We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Issue Out of the Central Fund. - Land Bill, 1930—Third Stage.

Contributions 1–190 of 583. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Land Bill, 1930
Enacted

No. 29 of 1930 ›

Section 1 makes applicable the Land Bond Act of 1925 to the Land Act of 1929. I do not know whether there is any necessity for it, because, looking at the Land Act of 1929, there seems to be a provision in it to make the provisions of the Land Bond Act of 1925 applicable to that Act. This whole question of the British guarantee for land purchase is one, I think, that the House might usefully look into just now. There seems to be no reason why we should mortgage the Central Fund of this State to the British Treasury to provide for a guarantee for the completion of land purchase. That is what the Act of 1925 amounts to. The credit of this State is said to be the highest in the world. It is high enough for investors at home, and our securities hold a very high place not only in London, but in New York. We are told of the vast number of investing people who are anxious to invest money in Irish stock. If that is so, it seems extraordinary that the guarantees and securities of this State which are good enough for all these investors should have objection made to them in one particular case, and that a case where, as everybody knows, there can be only one reason for the exception, and that is where the British landlords are to have their guarantee. The British landlords have done very well out of the people of this country and out of this State. The Land Act of 1923 and the Acts following it are substantially the same as the Land Bill which was drafted and agreed to in the Lloyd George Convention.

They have got as good terms as they would have got under a Home Rule Parliament or, as Lord Birkenhead said, as they would have got even from the English Parliament. They were not satisfied, however, with the guarantee of the Irish State, being as they are, enemies themselves of the Irish State, and being people who would be anxious that the Irish State should not succeed while, at the same time, they are very glad to get the good bargain which they were getting, though pretending they were not satisfied with that bargain. They had to have the English guarantee as well. The Free State Government got that guarantee. I think that the British landlords who have been bought out ought to be satisfied with the same guarantee and security as every other person who is concerned in this matter. Some people may call them Irish landlords, but they are really British landlords. The credit of the Free State is really good enough for everybody else and it ought to be good enough for them. We see no reason, therefore, for this first section at all.

Comment on this
Martin Roddy The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands and Fisheries (Mr. Roddy) Cumann na nGaedheal

I think Deputy Derrig is to a very large extent beating the air. This section does not refer at all to the present Bill. It refers to the Act of 1929, and it is merely an effort to bring the Act of 1929 into conformity with the Act of 1927 by incorporating Section 2 of the Land Bond Act of 1925. The Deputy will remember that in Section 5 of the Land Act of 1929 there was a provision made for the acquisition of certain ancillary fishing rights, which fishing rights it was necessary to obtain in order that there would be a unified control of these fishing rights, and in order to enable the Land Commission to acquire these rights it was necessary that a certain amount of Land Bonds should be issued. It is advisable that the Act of 1929 and the Act of 1927 should correspond, and that the sections relating particularly to the issue of Land Bonds should correspond, because it is quite conceivable that trouble might arise subsequently in the courts in the interpretation of these sections. It is quite possible that an agile lawyer might make it appear that the wording of the present section of the Act of 1929 relating to the issue of Land Bonds for the acquisition of these fishing rights would not mean what it was undoubtedly intended to mean. Hence the necessity arises for bringing the wording of that into conformity with the Act of 1929.

Comment on this

Would it not be time enough to do that when the lawyer had made a case? Apparently, this is a hypothetical case at the moment.

Comment on this

It has not arisen, but it may arise, and the Oireachtas must make provision for contingencies of that kind.

Comment on this

I must say that I cannot understand the case which the Parliamentary Secretary has made for this section. I do think, however, that he has made one important admission —that this section had nothing to do with what is the ostensible purpose of the Bill. This is a Vesting Bill, but now we are asked under the guise of this Vesting Bill, under cover of something that would appeal to popular imagination, to do something which whoever was responsible for the Act of 1929 thought the Dáil would not do, and that is to enter into further commitments with Great Britain in regard to Bonds issued on what are the natural resources of this country, and therefore the things upon which the people of this country have first claim. The Parliamentary Secretary, in the course of his remarks, has not attempted to deal with this fundamental issue. If this State is purchasing the natural resources of the State, purchasing, presumably, mainly from people who accept the duties and obligations of citizenship in this State, it ought not have so poor an opinion of itself as to be ready to cede to those people the right to have our commitments guaranteed by an external power. That is the fundamental issue in this matter. This section has nothing to do with the Bill. The main purpose of the Bill could be carried through without this section, and it is only put in here to secure by a side wind what could not be done here in the first instance.

Comment on this

How does the Deputy suggest that the removal of Section 1 would affect the guarantee?

Comment on this

It would at any rate leave it an open question. Its acceptance now by this House is an acceptance of the principle that the Bonds of this State before they become a marketable commodity, before they become an honourable pledge, must be guaranteed by an outside power. That is the fundamental principle here. It is an acceptance by the Parliamentary Secretary and by the Government and an acknowledgement that the imputation is well founded—that the Irish people are not prepared to pay their debts and that therefore before you can have any transactions or barter with them you must have a guarantee by an outside power. Is not that the principle behind this Bill? Is not that the principle behind the question of the guarantee which the British gave for Land Bonds, and that is the principle which the Parliamentary Secretary is now asking the House to accept? I think he ought to justify his position in the matter. We were not here when the Act of 1923 was passed, but now in 1931 we are not going to accept as binding and valid the principles that were then laid down. If the State wants to purchase the resources of these people from the citizens of this State for the use of the people of this State, then that purchase should be carried through without the interference or guarantee or sanction of any power outside this State. Under the section this principle would be violated. For that reason we are opposing it.

Comment on this

I am not at all sure that the fundamental question the Deputy suggests comes into this at all. I will assume that the question is really an issue as to whether the bonds issued by the State are a sufficiently good security. If there is such a question and if doubt arises the Deputy knows and the other Deputies on the benches opposite know why it arises. They know it arises precisely because they and people who sympathise with them in the country have raised in the minds of many people the gravest possible doubts as to whether if they were in power the obligations of this State would in fact be honoured.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Is the foundamental question at issue?

Comment on this

It is not necessary for me to speak because Deputy Law did not deal with the fundamental question.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I know he did not. I was going to prevent him from doing so. Is the fundamental question at issue at all under this section?

Comment on this

The question of guarantee is at issue. If the section does not go through I presume the question of guarantee will remain a doubtful one. The Parliamentary Secretary wants to qualify that position by definitely applying a guarantee to the bonds issued under the 1929 Act.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that the removal of this section would not affect the guarantee of Land Bonds at all. The Act of 1929 still operates. The section is introduced, as I tried to explain to the House, for the purpose of preventing litigation in future over the interpretation of two sections in two different Acts which really mean the same thing.

Comment on this

There is no doubt about it but this is to amend the 1929 Act. The 1929 Act is considered by everybody to be the most reactionary Act. that was ever passed through this House. It took from the people the ownership of land and the ownership of the rivers. The 1929 Act for the first time made it possible for the landlords to sell the rivers. This is to give an opportunity to the State of buying from the landlords the rivers which they never had before.

Comment on this

A point which might be made on this first clause is that it is unsatisfactory because here was an opportunity of reopening the issue of the guarantee. This guarantee was given for the purpose of land purchase under the Act of 1923. So far as I can gather it was not passed by any agreement.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

How does the Deputy suggest that Section 1 gives an opportunity of reopening discussion on the Act of 1923?

