Land Bill, 1930—Third Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 357–545 of 545. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 29 of 1930 ›
What is the Parliamentary Secretary's interpretation of his own Bill? What period is fixed after which claims cannot be heard but will be ruled out by a statute of limitation of some kind besides the ordinary one? Is there any definite limitation provided here, and if so what is the period?
Comment on this
That is not an answer. There have been several interpretations put forward and I want to know what is the Parliamentary Secretary's interpretation of his own Bill.
Comment on this
My interpretation is that which is contained in sub-section (2) (b) of this section.
Comment on this
I am not at all satisfied with the Parliamentary Secretary's explanation. This is a bigger matter than the Dáil realises. Most of these cases are held up in the Land Commission's Department for five or six years owing to the fact that the titles were not perfect. They are all to be dealt with now. We have a most extraordinary provision made here as to the length of time which can elapse before a payment is paid. We have sub-section (2) which the Parliamentary Secretary alluded to. The sub-section says that the time for claiming compensation shall be whichever of the following times is applicable, that is to say: "Where the person claiming compensation was under the age of 21 years on the day on which the purchase-money was distributed within six years after such person attains the age of 21 years." A boy might be 12 years now and in 9 years time he will be 21 years and six years after that he could claim the money. That is one case. The second case is: "Where the compensation is claimed in respect of mortgage, charge, or other incumbrance, within whichever of the following periods is the shorter, that is to say, six years from the day on which the last payment in respect of the principal of or the interest on such incumbrance was made before the making of the claim for compensation or thirty years from the day on which the purchase-money was distributed." Thirty years time, and two years was all that was allowed for claimants on the Dáil Eireann loan. And "where the compensation is claimed in respect of a superior interest within whichever of the following periods is the shorter, that is to say six years from the day on which the last payment of rent, interest or other income from such superior interest was made before the making of the claim for compensation or 30 years from the day on which the purchase-money was distributed."
This appeared to me to be the most ridiculous section that was ever brought in in any Bill, and Deputy Gorey will tell us later on that it cannot be interfered with. He told us that when we were looking for money for the tenants. We now know that this Act is going to bind this State for 30 years time to pay compensation to somebody who comes up with a claim and this special section is designed to enable us to look after the fellow who wants to get the money. I do not know who drafted this section, but it is the most ridiculous affair I ever saw brought into the Dáil. I do not know who the draftsman is or what salary he is paid, but I hope we will have the opportunity of dealing with him in his proper place. The idea of this special section is that it is brought in here to safeguard the landlords.
Comment on this
It is repetition for at least six times both on the amendment and on the section. The Deputy is making the same speech. It is mere repetition.
Comment on this
I am trying to get this section understood by Deputies who, apparently, are very anxious not to understand it.
Comment on this
I had to go into the matter, sub-section by sub-section, in view of the Parliamentary Secretary's reply to Deputy de Valera.
Comment on this
I said this is the biggest scandal ever brought in to a so-called National Parliament which rules the 26 counties at the present time.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary has indicated that by the appointment of a few extra examiners in the Land Commission the investigation of the title will be hastened. Does the Parliamentary Secretary seriously contend that the appointment of a few extra officials to this work-shy Department—a Department which is the greatest scandal in the State, whose officials do not work three hours, and spend most of those three hours per day dodging the clock and swinging the lead——
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary contended that investigation of title would be hastened by the appointment of a few extra officials. We have this Department, where there is no supervision, where there is no coordination, and where everything is haphazard and——
Comment on this
That is a matter for the Land Commission Estimate. It is a question of the administration of a Department. The Deputy can discuss that on the Estimate.
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment 66:—
"In sub-section (1), page 18, line 21, to add after the word `vendor' the words `or his agent."'
As is well known a good deal of the money that goes to the agent is dispensed by him and very often the landlord does not get anything. The money goes to certain people who have mortgages on the estate and consequently it would be only fair that this protection should be given to the agent.
Comment on this
It seems to me that this amendment is really not necessary as payment to the vendors implies power to pay the agent. The amendment is not necessary at all.
Comment on this
Perhaps the parliamentary Secretary would amend the section in this way. "Such purchase money be paid as they accrue to the agent of vendor or such other person who has been in receipt of payment on behalf of the vendor."
Comment on this
Well, of course, the agent can always be paid by the direction of the Judicial Commissioner.
Comment on this
Is this the case where a landlord has no title at all and where some thief has been collecting the money and pretending to represent the landlord?
Comment on this
I would like if some information were given by the Parliamentary Secretary as to what period of time is likely to elapse during which dividends on land bonds will be paid. Furthermore, will the interest on the land bonds which are held as a guarantee deposit be paid in the same way to the person entitled to receive it?
Comment on this
The interest on the land bonds held as a guarantee deposit will be paid exactly in the same way as interest on the purchase-money to the person entitled to receive it.
Comment on this
What period is likely to elapse between the order made that the dividends are to be paid and the distribution of the purchase-money? How long is this payment of the dividends on the bonds pending the distribution of the purchase-money likely to last?
Comment on this
I could not say. Under this Bill it is proposed to speed up the investigation of title with the object of getting the purchase-money distributed as soon as possible.
Comment on this
May I take it that the position with reference to the last section means that this State will not even protect itself to the extent of keeping a certain fund undistributed whilst paying the interest and the dividends on it? Surely that is a very natural form of insurance, and should be the one that should be adopted with all fairness to the State on the one hand, and would not be a severe hardship on the vendor on the other. It seems to me that the Parliamentary Secretary has provided even for the child unborn in this previous section. So careful was he in protecting minors that it would be but a short step further to provide for those who will be born a century hence. Is the community to get no protection whatever? An obvious way of protecting the community is there, namely, not to distribute a percentage of these bonds, but to reserve that percentage as an insurance fund to meet possible claims where mistakes may have been made, and to fix a definite period after which claims will not be considered.
