Agriculture Bill, 1930—Committee.
Contributions 136–270 of 270. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1930 ›
I move amendment 16:—
In sub-section (2), line 22, to delete the word "shall" and substitute the word "may."
I do not know if I understand the section rightly, but the Minister can correct me if what I say is wrong. It would appear to me that under this section if a county committee of agriculture were to submit a scheme, and if the Minister were to reject half of the scheme, he could compel the committee to proceed with the remainder of it. I think it is hardly fair to a committee to make them proceed with part of a scheme which they had drawn up after the Minister had knocked out 25 or 50 per cent. of it. The Minister could conceivably change their whole intention by so doing.
Comment on this
Of course, the Minister must approve of the scheme. That is all that is wanted. The Minister has no power then to refuse approval.
Comment on this
The point is this. The Minister could approve of 25 or 50 per cent. of the scheme—pick out a bit of the scheme that the committee would not have on any account if it were to be on its own. In that way I think it would be going against the spirit of the Bill by having the Minister's will cut across the committee in such a way.
Comment on this
I see the point. The Minister must approve of the scheme. Supposing a scheme is put up and the Minister approves of portion of it and the committee is unwilling to go on with the rest, there is nothing, as far as I know, to coerce the committee into going on with the rest of the scheme. Of course, they cannot drop all their schemes. That is all it comes to.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister will accept the amendment, because it says "may be given effect to and carried into execution" instead of "shall."
Comment on this
I think the section only applies to each particular scheme—it does not apply to all the schemes together. It says: "Every agricultural scheme shall be subject to the approval of the Minister..."
Comment on this
If you insert the word "may" they can put the scheme through without the approval of the Minister, and that is not what the Deputy wants.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister is reading the amendment correctly. "Every agricultural scheme shall be subject to the approval of the Minister"—that would still stand—"and if and so far as so approved of, may be given effect to and carried into execution by the committee." That is how the section would read.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy will bring the matter up on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
Amendments 17 and 18 were meant to be one amendment as a matter of fact, but amendment 19 is different. It is more or less the same idea going a little further. They refer to a scheme being put up by a committee of agriculture with regard to existing woods. I have an amendment down to a later section, but in case that amendment is defeated I thought that if the county committee were to raise the money in the county for the preservation of existing woods, if the ratepayers were to be responsible for the expenses incurred, and the ratepayers elected the members of the committee, either directly or indirectly, that the committee should have absolute power to look after the preservation of these woods. That is what the amendments would amount to.
Comment on this
These three amendments taken together would have the effect of removing the control of the Minister over the county schemes generally. The Deputy's point is that the county is paying for them. That is not so. They are being paid for out of a joint fund which is fed as to two-thirds of its total out of taxation and as to only about one-third out of rates.
Comment on this
At present and in future, so far as we can calculate. The present position is that at least two-thirds of the funds required for the service of these schemes is found by taxation and only about one-third by rates, so that the main argument of the Deputy, that the ratepayers are paying for these schemes and should have complete control of them, goes. The taxpayer is paying in the main for these schemes and should have some control over them. There is no doubt that it would be entirely wrong administration to give very large sums of money to the counties for specific purposes out of taxation and at the same time to retain no control over the expenditure of that money. That is what we would be doing if we withdrew the Minister's control over the county schemes. But there are even more important considerations. This amendment cuts to the root of the whole system of agricultural administration. The county committees have been in existence for a great many years. Their schemes have all been thought out with considerable care and have been amended and modified with experience. At the present moment you have been biggest and moment you have the biggest part of their schemes, which are general schemes, adopted and agreed to in every county; they have the approval of every county in Ireland, and are regarded as fundamental to our agricultural economy. The scheme would be accepted by nine farmers out of every ten as being vital for the country.
Take the question of live stock. You would no doubt get an odd farmer to say we should get rid of shorthorns and get Friesian cows. Five or six years ago you would get a good many farmers to say that, but now you do not, because they have learned a lesson in the meantime. In a county you would find people occasionally who would for a short time allow themselves to be rushed off their feet by something new—by some new stunt— accepting and adopting it. That would be all right if the harm done by adopting some entirely unsound scheme were confined to the particular county in question, but that is not so. It is generally agreed that the large white pig is ideal for this country; that is accepted and agreed by everybody, except certain districts in counties in the North, who say "No," but they are a small minority. If there is anything that we can say that is absolutely certain, it is that the large white York pig is ideal for this country as a whole. Now, suppose some southern county comes forward with a scheme, without much consideration, and because of some local grievance offers premiums to Ulster boars—suppose the Department had no power to prevent that, what would the effect be? It is agreed by all sane agricultural opinion that that would be disastrous, yet nothing could be done to stop it, and the effect would not be confined to the particular county that brought forward the scheme, but would affect numerous counties. The progeny of these boars would spread and would injure not only the particular county, but all the neighbouring counties, not only for a short time, but for a long time. In this way, unless there was some central control exercised over the schemes of the county committees of agriculture, which, taking them on the whole, embody the main phases of agricultural policy, you would have very great lack of uniformity. You would have counties now and again going off at the deep end and doing things without very much deliberation that they would very much regret afterwards. I give that one example.
[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]
On the other hand, you may have counties adopting schemes and the Department entirely agreeing, but finding out that while the schemes were quite sound the administration was going to lead to a great many abuses. We have had schemes for the distribution of seed of one kind or another, and while agreeing with the object of these schemes and the distribution, it was found that there was no provision at all made to see that the seed was used as seed and not as food for animals. We often had that case, and we often had to insist that while entirely agreeing with the schemes there must be arrangements made to see that they are carried out as intended by the county committee of agriculture.
