We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Issue Out of the Central Fund. - Land Bill, 1930—Third Stage.

Contributions 392–583 of 583. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Land Bill, 1930
Enacted

No. 29 of 1930 ›

Do you want to leave it to Wylie?

Comment on this

Why do you not abolish him then?

Comment on this

Is the Parliamentary Secretary prepared to consider the amendment or the points made by Deputies Gorey, Nolan and Corry. We are not tied to this amendment. We simply moved it in order to raise the general question of appeals from the Land Commissioners. Before we would withdraw the amendment we would like to know what is the attitude of the Parliamentary Secretary on the whole matter.

Comment on this

Under the Act of 1923 there is a right of appeal from the decisions of the Judicial Commissioner to the Supreme Court on questions of law. Deputies will probably remember that when concluding the Second Reading debate I said that I was very anxious that this matter should be discussed fully on the Committee Stage. The discussion has not added very much to my knowledge so far, because it is obvious that Deputies are rather divided in their views on this point. Upon the whole, I think it would be advisable to preserve the right of appeal which is given in the Act of 1923 on questions of law to the Supreme Court. Cases may arise where it will be necessary for the Land Commissioners themselves to appeal against the decisions of the Judicial Commissioner. These cases, of course, will only arise very rarely. Cases have already arisen, however, where the Land Commissioners have appealed to the Supreme Court against decisions of the Judicial Commissioner, and, of course, cases may arise in future. Taking everything into consideration, it will be advisable to preserve the right which we have in the 1923 Act of an appeal to the Supreme Court from the decision of the Judicial Commissioner on a question of law.

Comment on this

It seems to me that objection to our amendment is chiefly on the ground of expense. Is the Parliamentary Secretary prepared to get rid of the Judicial Commissioner as an appeal? Is the Parliamentary Secretary prepared to do what Deputy Gorey suggests?

Comment on this

That is not the amendment.

Comment on this

Are you prepared to take that suggestion?

Comment on this

I am discussing the amendment.

Comment on this

We are anxious to know if you would go further.

Comment on this

When that arises in a proper way I am prepared to answer.

Comment on this

It means that the Parliamentary Secretary is not prepared to give any information to the House to enable us to make up our minds on this particular point. It is obvious that if the Parliamentary Secretary has any opinion to express on the matter he ought to express it to the House. Surely it is not his purpose to get us to make decisions in the dark. I take it it is his duty to give any information he may have acquired as the result of the working of this particular Department. Deputy Gorey has made a point in reference to appeals. The suggestion was that instead of further appeals possibly we should cut out a certain appeal that is there already. The point made against that particular appeal was that it causes delay; that was the point made by Deputy Nolan, that there is delay on account of the bottle-neck of the single commissioner before whom all these things have to come. Is he prepared or not to adopt the suggestion made?

Comment on this

The point does not arise here.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It may be dealt with on the section, but for the present Deputies must deal with the amendment.

Comment on this

There is a question of the possible withdrawal of the amendment if that suggestion were adopted. That is why it is relevant.

Comment on this

The statement was made by Deputy Gorey that the Judicial Commissioner was responsible for delays in vesting. He is not responsible for any delay that may have taken place in vesting.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I did not say that.

Comment on this

I made that statement and can prove it.

Comment on this

The Judicial Commissioner has nothing whatever to do with the vesting of land. His duties commence really after the land is vested.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I made the statement, and repeat it, that appeals to the Judicial Commissioner work out in one way, inasmuch as the small tenants are not able to get legal advice and to bear expenses to meet the cost afterwards. I know of one case where the award of the Commissioner was raised five shillings and it involved two guineas costs. I had to meet that case myself. I think appeals should not lie from the Judicial Commissioner.

Comment on this

On a point of information, I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary does this section make provision where the date of lodging an objection has lapsed and the final list is already published.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. That can be raised on the question that the section stand part, but it has no relation to the amendment.

Comment on this

I would be very anxious to know if the Parliamentary Secretary is going to give way on the question of the Judicial Commissioner.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

This amendment has nothing whatever to do with the Judicial Commissioner.

Comment on this

It would be easier to have the matter out now. Was this gentleman's name mentioned in the Treaty, or anything like that, that we cannot touch him here.

Comment on this

I object to that section. I am not going to follow now Deputy Gorey's suggestion about the appeals. I could give a half a dozen cases where the Judicial Commissioner decided in a case as Judicial Commissioner and increased the annuity on the rent that he fixed as land judge. He fixed it in 1919 at a certain amount, and in 1925 or 1926 he fixed the annuity at a much higher amount. I have another case from the County Limerick also — I need not mention names — where he increased the rent by 50 per cent. on what his own valuer put upon it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is aware that we cannot criticise here decisions given by the Judicial Commissioner.

Comment on this

I am only following the example of other Deputies.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

No Deputy was allowed to criticise the judges.

Comment on this

I was only following up the bad example of Deputy Gorey.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I repeat I did not criticise any judge's decisions.

Comment on this

Here is a letter dated 7th February, 1931. It bears the number 4703/31 and the Record No. S. 2897, and it reads: "With reference to your letter of 26th ult. regarding the holding of"— I will not mention any names —"on the above mentioned estate, I am desired by the Land Commission to inform you that these lands were resumed by them on 26th February, 1930, when £1,750 in 4½ per cent. Land Bonds the amount of the compensation awarded to the tenant was placed to the credit of the matter. The Land Commission are not liable for any arrears of rates which accrued prior to that date. The allottees were placed in occupation, and in accordance with the terms of their purchase agreements they are liable for poor rates on their holdings from 26th February, 1930. The amount of £426 8s. 5d. mentioned by you as due to the Limerick County Council in respect of rates would appear to be arrears which had accrued prior to the Land Commission entering into occupation of the land and in these circumstances the Secretary of the Council can enter an appearance in the Registrar's Branch of this office against the before mentioned compensation of £1,750 as directed in the Local Government Department circular of 16th December, 1927, issued to all Secretaries of County Councils."— that is the point I want to come at—

"The allocation of the amount of compensation is a matter for the Judicial Commissioner, and it is understood that the question of the title thereto will be under investigation at an early date."

This letter was written on 7th February. The lands were divided in February, 1930. Still twelve months later the amount cannot be allocated to pay rates for four years accruing to 1930, because the Judicial Commissioner had not time to hear the cases. I was told there was a tremendous lot of such cases and that this case could not be taken out of its order. I maintain the Commissioners could settle this case themselves and certainly the county council ought to be entitled to the rates on the land. The reason there was delay in dividing was because the Judicial Commissioner could not hear the case.

There was an appeal from the decision of the Commissioners. It was an appeal to the Judicial Commissioner, and that was about five years ago. It was in respect of a little holding the total value of which was £1,750 They have had to wait five years for that appeal to be heard. I maintain that that should not be allowed to continue and a Judicial Commissioner should not have power under this Bill as in the 1923 Act. I will give one proof of my contention. In the first place, we have four Commissioners. When the 1923 Act was passed we had only two. Now we have four active men who have been trained in the Land Commission and they ought to be sufficient to deal with all these matters. In the Examiners' Office there are twenty-four men. I understand they were there in the past. These men sit constantly and any man who sees the daily papers can see in the Land Commission Court the list of cases in the Examiners' Office. In that office there is a staff of twenty-four, costing £14,729——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is getting away from the section.

