We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill, 1931—Committee.

Contributions 331–487 of 487. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill, 1931
Enacted

No. 43 of 1931 ›

As I pointed out, in endeavouring to persuade the Ceann Comhairle that this amendment was out of order, I want to say now again that it is entirely contrary to the whole spirit of the 1929 Act. In the earlier Housing Acts from 1924 to 1929, as far as reconstruction is concerned, the provision for reconstruction was made in urban areas. The intention was to provide grants for persons with large houses to divide these houses so as to provide housing accommodation for an additional number of families. There was a certain amount of direct reconstruction of ordinary houses proceeded with. The total number of such cases was only 600, and the reconstruction was entirely confined to urban districts. At a time when we are looking again at the amount of money which we have to spend, looking again at our urban housing problem, and, as a result of what is shown to us, then reducing the amount of assistance that we can give to people who are building houses other than houses for the working classes, as a matter of fact we are approaching the stage gradually at which no assistance from the public purse can be given directly except for the housing of the very poor and for the relief of insanitary areas—when we are approaching that stage Deputies ask us to embark on the provision of moneys for the reconstruction of houses in rural areas. At the same time Deputy O'Kelly would go further outside the scope of the 1929 Act which, as I pointed out, was for the provision of rural houses and would apply assistance to private persons with a scheme to get rid of insanitary houses in rural areas. Urban housing conditions have been pretty fully envisaged.

The problem is very big. We are able to approach that problem now with a definite policy of a new kind. I pointed out on the Second Reading that these grants and provisions here, in so far as they affected rural houses, got the same condemnation from the Deputy who represented Wexford as from the Deputy who represented Leitrim. I pointed out that, whereas 80 or 82 per cent. of the people in Wexford lived in houses of four rooms and upwards, for the area of Leitrim, Roscommon, Mayo, and Galway, comprising 100,000 inhabited houses, 70 per cent. of those, at least, lived in three-roomed houses and under. Gradually, as reports from the County Medical Officers of Health have been received—that is, in places where County Medical Officers of Health have been appointed—it is clear that there is a housing problem in rural areas that can be related to a condition of unfitness for human habitation, that can be regarded as a problem of being insanitary, that is the insanitary house problem in our urban districts. The problem is probably very big. A policy must be framed towards the solution of that problem analogous to the policy that is now being framed to deal with insanitary houses and the very poor in our urban districts. We have not yet had an opporunity in respect of insanitary rural housing and the housing of the poor in rural districts of looking at our financial possibilities and the extent of the problem. That the problem is a big one is quite clear when we realise that 70,000 people in four of these western counties are living in houses of three rooms and under. From the 1924 Act down assistance was given directly to private persons, not because it was thought the natural thing that private persons wishing to build houses should be assisted either by the ratepayers or the taxpayers, but because of the terrible shortage of houses and of very high building costs. That assistance for private persons was applied in rural areas as in urban areas, although it was in the urban areas that the pressure of the house shortage was greatest. The grants to private persons in rural areas have been gradually reduced in the same way in which grants to private persons have been reduced in urban areas.

Deputy Ward said that he knew that many of these grants were given to persons that could have and would have built their houses without these grants. We are now reducing gradually the assistance given to private persons and approaching the point at which the ordinary private person, whether in a rural or urban district, who may be expected to stand the cost of building his own house, will be asked to do it, with, if you like, the assistance of capital provided under the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act by the State. As far as direct assistance for the building of houses by persons other than the very poor is concerned, we are approaching the time when that assistance cannot be given. There is a type of person building in rural districts who has been getting this particular type of grant and who has expected it, and will be expecting it for a short period. We are not withdrawing the grant suddenly from these people, but taking it away gradually. We cannot, however, with due regard to all interests, the interests of the poor people in rural districts, the interests of people living in insanitary dwellings in rural districts, and the taxpayer and the ratepayer, embark in a haphazard way on a type of assistance to these until the extent of the problem that requires to be tackled in these rural districts has been very fully examined, and until there is a more general public appreciation of the extent of that problem and the amount of money likely to be involved. For that reason, I oppose the introduction of this amendment that, in a haphazard way, seeks to take out of the £25,000, provided for the type of persons expecting continued assistance in private building such as they have had up to the present, a sum for a purpose that our Housing Acts up to the present never provided for. In so far as it relates to insanitary houses, that is a responsibility of the local authorities, and has always been their responsibility, in respect of which they are given under this Bill additional powers under the Labourers Acts to deal with.

Comment on this

It is very hard to understand the Minister's opposition to this amendment. The title of the Bill is, "An Act to make better provision for the clearance of unhealthy areas and the repair and demolition of insanitary houses..." If the Minister only envisaged the problem in the towns and cities in the drafting of this Bill he should have set out in the title that it was not to have any application to the rural parts of the country. In so far as the Bill as it stands is concerned, unless this amendment is accepted by the Minister or carried by a majority of the House, it is not going to cause the disappearance or removal of any insanitary house in the rural districts. Insanitary houses in rural Ireland are not all occupied, indeed only a very small proportion of them are occupied, by the class of people who are described as belonging to the working classes. Where labourers' cottages do exist in rural areas for the housing of agricultural labourers, these houses are in a comparatively decent condition, and from the point of view of sanitation and habitability are reasonably good. There is, of course, a shortage of these houses, but they do not constitute the insanitary houses in rural Ireland. The insanitary houses in rural Ireland and the houses unfit for human habitation are occupied by small farmers. The Minister admits that the problem is a very large one. Having admitted so much, presumably he knew the problem was a very large one before he introduced the Bill, and it is difficult to understand why he made no provision to deal with this large problem. It is all very well to talk of the financial difficulties. Why should the rural section of the population be asked to contribute, and to continue to contribute, to finance the removal of insanitary dwellings in the urban districts and the cities while no provision is being made whereby the housing conditions under which they themselves live can be improved?

Comment on this

What about the Labourers Acts?

Comment on this

What use are the Labourers Acts to the small farmer? The only thing that can be done if that man's housing conditions are to be improved is to provide a grant large enough to buy the building materials for him and leave him a little margin over for the tradesmen. It is suggested that there is only £25,000 available under this section, and because of that fact this amendment, if passed, will for all practical purposes be inoperative. I do not think that is so. I think that if the Minister when the £25,000 has been expended comes to the House and asks for more money under this section, the House will not hesitate to give it. The President expresses dissent, but we find that the President has suddenly discovered £250,000, to the surprise of everybody for the relief of unemployment out of some mysterious fund that may materialise in the future. He has found that £250,000 on the eve of a general election, but he cannot find anything for the housing of the class of people this amendment is meant to serve. The Minister says that this amendment is contrary to the spirit of the 1929 and 1930 Acts. What difference does it make whether it is contrary to the spirit of these Acts or not? It certainly is not contrary to the spirit of the Bill before us. The problem about the 1929 and the 1930 and the other Acts that went before them as far as the small farmer or the occupier of an insanitary dwelling in a rural district is concerned is that he has not been able to avail of these grants to get rid of his insanitary house, because these grants have not been large enough to provide him with the building material.

I repeat what I said on the Second Reading, that to a very large extent the class of people who are able to avail of the provisions of the Housing Acts in rural districts were not the class of people who were living in houses unfit for human habitation. So far as the Minister's policy has gone, and in so far as the results of the 2½ million pounds paid in State subsidies for the building of houses are concerned, for all practical purposes we have as many houses in rural Ireland unfit for human habitation as we had before any of these Acts were passed.

The Minister said it is a very big problem, that he would like public appreciation of it, and that medical officers of health should report and all that sort of thing, until we got a full and adequate idea of the size of it. If the problem is as great as it is, even on the Minister's own admission, why not make a beginning towards its solution? If it is such a big problem, we are all agreed that it would take a very long time to solve it. I cannot see why this House, considering the majority of Deputies are from rural areas, should allow this Bill to pass in its present form without some such amendment as the amendment in Deputy O'Kelly's name. Such amendment would enable the small farmers in the country occupying one room and kitchen, with as many as ten people living in them—father, mother, and children of all sexes and all ages—to be rescued from such conditions. I repeat I cannot understand how this House could stand for that sort of thing when a Bill like this is before it. There are many houses in the rural parts of Ireland that could be reconstructed in such a way as to render them fit for human habitation, if they had decent roofs and floors, if the windows were of a decent size and constructed in a way that would enable them to open and let in fresh air to the houses. If these things were done by means of grants towards reconstruction, a very considerable improvement would be made in the conditions under which these people live. These things could be done if the Minister would accept this amendment. I urge him strongly to sympathetically consider this aspect of the question. He admits it is a big question, and I think if he is held up for finance in the carrying out of it he will have the sympathy of all Deputies in the House if he comes here to look for more money.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

How much of that will he be able to cash? The Deputy says the Minister can come here and get the money. Of course he can. No House will ever refuse money, but let me remind the Deputy that he and his Party in the last month or six weeks voted against the imposition of taxation to enable us to discharge the ordinary commitments of the present year. The Deputy said if the Minister wanted more money he could come here and he would get it. The strange thing about the two Deputies opposite is that neither of them seems to have studied this problem. There is a general election coming; they have spoken with their eye to that. How will they make this thing difficult for the Government? I am prepared to meet any of them on this question of housing, and on this particular question, at any time and in any part of the country, either rural or urban, and to put before the people their record in the past month when money was wanted and when they would not vote it. No one will deny that money provided under a Housing Act to be spent by building houses must be got from somewhere. What is the problem we have to deal with in connection with housing? The main source from which to get such money is taxation. None of the Deputies opposite, though they concern themselves very largely with what are called statistics, ever bother their heads about that. When we are considering the question of housing as a problem, what is the first thing to be done? If they read back through the gospels of the year, they will find that going against any nation a general will first of all sit down, take up pencil and paper and make out whether or not he will be able to meet his opponents with so many or whether, if they are stronger, he will have to add more. They have that lesson, but they do not bother about that. They do not at all concern themselves about the number of houses that will have to be provided in this country. What figure in the next twenty years is that likely to amount to? They never bother their heads about an estimate——

Comment on this

We asked questions to get those figures and we have them.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

If Deputies have them why not tell us what they are?