You have these two different examples: One class of scheme put up casually by one county which might be urged by a few breeders, at some suitable period when they were easily persuaded, and which would do permanent harm to the livestock not only of the county, but of the neighbouring counties, and it is necessary that somebody would be in a position to prevent that. You have the other sort of case I mentioned where schemes are agreed upon both by the county committees and the Department and where it is found necessary to amend them in detail. In a case like that the Department comes in and sees that amendments are carried and sees there is uniformity. In agricultural policy, whether it is right or wrong, everybody knows you cannot get results for a great many years. If you are looking for quick results it shows that you know nothing about the business. A policy may be right or wrong but it cannot give good or bad results unless you keep it in operation for a number of years. You must have continuity of experments carried out in a uniform may for a long time and over the greater part of the country. For all these reasons it is necessary, in the first instance, to give the Department of Agriculture control over the county schemes. That control has now been in operation for the past thirty years since the Department was established. Here we have an amendment which in fact means the taking away of that control. Is there any demand for that?
Comment on this
We are taking the amendments as they stand here and dealing with them along the lines they follow. Is there any demand for these amendments? I put it to the House there is no demand for them. There have been some small disputes on details between the Department of Agriculture and the county committees of agriculture. There are bound to be small disputes as to details for a short time, but taking the long period the Department has been administering schemes in co-operation with the county committees there has been no real dispute as to any big issue that lasted for any length of time. If this matter was put to the vote of the county committees of agriculture as a whole you would carry the proposal to leave the control to the Minister by a big majority. You have here the control which I say is necessary, and which, in the abstract, is absolutely essential for the reasons I have given. In addition to that, I advance what I regard as a very strong argument that you have this control being exercised for the last twenty years without any real friction, and I would say that there is no sign at this stage of a demand from any of the committees for a removal of the control.
Comment on this
Perhaps it is just as well that the Minister made a general statement covering these amendments, because we can deal with them altogether. I think there are sufficient safeguards without interference by the Minister. We have safeguards under such Acts as the Live Stock Breeding Act. With regard to the cases mentioned about the distribution of seeds, there must be safeguards under the common law to deal with it. Surely there must be safeguards under the ordinary law to deal with such matters. I have heard over and over again from various counties complaints as to the policy of the Department and as to interference in certain things. I heard from Deputy Aiken of a case of interference in the County Louth where the local county committee wanted to carry out extensive experiments in the sowing of wheat, and where they were not allowed by the Department to proceed as they say they could. Again, I knew of complaints from my own County of Wexford in the matter of the type of stallions they were allowed to keep there. Then you have complaints from Kerry as to the too rigid control in certain areas in the matter of the kind of cattle allowed in. In some areas they are confined altogether to the Kerry cattle. In other areas we find complaints as to the general policy of the Department of Agriculture. It was more or less with a view to giving certain Deputies an opportunity of mentioning their grievances that I put down some of these amendments, but I know that there is no use in pressing the matter further than that.
Comment on this
I move amendment 20, which reads:
In sub-section (1), line 54, to delete the word "shall" and substitute the word "may."
This is quite a different amendment from the others. This section makes it mandatory on the county council to strike a rate. I think, in the present circumstances, the House ought not to agree to a principle like this. We had a considerable amount of talk in the last twelve months about de-rating. I believe that the agricultural community had their hopes raised that de-rating was very near at hand. For instance, before Christmas it was announced that the Government were to bring in some scheme of de-rating. They were going to bring in a scheme to relieve agriculture of a million pounds. Some months later the Government came to a different frame of mind and we had the announcement that there was to be no de-rating this year. In the meantime, while this discussion was going on in the Press, we have had the rates increased on the agricultural community. While this discussion about de-rating was going on we had a Bill, the Vocational Education Bill, brought in which put on additional rates on the farmers. Under the Vocational Education Act it is possible to do many of the things which were sought to be done under this Bill. I was not present on the Second Reading, but I afterwards read the discussion in which Deputies Good, Fahy and T.J. O'Connell asked the Minister for his opinion on the matter. The Minister agreed that something should be done for agricultural education under that Act.
In addition to the Vocational Education Act we had a Bill passed through the House here a few days ago—that was the Local Government (Special Expenses) Bill. Under that Bill the local authorities will, in many cases, put up an additional rate of 3d. in the £ on the agricultural community. Then we had a Bill introduced a few days ago, and if it is adopted by some of the local authorities it will put on an extra penny on the rates—that is the Tourist Bill. In addition to that, we know that many of the counties, in the last year or two, were compelled to adopt certain public health schemes. They were compelled to appoint a medical officer of health. In that way the rate was increased in many counties. From what I can learn from the Press, there is hardly a county in the twenty-six that is not increasing its rates in the coming year, and any increase in rates is not very welcome to the agricultural community at present. If the Government are not in a position to bring in de-rating in the next year they should not pass any Act in the Oireachtas in this session that would make it mandatory on the county councils to strike an additional rate. I appeal to the Minister to reconsider this matter and allow the county councils the option they have at present, by substituting the word "may" for "shall," as this amendment proposes.
Comment on this
I fancy that this proposal in the Bill is unnecessary. Surely in the present state of affairs it should be left to the good sense of the county council to say whether they were of opinion that their ratepayers would be in a position to stand another 2d. in the £ under the Bill. That is a matter that surely ought to be left to their own good sense. During the past two months we have heard cries all over the country about the relief that was going to be given to the farmers. We had the President last November telling us that he was going to give immediate relief to the farmers. Is this increase of 2d. in the £ portion of the immediate relief that the farmers are getting? It is time we knew where we stood. During the last week I saw the effect of the Public Expenses Bill down the country. We have also seen the effect of the £300,000 relief grant down the country. The effect of these was that schemes that were hung up on the shelf for the last five years, because of the fact that the people were not able to pay for them, were brought up now on the 25 per cent. grant from the Minister, and as a result we have these works being put through, for which the local rates will have to provide 75 per cent. We have seen some of the blessings bestowed on the agricultural community. We have seen the result of these things on the local bodies, and we can see how they are working out at the moment. Surely the Executive Council should consider these things for themselves, and they ought to see that it should be left to the good sense of the local bodies whether they consider that the ratepayers are able to bear an extra burden of 2d. in the £ or not. In fact, it may be more than 2d.; 2d. is compulsory, and another 1d. may be added if they consider they are able to pay it.
