We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Road Traffic Bill, 1931—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 221–448 of 674. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Road Traffic Bill 1931
Lapsed

No. 38 of 1931 ›

I am dealing particularly with the cars that ply for public hire.

Comment on this

We come back then to the people driving public service vehicles. Do we require a medical test as well as a test for competency on the part of those people before they are given drivers' licences?

Comment on this

It occurs to me that surely this will affect the question of insurance and will affect the premiums the insurance companies will very likely demand if they have to take the risks of drivers suffering some physical defect.

Comment on this

I do not know that the insurance companies require any certificate with regard to drivers, whether their eyesight is good or bad.

Comment on this

I will be content if the Minister will consider the two points referred to—deafness and colour-blindness.

Comment on this

What about short-sightedness?

Comment on this

That can be corrected easily if the person uses glasses. There is no great difficulty about that.

Comment on this

I would like to ask Deputy Sir James Craig whether, in carrying out a test of competency under a skilled and competent member of the Guards, definitely trained for that particular class of work, a man like that could not apply simple tests in respect of deafness and colour-blindness and in respect of long or short sight?

Comment on this

I suggest that the Minister is indicating what might be considered a great offence in the eyes of the General Medical Council.

Comment on this

I will not ask Deputy Sir James Craig to answer. If we can narrow the thing down to this, that a competent member of the Gárda will carry out a test of competency in the driving of a vehicle—he ought to be capable of doing it—I will examine and discuss the matter from that point of view.

Comment on this

Will the Minister permit people who suffer from defective eyesight which can be efficiently treated by wearing glasses and who subsequently get glasses, to qualify then for a certificate? Personally, I think he should.

Comment on this

I feel he should. If a person is turned down on the question of eyesight and, after being provided with suitable glasses, reapplies, there ought to be no objection.

Comment on this

The general form of the Minister's statement raises an important question, a very serious question. We can contemplate a man being put in charge of a public service vehicle who is suffering from a very dangerous form of heart disease. That is a serious thing to contemplate.

Comment on this

Does the Minister contemplate leaving it to the discretion of the local Gárda officer to decide what is a suitable sight test, or will he lay down a general rule?

Comment on this

The Commissioner will have to lay down general rules as to what shall be done in the carrying out of a competency test.

Comment on this

Might I suggest to the Minister that the ability to read the rear number-plate of a motorcar is not a sufficient test?

Comment on this

I have been driving a car for years, and I have never had a serious accident, but I doubt if I would be able to fulfil the test of reading the number-plate of a car ahead at the distance specified in the English regulations, and I hold that I am a competent driver.

Comment on this

If the Minister and Deputies want to be fair, as I am sure they do, to all those who want to make a livelihood out of the transport industry, I think they should put all engaged in competition in that industry on the same basis, as far as the conditions under which they carry on go. Let us take the case of the Irish Omnibus Company, which is part and parcel, as Deputy Murphy may not admit, of the Great Southern Railways Company. Those engaged as engine drivers, guards, signal men in the service of the railway company are obliged in the interest of those who travel by rail to pass a severe eye-sight test, and to be called periodically when the officials of the Company desire before the medical officer in order to ascertain if their eye-sight is perfect.

Comment on this

Because the Minister has certain officials in his Department who are paid to see that that is done.

Comment on this

Why is it all done?

Comment on this

In the interests of the travelling public.

Comment on this

Does not the Deputy know that the working of the railways depends on the capacity to distinguish between a red light and a green light?

Comment on this

The red and green lights have some bearing on the safety of those travelling by rail.

Comment on this

Yes, but not on the roads.

Comment on this

Does the Minister suggest that a superintendent of the Guards without any medical experience is competent to say that any man coming before him for a driver's licence has perfect eyesight, or that he could read a number plate of a motor car a certain distance in front of him on the public road? Could he tell, if asked, the number of a car that was coming towards him or the width of the road? I think it is a very necessary condition in the interests of those travelling by bus to see that some test is applied by somebody who has a knowledge of what good or bad eye-sight is. The debate on this Bill has been remarkable for the number of Deputies who spoke about the safety of innocent people. As far as I can see, there are far more innocent people engaged in the motor industry than any other industry. The plea raised by Deputy Thrift and other innocent Deputies has been for mitigation of the fines and to see that these people do not get imprisonment.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

What has that to do with the section?

Comment on this

It has got to do with the Minister's reference to Section 12.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Section 71 is the section before the House.

Comment on this

The Minister was allowed to refer to Section 12.

Comment on this

There is nothing about innocent people in Section 12.

Comment on this

The Minister is so innocent that he is prepared to take a declaration from innocent people who look for drivers' licences, who make application to say if they want a job that they are physically and mentally fit to secure a driver's licence. That should not be allowed in the case of those who apply for positions in public carrying companies. I put it to the Minister that in the interests of those who will travel from time to time on omnibuses in particular, some test of fitness should be applied by some person who knows the difference between good eyesight and bad eye-sight.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I think if the Minister is going to go into the question of eyesight he should also consider the question of dealing with drivers of private cars. It is just as important that their sight should be corrected by proper glasses as the sight of the drivers of public vehicles. No person should get a licence who has not good eyesight.

Comment on this

As drivers of private cars are referred to I think there should be particular reference to members of the Executive Council, who can only see red at present.

Comment on this

They can distinguish it from green.

Comment on this

I do not think so.

Comment on this

Is the Minister prepared to go into this question before the next stage?

Comment on this

Yes. As I see it if you are not going to subject the drivers of public service vehicles to a general all-round medical examination, then, whoever carries out the competency test ought to have instructions that will enable him to detect obvious defects of eyes and ears.

Comment on this

I take it that this is a new tax that is being brought into force. Up to the present no fees have been chargeable for public service licences. Seeing that the Minister is getting very big taxes from these vehicles already is he prepared to defend the idea of a further tax, a tax that is to be indefinite so far as the Dáil is concerned? Section 76 provides that fees are to be fixed by regulation made by the Minister with the consent of the Minister for Finance. If the fees are only to be nominal surely he could fit them into the Bill without leaving the matter uncertain and to be made use of by the Minister for Finance for any purpose he may have in mind. It seems strange that in the case of vehicles already subject to two big and growing taxes—a seating tax in addition to a petrol tax—advantage should be taken on a Traffic Bill to increase the taxation upon them. I would like to hear from the Minister what is his idea for introducing further taxation on these vehicles.

Comment on this

The idea primarily is to meet expenses necessarily incurred in connection with the licensing in the same manner as in regard to competency certificates. Since 1921, there has been no such fee paid, but prior to 1921 there was a fee of four guineas paid. Deputies have referred to the British practice in other matters. The position under the British regulations is that for the licensing of a public service vehicle the owner pays three guineas. A certificate of fitness also costs three guineas. It lasts for a period of five years, unless revoked. Here the general proposal is simply to fix a fee that will cover the expenses incurred in dealing with the matter.

Comment on this

That fee will be paid into the Road Fund?

Comment on this

All fees in connection with this Bill will go into the Road Fund, except fees for parking attendants.

Comment on this

Seeing that the road tax is already paid into the Road Fund and that the Road Fund is as high as it could well be—substantially higher than it is in Great Britain— the case for a further tax to cover expenses arising under this Bill is not a very strong one. Would the Minister give us an idea of the amount he proposes to fix in respect of these vehicles?

Comment on this

The fee would be between £3 and £4, but it will all depend on what the running of this section will cost.

Comment on this

I suggest that in the third line of sub-section (2) the words should be "the amount of the annual licence fee," instead of "the amount of the licence fee." Further down, this fee is referred to as "the annual licence fee."

Comment on this

Thanks for drawing attention to that.

Insertion agreed to.

SECTION 74.

