Land Bill, 1930—Third Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 171–356 of 545. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 29 of 1930 ›
I move:—
In sub-section (2), after the word "any" in line 23 to insert the words "including the fishing, sporting or other such rights appurtenant to such holding."
This amendment is put down to get information as to the position of sporting, fishing and other rights. Are the particulars of the rights appurtenant to these holdings to be included in the lists, or what is the position exactly? The particular matter in which we are interested, as well as the sporting and the fishing rights, is the question of mountain grazing. In the West of Ireland, I understand, there are large tracts of land where the landlord has got a lease for sporting purposes and the tenants consider that this is a deprivation and that an arrangement should be made to transfer these rights to them through local trustees. It is a matter with which I am not very conversant, and I put down this amendment in order to elicit information from the Parliamentary Secretary as to what exactly is the position in regard to fishing, sporting and grazing rights.
Comment on this
The amendment as it is drafted would give to the allottees of untenanted land which has been sold the fishing, sporting, or other such rights appurtenant to such holdings. If this amendment were accepted it would deprive the Land Commission of any discretion whatsoever in regard to the disposal of these rights. In some cases these rights have not been acquired by the Land Commission at all. For instance, if the Land Commission is acquiring an estate under the Act of 1923, the Land Commission may not consider it advisable to acquire the sporting rights for the reason that their acquisition would cost the State too much, and if they acquired these rights they could not expect to re-sell to the tenants at an economic annuity. This amendment deals entirely with untenanted land. There is another point, that the word "appurtenant" is really a difficult word to interpret. A fishing right cannot be interpreted as appurtenant to a holding. A fishing right may be appurtenant to an estate or to three or four different estates, but you cannot say that a fishing right is appurtenant to a particular parcel of land given to a tenant on a particular estate. It is a matter entirely for the discretion of the Land Commission to dispose of the sporting rights in what they consider to be the best interests of the State.
Comment on this
What is the objection to the Land Commission dealing with local trustees on behalf of the tenants for these rights?
Comment on this
None at all. As a matter of fact they have no objection. The Land Commission dispose of these rights in various ways. There is no fixed rule or fixed method of disposing of the sporting rights. The Land Commission try to preserve them as far as possible and use them in the interests of the State. In some cases they let them to people for a season, or they may lease them for two, three, four, or five years at a certain figure. The money realised goes into the Land Commission exchequer.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary has really touched on what is the kernel of the amendment—the fact that there is no fixed rule which regulates the procedure of the Land Commission in relation to the rights once they have been acquired by the Land Commission. I am not very familiar with the question, but I do believe that the matter has been brought to my notice by people in the West of Ireland. I have noticed Deputies putting down questions in this House from time to time relating to the manner in which these rights have been disposed of by the Land Commission, and I believe sometimes that has been the occasion of a good deal of ill-feeling and dissatisfaction in particular localities. We think that it would be to the advantage of the Land Commission, and certainly to the advantage of the tenants, that these fishing and sporting rights should be disposed of in some pre-determined way, and that possibly the best way would be to vest them. Where they do exist and are taken over with the estate they should be vested in trustees for the benefit of the estate as a whole. It has been ascertained on one or two occasions as a result of a question put down in the House that the rights in some cases have been let to officials even in the Land Commission or ex-officials. I do not want the thing carried too far, but in connection with intimate personal friends of officials I remember Deputy Boland raising questions here of sporting rights on two estates.
Comment on this
That sporting letting was not made by the Land Commission. It was acquired from a private individual.
Comment on this
Was not the case that in some indirect way the Land Commission came into the negotiations?
Comment on this
I thought that the question was that these officials by virtue of their official position had been able to get those rights on particularly favourable terms and that there was intense dissatisfaction in the district.
Comment on this
I recollect the case perfectly well. The Land Commission did not make that letting at all. The sporting rights belonged to a private individual. There was a certain misunderstanding about the whole question, and I think that if Deputy Boland had understood the position properly he would not have asked the question; at least the Deputy confessed that to me in a conversation afterwards. The Land Commission have taken over the sporting lettings on wide tracts of mountains, and in disposing of these rights the Land Commission must be given a wide discretion.
Sometimes the sporting rights will be of no value after a few years, because the tenants will not conserve these rights and it will be impossible to make any fixed rule with regard to them. We must leave it to the Land Commission to dispose of these rights in the best interests of the State. We are disposing of them to make the highest revenue we can of the lettings. At the moment there is a very keen demand for them and we are realising a very substantial revenue as a result. They are advertised extensively on this side and the other side, in the sporting papers.
Comment on this
Take the mountains, say in Kerry, where the tenants would claim that they had rough grazing. What would be the position if the landlord had sporting rights on the same land? Would the fact that the landlord preserved his sporting rights deprive tenants of the grazing rights?
Comment on this
Not necessarily. I assume the Deputy is referring to the sporting rights purchased by the late Congested Districts Board. We ourselves are the landlords. We are responsible for the letting of these sporting rights, and as I told the Deputy we always let these sporting rights to the best possible advantage. These lettings do not interfere with the grazing lettings in any way.
Comment on this
Are there any sporting or fishing rights at present in the possession of the landlords?
Comment on this
Yes. In some cases the Congested Districts Board re-sold sporting and fishing rights to the landlords.
Comment on this
The big principle is under what form can the sporting and fishing rights be developed. There are three aspects of the case. Where the population is thick in the country, on tenanted land, say, or untenanted land divided up, you cannot have sporting rights without the co-operation of the people living on the land. At the same time I realise that it is very hard to get a combination of tenants that would make it effective with regard to the preservation or propagation. I had hoped that the new Bill drafted last year which, incidentally, was badly managed in the Ministry of Justice, would have been of some assistance. I also thought the Land Commission asked power to clear all the interests of the landlord with regard to sporting and fishing rights. I thought they were accepted under the 1929 Bill.
Comment on this
The Deputy should know that under the Act of 1903 where there was a voluntary sale between the landlord and the tenants in the majority of cases the tenants allowed the landlord to retain the sporting and fishing rights.
Comment on this
No. I only took power to purchase certain ancillary fishing rights to enable an entire fishery to be preserved as an entity.
Comment on this
That is if certain fishing rights fell into the hands of the Land Commission under the 1923 Act they would have the right to buy out the ancillary rights.
