We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Supplementary Estimate. - Town Tenants Bill, 1930—Committee (Resumed).

Contributions 119–243 of 243. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Town Tenants Bill 1930
Enacted

No. 34 of 1930 ›

The effect of this amendment, if carried, would be that a number of companies would proceed to register in Saorstát Eireann, which, I hope the Minister will agree with us, would be a very excellent thing. As to treating the citizens of this country and other countries with equal justice, I think that is a fair principle to establish; but would it be a fair thing or a just thing for a citizen of this country to register his company in England and to start his business here? I do not think it would, and it would be against public policy. The law should be the same for a citizen of this country as for any alien or stranger, and for that reason I think it is right that people running big business corporations or companies of all sorts should be registered in this country. The effect of this amendment would be to force a number of companies to register in this country where they are registered elsewhere.

Comment on this

This is a completely different problem, but the Deputy must bear in mind that, say, these companies which are so registered in Northern Ireland or England and carry on business over here will not change their registration, because they may lose rights in one or two premises. They have to look to their major business, and naturally their major business is carried on in the place where they are registered.

Comment on this

I hope Deputy Reynolds will make a fight for his amendment.

Comment on this

We have to stand up for fair play. The people I refer to are poor landlords with only one house, and these other people are rich corporations or companies. I think it is only fair that the poor man should not be jeopardised by this Bill. The Minister, I am sure, will agree that it is a small amendment, and, as Deputy Little said, if passed it will bring revenue to the country because it will be the means of getting some of these companies to register here. In all fairness, I think the Minister ought to accept it.

Comment on this

I move amendment 50:—

To add at the end of sub-section (1) a new paragraph as follows:—

(f) in the case of a tenement used as a residence the landlord owns or occupies but one premises used as a residence other than such tenement.

I hope I will be more successful than my neighbour, Deputy Reynolds, in moving this amendment. However, I am not over-optimistic, as I have heard peculiar ethics enunciated in connection with this Bill, especially from the Opposition, and I do not make much discrimination between the different sections of the Opposition. Section 17 of this Bill particularly perpetuates the Rent Restrictions Act, in some respects at least, and especially in the case of the owners of houses with whom my amendment deals. The object of my amendment is that people who bought a house before the passing of the Rent Restrictions Act with the idea of occupying it at a future date should be exempted. These people belong to classes such as civil servants. Some of these civil servants were able to keep a better house while in the Civil Service, but when pensioned they were not able to live in their houses. They scraped as much money as they could and bought a smaller house than the one they were residing in with the idea that they would occupy it when they went out on pension. Then we have widows of doctors, solicitors, and so on. Deputy Lemass leers at all this. I do not expect much sympathy from Deputy Lemass from what he has already said, but this is a thing that should not be treated lightly. It is a tragedy for those people. If Deputy Lemass had the same human nature as I possess and was as accessible as I am, he would have been approached and would have heard something about those people. They have come to me and put their case before me. They bought those houses with the idea of occupying them so that they may be able to give cheap education to their children when they arrived at a certain age. They let the houses temporarily, and in most cases before the Rent Restrictions Act was passed. The result was that they could not get possession of these houses. I need not go into the different reasons why they could not get possession, but it was obvious that the Rent Restrictions Act did not facilitate owners of houses in getting possession. Some of them are in the position that they want to sell the houses. It is a case of grim necessity with them to sell the houses to meet part of their debts. They find that they cannot sell the houses, and even if they are optimistic enough to hope that the Rent Restrictions Act will be repealed they are caught under this Act and they still will not be able to sell the houses or get possession of them. These are nearly all owners of one house. They have been called landlords, but they are owners in the same sense that a tenant farmer in Ireland is the owner of his farm. It has been said that the occupying tenant should be put in the same category as a tenant farmer. He is not in the same category. The tenant of a house simply occupies a house and pays for the use of it. The tenant farmer owns the house, because he has bought it or inherited it from those who went before him. It is the same way with the people whose cases I am urging. They also bought the houses, or perhaps inherited them from their forebears. Of course I know cases of tenants of land who hold on the eleven months' system. They are graziers, and after five or forty years they cannot claim a renewal of the tenancy nor prevent the farmer who owns the land from selling it in the open market. What I claim for these people is that they should be in a position, especially when it is a case of grim necessity with them, to sell the house in the same open market in which they bought it. They are owners of one house, and they are very poor people. I do not care what fixity of tenure you give a tenant so long as you give the owner of a house, especially the owner of a single house, the right to sell it when it becomes an absolute necessity for him, perhaps to pay debts which he is compelled by the law of this State to pay. I do not care particularly for the morality of this Bill or the honesty of it, though Deputy Geoghegan gave me a little lecture about honesty.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

I merely intimated that you were a monopolist of honesty.

Comment on this

I think it a most unfair thing that these people should be deprived of their property. I know that Deputy Lemass or Deputy Little will get up and tell me that they can sell the income of the house by way of rent.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Why not wait and hear them?

Comment on this

I have heard them before. I am avoiding the necessity of repeating it. However, I will be told that these people can sell the rent of the house. Selling the rent of a house is a very different proposition from selling a house and giving possession of it to a purchaser who wants to occupy it.

I think that will be admitted, and I think the Minister will bear it in mind. We have not the same scarcity of houses now as when the Rent Restrictions Act was passed. That is mainly due to the fact that the Government have given very large grants for the building of houses, with the result that nobody has a difficulty in getting a house at present. My experience is that they have no real difficulty. People want to get this fixity of tenure under this section simply because they want to get something to sell. I have already told the House on another amendment of a case where an occupying tenant waived his rights under the Rent Restrictions Act for the sum of £300 and allowed the owner, a very poor woman, to sell the house. That is what you are creating here, and I say that is dishonest. I ask every Deputy to give this very sympathetic consideration. I think that these are cases in which there should be exceptions made. I regard anybody who will vote against this amendment as fit simply to rob a little robin's nest. From the arguments I have heard, I am coming to believe that Deputies who, when considering many questions vote away other people's property, have lost any belief in such a place as Hades, where they will suffer for their sins. I fear that very much. I fear also that they think it is the easiest thing in the world to get into Heaven, and that no man is too great a blackguard to be forgiven and find a ready acceptance in Heaven. I do not agree with that.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

It is a long way from this amendment.

