Agriculture Bill, 1930—Committee.
Contributions 1–135 of 270. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1930 ›
I move amendment 1:—
In page 4, to delete lines 1 and 2.
There is no necessity for these words "the expression `annual meeting' has the meaning assigned to it by the Local Government (Ireland) Act, 1898."
Comment on this
I move amendment 2.
In page 4, to delete lines 3, 4 and 5 and substitute the following words "the expression `rateable value' means the annual rateable value under the Valuation Acts."
Comment on this
I move amendment 3:
In sub-section (1), page 7, line 17, to insert after the word "force" the words "and subject to the provisions of those Acts (except so much of Section 17 of the Superannuation Act, 1859, as enacts that for the purposes of that Act no person hereafter to be appointed shall be deemed to have served in the permanent Civil Service of the State unless such person holds his appointment or has been admitted into the Civil Service in the manner therein mentioned)."
The amendment is to make it clear that the Superannuation Acts apply.
Comment on this
I move amendment 4:—
In page 7, before sub-section (2), to insert the following sub-section:—
"(2) Whenever a person who has been approved by the Minister for Finance under the foregoing sub-section is a transferred officer within the meaning of the Civil Service (Transferred Officers) Compensation Act, 1929 (No. 36 of 1929) and is alive at the time such approval is given the following provisions shall have effect, that is to say:—
(a) such approval shall be deemed to be granted subject to a condition (in this sub-section referred to as the first condition) that any benefit accruing to such person under this section shall not be taken into account in determining any question of compensation under the said Act; and
(b) subject to the next following paragraph, such approval shall also be deemed to be granted subject to a condition (in this sub-section referred to as the second condition) that such person shall send to the Minister for Finance within one month after such approval has been notified to him a consent in writing accepting the first condition and in the event of such person failing or neglecting to comply with the second condition such failure or neglect shall operate as a cancellation of such approval;
(c) such approval shall not be deemed to be granted subject to the second condition if—
(i) such person dies before such approval is notified to him, or
(ii) such person dies after such approval is notified to him and within a period of one month from the date of such notification, or
(iii) the Minister for Finance certifies that having regard to bodily or mental infirmity of such person, such approval should not in the case of such person be deemed to be granted subject to the second condition."
[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]
Comment on this
This is a very long amendment and I should like the Minister to give a short explanation of what Section 12 means, as there is a great deal of difficult matter in it.
Comment on this
This section is to put officers of the Department who have been paid out of special funds in exactly the same position as if they were paid out of funds voted by Parliament—in other words, in exactly the same position as the rest of the Departmental officers. The special funds referred to were funds such as the Endowment fund. That fund was to some extent administered by the Board of Agriculture. There was another fund called The Cattle Pleuro Pneumonia Fund, which was established for dealing with pleuropneumonia, and certain veterinary surgeons were employed and paid for very long periods out of that fund, and remained afterwards as permanent officers of the Department. Then there were the funds of the county committees of agriculture. Certain officers in the service of the Department were paid out of county funds. These are the three main funds. Our desire is to put officers who, for a considerable portion of their career, were paid out of these special funds, and who are now regular officers of the Department in the same position as if they were paid the whole time out of moneys voted by the Oireachtas. Under the Superannuation Acts, when taking into account the establishment of an officer and settling the years of service which will entitle him to a pension the Minister for Finance is bound by the period of service which that officer has had, and which he has been paid for out of money voted by the Oireachtas. That, of course, gave rise to great hardships in the case of the Department because there were officers paid out of these special funds at the beginning of their career, sometimes for a very long period, and who were, in every sense of the word, permanent officers of the Department, but who because of a special provision in the Superannuation Acts would be debarred from full pension and establishment rights on account of being paid from these special funds. The purpose of the section is to place all these officers in the same position as other permanent officers, because in fact, they were permanent officers, as if they had always been paid out of moneys voted by the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
Not being able to follow the statement of the Minister, as he spoke so rapidly, I do not know whether I should sympathise more with the Parliamentary Reporters or with those of us who have taken some interest in the Bill, and particularly in regard to those who will be entitled to superannuation.
Comment on this
One of the handicaps which ordinary Deputies labour under is that they cannot move an amendment to any Bill which will involve State expenditure. I understand that my amendment has been ruled out of order because of the operations of that rule.
Comment on this
I suppose it is because it involves the expenditure of State funds and that a Private Deputy has no right to move it. If the Minister will explain why the amendment has been ruled out perhaps it would enlighten me.
Comment on this
The Deputy's amendment was ruled out because, in the first place, it would impose a charge on public funds and, secondly, because it was outside the scope of the Bill.
Comment on this
The Minister makes provision in the Bill, by amendment, for certain transferred officers, and I had in mind, when submitting this amendment, the case of a certain officer who had been, up to recently, employed as assistant agricultural overseer in the Department of Agriculture. He was then appointed secretary to a county committee of agriculture. If he had remained in his position as assistant agricultural overseer, he would have been a pensionable officer, but having served as an assistant agricultural overseer, and then, being promoted—if you call it promotion for a man to be deprived of certain pensionable service—to the position of secretary to a county committee of agriculture, the years which he had spent as an agricultural instructor have been spent, so far as that office is concerned, in vain, in reference to his pension rights. I ask the Minister to undertake to see that no hardship will be put upon persons of the class I have mentioned, that their services should be counted as continuous services, and that a man transferred from the Minister's own Department will not suffer any hardship.
