In Committee on Finance. - Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill, 1931—Committee.
Contributions 1–165 of 487. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 43 of 1931 ›
I just wish to call attention to the point that amongst the Acts amended are the Labourers (Ireland) Acts, 1883 to 1930. These Acts were continued by the Expiring Laws Bill passed last week. In the first place, is the definition right there? Secondly, has the Minister considered the point I raised that if it was intended that the Acts should remain in operation for a longer period than one year they should be made permanent by this Bill?
Comment on this
As far as that is concerned, for the purposes of this Bill there is no necessity to make it a permanent Act, and there may have been certain objections to doing it. I have not gone into the matter, but it creates no definite difficulty except that the Expiring Laws Bill has to include it every year. As I said, this Act is the precursor of a codifying Bill, and the only difficulty that will arise is that the Labourers Acts must be continued in the Expiring Laws Bill until such time as they are included in the Codified Housing Bill. As far as the definition of the Act is concerned——
Comment on this
There may be a point in that. We had a Labourers (Ireland) Act last year dealing with certain small things. Lower down, we include it in the general type of Labourers Acts, 1883 to 1931. On the 1930 Bill originally there was some small change made to enable rating difficulties to be got over last year.
Comment on this
I move amendments No. 1 and No. 2 as follows:—
1. In page 5, lines 42 and 43, to delete the words "or are for the like reason dangerous or injurious to the health of the inhabitants of the area".
2. In page 5, lines 45 and 46, to delete the words "such inhabitants" and substitute therefor the words "the inhabitants of the area".
These are drafting amendments. The words which it is proposed to delete are really redundant, and they might give rise to obscurity.
Comment on this
I am not so sure that is so. When is a building unfit for human habitation? Has that phrase been defined?
Comment on this
It is the sanitary officer of the local authority who decides when a building is unfit for human habitation.
Comment on this
I move amendment 3:
In sub-section (1), line 13, to add after the word "area" the words "which are unfit for human habitation or dangerous or injurious to health."
The purpose of this amendment is to make clear the difference between an area definitely defined as a clearance area and the original area that has been under consideration. If there are buildings in an area which is declared generally to be unhealthy, and that these buildings are not themselves in an unhealthy condition, it is not the purpose of the Bill either that these buildings would be destroyed or that they would be included in what is strictly defined as the clearance area.
Comment on this
The words "all the buildings in that area" refer here to the clearance area, mentioned in line 17. It is the intention that all the buildings in the clearance area will be destroyed, but the clearance area may have in it islands of good buildings. These would have been referred to in the words "any area" in line 10. All the buildings referred to would be in what has been definitely marked down as the clearance area.
Comment on this
I move amendment 4:
In sub-section (1), line 17, to add after the words "such area" the words "as so defined."
This is consequential on the other amendments.
Comment on this
I would like to know in regard to sub-section (3) whether it should not be the function of the council rather than of the city manager to declare an area an unhealthy area.
Comment on this
That is what it says. The declaration of any area is a reserved function. A reserved function is a function reserved for the council.
Comment on this
Does Section 7 make it any easier for local authorities to acquire land a good distance away from the particular clearance area; if land is not available have they the same power?
Comment on this
That would be dealt with in a separate way. If an area is cleared the satisfactory redevelopment of the area that is being cleared may necessitate the local authorities purchasing land which is either in the middle of the clearance area but has not been declared unhealthy or is adjoining it and it is very strictly linked up with the re-development of a clearance area.
Comment on this
I move amendment 5.
In page 8, at the end of the section to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"(5) The amount of any expenses due to a local authority under this section shall be a charge on the premises in respect of which expenses were incurred and the local authority shall for the purpose of enforcing such charge have all the same powers and remedies as if they were mortgagees by deed having powers of sale and lease, accepting surrenders of leases and of appointing a receiver."
This is to set out more fully the position of the local authorities. It puts them in a position of power to recover expenses that have been incurred by them in carrying out the demolition under Section 8.
Comment on this
I move amendment 6:
In sub-section (1), line 32, to add after the words "such area" the words "which are unfit for human habitation or dangerous or injurious to health."
Comment on this
I move amendment 7:
Before Section 15 to insert a new section as follows:—
"For the purposes of providing accommodation for persons displaced by the demolition of buildings under a clearance order the local authority may purchase by a compulsory purchase order any habitable house which has been vacant for a period of not less than three months."
I do not think in many places in Ireland at the moment the state of affairs prevails that I have in mind, but in case it does and houses are closed down for some selfish reasons as far as the landlords are concerned, I think the Minister should give the local authorities power to take them over and to use them. If the Minister would agree, I think it might be acceptable in the case of barracks and buildings of that sort also.
Comment on this
The local authority has already this power under Section 8 of the Housing (Ireland) Act, 1919, and we amplify that in Section 49 (1) by the addition of the words "are suitable for." Section 8 states: "The powers of a local authority to acquire land for the purposes of Part III. of the Act of 1890 shall be deemed to include power—
(a) to acquire any houses or other buildings on the land proposed to be acquired as a site for the erection of houses for the working classes; and
(b) to acquire any estate or interest in any houses which might be made suitable as houses for the working classes, together with any lands occupied with such houses."
The amendment to Section 49, sub-section (1) will give power to local authorities under (b) (1) of Section 8 to acquire any estate or interest in any houses which are suitable. These words are added "or which might be made suitable as houses for the working classes," so what the Deputy seeks to include in his amendment is covered by that section and made more in accordance with what he wants.
Comment on this
I move amendment 9, to delete sub-section (2).
Amendments 8 and 9 are really bound up together, and deal with the same thing. The trouble is that the word "may" in the second line of the section, it is feared, would have the effect of "shall". We were told here a few evenings ago by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that "may" when applied to a local body has the effect of "shall" and it is felt that if "may" there in fact meant "shall," it would make for delay, because the local authority might feel bound to serve that notice on persons other than the person in actual control, and that in that way it would lead to a great deal of delay to find out who those persons were. I propose to delete the sub-section altogether. Deputy Corish suggests that "may at their discretion" would meet the position. The difficulty we have in mind is if "may" is mandatory it would make for a good deal of delay in finding out those people who may have an interest or who may be entitled to serve a notice.
Comment on this
The purpose of the sub-section is that where there are a chain of owners it is desirable in so far as they may be conveniently found that they will all be advised as to the steps that are being taken with regard to an unhealthy house, because the person who is immediately in control of the house might not be prepared to suit the local authority's wishes, and the local authority might be driven into the position of taking action itself, whereas the person next or second next in the chain, if advised as to what was taking place with regard to the dwelling, might approach those people closer up in ownership, and might come to an accommodation by which the immediate owner might part with his interest to the other owner, and that local owner might meet the local authorities in their wishes, so that I think it would be undesirable to take that sub-section out.
