Public Business. - Relief of Rates on Agricultural Land.
Contributions 1–147 of 313. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:—
That the Dáil is of opinion that, in the present depressed condition of agricultural industry, the Executive Council should this year provide a special Additional Grant of one million pounds for the relief of the local rates on agricultural land, the sum allocated to each county to be in proportion to the average of the total assessments on such land in the county over the current and past two years.
Back as far as 1925, when a Bill was passing through this House providing a supplementary grant, the Minister for Finance indicated that the question of the best manner for the relief of rates was having his attention. That was six years ago. Since that time de-rating was brought into operation in England. When introducing the Budget in 1929, two years ago—the Act had been in operation for a considerable time before that— the Minister said that since the British Act was passed the question of de-rating had occupied the attention of Ministers and Departments. It is no harm to remind the House of the actual words the Minister used. He said that "in consequence of this British Scheme having been adopted the whole problem (of de-rating) has received a good deal of attention from Minister and Departments since the end of last summer. An inter-Departmental Committee was appointed to examine the matter systematically and its report was carefully considered." That was in April, 1929. A short time after that a De-rating Commission was set up and that De-rating Commission has been considering the matter for well over a year and a half. Here we are entering on another year and no provision is going to be made for the relief of the farming community. We all know that this question of de-rating and the manner in which relief is to be applied does need careful examination, but there is a limit to the time which we can give to the examination, and there is a very definite limit to the time that can be given to it when the industry affected is suffering severely and suffering in such a way that if we delay assistance we may very well find that it will be so crippled that the assistance will be given too late and that the steps which will have to be taken to bring it back to a prosperous condition will require a far greater effort on the part of the community than would be required if timely aid were given.
Now this motion of mine is not intended to be a substitute for a considered scheme of de-rating. It is purely a temporary measure introduced to give timely assistance, because we are of opinion that immediate assistance is wanted. It does not indicate, as far as we are concerned, the lines on which we would propose a de-rating scheme if the duty of proposing such a scheme devolved upon us. We have given to this problem independently a great deal of consideration. We understand the difficulties that are involved, and we think it would not be right, when this matter has been examined by a commission, to bring in any schemes of our own just when there is a hope that such a commission might report. We have got no indication from the Ministry that they have any scheme in mind, that this scheme would be available this year, and, as I said, we are introducing this because we feel that immediate assistance is necessary. It is a case of the old Irish proverb, "Gheibheann an capall bás an fhaid atá an féar ag fás." We want to see that the horse does not die whilst the grass is growing. Why is it this assistance is necessary? In the preamble to the motion there is a statement that the agricultural industry is at present depressed. I think we all know that it is.
I have some figures which I propose to give the House to prove that this state of depression is not an imaginary condition, that it is not the result of hypochondria as some Minister on the opposite side said it was, that it is a reality, and that being a reality, and agriculture being our most important industry, it is our duty to come to its aid at once. I will give some of these figures. Let us take the figures for tillage either before, during or immediately after the war, and compare them with the number of acres tilled at the present time. In 1914 the number of acres under tillage was 1,697,706. To-day the figure is 1,458,465. That is, it is 219,241 acres less than it was in 1914. If we were to take the year 1918, when we had 2,382,776 acres tilled, the diminution as represented by the present figure would be very nearly a million acres, 924,311. Since 1923 there has been a diminution of 210,836 acres, and since 1929 there has been a further diminution of 62,998 acres. Now, taking roughly, say an average of £10 an acre as representing the value of tillage crops, that would represent a loss of several million pounds. As compared with 1914, it would represent a loss of over £2,000,000, as compared with 1918, a loss of very nearly nine and a quarter million pounds, and so on. The diminution of 62,998 acres would represent a loss of about £629,000.
That is a loss due to the reduction of tillage. But side by side with the loss due to reduction of tillage, we have a diminution of the pasture stock. Our pasture stock has not gone up. If we take the figures for 1914, we find that there were 4,236,751 head of cattle in 1914; to-day we have 4,038,344. That is a reduction of roughly 200,000 head of cattle. In connection with horses— I will leave the odd figures out. There were 486,000 in 1914, and we have 447,000 to-day. There is a reduction of roughly 40,000 horses. The only thing there is an increase in is in sheep, but a comparatively small increase that does not at all make up for the reduction in cattle. The increase in sheep is only about 300,000, whereas the reduction in cattle alone is about 200,000, so you see the increase in sheep does not at all make up for the loss in cattle. So side by side with this diminution in tillage we have a loss of capital wealth in pasture stock as well. If we try to estimate this as far as pasture stock is concerned, we find again that we have a diminution of national wealth in the agricultural industry of some millions of pounds.
We have been dealing with butter fairly recently, and it is hardly necessary to call the attention of the House to the position in the dairying industry. Butter prices have fallen, the fall in price representing 24.9 per cent. decrease between 1929 and 1930. Comparing the quarter October-December of 1930 with that of 1929, there is a 32 per cent. decrease. If we compare the prices of eggs we find that between 1929 and 1930 there is a 15.7 per cent. decrease, and if we take the quarter October-December for 1930 and compare it with 1929, there is a 14.4 per cent. decrease. The more we examine it the more we are convinced. We find there is a diminution of capital wealth, a diminution of the farmers' income, and we find, side by side with this reduction in the price which the farmer gets for his produce and with the reduction of his capital wealth, that the prices of what he has to buy do not keep step at all.
It hardly needs proof to a House where there are so many farmer Deputies who know the position of the industry, from their own experience, in a way that no figures will really add to their knowledge of it or convince them more about it. But, in order to show each one that his own experience is borne out by the general statistical information, I am giving these figures. I am going to show that the reduction in agricultural prices is far greater than the reduction in the prices of the commodities which the farmer has to buy and, therefore, I think I will prove to you generally that the farmer is more hardly hit than other sections of the community, than even other producing sections of the community. From the index of agricultural prices, we find that for the year 1930 the average index figure was 124.8, taking the pre-war years, 1911 and 1913, as 100. That is, for the year 1930 agricultural prices were not quite one and a quarter times the prices in 1911-1913. If we take into account the fall in prices that has taken place since 1930—that is, the recent fall in prices—we find that the price of agricultural produce is much less than a quarter as much again of what it was in pre-war years. Fat cattle and fat sheep, for instance, the prices of which enter into the calculation of the index number, have both fallen heavily in price since last autumn. I gave you already the fall in the prices of butter and eggs. Fat cattle are 14.8 per cent. and fat sheep 27.5 per cent. cheaper than at the beginning of March, 1930.
Let us compare the general prices with the food prices. For food prices the index figure last January was 154. The general price index was 168. These are the retail prices. The position really is that whilst the farmer has to sell his produce at something like 15 per cent. in advance of the prices which obtained in pre-war years he has to pay something like 68 per cent. more for the goods he buys. Therefore, the position is telling against the farmer. The index number of food prices since 1924 has fallen by 21.4 per cent., whereas the general price index has fallen only by 10.6 per cent., and the unequal rate of fall has obviously been to the detriment of the producer of food as compared with the producer of other commodities.
There is one point to make, that this fall in prices which has occurred has been to the disadvantage of the farmer as compared with the producer of other commodities. A more serious loss has occurred to the farmer and that is due to the disparity between wholesale and retail prices. That disparity is constantly growing. It is growing to the disadvantage of all producers and especially to the disadvantage, as I have shown, of the farmer. The agricultural price index for 1930, I have said, was 24.8 per cent. above the pre-war level. Taking the recent fall it is probably at present about 15 per cent. over 1914, whereas the index of retail prices in general last year, 70.75 per cent., was higher than in 1914. That is the position of the farmer due to this fall in prices. It has been to his disadvantage as compared with the producers of other commodities. Therefore, as he is suffering from this disadvantage, we think it is only fair that the other sections of the community who are in a relatively better position than he is should come to his assistance at this particular time. More than any other section of the community the farmers are at the mercy of their market. The conditions of their industry are such that they cannot withhold their produce from the market or substantially restrict production. They are much more unfavourably situated than other producers in that respect. The traders in farm produce, the transport interests and others through whose hands their produce must pass before it reaches the consumer, are all in a position of much greater economic strength and are able to make the farmer bear practically the entire burden of the fall in prices. The retailers are also in a better position than the farmer is. The consequence is that the burden of the improvement in the standard of living of the other classes of the community and of the increased public expenditure has ultimately to be borne by the farming section of the community. That is the position and, being such, I think it justifies this motion to come to his relief not when some De-rating Commission will have reported in one or two years' time but immediately.
The importance of the agricultural industry is recognised. If anybody doubts it the census of production, showing the relative poduction of wealth in the farming industry and other industries, proves it. According to the census of 1926, the net output of the agricultural industry was 73.7 per cent. of the whole.
The output of the other industries and manufactures covered by the census returns was only 26.3 per cent. so that, roughly speaking, the agricultural industry is in relation of 73.7 to 26.3. As regards employment, the industries covered by the production census of 1926 only accounted for 107,000 workers. The census of occupations accounted for 186,000. The number employed in agriculture was 672,000. From the point of view of output of wealth, number of people employed and so forth, agriculture deserves to be regarded as our principal industry. On its prosperity must the prosperity of the whole community depend. That being so, everybody interested in the prosperity of the country as a whole must take seriously to heart the present position of agriculture and must be, if it is necessary, prepared to take from other sections of the community in order to assist agriculture. Everybody must be satisfied that to do that would be in the general interests of the community.
Speaking a couple of days ago on the Central Fund Bill, I pointed out that whilst the prices the farmer got for his produce were only about 15 per cent. in advance of the prices obtained in 1914, the burden of taxation upon the farmer had increased threefold. The purpose of this motion is to come to the farmer's relief and lighten that burden. Ministers in the Dublin election clearly foreshadowed relief for the farming community. The President, speaking in Dun Laoghaire, on November 22, said:—
The evidence the De-rating Commission had collected would be of the greatest assistance to the Government in order to decide what was the most suitable form the relief now to be provided for the agriculturists should take. We are agreed that the farmer deserves, and must receive, every assistance that, having regard to our resources, can be given to him.
I take it, therefore, that there is no need for me or for any speaker on this side to impress upon the Ministers and the members of Cumann na nGaedheal that the farmer deserves and ought to receive every assistance which can be given to him within our resources. Professor O'Sullivan speaking at Lusk said:—
When the Report of the De-rating Commission was available, he trusted that they would be able to give substantial assistance to the farmers, not through quack remedies but in a way that would be helpful to them and to the community as a whole. We, as a Government, believe that help must go to the agricultural community of this country, but it cannot be given by compelling people to grow wheat or by the application of tariffs. We should like to give it in such a way as to reduce the expenses of the farmer.
I remember seeing—I have not traced it—a leaflet sent out on behalf of the candidate in that election, in which it was stated that the principle of relief to the farmer was accepted and that £1,000,000 or so was to go for that relief. We propose, in this motion, to give relief immediately and the sum suggested is the sum that was mentioned in that leaflet. The Minister for Finance will say, no doubt, that the round million had some attraction for me. If the system proposed were such that I could get the actual figure—which is near a million —I would have chosen it rather than a million. If the Minister is prepared to take it that the figure should be one half the average rates on agricultural land, I would prefer it to the million because it would reduce the amount of calculation. The amount, I think, is slightly more than a million. The million was originated not by me, but by the advocates of this grant on the other side. I think that it is a fair amount. The amount we could afford at present would be roughly sufficient to give relief to the farmer of half the amount he is paying in respect of agricultural rates. That is roughly the intention of the motion—to provide relief for the farmer to the extent of half the rates he is paying on his agricultural land. It will be seen that the proposal is that the sum be allocated to each county in proportion to the average of the total assessments on such land in the county over the current and past two years.
Deputies who remember the origin of the Agricultural Grant of 1898, and who were here when the Supplementary Grant was passed in 1925, are aware of the lines on which that grant was to be allocated. In introducing the Bill of 1925, the Minister said that as he was in a hurry and wanted it to operate that year—he was in the same circumstances then as we find ourselves now—he proposed that instead of going into all these intricate questions as to the burdens of the different classes of farmers and trying to select the particular class of farmers best entitled to relief, the relief should follow, roughly, on the lines of the original Agricultural Grant. The proposition here is that it should roughly follow on the same lines. Waiting as we are for the Report of the De-rating Commission, and immediate relief being necessary, we think the simplest way to give this immediate relief would be to follow on those lines. The only point of difference is this: the old grant having been fixed upon a certain condition back in '97, is now more or less in the form of a flat rate, whereas our proposition is that the rate of relief should be in proportion to the present burdens. It would be about nine-twentieths if the million itself were adhered to, but, roughly, it is half, and the effect of it, if the grant is allocated to the counties in proportion to the average of the total assessments on agricultural land, will roughly be that the farmer will be relieved of half the burden which he has to carry. It is intended to operate universally so that every farmer in every condition—we are not taking these conditions into account because the examination would take too much time—paying rates on his agricultural land will be relieved of the same proportion of the burden. That is to say, the relief will be, roughly, half the burden in every case.
I saw some speeches that were delivered by members of the Labour Party in criticism of this motion. Deputy O'Connell, I think, said that this proposal was to divide the money in proportion to the valuation. It does not propose to divide the money in proportion to the valuation, but to divide it, roughly, in proportion to the services. The whole purpose is to divide the money so that there will be the same fraction of the burden relieved in the case of everybody. It is not to be divided in relation to the valuation; it is in relation, if you like, to the services, or the total rates raised by the valuation. The fundamental idea is that relief is to be of such a kind as will give a proportionate diminution of the burden right through.
The Labour Party has introduced an amendment, the effect of which is that there should be relief, not as would be the case with my motion of roughly half the agricultural rate right through, but that there should be relief of three-fourths of the rates in the case of holdings where the valuation of the land does not exceed £50, "and of one-half of such rate where the valuation of the land exceeds £50, and where the occupier satisfies the Minister for Agriculture that not less than 20 per cent. of the arable land is under tillage and that the sum required to provide this grant shall be raised in such manner as will not place any additional taxation on the small farmers and wage-earners." There is every evidence of speed and haste, notwithstanding that Deputy Davin said very careful consideration was given to this particular amendment. I do not know if the Deputy was correctly reported when he said that this amendment was brought forward by the Labour Party for the purpose of helping the Government out of a difficult position.
