We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Public Business. - Apprenticeship Bill, 1930—Committee.

Contributions 1–220 of 443. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Apprenticeship Bill, 1930
Enacted

No. 22 of 1930 ›

I move amendment No. 1.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

If amendment No. 1 is carried, the word "craft" will be deleted and the other words inserted, so that unless amendment No. 2 is met by amendment No. 1, I will have to put the question in a somewhat different form. Perhaps we could take amendments 1, 2, 3 and 4 together, as they all deal with the definition and then put a question, so as to save No. 2.

Comment on this

I am simply moving amendment No. 1 because it was pointed out on Second Reading that certain people had doubts whether or not a branch of a trade was being brought in under the definition, and I am moving to have it brought in.

Comment on this

As regards amendment No. 2 the intention in including a profession is to make it possible to have a profession like the nursing profession become a designated trade and to have the admission of apprentices into that profession regulated in a manner such as that suggested in the Bill. It appears that in that particular profession, at any rate, there is need for some such regulation, and it was thought, when the Bill was going through the Dáil, the opportunity should be availed of for doing that.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment 1 also apparently covers amendments 3 and 4. There is no doubt about that. If the word "occupation" be held to include "profession," it meets amendment No. 2.

Comment on this

A decision on the word "occupation" would meet the position, I think.

Comment on this

It meets the position so far as nurses are concerned, but not dentists, as we do not want them in.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment 5 is one of a number of amendments in the name of Deputy Good, dealing with the same point. I think the point raised in the amendment arises out of amendment 6, which proposes to insert a new section. Our practice has been to leave over amendments to the definition section, and take main amendments where they occur in the Bill. If amendment 6 is carried, a consequential amendment must be made in the definition section. I propose to leave over amendment 5 and to take the discussion generally, and a decision on amendment 6.

Comment on this

I am not so sure that that meets the point. In amendment 5, Deputy Good proposes to delete lines 14 to 22 inclusive. That is to say, he wants to take away the distinction between trade board trades and the others.

Comment on this

I want to take trade boards out of the Bill altogether.

Comment on this

If Deputy Good's amendment 6 is beaten, the Deputy is then, I think, precluded from getting trade boards out of the Bill altogether.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy cannot get them out of the Bill in the definition section. There are other parts of the Bill where they come in—in amendments 7 and 10 for instance. We can take them on the operative part of the Bill.

Comment on this

I move amendment 6:

Before Section 2 to insert a new section as follows:—

"The provisions of this Act shall only apply in respect of apprenticeship to any trade or branch of trade designated by the Minister after consultation with the Apprenticeship Committee appointed under this Act in any industry (hereinafter referred to as a Scheduled Industry) specified in the Second Schedule to this Act. Any such trade or branch of a trade is hereinafter referred to as a designated trade."

As I pointed out on the Second Reading a number of very difficult problems arise in connection with this Bill. The amendment I have moved proposes to deal with one of them. Deputies are aware that the Bill differs from the recommendations made in the report of the Technical Education Commission. On the Second Reading the Minister was somewhat doubtful about that. I hope that since then he has looked into the matter. The members of that Commission had no doubt in their minds as to what their intentions were. Their intentions were that the Apprenticeship Bill should become a compulsory Act. The Minister told us on the Second Reading that the basis of the Bill was a voluntary one. My difficulty has been to try and alter its character and make it compulsory. I am not so sure that the amendments I have put down will achieve the object I have in view. The amendment before the House has been taken from the South African Act, the Act that was recommended by the Commission in their Report. The difference in the method adopted by the Commission and the method adopted by the Minister was to some extent pointed out on the Second Reading. Attached to the South African Act is a schedule which sets out the different industries to which the Act applies. That schedule helps to get rid of the difficulty of interpreting such words as "business" and "craft" that occur in Section 1.

If my amendment is carried it will, I take it, amount to approval of the schedule in some form and that will have the effect of putting before the Minister the views of the House as to what particular trades should come within the operation of this measure when it becomes an Act. The way my amendment, if accepted, will work is this: that the House, having approved of the application of this Act to these particular trades, it will then be left in the hands of the Minister to deal with what are known as designated trades in the manner set out in the Bill. I suppose he will take a limited number of them to start with. After that these trades will come under the operation of the Act in accordance with the terms of subsequent sections. As to the principle of compulsion, what I would like to point out to the Minister is this—that the voluntary system has had a fair and reasonable trial. It is the system, so far as apprenticeship is concerned, that has been in existence for at least half a century. The system, as we found from figures put before the Commission, did not achieve the object it set out to achieve. In other words, it failed. I should like to give again the figures that I put before the House on the Second Reading of the Bill in support of that statement. It is set out in the Report of the Commission that there are 9,282 craftsmen engaged in the building industry, taking that as an example. In a return furnished by the Minister's Department it is stated that there are 961 apprentices in that particular industry in the Saorstát. I pointed out that if we had the number of apprentices that we should have in that particular industry in order to keep it up to normal level that figure, instead of being 961, should be 3,304. These figures, I am sorry to say, were questioned by a number of Deputies, including members on the Labour Benches. I hope that since the debate on the Second Reading took place the Deputies who questioned the figures I gave have looked into the matter and satisfied themselves as to their accuracy. On that occasion I said that the number of apprentices to the number of craftsmen engaged in the industry in order to keep it up to normal level should be one apprentice to every three craftsmen.

If they consulted anyone in close touch with the problem I think they would find that while it may be necessary to have a larger proportion in some trades—what we call the shortlife industries—on the average, that is the figure approved by those who have studied it. I hope before we have any other further questions on that issue from those representatives that they will give us some details in support of their contention, if they still question that figure. It is a figure that I have examined, not for the first time, and I am satisfied that it is an accurate one. Taking that figure as the basis, we see at once that the voluntary system has not produced the goods. In other words, where we should have 3,304 apprentices in an industry we have only 961. That being so, I am quite satisfied that the voluntary system has had a fair trial, and that it is a failure, and for that reason, something much more drastic is necessary if we are to deal with this problem in the way it should be dealt with.

I am afraid in dealing with this question some Deputies did not realise the importance or the magnitude of it. Under the recommendation of the Commission, vocational schools were set up for dealing with the training of these young people, so as to make them more adaptable to industry. I am afraid, even in connection with vocational training, that the House is not aware—and this is a point that bears on the Bill before us, and particularly on the amendment—of the magnitude of the problem now before the various vocational committees in the Saorstát. The Department of Education, under whose jurisdiction vocational committees work, has pointed out to them quite recently in a statement that there are 120,000 young persons in the Free State within the ages of fourteen and sixteen, and that 45,000 of these are in primary and secondary schools. The task of dealing with the balance of 75,000 is the task of the vocational committees. I mention that figure in order to give the House some idea of the magnitude of the problem we are dealing with.

It is quite obvious to anyone who has even looked into the question casually that if these Vocational Schools are to function, and to do useful work, avenues must be opened to give employment to many at present unemployed, and who cannot get into an industry. If we do not succeed in opening up these avenues to industry, then the money that we are spending on vocational education is not going to do any good. The success of the Vocational Education Act very largely depends upon this Bill. If this Bill does not open up avenues to employment at present closed, then, a great deal of the money being voted, and that will be voted in the future for vocational education will be wasted. Therefore, I say, that this particular Bill and this method of dealing with this difficult subject, is of vital importance to the State.

I am particularly anxious that in discussing a problem of this character, it should not be discussed in any sense as a political problem. I would like to see the views of the different parties given freely in order to try to achieve in that way the object we have in view. I would like to mention that it has been pointed out in a resolution passed by the Advisory Committee on Juvenile Employment in Cork—a very active Committee, which has done very good work in the past—that many of the boys and girls emigrated in the past, and in that way eased the problem, but they cannot emigrate in the future, for reasons that I need not go into. That adds to the difficulty. We cannot throw these people who cannot emigrate on the scrap heap. We must provide some opportunity whereby their services can be availed of, if not in this country, in some other country. From that point of view I would like to urge on the House that I am satisfied the only way we can deal successfully with this problem is in the way recommended by the Commission on Technical Education, and that is through the medium of a compulsory Apprenticeship Bill. The underlying principle in this amendment is compulsion. Whether it will achieve its object is another question. I would like the amendment to be discussed on that principle—that of compulsion as opposed to the voluntary system.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

Deputy Good in his statement referred to the necessity of finding employment for our young people in industry. I am entirely with him in that. It is essential that we should do so. The Deputy said that unless this Bill opens up avenues to industry it is of no use. I suggest that it is not by means of this Bill we will open up these avenues to industry. It does not seem to me to be a reasonable or a sensible method to put these boys into industry, and to find suitable means of livelihood for them, merely to secure by a compulsory measure that they will be apprenticed to a trade and learn a craft without having any guarantee that employment will be found for them in that trade when they reach the age for employment. Deputy Good talked of the proportion of apprentices to skilled men in a particular trade. I suggested on the last occasion that any figure of the kind would be a purely arbitrary figure, and nothing else. I do not care if the figure were one to three or one to four. It is an arbitrary figure and no proof can be adduced to show that it is the right figure. I suggest that the principle which should govern the matter cannot be fixed arbitrarily. These young people must depend upon the chance there is in a particular trade, having regard to the development of business generally and the movement in industry. All such considerations must depend on whether there is to be an opportunity for the employment of all these people afterwards at remunerative work.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy apply the same argument to the professions?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

Certainly, if I could do so.

