We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Supplementary Estimates. Vote 52—Agriculture.

Contributions 1–220 of 447. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Ernest Blythe Minister for Finance (Mr. Blythe) Cumann na nGaedheal

I move:—

"Go ndeontar Suim Bhreise ná raghaidh thar £10 chun íoctha an Mhuirir a thiocfaidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar críoch an 31adh lá de Mhárta, 1931, chun Tuarastail agus Costaisí Oifig an Aire Thalmhaíochta, agus seirbhísí áirithe atá fé riara na hOifige sin, maraon le hIldeontaisí-i-gCabhair.

That a supplementary sum not exceeding £10 be granted to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1931, for the Salaries and Expenses of the Office of the Minister for Agriculture, and of certain services administered by that Office, including Sundry Grants-in-Aid."

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan Minister for Agriculture (Mr. Hogan) Cumann na nGaedheal

This Estimate includes the sum of £880, grant in respect of additional sugar beet grown in the Cooley district; a sum of £1,169, loans to potato-growers in the Cooley district, and also £10,000 which, in fact, is for the re-purchase of Cleeve's toffee factory. There is the sum of £7,450 in connection with the administration of the Agricultural Produce (Fresh Meat) Act. These sums make a total of £19,499. The appropriations-in-aid amount to £4,683. These are accounted for by receipts under the Agricultural Produce (Fresh Meat) Act. That gives a total of £14,816. There are savings under other sub-heads amounting to £14,806, and the Dáil is now asked for the sum of £10.

As regards the grant of £880 in respect of additional sugar beet grown in the Cooley district, this is at the rate of 4/- per ton factory weight, to be paid to the Irish Sugar Manufacturing Co., Ltd., in respect of sugar beet grown on 400 acres, in addition to the acreage contracted for under the subsidised sugar scheme. It is estimated that the crop of beet will average 11 tons per acre. In addition to this grant, the sugar company will be entitled to a remission of the excise duty on the sugar manufactured from the beet grown on the 400 acres, which it is estimated will be £11 13s. 4d. per ton. The company have undertaken to pay to the growers of the beet on the 400 acres in the Cooley district the same price as in the case of beet grown under the subsidised sugar beet scheme. The loans, amounting to £1,169, to potato-growers in the Cooley district are repayable on the 1st April, 1931, with interest at the rate of 5½ per cent. per annum.

As regards the item dealing with the Agricultural Produce (Fresh Meat) Act. Deputies are aware that the Act came into force on 1st September last, so that the present estimate, £7,450, is for only part of a year. The estimate is required for part-time examiners who are normally paid by fees on the following scale:—£4 per 100 cattle; £1 per 100 calves; £1 per 100 pigs, and £1 per 100 sheep. In some cases where, owing to the small number of animals presented for examination the fees payable would be inadequate, the examiners are paid £2 2s. per day. In one case double the normal fees per 100 animals is paid.

As regards the item £3,300, contributions to local authorities—in Dublin, Cork and Limerick all the veterinary inspectors employed by the local authorities are available for work under the Act, and the Department make a contribution in respect of their salaries as follows:—Dublin, £1,500 per annum; Cork, £2,350 per annum; Limerick, £2,750; making a total of £6,600 for a full year. The £3,300 now asked for is in respect of six months from 1st September last to 28th February. Recoupment in respect of March will fall into next year. Marketing inspectors at £5 per week inclusive, are employed to see that the regulations as to packing, etc., of consignments of fresh meat are complied with. Travelling expenses are estimated at £130. The equipment and incidental expenses are estimated at £170. Appropriations-in-aid—that is receipts from licences—are estimated at £2,800. These are total receipts under the Agricultural Produce (Fresh Meat) Act.

With regard to the item of £10,000 in respect of Cleeve's factory, the position about that is as follows. This factory was purchased by us along with the Condensed Milk Company, and after some time was sold to a proprietor for the sum of £14,000, payable with interest by instalments. £4,000 of the purchase money was repaid, together with interest, and after that we found it necessary to put in a liquidator. The alternative at that stage was either to liquidate the company, in order to realise, or to re-purchase the company. We re-purchased the company, in fact, for £1,000. That is what we paid for it.

We took it over again with its liabilities as well as its assets. Its liabilities amounted to about £8,000, and its assets amounted to considerably more. The assets were in the shape of additional machinery, debts due to the company, stores and provisions, so that we have again in our possession the original Toffee Factory for what it cost originally plus certain new machinery, certain stores and certain debts due to it. Its assets are worth something about £8,000 and as against that we are paying certain liabilities which amounted to about £7,000. We decided to re-purchase Cleeve's Toffee Factory for the following reasons:—After selling it originally we came to the conclusion that it was a mistaken policy to have sold it. A Toffee Factory is an extremely useful thing in connection with condensed milk. It provides an outlet for condensed densed milk.

Since we re-purchased the factory we are running it on ordinary business lines and it has made a profit each month. We are now satisfied that it is a valuable asset in connection with the condensing factory. In fact, most of the condensing factories that I know have outlets of this kind for their condensed milk. There are other more important reasons from the point of view of the public generally. When this factory was up for sale secondly we were not the only possible purchasers. I am not in a position to say What would have happened if we had not re-purchased. I can only indicate what might have happened. Inquiries were made by outside firms with a view to the purchasing of the factory and by firms in this country also. There was some immediate danger that the factory would be re-purchased and closed. If that happened it would be fairly serious from this point of view— that there are 60 to 70 employees working there. They were working there at the time when it was sold and they are working there at the moment and there was a danger that they would be thrown out of employment. On the other hand, some of the people who were considering the question of buying it were the owners of toffee factories outside this country. They were buying it possibly to run it and possibly to close it. We could not contemplate the closing of the factory with any great equanimity. I think we have the support of most people in that. There was, however, another very good reason why we should purchase the factory. It was this-we have at the moment a monopoly as a result of purchasing this factory. We have a monopoly of Cleeve's trade mark and goodwill. Cleeve's trade mark and goodwill are very valuable for our butter and condensed milk. It was absolutely vital to us that this goodwill represented by this trade name should not be injured in any way, by, say, the production of toffee or butter or condensed milk by outside firms who might fail to maintain the reputation of that name as far as they had control of it. For instance, if this toffee factory passed over to somebody who turned out an inferior toffee or inferior sweets, that would react on what was to us a very valuable asset, the goodwill we have by reason of the fact that we own this factory.

We have the toffee factory back on our hands at the moment plus certain liabilities. But against these certain liabilities we have, on a conservative estimate, assets in the way of additional machinery, debts due and money paid for stores, etc., which are very much greater than the liabilities We work that factory in connection with the condensed milk factory. We are running it on ordinary business lines, and we find it a very valuable asset. The condensing of milk is not a very prosperous business. It is a business in which there is a tremendous amount of competition, especially from outside countries, and we cannot afford to neglect any profitable outlet for our condensed milk. We cannot afford to run a condensing plant on the lines of disposing of all facilities and profitable assets and endeavouring to hold on to assets not so profitable. No business concern could do that, and we do not propose to do it. On the other hand, we do not intend, if we can help it, to allow a state of affairs to arise under which any factory would be closed and the employees put out of employment. In addition, we do not intend to do anything which would, in any way, endanger the valuable asset that we have bought and the taxpayers have paid for—that is Cleeve's name. As far as the condensing factory and the toffee factory are concerned they must be run together. We are not anxious to remain in business, and are ready to sell whenever there is a purchaser. I may say that I do not anticipate there will be any difficulty in selling both, at a price that would be satisfactory, but that does not arise at the moment.

