We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

In Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 26.

Contributions 217–433 of 433. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Yes, you told them that they would not have to pay the annuities.

Comment on this

I do not think that if the farmers of Tipperary were told that they could keep the annuities quite legally Deputy Hassett would say that they should pay them, and if further benefits can be given to the farmers after the annuities have been held, I wonder will Deputy Hassett object to these benefits because the money should not go to the farmers of Tipperary but to the British. Deputy O'Donovan has been worried for the past three weeks as to how the annuities are to be distributed when they are kept here and how they are to go back to the people, and Deputy Bennett to-day was also interested in that question. Quite a number of other Deputies of Cumann na nGaedheal were interested in the question of the returning of the annuities in the shape of grants for the past few weeks and, to-day, they are still interested in that question. Could they not possibly, as I think I suggested once before, get together and hammer out a scheme to give back the annuities and assist the Government in that way, instead of trying to criticise the mention of the annuities in this Budget?

Comment on this

If you win, we win.

Comment on this

If Deputy Gorey would try and give some little help in this matter we might be able to speak to the Minister for Agriculture about improving Deputy Gorey's methods of farming, down in Kilkenny.

I did not hear a word, since the Opposition members started criticising the Budget, about the efforts to be made by the Minister for Finance to give employment throughout the whole of the Free State, by allocating quite a large sum of money for the improvement of cul-de-sac roads. I did not hear a word being said in praise of that. That, we hope, will bring employment into country districts where there are many unemployed, and there is not a word said about it. It never happened before in a Budget, and surely Deputies on the Opposition Benches who come from country districts, should realise that it is an effort that will bring employment and incomes into many homes and that, if they have any objection to £200,000 or £300,000 being spent in country areas on local works of that kind, they should state it here. That money is being got in many ways. It has to be collected in order to be spent, and I think that they cannot suggest a better means of collecting it than the way proposed by the Minister. There was a lot of talk about the tax on tea. Anybody who goes to the trouble of discussing that particular tax with anybody in the trade, will learn that it will not impose one fraction of a penny extra on the consumer. It cannot do it.

Comment on this

Who will pay it?

Comment on this

It was not so with the tax on sugar. The poor had to pay anyhow, in the case of the tax on sugar. They had to pay it directly, without any question of doubt, and surely the present tax is a more commendable method. People in touch with the trade—and it has been discussed with them by a lot of us—are convinced that it is the better way, and that it will not be passed on to the consumer. I think that any other matter mentioned in this Budget cannot very well be ignored by the people in opposition. Surely if we had not had them for ten years, trying to bring in an as-you-were Budget every year, they might have some right to criticise suggestions we have made. Perhaps the Minister for Finance is taking very drastic steps, but has it not been stated by Cumann na nGaedheal since they came into opposition, that drastic steps are needed? The ex-Minister for Finance, speaking to-day, stated, that, if he were in office, he would bring in an as-you-were Budget again this year. What would Deputy Morrissey's unemployed do if he did that? What would the housing problem do, and what would the thousands of young men and women who cannot now emigrate do if he did that?

Comment on this

Pay 4d. on tea.

Comment on this

Deputy Blythe would not put 4d. on tea. What would they do if an as-you-were Budget were brought in?

Comment on this
Mr. Brodrick

What will they do?

Comment on this

An effort is being made to increase and expand industries. Numbers of extra men have been employed since certain tariffs were imposed, and that should bring joy to the hearts of Deputies who were interested in the unemployed. All those matters should certainly be given their proper type of criticism by the Deputies opposite. If they could not get a better way of finding money to give employment they should at least admit that the unemployment problem could not be solved. The method of attack directed at this Budget is something that we might expect from people who were ten years in office, who created unemployment, who allowed cement factories to go out, who allowed other factories to go out, who built up in certain places white elephants supposed to relieve thousands and thousands of the unemployed, who allowed the Gaeltacht to go absolutely barren despite Gaeltacht Commissions, who allowed the fishing industry to die, who allowed several industries that they could foster to go out of existence. They now come along and criticise the efforts which are being made to try to bring back again the industries that they allowed to die out, and to try to give work to the unemployed whom they allowed to starve, and whom they now pretend to be concerned about.

Comment on this

Deputy Cleary is rather misinformed as to where the money is to come from for his cul-de-sac roads, which are so conveniently being provided for in the Budget. £650,000 is being taken from the Sweepstakes for these roads. They are to come from money that would not be available at all but for the initiative of men like Deputy Sir James Craig, of whom the Deputy has so much to say in criticism. As far as the Fianna Fáil Deputies are concerned, the only vested interest to be protected is the vested interest in patriotism that that Party is supposed to have. It would be no harm in this debate if, in a different spirit from the spirit in which Deputy Cleary spoke, the classes who are being attacked, and whose confidence in this country is being almost deliberately undermined by the Budget, should be asked to have faith in themselves, to have faith in a country that went through what this country went through from 1916 down; to stand by their country, even in the very difficult circumstances for them, and for the country generally, that this Budget suggests. The monopoly of patriotism in this country is not on the Fianna Fáil Benches or behind the Fianna Fáil organisation, and very well many members of the Fianna Fáil organisation know it.

Overshadowing every detail that might be discussed in this Budget is the fact that Deputy Hogan called attention to, that this Budget is the economic counterpart of the civil war. The picture that comes before my mind when contemplating the widespread way in which taxes are being imposed in this Budget, and the appendices of policy that the Executive Council have, bearing both on the Budgetary and economic condition here, is a picture published, I think, in the beginning of 1923, both in the "Irish Independent" and the "Freeman's Journal," of the railways here and the points at which they had been broken, showing where signal boxes were dismantled, rails torn up, and bridges destroyed during the civil war. It certainly was a terrifying picture showing the way in which communications were cut during that time. In the same way, there is no part of the country that is not going to be affected detrimentally in its foundations by what is being done in this Budget.