Comment on this
I thought it was Deputy Davin said it. I could not believe that he said such a thing, and I expected accordingly that we would have a denial of it. It was a newspaper report. Now I see that it is only a report of something that Deputy Derrig was supposed to have said. I do not know what purpose the Labour Party had, but I give them credit for whatever purpose is revealed on the face of the amendment. As far as I can see, the amendment is an attempt to anticipate the findings of the De-rating Commission, and to try to get some scheme of distribution which will assist tillage and the small farmer. If it did that there might be something to be said for the amendment. I do not think we are entitled at this moment to anticipate the findings, in the way of distribution, of the De-rating Commission. If this Commission has taken a year and a half to try to get some permanent scheme let us wait for that permanent scheme. This motion is not intended to secure anything more than immediate relief, and if the Labour Party's amendment means the same thing, to give immediate relief, it falls short of its purpose, because it cannot be applied as simply and as quickly as the motion can.
Comment on this
The Deputy will hear enough of "why." I assure the Deputy that if he had heard many of the criticisms from members of our Party of this amendment from the point of view of its feasibility he would be satisfied. I will give one or two reasons that occur to me. First of all, we have got the £50 valuation. I can imagine the criticism the Minister for Finance would level at the round figure of £50, the magic of that figure, why you had a sudden break at 50, and what about the man with a valuation of £49 and £51. If you had a scheme of this sort, in order not to have these sudden breaks, it must be scaled in some way. Deputy O'Connell would say, of course: "We do not design this as a perfect scheme; we are in a hurry." I reply: "Very well." If that is the attitude of the Labour Party they had better take our motion and try to get it through, because for this division of £50 there is no basis whatever.
Let us deal with another "why." The occupier has to satisfy the Minister for Agriculture "that not less than 20 per cent. of the arable land is under tillage." If Deputy O'Connell had heard the Minister for Agriculture telling us on one occasion that a host of inspectors, and so on, would be necessary in order to examine and to make certain that the 20 per cent. of tillage was actually there he would immediately see that there are insuperable difficulties from the practical point of view in putting this motion into effect. We have got to know that 20 per cent. of the farmers' arable land is under tillage. Of "arable land" probably the definition that Deputy O'Connell would like us to take would be of land that could actually be ploughed.
Comment on this
Then Deputy O'Connell is in a worse position. Perhaps the Deputy will explain, when he speaks, what exactly he means by "arable land." I will let him give that explanation. To my mind, if you mean by arable land land that can actually be ploughed we would have nice trouble in finding out the 20 per cent. But if you take another possible meaning of arable land, generally accepted when we meet the word in statistics, the Deputy will find he is in another difficulty, because it would be most unfair in many cases to insist on anything like this percentage. We are as anxious as Deputy O'Connell is to encourage tillage, but we do not see any way of doing so by a proposal of this kind. If Deputy O'Connell has any proposal for the encouragement of tillage other than a proposal which is clearly unworkable, and which would mean delay and extra cost of administration, taking away from the farmer some of the advantages we would give him, we will be prepared to meet him on that.
I suggest, however, that to put in this particular amendment here will defeat the main purpose of giving immediate relief to the farmers. I think that I have covered fairly fully the points I intended to make. I have shown that it is high time that this relief should be given. I have shown that the relief is justified, and that even members on the opposite benches are satisfied that it is justified. I have shown that this particular way of giving relief is the most expeditious way in which it can be given. I have pointed out to Deputy O'Connell, who has introduced the amendment, that such amendment is unworkable, and that if he were to press it——
Comment on this
No; our position is quite clear, but if he really wishes to get immediate relief for the farmer the best way to get it is through our motion. I was reading a short time ago a speech made by Senator Johnson, when the 1925 Act was introduced in which he mentioned the idea that it would be a useful thing if tillage could be helped. He welcomed the idea that some proposal was likely to be introduced for the assistance of tillage, and that some de-rating proposal was likely to come. Labour has had four or five years in which to work out this scheme of de-rating but it waits until this practical scheme of ours is put in here for giving immediate relief on lines that have been tested and known, it waits for this particular moment to bring in what we regard as more or less side tracking of the issue. I would like to think that it would help, but it seems to me that the only effect would be to side-track the main issue. Let us have a clear expression of opinion as to whether the farmer should not, here and now, get relief to the extent of £1,000,000 or whether he should wait for it until the examination undertaken by the De-rating Commission has been completed. If Deputies want it now let them vote for the motion. If they want to anticipate de-rating and to have a full discussion as to the best methods of relief let the Labour Deputies persist in their amendment. I hope that the Labour Deputies will support us in this motion, so that it can be put up clearly to the Government from all benches, other than the Government Benches, to make good their promise. We have introduced this motion neither to put the Government into difficulties nor to get them out of difficulties. We have brought it in because we believe that it is time that the farmers got relief without further delay.
Comment on this
I move:
To delete all words after the word "Grant" in line 3, and insert the following:—
"for the relief of the local rates on agricultural land sufficient to allow for the remission of three-fourths of the rates on agricultural land in the case of holdings where the valuation of the land does not exceed £50, and of one half of such rates where the valuation of the land exceeds £50 and where the occupier satisfies the Minister for Agriculture that not less than twenty per cent. of the arable land is under tillage and that the sum required to provide this grant shall be raised in such manner as will not place any additional taxation on the small farmers and wage-earners."
I think that everyone will agree that the House is at a very great disadvantage indeed in discussing this motion in the absence of such data as would undoubtedly be available had the Commission on De-rating which was appointed some eighteen months ago reported. I quite agree with Deputy de Valera that in the circumstances his motion is justified, inasmuch as there has been an altogether unwarranted delay on the part of the De-rating Commission in bringing in its report. It must be several months since evidence was taken and completed and, although I agree that the question is very complicated, I could not imagine how those who are on that Commission, those who have expert knowledge, could delay their report so long as they have done. Apart from that, there is no guarantee as to the length of time it would take the Government to consider that report when it comes to hand—I am assuming that it has not yet come to hand. If we were to judge by the length of time which it took the Government to consider other questions not so complicated as this, I am afraid that the farmers would have to wait a long time before any measure of relief would be given to them. That is why I say that the motion would be justified, even if it did nothing else beyond extracting from the Government a definite statement as to their plans and intentions for the relief of the farming community this year.
I agree with Deputy de Valera as to the necessity for relief and, as it is common cause on all sides of the House, there is no need for me to elaborate what Deputy de Valera has said. He has gone into the matter in great detail, and I do not propose to follow him, especially as the question of depression and the necessity for relief is admitted on all sides and does not need to be argued. I think that this is a time when it is appropriate that some indication should be given to the farmers as to what is to be the nature and extent of the relief to be afforded to them. This is the time of the year when the farmer is laying his plans, and when he wants to know what his burdens for the year are likely to be. This debate may be a deciding factor as to the amount of land he will till, the amount of manure or seed he will buy, and as to whether he will keep his stock or sell it off before it reaches maturity.
All these things are troubling the farmer at this juncture. Therefore it is essential that we should have a definite declaration from the Government as to whether they intend to give relief this year, and what is the nature and extent of that relief. As I have said, the motion is useful if it did nothing else than to secure such a declaration. As to the necessity for relief and the depression calling for relief, we are in agreement with the Fianna Fáil proposition, but when it comes to the question of the allocation of the particular sum which may be set aside, it is there we part company. Immediately it was reported in the Press that this motion was to be put down, and when the manner in which the proposed grant was to be distributed was indicated, I took occasion to criticise that method in a speech which I made, I think, in Drogheda, and I thought that by doing so I would give a hint to those responsible for the motion as to the necessity for a further examination regarding the basis of distribution of the money. The motion had not appeared on the Order Paper, but instead of taking the hint, as I thought might possibly be the case, a prominent member of the Fianna Fáil Party, Deputy Derrig, rather defended this particular method and said it was fair, and that everyone would be relieved according to the rates he paid, and also that it was an extension of the Agricultural Grant. I think it was on that occasion that the statement was made by Deputy Derrig that we were really helping the Government. That was the statement to which Deputy de Valera referred a few moments ago. I think it was Deputy Derrig who made that statement. I think that Deputy Lemass said something very like that later on.
Comment on this
That it was helping the Government—that was the general idea. These two Deputies have got into the habit of saying that kind of thing about the Labour Party, so that I did not pay as much attention to their remarks as I might otherwise have done. That, however, is not the case—it is not to help the Government. So far as the Fianna Fáil proposition is concerned, we are accepting the general principle of it but we do believe that a measure of relief can be given, and given immediately, which will be distinctly more favourable to the class of farmer who in our opinion is most deserving of relief in the community.
The amendment is simple and requires little explanation. There are three sections in it. The first two deal with the method of allocation and the last portion has reference to the manner in which the sum required is to be raised. For the purposes of allocation we make two broad divisions, those with a valuation of £50 or under, and those with a valuation of over £50. To those with a valuation of £50 or under the amendment proposes to grant immediate relief of three-fourths of their current rates—on agricultural land, of course. We are dealing entirely with rates on agricultural land. To those with a valuation over £50 it proposes to give relief equal to half their current rates on certain conditions. The conditions apply only to those whose valuation is over £50. Let me say at once, as Deputy de Valera himself admitted with regard to his own motion, that it is entirely because of the urgency of the question that this broad and rough-and-ready method of affording relief has been adopted by us. It is not the method we would adopt if we were framing a permanent scheme.
I doubt indeed if the method of pure and simple relief of rates would be the method which the Labour Party would advocate if they were framing a permanent scheme. I do not speak after having made a very exhaustive examination of the question but I do not think that merely to relieve rates irrespective of the effect which that would have on individual farmers is the best way. It is at least possible that a way could be found which would ensure that any relief given would be turned to the purpose of increasing production on the part of the farmer. It is quite possible that a way could be found to ensure, for instance, that the money was spent for the purposes of production. That might be difficult and it might require a very keen examination. I am sure it would. Machinery would have to be devised, and therefore it is out of the question as far as this particular proposal is concerned.
It might be suggested, and it has been suggested repeatedly from these benches and by our speakers so far back as the 1923 election and certainly in the 1927 election, that the time had come when certain expenditure that is now found from the rates should be found entirely from the Central Fund. This has special reference to the upkeep of main and trunk roads. We have argued that these can no longer be regarded as local services and therefore ought not be purely local burdens, as a matter of fact, that no portion of the local rates should go to the upkeep of the main and trunk roads. The same thing would apply to other services, such as the upkeep of mental hospitals. The capitation grant that is given from the Central Fund towards the upkeep of mental hospitals has not been changed since the early years of the century, despite the fact that the cost of maintenance in these hospitals has increased very much indeed. These are directions along which it would be possible to give relief if there was time to examine them. I quite admit that all these things would require time, and therefore we do not suggest them now. We had to fall back on the simple method of relief of rates, but even there we believe it is possible to make a distinction as to the people who will get the greatest relief. We fix the figure at £50. Quite obviously, Deputy de Valera and other critics will ask: "Why £50?" Why any figure? Why a million? We could argue about any figure to the same extent, and let me say quite candidly that if I have any apology to offer it is because I think this figure is too high. If I had my own way, and had regard only for my own particular constituents, the figure would be fixed much less than £50. I agree, however, that the lower down you go the more difficulty you would have in fixing conditions.
By fixing a figure of £50 valuation we do get in 92 per cent. of the occupiers of agricultural land, and that is a figure I want Deputy de Valera to take into consideration. Ninety-two per cent. of the occupiers of agricultural holdings in this country are covered by that figure. There are some within that figure who, I admit, are not deserving of any consideration, but they are a comparatively small number. In any case, by taking that rough-and-ready figure and taking into account all the time the same consideration which Deputy de Valera had in regard to the urgency of the matter and the time, we believe that it is fairer to everybody concerned, fairer to this particular class of farmer than the all-round proposition of Deputy de Valera. Deputy de Valera's motion on his own figures, and as I calculated too, approximately gives relief equal to an extent of one-half of the burden. Our proposition is that those with a valuation of £50 or under should be relieved of three-fourths of the burden.
I just want to say a word on the method of averaging the assessment. I think if Deputy de Valera examines his method he will find a rather remarkable thing, namely, that it will be least fair to the counties that have a progressively rising rate, that is, where the rates are higher this year than last year, and were higher last year than the year before. This method of averaging the relief will be least fair to those whose rates are higher this year. If he examines the figures he will find that is so, and it is the county that has a high rate this year that is specially deserving of relief in view of the depression. It will be said perhaps that if Fianna Fáil with a million pounds can only give relief to the extent of 50 per cent., and if we propose to relieve 92 per cent. of the occupiers of land, to the extent of three-quarters, that at first blush our proposal would cost very much more than a million, and that that perhaps is the reason we do not mention the cost in our proposal. That is not so, because if Deputy de Valera examines the figures he will find this further remarkable fact, that in the case of these 92 per cent. of the occupiers the valuation of the amount of land they hold is only 52 per cent. of the total valuation of agricultural land. The remaining 48 per cent. is held by the remaining 8 per cent. of the occupiers. These are figures I would specially commend to Deputy Corry. He will find that, roughly speaking, the figures are four millions held by the 92 per cent., and roughly 3½ millions held by the 8 per cent. These are very round and rough figures, as Deputy de Valera said. So that almost one-half of the £1,000,000, certainly £400,000 of it, would go to relieve the burden of this 8 per cent. who hold land of £50 valuation and over.
What would the proposal we suggest cost? Everybody will admit that it is difficult to measure that in the absence of the kind of data that would be available if the De-rating Commission had reported. It is not easy to make these calculations, but there is a considerable amount of data available. I will explain if the calculation is questioned, but I calculate that, roughly speaking, this 92 per cent. of people of £50 valuation and under could be relieved of three-fourths of their burden at a cost of £750,000 or £800,000. That is our main concern. We on these benches are not particularly concerned with the 8 per cent. as compared with the 92 per cent. At the same time, we recognise that they have a claim, and we suggest that we put in certain conditions with regard to relieving these. We should remember, and Deputy de Valera should remember it especially when he talked of the difficulty of it, that the number is small—8 per cent. In my own county of Mayo, out of 33,900 rated occupiers there are only about 600, or about 2 per cent. of them, with farms of £50 valuation and over. They are not very many, and the difficulty of applying this particular test is more apparent than real.
