We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Business. - Town Tenants Bill, 1930—Committee Stage.

Contributions 204–397 of 397. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Town Tenants Bill 1930
Enacted

No. 34 of 1930 ›

What period does the Deputy suggest?

Comment on this

I suggest six months.

Comment on this

I have no objection to six months.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

I move amendment 24:

To add at the end of the section a new paragraph as follows:—

"Where any part of the cost of an improvement is necessary in order to put the premises into a reasonable state of repair no additional rent shall be allowed in respect to such cost, and in no case shall the increase of rent be more than five per cent. of the cost of the improvements over and above the cost of putting the premises into a reasonable state of repair."

I put down this amendment because it seems to me the landlord should not be entitled to claim rent on the expenditure necessary to put a house into a habitable and reasonable state of repair. I hold that the amount of such expenditure should be excluded in fixing the rent. I also desire to limit the increase that the landlord should be entitled to claim on his expenditure when fixing the rent.

Comment on this

I do not quite follow what the Deputy has in mind in his amendment. Suppose there is a contract of tenancy and there is an obligation on the tenant to put the premises in repair. Suppose also that the tenant fails to do that, and the landlord is compelled to do what the tenant ought to have done, would the landlord not be entitled to increase the rent for the repairs that he has carried out?

Comment on this

Would any repairs mean improvement?

Comment on this

No repair is an improvement under this Bill. What I am anxious to get at is the idea that the Deputy has in mind in bringing forward this amendment. Repair is not an improvement within the definition here. I am not now so much on the actual wording of the amendment, but am rather concerned to get from the Deputy what his ideas on this are.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I see the point that Deputy Lemass raises now. I think that rules the thing out altogether.

Comment on this

If a tenant is compelled to carry out repairs that the landlord should carry out, then I think the tenant might get compensation from the landlord. If the landlord is under an obligation to put the premises in repair and fails to do that, and if the tenant serves notice upon him to do it, at present the tenant has very little remedy except to go into court and get a court order. That is a most difficult thing to do. But there certainly is a case to be argued. If the landlord is under an obligation to repair and the tenant serves notice on him that these repairs are necessary, and the landlord does not carry out the repairs, the tenant might be allowed to carry out the repairs and get a reduction in his rent to the extent of what the repairs cost. If that is what Deputy O'Connell has in mind I could meet him, but where the tenant is under an obligation to carry out repairs quite different considerations would arise.

Comment on this

I think one of the sections in the Bill that was introduced by Deputy Redmond proposed to give the tenant the right to execute repairs which the landlord had failed to do, subject to the approval of the court. If the Minister refers to that Bill he may be able to get an amendment on that line for the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Perhaps Deputy Redmond could tell us something about that.

Comment on this

There was a suggestion to that effect in the Bill.

Comment on this

Supposing there was a difference between the tenant and the landlord as to whether the repairs were necessary, would that be covered?

Comment on this

I think Deputy Redmond's proposal was that the tenant would go to court for an order entitling him to execute the repairs himself and then deduct the cost out of the rent.

Comment on this

Under the provisions of this Bill what would happen is that when the tenant served notice on the landlord the landlord might either come in or serve an objection. Then there would be the question of going to court. If the landlord did not serve the objection, and therefore was not going into court the tenant would carry out the improvements himself.

Comment on this

The Minister has only referred to a case in which there was an actual contract to carry out repairs.

Comment on this

That, I think, is the case that would have to be provided for, the case where there is a contract.

Comment on this

Arising out of the amendment introduced by the Minister, in which we extended the period from two to six months, I suggest that the words "as soon as may be" be not deleted from the section, so that the section would then read: "as soon as may be, but not later than six months from the expiration of such fourteen days." I would not like the impression to be given that there is, in any case, six months in which improvements can be effected, but that it should be obligatory on the landlord to do them as soon as may be.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this

With regard to paragraph (c), does the Minister think that is a reasonable provision? The paragraph provides that

if such tenant duly withdraws in accordance with this section the improvement notice served by him, such notice shall for all puposes be deemed never to have been served.

Is that quite reasonable? A tenant does not serve an improvement notice for fun, and should not the case go to the court to decide whether the improvement is a necessary one? After all, there are other people concerned in the maintenance of property besides the tenant and the landlord. The community is concerned, and I think that paragraph is unnecessary in the section.

Comment on this

If the tenant wishes to carry out an improvement— and again maintenance is not improvement—serves notice, and then discovers it is not to his advantage to do it, he is put in precisely the same position as if he had never served such notice. It seems to me that that is perfectly correct and fair. What does the Deputy want?

Comment on this

I wanted to go to court. The improvement notice has not been served for fun. It is a necessary improvement or it would not have been served.

Comment on this

Not necessary at all.

Comment on this

I move:

In sub-section (1), line 25, to delete the words "one month" and substitute the words "two months."

I am changing the three months to two months.

Comment on this

I move:

In sub-section (2), line 36, to delete the words "one month" and substitute the words "two months."

The same change takes place as regards this amendment.

Comment on this

I move:

In sub-section (2) to delete from the word "holds," line 40, to and including the word "subsisted." line 41, and substitute the words "has at the date of such notice been in occupation of such tenement under any tenancy."

This amendment is designed to make the sub-section express what I presume its framers intended it should express, but which, I think, it does not. I take it that the intention of the sub-section was that unless a tenant has in fact been in occupation of a tenement for five years or under contract for five years the improvement objection would be final. That is not what is in the Bill. The sub-section only relates to tenants who are under contract to remain for five years, or have been there for five years under a yearly or any lesser contract. A situation may arise where a tenant who has been in occupation for 20 years, and whose tenancy expired at the end of that time, then made a new contract for four years. If during those four years he desires to effect an improvement, the improvement objection would be final in his case, although he has been in occupation for 22 or 23 years, if he was there under a yearly or lesser tenancy. The five years give him the right to go to court and to defeat the improvement objection. If the contract were for two, three or four years, he could not go to court to defeat the improvement objection. It seems to me there is a defect in the drafting of the section, similar to defects contained in a number of later sections. Provision is made to deal with contracts for tenancies of five years, but no provision is made for those with contracts for two, three or four years. That is why I suggest the amendment. What the sub-section meant was that if a tenant was under a contract for five years, or if he had been there for five years under any tenancy, he could go to the court for the purpose of defeating the improvement objection that was served on him. It is merely a defect in the drafting.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is really defeating his own intention by the words which he suggests should go in. The intention of the section is, "unless a person holds a tenancy under a lease or other contract for less than five years or holds such tenement under a yearly or any lesser tenancy which has at the date of the service of such notices subsisted for less than five years then it should be final." The object of that is that if a person is only there for a short time he should not be entitled to execute very large improvements in a house that he does not intend to keep very long. I think the only effect of the Deputy's amendment would be that if a person took a lease for 25 years or for 100 years, for the first five years he would not be allowed to do anything under the amendment.

Comment on this

There are two alternatives.

Comment on this

Not in the Deputy's amendment.

Comment on this

The lease or other contract of tenancy for less than five years. If a lease is for more than that he has a right to go to court. I will take the case of a person under contract in a tenancy for four years who has been in occupation for 20 years.

Comment on this

If he is in occupation for twenty years he is entitled under the section.

Comment on this

The notice is not final.

Comment on this

It is final unless his occupation is for more than five years.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy take the whole section:—

(1) Where a tenant has served an improvement notice on his landlord and either such landlord or a superior landlord has within one month after such service served on such tenant an improvement objection in respect of such improvement notice, such tenant may, save as is otherwise provided in this section, within one month after the service of such improvement objection either:—

(a) by notice in writing served on such landlord or on such landlord and such superior landlord (as the case may require) withdraw such improvement notice, or

(b) apply to the Court under this section.

(2) Where a tenant has served an improvement notice on his landlord and either such landlord or a superior landlord has within one month after such service served on such tenant an improvement objection in respect of such improvement notice, and such tenant holds the tenement to which such notices relate under a lease or other contract of tenancy for less than five years....

Comment on this

That disposes of your first point.

Comment on this

"Or holds such tenement under a yearly or any lesser tenancy which has at the date of the service of such notices subsisted for less than five years." That is to say if he has not been five years in occupation.