Comment on this
Under the 1923 Act sporting rights are all transferred to the tenants, and considerable use has been made of the privilege, because all over the country game has increased immensely since it became the property of the tenants. Certainly hares have—winged game has not—but you will never get sporting rights in the country unless you have the co-operation of the people living there.
Comment on this
A case is at present being investigated by the Land Commission with a view to vesting where the landlord had returned 1,262 acres of untenanted land. The tenants deny that the land is untenanted; they claim that it has always been part of their individual holdings. The question at issue concerns the sporting rights. If the claim of the landlord is admitted the tenants believe that they will be deprived of the sporting rights, and they are determined that they will not lose these rights. As far as I know, the Land Commission cannot give an opinion on the matter. I think the Land Commission stated that the matter would have to go before Mr. Justice Wylie. How will such cases be affected by this Bill?
Comment on this
I would want to know something more about the history of this case before I could answer that question. If the Deputy wishes I will discuss the case with him privately.
Comment on this
There are other cases where tenants refused to purchase fishing rights because they were not handed over to them by the landlord under the 1903 Act. These tenants are now being compelled to purchase the fishing rights under the 1923 Act. A body of tenants purchased in 1906, but other tenants refused to purchase, and continued to pay rent up to 1923. They find now under the compulsory landlord Bill of 1923 that the fishing rights are handed over to the landlord.
Comment on this
The tenants have to pay for the bed of the river, which is measured on the acreage of their land. The case was tried in the High Court.
Comment on this
A Judge in the High Court held that the fishing rights remained with the landlord, but that the tenant had a claim on the bed of the river. Which is right? We want to see these things rectified in this coping-stone of all Land Bills which is to be the final word on land purchase. Surely when putting the finishing touches to it land purchase cases of definite injustice to tenants should be dealt with. Deputations have been with the Parliamentary Secretary and with the Minister in regard to these matters, but they are not rectified. Now, when we expect that they would be rectified we find that they are not. We want to know why. These tenants came to Dublin at their own expense to interview the Minister for Fisheries about the matter. After fighting the landlord from 1906 to 1923 they find that they are compelled under this landlords' Bill.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, the Act of 1929 was introduced largely to meet the grievances of tenants in which Deputy Corry is interested.
Comment on this
I would like to know from the Parliamentary Secretary if we could have the cases of riparian owners in Wexford dealt with under this Bill. Originally they had equal rights to the fishing with the landlord. Since the passing of the 1923 Land Act their claim has been contested by the landlord. The land is not yet vested. I would like if something could be inserted in this Bill to define the rights of these riparian owners, from whom we have had complaints. When the Act of 1929 was going through it was stated by the Minister for Fisheries or the Parliamentary Secretary that a certain section would define their rights. No section has been found to do so. The landlord contests their rights, and one of the riparian owners was imprisoned. It is hard on the riparian owners, who pay rent and rates, not to have the right to fish on the river. The Land Act of 1923 vested the fishing rights in the Land Commission, and in the Act of 1929 power was taken to give back the fishing rights to the landlord. The tenants' rights were not safeguarded.
Comment on this
It seems to me that it is only a matter of defining the tenants' rights. Surely that is a matter for a statutory tribunal like the Land Commission. It seems to me that there are ample tribunals to deal with the question.
Comment on this
The tenants had the right to fish in the river, but since the passing of the 1923 Act the landlord has contested that right and has prosecuted them.
Comment on this
In many cases since the passing of the 1923 Act the landlords in certain cases did vest the fishing rights in the riparian owners. Normally speaking, from the official and we would be against splitting up a river amongst riparian owners because of the fact that it would ruin the fishing in the area, unless you had a cooperative association of riparian owners to use the river as a whole. If, for instance, you had A., B., C. and D. along the banks of a river, the person nearest the mouth would fish as far as he could, leaving nothing for the man above him, and so on. As you went higher up the river the riparian rights would not be worth the paper they were written on. Normally speaking, it would be better for the Land Commission to conserve the rights pending the establishment of a co-operative association which the tenants might get up amongst themselves to set the river. Take a case where a man has purchased his holding under a former Land Act and got the fishing rights. B., his next-door neighbour, has also purchased, but the fishing rights on his land have been reserved for the landlord, while C. has the same rights as A. The case of B. comes under the 1923 Act and the fishing rights would vest in the Land Commission. The Land Commission would then vest them back to B., because they would be useless to the Land Commission, and they would trust to Heaven for some arrangement amongst the riparian owners not to ruin the river.
Comment on this
I am referring to the Slaney, on which the fishing is so valuable that last year it brought in £5,000 a mile. Certain tenants there have complained time after time that their right to fish was not contested until after the passing of the 1923 Act. Since then they have been prosecuted, some being fined and some imprisoned. Can anything be done to define their rights now? There appears to be no law to show that they have the same rights as the landlord.
Comment on this
The case I mentioned is one where the landlord sold an estate which is bordering on the river to the tenants. One tenant refused to purchase when he did not get the fishing rights. The quarrel went on from 1906 to 1923, when the Government stepped in and compelled the tenant to purchase. At that time the landlord began to set the river each year, although the tenant is paying for the river and also for part of the land that is flooded for part of the year. In this case I think the Minister was furnished with photographs showing three-fourths of the farm under water. The Parliamentary Secretary has so many cases to deal with that he has probably forgotten this one. I want to know why provision is not made in this coping-stone of all Land Bills for dealing with cases of this kind. Why have they not finished with the landlords for good? Why should the tenant pay rent for land over which the river flows? Why should he be paying rent for it while the landlord has the fishing rights? He is not alone paying the landlord for the land, but the landlord is selling the fish. Why should a tenant have to pay on the double? That is something that should be dealt with on the Report Stage if the usage of this House will allow it. It is a case in which we should have a definite statement from the Minister. Why should a tenant have to pay extra from 1906, after fighting the case with the landlord, until 1923, and then have a home Government come in and cut his throat, so to speak?
Comment on this
The amendment only deals with untenanted land, and this discussion relates to tenanted land and land vested under all the previous Land Acts.