Comment on this

I think a number of Deputies have been approached by representatives of toffee manufacturing firms in the Free State concerning this proposal to vote public funds for the maintenance of this toffee factory in Limerick. Many serious questions are raised by this disposal, and it would be well that they should be examined in detail by the Dáil before the proposal is agreed to. The position is, I understand, that the toffee factory was purchased with the other assets of the Condensed Milk Company of Ireland some years ago, and was then sold as a separate concern to the company mentioned in the Estimates. The purchase price, the Minister informed us, was £14,000, to be payable with interest by instalments. Is it a fact that the person who purchased the factory was under the impression that he was securing with it the right to use the Cleeve's trade mark, and the good-will of Cleeve's business?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I do not think so. If he was he acted in a peculiar way afterwards. He had the right to use it; we all had a right to use it. Anybody who bought any part of the assets of the company had a right to use the trade name, but so far as toffee was concerned we had not the exclusive right to the name. We discovered that other people in England had rights to use the name. We bought these rights for £3,000, of which sum the purchasers paid £2,000 and we paid £1,000. We did not buy the right to use the trade mark because we always had that; but there were certain people in England who claimed to have it also. We wanted a monopoly and we bought the monopoly; we bought their rights for £3,000, of which sum we paid £1,000 and the purchasers £2,000.

Comment on this

I understand the reason why the original purchaser was unable to meet the instalment payments as they became due was because he became involved in expensive litigation arising out of a dispute relating to the trade mark.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

There is nothing whatever in that.

Comment on this

That may be so, but the fact is that the original purchaser failed to meet the instalment payments and the Disposals Board then resumed ownership.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

They put in a liquidator.

Comment on this

Did there not something else happen in the matter in the meantime? The original purchaser sold his rights in the factory to another purchaser having, as part of the terms of sale, reduced the debenture charge to £10,000. What was the history of the concern during the period in which the second purchaser controlled it? Is it a fact that he also failed to make the factory pay sufficient to enable him to meet the interest charges and did the Disposals Board put additional money into the factory during that period? I am informed that the registered debentures amount to £20,000 and not £10,000, the figure at the period when the original purchaser transferred his interest in the company to the second purchaser. Is the Minister satisfied that the factory is capable of being run at a profit under present conditions in this country? Is it able to meet the charges on it? The position as I understand it is that two purchasers have had control of it during the period since it was originally sold. Neither of them succeeded in making it pay and the second purchaser is now the manager of the factory under the Board.

A number of important questions arise out of this. There are in this country a number of firms engaged in the manufacture of toffee. These firms are protected by a tariff, and encouraged by the Government to extend their productive capacity, which they did. Apart from Cleeve's factory in Limerick, I am informed that other toffee factories in the State are quite capable of producing much more than the annual consumption of toffee in this country. These people feel they have a grievance if another factory is going to be run in competition with them, subsidised out of public funds, and they have a grievance particularly because the manner in which the factory is being run is, in their opinion, unfair. The second owner and present manager of the factory commenced his operations by cutting prices and forcing other firms that could afford to do so to follow suit. The only firms that could afford to do so were foreign firms which have established places of business here. A number of native firms were brought to a very serious position in consequence of the price-cutting war inaugurated by Cleeve's factory. I understand that at present the factory is, in addition, running a money competition in connection with its products, and they are offering £1,000 in prizes. Is any portion of the money which we are now voting going for the purpose of subsidising that prize scheme?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Of the vote of £10,000 there is £1,000 devoted to working capital. There is a vote of £10,000 and of that sum £9,000 will go to liquidate certain liabilities. As against those liabilities we have certain new assets valued for considerably more. The balance of £1,000 is for working capital in the factory.

Comment on this

That £1,000 is to finance this prize scheme, and that is a form of price-cutting.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The sum of £1,000 is for working capital.

Comment on this

It is devoted to the prize scheme.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

And other matters. It is for working capital as a whole—say, a prize scheme.

Comment on this

The fact is that the Government is paying them £1,000 to enable them to finance a scheme of cash prizes and secure in that way additional sales for the toffee produced in the factory.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

No; the £1,000 is for working capital.

Comment on this

The Government is giving the factory £1,000 and the factory is spending that money on this particular scheme which means, in effect, a form of price-cutting. The other toffee manufacturers in the State have a grievance in that the taxpayer should be called upon to put money at the disposal of a competing firm, particularly when it is proposed to be utilised in the way I have outlined. We have in this country a number of manufacturers capable of producing all the toffee we require. It is now proposed to ask the taxpayer to put at the disposal of another factory a substantial sum of money to enable that factory to continue and increase its operations. That raises some serious questions. There is no objection in principle on our part to the State engaging in a business enterprise, but we think when it does so, it should confine its operations to such enterprises as are not likely to inflict damage on people already engaged in any particular trade.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Would it not be very hard to find them?

Comment on this

There are quite a number of industries in respect of which you could contemplate the State taking a monopoly, but I suggest toffee is not one of them. There are other industries much more worthy of help than the production of toffee. Is it fair that the State should engage in competition with private manufactures who have been encouraged by the State to establish themselves here and to enter into capital commitments in consequence of the tariff imposed? I quite realise that the Minister will justify his doing so on the grounds that here is a State asset which it is necessary to preserve, and if the factory is not kept in production the value of that asset will deteriorate. I think the Dáil should not be satisfied that the spending of this £10,000 is going to keep this asset unimpaired.

Is the Minister satisfied that he will at any time be able to dispose of this factory? I take it his policy now is not to dispose of it separately, but as part and parcel of the condensed milk plant. If that is not the case, then are we to contemplate the Minister coming here to the Dáil frequently asking for future subsidies in order to enable the factory to continue? The position is complicated by the fact that there are reasons to believe that the management of the factory is not satisfactory. The present manager is a former proprietor, who was unable to make the factory pay and meet the debenture charges. Moreover, he is a person who has been on two occasions in recent years, decreed in the Court for fraud—on one occasion, in connection with the rabbit-breeding scheme which was subsidised by the State to the extent of £500, and on the second occasion by a private employer, who detected him stealing his letters and extracting information from them relative to his trade, for the purpose of handing it over to his competitors.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What scheme is subsidised by the State?

Comment on this

The rabbit-breeding scheme associated with the Olympia Theatre there, or a shop close to it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

By what Department?

Comment on this

I am informed anyway that a subsidy was given in connection with that particular project.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

By whom?

Comment on this

By some Government Department.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I never heard of it.

Comment on this

I think if the Minister looks it up he will find that is so. The fact, however, is that the present manager of this factory was also associated with that particular scheme. and so managed it that a number of people took proceedings against him for fraud. The individual in question then came into the toffee trade, and his career in that trade was certainly a brilliant one, but fraught with disastrous consequences to those with whom he was associated. As I said, his proprietor found him opening his business letters and extracting from these letters information relating to the trade for the purpose of giving it——

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I think that is entirely wrong.