It seems to me that there is no attention whatever being paid to the interests of the community by the Parliamentary Secretary, while, as somebody said, he is meticulous in his care to preserve the rights of the vendor. Here is a section under which it would be possible for him to protect the community by keeping a certain reserve and paying the dividends on it to those who are entitled to them. This whole Bill is almost scandalous in its disregard of the rights of the community. I admit that in some cases it is very difficult to meet the difficulties that arise, but when an obvious solution is there I see no reason why the Parliamentary Secretary will not adopt it.
Comment on this
The Deputy seems to have forgotten Section 20. Under that section the Land Commission retain 10 per cent. of the purchase money as a guarantee against loss.
Comment on this
Until the Land Commission is satisfied that it is no longer necessary for them to retain such deposits. In addition, the Land Commission has always power to apply to the Judicial Commissioner to retain a certain amount of the purchase money in special cases where it is necessary to retain money to cover a certain charge or liability.
Comment on this
Because we are the custodians of the interests of the community as a whole and we ought to safeguard their interests. I might as well ask what is the meaning of any limitation imposed by statutes. Why not leave it all to the administration? Why not completely trust the Executive, trust the Land Commission, and every administrative body? It seems to me that there is no sense at all in representatives coming here. They must be willing to trust the Executive. Our purpose here is to provide by statute for the interests of the community.
Comment on this
I will ask the Deputy one question. How are the rights of the community involved in this particular section?
Comment on this
I quite admit that in a sense I am going back to the previous section, but the reason I am doing so is that here is a further opportunity to safeguard the situation if the Parliamentary Secretary cares to avail of it. The moment the bonds are distributed the money is gone and there is no chance of getting any recoupment whatever. Is not that so?
Comment on this
I admit that, but it is an extension of a principle that seems to me to provide the safeguard I indicated.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary has not answered my question, namely, how long is the guarantee deposit to remain?
Comment on this
It seems to me that it cannot hold after the distribution of the purchase money which is to take place almost immediately.
Comment on this
No, it will remain until such time as the Land Commission are satisfied that there are no further claims against it.
Comment on this
Surely, as Deputy de Valera said, there should be some statutory provision governing the distribution of the guarantee deposit.
Comment on this
Deputies will get an opportunity of dealing with that on Report. The section which deals with that has already been passed.
Comment on this
I am endeavouring to deal with the remarks of the Parliamentary Secretary. Surely I am entitled to reply to them.
Comment on this
I am afraid that this is one of the prices which we have to pay for allowing Deputies to go outside the section.
Comment on this
On Section 35, I notice that the Judicial Commissioner is getting another job under this section. I want to know whether it is intended to have more than one Judicial Commissioner. As has been pointed out, the Judicial Commissioner has already held up cases for three or four years, even without any new work being piled upon him by this Bill. Is there to be more than one Judicial Commissioner, or is this work to be piled on him in addition to that which he already has?
Comment on this
I think it is absolutely ridiculous. Deputy Nolan has called attention to the fact that the Judicial Commissioner is already overworked. Is it a fact that no individual in the State will be allowed to act as Judicial Commissioner except this particular individual? Is there some special clause in the Treaty under which no one else is allowed to have the last word on a matter for which the unfortunate tenants of the Free State have to pay except Mr. Justice Wylie?
Comment on this
May I point out that I never said that the Judicial Commissioner was over-worked. What I did say was that he had not worked at all.
Comment on this
I move Amendment No. 67 which is as follows:—
In paragraph (a), page 19, line 2, to add after the word "situate" the words "and if there be a local paper one insertion in such local paper at least ten days before the sale."
It is probable that notice would appear in the official paper it might not be seen by those interested. If there was a local paper I think that at least one insertion a week or ten days previous to the sale would be in order.
Comment on this
This clause has been designed to save expense in cases where only small amounts are due and publication in newspapers, either local or daily, has been omitted for that reason.
Comment on this
But it will have to be borne by the unfortunate defaulter. It seems to me that there is no justification for such publication where only a small sum is involved.
Comment on this
The Land Commission will see to it that the defaulter is made aware of the fact that the sale of his holding is about to take place.
Comment on this
I move amendment 68:
In paragraph (b), page 19, to delete the word "locality" where it occurs in line 10, and in line 12, and to substitute the word "county" in both places.
This is merely a drafting amendment. I do not think that the word "locality" has a definite meaning whereas the word "county" has. It is therefore proposed to substitute one for the other.
Comment on this
I hope, when the Parliamentary Secretary is putting in these advertisements in newspapers published and circulated in the locality in which such holding is situated, that he will insert them in newspapers which circulate in the locality. I cannot speak with much knowledge about the practice in the Land Commission, but I know that in other Government departments the habit has been to carry out the practice of the old regime in regard to such advertisements. For instance, where there was an old Unionist paper with a circulation of about 200 copies these advertisements were inserted. That practice has been continued with the result that practically no one in the county has seen them, I am not saying that because they happen to be Unionist newspapers, but because their circulation is so small. These advertisements should be inserted in newspapers which circulate in the county and which are generally read by the people.
Comment on this
I move Amendment (68) (a) as follows:—
"In line 12, page 19, to delete the word `Dublin' and substitute the words `Saorstát Eireann.' "
There is a daily newspaper in Cork and I was afraid that Cork Deputies might take offence if the publication of these advertisements was confined to newspapers published in Dublin.