Comment on this

I am not. There is no sense in these appeals, and I am giving an explanation as to why we do not want the Judicial Commissioner. I submit that this is most relevant. If every Deputy here were as relevant in the matter as I am we would get on very much more quickly. I am giving my very definite reasons, and I maintain that at present we do not need a Judicial Commissioner in view of the fact that he sits only once a fortnight. How are we to get through the vesting of holdings if that system is to continue?

Comment on this

I wish to support Deputy Nolan's objection and on the very same grounds. Under this Bill the Judicial Commissioner, to my mind, is an impossibility. This matter of the appeal to the Judicial Commissioner is absolutely useless. If the Judicial Commissioner is to decide all the cases that are to be sent to him, he will be sitting for the next fifteen or twenty years, if he lives so long. I have here a case to which I alluded some time ago. It is a case listed on the 28th March, 1929, now two years ago. That was an appeal to the Judicial Commissioner, and apparently he has not the slightest intention of trying this case yet.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is a question of appeal?

Comment on this

Yes, an appeal to the Judicial Commissioner. In despair the tenants came to me in 1929, and I advised them to continue paying their rates. I pointed out to them that if they refused to pay they would probably not be able to pay the arrears later on. One of them refused, and last year he was summoned by the Land Commission. The judge adjourned the case pending the decision of the Judicial Commissioner. Since then he has been served with another Civil Bill for a half year's rent and that case is pending. Here are two Civil Bills and the Circuit Judge cannot give any decision pending the decision given by Judge Wylie. That is where the whole case is held up. I consider the system ridiculous. There should be some means available by which those cases should be heard within a certain limit of time. I object to these appeals altogether. There are four Commissioners now and these Commissioners ought to be able to deal with these cases without any appeal to the Judicial Commissioner. I do not know why that individual should be brought into every Bill of ours here. Is there any special binding on the Government in connection with these Land Acts that these cases must come finally before the Judicial Commissioner? I suggest that in this case the office of the Judicial Commissioner should be done away with altogether. It is ridiculous in the face of it to have tenants waiting for four years for a decision. The trouble with those tenants is that they are continuing to pay their rents. They have been paying these rents since 1923 awaiting the decision of the Judicial Commissioner. When the tenants want a refund later on, they will be told that there is no fund out of which they can be paid. It is scandalous that these men should be saddled with all the delay of these appeals. The section of the Bill should be deleted unless the Government is bound by some agreement to this individual. I see no other way out of it. From the statement made by Deputy Nolan and from the decisions given by the Land Courts we must come to the conclusion that this Judicial Commissioner has been forced on the Government.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy ought to keep to the section.

Comment on this

I am keeping to it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Corry will either sit down or discuss the section—one or the other.

Comment on this

I am discussing it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Corry will resume his seat or discuss the section.

Comment on this

I submit that this portion of the section should not be there. It is there for one object only, and it should not have any bearing on a national assembly if this is a national assembly. If this is a national Government to make rules for the people of Ireland, that portion of that section should go out at once, and the Judicial Commissioner should not be the last Court of Appeal on land questions in the Free State. The statement made here to-night by Deputy Nolan, and what anyone can see by looking through the Land Commission findings, should induce others to look into these findings. That should bring such a storm of public opinion to bear on this individual that this matter of appeals should be finished. If we cannot finish them here they would be finished then once and for all. It is a perfect scandal that the Judicial Commissioner at this time should have power to delay these vestings. It is time that ended. If we were only a small Party in the British House of Commons working against a huge majority, I could understand why this should be allowed to continue, but I cannot understand it here. There should be no need for an individual like the Land Commissioner to be forced down the throats of the Government. Whether he is or not, I do not know, but the Minister should stand up and say so if he is not.

Comment on this

In my opinion it will be absolutely necessary to have some Court of Appeal from the Land Commission on the question of value. Under the 1923 Act and under this Act, if you have no Court of Appeal, the Land Commission will decide what retained holdings they will resume, and they will also decide the question of price. Therefore, to my mind, for the protection of the tenant of a retained holding, it is absolutely necessary to have some Court of Appeal on the question of value. I think a judge who hears the evidence of the valuers on behalf of the tenant and who hears his own court valuers as regards the market value of the tenant's interest, is the best final Court of Appeal you could possibly have.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I differ from Deputy Mathews. I know this question of getting rid of the Judicial Commissioner has been damned by the advocacy of Deputy Corry in dealing with a particular individual.

The procedure will undoubtedly be held up, and whatever hopes the Parliamentary Secretary may have of a speedy issue to the vesting orders will not and cannot be realised in the case of non-judicial holdings. All these non-judicial holdings will be the subject of valuation put on by a Land Commissioner. In each case they have the option of appeal to the Judicial Commissioner. Years will be occupied in dealing with all these cases, and the hopes we have of a speedy vesting cannot be realised in the case of non-judicial holdings, both tenanted and untenanted land. My one objection is on the question of value. I do not believe Deputy Mathews' contention in that respect will hold water. Value is the principal thing with regard to retained holdings, and that can be dealt with by the Commissioners themselves. On questions of law there ought to be an appeal to some court— I do not care whether it is judicial or not—but on questions of value there should be no appeal. I am very doubtful if sub-section 3 of Section 10 covers the whole functions of the Judicial Commissioner, because this is merely dealing with lists altogether apart from the question of value. I am not clear that the elimination of sub-section 3 of Section 10 would meet the position. I do not think it would. I am afraid you would have to come back to the main Act of 1923.

Comment on this

I ask the Parliamentary Secretary where lists have been published, and the time for objection has elapsed, and where vesting has not yet taken place, and the tenants did not make these objections through not being aware of their rights in the matter, is there provision now made for that class of tenant. Within the past year there have been a great number of estates dealt with and lists published out of proportion to what was done in previous years, I daresay in anticipation of this particular Bill. In a great number of cases landlords gave wrong returns; they gave returns of rents which did not obtain for 30 years, and which were 25 per cent. above what they were charging in 1923. They went back as far as 1870. The tenants, through lack of knowledge of their rights, did not object, and the time for objection has passed, but vesting has not taken place. Will the Parliamentary Secretary make provision in this Bill to deal with that kind of thing?

Comment on this

In reply to Deputy Gorey's point about the delay that may take place in connection with non-judicial holdings, the Deputy has forgotten that the Land Act of 1929 was introduced primarily for the purpose of dealing with the cases of non-judicial tenants. Under that Act the annuity is fixed automatically, and the Deputy may be interested to know that the number of objections lodged is very small. I do not anticipate that the Judicial Commissioner will be called upon to exercise his functions frequently in connection with these non-judicial cases. I deny that there is any delay whatever in the Judicial Commissioner's court. I think every practising barrister here knows that the Judicial Commissioner is one of the speediest men amongst the judiciary in getting through work. The delay is certainly not on the part of the Judicial Commissioner.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I listened to you ruling Deputy Corry out of order on the question of criticism of the administration of the Judicial Commissioner. In view of that ruling, has the Parliamentary Secretary the right to proceed on the same lines?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am afraid the Deputy misunderstood my ruling. I said I would not allow the Deputy to criticise decisions given by a judge.