Comment on this

The case was argued in court.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The fact of the matter was that this factory was owned by two persons, that they proceeded to quarrel at an early stage, and that each of them made wild charges against the other, all of which, I am sure, were grossly extravagant. I do not think they concern us.

Comment on this

I think they concern the House to this extent, that one individual who was a party to that quarrel, who acquired the factory for nothing practically as a result of the quarrel, who failed to make the factory pay, who continued in the position of owner of the factory, and increased its liabilities considerably, is being retained as manager of the factory. He is an individual who has a particular liking for prize schemes and who, in fact, is obviously the author of the particular prize scheme now associated with Cleeve's factory, a scheme which is going, in my opinion, either to break the factory or to involve the taxpayer in continuous subsidies.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Will the Deputy bear in mind that a series of charges is being made which it would be impossible for the Minister to counteract and the person concerned has not an opportunity to counteract them either because they are made under privilege? It is a very serious matter.

Comment on this

I am only referring to matters that can be verified from the records of the court.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

No, they cannot. The Deputy would not say outside all he has said here. I do not care if the Deputy goes on for ever, but he would not dare to say outside what he has now said here.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Apart from the merits of the case, it is a very serious matter if a business man is to be pilloried here and there is no opportunity given to him to reply.

Comment on this

That is not the point. The point is that the Government is coming to the Dáil and asking for £10,000 to pay the liabilities created by this individual and to provide him with £1,000 to continue his operations.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Nothing of the kind. The Government is asking for £10,000 to pay certain liabilities incurred by the company of which this individual was one member. There was a dispute between certain members of the company, and the Deputy is now airing that dispute. He should leave it between them. We have nothing to do with it.

Comment on this

Let us start at the point at which the State bought back the company. They took over the company, I understand from the Minister, for £1,000 and acquired at the same time the privilege of paying its liabilities.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

And took over considerable assets. We took it at our own valuation.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that the shares of the company were worth £1,000?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Quite.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, at that particular time the company had failed to make a profit, had failed to pay the interest, much less the instalments due, on the debentures, and had considerably increased its liabilities.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

It is also a fact that at the time there were a number of serious purchasers.

Comment on this

As we are getting on to this question of purchasers, I should like to know if, when the factory was sold originally, there were any other purchasers in the field?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

There were two.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that he did right?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Yes. We accepted the highest tender.

Comment on this

Were the purchasers offering cash?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Certainly.

Comment on this

But the actual purchaser was not?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

You ask if the other purchasers were offering cash. I could not say whether they intended to pay all down at once. When this was sold originally, tenders were asked for and there were two tenders received. These two tenders were practically the same in their conditions. There was only one difference and that was that one person offered considerably more than the other and the highest bidder got it.

Comment on this

The factory was sold on the instalment system and the purchaser for various causes was unable to meet the instalments. If there was another purchaser willing to pay cash for it, is the Minister not open to criticism for not having accepted that cash offer, even if the actual amount was less than the total of the instalment payments?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Was there such another person?

Comment on this

I am informed that there was.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I do not think so.

Comment on this

Did not the Minister say five minutes ago that there were two other purchasers?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

There were two purchasers originally, so far as I know—I can verify it before the end of the debate. The proposal of both was to pay certain sums by instalments. I shall verify that within ten minutes.

Comment on this

When the Government bought the factory a second time the Minister informed us there were certain purchasers in the field besides the Government. Who were these purchasers? I do not want him to give names, but were they people who contemplated operating that factory as a toffee factory as a private enterprise?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Some of them were.

Comment on this

Does not the Minister think that it would have been better in the interests of the State to allow that factory to be purchased by a toffee manufacturer to be worked as a private enterprise, instead of taking it over with public funds as a very doubtful asset, which the Minister will, in my opinion, find considerable difficulty in disposing of, either separately or in conjunction with the condensed milk plant? The whole matter has around it an atmosphere that requires removal. It seems to me that the Minister has not been frank with the Dáil in outlining the necessity for this Vote. Does the Minister think that this £10,000 will be the sum total necessary for the taxpayer to provide to enable the factory to continue, and does he see any possibility of the factory continuing to pay, except at the cost of putting out of business a number of people engaged in toffee production in the country? The toffee manufacturers have passed a resolution which was forwarded to the Minister, I understand, in which they expressed their amazement that public money should be used to pay the debts of a private company and to put up fresh money to run a prize competition of large dimensions to still further saturate the industry and increase the private manufacturers' difficulties in successfully conducting their business and which may mean closing down of some of the businesses already struggling for existence. The toffee manufacturers tell me that their productive capacity is sufficient to supply not merely the Free State but all England as well, and here is the Government financing an additional factory, and equipping that additional factory with new machinery in order to increase its capacity.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

No.

Comment on this

The person who is now the manager of the factory had equipped it with new machinery shortly before it was purchased from him. Is not that so? The position is that, although we do not want to see action taken which would definitely impair the value of this State asset, at the same time we are not satisfied that the value of the asset is going to be maintained in this way, or that it is fair for the State to engage in this particular enterprise in this manner. If the Minister was merely concerned to keep the factory working on ordinary commercial lines, then the toffee manufacturers would have little to complain of, because if the State did not do it, some other manufacturer acquiring the factory might do so. But when we find public funds provided to enable a factory to embark on this kind of sensational prize scheme, against which it is not possible for other manufacturers to compete, a much more serious question arises. No toffee manufacturer in this State would have any reason to complain if he is defeated in fair competition with a rival concern, but he has, undoubtedly, reason to complain when that rival concern has not merely behind it State credit, but is also facilitated, out of State funds, to embark upon this unusual and very expensive method of advertising. There is attached to this question a number of points that require elucidation and which the Minister has not attempted to clarify.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Ask them and you shall get full information.

Comment on this

Very well then, I shall put in order the queries I want answered. First of all: Is the Minister satisfied that the Disposals Board managed the business of the disposal of this particular factory satisfactorily from the beginning? Does he think they could have made a more satisfactory sale in the first instance? He has now come to the conclusion that it was a mistake in policy to sell the factory as a separate concern at all. Is he satisfied with the management of the factory, in view of the fact that two previous proprietors have failed to make it pay? Does he think that the present manager, who was one of the former proprietors, is capable of making it pay, even with the aid of State assistance?

When the Minister decided to buy the factory a second time is he satisfied that he paid a fair price? Did the £1,000 represent a fair market value of the shares? Have these shares any market value? Was it not possible to get them for a penny each or even less? When they decided to buy the factory a second time does the Minister not think that it might have been better to allow some of the other purchasers in the field, who proposed to continue it as a toffee factory, to acquire it instead of the State? Does he think it possible to run that factory on a profit paying basis without further State assistance other than what it is proposed to give under this Vote? Does he think it fair that the State should subsidise this particular concern to enable it to increase its competitive powers vis-á-vis the other toffee manufacturers in the Saorstát? Is he satisfied that the State will at any time be able to dispose of the factory to a private owner at a profit? Does he know that the value will deteriorate in time at any rate because of the fact that it will be a white elephant upon our hands which we will have to keep going or shut up or sell at a loss?

