We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Supplementary Estimates. Vote 52—Agriculture.

Contributions 221–447 of 447. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I would like to make this point clear. Is the Minister going on with this prize scheme? There is no use in bringing in extraneous matters. I want the Minister in his speech to come down to the question of production in the State.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The Deputy will hear my speech under whatever arrangement I think best.

Comment on this

On what grounds did the Minister interrupt Deputy Briscoe?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Because he asked me a question, and I think I was right in answering it. The Deputy invited answers. Apparently the proposition is that I should not close the factory but that I should run it without working capital. Who is to be the judge of what working capital is required? Supposing it was an outsider bought this factory and found himself in possession of it for three months. After all debts cannot be collected instantly. Debts cannot be collected within three months. The assets cannot be turned into money in three months. Supposing such a person having possession of the factory wanted £1,000 in capital, where does he go for it? He goes to the bank for the money. Is not that a normal transaction? But suppose I own the business I go not to the bank for the working capital but I come to the Dáil for it. I am criticised for doing so. No big business can be run without a working capital of at least £1,000.

When Deputies tell me that I shall have no working capital beyond what the company earns month after month, they are merely telling me to close down the factory. All this talk is so much waste of time and pure nonsense. Let Deputies get down to the point that I am to run that factory efficiently as a business proposition or, as an alternative, that I am to sell it. I want to sell it and I warn the Dáil that I will take whatever steps I can to sell both. But when I do sell both, people should not be coming to me to ask for guarantees as to what is to be done with the factory afterwards, or what the purchasers are to do.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will justify the price.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The only thing that will concern me, if I am selling it, is what usually concerns a business man—that is, the price.

Comment on this

There is something more than that.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I think it was made clear that Deputies will have an opportunity of speaking when I am finished. There is only one thing that will concern me in the sale of this factory, and that is the price, and not what is to be done with the factory afterwards. People do not do business on other than those lines. This is quite a big business down in Limerick. It has to face very big competition from people in the trade, such as Libby's, Nestle's, and so on. You are not going to sell a factory like this to small men. It is going to be a big deal if it comes off at all, but I want to make it clear that I shall get a free hand from the Dáil in this matter. It is my view that the Dáil should say to me that the Government should not be in business except as little as possible, and I should get a free hand to sell the condenseries and toffee factory as early as I can. The only concern I should have is the concern of any business man, namely, to sell at a price that will cover what I paid for it, and as much more as I can get.

Comment on this

If the State is making a profit out of this factory, why should not the Minister continue it as a State concern?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

All I am saying is that we are making a profit at the moment on the toffee factory.

Comment on this

On the whole enterprise?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am not going to listen to the suggestions that I should run a certain part of the business and close down the other part, and that I am not to employ this man, and that I am to employ that man, and to do all these things at the behest of members of the Dáil. I could not do the thing on those lines. I hope that is now quite clear to everybody. What I am really asking for is £1,000 working capital. I propose to do with that £1,000 what am advised to do with it. I do not need to say to the House that I do not keep in touch with the details of the business. There is a certain Committee in the Department in whom I have every confidence, and the special business of this Committee is to see to these factories. They employ the managers. I am satisfied in a general way with that Committee. That is all I can do. When I speak of myself I mean then whatever arrangements that Committee makes, and for that Committee I must take full responsibility here. I want this money now for the purpose of running the factory and keeping it going efficiently.

I do not propose to close the factory and hand over their trade mark and good-will free, gratis and for nothing to the rest of the manufacturers of toffee and condensed milk in the country. I am not concerned with whether the present manufacturers of toffee in the Saorstát are able to supply the needs of the country or not. I do not know. All I am concerned with is that I have a business here which I had to repurchase as a business proposition. It was repurchased by the taxpayers' money. It is making a profit. But I am not anxious to run it. I am anxious to sell it, and my special aim in this matter is that I will endeavour to keep both businesses going as efficiently and as paying as possible while I have them and sell them as soon as possible. I am not going to inquire as to whom I am going to sell them. But if there are no people within this country who are open to buy them, then we must sell them to others. I say this, that it would be the duty of the State when making a sale to see that these factories are kept open and working. That is the only consideration that I take into account. I say off-hand as Minister for Agriculture, whose interests are, of course, other than those of a proprietor, that it would be my duty to see when I am selling that the premises were kept open, that they have the best prospects of being kept open and of being worked at full capacity. In fact, if I could part with them with a reasonable prospect that employment would be increased and that production would be increased, then that would be a very good stroke of business. I propose to take steps immediately to see whether these factories cannot be disposed of on those lines and subject to those conditions, if I can dispose of them on those lines —and I believe I can—then I will do so quickly. Meanwhile I will not for one moment listen to the suggestions that have been made that I should try to carry on without working capital, that I should consult Deputy Lemass every time I want to advertise, and consult Deputy Briscoe over something else; nor will I listen to the suggestion that I should generally disintegrate the whole business by getting rid of it portion by portion.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not consider selling the creameries back to the foreigners?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

They are sold. What is the Deputy's point?

Comment on this

The Minister bought the whole unit. He said it was an economic unit and could not be disintegrated, but he can now sell back only portion. Nobody wants to buy your creameries.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I did not speak of any economic unit.