Comment on this

I would like to see it done.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

To some of the professions, anyhow.

Comment on this

What about the profession of the Dáil?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I do not purport to speak on this matter with the special knowledge which Deputy Good and others have of craft trades, but it appears to me that the figures he gave in regard to the proportion of apprentices to skilled men are absurd on the basis, as I reason it out, that if five years were the normal period of apprenticeship there would be a completely new staff every fifteen years. That would mean that the ordinary life of the average workman would be fifteen years and that he would have to clear out then and have his place filled by some of the apprentices that would be coming along. That would appear to me, although I do not profess to have any intimate knowledge of these matters, to be absurd. In any case I do not feel that it is possible at this stage to provide a workable scheme on the basis of compulsion unless we go very much further than, I imagine, Deputy Good would be prepared to go, because, as I mentioned on Second Reading, if you are going to control the entrance of people into industry you cannot leave them there. If you force them, through a system of apprenticeship, into industry you must do that which is anathema to Deputy Good, namely, you must have a considerable measure of State interference in industry to ensure that the people you have brought into a particular industry must compulsorily be provided with employment. Deputy Good, of course, will not go that far.

Comment on this

There is no compulsion on any boy. You are only giving him the opportunity.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

There is much more than that.

Comment on this

No more than making a teacher of him.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

There is more in the suggestion which Deputy Good puts forward. He said that the voluntary system has had a fair trial. I do not think that it has had anything in the nature of a trial such as is proposed under this Bill. He refers to only one or two particular trades. I think that the principle which is enshrined in this Bill ought to be given a fair trial and, if and when it proves to be a failure, let us try other and different methods, but let us then be prepared to proceed to go on with what will be the logical consequence of these things if they are carried out along the lines which Deputy Good suggests.

Comment on this

I understand Deputy O'Connell's attitude to be this, namely, that he would be in favour of a compulsory system if a workable scheme could be devised, that his objection to the amendment is that it is not workable and would necessitate undue interference by the State in industry. I do not think that it is possible to devise a workable scheme, nor do I think that Deputy Good has found one. Although I am in sympathy with the idea of compulsion which Deputy Good is advocating, I do not think that his amendment is one that could be passed. Deputy Good's statement, which is based on the report of the Commission, that the present voluntary system of regulating apprenticeship is not suitable to modern needs can, I think, be controverted. Deputy O'Connell has asked that the principle of the Bill be given a fair trial. It is practically impossible to say what the principle is. The Minister has not shown his hand at all. He has not indicated any policy in respect of apprenticeship. He has merely devised a machine for regulating the work of apprenticeship committees which may be established in connection with certain industries. I saw it stated in an article in a weekly journal that this Bill is a typical product of a Civil Service department in so far as it exalts the machine into a matter of policy and makes the principle something in the nature of a secondary consideration.

Deputy Good's amendment, in so far as it desires to introduce the principle of compulsion into the Bill, is, in my opinion, worthy of support. The particular method, however, which he has adopted, namely, of scheduling a number of industries and saying that the Bill shall apply to them at the discretion of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, is not, in my opinion, the best method. I dislike the scheduling of industries in a Bill of this kind, in the first place, because one always has the idea that certain industries may be omitted, and I think that in Deputy Good's list certain industries are omitted. The idea in the Bill is to have it apply to any industry which comes within the definition in Section 1, subject to certain steps being taken and, in my opinion, that is a better method. Amendment 8, in my name, suggests that the Minister should be given power to apply the Bill in respect of an industry to which he thinks it should be applied but in respect of which no application has been received by him. That would meet the principle which Deputy Good is advocating. That amendment, in my opinion, does not carry any of the disadvantages which attach to his. The main point we must settle is whether or not apprenticeship is to be compulsorily regulated. The present system, as Deputy Good says, has had a fair trial. This Bill is based on that system. We have conditions of apprenticeship in a number of industries regulated voluntarily. The Bill is to standardise methods of regulation and to give uniform constitutions to the committees, if there are such, in relation to particular industries in connection with apprenticeship.

The purpose of Deputy Good, with which I am in sympathy, is to provide that where, in the opinion of the Minister, it is necessary that the conditions of apprenticeship, as defined in Section 8, should be regulated, that he should have power to regulate them whether or not those engaged in the industry want such regulations. We have given examples of industries in respect of which we think that it is unlikely that application for designation will be made either by employers or employees. There may not be many such industries but it is in relation to any such as exist that the need for regulation is most urgent. That is why we would like to see the Minister having power, no matter what method is adopted of giving it to him, to apply this Bill, where he thinks it should be applied and not to depend on actions taken by other persons in order to have it put into operation.

Comment on this

I would like a further explanation both from Deputy Good and Deputy O'Connell. If the case made by Deputy Good, that in a particular industry there are only 900 odd apprentices when there ought to be 3,000, is well-founded and if that is typical of industry in general, then a good case has been made for something even more drastic than that contained in the Bill. That is where we are in difficulty. Deputy Good has given us an obiter dictum of three to one but he has not put forward, so far as I know, any basis on which he forms that belief. Deputy O'Connell, when challenged to examine that, said that it was simply absurd. As between the ipse dixit of Deputy O'Connell and Deputy Good I am not prepared to make a judgment. Neither of them is entitled to ask the House to decide merely on his obiter. Either of them has not put forward a case showing the basis upon which he makes his calculation. Deputy O'Connell calculated that on Deputy Good's basis the life, the employable time of a workman is only fifteen years. That is on the assumption that there would be no wastage in the apprenticeship, in the labour ranks or that there was no expansion in industry. Neither of these two propositions can be accepted. There is bound to be wastage and there must be expansion. If there is not expansion then we are faced with the whole of our unemigratable population who will either have to starve or be a load on pre-existing production so that we cannot assume either of the propositions. In regard to Deputy O'Connell's estimate of fifteen years, we have no evidence whatever apart from the statement made by Deputy Good in relation to the proportion of apprentices. Merely as a student in the matter who wants to know on which side to vote, I would be glad if either one or the other of these Deputies would effectively show his hand.

Comment on this

Deputy Good has told us that this amendment is intended to bring in the principle of compulsion. I think he realises himself that it does not achieve his object. He says further that it is in line with the report of the Commission and he has said both on Second Reading and again to-day, that the report of the Commission was in favour of the compulsory system. I think that is really one of the reasons why Deputy Good finds himself in a difficulty. He has put down an amendment which he says will bring in the principle of the South African Act, but the South African Act principle is not one of compulsion. What did the Report which Deputy Good himself signed say? The Report on page 72 refers to the South African Act in these terms:

In the Union of South Africa under the provisions of the Apprenticeship Act, apprenticeship became compulsory in such trades as decide, under advisory powers vested in special apprenticeship Committees, to adopt the provisions of the Act.

That is exactly the system we are trying to carry out. We have omitted one part of it. We did not schedule trades. The fact that Deputy Good's amendment does schedule trades, prevents not merely compulsion but prevents the voluntary system being ever applied to a trade if it is not included in his schedule. The Report did not recommend a compulsory system. It recommended something like what we have here. The amendment did not introduce a compulsory system but the aim of the Deputy is a compulsory system.

Comment on this

What part of the Report has the Minister read from?

Comment on this

Page 73, paragraph 163.

Comment on this

I think that visualises a compulsory system.

Comment on this

May I read it again:

In the Union of South Africa, under the provisions of the Apprenticeship Act, apprenticeship became compulsory in such trades as decide, under advisory powers vested in special apprenticeship Committees, to adopt the provisions of the Act.

That is not compulsory.

Comment on this

What is the meaning of the next sentence?