Comment on this

I ask the Minister to bear all this in mind. I do not want to intimidate Deputies, but I hope the Minister, as a Christian man and a Heaven-inspired man, will accept the amendment.

Comment on this

Not being a paragon of all the virtues like Dr. Hennessy, I am afraid I shall have to oppose the amendment.

It must be a very good thing for a person in Deputy Dr. Hennessy's position to know that he possesses all the honesty, morality and justice that he contends he possesses. If all the landlords go to Heaven I do not suppose Hell can be so bad a place after all. Deputy Dr. Hennessy said that there was no scarcity of houses and that nobody has any difficulty in getting a house. I advise him to have a consultation with Deputy O'Connor who, half an hour ago, told us that no tenant will be accepted by any landlord now, and that it is practically impossible to get a house to let in Dublin. They cannot both be right. Deputy Dr. Hennessy, of course, being honest, moral, just, and everything else, must be right and Deputy O'Connor must be wrong. As Deputy Dr. Hennessy is so anxious to start out on a new crusade, let him start with his colleague, Deputy O'Connor. He is likely to have more success there than anywhere else.

Comment on this

I may say that the great trouble in getting a house to let now is that the people who own houses have sized up the spirit of the Dáil here, or at least, of the potential Government, and they simply sell a house when it becomes vacant.

Comment on this

As the Deputy referred to me as stating that nobody will let a house now, I should like to say that I built two houses recently and have let them and not sold them.

Comment on this

Deputy Dr. Hennessy has contradicted himself and Deputy O'Connor has contradicted himself, so now we know where we are.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Now we can come back to the amendment.

Comment on this

When I read the amendment I thought it was Deputy Dr. Hennessy's purpose to provide that nobody should get a new tenancy unless the landlord occupies two premises for dwelling purposes. From his speech I take it that is not his aim. His aim is to provide that if the owner of a house is a poor man, then he can do all the injustice he wants and can be released from all his obligations under the Bill. He can evict a tenant, no matter how long he has been in occupation. He can charge any rent he can get, no matter how exorbitant. He can force up the price in any way he likes, provided he is poor. That is Deputy Dr. Hennessy's proposal.

The Deputy has just voted for a section of the Bill which provides that a person who has been in occupation of a house for forty years is to be given security of tenure. We tried to reduce that period, but despite our efforts that forty years stands. Deputy Dr. Hennessy even thinks that forty years is too short a period, provided the house is owned by a poor man who has only one other house in which he resides. If he is a poor man, he is entitled to do anything he likes. He is to be given every facility to squeeze his tenant, to charge whatever rent he likes, and to evict him for any cause, or even without cause, provided he is a poor man—not necessarily a poor widow. He talked about a widow, but the owner need not be a widow. There is nothing in this amendment about widows. It only refers to a landlord who owns one house besides the house he lives in, and he is to be allowed to do anything he likes. Where is the justice in that? What about the honesty, the morality and all the rest of it which the Deputy talks about? Do they only apply to the rich, not to the poor at all? If Deputy Dr. Hennessy is half as honest or moral or just as he pretends to be, he will withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

For very much the same reasons that I gave in opposing Deputy Reynolds' amendment I must oppose this amendment also.

Comment on this

The Minister is going to rob the robin's nest.

Comment on this

Or he will be sent to Hades.

Comment on this

I may be, but I do not think it is for anything which is done in this Bill. Deputy Dr. Hennessy should bear in mind that this Bill is the outcome of the report of the Town Tenants Commission, which was composed of men of standing in the country who were not out to rob anybody. They were simply out to do justice between two sections of the community, whose interests very seriously clash. If I may say so. I would think that my chances of getting to Heaven were increased rather than diminished by the introduction of this measure, but that is a matter of opinion. Now to get down to the serious thing here. This amendment simply means that if a person is going to take a house one of the first things he has to do is to examine into the financial condition of his landlord. A house will be of a different value if you discover that your landlord has only another house. Then you may be in a very bad position also, because you may take a house which you think will come under the Act because the landlord has got four houses. But he promptly goes away and sells two, and you are completely done. I, personally, do not think, apart from considerations even of that nature, that you can have a law differentiating between persons according to the length of their purse.

Comment on this

Apart altogether from the argument for or against this amendment, there is this consideration: the amendment does not deal with the case put by Deputy Dr. Hennessy at all. He made an ad misericordium appeal for persons who had no other means of subsistence, which is quite a different thing. If he had made an ad misericordium appeal on behalf of persons who had no other means of subsistence than their house rents it would be different, but here you may have a millionaire with a large residence, and property invested in stocks and shares, and only one other house. He is going to be exempted. Even the amendment, as drafted, does not meet the question that Deputy Dr. Hennessy wished to safeguard.

[Deputy Fahy took the Chair.]

Comment on this

Could Deputy Dr. Hennessy tell us what was the law in Ireland on this matter before the Milesians?

Comment on this

The alliance is too much for me. I ask leave to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

With regard to Section 19, the words "good and sufficient reason" in sub-section (2), I understand under the 1906 Act could include a refusal by the tenant to pay a reasonable increase of rent. In this Bill there is an attempt made to define the expression "good and sufficient reason" by sub-section (2), but it is not at all clear whether that ruling of the court that I referred to is now excluded or not. If it were here we might have a word or two to say upon that subject. Perhaps the Minister would say whether the intention was to give a definition of "good and sufficient reason" that would exclude such a proposal as that. That is to exclude from the meaning of the term a proposal to increase rent.

