Public Business. - Apprenticeship Bill, 1930—Committee.
Contributions 221–443 of 443. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 22 of 1930 ›
The amendment, as the Deputy wants to have it, would have the word "inclusive," so that you would have the same difficulty. You would have rules regulating the maximum number of hours, including overtime. That is the danger.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 19:—
In sub-section (1), to insert at the end of paragraph (d) the words "but not so as to increase the maximum number of such hours appointed by or under any other enactment."
I pointed out on the Second Stage that there might be other pieces of legislation—be fixed certain legislalation—with regard to children and their employment. This Bill might over-ride some of the earlier and more restricted Acts. I want to meet that in part by this amendment.
Comment on this
How does that work out with amendment 20? Will the Minister say what is the effect of amendment No. 19 on amendment No. 20?
Comment on this
To accept amendment No. 20 would then more or less impose as a statute the maximum number of hours not exceeding eight. I would rather leave that to be determined by other enactments. Then we will carry in the other enactments if they are there.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:—
In sub-section (1), to add at the end of paragraph (d), the words "and in the case of persons under 18 years of age the maximum number of hours, not exceeding eight, which may be worked in any day by persons employed by way of apprenticeship in such trade in such district."
This applies to persons under 18 years of age and regulates the maximum number of hours which they can work. Does the Minister agree to accept it?
Comment on this
I thought there was some sort of understanding on the Second Reading that the Minister would accede to a request I made that some section or sub-section should be introduced into the Bill which would provide the maximum hours of work to be worked by young persons under the age of eighteen and that the daily hours should be restricted. While it might be suggested that the 48 hours should operate, at the same time young persons might be worked for 48 hours in the space of five days. That is a tendency I would like to restrict. I do not think it would be a good thing, even for the industry. Whilst it might not be so injurious for adults or grown-up people to work long hours for three or four days at a stretch, it would have a very injurious effect on young people of about eighteen years of age. That is the reason I suggest this amendment should be adopted. I feel that the working hours each day should be restricted to a maximum of eight for a young person.
Comment on this
Amendment 19 has been accepted, and I intended that that amendment would meet the point that has been raised. It has been mentioned that this Bill might give the apprenticeship committee power to fix hours of working which would be far in excess of those allowed for young people under other Acts that are now in operation. I provide a guarantee against that through the medium of amendment 19. The members of the committee are forbidden to increase the number of working hours set out under any enactment now in operation. I promised to bring the terms of this Bill within the terms of existing legislation dealing with trade conditions and hours of working. I never promised to impose, through this Bill, any special conditions with regard to the hours to be worked by apprentices. If and when an eight-hour day becomes statutory in this country, amendment 19 will bring this measure into conformity. Until we have that condition of things here I do not feel disposed to impose any special conditions through the medium of this Bill.
Comment on this
Is there anything here to prevent young people working an excessive number of hours per day? I pointed out on Second Reading the danger that might exist. I had in mind that it might be advisable specifically to mention a maximum number of hours during which young people would work.
Comment on this
There is no reference to the maximum number of hours daily.
Comment on this
There is a definite regulation as to the number of hours during which young people should work.
Comment on this
Yes, in any week. I want to be sure that they will not be asked to work ten hours on one day and six hours on another day.
Comment on this
With regard to one fairly important trade in this country, Deputy O'Connell might be doing an apprentice a great injustice if he did not allow for irregular hours of work from day to day. I refer to the garage business. In a country garage there is no such thing as regularity of work. A car may come in one day, and it will have to be repaired within a certain time. There may not be another car for several days. The apprentice is there all the time, and if he is not allowed to be at the repair job, he will be losing a great deal of the training he is seeking. If his eight hours terminate at six o'clock, and if the car comes in at four or five o'clock to be repaired that evening, then, as he is compelled to go away at six o'clock, he obviously loses the very chance for which he is placed in the garage. In that particular trade there would be a great injustice to the apprentice.
Comment on this
I am opposed to that principle. If a boy works eight hours a day and finishes the eight hours at six o'clock, he should then go away. It would not be fair to keep him there. Can the Minister suggest anything, even to meet the case put forward by Deputy Moore? I object strongly to the suggestion made by the Deputy.
Comment on this
I propose to bring this measure within the terms of existing enactments, whatever they may be, with regard to young people. I do not intend through this measure to impose restrictive conditions. The committee may impose very restrictive hours, but that will be a matter for them. I did not intend to meet that point about a mixed number of hours per day. Of course, if that were fixed by some other enactment, or is afterwards fixed, that is another thing. I am stopping short at amendment 19.
Comment on this
This measure gives the apprenticeship committee power to establish hours, and it gives them power afterwards to amend or modify whatever regulations they may make if they find that abuses occur. I prefer to leave the matter in that lax fashion. In the meantime, if the eight-hour day came into being through an international convention, then it would have its application to this measure through amendment 19. I do not want to deal with the question of hours on this Bill.
Comment on this
Will the committee have power to make a daily maximum?
Comment on this
They will have power to deal with the maximum number of hours that will have to be worked in any particular week.
Comment on this
Is the Minister prepared to accept an alteration affecting the number of hours to be worked daily?
Comment on this
Will the Deputy inform me, from his experience of trades, is it a general practice to fix the working time on the basis of the day as opposed to the week?
Comment on this
Under the existing Factories Acts young persons are precluded from working more than a certain number of hours every day.
Comment on this
Supposing there is a breakdown in the machinery in the works, are the employees going to stop? What is the use of legislating any little business that we have in the country out of the country?
Comment on this
Before we take amendment 21, I would like to know what would be the effect of amendment 23, if carried?
Comment on this
What I had in mind was that the Bill was to be made compulsory. That was at the back of my mind when I submitted the amendment to make these deletions. The Minister has done away with the compulsory principle and, therefore, the amendment will have to go.
Comment on this
There is no use in making one part of the Bill compulsory and the other part voluntary.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 21:—
At the end of sub-section (1), to add a new paragraph as follows:—
"rules (in this Act referred to as rules regulating the educational qualifications of apprentices) in relation to the educational qualifications of persons entering on employment by way of apprenticeship in the designated trade for which such committee is established with persons carrying on such trade in the district of such committee."
This is the point that I raised on the Second Reading. I think the first regulation that the committee should make should be on these lines. The amendment makes it compulsory on the apprenticeship committee to make these regulations. It is essential that they should make regulations setting forth the standard of education that young persons entering an industry ought to have reached. Naturally, the standard will vary according to the various trades which young people will enter, but there should be some definite standard, and that is the object of my amendment—to make it compulsory on the committee to make regulations in regard to educational qualifications. That is much better than to leave it purely a voluntary matter.
Comment on this
I do not think that this is one of the regulations that the committee should be compelled to make. There are some rules that the committee will be obliged to make, but this should not be one of them. There is a Compulsory School Attendance Act. Everybody has to attend school up to a certain age. That is the standard of education which will apply in the case of some trades.
Comment on this
Why should you deprive the people who attain only that standard, and who cannot get beyond it from being trained in a trade in which they are suitable? It seems to me that it would only be necessary to make rules indicating qualifications for a trade where the possession of such qualifications is likely to mean better work from the apprentices or is necessary in the proper carrying out of the business. This should be an optional matter. I do not think it should be made compulsory on the committee to adopt such regulations.
