In Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 26.
Contributions 1–216 of 433. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:
"That it is expedient to amend the law relating to Customs and Inland Revenue (including Excise) and to make further provision in connection with finance."
Comment on this
Will we be given any opportunity of finding out some information on the Schedule to the Customs duties?
Comment on this
I understand that certain questions are to be asked with a view to elucidating some points in the Schedule and the replies will probably give the information the Deputy wants. If not, he will be entitled, as the House is in Committee, to put a question or questions.
Comment on this
My point is with regard to the Schedule of Financial Resolution 7, Reference No. 8, which says: "Putty in any form and paints and distempers in liquid form." I would like to ask the Minister if paints and distempers in powder and paste come under this category, and if not, what category do they come under? They are not specifically mentioned, only in liquid form.
Comment on this
I think the matter will appear quite clear to the Deputy if he reads the terms of the Resolution. The duty applies to putty in any form "and paints and distempers in liquid form (excluding white lead either dry or in the form of stiff paste, artists' colours in tubes, and any dry colours."
Comment on this
What I want to find out from the Minister is, if paints and distempers in dry form or in paste form are included or excluded?
Comment on this
I thank the Minister. There is a further question I want to put to him arising out of Reference No. 15 in the Schedule. I am anxious to know if wallpaper pattern books will come under Reference No. 15 or Reference No. 16. These two reference numbers deal with the duty on printed matter.
Comment on this
If the Deputy is able to convince the Revenue Commissioners that wallpaper pattern books are not printed matter, he may be able to get away with it.
Comment on this
I would be glad to know from the Minister if he could give an answer at a later date.
Comment on this
The next item I want to refer to arises under Reference No. 18—"Articles manufactured wholly or partly of wood or timber." Would the Minister say into what category wall-board comes?
Comment on this
I am not quite clear as to what wall-board is, but builders' woodwork generally is subject to the duty specified.
Comment on this
There is a further question I want to put to the Minister arising out of Reference No. 18. It speaks of articles manufactured "wholly or partly of wood or timber." What I am anxious to know is: is steel furniture included or excluded?
Comment on this
Would I be in order in suggesting that the Deputy should ask for an interview with the Revenue Commissioners for the purpose of getting the points he is dealing with cleared up?
Comment on this
I think if Deputy Davin had more experience he would not have made that suggestion about interviewing the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
Arising out of the suggestion made by Deputy Davin, might I point out that this is not a matter for the Revenue Commissioners at all? It is the duty of this House to interpret these matters and lay down the orders for the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce if it would be possible to give us at this stage an enumeration as between the 43 items that are to be tariffed, and if he would allocate the amount of £910,000 which is expected to be derived from them?
Comment on this
The only information I can give the Deputy on that point is that that estimate applies not merely in respect to the duties that are set out here, but also in respect to the duties which were imposed by Provisional Order.
Comment on this
Very good. The Minister is referring to the other 17 or 18 Orders. There are also these 43 items that are to be tariffed. We think that a segregation of the £910,000 revenue against all these items is necessary for a Budget debate. Can we have that information?
Comment on this
Will the Minister say how Deputies can discuss these duties intelligently without that information?
Comment on this
I cannot say how the Deputy will be able to deal with his personal inconvenience in that matter.
Comment on this
Arising out of Reference No. 32 in the Schedule "roof felting and felting substitute and other like substances intended for use as roofing material," would the Minister say if asbestos roof covering would come under that definition?
Comment on this
In connection with Reference No. 16 in the Schedule, which sets out stationery of certain descriptions that will become liable to duty, I would like to know from the Minister if he proposes to include in the Schedule paper cartons or containers, because, as many Deputies are aware, quantities of these goods are coming into the country.
Comment on this
No. The duty applies only to stationery of the descriptions that are set out in the Schedule.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that paper cartons with the names of Irish butter manufacturers, creamery manufacturers and others printed on them are coming into this country from places as far distant as Sweden?
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that possibly the greater bulk of imported printing is done in connection with the cartons to which I refer?
Comment on this
Yet the Minister seeks to tariff articles which are coming in in lesser quantities as represented in £ s. d.
Comment on this
I take it that the Deputy's point is that the tariff is not wide enough; that there are certain articles excluded that should be included?
Comment on this
Yes. As far as I can see there are two good features in the Budget, and this is one of them.
Comment on this
As regards Reference No. 15, I take it that bound books are not taxable? I see that unbound books are specifically excluded, but bound books can only be excluded if they are regarded as "matter printed on paper which at importation is pasted on or otherwise firmly adhering to cardboard." Does that mean that bound books are excluded?
Comment on this
Can we have from the Minister for Finance now, or at an early stage in the debate, information as to how he arrived at the figure of £250,000 "reduction in salaries in the Public Service" shown as item 5 on the expenditure side in the Explanatory statement issued? I think the House is also entitled to have the information asked for by Deputy McGilligan as to how the Minister for Finance arrived at the figure of £910,000 already alluded to.
Comment on this
We can move the adjournment until we get the information. I want to refer again to the question, to which I got a very unsatisfactory answer. We are told that there is £910,000 to be derived from tariffed articles. To-day, in answer to two specific questions, I was told by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that it was expected that the revenue would benefit by £200,000 on the two items mentioned. That would leave £700,000. I have asked for an enumeration of the moneys to be derived from the special headings or even the larger headings. I want a segregation. We are told that it is not advisable to give it. I suggest that is very unfair to a House which allowed the Minister for Finance an extra respite of two hours in order to prepare himself. I suggest to the House that we ought to adjourn until we get the information asked for. Is the information in the possession of the Minister?
Comment on this
The estimate has been prepared for me by officers who are competent to prepare it. I have accepted the figures, and I do not think it would serve any useful purpose to make the allocation that Deputy McGilligan requires.
Comment on this
How are we to discuss individual resolutions, without having some notion as to the burdens they are going to place on the taxpayers?
Comment on this
There is no use discussing it at all. It may be possible to give the information immediately, or it may require some time, but the House will co-operate for the convenience of the Minister. We cannot, however, consider resolutions unless we know what they are going to do.
Comment on this
The debate on the general resolution, as a general rule, is a debate on the general principles of the Budget. When the principal resolution comes to be debated on report stage, the information will then be available.
Comment on this
One of the items I suggest that arises for consideration on the general resolution is whether or not the method of getting in certain moneys is a suitable one, the most suitable one, or an effective one. We cannot discuss these three points without knowing how this block of one million pounds is going to be derived, and if the information is in the possession of the Minister, as he says it is, it is treating the House with great disregard, if not with insolence, to refuse it.
Comment on this
If Deputy McGilligan will throw his mind back to the last session, he will remember that we voted £2,000,000 in respect of a certain undertaking with which he was associated, and in regard to which he refused to give any particulars whatever to the House.
Comment on this
The points which Deputy McGilligan has made would be perfectly relevant if these tariffs were at this moment being imposed for revenue purposes only. They are being imposed, as I have said, because, first of all, they are necessary to fulfil the Government's economic and industrial policy.
Comment on this
I do not know if the Minister for Finance would tell us whether the Estimate supplied to him, and in his possession, is a detailed estimate, setting out against each reference number the revenue that may be expected, or whether he has only obtained a bulk sum. If he has only obtained a bulk sum, he cannot be asked to give any more to-day, but I think it would be reasonable that he should either get an estimate for each particular reference number, or that he should get an estimate over a number of groups. There are 43 particular tariffs, and the Minister could not be expected to give us 43 separate estimates, because there might be certain cases where it would be reasonable that two or three should be grouped together, but I think that the Minister should give us, either now, if he has it, or later on, if it has to be prepared, something in much greater detail than what we have got.
Comment on this
The suggestion made by Deputy Blythe is an eminently reasonable one and I would be prepared to meet it in that spirit. I do not think it will be possible for me to let the House have the information in the form in which Deputy Blythe has suggested it should be offered to-day, but I will have a memorandum prepared and circulated at an early date.
Comment on this
Might I suggest to the Minister that he would answer these questions civilly, when put, and take the House quite candidly into his confidence with regard to whatever information he has, and not try to lecture the House.
Comment on this
This Estimate of £910,000 was either a bulk Estimate without any consideration of the individual items, or it was arrived at by adding up the individual items. I presume, as I must attribute a certain amount of sense to the Ministry, that it was arrived at in the latter manner. Therefore, I presume that the information must be, as the Minister first said, at his disposal, and why, then, does he refuse to give it to the House? We are asked to impose taxes. The reason does not matter. We impose them, but the least we may know is what each particular tax is supposed to bring in. The idea of suggesting that we should debate, even in a general fashion, a Budget about £1,000,000 of which we have practically no information is ridiculous.
Comment on this
I think it is quite obvious that information given in the form requested by Deputy McGilligan and Deputy O'Sullivan would be misleading. Estimates must necessarily be conjectural. Arguments which would be based on a single figure relating to a particular item might easily be unfounded. It might be possible to group a number of the duties, as Deputy Blythe suggested, and give a reasonably accurate estimate in respect of the group, but to expect the Minister for Finance to give an accurate estimate in respect of each item, is asking too much, in the first place, and would be very undesirable, in the second place, because of the fact that under the circumstances existing now, any such estimate must necessarily be subject to quite a large number of considerations, the main consideration being the rate of development at which industrialisation will go on. It is clear that in respect of quite a number of these duties the effect on the Revenue will be to decrease revenue.
Comment on this
They are being imposed by the Government, not because of their effect on revenue, but because of their effect in supporting the Government's industrial policy. The Estimate which has been prepared by those whose duty it is to prepare it, and which was submitted to the House, represents the closest approximation possible to the probable yield in this year.
Comment on this
Will the Minister say what percentage of error does he think there would be in these items if they were presented singly?
Comment on this
The House has a right to discuss them when presented by people who have drawn up a Budget founded on a £910,000 estimate without any percentage error.
Comment on this
I should say that it is quite obvious from what the Minister for Industry and Commerce has said that the House is much more in the dark now than it was before he made the statement. We understood before he made the statement that these 43, plus 12 others, I think, tariffs, taxes or whatever you like to call them, were to produce revenue. We are to understand now that a number will produce no revenue, and to discuss the Budget in these circumstances is, I suggest, ridiculous. The Estimate may have been approximate, or not, but that £910,000 was made up by addition and subtraction so far as the individual items were concerned. Can we at least have that with the reservations he has made?
Comment on this
With reference to the particular point raised by Deputy O'Sullivan, if he reads the speech delivered yesterday by the Minister for Finance, he will see that provision was made for the obviously estimated character of these items.
Comment on this
And that provision was made in the Budget for the possibility of the yield of these duties proving less than the Estimate. I suggest, sir, that we can get no further in the discussion on this to-day. The Minister for Finance has undertaken to consider the preparation of an Estimate which will, as accurately as possible, under all the circumstances, group the various duties into all their classes. I think that meets the requests made from the opposite side in a reasonable manner.
Comment on this
The statement in the Minister's speech was:—
All are necessary for the fulfilment of our industrial programme, since we are capable of producing here everything to which they are applied and they will yield to the revenue £910,000.
Where is the doubt in that?
Comment on this
If Deputy Cosgrave will turn to that passage in my speech where I dealt with the present Estimates, and where I refer to the custom established by my predecessor of knocking off in some years five per cent., and last year two and a half per cent., for over-estimation, he will see that I indicated to the House that I was not this year going to avail of that precedent to the fullest extent; that instead of doing that I was allowing some part of the element of over-estimation to remain against the contingency that some of the new duties would not yield the revenue which we anticipated.
Comment on this
Might I suggest that if the Minister is not able at this stage to give the detailed statement he has promised later, he should, at any rate, give us some general notion as to how the figure of £910,000 is arrived at, because we have no idea as to what kind of method was adopted.
Comment on this
May I supplement what the Deputy has asked by adding this: Could not we, at any rate, get a segregation at this moment of these tariffs into those imposed for protective purposes and those imposed purely for revenue?
Comment on this
Will the Minister kindly give me some information as to where I shall find what he stated in his statement, because I have not been able to find it?
Comment on this
No, once is enough. That deals with the one and a half per cent. in respect of the cost of Supply Services and is not in respect of the Estimates of Receipts and Expenditure.
Comment on this
I suggest that if anything is to be said for this paragraph which has just been read out about over-estimation, it is an argument against the presentation of any Estimates to this House except in bulk form. We recognise that Estimates are only Estimates and that these are a little more conjectural than usual. We want even conjectural Estimates; otherwise we cannot be reasonably asked to discuss them.
Comment on this
In view of the assurance I have already given to Deputy Blythe, the best course for me is to move the general Resolution, and I do so accordingly.
Comment on this
There is a question I desire to ask before we go any further. This £50 which it is proposed to allow in respect of children: there is no deduction, I take it, from that? Is it subject to the ten per cent. deduction formerly given in the case of the £40 and £30? Is it a full allowance of £50?
