Land Bill, 1930—Third Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–170 of 545. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 29 of 1930 ›
The amendment deals with the question of sub-tenancies or sub-lettings which are in existence, where the consent of the landlord is not available and the tenants' or sub-tenants' title may be called into question. The Parliamentary Secretary stated yesterday evening that the absence of the landlord's consent did not render a sub-tenancy invalid. I do not know whether he adheres to that view or not. If that is so, and if the landlord's consent is not necessary, then there ought to be no objection at all to the amendment; obviously, it should be accepted. On the other hand, if the landlord's consent is necessary, as I understand it is, under the Land Purchase Code, I ask the House to accept the amendment, because there are large numbers of cases in the West of Ireland where persons in occupation of sub-lettings or sub-divisions have been there for generations, and it would be a great hardship if, through a technicality, that they had not got the title from the landlords, they were excluded from the benefits of Section 15 of the Bill dealing with sub-tenants.
Comment on this
Section 3, sub-section (1), of the Act of 1927 reads as follows:—
The tenant of a holding to which the Land Act, 1923, applies shall not, without the consent in writing of the Land Commission, sub-divide the holding, or sub-let the same or any part thereof, but it shall not be necessary for such tenants to procure the consent of the landlord to any sub-division or sub-letting or to any assignment of the holding.
It is perfectly clear from the wording of that sub-section that since 1927 the landlord has no power whatever to refuse his consent to a sub-division. That is entirely a matter for the Land Commission. If this amendment were accepted it would really mean the perpetuation of uneconomic holdings without any power in the Land Commission to prevent it. One of the primary objects of the Land Act of 1923 was the relief of congestion. This amendment, in my opinion, is in conflict with the object of the 1923 Act. It would mean, if passed, that the Land Commission would be obliged to recognise sub-letting in any part of the country. In other words, the Land Commission would be obliged to recognise all sub-lettings, and, as a result, uneconomic holdings created in any part of the country without their consent. The Land Commission have always exercised discretionary power, and I think Deputies will recognise that the Land Commission should exercise this power to prevent sub-letting, and thereby prevent the establishment of uneconomic holdings.
Comment on this
I think that statement does not meet the case. I think the argument that this amendment seeks to perpetuate uneconomic holdings is preposterous. What Section 3 of the Act says in sub-section (1) is:—
... the tenant of a holding to which the Land Act, 1923, applies shall not without the consent in writing of the Land Commission sub-divide the holding or sub-let the holding ... but it shall not be necessary for such tenant to procure the consent of the landlord to any sub-division" and so on.
But suppose that a holding has been sub-let or sub-divided for generations is this axe which fell when the 1927 Act was passed saying that such sub-division is not to take place, to rule out those people who have been in occupation of these sub-divisions for years antecedent to the Land Act of 1927 and of the Act of 1923? If Section 3 of the Land Act of 1927 means anything it means that after the passing of the 1927 Act proposed sub-tenancies will not be recognised unless the Land Commission has given its consent in writing. But to say that it shall hold in all cases even before the passing of the Act is extraordinary. Besides, I am not concerned with the aspect that the Parliamentary Secretary laid down. I have it from lawyers who have been dealing with these cases that the position is that in the court these people cannot take advantage of the Act without the landlord's consent. It is not that the landlords have refused their consent, but it is because the consent is not available, and as a result these tenants are excluded. If the Parliamentary Secretary is interested in these people and wants to abolish uneconomic holdings surely to goodness he cannot object to bringing them in under the present Bill now. This present Bill keeps them out altogether. Is the present attitude to keep them out altogether?
Comment on this
It does not matter when the sub-division was arranged. The Land Commission have still power to deal with sub-lettings, and it is clear that under the Bill no sub-letting can be created without the consent of the Land Commission. The Deputy knows that in this Bill sub-letting is dealt with in one section. It is perfectly apparent that the Land Commission must exercise discretion on this question of sub-letting because if the Land Commission have not discretion in this particular matter this sub-letting would go on to such an extent that this country would be confronted with another problem of congestion in the next 20 years. There must be discretion exercised by somebody, whether statutory or not, for the purpose of regularising this matter. The amendment proposed by the Deputy really makes it obligatory on the State to recognise sub-letting whenever it took place. It does not matter under what Act it took place. The Land Commission at present has power to deal with that problem, and I think the Deputy will admit that it is necessary that the Land Commission should continue to exercise that power.
Comment on this
This amendment is not like some of the other amendments. It deals with a particular case where a large number of persons are affected. The Parliamentary Secretary, as was pointed out yesterday evening, instead of showing any desire to meet these people or to try to keep them inside the Act, wants to avail himself of every opportunity to exclude them. That is simply what it amounts to. I cannot see that the difficulty of the Parliamentary Secretary cannot be got over by putting some limit as regards time. The landlord, of course, is not the Land Commission, and if the Parliamentary Secretary would like to look into the matter, it should be possible to arrange, while safeguarding the rights of the Land Commission, to meet the particular case we have in mind. I am not hide-bound in this matter at all. We have simply brought forward these amendments to deal with particular cases, and if the Parliamentary Secretary is prepared to discuss them and to meet us we are quite prepared to give way, but if the attitude is going to be taken up when a reasonable grievance is shown up here, where a large number of poor people are affected, that no effort is going to be made by the Department to meet us, then we shall only press the amendment to a division.
Comment on this
That is not the attitude of the Department. It is putting a false construction on the attitude of the Department. The Parliamentary Secretary has definitely stated that whether there were sub-lettings with or without the consent of the landlord it does not affect the right of the tenant. The only thing is whether the Land Commission will be forced in every case, whether it is desirable or not, to recognise sub-lettings as separate lettings. That is necessary, except we are going to change radically our policy of putting an end to congestion as far as possible. That principle must be upheld and discretion given to the Land Commission, except you want to revert to the old system and have congestion worse than ever. There is no proposal here to take away in any way rights from the tenants that they have. They have a perfect right to purchase except in some exceptional cases where sub-letting was brought down to a point of dividing three or four acres into two parts. It is necessary to leave the Land Commission some right. We need not assume that they will use their veto in every case of sub-letting, but they must be left a discretion.
Comment on this
I could not quite follow the Parliamentary Secretary's arguments in regard to this matter. In the first place, I would like to say that I am in thorough agreement with him on the question of the sub-division of holdings. I think there is no question at all about that, nor about what Deputy Gorey says, in regard to the inadvisability of having sub-divisions of holdings. I take it that this amendment refers to a particular kind of case where there was a sub-letting made years ago by the landlord. The amendment seeks to provide that that sub-letting should be recognised as valid, even though there was some provision in the original lease between the landlord and the particular tenant to say that there could be no sub-letting. Sub-letting has taken place without the cognisance of the landlord. As I understand the amendment, it only proposes that that sub-letting shall be deemed to be valid. If the Parliamentary Secretary says there is no question about it if the tenant can show that that is the case, of course that is a different matter, but Deputy Derrig has stated quite definitely that advantage has been taken of that to the detriment of the sub-tenant. It is a question of whether or not such sub-tenant can be dealt with under the Act. I cannot read into this that it forces the Land Commission to deal with the tenant if it does not wish to deal with him. It only goes to show that he is in fact a valid sub-tenant for the purposes of the Act if the Land Commission wishes to deal with him. In that case it should be looked into to see that such a case would be covered, and that a sub-tenant who would be a proper person to deal with under the Act would not be ruled out from the advantages of the Act by a mere technicality, by the fact that the sub-letting took place without the consent of the landlord, even though it was provided in the original agreement between the landlord and the tenant that he could not sub-let.
Comment on this
The difficulty in the mind of Deputy Gorey seems to be that it does not give the Land Commission sufficient powers to deal with sub-tenants of this kind who would also be tenants of uneconomic holdings. What it really does is to place the sub-tenant in the same position as an ordinary tenant of an economic holding. It gives him something that he can exchange for something else. There are a number of sub-tenants who have economic holdings, and these men would be very unfairly treated if they could not be dealt with as tenants.
Comment on this
I could give a case in point where a holding was sub-divided some thirty or forty years ago. The owner divided it between two sons, but the sub-division was never recognised by the landlord. Only one holding was returned to the Land Commission by the landlord, notwithstanding the fact that there are two separate tenancies. The difficulty arises in the fact that one of these tenants is in arrears of rent to the Land Commission. He is not paying his portion, and the Land Commission have taken proceedings against the tenant who is paying his share. They cannot recover from the other because he is not recognised as a tenant. The brother who is paying would be put in the position of having to take proceedings against his partner, which he does not like doing. Both places are held up. The Land Commission will not take the current rent from the man who is paying without getting the arrears on the other holding. I think it would be possible for the Parliamentary Secretary to look into a case like that and see if he could meet it.
Comment on this
I can assure the Deputy that I do not take any strong view on this matter, and that I only want to be satisfied that the discretionary power of the Land Commission is preserved. If it is not preserved, there would be a danger that promiscuous or wholesale uneconomic holdings would be created, and that we would be faced in the future with a new problem of congestion. Under the circumstances, perhaps, it would be better to leave the amendment over until the Report Stage, and meantime I will have an opportunity of considering it. I want to tell Deputy Derrig, however, that I intend to insist on the discretionary power of the Land Commission being preserved.
Comment on this
I move:—
In sub-section (1), after the word "made," both where it occurs in paragraph (a), page 9, line 63, and in paragraph (b), page 10, line 2, to insert in brackets the words "(other than so much of such advance as consists of the contribution of the State)," and in sub-section (2), page 10, line 12, before the word "amount," to insert the word "whole."
This is purely a drafting amendment, and has been introduced in order to ensure that the tenant shall not be called on to pay interest on sinking fund in connection with the State contribution to the purchase-money.
Comment on this
It has not been put down so much on behalf of the landlord as on behalf of the mortgagee.
Comment on this
I am not concerned with the merits of the amendment, but I know that it is out of order and that it cannot be moved.
Comment on this
I move in sub-section (1), after the word "case," line 8, to delete the word "one-tenth," and insert therefor the word "one-fifth."