With regard to Deputy Corish's amendment, whatever Deputy O'Connell read into anything said by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, I think it would be desperate, considering all the "mays" we have passed through, in one way or another, if we allowed ourselves to give approval to the idea that every place there was a "may" in anything passed through here it shall be construed to mean "shall."
Comment on this
Any lawyer will tell you that there are a great many places where it is read as "shall."
Comment on this
I am assured it does not mean "shall" here. Deputy Corish's words are no addition, as far as making the sense very clear.
Comment on this
It might mean that another dozen "mays" would be interpreted as "shalls" because we put in the modification here.
Comment on this
I would ask the Deputy to leave it to the draftsman. I will draw his attention to the things stated here.
Comment on this
It would be well that we had some kind of definition as to when "may" means "shall" and when it does not.
Comment on this
There are many cases in which it does mean shall.
Comment on this
This section provides that the local authority shall serve certain notices on owners requiring them to do certain repairs and in the following section power is given to them to do those repairs themselves if the owner does not himself take action. It has been suggested to me that a difficulty might arise which is not provided for here. We will assume that the owner is willing to do it but he finds it impossible to get rid of the people who are in occupation. Even one tenant in a block of dwellings may refuse to go out. It may be that there is no other accommodation provided for him. It is quite possible that that difficulty is provided for by previous Acts. I only put it to the Minister that there is such a possibility and I would be very glad if he would give an explanation.
Comment on this
I take it what Deputy Law means is where extensive repairs are being carried out and where the tenants ought to be removed.
Comment on this
I think there should be some stipulation that the same tenant ought to get back. I have a case in mind where notice was served by the sanitary authority upon a landlord to get certain repairs carried out. He immediately gave the person in the house notice to quit, and he brought back another person at a higher rent. There ought to be something to safeguard the tenants in that way.
Comment on this
I do not think there is in this Bill, and perhaps in any Act, power to make a tenant vacate a building in order that the owner might repair it. This work contemplates very close touch with the local authority. If you pass a law that will enable an owner to clear out a tenant while he is carrying out repairs and put on the owner the onus of bringing back that tenant at the same rent, I do not know whether that would be a satisfactory type of legislation. I would be inclined to leave it to the local authority, who understand the spirit of the Rent Restriction Act as applied to the house. I would leave it to co-operation between the local authorities and the owners of houses to make the necessary arrangements to facilitate the repairs in these unhealthy dwellings. I think it will be found that the local authority would leave nothing undone to help owners who are entering in a spirit of co-operation into the work of putting unhealthy houses into a satisfactory condition. I would sooner enter into a discussion with the local authorities as to what is involved in the suggestion of Deputy Law than to introduce a statute.
Comment on this
You may get an owner willing to do the repairs and the local authority anxious and willing to facilitate him, but the owner may be in this unfortunate position that it is impossible for him to do the repairs because of one obstructive person.
Comment on this
The repairs would need to be very extensive before it would be necessary to put a tenant out. It would not be unreasonable for a landlord if he did do extensive repairs to take advantage of the Rent Restrictions Act to get the amount that he is entitled to. What I want to guard against is this: If it is necessary, and a whole lot of landlords may consider it necessary, to put a tenant out, the owner should not be permitted to charge over and above what he is entitled to charge under the Rent Restrictions Act. In nineteen cases out of twenty, you will find people prepared to pay 100 and 150 per cent. more rent than a landlord is entitled to get. They are so anxious to get houses that they are not prepared to take advantage of their powers under the Rent Restrictions Act. I want to guard against that sort of thing.
Comment on this
There is nothing safeguarding it here, and I do not know that there is any safeguard in the Rent Restrictions Act, but if a case like that is likely to happen it will be where the structure of the house is radically changed.
Comment on this
I would rather leave it as a matter of co-operation between the local authority and the owners. If you make it a matter of law the owner may have a statutory right to put out a person, and there might be no place to which that person could go. If a local authority were so unreasonable as to pursue an owner in this particular way, without trying to accommodate him, I do not think any court would stand for the point of view of the local authority.
Comment on this
I am inclined to agree with the Minister that with a little bit of give and take on the part of the local authority, who know the position, the thing that Deputy Law suggests would not arise.
Comment on this
Has the landlord any power to add to the rent the expenses he has been put to in repairing a house?
Comment on this
I move amendment 10.
10. Before sub-section (5) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"Any such expenses may be recovered in a summary manner as a civil debt by the local authority from the occupier or occupiers for the time being of the house in respect of which the expenses were incurred and the person having control of the house shall allow such occupier to deduct any money which he pays under this enactment out of the rent from time to time becoming due out of the house or the part of same occupied by him, as if the same had been actually paid to such person having control as part of such rent: Provided that no such occupier shall be required to pay any further sum than the amount of rent for the time being due from him, or which, after demand of such expenses from such occupier, and after notice not to pay the person in control of the house any rent without first deducting the amount of such expenses, becomes payable by such occupier, unless he refuses, on application to him by the local authority, truly to disclose the amount of his rent and the name and address of the person to whom such rent is payable; but the burden of proof that the sum demanded from any such occupier is greater than the rent due by him at the time of such notice, or which has since accrued shall lie on such occupier: Provided also that in case any house or part of same in respect of which any such expenses were incurred becomes vacant before the whole of such expenses shall have been discharged the local authority may make a letting or lettings of the same for a period or periods and at a rent or rents not less favourable to the tenant or tenants than those of the former letting or lettings.
The local authority shall during the whole time they are in receipt of the rents of the occupier or occupiers of any house under this enactment maintain the same in a sanitary condition in accordance with the requirements of any statute or by-laws in force in relation to same, and the expenses incurred by the local authority in that behalf shall be added to the expenses recoverable under this section, and shall be recovered as part of same."
This amendment has been suggested by the City Manager and the law agent. They are of opinion that while the provisions in Section 20 are valuable, in practice they may be proved, to some extent at any rate, unworkable. It will be necessary to have arrangements such as are suggested in this amendment whereby the recoupment can be obtained from the occupier of the premises. I do not know whether the Minister has seen the statement sent around by the City Manager and the law agent, dated 18th November. If he has not, perhaps I will be permitted to read it.
Comment on this
I have seen the statement. We have had discussions both with the City Manager and the law agent, and amendment 11 is intended to meet the purpose the City Manager has in mind. It gives the local authority power to require that rents will be paid over to it until such time as the amount is fully repaid; that is, having got a decision that certain moneys are due to them from the owner, the local authority can get the amounts paid over. The main objection to the section as it stood was that it was thought a separate application would have to be made for every week's rent. Amendment 11 avoids that; and amendment 12 gives the local authority power to keep tenants in a place if the owner, for any reason, does not do so. It enables the local authority to rent any section of a house that becomes vacant after suitable notice of twenty-one days has been given to the owner.