Comment on this

Under a yearly or lesser tenancy if he has been 20 years in occupation, and holding under 2 years' tenancy.

Comment on this

There is no such thing.

Comment on this

There might be, and there will be if Section 17 is passed in its present form.

Comment on this

Two year tenancy is completely unknown.

Comment on this

Not statutorily impossible.

Comment on this

If there is a termination at the end of every two years and a new tenancy is created, I do not think there is any likelihood of anything of that kind happening. It is highly hypothetical. The Deputy's amendment would be fatal.

Comment on this

If the contract is for less than five years the notice is final.

Comment on this

The Deputy's amendment runs: "Has at the date of such notice been in occupation of such tenement under any tenancy."

Comment on this

For less than five years.

Comment on this

I will consider the Deputy's amendment.

Comment on this

I think that the Minister will find that it is all right.

Comment on this

I will consider it, anyhow.

Comment on this

In that case I withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'Connell Labour Party

I move:—

In sub-section (4) (b), line 53, after the words "tenement and" to insert the words "for the trade or business carried on in such tenement."

In this amendment an attempt is made to make sub-section (4) (b) a little more definite, and I think it will improve the section if the amendment is added. "Suitable for trade or business carried on." I think that is the important consideration.

Comment on this

Is it the Deputy's view that it is only in respect of business premises that compensation should be given?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

No.

Comment on this

Would not the amendment have that effect?

Comment on this

It would. I think that the amendment is not at all acceptable. "Suitable to the character of such tenement." Any improvement made in a shop, or anything of that kind, would be suitable to the character of the tenement. Suppose you insert the words "suitable to the character of such tenement for the trade or business carried on in such tenement."

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

What trade?

Comment on this

"And for the trade or business carried on in such tenement."

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

It is only additional.

Comment on this

I think that these words would mean considerably more than that. I think that it would have to be both trade and business. If you had a person carrying on a shop and he wanted to put in a bathroom, it would not be any improvement for his trade or business, and, accordingly, if he is not carrying on any trade or business he could equally be put out. I think that the words "suitable to the character" should remain in the Bill, and that these proposed words in the amendment would deprive tenants of a considerable number of improvements.

Comment on this

Has there not been a lot of litigation on the question "suitable to the character of the tenement"? Has there not been a tremendous amount of confusion?

Comment on this

I would not say that there has been a tremendous amount, but there has been some confusion.

Comment on this

I move:—

"In sub-section 4, lines 60 to 61, to delete the words `if the court so thinks fit.' "

I think that the Minister will probably admit that it will be found desirable always to have a time fixed, and that it will prove more convenient in working. It may repeatedly save applications to the court. If the words "if the court so thinks fit" are left in I think it will mean that the courts will always specify a time. I think that it will be found that the words in the Bill are practically ineffective, and if they are deleted it will mean that the court must necessarily fix a time.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I ask the Minister not to accept the amendment. In my opinion it gives discretionary powers to the court which it may or may not use as it thinks fit. As the Bill stands, it cannot operate unjustly either to the landlord or the tenant.

Comment on this

I agree with Deputy Byrne. I see no reason for compelling the court to specify a time in which improvements are to be made when the tenant is the only person concerned, and when the landlord refuses to do so. Surely in such cases the tenant should be allowed to complete the improvements in any time he thinks fit, unless there are circumstances under which, in the opinion of the court, the time should be specified.

Comment on this

I think that the amendment will save applications to the court.

Comment on this

Who will apply to the court?

Comment on this

The tenant.

Comment on this

I think that when you do not go into court it is well that there should be a time limit fixed. The court will be able to decide if a time limit is necessary. I think it is better to leave it to the discretion of the court, and I believe that it will work out all right.

Comment on this

I will withdraw the amendment for the present.

Comment on this

I move: "to delete sub-section (1)". Sub-section (3) of Section 3 of the Act of 1906 provided that a tenant would not be entitled to compensation for improvements unless he had given notice to his landlord of his intention to make such improvements and had received the consent of the landlord or, in default of that consent, the sanction of the court. There may be, and, in fact, there are, cases of tenants who in their ignorance of the law or for any other reason failed to give such notice and carried out improvements at their own expense. These improvements have increased the letting value of their holding. Is it fair that such tenants should be debarred from the right to get compensation for these improvements by this sub-section? Is it fair, in other words, that the landlord should be allowed to take advantage of a technical default in order to confiscate the tenant's improvements? We must remember that under the Bill these improvements must have increased the letting value of the holding and must be suitable to its character and also must comply with other conditions specified in different sections of the Bill. It seems to me equitable in such cases, although the tenant has not complied with the strict requirements of the Act of 1906, that he should be entitled to claim compensation from the landlord in respect of the increased letting value of premises when they are surrendered. I admit that there may be a perfect legal right to deprive him of such compensation, but justice and the law do not always coincide. In this case the claims of justice are sufficiently strong to override the strict legal arguments that may be advanced. We ask for nothing but that tenants who have improved their holdings should be compensated in respect of the increased letting value arising from these improvements when these premises are being surrendered to the landlord at the expiration of the tenancy. The Bill proposes to give all tenants that right, but certain tenants are excluded by this sub-section because they failed to give notice to the landlord under the 1906 Act. We want to bring them in, we want to wipe the slate clean, and let them start as from the passing of this Bill.

Comment on this

It appears to me that under the Town Tenants Act of 1906, for the first time, town tenants received certain privileges. They were entitled to claim for improvements which they had done to premises, but that Act, like this Bill, hedged that right round with certain restrictions which I think were reasonable restrictions. The improvements which the tenant made were the subject matter of compensation to him by the landlord if he did certain things. One of them was that he should serve notice upon the landlord that he was going to carry out these improvements and the landlord then had his rights. He had the right to go in and inspect the improvements and argue whether or not they should be carried out. He had the right to carry them out himself if he wished. Those rights which the landlord has are very similar to the procedure which we are setting up under this Bill. If a tenant was negligent under the Act of 1906, if through his own fault he acted to the detriment of the landlord, I cannot see why he should now come in and take advantage of his own default at the expense of the landlord. There are of course improvements which would come under this Bill and which did not come under the 1906 Act. To those I take it this sub-section does not apply, but the improvements for which he could have claimed under the 1906 Act if he had served notice, it seems to me, are improvements for which, if through his own fault he has not served notice, he should not now be entitled to claim.

We must look at this matter not only from the point of view of the tenant, but also from the point of view of the landlord who has suffered injury by the fact that the tenant has not given notice of the improvements. If we are going to say that the tenant can carry out improvements without giving notice of them, and that he will exactly have the same rights as if he did, all the provisions which we have in this statute would be simply so much waste paper. If we wipe out that in the Acts already passed, nobody would dream of serving notice under this Bill. They would simply say that the necessity for serving notice under the 1906 Act was done away with by the Act of 1931 and that if we had not done it by an Act of 1931, we would simply come along with an Act in 1941 or with some other Act and exactly the same thing would be done. The safeguards which we have set up under the Bill would then become just as nugatory as the safeguards in the 1906 Act.

Comment on this

I do not see how the Minister can describe the tenant's default as injury to the landlord. It seems to me that the landlord suffers no injury because of that default. He is going to get the premises with an increased letting value and for that he must pay compensation. No compensation would be paid unless the premises had been improved in value. He can let them subsequently at an increased rent. The tenant has improved the premises and we are asking that the landlord should pay for the increased letting value of the premises. The tenant's default does not mean any injury to him.

Comment on this

He might have carried out the improvements himself.

Comment on this

That is the only case the landlord could advance.

Comment on this

He could have seen at the time whether they were suitable.