Deputies have spoken from these and the neighbouring benches of the position as the farmer will find it. I ask Deputy Cleary, or any Deputy on the far side, to stand in imagination in some of our small towns, say a small town in Mayo, and ask himself what is this Budget going to do for that town. The Minister for Industry and Commerce might have been expected, when dealing with the matters that concern him in this Budget, to have something of the position in Dublin before his mind. We have this position in Dublin: that at the beginning of May in this year the total number of people on the live register of unemployed was 12,670, whereas last year, at the same time, the number was 7,200, or an increase of 5,470. Normally unemployment increases in the city in the winter. You reach the peak point in December and January, and then the curve falls. The highest point reached in January in the last four years has been about 10,600, and then there would be a fall. As I say, in May normally the figure is between 6,000 and 7,000. Beginning with the rise in unemployment from the date of the general election, and a further rise immediately following the election of the present Ministry, we find ourselves now in Dublin with 5,470 more people unemployed, or nearly double the unemployment in the city at this time of the year for the last four years.

I ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce what is there in this Budget which will, during the next year, the year of the emergency Budget, affect in any way that position except for the worse? Looking over the list of tariffs, we would like to know what ones are revenue tariffs and what ones contain in them any promise of creating industry here? Even if amongst those tariffed there are industries which will create employment immediately, it seems astounding that at such a time as this, when there is industrial depression all round, when our export trade with England, even in the best of circumstances, might not be what we would like it to be, the port of Dublin is attacked by these tariffs on goods, in respect of which there has been absolutely no examination, good, bad or indifferent, as to whether they are likely to be manufactured here or not. When the tariffs were about being put on, the people consulted were a small number of people directly and almost personally interested in getting tariffs. In these discussions, as far as we can find out, the distributor, who is the only type of person who could really speak for the consumer in these matters, was completely ignored. The result is that we have the chaos at the port here which is spoken about and which is quite unknown to the Front Bench opposite, and we have the difficulties of commercial people in the city having to find large credits at a moment's notice to redeem from the Customs the goods which have been waiting for them there, and which were caught by the tariffs.

We want to know from the Minister for Industry and Commerce how this Budget is going to affect Dublin City. In so far as we can see it is going to produce a very great deal of unemployment at our port. It is going to affect many people engaged in distributive occupations and it is going to affect many people employed by persons who are going to be hit by the tremendous increase in income tax and other taxes that this Budget imposes. It is a fact that many people to-day are continuing the employment of persons that they would certainly be prepared to dispense with because of financial circumstances if they did not feel that the persons whose services would be dispensed with would have nowhere to turn to for other employment. But that class of persons, and also persons normally in domestic employment, gardeners and people like that, whom normally there might be no tendency to dispense with, are hit from two sides. They are hit by the increased taxes, that is, by increased income tax as well as the effect of the customs duties. They are hit by the effect of them on their employers. The employer will also be influenced by the great parade that is made on the other side of this House as to the amount of employment that will be provided for people who are now without any employment.

The question has been asked as to how Deputy Morrissey wants the thing done; how we want the thing done. Deputy Cleary asks what the late Government did to provide work. He says they never offered £5,000,000 for housing. If the Deputy will refer to the figures made available as to the amount of additional work gradually growing as a result of the constructive financial and economic policy of the late Government, he will see in such figures as the receipts and payments in respect of unemployment insurance, where the total amount of receipts from employers and working people was £548,000 in 1923-24 and was increased to £703,000 in 1929-30, and went higher in subsequent years, marking an increase in people in employment. On the other hand, if we take the people registered in unemployment exchanges at this time of the year for some years past, we will find these facts. In May, 1923, the number was 29,000 registered. In 1924 the number was 28,700. In 1925, when there was special uncovenanted benefit given, the number was 38,000. In 1926 it was 25,000; in 1927 it was 20,000; in 1928 it was 21,000; in 1929 it was 19,000; in 1930 it was 19,800. The figures had decreased from the earlier years until we come to 1931, when the number was 24,000, and now the number is 32,944, nearly 33,000; so that the policy adopted by our Party put more people into employment on the one hand and kept less people unemployed on the other. At the same time provision was made throughout the country for payment to the able-bodied unemployed of home assistance. The policy we want pursued now is careful examination of the situation and a progressive going ahead on sound grounds. Satisfaction has been given generally by the tariffs put on by the late Government both to employers and to unemployed. Additional well-thought-out work has been given in that particular way, and only in one case—the case of boots—has there been any considerable criticism from the general public. But here we have thrown at our people, utterly unexamined, and withoutany apparent constructive minds behind it, what is called a whole new industrial policy. Just as there was, you might say, no mind behind what gave us the civil war, so as to what Deputy Hogan called the economic counterpart of it there has been no mind expressed to us here yet. It is an absolute leap in the dark, pitiless as to what the consequences to our people may be as regards unemployment or increased cost of living and with no concern for any interests outside our own country. And all this, as I say, when general world conditions are such that revenue has been falling here.

We have been told, on the one hand by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs yesterday, that we must not pride ourselves on looking too much to having an export trade. Our farmers are, as it were, told to contain themselves and not to bother about their export trade on the one hand, while on the other they are considerably taxed outside this Budget at a figure which I estimate at £1,400,000, on the ground that if farmers are as poor as they say they are, that they are not able to eat butter, and estimated by others at something like one million. That is being put on to secure an outside market for us. If there was anything that really ought to be done, if the Executive Council considered the situation was such as to warrant the bringing in of this Budget, then they ought to face up to the situation squarely. They ought to go and discuss with the British the question of disagreement with them. They ought to face up to their discussions fully and frankly and fairly. Because if we are going to have this Budget and then disagreement with the British upon certain points, and confusion and dislocation of our mutual trade with Britain, then I do not know where this Budget is going to lead us.

It was described this morning as a revolutionary Budget, but it seems to me to be a pre-revolutionary Budget, because if we are to have our external trade dislocated then there are elements of a revolution in the proposals made here, because it is a leap in the dark in regard to the cost of living and with regard to the creation of unemployment here, and a leap in the dark in inviting people in an irresponsible way to expect that the State will provide work for them. The Minister for Finance pointed out that the actual amount of taxation that is going to be taken out of the pockets of the people in addition to what was taken last year, is about £1,763,000—that is not taking account of the £1,000,000 to be borrowed for roads.