Comment on this

I want to stress the point that there is no delay whatever on the part of the Judicial Commissioner in hearing cases. What the Deputies do not understand is that the Judicial Commissioner cannot hear cases until they are lodged in his court, and the delay, if there is delay —I am assuming for the moment that there might have been delay in the case cited by Deputy Nolan; I do not know the case mentioned by Deputy Corry, because, I did not understand him—takes place before the cases are lodged in the Judicial Commissioner's court.

Comment on this

It must be over 12 months.

Comment on this

My point is that the delay took place before it was lodged, if, indeed, it has been lodged in the court even yet.

Comment on this

I have only the Parliamentary Secretary's word for that.

Comment on this

There is no delay on the part of the Judicial Commissioner. I think that even Deputy Geoghegan, on the opposite benches, will bear me out in that. There has always been a right of appeal from the Land Commission to the Judicial Commissioner on the question of price and other matters. It is proposed in this Bill to continue that right of appeal. That right of appeal is availed of more frequently by the tenants than by the landlord. In fact, in 75 per cent. of the cases heard by the Judicial Commissioner the appeal was by the tenant. I consider it would be unfair to deprive the tenant of that right of appeal to the Judicial Commissioner. It would lead to hardship.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

That has not been my experience.

Comment on this

That information can be substantiated. I do not propose to waive the right of appeal to the Judicial Commissioner. I consider that in many cases it is necessary to retain that right. Whilst I am as keen as any member of the Dáil to shortcircuit the Land Commission procedure I hold that in many cases it is vital to retain the right of appeal to the Judicial Commissioner on particular matters which he is responsible for dealing with, particularly the question of price. I agree with Deputy Mathews that it is right that there should be an appeal on the question of price. Either the tenant or the vendor should have such right of appeal both in regard to the question of price and to other matters in connection with which a right of appeal is provided in the Bill.

Comment on this

On the question of price, I would like to ask the Parliamentary Secretary whether there is any truth in the statement that the representatives of congests, or landless people looking for land and interested in the division, are not entitled to be represented in the Judicial Commissioner's court when the question of price is being decided. I would like also to ask him what is the position of the assessor. Is he purely a court official, an official of the Judicial Commissioner or of the Land Commission who values the land? A statement has been made that while the landlord can call in an expert valuer to give evidence as to the value of land before the Judicial Commissioner, the Land Commission do not put forward any expert evidence on that matter. If that is so, I think that the Land Commission should put it right.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary stated a while ago that he did not understand my point. My point is that on the 28th March, 1929, the estate of Constance Power, Record No. S.1173, was listed for hearing. We are now approaching the 28th of March, 1931, but that matter has not yet been heard though these tenants have already been robbed of £2,770 by the landlord and the Land Commission combined. Does the Parliamentary Secretary consider that that is a speedy transaction? Does he now say that there is no delay in Justice Wylie's court?

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary stated that 75 per cent. of the appeals to the Judicial Commissioner were appeals on behalf of the tenants. That surprised me. If he has any figures available over any particular period he should furnish them to the House and confirm that statement. The issue which arises in this discussion appears to be whether the landlord, who is the only person who seems to have benefited by appeals of this kind, should have the right of appeal to the Judicial Commissioner on questions of value. I have no hesitation in saying that he should have no such right at all.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not arise on the section under discussion.

Comment on this

It is the issue.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It does not arise under the section.

Comment on this

If it is true that 75 per cent. of the appeals have been brought by tenants, it shows that they have no confidence in the decision of the Commissioners. That, of course, happened in the past when we had only two and when they appealed to the Judicial Commissioner as the last word, but that is changed now. Why appeal on the question of value at all? Why go back on the valuation of the Commissioner's valuer and increase it? According to the evidence of the Judicial Commissioner's valuer he has increased it by 50 per cent. Therefore Deputy Mathews' point is ruled out there. The more I consider the points made by Deputy Mathews and the Parliamentary Secretary the more I am convinced that we should not have an appeal to the Judicial Commissioner. I would urge the Parliamentary Secretary to have this matter further considered on Report. I do not care to force the matter to a division, but I trust that the Parliamentary Secretary will be able to adjust the matter satisfactorily.

Comment on this

I move:—

"In sub-section (1), to delete the word `may,' line sixteen, and substitute the word `shall.' "

Section 11 deals with the retention of holdings and with the list of vested holdings. It allows the Land Commission, as under the Act of 1923, to retain such holdings as it may consider necessary, but the expression is that it "may" retain them. On Section 9 I had an amendment to excise the proviso which made inapplicable to Section 9 the terms of sub-section 6 of Section 28 of the Act of 1923. The Parliamentary Secretary pointed out that Section 11 covered my point. I would like to ask him what is the objection to making it mandatory on the Land Commission to retain these holdings? It seems to me, in the procedure as it now will be and in the rush of vesting — it is admitted that all holdings will automatically be vested — that it would be necessary for the safeguarding of congests and uneconomic holders that the Land Commission should exercise to the fullest such powers as it has for the retention of holdings. In order to compel the Land Commission to do so, I propose to substitute the word "may" by "shall."

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I trust that the Parliamentary Secretary will not accept this amendment, as it takes away all discretion from the Land Commission and the exercise of common-sense.

Comment on this

I would like to draw the attention of the Parliamentary Secretary to the procedure under Section 28, sub-section (6) of the Land Act of 1923 in regard to practices which are being carried on in Westmeath. I have here a notice from Iris Oifigiúil where the tenant of a farm consisting of 33 acres is informed that it will be retained. I would like to know why the Land Commission is carrying out this procedure in regard to this particular farm.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is raising this particular case on this amendment?

Comment on this

I will raise it on the section.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think the Deputy ought to raise a particular case except for the purposes of his argument.

Comment on this

I would like to indicate that whatever may be the practice in other parts of the country, I do not see the reason for the practice under this particular section which deals with the previous section in the Act of 1923, by which these small farms are being retained in County Westmeath. In other words they are going to be taken from people who own them for the purpose of dividing them amongst a couple of Black and Tans, and a couple of ex-R.I.C. men. I have here an extract from Iris Oifigiúil of March 3, 1931. The name of the tenant is William Gilsenan, and his postal address, Cooleighter, Drumcree, County Westmeath. He is going to be pegged out of 33 acres for three Black and Tans.

Comment on this

The Deputy will have an opportunity of raising that on the estimates.

Comment on this

It might be divided then.

