Road Traffic Bill, 1931—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 449–674 of 674. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 38 of 1931 ›
Every consideration that is involved in the rush hour or in the heavy rain question will have to be taken into account. There are two points that will have to be considered. The maximum weight that a vehicle may carry without injuring its structure in the first place will have to be considered. In the rush hour regulations we will have to see whether we can regulate the speed of vehicles carrying more than their normal number of passengers.
Comment on this
I move amendment 78.
"To delete the word ‘large' where it occurs in lines 46, 52 and 55."
I know that it would be more appropriate for Deputy Davin to refer to Geneva in connection with this amendment. This amendment is proposed in order to keep in line with the International Labour Convention, which prescribes a weekly rest. I cannot see why drivers of taxis employed by a company or by private owners should be exempt, as they seem to be specially exempted by putting in the word "large," and applying this weekly rest only to drivers of public service vehicles. I cannot understand why a taxi driver or two or three taxi drivers employed by a man who may have taxis on the streets, should not come under the regulations. I am therefore moving this amendment to delete the word "large."
Comment on this
Would it be possible to have Amendment 91, which stands in the name of Deputy Davin, discussed on this section? Deputy Davin's amendment applies to this section more than to the other one.
Comment on this
This is a very different thing. It is perfectly obvious that the conditions of work of a driver or conductor of a large public service vehicle are very different from the conditions of service of a taxi driver or the driver of a private hiring vehicle. It is because of the long and continuous strain on the bus driver and the regular continuous hours that we have applied these provisions, but the conditions under which the taxi driver or the driver of a private vehicle works are entirely different, and the regulations would not be warranted in our opinion in these cases. The difficulty is that it is too much rest these people will have.
Comment on this
I move amendment 79:
Before Section 111 to insert a new section as follows:—
The wages paid to any person employed in connection with the operation of the public service vehicle and the conditions of his employment shall not be less favourable to such person than the wages which would be payable and the conditions which would have to be observed under a contract made by a Department of State which contained a clause providing that "the contractor shall pay rates of wages and observe hours of labour not less favourable than those commonly recognised by employers and trade societies (or in the absence of such recognised hours and wages those which in practice prevail among good employers) in the trade in the district where the work is carried out.
This amendment, which we regard as a very important one, is put forward for the purpose of endeavouring to get the Minister to make it a condition for the getting of a licence that public service conditions, generally, should be imposed upon the people who look for or mean to secure a licence. The amendment embodies in reality the operative part of the fair wages clause, which is supposed to be inserted in Government contracts. I have been supplied with a long list of the conditions of service of the various bus companies in the Free State, including some of the principal ones as well as some of the very small ones. I have been given the conditions which apply in the case of the Great Northern Company Omnibus Service, the Irish Omnibus Service, the General Omnibus Service, and also a large number of cases showing the conditions which operate in what are properly called the pirate bus companies, because they are taking from those bus companies, who can afford reasonable conditions for their employees, the fares which they should not be allowed to take. I have a case here of one small bus company operating on the Dublin-Dalkey line where a young man is supposed to be engaged for 16 hours a day at 10s. a week.
Deputy Lemass and other high-wall tariff supporters protest against certain goods being allowed to come into this country from countries where these articles are manufactured under slave conditions. What I am really trying to secure, through the medium of the amendment, is that small or large bus companies or the owners of small or large buses, will not be allowed to secure licences through the agency of this Bill unless they undertake to give fair and reasonable conditions to those who secure employment in their service. The same issue is involved in this case as is involved in the case of this Government or this House allowing articles to come in from Russia or other countries where it is known that the articles are manufactured under unfair conditions. That is the case that has been put to the House by Deputy Lemass on many occasions, and we are in agreement with him on that question. I hope Deputy Lemass will look at the amendment from that point of view. I know the Minister will endeavour to look at it from that point of view.
Comment on this
I am going to suggest to an Leas-Cheann Comhairle that it is, but I did not want to spoil the Deputy's speech.
Comment on this
I was certainly convinced that it was in order myself, and I am pretty well satisfied that I would not be allowed to go so far if you, Sir, had not held the same view. The issue is clear to any person who reads the amendment. The amendment is down in plain English. It is an issue which the Minister and the House will have to answer in the division lobby if the Minister refuses to accept the amendment as a fair condition for the granting of a licence under the terms of the Bill.
Comment on this
I would like to support Deputy Davin's amendment. I think it is common knowledge that the wages paid to their employees by some of the bus companies operating in this country are scandalously low and the insertion of a clause of this kind would have, I think, a very beneficial effect. Some such clause was inserted in the British Act and there seems no reason why we should not follow their example in that connection. If we are going to provide facilities for the operation of omnibus services we should at least see that the conditions of employment are such as not to be, as they are in some cases, a scandal to the country. We know that it is only the bad economic conditions that prevail that make it possible for the proprietors of the buses in question to get people to work at such wages and under such conditions.
Comment on this
I would like to support this amendment. I have practical proof of nearly everything Deputy Davin has stated, corroborated by Deputy Lemass. In Cork City very bad working conditions exist on the services. The tramway service as you are aware was replaced by a bus system. The wages and the hours and conditions are abominable. I would appeal to the Minister, if he cannot see his way to adopt the whole of the amendment, at least to adopt the idea underlying it. I think it is admitted by most Deputies that people in charge of such vehicles as buses and other mechanically propelled cars should enjoy good working conditions. When I say good working conditions I mean that they should not be compelled to work abnormally long hours. The system that had obtained for a considerable period in Cork was that these men were compelled to work seven days, roughly between 60 and 80 hours a week. To my mind these conditions were a menace to pedestrians and other vehicular traffic. It cannot be argued that a man working for twelve or fourteen hours a day is fit to look after the valuable lives that he may be transporting over a long distance of country. When I say proper conditions, I mean ordinary working hours prevalent in that particular area and a six-day week. That is a kind of guarantee that the lives of those people who are travelling in these vehicles will at least get some measure of protection.
Comment on this
We are told that one of the reasons why this amendment should be accepted is because it is in corresponding legislation passed in England. First of all, the legislation that was passed in England was passed by what was described as a Socialist Government, and secondly, in so far as the other matter is concerned, it was not a traffic measure only. It was traffic and transport, providing for regulation by the normal licensing of certain people. We make a distinction here. This is traffic. Transport is to come. If this amendment is to be discussed here, I want to raise an objection to it in advance of its making its appearance on a Transport Bill. There is no precedent that can be quoted to me for regulating wages by statute in this way. It may be answered that it is done under the Trade Board Acts. It is done when certain specified conditions have been fulfilled, or rather when certain conditions are recognised as not being fulfilled.
Comment on this
It must be within the Minister's knowledge that certain agreements exist between the British Board of Trade and certain bodies of workpeople, notably the railway men.
Comment on this
These fair conditions of employment include wages and hours. They have to do with Government contracts. This is nothing of the sort. This is a free and independent agency that we are going to operate.
Comment on this
They are free to this extent, that whatever restrictions are applied they are applied to everybody, but it is not a Government controlled agency. It is not Government work. There is only one example that can be quoted as a precedent, the Trade Board Acts, which regulate wages compulsorily by legislation. For that there must be present two conditions, (a) that there are notoriously sweated conditions operating in a particular industry, and (b) that there is no trade union organisation strong enough to protect the workers. It is only when these two conditions are present that a trade can be specified under the Trade Board Acts, and the conditions which are to be applied to a sweated industry come into force.
There is no example comparable to what is being done here. The amendment provides: "The wages paid to any person employed in connection with the operation of the public service vehicle and the conditions of his employment shall not be less favourable to such person than the wages which would be payable and the conditions which would have to be observed under a contract made by a department of State"—that clearly indicates that what is being brought in here is the machinery that regulates Government contracts—"which contains a clause providing that ‘the contractor shall pay rates of wages and observe hours of labour not less favourable than those commonly recognised by employers in trade societies (or in the absence of such recognised hours and wages those which in practice prevail among good employers) in the trade in the district where the work is carried out.'"