Comment on this

"Good and sufficient reason," as it comes in here, means something that emanates from the tenant, something that shows that the tenant is an undesirable tenant, and that is a matter which the court must in the circumstances determine on the merits of any particular case. Of course, refusal to pay rent would be good and sufficient cause.

Comment on this

Refusal to pay a reasonable increase of rent, I think, was the decision of the court under the 1906 Act, but apparently the Minister is not prepared to give me information upon it.

Comment on this

As the Deputy is perfectly aware, when the rent in this case is fixed by the court such a question could not arise.

Comment on this

The tenant shall not be entitled to a new tenancy under the definition I have referred to if he has already refused to pay a fair and reasonable increase of rent.

Comment on this

You may take it that is not the case. It is perfectly plain.

Comment on this

I assure the Minister it is the case under the 1906 Act.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 51:—

In sub-section (1) (a), line 57, to delete the word "desires."

Comment on this

The purpose of amendment 52 is to provide some limit of time in which the rebuilding and reconstruction of the dwellings or the building as mentioned in the paragraph will be commenced. In a subsequent amendment standing in my name, certain penalties are provided in the event of failure to carry out the rebuilding or reconstruction. The big fault of the section as it stands is that there is no penalty whatever provided, and a tenant might be deprived of a new tenancy on the grounds that a landlord was able successfully to contend in court that he intended to pull down or reconstruct the dwellings even though he subsequently failed to carry out such pulling down, or reconstructing or rebuilding, as he had undertaken to do when before the court.

I realise there are many loopholes in my amendment and that it is not water-tight. The size of the operation which may be described as the commencement of the pulling down and the rebuilding would be a matter of considerable doubt, but I do think that there should be some provision here inserted to insure that a landlord who deprived a tenant of the right of a new tenancy on the ground that he intended to rebuild or reconstruct should commence and be compelled to rebuild or reconstruct within a definite time, failure in which would restore to the tenant his original right of a new tenancy as otherwise guaranteed under the Bill.

Amendment 53 proposed to insert a similar provision in respect of paragraph 3, which relates to the carrying out of a scheme of penalties and to provide that if the landlord deprives a tenant of a new tenancy on the grounds that he is carrying out a scheme of improvement on the property he should be under an obligation to commence that scheme in a period of six months, and that failure to do so would restore the tenant to his right to a new tenancy. Amendment 54 provides that where the court has decided the tenant is not entitled to a new tenancy under paragraph (a) or (b) on the ground that the landlord intends to carry out reconstruction or rebuilding or a scheme of development, if the landlord fails to commence his rebuilding scheme in six months the tenant would be deemed to be the tenant of the tenement and would be entitled to all rights under the Act regardless of whether compensation for improvements or disturbance had been paid. The Minister may criticise the particular proposals I am making. I realise they are not perfect. I found it extremely difficult to draft an amendment embodying my ideas, but I think that there should be inserted in the Bill some safeguard of this nature to prevent tenants being deprived of their rights either by fraudulent misrepresentation to the court or representations that ultimately were departed from.

Comment on this

I agree with a great deal of what Deputy Lemass has said. His particular amendments, however, do not commend themselves to me, because I think the landlord might require possession of a premises for the purposes of a genuine reconstruction scheme and that he may get possession of this house to-day and possibly may not be able to get possession of the neighbouring house for another year.

He cannot really start a reconstruction scheme economically until such time as he would be prepared to carry out the whole scheme together. To put a time limit, irrespective of what the circumstances might be, would, I think, be practically impossible. So far as the two first amendments are concerned, namely, 52 and 53, I will undertake to bring in, on Report, some amendments which, in my view, would be workable. They would probably be on the lines that a court would fix a definite period and that the work would have to be carried out within that period. The other question, as to what the remedy would be, is a very doubtful one, because if the landlord were given two years to carry out something and did not do it, the tenant, having been declared to be the tenant, would have to pay over the whole year for what he did not enjoy at all. The tenant, in all probability, in the meantime would have made other arrangements and gone elsewhere. I will bring forward amendments on the lines I have indicated on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 55 as follows:—

Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"Where it appears to the court that it is equitable and practicable that the tenant of a tenement who is held not to be entitled to a new tenancy on the ground that the landlord bona-fide intends to reconstruct the buildings, should receive a tenancy in such reconstructed buildings, the court, in lieu of compensation under the next following sub-section may order the granting of such tenancy on such terms as in the opinion of the court, justice may require."

This amendment is intended to deal with the case of a tenant who is held not to be entitled to a new tenancy on the ground that the landlord, bona fide, intends to reconstruct the building. It is intended in this amendment to provide, where it is practicable and where the court thinks it is equitable to do so, that the tenant should be given the right to a tenancy in the reconstructed building. In a number of cases it will not be practicable to do that. A shop may be reconstructed into two, or two shops may be reconstructed into one, but where reconstruction is of such a nature that the reconstructed building would be suitable to the same business as carried on before, and where the building is one which the tenant would like to occupy, we think that he should have a right, in lieu of compensation for disturbance, to a tenancy of the building when reconstructed, if he desires. If he finds that the building on reconstruction was unsuitable to his business, or for any other reason that he cannot occupy it, he could take the alternative of compensation for disturbance. We think that he should be given the right of exchanging compensation for disturbance for the right of a tenancy.

Comment on this

I am afraid that I cannot accept the amendment. I think that when the landlord, bona fide, for the purposes of the development of a district, decides to change the character of the buildings there, and where he himself prefers to pay the very substantial sum which he would have to pay to the tenant of a business premises when he is removed should be given a free hand as to how he is to reconstruct. If the landlord and tenant come to agreement, well and good, but I think if he is going to the expense of improving the whole place he should be given a completely free hand as to how he is going to deal with the reconstructed premises. In practice, I do not think that the amendment would work, because if the landlord and tenant wished to resume their business in the newly-constructed premises and if they are suitable, they would, of course, come to an agreement, but if the landlord does not want the tenant he would probably change the character of the newly-constructed building in order to keep the tenant out. When the landlord is bona fide improving the neighbourhood I think that the tenant should be satisfied with compensation.