Comment on this

What was the position of the factory when it was repurchased? What were the mortgage charges? The value of the factory was £14,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The mortgage charges were £8,000, reduced to £2,500; unsecured creditors, £5,498; secured creditors or preferential creditors, £1,794. That would come to about £10,000.

Comment on this

That does not include the £10,000 already owing?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

No.

Comment on this

That would leave the total figure at £20,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

But it must be remembered that we have the factory.

Comment on this

At the time the Minister bought the factory there were these liabilities, and, in addition, there was a sum of £10,000 owing to the Minister. That would leave £20,000 owing from a factory which the Minister agreed to sell for £14,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Yes.

Comment on this

The Minister bought the owner's right in that factory for £1,000. Was it worth £1,000?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Yes. The Deputy has the figures. What do they amount to?

Comment on this

A total of £20,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Let us say we have a factory valued at X. We had to pay £10,000, and what had we against that? We had, first of all, £4,000, which we received from the company itself. The figures I have given show our total outlay, and what have we against that? We have the factory itself; then we have £4,000, and that reduces the sum against us to £6,000. Then as against that £6,000 we have the figures which I have supplied to Deputy Briscoe. On a very conservative estimate we have £3,365 in debts and £3,415 worth of stores. You may take those figures as absolutely safe. We have new machinery which was purchased quite recently for £3,000, and it was valued at £1,000. We have other items such as stores and money in bank, and these could easily be liquidated for £2,000. In addition to all that, we have the good-will.

Comment on this

How much actual cash have you in the bank?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The amount is £78 5s. 11d. Taking these items as they stand, the bargain, from our point of view, was good. There is this much to be said, that the factory could have been purchased and closed. There was a danger that it would be purchased and closed, because it was regarded as quite an efficient factory. Whatever may have been its history when it was out of our hands, I am satisfied, from the point of view of location and equipment, that it is probably one of the best in the country, and there is every possibility that if it is run by efficient proprietors there can be more profit derived from it than from any similar factory in the country. As the result of our experience we are perfectly satisfied that the toffee factory and condensing plant should be run together or sold together.

Comment on this

Would it be incorrect to state that the Minister up to quite recently was negotiating for the sale of the toffee factory by itself and he could not get a sufficiently high bid?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That would be entirely incorrect.

Comment on this

When did the change take place in the Minister's policy? He did actually sell the factory. He has been abusing us for our suggestion, but the historical fact is that he himself sold it as a separate item altogether, apart from the condensing plant. He admits that was a mistake, but when did he discover it?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Very shortly after selling it. We bought the whole premises in 1926, and we sold the toffee factory practically immediately. We then started to work the condensed milk factory, and we found at a very early stage that it was a pity we had sold the other factory.

Comment on this

Why did you not take it back when it was in the market a second time? It changed hands after the first purchaser had finished with it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I know nothing of the circumstances under which the factory changed hands. That was a private matter between the parties concerned. They may have fallen out about it, but that had nothing to do with me. We got the factory back the moment we could do so.

Comment on this

Was not the Minister for Industry and Commerce consulted in order that the underwriters would pay off the £10,000 still owing?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I could not tell the Deputy that.

Comment on this

Does the Minister think the factory cannot now be carried on unless the State pays its debts and provides it with £1,000 working capital? When the Minister says the factory is making a profit does he mean that it will be all right when we agree to pay its debts and provide it with £1,000 free of interest?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

You are not asked to pay its debts. That is an unfair way of putting it. You have debts on the one side and assets on the other. I have pointed out that our assets are greater than our liabilities. Therefore, the taxpayer is not asked to pay its debts. The Deputy is trying to confuse the issue. So far as we are concerned, all that is required in the way of working capital is £1,000. The Deputy asks me if the factory is making profit and I say that it is.

Comment on this

Does the Minister state that the factory cannot continue to be run profitably unless this price-cutting scheme is embarked upon? Does he think it is fair to the other people engaged in this industry that the taxpayer should be called upon to subsidise this price-cutting scheme?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The Minister thinks it is impossible to run business without capital. We are entitled to sell our toffee at whatever price we consider will enable us in the long run to make a profit, and I say that we are making a profit.

Comment on this

Would it be possible to make a profit if the taxpayer did not provide the money?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

It would not be possible for the factory to continue as a paying proposition without working capital.

Comment on this

The Minister has referred to mortgage charges on the factory. Is it a fact that the present manager is a debenture holder for £2,500?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The present manager is an employee and has no other interest.

Comment on this

Who holds the debenture for £2,500?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That is paid off. That amount was formerly £8,000, but it was paid off for £2,500.

Comment on this

Who paid it off?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

We did, of course.

Comment on this

It has been paid off?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The debenture goes to people called Turner's in England.

Comment on this

Who paid it off?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

We did. That is part of the liabilities.

Comment on this

That is part of the £10,000?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

It is one of the liabilities.

Comment on this

What fixed assets did you get in exchange for that £2,500?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I have explained already, about ten times, that we got no fixed assets.

Comment on this

Did you get anything for it?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

We did.

Comment on this

What?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What I told you. As against these debts on the one side which included this £2,500 and also £5,314 we have these assets.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Did you get a receipt?

