding of these three citizens without justification but he is to pursue them with a hopeless prosecution which he knows in his heart and conscience he cannot sustain, and the House is asked to take the attack on the Attorney-General seriously. But it does not end with that.

(3) That no shots were fired by the party consisting of Messrs. Gilmore, Ryan and others.

That was found by this distinguished Tribunal. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney can directly insult the members of the Tribunal as much as he likes. Deputy Cosgrave, instead of openly and bluntly insulting them, or any of them, as Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney did, may get up, it seems to me, quite voluntarily, and make a statement from which any inference may be drawn and may be construed in any way that any person, according to his own mind, may like to construe it, but the public——

Comment on this

I should like to know in what way I have insulted this Tribunal.

Comment on this

The members of this House here——

Comment on this

The Minister has made a statement which is either true or false. I characterise it as false.

Comment on this

When I drew attention to a remark of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney's, and said that the Government of which Deputy Cosgrave was the head, repeatedly employed Mr. Lynch as their leading counsel and appointed him to judicial office, and when I went on to say that members occupying the benches opposite, when they had private litigation, had had resort to Mr. Lynch's services, Deputy Cosgrave thinks it well to get up then and make a statement like a sort of masculine Sybil.

Comment on this

The Minister has said "instead of insulting these men"—that implies clearly and distinctly that I have insulted them, and that statement is not true.

Comment on this

I have not any recollection of having said that Deputy Cosgrave——

Comment on this

Those are the words used by the Minister—"instead of insulting them."

Comment on this

I have no recollection of stating that Deputy Cosgrave insulted the men.

Comment on this

But the Minister said "Deputy Cosgrave, instead of insulting them." Obviously, that implies that I have insulted them.

Comment on this

Does it? I thought that implied the very contrary.

Comment on this

Oh, I see.

Comment on this

No one admires the adroitness of Deputy Cosgrave more than I do, but all his adroitness and ingenuity can hardly make that out to be a charge, and the Deputy really knows that.

Comment on this

But, at any rate, there is no charge?

Comment on this

There is no charge. The Deputy really knows that. The Attorney-General is charged with this abuse of his office, that he did not accept the words of men, who, without justification, wounded Gilmore and Ryan; that he did not make the injury done to Gilmore and Ryan greater by prosecuting Gilmore and Ryan, notwithstanding the findings that Carroll and Mudowney were themselves the aggressors without justification, and notwithstanding the findings that no shots were fired by the party consisting of Gilmore, Ryan and others. But there is still more that the Attorney-General would have had to swallow, because the Attorney-General is supposed to make himself conversant with the facts, and he is not supposed recklessly to launch prosecutions:

(4) That the said Detective Officers Muldowney and Carroll caused Messrs. Gilmore, Ryan and Lowe to be wrongfully charged with shooting at and attempting to murder them, the said Detective Officers, and for the purpose of causing them to be charged, deceived their own superior officers by making to them false and misleading statements...

What does Deputy Cosgrave think of that? What does he think of that? And his colleagues on the Front Bench accused the Attorney-General here of the grave impropriety and wickedness of entering into a conspiracy to refrain from prosecuting Gilmore and Ryan, and to refrain from acting upon the allegations of the two worthies, Muldowney and Carroll. Against these men these findings were come to by this court after a four days' trial, after cross-examination by the very eminent counsel who represented the police at that inquiry, after cross-examination of all the witnesses, and after an eloquent speech by that distinguished senior counsel, Mr. Fitzgerald, who represented the police. The Attorney-General is to be impleaded here in the cause of men who fired at and wounded citizens, without justification, men who deceived their own superior officers, men who made false and misleading statements, and, in favour of these men, after all that attempt to pervert the course of justice, the Attorney-General is, I suppose, to imitate the traditional figure of Justice itself, by placing some sort of wrapping around his eyes. He is to blind himself. He is to become blind to all these facts that were demonstrated so clearly at this four-day hearing in Kilrush and he is to prosecute not, as I said before, the men who fired without cause and wounded without cause; not the perverters of the course of justice; not the men who made deliberately false statements to their own superior officers. He is to prosecute the unfortunate men who were wounded without cause. Here is a further extract from the judgment:

We are of opinion that the superior officers acted in good faith, having been misled by these false statements.

In other words, the charges that were at first prepared before the District Justice and framed by a higher officer were framed in perfect good faith, because he was deceived. The superior officer was deceived, but Deputy Cosgrave here to-night or Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney or Deputy Hogan cannot say they were deceived because they have all the evidence. They have read the evidence given at Kilrush. When they come here to charge the Attorney-General with conspiracy, with procuring an injustice upon Muldowney and Carroll, they know the facts, facts that were not in the possession of the superior officers of Muldowney and Carroll, and those superior officers acted in perfect good faith but in error.

(5) That, in effecting the arrest of Mr. T.J. Ryan at Kilrush Hospital, Detective Officers Myles Muldowney and Matthew Mulkeen committed a serious assault on the said Mr. T.J. Ryan by beating him about the head with their revolvers; but that, having regard to our finding at No. 4 above, although Detective Officer Muldowney knew that the arrest was unjustified, Detective Officer Mulkeen was not so aware.