In connection with vocational education, we had some kind of assurance that agricultural education was going to be catered for. Apparently that has gone with all the other things. By degrees the rates on the unfortunate farmers will be shoved up to 6d. It is bad enough to have Ministers making promises about de-rating and then forgetting all about them when they find it convenient to do so. It is bad enough to see the local bodies writing to the Minister for Local Government looking for sanction for an overdraft of £120,000, as was the case recently in Cork, when the people could not pay their rates. The interest on that sum will have to be paid, and yet we have the Minister suggesting an additional 2d. on the rates here to-night. We had 4d. put on the rates last week, and 2d. the week before. The Government Party must imagine that the farmers and other people in the country have an unlimited supply of money, that there is no bottom to their pockets. I think that Deputy Ryan's amendment is a perfectly sensible one, and the Minister ought to accept it.
Comment on this
I have listened to the long list of Bills that Deputy Ryan mentioned as passed here that will place a burden upon the ratepayers. I am surprised that he has introduced an amendment to this measure which has for its purpose the killing of agricultural education in the country. If there is one burden the farmer does not want to be relieved of it is the money spent for the benefit of the farming community generally. If this had been introduced in relation to other measures there might be some other reason for it, but I do not think, no matter what our views may be on de-rating, that any of us interested in agriculture would like to see any prohibition placed upon the levying of a rate for agricultural purposes.
Comment on this
I find myself in agreement with the amendment moved by Deputy Ryan. I think this is not the time when it should be made compulsory on county councils to strike a rate for agricultural purposes such as are set out in this Bill. Deputy O'Hanlon has referred to this amendment as a step towards killing agricultural education.
Comment on this
I understood the Deputy to say that if this amendment were carried it would mean the killing of agricultural education in different counties. Each council is composed, to a large extent, of members of the farming community, people who are elected by the farmers and people who are looking every day at the results derived from the schemes of county committees. If the power to strike a rate of 1d. or 2d. is left in their hands, it seems to me they will strike a rate in proportion to the benefits that they see accuring from those schemes in their different counties. I have noticed Deputy O'Hanlon's attitude on other legislation that imposed further burdens by way of increased rates upon the farmers. I have noticed the attitude of some Deputies towards questions of this kind, and I have also observed their attitude upon such questions when in the country. I cannot understand where the consistency comes in when a Deputy advocates de-rating for the farming community and at the same time votes here for a Technical Education Bill which imposes a sixpenny rate, and a Public Health (Special Expenses) Bill which imposes an additional rate upon the farming community. I cannot understand the attitude of a Deputy who advocates de-rating down the country and declares that the farmers are entitled to it and must get it, while here he votes for legislation of the kind I have mentioned. That is not the sort of consistency I understand. We have the Minister for Local Government refusing to permit local bodies to strike a rate for the improvement of a cul-de-sac, or boreens and lanes, and, on the other hand, we have the Minister for Agriculture suggesting that it should be made compulsory on local bodies to strike a rate for the purposes of the Bill we are now considering. I cannot understand these varying attitudes, and I am not prepared to stand for any inconsistency. In my opinion this is a matter that can safely be left in the hands of county councils, the members of which know the benefits derived from various schemes, and they will be prepared to advocate a rate accordingly.
Comment on this
I quite agree with Deputy O'Hanlon that it would be very bad to deprive the farmers or any section of the community of education, and in that connection I advise him to read Sections 3 and 4 of the Vocational Education Act and also study the reply given by the Minister for Agriculture on 18th February in connection with the Second Stage of this Bill. Some doubts were expressed on that occasion by Deputy O'Connell, Deputy Good, and others regarding the classes to be conducted by instructors under the Department. The Minister said there was a possibility under the Vocational Education Act of getting agricultural classes. Taking Section 3 of that Act, we find that the expression "continuation education" means education to continue and supplement education provided in elementary schools, and includes general and practical training in preparation for employment in trades, manufactures, agriculture, commerce, etc. Sub-section (3) of Section 4 sets out that the Minister may from time to time, after consultation with the Minister for Agriculture, by order declare that the expression "technical education" shall for the purposes of the Act also include instruction in such subjects bearing on or relating to agriculture as may be specified in such order, and wherever any such order is made the meaning of such expression shall, for the purposes of the Act, be extended in conformity with the provisions of such order.
There are complaints through the country that vocational education, continuation education and technical education will largely benefit the towns, but will be of little benefit to the rural districts. There was a possibility of getting in agricultural classes, but we find the Minister for Agriculture stating here—and it is in consultation with him that agricultural instruction must be set up under that Act—"But so far as I know there is no agricultural teaching in any of the schools schemes dealt with under the Vocational Education Act." Therefore, he has not yet been consulted.
I suggest that if the Minister went into consultation with the Minister for Education a good deal of the instructional side of the work of these officers could be brought under the scheme of vocational education. Apart from that, laudable efforts have been made to co-ordinate education, which was a very disjointed thing some years ago, and these efforts have been attended with a considerable amount of success, but there is a danger here of severance again. I think that the Minister should get into touch with the Minister for Education, co-ordinate these classes and get the agricultural classes going for those in the rural areas who benefit little by the Technical Education Act. In that way Deputy O'Hanlon's objections to the amendment would be met and agricultural instruction could be provided.
Comment on this
I have nothing to add to what Deputy O'Hanlon has said except to prove that he is right when he says that there is no demand from the farmers for a reduction in the rate they are paying. While they may be suffering under high rates of taxation they do not begrudge the amount of the rate for the purpose for which it is made. We recently circularised every county council and we told them of our intentions in full. We told them that it was intended to make it mandatory to strike a rate of 2d. in the £ for agricultural schemes. We did that by a circular letter which was sent out on 31st January, and that letter reached every county council in the Saorstát. It was before them all and there was not one single dissentient. The county councils discussed it, and there was no objection of any kind to this particular proposal. There was one doubt expressed by the Leitrim County Council as to the legality of the steps which we were taking to effect our intention but there was no objection to it.