Comment on this
It is only right that the sporting and fishing rights should, as far as possible, be transferred to the tenants. Very often grave injustice is done by allowing the sporting rights to remain in the hands of the former owner. I have in mind vast stretches of rough mountain land, to which turbary is attached, that has been used perhaps fairly usefully in the matter of game in the past, when the landlord resided in the district and maintained a staff on the bogs in the form of gamekeepers to protect the property. After the sale of the property, however, the landlord in many cases left the district, with the result that while he retains the sporting rights they are of no value to him. There is practically no letting value attaching to them. The game has been left unprotected, and there is very little left. What I have found is that a few unscrupulous people in the locality took over the game rights for a nominal sum and very often set fire to the heather.
Comment on this
That is outside the scope of the amendment. The Land Commission have no control over it. The sporting rights do not belong to the Land Commission.
Comment on this
I am afraid some Deputies have not read this amendment. Deputy Corry certainly must not have read it, because he did not address himself to it.
Comment on this
This section says that the Land Commission may from time to time publish lists (in this Act referred to as lists of holdings on untenanted land) of holdings on untenanted lands vested in the Land Commission otherwise than by transfer from the late Congested Districts Board or by purchase under powers transferred from that Board. That would refer to untenanted land.
Comment on this
We are discussing amendment 49 (a) to sub-section (2). We are not on the section at present. The Deputy could perhaps make his point on the section.
Comment on this
I think this amendment would include what I have in mind, if you allow me to make the case. It is intended to deal with the inclusion of sporting rights and the vesting of them with the untenanted land.
Comment on this
If the Deputy will read sub-section (2) and also the amendment he will see that the amendment only deals with what is specified in the list.
Comment on this
I am anxious to give Deputies as much information as possible, but this is an amendment to a section which deals with the publication of the lists of holdings of untenanted land; in other words, land acquired under the Act of 1923. I have listened very carefully to the Deputy's statement, and he is obviously dealing with a sale under the Act of 1903 where the tenants allowed the landlord to retain all the sporting rights.
Comment on this
I am referring to sporting rights retained by the owner or landlord where an estate has been sold.
Comment on this
He has the sporting rights, because the tenants left him the sporting rights, as they did in the majority of these sales. It has nothing to do with the section.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy connect that case with the Land Commission? Will he point out where the Land Commission comes into that case?
Comment on this
I hold that if this amendment is accepted the Land Commission will have power to acquire this property and the sporting rights in the same way as they had power to take over the land.
Comment on this
If the amendment is accepted, I hold that it will include the right of the Land Commission to take over this property.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, Deputy Derrig did not ask me to accept the amendment. He simply put it down to get an explanation as to the policy of the Land Commission with regard to the sale of sporting and fishing rights on untenanted land.
Comment on this
Might I ask would the amendment help to prevent the recurrence in future of a case such as that mentioned by Deputy Maguire?
Comment on this
No. The amendment only relates to untenanted land, in other words, land acquired under the Act of 1923. The case cited was evidently the case of an estate sold under the Act of 1903. It was obviously an agreed sale between the tenants and the landlord, and the tenants evidently agreed to allow the landlord to retain the sporting and fishing rights.
Comment on this
That is a different case, but is it clear now that if untenanted land is being scheduled and acquired by the Land Commission they will include particulars of the sporting rights?
Comment on this
Except in the case of the voluntary purchase of untenanted land. It may be that in certain cases the Land Commission, as I explained earlier, because of the very high price which they might have to pay for the rights, do not deem it advisable to acquire them.
Comment on this
I think the Parliamentary Secretary said that in certain cases the Land Commission do not consider it good business to acquire the sporting rights.
Comment on this
At the present time have they in their returns particulars of these sporting rights?
Comment on this
I think in regard to sporting rights on rivers, unless fairly long stretches on both sides are under one common control, not much good can be obtained. If there are a lot of different riparian owners, as there are in the upper portions of the Liffey, the fishing amounts to practically nothing, because while one man likes to conserve, his neighbour does not, and you find a hopeless state of affairs for the most part. I think where there is such a variety of ownership and no control, there is nothing for it but for the Land Commission to take over control of the river if the fishing is ever going to be any good, or is going to be an asset to the country. As I say, speaking for a river on which I own a certain amount of fishing, I know there are certain portions of it that are practically useless because my opposite neighbour would not bother taking charge of his share, and so it becomes perfectly useless although it might be quite good if there was general agreement. If the Land Commission could assume control in such cases—I do not know whether they could or not—good would result, otherwise each tract of the river becomes practically useless. With regard to shooting rights, under the 1923 Act, very few tenants got the sporting rights, with the result that there is practically no game at all. Since 1923 there has been a great improvement. The land that has been vested is now producing game which it did not do before, and there is a chance now of game being preserved through the formation of clubs. Before that, the thing was practically hopeless.
[Professor Thrift took the Chair.]
It is quite a good thing to give the tenant the right over the shooting where they combine in protecting these rights, but to retain it from them for that kind of thing is perfectly useless and has proved so in the past.
Comment on this
I feel that I am in agreement with the principle enunciated in this particular amendment. I also feel that this is a matter that could be easily arranged between the Parliamentary Secretary and the mover of the amendment. The Minister for Fisheries put his finger on the whole trouble when he gave the very apt illustration of three riparian owners, A, B and C. I am quite conversant with the details surrounding these cases or similar cases, where the Minister pointed out that. A. might have the fishing rights vested in him through an agreement between landlord and tenant; B. might have no interest whatever in the river, and their neighbour C. might have an interest by being a riparian owner or lessee. The Minister would have us infer, and he would be right, that that was a very difficult problem. There is, number one, the question of policing the river. The whole thing seems to be very much involved. But as I view this matter I think it is one the Minister might take into consideration, because we all hope that, one of those days, the tenant farmers of this country will have the full fishing and game rights vested in them.
The thing becomes more involved when you look up some existing agreements. In many instances you have the tenant who has purchased and got his vesting order and who, by agreement with the landlord, has practically given away his rights in so far as they relate to winged game and ground game and so far as they relate to fishing. In other cases we have the fishing rights retained by the former landlord, and the ground and the winged game rights the property of the tenant, and vice versa. The Minister will agree that that obtains in many districts. But I feel that when Deputy Derrig put down this amendment he had more in his mind than the mere discussion of it in an academic manner here in this Dáil. It would be a very useful thing in cases where the tenant was rather indifferent as to whether he would have the riparian or the game right vested in him if the Land Commission would take over these rights with a view to holding them either for the future tenant, or for the Land Commission solely, as they have done in many cases.