Comment on this
I suppose there is no danger of this becoming a general rule rather than an exception? Are we to take it that this will not be brought into operation unless the landlord, by whom the repairs are carried out——
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 14.
In sub-section (1), line 60, to delete the word and figure "and (4)" and substitute therefor the figures and word "(4) and (5)".
We put in an additional sub-section to Section 8, and this is consequential on that.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 15:
Before Section 28 to insert a new section as follows:—
"(1) It shall be the duty of every local authority to consider the housing conditions in their area and the needs of the area with respect to the provision of further housing accommodation for the working classes and for that purpose to review the information which has been brought to their notice by the medical officer of health or as a result of inspections and surveys previously carried out or otherwise and as often as occasion arises or within three months after notice has been given to them by the Minister, to prepare and submit to the Minister proposals for the provision of new houses for the working classes, distinguishing those houses which the local authority propose to provide for the purpose of rendering accommodation available for persons to be displaced by, or in consequence of, action taken by the authority under this Act.
(2) In the year 1932 and in each fifth succeeding year the council of every county borough or other urban district which for the time being contains according to the latest published census returns a population of more than five thousand shall furnish to the Minister, in addition to any proposals submitted by them under the last preceding sub-section, a general statement of the measures which they propose to take during the five next succeeding years for dealing with housing conditions in their area and the provision of further housing accommodation."
This is taken practically bodily from the British Housing Act of 1930. I was looking through that measure and comparing it with the Bill now before us, and I notice that practically all this Bill might be said — of course with amendments — to have been taken bodily from the British Housing Act of last year. I thought it rather surprising that the Minister did not include this section as well. I think there are very useful powers contained in it, and that it would be an advantage to the Department to have returns of that kind so as to be able to see the progress made over a period of years. It would enable the Department to take a census of the number of unhealthy houses and the number of houses requiring to be erected in cities and towns. I think the powers would be valuable, and they would help to make certain that the Minister and the Department would be fully aware of the exact circumstances in regard to the housing of the people in the towns and cities. It would also afford opportunities of bringing housing conditions directly under the notice of local authorities and officials.
Comment on this
Under the Housing Act of 1919, Sections 3 and 4, it is incumbent on local authorities to proceed somewhat on the lines suggested in the Deputy's amendment. In addition to that, Section 27 of the present Bill makes it the duty of every local authority to cause an inspection of their districts from time to time with a view to ascertaining whether any dwelling-house is unfit for human habitation, and they will have to comply with such regulations and keep such records as the Minister may prescribe. Under Section 42 we provide that if it appears to the Minister that owing to a density of population, or any other reason, it is expedient to inquire into the circumstances of any area, the Minister may require the local authority to make a report. It seems to me that we have all the necessary powers that we require under these provisions in order to meet what the Deputy has in mind.
I would rather hesitate to get into a position in which in 1932 and every fifth succeeding year we would have a big volume of statistics coming into the office all at one time. I think with the responsibility on the Department of seeing that the local authorities get systematically after their schemes, we can work in a more satisfactory way. I would be against getting into a routine that would bring a huge volume of statistics down on top of us every fifth year, building us, perhaps, to the more detailed problems which can be taken one by one and which will be taken one by one, not only by the local authorities but by ourselves. I submit to the Deputy that we have here all the powers that will enable us to do everything he wants. The Minister has power to make regulations requiring local authorities to keep necessary records up to date. We have power to see that they will envisage their problems as a whole and make the necessary plans to deal with them. We have power to make them do so explicitly wherever in our opinion there has been failure.
Comment on this
Where is the power to compel the local authority to carry out a housing scheme if they fail to do so on their own initiative?
Comment on this
If we get into the position that there is a serious housing problem that the local authority will not deal with, no statutory provisions that we might have would help us really effectively to get after that, and I would sooner in these circumstances operate the powers of dissolving the local authority that was not attending to its statutory duties and putting in a Commissioner or a Commission to deal with the matter. Anything else would only mean friction, want of economy in facing a problem, want of efficiency in envisaging it and carrying it out. While I do not at all see anything like that, I can see dangers. If a local authority, having an obligation under the Housing Act of 1919, fails to carry out that obligation, we can mandamus them to do it.
Comment on this
What is their obligation apart from the obligation of making inquiries into housing conditions?
Comment on this
At the present moment, under the Labourers' Cottages Acts, we can put in a commissioner without disturbing the local sanitary authority from its ordinary sphere of duties. I think we could put in, for the specific purpose of dealing with housing under the Labourers Acts, a commissioner to carry out the scheme and then charge that scheme to the local authority.
Comment on this
The Minister is missing the point. He has talked about superseding a local authority which fails in its duty. As far as housing is concerned, the local authority has certain powers for the purpose of dealing with it. I do not think it is under any direct statutory obligation to provide proper housing accommodation in its area. I agree that Deputy O'Kelly's amendment does not provide any such obligation. But it does say that the housing authority shall review the position in its area, and, when the Minister requires it, it should state what it proposes to do in the way of housing for the working classes. That would enable the force of public opinion to operate on the members of the council.
Comment on this
Section 27 and Section 42 provide ample facilities for finding out the position as to housing in the area, but Deputy O'Kelly's amendment suggests that in addition to these sections it should be incumbent on the housing authorities to furnish the Minister with a statement as to the plans for dealing with the condition of housing in the district, so that the Minister will know if the local housing authority has met its obligation in that respect, and so, too, that the public in the district itself will have the required information.
Comment on this
There is nothing in Deputy O'Kelly's amendment that gives the Minister specific powers to make the local authority carry out a housing scheme.
Comment on this
I would prefer if that were possible that there should be power. What the amendment proposes is that the Minister will require the local authority to state definitely what it is going to do, so that the Minister will know and the public will know that it is dealing with its responsibility in that regard. Personally I would prefer that the Minister would have power to compel the local authority to carry out its obligation in this respect.
Comment on this
I think the Minister's own section is stronger than the amendment put forward by Deputy O'Kelly. The section in the Bill says that it shall be the duty of the local authority to cause an inspection of its district. I take it under Section 27 the Minister decides when the time is to be. That section makes it mandatory to supply that information. The section says "It shall be the duty of the local authority and every officer of the local authority to comply with such regulations, and to keep such records as the Minister may prescribe."
Comment on this
We are not proposing to delete that section. We propose to give him additional powers by this new sub-section. If the Minister does not want it we will not force it upon him. I do not think we could because we have not enough votes here to carry it.
Comment on this
It would strengthen the Minister's hands and the hands of the Department, and it would help to keep the position before the public if this amendment were passed. The amendment makes it mandatory on the housing authority. The Minister is taking powers under Sections 27 and 42 to get certain information as and when the spirit moves him. The spirit might not move some Ministers very often. They might not be anxious for additional work. The Department might think they had enough work on hands, but this amendment would make it mandatory that, at least every five years, to supply returns and detailed reports on the housing proposals during the five next succeeding years, as to what was to be done in certain areas; and these proposals would be sent to the Minister's Department. In my humble opinion that would be an advantage.