Comment on this

If they are not suitable the compensation is reduced accordingly. The improvements must be suitable to the character of the premises and under the 1906 Act, the improvements may not be such as to decrease the value of any other premises which the same landlord had. The landlord might put up the defence that he did not know of these improvements, but he will be able to recoup himself by the increase in the letting value. Instead of doing the work himself he is asked now to pay for the present value of the improvements when the premises are surrendered to him. It seems to me that the balance of justice is on the side of the tenant in this case.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I would ask the Minister to agree to the amendment. There were so many restrictions and so many conditions under the 1906 Act, with which the tenant was obliged to comply, that unless he actually obtained the advice of a solicitor, in nine cases out of ten he would be found to be in default on one or other of these conditions. Deputy Lemass's contention, and it seems to me reasonable, is that the landlord is not asked to pay for anything which he did not get. He is getting certain improvements, improvements which confer an increased letting value on his premises. I might astonish the House if I suggest that I have personally been a victim of these very provisions. I expended some hundreds of pounds on premises which I occupied. I gave notice to the landlord of these improvements, but I did not submit plans or specifications of them. I therefore did not comply with the conditions of the Act of 1906 and I find that I am not now entitled to one penny compensation.

I do not make any appeal to the Minister for any personal or selfish reason but I know that there are many people who are in the very same position under that Act. I know the Minister may be in a rather difficult position because he has to consider each side of the case but if it were possible to give this amendment sympathetic consideration I think it would not mean any injustice to the landlord or the tenant. The Minister knows better than I do that all these complications existed under the 1906 Act and that they operated to the detriment of the tenant. I think that where there has been a default, owing to the technical nonobservance of the 1906 Act, the Minister should try and remedy this injustice which undoubtedly exists in numerous cases. I think he would not be inflicting any injustice on the landlord.

Comment on this

It appears to me that underlying this rather dangerous proposal is the principle of retrospective legislation.

Comment on this

You always vote against retrospective legislation.

Comment on this

That is so. That is not the only difficulty that arises. Supposing a tenant has been lax in carrying out his duties and the present landlord has only recently purchased his premises, understanding that there was no claim to be made of this character and no charges against the landlord, because of the default of the tenant, it seems to me that that is unreasonable.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Byrne has hit the nail on the head. The Town Tenants Commission in their report stressed the fact that the compensation provisions under the 1906 Act were wholly inadequate. In fact the whole Act fell through. It certainly did not achieve its purpose. The arguments can of course be put up that the tenants were defaulting by not carrying out the provisions of the law. Surely when the whole matter is being established on what we hope is a permanent basis, if the tenant can claim as Deputy Byrne has claimed, and he has instanced his own personal case, that he has been at a loss it is not the purpose of the Minister for Justice to exclude him. If the landlord has a fair case the court will take it into account and in the long run all these matters will be settled by the court. I think it would be inflicting an unnecessary hardship and it would be a very retrograde step if we were going to make the Act of 1906 part of this Bill. If sub-section (1) of this section is carried it seems that that Act will be there as a definite barrier. I think the feelings of the Commission were that there should not be any such limitation and they certainly did not intend that these types of tenant should be excluded from the operations of the new Bill.

Comment on this

I am sorry enough as it is for the Minister, but I wonder what my feelings would be if he were to try now to pass a Bill which would make law what may be argued should have been done by the 1906 Town Tenants Act. That is why retrospective legislation is so objectionable. It is almost impossible to tell what the reactions of it may be. I think there are many cases where it may turn out to be most unjust and instead of removing some grievances it might bring about a great deal more injustice. Deputy Good has instanced one case, that of a landlord actually in possession who would have bought a house on the improvements effected in it with the knowledge that he was not going to be liable for any extra charge for those improvements. If this amendment were accepted, we would put a most unjust charge upon him.

Comment on this

I do not think the amendment can be described as retrospective legislation. The claim for compensation will not arise except in respect of a tenancy terminated after the passing of the Bill. The point made by Deputy Good is one that requires consideration, it is a point that can nevertheless be met. I wonder would the Minister be agreeable to leave the sub-section stand, but to insert in it words to the effect that the tenant shall not get compensation, unless the court determines in view of all the circumstances of the case, that justice should demand that he should get compensation? There may be a case in which the balance of hardship can be shown to tell against the landlord though I believe that in the majority of cases the tenant will suffer a great hardship if the Bill goes through in its present form. If the Minister does not see his way to accept my amendment to delete the sub-section would it not be possible to devise machinery by which the tenant who has carried out substantial improvements but who has defaulted in sending a notice to the landlord under the 1906 Act, could come to the court for compensation, and if the court considered that he was justly entitled to compensation, it could be awarded to him?

Comment on this

Of course my difficulty is two-fold. First, as I have already pointed out, under this Bill if you simply do away with certain safeguards which existed under the previous Act you are weakening the safeguards which you retain in this Bill and that is a very dangerous thing to do. Secondly, as Deputies Good and Thrift are perfectly correct in saying, when a person is purchasing premises he always sends in requisitions on title and he asks the vendor various questions about his title. One of the questions naturally would be "has any notice of improvements been served under the Town Tenants Act?" The vendor would answer "no" and the purchaser would be entitled to assume that none of the improvements were improvements that the tenant could claim. Deputies Good and Thrift were perfectly entitled to point out that in all these cases the purchaser would be very seriously damaged.

If you take the section, you have certain rights under it; those rights are given by the statute with certain restrictions. I do not think we can go back upon the matter at all. Deputy Lemass suggests that I might consider points to the effect that if the landlord was not damnified, if he was not sure that he was not in any way damnified by the non-service of the notice or by any other defect on the part of the tenant, the tenant should have his right to compensation. I will undertake to see if anything of that nature could be done, but I will not hold out any hopes to the Deputy that I will be able to do it. In view of the arguments put forward, I will consider the matter.

Comment on this

I think the balance of justice is on the side of the tenant, and I think I will press the amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I move amendment 32:—

"To delete sub-section (2)."

The sub-section provides that "A tenant shall not be entitled to compensation in respect of an improvement made before the passing of this Act on a tenement in contravention of the lease or other contract of tenancy under which such tenement was held." I think it is unreasonable to put in that provision—at least, to put it in that bald fashion without making any condition as to whether or not the improvement was made, even if it was in contravention of the lease, with the tacit consent of the landlord. There have been cases of that kind where improvements were made although the lease indicated that there should be no such improvement. Many improvements are made with the tacit consent of the landlord. You will have numerous cases where consent may be unreasonably withheld. The report of the Town Tenants' Commission indicates that the members of that Commission did not recommend that the exclusion should be so absolutely rigid as is put down here. They suggested, "unless the court shall be of opinion that the consent of the landlord or the next superior landlord should not have been reasonably withheld if same is applied for." There is no such provision here, and the effect will be that in such cases as I have mentioned the landlord will get the benefit of any definite improvement. I think it is unreasonable that the landlord should get the benefit of that improvement in the circumstances to which I have referred. I have in mind cases where there was no definite objection made by the landlord to the improvement, and also cases where his consent was unreasonably withheld. I do not think sub-section (2) should stand in its present bald fashion without some qualifying phrase.

Comment on this

I will consider how far I could modify it. We are establishing the principle in this Bill that consent shall not be unreasonably withheld, and I will consider if I could modify it so as to take in very rare cases.

Comment on this

Perhaps the suggestion that Deputy Lemass made in connection with the last amendment would meet the case? That suggestion is "unless the court shall be of opinion that the tenant had certain justification for his action."

Comment on this

I will consider what can be done.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 33:—

"To delete sub-section (3)".

I think that in drafting this sub-section we went a little bit too far. A contract for a valuable consideration may be a contract for a very trifling consideration indeed, and I think it might work out that a tenant might have made a very substantial improvement and he would not be able to come in at the same time under the building lease portion of this Bill, and he might be cut out from getting the value of his improvements altogether. I think the landlord is adequately protected by Section 10 (2). That is the section which gives the landlord any value that he may get for such improvements as he himself has made.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 34:—

"In sub-section (6), line 56, to delete the figures `1919' and substitute the figures `1921'."

This is merely a verbal amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 35:

In sub-section (3), line 28, to insert after the word "certificate" the words "or order of the court under the foregoing sub-section."

I think this amendment is necessary also in order to correct the drafting of the Bill.

Sub-section (2) gives the tenant the right to come to the court for an order to the effect that the improvement had been carried out while the landlord has refused a certificate to that effect. Sub-section (3) provides that the improvement certificate shall be proof that the improvement has been carried out. The order of the court shall similarly be regarded as proof of that. It seems a defect in the drafting.