What are we getting in an emergency way out of that increased taxation? Most of the things we are getting are going to increase the demand on central funds in future. In the very serious economic circumstances in which we find ourselves to-day, we are going to do away with the means test in respect of old age pensions, and we are going to give pensions to persons whether they are maintained or not. We are told that this is going to cost something like £250,000. We are told that there is to be an increased grant of £100,000 for housing. There are to be additional free grants to local authorities for housing of £350,000. I do not know whether it is intended to have the word "housing" there because we were told by the Minister for Finance that it is for drainage, public health works and a great scheme of cul-de-sac roads. There is also £150,000 for the relief of distress, £250,000 for relief in respect of rates on agricultural holdings, and £100,000 in respect to the provision of milk for necessitous children. Out of £1,763,000 additional to be taken out of the people's pockets this year £950,000 is to be given one way and £250,000 is to be given to old age pensioners. That is £1,100,000 out of the £1,173,000. Unemployment is provided for by work on the roads.

It was pointed out by the Minister for Finance, and by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, that the cessation of building at the present time arises as a result of the effect of the last Housing Act introduced by the late Government on speculative building. Immediately after the Minister's remarks Deputy Little explained that he knew all about speculative building and that it stopped because the market for the particular type of house that speculative builders built had been saturated. He gave the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce from his personal experience the explanation I gave in connection with the last Housing Act for forcing the speculative builders away from the type of house they wanted to build by removing grants from that type of house and directing their attention to the fact that it was a lower type of house our people required. If the increased grant for housing means that speculative builders are to be assisted now to build houses that are either not wanted, or are to build houses of a fancy standard that we are not capable of keeping up, then that £100,000 may provide a certain amount of employment this year that might not otherwise be given, but it is putting back in a way that will cost us more and more money for housing the natural and right tendency that was being brought about by our last Housing Act. We are going to be in the position that while our economic circumstances are such that this terrible burden must be put on the people they are going to be induced to live in houses that are very much above the hair-shirt standard, above even the standard that our people are able to pay for. As to the additional free grants for local authorities this is to some extent the beginning— although it is only called an emergency—of the policy that Ministers, when they were on these benches, spoke about, of meeting to some extent the cost of sewerage schemes and public health services throughout the country. That is a direction in which an appetite is very easily created, and while I know that it is very necessary work it is embarking on a line of expenditure that is not going to stop when the emergency has passed.

As regards the £150,000 of a special grant for the relief of distress, that is given at a time when the country has to bear this particular Budget in order to provide cul-de-sac roads up to the houses of individual farmers, to give these roads special attention and special top dressing. There are elements either of irresponsibility or a want of thought behind these proposals. It is in keeping with the absence of mind behind the tariff policy suggested in the Budget.

Coming to the provision of milk for necessitous children we were told by the President the other day that one of the things he would like to do would be to give greater powers to local authorities. If there is anything local authorities ought to be responsible for it is relief of various kinds. Outdoor relief throughout the country comes to £600,000 and is borne by local authorities. Why local authorities cannot deal with the provision of milk for necessitous children I do not know. We have given very considerable grants towards the relief of rates during the last few years. I do not know why, in addition, local authorities should not deal directly from the rates with the provision of milk for necessitous children. If the grant is being given as part of the general school meals system in then it is being given to a system in respect of which the State already bears 50 per cent. of whatever is expended. Why this matter could not be dealt with under that scheme I do not know. At any rate there is a general increase of expenditure through local authorities and there is a relief in rates that puts local authorities practically into the position that they are going to contribute out of rates less than the State does for their work. After the grant of this £250,000 the position with regard to local authorities is likely to be something like this: The total amount of money passing through their hands will be £9,500,000, of which £1,500,000 will be got locally from rents but not as rates, leaving approximately £8,000,000. Over £4,000,000 of that will be paid from the Local Taxation Account and less than £4,000,000 by the rates. With a system such as that, where the State is contributing more than the local people pay in rates, and some other moneys to the extent of £1,500,000, which will be secured from the management of concerns, for which the State has provided the greater part of the capital, we have no indication whether there is to be any tightening up of the central control over local authorities. Over every detail in the Budget there looms the fact that cannot be emphasised too often that this is really the economic counterpart of the civil war.

Comment on this

At the opening of this debate Deputy McGilligan, Deputy O'Sullivan and Deputy Mulcahy professed themselves very anxious to get information on points arising out of the Budget.

Comment on this

I did not ask for any information.

Comment on this

The Deputy's colleagues did.

Comment on this

I have been sitting here for four hours, and I was anxious to give Deputies any information they might desire, but not one intelligent question has been put from the benches opposite. I am a man of limited patience in the best of circumstances and I do not propose to prolong my agony any longer. We have been told that this Budget represents the economic counterpart of the civil war. From one point of view that is right. We are trying to bring about what can be fairly described as an economic revolution here. We are trying to terminate the system which has been in operation, and to substitute for it a new system. We are trying to do that because the old system has failed to confer any substantial benefit on our people. We have been trying it for ten years. For ten years we have operated in this part of Ireland the economic policy which Deputy Hogan was advocating this afternoon. We have been buying in the cheapest market and selling in the dearest. We bought superphosphates and chemical manures wherever we could get them cheapest throughout the world, regardless of what we could produce in our own country. We bought furniture, woodwork and the various things enumerated in Customs Resolution No. 7 in the cheapest market. We searched the world, and if there was any part where, by mass production, sweated wages and other means, articles could be obtained more cheaply than we could produce them, we imported them.

We have concentrated, on the other hand, our entire energy, all the resources of the State and activities of the Government in selling in the British market a limited number of agricultural commodities. We are now facing the results. Deputy Mulcahy has been talking of the seriousness of the unemployment situation. Of course, it is serious. That is one of the results. It is serious despite the fact that we sent out of this country in recent years, because we could not maintain them, over 300,000 of our people. That is stopped now. The late Government was able to solve, partially, its unemployment problem by the annual emigration of 25,000 or 30,000 young people. That is ended. We have a net annual immigration now. Those 25,000 or 30,000 people who, in other years, found an outlet through the emigrant ship are remaining at home and have to be provided for at home. Is it any wonder that the figures in relation to unemployment are mounting up or that the people of this country decided that it was time to make a change? We are here to make that change. In no way has that policy succeeded. We have been discussing here a Bill designed to preserve, as a desperate measure, our creamery industry. If there was one thing upon which the late Government staked its political reputation it was on its efforts to build up the creamery industry here. They threw everything possible into their efforts to establish, maintain and develop the creamery industry. They failed. At the present time, if we were not determined to preserve it until something better can be substituted for it—to preserve it if necessary by taxing ourselves—the creamery industry could not exist upon anything like its present scale. We cannot produce and sell butter in England at the price at which butter is being sold there now. The same remark applies to quite a range of other articles. So long as we allowed the old system to operate, the old system of the open port, the old system of buying in the cheapest market and concentrating our activities on selling a limited number of perishable products in one market, we were bound to get results such as we are facing now—results which have necessitated the emergency Budget before us. We are going to change that. The criterion which is going to decide whether or not a tariff will be imposed is not the price at which the particular commodities can be bought from some mid-European country, but the price at which our people can make them. That applies to every industry set out there.