Comment on this
I would add to what Deputy Lemass has said, that if we take the group of matters referred to in (a) (b) (c) (d) in sub-section (1) of Section 8 and sub-section (2), they would represent all that one would expect the apprenticeship committee to determine with regard to any group. We picked out the four that we thought were essential, and also the four that we thought would lead to less trouble in the calling together of the apprenticeship committee, and the least difficulty in having designation accepted by both employers and employees. My opinion is that if one of the latter paragraphs is left out so much more difficult will it be in the way of getting apprenticeship committees together or the idea of any designated trade being accepted. The more rules there are that have to be made compulsory by an apprenticeship committee the more difficulty there will be experienced by employers and employees looking forward to their trade becoming designated. This is one that gives the least difficulty. I am not so much against this as the others. At the same time what Deputy Lemass has said must be borne out.
Practically no education may be required to become a learner in some trades and manufactures at the moment; and then why insist on the apprenticeship committee prescribing a standard of education when, in fact, what the committee will do will be to prescribe a standard so low that anybody can pass it. I do not know what the Deputy thinks he is going to achieve or what extra value he is going to get by insisting that the committee shall prescribe this particular thing. Surely that should be left to the judgment of the committee. If they find that the training of apprentices is hampered because people are attempting to get into a trade without a certain standard of education, then it will be time to make a rule, but I think it would be a bad thing to insist on its being done now. It would make it a little more difficult to get the whole apprenticeship system adopted.
Comment on this
It would help the apprentices' sense of values if we had some standard.
Comment on this
Supposing one thinks of a certain type of learner where the people will be women of the age of 30 years, what education or qualification is to be prescribed? What is the test that is to be passed? I can see some difficulty in getting some standard of value in the case of women of 30 or 40 years of age.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 22:—
To add at the end of sub-section (1), a new paragraph as follows:—"rules (in this Act referred to as rules regulating the training of apprenticeship) requiring employers carrying on such trade in such district to train and instruct apprentices employed by them in a specified manner."
I look upon this as a very important amendment. In regard to the training of apprentices, it is the opinion of many trade unionists that that is one of the most essential things in the apprenticeship system. It used to be the practice in Government dockyards to ask some of the skilled operatives in the various grades to train apprentices. These skilled operatives were rewarded according to the efficiency shown by the apprentices. These dockyards turned out some very excellent craftsmen as a result of this system. The craftsman got a certain reward when he was able to show that his apprentices made some progress. The apprentice was subject to examination at various periods during the apprenticeship. The result was that the apprentice very soon became a finished tradesman or mechanic. We are also aware that in many of these trades the boys are apprenticed some with fees and some without fees and very frequently they derive no benefit at all from their apprenticeship. The consequence is that a number of unskilled operatives and mechanics and so on were thrown on the market every year.
I think there is an obligation on the employer to see, when he takes an apprentice into his shop, that that apprentice will be properly treated and will be an asset to his employer.
Comment on this
I would like to support this amendment. It seems to me that the two most important of these provisions are (c) and (d) of sub-section (2), that is the sub-section requiring employers to train and instruct the apprentices. I think that the whole purpose of our vocational education and apprenticeship system is to ensure that there will be an adequate number of properly trained workers in each industry, and the putting of these rules into the optional sub-section of this section will suggest that it is a minor part of the work of the committees instead of its being the chief part of the work. I think we should have a discussion upon the advisability of keeping any one of these in the optional part of Deputy Good's amendment, but as that has been withdrawn now, I can not discuss paragraph (d) at all at this stage. But (c) is just as important as (d). It would, in my opinion, be almost essential in the making of this Bill an effective instrument that the apprenticeship committee should be required to make rules regulating the training of apprentices over whom they have control. I think in the South African Act it is compulsory on the Minister, after consultation with the committees, to make regulations concerning the training of apprentices. In any case whether it is or not it should be made compulsory here.
Comment on this
I have a little bit more difficulty on this than on the last one. I think the effect of this might be to prevent the apprenticeship committee being established, because the employers and employees on the committee might find it entirely beyond their powers to draw up a code. Remember the paragraph runs: "Regulations requiring employers carrying on such trade in such district to train and instruct apprentices employed by them in a specified manner." They have to put down the course, so to speak. If there is a general sort of course easily applicable to learners or apprentices, I should say it will be done, but again I ask people to think of the consequences of making it compulsory. If you impose on them the obligation as part of their duties that they must lay down a code which employers have to follow if they have to train their employees in a specified manner, we may prevent the apprenticeship committee coming together at all. I think if we had an intermediary word between "shall" and "may," I would accept something more than "may" and less than "shall." I would make it my business to ask committees in all cases practically to make rules on all the points, but I cannot force it. That is no good to people who want it made part of their obligation. What we decided to do departmentally was, we would pick out things which could easily be done, and leave other things, where simple plans could not be made, to the good-will and good sensei of the committee. The Minister, in the background, may exercise a certain good influence on them by sending back a thing to be considered. I would make it my business to see that, where possible, regulations of this type would be brought forward, but I do not like to insist on this particular thing as a matter of obligation on the committee at this particular moment.
Comment on this
Where it cannot be mandatory, would the Minister devise any other method by means of inspection or other means to secure that these apprentices would get proper training? The words "in a specified manner" will be interpreted in the ordinary acceptation of the term. You have many instances of where lads were apprenticed to various trades in this country, and were kept during the major portion of their time doing work not appropriate to that trade at all. That should be put an end to, and if the Minister could see that by some method of inspection it could be got rid of it might meet the case.
Comment on this
The Deputy proposing this wants to have it compulsory. I am not sure, from the purport of the Deputy's last remark, whether he wants to cut out these words "in a specified manner." I think that would be difficult. The importance of the words is that a prosecution will follow a breach of these regulations, if these regulations are made. If an inspector goes into court against an employer on the vague charge that he is not training or instructing apprentices employed by him, it would be very difficult to get any satisfaction for that. The words "in a specified manner" are important and, at the same time, show the extreme difficulty of the case, because this has to be always viewed from the angle of coming to court afterwards, dealing with prosecutions for breach of regulations. In easy cases the rules will be made as, for instance, where either party can convince the appointed members that the rules ought to be made. I think that it ought to be left as a thing which the committee may do, provided the committee agree to it. It is better to leave it that way than to have it made an obligation upon them and have the committee possibly fail.
Comment on this
I move amendment 26:—
In sub-section (2), page 5, to delete paragraph (d) and substitute the following paragraph:—
"(d) rules (in this Act referred to as rules regulating the number of apprentices) fixing in relation to any specified employer carrying on such trade in such district the number (in this Act referred to as the standard number) of apprentices whom such committee considers should be employed by such employer in such trade in such district, and such number may, if such apprenticeship committee thinks fit, be expressed as a proportion of the number of persons of any class or classes employed from time to time in such trade in such district by such employer."
Objection was raised to (d) of sub-section (2) of Section 8 as it stood, and particular objection was taken to the words "`in any particular premises," because it was pointed out that there might be certain operations which would not be carried out in the premises of an employer at all, and it might be difficult to get a proper application of the law. He might be employed by a person on outside work in other premises also. Consequently, the amendment was drafted, and I think it not merely meets that point, but other points which arise.
[Professor Thrift took the Chair.]
We get away from the idea of the particular premises. We fix it now with regard to a specified employer carrying on a trade in a particular district, and we allow that the number may be expressed as a percentage of the number of persons employed from time to time by such employer.