Comment on this
Assuming the merits of the case were such as the Deputy has stated, this is a Bill dealing with officers of the Department of Agriculture—to see that they get what they are entitled to. The officers the Deputy is concerned with are officers of local authorities, and not officers of the Department of Agriculture. How can I deal in this Bill with officers of local authorities? The purpose of the Bill is to establish officers of the Department of Agriculture. A totally different Bill would be required to deal with the case the Deputy has mentioned, assuming all the merits of the case to be as the Deputy has stated. There is no more reason why you should deal with the officers the Deputy referred to in this Bill than with the officers of technical education committees established by local authorities. It cannot be done. This Bill deals with officers of the Department, a branch of the Civil Service of the State, not with local officers. It only deals with persons who are now officers of the Department of Agriculture. But it is provided that those officers who have had previous service in another capacity will have that fact taken into account. That does not alter the fact that there is no authority in this Bill to deal with persons who are not officers at present of any Department of Government and are officers of local authorities.
Comment on this
Yes; but the officer Deputy Anthony mentioned is a secretary to a county committee of agriculture.
Comment on this
Does not the Minister agree that the description "assistant agricultural overseer" connotes that he was in the Department of Agriculture, and that it was from there he took up the position of secretary of an agricultural committee?
Comment on this
Certainly. As agricultural assistant overseer he would be an officer of the Department, but the officer the Deputy referred to is not an assistant agricultural overseer. He was, but he is no longer.
Comment on this
It did. But the officer is not now an officer of the Department of Agriculture, and, consequently, with the best will in the world we could not deal with him in this Bill. I will say, without arguing the merits of the case, that I would be only too glad to have the matter discussed if it were in order. Obviously it is not in order. You can no more deal with such an officer under this Bill than you can deal with an officer of a local education committee.
Comment on this
If you were to consider such a case you would have to take all the circumstances into account and go into the merits. In this particular case the officer got a big increase in salary. He was an overseer at a smaller salary and he got a big increase and a much larger salary. The grievance he is suffering now is that he will not get the years he spent as assistant overseer allowed to him when his pension is being calculated by the local authority, but as against that other consideration would be advanced. I do not want to prejudice the merits of this case, but it can be said that he was promoted from a small position and given a bigger salary, and he will have, even before this Bill is passed, since the date of appointment a permanency and pension rights on a bigger salary. That might be advanced on the other side. But, whatever the merits, you cannot deal with an officer who is not an officer of the State at all in a Bill that deals with the officers of one Department of the State, namely, the Department of Agriculture. That is the whole trouble.
Comment on this
I move:—
In page 8, to delete all words and figures from and including the word "section," line 45, to the word "members," line 48, and substitute the following words "the provisions of this Act relating to the payment of travelling expenses to members of committees."
Comment on this
I move:—
Before Section 18 to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) Subject to the provisions of this section, every committee of agriculture shall, as soon as may be after the 30th day of June in each year, pay to every member of such committee such contribution (if any) as is authorised by the rules contained in the Second Schedule to this Act towards the expenses incurred during the preceding twelve months by such member in attending the meetings of such committee.
(2) No contribution shall be payable under this section in respect of any period of twelve months ending on the 30th day of June in any year to a member of a committee of agriculture in respect of his attendance at meetings of such committee held during such period unless he has attended at least half of such meetings.
(3) The following provisions shall have effect in relation to the period commencing on the 1st day of April, 1931, and ending on the 30th day of June, 1931, that is to say:—
(a) the said period shall for the purposes of this section be deemed a period of twelve months; and
(b) the foregoing sub-section shall not apply in respect of the said period.
(4) Any person who knowingly makes or allows to be made a false statement for the purpose of obtaining the payment to himself or another of a sum under or in pursuance of this section, shall be guilty of an offence under this section, and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding fifty pounds, or, at the discretion of the court, to imprisonment with or without hard labour for a term not exceeding one year.
(5) Any person who is convicted of an offence under this section shall thereafter be disqualified from being elected or being a member of any committee of agriculture or of any vocational education committee, or of any council, body, or committee which is a local authority within the meaning of the Act of 1925, and shall also be disqualified from holding any office or employment under any committee of agriculture or any vocational education committee or any such council, body, or committee as aforesaid.
I think the amendment speaks for itself. It is quite plain.
Comment on this
The only thing about it is that it is rather a hardship for members of the local authorities to have to attend for twelve months before they get any expenses. It may be very hard on some of them.
Comment on this
You could make arrangements if there was any serious hardship.
Comment on this
If the attendance were calculated after six months I think it would be an improvement.
Comment on this
I never thought it was a hardship, and as the point was not raised in any specific way, I do not think it is. If it was even a small hardship I think we would have heard of it before.
Comment on this
I will see if there are any administrative difficulties. I do not know of any at the moment, but we can deal with that matter again.
Comment on this
I move amendment 7:—
"To delete sub-section (2).
That is a very complicated sub-section.
Comment on this
Amendments 9 and 10 are more or less preparing the way for amendment 11, and if amendment 11 is not carried, I do not think that amendments 9 or 10 will be of much advantage. I will now move amendment 11:—
To delete sub-section (5).
Amendments 9 and 10 are as follows:—
9. In sub-section (2), line 10, to delete the words "and appointment."
10. In sub-section (4), line 19, to delete the words "with the approval of the Minister."
I have a great objection to any Bill going through the Dáil that will tend to extend the powers of the Local Appointments Commissioners. I think if we are going to appoint a committee of agriculture in any county we should give that committee as much power as we possibly can. I have other amendments later on which will deal with matters other than appointments. I quite realise there are much more important things to be done by the committees than the mere making of appointments, although an appointment in itself is, of course, important. Representatives on county councils and different committees in the country believe that they are as competent to select an officer for any particular post as the central authority here, whether the central authority make the appointment through a Local Appointments Commissioner or in any other way.