Comment on this

I move amendment 56 as follows:—

To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

"The amount of compensation payable under this section shall be a charge on the estate or interest of the landlord in the tenement in priority to all other charges, mortgages, or encumbrances thereon."

The purpose of the amendment is to provide that the amount of compensation payable under the section shall be a charge on the estate, or interest of the landlord in the tenement, in priority to all other charges, mortgages or encumbrances thereon. Although I realise that there is a considerable difference between the circumstances under which compensation is payable under this Part of the Bill and that payable under Part II, I think there is a case for this amendment. It is possible that the landlord would have mortgaged his interest in the premises and would be otherwise without resources and that the tenant, who has been deprived of the right of a new tenancy and awarded compensation for disturbance, might not be able to collect that compensation. The proposal is to make the compensation a charge against the tenement instead of a personal charge against the landlord. That secures for the tenant the certainty of the payment of compensation, if it is awarded. The circumstances under which it is awarded, under this Part of the Bill, are, we must bear in mind, that the tenant's business, to which he devoted his energy and in which he created substantial good-will, has been taken from him. He can suffer considerable loss, even his whole life's work, and there is no doubt that he should get whatever compensation the court awards him.

Comment on this

I cannot accept the amendment. Amendment No. 11 stood on quite a different footing because it referred to cases where the premises had been improved and then the mortgagees, or other persons interested in the premises, would get the increased security because the value of the premises had been increased by that amount. Here, however, quite a different consideration arises. It is proposed that the tenant is entitled, not for anything he had done to improve the premises, but to compensation for the loss of his good-will, which really is a thing which could not be assessed, as far as the improvement of the security which the mortgage has got, is concerned. I admit that there will be hardship in certain cases, but it will probably be a very odd case in which a tenant will discover that though he has got a decree the man against whom he has got it is insolvent. I am afraid that cases of that kind always have to occur. It is only a question when a man becomes insolvent as to which class of person is to suffer. If you are, unfortunately, run down by a motor car you may, in the circumstances, be fortunate enough to be run down by a person who is insured, or you may be unfortunate enough to be run down by a person who is not insured and who is not worth a penny. Sometimes you have writs against persons to recover damages which may not be worth the paper they are written on. These things, however, will happen. In this case, however, if people advance considerable sums of money on houses and are not guilty of negligence in any way and find themselves suddenly in altered financial circumstances, a thing which they could not possibly foresee, it would not be fair to adopt this method of recovery. I cannot accept the amendment.

Comment on this

Might I suggest to the Minister that the amendment of Deputy Lemass might be met in this way. I think there is a good deal to be said in support of the general principle at the back of the amendment. That is, that a tenant who finds himself dispossessed in pursuance of the provisions of the section, might subsequently find that the landlord, against whom the order for compensation had been made, was not in a position to pay it. I would suggest that sub-section 2 of the section might be amended, by providing that the court would have power to specify the time within which the compensation shall be paid, and that in the event of the compensation not being paid within the time specified, then the order excluding the tenant from the right to obtain a new tenancy under the general provisions of the Act would be inoperative and void.

Comment on this

I will turn over what the Deputy has stated in my mind, but I do not know how that would fit in with the general matter. This is a case that I think practically will not arise, because the case in which it would become really a practical question would be a case in which the landlord is pulling down the premises for the purpose of rebuilding and reconstructing the property. I do not think that you would ever find in practice that a landlord who is improving his property would be bankrupt. I think it is really a very theoretical question. I will consider it, but I will not pledge myself to bring in an amendment. I will consider what the Deputy has stated.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

I would have thought that the Minister has just stated reasons for the acceptance of the half-way course suggested by Deputy Finlay. If, as the Minister indicates, the landlord who contemplates rebuilding and reconstruction on a fairly large scale is genuine in his intention, and has at his command resources which will enable him to carry out that scheme, it is no hardship upon him to impose the condition that Deputy Finlay suggested —that it should be made a condition of his obtaining an order for vacant possession, that he should within such time as the court should consider reasonable—it could be left fairly flexible—pay or secure the compensation which has been adjudged to the tenant. If he has these resources at his command, it will be really no burden on him, and it will give the tenant an easier night's rest if he knows that he has at least some slight measure of security for the money.

Comment on this

I have already stated that I will consider Deputy Finlay's suggestion.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

The Minister hedged it round with many reservations.

Comment on this

Of course, I do not like to give a definite promise until I have made up my mind.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

The Minister sometimes makes up his mind very quickly.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 58:—

In line 31, to delete the word "direct."

The section deals with the measure of compensation for disturbance and provides that the measure shall be the pecuniary loss, damage or expense which the tenant sustains as a direct consequence of his quitting the holding. It is not clear what is the exact consequence of the word "direct" or what interpretation the court is likely to put on it. If there is any doubt what the interpretation is to be, I do not think we should pass it, because it is quite possible that we might find, in respect of the Bill when it becomes an Act, as was found in respect of previous Acts, that the intention of the Oireachtas would be reversed by a judicial decision based upon faulty or ambiguous phrasing. It is our view that the measure of compensation should be the loss, damage or expense which the tenant has suffered as a consequence, direct or indirect, of his having quitted the holding. I would, of course, limit the phrase "indirect." I would not put it in the Bill, but I think the word "direct" should not be in the Bill either, because it narrows the meaning very much. It might result in a very restricted interpretation which would involve hardships on tenants deprived of tenancies under this section or the previous section, and it might make it necessary for the Minister to acquire the bad habit of the Minister for Local Government and come along with another Bill to remove doubts.