Comment on this

I cannot accept the amendment. I might say that the Land Commission have always exercised discretion in regard to the retention of holdings. It is now sought to insert in the Bill that the Land Commission is not to continue to exercise that discretion. It would be obviously unfair to substitute the word "shall" for "may" in this section because it would make it obligatory on the Land Commission to retain a holding on which an advance of £3,000 or over has been made. The Land Commission only retain holdings for the purposes of relieving congestion. In very many cases these holdings will not be required for the purpose of relieving congestion, improvement, re-arrangement, etc. In other cases the tenant is using them in an up-to-date way and farming them according to the most up-to-date and most modern methods. In such cases the Land Commission will have naturally to exercise their discretion as to whether they will retain the holdings or vest them in the tenants.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

In the case of a holding, where an advance exceeding £3,000 is contemplated, public aid is being given to a comparatively rich man. The Parliamentary Secretary has mentioned that there may be cases in which a large farm is so desirably worked that it would, perhaps, be in the public interest to give an advance of over £3,000. What is there in the policy of the Land Act to justify subsidising a large farmer like that, because that is what it comes to? There is nothing in the Bill or in the amendment, as moved now, that will prevent that large and prosperous farm putting down, out of its own resources, the balance over the £3,000. All that is attempted by this amendment here is to erect an absolutely impassable barrier in the way of the large farmer or large grazier who seeks to raid the public purse for more than £3,000. He can get £3,000 by buying that large farm, and if he wants £5,000 or £6,000 let him go to a bank or raise it on his credit, or get it in any way he likes. The whole policy of the Act seems to be towards the creation of small tenancies. The limit has not been put unduly low, because where there is an advance of £3,000 one can envisage quite a large area. I would ask the House to say that there is nothing at all unreasonable in tying the Land Commission to prevent them landing out money to a greater extent than £3,000 for the purchase of such holdings.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I have a case in mind where a farm of 150 acres is concerned. The full £3,000 was exhausted in the buying, but there was a bit of land right in the centre of the holding, a glade of ten Irish acres. The Land Commission wisely exercised their discretion, and consolidated the ten acres along with the 150 acres. Will the Deputy say that no man ought to hold 150 acres, and that the Land Commission should not be allowed to exercise their discretion in that case? It is not a question of the Land Commission resuming and giving it to somebody else. It is not a question that the tenant has the option of going in and putting down his own money under this Bill. It is a question of taking the land from him, and that he should only hold a certain amount of land.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

As I understand it, Section 11 operates back by referring to sub-section (6) of Section 28 of the Act of 1923. This is merely a limitation of the price to be advanced by the Land Commission to £3,000. If the tenant finances it, if he pays the landlord money himself, or puts it up himself, I do not quite see where the obstacle is in the way. Undoubtedly under the Act of 1903 in numerous cases the tenant has, in fact, done so. I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to correct me if I am wrong in that statement. Under the Act of 1923 there was a limitation on the amount of the advance.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

That is right.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

Unless I am greatly mistaken in my recollection, in numerous cases tenants of the type indicated by Deputy Gorey have financed the transaction themselves. If there is anything in this Bill as drawn which would prevent the tenant of the 150-acre farm that we have heard about, putting up the balance over £3,000 out of his own resources, surely it is not beyond the ingenuity of the Parliamentary Secretary to put something into the Bill that would enable him to do it. At all events, the intention of Deputy Derrig's amendment is to prevent an advance of public money to any one tenant farmer exceeding £3,000. If he buys it himself we will not stop him.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

There is a provision in the Bill dealing with retention and resuming. That is quite a different matter to the 1923 Act.

Comment on this

I would point out to Deputy Geoghegan, who mentioned the limit of advance under the previous Act, that the limit of advance under the 1903 Act was £5,000. This was brought down to £3,000 under the 1923 Act.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

I stated that there was a limit under the Act of 1923 and that in many cases the price exceeded that limit, and that the tenant purchaser put up the balance of the purchase money himself. The records of the Land Commission will, I am sure, negative that statement of mine if it is unfounded.

Comment on this

There is a great difference between the limit of an advance of £3,000 and £5,000. I know of several cases under the 1923 Act where £5,000 was exceeded. The Land Commission had an option as they had under the 1923 Act of exceeding £3,000.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

And that helped to paralyse the finances of the 1903 Act. As everybody knows, the money provided under the 1903 Act ran out much sooner than the late Mr. Wyndham or anyone else anticipated. The Act of 1903 largely collapsed about 1907 because enormous advances were made for the purchase of large holdings by the exercise of the discretion of the Land Commission. We want to stop that tap from running.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Of course it did; they were cash transactions.

Comment on this

May I ask whether Deputy Gorey is in favour of raiding the public purse for more than £3,000? Does the Deputy think that anybody who has property which justifies an advance of more than £3,000 should be assisted to a greater extent than that? That is what the amendment means to stop, to prevent the public purse being used for advances of more than £3,000. Is it not right to stop that?

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Then you had better lay it down that in no case should that amount be exceeded.

Comment on this

Surely Deputy Geoghegan does not suggest that this amendment won't prevent the advance of more than £3,000.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

If this amendment is not carried the Land Commission may vest a holding, the standard price of which exceeds £3,000, in the tenant of that holding.

Comment on this

No. The Deputy knows perfectly well that under the Act of 1923, retention in the case where the advance is over £3,000 is automatic and will continue to be so. In the other cases under the sub-section the Land Commission has discretion. Hence, it is necessary that the word "may" shall remain instead of the word "shall" as suggested by the amendment.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Deputy Geoghegan should read the section.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

Perhaps Deputy Gorey will tell me what it means.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Sub-section (1) reads:

Where a holding included in a list of vested holdings would be a retained holding within the meaning of sub-section (6) of Section 28 of the Land Act, 1923, if that sub-section applied to it, such holding may, notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, be retained by the Land Commission.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

Retained by the Land Commission and used possibly for the purposes of amendment 16 to provide farms for evicted tenants.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 66
·
Níl 53
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Sub-section 11 (1) provides:

Where a holding included in a list of vested holdings would be a retained holding within the meaning of sub-section (6) of Section 28 of the Land Act of 1923, if that sub-section applied to it, such holding may, notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, be retained by the Land Commission.

If a farm of 36 acres, with a rental of £18, comes within sub-section 6 (c) of Section 28 of the Land Act of 1923, which says:—

Any holding as respects which the Land Commission declare that it is not in the public interest that the holding shall be re-sold to the tenant as aforesaid, whether on the ground that the improvement of the holding is essential and practicable, or otherwise; or

will the Parliamentary Secretary indicate how a farm of 36 acres that he considers necessary to be retained, "on the ground that the improvement of the holding is essential and practicable, or otherwise," seeing that this is one of the best-worked farms in the country, is to be brought under the Act of 1923? This is not an isolated case.

Comment on this

The Deputy had better put down a question about it, and I will tell him why the Land Commission proposes to retain it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendments 16, 17, 18 and 19 are out of order.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

Are the four being ruled out of order?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Yes.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

On a point of order, I would point out that amendment 16 provides for the application of lands retained under Section 11. The amendments are to provide parcels of land for evicted tenants. What are holdings being retained for unless they are to provide for evicted tenants and other persons who deserve to have holdings allotted to them.

