We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Business. - Relief of Rates on Agricultural Land.

Contributions 148–313 of 313. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

And take as long as over the Traffic Bill.

Comment on this

The Traffic Bill, the Town Tenants Bill, decimal points, and a long string of figures— anything but the motion on the paper and what it is put down for.

Comment on this

We have not seen your motion yet.

Comment on this

We got on this matter, which is a very simple matter, so many decimal points from Deputy de Valera that you would imagine that what is wrong with the agricultural industry is that it is suffering from some kind of smallpox. If we are to consider this motion as worth talking about, or if they are to consider it worth talking about—

Comment on this

It is about time, as you did not say much up to the present.

Comment on this

——I should like them, say, to turn Deputy Walsh on to the discussion. As recently as February last, as reported in the "Western People" of 7th February, Deputy Walsh referred to the possibility of a general election this year. Elections have been linked up very much with Fianna Fáil discussions on de-rating. Deputy Walsh dealt at length with the de-rating question, and stated that if de-rating is brought in and means additional taxation it will be of no benefit to those with low valuations of, say, less than £5, and the ranchers, the men of £50 valuation and upwards, will benefit at the expense of the smaller holders.

Comment on this

Were the words "the men of £50 valuation and upwards" in what the Minister has read, or were they interpolated by himself?

Comment on this

They are down in plain black and white in the "Western People" of 7th February, 1931. The Deputy is astonished that the same figures should get into the speech of Deputy Walsh as have got into the Labour Party motion.

Comment on this

A very sound, sensible statement by Deputy Walsh.

Comment on this

Of course, some of the opinions of the "Western People" may be very objectionable, but I certainly think that the editor will answer for his reporter and the accuracy of the statements there.

Comment on this

He might have more black and white than there is in that document.

Comment on this

It is a good sample of his black and white. It is a good sample of the black and white that the members of the Fianna Fáil Party have been responsible for on this question of de-rating in quite a number of counties. Even Deputy Lemass, as reported in the "Connacht Tribune" of 12/4/1930—of course, opinions may have changed somewhat since then—speaking at Loughrea, which I am sure Deputies opposite will admit is on the map, said:—

"I know there is an agitation in existence now which seeks to have de-rating carried out. I believe any scheme of de-rating which must be financed directly or indirectly out of taxation will work out to impose additional charges on the small farmers for the benefit of large farmers."

Deputy Lemass said that in Loughrea.

Comment on this

And quite right.

Comment on this

We have not heard from Fianna Fáil where the money is to come from.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

The annuities.

Comment on this

It was the fashion about September, October, November and December, 1929, to talk about annuities and all you could do for de-rating by the annuities, but then Deputy Fahy and Deputy Jordan decided that they would not go to war for the annuities if they could not get them by ordinary quiet means. They repeatedly assured their own constituents in Galway that they need not have the slightest fear on that ground. If they could not get the annuities by coaxing them or by getting some impartial Chairman to say——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I wonder could we coax the debate back to the motion?

Comment on this

It might be a good thing.

Comment on this

The point I want to make is that this million pounds must be got somewhere. The annuities have gone off the map and we will leave them off the map. The question is: Where is this money to come from? If money is wanted for the relief in any way of agriculture I think I can answer for the present Government Party and the Executive Council that they are prepared to find the money, and to find it without apologising to anybody as to the way they will find it.

Comment on this

Tell us how.

Comment on this

Just wait and see.

Comment on this

That is what you are telling the farmers.

Comment on this

When any sum of money was wanted for the building up of the country or for attending to anything which could only be attended to by providing money, we have never shirked the issue and never failed to find the money, and we will find this money.

Comment on this

How much?

Comment on this

Whatever money is necessary. In endeavouring to hide what this motion is about the discussion has gone off into all kinds of figures and figurative directions.

Comment on this

Annuities!

Comment on this

When it came to discussing how much was required Deputy O'Connell showed that he had gone very thoroughly and in a very exhaustive way into the matter in order to get the figures that he required to make his case. Nevertheless, I suggest to Deputy O'Connell that in the figure he quoted as to what Mayo would get under Deputy de Valera's motion he is about 20 per cent. out. If that figure is to be applied all round on whatever basis Deputy O'Connell worked out his £825,000, the total cost of his scheme would have to go up at least by 20 per cent. The whole trend of the discussion has shown, even if you were going to give relief to the farmers by a certain amount of de-rating, that you could not decide how it ought to be done until you see the material that the De-rating Commission Report is to put up.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say if the 20 per cent. increase is in the case of the holders of agricultural land over £50?

Comment on this

No. Deputy de Valera has as much consideration for the holders of land over £50 valuation as for those of £5 valuation.

Comment on this

I thought you were answering Deputy O'Connell.

Comment on this

I was saying that Deputy O'Connell was giving figures showing how much Mayo would get under Deputy de Valera's scheme. Perhaps the Deputy is right.

Comment on this

You are usually wrong.

Comment on this

At any rate I withdraw what I said about Deputy O'Connell's £825,000 having to go up by 20 per cent. I put it like this. If in figuring out what Deputy de Valera's scheme is going to do for Mayo, Deputy O'Connell can be out 20 per cent. we cannot take it that he is going to be perfectly accurate in figuring out what his own scheme is going to cost. We certainly want a thorough examination of any scheme that we may propose, and we are not going to be pushed out of that.

There is one thing that I would ask Fianna Fáil Deputies to consider in connection with this matter in the interest of a real thorough dealing with the farmer's problem. Deputy Hogan wants one cow and one sow and one acre additional.

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture wants that.

Comment on this

We do not want to make any Deputy on the Labour Party a present of that idea. The idea comes from here, but at any rate Deputy Hogan subscribes to it. I wonder has Deputy Hogan figured the matter out at all? He gave a figure of from £14 to £20 as the likely cost of a milch cow. It would be worth while figuring out how many years a farmer of the average size of holding in Clare would take to save up what he would get from Deputy de Valera's motion before he could buy his milch cow.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan (Clare)

Let us be quite clear on what I said. I said a farmer could not afford to give from £14 to £20 for a milch cow, and that he had not credit to get that from the Joint Stock Banks or the Agricultural Credit Corporation, but I said that many individuals would rear up a calf which would ultimately become a milch cow, but that the rate collector came in between, and that the calf had to be sold to pay the moiety of the rates.

Comment on this

I take it from the Deputy that a good milch cow would cost anything from £14 to £20, and if the person who wants to buy a milch cow does not want to go into debt and had to save up from year to year what he would get from Deputy de Valera's motion then I cannot say how long a Clareman would take to do it, but a farmer occupying the average holding in Cork County would have to save up for five years to buy this cow.

Comment on this

He will have to wait five years before you start to help him to buy the cow.

Comment on this

He would have to wait a terribly long period before some of the Deputies opposite started on the right lines to help the farmers. It was well that the second Corkman who had a conversation with Deputy Corry understood that. It is suggested that the Government Party are terribly anxious about this motion. Not the slightest bit of anxiety as to what the farmers think of this motion, and not the slightest bit of anxiety as to whether the farmers had to wait to hear dragged from the Minister for Finance what he would say as to what our attitude was towards the farmers. We are going to wait to have the De-rating Commission Report, and to have the information so carefully compiled and so carefully analysed before us before we decide how much money is to be raised in taxation for the relief of the farmers, and how that money is going to be spent.

[Deputy Fahy and Deputy Corry both rose.]

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Fahy.

Comment on this

May I ask one question of the Minister? (Interruptions and cries of "No" and "Sit down.") In view of the two conversations he alleged that were heard by a farmer— (interruptions.)

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I call on Deputy Fahy. Deputy Corry must sit down.

Comment on this

The Minister who has just sat down has given us a very fine tirade, but very little about this motion. He has spoken about the intent in our minds, and it is obvious in this respect he has many standards. He says that Deputy O'Connell went very carefully into the figures and quoted very careful figures in support of his case. But when Deputy de Valera went into figures, which the Minister dare not dispute, because they were from official returns of trade and commerce, showing the decline in cattle exports and the decline in tillage and what the percentages were, we were told they were vague percentages and so on. When Deputy O'Connell quoted figures, then, according to the Minister, great care was displayed, but when anyone in our Party quotes figures it is a laughing matter for the Minister, who is such a splendid clairvoyant that he can read what is in our minds. He states that this matter of de-rating is very closely associated with elections in our mind. The question of de-rating is closely associated with elections in the minds of other people.

We all heard quoted by the Minister for Finance the speeches made by the President and by the Minister for Education on November the 22nd last. Perhaps the Minister is not aware that there was a bye-election on at that time. I suppose indeed they had no connection whatever with the bye-election, but one of those speeches was delivered in Dun Laoghaire, and the other was delivered in Lusk at a time of a bye-election. Of course these Ministers, like the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Local Government, were very careful not to quote figures. They prompted the quotation of figures in other quarters. We find on December 22nd, when the bye-election is still on, a heading in the "Independent": £1,000,000 for the relief of farmers. Form of de-rating in the next Budget." That, of course, had no connection with the election; not at all.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

It has nothing to do with this motion.

Comment on this

Just as much as the Minister's quotation a few minutes ago. I am just as much entitled to quote as the Minister, and the Deputy did not object to the Minister's quotation.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

I did not interrupt.

Comment on this

You are interrupting now, though you did not then.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

There were enough interruptions then without Deputy Gorey.

Comment on this

I do not object to his interruptions. "The sum of £1,000,000," said the "Independent,""is being talked of in well-informed circles as the amount the Government hopes to find to enable it to come to the aid of the farmers. There is a good deal of speculation as to the form a scheme of de-rating will take. It is suggested that it may be formulated on a graded scale giving more aid to the small farmer than to the individual with a larger valuation." Then Mr. Belton got inquisitive as to what exactly were the Government's intentions. He put a public query to the President as to what the intentions of the Government were on this matter. Of course, there was no connection at all with the by-election.