Comment on this

You gave them to us yourself and you have the number.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Very well. I shall give the figures. In the last nine years we put up approximately or helped towards the construction of 26,000 houses in the country. Dublin's quota of that was about 6,500, so that approximately whatever is required for Dublin is about one-fourth of the housing of the rest of the country. Dublin's necessity in connection with the housing problem is approximately 20,000 houses. We can take it that somebody will have to provide 80,000 houses. Who is going to provide them? Apparently the rest of the people of the country. Where do we find them? According to the last census there is something like 625,000 heads of families, but as 60,000 of these, approximately, consist of only one person, we can only come to the conclusion that approximately there are 560,000 heads of families in the country. I shall make that quite clear and plain so that even Fianna Fail Deputies will understand it. 560,000 heads of families for 80,000 is at the rate of seven to one. Well, go out in the street and assemble seven men and you say to these men: "You seven have to provide one house for one of the seven of you." That is the problem. Seven heads of families in this country have to tax themselves in order to provide one house. Deputy Ward says if we were to come to the House we would get whatever money is necessary. We came to the House a short time ago for half a million and the Deputy and his Party voted against it.

Comment on this

Was that money for the provision of housing in rural Ireland?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

It was for dealing with the Estimates passed here, and housing was one of the services included.

Comment on this

In rural Ireland?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

In rural Ireland and in urban Ireland as well.

Comment on this

The Electricity Supply Board got two millions of it.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

The Electricity Supply Board did not get one sixpence of it, not even the penny mentioned in the gospel as the man's pay for a day. It shows what our troubles are here and how much we have to tell these people, and it shows how much they have to be instructed in order to make them understand even the elementary principles underlying any of our problems. That is the first problem that 560,000 heads of families have to provide houses for 80,000 over a period of twenty years if the problem is to be solved in that time. What is the Deputy's solution of the problem? That out of £25,000 approximately 400 people are to be helped. Have they bothered themselves about the finances of it or whether it is a fair figure? Have they gone into the question of the cost of houses? Deputy Ward says that we are to supply all the materials and something towards the building of the houses.

Comment on this

You will find the figures in the next amendment.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

There are two figures —a building grant of £80 and an improvement grant of £40. Deputy Ward said we were to supply the materials and give something towards the cost of the houses.

Comment on this

Yes. We estimated that the £80 grant would do that.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I am not accepting the Deputy's figures.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows and the President does not.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Excuse me. Has the Deputy ever built a house?

Comment on this

Only 70.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

With his own money? I know, because I paid. The Deputy built 70 for others. None of his own money was in them.

Comment on this

Whether it was my own money or not does not affect the price.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I know that type. The fact is the Deputy has put down £80 in the amendment, and he wants the cost of materials. Has he concerned himself with what the figure is likely to amount to in respect of the 80,000 houses I have mentioned?

Comment on this

What I have concerned myself about is that the rural population will get part of the money that is being put up by the State.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I will come to that. Outside the city of Dublin, three-quarters of the money that we have provided for housing, up to the present, has been spent. This particular method of distribution is the Deputy's solution. If we are to take 80,000 houses on that basis, it represents a sum of five million pounds approximately, or six million if it were the whole of the 80,000. It is not the whole; it will be approximately half way between the two. That is in respect only of the money outgoings. Now we have to examine the Bill to see how far this amendment fits into it. The Bill deals in the first place with insanitary areas and insanitary dwellings; in the second place with the provision of accommodation for persons who have to vacate an insanitary area, and, by reason of the density of population, have to be provided for outside the area; in the third place it deals with the provision of houses for private persons or virgin-soil sites or anything of that sort not embodied in the insanitary area or the extension scheme which is essential to the demolition of the insanitary area. The basis of the arrangement is that the local authority in each case will formulate a scheme and their officials will declare whether an area is an insanitary area or not. Why is that? For the very good reason that they have officials whose work it is to look after sanitation and who are paid for doing so. The proposal here is that the Minister is to examine and to be satisfied. "Where, in the opinion of the Minister, a dwelling-house is wholly unsuitable for the proper and healthy accommodation of the occupier."

The Minister is practically to become the agent of the local authorities in these cases. That is a complete and absolute change of the whole system of local government. What is he to do? How is he to do it? He cannot employ a local officer for that sort of work. He cannot be responsible for the decision of a local authority's servant. He must employ a staff. What staff will be required over the whole rural areas to examine all the insanitary houses? The Deputy could put down a half a dozen questions about houses in such places and ask the Minister if he had examined them. How many questions would be on the Order Paper in connection with the administration of this scheme? What is going to be the cost and how is it going to benefit housing to get that information? A new system is to superimpose on the existing system that is capable of dealing with it. If it were a local authority that had to decide that a house was insanitary, this might be said for it, that whoever framed an amendment concerned himself with a constructive policy for housing rather than with the platform effects of housing just before a general election.

Comment on this

Just before a general election?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Just before a general election. I expect we will have a general election within twelve months. I suppose the Deputy would be very disappointed if we had not. If Deputies think we are going to have it before Christmas I can assure them that I have no such intention and, what is more, I have not yet made up my mind when it will be. I am not a free agent.

Comment on this

The Unionists will settle it if they get enough cash.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

There is one thing certain, that those who talk loudest about that sort of thing are those who, perhaps, are living in very dangerous premises.

Comment on this

Insanitary houses.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I never matriculated in Trinity College. I can assure the Deputy that I could not afford it.

Comment on this

We know where you graduated. Do not draw us out on that question.

Comment on this

Where did the President get his doctor's degree? The less he says about Trinity College the better. He got it with "God Save the King" being played.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

If I recollect aright I got it from four Universities.

Comment on this

A "God Save the King" Doctor of Laws from Trinity College. The less you say about Trinity College the better.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I never matriculated there.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us now remember the dwellers in the insanitary houses.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I have an excellent memory. I do not abuse places and afterwards seek shelter in them.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

We will come to the Housing Bill now.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I was dealing with the construction of the Bill and how the Minister proposes the machinery would operate with respect to inter sanitary areas through the sanitary authorities and the medical officers of health. In the amendment it is proposed that the Minister should be practically in that position. I need not point out to anyone interested in local government the ridiculousness of that position. If the amendment were passed Deputy Corish could perhaps ask the Minister about every insanitary house in Wexford County. Deputy O'Kelly could ask the Minister if he had inspected every insanitary house in Dublin. Apart from that, the definition of "insanitary dwelling" is to my mind not exactly in accord with what is usually laid down in other Acts. Reference is made to unhealthy dwelling houses in Sections 3, 5, 19 and 21, and there is reference to rooms in Section 22. There are further references in Section 27 and 30, and insanitary areas are mentioned in Section 42. In certain cases provision is made for appeal to the Circuit Court in respect of some of these declarations. There is no such provision in the amendment.

As I said before, this alters the whole method of dealing with local authorities. If this amendment were meant to be operative—which I do not believe it was—the cost in respect of the running of it by the Department of Local Government would be approximately £1,000 a county. Is it contended that we are going to solve the housing question by increasing the number of our officials? Take that section which deals with the reconstruction of houses. Two decisions have got to be made in that case. In the first place, it must be described as an insanitary dwelling. In the second place, some official must be in a position to give a certificate that the work has been satisfactorily done. More cost. The expenses in respect of the administration of this amendment would be colossal, and housing is not a service on which one can afford to expend money unless one sees houses going up. There has been a reduction in the cost of building over recent years. In 1922, the average price per square foot was approximately 14/6. In 1931, it is 10/6. The original sum made available for house-building was reduced during those years practically in accord with the drop in the percentage of cost. The cost of providing one house is going to fall approximately upon seven persons. Let us see what the financial situation is. There is a sum of £25,000 made available in this measure for private persons. That is a relatively small sum. It is fixed in the light of the difficult financial situation we have—a most unusual situation. A most unusual occurrence took place this year. It was found that the level of taxation did not produce the money required. Extra imposts had to be provided by law in order to produce the money which was estimated as being likely to be required in April last. This is a time when we have got to consider the economy of every single Act that passes through this House, and to limit as far as possible the cost to the taxpayer of every service that comes before us. If we were dealing with the financial situation that obtained twelve months ago this Bill could have been and would have been more generous than it is. But we have got to realise that a reduction in the yield of taxation is a serious indication of the condition of affairs as regards finance. Whether we should ignore that fact and go on with expense is a matter upon which the Oireachtas must make up its mind.

