We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Issue Out of the Central Fund. - Land Bill, 1930—Third Stage.

Contributions 191–391 of 583. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Land Bill, 1930
Enacted

No. 29 of 1930 ›

Is that a capital sum?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

That is the capital sum, and the State will still have that capital liability notwithstanding what Deputy de Valera says, that the State will make something out of it. We have not. We have still that capital liability, and are still going to bear it. My information is that if this amendment were passed it would cost the State a sum of £269,000. I think that as when the Act was passed an advantage was given to every tenant holder of a reduction of 25 per cent. in his rent——

Comment on this

An advantage?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Yes. An advantage.

Comment on this

The majority of them were paying nothing at all at that time. You saved the landlords' bacon. You got money for them that they would never see otherwise——

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I did not save any landlord's bacon. I do not know any of them. If I was a member of the Deputy's family I probably would know some of them.

Comment on this

You saved their bacon.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Order, order. The President must be allowed to make his own speech; he is entitled to make his speech. The Deputy can make a speech afterwards.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

The liability of £1,300,000 will have to be borne for 68½ years. It was a fair estimate at the time if the Minister said five years on the evidence he had before him. If my calculation is correct, he had a number in mind of about 70,000 tenants at the time. I think the number far exceeds that. It is 100,000. What means had he of knowing what the correct figure was? Practically none. It was an estimate, and if he said five years and made provision for a possible extension to eight years, which is the length of the guarantee, it was a wise estimate. And nobody could be under any misapprehension when it was stated that the length of the term of the guarantee was for eight years. If this amendment is likely to cost the State £269,000, I respectfully submit it is out of order.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I would like to hear Deputy Derrig on the point as to where the money is to come from.

Comment on this

Deputy de Valera suggested that the President and the Executive Council should meet us and treat the matter seriously instead of taking up an attitude that everything that comes from this part of the House is a political matter. I do not know what the peculiar connotation of the word "political" we have just heard means. If it simply means that when a proposal to give restitution to those people is brought up here it can be downed by hurling the adjective "political" at it, the sooner we know where we are the better. But this has been brought up here very seriously——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will the Deputy meet the point of order that has been raised?

Comment on this

The amendment does not say anything at all about public funds. The amendment simply asks that the appointed day should be fixed on the 9th of August, 1928, and not later than the 9th August, 1928.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

It would make the Act retrospective to that extent.

Comment on this

Deputy Little pointed out that we have a consequential amendment No. 47—that is, the amendment to Section 20, which sets up a guarantee deposit; and when it is suggested that there is something unfair about the proposal, I would point out that this guarantee deposit is part of the machinery of the present Bill.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I do not want the Deputy to go into the merits, but to hear him on the question of what this amendment means and how it would affect public funds.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 46, I think, makes it clear as it stands that the money would be paid out of the guarantee deposits.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

What line is that?

Comment on this

In sub-section (4) of Section 20, to add a new paragraph as follows:—

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I have gone into the question of amendment 46, but I should like to hear the Deputy on this amendment.

Comment on this

I think it is because I expanded the amendment as it stands in order to show why we thought this question should be dealt with that the question of State funds arose.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I think Deputy Gorey, who spoke immediately after Deputy Derrig, mentioned the point first.

Comment on this

It does not, I submit, arise out of our way of meeting it. We quite understand we have no opportunity of putting forward here any amendment that would involve a charge on public funds—that is the prerogative of the Executive—and there is nothing in this amendment that does that.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Is there anything in this that does that?

Comment on this

I say there is not. I spoke in general terms of what would be just and fair, but we are limited in proposing our amendments by what we can do within the rules of the House, and we have kept within the rules of the House by providing that this should be met out of the Guarantee Fund.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

There is no mention of the Guarantee Fund that I can find.

Comment on this

Take it in conjunction with the section.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The effect of this amendment is to make the provisions of this Act retrospective.

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

And the effect would be that certain people paying money from the 9th of August, 1928, up to the passing of this Act shall be entitled to restitution of money so paid. Is that so?

Comment on this

There are two sources.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Apart from the sources, there are certain people now paying interest in lieu of rent, and they are now paying more than persons whose land is vested and who are paying land purchase annuities. If this amendment was carried these people would be entitled to the difference.

Comment on this

It depends upon what the Ceann Comhairle means by "entitled"? If he means legal action or anything of that kind against the Land Commission that is not so.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

What is the meaning of the amendment?

Comment on this

It empowers the Parliamentary Secretary, in dealing with the lists, to mention as the date of vesting a date anterior to the date he has put down. On the question of funds to meet that, he can, if he wishes, take my suggestion, which I submit I have a right to throw out. But the way prescribed in this amendment to meet this particular matter does not involve a charge on public funds.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

This Bill already provides for retrospective vesting. Sub-section (1) of Section 9 in the Bill, as originally printed, provided for the fixing of the appointed day retrospectively.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is "previous to."