These are the main queries. I may have some other inquiries to put to the Minister later. If he answers, however, I will be satisfied for the present.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

With regard to the individual mentioned, does the Deputy state he was convicted of certain offences or was prosecuted?

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

That he was convicted?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy has satisfied himself upon that?

Comment on this

After this estimate was first introduced I was hoping the reason of its suspension was that the Minister had looked into things as the result of information given to him, and that he had decided not to go on with it, but I see it was only postponed. Deputy Lemass covered most of the main points that we on this side have to put forward. I would like to ask the Minister if he is really as innocent in the affairs of this Company as he pretends to be, or if, in fact, he is not better aware of things than we are? If things are public property, surely to goodness the Minister must have cognisance of them. I am not going back as far as the original sale of this factory. The Minister gave us certain figures and, while we understand elementary arithmetic, and that two and two make four, and one and seven make eight, I have yet to learn that one and eight make nineteen. The Minister states that originally the factory was sold for £14,000. The Disposals Board accepted £14,000 from the original purchaser and, therefore, they must have had some idea of its value. We have not been told what capital value they put upon it arising out of the total purchase of the creameries. We have not been told that figure.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

And you will not be.

Comment on this

But we have been told that the original purchaser did pay back £4,000 of the purchase price, and that there was £10,000 left outstanding. The Minister has not made it clear if the Government is liable for that £10,000 if the purchaser did not pay. Was not the Government liable for £10,000 on this transaction originally?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

How?

Comment on this

Was there not a trades loan guarantee or anything of that nature?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I do not think so, but what has that got to do with this question?

Comment on this

I want to get some information from the Minister as to the exact figures. The factory has changed hands. The Minister is aware that the second owner of this creamery, the present manager, tried to float a company in England and that it was impossible for him to float it. The Minister possibly does not dispute that?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I do not burrow into these things. I have no interest, in such matters. I know the Deputy is interested in this sort of thing. I have enough to do otherwise and I have not the slightest interest in them. I am not interested in the flotation and I refuse to listen to any stories about it.

Comment on this

The Minister knows nothing about this company or the attempt to float it in England.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I will not say whether I do or not.

Comment on this

I think the Minister does know. The present manager sought to float this company in England and was not successful. The Minister spoke of the tremendous value attaching to the trade mark as a result of the quality of these toffees. The Minister stated in his opening remarks that the quality of the toffee and the trade mark were of such great value that these were the main things he wanted to preserve. I do not agree with that at all.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I do not know anything about the quality of the toffee. I do not say anything about it. Try and be accurate.

Comment on this

If that is not the meaning of the Minister's words, or if he has not said so——

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I know nothing about toffee.

Comment on this

I am surprised that this particular manager, who was a previous owner, did not buy this factory. The Government treated him very handsomely, I think, when they bought this share of the Drumm battery concern. He had his own money himself.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I know nothing about the Drumm battery or his share in it. Keep to the point.

Comment on this

There was a man who owned that factory who is now the present manager, from whom the Government purchased it, and it was not because he had not enough of money to purchase it, because he was handsomely paid when he was bought out of Celia, Ltd. My information is, he got something like £8,000 out of Celia, Ltd.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What has this got to do with it?

Comment on this

I am making the point that if the present manager, who was not long ago the owner, had such confidence in the factory that he had but to require £1,000 additional capital to assure its success, he had not any occasion to come to the Government, because he was already handsomely paid out of the concern in which the Government had taken over his interests, and he had sufficient capital to carry on himself.

Perhaps the Minister will understand it now. What I want to know is, if this manager is going to manage this concern on behalf of the Government, what control or check is there? How do we know, immediately this Vote is passed, that he will not order £5,000 worth or £10,000 worth of toffee-tins or thousands of tons of sugar, and that if the Minister eventually decides to close up the factory he will not be faced with all those liabilities which he must pay if it is a Government concern? It is all very well for us to say——

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The job of running or being manager of a Government factory is a nice one. Any irresponsible Deputy can get up and make charges against you under cover.

Comment on this

What assurance can the Minister give the House that the manager of this factory will not endanger this State with future huge liabilities?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I will ask the Deputy to nominate my managers for me, and then I will be perfectly safe.

Comment on this

I do not approve of the person——

Comment on this

It is not the Minister alone who is concerned.

Comment on this

I want to put this to the Minister: The Deputies on these benches have been given information by persons who ought to know something, not only about the toffee business and the management of it, but also of the present management of the Government factory. It is our duty to ask the Minister to give the House certain assurances that the doubts in the minds of those people who are citizens of this State are without any foundation, or else, if there is foundation for them, that the Minister is quite alive on these points. The Minister made a point that one of the reasons he was anxious to get it going was that there were 70 employees, and that if the Government closed it down these 70 would become unemployed. As against that, there are several toffee manufacturers in the State here who are in a position to produce more than there is a demand for. If this State factory is going to compete with the existing people, in what you might call subsidised competition, it is only changing around unemployment from one place to another, Possibly some of the toffee factories in our areas will close down, and you will have seventy unemployed in Dublin instead of being unemployed in Limerick. These manufacturers state that they are able to produce more toffee than there is a demand for.

I think we should be given some particulars, and I do not think the Minister should decide until we get further information. The Minister stated that in taking over the factory again he was not taking on any extra liability. There were £8,000 assets and also £8,000 liabilities. The Minister said there was additional machinery to what had been there before the Minister originally sold it. I want to know can the Minister state what amount of money has been spent on additional machinery. He has not given us that figure. How much does he value the machinery at, so that we can see the difference between the stocks and so forth?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The machinery put in was purchased at £3,000. We valued it at £1,000.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say £1,000 is a fair valuation?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am no judge, but I am well advised that it is.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

They got it at a Jewman's price.

Comment on this

A Christian remark.

Comment on this

On a point of order, may I ask, through you, that that remark be withdrawn as a slur on this House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think it is very improper, and the remark should not be made.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

If it is derogatory to the dignity of the House I do withdraw, but I do not see that it is. We have Jews and Christians in this country, and any Jew who is ashamed of being a Jew ought to shut his mouth.

Comment on this

There is an old saying about a silk purse and a sow's car. The Deputy would not understand it.

Comment on this

May I draw attention to the fact that the Deputy has not withdrawn the remark.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am quite aware of that. I think the Deputy, when asked by the Chair, should withdraw.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I do withdraw.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that he is well advised that £1,000 is a fair value put on the assets?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am satisfied that I am valuing it conservatively.

Comment on this

That means the other assets would amount to £7,000. We do not know what they consist of. We do not know what those stocks consist of, or what proportion of them are new, and if there are book debts.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I will give you the figures. There are £3,665 debts after £2,000 have been written off. Stocks are valued at £3,415 after a very big sum has been written off. I am satisfied that that is more than conservative. That is £7,000. There are definite assets of a couple of thousand pounds more. There is stock in trade, £648.

