In Committee on Finance. - Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill, 1931—Committee.
Contributions 166–330 of 487. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 43 of 1931 ›
But I would not be prepared to take this amendment here without any leading up to it on the part of people in the position of a local authority or without any arguments except those we have heard here.
Comment on this
Is not this portion of the Bill permissive, and the amendment is, therefore, permissive? The Minister has expressed a wish that such groups could be found anywhere as a result of vocational education. This amendment has been put down at the instance of men engaged in the building industry here in Dublin.
Comment on this
It was put down at the instance of trade unions. If Deputy Good is so careful that the interests of the trade unions must be looked after here, I can assure him that it was put down at the instance of the building trades unions, who made representations to us that if they had these facilities they would be in a position to do what the Minister says would be a good thing to be done, not only here but elsewhere.
Comment on this
I am rather afraid to interfere in this dispute, but the idea in the amendment appeals to me very much. It would be a splendid thing if we could give some of our fellow citizens a chance of spending their off hours in very useful as well as interesting pursuits. Deputy Good would see whether they could build better for themselves or for him. I think an experiment might be tried. It is very attractive.
Comment on this
This opens up quite a vista. One sees hundreds of unemployed being trained through our vocational schools and made useful citizens. Any scheme of that kind will have my hearty support.
Comment on this
The idea is not so new as people think. In 1913, a group of unemployed tradesmen in Dublin formed a society on merely nominal shares. They bought material and actually constructed houses. I was a shareholder myself. I was on the committee, and knew the inner working of the scheme. They constructed houses somewhere near Fairview, but then there was an epidemic of wars. We had a few of our own and there was the big war, and these put an end to it.
Comment on this
They did not become bankrupt. I was at the winding-up of the scheme, and know what happened. I do not know whether Deputy Lemass was closely acquainted with it or not— I do not remember meeting him at either the general meetings or the committee meetings. Therefore, the idea is not so new. I know perfectly well that there was good and effective work done, and what we heard so much talk about—good construction.
Comment on this
While I have a great deal of sympathy with the amendment, I think it would be very hard to work such a scheme. After all, a body of men going in for the building of houses must have some little credit in the country, so that they would be in a position to obtain credit from local suppliers. The scheme would be all right if we were sure that the persons who got these materials would use them to the best advantage. Would the Minister agree to the local authority guaranteeing the builders providers that they would be responsible for the payment of the material delivered to such groups of men as Deputy O'Connell speaks of?
Comment on this
Of course men could form themselves into a utility society for the purpose of building houses themselves without first asking for the material. It has been done already. I can quite appreciate the point raised by Deputy O'Connell, that there are certain types of people— bricklayers and carpenters—who would get together and build a few houses if this amendment were passed.
Comment on this
The Minister said that he is prepared to hear any local authority on it. He may hear local authorities on it when this Bill is passed.
Comment on this
I quite realise that I am to hear no local authority on it if this proposal is enshrined in this measure.
Comment on this
It is a bit revolutionary. Following on our general housing policy it is now proposed that local authorities will buy building materials and distribute them as an advance to persons who will go out and build their own houses. The implication is that they have no credit of any kind. What we are providing here is that persons who are going to have their houses built or who are going to build them themselves can be secure that the local authority would advance them at the time the house is built a considerable portion of the cost of the house, and that the local authority may make arrangements to make instalments of the advance to them, but only up to 50 per cent. of the approximate cost of the work that is done. That is a very considerable provision. As I say, the other contemplates a very special class and a very special way of dealing with that class. I wish, particularly in rural parts of the country, that we had circumstances in which a scheme like that were possible of being worked. I would more favourably consider any statement of the circumstances from any local authority that would show that the circumstances were such as to warrant a scheme such as that proposed.
Comment on this
I move amendment 25:
Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
Section 34 of the Housing (Ireland) Act, 1919, is hereby amended by the insertion of twelve hundred pounds in substitution for eight hundred pounds as the limit on the market value of houses in respect of which advances may be made.
I am accepting the Minister's £1,000 instead of £1,200, but I am proposing to put it into Part VI, whereas the Minister, and I think Deputy Morrissey, are proposing to put it into Part VII.
Comment on this
I understood that putting it in there would apply it only to new houses, and that is what I intended to do. The grants would be made only to people intending to construct houses.
I feel it is better that if a capital advance is to be made available it should be made available for the building of new houses. There is not much gained by an advance of capital to transfer the ownership of the house from, say, Deputy Corish to me, whereas, if there is capital advanced to me to build a new house, something new is being created. It seems it would be of greater advantage if it were used only in that way.
Comment on this
There is a difference between the amendment in Deputy O'Connell's name and the amendment in my name. As the Deputy pointed out, under his amendment it would be confined to a new house. My amendment leaves it open to have the advance made either in respect of existing houses or in respect of new houses. I am rather surprised at Deputy O'Connell saying that there is not much to be gained by giving a man an opportunity of becoming the owner of his own house. That is contrary to what the Deputy has always preached.
Comment on this
A man who occupies a house, pays rent to a landlord, and desires to become the owner of the house should get every opportunity of doing so, and for that reason I prefer my own amendment. At the same time I am prepared to accept the Minister's amendment because I think it is a fair compromise. The Minister's amendment, like my own, will enable an advance to be made to the person who builds a house or to the person occupying a house and paying rent for it.
Comment on this
I did not intend to say that it was not very much use. I did say that if it is a question of the use of capital by way of an advance being made by a local authority, I certainly would prefer the advance to be made for the construction of a new house. That would, as it were, add to the wealth of the local authority and it would be preferable to the mere purchase of a house—enabling a man to purchase his house.
Comment on this
The Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act was originally intended to enable people to purchase the houses in which they were living.
Comment on this
This extension covers people building houses, and also bring in the idea of giving them an instalment on the house to the extent of 50 per cent. of the whole of the work done as they go along, in order to help the building of new houses. You would want to have powers to enable people to purchase their houses, because a builder might build a set of houses, and a person might want to buy a house actually built. Strictly speaking, he might not be buying a new house; he would be taking advantage of this Act to get an advance in respect of a house, and clear off his debt with the builder, and the builder would be enabled to go on building new houses. You would want the elasticity that the amendment in the form in which it appears over my name and also Deputy Morrissey's amendment suggests, even to help new buildings.