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

Accordingly there is nothing in this amendment that is now before the House except a limit as to when this antecedent date is to be. It introduces no principle which is not embodied in the Bill already.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I would like to point out to the Deputy that that is wrong.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Let us hear Deputy Geoghegan's conclusion.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

I can only deal with one thing at a time. So far as fixing the appointed day before the passing of this Bill is concerned, I merely say that the Bill as already introduced on the part of the Government contains the power to fix that date previous to the passing of the Act. Deputy Derrig, by his amendment, provides that after "previous to" must not be merely a month or two months previous to, but that it must be away back in 1928. That is a difference in degree, I quite concede at once.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

There is no question of relevancy at issue. The question at issue is whether the amendment proposed would have the effect of imposing a money charge.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

The President of the Executive Council then raised the point of order, as I understand it, that by implication the amendment, as it now stands, will put a charge on public funds. That, of course, is entirely a matter for you, sir, to rule, but my submission to you is that there is nothing in that amendment, as it stands, that gives any person any right to resort to public funds. If it is said that there is, I would like to have an indication of the method that he is to adopt if he seeks to resort to the public funds. It is true that if our amendment simply stops where it is now, it will be as barren and as fruitless to the tenant as the words "previous to" which we find in the Bill under Section 1. That is another day's work. Deputy Derrig proposes by amendment 46 that the tenant is to have something more than the honour and glory of having his Appointed Day fixed in 1928. As the amendment before the House stands, I do urge upon you that it merely gives the tenant the right to have the Appointed Day fixed in 1928. It confers directly no financial benefit upon him.

Deputy Derrig proposes to feed his present amendment by means of amendment 46. If I am in order in referring to it at all I want to say that amendment 46 will prejudicially affect the landlords. There is no doubt about that. The argument has been urged by Deputy Gorey and it may or may not prevail with the members of this House, that there is something in the nature of a contract entered into between the State and the landlord under the 1923 Act, whereby it might be unjust or inequitable that you should now seek to give effect to the proposals to reimburse the tenants by passing amendment 46. But that is another matter. That will be discussed on its merits. It may be said when the time comes that you have a choice of evils. A wrong has been done the tenant. At least it will be suggested that a wrong has been done the tenant. The most favourable way in which this matter can be put, from the point of view of the Parliamentary Secretary is—to paraphrase something that he himself said—that there were difficulties inherent in it which made it impossible for him to carry out the hopes entertained by the Minister at one time.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is wandering from the point of order.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

I have, and I apologise for that.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

My position is that I desire information. My understanding of the amendment which we are now discussing is that it is retrospective in effect, and that it has been urged in favour of the amendment that its effect would be that the tenants would have to be paid back the difference between the land purchase annuities and the payments they have made in lieu of rent.

Comment on this

I would like to point out that we are fully alive to the restrictions here in the bringing forward of proposals dealing with the imposition or imposing of charges on the public funds. There is no charge proposed to be imposed on the public funds by this amendment nor in the consequential amendment, none whatever. Let those who are asking that the amendment should be ruled out of order in that respect, point out exactly where the amendment proposes a charge on the public funds.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I want to hear the Parliamentary Secretary on that.

Comment on this

The present amendment means, as I understand it, that the tenants will have to be reimbursed the difference between the payment in lieu of rent and the annuities which will be paid by the tenant under this Bill.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

By whom?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I want to keep to the point of order now.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

The money must be found somewhere. Before Section 20 becomes operative all those holdings which have been vested since 9th August, 1928, every estate or every holding which has been vested since then down to date are entitled to be refunded this difference. There is no money in the funds to which the Deputy refers. Those people will have to get it, and it must be from the State.

Comment on this

Not necessarily.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

The terms of the 1923 Act provided that the landlord was to get a certain payment in lieu of rent. If there has been any delay since in the vesting the delay is not due to the landlord.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

To this extent, that if there was any delay at all it was the delay of the machinery at the disposal of the Land Commission. It was the fault of the Land Commission, if you like; the fault of the machinery of the Land Commission, and it would not be held in law that the landlord should pay for any delay that occurred because of this fault of the Land Commission.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

What about the point of order?

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

It is suggested that the difference be met, and there is an allusion to a guarantee fund. As a matter of fact, there is no common guarantee fund. It is a guarantee fund in proportion to every estate. It is not a common fund. There is a fund in every case in connection with every estate, a separate fund, and it is for a specific purpose. It cannot and will not be held in any court that this is the responsibility of the landlord. If there is any liability at all it is the liability of the State. If it cannot be met and it will not be met by the State, there is no use in arguing the question.

Comment on this

I submit that it has not been shown in any way whatever that this amendment either directly or indirectly imposes a charge upon the public funds——

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

There is a way out.