Deputy de Valera talked about arable land. Arable land is scheduled since the war years, and I believe that the returns are available. The Minister for Agriculture would be able to tell us whether that is so or not— whether the amount of arable land in the possession of each individual or on each holding is scheduled. In any case, it is a matter for each of these particular people to make his case. Immediate relief can be given to the others. After all, we must remember that these people of £50 valuation and under are the backbone of the country. They are the people we hear so much about—the small farmers, though some of them are not very small farmers. A farm valued at £50 is quite a good farm. So far as the second class is concerned, our estimate of the cost would be about £75,000. I am calculating that by basing it on certain data made available in 1917 as to the number of farms which had 20 per cent. of tillage and over and, making due allowance for the great fall in tillage which has since taken place, I estimate the amount necessary to give the relief which I propose in that case would be £75,000.
Comment on this
I am making two divisions. I am suggesting that the amount necessary to give the relief we suggest to those with £50 valuation and under would be £750,000. In the second portion for those with £50 valuation and over and who fulfil the conditions we lay down—i.e., 20 per cent. tillage—it would cost about £75,000. I hope I have made that clear to the President.
Comment on this
I am afraid the Deputy put his foot in it the first time.
Comment on this
No. I am making two divisions. Deputy de Valera is making one clear cut. We are making two divisions. For those with £50 valuation and under we estimate £750,000, and for those in the other class above that, who would fulfil the conditions as to tilling 20 per cent. of the land, we estimate it will cost about £75,000, or a total of £850,000. In any case, let it be the million. I do not think it would be. I believe it would mean, as a matter of fact, a saving of £120,000 or so to the State. But, even if it were a million, we believe it would be divided more equitably in this particular manner than in the manner suggested by Deputy de Valera.
Who is going to suffer as a result of our proposals? As compared with Deputy de Valera's scheme, undoubtedly those who have farms valued at £50 or over and who till less than 20 per cent. of the land. I do not believe that Deputy Corry will have very great sympathy with that class of person, if I am to judge by what I heard in the last two or three days here. No one would suffer except whatever number of these landholders—these 8 per cent.—who are not tilling 20 per cent. Our main object here, if we are to judge by the many things we have been saying from time to time in this House, is the encouragement of tillage, because it is the encouragement of tillage which gives employment. I will say at once that there is one particular class of man, because I am quite ready to see the weaknesses of this, who may be engaged in dairy farming and have a valuation of over £50. That is one of the difficulties undoubtedly. The number, however, is not very large.
I spoke a moment ago of how these respective proposals would affect the various counties, and I put it to every Deputy to apply both proposals to his own county, where he knows the conditions. I have calculated that Mayo would, under Deputy de Valera's proposal, get about £30,000 for the relief of rates, or a little over that, perhaps. As a matter of fact, owing to peculiar circumstances, if you like, and the fact that the rates in Mayo have been raised very considerably as compared with two years ago, this sum would only relieve rates in Mayo to the extent of about one-third on any particular holding.
Comment on this
I do not think in every case it would be half. If I understand it, the sum allocated to each county would be in proportion to the average of the total assessment over three years, and I am pointing out that on the average over three years it would be lower.
Comment on this
Owing to the fact that the rates are higher this year in that particular county it would only get a sum that would relieve the burden to the extent of one-third. But our motion would relieve the burden of 98 per cent. of the landholders in Mayo to the extent of three-fourths. So far as Mayo is concerned, under our proposal they would get at least double what they would get under Deputy de Valera's proposal.
Comment on this
Deputy de Valera's proposal and ours is for one year only. In the county of Meath, which is in what may be called the opposite end of the scale to Mayo, they would get £45,000 as against £30,000 for Mayo. That is, they would get one-and-a-third times times as much as Mayo, while they have already got one-and-a-third times as much as Mayo under the agricultural grant.
Comment on this
I need not dwell on what I may call the social values in the difference between these two counties. The population of Mayo is nearly three times the population of Meath; there are almost exactly ten times the number of holders with fifteen acres of land in Mayo as there are in Meath. I need not dwell on these points. Numerous other examples could be given to show that the proposal made by Fianna Fáil works out to the disadvantage of the small farmer and to the advantage of the big farmer. And that is the real issue between Deputy de Valera's motion and ours.
I cannot understand, in view of all I heard repeatedly from the Fianna Fáil Benches, how this one objection to our motion that was mentioned can weigh with many of the Deputies on those benches to the extent that they were prepared to let some 6,000 of those people with big ranches and graziers and all that class of people about whom we hear so much get away with something like £400,000 of this money. Does Deputy Clery from Mayo approve of that, and do Deputies from Donegal, Galway and Clare approve of that? I cannot understand it. As I say, is this objection made to our proposal so weighty that it will weigh with them to that extent that those people who, after all, have a good share of the world's goods must get relief out of the common fund to that extent? So far as we are concerned, at any rate, we are not prepared to admit that principle; because we think there is no real substance in the objection so long as you have 92 per cent. of the farmers, and those the most deserving class of farmers, getting immediate relief as they would under this proposal of ours. I think the trouble and difficulty with the remaining 8 per cent. is not so great that we should allow them to get away with half the spoils as is proposed in the motion here. I think that must be plainly evident to everybody on the Fianna Fáil Benches, and on the Government Benches, too.
I want to refer for a moment to the latter portion of my amendment. There is no reference in Deputy de Valera's motion, and there was no reference in his speech as to where this money is to come from, but I think it is important. And while it is not our business to make definite suggestions or to go into any definite detail as to where the money is to be raised, it is our business to say—and we say quite definitely—that it must not be raised from the very class of people we are anxious to help. In other words we do not believe in what Deputy Nolan, I think, described when the Butter Tariff question was under debate, in feeding the dog with a piece of his own tail. We had a statement, and a very important statement, from the President on the opening day of the Autumn session, and I think it should not be forgotten when looking round for money for this particular proposal. He said, that the aggregate actual income assessed for income tax had increased by four and three-quarter millions during the period between 1923-24 and 1928-29. That was a remarkable statement. And we know that under various guises and for various reasons, the Minister for Finance for the last four or five years has been specially kind to that particular section of the community who are in the fortunate position of having to pay income tax. I do not know that the Minister for Finance himself would be prepared to say that the object he had in mind when he afforded that relief has been achieved. In other words, that the particular section of the community relieved have risen to the occasion to the extent that he expected they would. If it is a question however, of raising this money, we do say at once, that the strongest objection will be taken by members on the Labour Benches to anything in the nature of an indirect tax, or any tax on the necessaries of life, because these are bound to fall, and always do fall, most heavily upon the poorer section of the community. It is not our business to say definitely where this money is to be raised. I have thrown out a hint about the income tax; there are people who would make other suggestions.
The question of the petrol tax has been a favourite suggestion. I say again that while I merely refer to this I do so in order to emphasise what I have stated in our motion: "That the sum required to provide this grant shall be raised in such manner as will not place any additional taxation on the small farmers and wage earners"; in other words, that there shall not be any indirect taxation that would press most heavily upon the poorer section of the community. Deputy de Valera suggested to us that we should abandon this amendment and vote for the motion. I suggest to him that he should accept the amendment. I think from every point of view it is the most sensible thing to do. It is what in any case one would have a right to expect from that particular Party. The line the Fianna Fáil Party has always taken is that when any distinction is to be made, the distinction should be made in favour of the small farmers. The objection which he makes, as I have said, does not hold. So far as the vast majority of the small farmers and the wage earners whom we are anxious to relieve are concerned, our scheme could be applied and applied immediately to 92 per cent. of the rated occupiers. As a matter of fact I think it would be a much simpler method so far as that percentage is concerned than this system of averages which is set out in Deputy de Valera's motion. To tell the truth, I am not absolutely clear as to how it would work out under his motion in the different counties all over the State. I think our method is much simpler. So far as the county council secretaries are concerned they could much more easily deal with the matter by our method than they could under the suggestion in Deputy de Valera's motion. I suggest that the proper thing for Deputy de Valera and the Fianna Fáil Party to do is to accept the amendment. If, however, in the interests of the 6,000 who are going to get away with a big share of the spoils, they are going to join with the Cumann na nGaedheal Party in defeating the amendment, and if they succeed in defeating it, we will vote for the motion as the next best thing, because it contains the principle of relief. But in doing that I want to make it quite clear that we are totally opposed to this method of allocation where by such a small percentage will get away with such a big proportion of the grant that will be made available.
[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]
Comment on this
In the course of the Budget statement which I made in 1929 I indicated, as Deputy de Valera has already said, that a Departmental Committee had given some examination to this matter, and I pointed out to the Dáil in some little detail the complexities of the whole business. The question of de-rating became urgent after a de-rating scheme had been adopted in England. When that scheme had been put into operation a great many people here wanted that de-rating scheme adopted in its entirety and in all its details in the Saorstát. It is quite obvious that conditions here are different, that such need as there might then have been for a measure of the kind, arose from entirely different circumstances to the circumstances which dictate de-rating in England. I pointed out that de-rating was a very much bigger proposition here than in Great Britain; that whereas the sum required in Great Britain was 2.8 per cent. of the national revenue, the sum that would be required here was 9.2 per cent. of the national revenue. I pointed out the difficulties that would be met in raising the sum of money that would be required for de-rating along the British Government lines here. The sum that would be required here would be a sum of practically two and a quarter millions. I pointed out how that sum could not be raised by any scheme of taxation that could be devised, or it appeared that could not be raised by any scheme of taxation that might be devised without involving taxation of the necessaries of life. I pointed out that it would be almost impossible to raise that sum by a petrol tax or even to raise a substantial fraction of that sum by petrol tax. The sum required in England was raised by a tax on petrol. Here the maximum that could be got by a tax on petrol would be one-fifth or one-fourth or something around that of the whole cost of de-rating. I indicated that even a petrol tax, coupled with a conceivable or reasonable increase in income tax would not get the amount. I indicated moreover that from another aspect the proposition was a very different thing here to what it was in Great Britain. For, whereas, in Great Britain, agricultural land represented only two and a half per cent. of the total valuation, agricultural land in Scotland 6 per cent. of the valuation, in the North of Ireland 38 per cent. of the valuation, it represented 65 per cent. of the valuation here. I pointed out that, if we were to have de-rating on the English plan here, in the case of a great many of the local authorities 90 per cent. of the revenue would come from the Exchequer. I indicated that in such circumstances it would be impossible to allow local government as we know it to remain in existence.
To give something like 90 per cent. of their revenue to local authorities and allow them to carry on with their existing powers would invite an orgy of extravagance and inefficiency. Consequently I pointed out that the matter was one which was in every way a very much bigger proposition than the proposition that had to be faced in Great Britain, and an amount of consideration that it had not been possible to give to it up to that time, was necessary. Some time after the making of that statement a Commission was set up. The terms of reference of the Commission were:—
To enquire and report to the Minister for Finance as to
(1) The effect on production and employment of local rates at present levied on agricultural land and buildings and industrial and freight transport hereditaments.
(2) The probable economic consequences, including in particular the effect on production, employment, taxation and the cost of living, of affording partial or complete relief from such rates by means of contributions from the Exchequer to local authorities, or, alternatively, by transferring to the Central Government the administration of particular services at present administered by local authorities.
(3) The effect of affording such relief on the existing system of local government including local financial administration, and any modifications of that system which would thereby be rendered desirable.
(4) The basis on which Exchequer Grants are at present distributed to local authorities, and whether, and if so, in what manner that basis could be so modified as to secure increased agricultural and industrial production as a consequence of distributing the grants.
The Commission numbered 18 members, one of whom has since died. The Commission has given a very great deal of study to the problem. Not only have the Commission given a great deal of time to the work, but a great deal of time has been given by Government Departments which were required to supply material of various sorts for the information of the Commission. We are now reaching a point when the report of the Commission will be before us, and at that point we have this resolution set down. I say that the putting down of this resolution can serve no purpose, and can be intended to serve no purpose in connection with the matter, except the purpose of raising an ordinary sort of political debate. Because the time at which an announcement would be made in connection with this matter— the time at which it would be proper to make an announcement in connection with it—would be on the introduction of the Budget.
When, some four or five years ago, a measure of relief to rates was given, that relief was first announced in connection with the Budget when the general scheme of taxation for the year was put before the Dáil. The only time, and the natural time, for the Government to make an announcement in connection with the matter would be on the Budget, when the whole general scheme of taxation is before us. The members of this Commission have given a great deal of study and have devoted a great deal of work to the problem that is before us. They were asked to explore the various methods by which relief can be given to agriculture.
Reference has been made to the speech which the President delivered in Dun Laoghaire in November last. Some parts of it have been quoted. The President on that occasion, said: "The Government accept it that it is essential that an adjustment of conditions shall be secured to relieve the farmer of his most pressing obstacles, to assist him to increase his output, and secure better marketing facilities." Speaking in reference to the De-rating Commission, he said: "They are now engaged in the preparation of their Report. I cannot forecast what their conclusions will be. Whatever they are, the evidence the Commission has collected will be of the greatest assistance to the Government in deciding what is the most suitable form which the relief we intend to provide for the agriculturist shall take. We agree the farmer must receive every assistance that, having regard to our resources, can be given to him. The only question which remains is the form of assistance which will be the greatest value to him, and will at the same time render necessary a minimum imposition of burdens on the rest of the community."
As I indicated when reading the terms of reference of the Commission, they have to consider, first, whether de-rating is the only effective way to afford relief to the agricultural community, whether we might have some alternative to de-rating, or whether we might have some measure of de-rating coupled with other schemes and, secondly, they have to consider, in the event of it being found necessary to have grants from the Exchequer for the relief of rates, how these grants should be given, and whether, instead of giving the grants to the local authorities we should not afford relief of rates by taking over certain services. Everybody knows that in certain respects, at any rate, by taking over certain services, economies might be achieved through the measure of combination that would be thereby effected. It is the business of the Commission to consider all these problems and to put up some report to us.
My view is that it would be impossible to get any Commission of responsible people of this sort ever again to give their full mind to the work that would be put before them if we were, at this stage, before the Commission's report has been received, to pass a resolution of this sort. Whatever the conclusions of the Commission may be, they will be before the Government shortly. Any matters that they put up will be dealt with promptly, and the Government are in a position to deal with them promptly, because, apart altogether from the work of the Commission, this whole matter, as I have already said, has been engaging the attention of Departments and Ministers for a very considerable time past. It was the subject of Departmental consideration, and it was the subject of consideration by a sub-committee of the Cabinet before this Commission was appointed at all. There will be no difficulty, when the views of the Commission are before the Government, in coming to a speedy conclusion as to what should be done.