Comment on this
Can the local authority advance 90 per cent. of £1,000 with absolute security, or is it proposed to reduce that?
Comment on this
I never would like to interfere with the discretion of a local authority. It is their business.
Comment on this
We argued this before, and I tried to convince the President that the local authority should have the discretion.
Comment on this
The Deputy told me that he was learning something about housing on that occasion. Would the Deputy himself be prepared to advance 90 per cent. out of his own pocket?
Comment on this
Well, since this State came into existence. The history of Ireland did not start until two years afterwards.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 26 on behalf of Deputy Law:
In sub-section (2), line 36, to delete the words "hereby repealed" and substitute the words "amended by the substitution of the words ‘one guinea' for the words ‘ten shillings.'"
Comment on this
The amendment introduced here is really meant to meet circumstances that Deputy Law wishes to meet. Under the Registration of Title Act, dwellings acquired through the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act have to be registered. There is a fee prescribed. Land purchased under the Land Acts also requires to have the title registered under the Registration of Title Act. The cost of running the Registration of Title Office is borne by those who get their work done there. When you take into consideration the price people have to pay for registration of title, people who are forced to register their title because they acquired the land under the Land Acts, and when we compare that amount with what people have to pay when registering title, having acquired title with the assistance of the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act, we find that the people who have had their titles registered, having acquired houses under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act, are not paying the actual cost that ought to be paid. The amendment relative to Section 56 (2) sets out the fee of ten shillings. There will, in fact, be substituted for that fee the actual fee that registration of title as a general rule costs as estimated by the office. The fee will be raised. It may not be raised to a guinea, but it will be raised to the amount necessary to pay for the average registration of title. I suggest that Deputy Law's amendment is not necessary.
Comment on this
The local authority have no power to fix the fee. I think it is fixed by the Minister for Finance in consultation with the authorities of the Registration Office.
Comment on this
Will there be any limit to the cost of registration? Would you be prepared to fix five or ten guineas?
Comment on this
There is no reason why people who have their titles registered in this particular way should get specially cheap rates as against people who have to register their title, because they get their property under the Land Acts. It is simply a fair and reasonable way of having the cost borne.
Comment on this
On Section 56 I again want to raise the question that when it was decided to amend the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act, the recommendations of the Town Tenants Commission were not included. If the President does not place any reliance on the recommendations of the Town Tenants Commission, why were not the recommendations submitted on behalf of the Dublin Corporation given consideration?
Comment on this
At the time that this report was made it was the Commissioners who were in charge of the Dublin Corporation. In the report which they submitted, and which was printed as an appendix, they pointed out that: "Before advances can be made it is necessary to obtain from the city architect a certificate as to the soundness of a house, from the sanitary engineer as to its sanitation, and from the valuer as to the market value of a house. The law agent must then investigate the title, and if this is found satisfactory application is made to the Local Government Department for sanction to make the advance.... At any stage in the proceedings above detailed delays are likely to occur, if the premises on which a loan is sought do not comply with the various requirements of the Acts; and in this regard it has been found that the investigation of title and actual closing of the loan are causes of the longest delay... If certain amendments were made in the Small Dwellings Acts it is more than likely that the public would avail of them more fully. With a view to shortening proceedings local authorities might be vested with full powers and discretion in the making of advances to borrowers, independent of the supervision of the Local Government Department, the transactions under the Act being, of course, subject to audit. Furthermore, it may be possible to dispense with the investigation of title by the Land Registry and substitute therefor certificate of a solicitor for local authority. On such issue Land Registry to issue Land Registry certificate. Alternately dispense with examination of title by local authority and make the loan advanceable on the certificate of the Land Registry only. The title could be submitted by the vendor direct to the Registry without the intervention of the solicitor for the local purchaser or the solicitor for the local authority. This would save costs and the delay of two additional investigations of title."
There were some minor recommendations dealing with the procedure for the making of loans under these Acts, which have been proved to be very tedious in operation, and which the Commission state are mainly responsible for the fact that these Acts have not operated to anything like the extent anticipated when they were framed. We are amending and improving the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act. I am anxious to know why these other amendments suggested on behalf of the Town Tenants Commission and the Dublin Corporation were not accepted, that is, those recommendations about transfers. I have personal knowledge that the costs involved in three investigations of title, when the purchase is to be made in accordance with loans under these Acts and loans from an insurance company, were very heavy. I ask if it is not possible to remove these costs from the intending purchaser. If it is possible they should be removed.
Comment on this
This Section 56 is not meant to be an elaborate amendment of the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act. It is simply such an amendment as will enable us to leave moneys free to finance housing in connection with our present housing policy. I cannot say that I investigated all the detailed recommendations put up with a view to seeing to what extent matters may be improved in the procedure. I do not know to what extent these representations refer to any difficulty in getting new houses acquired by persons under the operations of the Act. This provision here is meant to deal with a definite part of our housing policy.
Comment on this
Is it ever intended to give consideration to these recommendations of the Town Tenants Commission?
Comment on this
In so far as they bear on the acquisition of houses, yes. But there is a very wide field in connection with housing that is yet to be reviewed, and I do not pretend to the Deputy that the field covered there has been systematically reviewed.
Comment on this
It seems to me that these Acts, if properly amended, afford an opportunity of dealing with the middle class housing problem without subsidy of any kind. If the Acts are made properly operative you can get houses built, and people installed in them as owners without any subsidy and without imposing any charge on the rates.
Comment on this
We cannot put, as we are likely to be putting, considerable sums of money into housing, particularly when the costs of house building stands as at present, without adequate examination by the local authorities or their proper officers as to the worth and the value of the building. I do not know to what extent examination of title may be shortened and the expenses cut down. The examination of title is a thing that cannot be dispensed with at all.
Comment on this
I would like to suggest that in the matter of the examination of title there is a good deal of unnecessary delay and unnecessary expense. More than what might be called reasonable amounts are paid, and something like profiteering in law does take place in connection with the transfer of houses from public authorities. I think that is a wide field and one into which the Minister might inquire and see whether the transactions cannot be shortened and cheapened.