If amendment 11 is agreed to, there would still remain power to the Minister to lay down the qualifications, the conditions of service, the salary, and so on. If the Minister were to tell the county committee of agriculture to make the appointment, and if he were to point out the necessary qualifications and the regulations applying to salary and pension rights, he could then, I think, safely leave the making of the appointment of any officer to the local county committee. I do not want to go unnecessarily into the question of the Local Appointments Commissioners, but, as I have said, the people in the country believe they have just as good a right to make appointments as any central authority. They say that nobody knows who the Local Appointments Commissioners are. Local authorities have been accused in some cases of being amenable to undue influences; but at least whatever appointment they have made, or have been allowed to make, it has always been made in the open, in the presence of the Press, and, generally speaking, they must give their reasons for appointing a particular person.
On the other hand, as conditions now exist, a person is sent to them by the Local Appointments Commissioners and no reason is given why that person has been selected. The appointments that have been made under existing conditions are made by people—I do not know whether by men or women—who have no knowledge of local requirements. They may have knowledge of the academic qualifications required for the particular post, but they have no knowledge of what the local requirements are. The members of the local authority have much more knowledge on points of that sort. After some of our recent experiences in this country I think we should not grant any extension of the powers of the Local Appointments Commissioners. We had a great deal of trouble during the last few months over some appointments made by the Local Appointments Commissioners. We ought not to extend their powers until we have an opportunity of discussing the matter fully in the Dáil, and deciding whether the legislation under which appointments are now being made could not be amended so as to give local people a little more option. I move amendment 11.
Comment on this
I desire to support Deputy Ryan. My experience of local government, and it goes back to the very initiation of local government in this country, is that the appointments made by local authorities have, as a general rule, turned out most satisfactorily. I have heard cases of corruption in local bodies cited, both in this House and outside. Invariably it happens that the people who start stories about corruption are disappointed candidates. So far as my experience of the Local Appointments Commissioners and their operations goes, I must agree with what Deputy Ryan stated about operations more or less in the dark; the light of the Press is not thrown upon their proceedings. I do not want to say anything against them, but they are not above suspicion, and a great number of people in this country are not satisfied that the Local Appointments Commissioners are all that they are declared to be; the people are not satisfied that the Local Appointments Commissioners are not directly or indirectly amenable to some little gentle pressure in the making of appointments.
For that reason, and especially as we are starting upon something new, I think it would be a very wise thing to leave the making of appointments in the hands of the local bodies, along the lines indicated by Deputy Ryan. As the Deputy pointed out, it can be indicated to those local bodies by the Minister, or whoever is in authority, on what lines the appointments are to be made, what the qualifications and salary are to be, and the particular conditions in the county for which the appointment is being made. I think it would be considered a reflection on the newly appointed committees if the Bill made it definite that they were not to be trusted with the making of appointments in future. For that reason I will support Deputy Ryan.
Comment on this
I would like to know how far this Bill will mean an extension of the powers of the Local Appointments Commissioners, as Deputy Ryan mentioned.
Comment on this
That is my impression—that it will mean no extension. I would like to approach the question from this point of view: if this principle of the making of appointments through the Local Appointments Commissioners will continue to apply to practically all local authorities—every local body—in the same manner as it does at the present time, I do not see any reason why these particular agricultural committees should be exempted. I do not think that is the right way. If this system of the Local Appointments Commissioners is wrong I do not think it should be attacked in this fashion. Merely making provision for one small section of the community is not, in my opinion, the proper way to deal with this matter. If the system is to be attacked at all, and if we are to condemn it, we should condemn it as a whole and not attack it in piecemeal fashion. What is proposed here is to attack that system only in so far as it affects a comparatively small section of the community. The county council, the board of health, and other local authorities have to make their appointments through the Local Appointments Commissioners, and I think it will lead to a certain amount of confusion, doubt and surprise if one body will be given power to make its own appointments while superior bodies such as the county council have that power taken from them under our existing legislation. If this matter is to be faced at all it should be taken in its entirely and as a matter applying to all local authorities. There was a Bill introduced some time ago by the Party to which the Deputy belongs. There was afterwards a Commission set up, and the Commission reported. Both in the Bill and in the report of the Commission, of which Deputy Ryan's Party were members, the principle of appointments being made by the Local Appointments Commission was admitted and accepted.
Comment on this
Then I must be entirely wrong in my reading of Deputy de Valera's Bill and the report of the Commission. There was a doubt as to the method. There was a question as to whether three or two should be recommended. But the question of taking the appointments out of the hands of the local body and giving them to some central body was admitted and accepted. Does Deputy Aiken deny that?
Comment on this
Then I would recommend him to read the Bill again. As I understood the Bill—and I will be glad to be corrected if I am wrong— that was the principle of it. Why refer the matter of appointments to the central authority at all? As I remember it, there was a provision for referring the making of the appointments to the central authority in Deputy de Valera's Bill. There were powers given to select one or two or three names, send them down to the local authority, who at a meeting would select one out of the two or three. If Deputy Aiken argues that that was not accepting the principle of the Local Appointments Commission, then that ends it so far as I am concerned. But I argue it does accept that principle. The principle is there, and if we are to take this system at all it ought to be taken as a whole and applied to every authority. While it applies to the county councils and other local authorities, the principle is there, and I cannot see what is to be gained by making an exception in the case of this particular body. I think there ought to be uniformity so far as the county councils and the local authorities are concerned, and I do not see any reason for making a distinction in this case. If the system is wrong, let us attack the system as a whole and get a better system. But let us have the same system applying to all local authorities.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Connell forgets that the Bill introduced by Fianna Fáil was introduced for the purpose of doing away with the major objection we had to the Local Appointments Commissioners. At the present time the procedure is that when a local body wants somebody appointed the Local Appointments Commissioners select one person, and they send that person's name down to the county council or other local body, who must appoint that particular person. We object to that, and, as time goes on, we are strengthened in our objection. A few years ago we introduced a Bill which would have compelled the Civil Service Commissioners to examine the qualifications of the candidates and send down three names to the local body. The local authority then would have the power of selecting a candidate.