Comment on this

Wait one minute until we see what he got.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

We have sundry debtors £3,665 and stores £3,415.

Comment on this

I want to know what he actually got for this £2,500.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

The factory.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. McGilligan) Cumann na nGaedheal

I understand that a Deputy has introduced into the debate a certain allegation with regard to moneys in connection with the Drumm battery, and I should like to have some indication as to the evidence upon which the Deputy based his allegation.

Comment on this

What I said was that the present manager of this factory was the previous owner, and that if all that was necessary to make it a paying concern was £1,000, then the present manager, who was the chief owner, should have been in a position himself to finance it, because, I understand, he was handsomely paid for his share in Celia Limited.

Comment on this

Is that all you said?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Handsomely paid! Did the Deputy put a figure on it?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

What was it?

Comment on this

I said I understood he got somewhere about £8,000.

Comment on this

I asked for some evidence, and the only evidence the Deputy gives is his own understanding.

Comment on this

My information.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy give some of the sources of his information?

Comment on this

I will get it for the Minister.

Comment on this

The charge has been made publicly. Let us hear the evidence.

Comment on this

There is no charge.

Comment on this

There is.

Comment on this

Will the Minister deny that the manager was one of the directors of Celia, Limited?

Comment on this

I will answer questions when you are finished.

Comment on this

Will the Minister deny that he was paid a handsome figure, whatever it was? I may be wrong. I did not say definitely. I said I understood it was somewhere about——

Comment on this

The Deputy has the initiative in this. He has stated this. I ask him will he give some indication of the source of his information. I will answer all the questions immediately, but, before I begin to answer questions, I should say that I think it is an undesirable practice for a Deputy in an irresponsible manner simply to fling out certain statements, simply saying "I understand" or "I am informed." Could we get some indication where he got the information?

Comment on this

I say that the Minister has taken good care that the accounts of this particular transaction will not be audited. Therefore, there is no chance of anybody in this House ever knowing what became of the finances of the Drumm undertaking. The Minister knows that. I was informed by people who are interested in the Confectioners' Association——

Comment on this

Will you give us the names?

Comment on this

No, but I will get the gentleman to come here and see you personally.

Comment on this

The Deputy could not give the name in this House?

Comment on this

I do not know the name of the gentleman but I will bring the gentleman to you. What I want to say is that he either got £2,500 less or more, but he certainly got something. My argument is that he certainly got more than £1,000. If that was all that was necessary for the concern to carry on he should have had that himself. If the man is not the same man, then I am entirely wrong.

Comment on this

The Deputy's evidence is that because certain accounts have not yet been revealed he is entitled to take the evidence of a gentleman whose name he does not know; that a certain individual got paid handsomely—that is to say, £8,000, or, as an alternative, something more or less than £2,500 out of the Government. That is what the definite charge now comes to.

Comment on this

I am making no charge.

Comment on this

That is the definite statement.

Comment on this

The Minister knows that on a previous occasion in this House when that particular item was under discussion he did state that certain persons in Celia Limited were paid or bought out by the Government for a sum of money—I think it was £5,500 or £5,000. Who held the shares? Whom were they bought from? This present manager was one of the directors and a big shareholder—in fact, one of the initial promoters.

Comment on this

Of what?

Comment on this

Of the Drumm battery.

Comment on this

We have seen that what the Deputy bases this on is this sort of statement. It will be a good criterion to test the Deputy's future statements in this House. Now for the truth. Mr. Wheatley is the man in question.

Comment on this

I have not mentioned his name.

Comment on this

The Deputy is always shy about names—the names of people against whom he makes charges or who made allegations against him. It is all in the Deputy's imagination. Mr. Wheatley, the man in question, did not get one penny of Government money in connection with the Drumm battery.

Comment on this

Did he get it indirectly from Dr. Drumm?

Comment on this

I do not know, but if he did he could not have got £8,000, because Dr. Drumm did not get £8,000.

Comment on this

That settles that—and we can now get back to the Condensed Milk Company.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy make any sort of amend for the statement he made?

Comment on this

The Minister quite obviously does not want this debate to continue.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say that Mr. Wheatley got nothing?

Comment on this

From the Government—nothing.

Comment on this

From the Drumm battery?

Comment on this

He knows damned well.

Comment on this

If he likes to make that charge again, let him do it and give his evidence.

Comment on this

I will get it for him.

Comment on this

On the question of sale, the Minister threatened he is going to sell this out. He practically told us he is going to get rid of it at any price. Then he mended his hand, and I am glad he realises that as a custodian he will have to deal with it as a business man would deal with it. He was only concerned with one thing he told us, and that was the question of price. We here have our own trust to carry out, and everyone of us ought to regard ourselves in a position in a matter of this kind as a board of directors would regard themselves. We are entitled to have every bit of information asked for——

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

You got it.

Comment on this

Every bit of information about the proposed sale with which we are threatened. These creameries were bought out with public moneys; a big price was paid for them. It was done in the national interest. This condensed milk factory, we take it, is a national asset, too. Is it not?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That means nothing. Everything is a national asset, including myself.