Comment on this

If it was satisfactorily dealt with instead of referring back to the Land Act of 1929 and carrying over the guarantee from that and from the Act of 1923 it could reopen the issue and base the credit of this Act upon Irish credit alone instead of looking for a guarantee from England. That would have opened the way to revise the terms of the Act of 1923 which Lord Birkenhead declared in the House of Lords was such an Act that the landlords in England would be delighted to get the same price for their land as the Irish landlords were getting under that Act.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

There is nothing at all in Section 1 of the Bill that would justify discussion on the prices the landlords got under the Act of 1923. The Deputy surely is aware of that.

Comment on this

This particular section is defective in this respect that it continues the present conditions. For that reason we are against it.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy cannot argue that on Section 1 of this Bill. What the Deputy is doing seems to me to be completely out of order. He is complaining that this Bill does not rescind the 1923 Act in an important principle which this Bill does not touch.

Comment on this

It is a connecting link. We are in this difficulty that there are some very valuable parts in this Bill from the point of view of the Irish tenants. There are other parts which are very objectionable. We can only fight the principles to which we object by dealing with them in those clauses where they arise. In attacking this particular section of the Bill, we must state our reasons. We see that this is a connecting link, and if this particular section were deleted it would leave in doubt the matter which we consider is at issue, and which is the best thing we can do.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Surely it would not leave the price which the landlords got in 1923 in doubt?

Comment on this

That is not the point.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

What is the point? This section refers to sub-section 2 of Section 5 of the Land Act of 1929. Would the Deputy address himself to that?

Comment on this

In a sense, the issue is a complicated one. This continues the conditions attaching to the guarantee, and I argue that because it does so the price of land arises under that guarantee. Unless a certain price had been given to the landlord that guarantee would not have been arranged.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Would the Deputy address himself to what is in this particular section about the Act of 1929?

Comment on this

It simply continues the conditions established by that Act. It is a continuing Act.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

Would the Parliamentary Secretary explain whether there are any powers taken in this Act to create Land Bonds? There is a reference here that the Land Bond Act, 1925, shall apply to Land Bonds created and issued by the Minister for Finance under the powers conferred upon him by the Act of 1929.

Comment on this

This section only refers to the Act of 1929.

Comment on this

What is the purpose of including it in the Bill? Would it not be better to introduce a simple Bill to do what the Minister proposes to do under Section 1? What is the ulterior motive?

Comment on this

The Deputy need not be in the least suspicious about any ulterior motive whatsoever.

Comment on this

He need not be, but he is.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 59
·
Níl 50
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I understood that it was only a sixpenny stamp that was required for these purchase agreements. Is it only to the stamp duty on such agreements that this section refers, or is there any other matter in contemplation? If it is a stamp duty on other documents we would like to have it made clear. There is a distinction between relieving the purchaser of his liability and relieving the vendor. The vendor has had his costs paid already, and he should not have further relief by way of stamp duty.

Comment on this

This section does not give any relief to the vendor. It is required primarily for the purpose of enabling the Land Commission to pay the stamp duty on mortgage deeds which are necessary to obtain in cases of tenancies on estates bought by the late Congested Districts Board out of their own funds. It is necessary to get the tenants to sign a deed of mortgage so that the parcel can be consolidated with their holdings. This consolidation is necessary for the purpose of preventing alienation without the consent of the Land Commission. The section applies almost exclusively to such cases. The duty is ten shillings.

Comment on this

It does not refer to documents dealing with transfer of title from the landlord?

Comment on this

It applies also to certain other documents in cases where the tenant enters into an agreement with the Land Commission to purchase for cash.

Comment on this

The whole section refers only to congested districts?

Comment on this

Yes, and it does not propose to confer any benefit on the vendor.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Parliament Secretary will explain what is the effect of sub-section (1) in connection with the words "in satisfaction of death duties"?

Comment on this

It removes the necessity for the immediate redemption of land bonds paid over by the Land Commission to the Minister for Finance in respect of death duties. Under the Land Bond Act the Minister is obliged to redeem these bonds immediately. The difference between the actual face value and the cash value of the bonds has to be made good out of the Guarantee Fund. Under this section I propose in future, if there is such difference that it will be made good out of the Land Commission Vote and will not be a drain on the ratepayers.

Comment on this

Would the Parliamentary Secretary think of extending that principle to the Guarantee Fund generally?

Comment on this

In what direction?

Comment on this

Extending that principle of relieving the ratepayers.

Comment on this

No, that is a different matter. It is outside the scope of the land code.

Comment on this

In what way is this sub-section complementary to the other?

Comment on this

It provides for setting aside moneys in that fund under the Land Act. It is purely a domestic and financial arrangement.

Comment on this

We are not quite clear in regard to sub-section 2 of this section, and we would like some explanation from the Parliamentary Secretary as to what it means.

Comment on this

I explained a few moments ago in answer to Deputy MacEntee that sub-section (2) was consequential on sub-section (1). It merely establishes machinery for setting aside in the land bond fund moneys paid into that fund by the Land Commission under this Act. This is purely a financial arrangement. It is purely administrative.

Comment on this

All moneys paid into it are automatically set aside for the redemption of bonds? That is the case under previous Acts.

Comment on this

I move:

"After the word `rate' in line 6 to insert the words `not exceeding three and one-quarter per cent.' "

I understand that in the congested areas where land was purchased the annuity was based on a rate of interest of three and a quarter per cent., and that most of the lands purchased in the congested areas were bought at that figure. In this section there is a provision that the Minister for Finance shall make regulations fixing the purchase annuity in these cases. It seems to us that it should be specifically stated in the section how exactly the purchase annuity is to be fixed. For that reason I propose to insert the words "not exceeding three and a quarter per cent." It may be argued that the Minister for Finance must have a certain amount of discretion in fixing these purchase annuities, but in the subsequent sub-section, sub-section (2) there is a reference to three and a quarter per cent. as being the price that is likely to be charged. In any case, seeing that the tenants have been paying interest in lieu of rent, even if there is a loss to the Exchequer, I think that the rate of three and a quarter per cent., which was originally fixed in the 1903 Act, and even before that, should be adhered to.

Comment on this

The rate of interest in all these cases is 3¼ per cent. I am prepared to accept the Deputy's amendment, but not in this particular form. As a matter of fact, the sub-section is worded in accordance with, I think, Section 30 of the Act of 1909. I do not propose to accept the Deputy's amendment as it is here on the Order Paper, but I will introduce an amendment drafted by myself on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Sub-section (3) states that "all moneys collected in respect of purchase annuities created under this section shall be paid into or disposed of for the benefit of the Exchequer in such manner as the Minister for Finance shall appoint by regulations made by him under this Act." What is to become of the moneys which are paid into the Exchequer by the Congested Districts Board tenants? I think that up to the present the Congested Board's estates were run on the principle of not acquiring income for the estate, but of providing employment, as far as possible, out of the moneys that accrued, keeping that simply as a reserve for future works.