My view is that anything that is to be done this year should, if possible, be in accordance with whatever permanent measures are to be adopted. If it is possible at all, whatever we are going to do in a permanent way should be done this year. If it is not possible to carry out whatever permanent scheme may be adopted, then we should endeavour to have an instalment of that permanent scheme. If it is not even possible to work out all the details in order to have an instalment of the permanent scheme, we should endeavour to have adopted something, at any rate, that is fully in line with the permanent scheme.
I think it is entirely wrong, in dealing with this problem, that we should follow the lines proposed in Deputy de Valera's resolution; it is entirely wrong to go along the old lines. For all practical purposes this resolution simply means going somewhere near doubling the two existing agricultural grants. Although there is a slight variation in distribution, the whole thing amounts to very little more than that. It would amount to doubling the existing agricultural grants without having taken into consideration at all the question of a reform of local government. There would also be the question of whether any such sum as this should be handed over to the local authorities without taking steps to see that the result is not going to be, in a year or two, the levying of taxation to obtain whatever money may be now handed over, with a consequent increase in rates, bringing them up almost to the amount that they were before this grant would be given. I know there are very many people who are most urgently anxious to have some system of de-rating, either complete or partial, put into operation, who hold that it would be entirely wrong to give big sums to the local authorities which would, perhaps, bring the rates down for a year or two. They hold it would be wrong to do that without examining the system, without seeing whether checks cannot be imposed upon extravagance, or whether some other adjustments in the machinery cannot be made that will ensure that the country is not going to be in a worse position in a couple of years than it is at the present time.
There is no need for a motion of this kind. The Government have stated, and the remarks made by the President have set out clearly and definitely their view, that, in the face of world conditions, and certain local circumstances, the condition of the agriculturist is such that relief is being afforded to him. There is only one question that remains to be settled, and that is the form that the relief should take. Of course the auxiliary problem of the particular method by which the money required for relief should be raised, remains to be solved. There was no motion before the Dáil when the Agricultural Grant was doubled in 1926. There was no motion a few months in advance, requiring that that grant should be doubled. There is no need for any motion now. The whole matter is being dealt with as one which must be faced, and faced immediately.
We do think that it is too complex and too serious a matter to be dealt with in the manner proposed here. As a matter of fact Deputy de Valera said he did not wish to anticipate the findings or the recommendations of the De-rating Commission. His motion is, in fact, an anticipation of it. Although it may be described and intended as a proposal for one year only, everyone knows that the adoption of any particular scheme for one year does mean that that line has to be followed for future years. If there is going to be any different distribution or any different method adopted permanently, it will be very much more difficult to get that adopted than if we do whatever we are going to do now, in line with any permanent scheme that might be adopted. I do not see any reason why, whatever permanent scheme is going to be adopted should not be adopted, either in whole or in part, or in some parallel way this year.
For instance if we were to reform local government it might not be possible to carry out the reform at once. At any rate the whole thing ought to be taken together. Any reforms that are to be carried out ought to be foreshadowed with any proposal for grants or expenditure. The extent to which the whole scheme will go must regulate, to a considerable extent, proposals of reform. If we were going to have de-rating on the British scale, I think something like complete abolition of local government, as we know it, would be necessary. If it was decided that relief should be given to the farmers by a means other than de-rating, if further schemes were found to be practicable, it might not be necessary to touch local government at all. If on the other hand, there was some substantial measure of de-rating, then something not so drastic as practical abolition of local government, but some other changes, might be sufficient to meet the situation.
At any rate, I think it is a matter that must be faced as a whole, and the only business-like way to meet this as a whole and to take our decision on all the matters together. The form of relief, the conditions in regard to reform of local government which may be attached to it, and the methods by which any necessary funds are to be raised, are closely related and the decision on all of them should be taken at the one time as far as possible by the Dáil. It may not be possible to adopt all of them at once, but, at any rate, whatever is the principle of the first proposal put before the Dáil any of the other concurrent proposals should be known to it. I think it is not necessary to go into details of any possible schemes at present. I think they should be dealt with at a later time, and they should be dealt with when not only the Government but the members of the Dáil have before them all the material the absence of which Deputy O'Connell deplored to-day, the material which the De-rating Commission has spent a great deal of time and labour in putting together.
Comment on this
Is the Minister making any promise whatsoever that anything will be done for the relief of farmers further than the present agricultural grant when the Budget comes along?
Comment on this
The proposal I am making is this. I have already stated that relief has been promised to the farmers in the clearest possible terms. The only thing that remains to be decided is the best form in which such relief should be given. I have said that the report of the De-rating Commission is very nearly ready, that it is to be available quite soon, and that the matter will be dealt with immediately, and that the Government is in a position to come to decisions in the matter without delay, because none of the problems connected with this matter are new to departments or the Ministers. When a decision has been come to action will be taken, and the action that the Government propose to take in connection with the matter will be announced as it normally would be announced in the Budget speech when the related proposals in connection with the raising of revenue will be before the House.
Comment on this
Is the Minister making a promise that he will announce further additional relief for agriculture in this year's Budget?
Comment on this
I am afraid the Minister was compelled very reluctantly to make the statement that he was going to give relief in this year's Budget, because if he was definite on that and gave us any indication of what that relief was to consist of I do not think we should lose any time on this motion. Seeing that the Minister is allowing the time of the Dáil to be taken up for the whole day on this discussion I think we should press him a little further and see what a division might do later on, and also see if his own Party and members of the allied Party, the Farmers' Party, will not bring some influence to bear on him in order to make his position even more clear before this discussion is over. It is not contested here at all that farmers want relief, and seeing also that Deputy de Valera gave the figures that are available on this subject, it is not necessary to make that case again. We admit from every side of this House, because I think we have not any members of the Dublin Chamber of Commerce here, that the farmers do want relief. The only thing, as the Minister said in concluding, is to decide what form that relief was to take and how to find the money. Those are the two big questions that have been agitating us for some years, and if those two questions are not yet solved by the Government we are not much nearer the solution.
I want to make this point as to the necessity for relief. As an agricultural country we are dependent greatly on the export market for the sale of our produce and we are competing there with many other countries. The question of the export of butter has been before us all very prominently for the last couple of years. We all know that during the twelve months of 1930 on the British market there was a very disastrous fall in the price of butter, with a consequent severe loss to the creameries and the suppliers of milk to the creameries. We know also that during the last few years a greater amount of butter has come in than before to the British market and that our three big competitors there are Denmark, New Zealand and Australia, and that they are getting the British market to a greater extent than we have ever got it.
We learn from the Report of the Tariff Commission on butter that during 1930 Danish butter realised a price of 23/- per cwt. more than Free State butter for the whole year. That means to the farmer supplying milk to the creamery a higher price of 1d. per gallon in Denmark than here. Take the other countries supplying, Australia and New Zealand; they are both exporting butter to the British market under subsidies. If we take even our rival, the North of Ireland, which is sending butter to England, the farmer there has the advantage of being de-rated, so we are at a distinct disadvantage as compared with our competitors in the foreign market. Unless something is done very quickly, as Deputy de Valera pointed out, we may not have the relief brought forth in time and we may find our farmers have gone out of production and will be in a much worse position to capture whatever part of the export market they had a couple of years ago. We find that is borne out by the figures of exports of milch cows from this country. A greater number of milch cows are being exported, and it would appear that some at least of the farmers are going out of the production of butter. Even in our home market we are up against the same competition. We are competing not alone on the British market but in our home market against bacon produced under subsidy. For instance, Polish bacon. If we take the grain business, we find we have been driven out of it completely. We have been driven out of the British market, and even in our home market we are competing against subsidised grain from Russia and Germany. The prices of the various commodities have gone down in the foreign market, and there has been, of course, a natural fall in prices at home, with the result that our farmers have found it impossible to remain in production and many of them have become bankrupt. I know in County Wexford, that I represent, a large number of farms have become derelict. No rates or annuities are paid in respect of them. The result has been that the County of Wexford has had the large sum of £22,000 deducted from the grants that were due owing to defaulting land annuitants. No rates have been paid on these derelict farms. There is nobody living on some of them. The farmers who have remained on their farms are, as a result, paying more in rates, and for a few years back we have seen a gradual rise in the rate struck in most counties. Of course, it is not altogether due to the derelict farms and the fact that certain farmers are going out of business. It is also due to the policy of the Government in putting on certain rates in counties, some of which were not there before and others of which were optional.
On the Vote on Account last week I mentioned certain rates that are being inflicted on counties. While the President was talking in Dun Laoghaire about the intentions of the Government in regard to de-rating and while other Ministers were talking about the intentions in regard to de-rating, Bills were brought before this Dáil which put additional rates on counties. The consequence is that the counties are now paying at least a shilling in the £ more. For instance, the Vocational Education Bill imposes a rate of 1¾d., rising to 4d. Then we have the Local Government (Special Expenses) Bill, which may put on a rate of anything up to 3d. in the £ on agricultural land. We had last week, or the week before, an Agriculture Bill which put a mandatory rate of 2d. in the £ on agricultural land where before the rate was optional. Formerly if the farmers who were on the county councils found they could no longer bear the burden of the rates they could, at least, knock off that 2d. rate for the time being, but now it is mandatory.
I mentioned also the position in regard to the money that was voted for relief before Christmas. Where the Local Government Department sanctions a scheme in a village or small town usually they offer 30 per cent. of the cost. The local people or local councils, being anxious to give employment, accept the 30 per cent. and take on the burden of paying the other 70 per cent. themselves. The rates have gone up as a result of all these things. I think there is a necessity for immediate relief for the farmers, if we want to keep them in production at all. The motion that was put down here was put down in its present form because it was simple and could be applied immediately. It was put down, more or less, on the lines of the present agricultural grant, with the exception that it was based on the rates raised during the last three years instead of being based on the rates raised in the year 1898. We would very much like to include in this motion provisions to deal with tillage, but we do not see that the question of tillage could be dealt with in a satisfactory manner in a motion like this.
As a matter of fact, we have on occasions during the last few years brought in motions here dealing with the encouragement of tillage, and we believe that the methods suggested in these motions would be best to deal with the encouragement of tillage. It is very difficult to differentiate in the rates as between those who till and those who do not till. As a matter of fact, the amendment, as it is put down here, is, in my opinion, in no way sufficient to encourage tillage or to induce a man who is at present tilling to continue tilling. Take the average rate that a man is paying on land at the present time to be 4/-, 5/-, or perhaps 6/- in the £. The relief that he is going to get under this motion, where he has a valuation of over £50, provided he tills, is half that. That is, he is going to get relief on five acres if he tills one. It works out really as a subsidy of 15/- per acre on tillage. That is not sufficient in present circumstances to induce people to till if they are not inclined to till without this inducement. If we look at the price of grain for the year 1930 as compared with pre-war prices, we find that the price of malting barley in 1930 was 10 per cent. less than it was in 1913 and 1914, and the price of oats is exactly the same as it was before the war. How could a farmer who has to employ labourers afford to till, when the cost of living is about 66 per cent. higher than before the war, on an extra 15/- per acre? In the case of oats he would get, for instance, £6 5s. for the produce of an acre before the war, and he would now get £7. How could he afford, on a subsidy of 15/-an acre, to till where the general cost of living has gone up by 66 per cent.? We had figures published in the "Irish Trade Journal" some time ago of agricultural wages as they were before the war and as they are at the present time. We find that agricultural wages have gone up by 100 per cent. from before the war until now. I am prepared to admit that even at the present time they are not high enough, that they should be higher. Nevertheless, the farmer who is selling barley and oats, and who has over £50 valuation, is doing that with agricultural labour which he was getting at 50 per cent. less before the war than he is getting it at to-day. That being so, this inducement of fifteen shillings per acre is not going to make him till.
Comment on this
We may be giving him less for all I know. We do not say, however, that we are going to get 20 per cent. of land tilled by this motion. We take it merely as a simple method—a method which can be put into operation immediately. We do not bother putting in a provision regarding tillage, because we think that it would be absolutely ineffective. During the Great War, when farmers had to till their land under regulations, we know that they did not make any attempt to till it properly. If there is an inducement to a large farmer to get a large portion of his land de-rated, he will probably—especially considering the price of grain at the present time— make a pretence at tilling in order to get that de-rating. If he has not been using his own grain or tilling for other reasons, he is not going into proper tillage on account of this amendment. He is going to make pretence of tilling 20 per cent. of his land to get de-rating.
This amendment would mean delay in getting a census of the tillage area. The Government, I am afraid, would insist on knowing what they were to be involved in under this proposal before they would adopt it. Therefore, they would have to get a fair estimate of the number of holders over £50 valuation who have 20 per cent. of their land tilled or would be likely to till 20 per cent. If the Government were willing to take a chance and say that the scheme was going to cost them three-quarters of a million, under Deputy O'Connell's proposal, or up to one million, and that they would put it into effect, there would be some justification for Deputy O'Connell's scheme. We know, however, that the Government is not like that. We know that the Government does not take chances with a quarter of a million, especially when it is for the relief of agriculture. They would not take a chance in this case and that would mean delay. What is more, it would mean dissatisfaction, because there will be always dissatisfaction where there is likely to be a dispute between the land holder and the authority paying the relief as to whether the 20 per cent. is tilled or not, and as to whether the 20 per cent. is really 20 per cent of the arable land or not. There would be a great deal of dissatisfaction. I believe that tillage must be encouraged on the basis of crop yield and not of area. This amendment means area. If there is 20 per cent. of the area under tillage, there is to be relief of rates. That is not a fair basis. If we want to encourage tillage, we should bear in mind that we will have to encourage the man who produces the good crop. The only way in which you can compensate the man who produces the good crop as against the man who produces a poor crop, is to pay on yield and quality of the crop, and not on area. This tillage clause only refers to men with over £50 valuation. In the Dáil yesterday, there was a discussion on a valuation clause in the Land Bill. The Minister for Agriculture then gave it as his opinion —nobody objected to it—that the valuation of good land in this country would be about ten shillings per acre.
Comment on this
This amendment means that a man with 100 acres, or under 100 acres, will get the 75 per cent. relief whether he tills or not. The only exception that is made is in the case of the man who has over 100 acres.