Comment on this

If the House wishes there is a way out. It is simply proposed that the benefits of vesting be given to the tenants as from the estate. There is nothing in our amendment that imposes a charge upon public funds, and I say that the President, or the Parliamentary Secretary or nobody else can show where this involves a charge on the public funds. I have put forward a suggestion. The House can afterwards, if it wants it, ask the Executive Council to bring it in. I was going to proceed on the terms of our amendment for the simple reason that our amendment had to be confined so as not to involve expenditure.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Will the Deputy explain where the money is to be found to meet the liabilities on all those estates vested since 1928? The money is not there yet. The tenants are entitled to get the money the moment this amendment is passed, and the Bill becomes law.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

They do not come within the section at all.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

It is not where the annuity begins, but where it ends, and if it ends in three years after a specific time then the State has to pay. It is not where it begins. That is a matter that the lawyers have told us nothing about.

Comment on this

If this amendment is passed it leaves two alternatives in the hands of the Government. If the Government choose to make up their minds to pay it out of State funds they can, but there is nothing in this to say that they shall. It does not arise here. On the other hand, they may take it out of the moneys going to the landlord, but here the question does not arise. The President is simply using this point of order——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Let us assume that points of order are legitimate.

Comment on this

The President made a definite statement that if this amendment were passed £269,000 would have to be found. The effect of our amendment would be that that £269,000 should not be found by the tenants who have been robbed for the last three years because the machinery of Government was not put into operation. Our amendment wants to give some sort of restitution to the tenants who have been paying over and above what they should have paid and what their neighbours paid.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

From where?

Comment on this

At the expense of the landlord because we have no other way of dealing with him.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is not the point of order. The matter seems to have resolved itself into this. It is agreed that if this amendment now being discussed were carried it would involve a charge on public funds, that it would involve the payment of a sum of money. There can be no doubt about that. It is now argued that if amendment 46 is in order and may be moved as relevant to Section 20 that the money which must be found, could be found under that amendment.

Comment on this

From the landlord?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Not from State funds?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment 46 is one to which I have given consideration. I have some doubt as to whether amendment 46 is relevant to Section 20 at all. I can see no method of settling this matter except to postpone the present question until we come to amendment 46 and see whether in fact amendment 46 is an amendment to Section 20, and whether it is relevant. I think we will have to leave over this amendment until we come to amendment 46 to see its implications under Section 20, and then let the amendment be put down again if necessary. I am refraining from ruling the amendment out of order so as to make that possible. What I have heard leads me to believe that it is out of order, but I am refraining from ruling it out of order now.

Comment on this

I understand your ruling You are not sure of the implications of this until amendment 46 is dealt with.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I would like first to hear amendment 46 dealt with.

Comment on this

If amendment 46 is ruled out on grounds other than its relation to this particular amendment where do we stand?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Then you are lost.

Comment on this

No, I submit it is not fair. That may be very nice for the President. I take it the Chair is not ruling just to facilitate the President.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

He is bound by his own ruling.

Comment on this

I quite understand the Ceann Comhairle's ruling. I just want to point out that I want to object to its having to depend on a section which may be ruled out on grounds other than its relation to this particular point. I suggest that if amendment 46 were not in order at all the point could be made that in its absence we might very well have to put in this other amendment which would be a valuable amendment. It would give the Executive power to deal with the matter as they consider best. My point is, that this amendment on which you intend to postpone your decision could stand on its own feet quite independent of amendment 46 and that, therefore, it would not be fair afterwards to rule it out because 46 was not relevant. I quite understand the Ceann Comhairle waiting to hear what amendment 46 proposes, in order to decide the question as to whether this particular section that we are dealing with now did or did not impose a charge upon the Central Fund. He has to wait for further information that may be given in the course of a debate on that. I understand that that is quite reasonable. But I would hold the other amendment to be reasonable and that is why I would like the point to be put now.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy de Valera is right in thinking that if amendment 46 is not in order this amendment is not in order, because it seems to me that the only way in which one can bring this amendment in is by agreeing to amendment 46, as it is now described to me. If that cannot be done this amendment cannot be moved. As I am at present informed the two amendments go together, and if provision cannot be made for the money which this amendment involves, coming from some other source than public funds, then the amendment is not in order.

Comment on this

I believe it can be. It lies with the Executive if they wish to do it.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

An amendment by a private Deputy which empowers the Minister for Finance to do something by way of spending money which he cannot do at present is out of order.

Comment on this

What I mean is this. If in the discussion of this amendment a representative of the Executive were to say, "We will agree that restitution should be made, but we will not provide it in the way you propose in amendment 46," it is their affair, not ours.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

If I should rule on this matter now the Deputy will be estopped on the next stage.