The Government in putting before the Oireachtas this method of dealing with the housing problem, had in mind what it was likely to be able to impose upon the taxpayers during the next five years. The basis upon which the costs of this Act are being laid upon the shoulders of the taxpayer and ratepayer is that each will contribute his quota in the ratio of fifty-fifty towards the solution of this problem. There is no such policy enshrined in this amendment. Before concluding, I want to say that in the year 1922 the yield of taxation was approximately £25,000,000. The sum of money made available for local authorities in that year was approximately £1,000,000. This year taxation is estimated to yield £21,700,000 and the sum made available for local authorities this year is £3,700,000. With these facts before the House, is this amendment designed in the interest of the taxpayer, the ratepayer and the person who requires a house? I do not believe it is. I do not believe it is a sensible or constructive suggestion as regards dealing with this matter. It disturbs the basis of the operations of the Bill which deal with insanitary areas and houses, by placing upon the Minister the responsibility of declaring them insanitary and adding costs to the State in respect of the administration of that portion of the Bill. Secondly, it imposes upon the taxpayer a contribution which, if it is intended to persevere, is beyond his capacity to bear at the present moment. Thirdly, if that be the contribution which the Deputies who have put down this amendment believe to be within the capacity of the country in respect of insanitary dwellings in the country, then I say in respect of slum areas in cities, towns and villages the Minister's figures—if this figure is correct— are entirely and utterly insufficient and should be increased. Then we are faced with the problem of assembling the seven heads of families and telling them that we are imposing upon them a burden for the building of a house for one of the seven which is greater than they ought normally be called upon to bear—a burden that no citizen, looking at the problem and having in mind the condition of affairs in the country, could honestly and with due regard to all the circumstances put upon them in connection with the problem of housing.

Comment on this

The best two arguments for the amendment in the name of Deputy Seán T. O'Kelly were made by the President and the Minister. If they had not spoken, one might have felt that a lot of things had been left unsaid by the supporters of the amendment. The President's remarks at the beginning of the speech were not very germane to the amendment. They were as far removed from the subject of insanitary housing accommodation in rural areas and as close to personalities as they could be. The President said that roughly 80,000 houses were required in the 26 counties. Nobody has suggested, as the President tried to make out, that these 80,000 houses should be built in one financial year and that the contribution by taxpayers towards the cost of those houses should be levied in one financial year. The President knows that very well. If we were to proceed to liquidate the liability to the people of this country in respect of housing accommodation and if, starting now, we were to do it over a period of 20 years—that is, in respect both of rural and urban housing—we would be doing something. The President visualised the Minister himself or his messenger going down under this amendment and examining a particular house and then going back later and saying that it had complied with the requirements. The President knows very well that he has imposed upon many counties, and has the right to impose on every county, a medical officer of health costing a thousand a year. Surely the medical officer of health is the Minister's official. He gets a salary of £1,000 a year and should be competent to describe to the Minister whether a particular house is insanitary or not, and where it has been repaired that it has complied with the requirements in his opinion. It is all nonsense for the President to say that extra officials would be required—an extra £1,000 per county to administer this. Even if the President's statement were correct that it would require that to liquidate the responsibility of the State towards solving the housing problem and meeting the requirements so far as the 80,000 houses spoken of are concerned, that would not be such a terrible thing. The Minister has his medical officers of health, and I hold they should be competent to do this with their other work.

Reference was made to the £250,000 suddenly conjured out of thin air for the immediate relief of distress. I recommend the President to write another letter. If he does possibly he will get £250,000 towards the solution of the housing problem. If he embodies in his letter the speech that he has just made here he may get some reply to it. The President's contribution in the debate on this amendment was a complete admission of failure to deal with the problem. Because the problem is too big for him or his Government he refuses to face up to it. He is prepared to allow continue the position that we have, particularly in the rural areas. The housing shortage there, keen as it is, must remain, according to him. There is no promise from the Minister for Local Government that he intends by another Bill to deal with that subject in a short space of time. When a Bill was introduced, and we asked to have a proper title put to it, that it was a Bill particularly for towns and cities, we were pooh-poohed and told that it was a Bill for the whole of the 26 counties.

The Minister admits—probably he has had reports from his medical officers of health—that there are insanitary dwellings in rural areas. He has probably got a real shock from the number of complaints he has received, and realises that it is going to be a big problem to tackle. There is a lot of talk about the £25,000. Does the Minister contend that on his estimate that sum of money is going to touch the fringe of the problem so far as it relates to insanitary dwellings in the urban areas—towns and cities? Deputy Law divided that sum of £25,000 by the Minister's contribution of £20 as set down in the Bill, so the result is that the amount available will only deal with 1,250 houses. This Bill proposes not only to give no attention to the rural areas, but to limit the Government's responsibility with regard to insanitary dwellings in urban areas— cities and towns—to the extent of 1,250 houses. If that is to be the Government's contribution towards the urban areas, then I say, bad and all as it is to do nothing for the rural areas, the Government are only making an apology in the matter of doing something in the other areas. The Minister's confession of failure is "I realise the sore is there, and I am not going to deal with it."

Deputy Ward points out that something must be done. He is familiar with the conditions in the rural areas and he has described them for the House. There are many other members of the House who also represent rural areas. If what the Deputy has described is correct, then it is a disgrace for the Minister to adopt the attitude that he has adopted. What are we taunted with? The President turns around and asks, "How many houses have you built?" I will put the some question to the Minister. Can he say that he has even built one house? How many houses has the President built? When we propose to deal with this problem we are taunted with these questions. Deputy Ward has been asked how many houses he has built. Out of his small resources and influence, from the point of view of building, the Deputy can say that he has built 70 houses. When one compares his resources with those of the Government, I think the Deputy has certainly made a bigger contribution to the problem than they have. That kind of discussion had, I think, better be left alone by the President. I wonder how many houses the members of the President's own Party have built. Deputy Ward has built 70 houses not out of his own pocket. The Minister takes credit for the number of houses that the State has built, but we can turn around and say that the money that went to the building of them was not his but the taxpayers.

I hope the President and the Minister will cease that kind of talk and get down to fundamentals. By means of Parliamentary questions we dragged from the Government the information that the number of families living in single room tenements in Dublin is 18,000. We feel sad about that as everybody does. The President says that 80,000 houses are required and because our requirements are so great let us drop the whole thing. Our answer is, tackle the problem now and make some contribution towards the alleviation of the distress that such a state of affairs must cause. We say to the Government, contribute something towards the upliftment and the health of the people whether in urban or in rural areas; do not pretend that by allowing £25,000 to be used for certain purposes and affecting only 1,250 houses in the cities and the towns that that is going to mean anything. If that sum of money were allocated to the city of Dublin alone it would not touch the fringe of the problem that is to be dealt with here.

The President talked of the damage that might be caused if questions were to be asked by Deputies week after week with regard to particular houses in a particular area. The Minister for Local Government took steps to prevent that kind of activity developing as regards old age pensions. When Deputies sought to take steps to see that justice was done as between old age pension claimants and the pension officers, the Minister put a stop to that. Now the President comes along and grumbles at the thought that questions might be asked in the House in regard to a particular dwelling in the country. Does the Minister deny my positive statement that his medical officers of health throughout the country are fully competent to deal with this matter, and that there would be no need to spend one single penny extra in the shape of official salaries if they were to be required to do what is asked here. They are competent to certify whether a particular dwelling in a rural area is insanitary or not. They are also competent to certify and to satisfy the Minister in cases where improvements have been carried out whether the work has been done in a proper manner. Does the Minister deny that, or does he stand by what the President said, that these men are incompetent to render that particular service? I hope Deputies will have the good sense to support the amendment.

After all, as Deputy Ward points out, every penny that the State spends as a contribution towards housing, whether by way of grant for a new house or a grant for altering an insanitary house, comes from all classes of taxpayers and not exclusively from taxpayers of urban areas. Unless the Minister can say definitely that he intends to bring in a Bill specifically designed to deal with houses in rural areas, he has no case for opposing the amendment. Certainly from his own contribution to the debate and from the President's contribution they have shown absolute justification for the amendment. If the Minister does not like the proposal that he shall be the final authority, he can very easily accept the amendment and leave it to the local authority to deal with it. That is an easy matter to get over. If he is going to take the attitude of saying "because I happen to be mentioned in the Bill, the thing shall not be done," I think he is not going to face up, as the President has admitted he is not going to face up, to the problem. The Minister himself must admit that he does not want to tackle the housing problem in the rural areas at all and he is only attempting to tackle it in the urban areas to a very small degree.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. P. Hogan (Clare) Labour Party

The principal fault which the Minister found with the amendment is that it is against the spirit of present housing legislation. I think that has a great deal to recommend it because the present housing legislation, as I see it in operation, has no spirit It is a soulless thing endeavouring to move and getting nowhere. The Minister has in this measure made building operations in the non-urbanised towns almost impossible. He has made it almost impossible for local authorities to undertake any extensive building operations in non-urbanised towns. When we come to deal with the truly rural places we find that he refuses to accept an amendment of legislation that is long overdue. For some time past, when we were discussing housing legislation here, appeals had been made and claims put forward from I think almost every side of the House that improvement grants should be given towards the reconstruction of houses in rural districts. Anybody who knows country districts thoroughly knows that houses in rural areas lend themselves very considerably towards improvement, and that a good many of the drawbacks and the drabness of country life are attributable to bad housing conditions. Roofs are low, windows are small, floors are bad and the ventilation necessarily bad and inadequate. The space is inadequate. The raising of roofs, the raising of walls, the improvement of roofs, the enlargement of windows and the improvement of floors would very considerably improve the great majority of houses in rural districts. A grant towards doing all that would probably do more towards relieving this shortage of eighty thousand houses about which we hear the President talk, than anything that might be done. That is very necessary.