Comment on this
I would like to know from the Minister whether the advance of fifty per cent. actually referred to the amount of work done exclusive of the quantity of materials on the ground? For instance, it may be that the valuer may see the walls of the house perhaps a few feet high. The cost of that amount of construction may be approximately £30 or £40, but there may be £60 worth of material on the ground. Would not the Minister take that into consideration when making an advance? Similarly the man building houses may have the doors and window frames prepared in his own shop and not on the site. I think that is a matter which the Minister should consider as to how much the valuer should certify for when he comes to inspect the house. The Minister may take that into consideration—whether it is fifty per cent. of the actual amount of work done or fifty per cent. of the actual amount of work done and the materials on the ground.
Comment on this
The actual amount of work done and how much is to be paid for it is entirely a matter for the local authorities. It is the valuer employed by the local authorities who will make the estimate, and, of course, he will have to be paid by the owner of the house. It is entirely a matter for the local authority to assure themselves as to the value of the work done.
Comment on this
They will have complete discretion, and I hope they will use it in a reasonable way, but I do not think it would be reasonable to take into account the cost of material that has been accumulated on the ground. It is only the amount of work done to the house that would count. It is a question that I am sure the local authorities will deal with in a commonsense way.
Comment on this
I move the amendment in Deputy Murphy's name: In line 56 to delete the figures "1932" and to substitute the figures "1933."
I would like the Minister to give this favourable consideration. It proposes to extend the date to February, 1933. It proposes to extend the period by a year. The position, as the Minister knows, is that the Housing Act expired in April of this year. A memorandum was sent out from his Department following the statement he made in this House early in the year, to the effect that if new legislation were introduced and passed in the House during this Autumn Session houses begun since April last would get the subsidy.
Some people had sufficient trust in the Minister to avail of that and to erect a house. These, no doubt, come under the operation of the Act and will qualify for the subsidy. But there are many people who were in very great doubt as to what the position would be, and when they asked if there was a subsidy for a house started, say, in June, July or August, they had to be told that there was no subsidy available. The position is that the Act is extended to February; but there are many people who are anxious to avail of the subsidy and who had not begun their houses, and it would be impossible for them to have their houses completed by next February. If they had begun to build any time from 1st April last they had only the promise of the Minister that if the Government were in power and got a Bill through the houses they had started would get a subsidy. Many of them were not prepared to take that risk and begin the houses unless they were sure that they would get the subsidy. They did not like to speculate. I feel that it would be only fair to extend the period for the completion of a house beyond February in order to give a number of people who are anxious to avail of the subsidy an opportunity to get it.
Comment on this
Section 57 makes available an additional £30,000 which is the sum estimated to be required to make good the promise that we made to pay to private persons building houses between 1st April last and 29th February next a £45 grant. Putting in "1933" here would have no effect, because the £30,000 will be used up on the people building houses within the terms of the promise made.
Comment on this
Has the Minister any knowledge of the number of houses in course of construction on the strength of the promise made?
Comment on this
I have knowledge of the promise made, and the intention is simply to keep that promise.
Comment on this
How can the Minister estimate the amount which may be necessary unless he has some knowledge of the number under construction?
Comment on this
Will the Minister consider extending the period in any case, even if not for a year? I suggest that the question of extending it to June should be considered.
Comment on this
We only intended to provide for those who were then building. If this Bill could have been introduced at the beginning of the year, the £45 grant would have come to an end perhaps earlier than it is coming now. The alternative arrangement of providing £20, plus £20 from the local authority, would come into operation, so that really the persons who are getting the £45 grant under the promise are getting it by way of a windfall, because this legislation was not ready at an earlier date. The amount of money at our disposal is definitely limited, and it was not possible to find more than £30,000 to deal with the promise given. The putting in of these figures here would mean nothing without the provision of additional money, and there is no intention to provide additional money for this superior class of houses.
Comment on this
If the amendment were carried, does it mean that people who built houses and completed them before the 28th February, 1933, that is, a year after the date in the Bill, would have the right to a subsidy?
Comment on this
It all depends on whether the Act in question was one in which the word "may" would have to be read as "shall".
Comment on this
Has the Minister considered how the Housing Acts have worked towards rural districts? No Housing Act ever provided for a grant for repairs to rural houses, and they lend themselves particularly to repairing. Now you are cutting them out, when what has been omitted from other Acts might be extended to them here.
Comment on this
The Deputy is probably referring to the next amendment which, I imagine, is out of order.
Comment on this
The Minister has not given any assurance that he is providing £30,000, for certain, for the carrying out of his promise.
Comment on this
The Minister states that he does not know how many houses are constructed or are likely to be constructed. He does not know but that the £30,000 will be too much to provide, even by extending the period.
Comment on this
I do not need to know exactly how many houses are being constructed. All I need to know is that a promise is made, and that £30,000 will cover that promise. It is only our intention to deal with the promise, and if money can be saved on that £30,000 it will be very badly wanted for other purposes.
Comment on this
But if £30,000 does not cover the number of houses?
Comment on this
Then I shall have to provide more money, because I mean to keep the promise, but I am reasonably sure that £30,000 will cover it.
Comment on this
I came to the conclusion that the Minister had a discretion, and I accepted the amendment for that reason. It appeared to me that the amendment merely extended the period during which the £30,000 could be spent, and that it would be at the discretion of the Minister and on that basis I accepted the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment 29:
In sub-section (1), line 60, before the words "private persons," to insert the words "public utility societies or".
Section 14 of the Housing Act of 1919, to which the Minister has referred, is the foundation of our present housing legislation. You will find that in that Act—and, I think I am right in saying, ever since—provision has been made by way of loan and by way of grants to public utility societies for the erection of houses.
Comment on this
We are on a different point. We are now on the question of grants. Not only was that provision made both by way of grant and by way of loan, but distinct preference was given in the regulations under the Act of 1919 and, I think, ever since to public utility societies, and that, I venture to suggest, is not done without good reason.
Comment on this
I do not like to interrupt the Deputy, but, as Deputy Corish has pointed out, paragraph (e), sub-section (1), Section 60, provides that "in the case of houses erected by a public utility society, the erection of which is begun after the passing of this Act, 15 per cent. of the annual loan charges in respect of such houses covers a period not exceeding twenty years."
The present worth of the annual grant is £45; and if the Deputy will refer to sub-section (c) he will see it is proposed to give public utility societies which are public utility societies within the meaning of the 1919 Act, a grant payable as an annual contribution towards the loan charges equal to the annual grant we are giving a local authority building houses for the working classes, when they are building houses unrelated to clearance schemes. In that section we do provide financial assistance for public utility societies. They can get a loan up to 75 per cent. of the value of the house under the 1919 Act.