We are told that we are putting on these tariffs without examination. The late Government kept them off without examination. The late Government would not consider the question of imposing a protective duty unless somebody engaged in the industry, or proposing to engage in the industry, made application, paid a fee, briefed counsel, went to the Tariff Commission and made his case. We are reversing that. We are putting on duties wherever a prima facie case exists for the imposition of duties. We will not hesitate to modify them in any particular if we find such modification is justified. But we are reversing the system and we want Deputies to get that into their minds, because they are talking here to-day as if the Fianna Fáil Government was only some sort of repetition of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, designed to operate the same policy. That is not the case. This Government is operating a fundamentally different policy. Deputy Dillon mentioned fertilisers. They serve as an illustration of the point I want to make. It is, undoubtedly, true that we can get cheaper fertilisers from the Continent than we can make for ourselves.

Comment on this

And better.

Comment on this

That is not so. We can get fertilisers from abroad more cheaply to a slight extent. The price of fertilisers imported from Belgium or Holland is about 50/- a ton. Freight amounts to about 10/-. The price of the home-produced article is about £3. The difference is very slight. There are a thousand men engaged here in the fertiliser industry. Are we to throw these men out of employment, to have them maintained by home assistance, to deprive them of the opportunity of earning their livelihood by their own work in order that we may get cheaper fertilisers from the Continent?

Comment on this

How many farmers will be thrown out of employment?

Comment on this

We are going to put the farmers in a position where they will get their fertilisers at least as cheaply as their principal competitors in the English market can get theirs. One of the reasons which make this tariff necessary is that, the British Government having imposed a duty on foreign fertilisers, these fertilisers are being dumped here at prices at which they could not be produced here.

Comment on this

Our chief competitors are Dutch and Danish.

Comment on this

Our principal competitors in the English market are the English farmers.

Comment on this

What we want to hear about are the North African fertilisers.

Comment on this

The North African stuff is free of duty. If the Deputy reads the Resolution he will find that out. The duty only applies to fertilisers not produced in Britain or in the British Dominions.

Comment on this

North Africa is not in the British Empire.

Comment on this

Then the fertilisers from there are subject to duty. Deputy Hogan talked about our discouraging the export trade. There is no decline in our export trade. We are taking steps which the late Government never thought of to encourage our export trade. But we are not going to do what they sought to do—to make ourselves dependent on one market—if we can help it.

We are going to spread out, if we can, but even in that one market on the development of which they concentrated all their energies, we are going to do as much as and more than they did to hold our position. It is true that Deputies opposite, by their foolish speeches, have been arousing prejudice against us in certain quarters, but that will die out in time, because in due course people will find out what the speeches of Deputies opposite are really worth and will attach due weight to them. We are told that this policy, if operated, will produce unemployment which will off-set, and more than off-set, the number which we hope to put into employment. If we expend £5,000,000 on housing and put into employment on these housing schemes 10,000 people, whom are we going to disemploy? If we are going to put three or four thousand into employment in the boot factories, whom are we going to disemploy? We are going to disemploy some undoubtedly. Deputy Hogan said that we are going to disemploy three for every one that we put into work. That is sheer nonsense. Even if we wanted to do it we could not do it. We are going to cause a certain amount of dislocation undoubtedly. I met a couple of days ago a deputation representative of commercial travellers who are losing their employment. I am very sorry for them and I am anxious to do everything I can to ameliorate the hardships they have to undergo. I am using the machinery of my Department, as far as I can to find them alternative work, but we are not going to modify our policy or deprive this country of a chance of developing because a few individuals here and there are likely to be inconvenienced or upset by it. We are trying to make it easier for them, but the change must take place now, because if it does not take place now, a year, two years, or five years hence may be too late. I am not sure that this change has not started too late.

Deputy Hogan said that in eight months' time we shall find out whether our policy has been a success or not.

I am prepared to accept that. I am prepared to back that policy, and if at the end of that period there are not more people in employment, there are not more industries in the country, there is not greater productivity, and there are not better conditions all round, then I am prepared to admit that this policy is not a success. Eight months is not a long period to undo the damage of one hundred years, but I am prepared to accept it as a test of this policy. I hope particularly that Deputy Morrissey, who has been parading his concern for the unemployed in this House for the past three or four weeks, will give it that eight months' trial. I was listening to him, and I asked him if he was prepared to suggest one single thing that could be done which would assist in easing unemployment, and he said that was the Government's job.

Our policy has been set out before you. We are only in office for two months, and that is as far as we have been able to get. There are some notable omissions from that programme, and I am prepared to say that there are more people, upon reading the Customs Schedule, disappointed because of omissions from it than there are people disconcerted because of anything included in it.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister has met them, because I have not.

Comment on this

I have met them.

Comment on this

I have met a lot of the other kind.

Comment on this

I want Deputy Morrissey, Deputy Anthony and those associated with them to bear in mind that that policy stands as a whole. Deputy Morrissey says that he is prepared to stand for some parts of it. He approves fully of the expenditure for the relief of unemployment, but he does not approve of the other side of the Budget.

Comment on this

What about the tax on tea? Deputy Morrissey referred to the tax on tea.