Comment on this
Does it not seem curious to make rules as to the number of apprentices which should be employed? The rule presumably, according to a subsequent section of the Act if it is made, can be enforced under the penalty of a fine, but a rule as to the number which should be employed seems curious. I could understand the phrase "must be employed."
Comment on this
It is the number which the committee considers should be employed, but there will be absolute liberty given to provide that that will be the number that should be taken. There are two other amendments which are somewhat linked with this amendment, an amendment to Section 20 and a new section proposed to be inserted before Section 21. The three go some what together. I think the small point the Deputy raises can be understood even from this. They will fix a number. It is said here that that is the number the committee thinks should be employed. That will be the number in relation to which prosecutions afterwards will be taken. I do not see any difficulty in the amendment.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy read the new section before 21 and the amendment to Section 20? The Deputy could read over that point about the word "should" and consider that we are attempting to fix numbers not in relation to any particular premises but in relation to the specified employees to be employed by an employer in such trade or in such district and the further point that the number may be expressed as the proportion to be employed by any particular person.
Comment on this
Supposing the employer has more apprentices than the local committee considers it advisable for him to have, is there to be any appeal on behalf of an employer to any superior body?
Comment on this
We will have to take the three together. Deputies must consider amendment 37 and amendment 38 as one with this.
Comment on this
I suppose there will be no need for making provision for people like painting contractors, for instance, who send their apprentices to any part of the country? I am thinking now of the phrase "whom such committee considers should be employed by such employer in such trade in such district." In the case of apprentices of that kind it would be very hard to define their district. I cannot quite see the way out, but there may have to be special provision made for cases of that kind.
Comment on this
"The employer's district"—the district here will be the district of the employer. If he has a certain number of apprentices he can send these off to certain parts of the country.
Comment on this
In that case, you would have such apprentices employed for perhaps the greater part of a year outside that district altogether.
Comment on this
Possibly; yet after all what we are aiming at is to get some relationship between the number of apprentices and the number of skilled tradesmen. Supposing an apprenticeship committee views a particular thing like that. The painting business is one in which the difficulty will not arise. Suppose it is viewed in relation to Dublin and you get an establishment which is accustomed to taking on work in other parts of the country. If it is agreed that a man shall be allowed to have so many apprentices, does it matter in the end where the apprentices are sent for training?
Comment on this
Difficulties of this kind arise occasionally. With employers the number of employees varies because sometimes they are busy and other times they are not busy, but the number of apprentices they have to take on is calculated on the number of employees they had when they were busy. Then when the work gets slack the local committee may say: "You have too many apprentices." If we are to have it one way we will have to have it the other way. If you are going to compel the employer to take so many apprentices if the emergency arises and the committee says he has too many apprentices, I want some way of dealing with the situation. That is my difficulty rather than the other difficulty, and I think any figures I have used have shown that. A subdivision of that character will be necessary.
Comment on this
I do not propose to take the three together. I say that the later two must be read along with this in order to have this properly understood. The special point to which the Deputy refers really comes on on the new Section 21.
Comment on this
You are going to bring this rule into operation. The employer, say, has six apprentices. If the committee make a regulation that he is only to have two or three, what is to become of the others?
Comment on this
Can the Deputy say what has been the practice hitherto in cases of the character to which he refers?
Comment on this
We had no apprenticeship committees hitherto. I would like to have some experience of their working before answering that question.
Comment on this
I think so far as the building trade is concerned these things are covered by agreement. I do not think that this Apprenticeship Bill will upset these agreements.
Comment on this
If there are agreements which are legally enforceable as between the apprentices and employers the enforcement of these agreements may still continue, but under this Bill the only thing to which force of contract is given are the rules made by the apprenticeship committee. Once the rules are made the employers and the apprentices are both deemed to be bound by these rules. As far as this Bill is concerned, several things are left out. They may be legally enforceable. They may be something further than what is here, but this Bill does not deal with these.
Comment on this
If the Minister, on the next stage, would bring in something that would deal with this situation, should it arise——
Comment on this
You can quite foresee that a committee might say that an employer should not have so many apprentices. What will become of the others?
Comment on this
I move amendment 28:
In sub-section (4), lines 58 and 60, to insert after the word "make" the words "rescind or amend" in each line.
The purpose of this amendment is to provide that when the committee makes a rule and gets the sanction of the Minister for the rule, it may not amend or rescind that rule without the sanction of the Minister.
Comment on this
The amendment seems unobjectionable at the moment, but there will have to be an addition —rescind, amend, or add to.
Comment on this
If the committee added would not it be a new rule requiring the sanction of the Minister in any case?
Comment on this
I move amendment 29:—
Before sub-section (5), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"An apprenticeship committee before making rules under this section in respect to any trade shall take into consideration the practices and customs prevalent in such trade and in particular any agreements existing between employers and trade unions in relation to the conditions affecting apprenticeship and shall not make any rule in contravention of any existing practice or agreement recognised by employers and trade unions in the trade without the approval of such trade unions."
This section deals with rules by the apprenticeship committees. The purpose of this amendment ought to be quite obvious. They would be useless, and would tend to defeat the objects of this Bill if rules were made without the good-will of the trade unions. The members of the trade unions, after all, are the persons who will have to teach these lads their various trades or occupations. I feel that it would be wiser to have these words inserted in the Bill so that friction may be avoided in the future, and that these rules will be drawn up in conformity with the rules of the trade unions affected. I think that is a very useful provision. I hope the Minister will accept it.
Comment on this
Under this amendment, as I understand it, the trade unions are going to regulate the number of apprentices.
Comment on this
Is that what the Deputy proposes? Is not that what we are trying to get away from all the afternoon?
Comment on this
My attitude in this is, that if the existing practice or custom prevalent in the trade, and the existing agreements are to rule apprentices, there is no reason in the Bill being brought in at all. If we are going to establish these as a standard by which everything must be ruled, there is no reason for the Bill, because if there are agreements there, and the people want them modified, I presume they can get them modified. At any rate, the trade unionists cannot have it that there may be compulsion put upon employers with regard to an existing agreement, but where they themselves do not like it the existing agreement must stand. There is very little in the way of compulsion in this Bill, but this would remove every vestige of anything approaching to compulsion. The whole approach to this matter must be rather in a conciliatory way, so that these things probably will be taken into consideration, but I think the Bill ought to be withdrawn if this is what is to rule. If this is going to be the criterion there is no use having the Bill at all.
Comment on this
I submit that it would be good policy to discuss this matter with these representatives. It does not necessarily follow——
Comment on this
The amendment says that the committee shall take into consideration the practices and customs prevalent in such trade and in particular any agreements existing between employers and trade unions in relation to the conditions affecting apprenticeship, and shall not make any rule in contravention of any existing practice or agreement recognised by employers and trade unions in the trade without the approval of such trade union. It is a bit one-sided.
Comment on this
I move amendment 30:
To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
"(2) If, owing to the death or insolvency of the employer or for any other reason which the Minister deems satisfactory, the terms of any contract of apprenticeship in a designated trade cannot be fulfilled, or if the parties to the contract mutually agree, the Minister, in consultation with the apprenticeship committee for such trade, may arrange for the transfer of the contract to another employer."