Comment on this

I do not think that this amendment is necessary. I do not see what further effect the Deputy wants than what is in the section. You have got your certificate.

Comment on this

The proposed sub-section deals with the case where a landlord refuses to give a certificate, in which case the tenant has the right to go to the court to get a certificate that the improvements were carried out.

Comment on this

That is the certificate.

Comment on this

It is not so described in the sub-section. It is described as an order of the court as distinct from the certificate and is not clear.

Comment on this

I think it is. As a matter of fact, if the Deputy just goes on to his next amendment——

Comment on this

I call the Minister's attention to the reading of the previous sub-section: "The court may make such order as justice shall require, including an order declaring that such improvement was duly made." It is not reasonable to say that that is necessarily to be an improvement certificate.

Comment on this

What does he proceed to the court for in that case? Is it not for an order to get the certificate?

Comment on this

To get the order.

Comment on this

To get a certificate.

Comment on this

Improvement certificate is defined in the Bill.

Comment on this

"The landlord of such tenant shall, on the application of such tenant within six months after the completion of such improvement, give to such tenant a certificate... in writing in the prescribed form." That is under sub-section (1) of this section. That is a document which the tenant has and that is the only document which he requires.

Comment on this

No. Sub-section (2) deals with the case where a tenant has duly applied under this section to his landlord for an improvement certificate, and such landlord does not give such certificate to such tenant within one month after such application, such tenant may apply to the court and get an order of the court to the effect that the improvement was duly made.

Comment on this

That will be the certificate.

Comment on this

If that is clear the amendment is not necessary. In fact, the purpose of the amendment is to make it clear that that order will have the same status as the certificate.

Comment on this

It is the certificate.

Comment on this

It is not clear.

Comment on this

If in sub-section (2) the wording were "and as the Court shall direct the landlord to give such certificate," this amendment would not be necessary. There is an order there instead of a certificate.

Comment on this

The improvement certificate mentioned in sub-section (2) of the section is qualified by the words "as against the landlord by whom it is given," so that it could not refer to an Order of the Court made under sub-section (2). Strictly speaking I do not think there is any necessity to bring in an Order of the Court within sub-section (3), because it is a matter of record as between the parties and would be conclusive as between them.

Comment on this

I move amendment 36, "to delete sub-section (4)." This sub-section provides that the landlord may withhold a certificate until he has received from the tenant the reasonable expenses incurred by him in relation to the giving of it. It is not a very big point but we think that the cost of meeting that certificate should be one of the obligations of ownership and should be defrayed by the landlord.

Comment on this

I do not think that would be fair because it is part of the tenant's title, one of the necessary proofs that a tenant has. The object of introducing this improvement certificate is to save a considerable amount of litigation between the landlord and tenant and it is entirely to the tenant's advantage that he should have this certificate as part of his title. I think it is only right, if he wishes a certificate, that he should pay for it. The landlord derives no advantage from the granting of the certificate.

Comment on this

I will not press the amendment if the Minister is accepting the next one in the name of Deputy O'Connell.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. J. O'Connell Labour Party

I move amendment 37:—

"In sub-section (4), line 37, to insert after the word `expenses' the words and brackets `(not exceeding twenty shillings)' and to delete lines 40 and 41."

I think even if the tenant has to pay the expenses there ought to be some reasonable figure named as the limit. I think we ought to put what we consider reasonable ourselves into the Bill and avoid all this going to the Court to have the amount determined and all that kind of thing. It is quite possible that the landlord may, for vexatious purposes, try and increase that Bill by adding all kinds of legal expenses and all that kind of thing. I think it would be well to make it a purely nominal charge.

Comment on this

I do not think it should be a nominal charge. It would be very difficult to say what would be a fair charge. If you fix the figure without knowing the exact amount of work which is to be done it is a most difficult thing to do. I think it is an impossible thing not only here but in other parts of the Act. There are amendments down but very much the same problem would arise. I do not think it would be possible to fix a definite figure as to what the expense of a certificate would be.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I think we can fix an upper limit.

Comment on this

What would expenses be? Would they include the employment of an architect by the landlord to report on the improvements?

Comment on this

It would depend very much. Suppose there is a very substantial improvement, say an improvement costing £700, £800, or £1,000, and that goes in. I think it would be reasonable that the landlord would see that such a very large sum of money had been properly expended and that he would have some expert advice. On the other hand, if it were a very small improvement I think the architect would be an unnecessary expense. Remember you would have to have something in the nature of a sliding scale of costs in that matter and it would be a matter rather more of expenses under the rules than of putting it in the statute.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I think something ought to be done to prevent the landlord building up an unnecessary bill against the tenant for the land certificate whether it is done in the rules or in the Act.

Comment on this

I am sure it is not suggested that the court will not be acting as fairly towards the tenant as towards the landlord.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

No.

Comment on this

It is provided in this sub-section that reasonable expenses incurred by the landlord shall be determined by the court. It is to be left to the court and I suggest the court is the proper authority to determine it.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

It is only in cases of dispute.

Comment on this

If there is no dispute there is no reason for us to fix any sum. It is only in case of dispute that the amount has to be fixed. If the Deputy is in a position to fix it, I think he is very lucky. I think it is a very difficult matter to declare, so difficult that I think it ought to be left to the court to be determined upon the merits of the case.

Comment on this

Is not there an inducement to the landlord to go to the court to claim higher expenses than the tenant should reasonably be expected to give, seeing that the tenant has got to bear the full cost of such litigation?

Comment on this

Might I suggest to the Minister that under Section 6 power is given to the Minister to make regulations regarding any matter that may be prescribed. It would seem that the question of mere expenses is a very small matter indeed to bring to the court, and if the parties had to go and contest the fee payable to the landlord in respect of the certificate, the amount involved in disputing that matter might be altogether greater than the amount payable to the landlord. I would suggest that the Minister would consider the maximum scale to be prescribed, and he can do that under the regulations which he is empowered to make under Section 6. It would depend on the amount expended on improvement in respect of which improvement it was sought.

Comment on this

I move amendment 38:

To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

"A memorial of every improvement certificate and of every order of the court under this section shall be entered by the landlord in the Registry of Deeds Office, Dublin, within one calendar month from the giving of such certificate or the issue in writing of such order or within such further time as the High Court or the Circuit Court may by order permit."

I think it is obvious that an amendment of this kind is necessary. The Minister himself proved it by his remarks on the amendment to Section 15. The purpose is to protect purchasers of property in respect of which the improvement certificate has been issued, to the extent of providing that such certificate will be registered and that it will be possible for them to ascertain its existence. If no such amendment is inserted in the Bill it might be possible for a dishonest vendor to withhold the information relating to that certificate from the purchaser and thus obtain an enhanced price.

Comment on this

I follow quite well what the Deputy is at and I might be able to meet him to a considerable extent, but as the amendment stands it would be completely impossible because in the Registry of Deeds they are regulated by certain statutes and you would have to amend right away the Registration Acts before you could have registration of certificates of this nature. Then there is a very elaborate procedure laid down in the Registry of Deeds because you are dealing with deeds of which you have to make an abstract and various other things. What I think might be done would be that there could be offices opened in the Circuit Courts where all these certificates could be filed and indexed. That would be a simple procedure. At the same time it would do away with the possibility of the tenant losing his certificate or after the lapse of many years its being forgotten, or anything of that kind, which may arise if an improvement is carried out. Twenty-five or thirty years afterwards when the improvements come to be valued what was done might be forgotten unless there was some place where the certificate could be left. I will see what can be done in the way of working in an amendment which will provide that the certificates may, if the tenant so desires, be filed in a local court.

Comment on this

I move amendment 39:—

In sub-section (1), (a), lines 50-51, to delete the word "partly" and substitute the words "to a substantial extent."

I suggest to the Minister that the term "wholly or partly" in lines 50 and 51 is too indefinite, that it really opens the door for the pretence of making an ordinary house into a business house. There should be some words such as I have indicated, to the effect that the business shall be of a substantial and true character. A case occurred, for instance, where somebody put up a bottle of sweets for sale in the window of a room and said he was carrying on a business. What is intended is that the premises are to be used in a substantial way for business purposes.