Appeals have been made, not alone from these benches and the Fianna Fail benches, but statements have been made from the Minister's own benches that some such measure is needed, and that some such consideration should be given. We do know that in rural Ireland a state of affairs exists where there are probably two divisions in a house and where probably, for decency sake, two divisions are made in one room, with inadequate cubic space, wretched flooring conditions and ventilation. These things could be easily remedied by raising the wall or, possibly, as Deputy Bennett said a while ago, by providing a loft-room which would help to give accommodation in the house. That is a thing to which the Minister should give consideration. He told us that he knows of its existence, but that he cannot deal with it. He told us that he has only £25,000 to play with. Surely that shows the bankruptcy of the Minister's housing policy. It shows his failure to face up to the situation as it exists. He has £25,000, and he knows that that will not touch the fringe of it. The President, dealing with the matter a little while ago, purposely confused the issues, because if there is a question about which the President knows anything, we must admit without equivocation that it is housing. I admit that freely, but he certainly got up not to deal with the housing situation in Ireland, but to confuse the issue and to create an atmosphere in the House against the amendment. That is the way he dealt with it.

If he wants money there has been a suggestion put forward from these benches before that there is a method of dealing with the housing problem on a national scale by the raising of a national loan to meet the contingency, and to meet it in a way which would eradicate the sore that is eating like a canker into the social fabric. We heard a lot of talk about the impracticability of it. Possibly the amendment is badly drafted. Possibly it is not related sufficiently to the local authority. I am speaking without any information as to what Deputy O'Kelly had in his mind when he said "Where in the opinion of the Minister a dwelling-house is wholly unsuitable." I should rather say "Where in the opinion of the local sanitary authority a dwelling-house is unsuitable." You could very easily correlate that with the local housing authority. You can very easily make your assistant surveyors the people to examine the houses and make their certificate the certificate under which the improvement or the rebuilding grant would be given. Clearly the thing could be worked and clearly the attitude of the President and of the Minister should be to accept the principle of the amendment and to redraft it in such a way that it would be possible for the grant to be given to the local authorities who declare a house insanitary and for the local assistant surveyor's certificate to be the certificate upon which payment would be made. The building of houses in rural areas is a necessity. The improvement of houses in rural areas is a greater necessity. While I support heartily the amendment as far as it goes for the giving of grants for the construction of houses, I support more heartily the suggestion in the amendment for the improvement of houses because houses in the rural areas lend themselves much more readily to reconstruction than any other type of houses we have in the country at the moment.

Comment on this

This amendment, no matter what the President may pretend about it, would be the only thing in this Bill if it were accepted, which would give an opportunity to small farmers either to improve or build houses under the measure when it is passed into law. No matter what statements the President is pleased to make about this amendment in order to confuse the issue, that is the fact. When previous Housing Bills were introduced here, we on this side on one occasion had an amendment down which was somewhat similar to the present amendment, that a grant would be given to small farmers throughout the country for the improvement of their houses. Anybody who understands the position of housing in rural Ireland will have to admit that the greatest necessity of the moment is the improvement of dwelling-houses in the country and not the building of new houses. Take as an illustration of that the number of houses that have been built. Mind you, the Minister for Local Government and the President have tried to make all the Party capital they can out of the number of new houses built over a number of years. Even if we take that number in its largest way, and allow the President to exaggerate the value and the number of houses in the most elaborate way, we still have to admit that the building of that large number of new houses has not touched the fringe of the housing problem in insanitary areas, because of this fact, people in most instances, throughout the country, built houses and availed of this plan, who could afford to have built them without a grant, and would have built them anyhow. That is the position in the West of Ireland, and let nobody pretend that it is not. A very small percentage of the people in the West of Ireland who built houses under the old housing grants built them because of the grant. The big majority who built them probably might have delayed a year or two, but anyway they hurried on to avail of the grant. If the amendment we proposed a couple of years ago on another Housing Bill were accepted to give £40 or thereabouts to the people who would improve their dwelling-houses, you would have a far greater percentage of insanitary housing conditions removed than you had under the Bills as they were. That is the one big mistake in all the Housing Bills which have been passed here.

Deputy Hogan has emphasised that fact as to Clare. He knows the conditions there. We know them too, Unless you accept this amendment the insanitary conditions in the West of Ireland will not be touched at all by this measure. It is no use for the President to pretend that he is not aware of the insanitary conditions. The medical officers of health in every county have been reporting to the Minister for Local Government the insanitary conditions of housing and the number of insanitary houses. Can the Minister state here now that a large percentage of those houses that were insanitary have been made sanitary because of any Bill passed into law, since he came into office? Can he state that the number of houses reported as insanitary to his Department are not now in that insanitary condition, because of any Bill that has been passed? He cannot say that. A number of houses remain insanitary, but new houses have been built. That is because they refused in the past to regulate the measure that was being passed in such a way that people in insanitary houses could avail of a small grant to improve their houses. The Minister must surely know that the number of insanitary houses in County Mayo is very large despite the fact that he may boast of the number of houses that have been built in County Mayo.

If this amendment is not passed the same number of insanitary houses will remain. Is it not better for the State that the greater percentage of people living in insanitary houses should be facilitated so as to avail of the grant? Get a smaller amount of money, spread it over a larger number and relieve people to a greater extent than they would be relieved by the giving of a grant for one house only. That is the part of the Bill I am interested in. I have discussed it with people who in the past were in the Department of Local Government and were interested in housing. They told me that from their experience in the past of schemes under the Congested Districts Board a greater number of insanitary houses were made sanitary and improved with a lesser amount of money than has been spent by the present Government on housing, because there was that clause in the Act which enabled people to avail of a grant for the improvement of housing.

I think the Minister should at least say that this amendment would be considered by him. He should know its value and that it will touch the insanitary conditions if it is accepted. He should, in turning the amendment down, not force the members of his Party to vote against it. It is not put down as the President tries to suggest in his usual petty fashion for electioneering purposes. We leave that to the President. He has discovered £250,000 in the last few days in a place where no one knew it existed and that money is to be used for election purposes. He cannot say that this has been for electioneering purposes because it is over three years ago since a similar amendment was put down by this Party in this House. At that time they found some other argument against it. The only argument they can find against it now is that it is done for electioneering purposes, because the President thinks the financial appeal of the Unionists will give him sufficient funds for the election within a short period. Why cannot they find some reasonable argument against this amendment? We had the President's talk about the possibility or impossibility of finding of money. We had a statement from the President that this Bill would not be as bad as it is—even from the President we got an admission that it is a bad Bill—only for the financial crash. We had quite recently this unfortunate admission from the President of the State, who is so proud of this State and its stable conditions. We had it from him that the Bill would not be as bad as it is only for the trouble we are in financially. As well as being an unfortunate admission, it is also an eye-opener for us, because the Minister for Finance, in introducing his supplementary Budget, assured us that economy would be rigidly enforced by the Government.

Now we know in what way economy is to be rigidly enforced. It is to be rigidly enforced in attacking the estimates that are to come for social services and the estimates that are to deal with the poorest of the poor, in attacking the estimates for the money that is to be given for housing in the slums in the towns and in the country, the money that was to go to house the poor, to wipe out insanitary conditions, and thereby wipe out disease and slums. The money is now to be reduced. We are to economise there. We have got the assurance of the President that it is one of the big ways in which they are to economise. The President after making that statement began to criticise members on this side of the House because we voted a few weeks ago against extra taxation here. He found fault with it. The greatest justification for the vote which we gave a few weeks ago against half a million pounds of increased taxation was the statement of the President here that economy was to be practised in the social services.

That, anyhow, justified us in voting against increased taxation, because we voted against that increase in taxation for no other reason than that taxation was being increased before the President or the Minister for Finance made any definite statement as to how they were going to economise, even though they told us that they were going to economise to the tune of half a million pounds. Instead of the President having to reduce the amount that was to be given to the housing of the poor and the wiping out of insanitary conditions in the country, he could easily increase it if instead of coming down first and foremost on the services that have to deal with the poor he would economise in other directions. When he talks of their having to economise in this way, I think we should remind him that he should find other ways, and that instead of subsidising other countries to the tune of £5,000,000 per year he should deal with the conditions here. Even the President himself felt that his arguments were weak.

Another argument used was that if this amendment were passed officials would be increased because officials would have to be sent around to see what houses are insanitary, as according to the wording of the amendment the Minister must be satisfied that houses are insanitary before they are to be condemned and new houses erected. Is not the Minister all along being informed as to insanitary conditions of houses in the country? What are his medical officers of health for? You do not need to increase the number of medical officers of health in County Mayo to find out what insanitary houses are there. The reports of the medical officers of health should be a sufficient indication to the Minister that he could state definitely that a certain number of houses are insanitary and, therefore, give the concession that is asked for in this amendment. Surely it is reasonable to expect that. I do not think that the Minister can make any real argument against it, except the lack of funds. I admit that that is a real argument. But the intentions of the amendment are good. Surely these things cannot be denied in justice by the Minister. It all comes back, therefore, to the argument that we are short of money and that we can only give £25,000. Surely the resources of the State have not run out to that extent. We were on the verge of a financial crash a few weeks ago and yet the Government, on one minute's notice, found £2,000,000 for the Shannon Scheme that they have all messed up. How is it they found that? If the Shannon Scheme had gone right that £2,000,000 would be here. I suppose if something else would happen in another Department to show up the mismanagement of affairs by another Minister they would easily find another million pounds to put it right. But when an essential social service comes to be tackled they can find no money for it. They are prepared to put it aside. I think it is deplorable, and I think it should be faced up to by the Minister. We should at least have a definite statement from them that they do not want to tackle the question or we should get the confession of failure which their opposition to this amendment means.