On December 8th a letter appeared, signed by President Cosgrave, in which he wrote as follows:—"I cannot forecast what the De-rating Commission's conclusions will be. Whatever they are, the evidence the Commission has collected will be of the greatest assistance to the Government in directing what is the most suitable form which the relief we intend to provide for the agriculturists shall take. We are agreed that the farmer deserves and must receive every assistance that, having regard to our resources, can be given to him." The Minister for Local Government now queries whether he needs that assistance at all. Deputy Finlay, speaking at Skerries after the election, is reported in the "Independent" of December 15th as saying: "The electorate knew the Party that could deliver the goods, because that Party had delivered them and was delivering them, and President Cosgrave's pledge to assist the farmers would be fulfilled." On December 24th the "Independent" had another article about the million pounds relief for farmers. All the promises and all the wild talk of a million for the farmers did not come from the Fianna Fáil Benches.

I have a quotation here from Deputy M.J. Connolly, T.D., in a statement he made that was duly reported in the "Longford Leader" on January 10th. He said: "Far from inflicting hardships on the farming industry, as the position would lead them to believe, the Government was doing its utmost to foster industry and in the latest effort in that direction about £2,000,000 will be made available to assist farmers. That will be done without inflicting undue hardship on the country." Perhaps the Deputy will give the benefit of his great financial genius to the Government in deciding how it will find £2,000,000 without inflicting any undue hardship on the community. We are asking for only a million.

The Minister for Local Government waxed sarcastic as to the scheme of de-rating that we were advocating. We are advocating no such thing. We have heard speeches from several members on the opposite benches mentioning promises about de-rating. We heard sums of £1,000,000 and £2,000,000 mentioned, but there was no sum mentioned by the Minister for Finance. Will the Minister for Finance or the Minister for Local Government say that £1,000,000 will be given in the Budget this year as extra relief for farmers? If they say that we will then know where we are.

Comment on this

Certainly not.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance told us the Government expected shortly to have the Report of the Tariff Commission. Last November the President told us that the report was practically ready, but we have not got it yet. The Minister for Local Government is not prepared to tell us on what basis any relief grant would be divided. We are told that everything must be taken into careful consideration; that the reactions on local government must be fully considered, and that careful consideration must be given to the wise advice that will come from the Commission. The Minister asked why Deputy de Valera had not outlined the manner in which this money would be expended. He asked why the Deputy had not put before the House a complete scheme for temporary relief.

The fact of the matter is, that the Minister, with all the Government Departments at his back, is not capable of putting any scheme before the House. I presume he knows what will be contained in the Commission's report. He must think that we here are super-men when he expects us to submit a scheme. He could not submit any scheme notwithstanding all the assistance he has at his back. He has not suggested any scheme of temporary relief, and he cannot have it both ways.

The terms of reference of the De-rating Commission were read out for us. We hope that the Commission will bring in a good scheme of de-rating. We have to take into consideration all the hypotheses linked up with the Minister's promises, the delay that has taken place in connection with the report of the De-rating Commission and the splendid promises made by the "Irish Independent." I presume the statements published in that paper were inspired, and they got their information from Government quarters, perhaps from the weekly communiques they get from the Minister for Finance. On February 22nd they stated that there was a surprising change in Cabinet policy, and they mentioned that the schemes the Government were considering for additional temporary financial relief for the farmers were, if not definitely abandoned, postponed for twelve months. We want to know if that is true. The Minister tells us that if certain things happen in relation to certain other things he will do so and so. We must take the wrappings off the parcel and see what we will find inside for the farmers. The Minister tells us that the local authorities must strike rates this year. Certainly they must. In 1926 there was a grant of £600,000 given, and yet the rates were struck.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy will explain why persons calling themselves Fianna Fáil representatives on the Kildare County Council walked out as a protest against the striking of the rate. Is that the party attitude?

Comment on this

I have no more control over a county councillor who happens to be a member of Fianna Fáil than the Government have over a P.C. who had to appear before the court and who happens to be a member of the Government Party. I have just the same control in that connection, and the Minister knows it. What have we to do with a county councillor who happens to be a follower of Fianna Fáil? We are no more responsible in that respect than is the Government for a P.C. who was arraigned for assault.

Comment on this

It is interesting to know that the people in the country who are against striking a rate do not represent the Fianna Fáil policy. It is satisfactory to know that.

Comment on this

I would like the Minister to know that we do not dictate to members of local bodies the same as the Local Government Department dictates to local bodies. The Fianna Fáil members on local bodies follow what they think right without consulting us or without being dictated to. That is the exact position. We would like to know what promise the Minister for Finance is now making. Is he prepared to give any relief this year to the farmers? I can assure the Minister for Local Government that none of us is advocating that rates should not be struck or collected. We are advocating that some form of relief should be given.

The Minister for Local Government spoke about the depression in the agricultural industry not being a sudden thing, and he mentioned that it has been going on for a long time. The farmers represent 72.3 per cent. of the industrial production of this country. We are told there is depression in that industry. If we are to take President Cosgrave's prosperity campaign into account, we must be suffering from what I may call progressive prosperity. Government Deputies have admitted in the country that the great industry of farming is depressed. It has been agreed by all sides in this House that it is depressed. The promises made by the Government are too vague. We want this million to be given in immediate relief. We think that the amendment submitted by the Labour Party might be very useful if there were a permanent scheme, but ours is not a permanent scheme.

This suggestion that we make to-day does not indicate what we would do in the matter of de-rating. If we were dealing with a scheme of de-rating we would distinguish between the small farmer and the grazier. If it were only for political motives it would be to my interest in Co. Galway to distinguish between the large grazier and the small farmer. We must, in the matter of de-rating, distinguish between the small and the larger farmers. We must recognise that some of the large farmers give a good deal of employment in the dairying industry. I make no excuse for them, but if they give employment this is not the time to lessen that employment. I would deal with them justly if we had any permanent scheme. It will not encourage tillage now, Deputy O'Connell says. Therefore it is penalising those who will not till. I say it is better to induce them to till than to penalise them for not tilling.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

It is not penalising them; it is a recognition of the fact that those who are tilling have bigger burdens to carry, and to that extent it would be a special measure of relief to them.

Comment on this

I do not think it is feasible. If this motion were carried you would have to deal largely with the Minister for Agriculture. Does the Deputy know what is his opinion about this matter? When a similar motion was before the Dáil some time ago the Minister for Agriculture waxed eloquent about the number of officials that would have to be appointed.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

The county instructors would do it.

Comment on this

I would like the Deputy to ask the Minister for Agriculture what he thinks of that. Apart from that I do not think you could fix it this year. The amount of land that is to be under tillage this year is already fixed. It is too late now to have that changed. It would cost a great deal, and we want immediate relief. If we get from the Government a definite promise of a sum—something to be mentioned in the Budget for extra farm relief—it would be time then to reconsider this motion, but not until then. We have got no promise that we will get anything, and seeing what promises were made on previous occasions we do not trust half promises made by the Minister for Finance now.

Comment on this

It seems to me that the two Parties in this House are now vying with each other in their desire to show practical sympathy with the small farmer, and that being so I think that the debate as a practical debate has now become unreal and insincere. The Minister for Finance has stated that he proposes in his Budget to mention what he is prepared to do for the farmer. I think, therefore, that any further speeches on this motion might very well be deferred until the Budget statement is made, and that then these speeches will be of some practical benefit, when we know what the Government is prepared to do.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

That is the only way to know what they will do.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Murphy know what the Government is going to give?

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan Minister for Agriculture (Mr. Hogan) Cumann na nGaedheal

This is an amazing debate even if a bit unreal. What has been the history of this business? More than a year ago a Commission was set up to go into the question as to whether de-rating is the correct way to give relief, and to give an answer to that question. It is more than a year and a half ago since that was set up. Three months ago the President of the Executive Council stated in unequivocal terms that the Government admitted the necessity for relief to the farmers and were prepared to give the farmers relief. That is the second step. It is now an open secret, known to every Deputy on the opposite benches, that the De-rating Commission is about to report.

Comment on this

Which report?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I will give the Deputy full permission to speak afterwards. I am making my speech now. As I said, that is an open secret. The party who have for the last two or three years been wasting my time and their time, and the time of the Dáil talking about wheat, tobacco and indiscriminate tariffs and the uselessness of the British markets, have suddenly woke up, and at the last moment have realised that de-rating is the goods, politically, and they rush in at the last moment with the motion which Deputy de Valera himself admitted is ill-considered, which he does not attempt to defend, and which he can only apologise for on the grounds that he is in a hurry. Now Deputy de Valera is in a hurry, and Deputy O'Connell is in a hurry. But what is the hurry? Is the hurry to relieve the farmers? I doubt it very much. The hurry, as everybody knows, is to get any political credit that can be got beforehand out of the report which all know is coming from the De-rating Commission which we set up——

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

And nobody outside the party asked you to set it up.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

That is the hurry and there is no other hurry. We are told that the farmers need relief. We are reminded that that is admitted. We have been given a number of reasons, some relevant and some irrelevant, as to why they need relief. We have been told, and I think it is a case made by practically every spokesman on the benches opposite, that the big disadvantage which the farmers are suffering from at present is the high cost of living and the high cost of production. I find myself in entire agreement with that. Deputy de Valera tells us that the trouble with the farmer is that the price which he receives for what he sells has fallen much more than the prices of the articles which he buys. That is partly true and partly incorrect. It is true that the prices of cattle and sheep have fallen. It is true also that the prices of some of the commodities, some of the absolute essentials of life which the farmer has to buy, have not fallen nearly so much as the prices of cattle and sheep. But what are these commodities? Boots, clothing and furniture. What are the other necessaries of life the farmer has to buy? Tea, sugar, flour. Compare the index figure for tea, sugar, flour, essentials for the small farmer, with those other essentials. boots, clothing and furniture, and what do we find? Sugar is at pre-war. Flour is practically at pre-war; clothing and boots are very much above the pre-war figure. The index figure for both boots and clothing is considerably higher than the index figure for cattle and sheep which the farmer is selling. Is there any doubt about that? I welcome this return to sanity on the part of Fianna Fáil, and I ask them who is responsible for the high prices of boots and clothing.

Comment on this

You are.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

We are partly responsible, but let the Deputy remember what they would have been if we abolished the Tariff Commission and if we adopted the Fianna Fáil policy preached for the last two years and which is now forgotten. I never see a word about it in the Monday morning papers now.