Comment on this

"A trade designated by the Minister of Mines and Industries, on the advice of a Committee, becomes subject to the law." Certainly an apprenticeship Committee is set up just as Deputy Good has proposed. Deputy Good proposes to establish apprenticeship Committees in certain designated trades, and then his amendment says that the Minister shall consult with those Committees, and after consultation the trade may be designated. Supposing an apprenticeship Committee which is established for the purpose of deciding whether or not designation shall apply to a trade says "yes" that is exactly the difficulty, I have not got a Commitee either of representatives of the employers or employees unless they appeal to me. Supposing a Committee which has been set up says after consultation with the Minister "we do not want to become designated," what is the Minister to do? Deputy Good's amendment leaves it to him either to leave it undesignated or to go on and designate it. The South African Act certainly recognises that the consultation is to be more or less approved by the Committee before designation comes about. I think the scheme of the South African Act is definitely the scheme we have here with the single exception that we do not schedule trades. Deputy Good's amendment schedules a trade in order to set up a Committee to advise the Minister whether or not the trade shall be designated, and so to have all the provisions of the Act applied. That is a limitation. At the moment I have the whole field of industry open to me. If I accept the amendment I am confined to those schedules, however wide and comprehensive the field may be. At any rate nobody has faced up to the difficulties or the difficulties of the compulsory system.

Deputy Good asked for compulsion on the basis that there are certain numbers of people leaving school every year, that these people are not brought into industry, that they cannot emigrate, and that they are going to be a burden on the community, but he does not show, and nobody has attempted to show, in fact it is not possible to show, that this Bill is a Bill with the intention of extending industries. That has to be done by other methods than these. The Bill is simply that when certain conditions arise we are going to see that apprenticeship of a particular type, better suited to present conditions, shall apply. Training will be given, suitable to the conditions in modern industry. The Bill does not attempt to extend industry. That is not part of its function. Deputy Flinn has remarked on Deputy Good's contribution to the debate that if there are less apprentices in a particular industry, and if it is typical of the industry, then something drastic must be done. Deputy Lemass remarked that the Report was a typical Civil Service production.

Comment on this

That was a quotation.

Comment on this

It was a quotation which the Deputy read to the House without showing any disapproval. The comments made by Deputy Lemass and Deputy Flinn are typical of the Opposition in Parliament. Something drastic must be done according to Deputy Flinn. Deputy Lemass says: "Accept my amendment and if after two years an appeal is not made for designation, the Minister may designate and have the whole conditions of the Bill operate." What are the conditions of the Bill? A Committee is set up which will in the first instance draw up regulations with regard to educational qualifications and so on. Supposing after two years, if the amendment of Deputy Lemass were accepted, an appeal has not come either from the employers or the employees in a particular industry, I may not have been able to induce an appeal from the employers or employees after two years——

Comment on this

The Minister said something now that he has not said before.

Comment on this

Leaving that out, it is open to me to induce it under the Bill. Supposing I have fallen asleep and nothing comes in, I may establish a Committee. Neither workers nor employers have moved in the matter and I establish a Committee. Supposing one or the other does not want apprenticeship conditions how do I get the Committee?

Comment on this

How do you get it if one side wants it and the other side does not?

Comment on this

Supposing that neither party has moved, what am I to do? What am I going to do to establish a Committee? I will not establish a Committee representing only one side, even under the present Bill. If one side so vehemently objects, and if I see that they are not going to act, obviously I cannot set up a Committee. What am I going to do in the Deputy's case?

Comment on this

It depends on the reason for failure; it may be that the workers are not organised.

Comment on this

Deputy Flinn says that something more drastic ought to be done. What could be done that would be more drastic?

Comment on this

The Minister, apparently, misunderstood my remarks. I suggested that a case had not been made by Deputy Good in so far as the Deputy did not give the basis upon which his own arguments were founded.

Comment on this

One of the Deputy's conclusions was that if there are less apprentices than there should be, and if that is typical of the industry, then something drastic ought to be done. We will leave that as a contribution to the necessity for compulsion. Deputy Lemass thinks that this carries on the existing system.

Comment on this

The principle.

Comment on this

According to the Deputy, it carries on the principle. It will be seen that the old conditions in regard to apprenticeship, indenture, long period of service, etc., had no application to certain industries. These industries are carried on by people who adopt different methods of training to the old apprenticeship conditions. This gets away from the old conditions as we knew them, conditions that were distinctly a question of a boy being apprenticed under rigid terms, it being left to his parents or guardian, or a trade union, or between those people and the employer, to see that the conditions were carried out. The conditions set out under this Bill gave us the best approach that can be got to something intermediate, something between the old lax and rather bad system of apprenticeship and the compulsory system that has been referred to. We suggest here a committee and we get employers and employees, in equal numbers on that committee. Associated with them we have one or three representatives of the public. The public representatives will try to get both parties to draw up suitable conditions. Once the committee is set up, we make it compulsory that conditions should be drawn up with regard to four items and then we say that there are other things about which regulations may be drawn. By the setting up of this committee we bring about a discussion in a friendly way as between representatives of the employers and the employees, always with an audience of impartial people composed of one or three representatives of the general public.

I think that system ought to be given a fair trial before people put forward suggestions about something drastic being done or about the formation of a compulsory system. It is open to me, under the Bill, to introduce representations where I think representations ought to be introduced. It may be that neither the employers nor the employees consider it desirable to have a particular trade designated. In such a case compulsion is no good. If both employers and employees are against a system, there is no advantage in going against their wishes. Our aim is to get both parties on a committee and associate with them members of the public, selected impartially. They can then try to get apprenticeship conditions drawn up. I plead distinctly for the terms in the Bill as showing a better appreciation of the conditions under which modern industry is carried out, and as giving a better approach in a conciliatory way to both employers and employees. As I have already indicated, members of the public will sit on the committee and endeavour to bring both parties together. This is much better than a compulsory system, which would only break down. No case has been made for compulsion, and compulsion should only be resorted to, if it is considered necessary, when thorough investigation has been made by the committee of the situation.

Comment on this

The Minister says that no case has been made for a change in the present principle. We must admit that the present principle is a voluntary principle. I have made a case to show that the voluntary principle has failed to achieve the results expected of it. I do not think one can do anything more than produce the figures compiled by the Minister's Department. I have produced those figures and, on the face of them, I have submitted a definite case to the House. I have given the figures exactly as they were given to the Commission by the Minister's Department. Those figures bear only one interpretation.

Comment on this

Is the 3,000 figure a Department figure?

Comment on this

It is the figure given by the Department to the Commission. I read the Report of the Commission and I gave the figures to the House. To say, in face of those figures, that there has not been a case established showing that the voluntary system has failed is to say something which is not true.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

Does Deputy Good say that there ought to be 3,304 apprentices?

Comment on this

That is the question I asked Deputy Good. The Deputy probably misunderstood me.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Connell declared that what you want to provide for those people is employment. With all respect to the Deputy, I emphasise that you want to put these young people first in the way of being employed.

Comment on this

Organise a continuous building scheme—a national scheme.

Comment on this

We will hear the Deputy later on about a continuous scheme. I want to put the young people in the way of being employed; I want to get them into the different trades which are now closed to them. Will Deputy O'Connell, or Deputy Anthony, tell me how a boy, anxious to become a bricklayer should proceed? How should a boy anxious to become a plumber proceed? We have thousands of young people in the country anxious to follow some employment. Some of them, doubtless, have a special aptitude for particular industries. How are we going to get them into these industries?

Comment on this

What are we going to do with all the idle people?

Comment on this

We would not have so many idle people if those avenues to employment were all open at the moment. I would like to point out the difference between young people going into industry and young people going into a profession. Let us take the profession of teaching. Is there any limitation to the number of young people who go into the teaching profession?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

There is a very strict limitation.

Comment on this

There is a strict limitation based on an examination. As far as I know there is no limitation on the numbers who can enter for that examination.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I would like to assure the Deputy that there is a very strict limitation. The number of teachers taken in is governed by the possible number who will be employed. I am afraid the Deputy has put his foot into it there.

Comment on this

I am afraid that Deputy O'Connell is mixing the problem. He is trying to make it a little more difficult. The Deputy is evidently talking about admission into the secondary schools.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

Not at all. I am talking about the teaching profession.

Comment on this

If a boy wants to get into the teaching profession, and has ability, what is the obstruction?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

The main obstruction is the number of vacancies that exist in the training colleges for primary teachers.