Farmers feel the burden of all overhead expenses, and are as concerned about them as any Deputies here, and they realise the advantage it would be to them to reduce the rate. Deputies can take it that farmers have a very keen appreciation of that fact, but not one suggestion came from any county council that we should lower the rate. That must be accepted as a complete proof that in the opinion of the farmers and county councils this is justified. Deputy Good shakes his head. As a rule members of county councils are quite vocal and when they have any grievances, real or imaginary, they are not slow in airing them. In spite of the fact that they are inclined to be critical on local bodies, not one voice was raised against this proposal. I do not say that some members of county councils might not have overlooked the matter or might not have seen its significance or the chance of making a protest. There may have been a few exceptions like that to explain the silence and the lack of opposition, but it must be taken as almost certain that the letter which set out the scheme fully reached every county council, that they all accepted it, and that it did not pass through all the county councils by default without the members realising its meaning. I think we must accept it as a fact that the county councils, as a whole, were convinced that this was a good proposal. How many proposals would have stood that test, even proposals that got the blessing of every Party here?
Comment on this
That is the very point I am making. We are on this proposal now and not on the others. How many proposals coming from this House got such a test as this one, which was before the county councils for two months? I would like Deputies to consider how many proposals affecting the rates of the farmers themselves would have been received so silently as this. They must have seen the reasonableness of the proposals, as otherwise there would have been opposition. There is a rate of 2d. under the old Technical Education Act, and more than three-halfpence of that is spent on agriculture in every county. What we are asking is a little more than a farthing in the £ in addition for agricultural schemes. I should say that that is fairly well realised by the county councils and that that is one of the reasons why there have not been objections to this particular scheme. I suppose that they realise that we have not made our demands as high as have been made in other branches of education. There is a demand, for instance, under the vocational training scheme of 2d., 4d. and, in some cases, 6d. in the £, and I understand, though I was not in the House at the time, that Deputy Good and others were 100 per cent. in favour of it, yet when I looked for an increase of a little more than a ¼d. in the £ for agricultural schemes there is all this ado. There is another point which justifies the proposal. No matter what Deputies opposite may say, our agricultural schemes are regarded by the country as sound, and they will not be changed by local farmers, no matter what politics they profess, because they know very well that they are sound. These schemes cost about £131,000, and we find, of that sum, £83,000 out of taxation and all that the local bodies have to find is £48,000.
Comment on this
I am giving the present figures. The present position is that there is more than 1½d. on an average levied for agriculture. Obviously the increase in that £48,000 will be very little, because the increase in the rate would be round about ¼d., in some cases perhaps a little more. £48,000 represents a rate of about 1½d. Even a slight increase in that amount would not alter the disproportion that exists between the amount found by rates and that found by taxation.
This question has nothing to do with de-rating. De-rating is another question entirely. If total de-rating is to come, then there would be the problem of finding this money in another way. The real question is whether at present these schemes are sound, and whether circumstances justify an increase of one farthing in the rate for the purposes of these schemes. I have no doubt the Dáil by a majority will decide whether this increase is justified. Whatever doubt there may be about it, there can be no doubt about this, that the majority of the county councils of the country, who are composed to a great extent of parties differing in political views, but who are closer to the soil than we are, and who have to administer these schemes, definitely agree with the Department of Agriculture. They have considered this fully, because it has been before them and explained in full to them for at least two months. There has been no opposition whatever from any quarter to this scheme.
Comment on this
Some of them have, so far as I know. I have heard no case where they have not.
Comment on this
The Deputy can advance that when he is speaking. I have received no intimation from any of the county councils that they are not likely to strike a rate. Of course, when you have a debate like this in the Dáil, when it becomes a question of politics, and when, in addition, everybody knows that these councils are going to strike the rate, Deputies think that there is no harm in letting themselves go.
Comment on this
It is not a matter of politics at all with most of us. We are not disputing the question as to whether a rate of 2d. in the £ is justifiable or not, or whether we would get a return.
Comment on this
For my part, I protest against the proposal in this Bill making it compulsory—compulsion all the time, compulsion in the Department of Agriculture, compulsion in the Department of Local Government, compulsion in everything, driving it down the necks of the local authorities. When the local authorities want to do something for the people whose affairs they are administering, when they want to do something for which there is a crying demand, the Minister for Local Government or the Minister for Agriculture says: "You cannot do this. You cannot strike a rate." It is the compulsion behind this that I, for one, will protest against.
Comment on this
The Minister says that the whole scheme of agricultural education is sound. There is a very grave doubt in the minds of a number of the most advanced farmers in the country as to whether the whole system of agricultural education is sound. Very grave doubts have been raised by a number of progressive farmers as to whether we are getting a good return for the money we are spending on agricultural education. I think everybody must admit that most of the money goes to paying teachers and very little gets down to the farmers. Some people hold that if, instead of spending £1,000 in a county to keep several instructors going round, we divided that up and gave 20 scholarships of £50 each to provide a few years' agricultural education for farmers' sons in an agricultural college, the money would be much better spent. The difficulty most farmers have is in the matter of their ability to read technical books. We spend a lot of money in making experiments around the country, but these experiments could be carried on at much less cost in some central place. If a sufficient leavening of the farmers were in a position to read technical books and to take all the meat out of them, we would get ahead much more speedily.
In regard to the particular schemes that have been approved and disapproved by the Department of Agriculture, there is a number of agricultural committees throughout the country who think that schemes which have been turned down by the Department should have been approved. I shall give one instance. In Co. Louth a year ago, a scheme was adopted to give free seed wheat to small farmers. Even the Minister for Agriculture himself has said that it would be a good thing if the small farmers grew sufficient wheat for their own needs. The County Louth Committee of Agriculture had a scheme whereby they were going to give free seed wheat to farmers with a small valuation. The Department turned that down and said that they should only spend £10 on that scheme—£10 on a scheme which the Minister will admit was a good and a sound scheme. They refused to allow them to go on with the scheme and yet they allowed £15 for a ploughing match in the same week. I think the farmers of the country, particularly in counties like Louth, where the farmers till from 20 to 50 per cent. of their land, are fairly well educated in ploughing their land, and that the £15 spent on the ploughing match would have been much better spent in giving free seed wheat to small farmers to make them self-supporting and to guard against the necessity of buying flour and baker's bread.