Comment on this
Is any provision being made by the Minister in respect of the deficit which the President of the Executive Council announced on the 29th April, 1932, when he said: "There is a deficit this year roughly of £1,400,000. That is what Deputy Blythe has left us, a Budgetary deficit of close on £1,400,000." (Official Report, col. 917, 29th April, 1932.)
Comment on this
We are closing an old chapter. We are wiping off the losses in respect of that chapter and beginning anew. We are not meeting Deputy Blythe's deficit. It has been already met out of borrowing by Deputy Blythe.
Comment on this
I take it there is adherence to that statement in April that there is a deficit of £1,400,000.
Comment on this
There was, and I am responsible for it, an over-statement in that regard; but in the official financial review of the past year the deficit is clearly indicated, if Deputy Cosgrave, in view of the importance of the occasion, will take the trouble to read it.
Comment on this
Does the Minister include the President of the Executive Council in that over-estimation?
Comment on this
If Deputy Cosgrave will read my statement he will be able to answer the question for himself.
Comment on this
Is it intended that we shall proceed by way of speeches or by way of cross-examination?
Comment on this
May I ask, with reference to the statement on page 13 that £1,000,000 is to be borrowed from the Road Fund, is there any provision made in respect of interest, in the Budget, for that sum?
Comment on this
It is to be borrowed on the security of the Road Fund and the interest will be charged against the Road Fund.
Comment on this
Without wishing to evade any question I should like to say that every point which the Opposition wishes to make against this Budget I shall be prepared to deal with in the usual way at the close of the debate. The procedure that is now being initiated is one that the Opposition, when they were on these benches, would never have conceded to us.
Comment on this
On a point of order. An agreement was come to which I am sure the Minister knows about with regard to the procedure in relation to the Budget this year. That agreement was of a different nature— at least it set up a new type of arrangement, different from other years. Following that arrangement, the resolutions were allowed to go through yesterday after being moved in the most formal way without any precise questions being put. That was done, we understood, to suit the convenience of the Government. The information is certainly desirable, and we could have got it yesterday by asking for it on the specific resolution. We let the debate go yesterday. That was a request made by the Government. We are now asking for the information we could have got in the ordinary way yesterday. It is, I think, part of the agreement?
Comment on this
Every member of the Opposition will have an opportunity of dealing with these separate items and of going into them in detail. It is obvious that any agreement made was never intended to cover the sort of cross-examination that is going on at present with respect to the whole Budget. You might as well ask for the details of the Supply Services immediately.
Comment on this
Surely if the Budget had been dealt with in the ordinary way like last year, or the year before, when Resolution 7 came to be moved the questions with regard to the segregation of this £910,000 could then have been put and normally would have been answered. Instead of asking them last night we are asking them now.
Comment on this
Normally they would not have been put, because it was necessary to get these resolutions through, as everybody knows, last night. Is it not quite obvious that with such a large number of Resolutions it would not have been possible to go through them in detail like other years when a smaller number was before us?
Comment on this
Distinctly it would, and particularly if the Minister did not ask for an extra respite of two hours?
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, that was not the first time such an arrangement was come to. I remember a couple of years ago we had a Budget speech also after five o'clock.
Comment on this
Nobody is denying that, but when the respite was asked for it is not fair to bring in the lack of time last night as an excuse for the refusal to answer questions. These questions could have been put if the Budget statement were made at three o'clock yesterday and the Resolutions could have been got through by 10.30 p.m.
Comment on this
I suggest that we go on with the usual debate on the Budget and that when we come to the separate Resolution any item of information required can be asked for. We are dealing with the Budget as a whole. This Estimate of £910,000 has been arrived at, as the members opposite know well, by adding up certain Estimates for a number of items. In each one of these a certain percentage of error is likely and the Minister, naturally, does not want to stand over every particular item at this stage, but in the bulk, this Estimate is regarded as fairly accurate. This is a bulk Estimate and there may be errors, plus and minus in some cases. I suggest that we go on with the business and any reasonable information required by the Opposition will be given in respect of each particular item.
Comment on this
We do not press for immediate information. The Minister can say that he will be able to give it at 6 o'clock or 7 o'clock or to-morrow. We do not want to take him at a disadvantage; we simply want information. I want some in respect of an item, mentioned in page 12, of £424,000 accrued interest on Savings Certificates. I want to know if the Minister has made provision for all that this year: if that sum is the only sum or whether it includes £150,000 which the ex-Minister usually provided for that. I am not pressing for an immediate answer but I want it.
Comment on this
I am sure the Minister will see the reasonableness of explaining a matter which has caused me some confusion in Financial Resolution No. 25. It says: "That there shall be charged in respect of the available surplus within the meaning of Sections 5 and 6 of the Public Charitable Hospitals (Amendment) Act, 1931... a Stamp Duty at the rate of twenty-five per cent. of the amount of such available surplus." In the paper handed to us this afternoon under the heading of Emergency Budget Receipts there is an item of Income Tax from Hospital Receipts from Sweepstakes. I want to know is the Stamp Duty the same as the Income Tax.
Comment on this
A question was already put from the Labour Benches to which I did not hear the Minister's reply and that was: Will he give some further details about the £250,000 which it is proposed to get by reduction in salaries of public officials.
Comment on this
If Deputy Blythe wishes an answer this afternoon I will scarcely be in a position to give it, for the reason that, while we must get £250,000, I have given an undertaking to certain members of the Civil Servants and other public servants that I shall see them before I definitely announce the scale.
Comment on this
I believe we shall have no difficulty in securing an agreement to yield to the community in the present circumstances that £250,000.
Comment on this
In reference to Financial Resolution No. 8, item 3—newspapers and periodicals imported in bulk quantities, etc.—when the Minister is making his statement on this Financial Resolution will he indicate the reasons which actuated him in imposing this? Is he aware that the restrictions already imposed by the operation of the Censorship of Publications Act are sufficient to preclude the introduction into this country of any objectionable matter? I would ask the Minister to amplify his original statement somewhat and give us the reasons for this impost, and also if he will have regard to its repercussions and effect on the reading public in this country. I feel that the Minister may have in mind the keeping out of the country—very properly, to my mind—of any matter calculated to have a dangerous effect on the morals of the youth of the country in particular. I would suggest to him, however, that matter of an educational character may also be kept out of the country as a result of this tax. Whilst I can see that the Minister may mean very well in this regard, I do feel, at the same time, that it is quite possible that it may have effects which the Minister has not contemplated.
Comment on this
I think the point raised by Deputy Anthony should be raised by him in his speech. I understand the Minister for Industry and Commerce will deal with that, and I myself shall also deal with it.
Comment on this
I do not want to embarrass the Minister, but I want an indication that he will deal with it in his speech. Am I to understand that the Minister for Industry and Commerce will deal with it?
Comment on this
Might I point out to the Minister for Industry and Commerce with regard to the tariffs, to the number of 43, that the Minister for Finance stated yesterday on page 40:
"All are necessary for the fulfilment of our industrial programme since we are capable of producing here everything to which they are applied and they will yield to the Revenue £910,000"?
Am I to understand from the Minister for Industry and Commerce's statement to-day that he is not in full agreement with the statement of the Minister for Finance, seeing that he has stated to-day that some of these are intended as protective duties and others purely for Revenue?
Comment on this
It may be necessary for me to speak before the Minister. Am I to take it that some of these duties are for Revenue purposes?
Comment on this
They all have some protective effect. Some minor ones however are designed to bring in Revenue also.
Comment on this
And the amount they will yield is £910,000. We should put in some word like "approximately" or "probably" after it?
Comment on this
I understood as stated before that a certain number of questions were to be asked by Deputies to elucidate points of the Schedule, such elucidation being necessary to the better conduct of the debate on the Budget. But if that degenerates into cross-examination across the floor of the House there will be no satisfactory debate on the Budget. The Minister for Finance has undertaken to furnish the figures which Deputy Blythe asked for, and I suggest that in the meantime the debate on the General Resolution should be carried on as a debate, and since the whole field of taxation and expenditure may be covered, there should be sufficient scope for Deputies.
Comment on this
Will it be allowable for a Deputy who has spoken on the General Resolution to intervene a second time if the reply from the Minister for Finance seems to warrant a second intervention?
Comment on this
Yes, and the Minister may answer if he desires. The Deputy might ask questions in the course of his speech.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce if Item 21, dealing with superphosphates, ground mineral phosphates, and compound manures embraces all phosphates coming into the country in a raw state.
Comment on this
It applies only to non-British phosphates. There is no duty on chemical manures coming from Britain, or any of the Dominions. The item applies only to the classes set out, in respect to which the existing supplies are sufficient.
Comment on this
With reference to the statement of the Minister for Finance yesterday, one of the things that was noticeable was the amount of time he spent at the opening of his remarks in trying to divert the attention of the House from the essentials of the Budget. Quite a number of pages of the statement are occupied with an attempt to prove that there was a deficit on the Budget for the year ending the 31st March last. Deputies have only to read his statement to see that there was no foundation whatever for the contention of the Minister, and that, so far from ending with a deficit, the last year ended with some small surplus. The Minister admits that certain items of expenditure may be covered by borrowing. One of the items which he admits may be covered by borrowing is compensation for property destroyed during the civil war or previous to it. There are items which he will not allow as proper to be met by borrowing, but for which a much stronger case could be made. It is simply ludicrous for the Minister to suggest, for example, that it is wrong to borrow for capital for the Local Loans Fund. The money that has heretofore been supplied to the Local Loans Fund has been lent out. Some of it is being gradually repaid and it is all earning interest. That particular provision is essentially one that should be made by borrowing, and not by taxation. If for the future the Minister alters the character of the Local Loans Fund a different position arises. Up to the present the Local Loans Fund has lent money on an economic basis and any money advanced to it was quite properly found by borrowing. It would be wrong to put a levy on the taxpayer to provide it. If it is right as the Minister admits to provide out of borrowed moneys for payments to private individuals for the re-erection of buildings destroyed during the civil war and the Anglo-Irish struggle it is equally right for the State to borrow to replace Government buildings destroyed during the same period whether they are centrally situated like the Four Courts and the General Post Office, or whether they are scattered over the country like Civic Guard barracks. There is just the same case for borrowing for the restoration of State buildings as for borrowing for the restoration of private buildings and the Minister is, in fact, arranging in this Budget to borrow for the restoration of private buildings.
The Minister suggests that it is wrong to borrow for afforestation. The only objection that can be made to borrowings hitherto made for forestry is that the sums were rather small. Is the Minister going to suggest that money spent on forestry is thrown away and that afforestation has no economic or commercial side whatever? I admit that money spent on afforestation cannot all be recovered and cannot all earn interest. I have not been able to lay my hands on figures given in a memorandum some years ago when this matter was considered, but the judgment arrived at was that half the money spent on forestry might reasonably be regarded as an investment and the other half, if you like, as a contribution towards relieving unemployment or towards beautifying the country, but not as economic expenditure. It is perfectly justifiable to borrow a part of the money spent on afforestation.
As regards money advanced to the Land Commission which is going to be repaid by the tenants, surely the Minister will not seriously contend, except when indulging in flights of oratory, that it is not correct to borrow for such outgoings? Anybody who thinks over the matter for five minutes, and who looks at the Minister's statement, will come to the conclusion that instead of there being a deficit of some £639,000, there was a surplus of nearly £160,000, and the Minister might have put that £160,000 to the Savings Certificates Interest Equalisation Fund. That would have been an ample contribution for the past year, because the amount of interest accrued but uncovered did not accrue last year and was not payable last year. There was no obligation on the Minister to wipe it off last year, and the contribution available to him would have been ample. I do not think the Minister was under any illusion—unless he put himself under an illusion for propagandist purposes—that there was any Budget deficit, but he wanted to create an atmosphere for the sort of Budget which he chose to bring in. He brought in a worse Budget than he need have brought in. As I indicated yesterday, I do not think it would have been possible for him to have brought in a Budget that most people would be glad to see and that would have given great and general satisfaction.
The Minister, having tried to confuse the minds of Deputies and of people who might read a report of his speech on the question of last year's Budget, also tried to create confusion about the question of the capital liability of the State. He seemed at times, when trying to create this confusion, as if, instead of giving an account of the position of the Exchequer, he was engaged in some sort of national stocktaking. Obviously, the Minister could not, on an occasion like the introduction of a Budget, undertake a national stocktaking, nor would he be called upon to do so. If he were to try it he would have to bring into account great numbers of items which we are not immediately concerned with. He brought in, however, practically as a capital item as an item of debt, the liability to pay over the land purchase annuities to the appropriate British fund, but he took no account whatever on the other side of the claim of the Government to collect the land annuities from the tenants. His balancesheet, in so far as we had it yesterday, seemed to be based on this: That the Exchequer is bound to pay over to the appropriate British account, but is not entitled to collect the annuities from the tenants. If he had been trying to make things clear instead of trying to create a fog he would, if he put on the liability side—which, of course, it was unnecessary to do—the requirement to pay over the land annuities to the appropriate British account, have put on the other side the debt owing by the tenants, and the two items would have cancelled one another out. But then he would not have been able to get up this grand total of debt with which he tried to create confusion in the minds of Deputies and others who read his speech, and thus prepared the way for the sort of Budget he introduced.