Now the Minister for Finance has already grabbed a large amount of the assets of the Congested Districts Board, which amounted, I think, in all to one million pounds when that Board was brought to an end, and it is very questionable whether the Congested Districts Board areas have—in spite of the fact that the Parliamentary Secretary assures us that they have been specially treated in the improvement works which go on from year to year, when you consider that the assets of the Congested Districts Board, amounting to one million pounds, were taken over—been getting more favourable treatment or are in a better position than they were under the old régime. I think a good case can be made to show that as much money is not being spent in the Congested Districts Board areas as was the case hitherto, and I deprecate the principle that is here laid down that money, the extent of which we do not know, should be handed over to the tender mercies of the Minister for Finance as the assets of this Board were formerly handed over, without any guarantee that the money will be handed back for the purpose of productive work. We would like some assurance from the Parliamentary Secretary, as far as he is in a position to give it, that these moneys will not be utilised for other purposes, but that the Congested Districts areas will have a first claim upon them.

Comment on this

Sub-section (3) refers to moneys spent by the Congested Districts Board out of its own funds, and if the Deputy will look up the Land Commission Estimates he will see that each year these moneys come in as Appropriations-in-aid.

Comment on this

I think only a small proportion of the income comes in; the one million pounds for example never came in.

Comment on this

I am only dealing now with this sub-section.

Comment on this

I think the Parliamentary Secretary is mistaken when he says that the whole income of the former Congested Districts Board comes in. Only a certain proportion comes in and the assets have already been taken by the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is running ahead and dealing with other sections of the Bill.

Comment on this

There is another matter I would like to raise on the section and that is a matter that was raised on another point as to the policy of the Land Commission in dealing with the purchase of land in these congested areas. It was said that land was purchased at a high competitive price and that then when this old Congested Districts Board was selling it the Land Commission fixed an entirely different price, the security price, up on it which was much lower. I would like to know if the present policy of the Land Commission is to sell purchased land, purchased at a high competitive value, at a value based on the security of the land which, of course, would be much lower.

Comment on this

I do not see how that arises under this particular section. The price at which land is being purchased is not a matter which can be discussed here.

Comment on this

If I am in order I would like to ask are we to take it that improvements done in the Congested Districts areas are not subsequently recouped from the purchase annuities but are regarded as free grants.

Comment on this

Improvements are paid for in the congested districts areas by means of free grants in practically all cases.

Comment on this

This is the same principle. The moneys, funds, and land bonds accruing from the sale of lands are all paid into the Exchequer and the Minister for Finance is to have complete discretion as to the manner in which he will spend them. I think the House should press for some assurance that until land purchase is completed and the re-sale and consolidation of holdings are completed in the congested areas, this money should be set aside specially for that purpose and should not be devoted to the general relief of taxation. The Congested Districts Board people were able to buy and sell land in the West of Ireland and give considerable employment. At the same time they made it a business proposition. I think the Land Commission ought to be able to do the same and ought not to give away to the Minister for Finance in absorbing all these moneys for the benefit of the Exchequer. The people in these areas are constantly crying out for employment. We would be doing a very bad day's work if we allowed this section to pass through without having some assurance that the same policy would be maintained and that the profits made on those resales of land are not going to other purposes. If we cannot get an assurance on this section we will have to vote against it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Is not this consequential on a section already passed?

Comment on this

Yes, but it raises the general question as to the attitude of the Government towards these moneys from the congested district areas. I want some assurance that money in the first instance would be earmarked for areas in the West.

Comment on this

The section really fills a blank in the Land Law Commission Act. By Section 7 of that Act all the property of the old Congested Districts Board was transferred to the Land Commission but there was no provision made for the transfer of the assets in land of the Congested Districts Board and this section has been introduced to make provision for the disposal of these assets now. Of course the Minister for Finance is responsible for the disposal of these funds. He is responsible for the making of the regulations and the Deputy will understand that I cannot enter into any guarantee on behalf of the Minister for Finance as to how he will dispose of them.

Comment on this

The policy of the old Congested Districts Board, if they did not spend all their income, was to hold it and spend it at a later time. Now, if money is not spent it goes back to the Exchequer, and has to be kept in it. Furthermore, a large amount of assets belonging to the old Congested Districts Board have been appropriated by the Minister for Finance. I think the House should press further in this matter that the moneys should be earmarked for the Congested Districts Board areas.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact the money which is realised by the Land Commission as a result of the Congested Districts Board activities in the past, does not pass to the Minister for Finance. All this money comes in as an appropriation-in-aid of the Land Commission vote. If the Deputy will take the trouble to look up the Land Commission Estimate of last year he will find that the excess money realised on the Congested Districts Board estates came in as an appropriation-in-aid.

Comment on this

It relieves the Exchequer to that extent. If the money did not come in it would have to be provided by the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

This section extends the provisions of previous legislation with regard to the Guarantee Fund, and the appropriation of portion of the local taxation grant against the payment of land annuities to county boroughs, and so long as the principle is admitted and is the law—and there seems to be no expectation at present of revising it—it seems equitable that it should also apply to county boroughs. However, the matter of the Guarantee Fund is one that has aroused considerable discontent in the country. The British Parliament, through Mr. Balfour, introduced this Guarantee Fund in order that the British Exchequer and the British taxpayer would not, in the long run, be responsible for any defalcations of arrears due to the inability of the Irish tenant purchasers to pay. As Deputies know, a certain amount of the grant was withheld from local councils until such time as the annuities were paid. It has caused annoyance to local bodies in certain counties. In fact in a good many counties considerable sums were withheld running into many thousands of pounds.

Comment on this

That is outside the scope of this section.

Comment on this

Why? Is not the whole question of the Guarantee Fund raised here.

Comment on this

The section is confined to county boroughs and does not deal with counties.

Comment on this

Apart from the doubtful equity of making the ratepayers pay for tenants who are unable to carry out their obligations there is the fact that in some areas you have large numbers of farms derelict or under water.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

In county boroughs?

Comment on this

Yes. It is quite probable that that is so in county boroughs as well as outside them. I would like the Parliamentary Secretary to let the House know whether the Land Commission are going to moderate their policy of attempting to collect annuities and making the ratepayers suffer as well, where it is proved that the lands are flooded and that the tenants have been at a loss either for one season or over many seasons. In such cases I think the Land Commission should have some machinery to deal with the matter.

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy will realise that a discussion on the Land Commission Estimate should be raised on the Estimate and not on this section.

Comment on this

I do not see any reason why it should not be raised.

Comment on this

It is outside the scope of this section.

Comment on this

I can assure the Parliamentary Secretary that in the drafting of amendments to the Bill it was practically impossible to pass through the net which the Ceann Comhairle designed. I think Deputies who are interested in matters that arise under this section should not be met with an attempt from the Government Benches to closure them. If an attempt is made let it be made at all events from the Chair.

Comment on this

We cannot see any necessity for this section. It appears that the British Government granted a certain amount of money for the improvement of land in connection with the settlement of ex-British soldiers under the Irish Land (Provision for Sailors and Soldiers) Act, 1919. The suggestion here is that the Minister for Finance shall make regulations whereby whatever additional value is placed on the land as a result of money granted by the British Government, he shall arrange to pay them back an equitable share of whatever they have allocated and spent to improve the land. We cannot see any necessity for this section. The ex-British sailors and soldiers in the Free State have a big claim against the British Government. I do not say that anybody will contend that they have got more than they were entitled to get from the British Government. We are definitely asked now to make arrangements for paying back to this wealthy Government a certain sum of money that it allocated; not for our benefit, not for the common good, but for the benefit of its own ex-soldiers and sailors. I do not believe for a moment that the British Government intends to press this question, or that it wants to get this money back. It is simply the extraordinary financial generosity on the part of the Government in office that has so often been manifested. As a matter of fact, the British Government has not carried out its guarantee to these ex-soldiers and sailors at all.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not arise now, surely?