The amendment states "in the trade," but Deputy Davin, by implication in his speech, confines it to the small bus companies: that the small bus companies must do what the big bus companies should do. I do not think that it is a fair test to apply. I do not think it is fair to try and equalise the conditions. What is the definition of trade in this amendment? Is it transport that is to be the thing? Is it an equalisation say, as between bus wages and bus hours and railway wages and railway hours? Might I advert to the distinction that has to be made in the conditions here as opposed to the conditions in England? People can say in England that there will be a number of transport agencies in any area, in any district in which work is carried out. What is the situation here? Leaving Dublin out of consideration for the moment, in most of the areas in this country there would be at the most two or three transport agencies of any substance where people could be called the folk from whom a standard is to be taken. This amendment means that you are going to stereotype in a particular area the conditions which are the best that have been achieved by the ordinary play as between employers and employees. I suggest that that is not fair in the conditions in this country. It is going to be much more unfair in the conditions that are likely to exist hereafter. To my mind, what the amendment does, whether it is intended or not, is to bring about this condition, that you are going to stereotype railway wages and railway hours on road services.
Comment on this
On an analysis of the amendment I think it is within it. Even if it is not, and even if it only goes to carry out the limited idea that the Deputy gave expression to, it will have the effect of stereotyping the wages, hours and conditions of the big bus owned companies upon the smaller companies. That is unfair. Further, it is without precedent by legislation to establish these things, excepting only where two conditions are present: (1) that there are notoriously sweated conditions in the business, and (2) that there is no organisation of employees able to stand up to the conditions.
Comment on this
The Minister, in arguing against the acceptance of this amendment, brings in the question of trade boards. As far as they are concerned, he said that before a trade could come under the Trade Boards Acts there must first of all exist bad conditions in that trade. On that I would like to say to the Minister that if he knew anything as to how the 14-seater buses operate on the north side of the city and in the county of Dublin he would be aware of the scandalous conditions that exist, both as to the hours the employees have to work and the wages they get. If the Minister is not prepared to extend to those in the smaller bus companies the conditions that obtain in the case of the larger bus companies, it may be information for him to know that many of the bus drivers in this city are called upon to work fourteen, fifteen and sometimes sixteen hours a day. Some of the drivers of these one-man buses are in receipt of the scandalous rate of pay of 25s. a week. Does the Minister mean to suggest that these are not bad conditions?
The second stipulation that he brings in is that there is to be proof given that there is no trade union existing as far as the employees are concerned. It is true as far as the City of Dublin is concerned that the trade unions have forced the larger bus companies to give at least a living rate of wages, but owing to the fact in many cases that these small buses are only what are known as one-man buses, they pay a scandalous rate of wages. It is impossible from a trade union standpoint to get the men organised.
I would point out to the Minister that while these are independent agencies and he does not want to compel them to come under the conditions of the amendment, at the same time Government interference has taken place and rightly so. I refer to another industry. Under the Shop Hours Act a shopkeeper, through legislation, is compelled to give an employee a half holiday. I do not think that this amendment of Deputy Davin is asking too much. After all the licence is issued through Government authority, and it is most important that these men should observe proper conditions as far as labour is concerned. In the interests of the travelling public it is not fair that these employees should be called upon to work long hours, and the Minister for Industry and Commerce, instead of defeating Deputy Davin's argument has made out a good case for it, and I hope seeing that this Bill is not being looked on as a Party Bill, as far as the House is concerned, that the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Local Government and Public Health will be prepared to leave it to an open vote of the House and then we will see who stands for proper wages and proper conditions and who does not.
Comment on this
I was rather amused by the Minister's attempt to frighten off the Deputies who normally sit on his left by asserting that the provisions in the British Act were passed by a Socialist Government. It was passed in the British House of Commons where the Socialists were not in the majority and it was also passed by the House of Lords, a body which, no matter what may be said about it, cannot be described as an organ of any Bolshevik institution.
Members of the House of Lords thought it advisable to insert in the Road Traffic Act a clause prescribing that certain minimum wages should operate on public road services authorised under that Act. It has got to be quite clear that it is wrong and misleading to compare conditions in this trade with conditions in any other trade. This is a trade which can only exist subject to the licence and the rigid control of the Government. Nobody can operate a road service here unless they are licensed to do it, and unless their drivers have undergone tests of skill in relation to their driving licences, and unless their drivers are licensed and have paid a licence fee and that all the regulations we have discussed are observed. In that trade, which we permit to operate, subject to all these restrictions, it is common knowledge that the wages paid to the workers are scandalously low. Surely it is an obligation on us to take some steps to see that an improvement is effected.
I am not defending the particular form of Deputy Davin's amendment. Neither Deputy Davin nor the Minister is an expert Parliamentary draftsman, but there is a clear idea that we want to have expressed in this Bill, and that is that these appalling conditions which we know exist in relation to some omnibus services should not be permitted. These conditions would not exist at all were it not for the pressure of unemployment which compels people to take any work they can get at any wage they can get. In this particular case, that pressure of unemployment had produced conditions worse than in any other trade because of the fact that it only started recently and started in a hurry. The usual methods by which organised labour can defend itself could not operate there. There is not, as far as I know, a highly organised financially strong trade union for omnibus workers, whether drivers or conductors. In time it may be possible to put pressure on employers to improve conditions, but at present the employers know, and the officials of whatever trade unions that exist know, that there is outside the union a huge number of persons with the necessary skill to operate in this trade, on the verge of starvation who would be prepared to step in and take any position offered if the existing trade unions refused to work under the prevailing conditions.
In these circumstances it appears to some of us that there is a duty especially on those who profess to be so much concerned with obviating the danger of social trouble in this country to see that these conditions are removed by Acts of Parliament, and that those who are permitted by the State to operate services under this Act shall at least treat their workers in accordance with the principles laid down in the Pope's Encyclical.
Comment on this
It is very interesting to hear the Minister for Industry and Commerce lay down as his main argument for opposition to this amendment the fact that it was put through the British House of Commons by a Labour Government. Deputy Lemass has answered that argument very effectively. The Minister says that there is no precedent for an amendment of this kind in any other Act except the British Act. The British Act does not exactly legislate in the way in which the amendment if it is accepted by the House would operate. There is a clause in the British Act which makes provision for the setting up of an industrial court to which disputes arising out of the contents of that clause are to be referred for arbitration and decision. If I am to take the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Local Government as being opposed to this amendment either in the spirit or the letter, I certainly must assume that they are standing for the intolerable conditions which at present apply in the case of the small bus companies of this State. In other words they are standing for sixteen hours a day at 10/- per week. If you are not, what is your alternative to this amendment? The Minister says it is not fair to equalise the conditions between small bus companies and the larger ones. Is it not a fact that the Minister for Industry and Commerce in the Railways Amalgamation Act of 1925 brought in under the Act all the large and small railways then operating in the Saorstát and equalised the conditions so far as conditions applied to them and to those who work for the amalgamated company?
Comment on this
I am pretty certain you did. You also made it obligatory for the amalgamated company to enter into trade union rates for these companies so that there was agreement.
Comment on this
What the Minister did in the Railway Amalgamation Act of 1925 is quite good enough to be carried out and applied to the public services which ply for public hire on the roads of this country. He says that the conditions which led up to the establishment of the Trade Board Acts were notoriously sweated conditions which could not be allowed by any trade union organisation in existence. Does he agree with this intolerable state of affairs that young or old bus conductors should be allowed to be engaged in this country by people who are getting the benefit of this Act and forced to work for 16 hours a day at 10/- per week. Was there anything worse at the time the Trade Boards were established by his Department or his predecessors, the British Government? I happen to be fairly well acquainted with the conditions which apply to men engaged as drivers and conductors on the different companies that ply for hire on the Dublin-Dalkey line. Is it fair to have the Blue Line Bus Company conceding fair and reasonable conditions to its employees and to have the small companies come along and force a sixteen-hour day at 10/- a week on their employees? Who is getting the benefit of that? Sometimes it goes by way of reduced fares due to the conditions I explained and at other times it goes in increased profits to the people who are allowed to get a licence under these conditions. The conditions which have made these intolerable conditions of employment possible must be attributed to the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the Minister for Local Government and to the Ministry as a whole who have allowed citizens of this State to purchase buses and run them on any route they like under any conditions they like. I say it is the duty of this House to make it a condition for the getting of any licences to see that fair and reasonable and human conditions of employment are applied to those who get the benefit of this Bill from this House. If you vote against the letter or spirit of this amendment—I do not say it is the last word in drafting—you are voting for the continuation of these conditions which I do not think apply to any other public service in this country.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin in order to emphasise the point said that my main argument against this amendment was that it was a Socialist measure. It was not my main argument.