Section 20 proposes to set up a system of guarantee deposits whereby the Judicial Commissioner on the application of the Land Commission may retain in land bonds out of the purchase-money such sum as he shall think proper, but not exceeding in any case one-tenth of such purchase-money. My amendment proposes to change one-tenth into one-fifth. A similar provision to this in regard to the guarantee deposit is found in the Land Act of 1885, the Ashbourne Act, Section 3. The amount retained there was one-fifth of the advance. I think that in view of the fact that there is a certain discretionary power and that there is no proof, so far as we can see, that one-tenth of the money will cover the items mentioned in sub-section 4, one-fifth ought to be put in. That does not necessarily mean that one-fifth will be retained, but that an amount up to one-fifth may be retained. In the case of small estates it is doubtful whether one-tenth would be sufficient. In any case, as regards estates which have been held over and not dealt with under previous Acts, I think that the House should have the safeguarding of the State in view and should not scruple to hold as large a guarantee deposit as would seem to be reasonable to cover all outstanding adjustments.
Comment on this
It is quite true, as Deputy Derrig has stated, that one-fourth of the purchase money was retained as a guarantee deposit under the Ashbourne Act of 1885, but it was retained for an entirely different purpose, namely, as security for the payment of the tenants' annuities. In this Bill the deposit is retained only for the purposes mentioned in Section 20. The Deputy is aware that the payment of annuities is secured under the guarantee fund. I am satisfied that 10 per cent. is adequate for our purpose. The matter has been investigated with the greatest possible care, and an exhaustive examination made of a large number of typical estates revealed the fact that the percentage varies in some cases from one to seven per cent., and that in others there is no variation, and the average percentage of error is 4. Thus we are allowing ourselves a wide margin when we give the Judicial Commissioner discretion to retain one-tenth of the purchase money. I am satisfied that it is quite adequate for our purpose.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy Derrig that it should be one-fifth. Take, for instance, the cases which I brought forward here last night, and in which a refund will have to be given to the tenants if they succeed in their claim before the Judicial Commissioner. I do not think that in those cases their rights would be covered by one-tenth, seeing that one-tenth, at any rate, would only be the amount due to them from this time forward and that they would have no guarantee from 1923 to 1931. They have been overpaying 10 per cent. from 1923 to 1931, and they would not be covered by one-tenth.
Comment on this
I move:—
"In sub-section (2), after the word `thereof,' line 12, to insert the words `in whole or in part.' "
It seems to me that there is a slight omission in sub-section (2) as it stands. The sub-section says that the guarantee deposit may be paid out. I want to make it quite clear that it may be paid out in part or in whole. I do not think that the sub-section as it stands covers that point, namely, that it may be paid out from time to time in part.
Comment on this
I do not think that the Deputy's amendment will really make the section any clearer, but would rather prevent the guarantee deposit being made available if any part of it were released. The section provides that the guarantee deposit shall be paid to the person entitled thereto less the amount retained for the specific purposes mentioned in the Bill. The amendment really means that the guarantee deposit may be paid out in part. That really to a certain extent defeats the object of the section— namely, that the deposit shall be retained in whole until such time as the Land Commission is satisfied that no claims will be made against it.
Comment on this
I move:—
To add at the end of sub-section (2) the words "no such deposit shall be retained for more than two years after the appointed day."
We have all heard a lot about the slowness of the Land Commission, and it is hardly fair to allow them unlimited time to retain these deposits. I think they should be bound by some time, either two or five years, so that we may know exactly where we are.
Comment on this
I do not think that the amendment can be accepted in view of the fact that the Land Commission is so slow in dealing with these cases. It would rule out those who would be entitled to the 10 per cent. Very few cases have been heard. Owing to the fact that the Judicial Commissioner is all-powerful, I do not see how they can deal with those cases at all. If Deputy Cole is anxious to get this amendment inserted he should support me in eliminating the powers of the Judicial Commissioner.
Comment on this
Is it not the position that although the guarantee deposit is retained, the people whom Deputy Cole has in mind will be getting interest on their money, so that there will not be any real injustice done to them?
Comment on this
I disagree altogether with the terms of the amendment. There would be no necessity for having a guarantee fund if it was not required to meet some risk, and a period of two years is too short to get over any risks there may be. I quite agree that there should be some period but, side by side with that there should be a period fixed after which no claims to the estate would be legal. The two periods should be the same. I would say that a ten year period would be reasonable. I would also suggest that a clause should be inserted providing that after that time no other claims to this estate would be entertained. It might be, perhaps, necessary to prolong the period further than ten years, inasmuch as there may be minors who are only just born now who would not be able to make a claim until they reached the age of twenty-one. It is a joke to suggest, if there is to be a guarantee fund at all, that the guarantee fund should be distributed after three years. The State and the ratepayers want to be protected. I quite agree that people do not come into the possession of an estate as, for instance, you would rob a bank or rob a heifer and sell it at a fair somewhere at a distance. Deputy Corry will bear me out in the statement that you could not do it as you could rob a bank.
Comment on this
The Deputy can address his own late Party. They know more about it than we do. A member of their Party was tried for it.
Comment on this
I was alluding to a member of Deputy Gorey's Party who was tried and convicted for robbery.
Comment on this
I think it would be quite admitted, even by Deputy Cole, that the State would have no protection at all if this guarantee fund were distributed after two years. There is no use in having a guarantee deposit if it is going to be distributed at the end of two years. Another point is that there will have to be a separate fund in respect of each estate. It is not a common fund. Each fund will have to be a separate fund dealing with a particular estate, and it is not the amount of money that is in question. I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary not to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
Deputy Cole in this and other amendments has shown his anxiety for the landlords. I wonder is he representing the views of the people who have elected him? Nobody has shown keener interest in the vesting of estates than the people in his constituency, the small farmers in the North. He is apparently more concerned with the welfare of the landlord. I wonder has he consulted his constituents before doing that?
Comment on this
My constituents will be able to look after me for anything I do here, if it is any information to the Deputy. I think if the time were extended to five years it would meet the case, but there should be some limit so that we would know exactly where we are.
Comment on this
Deputy Nolan apparently is suffering from an antijudicial commissioner complex, like some Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches who are suffering from an anti-landlord complex and who will avail of every opportunity to show it.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Cole does not press the amendment seriously. It would be quite impossible to fix a time limit. In any event the landlords are treated very well under this section. They are getting interest, as Deputy Derrig stated, on the moneys retained as a guarantee deposit, a privilege which they never enjoyed before. I do not think that the landlords would be prepared to press for a time limit in cases of this kind.
Comment on this
I move:
In sub-section (4), page 11, after paragraph (b), to insert a new paragraph as follows:—
"(c) moneys payable under this Act to the Land Commission in repayment of moneys paid by the Land Commission for interest and sinking fund on so much of the land bonds redeemed as were issued for the contribution of the State to the standard price of a holding."
This is purely a drafting amendment; it provides for the recoupment to the Land Commission Vote of certain moneys paid out.
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary say if he could deal with such cases as embankments broken by tidal waves, embankments such as are found on the Sheehy minor estate?
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary tell us exactly what amendment 43 means? "On so much of the land bonds redeemed." How "redeemed"?
Comment on this
Why is it necessary for the Land Commission to utilise the deposit for this purpose?
Comment on this
It is in respect of embankments. These are land bonds only in respect of a State contribution to the standard price.
Comment on this
I move amendment 44:
In sub-section (4) paragraph (c), page 11, line 31, after the word "on" to insert the words "or to be retained by the Land Commission for."
I think this covers Deputy Derrig's amendment.
Comment on this
With reference to amendment 46, in the name of Deputy Derrig, the matter contained in it was raised yesterday on an amendment to Section 9, and the amendment to Section 9 was postponed pending a decision on amendment 46. The point involved is whether amendment 46 will create a charge on public funds. I have given a good deal of consideration to the amendment, and I am not satisfied that it would create a charge on public funds. I have decided that the amendment can be moved to enable the House to come to a decision on it.
Comment on this
I move amendment 46:
In sub-section (4) to add a new paragraph as follows:—
"Any moneys paid by the tenant of a holding as payment in lieu of rent in excess of the standard purchase annuity of the holding which said moneys shall be paid to the tenant or deducted from any standard purchase annuity due by him."
We had a long discussion on a previous amendment to Section 9, namely Amendment No. 5, to which this was stated to be consequential. This amendment simply asks that part of the guarantee deposit fund as well as meeting the moneys that are to be payable under sub-section (4) of Section 20, as it now stands, should also be available for repayment to the tenant in whatever manner may be determined of whatever sum he has paid as payment in lieu of rent in excess of his standard purchase annuity. If this provision is accepted I think it is quite clear that it will not impose a charge upon the State. It provides the moneys which will have to be found to recoup the tenant for what he has overpaid. The money will be found in the guarantee deposit fund. We simply want to have a provision by which the Land Commission would be enabled to fix the appointed day in August, 1928, for example, a period which we consider very reasonable, allowing five years during which the work of vesting should have been done, and then recouping the tenant for the work he has done.
The only way in which it is suggested that this amendment was out of order was that the State would have to find the money. As Deputy de Valera pointed out yesterday if the House thinks that there would be an injustice, and that the State to some extent has profited—or, at any rate, has been responsible for the unfair treatment tenants have been subjected to—the State should come in. Of course, that is chiefly a matter for the Government. From our point of view our amendment is quite clear, and I think nobody can contend that it imposes a charge on public funds. In drafting the amendment we had to put it in its present form, to put it in order, but in moving it I may say we were quite aware of the fact that the State had its responsibility in the matter. That is a matter we, in opposition, are not competent to deal with, and we ask the House to take steps, since the machinery is there, to see that sufficient money is withheld until this restitution is made.
Comment on this
I understand from the Deputy's argument that a sum of £269,000 was the sum that the tenants paid in excess. I think Deputy Derrig in moving the amendment now suggests that this money should be supplied out of the Deposit Guarantee Fund, which to my mind, is simply saying this. He asks the Government to repudiate a bargain that was made with regard to the land bonds. That is the usual way of Fianna Fáil in recovering or finding money.
Comment on this
We are glad to see unmasked here by degrees the landlords' party in the Dáil. Deputy Mathews is very anxious that the tenants should bear the losses. He is definitely agreed that during the past three years the sum of £260,000 odd has been taken out of the pockets of the tenants by a combination of circumstances for which the tenant was not responsible, the combination of circumstances being the abnormal delay on the part of the Land Commission in vesting the holdings, and the fact that a large number of landlords whose rights have been so well protected by the Government have, in fact, no title to the land or at least could not prove sufficient title to enable vesting. We have a special protection party here for the landlords consisting of Deputy Mathews, Deputy Cole and their able assistant Deputy Gorey.