Comment on this

He referred to more than the tax on tea. I would like to say a few words about that. The tax on tea is put into the Budget for no other reason than to enable us to take the tax off sugar. It does not really affect the Budget. I ask Deputy Morrissey, Deputy Anthony or any other Deputy if he had a choice whether he would put a tax on tea or upon sugar? As far as the Budget is concerned it does not make any difference. It is not imposed in order to gain revenue, but it is put on to enable us to take the tax off sugar. If we are to decide, we have to bear in mind the various aspects of the question, the fact that in the first place the price of tea was never lower than it is now and that there are different qualities of tea, that owing to the process of blending no one is ever certain of the quality of tea he is getting. The only way by which the average housewife decides between one quality of tea and another is the price. Deputies must also consider that tea has a very low food value. It is not really a necessity of life, though a number of people live largely on it. On the other hand, sugar is a foodstuff which has a very high food value, and it has only one quality. It is particularly a foodstuff for children. Taking all these factors into consideration, ask yourselves if it were left to you to decide: "Would I put 4d. per lb. on tea or 4/8 per stone on sugar?"

We have various statements made to the effect that we are increasing taxation by 3½ million pounds. We are not doing anything of the kind. If Deputies will take the sheet which has been distributed amongst them, and look at the normal and abnormal sides of the Budget, they will see upon the expenditure side of the normal Budget an expenditure for Central Fund services and Supply services of £26,794,000. These are the estimates prepared by the late Government. If there had been no general election and no change and if Deputy Blythe were sitting on this side of the House, he would ask the House to meet an expenditure of £26,794,000. That would be his Budget. We are only adding one item to that— £270,000 additional provision for old-age pensions. We are deducting from it: Reductions in the salaries in the public service £250,000, and in administrative economies £100,000. Would Deputy Blythe have effected these economies? We are told that we promised that we would reduce taxation by £2,000,000. We are going to do it. It is not possible to do it this year, but we have made a start.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

And it will be done. New taxes have been imposed. These new taxes have been imposed mainly to meet the decline in the old taxes. We are not taking more from the people to meet normal expenditure. We have had to change the rate in tax and impose new taxes, but the amount that the people are being asked to pay to meet normal expenditure is probably less than they would have been asked to pay if the general election had not taken place. There is an emergency Budget, and it is in reference to that the increases take place. These increases are of a special nature. These is the bringing in of the hospital share of the sweepstake and making it the subject of income tax, and there is a special collection of income tax arrears. These are the two main items, and the entire amount of money secured by these means, plus another million pounds to be borrowed on the security of the Road Fund, is going to be used as set out on the other side, namely, for the provision of houses and for the relief of unemployment.

I am trying to get Deputies to face up to realities. Deputy Shaw and others have been talking about the manner in which these tariffs are being deplored by constituents of theirs. Deputy Shaw cannot have gone very far from his centre of activities in Mullingar. Let him go across to Athlone. Let him go into the woollen mills there to which we gave additional protection. There are 120, or 130 people now employed there who two weeks ago were idle, signing on at the Labour Exchange, most of them unable to draw benefit because they had exhausted their right to it. The unemployment in Athlone two weeks ago was worse than in any town in Ireland, worse in this respect that those unemployed had been unemployed for a longer period than elsewhere. We have had these figures in regard to unemployment analysed, and we find that an average of about 60 per cent. of the unemployed are unemployed for less than eight weeks at a time and that 40 per cent. are unemployed on the average for more than eight weeks. In Athlone, however, 60 per cent. were unemployed for more than eight weeks. That situation does not prevail now, and it does not prevail as regards a number of other towns.

Comment on this

What about Galway Woollen Mills?

Comment on this

The Galway Woollen Mills were closed down. Does the Deputy know why they were closed down? I do not want to make any promises, but I see no reason why these mills should not re-open in the near future.

I had a query addressed to me concerning the tariff on woollen cloth which I might as well deal with now. I think it was Deputy Morrissey who referred to the fact that no increase in employment had been effected as a result of the tariff imposed by the late Government. An increase in employment did take place, but there was subsequently a decline because the tariff was so framed that it could be easily evaded. The tariff was limited to cloth costing more than 2/- per yard, and outside firms were able to invoice their cloth in such a way that no matter what the Revenue Commissioners did it was almost impossible to prevent the tariff being evaded. As a matter of fact imports of this type of cloth increased after the tariff was imposed, and the protection given to the woollen mills was negatived. The woollen mills have now got the protection that they ought to have got three or four years ago and they are developing. There may be a certain dislocation with regard to certain grades of cloth which they are not able to make at the moment, but which they are setting out to make.

Deputies will remember that when the tariff was originally imposed the exemption limit was 1/6. When it was originally imposed there were some of the mills, at any rate, which equipped themselves to make this cheap type of cloth. They had hardly started making it when Deputy Blythe came along and lifted the limit to 2/6. In one case they bankrupted a man who had invested his life savings in the industry in order to make that cheap cloth. In another case they shut down a mill, which has since reopened, though it is struggling against adverse circumstances. That is why I say that once you put on a tariff you must give it a fair trial because you will not get people to risk their capital and their savings in these undertakings unless you give them some guarantee of security. That is why I say the tariffs we are imposing will stay on as long as I can keep them on unless a very exceptional case is made for their modification.

Comment on this
A Deputy

What is the length of that guarantee?

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy has been quoting figures from the live register. I do not want to deny that unemployment is serious. Deputy Mulcahy is mistaken in quoting these figures when he is trying to make points against Fianna Fáil. These figures are the justification for our emergency Budget.

There has been, as far as the information goes, no worsening of unemployment during the past two months. The number of registered unemployed has undoubtedly increased. It has been increased very largely by my own efforts. There is not a day in the week that I am not asking deputations from trades unions or deputations speaking for the unemployed to make sure that all these workers are registered. We want to make the Exchanges a really effective instrument for getting unemployed workers in touch with employers seeking workers. We are getting people on the register who never contemplated registration at the Exchanges before. We are being helped in our efforts to that end because of the fact that a considerable amount of employment is anticipated in Dublin in connection with the Eucharistic Congress, because of other announcements which have appeared in the Press concerning the employment likely to be available in different places and because we are setting out to ensure in every department and every sphere of activity which we can influence that people are going to be recruited through the Labour Exchanges if we can secure it.

The situation in Dublin, of course, has, to some extent, been influenced by various factors. One is the cessation of building. We need not argue at the moment what was the reason for the cessation of speculative building in Dublin during the past month or two. It may be due, as has been stated, to the Housing Act recently passed by the late Government. However, it may be due to other causes. There it is, but it is going to end now. We have provided there £100,000 to increase the grants available to secure that speculative builders will restart their activities. Another matter referred to is that there has been short time work in some of our factories subject to duties consequent on the forestalling that took place. Deputy Mulcahy talked of the chaos at the ports. The only chaos that I know of is this, that every shed, every ship, every dock, and everything associated with the ports was loaded up with goods brought in here in an attempt to forestall duties that might be imposed. In respect of some of the goods which are now being made the subject of duties, these duties will not bear fruit in increased employment for a long time on account of the forestalling.