I think confusion has arisen in the minds of many persons in dealing with this amendment. We are dealing with untenanted land, not with land that has been purchased, land that is vested in the Land Commission, I suppose, in all cases. I would like to ask the Minister would it not be possible for the Land Commission in those cases to have those rights vested in themselves, that is, where no other arrangement is made with the landlord or the person from whom these lands were purchased. I think this is preeminently a case in which if the full letter of the amendment mentioned here is not accepted at least the spirit of it might be embodied in the Bill. I think that would meet any objections that might be present in the mind of anybody. I have frequently found, going through the country—and this must be the experience of many other Deputies who either fish or shoot— that the tenant farmer who has the game rights reserved to him either comes to an agreement with his previous landlord, or, because he may have had these rights before, gives permission to shoot over his land. It is frequently found, however, that by stepping over the boundary fence you would be entering a tract of land where the sporting rights are reserved to the landlord. That has caused any amount of trouble in various parts of the country, and the same thing is true in regard to riparian rights. As I have indicated, I think the Minister might accept the spirit of this amendment and embody it in some way in its proper place in the Bill: whether that should be done in Section 23 or in some other section I am not capable of judging.
I do feel that the Minister for Lands and Fisheries put his finger on the whole trouble. I have experience of this myself, for I have been up against it on some occasions. I again repeat that it would be a useful thing to have embodied in this Act in some section the spirit which is indicated in the amendment put down by Deputy Derrig.
Comment on this
Deputy Anthony is under a misapprehension with regard to the whole matter. In fact, under the Land Act of 1923 the fishing and sporting rights do pass automatically to the Land Commission. They exercise a discretion over them. In one of the cases that I mentioned A purchased under the 1923 Act and he had the fishing rights in the river, and B purchased and had no fishing rights; C purchased and had the fishing rights, and D had not the fishing rights, and so on. In that particular case the fishing rights in B's holding vested in the Land Commission, just as in the other cases of purchase under the 1923 Act. But because of the fact that the fishing would be practically useless to the Land Commission, or for any other purpose, they probably hand it over to the tenant, since his neighbours adjoining him have the fishing rights. In a case where the river basin was mostly in one estate the rights would vest in the Land Commission. The Land Commission was able to deal with the whole river. In that case the Land Commission would hold the fishing rights, utilising them for the development of the fisheries there.
Comment on this
What happens in such a case if prior to the vesting the landlord has leased the sporting rights of the estate? Supposing that last year, in the case of an estate not yet vested, the landlord leased the sporting rights for five years, will that right given by the lease hold after the vesting?
Comment on this
I cannot imagine any letting that a landlord made or any lease that he would give that would not be governed by that Act of 1923. You have an estate, say, which comes under the 1923 Act, and during the period between the passing of the Act and the actual vesting of the estate any lease that the landlord makes must be subject to the 1923 Act.
Comment on this
Section 45 of the Land Act of 1923 deals with the whole matter. The section reads: "On the vesting of any lands in the Land Commission under this Act all sporting rights as defined in sub-section (2) of Section 13 of the Irish Land Act, 1903, including such sporting rights as may be superior interests, and all fisheries appurtenant to the said lands shall vest in the Land Commission, subject to any lease then existing as if the owner or owners had agreed to sell them at such price as in the absence of agreement shall be fixed by the Land Commission . . ," and so on.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Parliamentary Secretary read Section 4 of the Act of 1929, and he will get quite a different thing.
Comment on this
Taking it that the Parliamentary Secretary is right, this lease will hold after the vesting of the land, and it is not proposed under the present Bill to interfere with this lease in any way——
Comment on this
Yes, a prior lease. I am not asking this as an academic question. I have in mind a case where the lease was made two years ago, and the vesting is being prepared at the moment.
Comment on this
I take it this amendment was only put down for the purpose of eliciting information.
Comment on this
Yes, a large number of Deputies were anxious about it.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not going to press the amendment?
Comment on this
I move amendment 50a:—
In Sub-section (1), line 54, page 12, after the word "from" to insert the words "the gale day on which his rent is payable next after."
This is put down for the convenience of calculating the annuities. It is desirable that the annuity period should start from the gale day rather than that it should start at some period a week or a month after the gale day. That would mean having to make calculations as to the amount of the annuity from the gale day to the Appointed Day. This amendment really has been introduced for the purpose of making it more convenient for the Land Commission to carry out the operations of this Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendments 51 and 52:—
At the end of sub-section (1), page 13, to insert a new paragraph as follows:—
"(d) if a holding is sold to such tenant in exchange for the holding hereinbefore mentioned, until the gale day next after the date of the vesting order in respect of the said holding so sold."
At the end of the section, page 13, to add a new sub-section as follows:—
"(6) Where a holding is sold to the tenant of a holding comprised in a list of congested districts holdings or in a list of holdings on untenanted land and is so sold in exchange for the said holding comprised in such list, so much as the Land Commission shall direct of the payments made by such tenant to the Land Commission in respect of the said annual sum payable by such tenant under this section in respect of the said holding comprised in such list shall, from and after the date of the vesting order in respect of the first-mentioned holding, be treated as payments in respect of purchase annuity."
These are really drafting amendments. They provide that on the vesting of rearranged holdings the tenant shall get the benefit of all his previous sinking fund payments made since the date of the publication of the list of the holdings. It is in the interests of the tenants.
Comment on this
I move amendment 54:—
In sub-section (1), line 29, page 14, before the word "where" to insert the words: "Without prejudice to the powers in that behalf heretofore exercisable by the High Court and the Circuit Court the following provision shall apply, viz.:—"
I do not foresee that there will be very great opposition to this amendment. The amendment merely proposes to retain certain powers that exist already or that may exist—the power to amend these orders by judgment in action or certain powers that exist in the Circuit Court, powers that are not so far-reaching as the powers which Section 29 seek to give, but which may, perhaps, be more conveniently exercised locally. I do not know if it will be said that the section as it stands does not detract from those powers, but it is thought by many Deputies here, even if argument could be put up for that construction of the section, that for greater caution the words which the amendment seeks to introduce are not objectionable. For that reason I commend this amendment to the Deputies opposite. Possibly they are not with out reason for hoping that the Parliamentary Secretary will see his way to accept it or to accept some slight modification of it.
Comment on this
I really have no objection to the introduction of these words, but I do not think they are necessary, because the section does not interfere in any way with the powers of the existing Courts.