Comment on this

The possession of this factory is an advantage to the country as a whole. It is a necessary part of the dairying economy, if I may put it that way. It is a valuable adjunct to the creameries. Is the Minister going to part with it and let it go outside the country? I say for one we ought not to allow it go outside the country, and we want at the start from this side of the House to enter a protest against selling it to any interest outside this country. Would the Minister answer this question? Has he tried to get the farmers or any of the co-operative societies into this?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What does the Deputy think?

Comment on this

I expect if he was doing his business he would.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I have been awake at night over it.

Comment on this

I want to say definitely that in connection with the carrying on of this factory it is a matter of public enterprise and that full details should be considered here. We ought not to be asked to pass any Vote in connection with it without fullest particulars being given. If we hear, for instance, that a manager is appointed about whom there is good foundation for complaint we are entitled to ask the Minister whether he ought to be satisfied by simply knowing that he is a good toffee manager. Would the Minister give the running of his own private business over to a man whose only qualification was a technical one? He would not. If he did he would be at hand himself, day in and day out, to see that the man was only working on the technical side.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I have not suggested in any way, even by implication, that I agree with any of the statements made against Mr. Wheatley. I know nothing about the man, but I do not admit that the wild and irresponsible charges made against him are correct. The man is an employee so far as I am concerned.

Comment on this

He is an employee of this House and of the country in general. Everyone of us here, as far as we are concerned, have responsibility for this. We are asked to sanction this particular transaction and to let this particular employee take charge. The Minister may not credit it, but we believe there is something in this.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

In what?

Comment on this

In the charges made.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What charges?

Comment on this

The charges referred to by Deputy Lemass.

Comment on this

And by Deputy Briscoe.

Comment on this

I made no charges.

Comment on this

As far as Deputy Briscoe's remarks are concerned, we have a perfect right if we hear of things and we believe there is a foundation for them to bring them up, and the best amend which could be given to Mr. Wheatley is the amend the Minister was given an opportunity of making.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

My honesty against dishonesty.

Comment on this

This is a question of your statement. We are not in a position to hold a judicial inquiry into all these things. We can go a certain distance and find whether they are responsible persons or not, and if they are fairly responsible we have a right, if for no other purpose than to give those who have further information an opportunity of stating whether it is so or not.

Comment on this

You have the reasonable ground of an unnamed man.

Comment on this

The Minister is able definitely to state that this is not so. He has stated that Government money was not given. That was not the point. The point suggested was that he got money out of the Drumm battery. I do not want to go into that. I simply want to state that we have a right, and that we are not in any way abusing the privileges of the House, when representations are made to us, and when we have no other way of taking them up, to bring them forward in order that they may be investigated and that we may get definite information. We are entitled to make them, and we propose to make them and to continue to make them.

Comment on this

Propose to continue to make charges on the evidence of a man whose name the Deputy confesses he does not know!

Comment on this

Suppose a group were introduced to the Deputy and that one member introduced the lot, as being representative of a certain trade, he need not know the individual names. At the same time, if the statements were made with a certain amount of responsibility——

Comment on this

The thing we were getting at was the bona fides of the individual who spoke. You cannot get at the bona fides of the individual when you do not know the individual.

Comment on this

I make the definite statement that Mr. Wheatley was a director of Celia Limited and that he did get money for his shares, whether from Dr. Drumm——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Perhaps the Deputy will sit down. I will not hear another word about this.

Comment on this

He got the money, any way.

Comment on this

Of course he did.

Comment on this

This side issue was introduced by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I only referred to it because when I was speaking of Mr. Wheatley, as manager of the toffee factory, I said there were other things which we have a responsibility for, over and above being satisfied that he was a good toffee manufacturer. The question of his character is involved. If we were sitting here as a board of directors we would require something more than merely being satisfied that he was a good toffee manufacturer. The proposition here is to make available for that management £1,000. Apart altogether from the merits of the question as to what we should do with this particular factory, on the question of management alone, we are entitled to make our protest and to have the matter investigated as to the character of the manager. That is number one. As to this threat that the Minister is going to sell to the highest bidder, wherever he comes from, I want to say that we wish at this first opportunity to enter a protest against the selling of the factory to interests outside the country. A large sum was spent in buying it, in the interests of the Irish people. I am not satisfied that the Condensed Milk Factory cannot be run as an adjunct to the creameries. I believe it should be retained as an adjunct. What we are asked to consider is this whole question of this factory. Every one of us would naturally put ourselves in the position in which the Minister puts himself. Though we might feel that we had not the immediate and direct responsibility we have indirectly the same responsibility of making up our minds as to what is the best thing to be done with the toffee factory. How far it is necessary, how far buying the factory was useful, how far it can be made profitable, how far it is fair to finance it with State money in competition against other factories, all these are big questions, and in order that we should make up our minds upon them we want the fullest possible information. The Minister ought not to feel that unfair attacks are being made upon him, that his position is being made difficult or anything of the kind. It is perfectly fair and square. We are asked to vote money and we should not vote the money without the information asked for.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What information have I withheld?

Comment on this

I was speaking of your attitude. Your attitude was that this information should not be given.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What information have I withheld?

Comment on this

You only gave it when it was dragged from you.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Nonsense! Who dragged it?