Comment on this
I move amendments 69, 70 and 71:—
In sub-section (1) (c), after the word "water-source," line 29, to insert the words "or of the land over which such right of access is granted."
In sub-section (2), after the word "water-source," line 32, to insert the words "or of the land over which such right of access is granted."
In sub-section (2), after the word "situate," line 37, to insert the words "or such right of access granted."
These are only minor amendments. I am told that these amendments would clarify matters, that the right of access may be in question, and that it is not clear that the right of access is covered as the section stands.
Comment on this
I will accept these amendments. The point was undoubtedly overlooked when the section was being drafted.
Comment on this
I am also moving the following amendments, 72 and 73, to the same section:—
In sub-section (3), after the word "water-source," line 41, to insert the words "or of the land over which such right of access is granted."
To add at the end of sub-section (3) the words "or land."
Comment on this
The first amendment is not applicable to the owner of the land over which right of way is given.
Comment on this
He gets it by way of compensation. He is entitled to compensation under this Bill. These amendments are not necessary.
Comment on this
I move amendment 74:—
To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
"There shall be a right of appeal to the Judicial Commissioner from such order or any portion of same by any person affected thereby."
It is well known to the legal fraternity in this House that water rights have been a more fruitful cause of litigation than any other subject. For this reason I think that means should be allowed to those interested to have an appeal.
Comment on this
I really do not think it is necessary to provide an appeal to the Judicial Commissioner in such cases as this. After all it is a matter that can be easily settled by the Land Commissioners. Of course, if a point of law is involved there is already a right of appeal to the Judicial Commissioner.
Comment on this
It is not said so here. There is no loophole allowed at all. You cannot appeal to the Judicial Commissioner unless you accept my amendment.
Comment on this
There is a right of appeal on a point of law. I am not prepared to accept the amendment as I do not think it is necessary. It is very unlikely that any occasion will arise which would justify such an appeal.
Comment on this
Is the Parliamentary Secretary not aware that cases like this have gone to the High Court?
Comment on this
This is a very important question which affects farmers in various districts and they should have the right of appeal. It is a very big question as the Parliamentary Secretary and Deputies here are aware and it causes a great deal of trouble.
Comment on this
As I say there is undoubtedly a right of appeal on a question of law. If the Deputy thinks it right that the section should be extended I am prepared to consider it. As a matter of fact there is a right of appeal on a question of law and I do not think it is necessary to have a right of appeal for any other purpose.
Comment on this
I move amendment 75:
Before Section 38 to insert a new section as follows:—
"Any tenant who or whose predecessors have in fact enjoyed any grazing or turbary on the lands of his landlord for a period of 6 years or upwards whether by permission of his landlord or otherwise shall be deemed to have acquired an easement or profit a prendre appurtenant to such tenant's holding."
This is to cover cases where tenants had been in occupation of grazing or turbary, chiefly, I think, in the West of Ireland. When the vesting of the holdings came about it transpired that they had no title to the grazing or turbary on account of the fact of the landlord's consent being missing. The circumstances are somewhat similar, I suppose, as in regard to the question of the sub-tenancies which we have already discussed. I would like to have some information from the Parliamentary Secretary on the matter.
Comment on this
What is the meaning of "otherwise" in the second last line?
Comment on this
I do not think this amendment is necessary. In practice I do not feel it is required at all. Any easements the tenants have enjoyed before vesting are converted by the existing Land Acts into rights and never in my experience has any question arisen as to the length of time the tenants have enjoyed such rights. If such easements were claimed by the tenant and disputed by the landlord, it would be found that the landlord's case was that they were not intended to be enjoyed each year, that they were given for one year or given for some special reason for a limited period. In any event I could not accept the amendment as it appears on the Order Paper because it seeks to convert a six years' user of a grazing or a turbary easement into a prescriptive right for which the law requires twenty years. I am afraid that is far too fundamental a change in law to introduce in a Bill of this character. In practice at the moment no question of the period of years arises. The rights enjoyed by the tenants are vested in them without any question of the length of time during which they have enjoyed these rights.
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary be kind enough to be perhaps a little more precise in regard to this matter? The Parliamentary Secretary states that the law requires twenty years to make a title to an easement. Surely the Parliamentary Secretary does not suggest that any number of years will enable a tenant to acquire an easement against his own landlord? I would be very glad to hear if it is suggested that a tenant can by user as against his own landlord, not against somebody else, acquire an easement. The Parliamentary Secretary then seems to suggest that in some magical way what we seek to have done by force of law is done already.
The House might perhaps be interested to know how the tenant can get the benefit, which this amendment would confer upon him under the existing law, unless with the concurrence of the landlord. Of course, if a landlord, for convenience or prompted by any other motive, cares to concede to a purchasing tenant the right that is sought for here, the purchasing tenant need not avail of the power in the amendment, but we desire to provide for a tenant whose landlord is hostile. The landlord who hitherto may have been resident in a mansion, surrounded by a large tenanted estate, may have desired to live on terms of friendship with his tenants. There may have been a good deal of give and take. Now that the relationship of landlord and tenant has been put an end to, what reason is there to think that the landlord in future will be able to extend to people who are not his tenants the facilities he extended to them in the past when they were his tenants? When the Parliamentary Secretary said that this already could be done he did not state how it could be done. If the Parliamentary Secretary is referring to the Act of 1896, I think Section 34 is on lines akin to the lines on which this is drawn, but, of course, you have only to glance at the section of the Act of 1896 to see that while it went a certain distance in aid of the tenant it did not cover all the cases that might be covered by this amendment.