(1) The Commissioner shall not grant a public service vehicle licence in respect of any public service vehicle which does not appear to him—

(a) to be constructed and equipped in accordance with the regulations for the construction and equipment of mechanically propelled vehicles so far as such regulations are applicable to such vehicle, and

(b) to be in such a state of repair as to be serviceable, safe and otherwise fit for the accommodation of passengers.

(2) The Commissioner may refuse to grant a public service vehicle licence to a person who in his opinion is, by reason of his character or previous conduct or for any other reason, not a fit and proper person to hold a public service vehicle licence.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I move amendment 69.

Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"A public service vehicle licence shall not be granted to any person in respect to any large public service vehicle unless such vehicle is constructed so as to isolate the driver from the passengers."

This amendment is intended to ensure the greater safety of the travelling public. It refers only to the large public service vehicle and proposes that the driver of such a vehicle should be isolated from the passengers. I think that the House will agree that the driver of such a vehicle should have his whole attention concentrated on the management of his vehicle and on looking out for other traffic, and that it should not be possible for his passengers to distract him. Cases have been reported where there has been overcrowding and where sometimes two or three persons crushed themselves in beside the driver, thus preventing him from properly managing his vehicle. Some provision such as this should be inserted in the Bill to ensure that distraction shall not take place.

Comment on this

Would Deputy O'Connell consider the leaving out of the word "large" and altering the amendment so as to provide that no driver of a public bus carrying passengers should have anybody beside him? I agree that a person sitting beside the driver does distract him.

Comment on this

The position is that under the Motor Car and Public Service Vehicle Order, 1928, in the case of a vehicle fitted with a permanent roof—what would be a public service vehicle now—the driver's seat shall be so enclosed as to isolate the driver from the passengers.

Comment on this

Is that enforced?

Comment on this

It ought to be enforced. It is intended that some provision of that kind shall be enforced under the regulations under this Bill. If we put the provision which Deputy O'Connell suggests into the Bill now, it would apply to char-a-bancs, and you could not have a position in regard to char-a-bancs whereby the driver would be isolated. You have also the case of the one-man bus, carrying less than fourteen passengers, where a conductor is not required. It would be unreasonable to provide that the driver in that case should be isolated from the passengers, because he has to collect the fares. In the case of bigger vehicles, in the case of vehicles fitted with permanent roofs, the intention is that the drivers should be isolated. Some of these char-a-bancs are not covered by permanent roofs. They are driven quite openly and there is no necessity to have the driver isolated from the passengers. The intention the Deputy has in mind will be adequately provided for under the regulations.

Comment on this

The danger in the case of the char-a-banc is just as great as in the case of other vehicles. I was in an accident in a char-a-banc and the accident was due simply to a passenger—a very attractive young passenger—conversing with a rather susceptible driver.

Comment on this

The Minister states that under the existing law it is compulsory for the driver to be isolated from the passengers. In the Minister's own constituency—North Dublin— there are hundreds of buses plying for hire, in which the driver is not isolated from the passengers. I should like to call the Minister's attention to the lamentable accident, referred to by Deputy Lemass, which took place in the Coombe district some time ago. If the provision that Deputy O'Connell is now seeking to have incorporated in the Bill had been in operation then, that accident, I suggest, would not have occurred. The Minister is further aware that in his constituency fourteen-seater buses regularly carry fifteen, sixteen or twenty passengers and that passengers frequently converse with the drivers. In view of the long hours that these men work and in view of the danger to passengers, the Minister should accept Deputy O'Connell's amendment.

Comment on this

I assure the Deputy that my constituents are not allowed greater liberties that the constituents of other Deputies.

Comment on this

That was not what I suggested. There are more buses plying for hire in the Minister's constituency than in any other constituency. Consequently, the danger is greater.

Comment on this
Denis John Gorey Mr. Gorey

There is a danger as regards this matter. Sometimes you see passengers draped about the driver and occasionally the driver draped about a passenger. Where a passenger happens to be sitting beside the driver at a critical time, if that passenger, whether man or a woman, happens to be hysterical, they may make a grab at the wheel. I have seen that occur while I was driving myself. Only I saw, in time, the hand coming, there would have been a crash. It is undesirable in a vehicle of this description to have passengers beside the driver. This matter should be considered and passengers should not be allowed to sit beside the drivers of vehicles carrying six passengers or more.

Comment on this

It cannot be denied that this practice exists to a great extent in the southern portion of County Dublin, where you have a number of these fourteen-seater buses plying. I do not want to see these people driven out of business right away, but I suggest that regulations might be made or that the section should be amended in such a way as to make it impossible for a new bus of this type to come into existence after the passing of the Act unless the conditions laid down in Deputy O'Connell's amendment are complied with. The amendment, if put into operation right away, would apply to a number of these fourteen-seater buses that probably have another year or year-and-a-half to live in the transport world. An alteration could be made in some cases. I am not so bigoted against buses operating in this country as to refuse to travel on them, particularly when I cannot get any other means of taking me from one point to another. Some time ago I got into a bus at Burgh Quay late at night. It was a fourteen-seater, going out on its last journey. There were twenty-five passengers in it. On that bus the driver had to act as conductor.

Comment on this

And the Deputy got out again?

Comment on this

I kicked up a bit of a row all right. I do not want to interfere with people who have existing rights—rights in property if you like— but I would suggest that after the passing of this Bill no licence should be given to any bus-owner who does not comply with the conditions laid down in Deputy O'Connell's amendment. I think that is fair.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy can be assured that there is no new public service vehicle carrying over fourteen passengers being allowed in here now that does not conform to the regulations, with regard to construction, that I have spoken about.

Comment on this

There are twenty-seater buses operating at the present time.

Comment on this

I do not know how recently they were put on, but I would be surprised to learn that new buses are being put on here that do not conform to the regulations.

Comment on this

The regulations are not in operation.

Comment on this

That we have given consideration to the matter is shown by the fact that already we have made regulations.

Comment on this

But you have not put them into operation.

Comment on this

They may not be put into operation. It may be that the difficulties the Deputy spoke about are being taken into consideration by the Gárda. These buses may have been on the road before the Order I speak about was made. At any rate the matter has had consideration, and regulations have been made. In the case of public service vehicles which provide for the carrying of fourteen passengers, you have only one man on board who acts as driver and collector of the fares. In these cases you cannot require that he shall be a good way from the passengers. But you may require that the construction and fitting of the bus shall be such that no one will be sitting alongside him.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that in the case of most of these fourteen seater buses passengers have to enter where the driver is seated?

Comment on this

I am, but there is no objection to that. In the case of these one-man buses, as they may be called, it is much more satisfactory that the passengers would enter in that particular way if the driver has also to collect the fares. Otherwise, he would have to be going to the end of the bus to collect the fares. You have that class of bus and you have to cater for it. We can take into consideration the laying down of regulations with regard to the construction and fitting of buses of that particular kind. We do not want to put the driver into the position that Deputy Gorey speaks about. Then you have the charabanc. That has to be considered, too. Our attitude is shown in the regulations which we have made with regard to the more than fourteen-seater buses. I suggest that there the House has sufficient earnest of our outlook on the matter, and I submit that what Deputy O'Connell seeks to put in here now is more satisfactorily dealt with by regulations.

Comment on this

Does the Minister intend to enforce the regulations?

Comment on this

We intend not only to enforce the regulations but to enforce the Act.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I can quite see the advantages that may be gained from making regulations. I would, however, like to have the Minister's assurance that these regulations will be progressively enforced towards securing that measure of safety which I have sought to provide for in my amendment. I ask leave to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 70:

"In sub-section (2), line 50, to delete the words "or for any other reason."

Comment on this

I am accepting the amendment.

Comment on this

I want to call attention to the phrase "otherwise fit" in paragraph (b) of sub-section (1) of the section. I think it is a pity to leave to the Commissioner who, as far as I can understand from the Minister, is not to be responsible to this House either through the Minister or in any other way, with such a loose general phrase as that for his guidance. Apparently the interpretation of the words "otherwise fit" is left to the Commissioner himself. I understand that in recent months the Garda authorities refused a licence for a vehicle on the grounds that it was not properly painted though the owner of it would seem to me to be a man who would be a competent judge of what suitable painting was.