Some Deputies asked me about firms in financial difficulties because they were required to pay duty. I know of such cases, but these were firms who deliberately put themselves into that position. The firms engaged in a gamble. They gambled on being able to beat the tariff, entered into large commitments, and ordered large stocks. The tariff was put on before they could get delivery, and now they are in the position that they have to pay large sums in duty. We are not anxious to see any firms in difficulties, but I must remind Deputies that these firms did that despite a definite public warning issued by the Executive Council that any attempt at forestalling would be met by emergency duties.

Comment on this

Might I remind the Minister that the point which Deputy Minch made was that in the interregnum between the time that the tariff was put on and the time that supplies of home-made ladies' apparel would be available, retailers would have to pay spot cash for the duty on imported ladies' apparel instead of the deferred terms usually allowed on the purchase of merchandise?

Comment on this

That is a different problem. That is a problem of short-term industrial credit to which attention is being given. A large number of points in relation to some of these duties were raised by different Deputies, and I would like to deal with them. Before dealing with them there is one other aspect of the general question to which I should like to refer. Deputy Mulcahy talked about persons whose confidence in the country has been undermined by the Budget. If there are any such persons, I have never met them. I have been astonished by the fact that there are very large numbers of persons who now, for the first time, are apparently willing to realise upon their foreign holdings and bring their capital here for investment in Irish industries. There is no scarcity of capital to finance our industrial campaign. During the past week or fortnight I think it is no exaggeration to say that on the average five English firms a day came to my Department to ascertain the views of the Department concerning their starting factories here. We had announced our intention to bring into operation certain legislation, which in our opinion circumstances justified, that no new firms could come in and engage in industries here without our consent or permission.

That was to secure that those who put their money into Irish industries would be protected against highly-capitalised foreign combines coming in here and swamping them. We have to give that internal protection in addition to the tariffs.

In consequence of the announcement concerning that legislation every foreign firm that contemplated coming here approached the Department of Industry and Commerce first to make sure of its welcome. Some of them were told definitely by us that there was no room for them. Some of them were welcomed. Some of them are preparing modified schemes which will possibly meet with our approval. In a large number of industries there is very good reason to believe that those who know most about them, those who have been supplying our market for a long time from abroad, have not got that lack of confidence that Deputy Mulcahy has talked about. They are prepared to come in here and build factories and engage in production and secure the profits which successful industry in Ireland will produce. My only concern is to secure that we will not have to rely unduly upon foreign capital to get industrial development pushed along now. We are anxious to give all the preference we can to native capital and we will give it. I am glad to say that native capital is forthcoming in adequate quantities.

We have been told that there has been no examination of these tariffs. That is wrong. Careful examination was given to the various applications for tariffs that came before us. Where special difficulties appeared and it was not possible to have these difficulties examined in detail, the applications were put aside for later consideration. We are prepared to stand over every tariff that is set out in this schedule. But we are not unreasonable. We are not like the members of the late Government who, when they produced a Bill in the House, refused to alter a comma of it. If any Deputy thinks that a minor modification of any of these duties would help rather than impede industrial development, let him make his suggestion here or otherwise and undoubtedly it will receive very careful consideration.

On various minor points that have been mentioned I want to make two or three things clear. Deputy Dillon referred to blankets. Irish manufacturers have been making all grades of blankets except the low grade shoddy. The tariffs we are imposing are not new tariffs but an increase in the existing tariffs. The Revenue Commissioners have interpreted the old tariff so as to exempt cotton blankets from duty and these blankets will remain exempt. From time to time the blanket manufacturers have had to meet unfair competition, competition in the form of price cutting by their competitors. It was to meet that competition that they asked for an increase in the duty to 25 per cent. We, as the Deputies will see, are proposing to increase the duty to only 20 per cent. in the case of British goods, with a 30 per cent. maximum rate.

There is the matter of artificial manures. There are seven firms engaged in this industry, and they are scattered over the country. Consequently, they are well situated for supplying the farmers. There is one firm with a branch factory in London-derry and it supplies Donegal. As the duty has not been imposed upon British products, it is still in a position to supply Donegal. There are, on an average, about 1,000 workers engaged in the industry. It is not an industry that operates all the year round. There are slack and busy periods. The existing concerns are quite competent to supply all the requirements in the class of manures that are subject to duty.

Comment on this

Are there many of the 1,000 persons skilled workers?

Comment on this

I am afraid I could not tell the Deputy. Deputy Bennett referred to the duty on wire, and spoke of it as a tax on wire. That is nonsense. Articles subject to duty are capable of being made and supplied in this country. Any of the articles of wire manufacture which we are not capable of supplying are excluded. For a long time I considered whether we could not bring barbed wire subject to the duty. Existing manufacturers here claim to be able to meet all our requirements in the barbed wire way. However, we decided to exclude it until the matter could get further examination. It is not likely that a duty will be imposed on it for some considerable time to come.

Deputy Dockrell wishes to know what is the meaning of the term "accessories of photographic apparatus." The word "accessory" means something in connection with but separate from the article itself. I may tell the Deputy that the application of the term will not cause any administrative difficulty. Photographic apparatus imported by a person making a temporary stay in the country will be admitted free in accordance with the established practice. Small supplies imported by temporary tourists will be allowed in free.

Comment on this

There is the term "sensitised material." Does that come under the head of "accessories" and photographic plates?

Comment on this

If the Deputy will read the Resolution he will see that the duty applies to photographic apparatus and the component parts and accessories thereof. A roll of film is subject to duty.

Comment on this

Does the term "accessories" cover "sensitised material" which is not made here?

Comment on this

Yes, it does. That is mainly a revenue duty.

Comment on this

It is not included even in the British taxes?

Comment on this

There is a protective duty on photographic prints, a duty of thirty-three and one-third per cent.

Comment on this

That is different. I am talking of the material on which photographs are actually taken. That is excluded from the British tax.