Comment on this
I shudder as to the possibilities one can envisage here from the point of view of the Department. I do not know whether we are to carry out every fifth year something like the ten year census such as was carried out in 1926. We have a volume there dealing with housing. I can see a pile of statistics and figures coming in on top of the Department dealing with every sanitary area in the country, coming into a place where there are already a terrible lot of papers and not enough waste paper baskets.
Comment on this
It applies to urban areas. I am also afraid that to ask the Department to sit down facing such a load of statistics and passing them in review would result in blinding them and interfering with the work in getting on with the housing question area by area. I am afraid that the figures and papers involved would really only blind us to the work that we should be getting through month after month and year after year. Deputies should remember that it is already in the Minister's power to ask for a scheme. Under the Housing Act of 1929, which I say is the foundation of the powers that we have here, it is the duty of the local authority of every urban district or town to consider the needs of that district or town with respect to the provision of houses for the working classes. It is their duty to prepare and submit schemes for the exercise of their powers. The schemes shall specify the approximate number of houses, the nature of such houses, the amount of land required and the time necessary to carry the scheme into effect. We are providing our own way for getting information. The local authority has already as its duty the submitting of a scheme when asked for a scheme, so that we there really cover the point that the Deputy is concerned about in this amendment. It is really that we want in a practical way to approach the problem, to deal, in a step by step way, with the general problem of each area, rather than have a five years' review.
Comment on this
I do not wish to press the matter. I should like, however, to say, in reply to the Minister's statement where he talks of showers of statistics being fired at the heads of the Department, that there is nothing in the amendment asking for such. It asks for a general statement of the measures which the housing authority is to take during the following five years. There is nothing about statistics in that at all. All that is asked is a general statement of the housing conditions in the area and a statement of what they propose to do. If that is not practical work I do not know what practical work is.
Comment on this
The Minister has made adequate provision in his own Bill to get himself blinded with statistics.
Comment on this
I move amendment 16:
In sub-section (1), line 14, after the word "into" to insert the words "either before or" and to delete all after the word "implied" in line 23 to the word "and" in line 24.
This section provides that a landlord shall keep a house in all respects reasonably fit for human habitation. I cannot understand why that should only apply to houses in which the contract is entered into after the passing of the Act. Why should not that apply to houses where the contract is entered into before or after the passing of the Act? It seems to me only reasonable that the obligation should be on the landlord. To my mind there is a danger that by putting it in this way and applying it to contracts entered into after the passing of the Act, there will be an assumption that it does not apply to houses where the contract is entered into before that, although there is undoubtedly and ought to be an implication. I do not know whether it is already the law, but it is implied, in any case, that the obligation already rested on the landlord. The fact that a tenant rents a house to live in would mean that there was an obligation on the landlord to keep it in a habitable state for him. Objection might be made to making this retrospective, but we have many precedents in this House for doing that. In any case, it seems to me that that is a condition which ought to apply in the case of every rented house.
Comment on this
I am opposing the amendment, because we put in here a definite provision that will enable us to operate generally the provisions of this Bill. There may be many houses as to which definite contracts have been entered into already, and it would be dangerous perhaps to introduce a provision that would affect contracts already entered into.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that in most of the agreements there is a provision whereby the landlord keeps the house externally in repair, and the tenant internally? I do not know how Deputy O'Connell hopes to meet that difficulty in his amendment. It appears to me that he wants to throw the whole obligation, notwithstanding an agreement to the contrary, on the landlord.
Comment on this
Surely there is an implied obligation on the part of the landlord that the house will be in a habitable condition. What I fear is the danger that this section may be used to show that there is no obligation, implied or otherwise, on the landlord to keep a house in habitable condition unless a contract is entered into after the passing of the Act.
Comment on this
If the landlord entered into an arrangement with the tenant, and part of the contract with the tenant was that the tenant is to keep the house fit for human habitation, then it is the tenant's responsibility.
Comment on this
You are not allowing him to do that in future, notwithstanding any stipulation to the contrary.
Comment on this
"Provided that the condition and undertaking aforesaid shall not be implied when a house is let for a term of not less than three years upon the terms that it be put by the lessee into a condition reasonably fit for habitation...." You are enabling landlords to contract with future tenants to take this responsibility on themselves. We do not know what kind of a contract we might be infringing if we made the section retrospective.
Comment on this
I am wondering is there a weakness in the last lines of the section and is there a danger that they might lower the standard of housing in a particular area. There may be an area where the by-laws have been disregarded or neglected and not put into operation and in that way the general standard of housing accommodation may have fallen rather low. That would have to be taken into account in deciding whether or not a house is fit for human habitation. You might have the position that in Ballinasloe a house would be deemed to be fit for human habitation which would be condemned in Mullingar. I think there is that possibility in setting out here that the general standard of housing accommodation for the working classes in such a district will be taken into account. There is a possibility that where all the houses are bad a house that in another district would be deemed to be unfit for human habitation would be accepted as being fit for human habitation just because the other houses were almost equally bad.
Comment on this
I take it the general purpose is to limit the discretion of the local authority in determining whether a house is fit for human habitation. If the section were deleted would it mean that it would be at the absolute discretion of the local authority to say whether a particular house or a number of houses was unfit for human habitation? If so, I think the section should be deleted.
Comment on this
I think that it is a reasonable indication to local authorities in the case, say, of a particular house that is proposed to be condemned that it puts a kind of limit on their requiring the owner to go above a particular standard, if they are content to allow a particular standard to exist as a fair standard in an area. I think it is reasonable that local authorities should proceed in a sensible way, and that it is not necessarily any restriction on them. The section perhaps does not definitely apply, but I feel that it suggests a restriction on them in requiring an owner to raise the standard of his house, say, above the general standard.
Comment on this
Would it be open to the owner of a house to contest a demolition order on the ground that the dwelling was in accord with the standard of housing accommodation for the working classes in that district?
Comment on this
That presupposes that the general standard is satisfactory, whereas it might be unsatisfactory.
Comment on this
In dealing with a district as a whole, where unsatisfactory conditions exist it is a question of a clearance order. Even where conditions are bad enough to require a clearance order, the local authorities under the Bill have to show the Minister that they are able to provide for the rehousing of the people whom they propose to displace, and that their resources are capable of doing it. So that we have to measure the improvements which we want to bring about by our resources to bring about these improvements. Unsatisfactory housing conditions will naturally exist in some places until we have the resources to deal with them.
Comment on this
That is why I am objecting to the section. I shall give an example. There was a sketch published in one of the papers of an area which the Dublin Corporation contemplated clearing under this Bill when passed. It included one side of Gloucester Street and did not include the other. Could the owner of a house or houses on that side of Gloucester Street which it was intended to include in the clearance order object on the grounds that the standard of housing conditions for the working classes in that district was the standard set by his houses, and point to the other side of Gloucester Street as an example?