Comment on this

Is the Minister opposed to tariffs on boots and clothing?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I tell the Deputy that I will give him full permission to speak afterwards.

Comment on this

Answer the question.

Comment on this

What would the position be if income tax had not been reduced?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I know I am hitting home, but I do suggest that I am strictly in order and that I should be allowed to carry on when I am on the point. We heard from the benches opposite that the farmers were suffering from the great disadvantage of high prices for what they have to buy compared with the low prices for everything they have to sell. I have been saying that myself for years. The Deputies on the Fianna Fáil side should come over amongst us at last.

Comment on this

We are particular about our company.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

There is more rejoicing. Well, that is the case that was made from the opposite benches during the whole evening. That is the case made to show the farmers' disadvantages at the moment. What would the position have been if we had adopted the policy that the Fianna Fáil Party had been reiterating ad nauseam for the past three years? What would the position be if we had no Tariff Commission, if we had indiscriminate tariffs, if we had Deputy Lemass's policy, expressed when he was younger, not in years but in experience, that everything should be taxed until a case was made why it should not be taxed? That was his policy. Has that gone, is it all forgotten now?

Comment on this

It still is.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Who is the leader of Fianna Fáil? I sat here. I listened to questions. What are the poor clothing manufacturers to do? What are the poor woollen manufacturers to do? They cannot compete, even though they have so much. There was one answer from the other side. Your patriotic duty, the duty of any Irish Government who had the interests of the Irish people at heart, is to immediately increase the tariff. We all know you cannot do it. You have entered into some dark bargain with the capitalists in Ireland or in England, or the British Government. You cannot do it. I listened to that for years. I listened to suggestions that we should put up the price of bran and flour, that we should spend millions of the farmers' money on growing wheat. I listened to all these things in the last three years. Now the De-rating Commission, which has been sitting for the last year and a half, is blamed because they have not their report here. What were you doing in the last year and a half? You were preaching policies up and down the country which, for the whole of the day, you are endeavouring to run away from.

Comment on this

The only change in policy last year was on your part.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I remember four or five months ago when Deputy Lemass was in one of his enthusiastic moods which occasionally supervene. He told the country "We have won definitely on this policy of tariffs." What are we back to now? Reduce the farmers' overheads. I am flattered. These are amateur efforts to carry out my policy, but the intention for the moment is good. It was not to-day or yesterday that I discovered that. I think I am entitled to a little boast at the moment.

Comment on this

We taught it to you.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I pointed out that to Deputies for years in their salad days. At last they admit it. If I have read one speech of the leader of the Opposition I have read twenty on the following lines. They were all the same speech. I could say it off by heart. It is always the same speech, but delivered in different places. The Deputy will correct me in the exact figure. I am not as good at statistics as he. We export into this country twenty-one million pounds worth of food, drink and tobacco. Look at the millions we could leave in the country if we could tax these imports. To-day that Deputy talks about reducing the farmer's overheads and reducing the price of what he has to buy. He will go down to Limerick next Sunday again, and he will make the same speech about the twenty-one million pounds worth of food, drink and tobacco, which includes five million pounds worth of feeding stuffs and six million pounds worth of wheat, even though his angle now is opposite. The trouble of the Party opposite is that they have no real political or economic convictions. They simply have the crude line that if the Government say one thing, we want the other. I do believe in a vague kind of way there has at last penetrated into the recesses of their economic consciences the idea that they did talk a lot of nonsense in the past and that there was something in the policy which we have been putting forward and carrying out in the last three or four years.

Comment on this

What policy?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am afraid the Deputy would be incapable of understanding it. Nearly everybody in the country understands it. I am not going to waste the time of the Dáil in going into it. It is too big a question.

Comment on this

It cost you £500—slander.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What did it cost? The less said about that the better. Leave out slander. It is really irrelevant and leaves me quite cold. We will debate that, by the way, at any time. When the case was diagnosed for us, and we were told that the farmer was suffering from low prices on the one side and from high prices on the other, we were taken to another point and told: "Look at the decrease in tillage and the decrease in live stock." We were told that tillage had declined to a tremendous amount in the last three or four years. I will pay this compliment to the Deputies opposite. When Deputy de Valera was talking about the decline in tillage he was talking with some advertence to the fact that if his magnificent policy were carried out we would not have any such decline in tillage and we would not lose these millions of pounds. In other words, if we had succumbed to this silly nonsense about wheat-growing and tobacco-growing, and if we were growing wheat, and if we were taxing the country for the purpose of paying the farmer a subsidy on a crop which has fallen below pre-war prices, if we were carrying out any of these policies advocated for the last three or four years, we would have this money in the country.

As I am on the point, let me turn to Deputy O'Hanlon for a moment. I do not propose to discuss the agricultural policy just now. It is too big a question; but I do think at this stage Deputies should drop the habit of comparing prices now with prices three years ago and saying: "There you are, there has been a fall." That is merely silly. All prices have dropped. We can do a lot; we have done a lot, but we cannot prevent world conditions. If Deputies want to make any intelligent comparison about prices, they are up against a very difficult proposition, and if they want a difficult proposition I will give it to them. Compare prices now with what prices would have been if we had not put our policy into operation. That is the only real comparison. I heard Deputy O'Hanlon talking about the Dairy Produce Act, the Live Stock Breeding Act and the Agricultural Produce (Eggs) Act. I will leave out the Meat Act, as it has only been in operation for two months. He asked what have those Acts done for the farmer. He told us nothing. That is just nonsense. In what position would the creameries of the country be if we did not take the steps we took five years ago? Every speaker from the opposite benches has quoted the case of butter as an example of the plight to which agriculture has been reduced. It was not to-day or yesterday that we woke up to that situation. Four or five years ago we passed the Dairy Produce Act. Does anyone suggest for one moment that that has not increased and improved the quality of our butter? There are Deputies on the opposite benches who do know something about the creamery industry. I would like to hear them suggesting that that has not improved the quality of our butter.

Does not any Deputy who has any technical knowledge or knowledge of marketing know well that but for that Act our butter would be off the English market? Everyone knows it. The same thing applies to Irish eggs. There can be no question about it. The Live Stock Breeding Act has put millions of pounds into the pockets of farmers in this country. Every farmer knows it, and it is admitted freely by our purchasers and every agricultural association in Scotland, but it does not stop at that. People talk of the plight of the dairy farmer as if they heard about him for the first time last year. Come down a little later. Three years ago we purchased in one deal practically all the proprietary creameries in the country. What was the position of the dairying industry when we did that? Financially, creameries were in a very bad way, they were up against fierce competition, financed by one of the richest firms in the world. I remember deputations that came to me from creameries all over the country, telling me the position they would be in if this transaction were not carried out. We carried it out successfully, with the co-operation of the farmers, and at one stroke we put 75 per cent. of the creameries in a financially sound position. But for these two measures, the Irish creamery industry would not be able to stand up against the slump it is actually in, and that slump is not our fault. It was not to-day or yesterday we realised that the dairying industry was the foundation of our agriculture. When Deputies opposite were talking nonsense about crops and about growing grain for sale, and generally preaching theories in a way that you see boys in a debating school doing it, we were dealing with the real problem. We were saving agriculture in this country, and but for these measures that we had three years ago in regard to the dairying industry the position of dairying at the present moment would be disastrous.

Comment on this

Much better.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

What do you know about it?

Comment on this

As much as you.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I do not mind a man speaking honestly who has some knowledge of the subject.

Comment on this

As a matter of personal explanation, the Minister has directed his remarks to me for the last few minutes, the inference being that I objected to these Acts being passed. I never suggested that for one moment. I said I quite agreed with every Act I quoted, but that, notwithstanding the fact that these Acts were passed, the farming industry was depressed at the moment, and that the real results of these Acts had not so materialised as to relieve the farmer in any possible way. I do not want to be misunderstood. I think when you read the Official Report of my speech you will find that I did not go on the lines the Minister suggested. The Minister has warped my speech.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I beg the Deputy's pardon. I started by quoting what the Deputy said. The Deputy said in express terms that none of these Acts put a penny in the pockets of the farmers. These are his exact words. Is that correct?

Comment on this

Quite so, up to the present.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am not deliberately misrepresenting the Deputy. He said an agricultural policy was necessary. He went on from that to say that this motion was the first sign of an agricultural policy, this slap-dash motion to spend one million pounds in relief of agriculture.

Comment on this

The Minister should not misquote me. I did not say that an agricultural policy was necessary. I did say that this House had agreed, judging from the speeches that had been made, that relief for agriculture was necessary, which is quite a different thing. The Minister admits himself that relief for agriculture is necessary. And the matter is being brought to a head by this motion.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I think it is most unfair. We have two motions here, the Fianna Fáil motion and the Labour amendment. The first three hours of this debate were taken up with apologies by Fianna Fáil for their motion, and attempts to explain it and apologies by the Labour Party for their amendment and attempts to explain it and its implications. I sat here and listened to a rather interesting debate between the two Parties as to what they meant. I did note, in any event, certain things which rather amused me. The Fianna Fáil people told us that this is merely a temporary expedient. They did not wish to forestall the De-rating Commission Report. It is set out here in the motion that this relief of rates is only to last for a year. What is to happen next year? Was there ever anything like this? Is it seriously suggested that you can take off a million pounds of rates one year and put it on the next year? Or is it the case that by next year we will have our policy and we can put it into effect in substitution? If that is the position. I am quite ready to argue it on that basis. But, mark you, we are to have a million pounds given in relief of rates at the moment in this slap-dash fashion, in a fashion which its authors apologise for. Why? Because they have no permanent policy.

In the last three or four years surely this was present to their minds. Surely they could have examined this during the last two or three months and produced something that would be permanent if they were serious about it. But no, we are not, remember, going to forestall the De-rating Commission. You set up a De-rating Commission to consider whether there should or should not be de-rating. "Our policy is de-rate." That is not forestalling the De-rating Commission. Deputies seem to think that by merely stating black is white other people will agree.