This amendment here is intended to get rid of cases that were not foreseen by the draftsman of the Act of 1896; exception is taken to the period of six years. Six years after all is a long time. It is one year longer than the time that was expected to be sufficient to vest all the land in the Irish Free State in the tenant. Of course, sometimes the view is taken that a period of eight years was all too short. At other times it is suggested that perhaps a period of one year, if you want to antedate something, is too long. What is the objection to six years? Is it the suggestion that it be seven years or that it be seven quarantines? Will the superman of the Party indicate what is the suggestion about the six years? Up to the moment exception is taken to the six years, but we are not told why.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary, in speaking, seemed to conclude that there was not a great necessity for this amendment, as all this amendment proposes has been already done for the tenants. I know a section of tenants who would be very much interested in this amendment, and unless this amendment is accepted nothing has been done or will be done to give them the facilities they enjoyed for perhaps twenty years prior to the passing of the Land Act of 1923. Tenants had enjoyed the right of common grazing over a rough mountain, also the right to turbary. They have been notified by the Land Commission during last year that that right will probably be allowed to continue, as the Land Commission are taking over that portion of property upon which they had been grazing. But it will mean to these tenants that they will have to pay an additional rent for that right, an additional annuity for the privilege they have enjoyed free for over thirty years. Clearly there should be some interest taken in the tenants. The class of tenants I am speaking of are a section that at least should receive consideration, the congested areas tenants and the holders of uneconomic holdings. To add on an additional annuity to the rent they are at present paying will leave them perhaps in no better position than they were in prior to the passing of the Land Act. This is a state of things which clearly is not fair to these tenants, and it is going very much out of the way to confer a privilege on the landlord. The landlords have given over any rights to this property in so far as they have allowed it to be used by the tenants without interference. From that the House will understand that on this property they have been making nothing for over twenty years. Now the Land Commission is making it an asset for the landlord, and charging an additional annuity to the tenant, thereby removing any advantage the tenant derives from the Land Act. That is clearly not fair to the tenant.
On the matter of turbary there is a strong case that can be made for it. Where the landlord has been letting turbary and property of this sort, perhaps at a charge of 2 shillings a year, the tenants have gone to considerable expense, and have expended considerable labour in draining bogs and making roads for passing to and fro. If the Land Commission purchases this property from the owner unmindful of the fact that there has been a lien of grazing on it for over twenty years and deprives the tenants who have been getting it of turbary, they will deprive them of a considerable amount of money which they put into that property in draining their turf banks. That is the reason why I urge in the interests of justice that the amendment should be accepted in its entirety.
Comment on this
Will the Parliamentary Secretary deny that there have been cases under the 1923 Act where turbary existed before the Act and the Land Commission paid a price for the bog to the landlord and the redemption of the price plus the improvement of the bog have been consolidated with the tenants' annuity. Where free turbary has existed heretofore, is it right that any price, no matter how small, should be paid for the bog, and is it right that improvements on the bog should be also charged to the tenant? Should the improvement of the bog not come under the annual grant given to the improvement of estates? I hope that the mistake that was made under previous Land Acts, where only portion of the turbary was taken over, is not going to be made under the 1923 Act.
Comment on this
Deputy Geoghegan said that a tenant could not get an easement against his landlord. Under Section 34 of the Act of 1896 the tenant can get an easement.
Comment on this
I think I alluded to the section in the Act of 1896, which seemed to have in mind the fact that under the ordinary law a tenant can never prescribe against his landlord, never can get an easement against his landlord by mere user. The Act of 1896 went a certain way in the direction we are going.
Comment on this
In the particular section the Deputy quoted the fact is the tenant can get an easement against the landlord. Perhaps it might not go quite as far as Deputy Derrig has gone in his amendment. I do not consider this amendment necessary at all; in practice it is not required. Any easements which tenants have enjoyed before vesting are by existing Land Acts on purchase converted into rights. No question is ever raised as to the length of time tenants have enjoyed such easements. These cases are dealt with quite frequently, and no such question is ever raised by the Land Commission. I think the amendment proposes a fundamental change in the law, and I could not accept it as it stands. In any event I do not consider it necessary. With regard to Deputy Maguire's remarks the Land Commission, on his own statement, could not possibly deprive the tenants of rights that they enjoyed. Consequently I do not see that the tenants have any grievance whatever against the Land Commission. Under the existing law they cannot deprive them of these rights.
Comment on this
I had occasion to visit the Land Commission last year with regard to property in my constituency. I pointed out that the tenants on it had enjoyed certain privileges for a number of years. After investigation I was informed by the Chief Inspector that he was surprised to find that these rights were given away. He said that notice was being served on the landlord as the Land Commission was about to acquire the property, which was untenanted, for distribution amongst the tenants. When asked if there would be any charge, he stated that there would be, and that the people would get the privilege of grazing at an additional annuity.
Comment on this
It is a very important detail, and this amendment will cover it.
Comment on this
Does the Parliamentary Secretary admit that it is possible to fix an increased rent in respect of grazing rights on such land?
Comment on this
Does the Parliamentary Secretary not see any substantial reason for converting a mere privilege into a right, because if the tenant has a right against the landlord he has nothing to thank him for? We are dealing with cases where it was given by the express permission of the landlord, where no right could grow up or where it was a mere privilege, and we want to convert that as part of the final land settlement into a right. What is the practical objection to that? Is it expected that the landlord who, for a period of six years has stood by and allowed the tenants to exercise a right like this, intends to go back on it, so as to embarrass the tenant or as a mere matter of spite? Would Deputy Gorey, with his wide experience of the country, suggest any case where he feels it would be unreasonable that a landlord who has allowed something to be exercised as a privilege for a period of six years or upwards by tenants, should have that privilege converted into a legal right as part of the final settlement? The Deputy is probably the warmest supporter of the land owning community on these benches. It is a slight advance on the Act of 1896. It is now 35 years since that Act was passed, and I am sure that Deputy Gorey would be prepared on behalf of the landlords to go a little further than they went in the bad old days.