Comment on this
I dare say that meets it. I do not know whether the Minister contemplates a lump sum.
Comment on this
It is not a matter with which I am perfectly familiar, but it was suggested to me that there is considerable advantage in enabling public utility societies to get a substantial grant, because they were thus enabled by means of that to cover their expenses and in certain cases to sell their houses, not to make a profit, but to keep themselves clear and to continue building other houses practically on the same capital. If the Minister tells me that that case is met by the sub-section to which he calls attention I am quite satisfied.
Comment on this
There is this point. The Deputy mentioned the word "sell." If public utility societies, building houses and getting this grant, sell their houses and part with them by sale it is intended that the annual grant towards the house shall cease, because the intention is to develop and encourage public utility societies in drawing capital from the State and getting this grant under the Acquisition of Small Dwellings Act in order to build houses for rental rather than to sell.
Comment on this
I think there is a good deal in what Deputy Law said, that this will interfere with the work of the public utility societies. They have been able to carry on their operations so far and pay their way by means of the initial subsidy for the most part. Even if there is a prospect of ultimately getting some amount in payment of debts that have occurred on account of that, that will only apply in certain cases, but in many other cases they will not be able to carry out their operations and set the houses at a satisfactory rent.
Comment on this
It appears to me that Deputy Thrift has struck the real defect here. Public utility societies, generally speaking, have no great credit. They have a certain limited amount of credit, and the subsidy was of very great advantage to them in carrying on their work, and when finished selling their houses, then going ahead with the aid of another subsidy, and building another house or series of houses. While the new scheme will eventually mean, so far as the Government is concerned, the same amount actual of capital outlay spread over a number of years, it would not be of the same practical value to the utility societies. I am informed by those who have practical knowledge of the working of those societies that it will mean that their work will be greatly hampered, and that so far as the smaller societies are concerned probably their work will have to cease. They would not be able at all to meet their liabilities with the same prospect of building and selling houses as they have been able to do owing to the grants previously made under the housing schemes. I think in regard to public utility societies, if the Minister could continue the grants made under the last Act, the good work done by those public utility societies so far in providing houses for the lower middle classes, and which has relieved the pressure, would be able to continue. Otherwise there would be a considerable falling off of the work.
Comment on this
Could the Minister say what advantage the State will derive by preventing utility societies disposing of their houses?
Comment on this
I am not preventing utility societies disposing of these houses, but we are anxious that, outside local authorities, there would be societies that would build houses for persons who require houses slightly better than those that local authorities build, and who would be able to take these houses at rents they can be let at. I think a very considerable portion of our population want such houses at present, and that it is very difficult for them to acquire their houses by buying them. If there are people who want to acquire their houses by buying them, then they ought to be able to do it through some other channel than by preventing the development of public utility societies. That would be what we want, that is, to provide houses somewhat above the local authority class of houses for renting. Private persons anxious to buy their houses should take advantage, as they can, of the facilities given here for getting grants and forgetting credit under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act, they ought to be able to secure them in some other way. They might even be able to cooperate with the public utility societies in finding contractors who would build their houses, or as part even of a public utility scheme. We do not want that development to spoil the development we very urgently wish for from the development of public utility societies. If there are people who can buy houses from a public utility society there is nothing to prevent such a society selling these houses at a cost that to them is reasonable, but then they lose the annual grant.
Comment on this
I think the section makes the work of public utility societies very ineffective. I am one of those who visualises the time when the provision of houses for the working classes will be entrusted wholly to public utility societies, because the members of these societies have an opportunity of mixing with the working classes. The fact that these societies build houses and sell them is an incentive to people to become members of these societies. It has been stated over and over again, in this House and outside, that the mere fact of a man being a working man means that he has no money. Never was there a greater fallacy. From my experience of the working of Dundalk Public Utility Society, working men have put down sums ranging from £60 to £100. Some men have put down deposits of £300, who, before the creation of this public utility society would be classified as poor working men. If you exempt public utility societies on the plea that they build houses to sell, I think you will destroy the good work that has been accomplished by these societies. I hope the Minister will bear that in mind on the Report Stage. There are working men in this country anxious to become the owners of their houses. Ownership creates civic responsibility. There is no better way of making a good citizen than by making a man the owner of his own house. That class of person would not touch public utility societies were it not for the fact that he was going to become the owner of his house after a certain period. We were able to tap a source of wealth that very many people thought could not be tapped before the introduction of public utility societies. As the Minister is aware, we carried out a building scheme in Dundalk at a cost of £20,000. The houses are inhabited by men working on the railway. We paid the last penny to the builder a fortnight ago, there being a little profit left after clearing all expenses. In the near future it is the intention to build more houses in Dundalk. No matter what argument is put up about the State taking over the control of housing accommodation for the working classes, I maintain that, without co-operation and self-help, it will be impossible to solve the housing problem. You must have the co-operation and the help of the community, and the best means of securing such co-operation is through the instrumentality of public utility societies. If you exempt them from the benefits of the grant of £20, on the plea that they only build houses for sale, it will be difficult for the Dundalk Public Utility Society to carry on. Although the houses are actually sold, the period of redemption is very long, I believe, from twenty to twenty-five years. Another advantage in selling houses under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act is that the expense on the societies is lowered, because the tenants who purchased simply paid their rents weekly, monthly, or half-yearly, to the clerk of the urban council, who takes over the administration of the scheme until the debt is cleared off. There are many disadvantages in excluding public utility societies from the benefits of the grant, and I hope that on the Report Stage the Minister will consider the point.
Comment on this
Deputy Coburn contemplates a public utility society as the kind of society that would help private individuals handling the getting of their own houses.
Comment on this
Is there any reason at all why a public utility society, limited in its profits, registered under the Industrial and Provident Societies Act, while dealing with its right hand with the erection of houses suitable for the better paid working classes, and facilitated in the doing of that to the extent of having 75 per cent. of the capital cost of the houses advanced from the State, and of having an annual grant towards paying off the loan charges, should not also, with the left hand, act as guide, philosopher and friend to persons in the area who wish to build their own houses? Is there any reason why they should not help them with whatever amount of control they wish to set up, as a kind of information bureau, and in getting them advances from the local authorities under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act? I do not think that would in any way conflict with the other work of the public utility society itself. At any rate, our policy is to get the public utility society to turn its mind in the direction I speak of. I do not think it would be at all prejudiced by doing that, and by assisting in every way those who wish to provide their own houses to take advantage of the State loans and the State grants that we provide. Instead of having not very solid or responsible public utility societies we would have solidly organised societies acting as a guide to private persons.