It was ludicrous also for him to capitalise a payment like the R.I.C. pensions. These pensions are essentially a part of the normal cost of police and there is no reason why they should be capitalised and added to the total of the National Debt, any more than the pensions of Civil Servants, pensions of retired members of the D.M.P., or even old-age pensions should be so treated.
As I said, these payments in respect of R.I.C. pensions are part of the normal cost of police. Police charges in every country consist of wages of the existing force, maintenance of establishments and payment of pensions to retired members of the force. To build up a fantastic debt figure by capitalising items which there is no justification for capitalising is unworthy of a Minister introducing a Budget. He ought to try not to confuse people, but rather to make the position clear to people and to enable them to get a just estimate of what the position is. If we proceed along the lines the Minister has adopted, we could capitalise the salaries paid to civil servants and a number of other items and produce a figure far greater than the figure the Minister has produced. There was no reason for his stopping where he did. I do not believe that the Minister was himself confused in regard to that matter, nor do I believe that he was confused when he was running in and out from gold ounces to sterling and back again to gold ounces. He was trying to divert attention from the essential factor in his Budget. The essential factor in his Budget was simply this—that, with falling revenue, he thinks it appropriate to put heavy additional burdens on the taxpayer. There is no doubt that, owing to world conditions and to the general trend of prices, national income has fallen, and seriously fallen, during the last couple of years. Whether or not the fall in tax revenue is a true index of the fall in national income, I do not know, but it must be regarded as some indication of how national income is going. When tax revenue begins to fall, a Minister and a Government which took their duty seriously would try to reduce the burden on the public whose income had gone down. The taxes shown on the White Paper—the taxes in existence at the end of last financial year— would have brought in in the present year £1,300,000 less than they brought in last year and that although there would be a full year for the additional 4d. on petrol and 6d. on income tax which, normally, should have come to half a million additional. Comparing like with like, therefore, the yield of the taxes in existence on 31st March will be down in the present financial year by about £1,800,000. When we have the yield of taxation going down in that way and representing a decline in national income, the Minister thinks fit to increase the burden on the taxpayer.
This Budget proposes to take from the taxpayer £1,764,000 more than the total taken last year, including tax and non-tax revenue. Instead of carrying into effect the Fianna Fáil policy of reducing taxation—they said they could reduce it by two million without reducing the efficiency of the administration—the Government have chosen a policy which means that the taxpayer is to be asked to pay nearly two million pounds more than was taken from him last year. It seems to me that this is an entirely irresponsible and cynical Budget. It is all very well in a spirit of political prejudice to select certain classes of the community and to decide to fleece them, but the fleecing of any particular section of the community is going to have reactions on every class. There are no great accumulations of wealth here from which you can take large additional sums without affecting even the poorest member of the community. If the Minister takes, as he is going to do, very considerable additional sums away in income and other taxes, then he is going to reduce employment. If you have a man with a particular income and you take £200 from that income, you are going to affect employment. It may lead to the direct dismissal of an employee. If it does not lead to the direct dismissal of an employee, it will mean less trade in some shop, with ultimately the dismissal of a shop assistant or a factory worker. It is not possible to avoid the evil effects of an increase of taxation—particularly at a time when income is falling and when all sorts of people have to pull in their horns and reduce expenditure.
This Budget will, undoubtedly, give new employment in certain directions. If heavy taxes are put on manufactured goods, then factories are going to be started and people are going to be employed in those factories. But if, at the same time, all other taxes go up, if the cost of living goes up, if the goods people have to buy go up in price as compared with the price of the goods which they could have bought before the tariffs were put on, then you are going to have new hordes of people put out of employment in other directions. It seems to me that what the Government have failed to take any account of are the evil effects that increased taxation in any direction must bring about and that an increase in the cost of living must bring about, particularly at a time when national income is going down.
Taking the Budget in detail, a great number of items in it could be criticised. In a country like this, it is certainly a most ill-advised proceeding to bring direct taxation up to the level to which it has been brought in this Budget. In a country like this, where industrial development has not taken place, and where we have not the accumulations of wealth which would follow industrial development, it is a wrong thing to adopt a system of taxation which is only tolerable in a country like our neighbour across the Irish Sea, where there has been great industrial development and where there are great accumulations of wealth. It is all very well to talk about encouraging enterprise, about keeping capital at home, and encouraging capital to come here, but when we have the possibility of industries carried on here being taxed on their profits at the rate of 7s. in the £ it is going to have a deleterious effect. A particular firm will now pay 2s. in the £ Corporation Profits Tax. An additional 6d. was put on the Corporation Profits in the hope of inducing that firm to establish a colonial register here. For their own reasons, the firm did not establish that colonial register. It should be clear to anybody on the opposite benches who considers the general effect of the Government's political policy that that firm could not now, with any reasonable prudence, venture on the establishment of a colonial register. What is happening is that a tax which was meant to be a coercive tax in a particular direction cannot now produce the result that was desired by increasing the original tax. The firm will have to pay 5s. income tax, in the ordinary way, and 2s. Corporation Profits Tax. There is this to be said about the Corporation Profits Tax—that it represents an income tax even on investors whose income is below the exemption limit.
If you have a widow or an orphan who has an investment bringing in a small income, the two shillings Corporation Profits Tax means that such people pay two shillings income tax which they will not recover at all.
One of the reasons why I always felt that we had to keep income tax substantially below the income tax on the other side was that we had a Corporation Profits Tax here which did not exist in Great Britain. I think there can be no justification for at once putting the income tax up to the British level and bringing the general level of the Corporation Profits Tax up to 1/6, and the exceptional level 2/-. If the income tax was going to be put up to the British level, then the Minister ought to have made up his mind that it was going to have a very bad effect on business and enterprise if he retained the Corporation Profits Tax at all.
I can see no justification for maintaining the Corporation Profits Tax and producing this position, that an English commercial company working in Great Britain has to pay a maximum of 5/- tax, whereas our companies, if they are of any size, will pay an income tax, for that is what it all is, of 6/6 in the £. I think that is certainly not the way to encourage enterprise, and I think the Minister should not have been so ready to yield at this time to the demand for new expenditure or so slow to face up to the unpopularity of reducing expenditure. I will admit that it is a more unpopular task to reduce expenditure than to impose any taxation whatever, because taxation, no matter how sharply it is increased, hits most individuals in a relatively small way. There is only a minor number of people who are tremendously affected immediately by an increase in taxation, whereas economies produce great anger and great resentment and a sort of lasting antagonism. But I hold that in existing circumstances, with a falling national income, it was the duty of the Minister to have acted as a Treasury man for once, to have held the reins tightly on new outlay, and have faced the unpopularity of reducing expenditure. That could have been done and would have given better results and more employment.
The Minister is gathering new sums into his Exchequer for the purpose of creating employment, but every pound he takes out of the pockets of the citizens is increasing unemployment. Every pound that he is going to take out of the Hospitals Sweepstakes Fund is going to reduce the amount the hospitals have to spend and to create unemployment there. We have Bills introduced at this stage which mean a substantial increase in expenditure this year and more next year. Other new things are threatened. Social services are good, and there is no doubt that, with the way things are going in the world, social services are going gradually to increase. Every sort of Government will find itself obliged for one or other reasons to increase social services, but social services which do not help the very poorest should not be increased at a time like this. I come now to income tax differentiation. The person who had the public spirit, the enterprise, the patriotism, or whatever it might be, to put his money last month or the month before, prior to the tariffs being imposed, into extending his business or creating new employment, is going to pay income tax at the full rate of 5/- and, possibly, to pay 1/6 Corporation Profits Tax on top of that; but the man who held back until there were all sorts of tariffs, making it comparatively easy for anybody in certain industries, no matter how efficient, to make money for a time, is going to get a rebate of 20 per cent. Apart from the general bad impression that a thing like that will create in the minds of many people, it is an unwise thing because, if the 20 per cent. rebate is going to be given so readily, there are people who might think it would be a good thing to wait until next year and there might then be a rebate of 40 per cent., as well as the advantage of all these unconsidered, unjustifiable tariffs. The whole thing would be ludicrous if the situation in the country were not so serious as it is. It is something in the nature of a tragedy to have the Government behave with the levity it has shown in this Budget —beginning with the cynical misrepresentation we find in the first part of the Budget, proceeding to the levity of this heavy increase of taxation in the main part of the Budget, and then proceeding to the cynical live-horse and-you-will-get-grass statement in the last part. The suggestion is that all will be well next year; it does not matter what increased taxes are to be put on, they will be all reduced at the expense of the British Government or the British people next year.
Last year the Minister for Finance said all sorts of things could and should then have been provided out of the land annuities. Now when he is sitting on the opposite Benches, he has nothing to say about doing it this year, but he is going to do it next year. I suggest there is the same cynicism in these empty promises in the second part of the Budget as there is in the misrepresentations of the first part of the Budget and it seems to me that the Government is going to work enormous damage by their policy. They are going to lose capital to a very considerable extent. They are going to have established here uneconomic industries, ill-placed, ill-designed, ill-managed with which it will be very painful for some later Government to deal. They are going beyond any reasonable bounds in this tariff policy and they are going to cause money to be invested here in enterprises that will have no claim to live because an enterprise that cannot give, and cannot hope within some reasonable period of years to give, fair service to the people not necessarily as cheap as outsiders, but something approximate to that, has not any right to live. They are creating that situation. By this policy they are going to lose income tax and to lose income that would otherwise come to the country.
They are going to lose the possession of capital to the country; they are going to create all this mass of weak, inefficient industries; and then at the same time we have this carrot of the land annuities being held out which will prevent national tasks being faced seriously as they ought to be faced. If it were possible to move an amendment to this particular Budget, I think it would be a reasonable thing to ask that everything should be postponed and that the representatives of the Government should go to Ottawa and settle their outstanding differences, the differences at any rate, that they are raising with the British Government, so that we might see where we are going to be in the matter of Dominion Preference vis-á-vis the British. Because all the calculations in the Budget will lose their validity if the policy which the Government is pursuing puts the Free State outside the 10 per cent. Dominion Preference—all this will go, and the extra taxation that is being put on in another Bill will be useless. As I said already, £1,700,000 of new taxation more than was collected last year is being taken by the Budget. There is another Bill under which a sum that may be disputed, but which we may assume will be at least £700,000, is being taken off the consumer, making a total of £2,400,000 additional taxation this year. We are faced with this prospect because the Government are willing to give new services and unwilling to face the task of making the economies that ought to be made in an emergency like the present.
Comment on this
There is no doubt that the Minister for Finance may be congratulated on a rhetorical display which is quite equal to a Gladstone or a Churchill, and we must congratulate him at any rate on the effect that it has had upon the people of the country. It is not often that after praising a Minister, I blow my own trumpet. But I must say that as far as I am concerned, I am responsible, I believe, for giving more employment than the Fianna Fáil people have given yet, and I was responsible for raising more money for charitable objects than it is likely they will raise by similar means, at all events.
In regard to the Sweepstakes which I initiated here and which Senator Farren fathered in the Seanad, we have given at the present moment permanent employment to 2,000 people with a weekly wage of about £4,000, and in addition to that we have given temporary employment to people numbering over 4,000 with a weekly wage amounting roughly to £10,000.
That money is being distributed throughout the country. It is going into the shops and it is going in many ways to help the poor, because, as far as I have been concerned, I have been most anxious that in regard to those looking for employment in the Sweeps encouragement should be given to the taking of girls who were orphans and who were very poor and very dependent.
As far as the money received for the benefit of the hospitals is concerned it should amount to about 2¾ millions. When one comes to consider the particular proposal of the Minister in this respect one would think that the Emergency Committee had come to him and said: "For goodness' sake will you take some of this money from us, we don't know what to do with it?" The Minister has made no apology for the raid that he has made on this fund. I say that it is extremely unfair that when an Act was passed by the Oireachtas to raise money for charitable purposes that money should now be raided in order to provide revenue for the State. This Emergency Committee that the Minister spoke of, agreed some time ago to certain proposals as they had to do, but at all events they agreed to certain proposals, and one of the proposals that they agreed to with the Minister was that income tax should be charged upon the amount of money available for the hospitals. For a moment's retrospect, I should like to say that during last year the Revenue Commissioners wanted to impose income tax upon the amount available for the hospitals. A deputation waited upon the then Minister for Finance and he agreed to put into his Finance Act, 1931, a clause exempting the hospitals from being penalised by income tax. And not only did he do that, but he went a step further and made that proposal retrospective so as to apply to the two Sweeps that had previously taken place. In my opinion, that provision should have continued until the Grand National of this year which was run in the month of March. What does the Minister propose to do? From reading his paper last night I understand that he proposes to make a levy of 25 per cent.—in one place, it appears as stamp duty and in another place it appears as income tax—he proposes at all events to charge income tax upon certain amounts.