Comment on this

To the exclusion of the congests, I assume.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us have the point of order.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

On the point of order, I ask you, sir, to reconsider your ruling on these amendments, to say that, having regard to the substance of them, they are relevant to the principle of this Bill, and that in particular they are relevant to Section 11 dealing with retained holdings. There is nothing abhorrent to the principle of this Bill in providing for an evicted tenant, who is admitted within the Act already, so that he shall have the right to come in and ask the Land Commission to put his name on the list. How can it be said that these amendments are irrelevant? Surely it was intended that this Bill, while it might not mean finality in regard to land settlement, would settle the Irish land question, except for some exceptional or undreamt of cases.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is getting away from the point of order.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

I regret if I have wandered, but if this amendment is not to be discussed and adopted then the doors seem to be banged on the evicted tenants, about whom we have heard so much for a generation. I am only concerned with that point.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendments 16, 17, 18 and 19 are ruled out on the ground that they introduce a new principle into the Bill. They deal with a principle which was not included in the Bill as read a Second Time. I am not concerned with the merits of the amendments.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

The principle of the Bill includes the disposition of and the dealing with retained holdings. This matter of the evicted tenants was discussed on the Second Reading from both sides of the House. Deputies on both sides of the House alluded to it, and a division on this Bill would probably have been sought had it not been understood by Deputies on every side of the House that evicted tenants did come within the ambit of the Bill. The only new principle that is introduced by that section is that the evicted tenants can set the machinery in motion. They are already within the purview of the Act, the amendment is mere machinery; it is a matter of the working out of the Act rather than conferring any new right.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy discussing the point of order or making a speech on the amendment?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am afraid the Deputy is not discussing the point of order. This is an amending Bill, and it would not be in order in Committee to introduce a principle into the Bill which was not contained in the Bill as read a Second Time. It is quite clear that amendments 16, 17, 18 and 19 are introducing a new principle or a new class not contained in the Bill as read a Second Time, and therefore they are out of order.

The following amendments were agreed to:—

In sub-section (3), paragraph (c), page 6, line 50, after the word "sum" to insert in brackets the words "(if any)."

In sub-section (3), page 6, paragraph (d), to insert a new paragraph as follows:—

"(d) any sum which may be due to the Land Commission by the tenant in respect of the annual sum equivalent to the standard purchase annuity of the holding stated in the list of vested holdings including the proportion of such annual sum for the period between the gale day on which the first instalment of such annual sum became payable and the day on which dividends on Land Bonds are payable next after the appointed day."—(Mr. Roddy).

[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]

Comment on this

I want to know will sub-section (1) apply to the particular class of tenant that I referred to on a previous section. My question was: when official lists have been published, when the time for objections has lapsed, vesting has not yet taken place, and the tenants did not make these objections through not being aware of their right in the matter, will the provisions of sub-section (1) apply to these tenants?

Comment on this

What lists have been published recently?

Comment on this

The final lists of a great number of estates.

Comment on this

If the final list has been published then the section will not apply.

Comment on this

Even where they are not vested yet?

Comment on this

If the final list was published this section will not apply.

Section 12, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.

Section 13 ordered to stand part of the Bill.

SECTION 14.

(2) Every application under this section shall be heard and decided by the Land Commissioners other than the Judicial Commissioner and there shall be a right of appeal to the Judicial Commissioner from the decision of the other Land Commissioners on any such application and the decision of the Judicial Commissioner on such appeal shall be final.

Comment on this

I move:—

To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

"In the case of non-compliance with the provisions of Section 22 of the Land Act, 1923, as amended by this Act, the Land Commission shall have power to withhold a payment to the landlord in respect of payment in lieu of rent."

This section contains a provision allowing a tenant, if his holding has been excluded from the list of particulars sent in by the landlord, to take steps to have it inserted. It seems to us that, in addition to giving the tenant the right to take steps to have inserted the particulars of his holding wrongfully omitted, some steps should be taken against the landlord. Under the 1923 Act there is a very nominal penalty imposed on the landlord in case he omits to send in the particulars. It seems to us that the Land Commission should have power, as suggested in the amendment, to withhold from the landlord the payment in lieu of rent. If the landlord is holding up the vesting of the tenant's holding by simply refusing to carry out the law, and if he has been allowed to escape up to the present with the nominal penalty placed on him, the Land Commission, if they mean to get this Bill working, will have to take stronger steps, and I contend that they should seriously consider withholding at least one payment in lieu of rent from the landlord if he still refuses to hand in these particulars.

Comment on this

The Deputy's point is covered by Section 12 of the Act of 1927. Payment in lieu of rent, of course, is not paid until the particulars are lodged, and then it is only paid from the date on which the particulars are lodged. I think that completely meets the point.

Comment on this

Suppose the particulars had been lodged, if there is an error in the particulars, and it is only afterwards discovered, payment in lieu of rent might have started.

Comment on this

Payment in lieu of rent would still commence from the date on which the particulars were lodged, and the error would be rectified subsequently.

Comment on this

I move:—

Before Section 15 to insert a new section as follows:—

"Where the Land Commission have been in receipt of payment in lieu of rent in respect of any holding and the said holding is declared to be a holding to which the Land Purchase Acts do not apply such payment in lieu of rent shall be deemed to be in satisfaction and discharge of all rent which may have accrued due to the landlord up to and including the last gale day for which the said payment in lieu of rent has been collected."

This is an amendment to deal with a certain class of case which has come under our notice. The Parliamentary Secretary is probably aware of such cases. I do not know whether the amendment would meet with his approval, but if he is prepared to consider the question I would be prepared to withdraw it until the next stage. Where the purchase proceedings have been terminated without vesting in the tenant, and where the tenant has been paying payment in lieu of rent, it has happened in the County Wexford that the landlord subsequently took proceedings against the tenant for the recovery of the balance of rent which he alleged was due to him. That was a great injustice to the tenant who was granted his reduction in good faith and it seems to me that this is a loophole which the Land Commission should deal with. At any rate, we should not have the position that when the Land Commission, for some reason best known to themselves, and which the tenant could not possibly understand, decided to terminate the proceedings the landlord should suddenly pounce upon the tenant for a very large sum of money. There seems to be no way out of it, as the law stands at present.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy seriously proposes that I should introduce legislation for the purpose of meeting a case of that kind. After all, if a holding of land does not come under the Land Acts I do not see why I should be asked to introduce legislation for the purpose of enabling the tenant to evade his liabilities to his landlord.

Comment on this

Is the tenant evading his liability?

Comment on this

There are very few cases of that kind. I am sure the case cited by the Deputy is an exceptional one. In any event he is satisfied it is a type of case that cannot be covered by any section in this Bill. It would be obviously unfair. I think that it is quite apparent.

Comment on this

But suppose that through the neglect of the landlord he himself has not taken proceedings and allowed the matter to go on, and the landlord is receiving payment in lieu of rent for several years and then only establishes his claim, surely the very fact of his neglect to take these proceedings much earlier should estop him. I think we should provide for a case of that sort.

Comment on this

How do you suggest that we can provide for it?

Comment on this

By putting a limit to the period of years.