Comment on this

I think this is the most dangerous amendment that has been introduced in the whole debate, an amendment which the House could not possibly accept or the Minister could not possibly accept, because I feel sure if this amendment were accepted it would reduce the operation of the Bill practically to a mere farce. Anybody who represents the interests of the town tenants in this House could not accept the amendment proposed by Deputy Thrift. What does it mean? It means that a business premises where the ordinary tenant resides will be cut out from the operation of this Act. That is practically the meaning of it.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

All the little difficulties that Deputy Thrift appears to imagine exist, in my opinion, only in his imagination. The meaning of "business premises" is well known under the operation of the Rent Restrictions Act and I do not think there is any need for the deletion of this very important word in this section. I certainly ask the Minister not to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I agree with Deputy Byrne. I think that this amendment certainly should not be accepted. If it were accepted no one could be certain what was the precise meaning of the section until several cases had been fought out in court and decisions given. In view of the experience of the 1906 Act and of the danger that the intentions of the Oireachtas might be defeated by faulty drafting, I think we should try to be as crystal-clear as possible in everything we put into this Bill. The result of Deputy Thrift's amendment would be to make it uncertain as to what we were passing.

Comment on this

That is the very last thing that I desire. I think the words in the Bill open the door. I do not think any of the Deputies intend to suggest to the House that a pretence to be a business house should allow a premises to come under the provisions of the Bill in so far as it deals with business premises. Probably no Deputy means that, yet it would be perfectly easy for people to come in in a false way under the Bill. The indefinite word is the word that is in the Bill at present. I merely ask the Minister to make it clear that what he is legislating for are premises that are purely business premises and not for those that pretend to be business premises.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I think we have got the kernel of the word now—premises which are solely business premises.

Comment on this

I did not say "solely business premises."

Comment on this

I do not think the word "partly" to which Deputy Thrift objects really causes any matter of difficulty of construction because we have had examples of its use already in legislation dealing with houses and they have not offered any difficulty of construction to the courts. I do not think that what Deputy Thrift really desires in his amendment is to open, as it were, the door of inquiry into the character of the business which is conducted by a tenant. He said his motive in introducing this amendment was to close the door on certain frauds which might exist. As the sub-section is drafted, it deals merely with the user of the premises, what the ordinary person going into those premises would say they were used for. I certainly think that the only proper way, and the only satisfactory words under which any court could come to a conclusion, is where the tenement was used not in a complete manner for business purposes. The substitution of the words "to a substantial extent" for the word "partly" would undoubtedly open up an inquiry as to the volume of business and the character of business carried on by a tenant. For that reason, I would suggest that the amendment be rejected.

Comment on this

I am very much afraid that if this amendment were accepted the word "substantial" would be taken to mean a very large portion of the premises. Deputy Thrift is a little bit afraid of the word "partly" and cannot think of a better word. He admits that "substantial" is not a suitable word, and "substantial" would not be, because a very big business can be carried on in a comparatively small part of a premises. Personally, I do not think the word "partly" gives rise to any difficulty. It will have to be used partly as a business premises. It will not be used as a business premises if there is a jar of sweets in the window. The courts are not fools. No court will hold a premises to be a business premises unless there is actually a bona fide business being carried on in these premises. So we may take it to start with that the courts will satisfy themselves that a business is being carried on, and then they will decide as to whether it is a bona fide business or not. If they decide that it is a bona fide business, Deputy Thrift's difficulty will never arise. The only reason for putting in “wholly or partly” there means that part of the house may be a dwelling-house and that part of it may be a business premises. That is the real meaning of the words.

Comment on this

If there were any words in the Bill such as the Minister has used, that the premises were being in any way used as a bona fide business, I would be perfectly satisfied, but there are no such words there.

Comment on this

"Wholly or partly for the purpose of carrying on a business" means a real business.

Comment on this

Will the Minister undertake to look into it? I do not want to press the amendment, but I think we ought to do all we can to prevent advantage being taken of the word.

Comment on this

Very well, I will consider it without giving any undertaking.

Comment on this

I move amendment 40:

In sub-section (1) (a), line 51, to delete the word "therein."

This is designed to meet the case of persons such as doctors, lawyers, nurses, midwives, veterinary surgeons, certain insurance agents and certain commercial canvassers who might not be said to carry on their business in the premises, but, nevertheless, for whom the possession of a particular premises is a definite business asset. I can give a case of a nurse who has been residing for a number of years in a particular house. Her clients know that they can get her at that house whenever they require her services. It is as important for her to retain that address as it is for a business man to retain his shop. The possession of that house is a definite asset for her. Yet it could not be said that she carried on her business therein. It seems to me, therefore, that the section will be improved by the deletion of that word "therein." It would not weaken it in relation to ordinary business premises, and it would definitely provide that classes of the nature I have indicated would receive the protection which they require. These people would otherwise probably be regarded as in occupation of ordinary residential dwellings, and under the Bill as drafted would require forty years' occupation before becoming entitled to fixity of tenure. I think that these classes, to whom the possession of a well-known address is an asset, should be regarded as business people, and should be given the right of fixity of tenure after three years' occupation, as in the case of business premises.

Comment on this

I do not know that in fact there would be cases of what the Deputy says, because after all even a nurse who received telephone messages at a house or got messages at the door could be said to be carrying on part of a business therein and I think that certainly a barrister would carry on a considerable part of his business in his house, even though he did his work in court. I do not think from any point of view that the word "therein" is important, and I am perfectly willing that it should come out.

Comment on this

I move amendment 41:

In sub-section (1) (a), lines 51-52, to delete all words after the word "business" to and including the word "title," line 59.

The purpose of the amendment is to clarify the section, which in my opinion is badly drafted and liable to be misunderstood. If the words I propose to delete are struck out the paragraph would read as follows:—

Such tenant was, during the whole of the three years next preceding the termination of such tenancy, used by the tenant for the time being thereof wholly or partly for the purpose of carrying on therein a business.

These words, I think, express the intention of the paragraph and by the addition of a number of provisoes the Minister has succeeded in making it exceedingly ambiguous, that the right of fixity of tenure will be given in all cases to persons who have been in occupation of business premises for three years and using them for the purpose of business during that period. There are three different classes specified in the remaining portion of the paragraph (1) those holding under a tenancy from year to year; (2) those holding under a lease or under a contract of tenancy for a term of not less than five years; (3) those who hold a lease for a life or lives. The persons in these three classes if they have been in occupation of premises for business purposes for three years, get the right of fixity of tenure. It is obvious that there are certain classes omitted.

Anybody who has been in occupation of a tenancy for seven years gets a similar right. But I want to bring to the notice of the Minister a case similar to that which I mentioned on a previous section, of a person who might get a contract of tenancy for two, three or four years. The Minister says, and I agree, that such contracts are not usual, but if the Bill becomes law in its present form I think they will be fairly usual. A person who has a contract from year to year gets the right of fixity of tenure if he is there for three years. A person who has a contract operating for two years must have entered into that contract four times and must have been there for seven years before he gets the right of fixity of tenure. There is no sense in putting a person under a contract for two, three or four years in a worse position than a person under a contract for one year. I am satisfied that this is merely a fault in the drafting of the section, and that the whole section would be improved by the deletion of these words. I do not think that a person who holds under a contract of tenancy of less than year to year should be required to have seven years' occupation either. I think that a case of goodwill of substantial value might easily be built up in three years and he should not be deprived of it without compensation or good cause. That is the purpose of the amendment and I ask the Minister to accept it.

Comment on this

The Deputy is aware that this section is taken entirely from the report of the Town Tenants' Commission. The Town Tenants' Commission went into this matter very fully, and they have given us their report after they have heard the evidence on each side and after having heard the case put forward by every side. To begin with, I would be rather inclined to think these figures were chosen on an arbitrary basis, but you must have some sort of a figure somewhere. A person cannot go into a business premises for a month and then suddenly acquire rights in it.

Comment on this

He must be there for three years.