Comment on this
I am glad the Parliamentary Secretary does not see objection. Sometimes it is urged that when a particular remedy is provided all other remedies are excluded. It is to prevent the operation of that construction that it is desirable to introduce these words.
Comment on this
As I say, I do not think it is really necessary, because it is not intended to interfere in any way with the jurisdiction of the Courts, and the section as drafted provides a cheaper and more expeditious method of remedying the error.
Comment on this
I think I conceded at the opening that the section, as drafted, does give powers which hitherto have not existed, and does assist in many ways in dealing with vesting orders in which there are omissions or errors. At the same time, we desire to provide a local remedy that is available and may be resorted to in preference. However, we will be satisfied if the Parliamentary Secretary will consider the effect of the amendment. If the Parliamentary Secretary is quite sure that the amendment as it stands does not take away any existing rights we would probably be satisfied, but we would ask him if he has the slightest doubt that he should for greater caution put in those words or similar words.
Comment on this
I will certainly get the section examined. I have no objection to these words, but I am still of opinion that they are unnecessary.
Comment on this
That is a general question that runs through the Bill, and we should leave it open for the present.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, there is such an appeal already. I think you can rule this amendment out.
Comment on this
I may, perhaps, draw attention to a note by the Ceann Comhairle on this point. He suggests that you can raise the same question on the whole section, and it might be desirable to reserve that question until the whole section is being discussed.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, amendment 47 was to come up on this section also. We postponed it until Section 33 was reached. I would prefer to move the amendment.
Comment on this
I would just point out to you that if you move amendment 56 it will rule out amendment 57, and you may, perhaps, prefer to move amendment 57.
Comment on this
I propose amendment 57:—
In sub-section (1) (a), after the word "may," line 21, to insert the words: "after such notice by advertisement or otherwise as to the Court shall seem sufficient."
Paragraph (a) reads—"The court may direct payment of a claim in respect of which the court is of opinion that the title of the claimant, though imperfect, is nevertheless such as to make it improbable that any claim adverse to such first-mentioned claim could be sustained." The proposal in the amendment is to insert the words, "after such notice by advertisement or otherwise as to the court shall seem sufficient." By doing that, I think that some safeguard is introduced as regards the powers which are given to the court to enable the purchase-money to be paid out on an imperfect claim, which it has been argued is necessary if the Land Bill is to be proceeded with, and if unnecessary obstacles are to be removed. Some safeguard should be inserted, and the safeguard that the court shall issue due notice in respect of the matter to all who may be involved in no way places a real obstacle in the way of the court. They would still have the powers under the paragraph as it now stands. I think it is a very reasonable amendment. I may say here that we are not satisfied with a great many things in this particular Section, but this is a matter I think the parliamentary Secretary could meet us on without any trouble.
Comment on this
I have no objection to accepting this amendment but I am perfectly satisfied that the court would in any event issue an advertisement and it is rather unusual to dictate to a court how it should do its business. However, I am prepared to accept the amendment but it may need re-drafting.
Comment on this
I move amendment 58:
In sub-section (1) (a), line 24, to delete the words "make it improbable that any" and substitute the words "raise a judicial presump-that no."
The amendment is simply a change of words. The expression in the Bill is "make it improbable that any claim adverse to such first mentioned claim could be sustained." We want to put in what I am advised is a more legal way—"raise a judicial presumption that no," so that instead of its being merely a question of probability it will be a case where the court will have to exercise their judicial intelligence and definitely decide not alone that the thing is improbable but that there is in their judgment a definite presumption that no adverse claim could be sustained. It is simply the same thing in other words.
Comment on this
I do not think the amendment can improve the Section in any way. I do not understand the meaning of the words "raise a judicial presumption." I do not know exactly what the legal meaning of these words is. It appears to me that they have no legal meaning at all.
Comment on this
I move amendment 58 (a):—
In sub-section (1) (b), line 27, to delete the word "not."
Sub-section (b) as it stands definitely states "it shall not be obligatory on the court to inquire as to the existence or non-existence of any adverse estate, right, claim or interest which is not disclosed by such evidence."
We want to delete the word "not" and to make it definitely obligatory on the court to inquire. We put down the amendment in that form—it is really a direct negative—to elicit information. Why should it be made definitely not obligatory on the court to inquire into the existence of other claims? It seems to me that if there is a real objection to dictating to the courts it is in a matter like this. We definitely order the courts that they shall be entitled to act on the evidence of title of the first claimant and that it is not obligatory on them to make inquiry in the case of adverse claims. I think that we are directing the courts not to do a definite thing which to them may seem right and proper to do.
Comment on this
The clause really means that the court can act on the evidence submitted and that it will not be obligatory on them to look around and ascertain if there are other undisclosed claimants to portions of the purchase money. The deletion of the word "not" would mean that the courts could not accept the title offered by the claimant. The practice as to the examination of titles has worked satisfactorily for the last fifty years since the first Land Act was passed and it is unnecessary to change the procedure in that respect.
Comment on this
Does it not mean that it is obligatory on the vendor to prove his title?
Comment on this
It is obligatory on the other party to prove title but not obligatory on the Land Commission to do the work they should be doing.
Comment on this
In clause (a) it says that they can accept an imperfect title but then you go on to say in clause (b) that you must prove a correct title.
Comment on this
It does not mean what the Deputy says. An imperfect title may mean a flaw going back a hundred years or more. Title would not be held up for anything you could put your hand on, say, up to fifty years ago. I know a case which has been held up for 20 years in connection with the Land Act of 1903 owing to a flaw existing for over 100 years.
Comment on this
I am only dealing with the statement of Deputy Gorey, that it is obligatory on the claimant to prove his title.
Comment on this
Even though it may be imperfect, if they are satisfied that there are no other claimants they can go ahead.
Comment on this
Deputy Gorey means that the section does not relieve the Land Commission of the responsibility of inquiring into the title.
Comment on this
What Deputy Gorey said was rather misleading. This amendment was put down to elicit information, and that information, as vouchsafed by the Parliamentary Secretary, convinced a number of Deputies, but Deputy Gorey intervenes and makes a statement which is indefensible. I understand from the Parliamentary Secretary that it is intended to empower the Land Commission to take a risk, provided it is, in the opinion of the judicial officer, negligible or remote. We are satisfied with that. We merely put down the amendment to insure that that risk is remote. If we understand the Parliamentary Secretary to say that the present procedure is to guard against any substantial risk we are satisfied but we would not be satisfied with the gloss which Deputy Gorey puts upon the section.