Comment on this
Our motion does not pretend to make any of these distinctions. I might also say that, as the amendment is drafted, this poor man of over £50 valuation must satisfy the Minister that any relief he may get will not come from any taxation on small farmers or wage earners.
Comment on this
As it reads here, it does not. I am prepared, however, to take Deputy O'Connell's statement. This amendment has been on the paper for several days and, as it reads, this particular provision refers only to men with over £50 valuation.
Comment on this
It must have been dropped from the first day the amendment appeared on the paper. However, I accept the Deputy's word. Deputy O'Connell is anxious, naturally, to get this money without taking any of it from the small farmer or wage earner. What is a small farmer? If we are to judge from Deputy O'Connell's amendment, a small farmer is a man under £50 valuation. That is the distinction he made in the first part of his amendment. A large farmer is, consequently, a man of over £50 valuation. We are really going to say that every farmer, whether he tills his land or not, if he is under £50 valuation, must not be asked in any way to contribute to this relief. I believe that it would be impossible to pick out taxation in which he would not be involved in some way. A small number of those men will have motor cars. Therefore, you must rule out petrol. A few of them may possibly be occupiers of fee-simple land. In that case, I believe they are liable to income tax. You must rule out income tax. Where are you to get the money? I believe, as Deputy de Valera said, that this amendment was framed hurriedly, and that if all its implications had been considered, Deputy O'Connell would not have put it in so quickly. If he waited for six or seven years while this Commission was going on, he could have waited six or seven days longer before putting in an amendment to this motion.
Deputy O'Connell said that the farmer can now decide on the amount that he will till. I am afraid it is too late. I think that the farmer who will decide now on the amount of land he will till this year is not the type of farmer who should receive relief even if he did till. The man who would decide on tilling now would not be a tillage farmer at all.
Comment on this
I know that, as Deputy O'Connell has said, this refers to every farmer, but it is too late now to decide about tilling. I am surprised if Deputy Reynolds is right, that you could even now commence to plough lea land and get your crop sown. They should be sown within the next few weeks.
Comment on this
Do you think that either scheme is going to do anything for tillage?
Comment on this
Deputy O'Connell also said that the Labour Party has been advocating, since the 1923 election, that the central authority should take over main and trunk roads and mental hospitals. That has been advocated by practically every party that I know, in local polities at all events. I do not believe that any Labour speaker advocated that in giving this relief to the county councils for main roads, trunk roads and mental hospitals, you must relieve only the farmer under £50 valuation and differentiate between the men over £50 valuation.
Comment on this
I certainly did advocate that. I will show it to you in my election address, though I may not have mentioned the £50 figure.
Comment on this
It is the first time I heard it advocated. I heard it advocated by every party that mental hospitals and main and trunk roads should be taken over. I have never yet heard that there should be any differentiation made in the rates that would be thereby relieved. As a matter of fact, I think some county councils that passed resolutions were going to take the rates off as a whole, and not to make any differentiation between agricultural land and other ratings. Deputy O'Connell said that if he had his way the £50 figure would be less, that it was a round figure, but that if he had Mayo in mind it would be lower. I do not object to that. Some rough-and-ready figure has to be taken. The figure £50 appears to me to be very high. I would not regard the farmer of £50 valuation as a small farmer. I think the Labour Party's attitude on this matter is very liberal if they regard a man with 100 acres and with £50 valuation as a small farmer. Deputy O'Connell made a point about the three years which come into our scheme. I think the Deputy will find that exactly the same thing happened in Meath as in Mayo, that the rates have gone up fairly rapidly for the last three years. If we are hitting Mayo we are also hitting Meath.
Comment on this
I am talking of the total rate collected in the County Meath and of the total amount collected in County Mayo. I notice a peculiar thing about Meath, that it looks as if there were a revaluation. The total amounts of rates leviable off agricultural land in County Meath in the years 1928-29-30 were £91,000, £89,000, and £109,000: in Mayo the amounts were £57,000, £50,000, and £79,000. There is the same tendency in both counties. The point made by Deputy O'Connell that his amendment would give greater relief to County Mayo than our motion is not right, in my opinion. I had not time to study the figures. I saw figures with Deputy MacEntee yesterday and I took them as correct, that the total rate leviable on agricultural land in Meath has gone up just as much as it has gone up in Mayo, and that if you are doing an injustice to Mayo under the motion you are also doing an injustice to Meath. If you are doing an injustice to both a strong county and to a weak county, it comes to this, that it is justice all round, because you are doing the same injustice to everybody.
I do not know if Deputy O'Connell is right in the figures he gave of the total cost. Deputy O'Connell admitted that it might be doing an injustice where the valuation of a farm was over £50 where dairy cows were kept. I do not like to have to stand up for people of over £50 valuation, but that shows the necessity of examining the question more fully than the Labour Party has done. It will be found that in Limerick and Tipperary there are a considerable number of farmers over £50 valuation who keep cows and supply milk to the creameries. The number of landholders over £50 valuation was given by Deputy O'Connell as very small, being only 8 per cent. of the whole. While I cannot vouch for the figures, I am told that these 8 per cent. employ 90,000 agricultural labourers. That is a very big number to be employed. If we have large dairy farmers over £50 valuation, and if they are employing this amount of labour, I think they are just as much entitled to relief as tillage farmers, particularly this year, because they have been hit worse than any other type of farmer during the last twelve months. The tillage farmer was badly hit in the past, but for the past twelve months the dairy farmer has been badly hit. Eight per cent. of these landholders employ 90,000 agricultural labourers. According to the figures given by Deputy O'Connell, the small amount that would be required under his amendment shows that there is not much tillage. Therefore there must be a good deal of dairying. We should remember that employment. I do not want to go into any other points which Deputy O'Connell has made. I do not believe that the amendment will in any way increase tillage, because the inducement to do so is not big enough.
Comment on this
It will mean greater expense to the man who does not till.
Comment on this
If we in this Party thought that we could encourage those who are in tillage to remain in it and to employ additional labour, either in dairying or other agricultural industry, immediately, we would certainly do so, but we do not believe that it can be done immediately. That is where we differ. The Minister for Finance quoted some figures which he gave in his last Budget statement, and showed the difficulties regarding de-rating here as compared with those in England, Scotland, and Northern Ireland. Obviously there are difficulties, but no difficulties can deter us from finding some relief for agriculture. We have to get over difficulties, because agriculture cannot go on unless we give some relief immediately. The Minister for Finance has stated that they intend to do something in the coming Budget. We all hope they will. He stated that the time to do it was when introducing the Budget. He also stated that the introduction of a motion like this, while a Commission was sitting and preparing its report on the question of de-rating, would prevent any self-respecting Commission from sitting again on that subject. All I can say about that statement is that it is no wonder he left the House after making it. He told us that the Commission was going to report soon, and that if we were going to give relief now it should be done in a permanent way this year. We all agree with that if it could be done in a permanent and satisfactory way, but why did the Government allow the motion to go on if that is the case? They had only to get up and say: "We are going to deal with the matter in the next Budget." They did not do that. The Minister for Finance said: "If it is not possible to do it in a permanent way this year, at least let us give an instalment of it." Again he said: "Even if that is not possible, let us do something in the direction of a permanent way."
There are too many "ifs" about his statement. He stated that he expects the Commission to report almost immediately, and that the Government will be in a position to consider the report without any delay when they get it. By the time, however, that they consider the various "ifs" of the Minister for Finance I do not think that they will be in time for the Budget. The Minister said that there was no need for the motion, and that we should all know that the Government were going to deal with the matter because the President mentioned it in Dun Laoghaire last November. We often found the President and Ministers making similar statements before, but they did not come to very much. They have been mentioning the question of de-rating for the last few years. Whenever there is a bye-election it becomes a very prominent subject. When the bye-election in Dublin last year was over, however, we were told that nothing could be done about de-rating this year. Thus it will be seen that there is necessity for the motion. The Minister for Finance said that only two questions remained to be settled, namely, the form of relief and how to raise the money. The Minister may think that these are rather trivial matters, but to us they are very big ones. The form in which the relief is to be given has, we presume, been engaging the attention of the De-rating Commission for over eighteen months, and I suppose the question of raising the money has been considered, not only by that Commission, but also by the Department of Finance.
If we were in the position here of being able to say that we were only going through a temporary depression in agriculture and that we felt that at the end of 1931 we would have turned the corner—the corner about which we have heard so often—we might have some patience and even some consideration for the De-rating Commission, and give them time to present the best report possible and allow the Executive Council to consider it. There is, however, no time for that, There is no prospect for farming, so far as we can see. The prospects for farming were never worse. Up to last year we thought that things were going to improve, but now we see that they are going the other way and that relief is wanted immediately if we are to keep farmers in production. In the last issue of the "Irish Trade Journal" it was stated that the world's export of butter in the year before the war was 6,931,000 cwts., and in 1929 the amount was 10,232,000 cwts., so that the amount of butter available for export in the world's market had gone up by almost 50 per cent. We are competing also in that market with whatever butter we have to export. There were formerly some good markets, but now there is no free market except Great Britain left for imported butter. Even Germany and Canada, which were the two next best importers of butter after Great Britain, have imposed tariffs against imported butter because they are trying to produce their own requirements and, when that is done, as it probably will be done in two or three years, we will have all the surplus butter in the world dumped into Great Britain.
Are we in a position to compete in that market with our half a million cwts. against the ten million cwts. that will be thrown on the British market within the next few years? The same development is taking place in regard to bacon, grain, and, possibly, mutton and beef. So far, we have practically no competitors in fresh mutton and beef, but we have competitors in frozen mutton and frozen beef. We find year after year that the commodities sent from the Argentine or New Zealand, frozen or chilled, are coming closer as regards price to our fresh beef and mutton. Are we able to stand up against these competitors in the foreign market and get satisfactory prices for our goods? I do not believe that we can unless our farmers are helped to keep in their present production, if not to increase it. The Free State farmer has the smallest output of any farmer in the countries mentioned in the last Census of Agricultural Production. The output of the Free State agricultural worker is £96 a year. In Northern Ireland it is £104, in England £169, in Scotland £184, and in Denmark £196. Those people in England and Scotland have their own home market, and are obviously better equipped to withstand competition than we are because they have a bigger output and are better able to meet their competitors, seeing that they are getting, at least, some money into their hands to help them to do so. We are going to be up against these foreign competitors and we find that even in Great Britain they are tending towards protection. Recently they passed a Marketing Bill with the object of increasing agricultural production in Great Britain in order to hold the home market for home products. We find the Farmers' Union in Scotland calling for protection and safeguarding in certain directions.
The only chance I see, therefore, for our agricultural industries is at least to keep our farmers in the production in which they are engaged at present. If they once recede from what they are producing at present, they are going to lose even the small bit of the export market which they hold, and they are going to lose more of the home market, which is worse. At any time I suppose it is never too late to secure the home market for agricultural produce because we will always be able to recapture the home market for such produce. We have, however, to do more than that. We must be in a position always to pay for the imports which we require in this country. We do want some very necessary imports, and the only thing we have to export as a surplus to pay for these imports is agricultural produce.
There is no use in exporting agricultural produce unless there is a market for it, and unless we hold the market for it, we are going to be nowhere in a few years. Therefore, I say: Do not let the farmer go out of production. Do not delay in giving him the relief he wants. Let members of Cumann na nGaedheal and the Farmers' Party, at least, be quite certain, before going into the Division Lobby to vote against this motion to-night, that the Minister for Finance will definitely introduce in the Budget some measure of relief for agriculture.
Comment on this
This motion, if it has done nothing else has proved to the people who sent us here that in this House there is a consensus of opinion in favour of relief for agriculture. We have that demonstrated from every Party in the House, including the Government Party. That fact was known in the country for the last ten years, becoming more acute year after year. Deputies have quoted here, in the course of their speeches, statements made by various responsible Ministers and others, that relief was necessary for agriculture, from 1923, 1925 and subsequent years. While all sides have been admitting this fact, for those years past, up to the present moment nothing tangible has been done to assist agriculture until this motion was put on the Order Paper.
In comparing the motion and the amendment, I think myself that the Labour Party have not enhanced their reputation by producing this amendment. It is pretty obvious to me, as I think it is obvious to most members of the House, that there is no bulk of agricultural opinion behind the amendment proposed by Deputy O'Connell.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Connell says the small farmers. I come from a county of small farmers, perhaps the most typical county of small mixed farmers in the Free State. I have in my pocket at the present moment a mandate from 6,200 organised farmers of the County of Cavan, and they have instructed me to vote in favour of this motion. I am going to vote in favour of it. They have also, in discussing this question, for three or four years definitely stated that on this question of de-rating they, as I said, a community of small farmers and I will say the most industrious farmers in Ireland, do not take a selfish view of the question. They have stated, from the very start, that if de-rating of agricultural land is going to be a success in this country, we cannot differentiate between the large farmer and the small farmer.
The small farmer, notwithstanding what Deputy O'Connell says, and there may be something in it—that the small farmer will not get as great benefit out of de-rating as the large farmer—is not going to complicate this issue on the first occasion on which the necessity for the relief for agriculture has been brought prominently before the public. He is not going to complicate the issue by raising the question of the small or large farmer, to throw a spanner, as it were, into the works and leave a difficulty which the Government, if they were in a difficulty in dealing with this question, will seize on and say: "This is too complicated altogether. This question of dealing with the small farmer on a different basis to the large farmer will involve employing more officials. It will create difficulties all over the country, and consequently we will have to give more time to the consideration of the question." It is giving an excuse to the Government.
Comment on this
It is not a de-rating motion, but it is the preliminary to it. If the Labour Party are not in favour of de-rating let them say so now. If it is not a de-rating motion, what was the necessity for Deputy O'Connell to go into all the extraordinary calculations he made as to how much a small farmer under £50 valuation would get? I would call such a farmer a large farmer in my county. What is the necessity at all of de-rating if it is not to relieve agriculture? What I want to point out is that the farmers in my county are in favour of de-rating. They have given me a mandate to vote for this half-loaf policy, and that is all we can call it. It is a half-loaf policy. This half-loaf policy is necessary at this time of the year, when agriculture is in a most depressed condition, and when the farmers find it very difficult to know where they are going to get money to seed their land. They want to know what their obligations are for the future, and if they are certain that the rate collector is only going to take 50 per cent. of the present assessment later on, it will induce them to go in for more tillage with a lighter heart than under present conditions. There will be a better prospect of buying the seeds and manures they have to use this year.