We then come to the Labour motion. They attempt some permanent scheme of De-rating and they make certain distinctions. The big farmer is to get less than the small farmer; the tillage farmer is to get more than the grazier. That has been their consistent line. But it was the policy of the Party opposite up to to-day.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

And when they are asked to-day what has happened, they say this is only temporary. We are unable to think out a scheme that will work permanently, and hence we will have to drop the small farmer, to swallow our hatred of the big farmer, and to give exactly the same treatment to the grazier, whom we hate as the tillage farmer whom we love.

Comment on this

Why have not you a permanent scheme?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

We will have it. We are not accustomed to do business on the lines of introducing schemes that we do not understand. When we introduce our scheme here, and we will introduce our scheme here, as the Deputy well knew—that is the reason why you have this motion—it will be a scheme that will hold water, that will stand up to criticism, and that will have the support of every thinking farmer in the country. There is to be no distinction between the big and the small farmer! That is the new line of Fianna Fáil. I seem to remember yesterday's Land Bill. I sat for hours listening to the case made that the big farmer should not get anything like the same treatment as the small farmer. Has that gone by the board?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

They never stay "put." That is the trouble. Deputy Ryan used an expression which rather intrigued me and which he used outside this House some time ago. He said that the farmer should be encouraged to produce what he has been producing and should get every opportunity of doing it. I have been saying that for years. Does that mean that we will hear no more about our old friend, tobacco? Does that mean that we have definitely given up this policy of burdening some very big area of the country, even though the farmers decline to grow wheat? What is happening? Is that dropped also? We are to reduce the farmers' overheads. I have dealt with that. We are to reduce his cost of living. I have dealt with that. I want to put one question to the Fianna Fáil Party: will they stand definitely on the line they have taken to-night and cut out the politics? This motion is a political motion, and Deputy de Valera knows that well. This motion was introduced to forestall the De-rating Commission, to get whatever little political capital was going from any relief that we had definitely pledged ourselves to give agriculture this year. Everybody knows that. Everybody knows that six months ago the Fianna Fáil Party would not have touched this with a forty-foot pole. At the last moment they have wakened up to the realisation that de-rating is the goods, and now they rush in with their motion. Drop the motion; drop the politics. Do you stand by the line you have taken? Will you continue, seriously, on the line you have taken to-night—on the line that this is an agricultural country that, as Deputy Ryan said, must hold its export market? I used to say that. I was accused of being a traitor. Of course, nothing was ever expected of me. I was wept over by all sorts of patriotic people for saying that. Will you stick to that line? Will you also realise, as various spokesmen said here to-day, that the best service you can do agriculture is to reduce its "overheads"?

Comment on this

When are you going to do it?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I shall not tell you; it is a secret. That is exactly what we shall not tell you.

Comment on this

Until the next by-election?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Do not get me on to that. Will you stick to that line—to the line you took here to-night? I should like an answer to that question from some of the other Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party who are to speak.

Comment on this

Ask the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Do not keep up that gabble all night.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Corry must restrain himself.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Will you stick to that line—that the best service you can do the farmers of this country, who must hold their export market, is to reduce their overhead expenses? If you stick to that line, we can do business for the first time. We are next to each other. Will you take the clear implications of this line—that indiscriminate tariffs in a situation where you have practically all the producers, agricultural producers, who must have reduced cost of production—will you take the implications that indiscriminate tariffs in a country of that kind is suicidal? Will you stand to that? Will you continue in that line? If you do, we may have an intelligent agricultural debate in this House.

I welcome this debate. I think this has been one of the most illuminating debates we have had yet. I have been listening for a few years to debates on subjects that I could not take an interest in. The propositions put forward from the benches opposite were so unreal, so out of touch with the common sense of the country, so out of touch even with the commonsense of the farmers who vote for the Party opposite, that I could not take an interest in them, and could not, day after day, stand up and show the utter fallacy of them. It is clear that the conviction has been forced upon you that you have been on wrong lines. The real motive of this particular motion was political. At the same time, I do believe that the statements which have been made here from those benches, and which I just quoted, represent, to some extent, what Deputies really thought. It is the first time I have heard it. If Deputies will come down to these fundamentals and stand on them— they do not rule out tillage, they do not rule out a certain number of tariffs, because farmers are willing to make certain concessions in order to try to develop other industry; they do not rule out any sensible policy— if Deputies, with the knowledge which they have just now acquired in the realisation that you can have tillage, that you can have industry, that you can have a profitable agriculture and profitable industry within the necessary economic limitations of this country, which they have admitted to-night, are prepared to stand by these fundamentals—we can do business. If this debate, which started in a very unreal way, founded upon an unreal motion brought forward for purely political purposes—if this debate did nothing else but take Fianna Fáil Party a step—a very long step —forward in the direction of economic commonsense, then it would have done a good turn for the country, and it is the first time I could say that of any motion brought forward by Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

We are extremely grateful to the Minister for Agriculture for his kind remarks. They indicate, if I may say so, a far bigger advance in his attitude towards this Party and in his Parliamentary manners than any advance in the Parliamentary education of the Fianna Fáil Party. If the Minister, in his concluding remarks, did not refer to the question of economy all round and reduction of costs, I hope he will correct me. I take it that that was what he was concerned with. When Deputy de Valera spoke a few days ago on this question of economy, I followed, for a few minutes, in what, I think, was a very moderate way. I had expected that the Minister for Finance—the "housekeeper of the nation," as Deputy Murphy called him—would show some evidence of the desire for economy and reduction of costs that are such a source of heartburning to the Minister for Agriculture this evening. But we had no gesture whatever from the Minister for Finance to show that he contemplated any economies or that he proposed to reduce costs in this country to the level that our principal industry can afford to pay. On a celebrated occassion, when we were discussing the question of allowances to Senators, and when the Farmers' Party and the Cumann na nGaedheal Party voted down the proposal for a reduction of the Senators' allowances by £10,000, the Minister for Agriculture got up on a Friday afternoon— having an eye on Saturday's "Independent"—and poured forth what the wiseacres of the "Irish Independent" would call the floodgates of his eloquence on the Fianna Fáil Deputies who took their cheques and said nothing about them. I have no other business in life than this, but I am prepared to take the same cut in my salary as the Minister for Agriculture or any other Deputy on his side of the House. When we asked for a lead in this matter and said the men at the top should give the lead, we were not afraid to follow them—I was not, at all events.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

You should have been on that committee.

Comment on this

I do not believe in coming here with a lot of bluff and throwing dust in the eyes of the Irish people. If there is any sincerity about all this talk of economy and reduction in costs, why is there not some attempt by the Government to show economies in earnest? I submit that the Minister for Agriculture is simply bluffing the country. He has not the slightest intention of reducing his own emoluments or the emoluments of any officer in the service by a single sixpence. That is my reply.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Why did you not go on that committee——

Comment on this

Allow me to speak, as I allowed you. That is my reply to the Minister for Agriculture, and I am prepared to meet him on the question in any part of the country. This is a political question. I know that. I am prepared to put it on a man-to-man basis, and I am prepared to meet the Minister for Agriculture or the business men of his Party, who find it such a great inconvenience to come here and discuss the worries and the troubles of the farmers. We have the Irish Press telling us that we are wasting our time, that we should simply stay at home and let the Government deal with this matter in their offices, after many years produce their schemes from their pigeon-holes, and not let the Fianna Fáil Party assert they represent any volume of opinion. We represent opinion in this country just as much as the Minister for Agriculture. If the Minister for Agrficulture was sincere, why did he not put up that proposition to the farmers of Carlow, when they refused to hear him a few months ago—the proposition about reducing taxation and costs? When he saw that the Fianna Fáil Party was carrying on a successful campaign against him he swallowed his words. He went down to Athy some months later and said: "We must reduce costs at the top, in the middle, and at the bottom." He swallowed his own words as he swallowed his words on the tariff question when he introduced the butter tariff in this House.

As regards his remarks on the dairying industry, although we differ from the Minister for Agriculture and believe that his outlook is not alone bad economically but even dangerous to the country, we are certainly prepared to give him credit for anything he has done in connection with dairying. But his marketing scheme has not been above suspicion. I am not going to criticise it. I leave that to the representatives of the industry. They have told the country what they thought of his marketing system.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I am beginning to take this statement as a joke. It has been stated five or six times that I had something to do with some marketing scheme. The Deputy is suggesting that now. I had nothing to do, good, bad or indifferent, with any marketing scheme, and I shall not have anything to do with any marketing scheme.

Comment on this

It is quite true that the Minister has definitely put away the idea of compulsory marketing—the system of compulsory marketing which he was going to force on the creamery industry, whether it liked it or not.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

There is no foundation, good, bad or indifferent, direct or indirect, for the suggestion that at any time I was in favour of compulsory marketing. On the contrary, I opposed it from the very beginning, and Deputies know that perfectly well.

Comment on this

The cost of marketing and the methods of putting Irish butter on the market in England, the lack of advertising, above all the enormous overhead expenses; the failure to reduce freight costs, the failure to get proper salesmen to handle the market in England, the complete failure to appreciate conditions over there, the complete failure—which negatived the whole marketing scheme—to appreciate the situation where you had four or five combines in England in a position to hold up your marketing scheme by refusing to buy your butter when they could get Danish butter instead; the failure to appreciate these conditions has left the marketing scheme of the Minister in the position it is to-day. If he is convinced that his scheme is a good one and that the creamery industry is going to repay the half a million or more the Irish taxpayer has sunk in it; if he is convinced that it has a future, I ask him to go back to the representatives of the creameries, to take them into his confidence, ask them for their opinions, and not go over their heads, as he did when forcing this scheme upon them. When he has done that, and when his marketing scheme has unity, harmony and intelligence, and a proper appreciation of commercial conditions—when he produces that marketing scheme the creamery industry will accept it, and, as a Party, we will be prepared to accept it.

The Minister has asked what are we going to do next year, and he laid great stress on the fact that the Fianna Fáil Party stands for a policy of protection which he claims has increased the cost of living on the farmers. The tariff on boots was imposed before the Fianna Fáil Party came into this House —even before the Tariff Commission was set up—and it has never been reexamined. If the Minister for Agriculture was examining this question from the point of view of the cost of living and the impost placed upon the farmers, he should at least have got his Tariff Commission to investigate that matter. If he is satisfied that the tariff adds to the cost of living, places an undue strain on the consumer, or that there is profiteering, I submit that he should—we have suggested this over and over again—have brought such questions before the Tariff Commission and have the whole question reexamined. If we are not going to have a policy of protection for Irish indus tries, where are we going to get employment for our population? There has never been an answer to that question, and there never will be. The Minister for Agriculture wants this State to be a free-trade State—such a State as exists in no other part of the world.