Comment on this

I think Deputy O'Connell is satisfied. Let us take another profession. Let us take the medical profession. Any boy who wants to go into that profession and is not wanting in money, and has sufficient money to carry him through has no difficulty in his way. He is not met by the limitation argument or by the statement that there are only vacancies for so and so and such and such a number. If the boy wants to go into the medical profession that is entirely a matter for him and for his people. He is put through the course anyway. I want to see these young people put in a similar position to him. If there is not employment subsequently for them when they reach the end of their apprenticeship that is their look out, but I want to get the opportunity for them. That opportunity is closed at the moment.

Let us take the legal profession. What limitation is there against entering that profession? None that I know of. There is no limit whatever to a boy going into it. As to the question of subsequent employment that is a matter entirely for the boy and his parents. He may have to go abroad, but he is enabled to go into the profession. He can learn the profession. That is all I ask for those boys coming from our primary schools and who want to go into a trade or industry. If a boy wants to become a bricklayer, a plumber, a carpenter or anything else at the present moment those avenues of employment are closed to him. I say that is not fair. As far as that condition prevails I am quite satisfied that the money spent on our vocational schools will not achieve the results it ought. The money spent on them will be very largely wasted because there will not be opportunities for those boys when they leave the schools. That is the problem as I see it.

As regards this other question of the number of apprentices to the number of tradesmen, let us assume for the moment that the apprentice is thoroughly skilled in his trade at 23 years of age and let us assume that the average life is 63 years. That leaves 40 working years for the craftsman. It follows from that that in every ten years we lose 22 per cent. of the total or in every 8 years we lose 20 per cent. of the total. Take it that we lose in every ten years 25 per cent. of the total. Consequently, we must train 25 per cent of our craftsmen every ten years or 20 per cent. in eight years. A boy starting at the age of 15 years would reach efficiency at the age of 23. It is a well-known fact that many of those following a trade in the country parts come to the city to be trained and when their training is finished they return home. Others following other occupations will sometimes travel to distant places for information, and five per cent. under that head would not be excessive to meet these contingencies. That brings the proportion up to one-fourth or 25 per cent. Then we have further to provide for accidents, deaths and other causes which reduce the number to one in three.

I have been speaking now of comparatively long-lived trades. But we have short-lived trades, where these figures that I have just given will not be reached. That shows how the figure of one in three is arrived at. That figure is not questioned by those who have studied the problem, as I know, in other places. What I suggest to the Minister is this: That if we are satisfied that the voluntary principle has been given a fair trial, as I am satisfied it has, and that it has failed to achieve the object we have in view, then I think we ought to agree to give some other principle a trial and I now suggest the compulsory principle and that a Bill should be framed along those lines as we understood during the sitting of the Commission. The South African model was mentioned. There was no doubt at all in the minds of the members of the Commission that compulsion is necessary in view of the figures given to the Commission by the Minister's Department. These figures show that the compulsory system is necessary. The interpretation of the Commission was, and it is still their interpretation, that the South African Act is a compulsory Act. They recommend that the principle of that Act should be followed.

I suggest to the Minister that there is agreement on this point of compulsion and that this Bill might be re-drafted. I do not hesitate to point out the difficulty that one is in in trying to alter a purely voluntary Bill into a compulsory Bill. I laid bare that fact when moving my first amendment. I put forward that view. If we are satisfied that in the interests of those represented and in the national interests something should be done more than has been done, then I would suggest to the Minister to withdraw this Bill and to bring in a new Bill on a different basis.

Comment on this

I am opposed to this amendment. One would think, on listening to Deputy Good's speech, that an increase in the number of apprentices would increase industry in this country.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

That is naturally the inference that anybody would draw from the Deputy's remarks. Again, Deputy Good has suggested that some of those trades are closed boroughs. It might be a surprise to Deputy Good to find that I agree with him that there should be no closed boroughs either in the trades or professional crafts, but we must have regard to the whole position and not to take things piecemeal. We have, as a matter of fact, the professions very largely protected by the economic circumstances of the people. Whilst it may be said in theory that the professions are not closed to the ordinary people of this country, at the same time we do know that in order to enter any of these professions one must go through a university course, and take out a degree. To do that course requires the expenditure of a considerable sum of money, and I need hardly say that the majority of those who serve their time to trades and crafts are, in the main, people who cannot afford to take up a profession. I agree that there ought to be no barrier put before any intelligent boy in this country entering any trade or craft. I have always held that view, but I do not see how we are going to alter the whole economic position by suggesting that the more apprentices we have, the better it will be for the country. It is quite the contrary in my experience. I know that we have thousands of building trade operatives in the country unemployed. Will the multiplying of apprentices in these crafts increase employment? It will undoubtedly increase the number of skilled operatives, but when skilled operatives have no opening for displaying their skill what benefit will that be?

Comment on this

What is the proportion of skilled operatives?

Comment on this

I would like to suggest to Deputy Good that he knows very well that all these matters are arranged amicably between the employers in any given industry and the employees. They arrange for the proportion. They arrange that the proportion shall be one in five, or one in three as it is in some cases, and in practice it has been found that that number is quite sufficient. There were some crafts in which it was found absolutely essential to close down apprenticeship for a time altogether, and Deputy Good knows that action of that kind is not taken without some very serious reason.

Comment on this

I would like to know in what crafts did that happen?

Comment on this

I will give you the facts—the plumbers.

Comment on this

Not to my knowledge.

Comment on this

I can give the Deputy the names of the firms where it occurred.

Comment on this

Give us the particulars.

Comment on this

I will give them to the Deputy personally.

Comment on this

I appeal to the Deputy to give the information to the House where we can have it on record and where we can all use it. Giving it to me privately is absolutely useless information. We want to have it here where we can check it up and test it.

Comment on this

I will give the Deputy any information required in that way.

Comment on this

That information is no use unless I have it for the House.

Comment on this

We all want to see this Bill operative and become an Act. There are many features in it which will certainly help vocational education at the moment. In my view as one who has had some experience of the apprenticeship system I feel that the voluntary character embodied in the Bill is one of the best features and nothing can be gained by the amended suggestion of Deputy Good which I may say, with other amendments put down on the paper by Deputy Good, seems to be lifted entirely, without the change of a comma, from the South African Act. Deputy Good wants this to be made a true and accurate copy of the South African Act.

Comment on this

That is the report of the Commission.

Comment on this

From my reading of the Bill I think some of the most objectionable features have been put in and some of the best points left out.

Comment on this

I oppose Deputy Good's amendment. I think it would be fatal to the objects intended in this Bill to introduce the element of compulsion. So far as the Bill itself is concerned I think it is a very good one, but I can see results flowing from this Bill far greater than the question of the apprentices. In industries generally it is absolutely essential that the employers and employees should be brought in closer touch. If this Bill had no other thing contained in it than to bring employer and employee together it has a good deal to recommend it. I would like to see the time in this country when all industries and conditions of industries would be controlled by a joint labour board constituted out of employers and employees. When we get to that stage, and this is the first step towards it, we will have industry organised on a much better basis than it is at present. I have nothing more to say on the question. I served one time on a joint labour board. I saw employers and employees who had grievances one against the other. After a round table conference they composed their differences very rapidly. I think we are now making the first advance towards the establishment of joint labour boards in all industries. The Minister will have power to induce the employers and employees in certain industries to come in under this Apprenticeship Act without the suggestion of compulsion. I think step by step we will gather up the threads in the control of industry. It is better for the country generally that industries should be organised by those engaged in them than by any drastic measures the Minister may introduce.

Comment on this

I would like for a moment to refer to an analogy which Deputy Good tried to make between professions and industry. The difference is surely a simple one. It is agreed by, I think, most of the people who have had touch with this matter that the proper training for industry can only be given in the workshops. You can supplement it in the technical school and the technical school will probably have come to play a greater and more important part as time goes on. I think it has been agreed by the people concerned that workshop training is an essential. If we are going to have apprentices trained for some part of their course in their employers' premises there immediately comes out from that a difference as between the training for industry and the training for a profession. The man who wants to proceed to law or medicine goes through the ordinary course of education at his parents' expense practically all the time and goes to one of the recognised diploma conferring places. No private employer is put out in order that he might secure his diploma. He does not interrupt a private employer's business; he does not complicate the number of employees that a private employer has to take. He does not introduce any element of discordancy into his wages sheet. All these factors are summed up in the point made that you interfere to get your training through the private employer's place of business in the one case and you do not in the other.

Comment on this

Engineering is rather an exception.

Comment on this

So is the Bar and so is accountancy.

Comment on this

It has been said here that there were close boroughs. Deputy Anthony used the phrase in reference to Deputy Good's remark. I must say I expected to find, from all the rumours that I heard since I had any touch with industry, a great deal more in the Commission's Report with regard to the close boroughs.