Comment on this
I said it was not my main argument. I said it in one sentence and left it there. I say it again.
Comment on this
It was introduced by a Socialist Government and passed by the House, which allowed it to pass not because they liked the Bill, but because as everyone knows through Parliamentary manæuvring there was a particular Party in power who would not vote for the Conservatives if they did not allow it to pass. It passed the House of Lords under the same conditions. I say it again and leave it there.
Comment on this
I have not said it is an answer to it, but there are answers to it. The Deputy again took one part of my answer and tried to make an argument on that. Deputy Cassidy acted in the same way. I do not see what they alluded to in regard to sweated trades. I said there is no precedent of regulating by law, wages, except in Government contracts, and outside that, in cases of trades to which the Trade Board Acts apply. I said that trades to which the Trade Board Acts applied can only have application made when two conditions are present at the same time.
Comment on this
One, with regard to what I said are notoriously sweated conditions either by way of wages or hours, and secondly, when there is no organised body among the employees to fight the case.
Comment on this
I have been up against the Trade Union in relation to bus people. I would not like to have Deputy Davin go before them and to impute that they did not represent the small bus owners or that they had no hope of getting them in and fighting their case.
Comment on this
I say there is not notoriously the state of things that is alleged and that there is not present the other conditions, namely, that there is no one organisation or body to speak on behalf of the employees. The two conditions are absent.
Comment on this
The fact is that the Deputy is either illiterate, in which case he cannot understand it, or incapable to the extent that he will not make his own speech in his own time.
Comment on this
Simply taking the case of some line that may be paying 10/- a week and doing certain other things does not make the case for this amendment. Deputy Davin spoke of those who were going to get what he called the benefits of this Bill. I do not know who is going to be benefited under this Bill. I understand it was a regulating and restricting Bill.
Comment on this
It lays down conditions and leaves it open to anybody who complies with these conditions to run on the roads. There is no question of benefiting. Benefiting means singling out people and giving them something over anybody else. This is laying down conditions that people must comply with. Merely to say that it benefits people does not bring it within the ordinary conditions to which the fair wages clause have been applied. The fair wages clause has its application to work that is done under Government contract. It has been insisted on in the case of Government work because the Government ought, at any rate, to be in the position of the best employers. If we are going to have it applied in the future to any trade or business that is regulated by legislation I want to warn people as to the extent of this. If there is a regulation made with regard to speed or any matter—there are regulations made with regard to building of houses—does that mean that the building trades' wages are going to be fixed hereafter or that every trade on which there is an impact in any piece of legislation is going to be regulated?
Comment on this
The Deputy does not like it. It is not a parallel case at the moment, but it is going to extend to that. The Deputy is content for the moment to single this out. If we were nationalising transport certainly there is a case then for doing it, but I think it is completely inappropriate to this Bill, however pertinent it might be to the other.
Comment on this
Because it is called a public service vehicle you are going to insist on regulating all these men's wages.
Comment on this
I think not. That argument might be used on a later amendment in regard to broken hours, but it certainly cannot be used here. This is not a Bill produced on behalf of people who are not getting sufficient wages. We were told by Deputy Lemass that because certain people could not get employment otherwise they had gone into this business. He wants to regulate the wages. What is going to be the end of it? There will be more unemployment. The Deputy urged here in connection with another amendment that it would lead to the unemployment of drivers and conductors. This is definitely going to have the same effect. Deputy Davin made no pretence of his railway interests predominating.
Comment on this
It is also a railway interest, because for anybody who has a railway point of view this is a glorious amendment. It will certainly result in putting a number of buses off the roads. If that is what is aimed at let it be argued on that basis. It is not going to get men wages where these wages cannot at present be paid. To anybody who quotes an Encyclical to me I say it must be remembered that there is always an overriding thing in it, that the industry can afford it. That is fundamental to anything that is said in any Encyclical.
Comment on this
The Minister made great play with the fact that there is no precedent for this. On both occasions on which he spoke he stressed that there was no precedent for including in a measure of this kind such a thing as this. We can make a precedent. The fact that a thing has never been done is not an argument that a thing which is right in itself should never be done. Therefore, the question of a precedent might very well be ruled out. The Minister has properly described the Bill as one that lays down conditions and says that any one who complies with these conditions can run a service on the roads. That is his own description of this measure. All we are asking is that one of the conditions should be that a fair wage is paid and fair conditions of service observed. That is one of the conditions we think ought to be laid down. Are we to take it that the Minister says in effect that he is not concerned with this particular condition that fair wages should be paid and fair conditions observed? The Minister has control of the service inasmuch as without his permission it cannot operate. It has to fulfil certain conditions which are laid down before it is allowed to operate. All that we ask is that that condition, which we believe, and which everybody should agree, is essential, that fair working conditions should be observed by a company which gets the right and the privilege, if you like, to ply for hire on the road, should be insisted upon. The Minister attempted to draw an analogy between this and buildings because there were regulations about pulling down buildings and things like that. As was pointed out at the time, there is no analogy unless you licence builders and more or less give a monopoly to those who register. If we formed a builders' register we might then lay down the conditions for getting on the register.
Comment on this
The less the State has to do with either of them the better.
Comment on this
I suggest that it is not only reasonable, but that it is proper and right that before giving privileges, and they are privileges, to companies to inaugurate services one of the conditions that should be laid down is that fair wages and conditions of work should operate. Surely there is nothing wrong in that principle.
Surely the Minister is not going to say that he is not concerned in any way with the conditions that apply in a licensed service of this kind; that he is entirely giving it over to free competition and that he is going to allow free competition to rule and nothing else. If that is the principle that he means to apply in this case I would advise him strongly to read the Papal Encyclical again.
Comment on this
I formally move amendment No. 80:
In sub-section (1), line 63, after the word "vehicles" to insert the words "and for prohibiting or regulating the carrying of live animals in or on such vehicles.
Comment on this
It is a matter about which something will probably have to be done, and I shall consider it between this and the next stage.
Comment on this
There was a point raised on Section 106 and it arises on other sections, including this, about consultation with the local authorities when the by-laws are being made. The Minister says that under Section 8 the local authority would be given an opportunity, but there is nothing in Section 8 that lays it down specifically that the local authority would be given any opportunity of intervening or of giving its opinion or that it would be asked for its opinion on any rule or body of rules that might be made by the Commissioner with the consent of the Minister. If there is any authority in the area that ought to know something about the regulations—the appointment of spaces where vehicles might stand for hire and such other matters as are set out in the section—it ought to be the officers of the local authority. They ought to have some say in the matter. I think the Minister ought to give the local authorities a locus standi and every consideration before the by-laws are approved.
Comment on this
I urge that view-point on the Minister. I think the Minister ought to agree to amend the section by the addition of some such words as "after consultation with the local authority." A few words of that kind would make it all right. The local authorities ought to have some jurisdiction inside their own area.
Comment on this
Take Section 7. That section makes it clear that whenever power is conferred on the Minister by this Act "To make, approve of, confirm or consent to any order, regulation or by-law, to consent to any matter," the Minister may, before exercising such power, hold a public inquiry into the matter. My intention would be, where it impinged on the local authority in any way, that, before confirming any by-law with regard to any particular area, an inquiry, such as is contemplated, should be carried out in as inexpensive a way as possible. I will have the general run of sections dealing with the framing of by-laws examined, so as to see whether we could not, without unduly restricting ourselves in the matter, put in a reference to the local authority. We could have the regulations sent on to the local authority so that the local authority may discuss them and send them back with any recommendations they may consider desirable. Then the Minister, after examining these regulations, would have power to confirm the order. That might be one simple way of dealing with the matter and airing the thing locally without the necessity of having an actual inquiry. I will consider whether we could not put down something explicitly without tying ourselves up unnecessarily.