This is a section taken from the South African Act, which appears to me to be necessary in order to protect the interests of apprentices whose employers might die, become bankrupt, or, for some other reason, be unable to fulfil the contract. It seems to me to be necessary, although I am not convinced of it. The Minister, no doubt, has looked into the matter, and can tell us whether it is or not. There does not appear to be any provision to deal with the particular case of an apprentice whose employer goes bankrupt, and who is consequently unable to fulfil his contract with that apprentice. The purpose of the amendment is in such a case to give the apprenticeship committee power to transfer that contract to another employer, so that the apprentice's training would continue.
Comment on this
I am not at all certain that the full effect of the amendment is not contained in the concluding words of Section 12, "such committee may, if it so thinks fit, release both parties from their respective obligations under the agreement implied by this section, or modify such agreement." There may be one point left over by that, and it will be examined between this and the Report Stage to see whether the section meets the exact point the Deputy has in his amendment. However, I suggest that if there is going to be an amendment it ought to be more generally phrased than on the basis of death or insolvency—for instance, adding to it, "modify such agreement or substitute-another party to the agreement." That would probably meet it better.
Comment on this
I should like the Minister also to consider that an apprentice might be forced, perhaps against the will of his parents, to go to an employer chosen by the committee. I do not think that would be advisable. As I read the amendment, it is possible that a young apprentice, whose employer has died or becomes insolvent or disappears, might be forced to go to an employer with whom his parents did not agree. There is that danger.
Comment on this
Remember that it is always the committee may do certain things. The line of approach I take is, that I will consider meeting whatever difficulties there are in the section by adding to it "or substitute another party thereto." That is tied up to the preamble in the section already, that the committee may, if it thinks fit, do certain things. However, the Deputy can see exactly how far my amendment goes.
Comment on this
Has the Minister considered the question of whom the apprentice is to be bound to, because that is involved in the amendment we have just been considering? The transfer of an apprentice would be very much easier if the apprentice is bound, as a great many are now, to a committee instead of an employer. That is done with the object of giving the apprentice a better training. Supposing that the trade of an employer with whom he is learning his trade for any reason falls off, then the apprentice does not get the opportunity for learning his trade that possibly may be desirable. In that particular case, if there is any reason for the falling off of the trade, and if he is bound to a committee, the committee can transfer him to another employer who happens to be busy in that industry, thereby giving him a better training. That is a point that ought to be considered if the Minister has not considered it. It is one of the more modern ideas in connection with improving the training of apprentices and it is working most satisfactorily in several large areas in America.
Comment on this
Although Section 12 says that where the rules are in force a person is to be deemed to be employed under an agreement signed by such person and his employer—although these are marked out as the two parties to this agreement, the committee is also in it, because the committee then has power to modify. We have to a certain extent got in the committee, although probably not as directly as the Deputy would like.
Comment on this
The difficulty is this: The contract of apprenticeship is made between the apprentice or his parents and the employer and cannot be broken by any third party.
Comment on this
It would want to be a very special form. I ask the Minister to consider the other point. Instead of binding the apprentice to the employer, he should bind that apprentice to the committee. The employer is bound to train under this Bill, and the committee can regulate the way the boy can be trained, as to the hours he is to attend and other things like that. It does not alter the question of that training at all. It certainly does alter and make much more easy the question of transference from an employer, who may be slack, to an employer who may be busy.
Comment on this
I move amendment 31:—
In page 7, to delete sub-section (2), and substitute the following sub-section:—
"(2) If any employer—
(a) fails or neglects to keep such records as are required by this section to be kept; or
(b) wilfully or negligently makes in such records any entry which is false or misleading in any material particular,
he shall be guilty of an offence under this section and be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding two pounds and also, in case of failure or neglect to keep such records, to a fine not exceeding one pound for every day during which such failure or neglect continues after conviction."
There appears to be a defect in this. There was an obligation put upon the employer to keep records of wages, but apparently there was a loophole, that he might keep false records, and this is intended to meet that.
Comment on this
If a particular employer merely neglects to keep such records you put him on the same level of punishment as an employer who deliberately falsifies his records. I think there is a very big distinction. Deputy Cassidy's amendment, along with the provision in the Bill, would, I think, be much better, but here you put the two on the same basis. The failure of a man to keep records may be due to many things, but I would regard deliberate falsification as a much greater offence, and it should not, I think, be put on the same basis.
Comment on this
I think they are hardly put on the same basis. The same maximum is applied to both. Does the Deputy think that a maximum of £2 is not sufficient for falsification?
Comment on this
You leave a man open to the maximum fine who simply neglects doing it.
Comment on this
I suggest to the Minister that the fine for the offence prescribed in clause B should be progressive. You have very severe penalties for those who fail or neglect to keep records, that is, after the first offence is discovered, whereas apparently a man who wilfully makes a wrong record is subject only to a fine not exceeding £2, and if he repeats the offence twenty times the fine cannot be increased. There is something disproportionate there.
Comment on this
I might remind Deputies that this is a voluntary act, and if you put on penalties of a nature that an employer might consider excessive it may have its reactions. The employer may say: "I will not incur responsibilities and liabilities of that character, and so I will not take any apprentices." I should like that both sides should be before the Minister when he is considering this particular aspect.
Comment on this
He can do so now by moving to alter the figure £2.
Comment on this
There is a special amendment by Deputy Cassidy dealing with that.
Comment on this
The amendments are practically the same for the penalties. Amendment 32 is to change it from £2 in paragraph (b) to £5.
Comment on this
No. That only applies to the amount to be inflicted for falsification.
Comment on this
May I remind the Minister that the fines for breaches of contract seem in strange contrast with those provided in sub-section (2) Section 17? It provides: "If an employer employs by way of apprenticeship any person in contravention of this section he shall be guilty of an offence under this section, and shall be liable, on summary conviction thereof, to a fine not exceeding twenty pounds." An employer is liable to a fine of twenty pounds for employing an apprentice who has not the educational qualification, a thing that the Minister himself admitted it may be very hard to define, but the person who makes a deliberately wrong entry in his records is only subject to a maximum fine of £2.
Comment on this
The Minister, I think, suggests that the Deputies should reserve that point for the Report Stage, accepting his amendment in the form set out, and putting down an amendment for Report Stage varying the penalties.
Comment on this
As a workman myself, I must say that I do not think it would be wise to impose too many regulations upon employers. I find myself in some difficulty in discussing this matter, because in the country there is practically no work for apprentices at all. If you impose these regulations upon employers, it may be that you will be defeating the very purpose that this Bill has in view. I know employers at the present moment who are very loath to take in apprentices because their work is not continuous, and they cannot guarantee that the work will be continued long enough to cover the apprenticeship period of five years. I think there is too much legislation at the moment. I think that we should see that the work is there before we pass rules and regulations governing it, and if we did that the country would be much better off. I am absolutely opposed to any more regulations being imposed upon the employers or upon the workmen. Leave them alone, I say. I do not know how we got on for the past thirty-five or forty years without any of these regulations.
Comment on this
That is the most sensible speech that has been made here to-day. I have a number of young fellows in my employment learning their trade, and if I am to be compelled to do all the things that are sought to be imposed here somebody else, I think, will have to employ these people. Labour ought to recognise that they are doing very well in Ireland to-day. There is no country in Europe where they are getting better paid and where there is less unemployment.
Comment on this
I would like to ask are we going to have second reading speeches again here on the Committee Stage of this Bill and foolish statements such as we have just listened to.
Comment on this
I think if there was a comparison made between us the Deputy would not come out the best, even though he is leader of the Labour Party.