Comment on this

It is because housing conditions in the rural areas are very closely under consideration by us that we oppose this amendment. Deputies on the other side have talked a lot about rural housing and what they require done for housing, and they put forward an amendment which would show very little consideration for rural housing if it were examined pretty closely. Earlier today we passed Part III of this Bill, which gives power to an urban authority to declare that a particular house is in an insanitary condition and that it requires to be repaired. We gave powers to the local authority to insist on the owner at his own expense putting that house in a sanitary condition. A terrible lot of tears have been spilt over rural housing and over an amendment which would give that person ordered by the local authority to put his house in proper repair, to turn to the Minister and get £40. The person who would be ordered by the local authority to put a house that is in an insanitary condition in proper repair would be handed £40 out of the £25,000. That would mean that there would be very little to give around for some of the rural schemes that Deputies talked about. It is because Deputies have not considered the rural problem that they have come forward with a proposal like this as a solution of it.

Comment on this

I think the Minister has been inaccurate in a couple of respects. First, he criticised the drafting of the amendment. He is probably aware that the amendment was drafted by the official draftsman.

Comment on this

I was not talking about the draftsman at all. I am talking about a person in an urban area who has an insanitary house being given £40 to put it right.

Comment on this

Not necessarily. The house must be suitable to be occupied by a person of the working class. That particular part of the Bill is designed mainly to deal with tenement dwellings in the city. The houses intended to be covered by this amendment are houses occupied by the owners. There are very few such houses in Dublin. They are mainly in rural areas and owned and occupied by farmers. Consequently, it is quite clear that there is quite an unmistakable distinction between houses intended to be dealt with by Part III of the Bill and houses intended to be dealt with by this amendment.

Comment on this

The slap-dash consideration of the problem generally is reflected in the slap-dash putting together of the amendment.

Comment on this

It is a matter of principle and not a matter of wording.

Amendment put; the Committee divided: Tá, 45; Níl, 66.

Tá

Aiken, Frank.Allen, Denis.Blaney, Neal.Boland, Gerald.Bourke, Daniel.Briscoe, Robert.Broderick, Henry.Buckley, Daniel.Carty, Frank.Cassidy, Archie J.Clery, Michael.Colbert, James.Cooney, Eamon.Corkery, Dan.Corish, Richard.Crowley, Fred. Hugh.Crowley, Tadhg.Davin, William.De Valera, Eamon.Doyle, Edward.Everett, James.Fahy, Frank.Fogarty, Andrew. | Gorry, Patrick J.Goulding, John.Hayes, Seán.Hogan, Patrick (Clare).Houlihan, Patrick.Jordan, Stephen.Kent, William R.Killilea, Mark.Kilroy, Michael.Lemass, Seán F.Little, Patrick John.MacEntee, Seán.Moore, Séamus.Morrissey, Daniel.O'Connell, Thomas J.O'Kelly, Seán T.O'Reilly, Matthew.Powell, Thomas P.Sexton, Martin.Smith, Patrick.Walsh, Richard.Ward, Francis C.

Níl

Alton, Ernest Henry.Beckett, James Walter.Bennett, George Cecil.Blythe, Ernest.Bourke, Séamus A.Brennan, Michael.Brodrick, Seán.Coburn, James.Collins-O'Driscoll, Mrs. Margt.Conlon, Martin.Connolly, Michael P.Cosgrave, William T.Craig, Sir James.Crowley, James.Davis, Michael.Dolan, James N.Doyle, Peadar Seán.Esmonde. Osmond Thos. Grattan.Finlay, Thomas A.Fitzgerald, Desmond.Fitzgerald-Kenney, James.Good, John.Gorey, Denis J.Hassett, John J.Heffernan, Michael R.Hennessy, Michael Joseph.Hennessy, Thomas.Hennigan, John.Henry, Mark.Hogan, Patrick (Galway).Holohan, Richard.Kelly, Patrick Michael.Keogh, Myles. | Law, Hugh Alexander.Leonard, Patrick.Lynch, Finian.Mathews, Arthur Patrick.McDonogh, Martin.MacEoin, Seán.McFadden, Michael Og.McGilligan, Patrick.Mongan, Joseph W.Mulcahy, Richard.Murphy, James E.Myles, James Sproule.Nally, Martin Michael.Nolan, John Thomas.O'Connell, Richard.O'Connor, Bartholomew.O'Donovan, Timothy Joseph.O'Hanlon, John F.O'Leary, Daniel.O'Mahony. The.O'Reilly, John J.O'Sullivan, Gearóid.O'Sullivan, John Marcus.Reynolds, Patrick.Rice, Vincent.Roddy, Martin.Sheehy, Timothy (West Cork).Thrift, William Edward.Tierney, Michael.White, John.White, Vincent Joseph.Wolfe, George.Wolfe, Jasper Travers.

Tellers:—Tá: Deputies G. Boland and Allen; Níl: Deputies P.S. Doyle and Dolan.

Comment on this

I move amendment 29b:—

To add at the end of sub-section (3) (a), line 10, the words "provided that a farmer whose sole or main source of living is derived from land the valuation of which does not exceed £15 be given a grant of £45."

The main purpose of this amendment is to give to small farmers under a £15 valuation a grant of £45. This class of person cannot get any grant from any other source such as the Agricultural Credit Corporation. The President cannot hold that these are people who could build houses themselves or who would be in a position to do so if there was no grant at all. I think this amendment could easily be accepted. It is confined to small holders under a £15 valuation who derive their living mainly from farming. They are the class who are very badly off in the way of housing.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Much the same case exists in this instance as existed in the last. These Housing Acts have been in operation now for something like seven years and a considerable inroad has been made upon the problem since 1924. If the revenue position were better than it is, this Bill might possibly have been more generous, but that is a consideration which we cannot remove from observation at the moment. It may be that if we see an improvement, this particular grant might be reconsidered but at the present moment I am not in a position to justify any change in the financial side of the Bill as it stands.

Comment on this

The case that was made on the last amendment, as the President said, is practically the same case that could be made for this, except that this amendment is not so wide and it confines the grants to a definite class of person. It provides for a farmer whose sole or main source of living is derived from land the valuation of which does not exceed £15. That is limiting the persons to whom it is proposed to apply this amendment to a certain definite section of the population. Undoubtedly there might be additional funds required. I do not know to what extent. I do not know if anybody could tell right off what the extent would be to which money would be required at present. But if the amendment were passed an estimate could be made between now and the Report Stage. Again I repeat what one of my colleagues said speaking on the last amendment, when it is so easy to find £250,000 for other purposes, desirable purposes no doubt, it is reasonable to believe that some additional money could be found for such eminently desirable purposes as this is.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

This is not an amendment to provide additional money.

Comment on this

No. I am not proposing that we provide additional money, but the President said speaking to the last amendment that it would be necessary and in case it were necessary, it is possible he would know where to find it.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

We must discuss the amendment on some other basis.

Comment on this

The case is a good one for this amendment. I know a considerable amount or at least an average amount about housing conditions in Dublin. I know much less about housing conditions in rural areas, but I know enough to know that the conditions of housing in rural areas amongst small farmers is not anything like what it ought to be. Housing in fact is in a deplorable condition in many counties. It is quite true that the present might not be the most auspicious moment in which to find money. It is quite true that it is more difficult to find money now than it was in 1924 or 1925 or 1926. But the money was not found in these earlier years, and no real attempt was made to tackle this problem of rural housing any more than there was a satisfactory attempt made to tackle the question of urban housing. The attempt must be made some time and the sooner the better. The case is a good one considering the class of people it is intended to benefit under this amendment and I think the House ought to support it.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

The speech we have just listened to is on a par with every contribution to this debate made by the same Deputy. He tells us that nothing has been done. The fact of the matter is that 11,245 houses have been provided, and the Government contribution up to date is £712,000. As far as this particular amendment is concerned, it is practically the same as the last. The proposal is that, whether a house is insanitary or not the £45 is to be found. Well, it can be found out of the £25,000, but it simply means that only half the number will be provided. As I have said already, the financial basis of this Bill is on the assumption that the ratepayers will contribute a quota of an equal amount with the taxpayers. That basis runs through the whole of the measure. This has nothing whatever to do with the £250,000. There seems to be a great deal of dissatisfaction about the discovery of that particular money. The sum of money provided in respect of housing for the last ten years is £2,500,000. Whether that can go on at the same pace for the next ten years I am unable to say. The finances made available in this Bill are finances which, in the opinion of the Executive Council, represent the capacity of the taxpayers to bear. That is one of the main considerations in connection with the solution of any problem. It will be equally the main consideration for any Government other than this Government.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

This amendment will have to be discussed on the understanding that the money must be found within the £25,000.

Comment on this

I will discuss it on that understanding. I am glad the President realises that the financial situation in the country has nothing to do with this amendment. The question at issue is whether within the limits of £25,000 we are going to adopt the principle of grading our housing grants in accordance with the financial position of the persons to be assisted. The President has indicated the number of houses built under various Housing Acts. Who are the people occupying these houses? Are they the people who are in most urgent need of houses? The fact is that about 50 per cent. of the houses erected are five-roomed houses costing £500 to £600 to build.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

The figure is more likely to be £300 to £400.

Comment on this

I have the exact figures here.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Has the Deputy the figures for the rural areas?

Comment on this

The average cost in 1929 was £530.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

That is the average cost for the cities, taken with the country.

Comment on this

It is the average for the whole country.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

That is the point. There is a difference as between the cities and towns and the rural districts.

Comment on this

A greater volume of the assistance given by the State to housing has gone to the people who, although in need of houses, were much less urgently in need of houses than those whom it is intended to assist under this amendment.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Will the Deputy give us some information on that point?