As I have stated, the people have grave doubts in regard to a number of schemes approved of by the Department, and by the Department I mean the Minister. Certainly they have grave doubts as to the system of agricultural education. Practically nothing, as the Minister admitted here the other night, has been done except to force the local people to keep up an agricultural instructor. He is going to force them to do it and to strike a rate. These officials will be looked upon in future as the Minister's officials and the people will not have the same interest in them in future as they have had up to the present. The Minister has been in power eight years, and nothing has been done to start agricultural education in the primary schools. No scheme has been outlined by him for agricultural instruction in continuation or vocational schools. The whole thing has been allowed to go by the board. If we are going to do anything in this country to put it on its feet, and if we are going to make the farmers efficient, we will have to start in the primary schools and in the vocational schools. On some other occasion we can debate that matter more fully. We do not approve of this section in the Bill. We think that whatever hope there is of the agricultural instructors getting sympathetic consideration from the ratepayers, if they are forced down their throats the ratepayers of the country will look upon them with disfavour.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the word proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move:—
In sub-section (1), line 56, to delete the words and brackets "excluding any urban districts comprised therein."
Under this section a mandatory rate of 2d. in the £ will be struck in rural areas, while the urban areas will be excluded. I believe that under the Vocational Education Act urban areas get much more benefit than the rural areas, although the rural areas are contributing towards education in the towns. The towns, I think, should contribute towards the agricultural scheme. There should be a flat rate.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy aware that under the Vocational Education Act urban areas are burdened with a much heavier rate than that borne by the county councils? If the Deputy turns to the Schedule of the Vocational Education Act, Part I., he will see that county boroughs and urban districts start with a compulsory rate of 3d. in the £, while in Part II. the county councils start with a compulsory rate of 1¾d., with the exception of County Cork, where the amount is 2d. in the £. He will also see that urban authorities can go to a maximum of 6d., while the county councils only proceed to a maximum of 4d., so that the urban authorities are bearing their share of the educational rate.
Comment on this
There is only a difference of 1¼d. in the rates for the urban and the rural areas. This section is going to make a difference of 2d.
Comment on this
The maximum rate in the urban areas is 6d., and in the county areas 4d., showing a difference of 2d.
Comment on this
As the representative of an urban district, I object to this amendment, because if the working of an urban authority is mixed up with that of a county council the whole system of local government will be upset owing to overlapping of Departments. In the urban district a separate rate is struck for vocational training, and a portion of the rate is contributed to the county council. I think it is unfair to have any urban district brought into this Bill without consultation.
Comment on this
I fear that Deputy Carey is anticipating legislation when he says that he represents an urban district. In view of the fact that the rural areas are at present contributing towards vocational education, which, after all, is of far more benefit to the urban districts than it is to the rural districts, I think that the same rule should obtain here. If we were to trace back the different Bills brought into this House from time to time, we would find that practically every one of them is in favour of the cities and the towns, while the rural areas have to contribute to the cost of them. When the Housing Bill was brought in a short time ago, it was definitely stated by the Minister for Local Government that it was intended to benefit the boroughs and the urban districts.
Comment on this
That was brought in for the relief of the city of Dublin. It was made a central charge. I do not want to be led on to that line again. If I were, I would congratulate Deputy Good on his victory.
Comment on this
An awkward question for you. At present this kind of legislation is unfair and unjust. Since the rural areas have to contribute for the benefit of the towns, why should not the towns contribute for the benefit of the rural areas? This clause is unjust. Up to the present, I have not seen any attempt in this House to differentiate between urban and rural areas. If the Minister insists on this, he is going to create a very bad precedent for legislation which may come before the House later.
Comment on this
I am totally opposed to this amendment. Certain urban areas have been declared vocational education areas, and they have had their own committees set up. They are not receiving any aid from the county rates, and this amendment would operate very unfairly against them. There are areas described as "urban areas" in which no vocational education committees have been set up. They may derive certain advantages from the rural rate, but I do not think that these advantages are sufficiently great to justify the application of this rate to their centres. I think that Deputy Ryan should withdraw the amendment. I do not think that it would be well received in the urban centres.
Comment on this
In all the circumstances, I think it would not be fair to ask the urban areas to pay this rate.
Comment on this
Having heard the arguments, I ask leave to withdraw the amendment. As regards Deputy Good's figures, I should like to point out that the country is at a slight disadvantage. The towns are only contributing about 1¾d. towards vocational education. Here, you have the country paying 2d. in the £. If you take the two charges together—the agricultural charge and the vocational education charge—the rural districts will be contributing more than the urban districts.
Comment on this
I move amendment 22:
In sub-section (1), line 58, to delete the word "two" and substitute the word "one."
I have a considerable amount of sympathy with the Deputies from the rural areas who have complained of the heavy burden of taxation. I was not at all satisfied with the answer that the Minister gave—that he had written to the different county councils and that he had not received any objection from any of them to the imposition of a rate of 2d. I am afraid that at the speed at which we are passing legislation here even the county councils cannot keep pace with us. Under the old régime, the county councils, as the Minister has pointed out, levied a rate of 2d. in the £ for agricultural purposes and for education. That was handed over to agricultural committees. The agricultural committees, like all other committees, held on to the product of 1½d. and handed over only the product of ½d. for education. In fact, the Minister said that they did not hand over as much as ½d. for education. So naturally the Deputies have complained rightly that very little has been done for education in these areas, but on the other hand very little money has been provided from these areas for the purposes of education. We hope all that has been set right under the Vocational Bill. Under the Vocational Bill as passed here in the agricultural areas each county council sets up a county vocational committee. Similar committees are set up in the urban areas and similar committees in the county boroughs. That vocational education committee in the rural areas will have charge of vocational education in that particular area. It will in addition have the administration of a considerable sum of money, for we find that under Section 2 of the Vocational Bill in the first year, that is the year commencing the 1st April, 1931, the levy in the County Cork, in which Deputy Corry is interested, though he is not here, is 2d. in the £ to start with.