The "Irish Independent," on the 30th of December, told the people in a semi-official statement that "the county councils next year will be invited by the Government to administer a substantial sum of State-provided money which will go to the relief of the rates." It went on further and said: "From the experience gained during the twelve months, a permanent scheme will be worked out, not necessarily on the lines of the experimental scheme." Was it because there was an election in County Dublin, and because a general election was imminent at the time, that this statement was supplied to the "Irish Independent," that a considerable sum of money was to be granted to relieve rates, that it was only to be experimental, that, in fact, the Government did not commit themselves to it, but were giving it because—as we say the position is that now—urgent relief was necessary, and that in the meantime they would examine the possibilities of a permanent scheme? If there is to be any permanent scheme it must be on some such lines as we have laid down. De-rating is nothing new. The principle of rating relief is not new. It has been going on since the time of the abolition of the Corn Laws, and since 1898 particularly. In 1901 a Commission on Irish local taxation reported that agricultural land in Ireland should be valued for rating purposes at only one-fourth of its annual value.

We set up a De-rating Commission 30 years after that Commission had reported that the agricultural valuations should be reduced by one-quarter and the burden of rates removed from the farmer. After 18 months the De-rating Commission has not produced a report or, according to the Press, they produced a report and submitted it to the Executive Council. According to the "Independent," the Executive Council was not satisfied with it and—an unprecedented thing for a Government to do—they asked the Commission to reconsider the question and to say how best the million pounds could be spent. Then the Minister for Agriculture twits us because we have no permanent scheme. His De-rating Commission was not able to come to any conclusion or to such a conclusion as they ought to have come to if they had a proper appreciation of the position of the farming community in this country. According to the daily Press—the statement was not contradicted—the Commission had to be sent back again to learn something about their business, to learn that Irish agriculture does need relief.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

On a point of explanation, may I state that there is no foundation for the statement that the De-rating Commission presented any such report, and no such request was made by the Government to the De-rating Commission, good, bad, or indifferent.

Comment on this

Why was the statement not contradicted then?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

We have something else-to do. In fairness to the Government, I want to make perfectly clear that what the Deputy says are not the facts.

Comment on this

What are the facts, then? The Press statement goes on:

A matter which is influencing the Government in favour of the farmers is the fact that its protection policy in respect of industry has indirectly increased their burdens by making certain commodities more expensive.

The Government's tariff policy, according to the "Irish Independent," has increased the cost of living to the farmers. Who is going to remedy that? The Government which put that policy into operation. This wonderful correspondent, who has such splendid information that nobody but readers of the "Irish Independent" can obtain it, on Tuesday morning, says:

Through a system of de-rating, there might be handed back to the farmer a sum roughly equivalent to the amount which he contributed to the Exchequer through the industrial tariffs.

Are we to understand that there is a split in the Free State Cabinet as there has been on previous occasions?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Are we debating the views of the "Irish Independent" or the views of the Government?

Comment on this

We know who supplies the "Independent's" information.

Comment on this

If the Minister for Local Government, that master of Press cuttings, had not set a very bad headline, possibly I would not have thought of inflicting the views of the "Irish Independent" on the Minister.

Owing to the fact that Press cuttings, extracts from speeches, and so on, have entered largely into this debate I think it is no harm to quote the Political Correspondent of the "Irish Independent." Are we to take it that there is a split in the Cabinet? The Minister for Finance refuses to budge. The Minister for Agriculture says that while we are taking £1,000,000 from the farmers in taxation on boots, shoes and clothing, surely there is a case for giving it back to them. Possibly Deputy Heffernan in his more courageous moments supports the Minister for Agriculture in his efforts to stand up for the farmers against this Party, which seems to be ruled by the Dublin Chamber of Commerce. The Minister for Finance has a wonderful weapon. He asks, "Where is the money to come from?" In a statement which he made in the Dáil on the 24th April, 1929, columns 777-8, the Minister for Finance said:

"The de-rating of agricultural land and buildings would involve seven items of new or increased taxation, which I may recapitulate:—1/- on income tax."

How would the Chamber of Commerce like that?

"¼d. per lb. on sugar; 3d. per lb. on tea; 4d. per gallon on petrol and paraffin; 5 per cent. on boots; 5 per cent. on such apparel as is now subject to 15 per cent.; 6d. per lb. on tobacco."

Deputies will recognise that no Minister for Finance could bring a list like that to the Dáil for adoption and expect an enthusiastic reception.

Now that the Minister for Local Government has categorically stated that the money is going to be found to provide relief, when and if they think fit, are we to take it that the Minister for Agriculture or the Minister for Local Government has persuaded the Minister for Finance that the condition of agriculture is such, that the difficulty of collecting the rates is so great, that even those formidable impositions, which it is suggested are necessary to "raise the wind", will be accepted by the Dáil which seems to be quite unanimously in favour of relieving the farmer? Or is it that the Minister for Local Government has found some other way of raising the money? At any rate, it is not going to come from economies. I ask representatives of the farmers here to-night to note that there is no reply from the Minister for Agriculture when a straight and simple proposition on the question of economy is put up to him. His speech, in my opinion, was a swan song. He made no effort to reply to Deputy de Valera's statement in regard to the present situation in agriculture. Is he prepared at this hour of the day to tell the Irish farmers what he told them some time ago, namely, that the indications are that livestock prices will maintain their level or has he only the same hopes for the maintenance of livestock prices at the then level as he had for the maintenance of butter prices at the level they were at when he bought the Lovell and Christmas combine? Does he expect Irish farmers, as Deputy de Valera said, to agree with the attitude of "live horse and you will get grass"? So long as livestock prices continue or so long as there is even an indication that they are going to maintain their present level, then agriculture, whatever its condition, cannot be said, at any rate, to have reached the lowest level of depression. Is that the pronouncement of the Minister?

The Minister for Agriculture made no effort to contradict the statement of Deputy O'Hanlon that the prices on the Dublin cattle market to-day are worse than for many years past. Is that an indication that the Minister's prophecy is coming true—this wonderful Minister whose refulgent light shines over the jealous States of Europe which are not fortunate to possess such a star? Are the farmers on the Dublin cattle market to-day satisfied with the Minister's wonderful prophecy that live stock prices are going to maintain their level and that therefore there is no need to be unduly worried or anxious about the position of Irish agriculture? Whenever any proposition comes up, particularly from the Fianna Fáil Benches, it is a political question. It is only put up to fool the people, to blind and bluff the people. Ministers, in fact, say: "Let us dismiss it with an airy wave of our hand and return to our offices. If we can keep the daily Press dishing out the same stuff that they are dishing out to the farmers at the instigation of the Government for the last six months on the question of de-rating, there is even a reasonable prospect that we may be returned to office when we seek the suffrages of the people in a couple of months."

The Minister for Local Government stated that the rates must be collected. Who stated that they must not be collected? Was it any Deputy on this side of the House? Was it Fianna Fáil councillors in Co. Kildare? No, it was Deputy Jordan trying to inspire some enthusiasm into the almost defunct Farmers' Party, trying to ginger it up to do something. I commend the Minister for Local Government to turn his eloquence and reforming zeal on Deputy Jordan, of Wexford, who was the principal party to a proposal passed by the Wexford County Council to the effect that the council should not strike a rate. It was only last Monday they struck it. They deferred striking it until such time as the representatives of County Wexford put up a case to the Government to relieve the farmers by way of de-rating.

Comment on this

There is just as much foundation for that statement of the Deputy as there is for his other statements—that is none; good, bad or indifferent.

Comment on this

Were you not at the meeting of the county council when it was decided to postpone striking the rate pending a deputation to the Government?

Comment on this
Mr. Jordan

Certainly I was, but I was not responsible for it.

Comment on this

Did you disagree with it?

Comment on this
Mr. Jordan

I did not, but you are trying to convey to the House that I was responsible for it.

Comment on this

Did you vote for it? Deputy Jordan is in the splendid position of many other Deputies, who pretend to represent the farmers and who, rather than embarrass the Government when a simple proposition is put up to them, even in their own constituencies, to strengthen the hands of the farmers and to force the Government to do something, take up the attitude of being neither on one side nor the other. The least said about that the better.

Deputy de Valera has called attention to the fact, and I must repeat it, that in 1925 the Minister for Finance said that the whole question of the incidence of local taxation was being investigated by his Department. It has been investigated for the past six years. It was investigated for two years before Fianna Fáil came into this House. If there is any blame for not producing a permanent scheme for bringing local rating up-to-date and removing obsoleteness and excrescences, who is to blame? Is it Fianna Fáil or the Government, the Government who, on their own admission, have been considering the question for six years and still have not succeeded in producing anything? Is the other statement of the Minister for Agriculture that this proposition in regard to de-rating is introduced only now because the De-rating Commission is expected to produce its second or final report, whatever it may be called by the Minister——

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

I want to put it on record that that statement is untrue. I stated before that it is not a fact. I object to the Deputy here deliberately atacking people who, he knows, cannot reply. I stated specifically that there was no second report, and the Deputy is maligning members of the Commission when he persists in making that statement. He should, at least, accept my statement.

Comment on this

Why was it not contradicted in the Press? It was reported there.

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

Such a question!

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is contradicted now.

Comment on this

As for the statement that I took this opportunity to malign members of the De-rating Commission I take exception to it. I know some members of the De-rating Commission and I have the greatest respect for them. I simply quoted a statement in the Press which was not contradicted at the time, and I leave it at that.

Comment on this

If they were so much maligned, why did they not contradict it?

Comment on this
Mr. Hogan

If Deputy Aiken wants to say anything let him get up and make a speech.