Comment on this

It had to be dragged from you by one question after another. We expected to have in the original statement the fullest possible information which would give every one of us an opportunity of forming a judgment on the proposition. The reason I intervene again at this stage is to say that we do not favour the sale of the factory to interests outside the country.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

I want to say on this Estimate that, like Deputy de Valera, we would very strongly oppose the sale of this factory to anybody outside.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Do you honestly believe I could run it in face of this sort of thing?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I am coming to that. We would oppose the sale of it to any private firm. I think that will not come as a surprise from these benches.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

You are entitled to take that view.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I want to make it clear, in view of the Minister's attempt to argue the events which have taken place as a fatal objection to State enterprise, that it is not our conception of a State enterprise that this kind of thing should go on; that, for instance, we should argue and talk and discuss here every single thing that is done by a State run enterprise. It is absolutely impossible to do it on these lines. We would be just as justified in raising debates continually here and asking the Minister for Industry and Commerce why he appointed "John Murphy" instead of "John Jones" to a particular job on the Shannon scheme. I want to say that whenever I or this Party advocated State enterprise it was not on such a basis as that, or that we should regard ourselves as being entitled to get every particular of the business. The responsibility rests on one individual only, and that is the particular Minister upon whom we put the responsibility when we voted the money.

We might as well logically go into the details, as some Deputy behind me suggested, of the proportion of sugar in the toffee. My only point in rising was that I did not want the Minister to get away with it, as he did evidently, cheered on by Deputy Good and other people, from whom such cheers might reasonably be expected, when he said he was anxious to get rid of the factory as quickly as possible, and when he said that what has taken place here to-day is an argument against every man doing what he did in the case of creameries, using State funds in a State enterprise. Certainly nobody with any common sense will agree that business could be run properly if you were to have not one meeting of shareholders but a daily meeting inquiring into how the business was run.

Comment on this

In the prize-ring people are often admired for their footwork. I congratulate the Minister for Agriculture upon his footwork in this debate. He has changed his attitude so many times that I am sure every other Deputy in the House is, like myself, uncertain as to whether he is anxious to keep this factory or whether he is anxious to sell, or whether it has any good-will at all. The Minister stressed the point that the factory was now working at a profit.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

It will not continue very long at this rate.

Comment on this

Possibly not. At any rate, we know that it has not been making a profit for long, though it has remained under the same management for quite a considerable time.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

It has been making a profit every month since we took it over.

Comment on this

I will ask the Minister to prove that in a moment.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

You will have to take my word for it.

Comment on this

The Minister stated that under an efficient manager this factory would be profitable. The present manager is a gentleman not unknown in the commercial life of this country, though a comparatively recent arrival in the country. In the period in which he has been in this country how many successful businesses has that manager been associated with?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

He was not well looked after.

Comment on this

The Minister told us that the only thing he was concerned about was to get an efficient toffeemaker. How many toffee factories has this manager been associated with, and what has been the fate of every one of them?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

You know all about him.

Comment on this

I know something about him. I know that every toffee company with which he has been associated has either gone into bankruptcy or been wound up, or has been reconstructed, or has indicated in some other way that his management was not profitable to the concern.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

It is irrelevant, but that is not so.

Comment on this

At any rate, there is one thing certain, that those people who were associated with this very efficient manager were invariably glad to part company with him. Possibly the Minister may be glad to part company with him when he has as costly an acquaintance with him as other people had. I asked the Minister at the beginning what were the charges on the factory. He said that there was a debenture for £2,500 which they had paid off. What justification was there for paying off that debenture?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

None!

Comment on this

That is precisely the point I am going to make. I am glad the Minister admits that he has given away £2,500 of public money without any justification.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Not even an asset.

Comment on this

Because you had already Receivers in, and it was yours for the taking.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

We only got the factory.

Comment on this

You had the factory. You were registered as the first debenture holder for the first £20,000.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What do you know about it?

Comment on this

I am asking you is it correct or incorrect?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am telling you we got the factory.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I think the Deputy ought to address the Chair.

Comment on this

Very well. The Creamery Disposals Board are the first debenture holders for £20,000. Is that true or is it not?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

£10,000 I am told is the figure.

Comment on this

You were registered as proprietors of £20,000, I am informed. What chance have the holders of the second debentures of getting one penny? How did they come to have an interest in the company at all? How did those people who got £2,500 out of the Exchequer of this State for nothing, come to be interested in this company at all? The present manager of this company was fortunate enough, I believe, to make a particularly safe contract with them which they failed to fulfil, a personal contract which they failed to fulfil. He took proceedings against them which they settled on these conditions that they would put £8,000 in shares into this company and take second debentures for them. That £8,000 was given to Mr. Devlin who had personally guaranteed to repay to the Creameries Board the £14,000 purchase money. Of that £8,000 he redeemed £4,000 worth of debentures. He paid approximately £3,600 of debts to the company and then cleared out, leaving the Minister for Agriculture's efficient manager in possession of the company with £400. That is the position. This efficient manager was virtually the principal proprietor of this company after Mr. Devlin cleared out, and, under his efficient management, he could not meet the charges on the first debentures of £10,000 and on the second debentures of £8,000. A company which has fixed capital assets, according to the Minister, of something like £24,000 could not make enough profit to pay £900 debenture charges, and that is the efficient manager whom we are asked to finance under the proposal which the Minister has put before the House.