Comment on this

If the Minister reads the terms of reference he will see that it did not come within them.

Comment on this

May I refer to one thing which must have come within the terms of reference, because it is reported on. On page 84 of the Report, where this famous table supplied by my Department is included, there is this statement:

"The proportion of apprentices to skilled men which is specified in certain agreements between employers and trades unions indicates the maximum number permitted"—I I draw attention to this—"and represents a proportion barely reached in practice."

In other words the agreement as between the trade unions and employers, which is supposed to set up this close borough system, is criticised by the Report as representing a proportion rarely reached in practice. There may be other considerations that could not come before the Commission. They might have adopted that part of the Report had it come before them, but we are faced with the position that these closed conditions exist in some parts of industry, and the better way to get after them is by getting employers and employees, under the chairmanship of an outsider with two other impartial observers, and have the whole thing ventilated. It may be that two or three years' experience of this will show that there is this closed system prevailing in certain trades, and public opinion may be aroused against it by the reports that will issue from these committees or the attempts made by this Department to get the committee established and its failure. Then will be the time to think of some better approach to this position. That position has not yet been demonstrated. No one yet has any proof. There is a certain amount of talk about it. I think it is clear enough that something approaching that type of condition exists, and people attempt to get that sort of thing right, but how far the attempts are successful and what is the vehemence behind that attempt I do not know.

At any rate a time for a better approach will come when we have tried to bring these people together. I should say if we do find that there are trades and businesses for which we cannot get apprenticeship committees set up because the trade will not allow themselves to be designated the approach may have to be different.

Comment on this

Cannot that happen under the Bill?

Comment on this

It may happen, but we will see how far it will happen. It will not happen if people have agreed to form the committees.

Comment on this

If they fix the standard number of apprentices.

Comment on this

Then we are up against a situation which we will have to face in some way. I suggest it is impossible to face it in the way of saying to some employer: "You must take on so many employees." He must take them even if he does not want them or if it means that all his employees will walk out of his business. The natural reaction of the employer then will be to say: "You force these on us and you will have to pay strike wages to carry on the business, as our business is at a standstill owing to your actions." The only other way of dealing with it will be we will have to look to see that technological establishments are to be brought to a particular point of perfection so that they can give training there instead of in the employer's business. I hope there will be general agreement that, no matter what happens to the young person eventually, whether he is going to get employment here or elsewhere, that it is better to have him trained in one sort of skilled occupation than not to have him trained at all. But if we are going to assist industry by trying to force people into private persons' establishments against their will or subject them to certain changes arising out of other employment we will have to approach that difficulty but surely it is too early to shout about these difficulties until we have met them.

Comment on this

We are up against them at the moment.

Comment on this

They are in the Bill.

Comment on this

The Commissioners' Report used this phrase, "a proportion rarely reached in practice."

Comment on this

It did not come within the terms of reference.

Comment on this

I got a series of recommendations from the Commission with regard to the designated trades and so on. The paragraphs which preceded the recommendations give me certain information with regard to skilled men and apprentices, and I get below that particular statement that these things are generally ruled by agreement, and we have the statement that the maximum is rarely reached. There must be something in the terms of reference which enables the Committee to deal with that. At any rate it is there. I may be taking a wrong deduction from it, but the Report of the Commission is there, and the evidence tendered to the Commission is the main thing. Bringing the two sides together, under the observation and control of two or three impartial observers is, I think, the best system that we can devise at the moment.

Comment on this

Could the Minister give any real reason for refusing to accept powers to deal with the situation which can be contemplated, even though it may never arise? He talked about the dangers of compulsion. He said you have to force a particular employer to take in more apprentices than he is willing to take. That danger is in the Bill. If the employers and employees agreed to have their trade designated, and if the Apprenticeship Committee is set up, and it fixes the number of apprentices in relation to each factory, and if the owners of the factory refuse to take in that standard number of apprentices, he commits an offence against this Bill, and is liable to a fine.

Comment on this

Yes, if the people representing him have agreed to this.

Comment on this

You are not going to avoid that danger.

Comment on this

I think so.

Comment on this

The danger of workmen walking out on strike, because the employer endeavours to comply with the direction of the Committee?

Comment on this

The Committee will be representative of all the people.

Comment on this

They are appointed before the regulations are made.

Comment on this

They may be but they are appointed for the very purpose of making the regulations.

Comment on this

No. They are appointed under the obligation to make four definite types of regulations and with power to make others. A particular employer may have agreed to the designation of his trade on general principles without knowing the nature of the regulations that the Apprenticeship Committee for that trade are going to make, and when he comes up against these regulations he may find himself in very definite disagreement with them. That danger is there in relation to individual employers in designated trades. The Minister is refusing to accept compulsory powers because it may be there also in relation to individual trades. You may have failure to make a request for designation in a particular trade for some other reason than that neither employers nor employees desire to apply for it. It may be due to a lack of organisation on the part of employers or employees or to some other cause. What I am suggesting to the Minister is that he should take the limited compulsory powers that are conferred upon the South African Minister. The South African Act is a voluntary Act in principle, but the Minister has certain compulsory powers. He is obliged to act in consultation with the Apprenticeship Committee but he is under no statutory obligation to accept their advice, if, in exceptional circumstances, he thinks it inadvisable to do so.

The amendment that I propose is that if within two years no application is made for designation the Minister may make a special order if he is satisfied that it is desirable that such special order should be made. He would do everything possible to induce an application from one or preferably from both sides, but if the exceptional circumstances continued and if he foresaw in that particular industry that because of short-sighted policy the supply of trained recruits was likely to fall short of the number required at some future date, then he should have the necessary machinery to impose the will of the community upon the persons concerned. I cannot understand the attitude of the Labour Party. Deputy O'Connell's objection appears to be largely based upon the grounds that if you adopt a compulsory system you will have an undue amount of State interference in industry.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

Surely not.

Comment on this

That is what the Deputy said.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I said that if you trained people you would want to go much further. I am prepared to go, but Deputy Good is not.

Comment on this

Do not mind Deputy Good. It is Deputy O'Connell we are talking about. If Deputy O'Connell is prepared to do it later why not take the first step?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

It is not the first step.

Comment on this

It is the first step. I suggest that the purpose of this Bill is being misunderstood. Why have we passed the Vocational Education Act? Surely our purpose should be to provide a supply of skilled recruits for industry. If the sole purpose of this Act is merely to regulate the age of entry, the period of apprenticeship, the rate of remuneration, and things of that kind, then this is only a Bill of secondary importance. The main purpose of the Bill should be to provide the means by which we can be certain of securing an adequate number of skilled recruits for industry.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

Provided we are able to employ the skilled people we have.

Comment on this

That is another matter. Deputy Anthony dealt with that. He commenced by saying that he was not in favour of the close borough. Then he proceeded to defend that position and to make the fantastic argument that because unemployment is prevalent now we should deny training in the skilled industries to the young people.

Comment on this

It is a matter surely for arrangement between the employers and employees. The Minister has suggested that the close borough did not exist to the extent that the Deputy thinks. As a matter of fact, in the building trade about which Deputy Good knows something, there is an arrangement by which boys are indentured to carpentry by way of fee, where they are not the sons of carpenters.

Comment on this

There are no fees in the building industry.

Comment on this

I do not suggest that the close borough exists. When we have the Report of the Commission which says in relation to that particular industry that the employers are not taking in the maximum number of apprentices allowed by the agreement, surely that should alter Deputy Anthony's attitude. The adoption of the amendment would ensure that the maximum number agreed on by the trade unions would receive skilled instruction.

Comment on this

We would have to examine the reasons why this maximum was not reached. The reasons, probably, would be that there was not sufficient employment for those already in the trade.

Comment on this

The provision of employment for our people is a different matter. Is it the contention that because employment is absent at the moment we should deny training to our young people and bring them up as unskilled workers to fill casual jobs all their lives? That is the effect of Deputy Anthony's contention. Is there any reason why we should not have them trained? The fact that unemployment is prevalent at the present time is no reason why the workers of the future should be in the main unskilled workers, that they should be denied an opportunity of acquiring trades at the time when they can best acquire them.

Comment on this

That is the issue.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

We are all agreed upon that. I have said before that the particular method of providing compulsion which Deputy Good suggested does not appeal to me. I do not think it is necessary to adopt that method. I want to see the Minister have the power, which he may never be called upon to exercise, but nevertheless to have it, to impose an Apprenticeship Committee with power to make regulations upon any trade in which he thinks the circumstances are so serious that he should exercise that power, even though neither the employers' nor the employees' organisation makes application. The South African Minister has that power and, as the Minister is framing his Bill upon the South African Act, he should not deprive himself of it.