Comment on this
I move amendment 33:
To insert before Section 15 a new section as follows:—
"(1) It shall be an offence under this Act for any person without the written consent of the Minister directly or indirectly to require or permit any person to pay or give or to receive from any person any consideration, premium or bonus in respect of the engagement or employment of an apprentice.
(2) Any person guilty of an offence under this section shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding twenty-five pounds and on such conviction the court may order the person receiving such consideration, premium or bonus, to repay the amount thereof to the person by whom it was paid."
This amendment raises a question we had under discussion during the Second Reading of the Bill. That is whether there should be regulations prohibiting the giving or requiring of a fine or bonus as a condition of apprenticeship. A number of Deputies expressed strong views on this question, and urged that the Bill should be amended so as to make it illegal for any employer to require, or for any person to pay, a fine or bonus as a condition of apprenticeship. That is also one of the provisions of the South African Act upon which this Bill is founded. The Minister in preparing his Bill must have had, for some reason or another, definitely decided to insert this particular section. What his reasons were we are anxious to know. There is a practice in certain trades requiring that apprentices shall pay, in some cases, quite substantial sums before they are admitted to apprenticeship. That particular practice results in persons in poorer circumstances being debarred from these trades. It also results in some cases in particularly dangerous abuses, in so far as apprentices may be taken on by incompetent employers who have no real need for them, who are not in a position to train them, and whose desire is to extract the fine from parents of the apprentices. I have myself experience of one or two cases of poor people who scraped together a fairly substantial sum of money in order to get their sons trained in a particular business. They paid these sums by way of bonuses to particular employers who were utterly incompetent to teach their sons, and who, in fact, in one case decamped altogether before the period of apprenticeship had concluded. If we are going to set out now to regulate the conditions of apprenticeship in particular trades we should, I think, make it one of the rules that no payment of this kind be required from any person seeking entry to any trade, and that, so long as other conditions laid down in Section 8 of the Bill are complied with, admission to industry should be open to everybody.
That is the purpose of this amendment. The amendment in the name of Deputy Anthony is somewhat similar to mine. Both are based on the South African Act and embody a principle which, I think, should recommend itself to the House, particularly to those Deputies who have had experience of incidents such as I have mentioned.
Comment on this
I desire to support the amendment moved by Deputy Lemass. It is much on the lines of one that I have down. In view of all that Deputy Lemass has said on his amendment with regard to this system of taking fees for apprentices there is no need for me to say much. Like Deputy Lemass, I am aware of some very sad cases where parents or guardians of boys paid substantial fees to have them trained to some trade. Two cases occurred recently in Cork in the electrical trade. Fees were taken for the training of apprentices. The person who took the fees was not able to teach the boys any trade at all. He took his departure to England a short time afterwards and has not since been heard of. The practice is far more common than many people imagine. I understand it is quite common in Dublin City. It is pretty common in Cork City, too, but I think that some of those who acted in that way in the past will not try it on again.
Comment on this
I ask for a ruling that the amendments in the names of Deputy Lemass and Deputy Anthony are both out of order. They refer to the payment of a consideration, premium or bonus in respect of the engagement or employment of an apprentice. This Bill refers only to certain designated trades. The amendments refer to apprentices of all types.
Comment on this
I could not rule out the amendments on that ground. I take them as referring to apprentices to whom the Act will apply.
Comment on this
As Deputy Lemass's amendment stands, it applies to all apprentices. It would apply to an apprentice to a dentist.
Comment on this
I could understand the Minister's point if he gave that as a reason for not being able to accept the amendment as worded. Before ruling the amendments out of order, it would be necessary to have the point discussed.
Comment on this
I will discuss the point. If the amendment in its present form were to be inserted it would widen the scope of the Bill beyond designated trades. Deputy Anthony said that his amendment was exactly the same as Deputy Lemass's. His amendment, I presume, refers to all apprentices whether in designated trades or not.
Comment on this
I would like to have the amendment extended to all apprentices. If it is not possible to do that under the Bill, perhaps a slight alteration could be made in the wording of the amendment.
Comment on this
The Bill only deals with designated trades. At the moment the position is that the apprenticeship committee need not make rules in relation to the number of people who may be employed by way of apprenticeship. There is no obligation on the committee to make a rule regulating the numbers. If the committee does not make such a rule, then a premium may be demanded by an employer. If the committee makes a regulation with regard to numbers, the employer must take that number, and cannot enforce conditions of his own, but if the committee makes regulations with regard to numbers no premium can be enforced.
Comment on this
Supposing the number of persons seeking to be engaged as apprentices exceeds the number for which there are vacancies, then a premium might be offered and might be accepted.
Comment on this
With regard to these premiums, I think there is some misunderstanding. We had a good many people in our place, and never got a premium from them. In the case of people learning shop-work, the custom was for them to pay some little premium, but whether that is the rule now or not I do not know. In return for that premium the people who accepted them as apprentices kept them in their houses and supported them.
Comment on this
The situation is as I have just explained. There may be something in the point that Deputy Lemass urged a moment ago, that if there were a dozen people offering for apprenticeship and four of them say they will pay a premium, these four may be taken in preference to other people. If we want to prohibit that it is a very serious matter, and should be debated on a proper amendment, and not on this amendment, which is far too wide in its scope. The matter might be debated on a simple amendment prohibiting premiums in cases in which rules have been made regulating numbers.
Comment on this
Because if the committee do not think it desirable to lay down rules with regard to numbers, there must be some reason operating in their minds to prevent their doing that, for instance, special considerations applying to the business. Without knowing what those conditions are it seems to me that we should not casually do away with the rather common system of paying premiums or bonus for training to be given. There are certain obligations imposed on employers, and I would rather have the question of premiums tied up with some of these conditions. I picked out the rule relating to numbers, but the question might also be tied up with the rule relating to educational qualifications, although I think it would be rather ironic to tie it up with that. I object entirely to the amendment, because it proposes to sweep away the premium system from every profession or trade, irrespective of whether it is a designated trade coming under this Bill or not. I would object to the sweeping away of the premium system completely even in the case of a designated trade. I would prefer to have the question considered in relation to some rule or regulation that the committee can make. If Deputies express the desire to have premiums done away with generally in relation to apprentices in designated trades, then I can have considered, between now and the Report Stage, which of the paragraphs it should be attached to and what conditions should be attached to the non-enforcement of premiums.
Comment on this
It is not the custom, as Deputy McDonogh stated, in the larger industries, as far as I know, to accept premiums. In the industry with which I am connected there are no premiums. They have gone out of fashion. As the Deputy pointed out, there are trades in which premiums still are paid for certain returns which the apprentices obtain. I agree with the Minister that it would be inadvisable to sweep away the whole system without due enquiry. If the Minister is satisfied that it is desirable to maintain premiums in particular departments I think he should have liberty to do so in the Bill. I am quite satisfied that the question will not arise.
Comment on this
If the Minister is prepared to consider the matter, and to draft an amendment relating to the payment of premiums, and dealing with the number of employees, and to introduce such an amendment on the Report Stage, I prefer to withdraw my amendment. I realise that this amendment cannot go through in its present form. If the Minister will consider the matter and let the House know whether he is going to do so or not, so as to enable the question to be discussed on the Report Stage, it would satisfy me.