Comment on this

I do not think that this amendment can be accepted, because in the first place the landlord returned the number of tenants; some of them had judicial leases, others had not. But they came under the Land Commission for payment in lieu of rent. Afterwards, on the examination of the title and the leases of those tenants, it was found that some had judicial leases, and, therefore, they could then be vested. The others had not judicial leases, and were not vested. They did not come within the purview of the Land Act of 1923; they could not be vested. I do not think this Bill covers every case. There will be some exceptions still. The landlord had his right, and when those tenants were excluded from the Land Act of 1923 or the Land Act of 1927 there was no alternative but to go back to the other position, and then who would make up the loss? Was the landlord to suffer? Was the Land Commission to make up the loss to the tenant afterwards? Personally I do not see that they could. It is hard upon the tenant to have to make good the difference between the interest in lieu of rent and the non-judicial rent. If he could be brought in under the present Bill in any shape he would be satisfied, but that is beside the point at the moment. I do not see how the Parliamentary Secretary could accept this amendment.

Comment on this

I do not see what is to stop the Parliamentary Secretary from accepting it. The case he made is no answer. Nobody has made any case against the amendment. I quoted a case before about a court letting. If the Parliamentary Secretary would bring in an amendment on Report that would cover the case I have already quoted——

Comment on this

Oh, no. I was merely giving Deputies another opportunity to make up their minds as to what they really wanted.

Comment on this

We know what we wanted. I understood the Parliamentary Secretary asked to have the matter postponed so that he could find out what he wanted. If we were clear at the time that the Parliamentary Secretary had his mind made up and only wanted to know what we wanted we could have easily have settled the point. But even if that case were made right, the particular tenant whose case I quoted would be affected all the same, because he could not now possibly pay the difference between the rent due to the landlord and what he had paid in lien of rent. The difference amounted to £146. When the landlord found out from the Land Commission that this man did not come under the Land Act he sued the tenant for the difference which amounted to £146. The tenant is not able to pay that. The Land Commission offered themselves to take over the place from the landlord and give it to the tenant, but of course, the tenant cannot avail of that unless he puts up £146. How is a case of that kind to be got over? The tenant was paying interest in lieu of rent which he thought was his whole liability. The landlord was getting interest in lieu of rent which he thought was all that was due to him. He was quite satisfied until it came to the point when he found that this man did not come under the Land Act. Surely it is an injustice to put this man out of his holding because he cannot pay £146 to the landlord which the landlord never expected and probably does not want, but because the law is as it is, and the Land Commission do not want to be put to too much trouble about thinking out amendments of this sort, the Parliamentary Secretary is determined not to have a single comma altered in this Bill, and having the opinion that he has of himself and his department he thinks this House is not competent in any way to alter this Bill. Because of these things this man is to be put out of his holding and deprived of his living. We heard nothing at all against this amendment except that it is not necessary, and that Deputies are not serious. On almost every amendment the Parliamentary Secretary has said the Deputy who moved it had not read the section or taken it seriously. That is his attitude on every amendment. He has not dealt with any amendment on its merits, but always with the remark that the Deputy has not read the section or misunderstood it.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

May I ask under what head it was declared that this tenant did not come under the Act?

Comment on this

I explained that before. This holding at the time the 1923 Act was passed was held on a court lease, although his father and grandfather before him had been tenants of the place. At the time the 1923 Act was passed he held it on a court lease owing to a dispute.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

In a particular case?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I think the Parliamentary Secretary should accept this amendment. It is an important amendment, and there would be a grave injustice done to this man if the amendment is not accepted. Many cases will come up from time to time which the Land Commission will cover by the introduction of new legislation. This is a particular case, and we happened to come into possession of the facts a short time ago. A great injustice will be done to this man if the amendment is not accepted. This case has cropped up because two branches of the landlord's family had a dispute. This case was decided in court, and what was not foreseen or expected at the passing of the Land Act of 1923 happened. Were it not for that this case would not have cropped up at all. The position now is that this man is to be evicted or else to pay £150 arrears. In 1923 it was not definitely known who the proper owners were. It is only common justice to the tenant that this amendment should be accepted. I wonder what are we passing legislation for? Is it in the interests of the owners of the land or in the interests of the tenants? I think we are here to legislate in the interests of the tenants and not of the landlords.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

With regard to this particular case which was referred to already, it is quite possible that, although this amendment is meant to deal with a specific case, it might, at the same time, inflict great hardships in other cases. If this amendment were accepted and put into the Bill then it would apply to all cases, and not be limited to this individual's particular case. The difficulty might be met in another and better way. We discussed earlier in another amendment whether this class of case should be considered by the Land Commission as a continuation of a previous tenancy and then the terms of this Act would apply, whereby this question of looking for arrears would be done away with altogether.

Comment on this

It cannot be done away with.

Comment on this

I think this is not going to be an exceptional case. I know myself cases where persons in the position of landlords delayed in lodging particulars and taking proceedings to have certain holdings proved to be town parks. Suppose that the landlord should, to-morrow or the day after, take proceedings to prove that a particular holding is a town park, and suppose he succeeds in that? For the last eight years or so he has been receiving payment in lieu of rent, and now if he succeeds in proving the land a town park he will be able to follow up the tenant for the difference. I think the Bill should provide for stopping the landlord from getting anything more than he has got already.

Comment on this

It would appear that the amendment proposed in this case is one which is wrong in principle. The position of the landlord and tenant is one that is governed entirely by free contract between the parties, and, in the case of certain tenancies which existed at the passing of the Land Act of 1923, the Statute controls in certain cases the contract which existed between the parties. In this particular case which has been referred to by Deputy Ryan, apparently through an error on the part of the parties themselves, they considered that the 1923 Act applied, and that the Statute controlled their rights. It now transpires, and has transpired for some time, that the Statute has not controlled their rights. The effect of the amendment being carried is this, that it is a declaration by this House that in this or in any similar case the parties are resorting to their contractual rights which existed prior to the passing of the 1923 Act, but, by, as it were, a class of retrospective legislation, they are put on an equality, though they are outside the Act of 1923, with the tenants who are getting the benefit of that Act, an Act which in fact never applied to them.

Comment on this

With regard to what Deputy Finlay says, I do not know what the legal meaning of "free contract" may be, but I never understood that the contract between the landlord and the tenant was a free contract. Apart from that, it was not the tenant, but the landlord, made the mistake. He returned this tenant in the list of his tenants under the 1923 Act.

Comment on this

Surely Deputy Finlay will admit that ignorance of the law is not a plea that can be put up as an answer in any case, and if the landlord has neglected to conserve his rights he should not have any rights at all.

Comment on this

This tenant is entitled in a court of law to raise that as against his landlord in his claim for a return.

Comment on this

I think it is a wrong policy to have a matter of that kind decided in a court of law. It is a very obvious case.

Comment on this

There are two other cases which this amendment should cover. Take the case of a holding where the Land Commission may decide or have decided that the lands were substantially agricultural or pastoral. In these cases the landlord may go back to 1923. Since 1923 the tenants have got 25 per cent. reduction. It seems now from what Deputy Finlay has said that the landlord has the right to sue for arrears, though in fact he returned them in good faith in 1923. The Land Commission recently decided in the matter of the vesting of these holdings that they reverted back to their old status. Now the landlord has the right to collect his 25 per cent. In the case of holdings where they decided they were small holdings there was an additional 10 per cent.