Comment on this
I think that would be quite sufficient. I do not see the necessity at all for a public inquiry. A public inquiry involves the public body in an expense which it is not prepared to incur; and I do not think there would be any difficulty in having friendly conversations or consultations carried out in a friendly way between the Gárda authorities and the local authorities. By acting in that manner the matter would adjust itself. But I do think the Minister will agree that the local authorities ought to be consulted before regulations of that kind are made.
Comment on this
On Section 125 I should like to ask a question—it might perhaps be more properly asked on Section 132—as to whether the Minister can say if the taximeter is a monopoly in this country, whether the patent rights are enjoyed by only one person in the country. It would seem that if it be a monopoly, we are imposing a tax that may be unlimited on taxis plying for hire on the streets.
Comment on this
That particular question is under inquiry by the Minister for Industry and Commerce at present. I could not say whether it is a monopoly.
Comment on this
I move—
Before Section 133, but in Part VIII of the Bill, to insert a new section as follows:—
"For the purposes of this Act a person hiring a street service vehicle shall not be deemed to be the employer of the driver thereof and such person hiring the vehicle shall not become liable to pay any sums by way of damages, costs or otherwise on account of injury to person or property occasioned by the negligent driving of such vehicle."
We discussed the principle underlying this proposed new clause when we were discussing amendment 51 to Section 51; and I do not know whether the Minister will adopt the same conclusion that he came to in that particular case.
Comment on this
Yes. That whole question will be considered and an amendment will be produced on Report.
Comment on this
Between this and Report. The question is whether a person who hires a street service vehicle shall be deemed to be an employer and shall be liable for damages. We do not want to relieve the hirer of a vehicle from the penalties that ordinarily would fall on him if he was conspiring or inciting the driver to commit an offence.
Comment on this
It is the next amendment I was interested in, I beg your pardon.
Comment on this
I want to be clear with regard to Deputy Good's amendment. The Minister has promised that he will meet Deputy Good in some way or another. Will it come before the House in any form?
Comment on this
I am now dealing with amendment 81—"a person hiring a street service vehicle shall not be deemed to be the employer of the vehicle." That is open to two constructions. The first is that an ordinary man hiring a taxi or any other street vehicle shall not be deemed to be the employer of the driver and shall not be liable for damages in case he injures a person. But at the same time it might be an inducement to some persons, for the purpose of carrying merchandise or for other purposes, instead of having a permanent driver of their own car, to hire a taxi off the street and thus escape a good deal of responsibility in case of accident. I should like to be clear on that point. If this amendment were passed it would be quite possible for any individual who up to then might be deemed responsible as being the employer of the driver of a commercial vehicle to escape that responsibility by engaging day by day any vehicle off the street. I see the danger inherent in this amendment.
Comment on this
No one is compelled to have his own motor car nor is any shopkeeper going to be compelled to have his own private vehicle for delivering his goods. He is entitled to employ some contractor or any other person to do his service for him. Certainly, as is the intention in Deputy Good's amendment, to relieve the hirer of a taxi from responsibility for the driver's misdeed, is not the kind of thing that is going to hold out any inducement.
Comment on this
I quite see the point that Deputy Good is aiming at. His amendment sets out "a person hiring a street service vehicle." A whole lot will depend on the definition of a street service vehicle. As far as I can see, it is not defined in the Bill.
Comment on this
A street service vehicle might be deemed to be a vehicle which I, as a merchant or employer, might engage from time to time for the delivery of merchandise. I might have a contract with a person for three hundred days of the year and it is quite possible that I might scrap that contract if I found I could evade my responsibility under this amendment, if it is accepted.
Comment on this
The Deputy will find a definition of street service vehicle as a "small public service vehicle, the driver of which offers in a public place himself and the said vehicle for hire, and for that purpose stands or drives such vehicle in a public place ..." Section 119 contains further definitions with regard to street service vehicles.
Comment on this
The next amendment is the amendment on the Order Paper in the name of Deputy J.X. Murphy.
In sub-section (1), page 56, before paragraph (c) to insert a new paragraph as follows:—
"(c) requiring all traffic, other than traffic running on permanent rails, in the taking up or setting down of passengers to do so only when pulled in to the side of the road."
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy Murphy I beg to move the amendment. I am only sorry that it does not say must instead of may.
Comment on this
I am not accepting the amendment, but I am accepting the principle of it. I will introduce the matter again on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 81 (a) on the amendment paper:—
Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"The Commissioner may with the consent of the Minister, after consultation with the Minister for Agriculture, by regulation, provide for the licensing of drovers of cattle, sheep or swine, in any particular area or areas. Where by-laws have been made under this sub-section for any area it shall not be lawful for any person to bring, or cause to be brought, cattle, sheep or swine on to a road or street in such area, unless in charge of a licensed drover."
It would possibly save the time of the House in discussing this matter if I had an expression of opinion from the Minister as to whether he will accept the principle of the amendment.
Comment on this
The intention of this amendment is to give power to the Commissioner, with the consent of the Minister, to make a new by-law in the terms set out in the amendment. The largest industry in the State is the cattle industry and it has been the surprise of many visitors to our State to notice the small amount of care that is devoted to such an important industry. We here in the State are more or less accustomed to seeing drovers treating cattle—I do not say in all cases, but in many cases —in a way that such an important asset to the State should not be treated. I am sure the attention of all Deputies in the House has been drawn to this fact at different times. The extraordinary thing about it is that no action appears to have been taken.
It is the intention of this amendment to give power to the Commissioner to take action, if he so desires, with the consent of the Minister. It is in no sense mandatory. The need for this particular clause should not require any stressing in this House. All of us have seen drovers from time to time treating animals in a way they should not be treated. These men have been summoned from time to time and I have before me a list of recent cases and the reply in all cases that I happen to have is: "The name and address of the drover proved to be false, so the case had to be abandoned." That is the reply in six recent cases. It seems to be common knowledge amongst the drovers that immediately they get summoned for ill-treating animals, or driving any animal that is lame, or that should not be driven, they give a wrong name and address. I think it will be obvious to everybody who gives any attention to the problem that it is in the interest of the State that practices of this kind in connection with our most important industry, should not be allowed to continue.
Comment on this
I do not think we should debate on a Traffic Bill something that has reference to the ill-treatment of cattle. I thought the purpose of this amendment was quite different. We must deal with this thing from the point of view of traffic rather than from the point of view of the ill-treatment of cattle.
Comment on this
Quite so. Let us take the case of animals being driven through the streets. It has been pointed out by members of the Gárda Síochána, those of them who direct street traffic, that they see these animals being unfairly dealt with by the drovers. They are in the difficult position that owing to these men not being licensed and consequently not having numbers displayed on their arms, it is impossible to get information in regard to them. The members of the Gárda Síochána would have to leave their posts in order to follow those men and get their names and addresses. That would take a considerable amount of time and the police, because of their special duty, have not that time available. If these drovers had numbers on their arms the Gárda would be able to take a note of the numbers while the men were passing. It is absolutely essential, in connection with the protection of these animals, and in the interests of the State, that steps should be taken to prevent the injury that is being done them by drovers.
Comment on this
If that is all that is to be said in its favour, the amendment is absolutely out of order.
Comment on this
Surely the amendment has a very definite bearing on the traffic problem. Not alone does the question of cruelty to animals arise, but there is also the question of the control of animals on the roads.
Comment on this
It may not arise in connection with this Bill, but the question of how animals are to be controlled, while on the roads, so as not to interfere with ordinary traffic, certainly does arise.
Comment on this
I suggest it is very definitely there and, I submit, for that reason the amendment is in order. If Deputy Good cares to press the point I will surrender to him, but if he does not care to press it I would like to do so.