Comment on this
These are really amendments that were put up to previous Acts except for the words "or otherwise." I do not accept Deputy Geoghegan's suggestion that I am a friend of the landlords.
Comment on this
The landlords ought to be friends of the Deputy's after his performances to-day and yesterday.
Comment on this
On what particular section? This is the usual lawyer's trick. The Deputy will not put his finger on anything. Apart from that I think this amendment has merits where the tenant has been in the possession of certain privileges for a specified period. It should be considered as part of the assets. That privilege would not be given except for certain considerations. It is the same as a voluntary reduction of rent. In the 1923 Act, where a voluntary reduction was given, that was accepted as the basis of right. If it is not in same section already I do not see any reason why it should not be included now.
Comment on this
It is only fair to say in all seriousness that Deputy Gorey has put forward the best argument for this amendment. As the Deputy pointed out, it is similar in principle to the abated rent. Instead of payment in cash he is getting it in kind by a sort of concession. I urge on the House that the principle as enunciated by Deputy Gorey is necessary.
Comment on this
I think if the words "or otherwise" were left out the amendment could be accepted.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary says it is usual in the Land Commission to recognise rights in these cases. What is the objection then to the amendment being made law? No case has been made against it.
Comment on this
Especially in view of the fact that the principle, as pointed out by Deputy Geoghegan and by the Parliamentary Secretary, has already been established by the Act of 1896.
Comment on this
I move amendment 75a:—
In sub-section (1), line 49, after the word "turbary" to insert the words "including the right to acquire compulsorily such land or bog from tenants for the purpose of resale."
The object is to give the greatest possible facilities to those people requiring turbary. We very often find that tenants have to travel four or five miles for turbary and in doing so actually pass by a large quantity of turbary lying waste in the same or the next town-land. I also know cases where tenants have been supplied with turbary at a distance from their homes, but owing to want of drainage or convenience of access to this turbary these tenants have to pay a substantial rent for a more convenient supply. This amendment is put down in order to make available for such tenants the most convenient bog. It does not inflict a hardship upon anybody because when a person has a surplus supply of turbary it should be made available for those who want it. Turbary is a very vital matter in the life of every such person and it should be made available for him in the most convenient place.
Comment on this
This amendment is not necessary because the Land Commission already have the widest possible powers under certain sections of the Land Act of 1923 to acquire any bog anywhere particularly under Section 37 where the Land Commission are given very wide powers for the purpose of acquiring bogs. The section reads:
"The powers of the Land Commission under this Act to acquire any untenanted land shall include power so to acquire any bog for the purpose of providing turbary for the occupiers of land in the neighbourhood thereof, whether the said bog is or is not subject to any right of turbary of other persons than the owner, and whether or not an advance under the Land Purchase Acts has been made for the purchase of lands including such bog and if made, whether redeemed or not."
There are other sections also which give the Land Commission very wide powers for the purpose of acquiring bogs, so that the amendment is unnecessary.
Comment on this
I move amendment 76:—
In sub-section (2), after the word "define," line 56, to insert the words "and extend or improve ways and."
The position as regards roads and ways which have fallen into disrepair seems to a number of Deputies on this side of the House to call for attention, and I put down the amendment in order to get a statement from the Parliamentary Secretary on the question. I notice that under Section 22 of the Land Act of 1927 the Land Commission have powers to expend moneys, even after vesting, on improvements, except that the expenditure in that case is generally to be recovered as an annuity from the tenants who benefit. There are a great many complaints from all parts of the country about roads, long lanes, or boreens, or perhaps roads which might be link roads, which are of a semi-public character. Whatever class of roads they are, the Land Commission had a responsibility for them at one time. They have now fallen into disrepair. The number of tenants who use these roads is generally very small. You may have only one tenant, or perhaps six tenants, at the end of a long boreen of one or two miles. Unless some steps are taken to put these roads into repair it is beyond the power of the tenants to do it. I understand from Deputy O'Reilly that in his constituency there are cases of ways, which might not be described as boreens, leading to villages, but which are semi-public ways. We want to press the question of the repair of these roads and of putting them into a proper condition. Where they have fallen into disrepair owing to circumstances over which the tenants have no control, if the Land Commission now put them in a satisfactory condition I think the tenants would undertake to maintain them. The trouble is that they are not in a position to undertake the entire expenditure necessary.
Comment on this
I am not quite clear what the Deputy means by his amendment, but if he wants me to accept it I can tell him here and now that I will, with the possible exception of the word "extend," which is not required.
Comment on this
The point as to the word "extend" is that where you had carts, for example, on these boreens you may now, in some cases, have machinery, and the idea is that you will have to extend.
Comment on this
I move amendment 77:—
In sub-section (1), page 20, lines 21 and 22, to delete all from the words "the Land" in line 21, to the words "other Land" in line 22, and in line 24, after the words "appointed day" to insert the words "shall be apportioned between such untenanted land and such other land", and to delete all from the word "and" in line 24 to the end of the sub-section.
This is a drafting amendment. The apportionment of rates has to be made at the request of the Land Commission and it is not by them as is provided in the section. It requires an alteration of the wording to make the meaning quite clear.