Comment on this
But they had to select from one of the number sent down.
Comment on this
There was a very big difference in the principle, but the system we are trying to mend was the appointment and the selection being made by some three persons in Dublin. We tried to get that amended, so that the selection would be left with the local authority. They would select one of the three fully-qualified persons ——
Comment on this
Who would be selected by the central authority in Dublin.
Comment on this
No; the selection was by the council or the local authority— that was the principle in the Bill. Here we are up against a section in the Bill and we are going to stand against that section. We believe that it is the county committees of agriculture who should make the appointments. At the moment the county committees of agriculture are appointing their agricultural instructors and their poultry and dairy instructresses. This section in this Bill is an extension of the principle of appointment by Local Appointments Commissioners. We are going to oppose that. That section is giving the Local Appointments Commissioners more power than they had hitherto. We believe that the people who pay the rates should make the selection. I am sorry Deputy O'Higgins has gone, because he protested the other day that we were standing for taking the power out of the hands of the county council. If he were sincere in that, I would make an appeal to him now to stand with us in securing that under this section some little power would be left in the hands of the county councils or in the hands of the bodies appointed under them.
The people of the country as a whole are fed up with the Appointments Commissioners and the way in which they have been carrying on. If they are going to pay the rates, they naturally want to make the selections. It is a bit too good that a small group in Dublin should throw the nominee of the Minister on the people and compel them to pay him. Regarding these particular appointments, we believe that many people throughout the country, members of county committees of agriculture and others, know more about the requirements of the agricultural community and about agricultural education than the Minister or any three members of the Local Appointments Commission. Grave difference of opinion exists between the agricultural community and the Minister as to what is best to be done. We are not going to stand for the Minister and those closely associated with him in Dublin, dumping agricultural instructors and others on the farmers of the country and making the farmers pay them. I hope that Deputy O'Connell and his colleagues will see that this is an extension of the powers of the Local Appointments Commissioners and that it is going to give them more power than they had hitherto. I am sure that Deputy O'Connell is not satisfied with the work of these Commissioners and I hope that he will stand with us in supporting the amendment.
Comment on this
There seems to be some confusion regarding the Local Appointments Commissioners and the local committees. I do not think that one should be confused with the other. I think that the country will accept the principle that a central Appointments Commission is something that should be supported, but it is different in the case of local committees who make appointments. The only thing I have to say regarding these committees is that they should be taken from local representatives and not from people who represent nobody locally. I am prepared to have local appointment committees selected from the elected representatives of the people, county councillors and others, because in that way you will restore that confidence which appears to have been lost. In many cases I do not know what the qualifications of the people selected for these committees were. When you have local people at all let them be local people who represent the community at large, rather than people who represent nobody
Comment on this
The Appointments Commissioners are quite different from the local appointments committees.
Comment on this
I would ask the Minister to accept the amendment that appointments under the Bill be left in the hands of local committees. In the light of recent events, particularly in Mayo, this amendment should be treated a a different way from that in which it would probably have been treated a year ago. Appointments have been made for some time by local committees, and the Minister must admit that they have proved very satisfactory. Local committees feel their responsibility in the matter, and the appointments which they have made have turned out to be very good. I am sure that the appointments recently made, and those likely to be made in the future, will give more satisfaction to the people concerned, to the ratepayers, and, in the long run, to the Department than any made by the Appointments Commissioners. This Bill is an extension of the powers of the Appointment Commissioners. It widens the scope of their authority, but the Dáil, in view of recent happenings in County Mayo, should not give them these extended powers. We realise that recently one of the biggest blunders that possibly could be made by any Department or Government was made when a certain appointment in Mayo was insisted on. I am not going to discuss that appointment now, but prominent members of the Government Party themselves admitted that it was a great blunder and a great wrong.
This is the first opportunity since then which we have had of having the matter considered, even in a small way. In order to check, to some extent, the powers of the Appointments Commissioners, we should all agree to accept this amendment, but, if it is not accepted by the Minister, I trust that Deputy Dr. Ryan will put it to a division. In order to enlighten the Government on this point and to make them realise that they have gone a little too far—that is putting it very mildly—on this question of appointments. I would ask members of the Party opposite to vote for the amendment. As I have said, appointments made in the past by county committees of agriculture have been very satisfactory. Seeing that it is the local people who have to provide the rates, the wherewithal to carry out schemes, and that it is the people who have to pay up who are the people most concerned by the appointments made, I maintain that local committees should be given a little authority in the making of appointments. We do not object to some authority, the Minister or some commissioners, call them what you like, deciding as to the qualifications of those who present themselves for appointment.
Deputy O'Connell seems to have misunderstood the Bill introduced here dealing with this matter and the suggestions of the members of our Party who went on the Committee to deal with the question of the Appointments Commissioners. All we were concerned with then was that a certain body, call it what you will, would ensure that none but qualified persons would be appointed, that there would not be a danger of men being appointed who were not fully qualified. Our suggestion was that the names of those who are fully qualified would be sent to the local committees and that the local committees should appoint one of them. In this case, as I have said, we do not object to the Minister laying down what the qualifications should be and, when he lays down that none but qualified men should be appointed. The local committees are not given much power when they are confined to the appointment of qualified men only.