Comment on this

We may take that as being so by reason of the fact that about 50 per cent. of the houses were five-roomed houses, about 30 per cent. were four-roomed, and there was a smaller percentage of three-roomed houses. All that would seem to suggest that the greater part of the money was given to better class persons who sought to avail of the Housing Acts. The purpose of the amendment is to endeavour to secure out of the £25,000 a maximum assistance to persons in rural areas who are in need of houses and who cannot afford to finance the erection of a house for themselves. As Deputy Clery said some time ago, a large number of people got assistance under the Housing Acts who themselves would have built houses in any case even if there had been no grants available. People who are earning a living out of agriculture upon farms with a valuation of £15 or less cannot build houses unless assisted with a substantial grant. We believe that the proposed grant of £20, even with a grant of £20 from the local authority, will not be adequate as far as these people are concerned, and in their cases this measure will be inoperative because they will be unable to provide the balance necessary even for a three-roomed house.

£25,000 is the limit which the President says the State can afford to give in grants under this part of the Bill. If that is so, I think it is desirable that we should try and ensure that that money will go to those who need houses most and go to them in a manner which will enable them to avail of it to improve their housing accommodation. That is the purpose of the amendment and that is why we are proposing it. It raises a different issue altogether from that raised on the last amendment and one which should be very seriously considered before being rejected.

Comment on this

In the absence of information from the Government as to what their commitments are in so far as this £25,000 is concerned, it is very hard to have any kind of an intelligent discussion on the matter. I take it that the £25,000 mentioned by the Minister and the President is in connection with houses started within the last five or six months and as to which a promise has been made by the Minister that a certain grant will be paid. Am I correct in that?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I should have said £30,000. That is the position.

Comment on this

I agree with Deputy Lemass and I think that special consideration ought to be given to the small farmers whose houses are practically falling down and who, in many cases, would require to build new houses. I also agree with Deputy Lemass that certain speculators have been provided with money to build houses, and I suggest to the Minister and the President that they themselves even never intended that these people should be helped through the medium of an Act specially introduced for the housing of the working classes. I know of cases where private speculators have built houses and got grants of £60 and in some cases £80. They also got a rebate of rates. They took full advantage of that when assessing the rents and as a result are drawing 15 per cent. profit on their money. I would be sorry to think that that was the intention of the President in introducing these Acts which were called Acts for the housing of the working classes. I suggest that it is small farmers and people of that type that we ought to consider in a Bill of this kind before we consider giving anything at all to people who are well able to build houses for themselves without receiving any grant. From that angle I ask the Minister to reconsider his decision in connection with the amendment of Deputy Allen.

Comment on this

This amendment proposes that a grant of £45 should be given to people with a valuation of £15 or under, and has been attacked by the President on entirely different grounds from those on which he attacked the other amendment. He attacked this amendment by saying that it was not specified that only people with insanitary houses could get a grant, while he attacked the other amendment because it was confined to people living in insanitary houses. He cannot have it both ways. The last amendment was defeated because the President said it was confined to people living in insanitary houses. He wants this amendment defeated because it is not confined to people living in insanitary houses. That is a ridiculous attitude to take up and he cannot be serious in it. If that is his argument against the amendment, we would be willing to confine the amendment to people living in insanitary houses. Would the President accept it then? Of course he would not. He would not even think it worth while to consider it even then. Surely he cannot be serious. Surely an amendment of this kind is not a frivolous one. He should realise that when we laid down the valuation of persons who should get this grant and confine it to people who derived their livelihood from the land, we had in mind people living in insanitary houses. The President, if he knew anything of the insanitary conditions under which farmers have to live, should know that it is people with valuations of £15 and under who are living in the insanitary houses. Surely the President should give us credit for these intentions, but I suppose he will not. When he cannot attack this amendment from one point of view he goes back on his previous argument on another amendment and attacks it from another point of view. That is not a lead that should be given by the President. The President should discuss this matter on a higher plane.

In justice to everybody who is concerned with the insanitary conditions under which the people live this should be dealt with in a fair way and there should be some decent way of tackling the question of insanitary dwellings. The President's argument was that if we give a grant of £45 to people whose valuation is under £15 we will limit the number of houses to be built. I would even approve of that. I would prefer that less houses should be built, provided it is ensured that they are built for people with insanitary houses. Under the President's scheme people with very good housing accommodation will be able to build houses and they will be the only people who can afford to avail of the Bill in rural areas. Would it not be better to make it possible for people living in insanitary houses to build than to allow them to continue to live in disease-ridden houses? It would be much better to do it by this method. As the other amendment was defeated, it would be a good gesture and something decent on the part of the President to accept this amendment. I do not think that any Government Deputy will say that this is unfair or unjust to any section of the community anxious to build houses. It is as a matter of fact a method of meeting them and giving them a chance to build. When the justice of the case has to be admitted, could not the President meet us and accept the amendment?

Comment on this

I am in sympathy with the principle of the amendment, but, on the whole, I think it would not be fair to give a grant of £45 to farmers whose valuation does not exceed £15 and only give £20 to farmers, say, with a valuation of £16. Deputies forget one very material fact in connection with the giving either of a grant of £45 or of £20, and that is that the grant is contingent on the local authority in whose area the house is to be erected, making a similar grant. As I have said over and over again in this House, there is a limit to what this country can afford by way of subsidies and in the near future I hope to see subsidies done away with altogether and the building industry standing on its own legs. If unemployment increases here, the building or repairing of houses will be of very little avail. It would be better to devote any money that we have at our disposal towards giving employment rather than building or repairing houses. My chief objection to the amendment is that it is class legislation. Deputy Clery may laugh, but I should like him to show where it is not.

Comment on this

You are trying to get a way out of it.

Comment on this

You are giving £45 to one class of farmer and £20 to another. As far as I can see, in the present financial position of the country we cannot afford very much more.

Comment on this

A fully-fledged Government Deputy.

Comment on this

I may be a Government Deputy or I may not, according to Deputy Clery, but I am always prepared to face facts. I have done as much as anybody else to have houses erected for the working classes and o help people who needed houses badly. If this amendment is accepted, it would mean a great deal of extra work on the Local Government Department. It will mean that officials will have to be sent round the country to see that the valuation of those who apply for the grant is under £15 and that will mean a great deal of extra expense. On the whole, I think the Government are doing very well in providing the money they have provided, with the limited means at their disposal, in an attempt to solve the housing problem. I think it is only by the co-operation of all classes that any definite advance can be made in regard to the provision of houses.

Comment on this

I would be the last to wish to make any distinction in the matter of housing between town dwellers and the rural population, but I would like the Minister to take note of the fact that there is much complaint particularly amongst small farmers regarding this housing grant. Houses are badly wanted for the workers in the towns, but the small farmers say that either directly or indirectly they have to pay a good deal of the money for these schemes and that they get very little advantage out of them. Deputy Coburn spoke of the necessity of giving employment. We know the condition under which the small farmer lives, and we know that the small farmer could hardly live on his farm unless he had a son or two to help him. They often remain with their fathers until 40 years of age. As we know, the farmers' sons cannot now emigrate, and surely it would be giving employment if the farmer got this grant of £45 to help to build or reconstruct his house. They could do a great deal more work upon their houses for £45 than a town dweller could do. We have had reference to the housing of the working classes. I consider that the hardest of all workers in the country is the small farmer. I call him nothing but a worker, and a very hard worker at that. There is very great need for an amendment, such as that we are now discussing. Among the small farmers of Galway, I know many cases myself. It surely would not necessitate sending officials through the country ascertaining valuations when we know it has been the duty of the Land Commission and the Land Registry to find out the valuation of every man's farm. Is Deputy Coburn so simple as to believe the Land Commission does not know the valuation of farms. I do not think that it is making any great distinction, considering the operations of previous Acts, that this grant should be made to anyone with a valuation of £15 and under.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

The figures I have given do not include the Gaeltacht figures which would send the number up to close on 14,000 and the money up to close on £1,000,000.

Comment on this

Again, I submit that the President is only introducing these figures to side step the amendment which relates to the sum of £25,000 and raises the question whether or not we are to separate that in the form of £20 grants, some of which will go to people who do not need them or take some part of it for giving the £45 grant to the people who need it most. That is the issue.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

There is a bigger issue. What is to happen to a man whose valuation is £15 1s., or £16 or even £18? The valuation is no true index at all.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Connell

Why fix the limits of the amount in Section 29 of £30? What about the man with, perhaps, £30 1s.?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

What has the Deputy to say about it?

Comment on this

Why fix £30 and £25?

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

We will take that when it is raised. We are dealing now with the question that Deputy Lemass is particular about. I shall wait for whatever is to be said on that and deal with it when it arises. He wants £25,000 to supply only half the number. The Deputy says we should take a certain valuation. A man with a valuation of £15 1s. is out, but a valuation of £15 is in. If the Deputy takes that line obviously valuation must be perfect all over the country. We know it is not. We know that there are cases of men with £12 valuation who are much better off than people who have an £18 valuation.

Comment on this

I do not care how the President seeks to find people that need assistance most. He may count their cattle, sheep, or their pigs, but the valuation is the more practical test. It may not operate perfectly fairly as between the £15 and the £16, but it will operate to show that a man with a valuation under £15, whether that valuation be £14 or £13 or £11, will be able to get more assistance than the man above £15. If that is class legislation we stand for it.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Deputies do not like to be nailed to that, and Deputy Coburn has nailed them to it.

Comment on this

The President knows that this £25,000 is not going to be spent at all. He knows the local authorities will not put up the necessary £20, especially for speculative builders. No local authority will give the speculative builder £20 under this Act, if it is to go to the persons that Deputy Coburn wants it to go. This £25,000 will be here ten years hence.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Is the Deputy in serious doubt about that?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

Why put down the amendment then?