Comment on this

There is no point in what Deputy Little has said, as town parks are not excluded from the Land Acts. Deputy Little should know that. The proposal is this, that the tenant of a holding excluded from the Land Acts should be treated in exactly the same way as the tenants coming under the Land Act of 1923. Is that the proposal?

Comment on this

When returned by the landlord.

Comment on this

Yes. I take it the landlord returned the tenant in the bona fide belief that he was a tenant to whom the 1923 Land Act applied. It was subsequently discovered that it did not apply to this particular holding. I think it ought to be clear to any Deputy that no Minister could introduce a Bill to cover a particular case of that kind where it has been determined judicially that it is not a holding coming under the Land Act of 1923, and consequently the tenant is not entitled to any of the benefits to which tenants coming under that Act are entitled.

Comment on this

Was not the error committed by the landlord in the first instance, and why should the tenant have to suffer for that? Why should not the landlord pay for his own error?

Comment on this

That is a matter between the landlord and his tenant.

Comment on this

We do not believe it is. We believe that the tenant should be protected by setting some limit to the period for which the landlord could have redress. I should not use the word "redress" because the landlord has no case. The mistake has been made by himself. What we are trying to do here now is to prevent this hardship. Take the case of the tenant here. My proposition is to meet that case. The tenant has to pay up all these arrears or be evicted. It is a definite hardship on the tenant and it is the landlord's fault. We want to protect the tenant. He should be protected by this amendment or by a definite limit being put to the period of time during which he can recover the difference between payment in lieu of rent and the old rent. I do not think that any reasonable argument can be put up against the equity of the case we are making. Our duty is to protect the people who are not able to protect themselves.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

It seems the tenant is suffering from two hardships. One, he is sued for the allowance he was getting, and the other, a greater hardship, that he does not come under the provisions of the Bill at all. Would it be possible to appoint a committee to go into the matter with the Parliamentary Secretary before the Report Stage? The tenant is the successor to his father and perhaps his grandfather and he is excluded from the provisions of this Bill. There may be some way out of this instead of passing this amendment which would entail hardships in another direction.

Comment on this

Let that be pointed out.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

It should not be passed because of that, and a way out might be found by a committee in consultation with the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey has not pointed out how there would be a hardship in other directions. As he said, in this particular case there is a double hardship. The tenant does not come under the terms of the original Act, and he is now being excluded from the provisions of this Bill. There are two definite hardships. We are dealing with one of them at the moment. They apply to more than to the individual mentioned by Deputy Dr. Ryan. We are anxious to protect all cases that may come under this heading, and they may frequently occur. The Parliamentary Secretary has said that this thing does not occur very often. We do not know, but we know that certainly it has happened in this specific case, and we want to provide against this happening in the future and, if possible, to make restitution in regard to the past in so far as we can. As far as Deputy Gorey's suggestion is concerned, there may be a class of case which could be dealt with in the way he suggests, but the attitude of the Parliamentary Secretary is, no matter what case of hardship we bring up here, because it is not in the Bill he is not going to listen to any amendment.

Comment on this

Take the case of an uneconomic holding excluded under the terms of the 1923 Act. I have in mind the case of a woman on the Reilly Estate in the vicinity of Finea. She has been brought up for arrears of rent, and the next thing will be that she will be evicted. If it is an uneconomic holding the 25 per cent. reduction plus the 10 per cent. should apply to it for all time. In fact, the landlord should pay her a subsidy for living in the holding, and for the rack-rents that she had paid in years gone by. There is no consideration for such tenants.

Dealing with the whole subject of reduction of rents, what the tenant looks at is not that at the end of 68½ years the land will be fee-simple, but the reduction that he will get after the land is vested. That is what this Bill is about. The hardship that is permitted under this Bill in the case of uneconomic holders, and that has been referred to by Deputy de Valera and other speakers, should not be allowed. Certainly, as I said, the reduction should obtain for all time. In fact, there should be no rent at all on these uneconomic holdings.

Comment on this

I should have said land suitable for building near a town. It was a slip on my part.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 49
·
Níl 67
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

Before we proceed to deal with the next business, may I mention that I made a suggestion before in connection with this matter and I hope that it may be acted on. My suggestion is that a small committee should consult with the Parliamentary Secretary to get over the difficulty where an obviously technical flaw has occurred to deprive the tenant of the benefits of the Act.

Comment on this

What small committee does the Deputy suggest?

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I would suggest Deputy Dr. Ryan and Deputy Allen. I would be willing to act if I could be of any help.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is a matter to be settled between the Deputies concerned. It could be settled privately, as the Parliamentary Secretary suggests.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section 1, after the word "necessity," line 8, to insert the words "and where the portion so sub-let is land to which Section 24 of the Land Act, 1923, as amended by this Act applies"

This is an amendment which we would like to see inserted as a safeguard. In Section 15 dealing with sub-tenancies which are now to be made separate holdings there does not seem to be a definite provision specifying that such tenancies shall be only tenancies to which the provisions of the Act of 1923 should apply. I propose to make it quite clear as to the kind of lettings to be allowed in. At present there is nothing to show the nature of sub-tenancies which the Land Commission in their discretion might allow in. They might allow in sub-tenancies in the nature of residential holdings held by professional men. We want to have some safeguard in regard to this. Perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary might accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I think that the Deputy will find that his point is covered by paragraph (d) of sub-section (1). The wording is different from that in the amendment but it covers the same point, and perhaps it covers it a little bit more effectively than the amendment. The clause is designed to cover the point in which the Deputy is interested.

Comment on this

Should the Land Commission not specify that the sub-letting should be agricultural?

Comment on this

There is no necessity.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (3), page 9, line 33, to delete the word "Land."

This is purely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

On the section I must protest against the non-inclusion in the section of a provision, as suggested by Deputy Derrig, to safeguard the person whose holding is not being vested. Even though it was indicated by Deputy Finlay that he could go in and make a case against the landlord, it puts an extraordinary amount of expense on him which could be avoided now. It was a beautiful sight to see the farmers' representative going into the Lobby and backing the landlord to enable him to recover 25 per cent. arrears of rent. It was also beautiful to see Independent Deputies backing up the landlord to mulct the tenant who does not come within the provisions of the Act.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (1), after the word "sub-tenant," line 42, to insert the words: "or at the option of the tenant to have deducted from the purchase price of the portion of the holding sold to him a sum equal to" and add at the end of the sub-section the words following: "and such sum shall be added to the purchase price of the portion of the said holding purchased by the sub-tenant."

This section deals with the mutual rights of the tenant and sub-tenant, and gives the tenant the right to recover arrears of rent that may be due to him by the sub-tenant. We simply would like to have the alternative method. I do not know whether it is now better or not, but it seems to me that it would avoid litigation, and that it would be an easier way out for both the tenant and the sub-tenant. We are moving to insert the words "or at the option of the tenant to have deducted from the purchase price of the portion of the holding sold to him a sum equal to," and to add at the end of the sub-section the words "and such sum shall be added to the purchase price of the portion of the said holding purchased by the sub-tenant." That is to say, in the same way as compounded arrears were added to the purchase price, to add the arrears of rent due by the sub-tenant to the tenant to the purchase price.