Comment on this

The Minister did not give us these figures before, and I am sure he will agree that we are entitled to have them.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

If I gave them all it would overload the statement. I gave them to you as you wanted them.

Comment on this

The Minister will agree that when statements are made outside this House it is only reasonable that we should have figures. I am satisfied that these figures are given here. The main point is, is the Minister satisfied that with this factory producing there will not be over-production and that no one will get hit? Is he satisfied that the present factories can cope with the present demands, and if he is prepared to say here that the present factories working cannot meet the demand, then a lot of our arguments fall to the ground? On the other hand, if he is not prepared to say that and says the existing factories can cope with the demand is it fair for this House to use State money to provide Cleeve's with money and to sound the death-knell of their competitors? As Deputy Lemass pointed out, the competition is price-cutting. There will be a price competition, and State funds are used to advertise this toffee as against existing manufacturers. If they cannot get sufficient turnover they will close down and be turned out of business.

The Minister probably does know better than I do that the protection given to Cleeve's condensed milk produced by the creamery adjacent to this toffee factory counts and that when outside factories have to buy their condensed milk they have to buy from Cleeve's, unless they import it. The protection is sufficiently high to enable Cleeve's to sell condensed milk to the existing toffee manufacturers here. That means an extra preference for Cleeve's. They can sell to their own factory at cost, and they will not have to meet the charge of something between 20/- and 30/- per ton on the toffee. That is one item of protection that these ordinary toffee manufacturers would have to contend with. It is pointed out that it is very hard for the Minister to say whether the factory is making a profit because he cannot say that Cleeve's creamery and the toffee factory are segregated.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

They are separate accounts.

Comment on this

Is the Minister quite satisfied that there is no danger of an accident happening, such as sugar that should go for the manufacture of condensed milk being charged up to the sweets?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That would be a mistake.

Comment on this

Is the Minister prepared to say that it cannot happen?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am prepared to say that there is very little risk of that happening, no more risk than there would be in any well-run factory.

Comment on this

The Minister knows that a certain quantity of condensed milk is not of sufficiently high quality to be sold as condensed milk for ordinary purposes. Therefore, one of the things the Minister is standing over will be that this milk will go free, or at a reduced price, to the toffee factory to be turned into toffee.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I agree that such milk would be sold at a price less than if it were used for its own purpose.

Comment on this

The Minister will admit that Cleeve's factory will be the first factory to get it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I would agree that there is a slight advantage there, but that is not because it is owned by the Government but because it is connected with the condensing factory.

Comment on this

I am glad that the Minister sees that point and agrees. Then, first of all, Cleeve's factory has an advantage over ordinary competitors inasmuch as it will get from time to time condensed milk at very much reduced prices.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I did not say that.

Comment on this

The Minister has admitted——

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Perhaps I would clear up the matter. Any such milk is saleable and has a market value. If there is a small quantity of it and there are two or three bidding, obviously the condensed milk factory is more likely to sell it to its own factory than to an outside factory. In that way it has a slight advantage.

Comment on this

The Minister knows that an advantage lies there. If an independent person came along to buy that factory, one of the talking points for the purpose of selling the factory would be that it is adjacent to the creamery, and that a certain raw material would be got at a reduced price.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

No, but you will get a chance in purchasing it that you would not get otherwise.

Comment on this

If a man who was bidding for it happened to have his factory in Dublin he would have to pay the freight on the milk.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Exactly.

Comment on this

Therefore, he is at a disadvantage, and this factory from time to time is going to get certain raw material at a reduced price. Then Cleeve's creamery is not going to sell to Cleeve's toffee factory milk at the same price that it will charge to an ordinary independent competitor, because Cleeve's factory is part of the creamery and it will help it to succeed. That is a second advantage. The Minister now wants to give it a third advantage, namely, that the State shall subsidise its advertising.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Does the Deputy suggest that we can work this without working capital, part of which goes to advertising?

Comment on this

I am prepared to sit down if the Minister will assure us that not one penny of that money will be used in the way indicated by Deputy Lemass.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Certainly not. It means that we must give an undertaking that we will not advertise.

Comment on this

It is not a matter of advertising; it is a matter of thousands of pounds for prize schemes.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What do you call that?

Comment on this

I call it price-cutting.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

If I could express an opinion on that, I would be outside making millions as an advertising expert, which I am not.

Comment on this

What I want to get at is this. First of all, this toffee factory is going to have certain advantages over existing independent concerns. The Minister is not prepared to say that portion of this £1,000 is not going to be used as an indirect way of price-cutting. We have no means of knowing. All we know is that this is an indirect way of price-cutting against taxpayers who are contributing to subsidise this in competition with themselves.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Will you explain how advertising is price-cutting?

Comment on this

The advertising is to be paid out of the subsidy, while an ordinary factory has to pay it out of its profits. In that way, it is price-cutting. If we pass this Estimate we are going to put ourselves in the position of standing for unfair competition. That is what it amounts to. The Minister will not give us certain guarantees about the thing, and therefore we must air these grievances from the light in which we see them. I say through the advantages Cleeve's factory is going to have while it is run by the State it is going to be in unfair competition against the ordinary toffee manufacturers. I asked the Minister before and I ask him again can he say whether the existing toffee manufacturers are or are not in a position to supply more toffee than is required in the State? It has been officially communicated to me that the ordinary toffee manufacturers, apart from Cleeve's factory, are in a position to supply more toffee than there is a demand for. In fact, there is competition to try and keep up full production in each factory. When Cleeve's come into competition either the State is going to get it in the neck or some of these other toffee manufacturers are going to be hit.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The Deputy spoke of my refusing assurances. What assurances does he want?

Comment on this

Number one, that there is no danger of any raw materials being procured by the toffee factory at prices which will be cheaper than the ordinary toffee manufacturer can secure them in the open market. Number two, that the two firms are kept completely segregated, and that no charge, whether cost of management or in respect of raw material, that would ordinarily go to the toffee factory, is to be taken, accidentally or otherwise, by the creamery. Number three, that the Minister will not stand for unfair competition by allowing this working capital to be used for advertising prize schemes against the ordinary toffee manufacturers. Will the Minister further state that in no case the goods will be sold under the cost of production, by design or even accidentally?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

How would the Deputy like to run a business on those lines? Has the Deputy ever sold under the cost of production?

Comment on this

I have, of course.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

So have we all.

Comment on this

Nobody else has the State to make up the difference.

Comment on this

What I mean is, taking things generally, there is no under cost selling by design. The Minister did not say who had the right to the name of Cleeves in England. That seems peculiar to me. Who had the right to the name in England?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Cleeves, Ltd., England.

Comment on this

Cleeves, Ltd., England. If the State has taken over Cleeves holus bolus, as we were led to believe, and if Cleeves in England are not included in it, it is a rather peculiar position. Were these people originally in Limerick?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

They were originally in Limerick.

Comment on this

Were they different people?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

They were.

Comment on this

Is there any direct or indirect connection between the present management in Limerick and these people?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

No.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think we will have to have this debate by way of speech.