Comment on this

To make use of the money.

Comment on this

You know well the £25,000 is not going to be spent.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I have taken the average county, and I know the number of houses put up, and I know what 1d. in the £ would produce. The Deputy says this is not going to go on. He comes on with this amendment, although he says now it is a joke.

Comment on this

Your proposal is a joke. The one hope in getting local authorities to put up this £20 is that most of this £25,000 should go to a certain class of people, namely, the small householders under £15 valuation. They will not put it up for the class of people that Deputy Coburn wants it to go to, namely, the speculative builders.

Comment on this

This amendment, taken by itself would command the sympathy, I think, of every Deputy in the House, but taken in connection with others on the Amendment Paper, and Deputy Allen's argument, it assumes a different aspect. I would favour the amendment if I thought it feasible. I agree with Deputy Allen that it is very unlikely that the local authorities will advance £20, but it is far more unlikely that they would advance £45. If I thought this amendment would help rural housing I would be in favour of it. Taking the Co. Cavan, the farmer with a valuation of £15 and under is the type of man who wants assistance to build a house. Most of these farmers are living in rural slums. I do not think that this amendment making £45 available in such cases, and asking the local authority to give another £45 is going to assist. If I thought it would I would vote for it, but I do not think it will.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Hanlon has given the most extraordinary reason for voting against this amendment. He says if it stood by itself it would command the sympathy of the House, but because he thinks it does not stand by itself he is going to vote against it. The money would not be given without the local authority. The amendment does not stand by itself, It stands with the amendment that follows, amendment 30, which proposes to delete paragraph (c) of the section, in which case the money will become available to these farmers, irrespective of whether the local authority put up any money or not. If Deputy O'Hanlon is really in sympathy with the amendment he is bound to vote for it and the next amendment. His whole problem would then be solved. He can make this money immediately available for these poor farmers. It was quite obvious that when the President rose to reply to Deputy Allen he had not read the amendment and did not know what it related to. He gave an exhibition of wriggling——

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

I discussed it for half an hour before I came in here to-day.

Comment on this

He gave an exhibition of wriggling which would do credit to the monkey house in the Zoo. "What," says he, "is to become of the poor man with a valuation of £15 1s.?" What is to become of the poor old person who is 69 years and eleven months? We do not hear any mention of knocking off a month and making the old age pension available for a person 69 years and 11 months.

Comment on this
William T. Cosgrave The President

That person would get it in another month.

Comment on this

It would be quite easy to knock the shilling off the valuation. As to the £15, if the President knows anything about legislation, or if he turns to the Gaeltacht Housing Act, he will see that the figure there is £15. A holding of £15 valuation has always been regarded as a congested holding in this country, and one to which special attention should be given. The President has not advanced a single convincing reason against the amendment.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 45
·
Níl 64
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 30:—

In sub-section (3) to delete paragraph (c).

The paragraph of the sub-section which I propose to omit is that which restricts the grant of £20 to cases in which the local authority shall be willing to supplement that with an equivalent sum. This is a comparatively minor question—a question of detail and of administration. I am not myself aware why the Minister has for, I think, the first time imported this condition into a provision dealing with grants. I am not voicing a particular or a local grievance. I think it is only fair to say that my own county has benefited quite considerably under previous Acts. We have had a very considerable number of houses built in County Donegal with the aid of the various grants obtainable in previous years. I do not know the exact number but I know from my own observation that the number is considerable. Under the Housing (Gaeltacht) Act, the poorer quarters of the county have benefited, I understand, to the extent of about 500 houses, at a cost of something like £36,000. I am not voicing, therefore, a particular grievance. Further, having regard to the character of the operation of recent housing Acts, I do feel that it may reasonably be said that it is now the turn of the cities. The main purpose of this Bill is the removal of the slum problem. For that reason, I am prepared loyally to acquiesce in the decision already come to by which the amount available for grants in the future will be cut down to a relatively small sum. At the same time, I do not wish to see that sort of housing outside the Gaeltacht area come entirely to an end. It is the opinion of people whom I consulted that this restriction will act adversely on housing in the rural districts.

Comment on this

I agree with the argument put forward by Deputy Law, but it is not our intention that by the deletion of this paragraph we shall prevent the local authority giving any assistance it thought fit—£20 or more —to encourage people to build houses. We should like to leave the local authority free to give such grants. Possibly some of them might be prepared to go further and give larger grants than are provided for in this paragraph. We do think that the effect of this sub-section will be to stop house-building in several counties. The rural elements are complaining that rates are so high that it would be very difficult to induce local authorities to expend further moneys in this way. But that would not apply all round. There are areas where housing conditions are bad and where rates are high. Still, local authorities might be induced to make grants and in such areas house-building would be continued. But if the law be enacted as suggested in this Bill, and if the grant is made absolutely contingent on the granting of a similar subsidy by the local authority, the local authority will not, in many cases, do its part and, therefore, the arrangement will fall through. We can still leave it open to the local authorities to give this grant of £20 or more—give it, as it was before, by remission of rates on a sliding scale or in any other way, subject to the Minister's approval. There is a widespread opinion amongst my colleagues that the insertion of this restriction will have a bad effect upon the continuance of house-building.

Comment on this

I cannot agree with Deputy Law that there is anything minor about this amendment. All through this Bill, the State undertakes to provide loans to private persons, local authorities and public utility societies for building houses.

The grants that have been given to private persons are coming down on a reduced scale. We are near the time when grants to private persons ought to stop. The State provides capital for private persons and local bodies to build houses. Where a subsidy is being given either towards the building of houses in order to take people from insanitary dwellings, to build houses for the poorer classes or for the better paid working classes, the principle runs through the Bill that so far as there is a direct financial subsidy approximately half of that is given by the local authority and half by the State. If we do that in the case of housing in order to replace insanitary dwellings for the very poor, we certainly can afford to do it in the case of private persons. During the last seven years 467 houses have been built in the County Roscommon by private persons under the Housing Acts. In the same period the number built in Galway was 973. Progress can be continued in both counties at the same progress as is indicated in those figures by the local authority giving a grant of £20 from the rates. In Roscommon that can be done by the striking a rate of a penny in the £, and in Galway by a rate of 1½d. in the £. If, after all that has been said about the boon and the benefit it is to the various counties to have housing activity of that kind going on, the local authorities in Roscommon and Galway do not consider it worth while to strike a rate of 1d. and of 1½d. in the £, respectively, to maintain that activity, then that will confirm me in the opinion that the time has come to stop grants to private persons. For these reasons the amendment moved by Deputy Law and Deputy O'Kelly hits at a very important matter and is not acceptable.

Comment on this

The Minister forgot to mention that not alone do the local authorities give a grant equivalent to the Government grant, but they give more than the Government inasmuch as they give rebate of a certain amount of the rate payable on houses over a period, I think, of seven years. In view of that I think the Minister ought to give consideration to the amendment.

Comment on this

There is a remission of two-thirds of the rates for seven years.

Comment on this

That means that the contribution made by the local authority is greater than the contribution given by the Government.

Comment on this

In view of the Minister's attitude I ask leave to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment 31:—In sub-section (3) (d), line 23, to delete the figures "750" and substitute the figures "950."

In connection with this amendment perhaps I might refer to the amendment proposing to delete sub-sections (4) and (5). As these sub-sections stand there is a remission of two-thirds of the rates for seven years in the case of houses built with the floor area mentioned in Section 3 (d) (2). We propose deleting sub-sections (4) and (5), and putting in amendment 35 instead. By that amendment we are securing that if a house is built, even though the local authority does not give the £20, and that, therefore, the State does not give the £20, it will still be entitled to the seven years' remission of rates if the floor area is that mentioned in Section 3 (d) (2). I am seeking by this amendment to increase the floor area from 750 square feet to 950 square feet. The general financial result of that on buildings in urban areas will be this: The 950 square feet is intended to force building down to the type of building that the better class worker wants, that is to say, to force builders away from the £1,000 figure. At the moment the tendency on the part of speculative builders is to build houses round about the figure of £900. We want to force building down towards the class, above that of the ordinary working classes, that wants houses. That is why we reduce, in respect to urban areas, the floor area down to 950 square feet which would be about the floor area of a five-roomed house. In urban areas the position with regard to houses will be that a house that comes under the 950 square feet category can get the £20, plus the £20 from the local authority, with the seven years' remission of rates. That type of house will also be entitled to get a loan under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act if the floor area is above 950 square feet and under 1,250 square feet. There will be no grant, but there will be seven years' remission of rates. If the floor area is above 750 square feet, and if the value of the house is not more than £1,000, then in respect of that class of house a loan under the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act will also be available, but the remission of two-thirds of the rates will be only for five years as laid down in the Local Government Act. In the case of rural areas, houses with an area of 1,250 square feet can be given the grant, and in these cases also the remission of rates will be available.

Comment on this

If the grant is not given will there be a remission of rates all the same?

Comment on this

I would like to know from the Minister if he is prepared to increase the figure in respect to area from 950 to 1,000, and whether he has any definite plan in mind in relation to the particular figure that he mentions. In Dublin, at present, houses are being built for £750. The difference between the £750 house and the £1,000 house is very considerable. I am not personally interested in this, but from copies of plans which I have in my possession it would seem to me that a very serious disadvantage would result if the area of houses to be built was not at least 1,000 square feet. As between the Minister's proposal and what I suggest there is only a difference of 50 square feet. I would be glad if, before the Report Stage, the Minister would give me an opportunity of demonstrating these facts to him. I think it is very important that houses selling at £750, which are very useful to the type of people who can afford that amount, clerks and some civil servants, should not be cut off altogther.