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture said that this motion was only brought in for political purposes because the De-rating Commission was about to produce its report. May I quote from page 1010 of the Official Report of the proceedings on the 25th April, 1929, when I raised the question of de-rating on the Budget for the year 1929? The Minister for Finance then stated:

Deputy Derrig suggested that if it were not possible to de-rate, an additional amount should be given by way of agricultural grant. My feeling even about increasing the agricultural grant is that some further examination of the position of local government should be undertaken. It was perhaps all right to give a second £600,000 to Councils, for the relief of agricultural rates and leave the position as it was before. But if another substantial sum were to be given, as big as or bigger than that, as I suppose some people would ask, I think that one of the results of doing it would be that we would have a decrease in the rates the year the grant was given or the year after, and then we would have the rates creeping up again to the old figure. My own position is that I would not be inclined to give any more money to the local authorities from the Exchequer for the relief of rates until we had examined further the machinery of local government.

It is clear then that we raised the position in 1929. Deputy Corry also had a motion on the Order Paper, which he has already referred to, dealing with the question of the agricultural grant. It was not discussed, and the question of the agricultural grant or de-rating in general was not spoken of by this Party since the De-rating Commission was set up, simply because we knew that the answer would be that the De-rating Commission had not reported, that we knew very well there was a Commission sitting on the matter, and that it would be foolish to discuss it when the Commission had not yet made their report. We introduce it now because the County Councils have struck their rates; some of them have not yet struck them, and they want to know definitely what is going to be done. We introduce it secondly because the De-rating Commission has been sitting for eighteen months and has produced nothing. Whether the Commission produces its report or not, the Government should at least follow on the lines that the Minister for Finance and other Ministers have indicated, not alone in 1929 but in previous years, when they passed through this House in 1925 the Local Government (Rates on Agricultural Land) Act, and when they specifically laid it down in Section 2 of the Act that in any subsequent year the Minister for Finance could increase the agricultural grant to any figure he thought fit.

There was no necessity to introduce a Bill. The machinery was there, and all that was necessary was to increase the Estimates accordingly. Is it contended, then, that the Minister for Finance could not have taken the step of increasing the agricultural grant last year or this year by means of the powers he had taken unto himself in this Act to increase the grant? He could, of course, have done that without prejudice to the Commission which is investigating the question of de-rating. If the Commission is to result in any good whatever to the farming community it must be in some form of rating relief. Whether the relief is to come in the form of an increase in the agricultural grant, or in a form which might now be temporary, or whether it will be given in another form later on, when a permanent scheme is evolved does not concern us. We are simply dealing with the question that the Government have not followed the lines laid down in that Act. They know the position of the industry, and they have full powers to deal with it, and yet they have not taken the plain and simple means of increasing the agricultural grant.

The Minister for Agriculture referred to the Land Bill, and I notice that he was applauded by the Deputies of the Labour Party, who, strange to say, were absent from the House yesterday when the discussion was taking place on the principle of compensation for resumption of holdings.

Comment on this

How many of your own members were present when you were speaking?

Comment on this

I was present, and I speak for my Party. The leader of the Labour Party was not present, although he was chiefly responsible for raising this question of fair play for the owners of resumed holdings. He did not see fit to sit in the House to listen to the various arguments put up. In any case, the question of the acquisition of land for the relief of congestion, a policy that we believe in and that we stand for and that we are prepared to defend, hasnothing whatever to do with the question of the relief of rates on agricultural land. It is an entirely different question. I might as well say that Deputy O'Connell when he looks for relief for the small payers of income tax should demand that they should follow a particular calling in order to get that special relief as to demand that farmers, in order to qualify for a further relief of rates, should work their land in a particular way. If you are out to relieve taxation, whether it be central or local taxation, the only principle upon which you can give relief, and the only principle that has been followed up to the present, the principle upon which the Labour Party and the Government agreed in the 1925 Act, is to relieve taxation according to what the individual has to pay. If you want a policy of providing work in the West of Ireland, or of dividing land there, that is a different matter which can be dealt with through the Land Commission or some other Government department. We are now talking about relief of taxation, and that is a separate matter which the Labour Party have tried to complicate by introducing this amendment.

As for Deputy O'Connell's amendment, which remits three-fourths of the total amount of rates which he has to pay to the ratepayer under £50 valuation, is it going to be of any benefit to the small farmers in the West or the congests in County Mayo with holdings of £2 or £3 valuation? Does it matter in the slightest whether they get three-fourths or one-half or even the whole? If anything is to be done for them it should be the abolition of their rates altogether. If you abolished rates on certain communities in certain counties, that would be the only solution. My point of view is that if you deal with it on the basis of Deputy O'Connell's amendment you will introduce enormous complications into the system of local government. You will have large bodies of people paying low rates, and adjacent to them you will have people paying heavy rates. It is obvious that that is going to create a very difficult situation and that it would have to be carefully thought out. We are not opposed to the principle. What I say is that if we want to deal with the problem in the West there is a special way of dealing with it. The people there demand that they should get employment for their children, and that they should get the rich lands of the country to live on, and get them at a price, I should tell Deputy O'Connell, that would enable them to live on them.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

Are we to take it that this motion has no concern with the congests in the West? That is the clear conclusion from the Deputy's statement.

Comment on this

As regards rates in general, Deputy de Valera pointed out that the standard rate that was fixed in 1897, which is the basis of the present agricultural grant, should be brought up to date. That is as far as we can go into the matter at present. We are prepared to go further into the matter when some effort is made by the Government to produce a permanent scheme. At any rate, we can go so far as to say that we recognise that the agricultural grant should be brought up-to-date and should be put on the basis of recent rating instead of the basis of rating in 1897.

I should also like to call the attention of the House to the fact that since that year—which is an argument in favour of the motion—the rates have enormously increased. As far as the mental hospitals which have been referred to by Deputies are concerned, the capitation grant was only about 4/- when the standard agricultural grant was fixed. The capitation grant was said to be about 50 per cent. then. It was only 20 per cent. in 1927-8, the average cost per patient being something like 16/8. What is still more important is that the cost of these institutions is increasing. The increase in the number of inmates in 1927-8 was 15 per 1,000, and the increase between 1919 and 1928 was 10 per cent. No allowance is made either for the increase of patients or the increase in the cost of maintenance by virtue of the fact that the post-war cost, generally speaking, even with the same number of patients, is 50 per cent. greater than pre-war. You have increasing expenditure there. You have a standard grant based on conditions in 1897, and you have the fact also that the nature of the service would seem at first reading at any rate, to demand that it should be treated as a national service, that there should not be a distinction between, let us say, the people in the Dundrum Central Lunatic Asylum and the people in the Ballinasloe Asylum. If one class of patient is to be taken up and maintained and looked after by the State there is prima facie a very good case for treating the others in the same way.

As regards roads, there has also been an increase, according to the Minister for Local Government. As reported in the Official Report of the 30th April last year, column 1204, he said that there has been an increase of 80 per cent. on the cost of roads as compared with pre-war. What is still more extraordinary is that although the grants from the Government have been increasing by something like 10 per cent. annually, the expenditure for which the local ratepayers have to bear responsibility is also increasing at a fast rate. It is calculated that in 1931 the total amount falling on the rates in virtue of expenditure on roads was £1,140,000, an increase of over 6 per cent. as compared with the previous year which, again, showed an increase of over 6 per cent. on the year before. Therefore, it is quite clear that in spite of the increase of £600,000 in the agricultural grant given in 1925, the agricultural grant is not bringing up the relief of rates to the 50 per cent. level that it was intended in 1898 the farmers should enjoy. In England, the farmers every year since that, up to the time de-rating came into force, got 50 per cent. each year. In this country, although we are now giving relief, amounting to £1,200,000, the farmers are in the position that they are still paying something like £1,800,000 in rates. In other words, in spite of the fact that we are giving the farmers an increase of 50 per cent. in the agricultural grant they are still paying a balance which is 50 per cent. more than what they were paying altogether in rates in 1898. That shows that there has been an enormous increase in rates since 1898, that there is a very good case as conditions have changed so much for bringing the agricultural grant up to date.

I do not want to delay the House any further, but I simply will say that in poor rates, home assistance, and other services there is an equal increase. There is an increase of something like 60 per cent. in the poor rate for the current year as compared with pre-war years. It is quite evident, therefore, that to give the farmers even the 50 per cent. annual reduction in rates that they should have got in 1897, but that they did not get, not alone is the present agricultural grant of £1,200,000 inadequate, but even if you do bring the grant up to the 50 per cent. level which is asked for in this motion the farmer's difficulties will not be solved. Every year from this forward, if the policy of the Government as we have seen it during recent months is pursued, you will have further demands made on the farmers, further increases in rates for other purposes. Our suggestion is that in the present year, at any rate, the agricultural grant should be based on the level of the last three years.

Comment on this

Many Deputies who listen in the Lobby to the eloquence of Deputy Corry from time to time know that he claims credit for having forced the Fianna Fáil Party to table this motion. We cannot understand, however, why he comes along now as a private soldier to second the motion, and does a right-about-turn from the position he occupied on this question as late as 18th March this year, and even as late as yesterday in the debate on the Report Stage of the Land Bill. Deputy Corry, speaking in this House on 25th October, 1929, asked the leave of the House to move the following motion:—

That it is the opinion of the Dáil that the agricultural grant should be applicable only to the relief of rates on holdings which have a minimum of fifteen per cent. of the arable land of the holding under tillage, and that the amounts so retained be devoted to increasing the grants to holdings complying with the regulations.

Deputy Corry, on the 18th March, 1931, in the debate on the Vote on Account as reported in column 1697 of the Official Report, stated:

The farmer tills his land, and the more he tills the more he loses.... Why should we till at all? Why not allow the whole country to go back into ranches again?

That seems to me to be an absolute contradiction of and in conflict with the statements made by him in support of this motion. Having listened very carefully to Deputy Corry, I came to the conclusion that he had unconsciously made a case in support of the amendment and not in support of the motion moved by his leader. However, perhaps Deputy Corry, in the Lobby, and in East Cork and elsewhere, will be able to give some reasons, at any rate, why he has turned this somersault in such a short period, and why he failed to convince the majority of his Party to take the line which he took up on this very matter as far back as 25th October, 1929.