I wish to emphasise this point, that if the Minister had not put this money into the company the Turner Manufacturing Company would not have got anything, but, by Mr. Wheatley's influence with the Minister, they got £2,500. That was paid to the Turner Manufacturing Company, and this is all we have of it.

The Minister said he is not going to close down this toffee factory and present the good-will to other toffee manufacturers. What value is this good-will for which we are now going to pay, not £1,000, as the Minister would like the House to believe, but in actual fact £10,000? We could get, remember, the whole of this factory to-morrow. We have already receivers in on it, and yet the Minister is asking us to spend £10,000 in order to keep alive a good-will which I contend is of no value. What are the profits which this factory has made? How long has it taken to make profits? As I indicated before, before the new arrangement was entered into by the Minister, before the factory came under the control of the receivers the factory was not even able to earn enough profit to pay its own debenture holders. If there are not profits enough to pay the debenture holders, what possible good-will could attach to this factory as a going concern? It is merely a liability. It is no asset, and, therefore, any good-will it may possess is certainly not worth £1,000.

Apart altogether from the question of good-will, I state that good-will must be related and can only be related to the possible profit to be made by the factory. The Minister has stated that the factory has made a profit. What amount has been set aside out of its profits for depreciation? What amount has been set aside and allowed for capital charges? What amount has been set aside out of these profits to cover advertising charges? As soon as we know this we will be in a position to estimate the possible value of the good-will about which the Minister talks so loudly. The Minister has said that if the factory were run by an efficient manager it would be profitable. If there is one thing that is quite clear about the history of this factory, it is that the present manager is not an efficient manager, and that the only chance the Minister has of keeping the factory going and of creating a good-will which has been destroyed would be to change the manager.

Deputy O'Connell stated that we could not turn the sessions of the Dáil into a company meeting, that we could not have the manager here and interview him, and that the only person in a position to deal with it is the Minister for Agriculture. Very well. Before we sanction the expenditure of any further money to keep going this questionable commercial concern we ought to be satisfied, first of all, that the person who is now managing it is a person who is likely to show a profit. I do not believe, even if he were the most efficient manager to be had, that he could show a profit with the moneys allocated in the way in which the Minister indicated when introducing the Estimate. We have a factory which was disposed of for £14,000. I have some recollection that this factory was originally valued much more highly than that. At any rate, the amount of the fixed capital of this factory would have something like £24,000 or £25,000, even on a minimum computation, and, in order to run that factory and put it in a position to deliver an output which would enable it to show a profit upon that capital, we are going to provide it with a working capital of £1,000, most of which has already been earmarked for advertising, a service which should be discharged out of revenue and not out of capital. Consequently, we are going to reduce the working capital of this concern from £1,000 to something very much below that figure. I would ask any business man in the House if he thought he could take over a factory of this magnitude and run it successfully with a working capital of £500, run it even for three months successfully. I see Deputy John Good smiling at the idea.

Comment on this

I was smiling at the idea of the Government trying to run any business after what I have heard this morning.

[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]

Comment on this

I agree. The idea of the Minister coming to this House and glibly telling us that approximately £9,000 was to be used to discharge the liabilities of the company and that we are going to run the factory and show a profit with a working capital of £1,000 is too ridiculous to merit a moment's consideration from any man in this House with business experience. Yet that is the proposition you are being asked seriously to vote on.

Would any of you, engaged in business enter into such a proposition upon your own personal responsibility and think that you would preserve a reputation for business sense? We think if the factory is to be continued, even in order to enable the Minister to dispose of it, that there should be a change of management. We do not believe that Mr. Wheatley's personal connection with the factory is of such a nature as will induce him to consider his position, as manager, any more than a pied-a-terre while he passes on to “fresh fields and pastures new.” He has been a bird of passage since he came to this country. He remains a bird of passage and when he gets what he hopes to get he will leave it, leaving the factory on the Minister's hands still for sale and still without any goodwill.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. McGilligan) Cumann na nGaedheal

I just want to join in this debate for the purpose of underlining a comment made a moment ago by Deputy Good, that this debate is the death knell of State intervention to any large extent in industry, either by way of trade loan guarantee or anything else—

Comment on this

It is the funeral of State trading.

Comment on this

——if operations are to be continued under the type of criticism that Deputy MacEntee has devoted himself to recently. I will take two points that have been urged in this debate. Is it to be, for instance, an instruction from one part of this House to me that if I find a company run under a trade loan guaranteed by the State and operating under a manager who has a previous record of bankruptcy that I should interfere and stop that concern from going on, or try to get rid of that manager?

Comment on this

It is a pity you did not do it in the case of——

Comment on this

We will have to apply it generally. I would like that the Deputy would consult some of his own party people with regard to a particular manager. Secondly, am I to take it further as an instruction from that part of the House that if I find any company operating under a trade loan guaranteed by the State using these moneys for advertising purposes, I am to try to stop that company? The clamour in this case is that part of this money is being used for advertising.