In all the other county areas the compulsory rate from the 1st April next will be 1¾d. in the £ each year following the present year. That rate would be increased by ¼d. in the £. It is a mandatory rate until it reaches a maximum of 4d. in the £ in 1940. That rate will be administered through the county vocational committee, so that consequently the amount of educational activity—those committees, I might point out, work under the jurisdiction of the Minister for Education— under the jurisdiction of the county council would be very considerable in the future. It has been, I admit, very small in the past. When that Bill is passed that rate comes into operation. I am afraid that when these county councils with which the Minister communicated had before them this question of the imposition of a 2d. rate they were not at all clear whether that was for vocational education or for agricultural purposes.
Comment on this
I have some little difficulty in keeping up with these Acts, although I am a member of the Dáil. We pass Acts so quickly that really we get out of touch with them very quickly. We must not be too burdensome on the county councils, and my proposal is to give the Minister from the county councils practically what he has at the moment. Under this Bill he proposes that there shall be a mandatory rate under clause 32 of 2d. in the £. As I pointed out, the Minister only gets at the moment a maximum, that is, the agricultural committees get a maximum, of 2d. from the county councils, and they hand over ½d. for the purposes of education which, of course, is not administered by the Depart ment of Agriculture. I propose that that 2d. should be reduced to 1d. This clause further provides that any county council which is disposed to give additional moneys for the purposes of agriculture can do so up to a further penny in the £, so that 1d. would be mandatory, and county councils who are anxious to give more can give a further penny if they so desire. In addition to that, under sub-section (2) you have a further ½d. where the Minister has made a forestry scheme order in respect of the county.
Comment on this
Then the wording seems very strange. "Where the Minister has made a forestry scheme order in respect of a county the council of such county shall in every local financial year after the date of such order raise equally over the whole of their county (excluding any urban districts comprised therein) by means of the poor rate a sum ... equal to not more than a rate of ½d. in the £ on the rateable value of such county at the beginning of such year." I am glad to hear from the Minister that that is not mandatory, because as I read the clause it is.
Comment on this
There is a provision to the effect that the scheme can only be made on the suggestion of the county council. There must be agreement between the Minister and the county council.
Comment on this
If they agree to make the scheme, then the rate is mandatory.
Comment on this
In the opening of the clause you have "Where the Minister has made a forestry scheme order in respect of a county." Then follows: "The council of such county shall." However, we will leave that out of the question for the moment. Apart from that, each county must give to the Minister for the purpose of the agricultural rate 1d. in the £ under this amendment of mine. The clause is mandatory for 2d. I say if the Minister gets from that 1d. he practically gets as much as he gets at the moment, and gets sufficient for the purpose. I am satisfied when it comes to the knowledge of these local authorities that they have to strike 1d. in the coming year for the purpose of agriculture and that they have to strike, in addition, in the coming year 1¾d. for the purpose of vocational education, all the county councils in Ireland will become vocal and will satisfy the Minister on that point.
Comment on this
I do not think the Deputy is right when he says the county councils did not know what they were on. A letter was written to them, not talking of any Acts of Parliament, but, stating that the legislation under which they struck their rate was repealed and that it was intended to introduce legislation making it mandatory to strike a 2d. rate, a simple letter of that kind which could be understood by any county council. They could not be under any delusion as to what it meant. So far as this forestry rate is concerned I do not want to get involved in a quarrel about words. That rate is not mandatory in the real sense. It is provided "Where the Minister on the joint representation of the council of a county and the committee of agriculture for such county considers it desirable that steps should be taken to preserve existing woods and so on." So no forestry scheme can come into operation unless the suggestion comes from the county itself. I am afraid the position has been prejudiced by reason of the fact that a certain rate must be struck for vocational education. I do not think that is the right way to approach this question. I take it the Dáil discussed the question of what rate should be struck for vocational education on its merits when the Bill was before them, and I suggest we should consider what rate should be struck for agriculture on its merits also, and on the history of the case there is a very strong justification for a rate of 2d.
I think this objection to a mandatory rate of 2d. is not justified. It is not sound enough. I think this suggestion of a compulsory penny and a discretionary penny to follow is a sort of a suggestion to county councils that they should strike a penny and no more. The Deputy may say that is not so. I venture to say that I know the psychology of county councils just as well as he does, and that if you insert any provision to that effect, that they have to strike 1d. and no more, we may assume they will strike no more. At present they are striking 2d.
There is a point that I would like to bring the attention of Deputies to. Practically all the counties but three are striking the full 2d. rate for a very long time. They are giving 1½d. to agriculture, and they are doing all that voluntarily. They could not strike a higher rate than 2d. under these Acts, and I think it is reasonable to suggest that if they had power to strike more than 2d. they would have done it. They did it voluntarily for a great number of years. They gave more than 1½d. to agriculture, and at the moment you have the position that most of them are giving 2d. voluntarily.
Comment on this
They are giving 2d. Under my proposal 1d. would be mandatory, and they would have the option of adding another 1d.
Comment on this
I would prefer to have the whole lot voluntary than that—I am giving my own personal view—for the reason I have given, that I would be afraid it would be giving a lead to the county councils in the direction of striking a penny only. To have a penny compulsory and another discretionary, I am afraid, would tend in time to fixing a penny as the contribution from the rates. It would be a better position to have the 2d. discretionary, because at the moment, where there is a discretionary 2d. for agriculture and technical instruction, all counties except three are raising, and, on the average, they are paying 1½d. for agriculture. For that reason I do not like the Deputy's proposal.
Comment on this
May I point out that these county councils are contributing 2d. at the moment for the purposes of agricultural education, and they will be contributing from the 1st April next 2¾.?