Comment on this

That is why I am anxious it should be left open. I hold that there is no basis for ruling the amendment out of order, in that the Bill might be incomplete if it were allowed—in other words, the Ceann Comhairle does not sit in judgment as to whether every Act is fully implemented.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Oh, no.

Comment on this

Therefore, this is only implementing a certain section. If the Ceann Comhairle were to rule that certain things would follow if this were implemented I think the ruling would be unfair, or perhaps I should say unsound.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy means it would be outside the scope of the Ceann Comhairle's functions.

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

If this amendment is adopted, and nobody in the course of the debate is allowed to say that money should be paid out of State funds, then the debate would be unreal. It is only a debate on the basis of saying that money can be paid out of State funds that would be out of order.

Comment on this

We can conduct the debate without talking of where it is to come from.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 6, 7 and 8 are outside the scope of the Bill.

Comment on this

Do I understand that you are ruling out amendment 6 as being outside the scope of the Bill?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this

The Bill is entitled "An Act to make provision for the early vesting of holdings in the purchasers thereof under the Land Purchase Acts and for that and for other purposes to amend those Acts." In the first place I maintain that a very grave injustice has been done in the case of several estates throughout the country.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

The point of order is that the Bill provides for the early vesting of holdings, but you cannot vest holdings until you are able to fix the price which the tenant shall pay, and you cannot fix the price which the tenant shall pay on these particular estates unless the amendment is accepted.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The amendment deals with matters which are not in the Bill. It proposes to amend the principal Acts in a way that is not provided for in the Bill.

Comment on this

The Bill provides for the publication of lists. The amendment says: "Immediately upon the publication of a list of vested holdings tenanted land comprised in such lists shall become or be deemed to have become vested in the Land Commission on the appointed day." If these tenants are paying 10 per cent. more than what they were paying to the landlords in 1923——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Would the Deputy indicate some part of the Bill which deals with judicial holdings?

Comment on this

The whole question of the vesting of holdings deals with judicial rents. How can you vest holdings until you know the rents?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

These amendments deal with matters under the 1923 Act in a manner not contemplated in the Bill.

Comment on this

It is very difficult to be quite certain what the Ceann Comhairle will regard as coming under the principle of the Bill. It is stated in the title of the Bill that it is an Act to make provision for the early vesting of holdings in the purchasers thereof under the Land Purchase Acts, "and for that and other purposes to amend those Acts." I take it that the fundamental purpose of the Bill is to end an injustice done to a certain class of tenant. To me that is the main principle of the Bill in so far as it is intended to help the tenants at all. Here is a matter that is the cause of definite hardship which, I think, was brought to the notice of the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

It is outside the scope of the Ceann Comhairle's functions.

Comment on this

I quite understand, but what I mean is that, if the principle of the Bill is to deal with those cases of injustice, then the amendment comes within the principle of the Bill, otherwise I find it hard to understand what exactly is the principle of the Bill.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I am not prepared to define offhand what the principle of the Bill is. The Bill has been brought in, read a second time, and referred to Committee. In Committee amendments must be related to something in the Bill as read a second time.

Comment on this

I heard you ruling on one occasion that amendments to a principal Act could be inserted in an amending Bill to that Act. This Bill proposes to amend the Land Acts of 1923, 1927 and 1929.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

In certain particulars.

Comment on this

Yes. Would not any amendment to amend those Acts be in order?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

No.

Comment on this

I think I heard you ruling once that they would.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

That would be an interesting record. I think, however, that the Deputy's recollection is somewhat at fault. The principle on which we work in Committee is that you can amend the principal Act only within principles contained in the amending Bill as read a second time. The fact that the 1923 Act is mentioned does not enable a Deputy to amend the whole of that Act. We are restricted in our terms of reference, and any amendments which are at variance with the principle cited are not in order.

Comment on this

You are ruling that these amendments cannot be discussed?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this

So that this injustice will have to continue.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I am not concerned with the merits.

Comment on this

Then I am afraid that the Parliamentary Secretary will have to bring in a lot of amending Bills before we are done with it.

[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (3) to delete all words from and including the word "save" in line 35 to the end of the sub-section.

Sub-section (3) of Section 9 lays down the terms which shall be fixed for tenants when the Appointed Day is fixed. They shall be deemed to have entered on the Appointed Day into subsequent purchase agreements for the purchase of such holdings from the Land Commission at the standard price and sub-sections (2), (3) and (5) of Section 28 of the Land Act, 1923, shall apply in respect of such holdings in like manner as they apply in respect of the holdings mentioned in those sub-sections, save that such application shall not be prevented or limited by sub-section (6) of the said Section 28. Sub-section (6) of Section 28 of the Act of 1923 refers to what are called retained holdings. Retained holdings were excluded holdings which would otherwise be vested in the Land Commission on the Appointed Day.