The main burden of the arguments of the Minister for Finance against this motion is that it is inopportune. He does not say it is unnecessary. There is a lot in what he says when he puts forward the case, by inference, that it is unwise to anticipate the Budget statement. I am very glad to have got a declaration from the Government that they recognise that agriculture requires relief and that provision will be made for that in the Budget—at least we hope so. But, in the meantime, if this motion were not discussed in the House, or some motion on similar lines, would we feel confident that there was going to be very considerable relief offered to agriculture in the Budget? Personally, I do not see any indication of that beyond statements which up to this I would say were purely unofficial, statements which possibly might not commit the Government to any particular line when the Budget was produced, and which would leave it open to the Government to say: "We quite recognise that relief for agriculture is necessary, but we have not before us the report of the De-rating Commission, and until we have we do not know on what lines to proceed and the matter will have to be held over until next year."
On this matter of the De-rating Commission, Deputies, no matter from what county they come, will recognise that there is a general feeling, justified or otherwise, that the report is being held back unduly. That is putting the interpretation of the rank and file of the farmers in a very mild way. I do not want to go beyond that. But I think it is obvious that the report should have been produced before this. I have no knowledge of what way the Commission are going to report, whether it is to be for or against de-rating or a kind of half measure. But, if it is not a whole measure, so far as those whom I represent are concerned the relief to agriculture from de-rating will still remain a very vital question until it is completely dealt with.
It may be said, and said truly, that other methods might be adopted for dealing with the present depressed condition of agriculture and that relief might be granted in quite a different form. That is quite true. For my own part, I would much prefer to see the farmers in such a condition that we would not be relieving them from the rates, but that we would be in a position to make the farmers' capacity to pay rates—even higher rates if necessary—much greater than it is. The question of relief from rates is not the beginning and end of the assistance for agriculture by any means. What we want is to put the farmer in such a position that his capacity to pay rates and taxes and all his obligations to the State will increase, and that he will be able to bring up his family and carry on his industry in a much better and more capable and efficient manner and with greater profit to himself than he has been able to do for the last seven or eight years.
I have heard it stated outside by those who do not like de-rating that such things are rather a luxury, that the standard of living in this country is too high, and that until we reduce the standard and get down to a more modest form nothing can be done in this country. My answer to that is that the standard may, with some people, be rather high, but that the standard of 75 per cent. of the people, namely, the farmers, is far too low to maintain any industry in any country in the world. What we want to do is to raise the standard of living of the farmer. Deputy Gorey laughs at that. I am surprised and I am not surprised, because I dare say he will vote against this motion. But when a farmer Deputy laughs at the suggestion that the standard of living of the farmers requires to be raised, then it is nearly time to take stock of the people sent to this House to represent the farmers. Arguments have been put up as to the relief measures that have been given to the farmer in the last seven or eight years. I would not be surprised to hear different Acts mentioned, such as the Dairy Produce Act, the Fresh Meat Act, the Eggs Act, and the Live Stock Breeding Act, as Acts that have been of assistance in raising the standard of living of the farmer or putting him in a better position to pay his way.
I do not want it to be understood that I do not agree with many of these Acts. I do agree with many of them, as many of them were necessary. But, in actual fact, up to the present, a number of these Acts have not assisted the farmer in any way financially. Some of them, in actual fact, up to now may be regarded as penal Acts on the farmer. Take the Dairy Produce Act. I do not mean to say that that was a penal Act by any means, but notwithstanding the fact that it was on the statute book I found myself in the position of having not to vote against a tariff on butter because of the condition of the butter industry. That is a temporary expedient, and it is more or less a reflection on the manner in which our butter industry is being handled, even since the Dairy Produce Act came into force. As I said before in this House, I can visualise in the future the tariff of 4d. per pound on butter being one of the things that will defeat the very object of the Dairy Produce Act—that is, to produce the best butter in the world.
Then we have the Fresh Meat Act, passed, presumably, to assist the farmers. Has it done that? Go around the country and ask any farmer or pig raiser if the Act has been of any benefit to him. Has it put one sixpence in his pocket? Has it not made it very difficult for him to market his stuff, and has it not contributed to some extent to the fact that at Cavan Fair last Tuesday pigs that, six or eight months ago, would be sold at 50/- were going abegging at 14/- and could not get a buyer? These are the conditions in which our farmers are at present. I wonder was anyone in this House at the Dublin cattle market this morning?
Comment on this
What was the condition of the Dublin cattle market this morning? The worst market that was held in Dublin for years. I do not want to say this for the purpose of running down the country. I want to point out the condition in which the farmers are in the spring of the year when they want money to buy seed. You could not sell a beast in the market this morning.
Comment on this
There were very few buyers and I defy anyone to say that it was not the worst market held in Dublin for years. What are the reactions of that in the country down to the very poorest man who raises a calf? Take the Eggs Act. That has not put one penny into the pockets of the farmer. It is perhaps these Acts which put money into the pockets of the people whom Deputy Good, I think, indicated as between the producer and the consumer. The Deputy will find that between the producer and the consumer the Eggs Act and the Fresh Meat Act also come in.
Now as regards rates in the future. There is a certain amount of suspicion in the country—and when dealing with this question it is much better for us to be frank with one another— whether it is justified or otherwise, that certain Acts passed by this House dealing with rating were passed for the purpose of loading the people with separate charges that would not come in under the heading of de-rating. I refer to the Vocational Education Act for one—I am not speaking against these Acts—and to the Local Government (Special Expenses) Act, and to the Tourist Development Act. I have not one word to say against these Acts. They are all permissive Acts if you like; they give permissive rights to the farmers of the country to levy rates on themselves for certain purposes. It may be perfectly true that they need not strike these rates, if they like, but there are people who think that the time is not far distant, having regard to the present trend of legislation, when the people will have no right to strike rates, and when local representatives will be supplanted by managers, and when these permissive Acts will be converted into compulsory Acts, and that in the future the ratepayers will not be able to stand up against these compulsory Acts.
These are points of vital importance to our particular industry. If we are sincere in our belief, and the statements we make, as to the value of agriculture in this country and as to its importance in this State, we must understand, and most of us do understand, that if agriculture goes down we will have nothing to replace it in fifty years' time, because we could not by any possibility convert this country into an industrial country in that period. If there is depression in our agriculture and if there is difficulty in marketing our produce owing to world competition and conditions these conditions are also running through every industrial centre in the world. But if we are sincere in our desire to assist agriculture we must not be satisfied with merely giving it a dole off the rates; we must foster it in a much better way. We must see to the marketing of our produce. We must see that the ships that carry our produce are Irish as far as possible, so that a big amount of every penny that comes into the country goes to the producer and not to the middleman. That is the class of relief that I would like to see given to the farmers and, notwithstanding the jibes of a farmer Deputy here on my right, I still as a farmers' representative hold we are not doing half enough at the present time for agriculture in this country, that this half-loaf policy, at this stage, is better than nothing, but that when we are finished with this motion, and very probably it will be defeated, the question still remains to be dealt with and complete de-rating has to come and a great deal more relief has to be given to agriculture than de-rating can give.
Comment on this
I think I could very well start in this debate by quoting a statement made by the Secretary of the Agricultural Credit Corporation in his evidence before the De-rating Commission. He said that 75 per cent. of the farmers were in need of loans; that relief was required more by the farmer who employed labour than by the farmer working his own family, and that the labour employed had decreased 50 per cent. in the last ten years. I think if any case were required to be made here it was made by the evidence of that official. We have heard the Minister for Finance this afternoon telling us that this is a political move, and we had the leader of the defunct Farmers' Party saying that this was a political move on the part of the Fianna Fáil Party who were looking for the help of the farmers. The Fianna Fáil Party need not look for the help of the Farmers, because the farmers have long given up expecting anything from the Party they sent into this House to represent them and which sold them.
As long ago as last October this motion was being considered by our Party. It was not brought in as a political move at all. It was adjourned pending the report of the De-rating Commission, because we were anxious that the report of the De-rating Commission should be considered in this House in a non-political and non-party spirit. But what happened? We had the statement of the Minister for Finance made on the Budget that after the De-rating Commission reported it would take several months to consider a scheme of de-rating to be brought in here. He pointed out that different implications with regard to local government and everything else were involved in it. Then the next move we had was that the De-rating Commission was marking time to save another million or so for the financial jugglers.
Comment on this
I am not criticising it, but I am criticising the delay in bringing in their report. That delay looks very suspicious when one considers that the county councils have struck their rates, except those who refused to strike them until the Minister declares what is going to be done for the farmers this year. We heard a lot of soft talk about relief of the farmers. We were told: "Look at all the great things we are going to do for the farmers." I would like some Deputy to get up and to defend the policy of imposing rates upon one business, and one only, for local services. I do not see any reason why the farmers should be taxed for local services and the big importer or exporter or well-paid official should be allowed go free any more than anyone else. I do not see why we should have local contributions made for local services by everybody except those who are extremely well paid.
I do not see why we should have men paid out of the local rates, men drawing a salary of £1,000 a year out of the farmers' pockets, and out of that £1,000 a year contributing to the rates only on a valuation of £20. That is, the valuation of his house. Why should such a man get his £1,000 free while the farmer has to pay heavy rates on his income? If the farmer had an income of £1,000 a year he would be paying rates on a valuation of about £5,000. I can see no reason whatsoever why the one man can go free, and why men making large incomes in every other sort of business should go free, while farmers have to pay. Take the importer of coal in a local town, with a turnover of £5,000 to £10,000 a year. Out of that turnover he would contribute anything from £5 to £10 a year in rates. A farmer with an income of £1,000 would pay rates on a valuation of £5,000. I hope the House will not approach this matter in the light of "we are giving something for nothing to the farmers." If we give him this relief we are only restoring to him a very small bit of what has been taken from him, grabbed unjustly from him, since the Dáil came into operation.
That is the viewpoint from which I approach the matter at any rate. I can see no reason why any of those people in different walks of life should go free without any local taxation whatsoever, and with scarcely any contribution to local services, while the farmer's business is the only business taxed. The view I take is that there should be absolutely a re-casting of contributions for local services. What is the farmer paying for? For billiard table roads over which the officials paid by the farmers are to drive. If the farmer tries to take his cattle to fair or market over these roads he will find that quite a number of them will be injured by falling. If he takes his horse to the local market town he is in danger of the horse breaking its knees, owing to the way the roads are made for the convenience of officials.
These officials are not alone being paid here but they have already been de-rated to the extent of £326,000. That is the grant for de-rating given to officials with salaries over £400 a year. They are drawing in cost-of-living bonus a sum of £326,000 a year. After all, what is that but another form of de-rating these gentlemen? I say therefore, that the less we hear about giving the farmers something for nothing the better. One would have thought on listening to the Minister for Finance replying to Deputy Aiken a while ago that the poor fellow had been knocked down and his pockets picked. That is what he reminded me of when I looked across at him. In giving the farmer this relief that we ask for, we are only giving him what he is very justly entitled to, and it is even only half a loaf.
We hear a lot from time to time in the Dáil about the unity of Ireland. We read a great many statements about the unity of the country. Does anyone mean to tell me that there is a farmer in the North of Ireland who would be fool enough to come into the Free State so as to have the pleasure of paying rates? The farmers in Northern Ireland have paid no agricultural rates for the last two years. If you are ever going to bring in the North you will have to give them as good terms as they are getting from their own Government. I maintain that rates on agricultural land are an absolute bar to the unity of this country. All those opposite who talk about unity should consider that point.
The more we examine this problem the more convinced we become that the Executive Council have no intention whatsoever of doing anything for the farming community. We have had social service after social service clapped down on the farmers. The farmers have to pay for these so-called social services. We have had these matters in the Dáil year after year. There was no suggestion whatsoever that anybody but the farmer would be taxed for these social services. We have had public health services, vocational education, and all these other burdens clapped on the rates, with no intention of relieving the farming community. This thing has been going on until the burden has become so great that the farming community has at last decided it will not bear it any longer. That is the decision come to in County Cork. They have decided that they will not bear this burden any longer.
I want to say a word with regard to the peculiar amendment to this motion that has been set down by the Labour Party. I wonder if that amendment was seriously meant at all? I have looked very carefully through the Official Reports since the Dáil was set up. In the case of none of the agricultural grants that came before the House did the Labour Party take any steps to get these agricultural grants devoted to tillage farmers. During the debates on those grants what do we find? A pious wish expressed by Deputy Johnson on the 24th June, 1925, after the Bill had been brought in by the Minister for Finance giving £599,000 of an extra agricultural grant. I looked to see what was the Labour amendment to that Vote—to find if there was any demand for a 20 per cent. tillage on a minimum valuation of £50. There was nothing of the kind. There was only a pious wish by Senator Johnson of a new allocation some time. His own words were: "I am very pleased to hear from Deputy Wilson that it is the intention of the Government to consider, if not in connection with this year's allocation, at any rate in future years, the relevant values to the State, and therefore the need for a variation in the allocation in regard to the amount of land suitable for tillage which is being tilled." That is the statement made by Senator Johnson.
Comment on this
A pious wish that in the future allocation of the agricultural grant some consideration would be given to the tillage farmer as against the farmer grazing all his land.
Comment on this
In 1926 the Agricultural Grant Vote was again brought in, and the pious wish was not realised. In fact, I might state in the commencement that when the Committee Stage of the Bill was reached, when one would expect to see Labour amendments on these lines, we did not hear a single word from them on the Committee Stage of the Bill. There were no amendments on these lines from Senator Johnson, Deputy O'Connell, or anybody else.
Comment on this
The Local Government (Rates on Agricultural Land) Bill, which was introduced into this House on 24th June, 1925. The agricultural grant was £599,000. On that Bill there was not a single amendment brought in by the Labour Party on the lines of a 20 per cent. tillage. The agricultural grant was continued in 1926. An extra agricultural grant was brought in each year from 1926 until 1930, and voted upon, and not one single member of the Labour Party mentioned a word about tillage.
Comment on this
Put down a motion as I did. I set out that the agricultural grant should not be paid to any farmer who had not fifteen per cent. of tillage or who was not using his farm for dairying purposes. That was the state of things until the Government set up the De-rating Commission, and we are now awaiting the report of that Commission.