If the full power of appointment were in the hands of local committees to-morrow, they would, as a general rule, lay it down that the best qualified man should be appointed. The great mistake has been that local conditions are scarcely ever taken into account when local appointments are being made. If these conditions were taken more into account than they are there would not be so much objection raised to the Appointments Commissioners. Now that we have a chance of leaving a little power of appointment in the hands of local committees, I ask the Minister not to deprive them of that power, and I ask members of the Party opposite, as well as Deputy O'Connell, to reconsider their attitude on this subject. This amendment is not asking too much and it is not going to re-open the road which would lead back to the old system under which, somebody said, there was corruption. There is a clause which says that the Minister must see that qualified men only are appointed. This amendment, to me, as a representative of County Mayo, appears to be very important. Deputy Gorey and others may think that it is not very important, but in my view it has to do with a very important question, as we in Mayo unfortunately realised quite recently. For that reason, I am confident that Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies from Mayo, including the ex-Chairman of the County Council, especially in the light of his recent action in Mayo, will vote against the Government on this amendment. They cannot consistently take up any other attitude. If the Minister will not accept the amendment, we will force it to a division, and if that happens, Independent Deputies and, I am sure, Labour Deputies, as well as some members of Cumann na nGaedheal who have spoken very loudly in protest against the abolition of the Mayo County Council, will be forced into the Division Lobby in favour of the amendment.
Comment on this
I think the House is entitled to know, in view of the speeches which have been made, what exactly is the policy of the Party opposite with regard to the whole question of the Local Appointments Commission.
Comment on this
I think this question is involved, with all respect.
Comment on this
They have not made it plain to me. My criticism of this amendment is that it attempts to deal with what is, after all, a question of general policy in a very small and piecemeal way. Am I to understand— if I know or was clear on what their position is it might help me to make up my mind on this particular amendment—that so far as local committees are concerned, they want the system of making appointments by a Local Appointments Commission abolished? Are we to take it that that is their position?
Comment on this
Then their position has been changed completely since the time Deputy de Valera introduced his Bill and since the time Fianna Fáil Deputies sat on the Committee which dealt with this question. Are we to take it that that is so? It would be well if we had a declaration on that point. Let us see whether we are arguing this small application of the measure to one particular kind of committee, or whether we are actually attacking the whole system of appointments by Appointments Commissioners. In regard to the statement of Deputy Clery about appointing a qualified man, I always understood that it was not a question of selecting a qualified man, but of selecting the best qualified. You will get a man qualified for a position easily enough, but the Local Appointments Act was an attempt to set up machinery to get the best qualified person out of the number of qualified people who would be applying for the position. If, as Deputy Dr. Ryan states, it is now definitely their intention to have the whole system of appointments to local authorities by the Local Appointments Commission abolished, we know where we are.
Comment on this
I want again to impress on Deputy O'Connell that this section is an extension of the present system, and that we have gone all out against the present system. We brought in an amending Bill to the present system——
Comment on this
If we were bringing in an amending Bill now I am sure a number of members of Fianna Fáil would bring in a more drastic one. We may have to do it before long. Here is an occasion on which it is proposed to extend the present system beyond its scope at the moment. At the present time appointments of agricultural instructors, poultry instructors, etc., are made by the local people.
Comment on this
They are done by the Appointments Commissioners. However, I will explain that.
Comment on this
Up to the present, as far as we know, they have been appointed by the local committees. If what the Minister has said is correct, what is the necessity for the clause in this Bill?
Comment on this
It is to set up new committees. We are appointing nothing but committees of agriculture. We are abolishing the old committees and setting up new ones.
Comment on this
You are attempting to extend a scheme of which we do not approve, against which we did our best in the past, and which we will try to amend at the first opportunity.
Comment on this
It is quite obvious that Deputies opposite do not believe in the amendment, because they have tried to defend it by advancing reasons which they must know to be quite unsound. They think they are taking an opportunity of preventing the extension of the Local Appointments Commission system. That is not so. There is no extension of the method of appointment by the Local Appointments Commission, direct or indirect, in this Bill. The section reads as follows:
Every committee of agriculture shall be deemed to be a local body within the meaning of Part IV of the Act of 1925.
That is the Act that set up the Local Appointments Commission. This section says that the committee of agriculture, so far as these appointments are concerned, shall come within the terms of the Act. Is it suggested here that the local committees of agriculture did not specifically accept appointments made under the Local Authorities (Officers and Employees) Act, 1926? That is what is suggested. We passed this Local Authorities (Officers and Employees) Act of 1926, and under that Act a certain procedure was established. That procedure was to make appointments to local authorities by selection boards. What is suggested here now is that there was some section in that Act which expressly omitted committees of agriculture. That is nonsense and, while I do not give credit to certain Deputies for much intelligence, I find it difficult to believe that they are as ignorant as they pretend to be. All appointments were made by this Act. system and made under this Act. Now we are setting up a new system. We are re-organising new county committees, re-establishing a new kind of county committee of agriculture and we are specifying, as we should specify, that the new committee, just as the old committee, shall come under the Act for the purposes of local appointments.