Comment on this
What I am suggesting as a possible alternative would be either to put in a new clause to Section 8 (2), leaving it open to the committee to say that premiums shall not be enforced—either to do that, or else to say premiums shall not be enforceable except, and to tie that on to the exception to the rule which requires an employer to train and instruct.
Comment on this
Will the exact scope of the training and instruction which the employer must give be defined in the Bill or be outlined by the committee? I am not very familiar with conditions in industrial Dublin, but I was familiar with the industrial conditions in Belfast, where the premium system has vanished in relation to handicrafts, where personal instruction is not given by the employer. At this stage, so far as ordinary handicrafts and trades are concerned, they are an anachronism and should be abolished.
Comment on this
When he is drafting the amendment I would like to give the Minister some discretion in case he considers the wording too drastic. I suggest that premiums and fees might be allowed where proper training would be given or where there were special circumstances. I know the type of case Deputy McDonogh referred to where something is given in return, for instance, maintenance. That class of case could be covered by "special circumstances," and I suggest that the Minister should have regard to such circumstances.
Comment on this
What I propose to do is to consider an amendment which will be entirely within the scope of the Bill, and will have reference only to designated trades. Alternatively, I will consider making a new sub-section to Section 8 (2), clause (e), allowing the committee to make rules forbidding the taking of premiums in any case but leaving it to the committee to do so, and not making it compulsory on the committee, or else amend clause (c) of Section 8 (2) so as to allow premiums to be enforced if and when training is given.
Comment on this
I do not expect that that will be a very satisfactory conclusion— to prevent the giving of fees in a designated trade and to allow it to prevail in other trades. That will obviously raise the fees in trades not designated. Fees have been going up recently. I heard an employer remarking the other day that he thought he could live entirely on the fees from apprentices if he were prepared to accept all that offered. I think the Principal of the technical schools in Dublin could tell the Minister that it is becoming practically impossible to place boys who have been trained there because they are not able to meet the demands for fees made by employers. It does not seem to me to be satisfactory to have one class of trades where fees are prohibited and to have perhaps much bigger classes where they are allowed.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not want me to prohibit fees in trades outside the designated trades. I cannot do that in this Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment 36:—
In page 7, to delete sub-section (2) and to substitute the following sub-section:—
"(2) If any employer—
(a) fails or neglects to keep such records as are required by this section to be kept; or
(b) wilfully or negligently makes in such records any entry which is false or misleading in any particular,
he shall be guilty of an offence under this section and be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding two pounds, and also, in case of failure or neglect to keep such records, to a fine not exceeding one pound for every day during which such failure or neglect continues after conviction."
Comment on this
Was it purposely that the word "material" in Clause (b) of the amendment was left out? That adjective is used in other parts of the Bill.
Comment on this
I absolutely object to the wording of sub-section (2):—
If an employer employs by way of apprenticeship any person in contravention of this section he shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding twenty pounds.
To submit a person to a fine of £20 for employing an apprentice who had not the educational qualifications laid down in the rules is, in my opinion, a preposterous proposal. We must take into account the fact that very many employers will be unable to judge the educational qualifications of apprentices. If the Minister replies that such employers have the committee to appeal to, it must be remembered that very often there are ties of blood and family friendships that are urging them to employ particular persons. It could not be regarded as a very serious offence in view of the vague term "educational qualifications" to employ apprentices who would not be up to standard. I suggest that sub-section (2) should be deleted. In fact, the whole section is unnecessary in my opinion.
Comment on this
If the whole section is unnecessary we need hardly give the committee power to make regulations about educational qualifications. If they are not going to enforce it there is no use making a rule. It would be very drastic to wipe out the section.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy Moore that the penalty is excessive. I do not think it should be more than £2, unless the case is the same as the class of one we had a few moments ago.
Comment on this
The comparison made a moment ago was a wrong one, because Deputy Moore took a section for comparison which was not a comparable section. The scheme throughout is that there are rules which may be made. The penalty for contravention of the rules, I think, in every case is a fine of £20, but you come to certain things incidental to the rules, such as the keeping of records, where the penalty varies. I would like to have an expression by way of an amendment before the Report Stage. It might be held that the penalty for falsifying a record, for instance, is too small. It can be dealt with by amendment on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I will object to that unless the Deputy consequentially will say that he is going to move to delete part of Section 8 (2) (a).
Comment on this
Of course I would have to go over the whole Bill again to see whether there could not be another method found of promoting a good standard of education amongst apprentices rather than compelling an educational standard and enforcing it by means of heavy fines. I would not be prepared to give an opinion on that. As it stands, I do not think that the Dáil should pass it.
Comment on this
I think there is some confusion about this. There is a good deal to be said for Deputy Moore's attitude, and I think he should bring in an amendment at a later period, but at the same time we must have regard to the commonsense of the committees to be appointed. I take it that no committee will require an apprentice, say, to bootmaking, to have a university degree. It simply demands a certain standard of education, that standard being something of an elementary character. Any of us who have given any service on technical instruction committees knows that a number of boys came to the technical schools to avail of technical education, but were unable to go into the first technological class because they could not do simple multiplication. What is the use of giving a boy a formula to work out certain results when he cannot do simple multiplication? How can you ask him to do sums in simple proportion when he cannot add five and five?
Comment on this
It is not the fault of the teachers, but of the system, and of the class represented by Deputy Good, who kept the common people of this country uneducated. That is the cause. While it may be necessary to change the figure £20 to £10, I do not think that it calls for so much adverse comment.
Comment on this
According to Deputy Anthony, the sins of the employers are to be visited on the apprentices. Because the employers have not enabled the children to get a proper education they are not to be allowed to get training in a designated trade. I think it will be found that there will be so many different standards for different trades no committee will be able to fix an educational standard. As the Minister pointed out, there are a great many trades in which the lowest standard that would be fixed would hardly be required by the apprentices. If you visualise an instance where a man has a relation, a cousin or a nephew, who desires to be an apprentice, are you going to say that that man has first to look up the educational standard fixed by the local committee, and if the boy is not up to that standard, he has to dismiss him under a penalty of £20? Such a proposal is quite unreasonable.
Comment on this
The Deputy will consider an amendment for the Report Stage?
Comment on this
If the Deputy puts down an amendment for £2 on Report, we will all support him, except, of course, Deputy Anthony.
Sections 17, 18 and 19 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
SECTION 20.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 37 as follows:—
In page 8, to delete sub-section (1) and substitute the following sub-section:—
"(1) Where any rules regulating the number of apprentices made by an apprenticeship committee are for the time being in force and such rules fix a standard number in relation to any specified employer, it shall not be lawful for such employer to take into his employment by way of apprenticeship in the district of such committee in the trade for which such committee is established any person unless—
(a) either no person is then employed by such employer as an apprentice in such trade in such district or the number of persons then so employed is less than such standard number; and
(b) such taking into employment would have the effect of making the total number of apprentices so employed by him equal to such standard number."
This and the next amendment are the amendments to which I directed Deputy Good's attention earlier. This amendment aims at preventing the standard number of apprentices being exceeded by any employer taking in new apprentices. It allows, where the number had been exceeded before the rule had been made, the number in excess to be retained, but no new people to be taken on. That is the effect of amendment No. 37.