The amount received in connection with the Grand National for the hospitals was £841,000 in the month of March, 1932. The Minister agreed, I understand, with the Committee who met him that he would charge income tax upon that amount. The income tax was then 3/6 in the £. What does he propose to do now? I hope he will be able to deny it. As I take it, he proposes to charge 25 per cent. on that £841,000. Income tax on £841,000 at 3/6 in the £, which was the rate last year, would be £147,232. As far as I understand the matter, the Minister now proposes to take 25 per cent. of the £841,000, which would amount to £210,000, that is to say, a difference of £63,000. In my opinion, first of all, he failed to keep his agreement with the Emergency Committee who met him, and, in the second place, he is robbing the hospitals of an additional £63,000 that he has absolutely no claim upon whatever. I do not regard this as honest dealing, and I want to ask the Minister two questions. I want to ask him whether, when an Act was passed by the Oireachtas, the primary and sole object of which, as far as I was concerned, was to raise money to help the voluntary hospitals —I want to ask him whether he thinks that that Act should now be used as a means for raising revenue for the State. And I ask him, secondly, does he think that the Irish Sweepstake will receive the marvellous support in the future that it has enjoyed in the past when it becomes known to the public that the State has come in and augmented its revenue by grabbing £63,000 which should have gone to help charities. We are looking for money. But I do say that it is a poor thing to go out to the public that the revenue of the State must be added to by grabbing money that was originally got up for the benefit of the charitable hospitals.
Not only has the Derby Sweep, which is nearly over now, been adopted, but there has also been adopted a scheme for the Cesarewitch. Tickets have been printed and distributed and on these tickets there is a distinct assurance to the public that the amount of moneys received through the sale of tickets will be distributed as follows:—75 per cent., after the deduction of expenses, will be distributed as prizes, and the remaining 25 per cent. will be paid to the hospitals. The Minister may say: "That will go to the hospitals, but we will make the hospitals pay." As a matter of fact, he is going to deduct his 25 per cent. before the money reaches the hospitals. On a previous occasion, Deputy Blythe, then Minister for Finance, met the Committee and put a provision into the Finance Act of 1931 exempting the hospitals from income tax.
I do not like to say anything that might harm the sweepstakes, and I do not want to prophesy. I must say, however, that as soon as the people in other countries get to know that the State here is using, for revenue purposes, the money that should have gone to the hospitals, they will be less likely to support our sweepstakes. I think this is going greatly to injure the sweepstakes in the future. I do not say that it will destroy them. I know there are people prepared to buy Sweep tickets no matter for what object. There has been a tremendous feeling on the other side in regard to money coming over here, and I know that any Press agitation started on the other side would have serious effects on the Sweepstakes here. John Bull will undoubtedly take the advice of his newspapers. When he was advised to pay his income tax early he paid it beforehand, and when he was advised to stay at home in his own country he did so, and many of the Swiss hotels and hotels in other parts of the Continent of Europe are now bankrupt as a result. If a Press agitation is started indicating that the money intended for a charitable purpose is now going to be devoted to revenue purposes in this State, there will be a big holding up of the money that otherwise would be subscribed.
I am sorry the Minister has seen fit to make this raid upon charitable funds. If he could possibly withdraw from that position I would like him to consider doing so. He puzzled me by his statement last night to the effect that he was putting a levy of 25 per cent. on the total amount given to the hospitals. He made a statement that income tax is to be charged to the extent of £650,000. In another place he referred to stamp duty. I am not very familiar with these things. I do not know how one mixes up a levy of 25 per cent. together with stamp duty and income tax. At all events, there is confusion existing in my mind. I am sure this will be taken advantage of by people on the other side who are opposed to sweepstakes money coming to the Free State. One must take into consideration the employment given to hundreds of girls and, to a smaller degree, to men in the City. It must be realised, too, that 93 per cent. or 94 per cent. of the money is not raised in the Free State.
I think it is an unwise thing to put this duty upon newspapers entering the Free State. These papers are largely read by boys. I do not know why it was considered necessary to impose this tax. I know there will be tremendous feeling amongst schoolboys when they find themselves deprived of their papers, the reading of which certainly did them no harm. I have frequently looked at those books and papers, and I certainly never saw anything harmful in them. I do not know why the Minister insists upon encroaching on a schoolboy's weekly allowance to the extent that he will have to pay extra for his papers.
I do not like to say very much about the increase in income tax. I expect anything I may say will be thought to be personal. There are many people like myself who have not pensions, and we are only able to provide for our wives and families. It is as much as we can do to make provision for them after our deaths. The only way one can do that is by endeavouring to save money. When I made a similar statement some years ago insurance was suggested. Who can now pay the premiums necessary to make adequate provision for a wife and a large family? People like myself, who receive very small salaries for the amount of work they have to do, are extremely hard hit by any increase in income tax. If it hurts me and many people similarly placed, what is the hardship inflicted upon others?
A great number of people are speaking about clearing out of the country because they say they will not be able to afford to live here. I am quite sure the Minister is not troubling about that. He says, "Anyone who wants to go let him go." That was not the attitude taken up by the late Government. Over and over again, through the President, they indicated that there was room for everybody, and they wanted us all to work together. I came in here in order to do my best to improve the economic position of the country. Those who have been here since I came to the Dáil are aware that anything I have done has been in the direction of improving the condition of the poor. I am quite sure the Minister is making a great mistake in raising the income tax to the English level. It will affect me seriously, but, apart from that, I think it is going to do a tremendous amount of injury to industry. It will cause unemployment. I know several people who are considering whether they will be able to do with a servant less in view of the extra income tax they will have to pay.
I am quite sure the President and the Minister for Finance have made up their minds that they do not want anybody like me who might be inclined to grumble; they want to get rid of such people, people with some sort of a stake in the country. There does not seem to be much anxiety to keep us here. I have lived here since I was 18 years of age, and I do not want to go away if I can possibly afford to stay. With the increased tariffs, the increased cost of living, and a higher income tax it is extremely difficult for people like myself to remain because of our dwindling incomes. We will find it hard to meet our ordinary commitments. I will make one last appeal to the Minister. I think he would be doing a good day's work if he decided to do without the £650,000 he is going to take from the portion of the sweepstakes money that will be allotted to the hospitals.
Comment on this
I do not think that, with regard to any Budget heretofore, there has been so much doubt as there is about this Budget. Yet this House, which is supposed to represent the people of the country, seems to have a desperate fear of approaching it. With regard to the general position, and as to the nature and effects of this Budget, I submit it will close down every avenue of development in this country, and that it will bring about the very direct opposite to that which it is intended to achieve. I have seen it stated that this is the plain man's Budget. I have seen it stated that it is the poor man's Budget, and I have heard it stated that it is going to develop industries. The Minister for Finance said that it was going to make fertile again the green fields of Ireland. If it does that the Minister will have earned my enthusiastic support. But we are here dealing with the principles which it involves, and we want, from an examination of these principles, to test what will be its best possible results.
I want to join with Deputy Blythe and to put on record my emphatic disapproval of the method which the Minister adopted in what was, as Deputy Blythe stated, a national stocktaking. The Minister for Finance went to the trouble of building up artificial and fictitious debts and liabilities on the part of the State. Surely, if the State is, as the Minister said, in dire need, that was not the moment to select to endeavour to build up an artificial burden and thus try to beget further distrust in the future capacity of this country. On listening to the Minister, I thought nothing could be more fallacious than the method adopted by him to capitalise national liabilities.
In order to arrive at the major figure of the liabilities of the State, he takes the question of the land annuities. Having handled that for some considerable time, he arrives at the capital figure of the liabilities of this State in the matter of land annuities, placing the figure at £76,000,000. Everyone, even the poorest and smallest farmer in this country, knows that in truth and in fact the land annuities are not Budgetary items at all. Yet here in this House, when we are told that the State is in dire necessity, this sum that is being repaid by the tenant farmers of the country for the purchase of their lands is juggled with until ultimately a sum of £76,000,000 is set down as the liability of the State. What, in fact, is this liability of the land annuities? Let us put it accurately on the records of this House what this liability is. Assume that the farmer is purchasing his land on the hire purchase system and is paying the sums which he is, in fact, paying for the purpose of discharging this liability which the entire tenant farmers of Ireland are paying, and we have one side of the picture. But assume that it is only one single instance, and that the purchaser was paying the purchase money to the seller in yearly instalments, could it be assumed to be a Budgetary item? I submit again that that is a very unfair way of dealing with that matter. It is not fair to the State. As to the other aspects of that question, I am totally indifferent. But I think it is a wrong thing, particularly at this time of national necessity, to introduce and place on the records of this House and on the finance of this country a liability which is not, in fact, a Budgetary item.
This Government was to create employment and create industries, thereby abolishing unemployment. It adopts a very crude method of doing so. It levies an income tax of 5/- in the £, making a direct tax of 25 per cent. on industries. It increases the Corporation Profits Tax to 7½ per cent. on profits over £5,000, thereby imposing on any industry in this country earning an annual sum in excess of £5,000 a direct levy of 32½ per cent. It is quite easy to tell this House that there is going to be given an impetus to industry, but do we not know that taxes of that kind, for whatever purpose they are imposed, can have but one result? That result is to restrict output, to restrict development, and thereby impose on industry a burden that it cannot bear. It increases the cost of the articles produced, thereby making it almost impossible for those articles to be sold at competitive prices against goods from a cheaply taxed country.
We are told that tariffs, amounting to approximately £910,000, are to be imposed for the purpose of developing the industries of this country. On the other hand, the Government are imposing a direct tax of 32½ per cent. on any profits in excess of £5,000 earned by any industry in this country. How is such an industry to be built up? How is that industry to build up a reserve which, in fact and in practice, is the only protection for the employees of the industry against the rainy day? We know it is the practice of all firms to build up such reserves. Imposing an income tax of 25 per cent. is a direct prohibition against all industrial development. Doing it in a State like this, which has, for all practical purposes, only an infinitesimal national burden, is an outrage.
I want to make a vehement protest against the tax on tea. That is a tax with which I am immediately concerned. Listening to the language used by the Minister in connection with this tea tax last evening I could scarcely believe that I was sitting in this Chamber. I would like to repeat the language used by the Minister on that occasion:—"A tax on sugar is a ‘hard' tax. It cannot be imposed without a corresponding increase in the cost of living. It, therefore, falls heavily on the very poor. Tea, on the other hand, has little value as food. It is not a necessary of life. A tax upon it is a ‘soft' tax; that is to say, a tea tax need not necessarily involve a diminution in consumption or an increase in the amount spent upon the commodity. The poor can adjust themselves to it more easily than to a tax upon sugar. They will not have to pay more for tea, and I have no doubt that, with a tax on tea, we shall have enterprising grocers proclaiming to the public that their ‘2/8 tea is still 2/8.'"
That statement involves, in my opinion, two preposterous suggestions. It takes no notice at all of the fact that tea to-day, unfortunately, if I may say so, is a daily and hourly article of food for our poor people. I would like to know has the Minister behind him the representatives and members of his Party from the poorer parts of the Saorstát? I would like to know also what the Labour Party have to say on this tea tax? I enter a vehement protest against this tax on the poor. Tea may not have a great food value, but that is another question. As we all know, the very poor people of the country use tea once, twice, three times, and sometimes four times a day. I am sure there are many members of the House who will be astonished when I tell them that children are reared in this country who never taste milk and only very little sugar. Some of them get no milk after the maternal supply fails. After that they are reared up on a diet of black tea. Despite all that, we have been told by the Minister for Finance that tea is a luxury, as it were, that this is a "soft" tax on an article that, for economic and other reasons with which I am not now immediately concerned, is a daily and, one might almost say, hourly article of food for the very poorest of our people. If this is a plain man's Budget or a poor man's Budget let us say so, but do not put a tax on tea, which is used as an article of food in the case even of the infants of the very poor. The poor will not be able to bear it. We have been told that tea is not a staple article of food, and that still "the 2/8 tea will be still 2/8." I submit that is a cruel jibe at the expense of these poor people, and I resent it on behalf of those I represent. There are other features of the Budget, some of which, at least, do not intimately or seriously concern the class of people I represent, but I do protest against the tax on tea. When tariffs are imposed they must directly hit the poor. I am certain that will be the case as regards the tax on tea. In my opinion, it is wholly unjustified.