Comment on this
If Deputy Gorey or his new leaders in this matter think it fair for the tenants of the Free State to be robbed out of £130,000 practically per annum in the past two years, I am glad that there is at least some party in the House which is prepared to protect the tenants, and I look to the Parliamentary Secretary and his leader, the Minister, to see that the tenants are protected in this House against individuals who here form a very small minority and who after all should not be allowed to force legislation here to rob the unfortunate tenants of the Free State. It is time it ended. We are only looking for bare justice. The Minister when introducing his Bill said that the last of these tenants would be vested within five years. If anyone doubts that statement let them go and prove it for their edification. We are aware that those statements are not made on "spec," but why should the tenants be the only individuals to suffer for a landlord having a bad title? I am sure that the Land Commission even on that bad title have seized cattle, and evicted tenants throughout the country.
Comment on this
I am confining myself solely to the argument that the tenants are entitled to the 10 per cent. They are entitled to their just rights and no more. What we want is to get back for them what was stolen by a combination consisting of Land Commission officials and landlords with bad titles. That is all there is in the amendment. I am glad that at length the landlord party in this House have been unmasked, and that we see who is responsible for the robbery committed on the unfortunate tenants in the Free State during the last five or six years. That party are unmasked now, and we know the gentlemen who came here in the guise of leaders of the Farmers' Party, who brought in amendments that even the Minister in charge of the Bill could not tolerate. The amendments were to the effect that in every single case, going back for five years, the tenants were not to be entitled to the reductions they got prior to the introduction of the Bill. Deputies who came here as leaders of the Farmers' Party came forward with amendments to rob the unfortunate tenants whom they were supposed to represent. I am glad that the whole situation has been opened up, and that the farmers of the Free State will be able to see these people in their true colours.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, I would like to be allowed to correct the Deputy, as I do not want my position to be misunderstood. I am a tenant, and my sympathies are with the tenants. Deputy Corry stated that there was a party here for the protection of landlords. I think that is a wrong description. If the Deputy had stated that there was a party in this House against the repudiation of contracts it would be a truer definition of anything I said.
Comment on this
Reference has been made to the Land Act passed here and to the amendments that were put up.
Comment on this
I have a distinct recollection of what occurred although I have not the Official Report here now. Amendments were put up specifying that any abated rent operating up to a certain date should be the basis of purchase. Anything to the contrary is a falsehood. That must be known to anyone with sufficient intelligence to know the meaning of plain words.
Comment on this
I hope so. I never had any sympathy with anybody occupying the position of a landlord. The record of my life proves that. Every word I utter and every action I took goes to prove it. There are no tenants alive in Kilkenny, and no people dead, who shuddered at the name of Gorey as they did at the name of Corry in Cork. They all remember the name Gorey, but when Deputy Corry makes these statements he must be seeing the ghosts of two generations, his father's and his own.
Comment on this
The Deputy must be seeing the ghosts of dogs, the only things he has ever been associated with.
Comment on this
You would want to cure your own bagún first. The delay in vesting in the past was not the fault of the tenants. Neither can it be said that it was the fault of the vendors. If there was any fault at all it was the fault of the machinery that was set up by the State for which we, and the people, are responsible, and no one else. I am not going to discuss whether the period that has elapsed was a reasonable period or not, or whether the vesting should have taken place earlier, considering the magnitude of the problem. The promises that were made in 1923 were not the promises of the landlords. It must be remembered that the promises were made to the landlords and the tenants alike. The landlords were guaranteed certain payments, which they are entitled to recover and which cannot be taken from them. They are entitled to these payments by law.
It is now proposed to set up a fund for another purpose out of which to pay for the delay that took place in vesting. No court would sustain a claim like that. If such a claim were made in the law courts the verdict would be against it. I say that although I am not a lawyer. If the tenant is to be asked for recoupment, it would be necessary to look elsewhere than to the vendor for the money. The vendor has been fixed in his rights by an Act of this House, and if there is any liability at all it is a liability of the State. I would be delighted with this proposal, as I would be one of those who would benefit considerably. I have no objection to it if it can be done legally. At present I see no possibility of its being done at all. The landlords' rights are there, and they are guaranteed in the Constitution, so that it is futile to talk about this amendment, or to suggest that the money could be recovered from another source. Unless public funds are provided it cannot be done otherwise.
Comment on this
President Cosgrave and Deputy Gorey may get behind little points of order in this House and say that they cannot do anything for the people who were promised vesting within a short time. Those to whom these fair promises were made will want to get some other reasons than points of order as to why the tenants are going to be robbed of the excess payment they made.
Comment on this
That is what I said, that this is a liability of the State.
Comment on this
We are prevented by points of order, which President Cosgrave pleaded yesterday, from putting in amendments that the State and the landlords should bear their share, but that the tenant should not be asked to pay for the robbery that has been practised upon him. Deputy Mathews talked about the repudiation of bargains. What about the bargains that Cumann na nGaedheal made with the people in the different elections? Are they going to repudiate these bargains? When the Minister for Agriculture was putting through the 1923 Act he promised the people that vesting would be complete within a year. Then they came along in the 1927 election and they made a bargain with the people that if they got in they would complete the bargain. There is no talk from Deputy Mathews about the repudiation of that and other bargains which Cumann na nGaedheal made with the people.
Comment on this
Deputy Mathews to-day has pious hopes and sympathy, as he said, for the tenants, but the Cumann na nGaedheal interests are with the landlords. That is the secret of the points of order being raised to prevent us making restitution to the tenants who are being robbed. We are prevented by points of order from asking that the State should bear portion of the charge. If it comes to this, that we are prevented by points of order from making efforts to solve the question, if it all boils down to the question whether the landlords are going to pay this £269,000 or whether the tenants are going to pay it, we have to ask ourselves which of the two is best able to bear it. We believe that the landlords are best able to bear it, and as we have to make up our minds on this issue, we are prepared to say that the landlords should pay, and that the tenants who have been robbed of this £269,000 should have restitution made to them by the House. The President and Deputy Gorey and the others cannot get away from this, that the tenants for the last few years have made excess payments amounting to £269,000. We want that paid back to the tenants. We believe the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies and most of the Deputies who represent the farming community have made a bargain with their constituents that they will stand for fair play for them, and that is a bargain they should not repudiate.
Comment on this
Deputy Mathews contended, in his opposition to this amendment, that he spoke for the tenants. There are tenants and tenants. I contend that he spoke for the tenant that goes over the £3,000 valuation, the particular type of tenant we have in County Meath who has reduced the county to a wilderness; the tenant with 1,000 or 2,000 acres who, in some cases, has a landlord over him. Deputy Mathews speaks for that kind of tenant, for the people who have made County Meath the El Dorado of the Minister for Agriculture, the place on which he models the rest of Ireland, and his policy is to bring every county in Ireland to the condition where prosperity is counted in heads of cattle and not in human beings. That is the particular type that Deputy Mathews speaks for, the particular type of tenant who "hobnobs" with the aristocracy, moryah, at races and other social events. He does not speak for the small uneconomic holder in North Meath, to whom a shilling is more than one hundred pounds to the particular type he represents. I hope Deputy Mathews when he goes to North Meath will explain his opposition to this amendment to the small tenants there.
Comment on this
I should like to hear the Parliamentary Secretary make a case against the amendment. This state of affairs is entirely due to the failure of the legislative machinery, to the failure of the vesting clause in the Act of 1923. Because of that certain wrong has been done which is very widespread. The Parliamentary Secretary thinks no wrong has been done, but if there are people who have been paying in excess of what they should pay if the legislative machinery worked properly, there is clearly a wrong done to somebody. If there is a wrong done to somebody, somebody has gained. I do not presume to follow the intricacies of the minds of lawyers who shake their heads when I say that. I am merely a layman. Nobody can say that I am endeavouring to discuss this on Party lines or on anything but lines of common sense and fair play, when I say that if the legislative machinery was working properly people would have got a reduction of ten per cent., and if they have not got that reduction there is a wrong done. It is the duty of this Assembly to remedy wrongs of that kind. The tenant who has been paying this for a number of years has had to stand his ground against many things that occurred in that period, such as the disorganisation of markets, and so on. He had to meet these demands while the landlord's income was certain during that period, and did not fluctuate. If there is no legislation at present to remedy that wrong, I suggest it is the duty of this Assembly to remedy it and pass legislation that will empower the Government to withhold this from whoever has got away with the spoil, and to compensate the people who have suffered. A good many people have suffered during that period who could not afford to suffer and who cannot afford to suffer now, and there should be some remedy by which they would be compensated for this loss.
Comment on this
I have been listening to this debate with a very open mind. When a moment ago Deputy Hogan saw me shaking my head at one of his remarks it was not, I assure him, in any excessive subtlety. What I was dissenting from was merely this proposition, which was put forward I am certain in perfectly good faith, and which was put forward yesterday by Deputy de Valera and others, what at first sight does seem a perfectly obvious thing, that when there is a loss there must also be a gain; that certain people lost, therefore, that somebody else—either the State or the landlord or both—must have gained. That was the position put forward by Deputy de Valera yesterday.
Comment on this
In this sense there is a loss, that the tenants whose vesting has been delayed have no doubt paid more than they would have paid if they had been vested before now. That is not an admission on my part. It is a perfectly obvious fact, a small piece of arithmetical fact. Unfortunately the corollary which the Deputy draws is really not sound. It is, unfortunately, true in this wicked world that one man's loss is not always another man's gain. The world is so situated that it is quite possible to have a state of affairs in which everybody is losing. That sounds curious, but I think it is true. I am not sufficiently acquainted with the working of the finances of this Act to know whether it is true that in any sense the State gained through the delay. I do not personally think that it can have. I suppose it may have gained to some small extent indirectly in income tax, but I cannot think of any other way. It certainly must have lost at least a corresponding amount in the lengthening of the land purchase processes and the consequent continuous expenditure on the Land Commission itself. I am quite sure from what I have heard that the landlords as a class have not gained. It is quite true, as Deputy Hogan pointed out, that the landlords have presumably got the difference of ten per cent. between the amount paid in lieu of rent and the amount of land bonds would have brought in, whatever that may be. It is a little difficult to calculate, because it is a question of what you can sell and invest your land bonds for.
I assume for the moment that there was a certain gain there, but this should by no means be considered a net gain. In many cases, in consequence of the delay, owners were put to very great expenses; they had to take legal advice of various kinds and they were put to the cost of agent services, rental rate and estate offices, and in a thousand and one other ways they incurred expense. I speak neither as a tenant's nor a landlord's advocate, but I am quite sure that balanced against the difference in the money they receive the balance would be, for most of them, on the wrong side. I know this is a fact, and it is probably within the knowledge of other Deputies in the House that the owners have been complaining bitterly quite as much as the tenants of the delay. Cases have come to my own knowledge where people came to me and said: "Can you not try and get my estate through. I want to get finished with it and to pay off all my charges and to invest my money and be done with the business." I think these are considerations that the House ought to bear in mind when it comes to sum up on this matter.