It is not for any petty reason that I am raising this question. There is a very big issue involved in it. Before the vehicle is passed as suitable in the Commissioner's office the tax has to be paid on it. In the case that I have mentioned, although the tax was paid, a delay of a fortnight took place before the vehicle could be used. That was a very serious matter for the owner. Is there no way by which the owners of public service vehicles could be protected against having to suffer loss of that kind? The owner of the vehicle may not be in any way to blame, and yet on his own individual opinion the Commissioner may refuse to licence the vehicle. In my opinion this phrase "otherwise fit" should either be struck out, or the owner of the vehicle should be relieved from the payment of the road tax during the period that the alterations to the vehicle, required by the Commissioner, are being executed. I submit that for the Minister's consideration.

Comment on this

With regard to the phrase "otherwise fit" I do not know what other words you could put in. The regulations dealing with the construction, equipment and general condition of buses will be such as to indicate what is expected, and the Garda authorities, in turning down a vehicle as being unserviceable, will have to do so knowing that there is an appeal to the District Court against their decision. Did I understand the Deputy to suggest that there shall be a deduction from the road tax payable in respect of it during the period that the vehicle is off the road because the Garda authorities have decided that it is unfit for use?

Comment on this

Quite. I pointed out the fact that the fault that the Gárda may find with the vehicle may be a matter of opinion or judgment. It may be, as happened in recent months, that the Gárda do not approve of the painting of the vehicle and that it will have to be painted in a different way. It is a matter on which any two persons will differ, and practically to fine a man for not painting the vehicle, according to what the Gárda would require, would be wrong, and it may not be what the Minister would intend. Yet that would happen under the Bill as it stands at present. You may have a vehicle rejected because the Gárda do not approve of the painting. The repainting may take two or three weeks or a month. Meantime, a very heavy tax has to be paid on the vehicle. I suggest that such an owner would have a very good grievance.

Comment on this

I will have the matter examined to see in what way the Deputy's point can be met.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider adding to the final line of the first sub-section after the words Gárda Síochána, "specially chosen for competency in such work." There is a good deal of alarm amongst the owners of public service vehicles at the moment at the prospect of a member of the Gárda being chosen for this work. It is felt that the most competent member possible should be chosen for it, and that the Dáil should suggest to the Commissioner that the person or persons chosen for such work should be competent.

Comment on this

I will consider whether it would be reasonable to put in words like those. Of course, it is intended that the person entrusted with this particular work shall be specially chosen and, no doubt, specially trained.

Comment on this

With regard to the amount of the fine mentioned in the last line of Section 82—a fine not exceeding £10—is the figure not too low? Will the fine of £10 not be too low in the case of a defective vehicle which might mean grave risk to a lot of passengers?

Comment on this

Exception has been taken to some of these fines, and I have said that I will look into the matter. I wonder could we get any suggestion as to what should be the fine?

Comment on this

Personally I would be inclined to double that figure as the minimum.

Comment on this

We are getting the matter considered in any case, and if Deputies have any opinions on the particular fines proposed they can put down amendments for the next stage.

Comment on this

In sub-section (2) of this section would the Minister explain what is the object of making the driver responsible for the vehicle-plate being missing. After all, questions of that kind may easily cause friction between an employer and his employees. I can see no reason why two persons must be held responsible, particularly as the driver is not the owner of the vehicle. He has not any control over it, and he must raise the question with his employer. It may then lead to unpleasantness. We know that it is very hard to get employment at present. Very many drivers are so glad to have it that they do not want to be raising questions of that kind with their employers. I suggest that there is no need for that provision, and that it is quite sufficient to make the owner responsible.

Comment on this

I think it would be rather ineffective to make the owner responsible. After all the driver is the person close up against the vehicle, and the person that you must hold responsible for seeing that from day to day, or from place to place, the vehicle in the matter of lights, and in the matter of any other statutory requirements, complies with the law. I do not see that you could possibly exonerate the driver for driving a motor without a vehicle plate. On the other hand, in order to strengthen the control over these matters, we include the owner. We put the owner into the position also of being chargeable in respect of this offence, but if anyone is going to be charged in the first place in connection with the matter I think it should be the driver, because he is the person who has immediate control.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister will admit that a case like this may arise. A plate gets lost, and a new plate may not be obtained. The driver cannot replace that, he has to go on driving. The owner may take the risk of the vehicle being kept in use without a plate. He may say to the driver "You will manage to escape the Gárda." We all know that very many simple things like that are not observed until they have been missing for a long time. The owner may give the driver instructions that he is to go ahead and leave the question of the plate to him. It may be that the owner has the plate locked up in some office. It may be that he wants a new plate. Anything may occur in connection with it. Why does the Minister set out to provoke unpleasantness between the driver and the owner in regard to a matter like that? The driver has got to say to his employer "You must produce the plate or I will not take out the vehicle." This is a new provision and I do not think there could be a more unsuitable time for introducing it than the present, because of the difficulty of getting employment.

Comment on this

As far as relieving the driver of responsibility in the matter is concerned, I am quite sure that any court would relieve the driver of responsibility if he had duly reported the absence of the vehicle plate to his employer, and passed on the responsibility in that particular way. I think it is necessary to force the driver into the position that he will pass on that responsibility to the owner, if the owner is the person to supply the vehicle plate.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

It can be dealt with by way of amendment to delete the word "driver."

Comment on this

I move amendment (71).

In sub-section 1, line 22, to delete the words "a member of the Gárda Síochána" and substitute therefore the words "a person qualified by experience in the construction of vehicles (in this section hereafter called a vehicle inspector)".

The members of this group regard this amendment as a very important one. For that reason I hope the Minister will reconsider the section as it now stands and agree that a member of the Gárda Síochána is not in the ordinary way a fit and competent person to say whether a 'bus is from the mechanical point of view fit to ply for public hire. I am told by a skilled workman engaged in the trade of vehicle-building that if a skilled man had been previously appointed to go into the question of applications for licences, bearing in mind only the question of the construction of the vehicle and its condition, that many of the taxis and buses now plying for hire in the public streets and thoroughfares of the country would certainly not be on the roads. This Bill, and I give full credit to those who were responsible for framing it, has been largely drawn up on the lines of the British Road Traffic Act. Many sections have been copied word for word into this Bill.

Comment on this

Could you quote a section?

Comment on this

I would like to hear from the Minister why, when reading the British Road Traffic Act, he did not follow the lines laid down by the British Government with regard to inspection. Provision is made in the British Act for inspection to be done by skilled men, who know more about the construction and condition of a vehicle than unskilled men naturally do. The latest information I have in relation to the operation of the British Road Traffic Act, is that in four controlled areas skilled inspectors have been already appointed. Three further appointments were under consideration at the time I received this information. I understand, also, that the Six County Government has already appointed a skilled man as inspector within their area. The safety of the travelling public depends upon the competency, fitness, and qualifications of the driver, upon the construction and condition of the vehicle in which the passenger travels, and I think in a matter of this kind the cost is not going to be very great. Bearing in mind that the police force that we have in this country is very young compared with what it is in Great Britain and other places, where skilled men are doing this class of work, I think the Minister should accept this amendment.

In the case of railway engines and trams, the driver is practically a mechanic himself. Although the engine driver, before he is allowed to take charge of an engine, would on the average have 15 or 20 years' service as an engine cleaner and a fireman, still the engineer and the railway works must inspect the engine before it leaves the shed for service on the rails. The same thing applies to the tram, and I do not see why an unskilled man should be allowed to take over the work which a skilled man only is competent to do, and I hope the Minister will accept this amendment. We regard it as a very important question, and I will, if the Minister cannot see his way to reconsider the matter, be forced to ask the House to divide on the issue involved.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Deputy would leave the amendment stand as it is until the next stage. I agree to the principle of it but I cannot quite subscribe to the idea of calling the Gárda involved by a particular title. I agree that the annual inspection of these vehicles is a matter of great importance and should be done by very competent persons. I will consider what amendment to sub-section I will be necessary to emphasise that point. Perhaps the Deputy might repeat his amendment on the next stage.