Comment on this
If I correctly caught the drift of the Minister's words, it was this: that the policy of his Department is to confine public utility societies to building houses for letting purposes.
Comment on this
I do not think that is right in view of the extreme housing shortage. I think every agency which would enable the people to get houses, particularly houses of their own, should be encouraged, and that a public utility society which builds houses to sell should be encouraged, at any rate, to some extent. I might take the Minister's point of view, to the extent of saying that, possibly, a greater encouragement should be given to a large public utility society which would deal with a large area and build houses to meet the needs of the people who have to live in that area. They might possibly be encouraged to a greater extent. Nevertheless, the Minister should not set himself out to cut off suddenly such State assistance as has been given to a class of public utility societies, particularly those which, up to the present, were building houses to sell. There is a good deal to be said for the public utility society which builds houses to sell. If it is a small body its administrative costs must be comparatively small. The people with whom it deals must be thoroughly well-known to those managing the society. The risk of bad debt and everything else is decreased by the fact that it will only build houses which it thinks it can sell immediately. In that way I think its work is much more economical, under present circumstances, than that of a larger society. I do not think the sort of assistance which the Minister thinks the larger society would be able to give under this Bill would be of any value of people who wish to have their own houses built, and who are in a position to buy them, either by availing of the facilities granted in the Act or out of their own capital immediately.
The public utility society will have its own architect and will have a number of builders on its list. They will be able to cut down all the preliminary costs of building to a minimum. They will be able to do that much more efficiently and effectively if they are building houses, in the first instance for themselves, and afterwards transferring them to their clients. If it is the case that the public utility society can render any of the services, which the Minister outlined, to the people in a certain area, surely the best way to encourage it to do that is to provide it with that special assistance which, up to the present, it has enjoyed to enable it to build houses, because it will be able to build a large number of houses, reduce all the ancillary costs—architect's fees and other things that arise in these matters—and pass the full benefit of that reduction on to the people who are going to buy the houses. The Minister, up to the present, has not been able to justify his policy of restricting the public utility societies to the building of houses for letting only. I think a good case can be made, and has been made, for the public utility society which builds houses to sell them. The need exists for these houses and, if I had my way, instead of cutting the grant, I would be inclined to consider the increase of it by 25 or 50 per cent.
Comment on this
I think this matter requires a good deal more consideration than it has had. It seems to me that this scheme is ethically unsound. What we all aim at is to get the class of persons whom we are thinking of to be as saving and as economical as possible in order that these persons may be able to acquire their own dwellings as soon as possible. This scheme actually tends to discourage that. The more these people can set aside to get rid of their loan charges, the less they will be able to get towards paying the loan charges. I submit that that goes quite the wrong way. We ought to try to get the loan charges paid off by these people as quickly as possible instead of discouraging them.
Comment on this
I agree that the Minister's chief concern is to provide houses for the working classes, but I might remind the Minister that when a public utility society builds 40 or 50 houses this means that the same number of houses are made available for others. Many of the people who got houses erected with the assistance of the public utility societies in my locality left houses that they formerly occupied and made these houses available for the working classes in the same locality. I know myself about ten people who are occupying public utility society houses and who previously occupied houses built by the urban council. These houses belonging to the urban council will now be available for other persons. The public utility societies are fulfilling two functions—they are providing houses for people who want to become owners of their houses and they are making available houses for people by way of letting.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy see anything in the financing of public utility societies under Section 51 for the purpose of building houses to let to prevent these societies acting as agents for private persons desiring technical advice in getting their own houses built?
Comment on this
If the incentive to ownership is at the back of this, cannot they go to the public utility society and get advice from them as to getting their own private houses built as part of the society's general work?
Comment on this
I take it that the primary object of this Bill is to house the working classes. For the past ten minutes we appear to have been talking of other people. I would have a distinct objection to the public utility society getting a grant in addition to the grant of 15 per cent.——
Comment on this
Suppose we accept that, does anybody seriously suggest that houses built for sale by a public utility society will fall into the possession of the working classes? That may happen in two or three cases, but only in that number. The great majority of the houses will fall into the hands of people for whom they were never intended. I would be sorry to think that the Minister was bringing in a Bill to cater for people of that kind. If any grants are given, I hope they will be given to the local authorities to provide houses for the working classes.
Comment on this
What about the man with an industrious family who started humbly in life but, because of his thrift, accumulated a little money? Is he not to be considered?
Comment on this
I would remind the Minister that the fact that they get the type of tenant that I have referred to means that the utility societies are provided with a very large amount of their assets at the initiation of the building scheme. In the scheme to which I referred, deposits of £100 were put down. The lowest deposit was £50. These deposits were made by working class people who had been assisted by thrifty members of their families.
Comment on this
If we suppose for a moment that an alteration in the financial arrangement has been made, the strongest case that Deputy Coburn can put is that a person with £200 or £300 cannot get the facilities which he was formerly in a position to get from the public utility societies. So far as getting a house with a reduction of 15 per cent. in the annual loan charges for a period not exceeding 20 years is concerned he is in the same position as a person without money. In essence, what it comes to is this: That instead of entering into possession of a house without any charge on it at once, and getting the advantage of whatever sum would be made available in bulk form instead of in annual form as here, he is at no disadvantage. He simply postpones the purchase of the house for 20 years. He still has his £200 or £300, and he can place that money, I am sure, with the public utility society at a price probably not less than that at which they would get an advance from some public fund. Alternatively, if he were to put it into national savings certificates, he would get probably as high interest as would otherwise be available. The only disadvantage there to him is that he cannot lock it in his safe, or bank the title deeds of the premises for which he has a sufficient sum of money to put down. We are leaving him with that money now. He is still in possession of it, and he enters into possession of the same advantages as the person who has not got that money, or, alternatively, if the arrangement with the public utility society were that prior allocation of the houses would be to a person who could put down the money, then he would be in as strong a position as he was when he was put into a position to buy the house. I do not think there is a real material disadvantage to him except in the one case: that he does not get into immediate possession of the house with no charges in respect to the costs of the loans provided. He is simply liable for rates and income tax, if he is so liable. But the advantages that he can get in connection with the purchase for twenty years are exactly the equivalent to the position that he was in last year when he could get £45 of a Government grant towards the house.