If it was true that there was anybody who got away with the loot, then I say by all means let us see if we cannot get after it and recover it. My own belief is that there is no such thing. So far as the law is concerned, whatever Act has been passed can be changed by this House. But if there are questions of justice and equity, even at the risk of being called a landlords' man I say that we ought to do justice to all categories of our citizens and we ought not to do injustice under any misapprehension.
Comment on this
May I ask, as Deputy Law objects to that most grossly improper and unpleasant phrase, "getting away with the loot," where has this £269,000 gone to? Who has got it?
Comment on this
I know nothing of the particular figure, but, taking that figure as given, and assuming for a moment that such a figure is involved, I presume a large proportion of that undoubtedly has gone to the landlords as representing the 10 per cent. difference between the payment in lieu of rent and the annuity, but it does not follow by any means that the whole of that goes into the landlords' pocket. I do not know how much of it has gone to the landlords, but let me assume that a large part of it has gone to them, say two-thirds, I suggest that as against that you will find that the expenses of one sort or another to which the landlord has been put, and the loss that is entailed upon him by being prevented from winding up his business, clearing off his charges, dispensing with solicitors and agents, has been quite as much as he got, taking the class as a whole and not as individuals.
Comment on this
The plain meaning of that is that in Deputy Law's previous speech he was talking at random and did not know anything about what he was talking of, and did not take the trouble to inquire what the figures were. He just at first took up the phrase to which he objects, "getting away with the loot," and then he starts in and says: "I do not know anything about it."
Comment on this
If there is this £269,000, then it is the landlords that have got away with the loot.
Comment on this
I tried to understand the Deputy, but could not understand his first rambling statement, but his explanation that it was a rambling statement I did understand.
Comment on this
There is no doubt but there has been a loss to the tenants. The tenants expected to be vested a long time ago according to the Minister for Agriculture when he said that they would be all vested in about five years. I do not understand this amendment even now; I do not think it could be made good. Take the landlords who got land bonds in the last twelve months, how are you going to get after these? My whole contention is, and I am definite in that, that it is the superiority complex of the individual that is all-powerful in this Bill that is responsible for the delay. He comes into it fourteen times. If this Bill is to go through and become an Act with the same conditions that are in it, then, instead of the Minister being able to delete the words "Judicial Commissioner" where they are found, there is no doubt but that the Judicial Commissioner will delete from Deputy Roddy the words "Parliamentary Secretary."
Comment on this
Yes, on amendment 46 to Section 20. Who is responsible for all that? I read a letter last night and I may read it again now, or a portion of it.
Comment on this
The Deputy will have to address himself to what is contained in amendment 46, and will have to confine himself to that amendment.
Comment on this
I bow to your ruling absolutely, but if I was out of order Deputy Morrissey was a good deal more out of order last Friday in discussing the butter tariff.
Comment on this
I confess I could not exactly see the force of Deputy Law's argument. He seemed to imply that the money vanished into thin air. £269,000 is not a sum that will go into nowhere without anyone trying to get after it, if I may put it that way. Undoubtedly the one thing the tenant purchasers are aware of, particularly those who are not vested, is that it has gone out of their pockets. If it has gone out of their pockets somebody has reaped the benefit. The landlord has reaped the benefit to the extent of £7 5s. 3d. per £100 of the standard price—no inconsiderable benefit to the landlord. In addition to that, arising out of the Land Act of 1923, he has had other indirect gains. If it was not for the Act of 1923 I wonder how many landlords would be able to collect their rents even at the cost of 25 per cent. of their gross income. If the landlord had to use that 25 per cent. in order to secure his rents, at any rate he secured his rents. They were collected for him by the State, not only rents for the current year but also the arrears. I think he was very lucky to get away with the small loss of 25 per cent. of the nominal loss.
The real point is whether the tenant who, either because the State has been dilatory or that the landlord has been dilatory in clearing up matters of title, has had to bear the cost of the present arrangement should be compelled to bear it any longer. No members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party are prepared to say that the landlords are in fault. Then they must admit that it was the Land Commission that was in fault. If it was the Land Commission that was in fault then we submit from these benches that it is the duty of the Government to make good to the unvested tenants the amounts they have lost. The State has been the gainer, because if the land had been vested it would have issued land bonds earlier, and it would have to pay interest on the ten per cent. bonus every year since 1923.
In view of that, it appears to us that there is a clear case in equity for compensating the tenants for the losses they have endured during the past five years. For that reason we are putting the amendment to the House, and we hope the Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies who would like to do justice to the unvested tenants, if they cannot see their way to follow us into the division lobby, that at least they will bring private pressure to bear on the Parliamentary Secretary to have the principle of this amendment accepted.
Comment on this
The main objection urged by certain Deputies to this amendment is that Fianna Fáil are pursuing their evil course of repudiating contracts. Assuming that there is a contract between the State and the people on the one side, and the landlord on the other, in 1923, which I entirely deny, I think it is a most fallacious idea. But granting, for the sake of argument, that there was a contract in 1923 by which the land of this country was to be acquired on certain terms, a breach of that contract was committed, not by the mover of this amendment but by the draftsman and the introducer of this Bill. One would think that, on listening to Deputy Gorey or Deputy Law or Deputy Mathews, that it was we suggested that there should be an inroad on the landlords' purchase money. The Land Act of 1923 did not say that one-tenth of the landlords' purchase money could be withheld, but this Bill, as introduced here, by this Section 20 breaks that contract, if such a contract ever existed, because it provides that there is to be docked off the landlord's purchase money ten per cent. It provides how that ten per cent. is to be expended: It says, for instance, that part of it is to be expended—I am now reading the Bill as printed and not some fantastic Fianna Fáil amendment —Section 20 provides that part of this is to be spent or so much of it "on the repair or maintenance of embankments or other works as the Judicial Commissioner shall under this Act order to be repayable to the Land Commission by a person to whom the purchase money or any part thereof has been paid." No such right as that was conferred by the Act of 1923——
[Professor Thrift took the Chair.]
Comment on this
It is a curious thing that when something wild has to be said it is always said on the other side by an irresponsible person.
Comment on this
Irresponsible to the extent of having put the provision into the 1923 Act.
Comment on this
I suppose I might be pardoned if I were to adopt a slightly aggressive or offensive tone towards the Parliamentary Secretary, who is responsible for this Bill. But I would not be so grossly offensive to the Parliamentary Secretary as to make the suggestion that has been made from his own benches by Deputy Gorey —that the Parliamentary Secretary has foolishly introduced into this Bill a provision conferring power that already exists. Surely we must impute some talent to the Parliamentary Secretary and to the staff who assisted him. Yet it is suggested by Deputy Gorey that he solemnly puts in a section merely for the fun of printing it, giving a power that already existed in the Act of 1923.
I do not think I need waste very much time in trying to convince the House that the Parliamentary Secretary has not introduced a mere redundant provision. This guaranteed deposit created under the Minister's Bill is something new. One-tenth has been taken off. Destinations are found for that one-tenth other than the landlords' pockets. If there is this contract, this money should go into the landlords' coffers, but it is now provided that one-tenth comes off. This amendment proposes that in addition to the three destinations provided for under the sub-sections (a), (b), (c) of this section, there is to be a fourth one, making some sort of recompense to the tenants. We are told: "Oh, we should do justice." After all, is that doing more than begging the question? We are trying to do justice. It has been fairly well established now that a sum of £269,000 has left the pockets of the tenants of Ireland that would have remained in those pockets if the promise that was given in 1923 to have the tenants vested by 1928 had been carried out. The tenants have lost that sum of money. Tears are shed by Deputy Mathews about the landlords, the terrible thing it would be to go to the landlords for this money. Deputy Law says that the landlords are moaning because of this delay. I wonder could Deputy Law state exactly, what I can only state in a rough way, how much would the landlord have lost if he had received his bonds in 1924 or 1925?
The bonds have been constantly appreciating since then. The bonds have almost reached par. The landlord's position, like good wine, seems to have matured with age. The landlord gets his bonds now and he can sell those bonds now on the Stock Exchange on much more favourable terms than the landlords who got those bonds earlier. But what about the tenants? Can anybody suggest that this delay is affecting the tenants otherwise than detrimentally? The question has been raised: Who is to blame? If we try to fix that by a process of elimination, the tenant certainly is not to blame in the legal sense. He may be to blame in a wider sense for his fatuity in putting into office people who treat him like he has been treated, but that is another matter. The tenant could have done nothing to expedite the vesting of the land. Whether the landlord is to blame or not is left a mystery. When it suits the Parliamentary Secretary or whatever Minister speaks from the Government Benches we are told that one of the great causes of the delay is that the landlord did not furnish his title.
Comment on this
If I have misrepresented the Parliamentary Secretary I wish unreservedly to withdraw. I did gather, in the course of the debate, that the Parliamentary Secretary or the Minister had suggested that there was difficulty about the titles.
Comment on this
Then I wish to withdraw entirely what I have said in that connection. At all events, I need not withdraw what I have said, that the tenant is in no way to blame. Is the State to blame? If the State is to blame, while we may not have the power here to put the burden on the shoulders of the State, the Minister for Finance has the power to initiate such procedure, and possibly has done so already, because there is a financial resolution in aid of this Bill on the Paper. If that financial resolution, as it stands, is not enough to make reparation to the tenant from the State, if the State is the proper person to make reparation, it is only a matter of draughtsmanship to bring the financial resolution into such shape as will enable that reparation to be made. At first glance, certainly the State would seem to be to blame. What reason was behind that? The method of vesting that is in this Bill now is not even in the Act of 1923. I suggested on the Second Reading debate that the omission of such machinery as we now find in this Bill from the Act of 1923 was absolutely inexcusable. The Government in 1923 passed a compulsory land purchase scheme. They departed from the voluntary method of vesting that was appropriate to the voluntary scheme and necessary when the voluntary scheme was totally out of tune with this scheme. For that reason I would suggest that the State was to blame. Perhaps there may be an indication from the Parliamentary Secretary or from the Minister for Finance that the State, if to blame, will take some steps to remedy the wrong that has been done. However, it is not a question of sympathy or anything like that. We say that the tenants undoubtedly have suffered wrong to the extent of £269,000 when the Government departed from the 1923 arrangement by creating this 10 per cent. fund, and that it is perfectly fair and perfectly defensible to apply that fund towards making this reparation.