Comment on this

This matter has been the subject of a very considerable amount of conversations between myself and some of the builders in the city. As I understand their figures, the thousand square feet house is going to be £750. Someone must build houses between the class costing £750 and the houses the local authority is providing. What is happening at the present moment is that builders are building high up. Between the type of person whom the local authority is serving and the person whom the speculative builder is serving or the person served by the public utility society, there is a very big class of persons willing and capable of paying either rent or even buying a £500, a £600 or a £650 house. What is happening is that that class of person is not able to get a house either to rent or to buy. Some of them are being forced into houses costing £750 to £850, houses for which they are not economically able to pay. It is in an attempt to induce, by a certain amount of force, the speculative builders to build houses of an area of 950 square feet, that we offer them a grant below that figure. If they build between that and 1,250 they cannot get a grant, but they get seven years' remission of rates. If they do not go beyond £1,000 they can get the benefit of the Small Dwellings (Acquisition) Act. I think in view of the gap that exists between the houses which the builders are providing and local authorities are providing, that it is only reasonable to restrict the grant in urban areas to houses of 950 square feet or below that.

Comment on this

I suggest that the speculative builders have already come down to the price of £750 without any of this special pressure. If you are going to incapacitate them in their work in this way, I suggest it will tend to put off still further that far off day when we all hope that a sufficient number of houses will be produced.

Comment on this

At £750?

Comment on this

The £750 house will come down to £650 sooner if some inducement is offered to the builder to come down to that figure under some workable scheme.

Comment on this

I am trying to give a certain amount of inducement and I certainly suggest to the House that it is in the right direction.

Comment on this

I move Amendment 32:

In sub-section (3) (d), line 29, to delete the word "March" and substitute the word "January."

If this amendment were not inserted it might mean that the building of a house which might be started in January, might be held over until March. This will enable building to be begun earlier under the Act.

Comment on this

I move Amendment 33:

"To delete sub-sections (4) and (5)."

I have explained that the deletion of these two sub-sections and the substitution of amendment 35 is to make the seven years' remission or two-thirds of the rates, independent of whether the house gets a grant or not.

Comment on this

There was a case mentioned to me to-day of an urban council which had built houses and had sold some of them and who have the money in hands for building. They intend to build further houses, but they are wondering now if they build without having to raise a loan whether they will be entitled to claim the grants that are available.

Comment on this

Although they have not to raise a loan because they have money?

Comment on this

We would be very glad if there was a lot more like them.

Comment on this

I was asked to raise the question so that they could get an assurance that although they have not to raise money, the grants would be available for them.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendments 33 (a) and 34 to this Section are out of order because they clearly seek to increase the charge.

Comment on this

Arising out of this section I wonder if the Minister has got a copy of a printed circular sent to me. I got it this morning from one of my colleagues. It contains a resolution of the Tuam Town Commissioners which says:

"It has come to our knowledge that the dwelling houses recently built by the Town Commissioners are not entitled to a remission of rates under the Housing (Building Facilities) Act because the said dwelling houses were provided under the Housing of the Working Classes Acts."

Comment on this

By the local authority itself.

Comment on this

Cannot the local authority give a remission in that case?

Comment on this

I was under the impression they could and I was surprised to get this circular. Will the Minister explain that?

Comment on this

It is because the local authority provides a subsidised house under the Working Classes Acts, subsidised not only from the State, but subsidised from themselves. They fix a rent that is within the capacity of the occupier, taking into consideration that he has to pay rates as well. It would be only giving another concealed subsidy to the tenant to relieve the tenant of rates in the case of a house built by the local authorities.

Comment on this

These people say that the persons to whom they have let the houses are paying the full economic rent of the house and therefore that they should be entitled to a remission of rates on that ground. That is the main claim on which they base their statements.

Comment on this

I do not know what the full economic rent might be.

Comment on this

I do not know the details and I do not know the houses. I just got that resolution and it seems to me that they should get encouragement in that direction.

Comment on this

The local authority down there has seen fit to fix a rent for these persons in the knowledge that they will have to pay rates as well. That is entirely the local authority's own doing.

Comment on this

In that connection it is a question of adjustment. It is in the local authority's own hands.

Comment on this

They claim it is not in their own hands.

Comment on this

You can take it from me that the Minister does not unduly interfere in cases like that.

SECTION 60.

Comment on this

Section 60 to my mind is the most important section of the whole Bill. On this section depends whether local authorities can see their way to go any further with housing in their areas or not. The President to-day stated that if this Bill had been introduced this time last year better provisions might have been made. He said a serious situation has arisen. There is a reduction in the yield from taxation. That certainly is obvious to everybody. We all admit there is a reduction in the yield from taxation and we agree that steps have to be taken by the Government with a view to balancing the Budget of this year. If there is a reduction in the yield from taxation I think everyone will agree that that applies to every citizen and that the capacity of the people for whom local councils are supposed to provide houses will be lowered also. Notwithstanding that fact the provisions of this Bill have created a situation which will render it impossible for a local authority to provide a house for a worker in their particular area at a rent which he will be able to meet.

As I said on the Second Reading of this Bill, I would far prefer the financial provisions under which we have been working up to this. I know that the Minister will meet me with an argument by saying that even though the financial position is comparatively worse now than it has been under the grant system that inside of ten years the position will be better. But the position now, in my opinion, is something that we do not like. Take the position as it has prevailed up to the present. The Minister has already stated that the policy of local authorities must be directed towards the provision of houses for the lower grade workers. If that is the Minister's desire he should have certainly provided better financial provisions than those in this Bill. Under the old provision in operation now a house which costs £250 with a subsidy of £60 provided by the Government, and a similar subsidy provided by a local authority, could be let at 6/- a week. The same house at £250 under the provisions of this Bill, where 30 per cent. subsidy would be paid, would cost 8/- per week. I think the Minister will agree that that is not a very desirable state of affairs. The Minister has said that the State will provide 36 per cent. of the cost of loan charges and that the local authority would provide a similar amount. The Minister has not explained how the local authorities' assistance is to be applied and I would like to hear that. I also would like to hear what the Minister's conception is of what a rent ought to be in an area where wages range from 35/- to £2 per week. I think he will find that those are the wages that prevail in most of the provincial towns in this country.

Comment on this

I do not want to interrupt the Deputy, but these are matters, in so far as they are not the subject of amendment, that might be dealt with on the Fifth Stage, especially as we are so near the completion of the Committee Stage and as we have an arrangement to take the final Stages to-morrow.

Comment on this

I have no objection. I am not speaking for the sake of criticism. I want to help the Minister in this matter in any way I can.

Comment on this

It might be discussed at greater leisure on the Fifth Stage. I am satisfied that the Deputy's speech on this section is on lines that might more reasonably be dealt with on the Fifth Stage.

Comment on this

The difficulty that I am in is that I am looking for information on this section. I do not think anybody in the House is quite clear as to the implications of the financial provisions of this section. I would hope that the Minister would agree to have the Report Stage in Committee so that we might speak two or three times, if necessary.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

What does the Minister propose exactly?

Comment on this

My understanding of the lines upon which the Deputy was going was that it was a kind of Final Stage comment on the finances of the Measure.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

What is the Minister's own proposal about these amendments that have not yet been dealt with?

Comment on this

There is very little in these amendments that remains to be dealt with. If they cannot be dealt with before half-past ten, I would ask to have them transferred to the Report Stage and to have the Committee Stage completed to-night.

Comment on this

I suggest to the Minister that it is only right that the financial provisions should be discussed on this particular section. If this important matter is left over to the Report Stage and we have the Report Stage in the usual way, it would probably be lost in the general discussions on the Bill. I certainly would like to have an opportunity of going into the finances of the Bill, and I know that there are other Deputies in the House in the same position.

Comment on this

What are we to do with the amendments still on the Paper?

Comment on this

Deputy Corish's difficulty is that he wants particularly to discuss Section 60. In so far as he is not proposing to discuss Section 60 in the light of an amendment he need not do it at this stage.

Comment on this

I am in this difficulty: That the amendment that I would like to make would be out of order. I hope that I shall be able to persuade the Minister that these terms are not sufficiently good.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

If there is not agreement we can do nothing at all. If there is agreement we can either postpone these amendments and order the Bill to be printed as now amended, or insert all the Ministerial amendments that remain and order the Bill to be printed, so that it will be available in the morning, and on the Report Stage we could take amendments 36, 37, and 40 in their appropriate places.

Comment on this

So long as you do not restrict discussion too much on Section 60.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Of course, in the light of this arrangement now, I could hardly.

Sections 60 and 61 ordered to stand part of the Bill.

First and Second Schedules agreed to.

Third Schedule, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.

FOURTH SCHEDULE.

The following amendments in the name of the Minister for Local Government and Public Health were agreed to:—

42. In the second column to delete amendment 1 and substitute the following:—

"1. In sub-section (7) of Section 8 for the words ‘they think fit' there shall be substituted the words ‘the Minister thinks fit' and for the words from ‘any person' to and including ‘compulsorily' the words ‘any owner of any lands included in a clearance order or compulsory purchase order made under this Part of this Act' and for the word ‘scheme' at the end of the said sub-section the word ‘order.'"

43. In the second column to insert after amendment 5 the following:—

"6. In sub-section (3) of Section 47 the words from ‘or the time' to the end of the sub-section shall be omitted."

44. In the second column, page 33, after amendment 8 and before line 8 to add the following:—

"9. In article 6 of the Second Schedule for the word ‘three' there shall be substituted the word ‘two.'"

Fourth Schedule, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.

Comment on this