Comment on this
No, because in the first place it is not to a court that they will have to prove that.
Comment on this
In so far as a clearance area would be concerned, it is not a court but the Minister who would have the power to confirm that order and there would be an appeal to a court as to whether the Minister had exceeded his powers under the Act.
Comment on this
I would prefer to have it left to the absolute discretion of the local authority subject to the Minister but I am afraid this section introduces another principle that would permit an appeal from the Minister.
Comment on this
Perhaps we might let this stand until the Report Stage and we will have the matter considered. The only objection to letting this section stand is that it might prejudice a local authority in declaring a clearance area, in ordering a person to destroy a house because it is unfit for human habitation or to repair it— principally destruction.
Comment on this
This section provides that where buildings included in a clearance area are used for trade or business reasonable compensation may be paid to the person carrying on that trade or business on the ground of disturbance. In the event of the business being a licensed business and the destruction of the premises involving the cancellation of the licence what would the position be? As far as I know the obligation imposed upon the local authority under the British Act was that if that should take place they should procure a licence for such licensee in another area. I am now on the ground of compensation and I want to know on what ground could compensation be assessed in the event of the licence being taken away under a demolition order under the Act.
Comment on this
There is no discrimination between licensed trade or grocery business or butchers business.
Comment on this
Would there be any prospect of the local authority being required to pay heavy compensation on the grounds that not merely was there disturbance but that there was the definite loss of licence, which would be very serious for the trader concerned?
Comment on this
I think it is meant to be in the discretion of the local authority, subject to the consent of the Minister, that any compensation would be paid.
Comment on this
That is the point. I agree with Deputy Lemass that this ought to be more clearly defined in the section than it is. What it would mean in practice would be that when a local authority cleared an area and provided people with alternative accommodation there would be immediate claims for compensation. People would claim that they were entitled to compensation for being removed from one house in one area to another house, apart from the licence.
Comment on this
The great difficulty arises in connection with the licensed trade. You take a person with a huckster's shop or a small grocery business and put him into another premises in another area, he loses nothing except the cost of removal, but a licensed trader is not in that position; his licence is extinguished.
Comment on this
According to the section as it reads now, everybody is entitled to compensation, which might involve a very large sum of money, and that is very dangerous.
Comment on this
Is there an appeal to the court in the case cited by Deputy Lemass, that is, the case of the licensed trader? It is a good while ago since any case of that kind came under my notice, but many years ago cases of the kind did come under my notice in connection with the clearances of areas in Dublin. If I am not mistaken, some very heavy compensation had to be paid for one or two licences in the clearing of the area now known as Foley Street. If that same procedure were carried out now it would be another means of blocking the clearance of areas, because it would make the business entirely too costly. Even as the law will be after the passing of this Act, clearances of certain areas in Dublin will be very costly, even though additional powers are given. But if added to that there will have to be heavy compensation paid in the case of licensed traders for the extinction of licences attached to certain premises, local authorities will have to consider for a very long time whether they will move in the matter of clearing such areas or not.
Comment on this
The section deals entirely with unfit buildings. When we take into consideration the additional amendment we have introduced with regard to compensation in respect of the clearance of areas, and brought it into line with what was contemplated in regard to derelict areas, the compensation payable is the value of the site less the clearance, and that is all that is to be paid. Any additional payment made under this section is payment at the discretion of the local authority. The buildings that are referred to are buildings that are unfit and condemned to demolition. It is really only precautionary. Probably there may be some business buildings in that condition, including licensed houses, but the number is very limited. So far as the money has to be paid outside what is awarded as compensation on the basis that I suggest, it is entirely at the local authority's discretion and with the Minister's consent.
Comment on this
I am not so sure. We had the matter of the exact significance of the meaning of the word "may" in a discussion on the Mines and Minerals Bill the other day, and the Minister for Industry and Commerce told us that he was assured by his draftsman it would in many cases have the effect of "shall." I certainly think in this case "may" will have the effect of "shall," and a person claiming compensation can sue the local authority for it.
Comment on this
Personally I think it should be "shall." I think the trader is entitled to compensation when the local authority takes action which results in his being removed out of the place in which he had his house of business, but I am particularly anxious that the amount of compensation the local authority would have to pay should be determined in accordance with definite rules, and that the amount should not be excessive, because whatever the cost involved is it would have to be recovered from rents or rates on the premises. Special provision was made to deal with the licensed trade under the English Act. Deputy O'Kelly mentioned the fact that under previous clearance schemes carried out in Dublin the compensation that had to be paid to licensed traders was very heavy. The same circumstances may arise again. If some scheme could be devised whereby persons carrying on the licensed trade in an area that had to be cleared could be provided with a licence for a building in another part of the city compensation, or at any rate compensation to the same extent, would not be involved.
Comment on this
I would hesitate very much to saddle a definite duty upon the local authorities of paying for the expenses of removing people from unfit and insanitary areas to other accommodation which the local authority had actually provided.
Comment on this
When it is a question of a person who is in business in an insanitary area, and in a house that is condemned as insanitary, I cannot imagine definite rules upon which the local authority would base the amount of compensation they are going to give for disturbance. I feel that it would be very questionable whether we ought to put a definite duty upon them. After all the local authority is there to look after the general interests of the people, so that it is really a matter of examining the circumstances of a particular person and, to a certain extent, giving a fair public-opinion estimate of what a person so disturbed should get. However you qualify "may" I think it might be safely left to the local authority because the whole circumstances are too problematical and perhaps hypothetical to warrant our being rigid. So that subject to any conclusion we might come to as to the doubts that might be drawn around "may" I would like to leave the section so that a local authority, at its discretion, could pay this particular class of expense and compensation. I do not think we could draw the matter any more tightly.
Comment on this
I agree with the Minister that the section as drawn should be allowed to remain, and I agree with him that the amount granted by the local authority under it cannot be very great, in view of the fact that it is laid down here that the removal of the people is to be from premises which are incapable of being rendered fit for human habitation, and that "such reasonable allowance as they think fit towards his expenses in removing" should be made. That seems reasonable but we had better keep in mind what may arise as a result of it. The individual occupier of, say, licensed premises will not get very much in the way of allowance when removing from premises that are condemned. He will have to remove somewhere, but the case is bound to be made that he is losing something that was necessary for his livelihood. It is not like the case of an ordinary tenant being moved from one house to another.