We are not extending the system of local appointments by the Appointments Commission in any way. If that is clear, I have nothing to add to what Deputy O'Connell has stated. The system of making appointments, both centrally and locally, not by the Executive Council in the case of central appointments and not by the local authorities in the case of local appointments, but by selection boards —the Civil Service Commission in one case and the Local Appointments Commission in the other—whatever may be said of it set up a system that was a very revolutionary change from the old system. That system was a system of patronage. People talk of power and say "what power have we now?" I believe there are Deputies who think that power consists of patronage in the making of appointments. That is the only deduction you can draw from their language. The old system gave them that patronage. It gave the politician who chanced to be a Minister a very extensive power of patronage. The new system does not. It takes away all patronage and it transfers the power of making appointments to independent bodies. That may be right or wrong, but this can be agreed upon by everybody —that it was a revolutionary change. Now it is suggested, as Deputy O'Connell put it, that on an Agricultural Bill, in respect of one small authority with, in fact, very few appointments we should change the whole system. If this system is changed, it should be changed not casually but deliberately.
It should be changed after a complete examination, and after a very careful analysis of what has occurred since those Acts were passed. It should be changed after due deliberation, after taking care to make adequate arrangements for the making of appointments in the future. It should not be changed casually in this fashion, and, above all, for reasons which are entirely unsound. It should not be changed on the plea that this is an extension of the system. It is not that in any sense. It is merely applying the system to a body which we are setting up as a substitute for the old county committees of agriculture. So far as the system itself is concerned, Deputy Clery need not worry about Deputies in this Party. We are quite clear on the matter and so is the country. This system of appointment, not by local authorities, not by the Executive Council when it comes to the Civil Service, but by an independent body is, I hold, a sound system on the whole. I say that the great body of opinion of all kinds in the country is behind that system. It is realised by business people and by every person of good will that this system has brought about more and more efficiency. Of course, there are interests in the country who would like to see it modified in some details, but that is a minor matter. The system, on the whole, as established by us, and with the experience that we have had of it, makes us feel more in favour of it. We are satisfied that the good sense of the country as a whole is behind it, and we intend to stand by it in all appointments.
I wish Deputies would give up the habit of talking about corruption. The commonest way of attacking this system of the making of appointments by selection boards rather than by local patronage is to say: "Do you suggest that the county councils are corrupt?" We do not suggest that. You might as well say: Do you suggest that a Minister, we will say a Fianna Fáil Minister, could be corrupt? For the purposes of the argument, "No." Everybody who knows anything knows that if public appointments are to be made locally you will have an impossible position brought about. Influence is brought to bear on every side on behalf of candidates, and it is often very difficult to do the right thing. That is totally different, however, from corruption. Say that the Executive Council had to make all the appointments in the Department of Agriculture—and the Executive Council is as representative as a county council— look at the position that the Executive Council would be in. It would be an impossible position for any Executive, though each member of it was above reproach. Say that a girl was going for the position of poultry instructress in a county, under the agricultural committee, a neighbour's daughter whose people were of good standing, while another candidate, a stranger, might be considerably better qualified, the position would be difficult.
People should not be put into such a difficult position. It is not a question of corruption, and we are not now taking up the position that the necessity for the Local Appointments Commission or the Civil Service Commission is due to corruption either locally or centrally. As far as we are concerned, we believe that the best man or woman should win. We believe that this is the best method, and we stand by it. I put it to the Dáil that Deputies would be absolutely stultifying themselves if they abolished that system casually, rather than considering it deliberately. Do not abolish it in reference to one local body in a casual way for entirely local reasons that no one believes in.
Comment on this
The Minister wants to pretend that the Appointments Commissioners will always select the best candidate.
Comment on this
We have it on definite authority that the Appointments Commissioners have not appointed the best qualified candidates. It is for that reason that we ask the House not to give them the powers that it is now proposed to give them. We want to force the amendment as strongly as we can, not because there is corruption in local bodies, but because there is evidence of something wrong at headquarters.
Comment on this
I am very glad the Minister expressed the opinion that the necessity for the Local Appointments Commissioners was not due to the corruption of local bodies, because when the matter was discussed in the House before we did not get that opinion from every member of the Party opposite. Some of the members on the opposite side, when a Bill was introduced here, talked about corruption in the local bodies.
Comment on this
I never said there was not. There is corruption everywhere at times.
Comment on this
The Executive brought in a Bill to establish the Civil Service Commission and the Local Appointments Commission only when the biggest jobs in the Civil Service were filled. However, it is well to have a Civil Service Commission at all, even after the good jobs were all gone. Even if this is not an extension of the powers—and I may have used the word loosely—it is, at least, a continuation of the powers——
Comment on this
A Bill was introduced a couple of years ago, as Deputy Aiken explained, so that the Civil Service Commissioners would send down the names of three candidates to the local authorities, who would then make the appointment. Deputy O'Connell said that was not a change of principle. We are now going a little further and are asking the Civil Service Commission to send down the names of all qualified people. That is not a change of principle either.
Comment on this
If you change from one to three you are not changing the principle, but Deputy O'Connell says if you send from three to ten you are changing.
Comment on this
It is a question of picking the best qualified and making a selection.
Comment on this
According to Deputy O'Connell, we are not changing our principle by going from one to three, but we are by going from three to ten.
Comment on this
If you send them all it is a change of principle undoubtedly.