Comment on this
When I read the amendment it seemed to me that that was the bearing it had on the Bill —that as the Bill made provision with regard to the drivers of omnibuses it could make some provision also with regard to the drovers of cattle. But I am not prepared to hear a discussion with regard to the ill-treatment of cattle on a Road Traffic Bill. I heard that subject discussed here before, but I would not be prepared to hear it on this Bill.
Comment on this
Would you be prepared to hear a discussion on a proposal that the Commissioner, with the consent of the Minister for Local Government and Public Health, after consultation with the Minister for Agriculture, may define areas in which farmers and their sons will not be allowed to drive their own cattle on the roads?
Comment on this
We strongly protest against any such discussion. We think this amendment is a futile and unnecessary one, and it is making a laughing-stock of the Bill. It could not possibly be carried into effect. Take the case of a farmer going to a fair. It may happen that he will go to the fair in his trap. He decides to buy a cow and, if the area is a specified area, if it is an area to be subject to licence, he cannot employ a man in that town to drive home the cow for him. The thing would be quite impossible.
Comment on this
Just because there is a little scorn thrown upon this amendment is no reason why it should be let drop. I think it is worthy of serious consideration. It is quite reasonable to say that general regulations ought to be subject to special examples. Of course the farmer ought to be allowed to make special regulations for the transport of his own stock. But the trouble is there, that the traffic on the road, due to this kind of uncontrolled cattle crowding on the road and blocking out and frequently interfering with traffic is very serious. Not alone does that trouble exist, but it is a great wonder that it very often has not caused more serious accidents. It is quite a common thing on country roads to come round a corner and find a herd of sheep blocking the roadway. There is no avenue of the slightest kind and unless the greatest care is taken when turning round a corner an accident is the inevitable result. It is a great wonder to me that such accidents do not occur much more frequently.
What is sought to be secured in the Bill is that the driving of cattle over roads ought to be properly controlled by those who know how to do it. Further than that, a great nuisance arises constantly by cattle passing from the public roads into private grounds and trespassing in these places. I can speak from experience and say that that happens almost every week.
Comment on this
Trespassing. The cattle are allowed to go from the public roads into private places. In my own experience it happened a dozen times within the past two months. It should be the business of the driver to prevent that. I submit that if traffic is to be controlled the matter is worthy of the Minister's consideration.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Thrift propose that where a farmer lives on the side of a trunk road when putting out his cows in the morning or bringing them in in the evening, he must be subject to State control?
Comment on this
Surely that is the logic of the situation. As far as motorists are concerned, what is the difference between driving cattle from, say, Naas fair, a distance ten miles along a trunk road, and the case of a man living on the edge of a main road who has to drive his cattle two or three miles to the pasture?
Comment on this
The difference is that if a farmer is in charge of his own stock it is his interest to look after them properly. If the cows are not looked after properly there will be someone to come down upon for damages.
Comment on this
While we all have sympathy with Deputy Good in regard to the prevention of cruelty to animals——
Comment on this
We admire the loyalty of Deputy Thrift in coming to the rescue of the Deputy to get him out of the traffic block.
Comment on this
It would be interesting to know by what right Deputy Thrift is entitled to keep the approaches to his avenue open so that cattle can go in there and trespass. The idea of licensing drovers is ridiculous. I have some experience in this matter and I would be inclined to make certain things done by drovers offences, but this amendment goes nowhere to meet the situation. I have seen drovers who are very careful with young cattle and with sheep, but not so careful with big cattle. Some drovers often take very little trouble to get cattle off the road in order that traffic might pass. That is the only complaint I have to make. That conduct, of course, is not common.
Comment on this
I move:—
To insert before sub-section (2) the following new sub-section:—
"The Commissioner may with the consent of the Minister make, in relation to mechanically propelled vehicles and vehicles drawn by mechanically propelled vehicles, by-laws preventing excessive noises being made by horns or other instruments for the purpose of signalling. In making such by-laws, the Commissioner shall have regard, inter alia, to the tone of such horns or other instruments as well as the hours and the localities in which the use of the said horns or instruments may be permitted.”
This amendment is directed at abuses referred to by two other Deputies on the Second Reading of the Bill. They are abuses with which city Deputies are very familiar. It is a long-established principle of common law that freedom from noise is essential to the enjoyment of a house, and that any acts that affect such enjoyment are actionable at law. Modern municipal development tends to accept that principle. In a large number of cities, particularly on the Continent, a good deal of attention has been directed to the prevention of unnecessary street noise which makes for discomfort and loss of amenity, due especially to the new motor traffic. It has been found possible in some of the biggest Continental cities to abolish these noises completely. I was in a famous Continental city a few years ago, with which many Deputies are better acquainted than I am, and I was surprised to notice the remarkable change and the great improvement that had taken place in that respect. The use of motor horns is forbidden in the evening in some cities in Germany. There was great laugh some three years ago when municipal legislation to that effect was introduced, and it was suggested that the police should go to the local musical academy in order to take lessons in musical tone. The ridicule died down and the citizens now appreciate the change for the better that has been effected.
In Dublin at some hours of the day and at some seasons of the year in certain quarters this abuse is a scandal. There is a cacophony of horrible sounds—a great variety of ear-piercing squeaks, grunts and sounds— that I can only characterise as indecent. Some drivers think it is essential to make these noises in order to propel the car. I can only account for it that way. As was pointed out by another Deputy those who offend have a preference for quiet residential quarters and for late hours when there is no traffic about the streets. It is on these streets that these people qualify as drivers and work the horns the whole time. I think the Commissioner should have power to regulate the hours and to check the excessive use of horns in certain districts. Two very distinguished scholars complained to me that their life during certain hours of the day was made almost impossible with buses thundering past and the howling horror of noise and squealing and heavy vehicles shaking the streets. A good deal could be done to reduce this nuisance and to make the city more pleasant for people who are not in these cars. I have noticed that the better drivers rarely use the horns and rarely rush through the traffic making these horrible noises. The offenders are few and should be strictly dealt with. I do not allude to one source of complaint because the Minister I think has power to deal with it under Section 15. A number of motor cyclists tear through the streets without silencers. That practice is particularly horrible and I hope that the Minister when making regulations will take cognisance of that.
Comment on this
I accept entirely the intention of the Deputy as shown in the amendment. The whole question of noises will require to be considered to see if we do not want some provision like this to give us special powers. I refer not only to noises caused by horns and other instruments, but to noises caused by bad loading and the nature of the machine itself. In dealing with this matter, I may as well touch on Deputy Hennessy's amendment, 84 (a), which asks that audible signals be used on public service vehicles which shall have a distinctive note. According to that amendment, the Blue Line buses would have B flat and the Red Line buses C sharp. In the hope of abating noises, I do not think we ought to give special musical notes to special classes of vehicles. I think it would be found that a particular bus driver would be sounding his particular note all the time if there was a bus belonging to another line on the road.
Comment on this
I move amendment 83 on behalf of Deputy Haslett:—
To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
"Before making any regulations in pursuance of this section, the Commissioner shall consult the representative traffic organisations."
Owing to the rapid development of traffic regulation and the great number of cars on the roads, I think it would be very advisable for the Commissioner to take into consultation the people who are associated with this kind of traffic—the Automobile Association and similar bodies—before regulations would be formulated. He could send his regulations to them and ask for their comments.
Comment on this
We do not want to have a situation in which by reason of the fact that it could not be formally proved that before the making of the regulations the representatives of traffic organisations—whatever they are —had been consulted, the regulations would be invalidated. But, in fact, these consultations will take place and the Minister, under Section 6 and Section 8, can prescribe the manner in which, before they are submitted for the Minister's approval, these by-laws will have to be published.
Comment on this
I notice with regard to all the sections of the Bill where by-laws are to be made by the Commissioner that the text is "the Commissioner may, with the consent of the Minister." That does not mean, I take it, that the Minister has got to give his consent to the by-laws. It means only, I presume, that the Minister is to consent to the making of the by-laws by the Commissioner. In that case, we are in a very peculiar position. A multitude of things will affect traffic at every point, and we have no power whatever to discuss them in the Dáil, as the Commissioner is not responsible to the Dáil. I understood from the Minister's earlier remarks on the Bill that the Commissioner in this matter is not subject to the Minister for Justice, and that no Minister can be asked any question with regard to a by-law. Surely, it is not fair to leave the Dáil without the power to discuss a very objectionable by-law. So far as I can see, if the Bill goes through in its present form, that will be the position. No matter what complaints there may be, the Commissioner will be the absolute authority in such matters.