Comment on this

The general question arises whether the British Government should be repaid, and it calls for consideration.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Not on this section.

Comment on this

In any case we do not see any necessity for this section. We do not see that the British Government is likely to press for repayment of money spent on the welfare of ex-soldiers and sailors. If the section is passed there will have to be a roundabout procedure involving negotiations with Britain in winding-up the whole thing. You will have to collect this enhanced price from the ex-soldiers and sailors. We are against that.

Comment on this

I take it that the Parliamentary Secretary is aware of the position that existed prior to the acquisition of the lands for the ex-soldiers. A good many of the estates were held by the Land Commission from 1909, and certainly up to the time the war started. At that time the Land Commission made a considerable profit, and not only that, but I know estates where they were not satisfied to deal with the land, but sold the timber. They charged the ex-soldiers at the rate of £2 an acre for the land. I think the Land Commission was recompensed. The British Government left the ex-soldiers in such a plight that they were not able to pay, and I do not suppose the succeeding tenants will pay.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 60
·
Níl 52
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 3:

In sub-section (1), before the word "publish" line 11, to insert the words, "but not later than three months from the passing of this Act or three months from the date of receipt of the particulars hereinafter referred to whichever may be the later date."

The Parliamentary Secretary said on the Second Reading that he expected that all preparations would have been made for publication within three months. I understand that the machinery is ready to carry out this portion of the Bill. What we want is a definite limitation as to time. We suggest that it would not be too much to ask the Land Commission for a guarantee that the Appointed Day will be fixed not later than three months from the passing of the Act, or three months from the date of receipt of particulars. The particulars are in hand in the vast majority of cases, and the Land Commission have a reasonable alternative. If the particulars are not in hand, and they are not able to proceed with the vesting, then they will not be asked to do it in that case, but will get three months from the date on which they actually receive the particulars.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

It is obvious that this amendment could not take effect, even if passed. The fixing of three months as a definite date is quite impracticable, as was explained on the Second Reading, and as, I think, was anticipated by Deputy Derrig when introducing his Bill in 1929. In that case, with regard to non-judicial holdings at any rate, I think he fixed 1st June, 1932, as a limit. This amendment is a big advance on his own Bill, and I think it is impracticable, inasmuch as it could not be done. If the Parliamentary Secretary is able to carry out his guarantee given on the Second Reading, that before next year this will be finished, I think we might reasonably accept that.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

This amendment merely provides that within three months from the passing of the Act the Land Commission will publish lists of tenanted land referred to in the section. Allegations have been made from time to time about the sloth of this Department. If the allegations that we have heard are well-founded it might perhaps afford an explanation for the speech we have just listened to. But if there is any alacrity in this Department, Deputies, I am sure, would like to hear why a period of three months is not sufficient to draw up the lists of tenanted holdings. It is not enough to say that the landlord or land agent may not have done his part. Deputy Derrig has anticipated such an objection as that by framing his amendment so that the three months will run only from the receipt of the particulars in cases where they are not furnished already. Of course "particulars" there means full and complete and accurate particulars. This three months period will only run from the time when the Minister has received particulars which in every respect are in order. He is then asked to publish the lists of tenanted holdings.

Allusion has been made to Deputy Derrig's Bill of 1929. The Deputy who made that observation must either have refrained from reading that Bill or omitted to read this amendment. The amendment merely asks that the lists be published. The Land Commission are given plenty of time to provide for the vesting of the holdings. Nobody wants to rush them about that. They can take their own time and decide when they will vest the holdings in the particular tenant. Some of us are familiar with these particulars. They are furnished in a form which the Land Commission prescribes —a form designed, I am sure, to make it very easy for them to index these cases and take whatever office or routine steps are necessary before publishing these lists.

Anyone in this House engaged in his own business or profession may have from time to time to draw up lists far more intricate, sometimes far more extensive even than the lists contemplated here. If any man in business in a large way, whether he be a wholesaler or a manufacturer, were to be told by his subordinates, as this country is told by its subordinates, that a period of three months is too short a time to prepare this list of pending cases, I am sure he would be very much surprised. And I am sure he would take steps of a nature akin to what the country will be forced to take if the attitude is to be that as outlined by Deputy Gorey. The country will have to find some other subordinates who possibly will be a little more alert and do things a little more quickly. Perhaps the phrase "sack the lot" that we heard in another connection, some time ago, may be the only alternative to the acceptance of this very reasonable amendment that Deputy Derrig has tabled here.

Comment on this

In this amendment Deputy Derrig evidently only intends to deal with tenants coming under the Act of 1923. He apparently left out of consideration altogether the allottees of untenanted land and the tenants on the Congested Districts Board estates just as he did in his Land Bill of 1929. The Deputy, I think, realises perfectly well it would be impossible for the Land Commission to publish all the lists in three months after this Bill becomes law. He must remember that the Land Commission has to publish lists of 100,000 tenants, perhaps 110,000 tenants would be nearer the mark. Any Deputy will realise that it would be quite impossible to publish this list of tenancies in three months, and to check the particulars of rentals, area, and other matters that are necessary to be checked before the lists of vested holdings are published. I could not accept the amendment. I did state, when concluding the Second Reading debate on the Bill, that I hoped to have the lists of vested holdings not only under the 1923 Act, but Congested Districts Board holdings as well published within 12 months of the date this Bill becomes law, but I could not go beyond that.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

Are we to understand that it is only now in 1931 that the Land Commission are commencing to check particulars? The Statute— speaking from memory—became law in August, 1923. Soon after that particulars commenced to pour in. For 7½ years this process of checking presumably has been going on; it is not now the Land Commission are waking up to the checking. The Parliamentary Secretary referred to the Congested Districts Board cases. Probably he will be kind enough to elaborate that a little more. Is he referring to the lands acquired by the Congested Districts Board under the Statutes of 1903 and 1909? If he is, surely time enough has elapsed to tabulate these and have them in order. If the House is going to reject this amendment of Deputy Derrig, it is well it should understand what it is doing. Is it going to reject it on the representation that within three months these hundred thousand cases, or whatever the number is, cannot be checked and dealt with? If so, in the absence of some explanations from the Parliamentary Secretary, it would seem to follow that during the seven years no checking was done in the ordinary way. We would expect that vast numbers of these would have been segregated and examined, and that the whole material would be ready to shoot into the "Dublin Gazette."

Comment on this

Further to what Deputy Geoghegan has said I notice in column 312 on the Parliamentary Secretary's speech on the Second Reading of the Bill on the 19th February, that he said.

"With regard to the cases under the 1923 Act, I can assure the Deputy that we hope to fix an Appointed Day in the vast majority of them within three months of the passing of this Bill.

Therefore he states specifically that not alone will it be possible, but that it will be really fixed within three months of the passing of the Bill in the vast majority of cases. In this particular amendment we are not asking for the fixing of the Appointed Day. We are asking for the publication of the lists. With regard to the references which Deputy Gorey and the Parliamentary Secretary made to the famous Bill which I introduced, I want to say that it is a pity that they on that occasion did not give us their experienced views on the matter. They were then strangely silent. Their anxiety then was that the Bill should not get a chance. On this occasion, however, they are going to make up for their lack of vocal power then. I submit that this is a very reasonable amendment. Deputy Gorey has allowed himself to get to the position that there must be no limitation put on the operations of the Land Commission. It does not matter how easy the limitation may be. Deputy Gorey can be put up to make a case that there should be no attempt whatever to put limitations on the operations of the Land Commission.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I did not say that.