Comment on this

You have to take a figure; therefore you have to take three years. That is the figure that they arrived at and we have followed. Also they came to the conclusion that if there was a fixing for a definite period of time it was meant to expire at that termination, whereas a letting from year to year is a letting which in their view the parties have meant to continue for more than that particular period, but that when there is a letting for a definite short period then it was completely in the minds of both parties that a term should expire at the end of that short period. And therefore no tenant would take it who had any desire to build up a business on the premises, and there would be no bona-fide business built up and no bona-fide good-will. They having heard all the evidence came to the conclusion that these were the correct terms to fix, and I have not heard anything in what the Deputy has put forward that would lead me to consider that they who heard the evidence were wrong, and indeed I see no reason why we should abandon the figures that they so very carefully arrived at.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

One must, of course, attribute a good deal of weight to anything to be found in the report of the Commission that seems to have gone into this whole matter with such care and in such detail. But reading the report of the Commission, or reading this sub-section, the reason is not apparent for the exclusion of the two-yearly and three-yearly contracts. There may be a good sound reason, but it has not been revealed. I do not dissent in any way from some of the observations that have fallen from the Minister as to the practical results that would flow from that sub-section as it stands in the Bill if no attempt were made to misuse or to abuse the sub-section. It is fairly common knowledge that the Town Tenants Act of 1906 was defeated in many instances by conveyancing devices. The plain purport and intent of that Act was defeated by conveyancing devices, and the favourite device adopted was to make lettings from half-year to half-year, because the Act of 1906 provided that only yearly tenancies or greater really came within the ambit of the Act. Accordingly we found that all over the country the advisors of the landlords, quite legitimately, advised their clients, instead of making lettings from year to year, to make them from half-year to half-year and they would be outside the provisions of the statute. There was one estate where that prevailed to such a very large extent as to become a matter of widespread comment.

The reason that I draw the attention of the House to that is to show how this clause could be abused if it finds its way into this statute. We may find that a tenancy, apparently on paper quite all right for two years or three years, is made for the purpose of defeating this Act. It is quite possible, with a little ingenuity, that you merely need to have recurring tenancies of that duration with a merely trifling gap between them, or perhaps with only a notional or ideal gap between them, to defeat the purposes of the Bill. Some section of the House, or the whole House, might be glad if before the Minister would absolutely close the doors against this amendment that the House would be put in possession, either now or at some later stage, of the reasons that prompted the drafting of this section in what, at first sight at all events, seemed to be a very peculiar form, and that whatever is done, whether the amendment is accepted or not, that something should be done that would prevent these very extraordinary words being turned into an instrument for the complete defeasance of such an important section of the Bill as this is.

Comment on this

I have very little to add to what I have already said. There had to be some period fixed and the Commission fixed upon these periods. I am asked why these periods should go into the Bill. They go into the Bill because we consider there should be some period fixed, and that these are the periods which have been selected by the Commission after very careful thought. I completely agree with Deputy Geoghegan to this extent, that we should not be completely bound down by the findings of the Commission. The Commission sat and reported to this House, and then the duty, the obligation, of the House is to decide whether the Commission is right or wrong. It should not blindly follow the Commission, but if the Commission examined into the matter and heard the evidence, and if it is a Commission that we can trust, then it seems to me that prima facie the case is in favour of the Commission. They have balanced all the various reasons, and they thought that a person who merely goes into a house for a short time or for a definite and specific time should not be entitled to a renewal of the tenancy, because really the whole thing at issue here is a question of renewal of the tenancy in these business premises under Part III. of the Bill. It is not considered that a person who is only there for a very short time and who was meant by both parties to be only there for a short time, should then be entitled to be in practically for all time, and to have a renewal after renewal of the tenancy. Judge Meredith and the other members of the Commission decided that they would have to recommend a figure which would give a person in equity practically a permanent tenancy in a house. They fixed these figures. They heard, I suppose, a considerable amount of evidence. We must fix some figures, and they must be rather arbitrary figures. We want to have a reasonable time in equity for renewal. The mere walking in in the door would not do that. It is a difficult thing to lay down any definite time. I grant that the figure must be semi-arbitrary. The Commission laid down those figures, and I do not see any reason for departing from them.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

Speaking for myself I want to say that if there was embodied in the section the principle that has just been enunciated by the Minister I would be satisfied, that is if I rightly understand him. In the case of some tenant who was merely let into a house for a definite period of two, three or four years for a specific reason, more or less in the nature of an emergency or for convenience or for anything like that, then speaking for myself I see no very great reason why such a person should not be kept outside the provisions of this Bill. The words in the section as they stand would, I think, embrace a wider class than the Minister has indicated.

Comment on this

When I was speaking I did not refer to tenants holding under a temporary convenience. We discussed that question earlier in the afternoon at some great length.

Comment on this

It seems to me that the Minister is devoting his time to a defence of that part of this paragraph which is not being attacked. The essential part of it provides that a person who has been in occupation of business premises for three years and has during those three years carried on a business and built up a goodwill in the premises should be given fixity of tenure. No one has criticised that. As far as this party is concerned the period of three years is accepted as just and equitable. We agree that in any shorter period it could not be deemed that anything like a valuable goodwill could be built up. The question, however, is, should the three years' occupation for business purposes be not sufficient to give the tenant a right to a new tenancy, or must he hold under certain forms of contract or for certain periods as well? There are three classes of tenant provided for: those who hold under a yearly tenancy, those who hold under a tenancy of not less than five years, and those who hold under a tenancy for life or lives.

Comment on this

There may be tenants from month to month and week to week who would come in under it, too.

Comment on this

The right to a new tenancy after three years' occupation for business purposes is only given to the three classes I have mentioned. Those who hold from month to month or week to week must be seven years in occupation before they get that right, while those who hold under contract of tenancy for two, three or four years must have seven years' occupation. I feel sure that was not the intention of the Commission, that it was merely a defect in the drafting of their recommendations. I am sure that what they had in mind was that those who held yearly, or for a greater tenancy, should be entitled to a new tenancy if they had, in fact, been in occupation of business premises for three years, and, secondly, that those who held under a lesser tenancy should have seven years' occupation, during three years of which the premises had been used for business purposes.

It seems to me that if the paragraph was amended in that way it would be an improvement, although I suggest that even in the case of those who held for six months or from month to month that if they were three years in occupation for business purposes it should be sufficient. If a person holding from year to year can build up a valuable goodwill in business premises in three years, so can a person holding from six months to six months. In the case of the one as in the other they should be entitled to a new tenancy or, in default of that, to compensation in respect of disturbance if they are compelled to surrender the tenancy after the expiration of the three-year period. That is the purpose of the amendment.

Comment on this

I am afraid I cannot accept that.

Comment on this

I feel that if the section goes through in its present form we may find, when the Act comes to be put into operation, that the intention of the Oireachtas and the expressed intention of the Minister will be defeated by certain devices which can be easily contemplated. I would like to escape responsibility for letting it go through in that form.

Comment on this

I am afraid I cannot accept the amendment, though I would be prepared to consider a simplification of it if possible. The general principle of the amendment I could not accept.

Comment on this

Is the Minister adhering to the principle that a tenant who agrees to rent premises for three years may be debarred from the benefits of the Act, but that a yearly tenant is not to be so debarred?

Comment on this

The Commission put forward the view that in this country a tenancy from year to year is considered to be a continuing tenancy, and is, in fact, that. We all know that there are people holding for 50 and 60 years under a tenancy from year to year. On the other hand, a short tenancy for three years means that it was definitely in the minds of the parties at the time that the tenancy was going to be for three years and no longer. If it was not, then it goes on as a yearly tenancy. If they so decide to continue relations they always do so as yearly tenants.

Comment on this

In my experience the reverse prevails. In the case of premises that it is worth taking a tenancy of, most landlords will not consider any offer unless it is for a term of years.

Comment on this

A long term of years?

Comment on this

No. It depends entirely on the demand for the premises. Take a district like Marino. If there are a number of shops there a lot will depend on the demand there is for them, but it is quite possible that the landlord of one particular house would say—he is in a position to do so—"I am not going to let that house unless you take it for three years." The Minister's statement and his quotation from the Report of the Commission implies an inferior tenancy, one where the tenant comes along and fixes up a rent from year to year. The Minister's argument is utterly unconvincing. I very much doubt if the Dáil realised that is the question at issue that it would sanction what is proposed in the Bill.