Comment on this

I have explained that it is mainly a revenue tax.

Comment on this

It will destroy the whole thing.

Comment on this

It is only 10 per cent.

Comment on this

That does not matter.

Comment on this

Will the Minister consider having a schedule of accessories?

Comment on this

That can be provided, but the Revenue Commissioners do not consider that there will be any difficulty in administering that duty.

Comment on this

What is the point in taxing photographic prints? These are very important for research work.

Comment on this

The practice has grown up of some photographers having a studio here. They take photographs and send the negatives to England. They are printed and mounted in England and come back here. There has been a substantial loss of employment in this country in consequence, and we decided to stop that.

Comment on this

What would you purport to do with the photographs of Irish manuscripts abroad? This is a very heavy tax.

Comment on this

Would you say it only applies to portraits?

Comment on this

We have difficulties in that direction. We decided to limit the duty to photographs of not less than 25 square inches so that it would exclude the average snapshots taken by a tourist who would bring in his prints here.

Comment on this

Could you not limit it to a portrait?

Comment on this

We can consider that when we come to the next stage. The design is to secure that this practice of having photographers open a studio here and having the work of printing and mounting done in England shall not continue.

Comment on this

The point that I have submitted to the Minister is, in my opinion, a rather important one, particularly from the point of view of scholars, because it has a bearing upon educational matters.

Comment on this

That particular matter could be considered.

Comment on this

The same thing would apply to photographs connected with scientific work—plates. That is why I raised the point.

Comment on this

We will have these points dealt with at a later stage.

There is another matter to which I would like to refer, and I want to take this opportunity of dealing with it. During last week a duty was imposed upon motor bodies. We imposed that duty at the rate and in the manner in which we did impose it so that we would get all concerned to realise quickly that we were determined to secure for this country what exists in every other country except this, and that is a motor body building industry. Since then, in consequence of various discussions that have taken place, I am now satisfied that we are going to secure the fullest co-operation from all parties in having that industry established here in the shortest possible space of time.

In consequence of representations made and the delay that necessarily must take place in order to have the industry put upon a permanent basis, and in view of the depressed condition that exists at the moment, it is intended to facilitate the motor importers by reducing the duty upon the chassis. When the chassis is imported as part of a completed new car designed for the conveyance of passengers—not an omnibus—the duty will be 15 per cent. with a preferential rate of 10 per cent. That will not lessen the degree of protection which we have given to the coach-building industry. It will not lessen the inducement, which has already borne fruit, offered to certain motor manufacturers to have bodies built in this country. It will meet the special difficulty of the motor importers during the next two months. The concession will operate only for three months. At the end of that time it is hoped that there will be no car offered for sale in this country that will not have an Irish-built body.

I do not want to be misunderstood. The industry here at the moment is in a position to start building those bodies at competitive prices at the rate of from 75 to 100 per week, any statement to the contrary notwithstanding. Certain negotiations must be entered into and certain discussions must take place; contracts must be arranged between builders and manufacturers. It is to give time for those arrangements and discussions that the modification which we have decided upon will be put into operation.

Comment on this

What about the duty on the chassis?

Comment on this

The duty on the chassis is not being changed. In that connection I want to clear up some points that may be misunderstood. The duty upon parts of bodies will be removed entirely. At the present time these parts, like the entire bodies, are subject to a duty of 33 1-3 per cent., with a preferential rate of 22 2-9 per cent. That duty has operated here since the establishment of the Free State. We increased the duty upon the completed body, but we propose to take the duty off the unassembled parts. We could not remove it by a provisional order, but it will be removed by a special resolution which will be submitted to the Dáil in the near future.

The duty which we are imposing upon mineral oils of various classes does not apply to motor lubricating oil. Some doubts appear to have arisen on that point. If any Deputy wishes to have information concerning matters arising out of the Schedule, I will endeavour to procure it for him and present it when the discussion is resumed on the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

I must confess that I am rather confused about the duty on the chassis and the other parts of motor cars. I cannot at the moment quite make out what it is the Minister has taken the duty off.

Comment on this

By reducing the duty on the chassis we permit the importation of the completed car at only a slightly higher rate of duty than would have been charged if it were imported before the change in the body duty took place.

Comment on this

Has the Minister reduced the duty on the chassis?

Comment on this

Not yet, but we propose to do it as soon as the necessary resolution is prepared.

Comment on this

Will steel-stamped bodies be allowed in?

Comment on this

Steel parts will be free.

Comment on this

Could the Minister give me some information about number 34 in the Schedule—"Manufactured articles which are made wholly or mainly of brass, tin, or lead...."? That apparently will cover most scientific instruments used for research, educational purposes, and the like. Is it the intention to abrogate the present privileges given to such?

Comment on this

I can have that point looked into. So far as lead and tin are concerned, there is practically no import. The import of tin is very small. So far as brass is concerned, the object is, by the imposition of a small duty, to revive the brass founding industry here. If the Deputy is prepared to propose any modification of that resolution it can be considered at another stage.

Comment on this

Will the Minister include brass castings connected with machinery which is otherwise not dutiable?

Comment on this

I will have to have that considered. The desire, as I have said, is to give that small measure of protection as a first stage towards the revival of an industry that once gave very considerable employment in Dublin and elsewhere through the country. It is an industry which has declined very rapidly in recent years. I would be very slow to modify the duty in the slightest if that tended to weaken its effect. That would not apply in the case mentioned by Deputy Thrift. At the moment the industry's main output would be in relation to special parts and castings. Consequently to remove protection in that case would be to weaken the protective effect of the resolution.

Comment on this

I take it that does not apply to brass parts which are component parts of such things as electric motors?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy mean imported as part of the motor?

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

That is the type of work that at the moment might not be very well done in this country, because, as a rule, the brass fittings are made to a standard size and pattern. Would those come under the heading mentioned by the Minister?

Comment on this

Yes—all articles wholly or mainly of brass will be subject to the 10 per cent. duty.

Comment on this

In the case of old-established firms which branch out into new industry, will they be allowed a tax concession on new capital which they may employ, or will they have to form subsidiary companies?

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance will probably deal with that matter.