Comment on this

I hope that the Minister will be prepared to say that he will look into the matter again. There would be no satisfaction, in my opinion, from the point of view of public interest, in having this estimate opposed, in our voting against it and probably in our being beaten. I would prefer to see the Minister looking into the matter and giving the toffee trade an opportunity of discussing it with him, in all fairness to them and to him. Perhaps he might then find a way to satisfy not only himself but the trade. I beg of him seriously to consider the postponement of this particular item until he has had an opportunity of discussing it with the trade concerned. He can either satisfy the persons concerned or can come back here and tell us that their objections are unreasonable and, if he can show us that they are unreasonable, we must, I suppose, be satisfied. I suppose it is impossible to have all the information which some of us would like to have, and on that account, perhaps the Minister would postpone the matter.

Comment on this

Will the Minister make sure that the toffee factory will not have to repay the Oireachtas for the advertisement given to it by this debate?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I think that the toffee factory has got a bad advertisement.

Comment on this

I hope that we will have an opportunity of speaking after the Minister has spoken. A number of questions have been raised in this issue and if we heard the Minister's reply it might shorten the discussion. I take it that after the Minister has spoken opportunity will be given to Deputies to raise further points.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

There are a few remarks which I have to make on this matter arising out of the debate to which I have listened carefully, though I regret I did not hear the first part of the Minister's statement. As I understand it, if this Vote does not go through, this concern will be closed down and a number of people thrown out of employment. We have it from one of the Fianna Fáil Deputies that it is six of one and half-dozen of the other as to whether people will be thrown out of employment in Dublin. That is a contingency. The other is a certainty. It struck me, while listening to the case which Deputy Briscoe was making, that he was making it entirely from the brief supplied to him by the people engaged in toffee manufacture.

Comment on this

Not entirely.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

His arguments seemed to be entirely in their interests. I am not prepared to accept the statement of these rival manufacturers as being entirely uninterested. I do not believe it for one moment. I have no doubt that it is their interests, and their interests alone, that they are looking to in this matter. It would be hard to blame them. I do not blame them, but I will not allow them to take me in and convince me that they are acting in the interests of the general public, in the interests of the taxpayer, and that it is only the taxpayers' interests with which they are concerned. Some of these people put their views before us, but I cannot say that we were particularly convinced by their arguments. I am rather interested in a general way in this matter owing to what transpired during the discussion. We see the representative of the Government Party here, who on most occasions would denounce State intervention, advocating it in this instance, and, on the other side, people who always advocate State intervention, people like Deputy Lemass, objecting to it in this instance. I think it will be difficult when the responsibility is thrown on them for Deputy Lemass and Deputy Briscoe to reconcile their varying points of view.

Comment on this

We are dealing with a particular case.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

It is easy to deal with generalities, but the trouble arises when you come to deal with a particular case. If we are held up, as Deputy Briscoe is, by the obstacle of unfair competition, what will the State do? It is like the Shannon scheme. All the shareholders in gas companies in Ireland immediately cry out "unfair competition." Every man who has a share in a gas company complains about State interference and the shutting out of private enterprise.

Comment on this

Before Deputy O'Connell goes too far on the wrong track, I should point out that apparently he does not know that the existing toffee manufacturers, outside Cleeve's, are subsidised by the Government through a trade loan guarantee, and, if they go out of business, we will have to make the loss good out of the taxpayers' money.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

That does not make a great deal of difference. I do not put too much credit on the statement as to what these private firms are able to do. We have heard a lot about it before, but we are beginning to learn a lesson. We heard it from the boot manufacturers and from the clothing manufacturers. They got every chance, but they have not gone very far to carry out their promises. I have no opposition to the general principle contained in the Vote, and as a practical demonstration of State intervention I am prepared to support it. I say, as between the certainty of throwing these people out of employment and the possibility of others being thrown out, because of what Deputy Lemass has stated on the evidence of rival firms, I am prepared to take the risk and prevent the certainty of people being thrown out of employment.

Comment on this

There are two questions at issue. There is the question of State intervention in this case, State activity in this particular line. There is also the question that a number of rumours have been going round and have reached the members of our Party, and also, I suppose, the members of other Parties. There appears to be something unsavoury about this whole transaction. I did not pursue investigations into it, but I think that when a situation like that occurs it is the duty of the Minister to be frank and to give all the details necessary. If time for examination is required, that time should be given before we commit ourselves to giving State aid in cases like this. That is the first point, the necessity for careful examination, so that it may be clear to all of us who are asked to vote this money that it is a bona-fide, genuine transaction, that there is necessity for it, and the grounds of such necessity should be very clearly put to us.

As far as I am able to understand, the main point and the one particularly which induces Deputy O'Connell to vote for this—I think he said that he was going to vote for this particular Estimate—is that if it is not passed it will throw men out of work. There is nobody here who, in the present condition of things, wants to see any factory, which can be kept going, closed down. There is nobody who wants to see any number added to the unemployed. When we talk of State intervention in matters of this kind, we should certainly satisfy ourselves that we are not going to cause more unemployment. We ought to examine the matter, and I say there has been no examination of it—at least, there is nothing to indicate to us that there has been examination of it. It is not that we are opposed to State intervention in cases like this, but that we are opposed to this particular project. It is not because there is a difficulty— that we are all right so long as we talk about general principles, but that we are not prepared to apply what we say when it comes to practice. This is a case where it is held that the present producers can more than supply the market. If, for instance, it was like the boot trade, where the market is not supplied from home, then I, for one, would have no hesitation in saying that if the present boot manufacturers are not able to equip themselves and will not equip themselves to supply our needs, then the State should examine the question to see whether it should not supply what should be supplied by the manufacturers. This is a different question. This is a case where there is over-production, if anything.

We are not against, and Deputy Briscoe is not against, State intervention where it is necessary for the State to come in and to build up industries where they do not exist, but here is a case where State money is going to be used in an unfair way against other competitors. We want to see very definitely before that is done that there is good reason for it, that it can be justified on the grounds that if it is not voted there will be unemployment. The safeguards that we are looking for are simply the safeguards that an ordinary individual taking over a factory, apart altogether from the question of the work, would require. If we are going to take over a factory, we cannot, simply because the resources of the community are at our back, enter into that enterprise except with the same care that a private individual taking over a factory would exercise. Every question which Deputy Briscoe asked is a question that would have been asked by any person taking over a factory and working it for himself.

There are three questions involved. There is the question of whether State intervention is justifiable. There is, secondly, the question as to whether as a commercial proposition it is right. Thirdly, there is the question as to whether there is not something behind it, as suggested, other than the mere question of keeping people employed and keeping the factory going on. These are questions which we want examined. We want the Minister to give himself an opportunity of hearing the things that we heard, to give himself an opportunity of hearing the representations from the people in the trade that have been made to us. If after that he can come here and tell us that the case that has been made is contrary to the facts and that he can prove it is wrong, then we will have no hesitation in voting for this. The suggestion that this scheme is on the same footing as the Shannon scheme is all nonsense. I do not believe that any Deputy is going to suggest that we should enter into an enterprise quite irrespective of how it is going to affect the community as a whole. In every single case the State would have to satisfy us that there were good public grounds for doing it. That is the one ground. I agree with Deputy O'Connell that there is also a question as to whether it would keep in employment people who would otherwise be unemployed. If that is the basis it is all right, but it must be proved. The suggestion is not that there will be more people employed as a result of this Vote, but that there might very well be less. The Minister has talked about efficiency here again. We had it in the case of a proposed flour tariff. Are we going to start without examining where we are going? Are we going to have the state of efficiency as demonstrated in Limerick to the detriment of people elsewhere? Are we going to have a monopoly of the toffee manufacture in the State? Suppose that this is followed up to a conclusion, and that the State puts this factory in the position that it is able to wipe out other competitors, we may have a number of people employed in Limerick, but you will have a greater number of people unemployed elsewhere.