Comment on this

I want to refer to the remarks which have just been made. Deputy Lemass's amendment reads: "Provided that if no such application is made within two years of the date of the passing of this Act in respect of a trade for which the Minister is satisfied that it is desirable that such special order should be made, the Minister may make such special order." Am I to read into that that the Minister is not to make such a special order unless he is convinced that the parties want it?

Comment on this

That is what is there.

Comment on this

That is not what is there.

Comment on this

Unless he is satisfied that it is desirable to make it.

Comment on this

I may be satisfied that it is desirable, but I may also be satisfied that neither the employees nor the employers want it. Am I to make the order then?

Comment on this

If I am satisfied that one of them is vehemently opposed to it, am I to make the order?

Comment on this

If the employees make the application and the employers' organisation is vehemently opposed to it, will the Minister designate that trade?

Comment on this

Certainly not.

Comment on this

Why do it in one case?

Comment on this

Am I to read that into his amendment? It is certainly the tenour of the Deputy's speech. If I am satisfied the order should be made, but I am also satisfied that neither the employers nor the employees want it, am I to make the order? If I am satisfied further that one of the two parties is vehemently opposed to it and will not co-operate in carrying it out, there is no good in making the order.

Comment on this

What is to happen when the boys come out of the vocational school and want to get into industries?

Comment on this

I can see circumstances in which the Minister could make the order no matter who is opposed to it.

Comment on this

Supposing I designate a trade and get some sort of a committee. It will not be a very representative committee if one party is vehemently opposed, and I think I will be left in the lurch by the people staying away.

Comment on this

There is a Bill coming before this Dáil definitely regulating, in particular circumstances, admission to a particular occupation. Why should the Dáil impose by statute these regulations in respect of auctioneers and not impose them by statute in respect of some other trade, if the circumstances require it.

Comment on this

There are other things. You are prohibiting people from entering in that case, but in this case you are forcing people in by a positive act. I am taking the circumstances I spoke of: an application has not been made. I am convinced that it is desirable that a particular trade should be designated. I am further convinced that one of the two parties likely to be involved is vehemently opposed to it. I designate it nevertheless. I go looking for my committee. Am I likely to get representative members from the two parties in the circumstances I have outlined? Supposing I do get them, and I get the committee to establish certain regulations. Amongst the regulations they establish is one with regard to the number of apprentices in regard to a specific premises. I go to a certain premises owned by Mr. X and say: "Take in so many people." Supposing he is recalcitrant and says "No"? Supposing it is the employees who object to a certain number of apprentices and the employer says: "Certainly, but I know what is going to happen," and the next day he meets me and says: "This is what I foretold would happen; this place has been blacklisted and they are all going out."

Comment on this

Cannot all that happen under the Bill?

Comment on this

It is very unlikely. It is less likely to happen where one or the other party has asked for the application of the Act, and where I have made a special order. Remember, the special order implies giving notice to all who are likely to be affected. Where there has been no objection raised, or not sufficient objection to make me withhold the application for the designation, and where representative members have sat upon a committee and established a particular number, there is surely less likelihood of that occurring than where I do this on my own, in the circumstances outlined, in the teeth of clear opposition from one of the parties.

Comment on this

Must these Apprenticeship Committees be unanimous in their recommendations?

Comment on this

No. The application need only be made on the part of one party. Then there is the procedure of special order which gives notice to certain people. I do not know what form the Bill may take, but suppose it is passed as it is. They must make regulations upon certain things and they may make regulations about certain others. The employer knows about these because he will have notice given to him. There will be no objection to the making of the special order unless it is considered that it can be sustained. In these circumstances I say it is very much less likely that there is going to be any trouble with even an individual employer than in the other circumstances.

Comment on this

It is not impossible.

Comment on this

We cannot rule out possibility. In that possibility all that we can see is that we have against the recalcitrant employer the full weight of the group, including the employees.

Comment on this

Not necessarily.

Comment on this

We have. There has been an application made; the application has been considered, and a special order has been made. The procedure under the special order means notice to everyone likely to be affected. The committee has met and established certain regulations, and these have been confirmed. When all this procedure has been gone through, if you find the employer reluctant to employ a certain number you have, at any rate, against him the full weight of a certain group of the employers and of the employees.

Comment on this

Not necessarily. If the Apprenticeship Committee decide to make regulations in respect of the number of apprentices by a majority, with the employers' representatives upon the committee in opposition, would not the individual employer consider he would have the full weight of the support of all the other employers in that industry?

Comment on this

No, because it has to go through the procedure of confirmation. In these circumstances it would be the duty of the Minister to intervene and to see whether he will or will not confirm. Clearly there will not be confirmation with the full weight of the employers against it.

Comment on this

Even in that particular case it would not be impossible.

Comment on this

Instead of arguing on the minor point of possibility, I take the Deputy on the other point, which is the most likely to lead to trouble most certainly—the compulsory clause to be enforced in the teeth of opposition, or this other thing which is, I think, the root of this whole matter, that is the voluntary principle. You are going to try and bring people together and to agree on certain things. The whole lengthy procedure is to try and get their minds as one on a particular regulation. That is a far better system than acting against a declared opposition. That only leads to trouble. The trouble may have to be faced in this also, but, again I say, why meet trouble too early? Let us try this out. We can see what is going to happen. Deputy Lemass's amendment contemplates that within a period of two years no application is made. My policy is definitely going to try and introduce Apprenticeship Committees in as many industries and branches of industry as possible. On the point of organisation, if my division of trade-board trades and non-trade-board trades is left, the trade-board trades are supposed to include all those where the people are not sufficiently organised to be able to resist an attack upon wages. We get both the organised and the non-organised on the employees' side. The employers are, in the main, sufficiently organised through the Advisory Committees which I have at present.

Comment on this

The number of trade-board trades for which there can be Apprenticeship Committees is very few.

Comment on this

I do not think so. In practically every one of those trades in which there is a trade-board you can have an Apprenticeship Committee.

Comment on this

You will not have it in the milk-distributing trade.

Comment on this

They may be a very small percentage of the total, but you can have an Apprenticeship Committee in every trade-board trade.

Comment on this

May I point out to the Minister that the difficulties are greater than he visualises? There is a rather important industry here in Dublin, the bricklaying trade, and in that particular industry they will not allow any apprentices to be taken by the employer at all. How are you going to set up an Apprenticeship Committee in that particular industry?

Comment on this

How is it that that particular position was brought about?

Comment on this

The trade claims that they will only allow as apprentices to that trade the sons of bricklayers who are at present engaged in the trade, and the result is that in that particular industry the numbers are reduced by half in twenty-five years.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy understood my question. How are employers in that particular trade being brought to the point of accepting only the sons of bricklayers into the business?

Comment on this

As a matter of fact the employers of that particular trade cannot take in any apprentices. The apprentices are only those taken in by the trade; they are bound to the trade and not to the employers, and that is affecting the industry. It is as well that we should hear the other side in this matter. I do not want to cause any unpleasantness.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

But there are apprentices in the bricklaying trade.

Comment on this

Yes, but only the sons of bricklayers taken in by the trade. As a matter of fact no employer can take in an apprentice and as a matter of fact the apprentices are not bound to the employer but to the trade.

Comment on this

The Deputy says the employers cannot take apprentices. Why?

Comment on this

Because the trade will not allow them. The result to that particular industry is that the number of men employed in the city to-day is less than half the numbers that were employed twenty-five years ago and the shortage of employees at present in that trade is becoming a very serious difficulty.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

Is that the reason for the scarcity of employment?

Comment on this

Employment is so scarce because these men that have control of the trade have made it such a close borough that the output in that particular industry is exceedingly small. I happen to know, because in 1914 in Dublin we had four brick works employing over a thousand men. To-day three of these works are closed down, and we can hardly keep one of them open because of the competition of cement. If the bricklayers of Dublin gave a larger output we would not have cement houses built in Dublin to-day. In Belfast they would have none of these cement houses built because the bricklayers were determined to keep the cost of bricklaying down to such an extent that the cement could not compete.

Comment on this

Have the builders' profits been kept down?