Comment on this
That is another way of putting it. Whether there is such a thing as principle or not, I believe that many of the members of this Party agree with me that in the light of recent experience——
Comment on this
Mayo. We would be prepared to see the Local Appointments Commissioners scrapped once and for all. We are not prepared to agree to a section in the Bill which continues the power given to the Local Appointments Commissioners, and we are not going to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I would not agree, even in the light of some unpleasant experiences, and even in the light of certain exceptions, that may have arisen in the working out of the system—and everyone knows that no system will be perfect—to the scrapping of the Local Appointments Commissioners completely. It is surprising to me that this policy has been announced on the part of Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
I said I was speaking for myself, and that I thought I could speak for many members of Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
I took it that it was a definite announcement of policy. Looking over the matter for a great many years, I am perfectly convinced that the person who has gained by the present system, as opposed to the old system, is the poor man's son. He never got a chance under the old system, because it was the big faction in the county, the people with influence and pull, who got all the appointments, while the poor man's son, no matter how well qualified or educated, was shoved out because he was not in a position to exercise influence and power. The county families, as we know them, got all the good jobs in the old times.
Comment on this
Perhaps we could not. Whatever chance the son of the poor man, who has brains and ability, has of getting an appointment to-day, he has a much better chance if the appointments are carried out under the present system than by votes of people who might be in a representative capacity.
Comment on this
There may be exceptions. I am not arguing about Mayo. Deputy Clery and Deputy Ryan would not take up the position that this House ought to make the appointments to the Civil Service. That would be the complete analogy. If a county council is going to claim all these powers, the complete analogy would be for this House to make appointments to the Civil Service. No one would claim that the House is qualified to do that. I am quite prepared to admit that there might be exceptions, and I am quite prepared to say that sufficient importance is not attached, as Deputy Gorey said, to the local point of view. That is a matter of detail. If we are going to depart from the general principle, the person who is going to suffer most is the person who has ability but who is without any influence and without money.
Comment on this
This argument about the poor man's son without any county pull not getting a fair chance is the sheerest bunkum. Under the old county councils when applicants came up they were known and could be judged on their merits. If a family was known to be honest and efficient they had that much influence in the making of the appointment. At the present time, a man must belong to a national family, to one of Deputy Thrift's organisations, in order to get a pull over the Appointments Commissioners. The members of the Executive Council who appoint the Commissioners are not angels. They are not exempt from original sin any more than members of county councils. There is always influence of one sort or another being used when appointments are being made. At the moment, influence is being worked through national organisations, such as Deputy Thrift's, in order to influence the Appointments Commissioners secretly. We would prefer to see this influence threshed out in the open by the people who know the local circumstances and who have to pay the piper.
Comment on this
Deputy Aiken has stated that the members of the Appointments Commission are not always angels. That would be one of my reasons for opposing the system of Appointments Commissioners. The Minister for Agriculture stated that the system of Appointments Commissioners was introduced in order to relieve the members of local bodies of the responsibility of making appointments —because of the fact that in certain cases they knew the applicants for certain positions, they knew them to be farmers' sons or poor men's sons. I want to remind the Minister and this House that under the old system all these appointments were made in the open by people who were elected to positions on local bodies. These public men were elected to these positions because the people had confidence in them. They had confidence in them to make these appointments in the same way, I suppose, that they had confidence in us when they elected us to be members of this House.
I and some others had a certain amount of sympathy with the Government when they set up the Appointments Commissioners, but I must confess that my views have completely and absolutely changed in regard to that institution. With Deputy Ryan and other who have spoken, I am prepared to go all out to-day for its abolition. I feel that the argument advanced by Deputy O'Connell with reference to the poor man's son is tantamount to saying that there is corruption in local bodies—that even though the poor man's son was fully qualified he could not get an appointment from these local bodies. That certainly is tantamount to saying there is corruption in these local bodies. I have had some experience of the people who serve on local bodies, and I believe they are just as honest as any people the Minister could find to make appointments.
Comment on this
The Government has the selection of the people who act as Appointments Commissioners.
Comment on this
Neither those who make applications before this body nor the public know the pros and cons of what takes place behind the scenes. If we have local bodies, then we should not be a bit afraid to allow them to make appointments. They are elected by the people to serve on those bodies, and I say they are as capable of making appointments as any appointments commission that may be set up. For that reason, I intend to oppose the present system.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Connell spoke of the analogy of this House taking upon itself the duty of making appointments in the Civil Service. As far as I know, every appointment in the Civil Service is made through an entrance examination.
Comment on this
There are technical officers, for instance. They are appointed by a Selection Board.
Comment on this
I was going to say that the great majority of positions in the Civil Service are filled by means of entrance examinations. As regards positions under local authorities, I certainly would approve of having them filled by competitive examination as far as that could possibly be done.
Comment on this
Might I point out that the analogy attempted to be drawn between the Dáil and local councils is altogether wrong. The Minister for Agriculture denies that there is any question of general principle involved. In practice, the analogy is altogether wrong, because a local council has only two or three appointments to make, and a great deal of care can be exercised by the members in making their selection. But if we here were to be asked to make the appointments necessary to the whole service we would be in quite a different position. I hold that, in practice, there is a difference between the Dáil making the appointment and the local bodies making the appointment. Now, as to getting the best qualified person, there is no way by which the best qualified person for any position can be chosen—none. We might all make up our minds to that.