The licensed trader is being forced, against his will probably, to move out of business premises from which he has derived his livelihood, and he cannot be moved into other licensed premises. He may be able to get such premises, but it does not follow that he will. It may be possible that a court would determine, although there is no mention of it in the Bill, that such a person is entitled to have that fact taken into consideration, and to have an allowance made to him of the value of his licence, because it was his means of livelihood, and because there is no provision in this Bill—as there is in the English Bill—for giving such licence holder another licence elsewhere. I think it is reasonable to think that the court would take that into consideration, and might put a high valuation on the extinguished licence, because it was the means of livelihood of the individual from whom it was forcibly taken. I think the Minister should discuss that question with his Department, to see if it is necessary to bring cases of that kind specifically into the Bill. In one of the largest areas in Dublin, which might be called a clearance or an unhealthy area, I am strongly inclined to think that there would be licensed premises, the value of which would probably run into three figures. If the danger I see of heavy assessments of compensation for removal of these licensed premises being inflicted on the local authorities is realised, the cost of clearance in that area would be tremendous.
Comment on this
I am of opinion that under the common law, people who are disturbed in their business would be entitled, notwithstanding this Bill, to go to the court, and to get a certain amount of compensation. I do not think it is wise to bring into the Bill a provision that there should be an allowance paid to people removed from one house to another. I am sure that I am right in assuming that the house such a person would be sent to would be a better house. That should be compensation enough. In my opinion, if this is left in the Bill the powers given to local authorities might be abused, because the expenses of removal would have to be placed against the new scheme of housing that the people were going into, and in some way be a charge on the rents. It would be as broad as it is long. It is undesirable to suggest that an allowance should be given to people who are being transferred from a house in a slum area to a better house. In itself that is compensation enough. From what I know of local authorities I do not think it is wise to leave such power in the Bill, as hours might be spent discussing the amount of compensation that should be given. I think the power given is dangerous, and that the provision should be deleted.
Comment on this
Deputy Corish hit the nail on the head. Any disturbance that will be caused will be in the interests of the tenants themselves. There seems to be some case for the licensed trader, and perhaps the Minister will consider his position. I think Deputy Corish is right in saying that he will have a claim in common law.
Comment on this
I am not sure that there could be any claim in common law if a local authority, responsible for sanitary conditions in an area, comes along and says, "This house must be destroyed and the site cleared in order to make it sanitary." If there is common law to that effect, I do not know if it would be our desire to interfere with it. The implication of this section is that there is no such common law bearing on the situation. We may take it that for the purpose of this discussion there is no such common law doctrine. We are destroying an insanitary area. It is simply a contingency, more unlikely than likely, that there is a business place in it unfit to be left standing. The compensation that is going to be paid for premises according to this Bill is the value of the cleared site, less the cost of clearing it. That is the only money that is going to be paid for that site by the local authority, if it purchases it. If instead of clearing it itself, the local authority may say, "This is an insanitary area. I want you to clear that house." Having carried out that order, the owner of the site has the site, but he has less in cash by the amount of money which it cost to clear the site. This section gives the local authority discretion to pay such reasonable allowance as they think fit, with the consent of the Minister, towards the cost which, in their opinion, he will sustain by reason of disturbance of his trade or business.
Comment on this
Does the consent of the Minister apply to each case, or does it apply to the whole scheme?
Comment on this
It applies to allowances paid for disturbance in trade or business. The other matter is left to the local authority because it would be small in amount. What we have to decide is whether the local authority should have any power in such a case to make allowance.
Comment on this
If you interfere with their trade or business, it is all right, but the other question is different and I am afraid it will lead to abuse.
Comment on this
Do I understand then that Deputies think that we ought to take out removal expenses?
Comment on this
Yes. From what I know of local authorities, I think that provision will lead to abuse.
Comment on this
We are not imposing on the local authority any duty to do this but we leave it to their discretion in circumstances where they think it is reasonable to make payment.
Comment on this
The difficulty is that the local authority having power, it will be practically impossible to refuse to exercise it.
Comment on this
Once this is mentioned in any section of the Act, it will be incumbent on the local authority to enforce it in respect of everybody who leaves a house in a clearance area. I suggest that any decent-minded person will be desirous of getting out of a slum area and that he will be sufficiently compensated if he gets into a new house. I am afraid the provision will lead to abuse.
Comment on this
I would risk leaving the provision in and giving the discretion to the local authority. This will be always subject to the approval of the Minister.
Comment on this
If the Minister found that the amounts paid in some cases were high, he would take steps to ensure that that would not happen again. The matter would come under the notice of the Department, and the local authority would be informed that the Department would not give its sanction to such a high scale of allowance in future. I am still worried by the question of licensed traders. I do not know that I should be regarded as a defender of the licensed trade, but I am satisfied that under this section demands will be made on the Dublin Corporation for what some people might regard as extravagant allowances, because of the forced removal of persons occupying licensed premises, this removal following upon a clearance order. I have in mind a very wide area in the constituency of the Minister and myself. It extends from Gardiner Street down to the North Strand and from the quays up to Summerhill. All that area is not an unhealthy area, but a very big portion of it is. There are very wide areas within these boundaries that will probably, at some future date, be cleared as unhealthy.
Within that area and the sub-areas included within its boundary, there are a very large number of licensed premises. The owners of these premises are to be paid, with the consent of the Minister, a reasonable allowance towards the loss which a trader will sustain by reason of the disturbance of his trade consequent on his having to quit the house or building. In estimating the loss, regard is to be had to the period for which the premises might reasonably have been expected to be available for the purpose of the trade or business. That may or may not be long but efforts will be made to make the amount the local authority might think reasonable such a sum as would cover the value of the licensed premises. In so far as the amount of compensation or allowance is increased, the cost of clearing the area will be increased. The cost in such an area as I have mentioned will be very considerable indeed. If this cost were added to the other costs of the clearance, the amount would be very high and the consequent loss on any housing scheme afterwards engaged in by the local authority would be very high. Some provision is necessary to deal with cases of that kind— either a provision making licences available elsewhere or a provision for the retention of a certain number of the licences in the area. If we are to prevent extravagant claims and heavy cost being placed on the local authority, which cost will fall upon the ratepayers later, some provision such as I have suggested is necessary.
Comment on this
The Deputy is going on the assumption that houses would come into a clearance scheme which, in fact, would not come in because they would not be in the condition that they would be marked down for destruction. As regards the acquiring of land for the purpose of development, where houses might be cleared that were not actually condemned, compensation payable in these cases would be fixed by an assessor. The trade or business premises that might be involved in one of these clearance schemes where houses would be marked down as unfit for habitation would be more of the little huckster type, with a couple of bottles of lemonade in the window, or the coal shop type, or something like that. Local authorities would not, I think, be confronted with the question of allowance for disturbance in the case of a licensed premises of any reasonable kind.
Comment on this
I move amendment 17:
In sub-section (2), line 38, to delete the word "temporarily."