Comment on this

I think the word "direct" is necessary and that what the word "direct" means is a natural consequence of the removal. If you do not stick to the natural consequences, you would have, as the Deputy himself says, to go and inquire what was an indirect consequence, and the most far-fetched thing might be put forward as a consequence of the removal. It is only the direct and immediate consequence for which the landlord should be liable. For instance, suppose a man came forward after being removed from a house and that the measure of compensation was to be an indirect consequence of his loss, he might say: "Oh, I went into another house and the house was damp. My wife got a cold and I had to pay £40 in doctors' bills," or something of that kind. That would be, in a way, a consequence of his moving, but obviously not a direct consequence of his moving. If you take an indirect consequence, it would be a subject of compensation.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting that.

Comment on this

It is perfectly obvious that an indirect consequence of that nature is not what we contemplate as being the measure. You have to put in the word "direct" in order that these claims should not be brought forward. I have mentioned only one case, but there might be many other similar cases.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

I wonder will the Minister, on reconsideration, repeat or endorse some of the statements that have fallen from him now? Will the Minister deny that the law, as it stands, excludes remote damage or remote compensation of the kind that the Minister indicated as necessary to be excluded? The law already excludes that, and it surely does without the use of the word "direct," whereas if you introduce the word "direct" to the statute the court must seek to give some meaning and effect to it. The court must assume that this Legislature did not lightly put in the word there, and the court must give it a limiting effect.

The effect of the word "direct," if left there, is that compensation which, according to the ordinary rules of the law for the ascertainment of damage or the ascertainment of compensation, is to be cut down owing to the effort that the court must necessarily make to give some meaning and force to the word. Subject to correction by the Minister, I suggest that the law of the land already excludes remote damages and remote compensation such as would be unfitting to be paid.

Comment on this

I agree with the Deputy that the measure of damages in an action for tort is the natural and probable consequences of the result. If it were not the result of probable consequences then the damage is too remote. I do not know that in a section of this nature precisely the same principles of interpretation would apply. I think it is safer to have the word "direct" inserted in order to make it plain that it is to be the natural and probable consequences.

Comment on this

On the reading of the word "direct" can a person applying to the court get anything more than the price of removal? The only immediate direct consequence is that he has to move his things out.

Comment on this

Compensation for disturbance may be much more than compensation for removal.

Comment on this

Would the Minister accept the word "natural" that he mentioned in the beginning himself?

Comment on this

I think the word "direct" is an admirable word to express the idea.

Comment on this

The Minister explained that the intention of the adjective is to limit compensation to something less than it would be under the existing law.

Comment on this

You cannot go into a roving inquiry as to what remote consequences may be.

Comment on this

Are not remote consequences excluded at present?

Comment on this

This is an entirely new definition, and is largely borrowed from the definition in the Report of the Town Tenants Commission. It makes the measure of damages for compensation far and away wider than the old measure of damages. If the Deputy reads the Report of the Commission he will see that the Commission expressed the view that one of the failures of the old Act was that the measure of damages awarded by the court was too narrow, and that adequate compensation was not given. To counteract that, it was suggested that an amendment of the law should be made and that damages should be measured according to this definition practically.

Comment on this

That is not the definition of the Town Tenants Commission at all. The Minister on previous amendments has taken shelter behind the recommendations of the Commission. The Commission did not recommend the word "direct." The Minister is inserting that word himself. In paragraph 16 the Commission recommend that the compensation should be for the loss, damage or expense which the tenant sustains or incurs or will sustain and incur by reason of quitting the holding. That is a different definition from what the Minister proposes.

Comment on this

No. Of course in a report of that nature you do not have the precise drafting that you get in a Bill drafted as this has been, but the idea is precisely identical.

Comment on this

I think not.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: That the word proposed to be deleted stand part.

Tá 66
·
Níl 37
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 59:

To add at the end of sub-section (2) the following paragraph:—

"or

(d) where the tenancy is deemed by this Act to terminate immediately after the passing of this Act, within one month after the passing of this Act."

The necessity for the amendment arises because under sub-section (2) of the section notice to claim relief shall be served in the case of a tenancy terminated by notice to quit by not more than one month after the service of such notice; in the case of a tenancy terminated by the expiration of a term of years, not less than three months before the termination of the tenancy, and in the case of a tenancy terminated by the fall of a life on that event happening. There is no provision made for the case of the person added to the Bill by a previous amendment who holds on under the provisions of the Increase of Rent and Mortgage Act. The term in this amendment is within one month after the passing of the Act. I would like to have the views of the House on that period, because since the amendment was drafted it has occurred to me that possibly the term one month is too short. I fancy that the provisions of this Act will become fairly widely known, but they may not be known to everybody in the country who might like to take advantage of them, and in consequence I am rather inclined to alter the period of one month to six months. It is my intention to bring in a further amendment to make that alteration.

Comment on this

I agree to the alteration if it can be made now.

Comment on this

I accordingly move that the amendment be altered by inserting "six months" instead of "one month."

Comment on this

Does the Minister not think that that is leaving the matter rather long in doubt?

Comment on this

I do not, because if you tie people down to one month there will be a rush after the passing of the Act. I think you must give a reasonably long period so that the provisions of the Act may become known.

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this

If the Bill becomes law, as I hope it will, that will occur before the Long Vacation. If you confine this to one month that would occur in the holiday period of the year when solicitors' offices are not working full time. I really think that six months are necessary.

Comment on this

I agree that one month is a bit short but you are leaving an important matter hanging in suspense for a half year. I would say that three months would be more suitable.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Is the Minister taking amendment 60 and amendment 82 with this—they seem to be closely related?

Comment on this

We will come to 82 in due course.

Comment on this

Amendment 60 falls.

Comment on this

I move amendment 61, which reads:—

In sub-section (1) line 60, to delete the words "one month" and substitute the words "three months."

This is the same point that we had over and over again already.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

In another connection.