Comment on this
The President has come back to the point that I made at the start. The advantage to the public utility society has occurred in this way. It has built houses and has used all its capital in doing so. It has let those houses at a rent. After a time the tenant has saved enough to get that liability off his hands. The capital has come back to the public utility society, and with it it has built another set of houses. That will not occur for twenty years under this. Therefore, your increase in the number of houses will be curtailed to that extent.
Comment on this
I am not really very much interested in what happens to the individual who is anxious to build his house, what really interests me is whether this change in the provisions that we have hitherto made for public utility societies is going to injure the work of public utility societies. That is the only real point. Having listened carefully and quietly to everything that has been said, I confess that I am not yet convinced that the work of the public utility societies as we have known it in the past—I am speaking now of public utility societies that I know have built houses for people of the working classes—will suffer. I do not want to prolong the argument if the Minister will say that he will give further consideration to the matter before the Report Stage is taken. I ask leave to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I would like to say that I had the idea that these people were asking for a grant along with the payment.
Comment on this
They are asking for a grant which is not as valuable as what we are providing for here.
Comment on this
In the case of public utility societies which build houses to sell them, will they get this grant and the 15 per cent. even——
Comment on this
I understood the President to argue that the public utility societies would get the 15 per cent., even though they have sold the houses.
Comment on this
Then I misunderstood what the President said. That is where I say the whole scheme is wrong, that public utility societies building houses now and selling them will get no advantage.
Comment on this
They get the 15 per cent. all the time. The only point in dispute is that normally up to this a person could purchase one of these houses from the public utility society. Now that purchase is delayed for a period of twenty years. But it is purchased. The man has his money and he can lend it to the public utility society if he likes. They can borrow 75 per cent. of their money from the Board of Works. They will want more and this money will be available.
Comment on this
Why should a person be compelled to defer the purchase for twenty years? If a man, by saving and in other ways, is able to purchase why should he not be permitted to do so in five years. From what the President has said I take it that the purpose of the section is to ensure that a person would have to live in a house over twenty years before he can become the owner of it. I do not see that any advantage either to the State or to the community is to be gained from that.
Comment on this
I am not going to be cross-examined by the President. I did not interrupt him, and if he would endeavour to follow my good example in this debate we would get on better. I do not see that the two things mutually exclude each other. Apparently the Minister for Local Government thinks that they do, and that it would be inconsistent with the general purpose of the Bill to make an immediate grant to a public utility society for the purpose of enabling it to build houses to sell. I suggest that the Minister should leave an option to the public utility society to take either of these two things, whichever in its opinion will best enable it to meet the immediate needs with which it is familiar. If a public utility society wants to build houses to sell them, surely it ought to be facilitated to that extent.
There is another point. The President, I think, had in mind the individual who makes up his mind and says "I am going to buy a house, I am going to build a house," and he says "we will facilitate him." There is the other class of individual who, possibly, does not make up his mind either to buy or to build a house until he sees houses being built somewhere. He goes out along suburban roads and sees houses springing up in some particularly nice situation. These houses are being built by a public utility society. The surroundings please him and he makes up his mind to make his home there. If he can possible manage to acquire one of these houses on reasonable terms he will buy it. That is the sort of person for whom the public utility society quite legitimately caters. They would cater for that class of person provided there were some initial encouragement from the State in the form of this lump sum of a grant down. That kind of public utility society is completely ignored by the Bill in its present form. I think the House should consider the question of providing the alternative facility for the public utility society, and of giving it a grant which will enable it to build houses and sell them at the quickest possible rate. In that way we would be helping materially to reduce the housing shortage.
Comment on this
No. Let it act not merely as the agent, but as the original undertaker. Let the public utility society be the original projector of the scheme. Consider this position. The public utility society says: We have a plot of ground here and we will build houses on it. We have not the necessary capital, we go to the Local Government Department to get the grant. Armed with that and with some other funds we go and we build houses without having definite purchasers in view, but, knowing that there is a widespread shortage of houses, we feel that we are going to find purchasers inevitably for these houses. That is the class of enterprise that the Minister is deliberately discouraging in the Bill. I think it ought to be encouraged. A group of men having a certain amount of money will get together. They are in touch with builders and architects. They know that there are certain plots of ground available for building purposes. They say: We will form ourselves into a public utility society and limit ourselves as to profits. We are going to put up houses in this particular locality. We have not any particular persons in mind as purchasers, but we know that once the houses are built people will come along and buy them. That is the particular type of enterprise that ought to be encouraged and, in my view, it is the quickest way in which the housing problem is going to find its solution. For that reason I think the Minister ought to meet the House in regard to this grant.
Comment on this
All through this part of the Bill, what I am trying to do is to force the building of houses down from the £1,000 figure nearer to the figure at which the local authority is building. I am trying to force the provision of housing for the type of people for whom the local authority is providing houses. There are any amount of working class people looking for a better type of house than the local authority can give, a better type than that on which we intend the local authority to concentrate. We want to force the provision of houses of this particular kind for letting at a rent. We look to public utility societies to do something like that. If we do not get the public utility societies forced somewhat into a position like that, then we are leaving a section of the people who very badly need houses waiting on the people who are in a position to take the responsibility of owning their houses. We do nothing here to prevent public utility societies acting as agents for private persons and getting, as for these private persons, the grants which these private persons would ordinarily get. That is the policy there. I think no effort on our part should be left untried at the earliest possible moment to force the provision of houses of the type of which I speak and for the persons of whom I speak.
Comment on this
It seems to me that the Minister is wrong there. I agree with the Minister that we should try to secure the provision of the greatest possible number of houses for the working class who must live, because of economic circumstances, in small dwellings. I believe that we should use every incentive we can to do that at the earliest possible moment. At the same time there is the other problem which the Minister himself indicated, the problem of the worker who can afford a better house, who wants a better house because of his family and who wants to own that house. If the Minister wants to encourage the provision of houses for renting, he can do that by making the terms more favourable for the public utility society which will rent houses, but that is not a reason for cutting off altogether any State aid or encouragement from the public utility society which is going to build a group of houses to let them to certain unnamed individuals. The Minister will only think of a public utility society acting as agent for some particular individual who has approached it.