These retained holdings, according to the definition in sub-section (6) of Section 28 of the Act of 1923 comprise:—(a) any holding in respect of which the standard price exceeds three thousand pounds, or (b) any holding in the beneficial occupation of a tenant who is on the Appointed Day the proprietor of lands for the purchase of which advances have been made under any of the Land Purchase Acts, unless redeemed, if the total amount resulting from the addition to the standard price of the amount obtained by capitalising at the rate of four and three-quarters per cent. the original annuities payable on such advances, exceeds £3,000; or (c) any holding as respects which the Land Commission declare that it is not in the public interest that the holding shall be resold to the tenant as aforesaid, whether on the ground that the improvement of the holding is essential and practicable, or otherwise; or (d) any holding which in the opinion of the Land Commission ought to be retained for improvement or enlargement or for utilisation in connection with the relief of congestion — all which holdings are in this Act referred to as retained holdings. It will be seen therefore that if this proviso which excludes the operation of sub-section (6) is allowed to stand all holdings will automatically vest in the Land Commission. We think that the £3,000 limit and the provision as regards retained holdings for the relief of congestion ought to be allowed to stand and, therefore, the proviso in the sub-section ought to be deleted — that is, that holdings over the £3,000 limit or which were held to be necessary for the relief of congestion would not be vested.

Comment on this

The Deputy obviously misunderstands the whole scheme of the Bill with regard to retained holdings. In the Act of 1923 all tenants on the appointed day are deemed by Section 28 to have entered into purchase agreements except the tenants on holdings described in sub-section (6). Under the procedure in this Bill, when the appointed day is declared, it may not be known what holdings are to be retained, and consequently all tenants are deemed to have entered into subsequent purchase agreements. In a later section the Deputy will see that when inquiries have been made purchase agreements in the case of holdings which the Land Commission decide on retaining will be withdrawn. The procedure will be the same as that under the Act of 1923, with the exception that tenants on retained holdings are deemed to have entered into subsequent purchase agreements. It would be quite impossible for the Land Commission to ascertain beforehand whether a holding is to be retained or not. Consequently, where tenants have been deemed to have entered into subsequent purchase agreements and when, as a result of inquiries, we discover that the holdings ought to be retained, these agreements will be withdrawn and the holdings will be dealt with as under the Act of 1923.

Comment on this

Do I understand that the Land Commission cannot now say what holdings they propose to retain?

Comment on this

If that is so, will there not be more difficulty in acquiring these holdings for the relief of congestion?

Comment on this

No difficulty whatever. I have made it clear in a later section of the Bill.

Comment on this

What section?

Comment on this

Section 11.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (7) after the word "modification," line 55, to insert the words "that a court letting shall be deemed a contract of tenancy and."

I understand that there are a large number of cases in this category of court lettings. It is a rather technical matter, and there seems to be a good case for giving them the benefit of the Act.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

What does the Deputy mean by court lettings?

Comment on this

Where the letting is a letting made in court.

Comment on this

By what court?

Comment on this

By the High Court, I suppose, generally.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy is quite serious about the amendment.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I would like to have all the implications of the amendment put in a straight way so that we could understand it. I do not know what the amendment means. It might mean that in the case of a minor the court would make a letting without any intention that the land should pass away from the owner. The object of the amendment would seem to be to give the individual permanent possession as a result of that temporary letting. That would deprive the real owner of the property. This could be a very unjust provision. I would like to know what is meant by it exactly and how far its implications go.

Comment on this

I think there is a provision elsewhere in the 1923 Act which prevents temperory lettings being taken in. That is specifically stated. There is a provision in the 1923 Act excluding temporary lettings. These are lettings which go on from year to year for a considerable period.

Comment on this

I was told of one case that would come under this amendment. A dispute arose somewhere about 1917 between a landlord and a cousin of his as to who was the real owner of the estate. As far as I understand, from a note which I got here about it, a person who had not paid his rent for some time was reinstated by the court as tenant on tendering his rent. Nobody knew who was the real person to whom rent should be paid. The court reinstated him. Afterwards about 1925 when the dispute was settled as to who was the real landlord, it was found that this man did not come under the 1923 Act.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

This amendment may inflict considerable hardship. It may do justice in one particular case, but injustice in several other cases. If a man held land at all under a court letting, irrespective of the conditions under which it was made, his right is established, even though it was a court letting. This amendment might do a lot of injury that was never intended by the mover and I do not think that anybody could accept it.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

This amendment was introduced to meet cases with which we are all familiar — lettings made by the Court for seven years, but then continued on for a very long time.

Comment on this

What court?

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

I do not know whether the Parliamentary Secretary is really looking for information or laying a snare for me.