Comment on this

We came to rather a compromise on that question between 1 and 3 before. On that question we will keep up the compromising spirit and make it 2.

Comment on this

I move amendment 62, which reads:—

In sub-section (1) (a), line 13, after the word "statement" to add the words "and shall at the same time serve a copy of the same upon the landlord."

This amendment, I think, is only seeking to place everybody in possession of the facts that are necessary. I think it is only fair and reasonable that the landlord should be in possession of the full facts about him and so give him an opportunity of checking the statements made. That would be really necessary if this Bill is to be worked properly.

Comment on this

If the Deputy would look into my amendment 63 (a) I think he will find that it covers what is in the Deputy's amendment, and it goes further still.

Comment on this

I think 63 (a) covers it.

Comment on this

I move amendment 63, which reads:—

In sub-section (1) (c), line 25, to insert after the word "particulars" the words "which shall include the items of the cost."

If 63 (a) were made quite clear to include the items of the cost I would be satisfied. I think the word should be made quite specifically clear so as to include that point. It is just to get an answer from the Minister that I move this amendment.

Comment on this

I do not think this amendment would be necessary; it would be rather more one of prescribing the form which would be prescribed under the Act if it were thought necessary that it should be given. I think it is rather more a matter for the Rules.

Comment on this

The Minister thinks it might be brought under the Rules?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

If it would be putting further trouble on the tenant to include the items of the cost of the improvements, and if the Minister is satisfied, I will not press it.

Comment on this

It is not the cost of the improvements, but the increased letting value they create, and the insertion of the items of cost would only confuse the judgment of the Court.

Comment on this

I move amendment 63 (a), which reads:

In sub-section (1) to add at the end of the sub-section a new paragraph as follows:—

"(d) whenever an applicant is required by this sub-section to lodge in the Circuit Court Office an improvement statement, such applicant shall, either before or within three days after such lodgment, furnish a copy of such improvement statement to the landlord or superior landlord from whom such compensation is claimed."

Well, of course I think it is only just and really fair that the claim should be served on the other side.

Comment on this

I move amendment 64, which reads:

In sub-section (5), line 60, to delete the words "be bound by" and substitute the words "have regard to."

I think the words used in the sub-section are too restrictive on the judgment of the Court, and I suggest these modifying words in lieu of the very restrictive words used in the sub-section.

Comment on this

There is a difference between this sub-section and the other rather similar subsections to which the Deputy is referring. These will be Section 28 (5) and also Section 44 (5). There is this difference, that under Section 24 (5) it is obligatory upon the Court to refer to the Valuation Office, whereas under the other two sections it is only "may" or "if so requested shall." That makes, I think, a considerable difference between this and the other amendments here. The Valuation Office is brought in as a matter of necessity. Their report is to be binding.

In other words, the real thing is that we want to keep all appeals to the Court as limited as we possibly can. If the parties on this question of valuation and improvement come to the conclusion that unless there has been some very great mistake made by the Valuation Department, they will simply take the Valuation Department as being final, it will save a tremendous amount of going to the Courts. That is the reason why we have made it so much more definite here than elsewhere. Claims under this improvement section of the Bill or this part of the Bill dealing with improvements will be more numerous than any other claims, and both in the interests of the parties themselves that they may not have to spend very large sums in litigation, and also, to a lesser extent that the Courts may not be clogged by a huge amount of litigation, it is desirable that the Valuation Commissioners' report should be made as nearly binding as possible upon the parties. That is the reason why we made the differentiation between this and other sections.

Comment on this

I appreciate that. All the same I do not think that the Minister is correct in saying that the use of these words "be bound by" is necessary to avoid this litigation. Some loophole may remain. So far as the decision of the Valuation Department is concerned the insertion of the words "have regard to" would leave it just as before. It is more the form of the words, taking out of the Court its decision, and saying in effect that the valuator is to be the court.

I think the Minister might use the same words as are used in other subsections to which reference has been made. If there is any mistake in law or in fact, then you can make use of the loophole left by the words "have regard to." When coming to a decision, the Court, in fixing the amount of the compensation for improvements, would have regard to the figures given by the valuator.

Comment on this

I will consider the matter.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 65:

In sub-section (5), line 61, to delete all words after the word "valuation" to the end of the sub-section and substitute the words "and the several estimates and statements submitted by any interested parties: Provided that in no case shall the compensation awarded by the court exceed the amount expended by the tenant upon the improvements in respect of which compensation is claimed."

I think the Minister will admit that this is a fair and necessary proviso. It simply puts in specifically that the tenant is not to recover more for compensation for improvements than the actual amount he has expended. I do not think anybody would suggest that the tenant ought to make a profit out of these improvements. If the major limit of compensation awarded is the actual sum that he has expended, he cannot complain that he is being treated unfairly.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'Connell Labour Party

I wonder does Deputy Thrift realise that this might cut the other way? In the earlier portion of the Bill I suggested that the tenant should get at least the amount he expended on his improvements.

Comment on this

That is a very different story.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

It is, of course, but the landlord should not be allowed to make a profit.

Comment on this

Why should there be any limitation? Is not the tenant entitled to compensation for the increased letting value? Why should the landlord and not the tenant get the benefit of the improvements? If the landlord has to pay the increased letting value consequent upon the tenant's improvements, he is not subjected to any hardship and the tenant is merely getting what he is entitled to get. We must take into account the cost of building and how the value of money fluctuates. The tenant who effected improvements in 1913, which increased the letting value of the premises, might find the amount of compensation to-day would be a very poor return for what he expended in 1913, even though the actual amount is the same, measured in cash. The main point is that there is an increased letting value now if the tenant vacates, and there is a considerable difference in regard to the money value now as compared with 1913.