Comment on this
There does not seem to be any principle laid down in this section as to how the apportionment is to be made. It is an extraordinary thing that the Parliamentary Secretary has made no provision for an appeal on behalf of the occupier of the untenanted land.
Comment on this
This really follows the ordinary law. The apportionment of the rates is not a matter for the Land Commission but for the valuation authorities. There are certain laws relating to the fixation of rates.
Comment on this
May I ask on a point of information what is the meaning of the words in line 36 in brackets "other than a holding to which the Land Act, 1923, applies"?
Comment on this
They are already covered, of course. This section only applies to the resumption of either a portion or the whole of a holding on a Congested Districts Board estate.
Comment on this
I move amendment 80:—
In page 20, before Section 41, to insert a new section as follows:—
"Where, in the opinion of the Court, it would be inequitable that the Land Commission should resume a holding or part of a holding on payment to the tenant of compensation fixed on the basis on which resumption prices have heretofore been fixed, the Court in fixing the compensation in respect of such resumption may include therein compensation to the tenant for disturbance, and also may have regard not only to the value of the land to be resumed, but also to the damage, if any, which will be sustained by the tenant by reason of the resumption of the lands as affecting his user of other lands or otherwise causing injury to such other lands."
Comment on this
Does not this introduce a new principle altogether? Is it contended that the resumption price which now holds for the purchase of land in this case is not sufficient, and that an additional price in the form of compensation for disturbance should be introduced. We must have regard to the fact that in this matter the incoming tenant will, I take it, be responsible, and I think there is no proof that the burden of the incoming tenant is not sufficiently high already. The price that has to be paid for the land when it is resuming is sufficiently high and is in the nature of a competitive price. By the time the tenant has paid for all the improvements and so on in addition to this competitive price, I think he is sufficiently saddled with expenditure. A new principle entirely is now introduced, and it seems to me a principle introduced without any legislation whatsoever, that is the principle of compensation to the tenant for disturbance. Either the State is going to pay or the incoming tenant is going to pay. I take it the incoming tenant will have to pay. I say that on the face of it the amendment does not recommend itself to us.
Comment on this
If we take the case of a farm bought out under previous Acts on which there is already an annuity, the price paid for that brings up the annuity much higher than the annuity on the adjoining land in the same locality. The experience we have had is that on land taken over, say, of five or six hundred acres, on which there is an annuity, the price paid for the redemption of the old purchase money and the compensation to the owner, plus the annuity, is nearly twice as much as the annuities paid on the other side of the ditch, and, perhaps, for better land or land equally as good. If, as Deputy Derrig says, a new principle is to be introduced and there is to be compensation for disturbance and that is added to the annuity the new tenant will not be able to hold the land at all.
Comment on this
This is not a question of compensating the landlord, but a question of compensating the occupying tenant at the time. If we are not going to adopt that principle it is better to be quite candid about it and say that the principle of tenant right shall cease. If a tenant in that position has no right to sell or be compensated, which has always been the custom of the country——
Comment on this
The new sub-section does not deal with untenanted land; it deals with tenanted land. Is there any question about that?
Comment on this
If Deputy Derrig wants to continue his opposition on those lines, well and good——
Comment on this
Is Deputy Gorey not satisfied that the resumption price is sufficient to compensate the tenant? Surely if the resumption price is fixed in the court all these circumstances will be taken into consideration? I see here a new principle which can be carried to limits that would be very undesirable apart from the fact that it is imposing a burden upon the incoming tenant. We are definitely against that.
Comment on this
Any rights the outgoing tenant had are to be done away with. Does the Deputy imply that—that the interest of the outgoing tenant is to be done away with? If that is the policy of the Fianna Fáil Party they had better say so and let there not be any hedging about it. The country is very anxious to know at the moment what is their attitude upon this question. Does anybody suggest that land bearing an annuity is not worth, in the market, a considerable amount of money at the present market value, and that the tenant should not be compensated for disturbance except to the actual value of the holding? If that new principle is to be adopted, let it be adopted in plain words and let the country be told about it. I am quite satisfied to have plain speaking on the matter and no hedging.
Comment on this
I seriously contend, and the Parliamentary Secretary can explain it, that nobody contemplates taking over a tenanted farm. It is an untenanted farm, with perhaps an annuity on it. It does not deal with a residential farm.
Comment on this
I am not talking of that. Let the Deputy read the sub-section.
Comment on this
First of all, in order to clear Deputy Kennedy's mind, I may say this section relates to tenanted land only.
Comment on this
Is there not provision in the Land Acts that if residential tenanted land is taken over the person who occupied it will get land somewhere else?
Comment on this
This is not residential land at all. It is not subject to Land Commission annuities. It merely empowers a court, in fixing the resumption price of a holding, to allow in such cases, if the justice of the cases require it, some compensation in addition to the market value of the holding. As the law stands at present, the court is constrained to give the market value. The resumption price at present is fixed by the Land Act of 1881.
The court in fixing resumption prices must be guided entirely by that Act. The market value is really what the holdings would fetch in the open market and no more. Owing to various economic circumstances the market value may, at the time the holding is resumed, be unduly low. Prices may be bad, and there may be no demand for holdings of the size that it is proposed to resume. If the owner desired to sell in the ordinary way, if he were a prudent man he would certainly postpone the sale of the holding until such time as the market prices improved. The section really proposes to empower the court, in certain extreme cases, to give additional compensation for disturbance or injury. That additional compensation will be borne by the State. The tenant will not have to bear any portion of it in his annuity.