There is the other mass of people, the people who have not yet come forward to the public utility society, the people who have in mind the possibility of owning their houses, who have not yet taken a definite decision in that regard but would be stimulated into taking that decision if they saw some society providing houses for them. That is the class of public utility society for which I am speaking. I think the Minister's point could be met by giving that society somewhat less favourable terms than the public utility society which will build houses to let. My opinion is that anybody who will build houses for people in that social grade which we commonly describe as working class—it may be the unskilled labourer, the clerical worker or others, people like that of limited means—should be encouraged. After that, if the Minister wants to have his way, let him give greater encouragement to the people who build houses to let, but let him not cut off all State aid from the society which builds houses even for the purpose of selling them.
Comment on this
May I appeal to the Minister to look into the matter between now and next stage? He will freeze up the capital of the utility society. The utility societies are like a number of other bodies. They are out to build houses and make a little money at the same time. If they cannot sell houses——
Comment on this
Leave out the politician for the moment. If the policy which the Minister is aiming at is adopted it is going to freeze up the capital of the utility societies and prevent them doing the work they were formed to do, because if the capital is frozen up in the houses it is not liquid and they cannot make use of it. I appeal to the Minister to look into the matter between now and the next Stage.
Comment on this
Are the operations of the public utility societies dependent on the charitable public? I think it is the experience of Deputies that the people who go into these houses as tenants are not working people at all. That is true of every town in Ireland. I do not know how true it is of Dublin. On the other hand there is something to be said for not locking up capital. Another point to be considered is, will the rental which these houses command at present be the rental which they will command in 20 years' time? I have no objection to the Minister considering this matter, but the fact is that working class people who have no means are not in a position to go into these houses at all.
Comment on this
There is another aspect of the position of public utility societies to which I would like to call the Minister's attention. That is the position of public utility societies who are operating in rural areas. The Minister, of course, is aware that the number of these societies is quite small. They are not very numerous and I think it will be admitted that where these societies exist they have been doing good work under the Housing Acts, 1925 to 1930. If grants are not made available for such societies they will for all practical purposes have to cease operations in rural areas. The biggest difficulty that exists in rural areas for small farmers, especially uneconomic holders, is that they cannot get credit for building materials. They have been organised into building societies and public utility societies and the society has been able to secure credit with traders and to get building materials advanced to these uneconomic holders to build their houses. If this amendment is not accepted by the Minister it means that these people will be thrown back entirely on their own means and, as well as that, that with the amount of money that will be at their disposal, it will be utterly impossible for small farmers to take advantage of the terms of the Bill.
Comment on this
I do not admit that the public utility societies formed in country districts do serve any more useful purpose than getting for persons who were building their houses, the additional grant that was available simply because they called themselves a group or a public utility society. The public utility society that is referred to here is the public utility society registered under the Friendly Societies Act, not the type of public utility society that was provided for in the 1924 Act. Persons in rural districts now will have the benefit of the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act as well as of the grants provided, so that the question of capital does not arise in the way that it might have arisen in other days, when some of the rural public utility societies might have helped to some extent. The particular type of which Deputy Ward speaks will not exist in the new circumstances.
Comment on this
Does not the Minister realise that the type of builder to whom I refer in this amendment cannot avail of any of the loans and that the loans are no earthly use to the small farmers, the uneconomic farmers, who are up to their ears in debt, whose credit is completely exhausted, and who could be organised into a public utility society? The society could pledge its credit to the trader to supply the building material. These people are in occupation of insanitary houses unfit for human habitation. I have experience of one of those societies and we have certainly done good work. We have built 70 houses in the last 1½ years in the rural parts of the Co. Monaghan.
Comment on this
As I say, I really think the question requires more consideration, and I ask the Minister to suspend the matter until we have an opportunity of giving it a further examination in the interval. I would like to make further inquiries to see if I am not justified in saying that if this goes through it will after a short period completely bring to an end the operations of most of the public utility societies. I am sure the Minister would not like that. He wants them to build the houses for renting purposes. I quite agree with him, but if they apply all the money that they get to building such houses it will go a short distance. Then their work will stop because their capital will end. He should give us a further opportunity to make further enquiries to make our case and let him make his. If he puts this to a division now and if it is lost we cannot bring it up again.
Comment on this
It will be necessary to take the final stages tomorrow. I think there is an understanding on that and that the Bill is to be sent to the Seanad by Wednesday next in order that it may be law for Christmas. There is nothing to prevent a public utility society, as an agent for private persons, making use of the particular type of grant persons get here. We are not solving the housing problem except we do something to get public utility societies and builders to move down in the scale of the type of houses they are building, and in so far as public money for capital and public assistance in the matter of either grants or the equivalent of grants are concerned, the problem is such that we are intent on forcing their application to the building industry down to that particular plane.
Comment on this
On a point of order, this section proposes to amend Section 3 of the Housing Act of 1929. The Housing Act of 1929 provided for the making of grants to private persons building new houses. The amendment that is before us now, I suggest, is entirely outside the scope of the 1929 Act, which, as I say, was entirely restricted to giving grants to private persons building new houses. In sub-section (2) it is proposed to secure that grants will be given for the building of houses to replace insanitary houses, where a dwelling is wholly unsuited for the proper and healthy accommodation of the occupier. Sub-section (3) proposes to make grants for the improvement of existing houses. I submit that it is a complete addition of new things to the Housing Act of 1929, and that it is not proper to insert it in a Bill which, while amending the Act of 1929, amends it in a specific thing, but does not extend the scope of the Act of 1929 beyond making grants to private persons for building new houses. I submit that to introduce the idea of insanitary houses means that you introduce a condition which means that a grant given would not provide an additional house, but would provide replacement, and to attempt to extend the 1929 Act to include the improvement of existing housing is a thing that should not be done by an amendment to an amending Act. I submit that both these things are entirely outside this amending Bill, in so far as Section 59 is really an amending Bill to the Housing Act of 1929 alone.
Comment on this
This Bill will amend the Housing Act of 1929. It amends other Acts as well. Among other things, it purports to deal with unhealthy dwelling houses, unhealthy areas, and it aims at improving those places. It also deals with individual houses, unhealthy houses, and therefore I believe this amendment, (29a), comes within the scope of the Bill. At any rate, it has not been ruled out of order and I move it.