Comment on this
At this stage of the Budget discussions I assume that we would be more properly employed in referring to the general principles on which it has been drawn. I should like to say that I think this Budget, viewed from that point of view, is the best that has been introduced into this House since the Saorstát was founded. It is a Budget which has put upon the right level the pressing problems that any Government ought to try to deal with. It is a Budget which has not left housing unprovided for. There is the admission in it that the housing problem is an emergency problem, and one that requires emergency measures to deal with it effectively. I see also in the provisions brought before the House by the Minister for Finance a realisation of the urgent and pressing character of the dilemma of the unemployed poor. I know that the measures that he has had to take in order to meet these urgent and pressing problems were bound to be unpopular, particularly with bachelors. I have little doubt, however, in saying that the principle he has adopted in deliberately lightening the burden on married members of the community and on family members of the community is a sound and a Christian principle, a principle that I think will commend itself to all the people of this country.
I think the spirit in which the Minister has approached the redemption of the Fianna Fáil election promises to come to the assistance of the unemployed in no uncertain manner here and now is one also that will commend itself to the people. I confess that, with certain members of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, I was surprised, having listened to the very eloquent speeches of Deputy Blaney, Deputy Carney, Deputy Brady, and some other Fianna Fáil Teachtaí for the County Donegal, to find that economies have produced so little. I understood that when the Government Benches were occupied by Fianna Fáil Ministers the millennium would be at hand, that we were going to finance every kind of improvement out of savings. I think, perhaps, those Ministers, like a good many more of us, have with the passing of time grown wiser. I am glad, however, to see that in growing wise they did not grow cowardly. Finding that they were unable to finance these urgent reforms by the savings they had hoped to effect, they have taken their courage in their hands and called upon the community to come to their assistance to help them through. I believe the community will come to their assistance in no uncertain spirit.
I cannot pass without referring to the Seventh Resolution, because that brings us into quite another sphere. It has been repeatedly asserted from political platforms by the two big Parties that the agricultural industry is the most important industry in this country, and it has been repeatedly admitted on all sides that the tariff policy pursued by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government hitherto has shown little consideration for the interests of the agricultural community. They have been called upon to pay more for their boots, for their clothes, for this and for that, in order that the industrial arm of the community might be strengthened. What do we find when Fianna Fáil takes the helm? They have put a tariff, and a heavy tariff, on galvanised buckets. A few days ago they put a tariff on maize, to be ground into Indian meal, coming into this country. With regard to these tariffs, I am not going to go into details now because another opportunity will arise for doing that, but the position is that they have put a tariff on a large number of commodities that the agricultural community must have. They have put tariffs on that they admit are going to increase the cost of those commodities to the agricultural community. It is quite true that in the same Budget they have extended relief in respect to rates, but that is a poor contribution compared with the burden that is being laid on and that has been laid on the agricultural community by tariffs in the past.
Under sub-head 7 of this Seventh Resolution they have put a tariff of 20 per cent. on all blankets. No one knows better than the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who is one of the representatives of the City of Dublin—the same remark applies to any Deputy representing areas where there are people in straitened circumstances —that the omission of cotton blankets from the original blanket tariff was a great concession to the poor. It is not everyone who can afford a woollen blanket. A great many people must do with the best they can get in the way of a cotton blanket.
The manufacture of cotton blankets in this country is non-existent, and the amount of custom going to come to the Irish blanket mills by compelling the poor to do with one woollen blanket, instead of two or three cotton ones, is not going to amount to very much, and the amount of custom going to come to Irish mills, by making people do without any blankets, is not going to amount to very much. I think that there is very little doubt that if the manufacturers of these commodities are further interviewed, the Minister will be assured that that tariff is calculated to do nobody any good, and that its only effect will be to raise revenue at the expense of the people who habitually import that article. These are people in respect of whom I do not think any Minister will say that they are a suitable section of the community to turn to for revenue.
I do not want to go into this in detail, because the opportunity will arise again, but how on earth, in the present extraordinarily difficult situation the agricultural community have to face in their foreign markets, can you defend putting a heavy tax on foreign artificial manures? There are a great many of us to whom that tariff will mean substantial profit. Those of us who have been in the habit of purveying Irish or English-made manures will derive large additional profits from this tariff which the Minister is putting on the foreign product. The fact of the matter is, as we all know, that foreign superphosphate of lime is just as good as Irish or British superphosphate of lime, and far cheaper, and the result of this tariff will be, that there will be one shilling put on every cwt. of superphosphate of lime put on Irish land, and the Department of Agriculture has repeatedly declared that the land of this country is starving for phosphates. The same applies to the other compound manures, such as fertiliser and special manures for special crops. I cannot understand how any economist could defend such a proposition.
I do not know whether we could properly refer to the maize tariff now, but it is admitted that maize is the foundation of the pig and bacon trades, and also of the egg trade. It is the most widely used foodstuff we have in agricultural feeding. How on earth can the Minister defend putting a tariff on foreign maize, with the grave danger of raising the price of that essential commodity to the agricultural community? Surely these questions are deserving of consideration. I am not without hope that a courageous, and, I believe, an excellent Budget, will have removed from it at a later stage the blemishes which would justify the agricultural community in saying that they have been forgotten again. I am not without hope that the rigid party discipline, which does such credit to Deputy Boland and to the Whips of the Fianna Fáil Party, and which preserves such admirable silence on the Fianna Fáil Benches, will be strained, and that there will be some Fianna Fáil Deputies who will get up and tell their leaders that it is straining their loyalty to ask them to be a party to putting further burdens on the backs of the agricultural community of this country. They are not able to bear them, and Fianna Fáil Deputies from rural areas know they are not able to bear them. Party solidity is a virtuous and excellent thing, but I think there are occasions when golden rules may be broken, and I look forward to the expenditure of some Fianna Fáil eloquence at this early stage of the financial business of the House to check the ardour of the Ministers and to restrain their fury, when faced with galvanised iron, Indian meal, and compound manures.
Burdens there are, heavy burdens, and I agree that unless there were an emergency, as I think there unquestionably is, there would be a very strong case for saying that the burdens that are being laid on the community are too heavy. I gather from the Minister that he looks forward to a more cheerful year in 1932-33. I am not in entire agreement with him as to how he proposes to make that year more cheerful, but that is business for another day. I hope that, without going into that other business, the Minister will be able in 1932-33 to prepare another Budget, and when that time comes that he will be in a position to say that, without any international adjustments, this nation has reached a stage in its economic career when the burden on the taxpayer can be substantially reduced without making the poor suffer unduly.
Comment on this
I am afraid I cannot agree with Deputy Dillon in his praise of the Budget. If there is one term that can be applied to the Budget which would be generally accepted, it would be that it is a scare Budget. The Minister is rather amused at that, but it will scare the industrialist, scare the farmer, scare the labourer, when he comes to think of it seriously, and almost scare the crows. The Minister, in introducing his Budget, said that we were in for a hard year, and I think he added, an honest year. That depends on his interpretation of honesty. If it is my interpretation that for the first time we have the correct position of Fianna Fáil, as applied to the taxpayers of this country, definitely put, it will be an honest year, because hitherto in this House, in the country, on platforms and at cross-roads, everywhere, we were told by the Government now in office, that when they came into power, the first Budget they introduced would be a Budget that would give relief to the people in every possible way—relief in taxation, relief in expenditure, relief by every other conceivable method. What do we find? In addition to our direct taxation of two to three million pounds, no practical attempt at cutting expenditure and very little of the economies that were preached to us. This Budget, to my mind, is a deliberate attempt to hoodwink the people, to hoodwink the farmers, to whom many Deputies on the Government Benches, including Deputy Corry, who is so interested just now in my remarks, made promises of great future happiness and prosperity.
The Government, before the Budget was introduced, to placate the farmer I presume, brought in a Bill to provide a bounty for butter, the most part of which the farmer himself will contribute, and the other part of which will be extracted, if it can be extracted, from the consumer. The Government itself contributes nothing. That was the sop to the farmer to induce him to accept this Budget and the taxes which are being put upon him. Not content with starting on agricultural machinery and adding to the farmer's costs a sum which none of us can correctly estimate, the Minister has now, in Resolution No. 7, instituted numerous tariffs which will fall, perhaps, more heavily on the farmer than on any other member of the community, if I except the labouring man in the country and perhaps the worker in the city. He will have to pay more for his boots, for his clothes, for his buckets, as Deputy Dillon says, and more for his wire fences. I notice that the Minister has excluded barbed wire, but he is going to make the farmer pay more for any ordinary wire to fence his fields with. He has even taxed the galvanised iron with which, sometimes, in desperation, the unfortunate farmers cover the thatched houses which some of them are compelled to live in.
It would take me nearly a week to go through this schedule of tariffs. It would take me longer to estimate the probable cost to the farmers and the other members of the community. The Minister himself could not estimate it—he could not even make a shot at it. He jumbled it up in the combined figure of £910,000. We may call it one million roughly. He gave us no particulars whatever as to what any particular item would put on the consumer. For instance, I do not know, perhaps the Minister will tell me now, what this tariff on galvanised iron is going to cost the ordinary farmer in the mere matter of roofing his house or building a hay barn or using it in the many ways the farmers do use it. I do not know what it will cost him. I might put it at a figure which would be completely wrong. I should like to have some figures as to these things before I could really discuss them. The Minister might have given them to us. Nearly an hour was spent in an attempt to extract them from him. Eventually, the President told us, what the Minister might have told us at the start, that the Minister had arrived at this figure of £910,000 by the simple method of adding up the totals for the various tariffs. If he had done that and added it up it would not have taken five minutes to produce it in the House. He need not even have done the adding. We would have done the adding if he gave us the particulars.
As I say, this Budget is an attempt to hoodwink the various classes in this country. I started with the farmer because I am more interested in the farmer than in any other member of the community. But if we take the next worst-off section of the community—I say definitely the next worst off because I believe that the farmer is the worst off—if we take the section whom Deputy Corish represents—the labourers—the Minister has also made a deliberate attempt to hoodwink the labouring section of the community. He has again offered them a sop of one million or one and a half millions in grants in aid of work, grants such as have been given very often in the last ten years to assist labour. He provides one million from the Road Fund. Several millions have been provided out of the Road Fund within the last ten years to assist in providing work for labouring men without any great effect in lessening unemployment. Does the Minister really mean to tell us that this one million pounds for road work, or a couple of hundred thousand pounds for housing, is going to cure all the ills of the labouring classes? Is it even going to be any set-off against the huge bill which the Minister himself is imposing on the working section of the community? If you go through the list of items in Resolution No. 7, there is not an item in it which will not press on the farmers and on the labourers, every section of them, from the married man with a family to the women and the boys and girls. The man is going to be taxed for his boots, for his writing-pad and even for his ink. He will not be able even to write a letter to the Minister for a remission of some of the duties.
Comment on this
The women are not to be allowed to go free under this Budget either. We are going to tax knives and forks. I might have started off with stockings and dresses and the other preliminaries that women usually wear. They are all going to be taxed. Even the perambulator is not going to be allowed to go scot-free, because the Minister proposes to tax perambulators too. The Minister has tried to induce a number of bachelors to get married quickly. I do not know that he is going the right way about it. Having escaped myself for such a long period, I would say that there is nothing in this Budget to make me rush headlong into the happy state. When Deputy Corry goes back to Cork, I wonder what the boys and girls will say to him when they find that bicycles are taxed considerably. I wonder what the girls will say when they find that all kinds of perfumed soap which they use are taxed, as well as a lot of other articles.
But to get back to the real Budget itself, and to take it seriously. The main tax in this Budget is the income tax, and income tax is increased in this Budget to 5/-, and in certain cases to 7/-. Does the Minister really mean to suggest that he is going to provide work for the numerous unemployed that unfortunately exist in this country by that means? Is he going to suggest that by this imposition upon the well-to-do classes, even with the addition of the small grant he is making towards housing, he will induce the well-to-do builders of the country to engage in building operations? Added to this difficulty of income tax there are the other numerous difficulties in Schedule 7 in connection with the various items used in building, such, for instance, as building stone, metal door frames, metal window frames, sashes, and various other articles used in the building trade. Still the Minister tells us that the housing of the people is going to be proceeded with at a rapid rate when builders are taxed beyond endurance. With the cost of building mounting up every minute are they going to rush headlong and engage in building operations, with, possibly,, in the near future, a tax upon cement facing them also, because it is mooted it will be? We do not know. With all these additional costs facing them in the near future, is there any guarantee that builders will rush headlong into the construction of houses either for rich or poor?