Comment on this

I asked the question on a point of information.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

I will concede this, that what are called court lettings in the main were made by the Land Judges Court. We find most of them there. It is true, and I will concede this also, if it is concession, that lettings have been made by other courts in circumstances which, speaking for myself, I would not suggest ought fairly bring them within the ambit of the Land Acts. It is quite possible that the amendment as drawn might be so far-reaching as to embrace cases such as lettings during minority or lettings during the temporary insanity of some person and where it would be contrary to the spirit of the Land Act that the tenancy should be brought within the Code. Those are the exceptions rather than the rule. Possibly the Parliamentary Secretary might see his way to introduce an amendment himself which would meet the substantial cases where the tenancy to all intents and purposes is an ordinary tenancy though, in form, a tenancy which is outside the Act, and at the same time would safeguard cases such as a letting during the minority of an infant, the temporary insanity of a person, or cases like that. I do not know what my colleague would do, but if the Parliamentary Secretary would intimate that he would deal with the matter in that way possibly my colleague would see his way to drop the amendment.

Deputy Dr. Ryan has mentioned, from his own knowledge or from information upon which he is entitled to rely, a case which in substance and on the merits is within the Land Code but which by reason of the form of the letting is kept outside the Land Court. Nobody desires that. It sometimes means that you have one tenancy here and there marooned in the midst of land that is vested, a tenancy which in no material respect differs from the tenancies vested but which in that technical respect does differ and is excluded from the benefits of the Act. I say again that the amendment in so far as it would embrace lettings in minor cases and in cases of lunacy is perhaps too wide, but there are other lettings in which the tenants are merely ordinary tenants.

Comment on this

I could not accept the amendment. In fact Deputy Derrig has made no effort to make his intention clear. Deputy Ryan quoted a particular case but I am not sure from what he stated that it is really a case of a court letting at all. Deputy Geoghegan did not succeed in clarifying the position to any extent. I am really at a loss to understand what is the object of the amendment. Deputy Geoghegan admitted that it would be unfair to apply any amendment of that kind to lettings made by the court on behalf of minors or lunatics. It would also be unjust. I would like to know what particular type of court letting the Deputy has in mind. The Deputy knows that under the Act of 1923 such lettings are excluded.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

I understand that the letting Deputy Ryan mentions has been ruled outside the court although in substance it is an ordinary tenancy.

Comment on this

The letting of course might be treated by the Land Commission as ordinary untenanted land.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

Or it might not. The Parliamentary Secretary has stated that I have not succeeded in clarifying it. I cannot give the House an abundance of illustration, but I do think the Parliamentary Secretary might accept the principle that lettings which in substance were ordinary lettings and within the purview of the Land Acts but which, in form, were outside the Land Acts might be brought within. They differ from the exceptional and particular class that the Parliamentary Secretary and Deputy Gorey have drawn attention to.

Comment on this

It was really a court case, because in the year 1917 the tenant was ejected for non-payment of rent. There was a Chancery suit in the High Court going on between the landlord and a cousin of the landlord. When the tenant came and paid him arrears of rent and costs the Court gave a lease for ten years pending the termination of the action by the landlord. That was in 1917. In the year 1923 the Land Act was passed; the landlord then returned this holding with others, and the payment in lieu of rent was made from that on. In May, 1929, the Land Commission's solicitor applied to the court for an order as to whether the Land Act of 1923 applied to this holding or not, it being held at the time of the passing of the Act on a court lease, and the Land Commission ruled that he did not come under the Land Act of 1923.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

That was the foundation of a previous letting, no matter what the court says. Should it come under the Acts? If it was a continuation of a letting that, in the ordinary way, would come under the Act, I am amazed that it was so ruled.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

Then you will vote with us. You admit that it is a case which should come within the Act?

Comment on this

Would the Parliamentary Secretary even undertake to make this optional?

Comment on this

No. I am prepared to adjourn discussion on this particular amendment until the Report Stage.

Comment on this

The Land Judge said he was sorry. He had no option.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

Did the Parliamentary Secretary say that he was prepared to leave the matter open until the Report Stage?

Comment on this

Yes, so that the Deputies may make up their minds as to what they really want.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendments 11, 12 and 13 are out of order.

Comment on this

This is a Bill for the vesting of holdings, and under this section as it stands at present a definite injustice is going to be done in a very large number of estates where the tenants were enjoying voluntary reductions, some of 35 per cent., before this Landlords Act of 1923 was brought in. The landlords return the old judicial rent as the rent, and an increase of ten per cent. was made on these tenants by the 1923 Act. It might be argued that there is hope of an appeal to the Judicial Commissioner. The Parliamentary Secretary alluded to agile lawyers. He might also have included wily judges. In one of those cases a decision was given in 1924 by Mr. Justice Wylie: that for the payment of the arrears of rent and interest in lieu of rent the reduced rent was to be taken as the rent, but when it came to the vesting of the land the old judicial rent would have to be taken. This is the position of the tenants as they stand at present. Say a tenant's rent was £20. He got a voluntary reduction to £12, and under Justice Wylie's order that was further reduced to £9. On the day this vesting Bill comes into operation he pays £13. The Parliamentary Secretary would not believe it until I handed him Mr. Justice Wylie's judgment to read. We had the ruling of the Ceann Comhairle a few minutes ago on another section which he has adjourned.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Ceann Comhairle has ruled on that, the Deputy cannot go back to it. The Deputy must keep to the section.