Comment on this
The Bill makes provision for the framing of regulations and by-laws. In the case of orders and regulations, the Bill provides that they shall come under the review of the Oireachtas. By-laws deal with matters of very considerable detail, applicable in many cases to very definitely localised areas. It is considered quite sufficient that these by-laws, which will be prepared by the Commissioner, cannot be given effect without going through a prescribed examination and getting the definite consent of the Minister. If there are objectionable details in them, then any Deputy or any organisation or any local authority has the period between publication and the giving of consent by the Minister to make representations. In the case of matters of detail, such as the by-laws will deal with, it is more satisfactory that individual bodies and Deputies should make representations to the Minister as regards objectionable provisions than that these matters of detail should come under the review of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
Does the Minister mean that these by-laws will require the consent of the Minister for Local Government?
Comment on this
I suggest that the words need not necessarily be read in that way. The words are "the Commissioner may with the consent of the Minister." That does not mean that it would be necessary for him to get the consent of the Minister to the by-laws when made. He may merely ask the consent of the Minister to the making of the by-laws. There is nothing in this section which states that the Commissioner shall submit his by-laws when drafted to the Minister.
Comment on this
On the section, in consequence of local authorities being obliged to do certain things as a result of the by-laws made, I think it is apparent that local authorities should be brought into consultation when dealing with these matters. Sub-section (3) provides that the Council charged with the maintenance of a road in relation to which a by-law is in force shall erect certain signs and notices on such roadway. I think the Minister will agree that in fairness to the local authorities they should be consulted before any such by-laws imposing these obligations upon them are drafted. I would like to have an assurance, in connection with this section particularly, that there will be consultation between the local authorities and the representatives of the Commissioner in the area.
I do not see that it will do any harm at all. In view of the way that this section is drafted it makes that more necessary than ever. It will certainly make the task of the Gárda in a particular area easier. I believe it will only lead to irritation and contention if these things are done over the heads of the local authorities where they have to provide the signs and to maintain them. Provision should be made in the section that it be mandatory on the Commissioner's representatives in an area to have a consultation with the local authority. I urge that on the Minister because I think it is necessary. In this section, as it stands, the local authority is ignored altogether. I do not think that is desirable. If the Minister is desirous to have the traffic regulations carried out properly, in such a way as to ensure the safety of the public, then I submit that in giving effect to the section the local authorities are deeply concerned and ought to be consulted.
Comment on this
I think it is necessary that the regulations should contain a provision requiring motorists to lower blinding headlights when they are approaching other traffic, particularly in the city.
Comment on this
There is another point that I would like to see attended to. It is that when one motor car is passing another it should sound its horn. I do not know whether there is any regulation dealing with that, but in my opinion it is desirable there should be one.
Comment on this
At the risk of incurring the ire of Deputy Alton I would like to say, in reference to paragraph (1) which requires persons in charge of traffic or of specified classes of traffic, to give audible warning of their approach in specified circumstances or at specified places, that if the places are to be specified at which persons approaching a cross must give warning of their approach, then there is a necessity I think for some by-law requiring that sign posts be erected with a notice on them to this effect: "Blow your horn here."
Comment on this
During the consideration of this Bill a good deal has been said about omnibuses, tractors, lorries and ordinary motor cars, but very little has been said about the most important section that is affected by traffic, namely, the pedestrian. It is nearly time I think that some one got up and, so to speak, put in a word edgeways for the pedestrian. Any one who has observed traffic conditions in this city must have become conscious of the fact that the pedestrian who has a primary right to the roadway and the footpath—
Comment on this
Yes, a primary right to any part of the roadway or the pathway, does not get very much consideration. I am not finding any fault with the Gárda—I suppose it is due to tradition and to their training—but Deputies and others must have observed that in carrying out their duties in the city they will signal to the on-coming omnibus or ordinary motor car and will take no notice whatever of the pedestrian or group of pedestrians, of the infirm, or the nervous, who are waiting to cross the roadway. They are left standing on an island around a telegraph pole or a tram pole waiting to get across. People who have had experience of the carrying out of traffic duties in cities in other countries will have seen a whole stream of traffic held up in order to allow 20 or 30 school children to cross the streets, as well as nervous women, aged people and other pedestrians. Is there any reason why there should not be a regulation of that kind here?
What do we find in Dublin City? That buses pull up right across the street at points where pedestrians are expected to cross. They pull up right in the centre of the roadway and pedestrians, in order to make a crossing, are expected to walk around them. It is interesting to watch, too, the manner in which the Gárda give indications to motorists to approach as well as the manner in which motorists indicate that they are going to proceed in a particular direction. In the case of ladies, when they give an indication, one is not certain whether they propose taking a turn in a particular direction or whether they are simply "ta-taing" to some friend on the footpath. One is left in the position that he does not know if he responds to the indication but that he may be running into danger. There should be a regulation prohibiting motorists and the drivers of omnibuses from pulling up at crossings. Frequently at the corner of Abbey Street you find a line of omnibuses pulled up. You find two or three of them telescoped right in the middle of the street. I think it is time that somebody said a word on behalf of pedestrians. Motorists, as well as other people, have at one time or another to use "shank's mare" when going through the city, and they must have observed the conditions I have described. Despite Deputy Good's doubts, the pedestrian has a primary right to the use of the road and the footpath, and it is time that some consideration should be given to him. I hope that somewhere in the Bill a provision will be embodied enabling the Minister to make regulations to protect the pedestrian more than he is at present.
Comment on this
I would like to back up what Deputy Corish said with reference to local authorities. Sub-section (3) of Section 133, which has been referred to by Deputy Corish provides that "the Council charged with the maintenance of a road in relation to which a by-law made under this section is enforced . . shall erect, place, or make and shall maintain on such roads all such notices, instructions and directions," and so on. There is similar wording in other sections making it mandatory on local authorities to put up and maintain notices of various kinds. What I would like to know is, who is to pay for these notices? Is the local authority to be called upon to pay for them? The matter was under discussion recently at a Committee of the Dublin Municipal Council. They were of opinion that the cost of putting up these notices should be borne out of the Road Fund. There is a considerable amount of money collected from motorists, and it is primarily to facilitate motorists that these notices will be put up. It is the opinion of the Municipal Council, and members have been asked to bring it forward here, that the cost of these various notices—in Dublin the number of them may be very considerable—ought to be borne out of the Road Fund.
Comment on this
All the money that comes into the Road Fund except in so far that some of it is used to meet the expenses of administration, goes to the local authorities in proportion to the amount they spend on maintenance.
Comment on this
Yes, it could be regarded as part of the maintenance of the roads. We pay forty per cent. of the cost of the maintenance of all main roads. The cost of these would be included in that. I think that is the simplest way to deal with the matter. As to the local authorities I will see what we may say explicitly on that.
On the point of the pedestrian, as I understand it, the pedestrian has first right to the road. That is my understanding of the common law at any rate. Whether like many people, he is treated with the deference with which he should be treated, is another matter. As far as crossing roads or anything like that is concerned Section 133 (1) (i) refers to it. I have been concerning myself with the consideration of the position of pedestrians and cyclists in relation to motor traffic, whether it is reasonable that going along a country road, two pedestrians walking abreast should have to walk in single file in order that a motor car would pass them. I feel that two pedestrians walking abreast should have as much right to the road as a motor car and that the same thing should apply with regard to two cyclists. I do not know whether we might enshrine that in legislation. I do not know on the other hand to what extent the alleged grievances of pedestrians are really well founded.
Comment on this
As I say, we propose as far as crossing roads is concerned, to arrange for that in Section 133, but as to the advisability or otherwise of enshrining anything in this Bill, talking about the inalienable rights of pedestrians, I do not know whether it is feasible.