Comment on this

I think the Minister should reconsider his attitude in this matter. It seems very unfair that a tenant in for three or four years should be put in a worse position than a tenant who is in from year to year. The tenant who goes in for three years to build up a business puts in expensive glass shelving in the hope that he is going to do good business and that he will stay there. If a tenant is doing a fairly good business the landlord takes it that the tenant is going to be there permanently. It is a cause of expense and a nuisance to a landlord to have tenants changing. That class of tenant should get the same privileges as a tenant from year to year. Looking at it from the point of view of one who has had some little experience in these matters, I think there is no comparison between a year-to-year tenancy and a three-years' tenancy. Much more importance is attached to a person who gets a three-year tenancy. In fact some landlords refuse to give any tenancy for less than three years.

Comment on this

I think I might be able to meet Deputies to an extent.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister would like time to consider it?

Comment on this

I will consider how I can simplify it.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

Possibly a tenancy from year to year or a greater tenancy would meet the case.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (1) (a), line 52, to delete the word "either" and in line 53 after the word "thereof" to insert the letter and brackets "(i)"; in line 54 after the word "or" where it first occurs to insert the letters and brackets "(ii)"; in line 55 after the word "or" to insert the letters and brackets "(iii)"; and in line 56 after the word "or" to insert the letters and brackets "(iv)."

This is a minor amendment, because someone expressed a doubt whether three years occupation of business premises govern seven years total occupation referred to in the latter part of the paragraph. The words in brackets were intended to be inserted to make it clear that it did. Some doubt was expressed as to the exact meaning of the section. Perhaps the Minister would consider the re-drafting of the section in order to clarify it.

Comment on this

I move:—

"In sub-section (1) (b), line 61, to delete the word `forty' and substitute the word `five.' "

We come up now against one of the vital provisions of the Bill.

Comment on this

I notice who is moving it.

Comment on this

The Bill requires that the tenant of residential premises must have been in occupation for forty years before he can secure fixity of tenure, and have the statutory right to demand a new tenancy from his landlord. As I said on the Second Reading debate, and as a number of people said before, and since, in this House and outside it, that period is altogether fantastic. I feel certain that the Minister does not hope to get the Bill through with that period in it. He is merely putting the figure high so that if he reduces it he will be appearing to concede more than he intends to concede. The amendment suggests that the period should be five years. It is suggested that a tenant who has been in occupation for five years, who fulfils all the other conditions required of him by the Bill, or by his contract of tenancy, should be given the right to a new tenancy subject to a rent to be fixed by the Court, as the Bill proposes, on the basis of free competition, and provided that the landlord does not require the premises under any of the paragraphs of Section 20.

Surely it cannot be contended that that is unreasonable. The tenant must be in every respect a good tenant. Whether or not the period be five years or forty years, his tenancy can be always terminated if he fails to pay the rent; if he violates any condition of his tenancy, if he surrenders his tenancy, or if his tenancy is terminated for any good or sufficient reason at all. Surely its terms are wide enough, although qualified to the extent that good and sufficient reason must emanate from him or be traceable to some action of his. The tenancy can be terminated under any one of the provisions I have mentioned. What is more, the landlord can at the end of the period escape from the obligation of giving a new tenancy altogether, if he satisfies the court that he intends or has agreed to rebuild or reconstruct premises; requires possession for the purpose of carrying out a scheme for the development of property; or if he could prove to the court that the retention of the premises by that tenant was not consistent with good estate management. Surely there are in this Bill sufficient loopholes for the landlord to escape from the obligations to give a new tenancy, or if he is obliged to give it to terminate that new tenancy.

To make the qualifying period suggested by the Minister, forty years seems altogether ridiculous. It is the Minister's contention, apparently, that a tenant who has been in occupation of the same dwelling-house for thirty years, who during that period paid the rent regularly, and observed all the conditions of his contract, who never gave the landlord any reason whatever to justify his ejectment, can, nevertheless, be ejected without reason stated at the end of the period. I am sure there are very few Deputies who will contend that that is either equitable or fair. We are not proposing to inflict any hardship on the landlord. The tenant to whom he will be obliged to give the new tenancy after five years by our amendment, if it goes through, must under this Bill be a person who paid him the highest rent he could get in free competition on the basis of vacant possession for the premises. The landlord is secured that rent by statute. If he had invested his money in industrial securities rather than in house property, he might have lost it in a happening such as the Hatry crisis, or lost a considerable portion of it in some industrial slump. But if he invested his money in house property after this Bill becomes law, he is secured by law, the highest return he could get on it on the basis of free competition subject to his observing the other conditions of the Act.

I want to urge upon the Dáil, and particularly on the Minister who, no doubt, has the decisive voice, why the amendment I propose should be accepted. There are other amendments dealing with ten years and twenty years. Any case made for them can be made with equal strength in favour of five years. Except that some qualifying period must be there, I would say that any tenant who goes into occupation of premises and complies with the conditions of Section 19, should be allowed to remain in occupation without fear of disturbance. In other words, it should not be at the discretion of the landlord to put out of occupation a tenant who is paying the rent, observing all the conditions of a contract of tenancy, and against whom the landlord cannot advance in the words of the Bill "any good and sufficient reason" for ejectment. That has been the demand of town tenants for a number of years. It was supported by people of all sections of the community as just, and I think the Dáil, to which the town tenants have been looking for the amendment of the Act of 1906, should not refuse them what they ask. I do not want to go into the matter at any greater length. I am sure most Deputies have received representations concerning this particular matter from their constituents, and from persons intimately affected by the proposals in the Bill. I am sure that the farmer Deputies in particular, who have secured not merely fixity of tenure, but the right to purchase for themselves, remember how the town tenants assisted them in fighting their battle against the landlords in the days of the Land League. They subscribed to the funds, went to jail, and did other things that made the land war successful, and they will not now turn down the town tenants when their own battle is being fought and reject reasonable claims which are being advanced on their behalf.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'Connell Labour Party

I support the amendment. May I explain to Deputy Lemass and the House that the amendments which are down in the names of some members of our party embodying ten, twenty, or other figures, have been put down in case this amendment embodying the period of five years is defeated.

Comment on this

You will not get £20 for a cow if you declare your intention of taking £10.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

It is always well to be prepared for the worst. I strongly support the views of Deputy Lemass. All through the years during which the town tenants have been agitating they always put in the forefront of their demands this claim of fixity of tenure, the right to their homes. It should be remembered that a person who lives in a house for ten, fifteen or twenty years, regards that house as a good deal more than four walls or a collection of bricks and mortar. It is a home, with all the associations which that word conjures up. It may be that when he got married he rented that house, lived there and reared his family there, and it has, as I say, all the associations for him which we associate with the word "home." There is much more than material interest involved. There is a sentimental interest. There is a feeling that if he is put out of that home, while he is willing and ready to meet all the obligations which he had undertaken, a grave injustice is being done to him. In essence, his claim is very much the same as that which the farmers put forward, fought for and won, forty or fifty years ago, namely, the right to their own homes.

It seems to me that there is no sound argument whatever for fixing the period at such abnormal length as forty years. No adequate case seems to have been made for it in the report of the Commission. Talking of the report of the Commission, it seems strange to me that the Minister, following so rigidly the recommendations of that report, has forgotten altogether the recommendations found on page 25. He has made provision in the case of business premises and accepted forty years and fifteen years in paragraph (c), but the recommendations in the third case, giving a right in seven years in certain conditions, has been left out altogether and nothing has been said about it.

Comment on this

That has reference to the Increase of Rent Act.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

The Minister brought in some sections to-day that had reference to that Act.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

In any case, the claim made in the amendment stands on its own legs. It is a very strong one, and I cannot see on what grounds Deputies could support the section as it stands, to the effect that a man who occupies a house for any period less than forty years has to go out, just on the ipse dixit of the landlord, without any right of renewal of tenancy or anything else. That is a most unjust and unfair proposition, and I hope that the good sense of the House will reject it and accept the amendment.