It is said that people will benefit if there is rationalisation of industry. There is a very big question involved in the matter of rationalisation as to whether under our conditions it is going to cause unemployment or not. I suggest to Deputy O'Connell that he should move cautiously before voting for this, simply because the Minister says he is able to get 40 or 50 men employed in Limerick. I suggest to the Minister that he should march very carefully, or he will find that instead of leading towards employment he may be going in the opposite direction.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I have been told three or four times by different Deputies that the fullest information should be given in this case, and I think even Opposition Deputies will agree that I have answered every question that has arisen at the moment. A number of questions were asked by Deputy Briscoe, and he also prefaced his remarks with the suggestion that full information should be given, and I think I answered him. There is one question I have not answered. I have been asked by Deputy Lemass what were the conditions of the original tenders. He wants to know how many tenders there were, and whether one party who did not get the factory offered to pay cash down. There were only two tenders. The terms of the tenders were the same. They were to pay by instalments, but one was considerably higher than the other, and we accepted the higher tender. That is a full answer to the Deputy's question. Deputy de Valera also says that we should have full information. You have full information, and if any Deputy in this House wants any fuller information I will get it. There is one thing that I will not do—answer questions with regard to disputes between any of the parties who formerly owned this factory. I refuse absolutely to enter into or listen to any charges or counter-charges made by people who formerly owned this factory. Deputy de Valera spoke about unsavoury details and statements. These should never be mentioned in the Dáil unless, first of all, they are relevant. There is no use in trying to generate an atmosphere of suspicion, that there is something to be covered up.

Comment on this

I would point out to the Minister that we did not generate it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What other purpose could be behind this? The Deputy gets up and refers to unsavoury rumours about this, and wants to know what is behind it? All that can point only to one thing, and that is to generate an atmosphere of suspicion. There is the suggestion there that there are, perhaps, corrupt reasons for this deal. It could not mean anything else. Deputy Briscoe, and Deputy Lemass especially, threw wild charges about in regard to the present manager of the factory. These charges do not affect me as Minister for Agriculture. The character of the present manager only affects me in so far as he is a good or bad toffee maker. I propose to leave those disputes where they are now. They have got nothing whatever to do with me. I would be very much surprised if they are left where they are now by the parties interested. I refuse to discuss disputes between any of the parties who made up the company which formerly owned the factory. When I bought this Condensed Milk Company I had not a tremendous amount of experience in business. I happened to be the Minister for Agriculture and a politician. I realised that I was in a peculiar role. Wisdom dictated to me to keep all businessmen at arm's length.

So far as this company is concerned, the toffee factory, the creameries, the condensing plant, the mills, houses and all the vast property that we bought, I can say this, that I hardly have ever had an interview in my office with any person who was interested as a purchaser, prospective purchaser, buyer or seller. Everything was done through the solicitors. I kept all business men at arm's length. I will not listen to any charges which do not affect me, any charges by people who perhaps now own property which we formerly owned and re-sold. I have got absolutely nothing to do with them, and I am not going to listen to any of these charges. I have no concern with any of these persons now except in so far as they are employees of mine, and in that respect I am only concerned with their technical efficiency.

Let us drop once and for all the pretence that there is anything being hidden. I have given full detailed information with regard to this particular transaction. It will be remembered that I actually interrupted so that I could answer specific questions. I am prepared to give any more figures that are required. If I am asked for a figure which I am not prepared to give, then I will give the reasons for that. Obviously, there are certain figures which I could not give, but I want this to be made plain, that there will be no secrecy whatever. Everything ought to be known. I hope at least that my position in the matter will be understood.

Deputy de Valera tried to work himself into an anxious frame of mind on the question of rationalisation and State efficiency, and protested against that. I do not hold this factory because I have any particular business theories or because I think that the State may usefully take over factories and rationalise them. Least of all do I hold that the Department of Agriculture can run a business much more efficiently than, say, a business man or a company. If there were any members here who had any doubts in their minds as to the possible advantage of the State running industries, I am sure this debate will have succeeded in dispelling them. Just imagine me trying to run a toffee factory, condensing factory, or creamery and being subjected to the sort of criticism you get in the Dáil—if you like, rightly get in the Dáil. The two things are incompatible. Take the case of this toffee factory. Suppose that I want to sell it. Would it be easy to do it after this debate? Suppose that I wanted a new manager, would it be easy to get one after this debate? Of course not. Most people in business are timid. They are not used to making speeches; they do not like to see their names in the newspapers; they do not like to get criticism; and, above all things, they do not like to hear aspersions on their character, especially when these are made in certain places on privileged occasions. In any event, we all know that business people do not like to be criticised in that fashion.

Comment on this

But a great many of them like Government jobs.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Quite so, and that is the very thing I am pointing out. It is almost impossible—it is extremely difficult, at any rate—for a Government Department to run a business for that reason. The Deputy knows quite well that this debate will make it extremely difficult for me to run this business. I am not complaining of the debate. I suppose the normal duty of an Opposition is to oppose, and of members of every Party to speak freely. That, I take it, is the reason why statements made in the Dáil are privileged, so that everything can be elicited. But that is not the way business is run. Any business man listening to this debate must realise that it would be next to impossible to run a business if its details could be criticised in the Dáil by an Opposition in face of the person responsible for it, who must answer all questions relating to it. A certain amount of goodwill was required in order to make that big transaction, which involved the purchase of the Condensed Milk Company, including the creameries, toffee factory, etc., a success originally. We got that good-will from the country and fairly well in the Dáil up to the present, but I can see there is a change to-day.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister a question? Did he not refuse to give to a Committee of the House full details, such details as would preclude the necessity for discussing this matter openly? Did the Minister not refuse to give the information we wanted at the time the transaction was begun? Now the Minister is creating a terrible racket because things are being discussed in public when, in fact, he refused to meet people and discuss them in any other way.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What did I refuse?

Comment on this

The Minister refused to meet a Committee of the Dáil to give information and details with regard to the purchase of this business.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

In the case of the Condensed Milk Company I refused, but I am not now talking about the Condensed Milk Company. I am on the question of the re-purchase of Cleeve's factory, and I am giving full details. As I have pointed out, I have no theories in regard to the State running business. I am not anxious to continue to run this factory or to run the Condensed Milk Company. I am not in possession of it voluntarily. I am not in it in order to show that the Department of Agriculture can make toffee more efficiently than anybody else, or that it can make condensed milk more efficiently than anybody else. I have no such views. I have the factory because I must have it— by accident if you like. When I bought the Condensed Milk Company it included this factory. In order that I could buy the creameries, I had to buy the lot. I have to run this factory until I can dispose of it. I have to run the business done by the condensing plant and the toffee factory efficiently in order to keep the good-will there and until I can dispose of them.