Comment on this
While the arrangements for pedestrians are not very good, I do not think it would be quite fair to the Guards to say that as far as the most congested parts are concerned, their interests are neglected. For instance, at the corner where people turn from Nassau Street into Grafton Street, one may see the Guard on duty there holding up the traffic to allow pedestrians to go through. In certain other parts very much consideration is not given to pedestrians. On the other hand, pedestrians do not give much consideration to themselves. I am driving a motor car for twenty years myself and I can say that it is an old established fact that if one is driving along Dame Street one is met with a constant procession of people crossing the streets at these points. If a regulation were made according to Deputy Hogan's suggestion that people should cross the streets at one particular point, and that the Guard should allow them to pass in bunches, as it were, it would be a very good thing. While the present condition of affairs may not be all that pedestrians could wish, in certain parts of the City the Guards do look after them. I say that as a motorist who is constantly about the streets.
Comment on this
In view of the obligation which local authorities are obliged to take on themselves in consequence of by-laws that will be made under the section, would the Minister not be prepared to put after the word Commissioner, "after consultation with the local authority may, with the consent of the Minister"?
Comment on this
If I have said it once, I have said it thirty times that the question of handling the pedes trians on the part of the Commissioner in the City is not so very easy. I think there would be a terrible outcry if the Commissioner laid it down that a person wishing to cross from the shop of Siemens Schuckert on one side of O'Connell Street, to the Gresham Hotel on the opposite side, had either to go down to the Pillar at one end of the street or up to the Parnell Monument at the other.
Comment on this
Much has been said on this Bill about danger signals for motorists. I would like to see some arrangement by which pedestrians would signal to motorists, but I would appeal to motorists to take some recognition of these signals. The fact that these signals are ignored very often may not be so dangerous in the vicinity of Dublin where you have steam-rolled roads, but down the country where the roads are not kept in repair, you have large potholes which in wet weather become filled with water and slush. Motorists driving along these roads at 30 or 40 miles an hour destroy the clothes of the unfortunate pedestrian. On one occasion I saw a respected parish priest who had to get inside the ditch from one of these motorists, and even then he was not safe, because his coat was covered with mud. I would like to see some arrangement by which when a pedestrian holds up his hand, a motorist would slow up. I think there should be some recognition of pedestrians signals in that way.
Comment on this
I move amendment 84 (a)—
At the end of sub-section (1) to add a new paragraph as follows:—
"(o) Providing that the audible signals to be used on public service vehicles plying on specified routes shall have a distinctive note which will indicate the particular route on which such vehicle is plying."
This amendment has for its object the provision of distinctive signals that will indicate what route the bus is travelling. In fact it would be as well for me to say that from the time a bus starts until it reaches its terminus there are no stopping places such as are provided in the tram service. The traveller has to rely on his own alertness to signal for the bus to stop. It is not such a problem in the daytime but it is very difficult at night. Even in a short three-quarters of a mile a man or woman has to turn round many times to see if a bus is coming. I took this measure of it myself, that I had to turn practically 100 times from one end of Harcourt Street to the other. My suggestion to prevent that is that the buses travelling on each particular route—I do not think you would have more than five or six routes on the south side of the city—would have some kind of signal permanently attached to the bus and that would be permanently acting. I do not see that there is any need to have disagreeable sound amongst them. I remember in the old days of the horse trams each of them carried a bell and the bell was always ringing so that at any rate you knew when your tram was coming. At present you have no idea of the bus that is coming behind you. As I stated, you have all the time to keep looking back to see if your bus is coming. The fixture containing the signal could be simple and it could contain a note that would be of a more musical character than a noise.
Comment on this
If you were to witness the difficulties that people have in looking back for their buses, you would realise that it is a very serious matter at night. I am afraid Deputies, especially from the rural parts, might be inclined to treat the matter lightly, but if you were living here in the city you would not treat it so lightly. I would ask the Minister to give it every consideration because I believe it will be a source of facilitating the public travelling by buses. He need not worry about any unpleasant noises because I am assured there is a person already available to supply an instrument that will be both efficient and musical.
Comment on this
But the Minister a moment ago suggested that this motion might be taken in conjunction with another one. I quite see the difficulty which the Minister envisaged. If we have, as the Deputy wants to have, a number of distinctive notes I think we ought to know the old major scale. It would give us eight notes to go on with. I do not know how many services there are in Dublin, but I can just imagine the horrible state of affairs we would have if each of these buses were to look for sharps and flats and run over the entire gamut. There would be such a discord that the last stage would be worse than that envisaged in Deputy Thrift's amendment. I suggest if Deputy Hennessy would improve the amenities of this country why should he not go a little bit further and have a chime on these buses. We could have Deputy Thrift with his little chime "At Trinity Church I met my doom." We could have Deputy Donovan chiming "Come to Glengariff, Come," we might have Deputy Mongan with "The Men of the West," and Deputy Bennett might have attached to his motor car the chime "Limerick, is beautiful," and so on.
Comment on this
I would suggest that the Minister for Industry and Commerce have attached to his motor car "Where the River Shannon flows." I wonder how Deputy Dr. Hennessy suggests, if we are all going to have distinctive chimes, where they are to be got.
Comment on this
Your trouble is at night. When you are travelling you are not able to distinguish between the noise of the engine of a private car and of a bus.
Comment on this
That depends on where you were last. I could distinguish it at any hour of the night. I suggest that the Minister's difficulty would be quadrupled in this manner. It will be far easier to prescribe for ordinary patients where your mistakes are covered up in a few days. I suggest that if Deputy Dr. Hennessy insisted on this he would not have sufficient notes to meet the case if he wants to have the chimes I referred to. I do not suggest that they might all go off together like the patients. I suggest that he should have some distinctive harmony.
Comment on this
Yes, and Section 106 proposes that, so that Deputies will not have to twist their necks so often going home. They will know that all they have to do is to go on to the next stage. Also, they must know that the one particular bus is not confined to a particular route, and they might have a few spare notes knocking around; so with them the matter is not feasible at all.
Comment on this
Would there be any objection to the buses having speaking advertisements, such as "Up Dev." or something like that?
Comment on this
I have only one thing to say before withdrawing the amendment, that it would be a very valuable thing if you had in every bus in the country and town, call it a distinctive noise if you like, a sound to indicate that there is something of a murderous character coming on.
Comment on this
On the section I want to repeat again what I said in regard to Sections 124 and 133 in regard to local authorities. The same applies to Sections 135, 136, 137 and 138. The local authority ought to have some say in the matter, and ought to be consulted.
Comment on this
I move:—
In sub-section (1) (b), line 46, after the word "conditions" to insert the words "other than any conditions prescribing fees to be payable in respect of parking."
Amendments 85 and 86 really hang together. It is a matter of objection to paying fees for the parking of cars on the streets. The streets are supported by the rates, and there is great objection on the part of motorists who live out in the country and have to motor into the city every day to have a tax compulsorily placed upon them and to have to pay fees for parking their cars on the street. I do not think there would be any objection to paying a fee if the local authorities provided a suitable car park. What a number of these motorists feel is that it is a very unfair thing to add to their motoring expenses a sum of £7 10s. a year—to pay 6d. every day for six days of the week, which adds considerably to their motoring expenses. For that reason I move the amendment.
Comment on this
The position is that, arising out of street conditions in the city, the Commissioner of the Gárda Síochána has actually arranged a certain number of parking places and appointed parking attendants, whose duty it is to see that there is no unauthorised interference with the cars and their contents. As far as I know, and I would like to hear any Dublin motorist on the subject, it has been a convenience to the motoring public. The attendants are there voluntarily. They have no right to a fee, but, in fact, they do get a fee of about 2d. or 3d. The whole arrangement as far as I know is regarded as a convenience. This is simply a proposal that this ought to be organised by the Commissioner so that the fee can be charged for the motorist using the parking place.
Comment on this
What is the position with regard to these attendants? Are they paid a fee or are they simply dependent on tips?
Comment on this
They are dependent on the contributions they get, the twopence or threepence they get from each person.
Comment on this
They are there, as it were, licensed by the Commissioner. They wear armlets. They are responsible for seeing that there is no unauthorised tampering with the cars or their contents.