Comment on this
I move:—
In sub-section (1) (c), to delete all the words after the word "as," line 45, to the end of the paragraph and substitute the words, "such person would have been entitled to receive had he claimed within the time for claiming compensation without interest and after deducting such costs and expenses as in the judgment of the court were occasioned by his delay in making his claim."
Sub-section 1 (c) provides for the payment of compensation to persons who subsequently prove to the court that he or they had a claim, even though a previous claimant had been paid, and that compensation should be paid to those subsequent claimants who proved their title. This amendment does not involve a big matter, and perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary will accept it.
Comment on this
I am not sure that the Deputy is quite clear about the amendment. If I were to accept it, it would mean that the court in all cases must pay claims in full, and cannot exercise any discretion in the matter. As the clause is worded at present, there is a certain amount of discretion allowed, and the court may not allow a full claim unless the merits of the case justify it. The amendment makes it obligatory on the court to pay the full amount in all cases. As the section is drafted, it gives the court a certain discretion, and it is not obligatory on them to give the full amount. There may be circumstances in which the court would not be justified in paying the full amount. There is really very little between us. It is only a matter of interpretation.
Comment on this
No doubt the court is better able to deal with cases when they come before it than we are now, but it seems to me the court has complete discretion as matters stand. Would not the Parliamentary Secretary consider making some provision as regards costs and expenses, and the question of interest? They are really only minor matters, but perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary would look into them.
Comment on this
The amendment proposed by the Deputy means that it is obligatory, mandatory, on the court to pay the full amount of compensation. The section, as it is worded, gives the court a certain amount of discretion. There are certain cases where it is not necessary to pay the full amount, where it would be unfair to the State to pay the full amount claimed and the question of expenses will be taken into consideration.
Comment on this
I move:—
Before sub-section (3), page 17, to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"(3) In the foregoing sub-section of this section references to the day on which the purchase-money of an estate is distributed shall be construed as referring to the day on which that portion of the purchase-money of such estate in relation to the distribution of which compensation is claimed is distributed."
This is merely a drafting amendment to define the date on which the money is distributed.
Comment on this
I move:—
To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
"Any sum which might be paid to an agent under sub-section (8) of Section 40 of the Land Act, 1923, on his ceasing to act as such agent, may, in the event of the allocation of the purchase money occurring before he has ceased to act as such agent, be retained by the Judicial Commissioner out of the purchase money and may be paid to the agent in whole or in part at such time or times as to the court may seem just."
This is a drafting amendment. Under the provisions of the Bill the agent in most cases will not cease to be an agent until the purchase money is allocated. The amendment enables payment to be made to him on account out of the sum coming to him even when he has ceased to be an agent. It is a continuation of the right which agents had under the Act of 1923.
Comment on this
Amendment 47 and the consequential amendments will have to be taken now. Shall I propose them formally?
Comment on this
All the Deputy can do now is to speak on the Section and raise the subject matter of the amendments. If they are not agreed to the Deputy can vote against the section.
Comment on this
The Deputy can raise the subject matter of that.
Comment on this
Have I not a right to get a decision on amendment 47 as distinct from the other amendments?
Comment on this
There was an agreement come to that when we reached Section 33 we would go back to Section 20 and discuss amendment 47.
Comment on this
I think the best way would be to move amendment 47 as an additional clause to Section 33 and then take amendment 56, because voting against the whole Section is the same as deleting part of it. It goes with amendments 62 and 64, which are on Section 33.
Comment on this
Amendment 47 deals specifically with the guarantee deposit in Section 20. I do not see how it can be raised except incidentally in connection with Section 33.
Comment on this
Apparently the arrangement was to postpone it until the Deputy came to Section 33.
Comment on this
That was merely to save time because many of the arguments adduced in favour of amendment 47 would apply to many of the amendments in connection with Section 33. Of course amendment No. 47 cannot be made a sub-clause of Section 33. If it is to be adopted at all it must form part of Section 20.
Comment on this
Cannot the Deputy raise the whole matter and get a definite decision on it on this section?
Comment on this
I would be quite willing to raise the whole matter but I would like to have a decision on amendment 47 as a distinct matter from Section 33.
Comment on this
If the Deputy wants to get a separate decision I am afraid he will have to get it on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
On other Bills this has been the practice. For instance, in the Betting Bill when a certain definition in that Bill was connected up with a clause in a subsequent section, the Ceann Comhairle postponed the taking of that definition until we came to the particular clause. Then he took the definition and placed it in its own niche, and read it with the other clause. The understanding about this particular amendment was that when we arrived at this part of the Bill we would go back and amend the previous section by either adding that particular clause——
Comment on this
The Deputy can get exactly the same point discussed on the Report Stage, and I have no doubt that he can get permission to deal with it in a committee way on that Stage.
Comment on this
If, in fact, the arrangement was that outlined by Deputy Little, ought not that arrangement be carried out?
Comment on this
I began by giving Deputy Derrig the option of moving the amendment, but he did not seem willing to do it.
Comment on this
I am quite prepared to move the amendment.
[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]
Comment on this
The point is when we came to amendments 56, 62 and 64, the Acting-Chairman, Deputy Thrift, said they would have to be discussed on Section 33, and I called his attention to amendment 47. He said the best thing would be to discuss the whole matter as the same principle underlies the three amendments. I am not clear what the position then would be. Can we have a vote, if necessary, on these amendments separately, or is the position that if we had a vote on them and were defeated, we could not again raise the matter?
Comment on this
The Deputy, if he wanted a decision on Section 33, could get a decision on the section. The Deputy cannot move 47 now, because the Committee passed the section. That does not rule the Deputy out. He can bring amendment 47 up on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
Irrespective of the fate of 62 and 64 now, I had better discuss the general question.