Comment on this
I move amendment 38 as follows:—
Before Section 21 to insert a new section, as follows:—
(1) Where any rules regulating the number of apprentices made by an apprenticeship committee are for the time being in force and such rules fix a standard number in relation to any specified employer, if and whenever such employer employs in the district of such committee in the trade for which such committee is established either no apprentice or a number of apprentices less than such standard number, such committee may make an order in the prescribed form requiring him to take into his employment by way of apprenticeship in such district in such trade such number of persons as will make the total number of apprentices employed by him in such district in such trade equal to such standard number.
(2) Whenever an order is duly made under the foregoing sub-section in relation to an employer and such order is personally served on such employer, it shall be the duty of such employer to comply with such order within one month after such service, and if he fails so to do he shall, unless he satisfies the court that such failure was due to some unavoidable cause, be guilty of an offence under this section and be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding ten pounds.
This amendment refers back to the point which Deputy Moore mentioned on Section 8, the number which the committee consider should be the maximum. This enables the committee to enforce the number which it considers should be employed, if the employer, despite the fact that the committee has intimated that opinion, insists on employing a number less.
Comment on this
That, of course, gets back to the committee on which there will be representative members and gets back to the Minister who has to confirm in regard to the particular business or particular employer specified in a particular district.
Comment on this
I submit that this amendment, as worded, is a bit too dictatorial. Possibly it is not intended to be so but I think it could be made less so and be just as useful. If it read, "may, if suitable representations to the employer had been made without effect," I think that would make the amendment more useful. As it stands, you have a committee and there may be an employer that none of them has any particular reason to be sympathetic with. Such employer may be found not to be employing the requisite number of apprentices and the committee may make an order compelling him to take the necessary number into his business. Would it not be better to proceed by way of representation because he may have a good case to make? Presumably any rule made under this section need not be strictly obeyed under all the circumstances.
Comment on this
My difficulty in regard to this proposal is similar to that which I explained before. There are times when an employer can usefully employ a number of apprentices but there are other times when he can only employ a considerably lesser number. If he is bound to employ the larger number when trade is bad and the number of tradesmen are few, it is putting a somewhat unfair obligation on such employer.
Comment on this
It might happen that in the building trade a builder might be busy for six months and have employment for a number of bricklayers and carpenters. In that case the rule was, one apprentice to three tradesmen.
Comment on this
The builder after six months might have absolutely nothing to do and in that event what is going to be done? The whole Bill is bristling with difficulties and the Minister will find that out when he comes to put it into operation. There is no need for all this legislation. It would be much better to leave things as they are. There may be apprentices bound to a builder who has no work. Am I to understand that a builder can keep an apprentice on for five years, though he may be as good at the end of three years as at the end of five, and that he will be prevented from going elsewhere? The whole thing is ridiculous.
Comment on this
I am sorry that the Deputy was not here earlier when a considerable number of Deputies wanted to make the whole Bill compulsory. It was not, apparently, couched in a sufficiently dictatorial manner. I suggested that we should advance by slow steps and have the voluntary principle tried out. Now I hear some of the advocates for compulsion coming round to my point of view.
Comment on this
The Minister knows that there is a big difference between passing a Bill with compulsory powers and suggesting to a committee to be dictatorial in their relations with an individual employer.
Comment on this
The attitude of compulsion that was expressed here was first of all that there should be no waiting upon people to make application, that there should be an enforcement of this whole Act upon people whether they applied or not. There was further a desire to amend the Bill so as to make certain things which the committee, may at its discretion settle by rule, compulsory on them by rule. Deputy Coburn was not in for the discussion but on that very point there was a discussion. As the Bill stands at the moment the committee may not establish any rule, that is, the duty is imposed upon them to establish a rule but if they do not do it there is no enforcement. Deputy Good amongst others wanted to make this one of the points upon which the committee had to make rules and I think Deputy Moore was in favour of that principle also.
Comment on this
What we object to is that portion of the Bill is compulsory and other portions of it are optional. Whenever the Minister thought it might be useful to put something in he inserted it, but where he thought it would not, he would not insert it. There is no principle underlying the Bill.
Comment on this
The Minister knows very well the difference between the two things we indicated. In this case, it is a matter of administration, that the committees should not be encouraged to be arbitrary in their actions or in their orders to particular employers. There is a suggestion in this amendment that they can act in a very arbitrary way. That is very different from the Dáil deciding to be arbitrary or deciding to make certain things compulsory.
Comment on this
Exactly: let us force everybody into it whether they like it or not, and insist on the committee carrying out its duties and making rules in regard to numbers, but when they are going to carry them out against an individual employer we are to see that they are to be meek and mild towards them. What is the dictatorial committee going to do?
The committee may make an order requiring a man to take into his employment such a number as to make the total equal to the standard number. There is a sub-section which follows providing that when the order is made the employer must comply, and if he fails to do so he shall, unless he satisfies the Court that the failure was due to some unavoidable cause, be guilty of an offence. I do not know what other buffer is required between the committee which, we will have to suppose, is likely to act in a reasonable way and this employer. If the committee is so full of hostility to one employer—these were the circumstances the Deputy outlined, the committee being inimical to a certain employer, deciding to force it on him, subjecting him to very vindictive treatment, and going to force on him a certain number of employees—does the Deputy think that this hostility is going to be lessened in any way if you ask them to make representations to an employer before serving an order on him? I do not think it helps the would-be victimised employer to any great extent. I think there is sufficient difficulty in the matter already, and a sufficiently easy approach to the difficulty in the matter already. The committee establishes what it thinks would be the proper number. It gives notice of that. If it finds that an employer is not complying it serves notice on him to take on the number, and then Court proceedings follow if he refuses. I do not know what the Deputy wants.
Comment on this
The stages are then: the committee decides on a certain number of apprentices to each employer; it is reported that an employer in the district has not complied with that rule; the committee then immediately serve notice on him to employ that number, and if he has not done so within a certain time, the next stage is that he is taken into Court. I submit that it could be made less unpleasant than this, but I am not prepared to press the matter.
Comment on this
Before the amendment is put finally there is one aspect of the question that should be considered. Supposing a committee says to an employer, "You are to take so many apprentices," and that that employer takes on that number of apprentices, the members of the local trades union may say, "We will go out on strike." Is any penalty to be imposed on the local trades union, or is all the penalty to be put on the employer? We want the Bill to be fair. I have not seen that any penalty attached to any trade union in this connection. They happen to do things which are illegal, like the rest of us at times. They would make it difficult for the man to take on the number of apprentices by saying, "If you take them on we will go out on strike." On the other hand, if he does not take them on, he is penalised by the committee. Whose advice is he to take? The obvious thing is to put in a clause——
Comment on this
Would the Minister not consider leaving the period between the serving of the order on the employer and the time when he must comply longer than a month? After all, the employer, I presume, would be entitled to exercise some personal choice with regard to apprentices. If he has only got a month in which to make his choice it may take him over this time to get suitable persons. I submit that the period in which he should be allowed to choose his apprentices might well be left to the committee.
Comment on this
The Minister is giving a reply then to my argument, and therefore I must determine whether I am going on with my proposal or not. That is a more direct way of doing it.
Comment on this
I move amendment 39:—
In sub-section (2), page 8, to insert in line 46 after the word "held" the words "within the normal working hours of such apprentice and" and to delete in line 47 the word "person" and substitute the word "apprentice," and in sub-section (4), page 8, to delete in line 65 the words "so far as the same may be necessary."
This point was raised on the Second Stage with regard to the question of night work, and I am meeting the suggestions then made.