Comment on this
The amendment to this Bill alters the construction very vitally of certain Acts. This particular amendment deals with what are called insanitary houses. The Acts which it seeks to amend are from 1925 to 1929, and they had no reference whatever to insanitary houses. They were concerned with the provision of new houses only. It alters the method of declaration of an insanitary house and places upon the Minister certain obligations. I presume the Minister is not intended to go around the country whenever there is a notice given of an unhealthy or insanitary house. It does not even set out, in respect of a house unsuitable for a dwelling, the characteristics which distinguish that particular phase.
Comment on this
No, but I am pointing out what the amendment really means. That particular phase of it is the business of the local authority. The Minister has no sanitary or sub-sanitary officers to give him that information, and there is no money provided for that in the Bill.
Comment on this
If it were found that the amendment was in the wrong place, that would not be sufficient to rule it completely out of order. We would have to take some steps to see that it was put in the right place. As regards the question of the scope of the Bill, Section 59 says:—"Notwithstanding anything contained in the Housing Acts, 1925 to 1930"— those words could not be wider—"as amended by this Act, the Minister may, under Section 3 of the Housing Act of 1929 (No. 12 of 1929), as modified by this section ..." That is, as modified by this section when it will have passed through both Houses of the Oireachtas. For that reason the amendment seems to me to be relevant, particularly in view of the general nature of the Bill which, in another place, deals with the repair or the demolition of insanitary houses. Purely on the question of order, it seems to me that the amendment, without any regard for its merits or demerits, is relevant. As regards the question raised by the President, that no money is provided under this amendment to enable the Minister to carry out the duties that the amendment proposes to impose upon him, that is another matter and it is not being put to me, I take it.
Comment on this
Oh, yes; I am putting it with all the force I possibly can.
Comment on this
Any relation there is to unhealthy areas is simply providing an amendment to the Act of 1890, and is entirely confined to local authorities. The Housing Acts, in so far as private persons are concerned, have never concerned themselves with the question of substitution of insanitary dwellings, and it is on the insanitary question a complete and new extension of the application of the law with regard to houses in respect of private persons.
Comment on this
It seems to me that these are arguments that could well be used against the amendment. This Bill is extremely wide. It is called a Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill. It amends various Housing Acts in a great variety of ways, and any attempt to carry that amendment further, as long as it can be connected in some way with what is in the Bill, is in order. With regard to the question of the money, Deputy O'Kelly has not spoken on that particular matter. It could be argued that the Minister's present officers would look after that particular aspect, but the Chair is not in a position to say whether they could or could not do so.
Comment on this
I am glad the Chair has ruled that this amendment is in order. I am rather at a loss to understand why there was such great anxiety on the part of the President and the Minister to have the amendment ruled out. It is certainly interesting to observe their attitude. Perhaps before the discussion is finished the President will let us know why he was so keen on not allowing discussion on this amendment. The amendment simply asks that certain powers should be provided and given to individuals. This relates, particularly, to rural areas where, as everyone knows, there is at present a very big proportion of insanitary houses. In many of these houses there are very large families. We are anxious that there would be continued the power that has been given under different Acts here in recent years in order to permit a grant to be given to people in insanitary houses.
Sub-section (2) of the amendment says:—"Where, in the opinion of the Minister, a dwelling-house is wholly unsuitable for the proper and healthy accommodation of the occupier thereof and his family..." There are many such houses, and it would help materially to improve housing conditions if grants such as were heretofore made could be made now to people living in houses of that character, particularly in rural areas. There should be something done to provide these people with decent housing accommodation.
I do not think anybody here can contend that there is not a tremendous demand for improved housing conditions in rural areas, especially houses for small farmers whose valuations are very low. Local authorities, rated as heavily as they are under present conditions, find it very difficult to get money to enable them to give grants to such people for building purposes. We would like to give grants to these people to enable them to build new houses or, as is suggested in sub-section (3), to improve their present dwellings in so far as they are insanitary. If they are insanitary, everybody here would rather, if we could afford it, give them grants to help them to demolish such houses and erect proper dwellings.
As our finances will not allow us to do that in every case, it would be well that the grants that were made in some years gone by for improving houses could be continued. There is a very pressing demand. There is frequently brought up in discussion on housing matters by our own and by other Parties, this strong and insistent demand for grants for improving rural housing. There are farmers of small valuations in the country, with small houses and large families, and they want to improve their houses. They want to make their houses sanitary, a condition in which they are not at the present time. The passing of this sub-section would make possible the reconstruction or improvement of their houses.
Comment on this
Before the debate closes I want to say that Deputy O'Kelly and I have been thinking on similar lines in relation to similar amendments, but this is not one of them. There is one factor here to which Deputy O'Kelly has not referred. He is far too keen to overlook it and he is far too honest I am sure to mislead the House in the matter. If Deputies look at the Bill they will see that this amendment which has been put down proposes to insert before sub-section (2) of Section 59, three new sub-sections. It lays down that for the purposes of this section the aggregate amount of the grant made is £25,000.
Therefore £25,000 is the total amount available for grants under this Bill. Under the proposals in this Bill a grant of £20 is to be given by the State and £20 by the local authorities. Deputy O'Kelly, in this new sub-section, proposes that as far as the State is concerned the building grant should be £80 as against £20 in the Bill. I have often in this House before now stated that I am not a great mathematician, but even my powers of arithmetic are equal to dividing £25,000 by the figure 20 in one case and by 80 in the other. Having done that I arrive at the conclusion that whatever number of houses could be built under the scheme which is proposed in the Bill when you provide £25,000, it is fairly obvious that only one-fourth of that number can be built when the amount is divided by 80. Consequently the nett effect of Deputy O'Kelly's amendment, subject to the overriding condition that there is only £25,000 available, means that only one house can be built under his amendment where four could be built under the section as it stands.
Much as we would all like to see considerable grants given to people for building new houses, still if I had to choose between a relatively small grant given to a large number of people and four times that grant given to one-fourth the number of people, I would certainly prefer the smaller grant to the larger number of people. I presume Deputy O'Kelly will say that it was impossible for him or for any private Deputy here to propose to increase the £25,000. That is so. I think we have to take it that that sum of £25,000 represents the utmost amount which the Minister for Local Government and the President—I mention these two because they are present—can allocate for the purposes of housing.