Deputy de Valera, in moving the motion, in a mild and moderate speech, furnished Deputies with a considerable amount of statistics to show that the agricultural industry is suffering from acute depression. That was not necessary. Any Deputy, especially a Deputy who represents a rural area, who knows anything about the state of affairs in the country, does not need to be convinced by figures that that is the position.

Deputy de Valera quoted figures which were unnecessary from the point of view of the average Deputy, but he failed to furnish the House with figures that we expected him to give, namely, figures showing the amount which each county would get as a result of the allocation of the sum of £1,000,000 mentioned in his motion. I hope Deputy de Valera, when he replies, will furnish some such information, because that is the only proof that Deputies can get, and especially the farming community in the areas concerned, as to the real meaning of the motion to the tillage farming community, and especially to the small farmers about whom Deputy Corry and others on the back benches of Fianna Fáil have been wailing so long.

Apart from the extraordinary somersault made by Deputy Corry within the period of a year, I think the next most extraordinary statement was made by Deputy O'Hanlon. He told the House, and I hope it will be printed in Cavan and that his words will get back to the small farmers in Cavan, that he held a mandate from 6,200 organised farmers in Cavan that they did not want 75 per cent. reduction on the existing rates, but that for the sake of the country, and to show their patriotism, they would prefer a 50 per cent. reduction. Will Deputy O'Hanlon tell the House what is the name of the organisation with which these people are associated? I would be surprised to know that there was in the whole Free State 6,200 farmers organised, not to mind in the County Cavan. If there are 6,200 farmers well organised in the County Cavan, Mr. Baxter should be back in the seat now occupied by Deputy O'Hanlon, that is if they belong to the Farmers' Union. Looking at it from the point of view of valuation of the small farmer, we find that in the County Cavan there are 986 farmers with a valuation of over £50, compared with 12,237 occupiers of agricultural holdings with a valuation of £50 and under. If our amendment is passed these farmers would be given an immediate reduction of 75 per cent. on the existing rates. Deputy O'Hanlon is the greatest patriot that ever came into this House, but I doubt if he speaks the mind of 6,200 organised farmers in the County Cavan when he makes that statement. There are only 321 farmers in the County Cavan who hold over 100 acres of land.

Boiling this whole debate down to figures and looking at it from the point of view of how it is likely to affect the area I represent myself, I have taken the trouble to get out some figures. Working from the figures furnished to me by the Secretary of one county council in my area, I find that in the case of the County Leix there is a total of 9,667 holdings. Out of that total 1,027 are occupied by people with a valuation of over £50, whereas the remaining 8,640 have a valuation of £50 and under. Looking at it from the point of view of how the people with a valuation of £50 and under would be affected by the motion and the amendment, I find that taking holdings with a valuation of £50—and they are mostly tillage farmers—they would get a reduction of £7 5s. 0d. on the basis of a £50 valuation as the result of the passing of Deputy de Valera's motion, whereas the same individuals as a result of the passing of the Labour amendment would get £13 2s. 6d.

The Census of Production, and of Population, and other figures, go to show that it is the tillage farmers who have been losing most in the past four or five years. Naturally, as Deputy Derrig said in his recent speech at Borris, these are the people who should get the benefit of any reduction in rates that the nation can afford to give at the present time. Deputy Derrig, speaking to the small farming community at Borris, said:

By all means let us have relief all round, but let us begin where the taxation presses most heavily and most unfairly.

Deputy O'Connell proved conclusively in quoting the case of Meath, with an average valuation of £49, and Mayo with an average valuation of about £10, that the County Mayo carried a population of three times County Meath. That is the case in all the counties where tillage farming is carried on, and that applies almost altogether in the case of the 346,000 people in this State who occupy holdings with a valuation of £50 and under. These are the people who should get the benefit of any reduction in rates which can be brought about as a result of this or any similar motion.

Deputy de Valera by this motion asks the Dáil to provide £300,000 out of that £1,000,000 for 6,000 farmers with a valuation of over £50. Deputy Corry talked about the damage likely to be done to the agricultural workers in Tipperary, Limerick and Cork as the result of the passing of our amendment. I quite agree that there may be exceptional cases where hardship will be caused as the result of the passing of our amendment. We considered an alternative scheme very carefully which would be likely to give a reduction in rates on the basis of the number of agricultural workers employed by the farmer and especially the large tillage farmer. Will Deputy de Valera furnish any evidence to show that proof can be given from year to year from any source whatever as to the number of people who would be employed continuously on farms of £100 or £200 valuation? Deputy Corry talks about some East Cork farmer, some bloated capitalist, a landlord presumably, who gives employment in a particular period to 22 people. He walked into the kitchen of this landlord or lord of the soil and found 22 people eating at his table. I suggested at the time, and I think I was right, that that must be on a day when this gentleman was threshing, because he would not find the same number of individuals eating there if he went there 15 or 20 times during the year for any other purpose. We know well that a farmer with £40 valuation would possibly have 22 people helping him to thresh under the conditions in which threshing operations are carried out. However, Deputy Corry has an elastic imagination and picks out the exceptional cases to prove that our amendment is likely to hurt some of his new landlord friends, some of the people whom he was denouncing yesterday

Take the County Tipperary. Out of the total number of people occupying agricultural holdings in that county there are only 2,760 with a valuation of over £50, leaving 19,895 who will get the benefit of the 75 per cent. reduction which our amendment would give them, if passed. Take the County Limerick. The Deputy talked a good deal about Limerick and, apparently without any figures at his disposal, he looked upon that county as a county which would be likely to be ruined as the result of the passing of our amendment. In County Limerick there are 17,923 occupiers of agricultural holdings, out of which only 2,345 are occupiers of holdings with a valuation over £50. If these 2,345 farmers in the County Limerick and the 2,760 in Tipperary can prove that they till at least 20 per cent. of their arable land they, in addition to the other people under £50 valuation, will get an immediate reduction of 50 per cent. in their existing rates.

Deputy O'Hanlon also made a remarkable statement. He stated that if total de-rating is not given to the farmers the question will still remain a vital one. Are we to understand that Deputy O'Hanlon is an advocate of total de-rating, or would he put any limit on the valuation of the occupiers of the agricultural holdings whose rates whould be completely wiped out at the expense of some other section of the community? Deputy O'Hanlon said that he was opposed to 75 per cent. reduction of the existing rates, as proposed in the Labour Party amendment and he is going to vote for a 50 per cent. reduction, for the patriotic reasons already given. He allows us to infer, if he did not actually state it, that he is in favour of total de-rating.

These were the extraordinary statements that were made by some of the opponents of our amendment. Deputy de Valera is the man who should produce his figures for the information of the farming community and for the information of the public whom he is addressing this evening. He should produce the figures, for county after county, of the additional amounts which would be given as a result of the passing of his motion if it is passed. Side by side with these figures he should also give us figures of the amounts which would be given as a result of the passing of Deputy O'Connell's amendment, if the amendment is accepted by the House.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance is usually, if not convincing, at least plausible. When he gets up and makes a speech on a question such as this of the kind that he made, I think it is pretty certain from it that there is very little of a case to be made on the other side. His objections to this motion appeared to me to be anything but sensible. They appeared to me to be absolutely and utterly childish. Deputy Ryan, following him, pointed out how utterly childish they were. Just imagine putting forward as a reason for rejecting this motion, that if we passed it now when the de-rating policy is being considered by the De-rating Commission, that henceforward no body of men with self-respect could be asked to undertake a serious investigation. Does he not know full well that this motion was put forward here because we all understood and accepted that the examination of this question of the best means of giving relief was likely to be a protracted one; and that when recommendations are made here and placed before the Dáil, a considerable time will have to be spent before there will be anything like an acceptance of the principles put forward?

The Minister said that whatever scheme was adopted now should be in the nature of a permanent scheme. He did not think of that back in 1925 when he gave the very self-same reasons for bringing in a supplementary grant that it was the quickest way to give— relief.

These are the very same reasons we are giving for bringing in this motion. I want to make it clear to everybody that the reason we brought in this motion was that Deputies in our Party who are members of local bodies understood that if relief were to be given to the farming community it should be given immediately. They pressed upon us to submit this motion in order that the Government, if they really meant business, would be able to give relief this year. If this motion is passed its effect will be that there will have to be provision made in the Budget for the giving of this relief of one million pounds. If we do not pass the motion then we can only depend on the indications given to us from the opposite benches. When we tried to nail them down, not one of them would give us anything that we could regard as a definite promise. They told us to wait and see. They did not tell the farming community or other sections of the people to wait and see when the bye-elections were on.

We believe they are playing the same trick on the community in regard to this de-rating question as they played when Deputy Rice spoke of the fifteen millions that were going to be made available for housing. There was inspiration given to the Press recently that the scheme was off, and the conclusion the people were asked to draw by the Press was that the Government had changed its mind, and that they would have to wait for another year. It was in these circumstances that we put down this motion. We do not want to get any political capital out of it. Our policy with respect to de-rating was proclaimed long before this. We held that if we kept the money that is being paid over to England in respect of certain matters the whole of the rates on agricultural land could be remitted and we would have some millions to spare. When we put forward that suggestion as a practical way of getting the money without any hardship—keeping money that belonged to us—we were told "Let us have a policy that will deal with the present time. Your opponents are not prepared to accept that policy; we expect you, if you want to give us relief, to put forward a policy which your opponents can accept."

That is what we have done by submitting this motion. We want the million pounds given, and we do not want it to be put off any further. The Minister for Finance told us that there would be an orgy of spending if this money were given; that the whole system of local government would have to be rearranged before money like this could be given. Are we going to wait until the whole system of local government is changed so as to suit the views of the members opposite, so as to prevent what they call an orgy of spending? Now, this orgy of spending cannot take place this year. There are definite commitments which the local bodies will have to meet. We know what those assessments are. They can be followed up. And if there was any attempt to manoeuvre so as to get an unfair proportion of this grant, the idea of the three years' average would preclude it.

Deputy O'Connell complained that under this system of averages Mayo would suffer somewhat. Is it not fair to give relief in accordance with the average expenditure for the last three years? It is not this year alone that this depression has come upon us. It has lasted a considerable time now. And is it not fair, when giving relief, that the sums spent in the last three years in the local services should be taken into account? I am not making any particular point on that. But I say that if Mayo had a small sum to pay in the last three years, that meant that only a small sum by way of rates was taken out of the pockets of the Mayo ratepayers; and if they get a less sum now it simply means that they had to pay a less sum out of their pockets before.