Then we have the tax on tea— another camouflage for the unfortunate poor. The Minister said he had removed the tax on sugar because it was daily used by the poor, and he substituted this tax on tea, which he said was also daily used, but that the one would balance the other. We find that they do not. There is an item of £18,000 which the Minister is going to collar from the poor in this case. There is a further additional item which he carefully conceals, that while 90 per cent. of the tea consumed is consumed by the very poor, not 60 per cent. of the sugar on which the duty is paid is consumed by the poor. I should say the great bulk of the sugar is used in factories, by confectioners and other such large users of sugar. Tea is not so used.
Comment on this
The poor do not. They will never taste sweets again when the Minister for Finance has done with them. As I said, this tea duty is coming directly from the poor. The Minister admits taking £18,000 from the poor in this way, and indirectly he is going to take a concealed sum, the amount of which he would not tell us. Again from lack of detail I cannot tell the amount, but it will be a big amount. All the duty on sugar did not come from the poor, but nearly all the duty on tea will come from the poor and will fall most heavily upon the poor. The Minister tells us he is giving relief to the poor, but the whole Budget is a camouflage on the intelligence of the poor.
Then again the Minister said we were to have an extension of the social services. Of course! The Minister proposes to extend the provision for old age pensions. Will the old age pensioners be happy in the knowledge that the sum given in relief to them in the extension of their old age pension privileges is extracted from the sick and needy poor by raiding the provisions which the sweepstakes have made for the very needy and sick poor in the various hospitals in Dublin, Cork, Limerick, Waterford and other places in this country? Will the poor and needy who get some additional help in their old age pensions provisions be satisfied when they know that the relief given them is obtained by lessening the provision made possible for the poor, in the hospitals and without any help from the Minister? I say this tax upon the hospitals is an iniquitous tax. Without going into all the consequences that may develop, as Deputy Sir James Craig said, it is a direct tax upon the unfortunate sick poor of the State. One might examine Resolution No. 8 for quite a considerable time and derive quite a considerable amount of painful knowledge from it, but in the absence of details, for which we pressed the Minister, it would be idle for anybody to try to go carefully and definitely into it. As I said this is a scare Budget. There is no section or individual in the community to-day who is happy in his mind as a result of it. It will set back industrial development, and will make, if I may say so, a great addition to the unemployed. The consequence naturally must be that when people and firms are taxed beyond endurance they must resort to the desperate remedy of lessening their expenditure. Unfortunately in lessening expenditure firms and individuals have to lessen the number of their employees. Therefore I am afraid whether we are farmers, shop-keepers, or otherwise engaged in business we will be faced with the necessity of cutting our expenditure and going in for retrenchment.
One of the retrenchments perhaps that will be the least pleasing is that which must necessarily add to the number at present unemployed in this unfortunate State. The Minister yesterday in one part of his speech told us that the one-eyed man is king amongst the blind. He stood there expanding his chest like a bantam in a farmyard when he told us that. I make bold to say that in the realm of financial manipulators the Minister will go down to history as an emperor amongst the blind.
Comment on this
I do not intend to keep the House very long, but I want to say that in my opinion this is an appalling Budget and will lead to bankruptcy on a wholesale scale within six months. That is my fixed view about this Budget. It would be quite impossible to deal with details except in a very long speech, which I do not intend to make. But I want to put on record here that since this Government came in everything they have done and everything they have said, whatever other effects they may have had, have had these two effects: (1) they have increased the price of everything the farmer has to buy, and (2) they have decreased the price of everything he has to sell. That is bound, inevitably, to lead to the bankruptcy of this country. This Budget I can only describe as the economic counterpart of the civil war. The civil war was not a war in any real sense of the word; it was an attack on property, an attack on the structure of society, as we know it. It failed. This is a more insidious and, I think, it will be a more effective attack. When I read this Budget, when I see the taxes that are imposed, when I find that the clear object is to strip everyone in the country who is working and to distribute what is obtained, when I take into account that the great agricultural export trade of the country is discouraged by every possible means and that whatever little non-agricultural export trade we have is also discouraged—when I take that into account, on the one side, and when I take into account on the other side, all the impositions that are deliberately levied on every man who is working in the country, whether he is rich or poor, then indeed all the political jargon that we heard about the Treaty and the Oath goes back into its right perspective.
The fact of the matter is that all the debate that took place before this Budget was introduced was about an issue that neither Party opposite was concerned with. It was all, as a previous speaker said, so much camouflage. I could understand, while I would not agree with, a Party who had, after consideration, after examination, decided that the economics of this country were unsound and could not last, that it was necessary to change them, to change the whole economic structure of the country and that whatever sacrifice was necessary as a result of that change and dislocation would have to be borne by the citizens who live in the country to-day. But what do we find here? We find a political policy which is going to accentuate and double the sacrifices that the economic policy will call for.
We are told from the benches opposite that the State and the nation are the people of the country and that it is the people of the country they are thinking of. What have they done? This Budget will bring unemployment. For every single man put into employment artificially at the expense of the taxpayer and consumer by the political spoon-feeding of this Budget, there will be three men disemployed. It will bring want, unemployment and decreased production in its train. That is what this Budget is going to do. What are we told? That in five years all these processes will be reversed, that in the meantime we must suffer, and the suffering must be accentuated by the political policy which preceded it. I am going to be asked what I mean by "the political policy which preceded it." The fact of the matter is that the effect of everything the Party opposite have done since they came into office has been to create a hostile market abroad and to increase the price of goods at home to every Irishman, whether rich or poor, labourer or farmer, agriculturist or industrialist. And this Budget is to be debated with laughter! I tell the gentlemen opposite that there will be no laughter in this country in eight months when the real reactions of this Budget are made clear and when they make themselves felt.
I have no great respect for the judgment of the Ministers or of the Party opposite. They know that. I have never hidden it. But I cannot believe that they do not see where this is leading. I go so far as to say that there is a shrewd idea behind this— that in making a bankrupt you make a citizen who has a vested interest in unrest. What political party is going to profit from that? I go so far as to say that that could be the only logical justification of this Budget. I tell Deputies opposite who find the whole thing so amusing that after one year's experience of the reactions of this Budget there will be less laughter and more tears, not only outside but in this Dáil.
I hope we will have an opportunity of debating this Budget again. We cannot debate it now. We had the humiliating spectacle this morning of the Front Bench with scarcely a single Minister who seemed to know what the Budget was about. Apparently the Minister for Finance concentrated all his unexpended energy on what he regarded as a fine literary production. He did not seem to know the details of his own Budget. I do not know who prepared it. I know who did not prepare it. I know that, as it is presented to the House at present, it is, from every point of view, as bad, as degrading and as harmful a production as could be presented by any Government. I deliberately repeat the sentence with which I began—that this Budget is going to do more real harm, to cause more real suffering and more real want in this country than did the civil war. It is the economic counterpart of the civil war, and it rightly comes from the President of the Executive Council.
Comment on this
As regards Number 28, I should like to know from the Minister what is meant by the words "photographic apparatus and component parts and accessories thereof." What do "accessories" include? I have here a catalogue of Messrs. Kodak. It contains 216 pages, descriptive of accessories. Generally speaking, all the items in these 216 pages would come within the terms of this Resolution. I should be glad if the Minister would state what "accessories" include.
Comment on this
There is one other point dealing with photographic material that I would like to have explained. I do not know of any manufacturer of photographic apparatus in this country, but from an experience that I had on the quays this morning I imagine that every tourist coming to this country who has a camera will have a certain amount of difficulty with the customs officers. I take it that it is not the intention of the Government that a tourist who comes here with a camera will have to stand a certain amount of cross-examination. I am putting the question to the Minister to see if the game is worth the candle in this case.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance has dealt a staggering blow to industry and commerce in the Free State, and has delivered a blow which I would describe as a foul one, because it is below the belt. The reason I say that is that the Party that is now in power got no mandate at the last election to increase taxation. The outstanding case made to the electors was the promise to reduce taxation. I challenge the President to reply to the statement I am going to quote from an advertisement that was issued by the Fianna Fáil Party in February, which stated: "The burden of taxation can be lightened by not less than two million pounds a year." That advertisement appeared in the "Irish Independent" of last February. The Minister for Finance stated here yesterday that the burden of taxation is to be increased by £3,500,000 a year under the first Budget he introduced. I say that the people have been deceived, and that they have been fooled, but they cannot be fooled all the time. I challenge the Government to deal with the policy they advertised. The pledges they gave, and which they were in honour bound to carry out, have been absolutely disregarded. I believe this Budget is going to disgrace the Government in the country. There is no doubt that they have broken their pledges and their promises. The crushing burden of taxation that is going to be imposed will mean increased unemployment, because those who have to bear the burden will economise. They will be forced to economise by reducing the number of persons in their employment. The Minister's scheme to provide employment will be counterbalanced by the number of people who will be thrown out of employment owing to the undue burden that is being placed on trade and commerce, at a period when trade and commerce were never less able to bear it. This is supposed to be a poor man's Budget. It is no such thing. No people in this country will suffer more from the Budget than the poor, because they will have to pay very much higher prices for everything they purchase.
Labourers, farmers and professional men will have to pay increased prices for everything they purchase. I will go so far as to say that the increase will be at least fifty per cent. in the case of persons who have to purchase their requirements. A good deal could be said for tariffs being imposed on articles that could be manufactured here, but I cannot understand why heavy tariffs are to be imposed on articles which will not be manufactured in this country. Farmers whose markets have been taken from them, owing to the policy adopted by the Party on the Government side, are now going to be asked to pay at least 33 per cent. more for goods that they have to purchase, at a time when they cannot get a fair price for their produce. Many Deputies asked questions about articles that were or were not included in the Resolutions. The only things that I see excluded from taxation in this Budget are air and water, and we do not know the morning that we may wake up and find them taxed. Now that everything is being included, it is practically certain that they will also be taxed.
I want to deal with the entertainments tax, particularly with regard to racing. I know that it is difficult to object to the entertainments tax when everything other than air and water is being taxed. At the same time I remember that the Minister for Finance served on a Committee with me, of which Deputy Ruttledge was chairman, and after hearing the evidence of breeders, racehorse owners and other persons interested in the industry, we brought in an unanimous report that the entertainments tax should be taken off racing. The Minister now comes in and reverses his own decision. That Committee heard the evidence of experts, of owners, and of breeders, but the Party opposite does not seem to put much value on the importance of the export trade in thoroughbred horses. I think I am correct in saying that it is the second biggest asset we have in this country. What is the Government going to do? They are going to put on the entertainments tax, and by doing so they are going practically to extinguish race meetings. Everyone knows that the race companies reduced their prices when the entertainments tax was taken off, and they were beginning to get the public back to their meetings. The stakes were also heavily reduced. The result of the proposals in the Budget will be that for a comparatively small amount of money the vast majority of the race companies will be prevented from carrying on. The racecourses are the shop windows in which breeders who export horses to the value of two million pounds yearly exhibit their goods. If the intention is to pull down the blinds on the windows, let them do so, but the result will be to create an amount of unemployment.
I have previously spoken at length on this question and I do not intend to develop the matter any further. I am afraid there is very little use in doing so. However, at the eleventh hour, I will ask the Minister to reconsider the matter in view of the amount of money involved. Personally, I do not care twopence because I have practically ceased attending race meetings. The tax that was imposed on betting has prevented anybody from having a chance of returning from meetings richer than when going to them. I do not like to see an entertainments tax on outdoor sports in the interests of the youth of the country. Latterly the young people were taking more interest in sports than in politics and other meetings that were no good to the country. They now go to football matches, sports, and races and, in my opinion, it is a bad principle to tax these gatherings, or to discourage outdoor amusements. I am surprised that the Party opposite does not encourage the youth of the country to amuse themselves at such gatherings.
The entertainments tax is going to hurt all these things, and I ask is it worth it from the point of view of revenue? Deputies on the opposite benches will be going home to-morrow night and I invite them to consult their constituents, because I have never seen in my experience of politics such a slump as has occurred in the policy of the Party opposite. I say now that if there was an election in the morning on the Budget policy alone, apart from the way they treated the farmers by depriving them of their only market, they would be snowed under. People ask "What are the Labour Party going to do? Surely they are not going to vote for all these tariffs that are going to come along and paralyse us?" I said "I cannot answer for them," but they seem to be in an impossible position, because they are doing what they do not believe in. They are voting for a policy they do not believe in.
Comment on this
No doubt they are interested, and genuinely interested, in creating employment, but they are going, by this policy of wholesale tariffs, to penalise 90 per cent. of the people they represent without any gain. This policy is going to penalise the trade of the towns and it is going to bring very little assistance to people down the country. It may possibly provide funds for better housing. If it does I will be delighted, but I say that the Fianna Fáil Party got no mandate for this wholesale tariff policy. If they asked the people at the time they certainly would not get a mandate, and if they went to the country now the one result would be—"Also ran, President de Valera."