Comment on this

As I understand this proposal it would deduct the sub-tenants arrears from the purchase money going to the landlord and add it to the value of the intervening interests of the tenant. The Land Commission does not collect rent from the sub-tenant. The sub-tenant pays his rent direct to the tenant. Consequently the Land Commission is not in a position to know whether the sub-tenant is in arrear with his rent or not. The tenant may have paid his payment in lien of rent up to date, and it would be quite unfair to penalise the tenant because the sub-tenant is in arrear with his payment of rent In any event my difficulty is that I do not know whether the sub-tenant is in arrear or not. I have no means of ascertaining what the amount of arrears is, if any, which the sub-tenant may owe to the tenant. There is no machinery at my disposal to ascertain that.

Comment on this

Are the sub-tenants not set out in the landlord's list?

Comment on this

In no case?

Comment on this

They may be in some cases, but there is no obligation on him unless he knows them.

Comment on this

How has the Land Commission cognisance of sub-tenants?

Comment on this

Yes. They are discovered also in the course of inspections by our surveyors or inspectors down the country.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Parliamentary Secretary to consider the matter so as to bring in an amendment to make it compulsory on the landlord to reveal or to indicate sub-tenancies? It is a hardship on tenants as they may not be aware that they have to apply in this way. I understand that, as matters stand, the landlord is not compelled to give a list of sub-tenancies. If that is so, as I understood the Parliamentary Secretary to say, would he not consider the question of amending the Land Bill so as to make them provide these lists?

Comment on this

The landlord of course may not be aware of the existence of the sub-tenants at all.

Comment on this

Need not be aware?

Comment on this

In the majority of cases he would not be aware. He has no knowledge in many cases. These are sub-tenancies on tenanted holdings.

Comment on this

Does the Parliamentary Secretary suggest that the landlord need not be aware of these at all?

Comment on this

He may not be aware.

Comment on this

Are they valid without the landlord's cognisance?

Comment on this

The Deputy referred to the fact that the landlord did not return the sub-tenancies. I am replying to that by stating that the landlord, in the majority of cases, would not be aware of the existence of such tenancies. These are sub-tenancies on tenanted holdings — sub-tenancies created by his own tenants.

Comment on this

Is it possible to have these sub-tenancies valid without the cognisance of the landlord?

Comment on this

Of course, yes.

Comment on this

Will the sub-tenant become a tenant under the Land Commission?

Comment on this

Yes, and will pay an annuity direct to the Land Commission.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (1), page 9, after the word "rent" where it first occurs in line 42, to insert in brackets the words "(as reduced under section 23 of the Land Act, 1923)" and after the word "rent" where it secondly occurs in line 42 to insert in brackets the words "(as so reduced)" and in line 46, after the word "of" to insert the word "such."

This is purely a drafting amendment. It makes it quite clear that the sub-tenants are entitled to the 25 per cent. They pay rents in the same way as ordinary tenants and are entitled to that reduction.

Comment on this

I move:—

Before Section 17 to insert a new section as follows:—

"Where part of a holding has at any time prior to the passing of this Act been sub-divided or sub-let without the consent of the landlord in breach of a statutory condition affecting the holding or of any covenant or condition in the lease or agreement for letting of the said holding and any person is in actual possession pursuant to such sub-division or sub-letting the sub-division or sub-letting shall be deemed valid."

This is to cover a large number of cases which occur, I understand, in the West of Ireland, where the landlord's consent has not been given, which we were glad to hear from the Parliamentary Secretary a moment ago, is not necessary, but which lawyers say is necessary under the Land Purchase Code to make sub-tenancies valid where a sub-letting has grown up. It has been known as a sub-letting or sub-division for generations though the consent of the landlord is not available. The fact that the landlord's consent is not available should not be called in to deprive these people of the benefits of this section dealing with sub-tenancies. The condition of affairs is well known to Deputies in the West that you may have sub-tenants in possession of sub-divisions, or commonages, or various other rights which really are the landlord's legally, but to which from lapse of time and failure of the landlord to intervene the tenant could to a certain extent say he has a prescriptive right. We think in cases like that where the thing has, so to speak, gone by the board the fact that the landlord's consent is not there should not be sufficient to deprive these people of the benefits of this section.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

This amendment is aimed at manifest inconvenience in various parts of the country. There are many cases in which tenants have sub-let and have subsequently repudiated their own act in sub-letting and in many cases evicted a sub-tenant on the mere technicality that the sub-letting was void because the consent of the landlord to a breach of the statutory condition or to a covenant in the lease had not been obtained. From the observations of the Parliamentary Secretary in reference to amendment 36 it is possible that this evil is more widespread than was anticipated on these benches, because the Parliamentary Secretary stated that in most cases the landlord was not aware of the existence of these sub-tenancies. This is so in the majority of cases."

The Parliamentary Secretary has peculiar sources of information. He has the whole network of the Land Commission at his command and I am not surprised to hear that this is an injustice more widespread than we thought at the time we framed this amendment. I do hope that the veto of Deputy Gorey will not be imposed on this amendment. Remember probably in his own constituency and appended to these 150 acre farms of which he is so proud there are quite industrious sub-tenants who may not have gone through the whole legal routine in obtaining their sub-tenancies or sub-divisions. Deputy Gorey has dilated on the great burden it sometimes is to small sub-tenants to have to employ a solicitor or counsel as advocate. May I say that I agree with Deputy Gorey that in some instances that is a great burden?

Accordingly you find all through the country that small holders have tried to evade the hardship of the bill of costs by going to somebody and arranging a sub-letting, perhaps, in the forge while having their respective horses shod. The two of them treat it as an honourable arrangement until unfortunately there is a quarrel, or until the the sub-tenant seeks to assert his rights as a sub-tenant under the statute. Immediately he is told, "Oh give me possession, you are only a trespasser." I hope this will not be treated in a partisan spirit. It is an amendment that must tend to aid many citizens who sympathise with Deputies who sit on the Labour Benches. It will certainly help many who, if the Farmers' Party is a genuine Farmers' Party, sympathise with the Farmers' Party, and even who sympathise with those who sit on the benches opposite, who, though they may be more delighted to find themselves in association with the 150 acre farmers, do not at certain times disdain the aid of the small sub-tenant, who has in a rough and ready way carved out a little holding for himself from a Larger tenancy, although his title may not pass the scrutiny of the Land Commission or of the conveyancing counsel or solicitor. This amendment does not inflict any real hardship on anyone. It merely seeks to give full artistic effect to arrangements that have been treated as honourable, honest and straightforward throughout the country.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I do not know of any such tenancy as that to which Deputy Geoghegan refers. The position of sub-tenants is very adequately protected under the 1923 Act.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

Provided they are legally sub-tenants.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

There is no doubt about their position. If they are paying rent to the tenants they are sub-tenants. There is provision in the amendment where that was done without the consent of the landlord. That has reference to a breach of a statutory condition. I do not think there is such a holding. I have not heard of it. This amendment is drafted to deal with it. I think once a tenancy is created and is in existence for a certain period there are rights in the tenant. The rights of sub-tenants were well defined in the previous Act.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

I wonder would the Parliamentary Secretary endorse that statement. I move to report progress.

Comment on this