Comment on this

That however is the position. There is no provision about twelve months. For that we have only what the Parliamentary Secretary states. The Minister for Agriculture said a number of years ago that the operations under the Act of 1923 would not take more than five years. We know that that undertaking has not been kept. As long as a thing is not definitely stated in the Bill we cannot take any cognisance of it. We want to make things definitely clear now and if Deputies here are going to vote against the amendment they are doing a foolish thing. They are only giving the Land Commission a loophole for escaping from the responsibilities which the House is anxious to place upon them.

Comment on this

It is perfectly evident that neither Deputy Geoghegan nor Deputy Derrig understand the section to which they have tabled this amendment. Deputy Derrig asked why not publish a list and fix the Appointed Day at the same time. If the Deputy had studied the section carefully he would find that that had been already provided for.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I wish to state that I did not make the suggestion that the Appointed Day should not be published. I said that in this particular amendment we are not dealing with the fixing of the Appointed Day; we are only dealing with the publication of the lists.

Comment on this

In any event, the Deputy's amendment only refers to the tenants who purchased under the Act of 1923.

Comment on this

It refers to all tenants.

Comment on this

It does not. It deals only with tenants under the 1923 Act, leaving out of account tenants on the Congested Districts Board estates. So I assume that if this amendment were passed the Land Commission would be free to deal with the Congested Districts Board tenants at any time they liked.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

That makes it all the easier for the Parliamentary Secretary to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I am prepared to give the Deputy credit for good intentions, and that he does mean to include the Congested Districts Board tenants. The Land Commission, at the moment, are preparing these lists, and there is no doubt about it that within a short period after this Bill becomes law it will be possible to publish quite a number of them, but it would be quite impossible to do it within three months from the date of the passing of this Act.

It is a comparatively easy matter to list the tenants who bought under the 1923 Act, but it is much more difficult in the case of the Congested Districts Board estates. There is very little information available. It is specifically stated in the Bill that certain information must be given in respect of each holding; consequently it will take more time to ascertain the particulars required in these cases. I am hopeful that within twelve months of the passing of the Bill that these lists will be published in respect of the 1923 holdings, and also in respect of the Congested Districts Board holdings.

Comment on this

Why does not the Parliamentary Secretary himself fix the date in the Bill—why does he not state at what date these are to be prepared?

Comment on this

I cannot go further than I went when replying on the Second Reading of this Bill.

Comment on this

Are we to take it that you might be as near to your guess of one year as the Minister for Agriculture was when he said it would take five years?

Comment on this

I have stated definitely and specifically that I hope every holding will be vested within a year from the passing of this Bill. Beyond that I cannot go.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

Does the Parliamentary Secretary say that the Congested Districts cases are within this amendment at all?

Comment on this

I do not. They could not be within the amendment. This is an amendment to Section 9 and Section 9 does not deal with the C.D.B. cases at all.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

Will the Parliamentary Secretary say then how the C.D.B. cases could prevent his complying with this amendment? As I understand the Parliamentary Secretary's observation, he explains his inability to carry out the terms of this amendment by stating that he has not got sufficient material in the C.D.B. cases. The amendment is not concerned with C.D.B. cases at all.

Comment on this

It was intended to be. The Deputy, not understanding the section, made a mistake in drafting the amendment.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

I suggest that the amendment is gathered from the wording of the clause.

Comment on this

Did not the President state that the lands would be vested by January next?

Comment on this

I think the pious wish of the Parliamentary Secretary cannot be given much heed to. He is certainly making excuses, because he assumes that certain types of cases that were meant to come under this amendment are not under it. Therefore, he could not accept it even though it referred to tenants that he himself thinks could be brought in under this amendment, that is, non-vested tenants. Are we to take it that it is only now they are examining these cases? Surely his argument is worthy of less consideration when we realise that since the passing of the 1923 Act very definite promises and undertakings were given by the Minister for Agriculture as regards vesting. He fixed the period of five years which seems very reasonable from the Minister's point of view. The Parliamentary Secretary now hopes that within one year he will be able to have the vesting done. But he gives no definite undertaking either.

The introduction of this Bill is in itself an admission by the Government of the very grave wrong that has been inflicted on non-vested tenants and, surely, it is time for us in this House to tie the string very tight as regards the Land Commission's power to have further delays in vesting. Surely it is our experience that, as far as red tape and the tying of the strings are concerned, the Land Commission is one of the Departments which stands out ahead of all the others. Now that we have the power to limit the Land Commission's inertia, to some extent, I think we should tie it down to some definite undertakings. If the Parliamentary Secretary can give a definite undertaking that within a certain period the work will be done we need not take such a serious view of it, but the pious wish is expressed that it may be done within a year, after many promises having been given within the past 5 years and it is not yet done. I think it is right to put it to a division and that Deputies who stated from time to time that they are very anxious to hurry up the vesting of holdings would be given an opportunity of showing where they stand. No attempt has been made by the Parliamentary Secretary to make a case against this amendment. On that account, I think we should divide on this matter.

Comment on this

I think if the Parliamentary Secretary is honest in this Bill and if it is going to have the end which it was stated in this House it was going to have, he will accept Deputy Derrig's amendment. I remember hearing Deputy Gorey here on a famous occasion in 1929 making practically the same statement that Deputy Derrig made in regard to the vesting of these holdings. Of course it suits him to turn inside out every second day. If this Bill is going to have the effect which the Minister says it is going to have, namely, the early vesting of holdings I do not see any reason why he should not accept the amendment. If the Parliamentary Secretary's "I hope" is like the "I hopes" of the Minister for Justice——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister for Justice has nothing to do with this Bill.

Comment on this

I am dealing with the statement made by the Parliamentary Secretary. I take it the "I hope" from the Parliamentary Secretary is the same as the "I hopes" from the Minister for Justice, and it will mean that this will be done under the Kathleen Mavourneen system: "it may be for years and it may be for ever." I think if the Parliamentary Secretary is honest in stating that this Bill is going to speed up the vesting of holdings he should accept Deputy Derrig's amendment.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 51
·
Níl 63
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I move:

In sub-section (1), line 11, after the word "publish" to insert the words "in the prescribed manner."

This is merely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move:

In sub-section (1), line 17, to delete the words "previous to."

I think that if the Land Commission nominated the appointed day prior to the date of publication it might lead to a lot of abuse. If these two words were deleted it might make it simpler.

Comment on this

The appointed day will be some day in or about the day the list is published. It might be convenient for the Land Commission to fix the appointed day on the gale day which might fall on the day before the list is published. The date of the publication of the list will depend on the date of publication of Irish Oifigiúil.

Comment on this

Would the Land Commission not be aware of that?

Comment on this

Hence the section is worded as it is.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this

I move:

In sub-section (1), line 17, to delete all words after the words "previous to" and including the word "list" in line 18 and substitute the words "but not later than the 9th August, 1928."