Comment on this
I do not intend to enter into the wealth of detail into which Deputy Bennett entered, but I must confess to a certain amount of relief that such things as roads, relief of unemployment and housing have been dealt with in this Budget. It would comfort us still more if we knew that these services were not to be financed at the expense of other services. I see the Hospital Sweepstakes are to be taxed. That will deprive us, naturally, of grants to local authorities for building additions to hospitals. I must confess to a considerable amount of disappointment that agriculture has not been adequately dealt with in this Budget considering its importance to the country. Almost everything that the tillage farmer, at any rate, requires has been tariffed, but nothing practically has been done to secure for him a market for his produce, particularly such things as barley or malt. The other day I asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce to do something for us, but he was cold to my appeal.
I think when we bear in mind the enormous necessity that exists for artificial manures the tax on them is a serious matter for the farmer. Anything in the nature of a tax on the requirements of the farmer is bound to militate against his ability to produce at an economic rate, and that undoubtedly is a tremendous set-back to agriculture, coming from a Party that has promised, as the present Government promised, to help agriculture when they were going before the country. True, there is this addition of £250,000 for the relief of rates, but after all that is a small sum compared to what could be done if adequate protection were given to the products of the tillage farmer. I think that if the Government devoted their attention to procuring markets and safeguarding the products of the land it would be better than tariffing the requirements which the farmer needs for carrying on production. It must be apparent to members of the House that in failing to help the farmer the agricultural labourer is also affected. It only adds considerably more to the ranks of the unemployed in that particular class when the farmers are getting rid of them.
I feel that one of the things that has not been adequately dealt with by the Minister in this Budget is the question of salaries in the public service. The cost-of-living bonus has not been touched, and apparently it is his intention not to touch it. That is probably due to the fact that the Minister has been the cause of what will probably be a very material increase in the cost of living. That again will hit the agricultural community, as any small concession given in regard to the relief of rates will be counterbalanced by the increase in the cost of living and the cost of the farmer's requirements. I emphasise the farmer's needs because, after all, it is from his production that most of our national income is derived, and when we contemplate the future risks which are attendant on his market, whether from depression or from other likely action that may be taken owing to the fact that imports to this country are now heavily taxed— if for no other reason their capacity to purchase from us would be lowered as a result of these tariffs—the position merits serious consideration.
Another matter that perhaps might engage the Minister's attention would be means for assisting loans to farmers to enable them to carry on. That is a very urgent matter, of which I think the Minister would have been wise to take cognisance in the Budget. Nothing is more necessary at the present time, owing to the depreciation in the capital resources of the farmer. If attention had been paid in that direction it would undoubtedly have assisted him far more than some of the efforts which have been made in taxing almost every requirement which the farmer has to make use of in carrying on his production, whether agricultural machinery, manures, or other requirements which were enumerated by Deputies who spoke before me.
Roads have been improved. That will help us to assist the tourist industry. It will induce people to come in if we create an atmosphere in this country which will encourage them to come in. Better housing will also create employment, will produce better health amongst the people, and will undoubtedly be an added asset in the country's wealth.
There is one point I should like to mention and that is the income tax. I have not the smallest doubt that the late Minister for Finance would have explored that avenue if it had appeared to him an advisable thing to reduce the attraction which a low income tax provided for wealthy people to come over and live in this country. I am personally aware that large numbers of people have come over and taken up their residence in this country owing to the cheap living, and owing to the facilities they were given for such things as hunting and various other attractions which provided a means for well-to-do people of securing amusement for themselves. Any tax or other discouragement that it put on that class of people has, undoubtedly, a tendency to reduce their capacity to employ. The inducement to reside in this country is done away with whether they are people of English nationality or whatever nationality they belong to. There is no doubt at all about it that the effect on these people is adding seriously to the ranks of the unemployed without giving us a very material increase in revenue. It may also be a serious set back to the industrial side of the question. I am in absolute sympathy with making people pay who are able to pay. But those factors should be taken into consideration.
We shall have to direct our attention in every Budget in future towards providing encouragement to the agricultural community to produce more, and towards taking away any restrictions that are placed upon their efforts to increase production and thus add to our national wealth. By doing so you are aiding a huge working class. The great majority of them may not be employers, but there is a great risk that if they are not able to carry on production on their farms they will be adding to the already heavy list of the unemployed. We have heard of the farmers in this country who are seeking home assistance, to our shame be it said. At the same time we have to direct our attention towards trying to save as much as we possibly can of our national income.
Comment on this
I do not intend to make a very long statement on this Budget. I was somewhat sorry to listen to the Minister for Finance yesterday when he spoke of the golden tipped arrow that he had for a certain type of citizen in this country, because I think it would be better described as an eighteen-pounder or something like that, and that it was likely to explode at any moment. I was sorry to hear the Minister say that not only had he golden-tipped arrows, as he said, for these citizens but that he had poisoned darts as well, and poisoned darts in particular for members on these benches. I do not want to criticise him unduly, but at the same time I feel that in the matter of a national Budget such as this, some of the shafts that he had in his quiver and that he fired from it could be very well left there. However he saw fit to fire them, and I do not think that it was to the dignity of the Government of this country or of the Minister that he should have discharged them in the manner that he did. In discharging them he said that the ex-Minister for Finance had ignored the Hatry crash. Well, unless some Almighty Power guiding the destiny of this country helps, us I am afraid that a Hatry crash is likely to be the result of the Ministerial policy of the present Government. The Minister for Finance also complained that the ex-Minister had ignored certain happenings in England. I should like to say on that, that the new administration seems to be poisoned with the same virus, because they are ignoring things which are happening across there also.
For the last week or ten days we have heard very much about mandates and about what the Government was bound to do because of the pledges its members had given. With Deputy Shaw I should like to point out that not only were these pledges advertised but they were spoken of from every platform. One of the things said was the definite statement that the burden of taxation would be lightened by no less than two millions. And what is being done? The very first Budget of the new administration is one to increase taxation by three-and-a-half millions. In the same advertisement the Fianna Fáil Party talked about 1,410,000 acres of tillage; and the very next thing they do, instead of helping the farmer or encouraging him to produce this tillage, is to put a tariff upon the machinery and upon the other things that are necessary in carrying out tillage operations in the country generally.
The problem of unemployment was to be solved right away. I agree that the Government are doing something in the Budget in the way of a Relief Grant. But that does not, in any way, carry out the programme that the Fianna Fáil Party put before the country and on which—there is no question about it—the people voted for them. I am not a bit uneasy whether or not they will win the next election. I hope they will not. I do not agree with Deputy Shaw at all. I do not care whether the Fianna Fáil Party are beaten at the next election on this particular question or not—I hope they will be—and I do not care if I saw them facing the country to-morrow. But if they face the next election with as deceptive a programme as this, and the next day carry out a policy so contrary to it, well, I think that they could get away with anything, and I think that they can, as a matter of fact.
The Budget is increasing taxation all around, and there is one particular class of citizen that I think should not be taxed any further, and that is the pipe smoker, the tobacco smoker. As a lover of the pipe, I think that we are entitled to get our smoke without any greater hardships, because I think when income tax is paid by anyone who is in the position to do so and when everything else is paid, there will be nothing left.
We were told a great deal during the election of the huge reductions that could take place in salaries. What is happening? The best that the Minister says now that he can do is to secure a reduction of £250,000. And what do we get for that? A dissatisfied Civil Service, a dissatisfied or perhaps uneasy Army and Police Force, a dissatisfied Postal Service and Teaching Community, and all that for £250,000 out of a total Budget of £30,000,000. I respectfully suggest that £250,000 is in no way a recompense for the uneasiness and hardships that are imposed by these reductions on the public servants of the State. I think that it is very unfair. Remember that a happy, contented, energetic Civil Service and State service is worth more than £250,000 a year—much more, I think. I think it is very false economy. And as the Minister has not yet committed himself to that, because he said he was seeing certain members of the Civil Service, I would ask him to consider it very carefully.
Anyhow, so far as the Fianna Fáil Party's programme of huge reductions is concerned, I look upon it as the case of a big body in great labour bringing forth a midget. That is all it was. As a matter of fact, I could describe it as a white elephant. Again we have a tariff on Indian meal. In the constituency that I represent Indian meal is a very important item to the farming community of the district. Not only is it important to the farmers, but to the labourers and workers. They al keep a pig, some poultry, and thing like that, and the staple food for these is Indian meal. By that particular tariff you are increasing their cost. I know what I say about Indian meal does not apply so much to Westmeath as it does to Longford, but in the County Longford it is going to be a very great hardship on the people. I am sorry to say that in a great number of cases Indian meal has to be used even as food for the people themselves. Some people may not like to admit that, but it is nevertheless true. You are taxing the staple food of a number of people. Some one may say that the standard of living should not be so low, but I can tell you that by the time the policy of the Fianna Fáil Government is carried through, that policy which they profess to be one of providing employment for everybody, there will be a number of these very people in a bad way.
I do want to protest against this unwarrantable raid on the Sweepstakes money. The Public Charitable Hospitals Act was passed by the Oireachtas purely for charity. Many Deputies here spoke against extending the Bill even to the county hospitals that were maintained by local taxation. They argued that a fund like that which was being raised by Sweepstakes should not be used to relieve the rates in the country. But here we have the Minister for Finance making a definite raid on this charitable fund. I think it is a most outrageous proceeding. It is a thing that they should think twice about before doing. As has been pointed out by Deputy Sir James Craig, the present Sweep is being run and for the Cesarewitch tickets are already issued all over the world. If this proposal goes through there must be some steps taken by the people running the Sweepstakes intimating to the purchasers of the tickets that the State is now taking some of the money from them that formerly went to the hospitals.
It will tell very badly for this country that we are doing such a thing, but if the Hospitals Trust do not inform the public, generally, that the State is getting some money out of these Sweepstakes, it will be a case then of their getting money under false pretences. They must tell the people of the world that these Sweepstakes are for a certain purpose. If they do not inform the subscribers that the State is taking some of this money for their own purposes they are guilty of false pretences. If an ordinary individual down the country tried that sort of thing the Attorney-General would tell him what he thought about him and he would put him in a certain place. The Government cannot do what the ordinary individual is forbidden to do. In a matter of that kind the Government has no greater moral rights than the ordinary individual. I do not wish to occupy the time of the House much longer, but I ask the Minister to reconsider the matter of the reduction of salaries and allowances. That reduction is only bringing in £250,000 a year. I also ask the Minister to reconsider the matter of the Sweepstakes.
Comment on this
There are certain parts of this Budget which are very welcome to me. If we could deal with the Budget or if we could concern ourselves only with its partial effects we might, or at least I might, welcome it. I welcome in particular the gesture which the Executive Council is making towards the relief of unemployment. I am hopeful that the Minister will be able to tell us later on that the promises which he held out to us yesterday in his Budget speech, as to the effect of his proposals upon unemployment, will be borne out. But I am afraid, viewing this Budget as a whole, that it will drive many more people out of employment than it will put into employment. Unquestionably, this Budget will provide temporary employment for a certain number of those at present unemployed. But viewing the Budget as a whole and having regard to the effect it is going to have on the country as a whole, I suggest that while it may cause a certain number of the unemployed to find temporary employment it will lead to the disemployment of many men and women who are to-day in permanent employment and who are living under decent conditions. Certainly, I have no doubt whatever that the burdens this Budget imposes will lead to the disemployment of many people who are to-day in permanent jobs.
I do not want to go over the grounds which have been covered by former speakers, and I do not want to go back too far to remind Ministers as to the promises they made with regard to the reduction in taxation. I do not want to be so unkind as to remind Ministers that the present Minister for Agriculture stated not long ago that this country could be run for twelve millions a year. We were told within the last three months that an immediate saving of at least two million pounds could be made on taxation, but we find to-day that three-and-a-half million pounds extra taxation has to be found by the people.
I want to point out that this taxation will eventually find its way back to the agricultural community and to the working classes of this country. There is no doubt whatever that if you increase the burden upon industry and upon employment it will be passed on. Merchants and manufacturers are not going to bear it themselves. To whom is it to be passed on except to the agricultural community and to the workers of the country? We have 43 new tariffs in the Budget. I would like that the Minister for Industry and Commerce would tell us who is going to benefit by the imposition of those tariffs? Who is going to benefit by the tariffs imposed within the last three weeks? A very small section of employers and possibly a number of the unemployed.
To-day the Minister informed us, in answer to a question, that as a result of the tariff imposed by the last Government upon woollens and worsteds, not only was there not an increase in the number of persons employed in that industry, but there was a decrease. The people were made to pay for that. I would like the Minister for Industry and Commerce, if he does intervene in this debate, to give us what he conceives to be the reason for that state of affairs. Perhaps he will tell the House whether he believes there was no increased employment in that industry because the tariff was not high enough? Has the Minister satisfied himself now that, as a result of the new impositions, there will be increased employment given in that particular industry? Nearly every tariff imposed will either directly or indirectly—mostly directly—hit the farmers of the country, and hit them very hard. Some of the tariffs were imposed for the purpose of collecting revenue, because there is no possible chance of some of the tariffed articles being made in this country. The Minister knows that quite well. We now find ourselves in the position that employers will probably be forced either to reduce the number or reduce the wages of their employees. The cost of living for every worker has been substantially increased, and will be further increased as a result of this Budget.