I have put down the amendment primarily for the purpose of eliciting some information from the Minister as to his policy in regard to open spaces, particularly in the cities. This section, as Deputies will see, deals with the acquisition of derelict sites. The first sub-section gives a local authority power to acquire, either by agreement with the consent of the Minister or compulsorily, a derelict site, notwithstanding that such site is required for such purpose. Sub-section (2) goes on to say that a derelict site so acquired by a local authority may, "with the consent of the Minister, pending its ultimate appropriation for the purpose for which it was acquired, be used temporarily by the local authority as a playground or recreation ground for persons of the working classes and other persons." I want to call attention to the wording of this. If Deputies look at Section 38 they will see that there power is given, among other things, to the local authority "to provide and maintain, with the consent of the Minister and, if desired, jointly with any other person in connection with any such housing accommodation, ...any playgrounds or recreation grounds, open spaces or other buildings or land which, in the opinion of the Minister, will serve a beneficial purpose in connection with the requirements of the persons for whom the housing accommodation is provided."
There are two distinctions between these two sections. One is that, in the first case the provision is temporary, and in the second it is permanent. In the first case, the provision is to be general for persons of the working classes and other persons, and in the other section permanent provision is made, but the provision there is restricted to the persons for whom the housing accommodation is provided. I think I follow the idea of the Minister, but I would like to get from him a statement as to what exactly he has in his mind here. It is not very clear to me why there is a distinction in the two clauses between the classes of persons for whom accommodation is provided. I do not attach any particular importance to the word "temporarily" one way or the other. It is clear that if that went out other things would have to go out. I just take it as a convenient peg to hang a discussion on for the purpose of eliciting information from the Minister as to what he has in his mind in this connection.
Comment on this
There is nothing vital in putting in the word "temporarily" there. It is put in as a precautionary measure. The idea is that derelict sites may be cleared for the purposes of Part III of the Act of 1890. They may be cleared, even though the local authority is not prepared to go on with a housing scheme right away. There may be a danger if this was used as a playground for the public, that the public might acquire a right of way that would interfere with the local authority if it wanted to use that playground afterwards for the purposes of a housing scheme. The word "temporarily" is supposed to introduce a precaution there.
Comment on this
But take it the other way, that the local authority wished, later on, to keep it as a playground would there be anything to prevent their doing so?
Comment on this
There will be nothing to prevent a playground being set aside as a playground in connection with a housing scheme decided on for a derelict site. It is not the intention that the local authority will set out and clear derelict sites for housing purposes, and then not go ahead with their housing schemes.
Comment on this
It might easily happen on reconsideration, when they came to plan out the whole area, that they might find that a particular site or sites could be more usefully employed for a playground than for building.
Comment on this
In that case they would actually be making use of the ground for the purposes set out in Part III.
Comment on this
Is it necessary to have that invidious condition in the section "working classes and other persons"?
Comment on this
It need not be restricted to working classes. In this case the whole housing code is a housing code for the working classes.
Comment on this
I move amendment 18:
To delete sub-section (3) and substitute therefore the following sub-section:—
"(3) Where a local authority acquire compulsorily a derelict site for any of the purposes of the Housing of the Working Classes Acts the compensation to be paid by the local authority in respect of the acquisition of such site shall be assessed in accordance with the provisions contained in Part I of the Third Schedule to this Act and, subject as aforesaid, shall be assessed in accordance with the Acquisition of Land (Assessment of Compensation) Act, 1919, as amended by the Acquisition of Land (Reference Committee) Act, 1925 (No. 22 of 1925)."
Elsewhere, in response to representations from the City Corporation, we change the compensation in respect to clearance areas. Originally the compensation to be paid was the value of the sites cleared. On representations made it is reasonable to consider that the compensation paid should be the value of the site cleared, less the cost of removing the buildings. The Third Schedule is, by amendment, altered so as to indicate that that will be the compensation. The result is that the lines upon which compensation will be determined will be the same for a derelict site as for a clearance area. Instead of putting in there the special way in which compensation would be determined in respect to derelict sites, we simply refer to the derelict site section in the same way as we refer to the clearance area section to the Third Schedule.
Comment on this
I move amendment 20:
To delete sub-section (4) and substitute the following sub-section:—
(4) For the purposes of this section the expression "derelict site" means any land situate in an area inhabited mainly by persons of the working classes or in close proximity to such an area which is
(a) the site of a building that has been demolished or which is in a ruinous and uninhabitable condition; or
(b) land which has not been and cannot be built upon without clearance and levelling and is or is likely to become in such a state as to be a nuisance or injurious to health by reason of the deposit thereon of filth, rubbish or other insanitary matters or otherwise; and
(c) which is land which has been lying undeveloped or not re-developed for a period of not less than three years from the time at which the local authority determine by resolution to acquire the land.
This amendment meets the intention of amendment 19. I ask leave of the House to amend this amendment by reason of the fact that the word "from" in the third line of paragraph (c) may give rise to a certain amount of ambiguity. I ask the leave of the House to delete the word "from," and to substitute the words "immediately preceding."
The paragraph will then read:
(c) which is land which has been lying undeveloped or not re-developed for a period of not less than three years immediately preceding the time at which the local authority determine by resolution to acquire the land.
Comment on this
I move amendment 21:
In sub-section (1), line 26, to insert the word "Act" after the word "this".
This is just a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment 22:
In page 24, to delete sub-section (6) and substitute therefor the following sub-section:—
"(6) Section 17 of the Housing (Ireland) Act, 1919, which confers powers on the Commissioners of Public Works in Ireland to make loans to private persons shall become a permanent enactment and any provision in any Act in force at the date of the passing of this Act which limits the period for which the said section is to remain in force shall cease to have effect."
This is an attempt to meet the House to some extent in eliminating the matter of the Expiring Laws Bill. This section is continued under the Expiring Laws Bill year after year and we are making it permanent here.
Comment on this
I move amendment 23:
In page 24 to insert before Section 51 a new section, as follows:—
"Where a local authority acquire compulsorily any house which is suitable or might be made suitable for persons of the working classes for the purposes of Part III. of the Act of 1890, as amended by any subsequent enactment including this Act, the compensation payable in respect thereof shall be assessed in accordance with the provisions contained in Part II. of the Third Schedule to this Act."
Part II. of the Third Schedule makes it clear that when a house is compulsorily acquired in an area, not being a clearance area, in making an award in respect of the compensation that will be paid for it and in taking into consideration the rents, etc., received out of it, the arbitrator will take into consideration whether the house has been used illegally or in an overcrowded way. It also provides that the arbitration will be based on a consideration of what the rent would be if the house were not used for illegal purposes or were not overcrowded.
Comment on this
I move amendment 24:
At the end of sub-section (1), to insert a new paragraph (e) as follows:—
(e) In lieu of an advance in cash an advance under these Acts as amended by this Act may be made to a public utility society on behalf of a person or persons qualified to receive an advance by means of a supply of materials suitable for the construction of houses and when the local authority decide that an advance shall be made in the form of material such advance may be made as soon as the local authority is satisfied that such material will be used for the purpose stated in the application for an advance.