Comment on this

Do I understand from the Minister that he is prepared to accept the view contained in the amendment that this kind of work should be left only to a skilled person?

Comment on this

That the person carrying on the special annual inspection of these should be a qualified person.

Comment on this

Does the Minister mean annual inspection only?

Comment on this

The type of inspection that is contemplated in the annual inspection whether an inspection of that particular kind takes place periodically or not. I would not subscribe to it in the case of Section 86.

Comment on this

In the case of a first application for a licence for a taxi to ply in the streets of Dublin the Minister agrees in that case that a skilled man should be asked to undertake the work.

Comment on this

Yes, that a skilled man should be asked to undertake the work. I will have to consider in what way I will have to redraft the section to emphasise that.

Comment on this

There is a phrase in Section 85: "the Commissioner may at any time and as often as he thinks fit." Does the Minister not think that that is too wide and that there ought to be some limitation? In some areas it might lead to victimisation, or petty tyranny of some kind or another. An official might get his back up against a person for some purely private wrong. God knows what grievance they might have against one another, and the position might happen that a bus-owner might be driven out of business before any complaint could be investigated at headquarters as to the tyrannical actions of the subordinate officer. I think the wording as it stands at present would leave it open to an individual who might be inclined to act in that way to do so and to put a car-owner to very great difficulty and even to the extent of driving him out of business unless the Minister could see some way of tightening it up. "He may at any time and as often as he thinks fit"—several times a day a car might be operated on. His business might be interfered with in the most unforeseen and unjust way. I think there ought to be some limit.

Comment on this

I think there is some point in Deputy O'Kelly's remarks. It occurs to me that a man may be running three or four buses on a particular road and may be required to produce all his buses at the same time for inspection which may leave it that he would be unable to provide his usual services on the road. There should be some attempt to use the blessed word "reasonable." I suggest the words "at any reasonable time," so that some safeguard would be assured for the owner of the buses that would permit him to make representations that the time selected by the Commissioner of the Guards was not convenient for his business.

Comment on this

Do not the words "fit and reasonable" mean the same thing?

Comment on this

"May at any time and as often as he thinks fit."

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

It looks to me that 86 is wider still.

Comment on this

It is, of course, but we are dealing with this section at the moment.

Comment on this

It is no harm to say at the moment that the grievance one hears is that inspection is wholly inadequate and that vehicles are allowed on the streets that would not be allowed if there were proper and adequate inspection.

Comment on this

To carry the point from theory to practice, perhaps the Minister would be interested to hear that the bus owners in Dublin are at present jealous of each other on the grounds that the Gárda are supposed to favour particular bus services. Nothing is more common than accusations of favouritism by the Guards towards bus owners. I do not say for a moment there is any foundation for it, but it is everyday gossip that certain people are getting away with it in the matter of freedom from prosecutions, and so on. As this section stands, similar accusations will be made, and it is desirable from every point of view that no grounds should be left for such abuse.

Comment on this

We put on the Guards the responsibility of seeing that public service vehicles are in a fit and proper condition, and we must have power by which the Commissioner, if he thinks that it is reasonable, that any particular bus should be systematically inspected should have power to do that. I do not think that we can contemplate that the Commissioner will act in a discriminating way as between different classes of buses or between the buses of different owners. Once it is agreed that the Commissioner must have power to have a bus inspected at any time he thinks it reasonable because of anything he knows about it, or because of the way in which it is behaving he should have that power. Once we agree on that and see whether there is nothing likely to be objectionable in these words we can arrange it.

Comment on this

It is not suggested that the Commissioner would be guilty of that but subordinate officials, perhaps close to headquarters or otherwise. At any rate subordinate officials, might be guilty.

Comment on this

Is it clear that this section only relates to inspections of which three days' notice must be given?

Comment on this

Yes, regular overhauling.

Comment on this

I move amendment 73:

In sub-section (1), line 42, to insert after the word "Síochána" the words "specially appointed by the Commissioner because of his qualifications for the duties hereinafter mentioned and wearing a badge or other sign to indicate his authority under this section".

This is the same idea that Deputy Davin had in mind on the previous section that the Gárda appointed for this work should be one with qualifications. It is also suggested that he should have some means of special identification showing that he was appointed for the specific purpose of work under this section.

Comment on this

The purpose of this inspection is entirely different from the purpose of the inspection under Section 85. The intention is that any member of the Gárda Síochána at all, if he thinks it is called for, may enter on any bus and inspect it superficially. If he has any doubts on seeing how the bus acts in a particular place and fears there is something wrong with the brakes he may ask the driver to operate the machine with a view to verifying that the brakes are really in good condition. It is a superficial inspection of a kind that the ordinary Guard on traffic duty or otherwise ought to have power to do if there is anything obviously wrong.

Comment on this

Does the Minister ask us to believe that every member of the Gárda will be capable of such duty? What proportion of the Guards are taught to drive a car? If a member does not himself drive how could he be capable of carrying out duties under this section? Even if he did drive there are some hundreds I am sure in that service who like myself and many others could not understand the mechanism of a car no matter what training they got. The Minister ought to know that there are people who are incapable of understanding the mechanism of a motor car. There are as many people as there are people suffering from colour-blindness which we spent a lot of time discussing to-day. It is not merely a superficial inspection. It is going to be a very thorough inspection. It gives an officious Guard a tremendous opportunity for causing trouble. This would be equivalent to passing a vote of confidence in every Guard in the country, that he will act with scrupulous care and avoid giving unnecessary trouble, that he will have no such thing as a grudge against a bus driver, a conductor, or anything like that, that he will be a judge of the mechanism of a car and can tell whether the engine is in order or not. I think it is the most outlandish proposal that was ever made in the Dáil.

Comment on this

I would like to give the Minister a case in point. Only recently when an owner of a bus was summoned for having defective brakes he satisfied the court that the brakes had been only overhauled a week before. The summons was dismissed. In the course of the examination of the sergeant who brought the charge, he was asked if he had a practical experience of driving a car or acting as a mechanic. He replied that he had not. Yet that sergeant was specially detailed for work of bus inspection.

Comment on this

I think the issue, which is a very serious one from the trade union point of view, that was raised in Section 85 cannot be separated from the one now raised by Deputy O'Kelly on Section 86. I do not see why an ordinary Guard for instance should be given the right asked for by the Minister in sub-section (a) of Section 2—"prohibit the use of such vehicle for carrying passengers for reward until repairs indicated by him have been executed." The Minister will, I think, in his serious moments candidly admit that an ordinary member of the Guard is not competent to indicate the nature of repairs required to be done to a vehicle.

Comment on this

He is competent to say that the thing has no lights, and to see that it does not carry on without lights.

Comment on this

There is nothing mechanical in that particular class of work, but a Guard may "require the driver of such vehicle to drive such vehicle forthwith to a convenient place indicated by such member for such inspection and examination." The Minister has admitted, in a qualified way, that there is something to be said for the amendment which I moved depriving the Guard of that right so far as it applied to Section 85. I think the inspection work should be done by a skilled man. The members of this Party feel very keenly on it, and will press that point of view very strongly when the matter comes up again. I appeal to the Minister that between this and the next stage of the Bill he will reconsider the drafting of the section so as to leave to the Guards any work of the kind he has referred to dealing with the question of lights, but we will not admit that an ordinary Guard who has no experience of vehicle-building, and who is not a skilled man, should be given rights under this Bill, which in our opinion should be held by skilled vehicle builders.