The suggestion of Deputy de Valera, so far as it means anything, is this that we should close the toffee factory. I have spoken of the disadvantage of my running any business as Minister for Agriculture. The position at the moment is that there is a business there which consists of the condensing plant and the toffee factory. They are the same business and the two form an economic unit. Now I am asked to close the toffee factory or to sell it, and then, presumably, having put myself under the further disadvantage of getting rid of the paying end of the business to run the other business efficiently.

Comment on this

You did sell the toffee factory, in fact.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I did sell it, and I found that the purchasers were unable to pay me. I have very little experience of condensing factories, but I found it was a mistake to have sold the toffee factory, from the point of view of keeping together an economic unit. I found that the toffee factory was extremely useful to the condensed milk factory. I find that still. It is making a profit and I re-purchased it for two reasons. I did so as a business matter because I considered it the proper thing to do. This toffee factory is making a profit in the ordinary business way, after making allowances for overhead costs of production, and so on. It is making a profit in the sense that I might speak of any other business, and I find that the two make an economic unit.

Comment on this

What is the necessity for this vote of £1,000 for working capital?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am asked what is the necessity for working capital. One would think that Deputy Lemass and Deputy Briscoe had absolutely no experience of business. Do these Deputies think that you can keep any business static? If you aim at keeping a business stationary, what is going to happen? It is put to me in all innocence; we want certain undertakings that you will not advertise; that you will not charge this or that. That is put forward by people who may have no experience of business but who should know that business cannot be run in that way. I cannot aim at keeping the business where it is. No business could be run on these lines. You must keep developing or go back. This extra working capital is required for the business. If any business goes back every business man knows what will happen.

Comment on this

Is the Minister not satisfied with the profit that the business is now realising?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am.

Comment on this

Why does the Minister want to increase it by this particular method?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That is my business. I have responsibility for it, and I must keep it going. I must keep the good-will. I consider it necessary to advertise and to take the precautions that any other person would take.

Comment on this

Why is it necessary to keep this factory?

Comment on this

To keep it going.

Comment on this

It is the same as the butter tax; the vested interests are behind it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Behind what?

Comment on this

The vested interests are behind it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What are the vested interests?

Comment on this

Deputy de Valera was quite right in his contention here to-day.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I think I am entitled to know what are the vested interests. I have this unit at present. I am anxious to sell it. What I would really like to know from the Dáil is: Have I the permission of the Dáil to sell both? The sooner I can get rid of these factories the better I will like it. I have been trying to do it the whole time. I am very anxious to get rid of both factories. I know perfectly well that if Deputies woke up some morning and found that I sold both to a proprietary firm, and got a good price, there would be a scene in the Dáil. You cannot have it both ways. I am in a difficult position. I am running a business, and I am subject to the criticism of the Dáil. Either I must be allowed to run this in a business way, to advertise, and to keep what is paying, and refuse to answer foolish questions, and deal with people who are making silly charges that I have nothing to do with or I must be allowed to sell both. One thing I will not do, and that is to sell piecemeal.

Comment on this

Or sell at a loss.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

To sell what is profitable. The toffee factory is profitable in itself, and is profitabel as an adjunct to the condensing factory. It makes the condensing factory more profitable. There are other ends but people want to buy the profitable end. As guardian of the taxpayers' money I will not proceed to sell this business piecemeal, and I will not proceed to give away a valuable part of the good-will by closing part of the business, as the Deputy suggested.

Comment on this

I have not suggested any such thing.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I will not do that. If the Dáil asks me to do that then they are asking me to do what is unreasonable. I propose to do what any other business man would do. At the moment it is difficult to sell any business. You have to keep the paying ends going to make them attractive. I think I can sell this business. The condensed milk side and the toffee factory are an economic unit and I want to sell it. I have been anxious to do so for months.

Comment on this

Why did you not do so?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

It is never too late to mend. I think it should be sold, as I do not think the Government should have anything to do with these factories. Let there be no misunderstanding. I am not going to break it up, to close one part and sell another part, or to let the whole thing disintegrate and go to the devil. Let us be clear about the matter. I have a unit that I believe I can sell at a good price. Do I take it that the sense of the debate is that it should be sold?

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, when the Minister bought out Lovell and Christmas did he not buy them out for the benefit of this country? Is he now going to sell back to the foreigner probably at a loss?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

There you are. That is the glorious position I am in. I am expected to run this business in the face of most irresponsible criticism.

Comment on this

That is your responsibility.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I have to run this business, a thing I should never be at. I hope Deputy Coburn is satisfied now.

Comment on this

You stand in a different position. I am out for honesty in public affairs.

Comment on this

How did the Deputy come in here?

Comment on this

Yesterday's debate on the butter tax finishes me as regards honesty in public affairs.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I have to run this business in the face of very difficult, if you like hostile, and, in my opinion, unfair criticism. At any rate, it is criticism which no other business would stand up to, with all the details advertised to the public and the managers criticised in public. Certainly I am being put in a very difficult position, if I want to get employees. I am suffering from all these disadvantages and, in addition, any time any part of my business seriously competes with any other interests I am to close it up and to make a present of my good-will to them. I am to disintegrate the whole business and, as a result, meet with huge losses, and then be pilloried in the Dáil as inefficient. I refuse to accept that position.

Comment on this

You are the most efficient Minister for Agriculture in Europe.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I actually do not believe that myself. I want Deputies to take this question seriously, and to look at the problem as a whole, because I am seriously concerned here. I hope I have made my position clear. I refuse to disintegrate the whole business or to make losses. On the contrary, I intend to take every step that any business man would take to try to make the business a paying one. I think the business should be sold. I think there is no way out of it. If this debate has done nothing else but to show the impossibilities of the position, to give the country a certain amount of light on the whole matter, and to enable me to tackle this problem of selling the condensed milk company and the toffee factory as one unit to the highest bidder, then it will have served a useful purpose. But I will not, under any set of circumstances and for any special pleas, agree to the proposition put up by the other side that I should close this factory.

Comment on this

Nobody suggested that.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That is what it comes to. The proposition made is that the factory should not advertise.

Comment on this

That suggestion was not made.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What suggestion was made then?

Comment on this

That you are indulging in a form of advertising which is illegal in other countries and which is unfair to the people engaged in this business in this country.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What does the Deputy know, or what do I know, or what does the House know about the proper form for advertising toffee?

Comment on this

The Minister is side-stepping the point again.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am not side-stepping any point. Is not advertising a business proposition for the company? Deputy Briscoe will tell you that you are not to use a certain type of utensil in the factory, that it is unfair to somebody else. And then someone else will come along and make a suggestion that I should use Killaloe slates in the factory instead of some galvanised material. How can I or anybody else run a business along those lines?

Comment on this

That is not the point. The point is that if the Minister were to conduct an advertising campaign out of the profits of the business there would be no complaint, but in this case the Minister is using the taxpayers' money in that respect.

Comment on this

Yes; we complain of the using of State money for this purpose. That is the real point.

Comment on this