Comment on this

That argument lost its value and met with very little success when it was urged in the interest of the landlord. The very same case as the Deputy has now submitted might just as well apply to the landlord, who has to meet the fluctuations in the money market just as well as the tenant. Surely Deputy Lemass does not suggest it is just that the tenant should be allowed to make a profit out of what does not belong to him? He expends money on repairs. All this proviso suggests is that at most he should not get more than he has actually expended. If that is not accepted, then something unfair is being sought. The suggestion is that the tenant should get back all his money; he would have the advantage of the improvements during the time he was in occupation and he would not lose a penny. I do not think that that could be considered fair.

Comment on this

Why should the landlord get the benefit? The increased letting value is not the result of the landlord's action. It is the result of the tenant's efforts and the landlord should not have any claim to it.

Comment on this

If the tenant conceives these improvements and has had the enterprise to go to the trouble of carrying them out and expending money upon them, he is surely entitled to some compensation for all he has done.

Comment on this

I think the increased letting value is the test that you must take, and, just as I thought the amount which the tenant had expended should not be the measure of damages, as Deputy O'Connell pointed out when I opposed the amendment proposed by him a few days ago, I equally think that what he receives in compensation should not be limited to the actual amount which he has expended. Look at it from the landlord's point of view. He gets a certain increased letting value, and that is what he has to pay for. It really does not matter twopence to the landlord what it cost the tenant. The tenant may have done the work very expeditiously and cheaply, and may get actually more than he has paid, but I think that is very unlikely. The tenant will in most cases get less than he has expended, because he will have enjoyed, for a considerable period of time in most instances, the improvements which he has made.

Look at it from another point of view. Suppose this was an improvement which would add very considerably to the letting value of the premises; in other words, the tenant thinks that by making this improvement he is adding very considerably to the letting value of the house and is making a very good investment of his money. Under this Bill it is always open to the landlord to come in and say: "I will make those improvements myself." He may think that here is an improvement, the cost of making which will be comparatively small, while the resultant advantage to the property will be very large. In that case he may decide to carry out the improvements himself. He always has got his option. I do not think I could accept the proposal now submitted.

Comment on this

He may decide to make the improvements if he has the necessary capital, but suppose he has not that capital?

Comment on this

I am sure that in those circumstances he would be able to get the capital. If he has not the capital and cannot carry out the improvements, he is very fortunate to have a tenant who has the necessary capital and who will improve his premises for him. I do not think he can complain if he is not in a position to improve the premises and he has a tenant who is prepared to improve them. I do not think he can complain if the tenant adds to the letting value of the premises.

Comment on this

I should hope that it is a contingency that will very rarely arise.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 66:

To insert before paragraph (d) a new paragraph as follows:

(d) if the Court finds that such tenant is not entitled to such new tenancy and the notice of the intention to claim relief on which the application is grounded does not include a claim in the alternative for compensation under this Act, the Court shall nevertheless consider whether compensation should be awarded and if it decides to award such compensation shall fix the amount thereof.

I think the wording of this amendment is somewhat faulty, in so far as it does not make it clear that it is intended to apply only to those entitled to compensation under Section 20 (2). The idea is to provide that if a tenant of a business premises is entitled to a new tenancy or, in the alternative, compensation for disturbance, but through error or otherwise applies to the Court for a new tenancy, he should not be debarred from getting compensation for disturbance if the Court decides against him on the question of the new tenancy. I think that some such amendment is necessary in view of the provisions of paragraph (e) of this section.

Comment on this

I had, as a matter of fact, practically ready before the Committee Stage an amendment dealing with this matter. I was late to insert it for the Committee Stage. It would have delayed the Committee Stage. It was an amendment on the lines giving the Court power to amend the application where it thinks it would be just. It is my intention to propose such an amendment on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment 67:—

In sub-section (1), line 48, to delete the words "one month" and substitute the words "three months."

The same point here arises as before.

Comment on this

I move amendment 68:—

In sub-section (2) (a), line 58, to delete the word "week" and substitute the word "month."

This is again lengthening the period. I looked to both sides, and I agree with Deputy Lemass.

Comment on this

I think it would be a pity to break up such a happy combination. I agree also.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I move amendment 69:—

In paragraph (c), line 65, after the word "years" to insert the words "and subject to the provisions of paragraph (b) of this section without the consent of the tenant shall not be less than fifty years."

This is the section where the Court fixes the term of the new tenancy, and it has been represented to me that in addition to fixing the upper limit, the maximum period, there ought to be a minimum period as well, subject, of course, to the provision set out in sub-section (b). The suggestion is that the figure which I have put down here of fifty years ought to be the minimum period.

Comment on this

I have given considerable thought to this amendment of Deputy O'Connell's, because it is perfectly plain to me that a practical minimum would be a very great advantage to the landlord, and it is not as plain to me that it might be of equal advantage to the tenant. If a landlord is going to have a fair rent fixed in respect of these premises, it is obviously very much to his advantage that the term should be long rather than it should be short, that he would have a tenant there fixed for a very considerable time, and my difficulty is rather that from the tenant's point of view, if there is a minimum fixed, though the tenant may say "I do not want it for this length of time," the landlord will come along and say you will have to take it for that length of time. You will probably find when the duration of a term is being fixed in Court that the tenant is more often anxious not to be burdened with the house for a tremendously long term rather than that the landlord is not anxious to have his house let for a very long term. It may be that the tenant may consent to the term being less than fifty years. Unless he so consented, it must be, but it does not say, and I do not think it can be fairly made to say, that it shall be only such term as the tenant wishes. I am inclined to accept, subject to an alteration, this amendment. I do so with just some little hesitation; it may work out a little bit hard on tenants in practice.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I was asked by representative tenants to put down this amendment. I take it that they considered the thing.

Comment on this

I accept the principle.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

Is the Minister accepting amendment 69.

Comment on this

Subject to re-drafting. I will bring in an amendment to meet amendment 69.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

May one ask that the Minister would so frame his amendment that the tenant will have the option of seeking a term of fifty years. I think that probably that is the real intention. Certainly that is what many tenants would like to have. There might be cases in which it would be inconvenient for a tenant to be burdened with a term of fifty years.