The Parliamentary Secretary has just admitted that the Land Commission may, in fact, fix the appointed day previous to the date of publication of the list. They have the power to do so. Is there any reason why they should not do it? Is there any reason why they should not, as far as possible, endeavour in fixing the appointed day to give restitution to the tenants for the moneys they paid and to make those moneys go in redemption of the purchase moneys, not from a date some time this year or next year, but from a date, say, in 1928? Some of these tenants who are not yet vested were actually bought out under the 1923 Act. They are not yet vested and are now in the position, even though partial remedy is being afforded and partial restitution made to them, of being at the loss of the moneys which they paid in lieu of rent over that period.

As there was a definite promise made to them that all land would be vested within five years and that the payment period in lieu of rent would not extend more than five years, we think that as the machinery is provided in this Bill for fixing the appointed day previous to the publication of the list, it ought to be fixed, say, five years after the passing of the 1923 Act. At that date, as I understand it, if the intention of the legislature were carried out, the land would have been vested. As I pointed out in my speech on the Second Reading, the tenants in the condition in which they find themselves, with the general depression and fall in prices, would, if they were still paying rent to the landlords, seek for alleviations. They are not getting alleviations under the Bill. They are simply getting what they are entitled to and what the law allows them.

Some effort is made to improve the machinery but the definite promise that has been made that benefits would accrue to the tenants within five years is not being carried out. There is not any time limit. Just as in the case of the previous amendment, the Parliamentary Secretary will probably say that this is impossible, that the date cannot be fixed. The machinery is there and the admission has been made that you can fix the date previous to the present date. As has been done in Northern Ireland, we think that vesting might in all cases be made retrospective and that the appointed day be fixed five years after the passing of the 1923 Act. The fact that the tenants are not vested up to the present and that we are seeking to fix the appointed day in August, 1928, means that they shall enjoy the privileges from that date. The Government can, if they wish, by accepting the amendment say to these tenants: "Five years ago we gave you a reduction that was of some advantage but, nevertheless, seeing the large numbers that were bought out, even before the 1923 Act was passed, we think that we should make more restitution and therefore we will fix a date in 1928 and to that extent make a sacrifice." Since the machinery is there and since the Parliamentary Secretary has admitted that it allows for retrospective vesting, although he wants to limit it to the gale day preceding publication, we think that the appointed day should be fixed in 1928.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I would be very glad if effect could be given to this, but the fact is that the landlord has got this money in lieu of rent. The money has been paid out and, in my view, the only way to do it is through the State if they are satisfied. Personally, I do not object, and I do not think that anyone else could object. The money has been paid, and there is no use in trying to get it back, because I do not think that you could legally do so. As I say, the only way of doing this is through the State.

Comment on this

Has not the State and the landlord benefited by the delay in vesting? If that is so, I do not see any reason why recoupment could not be made to the tenants at the expense of both the parties who have gained. This date in 1928 was fixed as five years from the passing of the 1923 Act. That was the date, I understand, which was given at the time as marking the end of the period which would have been necessary, in what was regarded as the normal course, for vesting at that time Five years would appear therefore to be a reasonable time for the State to carry out the obligations placed upon it in the House at the time. It seems to us that restitution should be made to those who have been compelled for a larger period to pay a sum over and above that which they would have to pay if vesting had taken place. Our proposition is perfectly clear, and the further proposition in connection with it would be that restitution should be made.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

By whom?

Comment on this

By the State on the one hand and the landlord on the other. Both of them have gained by this delay and the unfortunate tenant has suffered. We think it is only right that portion of the amount that the landlord gains and of the amount that the State gains should be given back. That can be done. The landlord is not completely paid out, and the State to my mind is under an obligation to pay this back, to return the money it has gained over and above what the State would have got if vesting had taken place at the end of the five year period.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

To a certain extent what Deputy de Valera states is true. The State agreed to add to the purchase price what the tenant had to pay. If it could be said to that extent both gained——

Comment on this

That is what I mean —what the State has not paid out it has gained.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I have no objection if the State agrees to pay that.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

That liability is there still.

Comment on this

I could understand the opposition to this amendment in the British Parliament where there would be a landlord majority in opposition, but I cannot understand it here. We thought that it would be enough to point out the injustice that was probably overlooked by the Parliamentary Secretary, to have the matter remedied at once under this Bill. It has been admitted here repeatedly by the Parliamentary Secretary during the three years that we have been here, when he was challenged on the question of vesting, that the reason for the delay in vesting thousands of tenants was that the titles were not clear. It was not the fault of the tenants that the titles were not clear. It was the fault of the landlord. Why should the tenant have to pay because of that?

Comment on this

The title did not delay vesting.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon. If I had the official debates here I could quote your statements to that effect.

Comment on this

The investigation of title has nothing to do with vesting.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact there were cases mentioned by members of our Party where tenants were 17½ years purchased, and where they were not yet vested. Surely these tenants deserve from any kind of national Government to be given restitution, for it is only restitution. This is only going a small way to meet the restitution to which they are entitled. As a matter of fact, all the Land Bills, we might say from 1923 onwards, dealt with the die-hard landlord who would not sell under any voluntary system until he was caught by the neck and compelled to give in. There has been too much leniency shown to that class here. We are only looking for mere justice. It is in the power of the Land Commission who are getting rents to give this abatement to the tenants. It is in their power to vest back. Why should the tenant have to suffer for delays either on the part of the Land Commission or because of bad title by the landlord? The tenant is not to blame in either of these cases. The injustice can be met by dividing it between the landlord and the Land Commission. I do not care on what Department the blame is put, but the blame is there. I do not see for the life of me why any national Government would not give restitution in these cases when it is in their power to do so. I cannot understand the action of the Parliamentary Secretary in refusing to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

The money in question really amounts to a very small sum so far as the landlord is concerned, because it is only a matter of one-quarter per cent. of the annuities that would go to the Sinking Fund, and it would only go back for three years. Therefore the landlord would not lose very greatly by the transaction. On the other hand, the tenant would get a certain amount of benefit in the reduction of the annuity by 10 per cent. Obviously the State would get an opportunity of retaining a certain amount of money under Section 20, further on. The purpose of Amendment 46 is to complete this amendment. I would draw the Minister's attention to the fact that Amendment 46 is consequential upon and is implementing this amendment by which it would be in the power of the Land Commission to use certain moneys retained by them and which Section 20 empowers them to retain for the relief of the landlord.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Would that suggestion stand in any law court? I am not arguing the question, but this House has passed an Act specifying that certain percentages are to be paid to the landlord in lieu of rent. That has been done under an Act of Parliament, and any Act passed now cannot nullify it. The money has been paid, and in my judgment cannot be recovered. The only way the money could be paid now would be by the State. I am not a lawyer. Perhaps the question will be answered by Deputy Geoghegan.

Comment on this

The amendment proposes to make retrospective the appointed day to the 9th August, 1928, and I assume it is intended that the State should pay the difference between the payments in lieu of rents and the annuities fixed under this Bill.

Comment on this

Not the State alone.

Comment on this

I understood the Deputy to say that.

Comment on this

My suggestion was that both parties gained—the landlord by the delay in vesting and the State by not having had to pay what it would have had to pay if vesting had taken place. It is only fair that if restitution is to be made it should be made by the parties who have gained owing to what we take to be unreasonable delay after five years.