Comment on this

May I point out that I think the object of this section is misunderstood. The inspection that we were talking about under the previous section is inspection that has to take place at regular intervals to see that the vehicle is in proper running order. Let me illustrate what I understand by this clause. Supposing I am motoring along a roadway. I have to pull up suddenly by reason of some obstruction. I am followed by a bus and that bus runs into the back of my car. I get out and ask what he means. He pleads that his brakes are defective. Is that a vehicle that should be allowed to continue on the roadway? I can call any Guard who is in the particular area and draw his attention to the fact that this vehicle is not safe for other road users and should not be on the roadway. He can inspect it and if he is satisfied with the statement he can order it off the road. That is the protection that ordinary road users are entitled to. It is not a point turning on whether it is mechanically perfect with which the other clause deals. It is dealing with the rights of ordinary users. I hold, as an ordinary road user, that I am entitled to call upon a Guard if I see a vehicle on the road that is a danger to other road users.

Comment on this

May I ask the Deputy to explain what is meant in putting in the words in sub-section (2) (a) "until repairs indicated by him have been executed".

Comment on this

Repairs to the vehicle.

Comment on this

Indicated by an unskilled man.

Comment on this

Deputy Good put it perfectly as far as brakes are concerned. It may be that the Deputy sees a driver going around a corner in a way that suggests his brakes are not working. Naturally he gets terribly vexed and calls a Guard and says this is one of these terrible buses.

That Guard surely is entitled to stop that bus and say it cannot carry on until repairs to the brakes are carried out. Buses are required to have all kinds of little things in order. They are supposed to have their fuel tanks properly corked and not stopped with a rag. They are supposed to have a fire extinguisher and other little details like that. It should be within the function of any Guard to board a bus to see whether the minor regulations were being carried out. I do not accept at all that there is any relationship between the type of inspection contemplated in Section 86 and the inspection provided for in Section 85. Under such provision as we make in Section 86 we want to give a Guard power to do the type of thing suggested.

Comment on this

Does the Minister hold that a Guard who has not any training in motor mechanics, and who has not any experience of driving a car, would be capable of carrying out the particular duty he mentioned of looking after the petrol tank to see that it is properly plugged?

Comment on this

He will be capable of seeing whether the petrol tank is operating in such a way that petrol is dropping around the car.

Comment on this

Does the Minister expect a man who has never looked into the inside of a motor car to undertake that duty? That is rather remarkable. I think the Minister is assuming too much.

Comment on this

There may be a competent person who has had experience of motor cars in the bus and he may notice that particular defect, and, realising the seriousness of it, he may complain to a Guard at the next stopping place.

Comment on this

That is not in the Bill.

Comment on this

Any Guard ought to be able to do it.

Comment on this

The Guard may without any reason to suspect the vehicle at all stop it and examine it. Surely the temptation to a Guard who would not be a very responsible person, and who would be ignorant of mechanics, to order the bus away for inspection and to order the people in it to get out and go where they like while that inspection is being carried on, might be very great. The temptation might be very great to a Guard who would not know much about his job, and who might for selfish reasons behave like that.

Comment on this

We cannot assume that the Gárda as a class are unintelligent and that their temptations run along abnormal lines.

Comment on this

It is not the matter of the Guards as a class but of an individual Guard. Although there is ground for giving Guards power to inspect or stop buses if a complaint is made, that is not the provision here. If the Minister would amend the section to give power to any Guard on the receipt of a complaint to cause such stoppage and inspection to take place, or to a Guard specially detailed and qualified to do it without any such complaint having been made, it would meet the point we are trying to safeguard.

Comment on this

A Guard may be quite as competent himself to realise that something is wrong with a bus as if he got a complaint.

Comment on this

If the Minister is travelling from Ballina to Dublin some night and half way on the journey a Guard stops the bus, tells him to get out and the driver to drive away to some place to have the bus inspected, and he finds himself left on the road with no possibility of getting in anywhere for the night, he will realise that there is something to be said against this.

Comment on this

It is very hypothetical. The longest way round might be the shortest way home if I were travelling on a bus without brakes and were put out on the side of the road.

Comment on this

Brakes are not mentioned here.

Comment on this

I am prepared to give the Guards who have ordinary intelligence some of the limited powers indicated by the Minister, but I am not prepared to give them the powers asked for in sub-sections (a) and (b). These are the only words I object to, "repairs indicated by him." If the Minister will say "necessary repairs," leaving it to somebody with skilled knowledge to say what is required, I would not have the same objection to this section. But I say that an unskilled man is not the proper person to indicate the nature and extent of the repairs to be carried out to a bus when it breaks down. I do not think it is safe to give him the power to do it. I am sure the Minister would not hand over a doctor's job to an ordinary Guard. If he did, I think Deputy Dr. Hennessy would be talking more than he has been on this Bill.

Comment on this

I do not think it requires any particular competency to detect, in connection with a public service vehicle, the things which are an immediate and obvious danger to the public. I think that Guards noticing these things ought to have the power to put a bus out of commission until steps are taken to have the defects remedied.

Comment on this

Defective brakes would be the most serious defect. Does the Minister still hold that a Guard, who has never learned to drive a car and has no experience of it, would be competent to judge whether the brakes were in order or not?

Comment on this

If in his opinion it was dangerous to allow the vehicle to continue in the condition in which the brakes were, then I think he should have power to prevent that vehicle continuing.

Comment on this

Of course the Guard, in order to be on the right side, would, in all such cases where he had any reason to suspect it at all, order it away for further inspection. Are you not inviting the Guard, who has no confidence in himself with regard to repairs to a motor car, to send the car either at the request of a passenger or on his own initiative, for further inspection?

Comment on this

You are.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister that it is necessary that a Gárda should have power in case he suspects that anything is wrong with a car to hold it up and order the people off, if he believed that it was unsafe for the people, and prohibit the driver from going any further, but there should be something in the section to say that the Gárda should suspect something to be wrong, that he should have some reason for believing the car was unsafe. It might not be that the car was unsafe, but that he suspected the driver to be drunk, because he was driving in a negligent or unsafe way.

Comment on this

I think the Minister will admit that under the existing regulations the Gárda have a certain amount of power. Has that power been exercised in all cases to the safety of the travelling public? I quoted a few cases here last week in which I pointed out that buses were plying for hire here in the Saorstát that had been condemned in Northern Ireland. As Deputy Davin pointed out, under the British Road Traffic Act it is necessary for vehicle Inspectors to be appointed who are competent and skilled men. No such regulation at present applies to the Saorstát, with the result that there are buses plying for hire here which are a danger to the travelling public.

I think the Minister should agree to some modification of the section, so that skilled men should act in lieu of Guards. I think it will be admitted that a Guard who has no mechanical or other knowledge of a car is not in the position to say whether a vehicle is safe or unsafe. If it were an ordinary driver of a car he would be in a much better position, as he would have the same knowledge as the driver. I think the Minister should take into consideration what is embodied in the British Road Traffic Act, and see that competent men should act as Inspectors and decide whether a public vehicle is properly constructed, and is kept in a proper mechanical state of repair.

Comment on this

Does not the Minister admit that a competent bus driver is himself, because of his qualifications and experience, more competent to indicate the nature of the repairs to be carried out than an ordinary Gárda?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

They often take risks.

Comment on this

There is only one addition I think that might be made to the section and that is that any member of the Gárda on examination of the vehicle may for any reason that is reasonable require it to proceed either to some particular place or continue its journey at the speed he shall indicate.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Will the Minister not say any member of the Gárda who has reason to believe that the car is unsafe?

Comment on this

That certainly is implied. I shall have the section examined with a view to seeing if it is necessary to emphasise that.

Comment on this

On that would the Minister consider the question of amending the maximum fee for these licences or would he give some indication of what the fee is likely to be?

Comment on this

I shall consider that.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is on the question of licences generally.

Comment on this

I move amendment 74:

In sub-section (1), line 54, and in sub-section (2), line 58, to delete the word "fourteen" where it occurs in each line and substitute therefor the word "eight."