Comment on this
Surely the argument of the Parliamentary Secretary is that the Land Commission must make provision to give higher prices than the market value for the land that is to be resumed. That is the statement the Parliamentary Secretary has made now. Are we to take it that the new principle that is to be embarked on now, with the support of Deputy Gorey, is that higher prices than the market value are to be given for the land? That is the statement the Parliamentary Secretary has made in defence of this section. Am I to take it that Deputy Gorey is supporting an amendment of that kind?
Comment on this
When it is done in the interests of the community, and the man is forced out of possession, are you to give him the big prices of say 1918 while in 1931 the price has depreciated?
Comment on this
I cannot understand why Deputy Gorey should support an amendment of that kind. I have heard the Deputy pleading for more delay in the purchase of estates until the price of land would depreciate more.
Comment on this
Now we find Deputy Gorey supporting an amendment which enables the Land Commission to give higher prices than the market prices. Surely Deputy Gorey will have to admit, if he knows anything at all about the question of the taking over of land, that very much higher prices than the market value of the land are being given at present, with the result that the tenants, when they come into possession afterwards, find it hard to carry on, and many of them have to give it up. I do not think that Deputy Gorey is really serious in supporting this amendment.
Comment on this
If the Deputy is serious I take it I was mistaken as regards his gesture of goodwill, which he made a few moments ago, in forcing the Parliamentary Secretary to accede to the amendment of Deputy Derrig. I thought he did that in the interests of the tenants, but I think now I must have been mistaken.
Comment on this
It is not in the interests of the landlords; it is in the interests of the tenants.
Comment on this
Very well—a tenant who is a landlord much of the Deputy Gorey type. We know very well that if Deputy Gorey were being forced out of his estate by the Land Commission that he would be anxious to get a higher price than the market value. This is an amendment in which he is interested, not that I hope he is going to sell out and leave the State. There would be a vacant space left in after his exit. A very serious case was made for this amendment by the Parliamentary Secretary. The Parliamentary Secretary knows his business. I believe myself that if the Minister who introduced this amendment did not make his debut in this amendment it would be better for it. This is a most unfortunate incursion of the Minister. If the Parliamentary Secretary were left to himself, coming as he does from the West of Ireland and knowing what congestion means, it would be better for the Bill. The Parliamentary Secretary has not become so Dublinised as the Minister for Lands and Fisheries. If the Minister had known the position in the West of Ireland he would never have introduced this amendment here. That amendment is one that the Parliamentary Secretary would not himself have brought in, because his experience in the West of Ireland, time after time, is that complaints of the rents or annuities have been made by the tenants who are put into possession of holdings that have been resumed by the Land Commission. The complaints always are that the annuity fixed on the holding is too high. Are we in this Bill, which is going to put the coping stone on all previous Land Bills, to give power to the Land Commission to raise the price of the land that they are taking over and to raise it above the market price?
It is very poor consolation to Deputy Gorey who is a taxpayer to say that the State is going to pay. It would be even more just to say that the incoming tenant must pay and not the State. I think it is unfair to Deputy Gorey to make him bear part of the burdens of the higher price which is going to be given to some landlord for the disturbance of a lifetime in putting him out of his land. If Deputy Gorey is in earnest he should restrict or take something from this tenant, and see that this incoming tenant would pay, and that it would not fall on Deputy Gorey or the State. If Deputy Gorey is anxious to bear his part of the burden of the extra cost as an act of restitution to the small farmers and to the uneconomic land holders of the West of Ireland, we accept it in the spirit in which it is given, but we do not think it wise. We think there could be a better gesture of restitution made by Deputy Gorey. For instance he could come to this side of the House. That would be accepted as a greater act of restitution than this gesture of forcing the Land Commission to raise the price of land. Besides when it comes to that and the Land Commission or some friend of the gentleman who is being dispossessed, makes the case that he is not getting enough money, but that there is a section in the Act which gives power to give more, how are you to calculate what he is to get for this disturbance? What exactly does disturbance mean? Is it the transportation of the tenant from one holding to a holding in some other part of the State? Is it based on the number of his family? Where are you to draw the line? Is it to be based on his standing with the heads of the Freemason organisation or is it to be based on his standing as a good sterling Catholic? Where and in what manner are you to base the price of that disturbance? I think you are going on very slippery ground in passing or supporting this amendment. If the amendment is what the Parliamentary Secretary said it was, it is a very wrong amendment. We would not like to see Deputy Gorey making restitution in this way by helping to have an amendment of this kind carried.
Comment on this
I think the reason for this amendment would be that it was found in practice that the method previously adopted did not give a fair or equitable price to the tenant of a resumed holding in certain parts of the country. We have come back to the Act of 1881. There was a section in the Act of 1881 which gave the landlord leave to resume if he satisfied the court that he had a good and sufficient reason for resuming the tenant's holding. The section went on further to say that the tenants would get the market price. That meant sale in a free market with unlimited competition— the price he would get in these circumstances. The tenant under the Act had free sale and fixity of tenure. Now we come to the basis of compensation to the tenant under this Bill. There was embodied in the Act of 1923 the section I speak of, Section 6 of the Act of 1881. The only difference was that the words "Judicial Commissioner" were put in instead of "courts." I want to show how that affects certain parts of the country. In certain parts of the country where there would be a number of what are called retained holdings, if a tenant would offer one of these holdings for sale, a vested holder or a tenant who had signed a purchase agreement for £3,000 or over could not buy or, at least if he did buy, he bought at a very considerable risk, for the holding would be resumed within a very short period. The holding may be resumed if he took the risk of buying it. Neither could the tenant of a retained holding make an offer for it because his difficulty is to get an advance from the Land Commission sufficient to buy his own holding. I think that ought to satisfy Deputy Clery that in these circumstances there would be limited competition.