Comment on this

The Deputy must remember that immediately on the passing of the Act of 1923 the rents of the landlord were reduced by 25 per cent., and in addition that they are still paying 7 per cent. on their charges. That is not an unusual rate of interest on mortgages and incumbrances. Actually the landlords are getting no advantage and are not gaining to any extent at all. The question of delay under the 1923 Act has been raised, and I think Deputy Derrig also referred to an earlier Act. We can leave the earlier Act out of account as there are scarcely any cases to be vested under it. I deny that there has been any delay in the vesting of land. The delay was inherent in the Act of 1923, and hence the tenants were given very substantial concessions, viz., a 25 per cent reduction in rents. At the time no one could have anticipated the difficulties that had to be contended with before holdings could be vested in the tenants. It was impossible for any Minister to foresee what time would elapse from the passing of the Act until holdings were vested. Deputies will remember that in order to remove some of the difficulties in vesting, a special section was introduced in the Act of 1927 to enable compounded arrears of rent to be added to the purchase money. Since the Act of 1927 became law the rate of vesting has increased considerably. The proposal now is that the difference between the payment in lieu of rent and the annuities will be borne partly by the State and the landlords. I assume that the money is to come out of taxation. In any event it means increased taxation. Deputies must remember that the landlords were not the only claimants to the purchase moneys of the estates. There were other claimants besides the vendors some of whom were very poor and it would have been an injustice on these claimants if they were to be deprived of portion of the income which they derived from these lands. When Deputy Derrig introduced his Land Bill in 1929 he did not make the appointed day retrospective. He fixed the appointed day for non-judicial holdings some day in June, 1932.

Comment on this

I would ask to be allowed to contradict that statement. The Parliamentary Secretary has made it on several occasions. What the Bill stated was "not later than". It did not fix the appointed day at all.

Comment on this

For the other tenants the time was December, 1929. It would be interesting to know what has happened since 1929 to force the Deputy to the conclusion that the appointed day should be made retrospective.

Comment on this

That was the whole object of the Bill, to end the injustice that was taking place.

Comment on this

But the appointed day was fixed considerably ahead—three years in the case of judicial tenants.

Comment on this

I would refresh the Parliamentary Secretary's memory by directing his attention to a reply he gave me on the adjournment on the 28th February, 1929, dealing with the question of the vesting of holdings.

"It is impossible to rush unduly the vesting of lands. There is a great deal of legal procedure to be gone through. The Land Commission in dealing with this question of vesting must be sure there is a clear and secure title to the tenant when vesting. If the proceedings were unduly rushed that would only result in litigation costs to the tenants."

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

To the tenants?

Comment on this

"It is to the credit of the Land Commission that it has never been known in its history, once it has vested a title in a holding to a tenant, to have that title upset. I have never heard of such a case. The procedure is very elaborate. This question has been examined over and over again with a view to seeing would it be possible to simplify it in any way. I have in the past three or four months gone into this to see if simplifications were possible and I have found it cannot be simplified, if you want to make certain that, once a tenant's holding is vested in him, there is a clear and secure title."

Comment on this

I did not say a word about the landlord or the vendor.

Comment on this

You said that the reason for the delay in vesting was that you had to make sure of the title.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

The tenants?

Comment on this

He could not simplify it in 1929.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

The Deputy does not understand the difference between the landlord's and the tenant's title.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

Surely it is not suggested that the Land Commission investigates the title in the tenant's interest. The only title to be investigated is the landlord's.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Read the question and answer.

Comment on this

"The Land Commission in dealing with this question of vesting must be sure there is a clear and secure title to the tenant when vesting."

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

That is the point. That will penetrate the Deputies' heads towards morning.

Comment on this

It penetrated yours long ago just the same as the Bills you brought over to London.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Let us keep to the Bill.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary has again referred to the Bill I introduced. I pointed out before, and I will repeat it now that his statement was not correct that the appointed day was fixed in the Bill. The Bill stated that the appointed day shall be fixed "not later than". If the Bill was passed the Land Commission could have fixed it in 1928 or 1929.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not deny that he mentioned a date in his Bill.

Comment on this

I do not happen to have a copy of the Bill here now. You do not criticise it except when you are outside the House. I did not mention the date suggested. The Parliamentary Secretary has suggested that this amendment which simply looks for fair play for the tenants is going to secure something at the expense of the landlords, and he has made a woebegone appeal for the mortgagees who have to live out of these estates. There is provision in other parts of the Bill whereby the mortgage charges are fixed at 4½ per cent. Nobody suggests that the landlords are going to live on air. The Land Commission have already taken good care to look after them and they have fixed the mortgage charges at a flat rate of 4½ per cent. They are going to pay them pending distribution of the purchase money the dividends on the Bonds so that pending the retention of moneys in the Guarantee Deposit set up under this Bill (the retention of ten per cent. of the purchase money to clear up subsequent adjustments) the landlords will not suffer because they are being paid dividends on the purchase money. Taking all the facts into consideration, and seeing that the mortgage charges which the Parliamentary Secretary referred to at 7 per cent. are being reduced to a flat rate of 4½ per cent., I cannot see that the landlords are going to suffer. I must call the attention of the House to the fact that the Act which this Bill amends was not better as regards Irish tenant purchasers than any Act that went before it. I would like to call attention to the words Deputy Little referred to and which were used by Lord Birkenhead in the House of Lords:—

The noble Earl will, I think, not deny that this Bill is as favourable to Irish landowners as any Bill which any Irish Government could at this moment pass, or as any English Government could have carried through Parliament in this country from the year 1916 onwards.

He went on to show that the prices fixed for land were the same as those fixed under the 1920 Act and by the Lloyd George Convention, and that in addition the landlord had the supreme advantage that he would have an inextinguishable claim after the 1923 Act was passed to a return of roughly 67½ per cent. of his gross rent and he would continue to draw that. Furthermore he said that their costs were being paid and that the 10 per cent. bonus the State was giving was substantially the same as that granted under the 1909 Act. I cannot see where the Parliamentary Secretary makes out that there is injustice to the landlord. The landlords have had a very good bargain and in this particular matter where we are looking for restitution for the tenants, we want something more than a reply that it can only be got at the expense, of the landlords. It can be got by utilising the Guarantee Deposit Fund and by the State doing something to make up the difference. As I stated out of the £6,000,000 that the State has wrongfully taken from the tenants, without giving them any real benefit, the State has got £1,000,000 in respect of income tax. The State as well as the landlords can very well afford to make sacrifices—not very great—to enable the tenants to be given the advantage of the Sinking Fund since 1928 and a reduction of five or ten per cent. as well during that period.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Does the amendment mean that the State must pay something to someone?

Comment on this

No. The argument is whether the landlords or the State should pay.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I allowed this amendment but I am being steadily convinced by the debate that it should not have been allowed at all.

Comment on this

I cannot imagine that the Executive Council are prepared to do half hearted justice in this particular matter. They have introduced a Bill to end continuing injustice to the non-vested tenants. Are they going to let the injustice which has lasted for 3 or 4 years pass without any attempt to right it? It seems to me that this amendment is reasonable in every way. The amendment aims at securing that a reasonable period should be set to the time the Land Commission could take to put the 1923 Act into effect. We took five years because the Minister indicated that that was the length of time it would take. I put it this way. If this Act were to take a longer time to be put into operation than five years those who come in after a reasonable period of five years should get the same benefit as those whose cases were able to be considered within the five years.