Comment on this
For the purposes of education and for the purposes of agriculture. Then from 1st April next, even making a penny mandatory, they will be contributing 2¾d., because there will be 1¾d. mandatory for vocational education and 1d. for the purpose of agriculture under this Bill. In addition, any of the county councils that so wish can give more for the purpose of agriculture up to a penny.
Comment on this
I would like to be clear on a matter that was raised by Deputy Good on the last occasion on which we were dealing with this Bill. How far are the vocational education committees permitted to have in their schemes a scheme for agricultural education? I have been told that a certain local committee sent up a scheme dealing with agricultural education and that it was turned down by the Minister.
Comment on this
I can make inquiries on that point before the Report Stage, but I do not know that.
Comment on this
From what the Minister said on the last occasion here, I take it that the agricultural education in which he is interested is of an exceptional and practical type.
Comment on this
Instructors would give to adults, who would be for the most part actually engaged in farming themselves, a type of practical education that is not the same as was mainly contemplated under the Vocational Act.
Comment on this
Then is it not quite clear that there ought to be considerable opportunity given to the vocational education committees to have in their programme a scheme of agricultural education? Will the Minister not admit that there is room in it for that in addition to any education that may be given by his Department?
Comment on this
My information at present is that there seems to be some idea in the mind of the Department, whether the Education Department or the Department of Agriculture I do not know, that agricultural education should be confined to the type of education that is provided for in the Agriculture Bill.
Comment on this
It would be entirely contrary to the spirit of vocational education.
Comment on this
So I believe. That is why I raised it. It seems to me that the education provided for under this Bill is quite different from the type contemplated in the Vocational Education Act, and that any educational facilities provided under this Bill should be over and above those which were contemplated in the Vocational Education Act, and that if there is provision being made it ought not to be so as to prevent the local committees from having agricultural schemes embodied in their programmes.
Comment on this
In the first place, definitely, the Vocational Education Act includes agriculture. In the next place "the Minister may from time to time, after consultation with the Minister for Agriculture, by order declare that the expression technical education shall for the purposes of this Act also include instruction in such subjects bearing on or relating to agriculture as may be specified in such order." So that the Vocational Education Act definitely includes agriculture.
Comment on this
I submit that that more or less strengthens my suspicions, because it seems to indicate that before agriculture will be considered as a technical subject, coming under the Vocational Education Act, there must be consultation with the Minister for Agriculture, and that he must agree. In other words that it is not automatic.
Comment on this
Therefore, there is a specific reservation made in the case of agriculture. What I want to be clear on is that the provision in regard to agricultural education should not operate in any sense to exclude vocational committees from having agriculture in their own programmes.
Comment on this
The more vocational education committees take advantage of the Vocational Education Act to provide agricultural education from their funds the better I am pleased. That is our point of view, any extra agricultural education that is given so much the better. I take it what Deputy de Valera wants to know is, is there any objection on principle or whether there is to be any education given except the education we give. Certainly. If there was agricultural education given in any other way and paid for under other Acts we would be only delighted, with this condition; if, for instance, there was consultation between the Minister for Education and the Minister for Agriculture in regard to a vocational education scheme for agricultural education of course the Minister for Agriculture would have certain views on any specific scheme as to whether it were sound or not, but in general the more agricultural education that is given the better.
Comment on this
I am very glad to hear that. I was surprised when this matter was brought to my attention. A member of a local education committee told me that a scheme had been submitted which involved for the most part a scheme for agricultural education and that it was turned down. The assumption was that it was turned down not on the merits of the scheme as an agricultural scheme but because it was agricultural, not because the Minister for Agriculture was not satisfied with the particular way in which the scheme for agricultural education was to be carried out, but because it had reference to agriculture. I thought it very strange, if it were true, that the Minister meant to confine agricultural education solely to the type provided in this Bill.
Comment on this
It is quite apparent from the Minister's reply to questions on the Second Stage of the Bill and to-day that he has formulated no definite scheme of agricultural education other than that carried out by the Department's instructors.
Comment on this
Is a debate on agricultural education in order on an amendment of this kind? We debate that on the Estimates every year at great length. I want to make the point that it is quite impossible to have an adequate debate on agricultural education generally on the Committee Stage of a Bill like this.
Comment on this
We are not going to have a debate on it. This is a question which arises out of this amendment. We who are interested in agriculture would like to get some scheme outlined by the Minister, that he should declare his own mind anyway as to what he intends agricultural education to be in future.
Comment on this
Yes, for specific schemes that the Dáil is aware of.
Comment on this
These schemes for the most part are optical demonstrations to farmers that things can be grown.
Comment on this
If there was a system of agricultural education whereby young farmers were taught to digest the ordinary technical books on farming and the leaflets issued by the Department there would be no necessity for a large proportion of this rate. If a young farmer could take up books and by studying them find out how certain things could be done in the line of agriculture, that certain things could be grown under certain conditions with certain manures, etc., there would be no necessity for striking a 2d. rate and having agricultural instructors going round simply giving demonstrations to farmers of things that are contained in these books. Our whole system of agricultural education is wrong.
Comment on this
The Deputy is going into the administration of the Department rather than discussing the amendment.
Comment on this
This is going to give the Department power to strike a 2d. rate when they like. I do not think we should be cribbed in that way in discussing a matter like this.
Comment on this
I am not curtailing the Committee unduly. I am giving the Deputy full liberty on the amendment, but I cannot allow him to go into the question of the administration of the Department on an amendment such as this.
Comment on this
There is every justification that only a penny rate should obtain, and that there should not be a mandatory 2d. rate, because every farmer in the country is convinced that the value he is getting for this is absolutely nil, and that from the point of view of improving agriculture and the working of it the instructors might as well be in Hong Kong. They are no use in the counties at all.
Comment on this
Yet all these fools are up at the Show buying premium bulls out of this fund to-day; they are so convinced it is all nonsense.
Comment on this
Question—"That the word proposed to be deleted stand part of the Bill"—put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move:—
In sub-section (2), page 13, line 9. to insert before the word "raise" the words "if so required by the Minister during the preceding local financial year, but not otherwise."