Comment on this

I am keeping to the section. I have here one case where the tenants, if they succeeded in their contention, would have been robbed of £2,700. I consider that a very grave injustice. These tenants' cases were listed for hearing on the 29th March, 1929, and they are still without any decision having been come to. Attempts were made to bring them into the ordinary courts for non-payment of rent. One tenant refused to pay his rent, and the Circuit Court judge adjourned the whole proceedings pending the decision of the Judicial Commissioner. Those tenants are still hanging between heaven and earth. They have paid £2,700, and if this vesting Bill comes into force as it stands at present they will be robbed for all time. The tenant whose rent is to be raised from £9 to £13 is now going to be robbed of £140 by this Act alone. I had hoped to get finished with these amendments. I am aware of the argument that might be used. I heard arguments used by Deputy Rice a few days ago. We heard sneers from Deputy Gorey. I wonder was Deputy Gorey secretary of the County Cork Farmers' Union when they went down to his landlord and threatened him with a gun. The argument was brought up here against those tenants by Deputy Gorey on the amendment to the 1923 Act.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy cannot make a Second Reading speech. I will hear the Deputy on the section.

Comment on this

I am arguing that the section, as it stands, will do a very grave injustice to a large number of tenants, and I am dealing with the arguments that may be used against these tenants. One argument was that the reductions were got by force. I have here a reply to the objections by the landlord. That reply states that he got a letter from the secretary of the Unpurchased Tenants' Branch of the County Cork Farmers' Union asking him to meet them, and it was with these he made a settlement, which he maintains is temporary.

Comment on this

What rank had he in the Irregulars?

Comment on this

The Irregulars as you call them — the Irish Republican Army — did not exist at that time.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must keep to the section.

Comment on this

This is going outside the section and it is out of order.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is a different point.

Comment on this

Any arguments that were brought forward were absolutely misleading.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy might deal with the section now.

Comment on this

The section is going to confer a very grave injustice on a large number of tenants. We are told that this is the final coping stone. If so, I wonder how the tenants will like to be robbed for the next 60 years after being robbed of £2,700 since 1923 by a National Government, so-called. I had hoped that amendments would be met. I tried by every means in my power to have them met by the Parliamentary Secretary. They have not been met by him. I brought these cases to the Parliamentary Secretary's attention on the 28th February, 1929.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is discussing a matter which has no relation to this section. The Deputy's argument cannot have any relation to it.

Comment on this

The section deals with the vesting of land.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Let me decide the point of order. It has already been decided that the amendments have no relation to that section and therefore the arguments can have no relation to it, and are out of order.

Comment on this

I am not arguing on the amendment. I am arguing that the section as it stands is going to confer a grave injustice on certain tenants by in some cases increasing their rents 45 per cent. That is an injustice the Parliamentary Secretary never dreamt of. On the 28th February, I stated that a large number of tenants in my district, in which are included about five estates, got voluntary reductions of 35 per cent. on their judicial rents from the landlords. Under the 1923 Land Act these tenants were compelled to purchase, and had to accept 25 per cent. reduction instead of the 35 per cent. they had.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Has the Deputy not been informed that the matter he is bringing forward cannot be dealt with under this Bill and therefore has no relation to the section? The Deputy is wasting time and is out of order.

Comment on this

My point is that this Bill compulsorily vests the holdings in the tenants at the old rents.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is not dealing with what is in the section, but with what he would like to see in it.

Comment on this

No, but with what I see in it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Then if the Deputy will keep to that he will be in order.

Comment on this

I am keeping to that particularly. Clauses 1 and 2 deal with what I am alluding to.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

They do not.

Comment on this

They deal with the publication of lists of vested holdings and once vested the tenants cannot argue about the matter.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is where the Deputy and I differ, and that is where he is out of order.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary completely overlooked the point. He stated in reply to my statement:

"That is sheer nonsense. The 25 per cent. was based on the abated rent the tenants were paying at the passing of the 1923 Act."

Either the Parliamentary Secretary is wrong in his deduction or the Judicial Commissioner was wrong in his findings. I do not care which.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (3), to delete all words after the word "Commissioner," line 11, to the end of the sub-section and substitute the words "shall be subject to appeal to the Supreme Court."