Comment on this
I move amendment 41, which reads:—
In sub-section (3), line 59, to delete the word "section" and substitute the word "sub-section."
Comment on this
I intended to change the wording of it. I want the word "sub" inserted before section so as to have read it "sub-section."
Comment on this
I do not understand the reason for the change. I think the whole thing is contained in the section to which the Deputy's amendment refers and not the sub-section.
Comment on this
Will the Minister accept that where unavoidable causes arise, and where the apprentice is working longer than an eight hours' day, it will be taken to mean an unavoidable cause, such as sickness? It would be rather unfair to penalise a lad who has been kept by a builder working in the country, and expect him to attend a technical school and do night work, when he has completed his ordinary day's work.
Comment on this
The Deputy's amendment is to Section 21, as it is in the present Bill, and he proposes to change the word section in three places and to put in the word sub-section. I think the thing is entirely wrong.
Comment on this
I am trying to safeguard the position that I indicated earlier, and I wish to say that I tried to induce the Minister to have a day fixed not greater than an eight hour day. I want that amendment inserted in order to obviate any trouble occurring in this section, where, as I have tried to indicate, a boy might be kept working at a building a good distance from the technical school, and because of that fact he could not attend the school at night.
Comment on this
I want to ask if Deputy Anthony is in favour of fining an apprentice because of his absence? In one amendment he was proposing to fine him £1. The apprentice is getting 5/- a week and he may be fined £1.
Comment on this
Before Section 24 is passed, may I ask the Minister if he has considered making any provision against the giving by employers of certificates which are incorrect and misleading as regards the apprentices? This is one of the plagues of the day and it is doing a very great amount of harm. Apprentices who have merely knocked about in a business, and who have been attached to it in the vaguest possible way, are able to get splendid certificates from employers. Very often these certificates are couched in the most elaborate language, testifying to the skill and industry these apprentices have shown and their genius for business—all of which is often entirely incorrect. Very often too these youths are in trades where the employment bears on the safety of human life. It is a very frequent complaint throughout the country that testimonials or certificates from employers in a good many trades cannot be trusted at the present time—that no reliance can be attached to them. It looks to me, without having heard anything from the Minister on the matter, that to ignore that matter was a curious omission on his part. It would have been a very useful reform if he had provided against the giving of certificates that would be incorrect.
Comment on this
I am glad that Deputy Moore has raised this point because it is a most important one. The standard of craftsmanship has fallen very considerably in recent years and I am not sure it is not continuing to fall. We would like to see the standard raised rather than to see it falling. This is a point that has been worrying a number of employers for a considerable period. A number of them are agreed that before the apprentice gets a certificate he should be called upon to pass an examination in the craft to which he is being apprenticed and that he should not be allowed, if he has not given any attention to his work or to his work in the schools while he has been passing through his term of apprenticeship, to get that certificate. Such a boy should be penalised. Furthermore, that is the only way that will raise the standard of craftsmanship. I would like the Minister to consider that particular aspect of the question. It is unfair that a boy who is of a very poor standard from the point of view of his craft and who has given no attention to the business should be set free and treated after a certain time in exactly the same way as the boy who has given attention to his work and knows his craft.
Comment on this
Whilst I agree in general with what Deputy Good has stated, still I think the boy is penalised enough if, as a result of his inefficiency, he will not get employment. Surely the employer is not such a fool as to keep an inefficient man in his employment. It would be up to the apprentice himself to make himself efficient in his trade, otherwise when he is finished with the apprenticeship he will not get employment. I am sure Deputy Good would be the last man to keep in his employment a man who is inefficient. I do not know how the Minister could include in this Bill a section dealing with the point raised by Deputy Good and Deputy Moore. Many a time, I am sure, Deputy Moore gave a character to a person in order to get employment and perhaps the new employer might not find the man at all efficient or up to the necessary standard. Of course Deputy Moore would give that character in good faith. Any other employer might just do the same. It is hard to fix a general rule in these cases. The whole thing would depend upon the employer. He will soon find out whether the man he employs is capable or incapable, and if he is not a good man he will not keep him.
[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]
Comment on this
I think the last speaker has given the answer to the points that have been raised. The complaint is made that a man might go into a particular trade and he would get the same wages as really skilled persons although, because of his lack of skill, he would not deserve those wages. I think that matter would be regulated by the employer, who would very soon find out if the man were worth retaining. As to whether people will get into occupations under what amounts to false pretences, I would like to point out to Deputies that a register is to be kept under the provisions of this Bill, and that register will give a certain amount of information in regard to workers. There will have to be a register kept and particulars will have to be entered by employers. That register will be open to inspection. If an employer wants to find out anything about a worker, he can go to the register and he will see the particulars laid down under the designated trade to which the worker is attached. He will see there details about education, progress, etc. Of course, there would be nothing like a certificate. To advance to that point would bring us a very long distance. It would necessitate the setting up of some examining body with power to issue what would correspond to a leaving certificate. I doubt very much if that is required, but if it is pressed it would mean going a long way.
Comment on this
On Section 26, I would like the Minister to give us some information as to what is meant by authorised officers. As will be observed in Section 28, these officers are given very wide powers. They can enter an employer's premises and inspect his pay-sheets, and they can ask all sorts of questions. If the employer or his officials do not supply the information, and if they do not act in a courteous fashion, they are subject to penalties. What particular officers has the Minister in mind? What class of individual comes under the heading of authorised officer?
Comment on this
There is a definition with regard to authorised officers, and it sets out—"the expression `authorised officer' includes any person authorised in writing (either generally or for a special purpose) by the Minister to exercise all or any of the powers and perform all or any of the duties conferred or imposed on an authorised officer under this Act." In the main they would be officials who are at the moment industrial inspectors and, possibly, the factory inspectors might be authorised.
Comment on this
With regard to Section 34, which deals with the expenses of members of apprenticeship committees, are the members to be paid?
Comment on this
That would have to work itself out in accordance with the duties that would be laid on the members of the committee and the amount of their time that would be taken up. The appointed members of trade boards get a certain amount of extra remuneration, but the other members get only sufficient to cover their expenses; I mean the representative members. That will be what we will have in mind at the start.
Comment on this
It might be quite right to pay the expenses of persons who would have to travel to attend meetings of the committee, but take the case of members residing in the city—they would not have to go to any expense.
Comment on this
Does the Minister set any limit to the number of meetings to be held? That would have an important bearing on the expenses.
Comment on this
It is not limited in the Bill and, to a certain extent, it will depend upon the committee. Of course there can always be a certain amount of supervision. The remuneration and expenses have to be sanctioned by the Minister for Finance—such as will be sanctioned by him.
Comment on this
With regard to amendment 45, which deals with the schedule, I agreed on the point submitted by Deputy Anthony to bring in an amendment to allow duly authorised agents. I may put that in, in preference to Deputy Anthony's own term of solicitor or agent.
Comment on this
Representations have been made that we should allow a considerable interval between this and the Report Stage. A date was mentioned yesterday which I would like to accede to; but it may be too near the end of the Session. I am prepared to suggest this day fortnight for the Report Stage. If at that time we are not within sight of the end of the Session, and if there is a possibility of getting the Bill through at a later period, I will propose not to take the Report Stage until a later period.
Comment on this
I am anxious that the Minister would leave the next stage as long as possible. There are numbers of matters one would like to consider and, after our discussion here to-day, there are numbers of bodies that would like to give the Bill their consideration.