Comment on this
I did not put my faith in the Government. The whole position of de-rating was being considered by the Government, and I was waiting for them to bring in a Bill.
Comment on this
Why are you running away from your own motion now?
Comment on this
I am not. My point is that from 1926 to 1930 the Labour Party did not utter a single word with regard to 20 per cent. of tillage on a £50 valuation when that extra Agricultural Vote was brought up for consideration.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Labour Party should give Deputy Corry an opportunity of making his speech.
Comment on this
I am quite happy listening to them. According to the statistics that have been prepared, we have in County Limerick, the county that would be most affected by Deputy O'Connell's amendment, no less than 8,400 agricultural labourers who are apparently to be thrown to the wolves.
Comment on this
There are no proposals in the amendment affecting the dairy farmers who, if the statistics are correct, employ much more labour than the tillage farmers.
Comment on this
There is no proposal in the amendment suggesting any provision for finding employment for 8,400 agricultural labourers in Limerick, for 10,700 agricultural labourers in County Tipperary, or for 9,000 agricultural workers in my constituency. All those labourers are to be slaughtered if we are to take the proposals put forward by Deputy O'Connell into consideration. In County Limerick you have employed on the farms 25,200 people— farmers, their families and their labourers.
Comment on this
I wonder how many of these people will come under Deputy O'Connell's amendment. It has been admitted by the Minister for Finance, and indeed by everybody else, that the rateable valuation in this country cannot be taken as any basis because of the fact that the tillage areas were valued on the Griffith system of valuation at three of four times the valuation of grazing areas. This is going to hit the tillage farmer, the farmer that Deputy O'Connell wants to save. It will hit him except in so far as he is going to get 50 per cent. under the amendment when he satisfies the Minister for Agriculture that he is tilling 20 per cent. of his land. I am amazed at Deputy O'Connell's selection of the Minister for Agriculture as an authority on tillage. It was one of the most amazing things that I read in the amendment. Deputy O'Connell selected as an authority on tillage the Minister for Agriculture. That Minister is better known in my constituency as the Minister for Grass. He is the gentleman who is selected as an authority on tillage.
I wonder how many new officials are to be appointed to measure the 20 per cent. in the case of each farmer. I had a little experience in that connection from 1917 to 1919 when we had the compulsory tillage order brought in by the British Government. Each farmer was compelled to till so much land. If ever there was a bigger fraud perpetrated on this country, I do not know of it. Fully £6 or £7 a week was paid to gentlemen driving round measuring the number of half acres tilled by the farmers and all this money was paid out of the farmers' pockets. Most of the million pounds would go that way under the amendment. I quite appreciate the idea of the Labour Party looking for increased employment for officials. I quite appreciate that they are prepared to throw overboard the unfortunate agricultural labourers because the labourers are not now aristocratic enough for them. The agricultural labourers do not count any longer in the scheme of things. Extra officials will be appointed travelling the country finding out the farmers over £50 valuation who will satisfy the Minister for Agriculture that they have 20 per cent. of the arable land on their holdings tilled. Who is going to decide what is arable land? Perhaps it will be the Minister for Agriculture, and I would like to know how long it will take him to go from farm to farm.
Comment on this
Those are things we would like to have threshed out. I never witnessed anything like this hurried rush of the Labour Party to get an innings, and I never witnessed so poor an attempt as they have made. I expected better from them. A tillage farmer in my constituency with a valuation of £50 a year would have about 30 to 40 acres. That might be rather amazing to Deputy O'Connell. I would not be at all surprised if it were, as he is judging by this little bit of the County Mayo he rules so carefully, and County Mayo employs altogether 1,351 agricultural labourers as against 8,400 in the County of Limerick, where he would give no relief at all. Those are points which I think Deputy O'Connell ought to consider carefully. I do not think that the Labour amendment is worth bothering with, much further at any rate. In the first place the machinery to be set up by the Labour amendment might be set up by a proper speeding process in 12 months or two years. It would not be set up any sooner. If we were considering a scheme of permanent de-rating we would probably take the Labour view or something approximating to it on the de-rating proposals here, but we must also consider the dairy farmer of whom Labour is ignorant. He is of no interest to Labour, but in the County of Limerick he employs 8,400 labourers.
I can assure the House that we would not dream of bringing in this million pound proposal as it stands except as a purely temporary proposal dealing with this year only, because the Government was attempting to shirk the definite promises they have given to the farming community. If this motion has done nothing else it has definitely prevented the Executive Council and those who support them from shirking their duty this year on this matter.
We had a statement from the Minister for Finance that he was going to make a definite statement on de-rating on the Budget, but last week we put proposals before him on a portion of the seven million pounds on account. The only contribution they were giving in that towards the relief of the farmer was the old £300,000 for four months on an agricultural grant, the same as usual. That was the tune of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party last week. If we have made the Minister for Finance whistle a different tune I think we have done a good day's work for the farming community of the Free State. A short time ago I happened to meet in my constituency a farmer who would be considered an enormous rancher by Deputy O'Connell. He had a valuation of £200. He asked me was there any hope of de-rating this year. I told him that there was no hope that he would get anything. He asked me into the house, and in his kitchen there were at dinner 22 workmen, who were working on that farm and who were getting a livelihood out of that farm. He was giving them permanent employment and, in addition, employed from 15 to 20 extra men from the 1st of May to the 1st of November. Is that farmer going to be put outside the scope of any of the relief, even under Deputy O'Connell's amendment? That farmer cannot be put out in the cold.
Comment on this
He would have to satisfy the Minister for Grass that he had 20 per cent. of his holding under tillage.
Comment on this
But look at the difficulty he would have, and the high time some official would have down there for a fortnight, pretending to measure the ground and getting £7 a week out of the million. We have to consider in this proposal men like him, who are an asset to the community. I hold he is a bigger asset to the community than the retired or even the active publican who would have 50 acres of land in the County Mayo or probably 100 acres of land with £40 valuation and who would get three-quarters of his rates wiped out by Deputy O'Connell and perhaps not till an acre at all.
I expected something better from Labour. I do not know how they came to make such idiots of themselves as they have in this. I never thought I would see Labour throwing overboard the 8,400 agricultural workers in the County Limerick or the 9,000 agricultural workers in my constituency. I have the greatest respect for the agricultural workers, and think they are the only people in this country who are not drones. I will take another instance. The average farmer in my constituency would be over £50 valuation. I will give you a description of the affairs of that farmer. The moment his son can be kept at home from school without being arrested by the Civic Guards he is made work and kept on as an unpaid labourer until he reaches 40.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Donovan knows the circumstances just as well as I do; so does every rural Deputy. They know that but for the unpaid labour of the farmers' sons and daughters they would not be able to pay the rates and annuities of the present day. Those men are unpaid labourers, living on the farm in order that through their labour social services might be afforded to gentlemen whose salaries will be trebled by the Minister for Local Government from time to time and for whom the Minister has the greatest sympathy.
The Minister for Local Government would not even dream of giving any rebate of rates that would not be for motorists' roads. No matter how much a county council would spend on the ordinary link roads and by-roads they would not get any rebate. As a matter of fact, the policy of the Minister for Local Government, in recent years at any rate, has been to compel the county councils, by bribes and other means, to spend more money than they can afford in making billiard-table roads for motorists. I can see no reason whatever why this motion should not be accepted. As the Minister for Finance said, it will take a very long period before the report of the De-rating Commission can be considered by this House, before it can be considered by the Ministry, and before all its implications with regard to changes in the local government system and otherwise can be considered.
[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]
If we are to judge by the speed, for instance, that was shown in the case of the Town Tenants Bill, it will take ten years and then there will be only an instalment brought in. From 1925 to 1931 the Executive Council have been considering the Town Tenants Bill and we are now told that an instalment is being brought in. If it takes the Executive Council five years to consider a Town Tenants Bill, how long will it take them to consider the report of the De-rating Commission and to change the local government system, as the Minister for Finance stated they were going to do? By the time it would be considered the farmer would be as scarce in the fields of Ireland as a Red Indian on the banks of the Manhattan.
I would like if some Deputy would get up and explain why the business of farming should be the only business to be taxed for local services. Why not, for instance, tax the importer of agricultural seeds and manures? Why not tax the importer of coal? Why not take one of the Minister's officials with £1,500 a year and £199 13s. 0d. of a bonus for fear he would go hungry and compel him to pay something for local services? I suppose the argument would be that the gentleman pays income tax and the farmer does not. The man with the £1,500 a year gets de-rating to the extent of £199 13s. 0d.
Comment on this
That is a statement that we must take with a grain of salt. I do not want to go into the actions of the Minister for Local Government in regard to the Cork County Council.
Comment on this
I think it is not relevant to this debate. But if he draws me I will try and do a little by turning my deaf ear to the Ceann Comhairle.
Comment on this
I would like that the Minister for Local Government would get up and justify the taxation of the farmers for local services while allowing these gentlemen to go free. Above all, I would like to see some of the rural Deputies getting up to justify their voting against this million pounds proposal. After all, it is only a sop of what the farmer is justly entitled to; it is only a small piece of what has been robbed from him by this Dáil from 1923 to 1931. I would like to hear those who were sent in by the farmers to represent them here explaining why they are going to walk into the Lobby to-night to sell the farmers who sent them in here for whatever mess of pottage the Government has given them. Is Deputy Hassett going to walk into the Lobby and vote against relief for the farming community, who he knows are definitely and justly entitled to it?
Comment on this
The Deputy has told us that he is going to give the farmers a lot more than what we can give them. I hope that the scourging we have given the Cumann na nGaedheal Party in the last few weeks will have the effect of compelling them to come to the aid of the farmer. I hope to see in this House after the next general election a party that will do justice to the farming community, as Cumann na nGaedheal never dreamed of doing justice to them, and as Cumann na nGaedheal never would do justice to them. I only enjoyed one thing here to-night and I enjoyed that thoroughly. It was the picture of the Minister for Finance, looking like a poor fellow who was after being knocked down and robbed, when there was dragged out of him a statement that he was going to come to the relief of the farmer. Whether he likes it or not, he has to give it.
Comment on this
I suppose it is fitting in the penitential season of Lent that our sins should be publicly paraded before us, so that we might examine them closely. Listening to some of the statements that have been made, we find that the sins of the Labour Party are three. They have tabled an amendment to a Fianna Fáil motion. That is a very serious offence, evidently. And they have neglected to table that amendment for some time. That is another offence. The third is that we have mentioned the word tillage in our amendment. I do not think there is any need of discussing the first. A motion is fair game for any amendment by any Party. Regarding the statement about tillage, we do not put forward whatever is contained in our amendment as our cure for the slackness in tillage. We do not say it is put forward as any cure for it. We put it forward merely as a recognition of the fact that there are some extra charges on the man with over 50 acres who is tilling. We were asked why we did not put down this before. For many years when we were the chief official Opposition we were unfortunately very keenly conscious of our inability to carry such a thing in this assembly. When others came in and took over the position of official Opposition, we naturally thought that such an important matter would be dealt with by them. When we found them dealing with it and proceeding on wrong lines, we thought it was our duty to give them the benefit of whatever information our experience had provided us with on this matter.
It should be remembered that 92 per cent. of the people interested in this matter can be dealt with without any reference whatever to tillage. That is an important point to remember. As regards the other 8 per cent., I think it has been pointed out, and pointed out with effect, that arable land has been scheduled since the war period, and that there is no great difficulty whatever in the Government ascertaining what is the amount of arable land in any person's holding. The main thing, however, to consider is that 92 per cent. can be dealt with immediately, and that the other 8 per cent. will not take as much time or such a horde of officials as Deputy Corry thinks. Referring to Deputy Corry's remarks on this amendment, it is interesting to note that Deputy Corry himself tabled an amendment recently that would have involved, if it had been carried through, a similar horde of officials. The Government offered some time ago some sop in this matter of de-rating. They said they were going to do something or other. They are in the habit of making these statements, probably without considering them. I do not think they consider them fully, at all events, because they scarcely ever do anything on the lines indicated in their promises. When they made this promise, Deputy Corry's proposal fell through. The charge which he makes against us could have been made against himself when he brought in this proposal.
The motion and the amendment are directed towards securing certain relief for the farming community. No matter what has been said to the contrary, I think it is incumbent on the supporters of the motion and amendment to make a case for this relief, and to show how the amount of money that is proposed to be expended will reach, in the most effective fashion, the community it is proposed to relieve. If we were to follow the many hares that are started, we would never get to the motion or amendment proper. Whatever about Limerick or any other place, if we were to cease to deal with land on the grounds that Deputy Corry put forward, probably no landlord in the country would be disturbed, because a great many of them do give employment and their places would be kept intact because of their giving employment. Deputy Corry's suggestion was that the man with £200 valuation and 20 employees should have his farm kept intact, and thus prevent 100 uneconomic holders from getting a decent living in his stead. Why should we have so much compassion for a man with £200 valuation?
Comment on this
I will divide it by nothing. Evidently, Deputy Flinn is divided in his own mind as to what is the proper action to take on this matter. That is what is troubling him.
Comment on this
Even on a valuation basis alone, a very good case could be made out for this amendment. We do know that land that was valued on a wheat-producing basis has long since ceased to be wheat-producing land. In my own county, I know land valued on a wheat-producing basis, which would not now produce black oats. As a matter of fact, it is producing rushes at the present time. It is not easy to arrive at a figure representing the average rate on agricultural land throughout the State. We can assume with safety that it is 5/- or 5/6 in the £. That is a conservative estimate. The rates, which in 1913 were 2/- on agricultural land, are at the present time something like 5/- or 6/- in the £. They have gone up three-fold. Each one can examine the position in his own county. In my own county they were 2/10 in 1914; 3/10 in 1916 and 7/-in 1931.