Comment on this

The bricklayers of Belfast succeeded in keeping out cement houses, but in Dublin not a house is built of bricks at the moment. They are all built of cement, and in a few years, unless something is done to remedy this, bricklaying will be a thing of the past. It is these restrictions of the trade union that are affecting this particular trade, because boys are kept out of the bricklaying trade unless they are the sons of tradesmen. Why it should be I do not know, but it is restricting employment in the allied industries. It is all very well dealing with a particular problem, but I want to have this question looked at from the point of view of the mother and of the father who have three or four sons and want to get them into industry. You talk about all these difficulties created by other organisations, but let us look at the real difficulty—the difficulty of the parent who wants to get employment for his boys. What is he to do? What are we to advise him to do? It is said: "Send him to a vocational school," but when he gets through the vocational school how is he going to get into industry unless the avenues of industry are opened up to him and the barriers removed? Why should there be barriers in industry greater than in the professions? Unless these barriers are removed and there is more employment in industry we will not get over the difficulty by vocational schools. I want something done to deal with this problem. I have seen this problem as a member of the Juvenile Employment Committee in Dublin for many years. We are face to face with this problem, and it is becoming more serious from year to year. In Dublin last year we had some 5,000 new applications from young people leaving our schools. We could only find employment for less than 1,000. What is to become of the rest? Are they to be thrown on the scrap heap and given no opportunity? A lot of these will find employment in occupations that lead nowhere. We want the avenues to industry opened up and the barriers removed. We want this Bill to remove these barriers in the interests of the State, and I say it does not remove them. If the Minister could call a conference of those interested in trying to get some agreement whereby these obstacles could be got over, we would make some progress. But I am satisfied that this Bill in its present form is not going to help the situation, and the problem will grow much more serious than it is. I am anxious as the result of the work of the Commission and the assistance of the Department that something real and practical should be done. It is a pressing problem and calls for something to be done.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The discussion on this amendment No. 6 has wandered over No. 8 also. They are in a certain way related, but No. 6 is the main amendment, and No. 8 differs from it in several radical respects. I propose putting No. 6 first. Does the Deputy insist on pressing his amendment.

Comment on this

As far as I can see there is no support for it.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I shall support Deputy Good.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

There is still no support for it.

Comment on this

I cannot say that even the Deputy's support fills me with hope. In view of the expression of opinion elicited, I have no objection to withdrawing the amendment. Probably the discussion we had may serve some useful purpose.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

I think amendment 7 falls as consequential.

Comment on this

I think amendment 7 will be looked upon as an alternative to No. 8, but of a different type. Deputy Good simply proposes to remove a sub-section that would forbid a special order being made unless a special application was made for it.

Comment on this

Amendment 7 is consequential, I think, upon amendment No. 6.

Comment on this

I think the purpose of amendment 7 would be to provide that the Minister may make an order to designate a trade, without receiving an application from anybody.

Comment on this

That is what it comes to.

Comment on this

I would like the Deputy to propose his amendment, and I shall support it.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Is the Deputy moving or withdrawing his amendment?

Comment on this

I feel, in view of the expression of opinion that amendment No. 6 has elicited, that the object I had in my mind to eliminate this particular sub-section could not be achieved. At least what I had in mind was that the Minister should have power in the event of neither party applying for the setting up a committee that the Minister should have power to intervene in such a case, and in the interests of the State set up a committee, and take such steps as might be necessary.

That is the principle that is embodied in it, and that I tried to outline in connection with amendment 6, but that particular proposal did not seem to meet with general acceptance. If the larger application of the principle did not meet with general acceptance I do not see that there is very much use in pressing this minor amendment.

Comment on this

I am prepared to accept amendment 7. Amendment 6 has been rejected by the House, not so much for what was in it as for the principle behind it. The amendment set out definitely to establish the compulsory principle, that a trade could be designated against the will of either employers or employees, or both. Deputy Lemass, in amendment 8, provides that if there is no application made within two years, that then, if the Minister is satisfied it is desirable that a special order should be made, the Minister may make such special order. Deputy Good's amendment, No. 7, makes the same approach to that, but in a better way, because he simply proposes to cut out the part of the section which says that no such special order can be made unless application is first received by the Minister in the case of a trade-board, and in the case of a non-trade-board that application is made by or on behalf of employers or employees. If that is cut out it gives a little more laxity.

I have stated my policy, that I would examine the circumstances beforehand. Unless I found there was likely to be no definite opposition to this I would not make a special order. That leaves the position a little bit more lax, and means that the Minister could act, if he thought, for instance, that people were not making application because they had not the matter properly before them. That is why I much prefer amendment 7 to amendment 8. The latter postpones this particular thing for two years, and it also puts the matter in a rather contentious way.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

If there was any guarantee that the policy which the Minister has declared would be the policy for all time then no danger might exist in cutting out this particular provision. But if somebody else came along with a different policy he would have the power to apply special compulsory powers, and to make regulations, even though one or both parties did not want the regulations.

Comment on this

That is the danger.

Comment on this

Is it the Minister's argument that he could not go very far if there was violent opposition on one side or the other?

Comment on this

On the section, there is just one question that I would like to ask the Minister. In paragraph (a) of sub-section (1) it is provided that "the Minister shall by another order." Should not that read "the Minister shall by a special order?"

Comment on this

That is a point that I had not adverted to, but I will have it examined before the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Deputy Good has some amendments down which would seem to indicate that he wants to abolish the division between trade-board and non-trade-board trades. We passed amendment 5 which relates to that matter only in connection with the definitions. I was under the impression that the matter would come up again on amendment 6, but it did not.

Comment on this

I cannot see what use it is to establish trade-boards under this Bill. Possibly the Minister will give us some information. The only advantage that I see the Minister derives from the existence of a trade-board is that he does not appoint an apprenticeship committee where a trade-board exists. I do not think that is an advantage, because a trade-board is appointed with a different object altogether. It is appointed to discharge different duties. I was anxious that the trade-board proposal should be eliminated from the Bill. How far the Minister approves of that I do not know. I do not think that any trade union in the country would want to have the same representatives dealing with apprenticeship questions and ordinary trade-board questions. The mixing up of the two is not going to be any advantage to the apprenticeship committee or to the trade-board.

Comment on this

Would the Minister enumerate the advantages that he sees will arise from the differentiation? Deputy Good's point seems to be that trade-boards were established for an entirely different purpose to that of dealing with the question of apprenticeship.

Comment on this

The apprenticeship committees will have as part of their duty the regulation of entry and the conditions of entry. My main point is that there is certain over-lapping of functions. I must do either of two things. I must abolish the trade-boards as they are at the moment and establish in their place these apprenticeship committees giving them the functions set out, or else I must take the trade-boards as they stand, and add to their present functions the duties laid down under the Bill. I have very good committees at the moment under the Trade Board Acts. They have been working very efficiently, and they are the model on which this particular machinery was prepared. I think it would be rather disastrous either to remove them or to reappoint them as apprenticeship committees. I would prefer to leave them as they are, and add the work of the apprenticeship committees to their present duties. If I thought that what Deputy Good said was true, I would be very much shaken in my belief, but the opinion that I hold in regard to them is exactly the reverse of the Deputy's. Pretty nearly every organisation of employees would appoint the same people to these committees that they have previously appointed under the trade-boards. I think the best thing is to keep them. If, as Deputy Good said, speaking of employers, a distinctly different type of man would be put on, I would like to have an opportunity of discussing that later with some of the employers.

Comment on this

They are entirely different problems.

Comment on this

There is certain over-lapping, but the fact that they are doing this other work already in no way detracts from their value in so far as serving on the apprenticeship committee is concerned. There is going to be over-lapping, but I think the best thing to do is to allow the trade-boards to remain and give them these new duties. If necessary, we can attend to the personnel afterwards, if that is found to be a difficulty.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy Cassidy, I move amendment 11:-

In sub-section (1) (a), line 50, after the word "members" to insert the words "chosen by the Minister in consultation with the organisations of employees and employers."

This refers to non-trade-board trades and includes craftsmen and skilled operatives, men with a long tradition of trade union activity behind them. They constitute, Deputy Good will agree, the better organised trades. I think the attractive feature of the Bill is that so many of its provisions are voluntary. The Technical Commission in its report recommended that representative members should be chosen in consultation with the organisations of workers and of employers. We would like to see that recommendation enshrined in the Bill. I think the Minister admitted that for the proper functioning of these committees it will be necessary to have manifestations of goodwill on both sides. For that reason I think it is necessary that the words in the amendment be inserted in order to facilitate the general working of the measure.

Comment on this

It is clear from the Bill that the members are to represent an equal proportion of employers and employees engaged in each trade. The amendment proposes to impose a condition that they shall be chosen in consultation with organisations of employees and employers. There may be districts in the country where there are no such organisations, and therefore I think it is better leave the Bill as it is. The members will have to be representative. Under the trade-board system we have no difficulty in getting representative members. The spirit of the amendment is acceptable to me, but I think that if the amendment were to be inserted it would make the Bill a bit rigid.