A red herring has been pulled across the track by suggesting that there is no pooling. What need is there of pooling? Out of a small estate there will be a small percentage; there will be only a small reparation to make if the estate is small. If the estate is large there will be a large deduction from that particular estate, but quite sufficient to finance the requisites of that large estate. The fact that there is no pooling I think need not give this House a great deal of difficulty. The one thing I do wish to stress is if there is any repudiation of contract here, it lies at the door of the draftsman of that Section 20 and of the Parliamentary Secretary and of the Government who sponsored it.
Comment on this
Deputy Geoghegan, in the course of his speech referred to the contract argument. I would remind the Deputy that there was nothing in the contract setting out that vesting should be completed in one year, two years, or in any specified period of years. On the contrary, the 1923 Act made it clear that vesting would be a matter of time. I stated yesterday, when speaking on another relevant amendment, that delay was inherent in the Act of 1923, and hence it was that the tenants were given the very substantial reduction of 25 per cent. which no tenants were given under any previous Land Act. It was made abundantly clear at the time the 1923 Act was being passed through this Dail that a certain period of time must elapse between the date on which the land would vest in the Land Commission, and the date on which it would finally vest in the tenant. Now it has been suggested that the Minister for Agriculture on one occasion mentioned that vesting might be completed in a period of five years. No Minister was in a position to say that vesting would be completed at the end of a certain number of years, because in 1923 and 1924 no Minister could have known the real difficulties inherent in this whole problem of vesting. As a matter of fact, this Land Bill would not be possible were it not for the experience which the Land Commission has gained during the years since the 1923 Act was passed. It is only as a result of experience that it is possible to devise a machine for the purpose of speeding up the vesting of land. The amendment reads:
"Any moneys paid by the tenant of a holding as payment in lieu of rent in excess of the standard purchase annuity of the holding which said moneys shall be paid to the tenant or deducted from any standard purchase annuity due by him."
Yesterday, Deputy Derrig, Deputy Geoghegan and Deputy de Valera stated that the amendment covered the Congested Districts Board tenants as well as the tenants still to be vested under the Act of 1903. This amendment only deals with tenants under the Act of 1923, and it leaves out of consideration altogether the 20,000 odd tenants on Congested Districts Board estates, tenants who have a very much greater grievance on the score of delay than the 1923 Act tenants, tenants on whose behalf a certain case might be made for some special consideration. These tenants have been left out of consideration altogether in this amendment, just as they were left out of consideration in Deputy Derrig's abortive Land Bill of 1929. If it is proposed to give to the tenants coming under the Act of 1923 special treatment, because of the alleged delay which I deny, why does the Deputy leave out of consideration altogether the tenants on Congested District Board estates and the small number of tenants still to be vested under the Act of 1903?
There is another point. It would appear from the speeches from the Fianna Fáil benches that the landlord was entirely responsible for the delay in vesting. I think I made it abundantly clear yesterday that the vendor has certainly not gained and, as a matter of fact, vesting very frequently has been held up by objections on the part of the tenants. Vesting is frequently held up because a tenant is not satisfied with the parcel of turbary the Land Commission offers him, or because he is not satisfied with the portion of grazing the Land Commission is prepared to allow him, or with certain other arrangements which the Land Commission is making on his behalf. Vesting is often held up for these particular reasons, and I assume the Deputies will recognise in such cases that it would be grossly unfair to deduct any money from the vendors for the purpose of compensating tenants who themselves have delayed vesting for one reason or another. It is quite usual to come across a number of cases where tenants refuse, for one reason or another, to avail themselves of vesting because they allege the Land Commission is not treating them as fairly as they should.
Let us assume that the vendor has been paid his purchase money, less 10 per cent. of the guarantee deposit. That will not be deducted in every case. It will only be deducted when the Judicial Commissioner is satisfied that it is necessary to deduct it. The vendor has been paid his purchase money, and there may be a number of claims against it. There may be half a dozen or a dozen claimants and there may be other charges in respect of it. If this amendment were passed it would mean that the Land Commission would have to demand back from the vendors the difference between the payment in lieu of rent and the annuities in respect of the tenants on the estate. The vendor in return would have to make claims against the particular claimants who have received portion of the money paid out by the Judicial Commissioner. There may be a dozen claims in such cases, as there are all sorts of charges against purchase moneys which are, of course, adjusted by the Judicial Commissioner before the money is distributed. The vendor in order to recoup himself will probably have to follow some of these persons all over the world to get back from them that portion of the money to which he is entitled. The amendment, if passed, would give rise to all sorts of complications and would be absolutely unworkable, as well as inflicting serious hardship on many vendors who are not responsible for the delay in vesting. In many cases, as can be shown by the records, the delay is due entirely to the tenants themselves.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary has tried to get away from the amendment by pretending that it does not cover the whole ground. Whose fault is it if it does not do so? Certainly not ours, because the scope of the Bill as introduced was such as to preclude the widening of the amendment to meet these cases. The Parliamentary Secretary when introducing the Bill spoke as one obviously conscious that it was a great occasion. He made a long speech on the history of the Land Acts, declared that the coping stone was at last going to be set to all this long legislation, and, in fact, he moved Deputy Sheehy to a state of ecstasy over the work that was going to be completed. We have taken the Bill and have tried to make it a measure that would really remedy a crying injustice. The only reason why anyone should be glad of the introduction of the Bill is the fact that there is a clause in it which proposes to put an end to injustice, the injustice of compelling tenants to pay sums in excess of that which their neighbours were paying, not through any fault of their own, but simply due to the fact that the machinery set up here was so sluggish that it would take forty years to do work which was anticipated to be done in five.
We proposed in several amendments to do real justice, not merely to try to bring this vesting to a head by specifying a certain time within which it would have to be done, but to do justice by attempting to make restitution to those who have been mulcted in a sum of £269,000, as has been admitted. I indicated here, when dealing with the other amendment, consideration of which is postponed for the moment, that were we the majority Party we would deal with this on the grounds of justice, and we would apportion the gain as between the landlord and the State, and make good to those who had to lose this sum from the gains of those who had gained. It was pointed out by Deputy Aiken that the rules of the House prevented us from bringing in an amendment which would deal with the matter on those lines. Therefore, the only choice left to us is this, namely, whether we are to see these tenants continuing to suffer from this injustice or whether we are going to put a burden on the landlord. So far as we are concerned, we are determined that if we can prevent it the tenants will not suffer. If the majority Party think that the other party ought not to suffer, or that we are by this amendment inflitcing hardship, they can introduce a remedy which we are not in a position to introduce. That is their responsibility.
So far as we are concerned, we ask the House not to permit this injustice to be done to the tenant. The only way which private Deputies have of preventing that injustice is to vote for this amendment and then compel the Executive, if they want to safeguard the other party, to bring in an amendment of their own. We cannot do it ourselves. It is ridiculous in reference to a Bill of this kind to speak of it in the laudatory terms in which it has been referred to when it permits this injustice to continue. We are going into the Lobby in favour of the amendment. Even though this is not the sort of remedy which we ourselves would have introduced, the Parliamentary Secretary can bring in a remedy himself. As far as widening the scope of the Bill is concerned, our experience, after listening to the debate, is that there is need for Deputy Derrig or some other Deputy to bring in a further amending Bill.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary need not try to get away on that. He knows very well that there is no incentive whatever to any private member to do any constructive work in this House, because the moment he attempts to do so and spends the amount of labour which he would have to spend on a detailed Land Bill, it is thrown out. If there was any indication given on any occasion that constructive work on this side of the House would be appreciated, or that it would mean something more than loss of time, the House would have got a good deal more constructive work from this side. No one wants to spend an amount of time and trouble on drafting such a measure as an amending Land Bill if it is going to be immediately thrown out because it does not suit people on the other side of the House, who always pretend that we are bringing in things here for political reasons. Politics have got so much into their own heads that they can see nothing but politics elsewhere, and when an honest attempt is made on this side of the House to do useful constructive work it is always found to be in vain. Here is an attempt on our side to do justice and to give Deputies an opportunity of remedying an injustice, but, instead of seeing what is the fairest way to do it, it is sought to put it aside on the futile pretence that we have not dealt with everyone who has to be dealt with. The Parliamentary Secretary could remedy that by making the Bill sufficiently wide at the start.
Comment on this
It is not wide enough. The rules of the House would not permit an amendment to cover all the matter.
Comment on this
They would not. The information we have got is that we could not bring in such an amendment. On the other side we have Deputy Mathews going back to the idea of repudiation of contracts. It was pointed out by Deputy Geoghegan that there was a provision in this Bill for things that were not contemplated under the original Act. If it is possible for the Parliamentary Secretary to recoup the Land Commission for their expenses, I see no reason why provision should not be made for recouping the tenant for sums which he has paid over and above what he should have paid. We ourselves are not satisfied that this is the best way of dealing with it, but we are determined that if an injustice is going to be done, it is not the tenant that will suffer for it.
Comment on this
It is agreed on all sides that there has been an injustice inflicted on tenants who have been paying interest in lieu of rent for the five years after the 1923 Act was passed. That injustice is so glaring that it has been referred to on many occasions in the editorial columns of the "Irish Independent," and I am sure that no Deputy could by the wildest stretch of imagination accuse that paper of being unfriendly to the Government or of trying to place it in an awkward position. Yet that journal has on divers occasions called attention to the great injustice caused to tenants owing to the delay in their vesting, that they have had to pay at least from 5 to 10 per cent. more than their neighbours whose land was vested, had to pay. I think that the Parliamentary Secretary in his speech was rather harsh on his own officials. He gave as a reason for the delay in vesting, the lack of experience of the officials of the Land Commission—the most extraordinary explanation that was ever given by any Parliamentary Secretary. Surely the Land Commission should have and has experience, but perhaps the real explanation of the delay can be found in the expenditure of £8,000 which is necessary for 16 or 18 additional inspectors to inspect these lands with a view to having them vested. Therefore, it seems to me that had the Parliamentary Secretary expended this £8,000 some four or five years ago, he would have saved the tenants the sum of £269,000.