Comment on this
The Deputy did not move 62 or 64 or 47. Therefore, the Deputy has the right to move these or similar ones on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
On the section, Section 33, as the House is aware, sets up machinery for expediting the distribution of the purchase money, first, by permitting or directing the Court that the purchase money should be paid out even where the title is imperfect, and secondly, without having to inquire into the existence of any adverse claims. This section provides compensation for subsequent claimants who prove to the satisfaction of the Court that they had a title. Compensation is, however, to be paid out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas. Now, it seems to us that there is no valid reason for paying this compensation out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas, and the scheme of our amendments was to have compensation met out of a special fund of 2 per cent. which would form part of the guarantee deposit. In that way the money which would go to meet compensation would be provided from the purchase money which is being withheld. As has been now stressed, the guarantee deposit is being set up for a specific purpose to provide adjustments. If the principle of the guarantee deposit is admitted for adjustments later on, I certainly think it should be an equitable and a fair thing that the guarantee deposit should also apply to this provision for compensation. I do not see why the taxpayer should be made amenable. The amount of money involved, I understand from the Parliamentary Secretary, is not expected to be very large. It is undoubtedly a hypothetical question. We have no idea whatever of the extent to which we will commit the State if we pass the section as it stands. I would like to hear from the Parliamentary Secretary why the State should provide the money and why the guarantee deposit should not be made responsible.
Comment on this
I do not think there is any necessity for a guarantee deposit in this case. The Land Commission for the last twenty or thirty years acted as if this section had been the law, and no single claim has been made against the Land Commission in respect of any purchase money paid out. This section is taken from the Northern Ireland Land Act of 1928. I understand in Northern Ireland they have investigated a certain number of cases and no claims have been made against the Land Commission there. I am perfectly satisfied that no claim will be made here, but it is better to have this section in this Act, because the Examiners of Title will have to deal with a glut of work during the next few years.
There is another point and it is this, it enables the Land Commission to deal speedily with the investigation of titles to small estates. The titles to the large estates are always clear. The titles are not always so clear in the case of small estates, and this section will enable the Land Commission to deal speedily with the investigation of these titles. It is most unlikely that any claim will arise in connection with the purchase money distributed by the Court under this section. In any event, the Judicial Commissioner, if he is of opinion when distributing purchase money that a claim may be made against it at some later date, has power to withhold a certain portion of the money to meet that claim.
Comment on this
Those are his general powers as Judicial Commissioner. He has always enjoyed those powers. They have been conferred on the Judicial Commissioner since the Land Act of 1881.
Comment on this
I thought it better to include the section to help the Land Commission to speed up vesting in small cases. I decided it was better to have a section such as this in the Act.
Comment on this
I understand from the Parliamentary Secretary that he is satisfied these things will not occur. There will be no claims because they have never occurred before. That is his argument.
Comment on this
I explained that the Land Commission had acted as if this section had been in operation for the last thirty years in the case of small estates.
Comment on this
There never were any claims of this sort before. Therefore, they will not occur again. Is not the whole atmosphere changed?
Comment on this
I suggest vis a tergo has been applied to the Land Commission and they are going to hurry up. Up to the present they have been at a circumlocution pace. They are prepared to take twenty-five or thirty years or seven generations if necessary to vest land and now they are going to be actually asked to hurry. They are people with two speeds, dead slow and dead stop. We are to assume that the same conditions will occur when they are asked to get into high gear.
I do not believe it for a moment. These people have been doing their work in a "dolce far niente," a Kathleen Mavourneen atmosphere, and apparently they have not been educated to hurry. It seems to me that we are introducing into the Land Commission something more than the snail's pace. In the progress of affairs you cannot argue that exactly the same things that happened under the recognition of the snail's pace as the right pace is going to happen again. It seems to me that the whole argument of the Parliamentary Secretary was due to sluggishness to almost go-astern, dead stoppedness. They have always been able to take long enough not to have these things arising. Now, when they are asked to vest land, it looks as if such questions will arise. If they do arise, it looks reasonable that the State should take an insurance premium of two per cent. to meet these cases. That is a reasonable proposition, and as a preliminary, I suggest to the Parliamentary Secretary that it is the first indication of his intention of running the Land Commission as a businesslike department, and that he will insure his risk in this matter.
Comment on this
I think this is the most ridiculous section that was ever introduced into any Bill when the greater portion of the money has been spent. The Parliamentary Secretary then started to prevent the tenants by every means in his power getting back any of the money that was robbed from them during the last few years. We have this special section inserted, first to provide the purchase money for landlords with bad titles, and secondly, to pay compensation to other claimants who may come in subsequently and establish a claim. The money is to be provided out of State funds—out of taxes—and probably is to be provided by tenants who have been already mulcted. It is the most ridiculous section I have ever seen in any Bill. Sub-section (4) is the most combative part of the Bill. It provides that when the thief is gone with the loot, perhaps for five or six years, and the money spent in Monte Carlo, the Land Commission is going to go after him and make him return the money. What is the idea underlying that sub-section? Provision is made in the Bill whereby a landlord with bad title is paid the purchase money. What is to prevent the Land Commission from withholding the purchase money until the title is made perfect. What is the need for the sub-section? Is it not bad enough to have a National Government collecting rents for the landlords of estates, where the title is bad? That is a thing that tenants in their wildest dreams never expected to see taking place in this country.
As if that were not bad enough we have a special sub-section to provide compensation for any gentleman who comes along after the original purchase price has been paid to another man. That compensation is to be paid by the State. It seems most ridiculous after purchase money has been paid to a gentleman with bad title, that compensation is to be paid to another gentleman who may come along three or four years later with a better title. The Free State Government is then going to search the four winds of the world for the man who went away with the loot in order to make him disgorge. The section indicates the frame of mind of those who brought in this loot for landlords Bill—which is the appropriate name for it. I understood the Parliamentary Secretary to say that he got the idea for this section from the Land Act passed in the Northern Parliament where no claim had been made under a similar section. He went to the landlords of Ulster, who have formed a Parliament there, and brought down this section to be put into a Bill here, in a so-called National Parliament. The Parliamentary Secretary expects Deputies on the opposite Benches to vote for this section. Surely we are not going to have that state of affairs. Surely Deputies opposite are not going to let themselves to be led by the nose, so to speak, into voting for this section, fearing that they would be thrown out of office by thirteen or fourteen Deputies here who represent the landlords. I ask Deputies to consider whether their constituents would stand for it.
Let them look at it in the light that it provides for nothing else but for wholesale robbery by a Government which refused to return to the unfortunate tenants £269,000 that was taken from them. Deputies voted against returning that money to the tenants and now they are going to vote money to landlords to which they have no claim. Surely we are not going to have that state of affairs in this so-called National Parliament, no matter how low national ideals may have fallen amongst those on the opposite benches. I hope this section will be eliminated, seeing that there is nothing to prevent the Land Commission when they are not satisfied with the title from withholding the money until the title is proved.