I was asked to give figures. Figures are not necessary to show the effect of this. I pointed out that the effect of it would be the same all over except where it is slightly altered by the average. Apparently Mayo is in a unique position because its rate was lower a few years ago. Its rate has advanced more. They will get the advantage of the advanced rate and the disadvantage of the lower rate. It will be on the average. The all-round effect of this motion is this, that every ratepayer in the country who is paying rates on agricultural land would be relieved in respect of such rates of roughly half the amount he would have to pay. That is what it amounts to. I have those figures that Deputy Davin asked for worked out. I have not all these figures. There is a certain amount of calculation involved. In any case, it cannot be absolutely worked out without the whole of the assessments. Carlow will get £14,000 to £15,000, Cavan something over £26,000, Clare, about £50,000, Cork £115,000, Donegal about £43,000, Dublin County £45,000, Galway about £74,000, Kerry about £49,000, Kildare about £33,000, and so on. Mayo would get about £29,000 or £30,000. They are calculated fairly rapidly, but anybody who wants to know what is roughly the sum that any county would be given in relief and the amount of relief that would be given by this motion can get it by saying that it would amount to about half of the present burden.

Comment on this

How much in the pound would it be? What would be the allowance in the pound?

Comment on this

The proportion in the pound would be got in the same way. Where there would be an average rate of 6s. this would give relief to the amount of 3s.

Comment on this

That is not my point. My point is that when you take the average, a county which has, if you like, been economic in its administration for the last three years, will come out worst. I have seen figures worked out, and these show that while some counties would get 4/4 in the pound, other counties would get as low as 2/1 in the pound.

Comment on this

The relief they will get will be proportionate. The relief would be about half the average rate. If the county has been worked economically, what will that mean? It means that there has not been a burden upon the taxpayers. This motion is going to relieve the people who bear burdens in proportion to the burdens they are carrying, and in proportion to the services they rendered by carrying these burdens. If a county has good social services and makes provision for home assistance, and so on, such provisions will mean extra burdens. Those who contribute most of these burdens will get comparatively the greatest relief. The whole principle is to relieve proportionately those who are carrying the burden of rates and relieve them roughly to the extent of one-half.

Our policy with respect to de-rating was complete on the assumption that the moneys were to be got by retaining what is at present, in our opinion, being paid away needlessly. We have also made it quite clear that we favour a system which would discriminate to the advantage of smaller holdings—the holdings of the small farmers. Why are we not doing that here, it may be asked. Why are we opposing the proposal put forward by the Labour Party which seems to indicate a line of approach in that direction? I say to the Labour Party that we are opposing their proposal because of the fact that we want a definite motion that the gentlemen on the opposite benches will have no excuse whatever for rejecting. We do not want those on the opposite benches to bring up red herrings as to whatever differences there may be between a £49 valuation and a £51 valuation. We do not want them to get away with the idea that there would be a great deal of expense in connection with the administration of this scheme.

Deputy Hogan of Clare pointed out very rightly that the present condition of things did not occur overnight; that there has been a certain continuous growth. We ask the Labour members to put this question to themselves: Is it fair that a man who has no inducement whatever to till should be penalised? That is exactly what it means. I think it was Deputy Davin who pointed out that the farmer who tilled at the moment was the man who suffered most. If that be so, is it fair to penalise him? It means that you penalise certain people because they do not till their land. The way to look at it is that if you do not give a person whatever privilege his neighbour may be getting you are to that extent penalising him and there is no use in trying to make it appear otherwise by any form of words.

Speaking for myself, I would not be prepared to penalise any person at the present time for not having more tillage because there has been no inducement given to him to do more tillage under the existing State policy. No policy has been put forward by this Government to induce people to cultivate more land. I think it would be unfair to penalise anybody in this respect and it would be particularly unfair to penalise the man with the £51 valuation as compared with the man with a £49 valuation. Any scheme which would give encouragement over an extended period and with a definite prospect in view would be on a different plane. This proposal here, however, is for a year only. If the proposal from the Labour Benches were adopted it could only be regarded as in the nature of a penalty.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

Its adoption would prevent us from giving a huge slice of the money to graziers, for the most part.

Comment on this

If Deputy O'Connell were to make a thorough investigation of the effect of the proposal upon individuals I am perfectly certain he would find that he would be penalising a large number of people other than graziers, people he would not dare to penalise, people who are giving employment. There are people in the country obliged to work according to the system of economy preached here by the Minister for Agriculture, and that was forced upon them by circumstances.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy accept that view?

Comment on this

I have made my view about the future quite clear. We stand for the encouragement of tillage, for making the land do its primary duty, which is to provide food to minister to the wants of the community and carry the population.

Comment on this

Vote for the amendment so.

Comment on this

No, I will not vote for the amendment, because the amendment is not going to do that. It is only a one-year business, and for one year it cannot encourage tillage; it does not indicate any general policy. It is a gesture, if you like, on the part of the Labour Party. As a gesture I agree, but as a practical proposition to put up here against people on the opposite benches, who are not disposed to give relief this year as far as we can see, it will not be effective. I think it is a bad proposal from the point of view of a policy to put up to the Government, because if they went seriously to attack the Labour proposal—they did not do it—as they would if it were the one substantial motion before the Dáil, they would have adopted a different course. They are not able to attack this motion because they know they are giving relief on practically the same terms. They know they are already giving a million, and this is simply adding to a sum given before.

Comment on this

Then you are in agreement with them?

Comment on this

I am in agreement with them? Unfortunately I am not, because I do not believe that your proposal or ours is going to carry a majority here. I am not in favour of the principle of allocation as a permanent policy. I am in favour of it as the simplest at the moment and as the one, in all the circumstances, that is going to bear most fairly on the community.

I want to make another point clear. It is said that I did not point out where this money was to come from. No, I did not. Deputy O'Connell did not point out where this money was to come from. He indicated that he did not want it to come by way of indirect taxation on the section of the community which is least able to bear it. With that we agree, and if there was any proposition that it would put such a burden of indirect taxation on the section Deputy O'Connell wishes to protect we would vote against it. Where is the money to be got for it? I am precluded from referring to the land annuities in connection with this motion. It is not that I am abandoning our case, but I did not want to have another red herring across this debate by the Deputies on the benches opposite. I gave figures which the Minister for Local Government did not understand to prove a certain thing, that if it were necessary by taxation to come to the relief of the farmer it should be done and we would be justified in doing it. I did not say it was necessary, but I say if it is proved to be necessary I am prepared to take up that way of finding the money. What way is it to be found? We pointed out here in the last two or three days ways in which a sum equivalent to that mentioned in the motion can be found by economies. We pointed out the direction in which these economies can be effected, but the men who talk of economies "at the bottom, in the middle and at the top" were not prepared to face these economies. On the benches opposite it was said that we were not prepared and that we were always putting forward motions for relief of this, that and the other thing. We are bringing forward motions for relief of those who need relief, and we think that the burden ought to be borne by those who can bear it. If it were necessary to put a tax on petrol—

Comment on this

Or increase the income tax.

Comment on this

Or increase the income tax. If the economies we recommend cannot be carried out, and we believe they can, I am prepared to stand over that motion and to back it up by finding the moneys necessary by taxation of those who can bear it. I hope then that every Deputy here will realise that we are not making mere gestures, that we are prepared to back up the motion with deeds, because we believe it is necessary in order to give needed relief to those men who are in the agricultural industry. The Minister for Agriculture told us how we had been converted to his ideas. One would imagine that agriculture was in a magnificent condition in this country instead of being in the condition in which it is. The feeling that those engaged in agriculture are in need of relief is as strong on the benches opposite as it is here. The need of it has not been questioned by anybody. Why is relief needed if the policy of the Minister for Agriculture has been so successful as he tells us it has been? We do not agree with his policies because they give no hope to the farmer for the future.

All the Minister for Agriculture can tell the farmer is to stick it out, to tighten his belt. When he wants to give a little bit of hope he says that those who are pointing to the facts are mere pessimists. They are hypochondriacs. There is no Deputy here who has not accepted the fact that depression does exist amongst the farming community, and if the condition of agriculture is such as we know it to be, is it not the best proof in the world that the policy that the Government has followed for the last eight or nine years is a rotten one? It is a bad one, and we believe that the policy which I have spoken of and which other members of our Party have spoken of from day to day—we will repeat it until the people understand it, until it wins through—with respect to agriculture is the only sane policy at the present time. The Minister tried to turn this debate and the fact that we admit that the farming section of the community relatively to other sections of the community has heavier burdens into an argument against tariffs. It is not an argument against tariffs. I think I heard Deputy Derrig read a statement made by a member of the opposite side, to point out one of the reasons why the rest of the community ought to give help to the farming community is because the tariffs imposed for the advantage of industry do bear more hardly on them than on others. That is a good reason in order to equalise the burdens. We have stood for protection, not merely for industry, but for the farming community, because with all-round protection any burdens will be equalised and the advantages will also be common. Is the farmer interested in building up industry? I say the farmer is, and I say the development of industry is one of the best ways of relieving agriculture. We know that the land under the present economy is carrying more people than it can support. We know that the outlet for the farmer's sons at the moment is industry. We want to build up side by side with our agriculture our industries, but our agriculture is here at the moment, and the question for us at this moment is this, are we going to save that which we have and then build up side by side with it its auxiliary, or are we going to concentrate on building up industry and let what we have go by? I think that would be a very bad policy.

Comment on this

There are a good many Deputies in this House who desire to express their views and who have not got an opportunity of doing so. May I ask the President if he will say definitely whether the Government intend to grant relief to agriculture in the coming financial year?

Comment on this

And how much?

Comment on this

And why?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I have already stated in public, and it has been quoted here, that it is the intention of the Government to do so. I want to say that the Government's policy is not dictated by the Deputies opposite.

Comment on this

How much are you going to give?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

That will be told to the House, not to the Deputy.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 11
·
Níl 121
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Division

Motion put.

Tá 62
·
Níl 73
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?