Comment on this
For certain. It is all a question of opinion. Very often we go upon academic or other qualifications. Very frequently, in practice, these work out the wrong way. Men who, by accident or otherwise, are thrown into positions that would ordinarily be filled by people with certain academic qualifications have turned out, in practice, very much better than the people selected on academic qualifications. I do not say that is always so, or that, as a general rule, these qualifications do not denote ability. We have accepted such tests as the best we can get. I believe, myself, if you make regulations of as searching a character as you can to provide that those who are selected will be of a class that will have the necessary technical or other qualifications of that particular type, then a body of people locally who know intimately the candidates are more likely to make a good selection than are others, provided that unqualified persons cannot go up, so that undue influence or other pressure cannot be used, and that such cannot have an effect. In other words, if you rule out those obviously unqualified, then a body of local people, a committee sitting in judgment upon these, knowing them intimately——
Comment on this
I presume, in that case, there are some qualifications. I cannot imagine any local body deciding a position where technical qualifications are involved without having some evidence as to the qualifications. We brought in a Bill which was really only a step on the road as far as the greater part of our Party is concerned. We felt, whatever chance there was of getting that particular Bill through here, that there would be no chance of going further. Some of our Party were satisfied with that as a first step, but it did not represent by any means the ultimate views held by a large section of our Party. If you can provide by your regulations that only such as are qualified in this manner—I am trying to get a term, academic or technical qualifications, educational or other qualifications—can be considered for an appointment, then the ultimate judgment can be very well left to the local bodies, the reason being that they are much more interested in getting a good appointment than people sitting in Dublin who, no matter what sort of candidate they select, will not have to live, so to speak, with that candidate for the rest of the time. The local body, if it appoints a bad official, has to suffer from the incapacity of that particular official during the whole period of his office. The selection committees are sheltered from the consequences.
Therefore, it seems to me the two things you want to provide are, firstly, that only people fit for the position can possibly be considered as candidates, and, secondly, that those who are most intimately affected will have the ultimate choice. I think that in the long run this is far the best way. We have heard about influences that are brought to bear in these cases. These work in different directions. What I mean is: they more or less balance one another. If there are two or three candidates, a person being approached from one side or the other has finally to make up his mind to vote for the person he thinks best in all the circumstances.
I do not think this local pressure, as it is called, really matters so very much. I believe that the members of the local councils very quickly, when they realise what is involved, learn to stand up against forces of that kind, and there is the great safeguard of publicity. If there is a local medical appointment, and if the person chosen is obviously not the best qualified person, if in practice, for instance, there is chosen some one who does not attend to his duties, who, for instance, is guilty of a number of things medical men, I am told, are sometimes guilty of, who is going to suffer? The local people suffer. They know about it, and when a council is going to make a new appointment, if it knows the history of the person at all and knows his character, it is not going to vote for somebody who is obviously, from his character, not fit for the position. That is so in the case of medical appointments, and largely it is so in the case of other appointments. I was one of those who more or less advocated the Bill that was brought in here. It represented, to a large extent, my views, but, as time goes on and I see no way of getting publicity for the methods of selection by these selection boards, I, like Deputy Smith, am going more and more every day to the position I have indicated here now. I believe that in the long run you have got to trust somebody, and it is better to trust those people who will have most to suffer if things go wrong than to trust people who are sheltered from criticism. Nobody can know what are the principles upon which selection boards act, and, as far as I know, there is a great deal of criticism of appointments that have already been made as being un suitable. I am not able to give any specific examples, but I believe there is no smoke without some sort of fire. I believe there is ground for some of these complaints, at any rate, and, in connection with this particular amendment here, our attitude is that we want to protest against the continuance of that system and we are using this particular case as an opportunity to indicate that we are not at all satisfied with the existing system and that if we had our way it would be changed.
Comment on this
I am rather sorry that the whole question of the Local Appointments Commission has been raised in the manner in which it has been raised. I can quite understand the views put forward by Deputy de Valera. His Party are pressing that something should be done in connection with it, and I must say I have a certain amount of sympathy with the views put forward by Deputy Dr. Ryan and Deputy Aiken. Knowing, as I do, the operations of the Local Appointments Commission, I certainly know of appointments that have been made by the Local Appointments Commission that were not very desirable. I feel absolutely certain, from our experience of public bodies, that the best qualified men have not been appointed.
Speaking for myself on this matter, I believe that a qualifying examination should be sufficient so far as local bodies are concerned. If you have a Commission who are prepared to examine candidates for a certain position and this Commission finds that people are qualified for the positions for which they are applying, surely that ought to be sufficient. What is happening at the present moment so far as local bodies are concerned? I have in my mind the question of borough surveyors under urban councils. I know of cases where men applied for positions in certain areas and they just used these positions as a medium to procure higher positions, leaving the local authorities there after a few years. It certainly does not tend to greater efficiency if local authorities are to have new surveyors every three or four years. I believe that if there is a local applicant for the position, and if the man is sufficiently qualified to take up the position, and if there is unanimity so far as the local council is concerned as regards his appointment, that man should get the appointment even though there are others who are more highly qualified so far as academic qualifications are concerned.
I certainly think the whole system requires examination in that connection. With the principle of the Appointments Commission I agree. I have already voted for that. I do not think that this is a proper time to raise the matter. I am of opinion that the section should not have been put in this Bill at all, and that it is a pity to have the matter raised now. I believe the time is ripe to raise the whole question of the Appointments Commission.
Comment on this
Amendment 11: Question—"That the words proposed to be deleted stand"—put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment 12:—
To insert at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
(2) Before removing under this section from his office or employment an officer or servant of a committee of agriculture, the Minister shall give to such committee and also to such officer or servant at least one fortnight's notice in writing of his intention to so remove such officer or servant, and if such committee or such officer or servant before the expiration of such notice request in writing the Minister to hold a local inquiry under this Act in relation to the performance by such officer or servant of his duties as such officer or servant, the Minister shall not so remove such officer or servant unless and until he has caused such local inquiry to be held and considered the report of the person who held such local inquiry.
(3) A notice of the Minister's intention to remove from his office or employment an officer or servant of a committee of agriculture under this section may be served on such committee by sending it by post to the chief executive officer of such committee and on such officer or servant by delivering it to him, or by sending it by post to him at his last known place of abode.
The point is that before an officer is dismissed he should get notice. It seems to be reasonable.