This amendment is designed to make it compulsory that all buses plying for hire shall carry a conductor. Under the terms of the section it is not necessary for a bus to have a conductor if it has capacity for not more than 14 passengers. I think that every argument that could be advanced for a bus having seating capacity for more than 14 passengers to have a conductor could be advanced to a greater extent in connection with buses having seating capacity for 14 or under. In many cases it will be found that buses having seats for only 14 passengers carry 18 or 20, and sometimes a 12-seater bus carries 15 passengers. Under the terms of this section a 16-seater bus would be required to carry a conductor, but if the owner of a 16-seater bus wanted to come within the terms of this section he could quite easily remove a double seat and make it a 14-seater bus, so that he would not be required to carry a conductor. There is one important point to which I would like to draw the Minister's attention in connection with the safety of the travelling public. The Minister is aware that so far as the 14-seater bus is concerned, the person in charge must not only be his own driver but he must also collect the fares. He has also to open the folding doors. It is well known that when passengers are travelling in a 14-seater bus, and when they rise from their seats to get out they do so before the bus becomes stationary, and the driver holds out his hand to get the money while the bus is still in motion. I submit that this is a positive danger to the travelling public. As I said, every argument that could be put forward requiring a bus having seating capacity for more than 14 to have a conductor could be put forward to a greater extent in the case of a 14-seater bus. There are hundreds of 14-seater buses that have no conductors. The drivers of these buses have to work from an early hour in the morning until late at night. Some of them have to work 14 hours a day. I put it to any person in this House competent to drive a motor car to say what is the physical condition of a driver who is driving for 14 hours, and who, in addition, has to collect the fares and who has to open and close the folding doors for passengers. I submit that in the interests of the travelling public the Minister should accept this amendment. In addition to ensuring the safety of the travelling public, the acceptance of this amendment is going to mean the absorption of quite a large number of unemployed drivers. There are a great many such drivers in the country, and I think the Minister should agree to accept this amendment in their interests as well as in any other.

[An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.]

Comment on this

The amendment is not acceptable. In the first place, if a 16 seater bus should take away two seats that is not going to have the effect mentioned by the Deputy, because under Section 16 we have power to make regulations for calculating the seating capacity of any vehicle. As a matter of fact, that is going to be changed in order to make it the calculation of the passenger accommodation. So that it need not necessarily depend upon the seats whether a bus is regarded as a 14-seater or not.

Comment on this

Sub-section (2) refers to the seating accommodation.

Comment on this

Section 16 is framed in terms of seating accommodation, but we want to make that passenger accommodation, and there will be a consequential amendment, so that the 14 seats mentioned here will be 14-seater accommodation as measured under the regulations that will be prepared. I do not know any bus carrying eight passengers. But in certain places a 14-seater will be the economic bus. If you insist that a 14-seater bus must carry a conductor as well as a driver you will put such buses off the road. You tend, at any rate, to increase fares. In the case of a 14-seater or a 12-seater bus you have a particular number of passengers whom the driver can serve both as driver and conductor. We consider that the 14-seater bus is of that particular type. Under section 109 regulations will be made governing the number of extra passengers that, in special circumstances, such as rush hours, a bus may carry. I will bear in mind when framing these regulations that the one-man bus cannot be expected to deal as satisfactorily with a rush hour as the bus in which you have a conductor. Precautions may be taken in that direction that may save the particular type of abuse in respect of the one-man bus that the Deputy refers to, but I think it would be wrong to require a 14-seater bus to have a conductor as well as a driver.

Comment on this

The Minister has endeavoured to point out that it would be a hardship on the owner of a 14-seater bus to have a driver and conductor. I may mention that in Dublin the Tramways Co., which have larger buses, have both drivers and conductors. In addition to that the Tramways Co., whose buses are running on the permanent way have to pay a certain amount for the upkeep of that permanent way over and above road taxation or insurance. Consequently it will not be such a hardship on the owners of 14-seater buses to have to employ a conductor. I submit that it is advisable to have both driver and conductor, first, for the sake of the travelling public, and in the second place, in order to absorb some of the unemployed drivers and conductors. The Minister has not given any definite reason why a 14-seater bus should be exempt from the regulations which he wants the owners of buses of larger seating capacity to adopt.

Comment on this

If Deputy Cassidy's amendment were carried into effect instead of benefiting unemployed drivers and conductors he might be increasing unemployment generally amongst them because it would ultimately put off the road a number of small buses that are now barely paying their way.

Comment on this

I support this amendment for the purpose of putting these small owner-driver buses out of business quicker than they will put themselves out. These people buy the buses on the hire-purchase system and they go out of business when the buses themselves go out of existence. The average individuals who own these small buses go into the business with out any realisation of the fact that they will have to go out of it within a very short time. Experience during the last four or five years has shown quite clearly, and I am sure the returns that ought to be available will prove that, that these people come into the business under certain conditions and they go out with the life of the bus. I think we should encourage those other people who can put buses on the roads that will properly accommodate the traffic that is waiting for them. There is ample traffic available if only proper provision is made for the carrying of passengers. I am referring now to the transport business in so far as it applies to the roads. Perhaps some Deputies have been sufficiently interested to observe the conditions which apply in the case of Dublin with regard to the requirements of passengers who want to be carried to and from certain parts of the city and suburbs.

Comment on this

This applies outside Dublin.

Comment on this

I disagree with the Deputy that it applies to any great extent outside because I believe that in the case of Dublin, Cork, Limerick and Waterford, where buses run any distance away from those cities, they generally are of a thirty-two or thirty-six-seater type.

Comment on this

There are others.

Comment on this

Very few, and the few that are there are only waiting for their own funeral.

Comment on this

The Deputy wants to finish them off quickly.

Comment on this

The 8-seater bus, which is driven by its owner, has a very short life in the transport of this country.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. Hogan (Clare) Labour Party

A short and a merry one.

Comment on this

Probably a merry one. If he is fond of anything in the nature of amusement he will find out when the life of the bus ends that he has not enough to pay the last instalment to the person from whom he bought it, either first-hand or second-hand.

Comment on this

Or even enough to meet the wages of the conductor.

Comment on this

Very often the wages of a conductor might mean the profits of the driver. Deputy Lemass need not be unduly worried about the number of people who will be adversely affected if these small buses go out of existence. There is ample trade for the people who make proper provision for carrying passengers to and from different parts of the country. In the interests of the transport industry, and in the interests of the people who think there is a lot of money to be made out of 14-seater buses or other small buses of that type, the stricter the regulations that will be applied to them the better in the end. Deputy Lemass will not have to attend the funerals of many of these people if he supports Deputy Cassidy's amendment.

Comment on this

They will be all gone.

Comment on this

Deputies who have been studying the British Act will realise that this is not a section that we have taken out of that Act. That Act refers to buses accommodating twenty passengers, and in certain circumstances twenty-six.

Comment on this

The Minister stated that under existing regulations the authorities have power to compel the driver to be isolated from the passengers. In many cases, if not in all, that is necessary for the safety of the travelling public. If those regulations are enforced, and if the driver of the 14-seater bus is isolated, how will it be possible for that bus to operate, having only a driver and no conductor?

Comment on this

In objecting in its full sense to the amendment of Deputy O'Connell I pointed out that it is undesirable in a case like that, that the driver would be completely isolated.

Comment on this

The Minister will probably learn more about the matter between this and the next Stage if he calls for certain returns from the Department of the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. Hogan (Clare) Labour Party

Or if he goes for a drive in a bus.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 75:—

To add at the end of sub-section (1) a new paragraph as follows:—

"(k) approving the places in such area which may be purchased by approved omnibus companies for the purpose of erecting terminal stations for approved long distance routes."