Comment on this

It has been said so.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

And in this very trade which is complaining about this factory there is an individual who is running on Government money who has not yet met his obligations towards the Government, and who pleaded as part of his excuse on one occasion that he had to spend a great deal of money on advertising. In fact, the Government money was linked with that advertising scheme.

Comment on this

My contention was that the Minister for Agriculture stated that he was providing £1,000 for working capital and that a considerable portion of it had already been earmarked for advertising.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Part of it, not a considerable amount.

Comment on this

Part of it, and consequently the real working capital of the company would be reduced by the amount allocated to advertising, so that the amount of working capital which, at the outset, was already too small was, after allocation, rendered much smaller still.

Comment on this

I do not know whether the Deputy's view is the view of his Party on this matter, but am I to take it that there is no objection to any part of this money voted by the State being used for advertising even though advertising will react adversely on the firms competing?

Comment on this

The objection is to the form of advertising. It is a form of price cutting. I do not think that public money should be used to enable one concern to cut prices.

Comment on this

Price cutting. We are getting to another point, the Document No. 2 of advertising. If money supplied by the State is used in a form of advertising there is price cutting and it is to be ruled out. Is the Deputy to be the arbiter in such cases?

Comment on this

It is a matter of common sense.

Comment on this

I am to take the Deputy's common sense. It is difficult to get that. It will vary with the week-end mood. It will be pro one thing and anti another from time to time. If that type of criticism is to be put up against persons and managers who are not under the control of people here as to the manner in which the money is to be used, undoubtedly the House will have to come to the conclusion to which Deputy Good has come, namely, that State trading or interference by the State must be at an end.

Comment on this

Has the Minister that complaint to make against the Shannon scheme?

Comment on this

If the Deputy goes on he must make that complaint against the Shannon scheme. The House did not make it. The Labour Party have a particular view in regard to State trading which is based on common sense, and when the Labour Party think that a concern is being run with State money they will not attempt, just for the sake of a certain amount of Party satisfaction, to put down that industry and keep people out of employment. The Deputy's Party, however, will do so.

Comment on this

The fact is that the State in this case acquired the factory by accident. It was a mere accident that in order to acquire creameries the State had to buy a toffee factory. The question whether the State should or should not engage in commercial enterprise is not going to be decided in relation to this question of toffee. That is sheer nonsense. The Minister is only making a debating point. We contend that there has been considerable mismanagement on the part of the Minister as regards toffee. He admitted it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

No.

Comment on this

Of course he did.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

No.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Has the Minister for Industry and Commerce finished?

Comment on this

The Deputy is making my point.

Comment on this

I was under the impression that the Minister was finished.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I was under the impression that the Minister was yielding to interruption.

Comment on this

I want to make a few points arising out of the Minister's reply. Our contention is that this business was mismanaged, and that the taxpayer has been involved in a loss owing to this mismanagement on the part of the Minister. If the Minister had not made an initial mistake we would not be asked to-day to vote £1,000. That is why we are anxious that the fullest information should be given to the Dáil. We have never criticised, and will never criticise, an industry subject to a trade loan guarantee until the Minister comes to the Dáil asking the taxpayer to make good that guarantee, in which case we will make sure that the Minister fulfils every obligation imposed under the Trade Loans Guarantee Act, and, if not, we will subject him to the same criticism.

Comment on this

We are horrified at the fact.

Comment on this

I intend to vote against this proposal. I am not convinced that the thing is genuine. It has, I suppose, been thought diplomatic on the part of the Government to narrow this discussion as between themselves and the Opposition. I am going to go with the Opposition, because I believe that it should not be the duty of a Government to interfere with private enterprise. I say, so far as Government intervention is concerned. "Hands off private enterprise." If this industry cannot be carried on by private enterprise I am confident that it cannot be made a success by Government intervention. I do not mind whether it is placarded throughout the country that the refusal to grant this Vote means the closing down of these works and more unemployment. I will stick to that. The whole question of creameries, condensed milk factory, and toffee factory is brimming over with suspicion, and I am confirmed in that opinion by the discussion here during the last three or four days.

I agree with Deputy de Valera and the other members of the Opposition Party that it is absolutely unfair to use public money in bolstering up an industry in competition with private firms engaged in the same industry, even though the successful carrying on of such industry by the Government might mean the closing down of other factories, thereby creating more unemployment. My chief objection to this Vote is the solicitude shown by the Minister for Agriculture in regard to certain industries in the South of Ireland as distinct from others in the northern parts of the Free State. The Minister seems to have a very soft corner in his heart for industry in the South in comparison with other industries which should also command attention from his Department. While I do not want to appear narrow-minded or desirous that industry in the South should not flourish, I must look after the industry in the northern area as well.

The Minister has shown very little consideration for the agricultural industry about the Cooley area, very little solicitude for the farmers in that district, but when it comes to a question of creameries the Minister has no hesitation in asking us to vote a large sum of money for the carrying on of that industry in the south. I do not believe that that is right. I am absolutely opposed to the Government carrying on any industry on its own. It has been sought here to draw an analogy between this business and the Shannon scheme. The latter scheme was started by the Government and is really a national scheme, whereas the industry under discussion now was initiated by private individuals, so that the Shannon scheme has no relation to the matter under discussion. Although I represent Labour, I dissociate myself from the attitude of the Labour Party as regards nationalisation, and I say: "Hands off private industry."