Section 10 deals with vested holdings and there is provision that objections shall be considered by the Land Commission and that there shall be right of appeal to the Judicial Commissioner. We have a number of amendment such as this one, declaring that the decision of the Judicial Commissioner shall not be final, but that there shall be an appeal to the Supreme Court. It seems to us that the fullest possible latitude should be given in cases like the present, where there is going to be a great rush and a great change in procedure, and that in the interests of fair play and justice the fullest possible right of appeal should be given. We propose that there should be the elementary right of appeal that there would be in other matters in the courts generally, and that there should be a final appeal to the Supreme Court. No doubt the present system is a very good one. It might be argued that it is more expeditious and probably costs less in the long run. Nevertheless as the sums involved are very large, and as the matter is very important for the State, I think that in any decisions which are to be laid down as final we will be well advised to have the opinion of the highest court in the land. For that reason I think that an appeal to the Supreme Court should lie. The Judicial Commissioner is a very efficient Judge, and there is no doubt but that his special knowledge of the work and his experience give him a unique position in the judiciary of this country. We have no doubt but that fair play will be given in this Court to the tenants and to all concerned, but as very important principles may be laid down, we think that there should be a right of appeal on these technical questions, which often involve such large sums of money and such important interests. We think that there should be no attempt to stop litigants from having it out if they want to in the highest Appeal Court in the Free State.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I take the contrary view. I have had some experience even of the provisions for appeal under the present Act, and I find them working out very unjustly indeed against the tenant. In many cases the tenants concerned are tenants excluded from previous Acts. They are isolated individuals in many cases, and not large combinations which could have the best legal advice. I have half a dozen cases in mind of non-judicial tenants. The Land Commission sent out their official to fix the value. An appeal was lodged by the landlord, and none of these tenants had the means to come to Dublin, with the result that the appeals went against them. I would be inclined to do away with all appeals and not to extend them after the Land Commission official has fixed the value. I would be inclined to curtail it very much. Some question of law might perhaps arise, but I do not see how it could. I do not think it desirable to extend the principle. If it were possible to do it, I would move an amendment that there should be no appeal from the Land Commissioners sent down to value the land.

Comment on this

I would second that.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I know half a dozen cases in which the tenants let the appeal go by default. They were so poor that the landlord was not even able to recover the costs. I advised them not to pay.

Comment on this

Does not Deputy Gorey rather take it for granted that the right of appeal must mean an appeal by the landlord as well as the tenant? Would the Deputy be satisfied if the appeal only lay with the tenant?

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I do not think you can have legislation on these lines.

Comment on this

You can. It is, I understand, already in the licensing laws.

Comment on this

Any portion of this Bill which allows an appeal to the Judicial Commissioner would be strenuously opposed by me. The majority of decisions which I have seen during the last few years lead me only to one conclusion, that the Judicial Commissioner——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy knows very well that he is going to make a statement that should not be made. The Deputy must not criticise any decisions given by a Judge.

Comment on this

If that is the case, we are practically powerless in dealing with this matter and it is all the more reason why we should not leave this power in his hands. The case I mentioned on the last section absolutely bears out my contention. The Parliamentary Secretary knows very well the decision I am alluding to. I gave it to him last week and I take it he read it, and I would like to have his honest view on it.

Comment on this

That case is not decided yet.

Comment on this

The case I gave occurred in 1924 and was decided.

Comment on this

There must be another Judicial Commissioner then besides the Commissioner who gave the decision. At any rate, I think vesting such a power in the hands of one man is absolutely wrong and should be abolished. When we have officials in the Land Commission we should trust them that much without extending the power to individuals in whom the tenants have no confidence. They know them too well to have any confidence in them.

Comment on this

I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary not to accept the amendment. I am very much in sympathy with the suggestion of Deputy Gorey as to deleting the last three lines of Section 3 (9), that is, leaving the power in the Commissioners' hands altogether. There is no reason why four Commissioners should not be able to decide these cases. Three Revenue Commissioners are able to decide cases. A decision of the three Commissioners of Public Works is final. Why should not the four Land Commissioners be able to decide cases without an appeal to the Judicial Commissioner, especially in view of the fact that the Judicial Commissioner sits only about once a fortnight. Deputies on the other side are continually complaining of the delay in vesting. If an appeal from the Judicial Commissioner to the Supreme Court is going to be allowed, it will mean that five generations will not see the finish of the appeals — there will be no ending to them. As evidence of that I should like to read a letter I have here.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy ought not to read any letters.

Comment on this

I submit that I can read this letter, and must read it. It is a letter in reference to the Judicial Commissioners' delay in vesting. It is from the Land Commission.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is confined to dealing with the amendment before the House.

Comment on this

Then I shall raise the matter on the section itself. I ask the Parliamentary Secretary not to accept this amendment, and I ask Deputies on the other side not to press it, because it is going to be very embarrassing to the Land Commission, and very much more embarrassing to the tenants. The fewer appeals there are the better.

Comment on this