The section sets out a number of purposes for which the Commissioner may make by-laws. My amendment proposes to make an addition to that. The proposal is not in any sense man datory. It only gives the Commissioner power to make recommendations, and the underlying feature in connection with it is that it is considered by many that there should be terminal stations, somewhat similar to railway stations, for buses running long distances, where there can be waiting-rooms and other conveniences for the public. At present we have nothing at all of that kind. These long distance buses park in the streets. A large number of people are waiting for them to start. The people have to wait in the streets, and in many cases there is inconvenience caused. This merely gives the Commissioner power, with the consent of the Minister, to approve of suitable sites for such stations for long distance buses.

Comment on this

The Deputy seeks to make provision in this amendment for a thing that, as far as the Bill is concerned, we do not contemplate taking any power for. This Bill deals with traffic on the roads, and sub-section (1) (a) gives power to the Commissioner to make by-laws appointing the places which may be used as a stand and starting-place for large public service vehicles. It has not been argued that the proper regulation of the traffic demands the putting off the streets of all vehicles using the streets as starting-places. This amendment suggests that the Commissioner ought not to allow buses to use the streets as terminals in their journeys: and it speaks of approved omnibus companies. We have been particularly careful in this Bill that the Minister and the Commissioner will not be placed in the position of discriminating between one bus company and another at all. Any discrimination of that kind would eat in on the Industry and Commerce side of the transport problem. We have to deal with traffic alone in this Bill; and if there are any problems involving discrimination between different omnibus companies they must arise in connection with the framing of a Transport Bill. I do not know that the Transport Bill would contemplate stating that omnibus companies approved under the Bill should have proper private terminal stations. I do not know whether that would not be imposing a great burden upon some of these omnibus companies. But as far as my responsibility goes, and as far as the responsibility of the Commissioner goes, I do not know how he can deal with approved omnibus companies in any way under this Bill; and I have not heard it argued at all that the Commissioner should be given any power to order the buses that are at present using the public roads as their terminal stations off the roads, and order them to find terminal stations of their own. I think that would be a far-reaching power to give the Commissioner.

Comment on this

I sympathise with the suggestion contained in this amendment put forward by Deputy Good. I am rather surprised to hear from the Minister for Local Government and Public Health that the Minister for Industry and Commerce has anything to do with the regulation of the road traffic beyond the powers conferred upon him by the Railway and Road Motor Services Act of 1927.

Comment on this

I am talking of the new Bill.

Comment on this

I cannot talk about the new Bill because I do not know what is to be in it; but I know from the remarks that the Minister for Local Government and Public Health allowed to drop that he does not know very much about it either.

Comment on this

It is coming.

Comment on this

Yes; it is well overdue, at any rate. This Bill, apart from the very limited power of the Minister for Industry and Commerce, deals with the regulation and licensing of the road traffic services, and fixes very definitely under its sections, and the regulations that may be made under it, the conditions under which licences shall be given, and the conditions under which these companies shall operate on the roads. If companies are to be allowed to operate on the roads under an Act passed by this House, for which the Minister for Local Government and Public Health is responsible, I think it is not wrong that the Minister should be asked to take power or be given power to say that these people will provide proper stopping places and terminal stations for those who will have to wait for a long time, so that they may not have to wait under the very unfair conditions which prevail at present, and that he will be given power to secure that provision will be made for waiting rooms, and for the conveniences required by the travelling public. Deputy Corish suggests that that would kill the railways. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has been given by this House power which has, I think, nearly killed the railways. These powers, put into operation by the Minister who is responsible for them——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy stick to the amendment?

Comment on this

If the Minister for Local Government and Public Health is going to be given very drastic powers to make regulations which will fix the conditions under which licences shall be given, and under which public service companies will be allowed to operate, I think we should be very clear as to these conditions. I sympathise with the suggestion contained in the amendment. It is not the first time that that suggestion has been placed before some of the Minister's colleagues.

Comment on this

When I was putting down this amendment I was in some doubt as to whether it really came within the jurisdiction of this Bill, but when I came to consider the matter under this Bill I observed that the Commissioner of Police decided starting and stopping places; and really if the Minister thinks that this question of starting and stopping places would more properly come under a Transport Bill, it seems to me that there is a certain amount of overlapping. I think the question of stopping and starting places comes within the jurisdiction of this Bill; and if that is so, the starting stations and the waiting rooms and the other conveniences of such a station should certainly be settled by one and the same person, that is the person who settles the starting and the stopping places. I think that is clear. And as I pointed out to the Minister, there is nothing mandatory in this. If he thinks that it is not desirable to authorise these companies to erect such conveniences and shelters for the public, so that they might wait in some comfort for the departure of the buses, well, then, my amendment is not mandatory and need not be put into effect. But it seems to me that a certain amount of development of that kind is desirable in conjunction with the development of the bus traffic; and as I visualise the ambit of these two Bills, it appears to me that the regulation of such a development comes within the Road Traffic Bill rather than within the Transport Bill.

Comment on this

I move amendment 76:

Before sub-section (4) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

Before making a by-law under this section the Commissioner shall give notice to the appropriate local authority and the representatives of the traffic operators and of the employees of the operators of his intention to make such by-laws and shall have regard to any representations made by such local authority or persons before making such by-law.

Under the section the Commissioner is given certain powers, some of which up to this were in the hands of local authorities. For instance, obstructions in the streets of urban areas were attended to by the local authorities, and in view of that I think the Minister should accept the amendment. If the Minister wants the Bill to be carried out the co-operation of the local people will be required. I do not see anything unreasonable in the amendment necessitating that the Commissioner of the Gárda should consult the local authorities. I believe that it will be found more satisfactory if that is done.

Comment on this

The Deputy will remember that on another stage he spoke about the cost of inquiries. The position is that under Section 8 whenever I have to approve of by-laws, as in this particular instance, the proposal to do so may require to be published and an enquiry may be held. I stated then that I would go into the matter and see that the cost of enquiries was reduced to the cheapest possible rate. It seems to me that putting in this amendment might easily involve more expense and more confusion than by having the matter dealt with under Section 8 and going through the usual process of publication and enquiry if necessary.

Comment on this

Does not the Minister think that this comes into conflict with some section of the Public Health Act under which the local authorities have power to remove cars or motor buses from the streets at certain times when they are an obstruction? What I want to secure is that any powers local authorities have will be retained. I think it is not unreasonable that local authorities should be consulted by the Gárda before a station of this kind is established. After all the local authorities have certain responsibilities in the matter.

Comment on this

In practice it would not happen that they would not be consulted. In so far as the by-laws will refer to any specified area it will arise out of the conditions there and out of the consideration given the matter by the Gárda in conjunction with the local authorities or whomsoever else may be involved. Naturally the most efficient way of having them brought together would be for the local people to be consulted by the local Guards before the material for the by-laws was submitted to the Commissioner, so that the sending of them down for any enquiry under Section 8 will be purely formal, as the ground would have been completely sounded beforehand and the by-laws would have grown out of local experience and consultation.

Comment on this

Do I understand that that will be done?

Comment on this

Hitherto when the Guards considered that certain places should be parking places they had to consult the local authorities. They worked amicably.

Comment on this

That is the normal process.

Comment on this

On the section, I would like if the Minister would tell the House what is the exact purpose behind clauses (h) and (i). The purpose of paragraph (j) is clear, but I do not understand why it is desired to prohibit public service vehicles standing or stopping at specified places in a particular area either generally or during particular hours. Will the Minister tell the House what is the purpose in giving power to the Commissioner to make by-laws in relation to that?

Comment on this

I can only contemplate that traffic in, say, densely populated urban areas may be of such a kind that vehicles would not be allowed to stop there during certain hours. To some extent I take it that that might apply to Grafton Street and places like that at the present moment.

Comment on this

Buses do not go down Grafton Street.

Comment on this

I emphasise it as the kind of area in which different traffic regulations apply at certain hours.