In my opinion there has been no cogent reason put forward by the Parliamentary Secretary for the delay in the vesting of these lands. As I stated on Second Reading, if it was possible to introduce this Bill in 1931, it was equally possible to introduce it in 1927 or 1928. I think that the amendment is a reasonable one. It has been put forward in a very reasonable manner, and is one which should commend itself to the sympathy of everyone in the House. I agree with Deputy de Valera that if instead of treating with contempt everything that comes from the Opposition Benches, whether they be Fianna Fáil or Labour Benches, the Government met them in the proper spirit, much more progress would be made with Bills, and much more beneficial work would be done for the country.
It is agreed on all sides, even on the Government Benches, that this injustice does exist. Why not remove it? Why not try to make some retribution to the tenants who have been paying excessive rents? Everybody knows, judging by the position of the agricultural industry at present, that everything counts, whether in rent, overhead charges, or in local or national taxation. Anything saved in that way means something to the farming community. This in itself would mean a big thing. It would mean, as has been pointed out, five or ten per cent. I see nothing unreasonable in the amendment, and I think it is one to which the Government should give special sympathy. If necessary, it could arrange to deal with the whole position, and an agreed amendment for that purpose could be moved on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
Every Land Bill that was introduced created some sort of problem after it became an Act, but I think the Parliamentary Secretary has succeeded in creating a problem in this case before the Bill becomes an Act at all. This question of compensation for tenants who are not vested will become a serious problem. I think the Parliamentary Secretary has an opportunity now in this amendment, if he would only accept it, of settling this point. If should be to the interest of the Government as well as to the interest of the whole Dáil, when an opportunity occurs like this, to make every endeavour to bring the land problem of Ireland as quickly as possible to a solution. I think we are long enough discussing land problems. The Government, which started in 1923 with an Act which was in five years to solve the problem, should really attempt to make an effort to prevent such a serious problem as this arising by accepting the amendment. The Parliamentary Secretary left no doubts at all in our minds as to who gains in this case. The whole House is unanimous on the point that the unfortunate tenant has lost, but the Parliamentary Secretary was good enough to inform us that the landlord has certainly gained.
Of course the problem of getting after the landlord is, I know, a difficult one. The Parliamentary Secretary made great endeavours to prove that it would be almost an impossible one. At the same time I think that every Government has its responsibilities as far as equity is concerned, and there is a serious responsibility thrown on this Government. The sum is not a small one. It is a quarter of a million of money. A quarter of a million of money spread amongst farmers who are not vested is not to be considered of little importance. Some two years ago I asked a question of the Parliamentary Secretary on this point, and he told me that it was not possible to estimate what the losses were. It seems now quite evident that the losses are £269,000. At that time it was not possible. It can hardly be admitted that the Government did not know that this was going on. I do not see how they can justify themselves. I believe that if they do not take it in hands now that those tenants will compel them, or compel some future Government, to take it in hands.
The result of the whole thing is that instead of the Bill relieving or settling all the problems which the Parliamentary Secretary told us it would settle it is going, to a large extent, I think, to dissatisfy the farmers. No doubt they will get vested, and immediately on vesting they will have the satisfaction of this particular reduction. That is, however, for tenants of the future, and the tenants of the past will have a very serious grievance. I think it would be only justice if the Government would face up to that. If they could not agree to satisfy them by reimbursing them to the amount of £269,000 I do not see any reason why they should shirk the responsibility of satisfying them with some portion of the money. Some proportion of the money should go back to the tenants, because, through economic depression and world influences, they have been placed in a most unfortunate position. Different proposals are being put forward for their relief, so that no Deputy in this House can have any doubt in his mind but that there is great necessity to relieve them. I believe that, for the success of this Land Bill, the Parliamentary Secretary should consider this amendment. It will certainly give some portion of the money which they have lost to satisfy these farmers.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary, in speaking a few moments ago, referred disparagingly to the amendment, inasmuch as it did not include the wider range of tenancies in the earlier Land Acts, and also the tenancies in the congested districts area.
Could I infer from his reference that he would be inclined to consider an amendment if it included both these classes, or was the point made merely as an argumentative point and not intended to carry with it any suggestion of a practical sort?
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary is not obliged to answer a question in debate.
Comment on this
If the Parliamentary Secretary does not answer, his suggestion was nothing more than a cheap point. I would like to remind the Parliamentary Secretary that some years ago in this House a very strong case was put forward as to why his Government should make amends to the tenants, who suffered a much more considerable loss through delay in vesting than the tenants we are dealing with now. To deal with the question would have meant the re-opening of the financial question between this country and England, as the delay in vesting in the earlier Land Act was due to the war. As a result of that, moneys that the British Government had contracted to set aside for the purpose of completing the land purchase were diverted to other purposes. His Government took no action to deal with these tenants, but the Parliamentary Secretary finds it a debating point to refer to them now and to have some regret and to have some doubt about the inequality of dealing with a section of tenants for whom we keep on legislating at present while leaving the major section neglected.
The Parliamentary Secretary said that the Bill was wide enough to include every section of tenants, and wide enough to include every interest of the tenants, notwithstanding the fact that a most important section dealing with the evicted tenants, when introduced by our Party, was ruled out by the Cheann Comhairle as not being within the ambit of the Bill. Dealing with the other section, those in the Congested District areas, I think the Parliamentary Secretary should be the last man to make reference to that section of the community. He is a representative of the Congested District areas, and he knows that the resources and funds left in the Congested District areas were robbed by his Government, and he knows, as Parliamentary Secretary responsible for this Bill, that he has introduced in this Bill a clause that robbed the Congested District areas of the last roost contained in them. Clearly the Parliamentary Secretary is not meeting this amendment in a fair way. His arguments are small points of debate. This is not a proposition that calls for debating qualities, but for administration of justice to a section of the community. We, on this side, have endeavoured to meet them by every step in our power by stating that vesting should be retrospective. We have had a proposition before for tenants who suffered more than those tenants.
Comment on this
Before the House votes on this, I would like to remind it again of the admission which the Parliamentary Secretary made at the beginning of the speech. He said if it had not been for the experience gained in 1923 it would not have been possible to bring in this Bill. I do not think that even Deputy Gorey would dissent from that, but what is the implication? The implication is, that for the past seven years the tenants have been paying 75 per cent. in lieu of rent because the Land Commission was not sufficiently experienced to deal with the problem of vesting. Now, who should pay for that inexperience? We contend that at any rate, it should not be the tenant. It has not been due to any fault of his. If fault there is it lies with the Land Commission upon the Parliamentary Secretary's own admission, and if it lies with the Land Commission then the State ought to bear that extra ten per cent. That is the principle that is at issue in this amendment. I do not know whether the Cumann na nGaedheal Party have given any consideration to it whatsoever. Judging by the number of members who are here in the House, I do not think they have. I do not know whether the Independment Farmers' Party has given it any consideration, but if they did give it a moment's consideration would they not have insisted on the Parliamentary Secretary accepting the principle of the amendment, and if the Bill is drawn in such a way that we could not make our amendments wide enough to cover every case could they not have insisted on a report stage that he would have put down an amendment which would be comprehensive? I suggest that no person can go into the Lobby, in view of the Parliamentary Secretary's own admission, and vote against this amendment without consciously doing a wrong to the tenant. That is the issue that is before the farmer, particularly in the Cumann na nGaedheal Party and that is the issue that will be put before the country.
Comment on this
There is no injustice to anybody. This has been conducted on a sort of plane which bears no relation to the facts. So far as I can understand the matter there has been no blame attributable to anybody. The tenant undoubtedly whose land was not vested had been paying 10 per cent. more than he would if it had been vested. It is not an injustice to the tenant that there were difficulties in the carrying out of the 1923 Act, which caused vesting to be delayed a little longer than had been hoped. There was no guarantee at any time that vesting in any particular estate would be completed by a particular date. The Land Commission is not to be blamed for not bringing in this earlier. What happens now is that as a result of work and experience it is found possible to devise a new scheme which will have the effect that the tenant will get his full 35 per cent. reduction from 1st May next instead of having to wait for a very considerable time longer, if this scheme had not been devised.
There is no reason at all why we should select some particular date and say we wanted retrospectively to give the tenants 35 per cent. reduction as from that date and that other people, who would have to meet their own charges and who find their own charges heavy enough, should have this burden thrust on them. The correct way to look at it is that the tenant had every reason to be satisfied when he got 25 per cent. reduction under the 1923 Act, a thing he would not have got under previous Acts. Now it is found possible to devise a method of amending the 1923 Land Act that will give him the whole 35 per cent. before the ordinary formalities have been carried through and the whole investigations have taken place that would ordinarily be required. There is no question of injustice. There is the ordinary hardship that often occurs inevitably in all sorts of human affairs. To suggest that because there are difficulties in this country which, as the Parliamentary Secretary has pointed out, are often due to the tenant that there is some moral obligation on the ordinary taxpayer to come to his rescue retrospectively seems to me to be fantastic. The obligation that is on the Government and on the State and the public generally is that which is being discharged by this Bill, and that is as soon as it was possible to devise a scheme that would overcome or get around the difficulties which prevented vesting under the 1923 Land Act, a scheme was devised to give the tenants the advantage of the 35 per cent. reduction from the beginning of May next. If this Bill is passed in sufficient time then I think the State has discharged all the liabilities the State can be expected to discharge.
Comment on this
There was injustice by which a tenant who was paying £100 before the passing of the 1923 Act afterwards, if vested, would be only paying £65, but who had to pay £75 during the intervening period as payment in lieu of rent. If you add to the £10 reduction roughly £3 10s. that went in sinking fund, that tenant who had been paying £100 rent before the Act of 1923 was passed lost about £13 10s. a year owing to the inefficiency of the Land Commission or whoever was responsible. Roughly, it amounted to one and a half year's annuity. When we consider that not alone is the tenant purchaser not getting any stay whatever from the Land Commission in respect of his annuity—that ultimately he has to pay all his annuities as they fall due, and furthermore, as a tax-paper has to pay the whole cost of the Land Commission, and that not a single penny is deducted for costs of collection, I think it will be seen that the tenant has been treated unjustly in two ways. In the first place, the deduction to which he was entitled if vested was wrongfully kept from him, and in the second place as a taxpayer he has been paying all the time for maintaining, as Deputy Geoghegan pointed out, an inefficient system. From the first day it was set up it had not in contemplation the new circumstances and did not set out to do the work in the way it should.