Comment on this

I move amendment 12:-

In sub-section (1) (a) to delete subparagraph (ii) and substitute the following: "one member who shall be chairman appointed by the Minister."

I hope the Minister will see his way to accept this amendment.

Comment on this

I object to all the amendments dealing with this. I think there are some trades where there is such definite organisation and amicable agreement between the parties that a single appointed member to act would be sufficient, but there are others where I think it would be better if three outsiders were appointed. This is a case where a certain amount of laxity is required. I must advise the House against cutting down the number to one.

Comment on this

How would the Minister guard against this danger? Assuming that you had the position of three on each side representing employers and employees in the case of some industry how is the chairman going to be elected? Would it not be a better plan for the Minister to nominate a chairman?

Comment on this

He does under sub-section (1) of Section 5.

Comment on this

Section 5 (1) says that the chairman of every apprenticeship committee shall be such member of such committee as the Minister may appoint.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Does that meet the point?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

Yes, but I think that the point of Deputy Anthony's amendment is that he only wants one.

Comment on this

That is the other point.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I did not hear Deputy Anthony make his case for the amendment, but I think that that is the important point. Much of the Minister's argument would seem to me to be in favour of that, namely, that the one man appointed as chairman ought to be a person who would, as it were, hold the balance evenly, and be in the nature of a conciliator, as it were, between one side and the other. If the Minister does not get agreement under the scheme he will not get very far with it. If he gets a decision by a majority, by the votes of the appointed persons throwing in their lot with one side or the other, according to his argument, he will not get very far. It seems to us that if the whole idea behind this Bill is the principle of agreement, or the largest possible measure of agreement, it would be better to have one man who would, as it were, be in the position of a conciliator, a person who would bring the two parties together.

Comment on this

I think that the Deputy is speaking a little more to the point in regard to the appointed member, or members, not voting. If there were three appointed members and they had not power to vote it would not matter. I object to both amendments, both to cutting down the number to a single person and to the one which would preclude that person, or persons, from voting. I would ask the Deputy to consider the rather serious work to be done by these committees. They have to make rules under the section establishing apprenticeships. There will be conditions of employment, wages and maximum hours of work. Then they may go on and, in relation to compulsory powers, deal with educational qualifications, age limits, training, and the regulations as to numbers of apprentices. On foot of these regulations afterwards prosecutions will lie. That is a rather serious responsibility to put on one person in an important industry, which may not yet be properly organised, and may not be very stable. I would prefer to have the weight of the three persons thrown in, mainly on the side of argument, because although the matter may come up on a clear division—employers on one side, employees on the other, appointed members being split—I would much prefer, having the final judgment, to see whether the three appointed members were on one side or whether there was division between them. There is, of course, always the power in the background to refuse approval. The discussions can be better carried on by three persons appointed than by a single individual. The items of discussion and the details of voting are the important things. I think that the whole weight of argument is in favour of three and of these three voting. It will not be a matter of majority decision, one way or another, but rather of weight of argument and reasons advanced. There is better opportunity of getting an expression as to what is happening from three rather than from one person. I think that three persons would find themselves more comfortable on such a committee, dealing with important matters, than one individual, as the three would share the responsibility. I would plead earnestly for the power, at least, to appoint three. That power need not always be put into operation.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I move:—

"In sub-section (2) (a) (ii), after the word `Minister,' line 9, to insert the words `in consultation with the local or national associations of employers' organisation and trade unions respectively.' "

It seems to us that there ought to be some consultation with both parties before members are selected. This does not bind the Minister to anything but merely suggests that there ought to be consultation. I think that that would be a very wise step for any Minister to take before making appointments on these committees. He need not accept their advice but he ought to ask for it.

Comment on this

In this case they have their representatives on the committee.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

Before the Minister appoints the members does he consult the committee?

Comment on this

There are already members of the trade boards on the committee.

Comment on this

I have no consultation with trade board members. My point against this amendment is the same as that against the previous one. There may not be a local association of employers in a particular area and if I went and consulted a larger national group, put the names before them, and they were objected to, would the Deputy consider that I still should appoint them? In that case the authority of the man would be very much weakened, and, having revealed that fact to the person, I doubt if he would act. This is rather a difficult type of work to throw on people. It has been done with good spirit under the Trade Boards Act by people who act in an honorary way. Perhaps the Deputy would tell me privately, because I have not heard openly that there has been any objection to the people appointed. I think that the same spirit will run through these committees, and I think it better to leave it run in the way indicated in the Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I cannot say that there has been any objection. If the Minister found that there was objection to a certain person, I think he would be foolish to appoint such person. If there were any such objection it would be better for the Minister to know beforehand rather than to allow it to reveal itself after the appointment is made.

Comment on this

I move:—

"At the end of sub-section (4), line 7, to add the words `such regulations shall provide in the case of apprenticeship committees for non-trade board trades that the chairman shall not vote.' "

Here again you find that in many parts of the country these non-trade board trades are not organised in any trade union. It is not always easy to get an impartial chairman in such areas. I suppose that nine times out of ten you would get a chairman who would not be impartial, who would lean on the side of the employers, and who would be against the employees. In order that the chairman should be above suspicion he should not have a vote.

Comment on this

I have made my plea that these people should be as numerous as three and should be allowed to vote. This is not a case in which voting rules. In the end, it is not a majority of votes that is going to decide but the circumstances about the whole discussion, the circumstances under which the votes were cast and the possibility, without serious difficulty, of carrying out the regulations. It is not a question of throwing either a group of employers or a group of employees into the hands of two or three outsiders. They should be allowed to exercise some discretion on the committee and indicate their point of view, even to the extent of voting. I think it is proper that the responsibility of voting should be put on them as it will add to their importance considerably. If the appointed members are found out afterwards to be particularly biassed in one particular direction, they will not last for any considerable time because otherwise they would only throw the business into discord. As we have allowed them to remain with regard to numbers, we should allow them a certain amount of discretion by allowing them to vote. It is not decisive.

Comment on this

Does not the Minister recognise the danger? If it is a question relating to apprenticeship, and if it cannot be decided except on the casting vote of the chairman, it still remains a question. Assuming that they were divided in the proportions of three and three or four and four, and that the chairman gave his casting vote, it still remains a question between the representatives of the employers and the employees. I want to obviate that and to facilitate the easy working of the Bill. If I could be quite sure that what the Minister has in mind could be translated into action, I would be prepared to withdraw it. I want to point out the difficulties that will exist if there is a casting vote given by the chairman.

Comment on this

I think too much importance is being attached to the word "vote." For instance, supposing the Bill was changed to meet this situation: that there would be a discussion, and that there would be sent to me a statement as to the vote between the representative members and a recommendation from the appointed members, that would meet my purpose equally well, but there is really nothing more than that in this voting. It only means that persons selected as being impartial, people from outside, people who have no connection with the trade, can give their interpretation of disputed points of view to the Minister. If Deputies would say on another stage that instead of voting these members should say what has been the result of the discussion amongst the representative members, and then would add their own recommendations concerning the matter, that would meet my point. There is nothing meant by their having a vote. If the Deputy thinks that once there is a casting vote of the chairman the thing goes ruthlessly along, that is not the way at all.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (1), (d), line 30, to delete the word "inclusive" and substitute the word "exclusive."

Comment on this

This is a typographical error.

Comment on this

I am not so sure. It relates to the words "inclusive of overtime" in paragraph (d). I am not quite sure whether there was a drafting error there or in Section 15, which relates to the same paragraph. The wording there was "exclusive of overtime," and I took it that "inclusive" was meant. I submitted an amendment to change "exclusive" to "inclusive." It seems to me that it should be "inclusive of overtime," and that in relation to apprentices the maximum number of hours fixed should not be capable of being defeated by any arrangement for overtime, and the committee who fix the over-riding maximum should not include ordinary work or any overtime which may be necessary.

Comment on this

The working of this is quite different to what the Deputy points out. In all these trades there are fixed hours, but there is overtime in addition. Every trade has a regulated number of hours.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I think it is better to have it exclusive, because otherwise they may fix a high maximum to cover overtime.

Comment on this

That is one of my objections to it, because as I said previously, we have to treat this as being done through the particular shops or employers' premises or place of business. The employer may have to work overtime. The apprentices' hours will be regulated by the hours of work worked by the other people. If we put in here "inclusive of overtime," it would mean a considerable disorganisation. If not, then what Deputy O'Connell says would occur.

Comment on this

If the word "exclusive" was in, I take it it would mean the number of normal working hours, and consequently the number of additional hours that might be worked in any particular period——

Comment on this