Comment on this

In the two Bills which I introduced here dealing with the matter of town tenants the principle of fixity of tenure was embodied. According to the sub-section as it stands, the period is fixed at forty years. I do not know how the Minister arrived at that figure. With the principle underlying this amendment I am in entire and strong agreement. What Deputy O'Connell has said must, of course, be admitted by everyone in this country. There is not a great shifting population in the Free State, such as exists in industrial nations like England and other countries. People have been residing in towns in the same houses for a very considerable period, but, at the same time, I do not think that it should be necessary that the period should be forty years. I think it is well that there are other amendments down here suggesting that the period might be longer than five years, if this amendment is defeated, and less than the forty years suggested in the sub-section. Possibly the Minister may be open to compromise on this matter as it is not really so much a question of principle. Perhaps a good deal of discussion might be saved if the Minister would be prepared to state now at the outset whether he is willing in any way to meet the proposers of these various amendments by suggesting a period less than forty years. That period does seem wrong and undoubtedly this Bill will lose a considerable amount of its effect if this section is passed without amendment. I think that the town tenants generally will regard the Bill as almost nugatory. I think that the period should not be as long as forty years. Perhaps something in the nature of a compromise say, ten or twenty years, would be acceptable to the Minister and also to the various proposers of these different amendments. There is really very little to say in favour of the forty years' proposal, and, perhaps, there is also little to say in favour of the five years' period.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

Because five years is a very short time. I think there might be a compromise arrived at and that would shorten the proceedings here. The debate is being conducted in a very amicable fashion here and we have, in fact, refused to go into the Division Lobby several times. I trust that the Minister will be prepared to continue the good work he is doing and bend to some extent to the views expressed by the proposer of the amendment.

Comment on this

I see great danger in the amendment if it is passed. The section itself even is objectionable. We must bear in mind the fact that there are very poor people who are judicially, and perhaps unavoidably, described as landlords in this Bill. There is the case of an owner who owns only one house which might be worth from £500 to £700, and which was bought, not for the purpose of rent-charging or earning dividends, but with a view to occupation by the purchaser at some time. The Rent Restrictions Act, however, was passed and prevented that. I know widows owning houses from £500 to £700, or perhaps £1,000, who have to keep orphans on some £60 or £70 a year— you can call them landlords or landladies if you like. In the event of their wanting to sell such houses the provisions in the section, which is further aggravated by this amendment, will prevent them selling the house in the very open market in which they bought it. I have an amendment down later dealing with this class of house. I think it would be very unfair to such people of whom I speak. We have been appealed to in this case on the ground of fixity of tenure.

The farmers are appealed to. I am a farmer myself, in addition to following other occupations of not much profit to me. There is no analogy between the two cases. In fact the analogy with the farmer lies in the case of the owner of the house whom I described. Such owners came into ownership either by purchase or perhaps through a dead husband, as in the case of the widows of whom I speak, building the houses. Are you going to tell the farmers of Ireland who came into the possession of their houses, or who have inherited their farms, that you are going to restrict their market in the case of sale? Are you going to say that they cannot sell their farms to the highest bidders? If the amendment is carried it will mean this in the case of these very poor people—I could cite the case of lots of them—it will mean that if they put up their houses for sale—they may have to put them up and be compelled to do it—they will have to take any price the occupying tenant offers. I doubt, having put that case before you, whether you will at least include these people. So far as the owner of twenty or thirty houses is concerned, he has them merely for the legitimate rent profit. He does not sell them, and I cannot imagine him, if he has a good tenant, being in the least anxious to get rid of that tenant. In regard to the cases I have mentioned, the section in the first place is at fault, and the amendment makes it very much worse. If you are talking of any compromise, you ought to bear in mind the very poor people I have mentioned.

Comment on this

Might I say in reply to Deputy Dr. Hennessy that the case is not as black as he paints it because under this Bill, to begin with, the rent is fixed according to the market value and in the open market that man will sell for the capitalised value of the rent of his house. It does slightly restrict the market because he cannot sell it to a person who may want to occupy the house, but the market value of it is made fairly stable under the Bill and if the occupier wants to buy it he buys it at that figure. If he does not buy it, it may be sold in the open market and he sells it at the capitalised value of the rent to the new landlord. Provided a person who owns the house gets a fixed rent out of the house, if there is a good tenant in it, I cannot see that any grievance is incurred by such a landlord. As a matter of fact, the particular section with which we are dealing has done more to discredit the Bill than almost any other section in it. People all over the country, one might almost say, have ceased to take an interest in the Town Tenants' Bill when they heard that the terms in the case of householders meant that they should have had a tenancy lasting for forty years. If I wanted to be malicious with the Minister, I would request him not to make any compromise, but to stick to the period of forty years. I am sorry that Deputy Redmond did not take up as strong a stand as he did on another Town Tenants' Bill because we want to pull as hard as we can in this House in order to get the fairest bargain for the tenant. I think that so long as houses remain a good investment from the landlord's viewpoint no great grievance is suffered by the landlord, and, on the other hand, the amendment gives security of tenure to the tenant, which he has never enjoyed before.

Comment on this

I am rather surprised at the speech delivered by Deputy Dr. Hennessy and also by the speech delivered by Deputy Redmond. I remember being in the House in 1924 and again I think in 1926, and, speaking from recollection, I am sure that at that time, if even the five years qualifying period were suggested, Deputy Redmond would hardly be prepared to accept it, because as the Deputy knows quite well one of the main planks, if not the main plank, in the platform of the Town Tenants' organisation for over thirty years has been security of tenure in the home. As Deputy Lemass and Deputy Little have pointed out, the landlord's interest is safeguarded very fully under the Bill in Section 19. What we are asking is merely this: that after a period of five years—and surely the landlord should be satisfied within a period of five years whether the tenant is or is not a satisfactory tenant—the tenant should have security in his home as long as he paid the rent, and satisfied all the conditions laid down by the law. We hear a good deal of talk in this country from Ministers and others about the necessity for stability, and the necessity for good citizenship, about people having a stake in the country so that they may have some interest in it, with all of which I agree.

I ask the House how can we expect a man to become a good citizen, or how can we expect him to have a stake in the country if he feels that, notwithstanding the fact that he has complied with all that is required of him towards his landlord and paid his rent, he does not know the moment he is going to be evicted? I put it to Deputy Dr. Hennessy, as a farmer, that if, notwithstanding the fact that he is paying rent for his farm and for his house for a period of 30 years to the Land Commission as his landlord, let us say, and that during that time he has worked his farm to the best advantage, that he has paid for the house and paid his rent and rates punctually, and that at the end of 30 years he gets notice to quit——

Comment on this

I would have the right to sell in the open market.

Comment on this

We are not asking for all the rights the farmers have at the present moment. All we ask is that there should be a clause in the Bill to give the tenants the right to become the owners of their houses.

Comment on this

There is no analogy. The only analogy would be with the eleven months' grazier.

Comment on this

I put it to Deputy Dr. Hennessy, if he were a tenant of a house here in the City of Dublin for which he was paying £100 a year, a good tenant, that he paid his rent regularly, that he had lived in the house for ten, twenty or twenty-five years, and that at the end of that time the landlord, for no reason, served notice to quit on him, would he not be satisfied that he had a great grievance against that landlord?

Comment on this

He might desire to sell the house to pay the debts due by him to the State. That is what I wanted to advert to.

Comment on this

Deputy Hennessy wants us to enable him to take full advantage of the shortage of houses for the purpose of profiteering.

Comment on this

I want to put it from the other point of view. Deputy Dr. Hennessy is talking about the landlord or the landlady who is the landlord of one house. These are not very many, taking them with regard to the whole number, but I think he should remember that this section affects hundreds of thousands of householders throughout the country at the moment and if and when the Rent and Mortgage Interest (Restrictions) Act ceases to operate it will affect hundreds and hundreds of thousands. So far as the town tenants of this country are concerned—and when I say town tenants I am thinking of the ordinary residents in towns not so much the business houses—they are covered by this section. I am thinking of those and it is for that reason I say that this is the most important section of the Bill for us. I move to report progress.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say when the debate on this Bill is likely to be resumed?

Comment on this

I cannot say now.

Comment on this