On the other hand the landlord about whom there has been so much talk has had a gain of about £7 5s. 3d. yearly as compared with what he will get when the land is vested and the purchase annuity fixed. Besides that, the landlord had his income guaranteed by the State. I would like to see any Deputies getting up and arguing that if this Act had not been passed, and if steps had not been taken by the State to finance land purchase, the landlord would have had any income at all. What is there to show that he would? Not only has the landlord's income been guaranteed but the arrears have been collected. Still the argument was put up that some injustice accrued owing to the fact that he did not get his land bonds. That was shown to be quite fallacious, because the land bonds have appreciated in value and are worth far more now than they were in 1923. Taking all the circumstances together, the landlord has not done badly. He has done very well. On top of that we have paid his legal costs and thrown in a ten per cent. bonus to complete the transaction. Where is the injustice to the landlords? Even if there was injustice —which has not been shown—that is no justification for the wrong that was done to the unvested tenants. A sum of six millions has been paid by them since 1923, but none of it has gone to redeem the purchase price.
As Deputy MacEntee pointed out, we are prepared to support the Parliamentary Secretary or the Minister for Finance if they accept the principle that there should be restitution. We are certainly prepared to extend it to tenants. As a matter of fact, Deputy Maguire was anxious to have an amendment to deal specifically with tenants who purchased under the 1903 Act, and whose cases he had often brought before the House, and who have been paying interest in lieu of rent for seventeen or eighteen years. We take it that a reasonable case can be made for those who have been wrongfully paying for at least five years, cutting out hard cases that we know of and which, it might be pointed out, were exceptional. We took the cases generally and tried to strike a fair average. If we erred we erred by being lenient for the State. We did not err in leniency towards the tenants. We could have gone back further even than the 1923 Act, and could have pointed out the cases of tenants who have been paying, perhaps, for a score of years, and not a single penny of the money has gone to redeem the purchase price.
As far as my information goes, the Minister for Finance was not correct when he said that under the 1923 Act tenants benefited by 25 per cent. of a reduction, and that that had not been the case previously. I understand that under previous Land Acts there was a reduction. That may not have been a statutory reduction, but it was a reduction as interest in lieu of rent, paid during the period before the tenant was vested. As I said yesterday, there was no new principle introduced in the 1923 Act. It was a continuation of the Acts of 1903, 1909, and 1920. I challenge anyone to say in what particular, except in this matter of the speeding up of vesting, this Bill is superior to the English measures. It is not; it is simply a continuation of the process. Deputy MacEntee has rightly called attention to the grotesque argument that we would not have this Bill at all only for the work and the experience of the Land Commission. The people who use that argument get up in this House and abuse the Fianna Fáil Party for the defects in their Bills or proposals, quite oblivious of the fact that the Fianna Fáil Party has no staff, no Land Commission, and no draughtsmen to prepare proposals. As Deputy de Valera said, we would be quite satisfied if the idea were, at least, accepted as a basis for discussion, but if the present state of affairs continues, and if any proposal from this side is automatically ruled out of court, and automatically regarded as a political move, I would like to know what is the use of an Opposition? This is one of the questions where we have honestly tried to improve matters, and I challenge anyone to show where, as far as the Land Commission generally or the Gaeltacht services are concerned, this Party is in any way to be criticised. We try generally to encourage the Land Commission, and we do not try to cut them down in any way. We try to encourage them, and where we feel they are doing a good thing we try to support them. I do not want to prolong the argument any further. The position is that we have got no guarantee whatever or any proposal from the Government to show that this question will even be considered by them. I think it is a nice state of affairs, when Deputies from their own benches have in fact supported the principle of the amendment and have spoken to it so favourably, that the Government have so little cognisance of them or of us or of the general position of the tenants that they are not even prepared to discuss the question and come back with some proposals to meet us at a later stage.
[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]
Comment on this
I have listened to a great part of this very long debate. It seems to me that two injustices in particular are being complained of by the Fianna Fáil Party. One is an injustice peculiar to themselves. It is that the Government do not pay sufficient attention to their amendments. Deputy Coburn seems to agree with them in that grievance and thinks it is a terrible injustice that their amendments——
Comment on this
Two ways of remedying these Fianna Fáil injustices have been put forward, at least by implication. One is Deputy Coburn's suggestion, which is that all amendments of the Fianna Fáil Party to all Bills be automatically accepted by the Government. The other is Deputy Derrig's proposal, by implication, that the Fianna Fáil Party should be provided with a Civil Service, a Land Commission and a draftsman of its own——
Comment on this
——in order to devote that intelligence and that capacity and earnestness to all the work of the Dáil which Deputy Derrig, I understand, said it had been able to devote only to a few Bills up to the present. These two suggestions are really to my mind worthy of the whole debate, because I should like to suggest that there is a third injustice involved in the whole matter, and that is the injustice to the public that we should sit for such a long time discussing what really amounts to one of the silliest amendments ever put forward. I always knew Fianna Fáil had a great opinion of the Minister for Agriculture, but I never thought they had such a terrific opinion of him that they would base, upon what amounts to an obiter dictum passed as far back as 1923, the statement that because that obiter dictum did not turn out to be true, therefore an injustice was being done to the tenants. That is really the Fianna Fáil case. The Minister for Agriculture in 1923 gave it as his opinion that it would probably take five years to complete the vesting of all the holdings in the occupiers.
Comment on this
Eight years afterwards it is a terrible injustice to the tenants, according to Fianna Fáil, that the Minister for Agriculture did not prove right. We have a great opinion of the Minister ourselves, but we do not attach such superstitions reverence to his words as to make it a kind of legal injustice worthy of being remedied by an Act of Parliament that words which he happened to use— unfortunately he does not always use as many words as Deputy MacEntee— in the course of a long speech on a complicated Bill did not happen to turn out true in five years' time.
The real injustice would be if this amendment were accepted. The proposal is that an arbitrary date in the year 1928 shall be taken and that all tenants whose land was not vested in them at that period shall have repaid to them the difference between the interest in lieu of rent and the annuity from that period until now. That is the proposal. The date is based not on any legal enactment which would create justice or a notion of justice, or would create a real demand from what Deputy de Valera persists in calling restitution. It is not based on that. It is based on the obiter dictum of the Minister for Agriculture. I want to know what about the case which goes back just a little further in 1928. What about the tenant who was vested only just a month or so before this date? Why should one particular date be selected and all tenants on one side of that date get this advantage and all the tenants on the other side not get the advantage? The Deputies on the Fianna Fáil Benches can say what they please about the Land Commission. The fact is that in these particular cases no right whatever exists to this return or to this restitution, as Deputy de Valera calls it. It has happened by an accident, as it does happen in dozens of other Acts, that certain citizens, because their turn has not come, have had to pay a little more for a little longer than certain other citizens. That is all that has happened. It is proposed to select an arbitrary class out of that number of citizens chosen on a phrase used by the Minister for Agriculture, and to recoup these and to leave all the others alone. Deputy de Valera made a great grievance because the Parliamentary Secretary referred to Deputy Derrig's abortive Bill. Deputy Derrig introduced that Bill, and it was quite within his competence then to deal not only with all tenants who had this alleged grievance under the 1923 Act, but with all tenants who had grievances before that Act, and he did not do it.
Comment on this
I have not got the Standing Orders, but I do not think it matters, I do not think that I am out of order at present.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Deputy should get it to see how much Deputy Derrig could or could not do.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy suggested that Deputy Derrig was held up by the rules of debate. These big strong rules of this House have a tremendously crippling effect on the vast intelligence of Fianna Fáil. They are tying their hands every moment. Deputy Aiken's grievance is not so big against the Ministry, which he hates so much, as against the very fact that there exists an institution here, and that that institution has rules, and that Deputies Aiken, Lemass and Derrig are not able to get round these rules in some way.
Comment on this
I suggest that real injustice would be done if this amendment was carried, whereby a small number of arbitrarily-selected tenants would get benefits from some source. There again Deputy Derrig, says that the tenant has been paying for the Land Commission, and that it is a terrific injustice to make him pay the Land Commission because it is so inefficient. I say that it would be equally an injustice to make the tenant pay under this amendment for what Deputy Derrig terms the inefficiency of the Land Commission, because that apparently is what the amendment means. Either the landlord will pay this sum or the State will pay. If the State pays it, it will have to be paid again by the tenant farmer, with whom Deputy Derrig is so sympathetic, because he has been paying for the inefficient Land Commission for a number of years. The whole amendment seems to me to be really nothing short of a fatuous one, and if carried would do far more injustice than the injustice it purports to remove.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance has told us that there is no blame attaching to anybody. One specific sum of £269,000 is covered by a neglect or a defect, and no blame is attaching to anyone? In other words the existence of the Cumann na nGaedhael Government during that particular time was a visitation of God. That seems to be the whole argument. Due to the experience and work—that is the phrase—recently, apparently of the Land Commission they have now succeeded in being able to device something which during the lapsed period of the visitation of God they were unable to do. What has been the experience and what has been the work that so stimulated the grey matter in our Government of duds, that they can at a specific moment, at a critical and psychological moment, deliver the goods which they could not deliver before? What has been the experience, what stimulated them? What got them going? Then we have been told that this Bill, the only good part of which is the Derrig clause, is not to be compared to the abortive Bill of Deputy Derrig. Abortion is of two kinds—natural and artificial, and Deputy Derrig's Bill was abortive. The core, centre and purpose were all in that Bill, but the grey matter of the Land Commission, and the grey matter of the visitation of God was not stimulated by the imminent presence of a general election. I believe that general elections are good if we had enough of them. If we had to submit to a continuance of this Government, I would have a general election every week in the hope that its grey matter would be stimulated into the delivery of the goods, into getting the experience of doing work which, unless and until they have that selfish stimulation, they will not do and never have done.
The Minister for Finance told us how horrified he was at the suggestion of retrospectively dealing with these matters. Now the Minister for Finance complaining of retrospective legislation is a case of Satan rebuking sin. It has been what the Government has lived on. I have warned this House in relation to a specific clause of the Finance Bill that was retrospective, that under the same principle of that Bill, every contract of every sort and kind which has been entered into in this State, either between the State itself and individuals, or individuals in the State was at risk. That did not worry the Minister for Finance. It is only when retrospective legislation interferes with his particular policy at a particular moment that he has any objection to it.