Comment on this

If it is intended in (j) to fix definite places at which buses will stop to discharge passengers and to prevent them picking up or discharging passengers, is it intended to insist on that regulation with regard to tram cars?

Comment on this

As far as I know it is done by tram cars at the moment. They have regular stopping places. I admit that some of them are at the wrong places.

Comment on this

They may stop any place.

Comment on this

They pay way-leave.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

I move amendment 77:—

Before Section 107 to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) Subject to the provisions of this section the Minister may grant to any person applying therefor a licence (in this Act referred to as a "road service licence") to provide such a road service as may be specified therein and a vehicle shall not be used as an omnibus except under such a licence.

(2) For the purposes of this section a vehicle used as an omnibus shall not be deemed to be so used under a road service licence unless it is so used by the holder of the licence and in accordance with the provisions thereof.

(3) The Minister shall not grant a road service licence in respect of any route if it appears to him from the particulars furnished in pursuance of sub-section (5) of this section that the provisions of Part IV of this Act relating to the speed of mechanically propelled vehicles are likely to be contravened, and in exercising his discretion to grant or to refuse a road service licence in respect to any routes and his discretion to attach conditions to any such licence shall have regard to the following matters:—

(a) the suitability of the routes on which a service may be provided under the licence;

(b) the extent, if any, to which the needs of the proposed routes or any of them are adequately served;

(c) the extent to which the proposed service is necessary or desirable in the public interest.

(4) Subject to the provisions of this section the Minister may attach to a road service licence such conditions as he may think fit with respect to the matters to which they are required to have regard under the preceding sub-section and in particular for securing that:—

(a) the fares shall not be unreasonable;

(b) where desirable in the public interest the fares shall be so fixed as to prevent wasteful competition with alternative forms of transport, if any, along the route or any part thereof or in proximity thereto;

and generally for securing the safety and convenience of the public; and the Minister may from time to time vary in such manner as he thinks fit the conditions attaching to a road service licence.

(5) Every person applying for a road service licence shall submit to the Minister:—

(a) particulars of the type or types of vehicle to be used; and

(b) in the case of regular services the time-tables and fare-tables of the services which it is proposed to provide under the licence; and

(c) in any other case such particulars as to the frequency of the services and the times to be taken on the journeys included in those services as the Minister may require.

(6) If where an application has been made for a road service licence it is represented to the Minister by any person interested in or affected by the application that it is necessary or desirable in the public interest that the Minister should fix the minimum and maximum fares which the applicant proposes to provide under the licence, the Minister may fix such fares and make it a condition of the licence that fares shall not be charged under or in excess of the minimum or maximum.

This amendment is, more or less, an extension of the section which has been passed. It indicates in a more definite way the conditions which we think should be laid down by the Minister for the control and regulation of traffic. The purpose is that if a public service is initiated it should have regard to the public needs, so as to prevent the kind of thing we see, especially in the suburbs of the city, where small bus owners come along and ply only at times which suit themselves, taking as it were the cream of the traffic, and having no regard for the public convenience. I understand that one of the biggest bus companies in the country is subject to regulations laid down in the Railway and Road Motor Services Act, and that the tramway buses are similarly controlled. We should like to see some regulation which would govern private bus companies and private owners, so that they would have some regard for the convenience of the public. That is the object I had in putting down this amendment, and I would, like to hear what the Minister has to say about it.

Comment on this

This amendment is hardly in order on this particular Bill. It deals with matters which would, in our opinion, properly arise on the Transport Bill, which we expect. It would be undesirable for us to proceed to frame regulations such as are suggested in this section until we have seen the Transport Bill and know what the transport plan is.

Comment on this

Can the Deputy say, in anticipation of the introduction of the Bill, that the Minister for Industry and Commerce is seeking power to control public road services in this way?

Comment on this

If we are going to have the question of transport control under consideration in the near future, as we have been told, then the suggestion of Deputy O'Connell, as contained in this amendment, would be better held over.

Comment on this

It is transport control, not traffic regulation.

Comment on this

Are we going to have such a thing as a Transport Bill?

Comment on this

You have been told so.

Comment on this

By whom?

Comment on this

I told you. You must not have been listening.

Comment on this

In this House?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

The Minister attaches certain conditions under section 107 to bus owners with regard to approved routes and that sort of thing. This is only an extension of the other section.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy ask the House to believe that it is appropriate in a Traffic Bill to put in such a clause as this: "The Minister may attach to a road service licence such conditions as ... (a) the fares shall not be unreasonable"? Is that traffic?

Comment on this

I do not want to create any jealousy between the Minister for Local Government and the Minister for Industry and Commerce on the transport question. I am glad if the day is coming when, instead of having three Ministers partly responsible for but in reality nobody really in control of transport, we are going to have one Minister really responsible for transport and the conditions under which it will be carried on.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin.

Comment on this

I am prepared to wait for the Bill to be introduced by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, but I would like to get intimation from the Minister that the principle of the amendment moved by Deputy O'Connell will be given effect to in that long-promised Bill. The real intention of the amendment moved by Deputy O'Connell was to put pirate buses under proper public control. We have certain bus services tied down very strictly by regulations which this House gave power to the Minister for Industry and Commerce to enforce. There are other bus services not subject to the same control. Every Deputy interested in securing proper transport services—whether by road, rail, or canal—will admit that the same conditions should apply to those who apply for licences in any class of transport. Why should we allow, by refusing to bring in proper legislation, pirate buses to come along and pay their employees, who work 16 hours a day, 10s. a week, and undercut the fares of bus services which employ men on a fair and reasonable basis? That is what Deputy O'Connell wants to get at. The sooner the Minister for Industry and Commerce brings in a Bill and gets it through this House the better it will be for those who want proper transport services and those who want to get fair, reasonable, and proper employment on road or rail services. He should stop making promises, and let us have the measure and let us have one Minister in control instead of three.

Comment on this

As I said by way of interjection, this is a matter for a Transport Bill. I do not want it to be taken from that that in any Transport Bill I bring in I will reduce the number of Ministers who are looking after transport and traffic and kindred things. I do not want it to be taken that the clauses in this amendment are going to be included in any Transport Bill which I may introduce.

Comment on this

What about your International Labour Convention?

Comment on this

Where is that referred to in this amendment?

Comment on this

You can read it into it.

Comment on this

I want to know the exact significance of the words "as far as practicable."

Comment on this

As far as practicable.

Comment on this

They must have been put there for some reason. Is it anticipated that there are any words for which Irish equivalents do not exist, or why is the section qualified in that way?

Question agreed to.

SECTION 109.

Comment on this

This section gives the Minister authority to allow the carrying of additional passengers during specified hours or on specified occasions. I take it that that will include the occasion of football matches or other occasions upon which large crowds will have congregated and the normal traffic facilities will not be sufficient. In that connection, considerable complaint has been voiced by representatives of the bus owners that the regulations concerning the maximum number of passengers are very difficult to enforce, and that frequently they are subjected to substantial fines for allowing a number of passengers on their vehicles in excess of the maximum permitted when it is practically impossible for them to keep them off. The regulations are not apparently enforced in some instances with any degree of common sense. That applies, particularly, to the number of passengers permitted on buses on Sunday evenings returning from seaside resorts such as Howth. It is the practice of people going to these resorts to defer their return to the last minute.

There are only a limited number of buses available and they all try to mount the few buses there are. Bus owners have been fined for permitting them to do so. They themselves are prepared to take any risk rather than be under the obligation of walking home or staying for the night. I do not think there is a single case of an accident happening to a bus because of the additional number of passengers permitted to board it. Some easing of the regulations might be permitted wherever special circumstances exist or, generally speaking, all round. In England and Northern Ireland the regulations in that respect are not nearly so strictly enforced as they are here. An accident due to this cause has not, I think, yet happened in this country.

I think the bus owners have a legitimate grievance because either they have got, by force in some cases, to expel the additional passengers from the vehicles or leave themselves liable to a substantial fine.

Comment on this