This amendment seeks to empower local authorities to make advances of building materials to a public utility society. I might say that it has been put down in response to representations which we received from groups of workers. It has been pointed out that it might be possible to find a group of workers who would be anxious to erect one, two or three houses for themselves, men who would be engaged in their ordinary work in the building industry and who would do this in their spare time. If they were to take advantage of the Act they would require a certain amount of capital, in any case, to go on with, but, as the Bill stands at the moment, the advances are made only to them by instalments. It is to be assumed that a certain amount of the work would have to be done before they could get any payment. The point is that they would want capital right from the beginning, and it is thought that if the materials were made available to them it would facilitate them in their desire to get on with the erection of the houses. The argument might well be put forward, that if you were to advance cash right from the beginning, you would not be quite sure that the cash would be used for the purpose for which it was intended. That is the reason why the advance is only made when a certain amount of work is done. That is the difficulty we require to get over by this proposal, namely, that an authority will be in a position to advance building materials to a group of workers, who are prepared, and who satisfy the local authority in that way, to take on the building of a few houses for themselves.
I think it would be found, assuming that the case were made that the labour will cost half and the materials half, that the advance would only require to be 50 per cent. whereas the Act would allow a much bigger advance if the advance were to be made in cash. As I say, the amendment is put down at the request of groups of workers in the building trade, so that it might be possible for a group of men to organise the building of a few houses for themselves if they had this facility. It is thought too that this would be an economical way of dealing with the matter, because the local authority might be in a position, especially a local authority engaged in large building schemes, to supply materials much more cheaply than the people themselves could get them if the cash were advanced to them, and if they had to purchase them themselves. So far as the actual wording of the amendment is concerned we are not tied to it. It is quite possible that the amendment might require redrafting, but we would like the Minister to consider the principle of the amendment favourably, and have it or something like it inserted in the Bill.
Comment on this
As far as public utility societies are concerned they do not come under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act at all They are enabled to get money under the Housing (Ireland) Act of 1919, so we are really dealing with private persons. A private person proposes to acquire a house, and he applies to a local authority for an advance under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act. Let us say the advance is going to be £450. That advance is going to be repaid over a certain number of years. Deputy O'Connell's amendment is to the effect that the local authority will supply him with a certain amount of building material, and a certain amount of cash.
Comment on this
Surely under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act we make provision for it here. Let us speak of private persons, because public utility societies are different. They are going to build a certain number of houses. If the advantage of the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act is going to be given—let us say 75 per cent. or 80 per cent., in fact, the local authority is able to give an advance of 90 per cent. of the houses as valued, the 90 per cent. of the houses as valued cannot be advanced to the private person in materials. The purpose is to help private persons by advancing up to, not necessarily 90 per cent., because the local authority can say as a matter of policy: "We will give 80 per cent. or 75 per cent.," but they are empowered to give 90 per cent. of what you call the capital value of the house. They take that money on an undertaking to repay. I do not see how the advance of that money can be made effective to a private person or to a public utility society under the 1929 Act, where they get 75 per cent. of the value of the house. I do not see how you can mix up materials in the matter of a loan. The materials cannot cover the whole lot.
Comment on this
Surely it is not essential that the whole lot must be covered.
Comment on this
That is what I understood, that they must have a certain amount of material and a certain amount of cash.
Comment on this
My amendment reads:
"(e) In lieu of an advance in cash an advance under these Acts as amended by this Act may be made to a public utility society on behalf of a person or persons qualified to receive an advance by means of a supply of material."
Let us take a group of people who want to build four houses for themselves. They are building trade workers who are prepared to work in the summer evenings in their spare time. If you give them cash, very well, but the point is that cash cannot be advanced at all. Cash will only be advanced to them when a certain amount of the work is completed. They are not in a position to raise any capital to begin the work without help, and what I suggest here is that they should be facilitated by having the materials at their disposal in lieu of cash. Give them cash if you wish, but of course objection will immediately be made with regard to the advance of cash. We have no assurance that they will use the cash to build the houses. That objection will be legitimately made. It is the general principle that a cash advance is made only when a certain amount of the building work is completed. If these men are able to work up the material themselves a group of them may co-operate to build five or six houses. They may not require any more than just the materials. That is the suggestion made in the amendment.
Comment on this
This amendment has been put down at the express desire of some bricklayers, carpenters and people of that kind, and I cannot personally see the objection on the part of the Minister to giving material instead of cash. Of course it must be distinctly remembered that in sub-section (c) it says "the total advance at any time is not to exceed 50 per cent. of the value of the work done." That means that these people would only be getting their money in dribs and drabs and would not be in a position to purchase materials economically. I think it ought to be the desire to secure that these people would be able to buy materials as cheaply as possible. The Minister ought seriously to consider going into the matter between now and the Report Stage. When you get people who are desirous of building houses for themselves and prepared to put their own labour into it, I believe they should get some encouragement further than the encouragement given in this Bill.
Comment on this
Might I point out that I cannot see the difference. I listened very attentively to what Deputy O'Connell has stated, but I cannot see the difference between advancing money and advancing materials. Materials are practically money. If there is no security for the advance of the money, where is the security for the advance of the materials? Deputy O'Connell says that if this money is advanced there is no security that the money will be applied to the building of a house. What is the security if building material is given? Building material is money at any time. Besides, if people steal building material there are always people who will buy it. It seems to me there are more difficulties here than there are in connection with cash. As far as I can see, the cash would be more useful to the man, because he can get materials when he needs them. It is what Deputy O'Connell is always arguing—bulk purchase. Many sites will not hold sufficient material for a house. You want it coming in at intervals. I cannot see the difference between money and materials, and I see much greater difficulties in connection with materials than money.
Comment on this
These people would not be in a position to get cash.
Comment on this
When they use up material to a certain point equivalent to half the value of the house, how are they going to get on?
Comment on this
The point is you must get some cash before you can provide materials. You cannot do work if you have no material. Surely some kind of an inspector would see that things would not be done as loosely as that.
Comment on this
The Deputy seems to forget that there must be security for the advance. Where the money is directly advanced there must be security for it. If it is advanced through the medium of materials will he show me where there is any security for the money the local authority has put into materials?
Comment on this
The Deputy who put forward this amendment argues that a man must have some capital to put up a certain amount of building before he can get an advance. In other words there must be security before he can get the money. If the money is to be turned into materials, where is the security for the local authority?
Comment on this
I would wish that generally or even in a few odd parts of the country Vocational Education Committees' work and other work of that kind had so far advanced that odd groups in our population were so trained that you could hand out building materials to them and that they would go and build their own houses.
Comment on this
The proposal here is that power should be given to local authorities to buy building materials and give them out as a matter of loans to persons who will undertake to put up their own houses. If I can get a proposal from a local authority to that effect I will get it very carefully considered.