In fact listening to the debate it struck me in many cases for the sake of justice where length of time would have to be taken to put a measure into operation it would be wise to name a time within which the normal working should take place. Those who could not take advantage of the measure owing to delay in administration I think should get the same benefits as those who were able to avail of the measure within the specified period of time. What I mean is this: Five years is a reasonable period. Was there any reason why when the 1923 Act was being passed that we could not have it established as a principle that no member of the community affected by this measure would fail to get the advantage of it within that period. That seems to me reasonable. Therefore we are simply asking that those who, on account of the difficulty of putting an Act into operation, were denied the benefits after an unreasonably long period had elapsed should get the benefits that would have accrued to them, if they came within the class dealt with between 1923 and 1928.

Then as to restitution. Where is it to come from? Obviously from those who gained by the delay. The delay was not designed by the Parliament. The delay was accidental. In a sense it cut across the intentions of those who passed the Act, and therefore let the loss be apportioned amongst those who gained by that delay. On the one hand the landlord has gained and on the other hand the State has gained because it was not called to make the contribution it would have been called upon to make, if the vesting had taken place within this period. It seems to me that those who gained ought to give it back to the individual. The Act was passed for the benefit of the individual. The individual has suffered, and the State is bound in justice to make restitution. In the same way the landlord ought to be compelled to make restitution for what he has gained. That is the fundamental purpose of this amendment. I would like to know whether the Parliamentary Secretary and the Executive Council are prepared to meet us in this matter. Have they made up their minds definitely that all they can do, and will do, is to prevent the continuance of the injustice, and have they closed their minds definitely to any thought of restitution? I hope they will not try to do justice in this halting way. If they want to settle this matter of injustice which has been crying out for settlement so long—if they are going to do it at all let them do it right.

I hope they are going to meet us in this. We are not unreasonable in it. The Parliamentary Secretary might take some time to examine it and be able to give us the apportionment, for instance, of the cost to the State, on the one hand, and what the landlord would have to pay back, on the other hand. I think it was suggested by the Parliamentary Secretary that this was supposed to be made good out of taxation. That is not my view. If a tenant has been paying too much for a period, say, of five or six years, we might take five or six years to make it good to him by reducing the annuity he has to pay by a corresponding amount. As I say, we are not unreasonable in this. We think this is a necessary part of any attempt to do justice, and I hope the Parliamentary Secretary and the Executive are not going simply to hold by the attitude which has been indicated.

Comment on this

One would think from the statements of Deputy Gorey and the Parliamentary Secretary that land tenure in Ireland was the fairest thing in the world and that landlords were the finest set of fellows in the world.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Not a word about it.

Comment on this

That is the whole attitude. We have heard how the landlords suffered from the twenty-five per cent. reduction. We have not heard that these landlords were the people who resisted coming in under any other Land Act—who resisted any voluntary settlement—and that they were compelled by the Land Act of 1923 to come in. This Bill does not state that they will get any worse terms than under the 1923 Act. They are going to get fifteen years' purchase. Are they not much better off than the owners of the estates the tenants on which were vested in 1925, 1926, 1927 and 1928? Have they not drawn ten per cent. more? Have they not eight years added on to the 68½ years' purchase which will commence if the Bill goes through as drafted? Will they not have the benefit of the extra ten per cent. for that period of eight years? Have the tenants no rights in these cases? Take the case where a rent is non-judicial and where it becomes judicial. What about the extra charge to the tenant?

As to the State paying its portion of the costs, I seriously contend that it is the lack of system and the haphazard way in which the Land Commission deal with estates which have been the cause of the non-vesting of a great number of estates. The officials go down on a Tuesday, and in my constituency are, say, in Athlone in the morning and Castlepollard in the evening. They take a few details and they are at that rigmarole from one end of the year to the other. It is the lack of system, the want of co-ordination, and the inefficiency of the Land Commission that have been the cause of the non-vesting of a great number of estates under the 1923 Act. Therefore, the State should bear its portion of compensation to the tenants who have suffered as a result of this inefficiency. The cost of the Land Commission for that period has been £5,000,000, one-quarter of the actual money involved in the vesting of the remainder of the estates. I wonder how many Deputies on the opposite benches made an estimate of the total cost of the Land Commission since it was set up and related that to the benefits that have accrued to the tenant farmers?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

That calculation would bring us some distance from this amendment.

Comment on this

I am trying to indicate that the non-vesting and the grievances of the tenants involved have been caused by the inefficiency of the Land Commission.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

There is one point I should like to have cleared up if possible, and that is whether it is proposed to put a charge on the State, because if that is so I would be inclined to raise a point of order. As regards the other question raised by Deputy de Valera, I presume Deputies opposite have not read up the history of the Land Act of 1923. They mentioned that the Minister promised the completion of land purchase in five years. Assuming for the moment that that is so—I have no distinct recollection of the Minister saying it—one thing is present to my mind, and that is that the guarantee in respect of the issue of Land Bonds was for eight years. Obviously it was not necessary to get a guarantee for eight years if the whole thing could be completed in five years.

Comment on this

You always make sure, naturally. You want to add a margin.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Precisely. As far, therefore, as the five years is concerned it is slightly damaged.

Comment on this

The promise was not serious.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I do not know what the Deputy means by saying it was not serious.

Comment on this

While the promise was made that it would be five years, they took good care to allow themselves eight.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

That is what the Deputy calls not serious. I should like to know the Deputy's idea of what would be serious, if that is his idea of not being serious. When this Act was passed in 1923 it established a principle that had not previously been put into operation in connection with any previous Land Acts; in other words, an immediate reduction was given to every tenant holder whose land had not yet been purchased. Under the Land Act of 1903 there was voluntary purchase. That voluntary purchase started some time after 1903, and it took many years before it commenced to get into full operation. But directly the 1923 Act was passed the 25 per cent. reduction was given in all cases. So that there was in the minds of the Government at that time the necessity for striking a fair bargain in all cases. It was quite understood that certain cases would be completed in the first year, a certain number in the second year and the third year, and that some might go on for a longer period. It must have been in somebody's mind that it would take eight years, or it would not have been necessary to look for an eight years' guarantee from 1923. The Deputy smiles at that.

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

That is not serious, according to Deputy Little.

Comment on this

The eight years was serious, but the five years was not.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I do not regard this amendment as serious. It is an afterthought; it is the politics of this matter. It is one of the things that are sickening about politics. It is one of the things that make one disappointed with the representation which we have at present. I have here a copy of the Bill introduced by Deputy Derrig. The earliest date mentioned there was 1st December, 1929. I can imagine a meeting of the Party opposite and Deputy Geoghegan, having brought a little intelligence into it, saying: "You must do something better this time," and I presume we have an earlier date in consequence. There is a later date mentioned in Deputy Derrig's Bill of 1929—1st June, 1932, which is probably the comparable date in this particular instance.

Comment on this

Probably it is not.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Probably it is. The Deputy will not deny it.

Comment on this

I will deny it.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Personally, I am not acquainted with any landlord who sold his land in 1923, but speaking as a person who has a little knowledge of the value of money I would have taken 70 per cent. of the price down in bonds delivered to me in 1923 if I held the land, rather than take all the advantages that Deputy de Valera has referred to in saying that I would have gained by not getting them until 1931. I think that Deputy Geoghegan would do the same thing, and if he would not, he is not the wise man that Deputies opposite think he is.

Comment on this

You saved their bacon.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

More than that he saved, and I advise the Deputy to do the same. Now, as far as the State contribution to this particular problem is concerned, it is a very considerable sum. The sum of money involved is £1,300,000 approximately, which is the contribution of the State in this particular matter.

Comment on this