Comment on this
I think they are a distinct boon, but suppose they do not look after their business, have you any redress?
Comment on this
You have the redress that the Commissioner can withdraw an attendant's licence. He can prevent him being occupied on that particular class of work.
Comment on this
How many cars would be on a stand? Would there be forty or fifty? How much would an attendant make in a day? I understand they demand sixpence and that nothing less would be very welcome. A man could make 25/- a day judging by the number of cars I see. I do not know the accommodation on each stand, but it occurred to me that there ought to be a reduction in their charges also.
Comment on this
This provision which it is sought to delete from the section is to enable the Commissioner to fix the parking fee. That fee would be fixed in such a way as to provide a reasonable income for an attendant looking after a particular place.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister if he would be favourable to giving out tickets that would be available in any parking place in the city. If a person were moving from one part of the city to another he may have to pay in three or four different places which would be a rather serious matter. In Belfast I believe they have an arrangement by which a ticket is given to each person who is parking a car. That ticket may be used in any other parking place to which the car might be moved during the day. If the Minister would consider such an arrangement here I would be prepared to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I certainly think that that can be done in the working of the scheme. If a person comes to Stephen's Green and pays twopence for a ticket that ticket can hold good for the day. I think the fees ought to be arranged in such a way as would finance the scheme. A ticket would be issued for the day and that could be used for all parking places on the street.
Comment on this
I am agreeing on principle to the amendment. I will introduce an amendment that will meet the matter.
Comment on this
In many towns throughout the country along the main thoroughfares it is the practice to allow cars to be parked on both sides of the street allowing only a narrow passage through. The consequence is that there is great danger to children who run behind the cars. The motorists have no chance of seeing them. I have seen a child knocked down by a car moving slowly.
Comment on this
That is so especially in provincial towns. In many cases where the streets are narrow there is rather indiscriminate parking of cars. There does not seem to be any control. The Civic Guards do not appear to interfere. Greater precautions are necessary in many of these towns.
Comment on this
This section states "Every person who, without lawful authority, does any act (whether of commission or omission) whereby the passage of traffic through any public place is wholly or partially obstructed or which causes or tends to cause such passage of traffic to be so obstructed shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall on summary conviction thereof be liable to a fine." I think we are approaching a general election when public meetings will be held throughout the City of Dublin. These public meetings may prevent traffic from passing through. Those who are holding the meetings in that case would become liable to a fine.
Comment on this
There is a more serious objection than that. The section of course is very much required in some respects, but where you have fairs being held on public streets there can be very rough abuse of the section.
Comment on this
The whole section is under consideration. In any attempt at redrafting we will take into consideration the position the two Deputies spoke about.
Comment on this
I do not know if this section can be used to prevent the holding of fairs in streets in towns.
Comment on this
I know from experience in trying to pass in a car through towns where fairs are being held that it would be practically impossible for the first sub-section to be observed or for anything to be done which would secure the free passage of cars through these fairs. Neither do I think it is desirable that any restrictions should be imposed on the holding of these fairs or that it should be made obligatory on persons sending cattle for sale to send them to places other than where the fairs have been held for generations.
Comment on this
There is no power in that section that will enable fairs to be stopped in places where they have hitherto been held.
Comment on this
May I ask if a public place referred to in sub-section (3) is a parking ground, would it be covered by the sub-section—"there shall be carried on every mechanically propelled vehicle while it is in a public place during lighting-up hours, a lamp." Surely one of the advantages of a parking place is that that is not necessary.
Comment on this
In Section 148 (d) provision is made for exempting parking places from the operation of the section: "exempting from the operation of any particular provisions of this Part of this Act or any regulations made thereunder vehicles' which are stationary in a place which is a parking place within the meaning of this Act."
Comment on this
I would like to ask the Minister if he would put down for the Report Stage an amendment to this effect: "In addition to any other light that may be carried, a red reflector be also carried showing the rere of every vehicle, whether mechanically propelled or not." My reason for suggesting this is, that I once nearly met with a very serious accident when motoring at night by coming on top of a car whose rear light had gone out. The cost of a reflector would be very small, and if there were a reflector on every car everyone would know that even if the rear light had gone out, he would be safeguarded by the reflector. It would be a precaution which would save many accidents, and I ask the Minister to consider the matter.
Comment on this
That is that whether provided with a light or not, all vehicles on the road should be fitted with a reflector?
Comment on this
Under sub-section (4) apparently cars of every description and loads of every description would be obliged to carry two lights, one before and one behind, or else a reflector. How is it suggested that a load of hay should be lighted? It would be nearly impossible. I am afraid that a condition such as this would be irritating and annoying to farmers. When a farmer's car has to go a few hundred yards from one field to another, he would be supposed to have a light at the rear as well as in front. I am afraid the section will cause a lot of annoyance and irritation and will not serve its purpose.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister does not contemplate having a rear light when pigs are being brought to fairs and markets?
Comment on this
I strongly support the section which requires that horse drawn vehicles should carry a rear light or reflector, because whatever inconvenience may be caused the safety of human life is also involved.
Comment on this
I think it will be admitted by motorists that a reflector is as effective as a light. There is no question of a candle going out. We know that a very small reflector on a bicycle is of considerable assistance to motorists because they can see it. A large reflector attached to a car would be as effective as a lamp in my opinion and would only cost a few pence. I ask the Minister to give particular attention to the question of reflectors.
Comment on this
I am not in favour of making it compulsory to have a reflector or light on the back of carts. It would be almost impossible to keep it there. I do not know how a reflector could be kept on the tailboard of a cart used for putting out farmyard manure. If a man has to bring, say, two loads of manure up to a field——
Comment on this
He may be returning home after dark. Farmers often have to draw manure half a mile away and often a man has to bring two carts with a horse behind the second one and is he to have a light on them every time he is going home after dark?
Comment on this
I shall give consideration between this and the Report Stage to the point which Deputy The O'Mahony suggested with regard to reflectors. Might I say at this stage that there are three amendments remaining to be discussed? One deals with the question of carrying lights where animals are being driven along a road. Another is an amendment by Deputy Davin which is a transport matter rather than a traffic matter. The next is an amendment by Deputy Everett of which I accept the principle and propose to introduce an amendment to deal with the matter on Report. As we are going into Committee again on the Report Stage, in order that the business before the House to-morrow may be transacted and private Deputies' time may be given, I suggest that we should conclude the Committee Stage of this Bill by 10.30 and that these three amendments might be held over for the Report Stage. That would materially help business.
Comment on this
Is the Minister giving an undertaking that the principle of my amendment will be contained in the proposed Transport Bill?
Comment on this
As the Leas-Cheann Comhairle has not ruled the amendment out of order at this Stage, I presume he will let it appear on the Paper for the Report Stage.
Comment on this
Is the Minister insisting on retaining the provision about having two lights on a car?
Comment on this
The Deputy can deal with that on the next Stage. I am taking it that the House agrees to the Minister's suggestion.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Minister a question. Deputy Sir James Craig raised the point in regard to the use of headlights, particularly in well-lighted places. Are the headlights on stationary vehicles covered by this?
Comment on this
The Minister can make regulations "restricting or controlling the power, height, width, and range of the light projected by the lamps carried lit thereon in a public place or in any particular public place or class of public places and the angle of projection of the beams of such light and the temporary or partial obscuration of any such light and the extent and mode of effecting such obscuration." I suggest, as we will be going into Committee again on the Report Stage, that the discussion on the question of lights on drawing and drawn vehicles and so on, might all be postponed to the Report Stage without prejudice to any position that might be taken up.
Comment on this
Wednesday, 25th inst. I do not know whether we will be in a position to deal with the Report Stage on that day, but at any rate I would like to put it down for that day.
Comment on this
As early as possible. I should like to give Deputies a week to consider my amendments before the Report Stage. If I am not in a position to do that, then we will not be able to take the Report Stage on the 25th, but I should like to put it down provisionally for that date.
Ordered accordingly.
The Dáil adjourned at 10.30 p.m. to Friday, 13th November.