Also it had another blot. If any of these people bought that holding to-morrow or within a year or two after the purchase, that holding might be resumed by the Land Commission, so that the tenant, instead of selling under the advantages he got under the Act of 1881—free sale and fixity of tenure—had to sell with very restricted competition and uncertainty of tenure. I put it to any reasonable person in the House that the market value under the two conditions which I have explained to the House would be very different things; in the one case an auction with free sale and fixity of tenure, on the other an auction with restricted competition and uncertainty of tenure. That is the position. I think the reason I have given is to enable the court under the Act of 1881, and the judge under this Act where these conditions prevail, to give what would be a moderately fair price to the tenant, and not confiscate the tenant's property altogether.
Comment on this
I wonder what class of land is it intended under this section to resume? Am I to take it that it is now the intention of the Parliamentary Secretary to resume the 361 acres they gave to a district justice in Tipperary, and that he is going to be compensated under this section? Is that the special land that is going to be resumed? I can see no portion of this new section which provides that the tenant will not have to bear the burden of the extra money which is going to be paid out. No portion of this section states that the burden is going to be borne by the State. I was wondering what induced the Parliamentary Secretary to put in this special section until I saw Deputy Mathews get up. I am surprised that there was not an amendment down by Deputy Cole, but apparently the landlords' Party decided in this case it would come better from the Parliamentary Secretary himself. The majority of those estates which have been taken over and of the tenanted land which has been taken over by the Land Commission has resulted in rents being placed on the tenants which are entirely beyond the power of the tenants to pay. Those of us who know farming conditions at the present day know that it is very difficult for farmers to pay their annuities and to keep their families. Now it is proposed to pile more charges on to them and make their position impossible. Anxious as we are to get rid of the ranches, getting rid of them at the price is not worth it. I would prefer to see the ranches left there until a Government would come in that would be prepared to deal with them in the way they should be dealt with, not a Government that is going to pay them a price for their land first and then compensation for disturbance. What really happened in regard to this Land Bill is, first, the Parliamentary Secretary did his best to improve on the Land Bill which we brought in in 1929, and when he was finished with it he called in the landlords' party, and they put in extra provisoes, and the whole thing mopped up together was made into a Bill and brought in here.
That is the only thing that I can see about it. I cannot believe that the Parliamentary Secretary in any sane moment believes in some of the section brought in here to-night. The idea of adding to the annuity, first of all, the price that would be paid to the tenant as compensation and, secondly, the extra damage that would be caused to the tenant, will surely raise the annuity on that land to a price which the tenant cannot pay. I would like the Parliamentary Secretary to explain in what portion of this section provision is made for relieving the incoming tenant of his extra burden and what portion of it says that some of it will be borne by the State.
Comment on this
This is altogether an unnecessary section. Deputy Gorey tried to lead us to believe that the Land Commission were about to go around to residential farms like his own and take them.
Comment on this
The meaning of this provision is this: take an estate like the Kilwarden estate with 2,000 acres, most of which has been grabbed. Annuities are paid on some of it and more of it is fee farm land. Portion of that is taken from the owner and given back to the people who were evicted from it. Will Deputy Gorey contend that there is hardship on the owner in that case? Does the individual who has portion of his 2,000 acres taken from him in that case suffer hardship where there are only a couple of herds employed?
Comment on this
Does the Deputy contend that the court in fixing the compensation to be paid to that particular grabber in respect of such resumption may include therein compensation to him for such disturbance? That is the contention which Deputy Gorey puts up. He is to be pitied. The Parliamentary Secretary is making provision for that particular type whether the land is attached or unattached to that particular estate. I take it that it is unattached, that it is dealt with separately. The amendment provides for extra compensation for this particular type of person who is no good to the community whatever and who, as I said in reply to Deputy Mathews, has made a wilderness of County Meath, the finest country in Ireland. Deputy Mathews talks about fixity of tenure and fair sale, but the people who enunciated those principles certainly had not in mind the type of farmer whom Deputy Mathews represents. It would make them turn in their grave if they thought that they fought for those principles for the type of grabber and grazier whom that Deputy represents. The Bill should be concerned with small farmers, working farmers, and farmers who give employment, and not with the grazier and grabber whom the Bill in many of its clauses is intended to facilitate.
Comment on this
There is a certain convention in this House in which one member of a party listens with a good deal of tolerance to what is said on his own side and hears, possibly, speeches with which he disagrees and, unless he is moved by what may be called a vital difference of opinion, hesitates to intervene. Quite frankly, however, I feel that the ordinary bounds of party loyalty in this case have been somewhat overstrained. I have listened to speeches from Deputy Kennedy, Deputy Clery, and Deputy Corry, and I desire to dissociate myself in the strongest possible manner from those speeches. Through those speeches there runs a deliberate and, I think, a conscious ignoring of the supreme achievement represented by the action of the Minister for Fisheries and by the amendment of that Minister. The Minister has achieved the impossible. He has done something which the massed brains and the information of the whole Department behind the Parliamentary Secretary have failed to do. He has done something which the brains of the Parliamentary Secretary have been incapable of doing. He has done something which the massed intelligence of the Farmers' Party has not been able to do—he has made a rotten Bill worse.
Comment on this
This amendment is not very easy to understand, because I have an idea that if it is passed the result will be that the division of land can be held up to a large extent. Towards the end of the amendment it talks about a second farm. There could have been a third farm. The result of the compensation clause would be that it would be impossible for the Land Commission to take land over and divide it at anything that would be like an economic price to-day. Therefore I take it that the whole result would be that the land could not be acquired. I have no idea as to what quantity of land would be in the position which this amendment is intended to cover. I move to report progress.