Comment on this
With regard to amend ment 25—"In sub-section (2), line 10, to delete the words and brackets `excluding an urban district comprised therein' "—I suppose I have to withdraw this amendment, but there is more reason for the urban district contributing to the preservation of the woods, because they get more value out of them from picnics and so on than the country people.
Comment on this
I move:—
In page 13, to add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
"(3) All acts and things done before the commencement of this Act by the council of a county in relation to the making of a poor rate for the local financial year commencing on the 1st day of April, 1931, shall (where the amount to be raised by means of such poor rate includes the amount of the agricultural rate) be as valid and effectual as if sub-section (1) of this section were in force at the time such acts or things were done."
Comment on this
I move:
In sub-section (1), before paragraph (d), to insert a new paragraph as follows:—
"(d) to defray any payments required to be made by such committee under the provisions of this Act relating to the payment of travelling expenses to members of committees."
Comment on this
I move:
In sub-section (1), to insert before paragraph (d) a new paragraph as follows:—
"(d) to defray any debt due by such committee to the Minister in relation to the holding of a local inquiry by the Minister."
Comment on this
I move amendment 35:
Before Section 43 to insert a new section as follows:—
"Every regulation made by the Minister under this Act shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas as soon as may be after it is made, and if either such House shall, within twenty-one days on which such House has sat after such regulation is laid before it, pass a resolution annulling such regulation, such regulation shall be annulled accordingly but without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done thereunder."
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 36:
Before the Second Schedule to insert a new schedule as follows:—
"SECOND SCHEDULE.
Rules for payment of Travelling Expenses.
1. In these rules:—
the word "committee" means a committee of agriculture;
the word "contribution" means a contribution payable under this Act to a member of a committee towards the expenses incurred by him in attending the meeting of such committee.
2. Every member of a committee shall, at the commencement of his term of office as such member, communicate in writing to the chief executive officer of such committee the address at which he ordinarily resides, which address is referred to in these rules as the official residence of such member.
3. The contribution to be paid to a member of a committee in respect of his attendance at any meeting shall be calculated on the length of the journery from the official residence of such member to the place of meeting of the committee and the mode of transport used for such journey.
4. Where the journey from the official residence of a member to the place of meeting of the committee could be made by more than one route or by different modes of transport, the journey shall, for the purposes of these rules, be deemed to have been made by the route and the mode of transport in respect of which the payment under these rules would be the least.
5. There shall be paid to every member to whom a contribution is payable under this Act, a sum calculated in the manner prescribed in the next rule in respect of each meeting of the committee attended by him, subject to the limitation that no contribution shall be paid to any such member in respect of a meeting held at a place situate less than five miles by any route from his official residence.
6. The sum payable under the preceding rule in respect of each meeting shall be calculated as follows, that is to say, four pence for each mile of the journey from the member's official residence to the place of meeting travelled by railway, and five pence for each mile of such journey travelled otherwise than by railway."
This is purely for the purposes of definition and it prescribes the organisation and routine of the Committee.
Comment on this
I move amendment 37:
To delete paragraph 3 and substitute the following paragraph:—
"3. The following provisions shall have effect in relation to the consitution of every committee of agriculture for a county, that is to say:—
(a) the number of members of such committee to be appointed in an election year at the annual meeting of the council held in that year shall not be less than three times nor more than four times the number of county electoral areas in the county at the date of such annual meeting;
(b) subject to the provisions of the foregoing sub-paragraph, the number of members of such committee to be appointed in an election year at the annual meeting of the council held in that year shall be such number as the council think fit, and such committee shall, notwithstanding any change in the number of electoral areas in such county in the meantime, until the annual meeting of the council held in the next following election year, consist of such last mentioned number of members."
Comment on this
If this amendment is carried, amendment 38 cannot be moved in its present form; it could by agreement be moved as an amendment to No. 37.
Comment on this
There are certain county committees—at least one—that consider the number is small. They would like to have the option of electing five for each electoral district. I do not know whether the Minister has any objection to that. My amendment reads: "In rule 3, line 24, to delete the word `four' and substitute the word `five.' "
Comment on this
It is felt that five would be too much, but I will consider the matter between this and the Report Stage. I would want to apply that to the number of electoral areas in the various counties so as to see how it works out.
Comment on this
I move amendment 39:—
In rule 4, line 27, to delete the words "one person who is" and substitute the words "three persons who are."
I thought there should be at least three instead of one person from each area so as to have the members better distributed. Under the Bill there must be one person from each area.
Comment on this
At present you do not have one person from each area and we are making it mandatory to have one. If there is one representative from each area you are doing fairly well.
Comment on this
It might keep outstanding men away in some counties.
Comment on this
I move amendment 40:—
In rule 5, line 31, to delete the words "or has an estate or interest in some agricultural land in the county."
I cannot see the necessity for this qualification. The rule sets out that this person must have a practical, commercial or technical knowledge of land or have an estate or interest in some agricultural land in the county or have special local knowledge of agricultural matters. The person who has an estate or an interest in some agricultural land in the county but who might not have a practical commercial or technical knowledge of land—surely he should not be on the committee?
Comment on this
It is only to make assurance doubly sure. I do not believe there is much value in the rule; it is a pious aspiration. I do not think the rule will make any very great difference.
Comment on this
I would like the Minister to look into rule 10; it is possible it may conflict with rule 2. If a minimum number of councillors were on the county committee and one of the minimum were to resign, he would not be eligible for re-election. Rule 2 points out that every committee shall be composed either wholly of persons who are members of the council or partly of persons who are and partly of persons who are not members of the council. Suppose the absolute minimum of one were on the county committee. If he were to resign he would not be eligible for re-election.
Comment on this
The Deputy's point apparently is that if there was only one member of the county council a member of the committee and he resigned, he would not be eligible for re-election. Then you would find nobody at all from the county council on the committee. That did not occur to me. It is not likely to occur, but it might be provided against. I will look into that matter.
Second Schedule, as amended, agreed to.
Third Schedule and Title agreed to.