Comment on this

May I ask the Deputy why he did not speak in opposition to the trade loan guarantee given to the Drogheda meat factory?

Comment on this

I was not here then.

Comment on this

I am at a loss to understand the attitude on this and other economic questions of the Fianna Fáil Party, and again the attitude of Deputy Coburn. Deputy Davin anticipated me when he asked the question —did Deputy Coburn object to State interference or State help when thousands of pounds were advanced to the Drogheda meat factory.

Comment on this

And lost.

Comment on this

That, I understand, was a very bad economic proposition.

Comment on this

That was different from the actual working of the factory.

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture made it very clear that so far as this undertaking which we are discussing is concerned it is now a paying proposition, an ordinary commercial proposition. The suggestion from Fianna Fáil was that he should sell this industry piecemeal.

Comment on this

No one on the Fianna Fáil Benches suggested that.

Comment on this

It is like offering a plum to a small boy when the fruit has been eaten and nothing but a stone is left. The Minister has made it clear to me at any rate that this is a commercial proposition. He has come to the House, as he said himself, as he might go to a bank. An ordinary commercial man would go to the bank and ask for an advance of £1,000 to continue such an enterprise until such time as he is able to sell it to a group of people who are able to run the business. The only objection I see to the Minister's attitude is that he might sell this enterprise to an outside combine who might afterwards close down the factory, though he has indicated, in some way at least, that he is able to give a certain guarantee that the business will be carried on and that a certain amount of employment will be given. I am certainly at a loss to understand the attitude of Fianna Fáil in this connection. It is quite at variance with the public announcements which they have made on platforms on every Sunday for the past few months. Am I to understand, in regard to a State enterprise where undoubtedly certain profits are earned, that because these profits are earned the objection from Fianna Fáil is that the State must not cut prices while it is making a profit, and that we must leave it open for other firms to profiteer at the expense of the public?

Comment on this

Cutting prices out of taxpayers' money.

Comment on this

The Minister stated that this is a profit making concern. It is a profit making concern whether it is the taxpayers' money or other people's money. There are other people in competition with the State. It is only a temporary competition, but the Fianna Fáil Deputies object because other people in their business are not allowed to make more profits. The Fianna Fáil attitude summed up is that the State is selling at a profit. If the State is making a profit all the other people in the business are making a profit, but Fianna Fáil says: "We want private enterprise to make further profit"—in other words, to extract more money out of the consuming public in the country.

Comment on this

Is the Labour Party against profits?

Comment on this

So far, at any rate, in this enterprise the Government has made good. We do not object to State enterprise so long as it gives decent employment under fair conditions. There are two kinds of nationalisation. In this respect at any rate we have had the most acceptable form of nationalisation. We have a Department of Government which says in effect: "Here is an industry which we are prepared to carry on until such time as we can sell it as a going concern." There may be a difference of opinion between the Labour Party and the Department there, but we feel so long as it is an economic proposition the Government should carry on so that when this factory is handed over to private enterprise the Government can hand it over as an asset and a paying proposition. On the other hand, Deputy Lemass states that there are other people in the industry who want to make more profit. The profit made by the Minister for Agriculture is but the case which it is endeavoured to make for the people outside, that they should be allowed to make the plus something less. I commend the efforts of the Minister in this case. There is absolutely no case made in opposition to this vote. The Minister simply says in effect "I want £1,000 to carry on this business proposition." This House has no valid reason to refuse it.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I only just desire to say that personally I feel there should be a definite limit to State interference, but I do admit that under certain conditions you may have a Department of State carrying on business. If you have, we must have a general level of understanding, intelligence and public spirit amongst the Parties here. That is what Deputy O'Connell stated. I am willing to admit that the Labour Party have been fair from their point of view. They are quite in favour of State enterprise but realise its limitations. They realise also the necessity for a high level of understanding here. Then you have the Fianna Fáil Deputies who have been always preaching about State enterprise. I am quite satisfied from this debate—and I want to put it on record—that it is quite impossible to carry on anything in the way of State enterprise here, and I refuse to do it. It is impossible to have State interference in business or to have the State running an industry while you have the complete lack of understanding, intelligence and public spirit that has been evinced here on the opposite benches.

Deputy Anthony spoke about making a profit. I am making a profit for the moment, but I do not believe it can continue; the disadvantages are too great. I stated that I am selling this factory. This debate will make it more difficult, as far as I am concerned, to sell it, and I want to tell the House deliberately that I refuse to accept the responsibility of running this business, in the difficult times we have now and on the conditions put up to me in this House.

Comment on this

Not by us.

Comment on this

Is the Minister showing the white feather?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Not by you. I want to be quite frank with the Party opposite, but so far as I am concerned my desire is to sell this business as a whole on one condition and one condition only. That is, that the business be kept running and be developed if possible, and that at least the present labour be continually employed. I want to put that on record. Meanwhile I want to carry it on, and I ask the Dáil to give me this assistance.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 76
·
Níl 47
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?