And by reason of that circumstance, Detective Officer Mulkeen is a member of the Gárda Síochána to-day.

(6) We are of opinion that the complaints of delay in conveying Mr. T.J. Ryan to hospital after arrest have not been established and that Superintendent Feeney and Sergeant O'Reilly did everything in their power to have him removed to hospital as soon as possible after his arrival at the Gárda Síochána Station. We find that during his detention in the Station he was not in any way ill-treated.

(7) Regarding the allegations of ill-treatment of Mr. G. Gilmore in the hospital, we are of opinion that he was unnecessarily disturbed and annoyed, having regard to his condition, by Detective Officer Thomas Murphy, but that the charges in this respect against Detective Officers Bernard Hanley and James Brennan have not been proven. No allegation was made against Detective Officers Patrick McCaffrey and James P. Hughes, and we are satisfied that they acted with every consideration.

(8) That the allegations regarding the ill-treatment of Mr. T.J. Ryan in hospital have not been sustained.

Signed:—

Patrick Lynch,

John G. McGrath,

D.J. Brown.

Comment on this

Is it to be published? Is the whole of the report to be published?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

And the evidence also?

Comment on this

The report, I can say without hesitation, will be published, because the expense of printing and circulating the report will be trivial. If Deputy Cosgrave is serious in suggesting that the evidence should be published I shall be glad if, in a day or two, he will put that matter to me advisedly. The evidence after a hearing lasting four days is, of course, very bulky. The hearing lasted for four days; there was quite a lot of examination and cross-examination. The evidence is very bulky. I do not think the House would expect me here and now, impromptu, to give an undertaking that I will incur the very considerable expense of having that evidence printed. I am not saying that I decline to do it. I suggest to Deputy Cosgrave that he might consider putting forward that proposal on another day. I may say that I will be greatly impressed by any suggestion Deputy Cosgrave makes. If he feels that the expense of printing the evidence would be justified, I certainly shall seriously consider it and I shall probably seek authority for the expenditure.

Comment on this

Would the Minister also consider the advisability of printing a few of the earlier ones? I would like to see them in print.

Comment on this

Has not the bulk of the evidence been published in the Press?

Comment on this

I think it has. I have read the actual typescript from the stenographer as part of my duty. I read the newspapers in a casual sort of a way. The evidence as given in the newspapers is by no means as full as the stenographer's transcript. At the same time, I think the newspapers did give the substance of it; they did really give the meat of the evidence. However, it is really a matter for Deputies. If any Deputy feels that the evidence should be printed in the form of a White, a Blue, a Yellow, or any other sort of book, he has only to put forward the suggestion.

Comment on this

If the Minister's answer is quite correct, that the bulk of the evidence has already been published in the newspapers, then I think Deputies will agree that the publication of it would add very few pages to the report which it is proposed to publish. The amount of evidence which has already appeared in the newspapers, if it represents the bulk of the evidence, will not increase the volume very much if it is included.

Comment on this

The phrase I used —and if I did not use it I meant to— was that the substance of the evidence appeared in the newspapers. If I did say the bulk of the evidence, in the sense of suggesting that the newspaper account was as extensive and voluminous as the stenographer's typescript, then I was erroneous. I am not sure that I did say bulk. I think I said substance.

Comment on this

Deputy MacDermot's question was to the effect that the bulk of the evidence had already appeared in the Press.

Comment on this

I interpreted the Deputy as meaning the pith of the evidence.

Comment on this

That is what I did mean.

Comment on this

The material evidence.

Comment on this

I have made it perfectly clear that if there is any substantial demand for the publication of the evidence I believe I will get the authority of the Executive Council to accede to that demand. I give an unqualified undertaking as regards publishing the whole of the report from end to end. There were other allusions in the course of speeches from Deputies opposite that might in a sense be construed as extending to me. There was an allusion, for instance, to the case of Dempsey. The Attorney-General is being charged with being rather heinous in regard to it and, while the word "conspiracy" was not used in regard to the Dempsey case, the words used were almost equivalent to that. I merely want to say now that when the appropriate opportunity offers, if any Deputy wants to raise the Dempsey case, I will deal with that case. I will deal with it in this way: I will give the facts whether they are for or against the Government.

I believe that if all the facts of the Dempsey case have to be brought out they will have a crushing effect on the Party opposite. Before I sit down I want to guard against any possible suggestion that, because I do not now deal with the Dempsey case, it will be taken that I in any way assent to anything said from the opposite side, by way of attack on the Attorney-General. I do not. I venture to think that I cannot be accused of undue vanity if I feel that I am a member of an administration—including in that phrase the Attorney-General, because, as I said before, he is one of the great statutory officers in this State—that, in the short space of six or seven months, has done a great deal to root into the people of this country a sense of respect for the manner in which prosecutions are conducted, and a sense of respect for the administration of justice generally; an administration that has ensured peace in their movements and peace in their minds for all the citizens of the Irish Free State in that time.

Comment on this

Kilmallock.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 69
·
Níl 48
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?