There is retrospective provision already in the Bill. The date concerned is already to be retrospectively arranged. What difference is there in principle? There is an old saying, and it is a legal saying, that every wrong has a remedy. There has been a wrong in this case, and the mere fact that this Ministry have not wakened up to it until a general election was on their heels does not alter the fact that there was a wrong. Are they going to remedy it or not? That is a simple question. Right through this debate, and I have listened to a great deal of it, when amendments have been put forward, the Parliamentary Secretary has got up and made his prepared speechette —a little thing written down for him, and which frankly he read with amazing ingenuity. He sometimes deceived even me. The prepared asides even had been marked on the wide margin, but when he was faced by discussion and detailed knowledge of the matter that he was supposed to discuss, he got up and mumbled like Deputy Law did. He has not been able to meet reasoned detailed discussion upon this Bill. He has been able to deliver the little excellently prepared speeches, and I want to bear tribute to those who prepared them, but he was hopeless afterwards.
And why? Because he got his orders; because the Land Commission, which has had experience of having injected into this House a body of people representing opinion which is determined to have things done; because the Land Commission, which has got its notice to get on or get out, has naturally given him just that amount of rope. He is not allowed to go any further. Therefore, there is no blame attaching to anybody. There is certainly no blame attaching to any member on that Bench of duds, not a demi-semi quaver to a Minister upon that Bench of duds as long as they have behind them a body which will let them be treated as the office boys of their departments instead of Ministers of this House.
Comment on this
If this 1923 Act had been a voluntary measure there would have been some ground for the statement of the Minister for Finance. It was not a voluntary measure. It was a measure forced upon the tenants of the Free State at the bidding apparently of a certain number of landlords whose votes were necessary to turn the scale.
Comment on this
I would remind the Deputy that we are discussing amendment 46. This is not a second stage Debate. We are on amendment 46.
Comment on this
The position is that the tenants were forced into this agreement. They were told at that time that in five years they would get the extra ten per cent. reduction. That contract is just as binding as any contract made with the landlords. In a House like this we ought at least to pay as much attention to the position of the tenants as to the position of the landlords in every case. That is the whole situation we have to deal with— whether it is the tenants' interests or the landlords' interests are to be considered here. It has been admitted by the Parliamentary Secretary that it has been taken out of the pockets of the tenants. It is not a matter for us to consider who has got this £269,000, whether it has gone to the Land Commission for the collection of the rents or the interest in lieu of rent or whether it has gone into the pockets of the Minister for Finance in the shape of income Tax or whether it has gone into the pockets of the landlord. The position we are faced with is that this money has gone out of the pockets of the tenants and it is our duty to see that the money is reinstated there. When I was last speaking on this matter I made a statement in regard to the amendment which had been moved in this House by Deputy Gorey.
Comment on this
That statement made by me has been denied. If that statement is wrong I am prepared to withdraw it, but if it is right I will prove it.
Comment on this
Here is an amendment moved to the Land Act of 1923: "For the purpose of this part of the Act and of the Schedules attached to the Act, rent, whether on a judicial holding or otherwise, shall be understood to mean any abated rent accepted by a landlord for a period of at least five years previous to the first gale day of the year 1921."
That is from Volume 4 of the Official Debates, page 1015. It is an amendment proposed by Deputy Gorey in the Dáil. At that time Mr. Hogan, the present Minister for Agriculture, had charge of the Bill, and his reply to this amendment was that Deputy Gorey's amendment would rule out hundreds of genuine cases. He did not accept it. Deputy Gorey withdrew the amendment, and the amendment proposed by Deputy Hennessy was accepted. Apparently owing to this, and acting on the knowledge that here in this House there had been in existence a Party led by Deputy Gorey who were prepared to ignore the tenants' claims to get abated rents recognised from 1915 onwards these men are at the present day unfortunately paying ten per cent. rent more than they were paying in 1923. The Minister for Agriculture cannot see any injustice in this. Can he see any injustice in the fact that the 1923 Land Act in several of these cases increased the rents by ten per cent., and that these tenants had since been paying ten per cent. increase on their own rents prior to 1923, and that no provision is made in this Bill to meet their case or to remedy that injustice? This Bill has been described as a Bill which is to put the coping stone on all Land Bills. But there is no remedy whatever for this injustice in this great Bill. We had here a definite denial from Deputy Gorey. Does the Deputy still persist in that denial in the face of his own amendment that I have just read?
Comment on this
Certainly; that amendment introduced and got accepted what was never in a previous Land Act. The abated rent would have to be the basis of purchase.
Comment on this
That amendment has been finished with. Deputy Corry will have to deal with the amendment we are now discussing or discontinue his speech.
Comment on this
I am quite satisfied to leave the issue of that amendment stand now. I hope to have an opportunity of dealing with it again next week when we will be introducing a new Land Bill, a Bill to deal with the deficiencies in this Land Bill. This is the best that can be offered to the tenants when we have the Minister for Finance and the Parliamentary Secretary for Lands telling us here baldly that we have collected £269,000 through the Land Commission from the unfortunate tenants.
The Ministers have done worse than that. In 1923 they brought in a compulsory Land Bill which increased the rents of the tenants by ten per cent. Even when that injustice had been pointed out—and it was pointed out repeatedly time and again from 1927 onwards—the Parliamentary Secretary did not propose one single section in this coping stone of all Land Bills, to rectify the injustice. Why, if this is the coping stone of all Land Bills, should we have this special vesting section? A man at present paying £9 a year rent will find that the moment this vesting section will be in operation he will pay, not £9 a year but £13. That is the sort of Bill the Parliamentary Secretary has brought in here to show the ignorant Deputies what his Land Bill really is. Deputy Hennessy introduced an amendment here, and we had a statement here yesterday from the Parliamentary Secretary in which he alluded to agile lawyers. Is Deputy Hennessy now satisfied with the portion of his amendment which hands these things over to the Judicial Commissioner? The Parliamentary Secretary refers to agile lawyers. What about wily judges?
Comment on this
I want to tell Deputy Corry that he will have to keep strictly to order. The Deputy has been trying to abuse the privileges of the House.
Comment on this
I just wish in conclusion to ask Deputies opposite to stand by the unfortunate tenants who have admittedly been robbed of this money. So far as their contracts are concerned, the contracts bound the Land Commission or the Minister who introduced the Bill or the Executive Council who are responsible for its introduction—
Comment on this
The object of this amendment is to give the Government an opportunity of whitewashing itself, an opportunity of fulfilling and realising the promise made in 1923. One would have imagined that the present President, with his nimble wits and sense of politics, would have jumped at this amendment and accepted it because it gave him the opportunity of fulfilling that promise made in 1923, that the vesting of lands would be completed in five years. Instead of that, we find that he and his colleagues are putting up all sorts of subterfuges for not accepting that amendment. We have the subterfuge, first of all, on a point of order, that we could not deal with the thing because it involves a question of public finance, thereby clearly writing it down that the Government is not going to budge in this matter, and not going to take any step to facilitate the carrying out of this amendment. We have all sorts of amazing reasons given for the non-acceptance of this amendment by the Parliamentary Secretary. One of those was that the landlord would have to follow various persons who had received portions of the land bonds or the money which they had received on payment of the land bonds, a reason and excuse which, on the face of it, is absurd when we consider the nature of this section, because in this we are dealing purely with estates which have not yet been vested and, therefore, with bonds which have not yet been given to the landlord. He said that we did not deal with tenants in congested areas. We could not deal with them under this section except in the most strictly limited way within the terms of reference set out in the Title of the Bill.
It is a pathetic thing to find the Parliamentary Secretary using as a means of protecting himself against our arguments a Land Bill introduced from this side of the House. It is the precedent he goes on, the standard of his judgement now, the Bill which he repudiated some time ago. He does not seem to have realised that if he had allowed the Second Reading of that Bill to have taken place he could have brought in amendments in the Committee Stage implementing the principle in the Bill. It was a matter for further discussion, but he puts the blame on us for not having completed the thing when he himself was a party to throwing out the Bill before it could be properly considered in detail.
Some of the Deputies upon the Government Benches, however well intentioned they may be, are doing their own Party a great injury. I think it is unconscious on their part. They suffer from what one might call the landlord complex. They know this landlord and that landlord who were decent fellows, and they do not see why after all landlords should not get the benefit of £269,000. After all, what is it? It is only a fleabite if you like, a small thing, which does not matter, but they are bringing their own Party into grave disrepute by taking that line of conduct. How many of the Deputies on the other side depend for their votes upon the small farmers of Ireland? How far does the Government itself depend for its existence upon the farmers of Ireland? Remember it was at a very crucial period in her history that they introduced the Land Bill in 1923. The Government had at that time come through a very terrible period of crisis in the country. They were looking about for something by which they could placate the people and hold on to power, and the most effective measure for holding the Irish people, they knew from experience, was a Land Bill which would complete land purchase. The promise which the then Minister for Lands, who is now Minister for Agriculture, made was a very vital part in the contract between the Government and the people, because the people would not have sustained them in power if they had not received that promise from the Government, that the Land Commission was going to be very speedily settled. And what are we doing? We are merely trying to fulfil and realise a promise made by our enemies to the people. What hardships are the landlords suffering by this amendment? They have gained, if you like, by a windfall. It may not have been their fault that land purchase has not been completed, though probably in a great many cases it was delay on their part in supplying particulars and so on that delayed the vesting of estates. But in no case, let us suppose, they were to blame for it. It was for them a windfall that they received over the last four or five years payment in lieu of rent instead of receiving their land bonds. What grievance have they got if that which was really a windfall should be returned to the people from whom it was taken and people living in a condition of poverty to whom a pound would mean for more than £100 would have meant to the landlord? As Deputy MacEntee has already pointed out, it was an immense boon to the landlords, over a period when the country was so disturbed, that their rents should have been collected for them and collected almost free of cost.
Comment on this
I know, but the landlords know very well that they could not have collected their rents at the same cost at which they were collected in that disturbed period. As Lord Birkenhead said in the House of Lords in 1923, the English landlords would have been very glad to have 70 per cent of their gross rental collected on the same basis as the Irish Land Act provided for. Then again, by windfall, the landlords are getting their bonds now at a premium. Surely those who are representing the interests of the landlords in this House are overstating the case. They are blackening the characters of the landlords much in the same way as the old land agents did with the old landlords long ago. They are going beyond the limit that any decent minded landlord himself would go. But, unfortunately, this House is controlled by a Party which is tied, bound and spancelled, by a certain section of the landlord influence in this country. They have to look to those interests for their funds in fighting the Irish people. They have to look for their support in keeping out the terrible Fianna Fáil Party. The struggle in Ireland is becoming clearer and clearer every day, and nothing has cleared up the situation better than the way in which the Government stood pat against this amendment, because it is becoming clearer that they are bound by those who supply money to their funds, and that they cannot depart by one iota from what they think the landlords are demanding from them.