Comment on this
There is a remarkable contrast between the attitude of the Minister in this section and in the section that has been referred to by Deputy Corry. There is the meticulous care which the Parliamentary Secretary exercises in protecting rights which he pleads are almost non-existent. The grounds on which he advocates acceptance of the section almost amount to this, that the section is unneccessary because so far no claim has ever arisen. But out of the abundance of care he wishes to protect any possible chance of such a claiming arising in the future. Contrast that attitude with his attitude towards the tenants, who have a real grievance, because they have had to make payments in lieu of rents over a long period.
Although the case made by the Parliamentary Secretary may be correct, that it is only a small matter, at the same time, it involves a very invidious and vicious principle. The very fact that it is such a small matter should induce the Parliamentary Secretary to drop it altogether. For the very reasons which he has put forward before so often, that amendments from this side of the House were unnecessary, I think that he should withdraw the section, especially as it embodies a principle which is invidious and may be the subject of abuse, and which is going to take money out of the pockets of the taxpayer. If there is to be a fund reserved for such a purpose, it should be the reserve fund taken from the purchase money and it should not be taken out of the moneys of the State.
Comment on this
I should like to appeal to members of Cumann na nGaedheal who express sympathy with the small farmer to consider well what they are going to do here. They are proposing to guarantee payment to landlord claimants, no matter when they turn up. It may be this year or it may be in 20 years, but they are going to secure that these claimants, whenever they turn up, will get their full pound of flesh. They are going to repay them for something that their ancestors seized from the people. Just compare the treatment that is going to be meted out to the landlords with the treatment given to the subscribers to the Dáil Eireann Loan. A definite arrangement was made by the Minister for Finance that claims for repayment of subscriptions to the Dáil Eireann Loan could only be made within two years. After that they were to get nothing, although they had come forward in a time of national stress and subscribed voluntarily to national funds. Very different treatment is being meted out to the subscribers to that loan from that which it is proposed to mete out to the landlords. I think it would be quite a reasonable thing to ask the landlords to give the 2 per cent. insurance premium that Deputy Flinn has suggested. If after a certain number of years no claim comes forward, then the principal and whatever interest may have accrued can be distributed amongst the landlords in proportion to the sums they put into the insurance fund. We have the greatest possible objection to giving the landlords the right to come forward for a great number of years and make their claims, seeing that the subscribers to the Dáil Eireann Loan have only got a few months to put in theirs.
Comment on this
This section is one of the most reactionary in the Bill. It will compare very badly with the attitude adopted towards the tenants. The tenants, in order to get assistance from the State to purchase their holdings must become co-operators, and everyone of them is a security for payment by the others. That is the condition that is applied as a test to the tenants. Whether they like it or not the farmers are jointly responsible for the payment of each other. Now we come to deal with the position of the landlord. If there is any question of security for him, the State is asked to bear it. If any faulty title is passed over on the Land Commission in the new rush that is coming, the tenants must bear that. The landlord must be paid his money and it must be done quickly. Would it not be reasonable to put the same responsibility on the landlords as on the tenants? If the State is going to pay the money over to the landlords, why not make the landlords co-operators in this to the same extent as the tenants? If through misjudgment or over anxiety to speed up matters money passes out of the hands of the Land Commission to some claimant to property who ultimately turns out not to be the proper claimant, let the landlords be responsible by creating a fund in advance to meet such a contingency. Clearly that is only common sense. This section proposes to make the State responsible all the time, to make the State responsible, first for each tenant co-operator to the extent he is responsible for the payment, and, secondly, to make the State responsible for the payment to the landlord; and, in the event of a mistake being made by paying the wrong owner, the State is again responsible for the payment of the second, and perhaps the third, fourth and fifth claimant. There is no limit to where this thing may lead us. So that instead of buying out the landlords' interest once, as we assume we are doing under these Land Acts, we may in reality have to buy it out oftener. There should be some guarantee here but that guarantee should not be the security of the State. It is quite enough for the State to buy out the interest of the landlords once and the State should seek guarantees that they will not be asked to repeat that again. The security suggested against that is, that the landlords should take their share of responsibility, and if payment is to be made to them as a class and risks are to be taken as a result of immediate payment, then they must take the risk of any mistake that may happen through paying the wrong person.
Comment on this
The discussion on this section has revealed an anti-landlord complex. This is not designed to facilitate the landlords.
Comment on this
It is designed to facilitate the investigation of the tenant's title primarily, particularly tenants whose lands we propose to resume. It is also designed to save the taxpayer and the State, because in the case of a resumed holding it is obligatory on the Land Commission to make a rigid investigation into the tenant's title, and it may mean that the tenant will have to carry out such an investigation in countries outside this State. In some cases he may have to carry out that investigation in Australia, New Zealand, America, or some European country. In that case the expenses have to be borne by the State out of the Costs Fund, and these expenses are very heavy, so that this section is really designed to save the taxpayer and the State, and to facilitate the investigation of title, to facilitate the Land Commission in dealing with the resumption of land, and in distributing it amongst those for whom it is intended.
Deputies misunderstand the scope of the whole section. In reply to Deputy Flinn, who obviously does not understand the aim and scope of this Land Act, I must say that I have not time to deal with all the inaccuracies in his statement. I am satisfied that our Examiners will not increase the pace in their investigation of title by one tittle. The investigation of title is very difficult, intricate and detailed work, and it cannot be carried out at a fast pace. We propose to increase the rate of progress by increasing the staff of Examiners, which is the only way that we can do it.
Comment on this
Will the Parliamentary Secretary say what single word he has offered against the question of whether or not he should take an insurance premium for the risk?
Comment on this
It is all very well for the Parliamentary Secretary to snarl, but snarling is not an answer to my argument. I have suggested that when this Department started to be a business Department it should do what an ordinary business would do, namely, insure against risk. Snarling is not an answer to that.
Comment on this
This is a rather serious matter in which the State and the community as a whole may have to pay the piper. Suggestions were made to the Parliamentary Secretary that he should safeguard the community in this respect and that a limit of time at any rate should be put in. There is nothing as far as I can see to indicate the period after which no further claims could be put forward.