Yesterday the Minister for Finance told us that tea was a luxury. It may be a luxury for the Minister, but it certainly is not for fully 99 per cent. of the workers. Does the Minister know—if he does not I am sure the Minister for Industry and Commerce will tell him—that very large numbers of workers, and more especially those men who are at the moment unemployed and who are dependent upon outdoor relief and charity of various kinds, have nothing but bread and tea for six or seven days of the week, and they consider themselves lucky if they get meat and potatoes for one meal in each week? Does anybody suggest that tea is a luxury for those people? I am talking now of what I actually know to be a fact. Perhaps the majority of the unemployed in this country have tea and bread as their only food. I suggest it is most unfair to impose a further 4d. a lb. on tea.
Of course, we will be told that the farmers have not been forgotten and the agricultural grant is to be increased by £250,000. I am glad Deputy Corry was able to force his views on the members of the Executive Council. The farmers, in so far as they have any reason to be thankful, ought to be grateful to Deputy Corry. I read quite recently a speech made by Deputy Corry at the Cork County Council meeting. When the question of the agricultural grant came up he said "The least our Government will have to give is a million, which they moved as an amendment last year when the other Government were giving three-quarters of a million."
Comment on this
I pay Deputy Corry the tribute that he succeeded in getting the Executive Council to accept his views.
Comment on this
A million does not mean keeping promises. Full and complete de-rating was Deputy Corry's promise.
Comment on this
I would like to add my voice to the protest made regarding what has been described as the raid upon the funds allocated to the hospitals from sweepstakes. I want to put forward an aspect of the matter which has not been touched upon so far as I know. We have to remember that a considerable portion, if not the major portion, of the money received by the hospitals goes into extensions, buildings of various sorts. In several cases new hospitals were built. That gives considerable employment. We must remember also that the raid is not confined to funds belonging to hospitals in Dublin, Cork or Limerick. The raid will also be made upon the money made available for county and other hospitals under boards of health throughout the country. Whilst some of the Dublin hospitals have been lucky enough to have participated in the earlier schemes, it is only in the last sweep that the country hospitals benefited. When you take £650,000 from the hospitals' share of the sweepstakes you are taking it from the hospitals throughout the country just as well as from the hospitals in the cities. In that way, directly or indirectly, you are hitting the rates in the different counties. We will have other opportunities of discussing this Budget and going into it in more detail. I take it we will be permitted to discuss it when the Resolutions are reported and also on the Finance Bill.
Whilst I must give the Minister full credit for the gesture he is making towards the relief of unemployment, I believe the proposals contained in the Budget will lead to the disemployment of very many people who are to-day in what they regard as permanent employment.
I wish to refer to another matter in the hope of getting a statement either during the course of this debate or to-morrow. I have in mind the motion relating to unemployment which appears in the names of Deputy Anthony and myself. The President spoke for over an hour on that motion. He dealt with unemployment and referred to the steps the Government proposed to take to deal with it. The Minister for Industry and Commerce and also the Minister for Finance spoke on the matter. I do not want to go into this matter now, because it will come up for discussion again. I want to point out that there is no reference whatever in the Budget to maintenance. I agree that the Government appear to be taking every step that can be taken in the present circumstances to provide schemes which seem to them to be sound for the absorption of the unemployed. I put it to the President that when he accepts my motion—he said he was accepting it—he ought to tell us what he is going to do to maintain the unemployed until such time as they are absorbed in different schemes. I hope somebody will deal with that point.
Comment on this
Having heard Deputy Morrissey, I am tempted to intervene. I think he has a bit of a nerve to rise amongst his newfound friends and criticise this Budget. I do not know what Deputy Morrissey wants; having heard him speaking now, I am convinced that he himself does not know what he wants. He has not the faintest idea of what he wants, unless it be that he wants it to appear that he is terribly dissatisfied with the Fianna Fáil administration, so dissatisfied with it, that he can be looked upon by the members who constituted the late Government as one of themselves. He is trying to justify his place amongst his new found friends, but at the same time he wants to hold a fairly friendly place with the Fianna Fáil Government——
Comment on this
But Deputy Morrissey has no fault to find with their attempt to deal with the unemployment problem. He has no fault whatever to find with that. They have done everything that could possibly be done to provide for the unemployed, but still, of course, the Deputy could not praise them because of the position he now holds. That would not be playing the game with those who are now on the Opposition Benches. They have hopes that Fianna Fáil will—as one of them said a few days ago—get just enough rope to hang themselves. If Deputy Morrissey is basing his hopes on that, I am afraid he is making a very big mistake. If he wanted to criticise the Budget, why did he not make some suggestions as to how a better one could be introduced?
Some time ago the Deputy had a motion on the Order Paper dealing with the unemployed. Judging by his attitude since, that motion was put down without an atom of sincerity on his part. The motion asked that the Government should provide either work or maintenance for the unemployed. As soon as the Government set about doing that, the Deputy criticises them very severely. He criticises them because they put on tariffs to help to meet that situation, and to provide a sum of £5,000,000 for housing. Immediately they do that Deputy Morrissey attacks them by saying: "If you do not be careful in your efforts to give employment to the 80,000 that are unemployed, you will disemploy 4,000 or 5,000 from the petted trades in Dublin." Now the Deputy cannot have it both ways. When the Deputy's attention was drawn to the fact that £5,000,000 was to be provided by the Fianna Fáil Government for housing, he was so flabbergasted with that wonderful effort that he said: "My God, where are they going to get £5,000,000 for housing?"
Deputy Morrissey is in fairly good favour with the members of the late Government, and he knows well that during the ten years they were in office they never made an effort to find £5,000,000 for housing. They never made an effort to encourage the starting of industries here, and yet Deputy Morrissey had very little fault to find with them. During the term of office of the late Government—during the Deputy's in and out tactics, to use the language of Deputy Blythe, with the late Government—he never suggested in the strong terms he is suggesting now, that the unemployed should get any fair play; so that his attitude on this Budget is a good indication of his present position. He wants to have a foot in both camps. I do not see why the Deputy should take up the attitude that was taken up by Deputy Sir James Craig when an effort is being made by the imposition of tariffs to build up industries in the country. Deputy Morrissey was in the Labour ranks at one time. I think he should try to remain a little longer in them, and should not all of a sudden go over to the policy advocated by Deputy Sir James Craig.
Comment on this
Deputy Sir James Craig stated to-day that, as a result of this Budget, there was every danger that not only other people in this country but that even he himself might have to leave it. I am sorry if the Deputy feels that way. I am convinced that if he goes he may find it a good deal more difficult to get the British Government to employ him in England than he finds it to get employment here. I do not know what Deputy Sir James Craig is going to gain by going over to England as an unemployed man.
Comment on this
I am glad to hear it—or to Ulster either. But that, at all events, is the threat that was used, "that we must all clear out." I think a threat of that kind should not be used by any Deputy either on his own behalf or on behalf of anybody in industry in this State. At a time when an effort is being made to try to give employment to the thousands of men who are out of employment we get this statement: "We will all clear out immediately." I would remind those who have made that statement that the unemployed have been clearing out of this country on the emigrant ships during the past ten years. While that was going on why did not Deputy Sir James Craig come forward and say that he would go along with them? Unemployed men of as good brawn and bone as Deputy Sir James Craig, or any of those who have been talking in that strain, have been going out of this country for the past ten years. Therefore, let us hear no petty gibe from Deputy Sir James Craig or those occupying the benches opposite with him about clearing out. But immediately an effort is made to try and balance matters between the down-and-outs in this country and the wealthy classes, we are told that the wealthy classes will have to clear out.
Comment on this
I just want to say that when Deputy Cleary has done as much as I have for the poor of Dublin —I have been attending the poor of Dublin for 45 years for nothing—then he will have the same right to speak for them.
Comment on this
We all recognise that Deputy Sir James Craig has sacrificed himself year after year for the poor and the down and outs of Dublin, but we think that he should not throw up the sponge now. He should stay a little longer.
Comment on this
I am very glad to hear that the Deputy is not going, but he told us that he was going to clear out. I hope he will remain longer, and that he will work as hard as he has done in the past for the unemployed of Dublin. If he does I am sure he will find greater sympathy in the ranks of the new Government than he did in the case of the late Government. What I object to is the attitude that was adopted by Deputy Sir James Craig in the course of his speech. The same attitude was taken up more or less by Deputy Morrissey, and it was this: "that while you are putting on tariffs in the hope that industries will be started in the country and thousands of men given employment, there is the danger that you will injure certain vested interests here, and because you are making an attempt to do that in a big way lots of people will have to clear out and go to live in England." I object to Deputy Sir James Craig making insinuations of that kind. I do not think it is good citizenship either, and I am afraid that Deputy Morrissey is becoming affected by the same kind of restlessness.
They attack the Government because the Government are taxing the Sweeps, and one of the main reasons for the attack is because the Sweeps are a source of employment. Was that the reason? I heard Deputy Sir James Craig say that the British will object to buy Irish tickets and the chance of winning £30,000 because a certain tax is going to the Government, that money will not come across the water and a number of people now employed by the Sweeps will be disemployed. Were the Sweeps started to relieve unemployment? Deputy Morrissey made the same statement about unemployment—the Sweeps are taxed, Sweep tickets will not be purchased, and, therefore, people will be sacked from the Sweep offices.
Comment on this
I accept that, but, at least, Deputy Sir James Craig made a very clear point out of that, that the Government should not tamper with the Sweeps because by doing so the hospitals will not get so much money; that then, by the Government getting a tax out of the Sweeps, the British people will have a decided objection to buying tickets, because by doing it they are paying revenue to the Irish Free State Government.
Comment on this
That is the type of criticism that we had from the Opposition Benches this afternoon. When we were in that position we were twitted to put forward suggestions for a better way of doing things. They have not suggested a single thing since the present Government came into office. Deputy Hogan, the late Minister for Agriculture, has said "bankruptcy immediately with this new Budget." The Deputy did not prove how it was going to come about. He gave no indication of that. When Deputies get up to criticise in that way they should either show how these things are going to happen or how revenue can be raised in a better way than that outlined yesterday by the Minister for Finance. Some of them said social services are not going to be cut. We know very well that was their way of providing revenue and of balancing a Budget. If the present Minister for Finance came in and cut social services to a certain extent, if he reduced the Old Age Pensions and the Agricultural Grant to a certain extent, would Deputies opposite agree that the fairest and the best thing was being done? But the Minister did not do that. To a great extent, he is making an effort to extend social services, and in order to do that money has to be got somewhere. The Deputies opposite have not pointed out an alternative way to that of the Minister for Finance of finding the money. What then is their objection to this Budget? They objected to the cutting of salaries, but we are quite used to that attitude on their part. Their view was that high salaries had to be paid in order to get the best brains in the country. We believe that when you have a certain number of people at home, about whom Deputy Morrissey a fortnight ago was terribly anxious—80,000 of them, with nothing to fall back on— we should try and see that the burden was balanced between the rich and the poor. Any fair-minded man, who can leave out party prejudice, would have to admit that that balancing is, at least, being attempted, in a decent and very frank way by the present Minister for Finance.
We are told that industries will close down and a lot of people become disemployed because income tax is being raised. I thought that the sense of honour of the Deputies opposite, which makes them so proud of their co-equal status with Britain, would make them very proud to say that we are able to stand up and pay as much as Britain is paying in income tax. I thought they would admire that step towards co-equality. Surely, when they are so very anxious for co-equal status with Britain, they should not get it in the back-stairs method, but should try to get that status, and to be co-equal members when they are able to pay for it. You should pay for your loaf, and I think there should be a better spirit of citizenship of the Empire amongst the gentlemen opposite, and that they would say "England is paying a certain amount in income tax and we will pay as much. We are able to do it as members of the Commonwealth." I do not see why they should have such a decided objection to increasing income tax if only for that reason alone and the same could be said of other services.
The criticism of the people who speak against this Budget is not directed towards improving matters, or pointing a better way, but to an effort to create a certain atmosphere of unrest amongst the people in spite of the fact that they realise that good is going to come out of it. Deputy Hassett interjected something at an earlier stage about the land annuities. Fianna Fáil, at the last election, hoped for success, but they never thought that they would succeed in going so far as to form a Government. We have succeeded very well since. We have not only succeeded in forming a Government but in winning the support of quite a number of Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies for our case for the holding of the land annuities. Deputy Hassett wants to know how they are going to be divided immediately. We will be glad to have his assistance when the question of holding the land annuities comes up.