Surely that is a considerable increase in the burden the farmer has to bear. It is not alone a charge upon agricultural produce; in a great many cases it is a charge on agricultural capital. It is a drain on agricultural capital, for the reason that to meet the demand note of the rate collector cattle have had to be disposed of. The economic unit of the farm, therefore, becomes an uneconomic unit because it could carry a cow which has to be disposed of in order to meet the demand note. That is the position regarding increase in rates. On this matter, I should like to quote from one who would be probably regarded as a better authority than I am. I refer to Deputy Heffernan who, at the time he made this statement, was leader of the Farmers' Party. He said:—
Take the local rates. I live in a county that has not been at all one of the highest local rated counties, a county that has been, from the point of view of local administration, perhaps one of the best managed in Ireland. I would like to say, in spite of that, we are of opinion that the rates we are asked to pay, and in particular what the farming community are asked to pay, are intolerable. I will give you an instance of the rates that had to be paid in one of the lowest rated unions in the county. The rate for 1914 was 1/10 in the £; 1917, 2/2; 1919, 3/9; 1920, 4/4; 1923, 5/10: and 1924, 5/- (Vol. 7, cols. 2146 and 2147, June 11th, 1924.)
That total impost now means a charge upon agricultural production and agricultural capital of something like £900,000. What has accumulated since 1914 should also be taken into consideration.
Another matter which was referred to by Deputy O'Connell should certainly be taken into consideration by the Government in any scheme they put forward. Take, for instance, the capitation grant for inmates in mental hospitals, etc. Years ago it was fixed at 4/- per head. The cost of maintenance then per inmate was probably £20. The cost of maintenance of an inmate at present is something like £60. Yet the capitation grant still remains at 4/- per head. That is surely a matter that should be looked into and altered. These are the main items on one side of the statement of accounts. If I were so inclined, I could add other items. I could make out a local case where the Government de-rated the property of the Electricity Supply Board, under the Shannon scheme, and so militated against a large section of ratepayers in the administrative county of Clare.
I could point to the impost put on the rates of the county in the matter of extra health charges while the Shannon scheme was in operation, and also to the medical assistance and the hospital treatment that had to be given to the workers on that scheme. Probably that will hold for another day when we will have a better opportunity of dealing with it. I would like to take a hurried glance at the revenue side of the accounts. I think it would be well for us to understand that the situation of the farmer to-day is not one that he came into immediately. It is the culmination of a series of causes operating over a considerable period, and further, I think it would be idle to rely entirely on published figures for an accurate estimate of the position of the farming community. There are several tests which we could apply to gauge the position of the farming community. We could talk about the cattle population, about cattle exports, about agricultural produce exports and agricultural production. These are tests that we could very easily apply, and, considering the pros and cons, we could safely assume that in the main the figures are correct. Regarding the cattle population we find that between 1923 and 1925 there was a reduction of 286,278 animals. The diminution was not attributable at all to exports, for we find that in 1924 and 1925 the export of cattle fell by 250,000 animals, representing a value approximately of £4,279,591. Between 1924 and 1926 there was a reduction of 307,002 animals, representing an approximate value of £5,200,000. Coincident with the reduction in cattle we had a reduction in tillage between 1924 and 1925 of 40,000 acres. There was a reduction of butter exports between 1924 and 1925 of 55,655 cwts., representing a value of £390,000.
Between 1929 and 1930 we find a drop in the cattle population of 99,000 animals, and a reduction in the amount of tillage of about 102,000 acres. In the matter of produce there is a diminished acreage and a steady decline in everything except beet. It may be no harm to state the amount of produce per acre in tons as between 1929 and 1930. It is something like this: wheat in 1929, 31,718 tons; 1930, 29,260 tons; oats, 1929, 689,385 tons; 1930, 632,146 tons; barley, 1929, 127,720 tons; 1930, 118,215 tons; rye, 1929, 3,159 tons; 1930, 2,944 tons; potatoes, 1929, 3,006,676 tons; 1930, 2,337,452 tons; turnips, 1929, 3,680,944 tons; 1930, 3,175,975 tons. In all agricultural produce there is a steady decline in the tonnage and the acreage under tillage.
Taking the value of what has been produced we find in the "Trade Journal" for February that the index figure in 1911 was 205; in 1912, 160; 1913, 144; 1914, 160; 1915, 157; 1916, 140; 1917, 131; 1918, 137; 1920, 124.8. Not alone has there been a steady decline in the cattle population, in cattle exports and agricultural produce exports, but there has been a decline in the amount of agricultural produce and in the price of these products. The motion in the name of Deputy de Valera proposes to give some compensation to the farmer for this series of reverses by providing one million pounds towards relief of the rates. We were induced to put down the amendment because we do not consider that there would be equitable distribution of that money on the basis of the motion. We consider that a certain section of the community that has suffered for a number of years through dislocation of markets and disturbances of various kinds, has a greater claim upon the State, and that they are in more need of this relief than other sections of the farming community. That is the reason we put down the amendment—that people under £50 valuation should be granted a reduction of three-fourths of the rates assessed on them.
On looking up the statistics we find that there are roughly 350,000 holdings under £50 valuation, and about 32,000 holdings over £50 valuation. If we were to work on the basis of the motion, and according to the rate of assessment, then half of this million pounds would go to the 32,000 holdings, leaving only the other half to be distributed amongst the 350,000. We do not consider that an equitable way of dealing with the situation. We consider that the large farmers have greater resources. They have proportionately less overhead charges, and they have certainly greater credit in the banks and in the local shops. We consider that the small farmer is more in need and that he certainly has a greater right to a just portion of the million pounds than the large farmer. We considered that the best way to see that he got it was by tabling this amendment. In the constituency that Deputy de Valera and I have the privilege to represent there are something like 17,000 holdings under £50 valuation.
I find that there are something like 948 holdings of over £50 valuation. Taking Clare as a unit, about which I probably know something, on the basis of Deputy de Valera's motion the administrative county would get something like £50,000, while under our amendment it would get something like £65,000, working it out in round figures. I have calculated that Clare would get £2 12s. 6d. per holding under the motion and something like £4 per holding under the amendment which the Labour Party has tabled.
Comment on this
I can let the Deputy have the figures later. The position appears to me that we would give a reduction of three-fourths of the rates to 17,000 holdings and that we would give 50 per cent. reduction to 950 holdings. That is a difference of over 20 per cent. I assume that we are doing the greatest good to the greatest number in giving a three-fourth reduction to 17,000 holdings. It would work out at about £4 per holding, whereas under the motion it would work out at something like £2 12s. 6d. I notice that the Minister for Agriculture has just come into the House. I want to say that sometimes he initiates a slogan with which I agree. He said, for instance, that an extra cow, an extra sow, and an extra acre of tillage would go far to relieve Irish agricultural depression. These may not be his exact words. They are a free paraphrase of them. I would like to ask him, on the strength of that slogan, to support our amendment.
I would put it to him this way. There must be some means discovered of finding capital for the small farmers. I come in contact with small farmers very often and find that they cannot get sufficient capital to make their holdings economic. The joint stock banks are of very little use to them. It is almost impossible for small farmers in my constituency to get capital from these banks. The Agricultural Credit Corporation is, if anything, worse than the joint stock banks. Anyone who has dealt with that corporation knows that you would have to extract money from it with a pliers.
Probably the Minister for Agriculture is saying to himself: "If we put this amendment into effect what value will £4 per holding be to the average small farmer in the matter of capital?" It will be of very great value to him as capital. It is useless to suggest to the small farmer that he should go to the open fair and pay from £14 to £20 for a milch cow. He has no means of getting the money. In a great many cases he endeavours to rear up a milch cow, but what happens? At a certain period of the year, when the rate collector comes along, the calf that he intended to become a milch cow has to be disposed of to meet the moiety. The hope of the farmer and his family of being able to rear a milch cow, and thus make the farm economic, has to be abandoned, and, as I say, the calf has to be sold to meet the moiety of rates.
Not alone has the hope of rearing the milch cow to be abandoned, but the farm has to remain an uneconomic unit, because, though it is probably capable of carrying another cow, that cow cannot be put there, and the grass and other things which could be utilised in the production of milk have to be abandoned also. That disposes to some extent of part of the Minister's slogan concerning the extra cow. The very same thing happens in regard to that portion of his slogan about the extra sow. The outstanding moiety has to be met by the disposal of the makings of the extra sow, and the hope of the extra acre has also to be abandoned owing to the cost of seeds, fertilisers, or farmyard manure. I do not think that any case could be seriously made against either the motion or the amendment. I think, however, that the motion, as it stands, will not deal fairly with the vast majority of farmers who are in need of relief. I think that the great majority of them will not get their just share of the £1,000,000 suggested to be distributed, and I think that our amendment will succeed in securing that the small farmer, the man who has no credit with the banks, and who has no cash, will be able to make his farm an economic unit. He will be able to retain the calf to become the extra milch cow, to retain the extra sow and not dispose of the young pigs, and to prepare that extra acre of tillage, thus enabling him to carry out the Minister's slogan.
Comment on this
I think that there is great danger that this House, sticking its head into a lot of figures and decimal points, is going to lose sight of one very important thing on which this debate bears. The rates that have been struck in the current year throughout the country must be collected. The moneys that are necessary to run local government in this country for the next year must be fully and truly estimated, and arrangements must be made to have them collected by means of rates. The local bodies throughout the country for the coming year will have to make up, in one way or another, £50,000 for the additional land annuities which remained unpaid last year.
If we are going to have the position that money has to be found for the running of local government services, in addition to making up for rates which have been uncollected out of the current year's warrant, to making up for money improperly estimated for, or, if estimated for and rates struck, not definitely collected, the position of this country financially and socially is going to be disimproved. Deputy Corry told us a story of a conversation with a Corkman which he thought had some relevance to this debate or to the question before us. I heard of a conversation much more relevant than that which Deputy Corry had with the Corkman. In this case he was asked: "How do you like the £1,000,000 we are giving you?" The Corkman replied: "It is fine, but I wish you thought of it long ago." The speeches of Deputies on the opposite benches have been such as showed an endeavour on their part to keep away as far as possible from the intention in their mind when putting down this motion. Deputy Corry, who, according to himself, has been hatching the motion at least since October, could not entirely keep away from the intention, and could not prevent his tongue from travelling over the political implications of the motion or from travelling over the discussions that took place at certain county councils where some members asked the council not to strike a rate for this year until this great motion was disposed of.
The farmers of this country, as represented and as sitting on county councils, have shown that they do not think much of this motion. The farmers of this country were not depending on Deputy Aiken this evening to draw a statement from the Minister for Finance to know how their interests stood in the light of the general policy of the Government. The Minister for Finance read out the terms of reference of the De-rating Commission, and the implications of these terms of reference were perfectly clear. As Deputy Hogan stated, the present difficulty of the farmers is not one of sudden growth. Whether the difficulties that the farmers are in are such that they can be materially assisted by de-rating relief of any kind, is a thing that requires very thorough examination. Deputy Lemass told us in a recent speech that this motion was put down because the Fianna Fáil Party saw in the Press that the Government was going to do nothing. Saw in the Press! Deputy Allen, one of the Whips of the Party had information on that subject long ago. On the 29th March last year, in time for a motion of this kind before the Budget of last year was introduced, he was able to tell his own constituents at Newbawn in County Wexford, as reported in the "Enniscorthy Guardian" that "The Free State Government had set up a Commission to enquire into the question of de-rating but it was for the purpose of keeping people talking, and that the Government did not intend to de-rate. When the Fianna Fáil Party got into power they would carry out de-rating. They would keep the £5,000,000 per annum that was going to England at home and that would be used for the benefit of the country."
Comment on this
Why in these terrible circumstances of the farmer, that I am sure Fianna Fáil Deputies realise, as well as Deputy Hogan, are not of sudden growth, why not in March of last year when the Chief Whip of the Party was able so freely to tell his own constituents, and no doubt his Party, what the position and the Government attitude in regard to de-rating were, put down this motion? The putting down of this motion at this particular time is just typical of the actions of Deputy de Valera as Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party. Pressed by the tail of his Party in an indecision of mind he seeks refuge in action.
Comment on this
He seeks refuge in action, and he puts this motion down although he knows that the De-rating Commission are about to report.
Comment on this
He puts it down at a time when by using the discussions of the least reputable farmers in the country on some of the county councils, he can get a sounding board for his great, deep and heart-felt sympathy for the farmers. He endeavours to create, by a non-rate striking position, confusion in the country in the first place, and attempts to stampede the Government into taking action supposed to be for the relief of farmers without a thorough examination of the matter. The farmers looking for relief and help are looking for it on the true statement of the full facts, and they have shown that they are not to be led into the position by any Party that it can be said that they are taking relief which in the first place it has not been fully shown that they deserve, and in the second place, that they are taking relief which it has not been fully shown is being applied for the purpose of bettering the farming community and the farming industry as a whole.
Comment on this
The Deputy can say where there is a county in the country that comes under this particular motion that is not going to strike its full rate.
Comment on this
They struck their own rate, and they asked the Deputies for the Limerick constituency to support this motion. That is all.
Comment on this
The Deputy can say all that he has to say here when he is on his feet. He can explain what he thinks these Limerick people are going to do in regard to making provision for their local government services next year. We, here, are not going to be driven into taking an action that we are not fully convinced is the best possible action that can be taken for the benefit of farmers. We are not going to allow any Party in the country to put the farming community in the country into the position that anyone can say that they have got relief that was not fully and thoroughly examined.
Comment on this
We have been told from the Fianna Fáil Benches that if they gave us the full and great benefits of their own great brains on this matter, this is not the scheme they would put before us. They have been hatching the thing for a long time, but they are not showing their hand. They do not accept responsibility for saying that this is a good way to relieve farmers. Deputy de Valera is not prepared to saddle himself entirely with the actions and the mind of Deputy Corry on this matter. The Labour Party have expressed very great surprise that Deputy Lemass should say that their amendment was nonsense, and that it should be repudiated so vigorously by Deputy Corry in the name of the agricultural labourers in County Cork and in Limerick.
Comment on this
At any rate they do not think much of it. I would like to hear Deputy Walsh from Mayo on the situation. I would like to hear Deputy Lemass himself on the situation. Deputy Corry says that the reason they will not accept the Labour Party's amendment is because of the agricultural labourers.
Comment on this
I would advise Deputies interested in the matter to look at the report of the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis about October last for an explanation of the matter and to see what Deputy Buckley's mind was on the question of forcing people to till. Forcible tillage was discussed at that Ard Fheis.
Comment on this
No, it was not, because the Counties of Meath and Kildare, where all the great agricultural labourers are, do not want compulsory tillage. If the members of the Labour Party went into it they might find that the grazier mind, and not the mind of the agricultural labourer, was behind the attitude of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
I am only prepared after the fullest possible examination of the matter that has gone before the De-rating Commission to say what is the proper thing to be done for the farmers.