Comment on this

That is one of the difficulties that was running through my mind in the drafting of this, because if you fix a term of fifty years you visualise that at least fifty years is to be the normal and it would be very difficult indeed to draft it so that the term shall be only for such term as the tenant would like. There are two people who would have to be considered. As I say I am willing to accept this, but it can only be that the duration of a new tenancy, without the consent of the tenant, shall not be less than fifty years; possibly on rare occasions the landlord may force the term on him.

Comment on this
James Geoghehan Mr. Geoghegan

I understood that Deputy O'Connell, the mover of the amendment, indicated that he would be satisfied if the clause were so amended that the tenant would have the right to demand a term of fifty years if he so elected, but that it cannot be thrust upon him.

Comment on this

Amendments 70, 71, 72, 73, 74 and 75 all raise one question and might be discussed at the same time. That is the question of the definition of a fair rent. I do not know which amendment the House wishes to discuss. Number 70 is not the one.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

71 seems to be the one.

Comment on this

I do not know that it is.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

If 71 falls, 72, 73 and 74 will fall.

Comment on this

72 has no connection with 71.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

It is a case of 74 or 75.

Comment on this

We can discuss on 70 the general definition of fair rent. I move amendment 70, "to delete paragraph (e)." This section again raises one of the main principles of the Bill.

With regard to paragraphs (f) and (g), the question of whether or not that is a fair basis upon which to calculate the rent to be paid by a tenant who is deemed by the Dáil to have a statutory right to a new tenancy is the issue before us. It is proposed that a tenant who has been in occupation of a dwelling-house for forty years, or who has been in occupation of a business house and established a goodwill in the business in that house for three years, or who has doubled the letting value of the dwelling in consequence of his own improvements, should be given a new tenancy only on this condition, that he would agree to pay the landlord the rent which that landlord would get on the basis of taking possession in the circumstances of normal competition—in other words, the full competitive rent of the dwelling or shop, as the case may be. Is it fair that such a tenant, possessing such an equity to a new tenancy, should be required to pay the full competitive rent, and, if not, what rent should he be asked to pay? There are various proposals on the Paper before us. There is a proposal in the name of Deputy O'Connell that if the building was let in 1914 the rent payable should be the rent actually paid in that year.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

No.

Comment on this

The Deputy's amendment is: "In respect to houses built prior to the 4th of August, 1914, shall not be more than the rent permitted by the Increase of Rent and Mortgage Interest (Restrictions) Act, 1923, and in respect to houses built after the 4th of August, 1914." There are other proposals in the name of Deputy Byrne, and there is an amendment to this definition in the name of the Minister. We considered this question most carefully. We were attracted originally by the proposal which Deputy O'Connell is submitting, that is, in respect of houses which were let on the 4th of August, 1914, the rent should be the rent now permitted under the Increase of Rent Act. The big difficulty in that connection is, however, in the first place it omits from the scope of the Bill a large number of houses which have been constructed since the 4th of August, 1914, and, secondly, that this Bill, unlike the Increase of Rent Act, is a permanent measure, and it seems very undesirable to have the circumstances of 1914 as a standard in a Bill which may be in operation in ten or twenty years' time in circumstances that we cannot possibly foresee. The view which we took was that some method of computation of the rent should be arrived at which would be easily operated and applicable in all circumstances. We could say that the rent to be reserved under the new tenancy should not exceed the rent to be reserved under the old tenancy. But that also would leave out of account certain important factors. The letting value of the tenancy might have gone down considerably, or, alternatively, it might have gone up in consequence of action by the tenant, by the landlord, or by the local authority. In the majority of cases which are likely to arise in the immediate future, it will be found that the rent as defined in paragraph (f) of this section is likely to exceed the rent reserved under the old tenancy, particularly, of course, if that old rent be regulated by the Increase of Rent Acts. The question is whether the difference between the new increased letting value and the old rent should go to the tenant or to the landlord. We may say that the rent shall be the rent under the Increase of Rent Act or under any circumstances shall be the old rent. In fact, we are giving to the tenant the full benefit of the increase in the letting value that has taken place.

[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]

If, on the other hand, we say, as the Minister proposes we should say, that the landlord is entitled to get the full competitive rent of the building, we mean that the full benefit of that increased letting value is to go to the landlord as against the tenant. The proposal which we are submitting to the Dáil is in the nature of a compromise, a proposal that in effect the difference should be divided between the landlord and the tenant. That difference may, as I have said, be due neither to the action of the landlord nor the tenant. It may be due to a variety of causes, not the least of which might be the expenditure and enterprise of the local authority in the area. If there were a local council which carried out considerable improvement schemes in the neighbourhood of the dwelling, which installed a water supply, sewerage and other services of that kind, the increase in the letting value of the dwelling should properly go to the persons who paid for those improvements—that is the ratepayers in the area. We considered very carefully whether it could not be possible to devise some means by which that increased letting value could be secured for the ratepayers, but we found ourselves up against considerable difficulties, difficulties in which any Party in opposition must find themselves when attempting to frame intricate amendments to a Bill of this kind. We could not do it. So we arrive at this proposal—that the increase in the letting value should be divided as between the landlord and the tenant in the proportion of fifty-fifty. Where it is found that the gross rent, as calculated in accordance with the provisions of paragraph (f), exceeds the old rent, then the rent to be reserved under the new tenancy shall not be in excess of the old rent by more than half the difference between the gross rent as calculated in accordance with paragraph (f) and the old rent. On the other hand, where it is found that the gross rent, as calculated in accordance with paragraph (f), is less than the old rent, we propose that the new rent should be the rent as it is calculated. There is another proposal to split the difference. In that case, when the letting value of the premises has decreased, we do not propose that the tenant should be asked to pay more than its letting value. I move to report progress.

Comment on this