Comment on this

I will refer the Minister to Financial Resolution No. 11, Section 5. That sets out that whenever the Revenue Commissioners are satisfied that any cinematograph film imported is of an educational character they shall exempt such film from the duty ordinarily charged on cinematograph films. Is there a disposition to allow in films of importance to surgeons, and in respect of which a rent has to be paid? If delay took place in the release of those films it might be considered almost as cheap to pay the tax as to have to wait for some time for its release. Will the Minister inquire into that matter?

Comment on this

Are not the terms of the Resolution quite clear to the Deputy?

Comment on this

The section in question reads:—

"... whenever the Revenue Commissioners are satisfied that any cinematograph film imported into Saorstát Eireann is of an educational character, they shall, subject to compliance with such conditions as they think fit to impose, exempt such film from the duty on cinematograph film mentioned in this Resolution."

Comment on this

My first point is that a film may be of an educational character and may be very important to surgeons because of its educational character. The second point has relation to the conditions which may be specified. The conditions deal with the rental to which such films are liable—and that rental is considerable. Those might tend to overbalance the other advantage.

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy does not want the Government to change now a system which has been in operation under his own Government for years and, apparently, has been found quite satisfactory by the Deputy up to this moment?

Comment on this

I have been informed since I went out of office——

Comment on this
Mr. Brady

The Deputy is learning.

Comment on this

That is what the Deputy who has spoken will never be able to do—it is beyond him.

Comment on this
Mr. Brady

That system was in vogue under your own leadership.

Comment on this

It is beyond the Deputy to learn. May I ask whether, in view of what I have stated, that the rental that is charged in the event of a delay may overbalance the cost of the duty, that some more expert method of dealing with it might be devised? It might be very necessary to get it almost at once. In special cases it might be wanted at very short notice.

Comment on this

Do I understand the Deputy to ask that this Government will remove the disabilities which he imposed on these people without having the question examined? It took him ten years to realise that these existed.

Comment on this

I did not look to find it out. I have been informed of it, as I told the Minister, since I went out of office. I am asking will it be inquired into.

Comment on this

I promise the Deputy that it will, and everything will be done to meet the case of these people.

Comment on this

Arising out of Reference No. 16 in the Schedule to the seventh Resolution, dealing with the duty on printing, would the Minister be prepared to exclude from that the case of a certain journal or journals, the inside of which—just a few pages— is printed in England? I am referring to certain parochial journals which are printed in Cork, Dublin, and in other centres. They are composed principally of parochial news. The printing of them gives a good deal of employment. I understand that the printer's bill in Cork last year was about £350. The method in operation is the only economic one of bringing out certain of these magazines. I would be glad to hear what the Minister has to say on this.

Comment on this

The point referred to by the Deputy can be looked into. I do not know what magazine he has in mind.

Comment on this

I would like to know what steps the Minister intends to take to amend the Provisional Order with regard to motor vehicles so that motor vehicles at present at the ports can be cleared under the new regulations.

Comment on this

There will be no change at all in the duties imposed by the Provisional Order, but a separate Resolution amending the existing law with relation to the duty on the chassis will be brought in for the consideration of the Dáil.

Comment on this

Could the Minister say when? Will that not affect the complete vehicles that are at the ports waiting to be cleared?

Comment on this

Could the Minister give any indication as to when that Resolution will be introduced to the House? I would point out to him that there are a great many vehicles held up at the moment.

Comment on this

That is not a matter for me, unfortunately. I am trying to get the Resolution prepared and drafted immediately and to arrange for its introduction and passing.

Comment on this

The Minister said that there were seven firms engaged in the manufacture of artificial manures. Is he able to say if these are all independent firms?

Comment on this

No, not all, certainly.

Comment on this

I want to put two questions, if I may, to the Minister for Finance. It is a very good quality in a Minister for Finance to be pessimistic, but I am wondering whether he did not make our flesh creep rather unnecessarily on the subject of the departure of Great Britain from the gold standard and its effect on our national balance sheet. The Minister referred to the depreciation in the value of our national assets resulting from that departure. I am wondering whether there is some stupidity on my part or whether he neglected two considerations. One is that as the pound sterling remains the basis of our currency and has kept up its internal purchasing power, the depreciation in the value of our assets would seem to be purely theoretical. The other consideration that he seems to have forgotten is that if our assets had been diminished by the departure of Great Britain from the gold standard, our sterling liabilities would have been proportionately diminished. I find no allusion to that in the statement that the Minister made to the House. The other question I want to ask him is: Why, from the scope of his economies, he should have excluded us politicians. I quite realise that politics ought not to be a reserved enclosure for the rich, but it seems to me, all things considered, that some reduction could have been made in the allowance to Deputies, taking into account the amount of time that we sit in the course of the year and the fact that it is perfectly practicable for any of us to have a business and earn money outside this House. What I say about the Dáil applies more strongly to the Seanad. It seems to me that a very substantial reduction could be made in the allowance to Senators, and that those gentlemen might very well give the amount of time that is demanded from them to the service of their country for a smaller remuneration than they receive at present. We have got to remember that, in both cases, we receive first-class travelling expenses. That has got to be taken into account as well as the allowance or salary.

About the Budget in general, I only I propose to say a few words. My feelings with regard to it are mixed. It always seems to me that there are only two problems in this country that really matter. One is partition and the other is poverty, and I am always inclined to resent anything that distracts us from those two problems. I would like to see the minds of the people of the country concentrated on them as much as possible, and in so far as this Budget can be regarded as an earnest, chivalrous attempt to overcome the ogre of poverty, my sympathies go with the Government. I only hope that the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance are right in their predictions of everything blossoming like a rose in a year or two as a result of their policy. Unfortunately these predictions carry my mind back to the 1909 Budget of Mr. Lloyd George, when he talked about rare and refreshing fruit, and I cannot help being discouraged by the result of his prophecies and how little the events that followed bore out what he then forecast. I think it ought to be realised that the ideas which are behind this Budget are not in any way original; that the Budget is based on ideas taken from two schools of economic thought, both of which I believe to be profoundly mistaken. These schools are the school of economic nationalism and the school which believes that money is better employed in the hands of a Government than in the hands of a private citizen. I fought the last election largely on economy and roundly attacked the Cumann na nGaedheal Government for having been extravagant. I hope that the extra expenditure that we see provided for in this Budget is really going to be only emergency expenditure and that the Fianna Fáil Party are sooner or later going to show that they meant what they said when they advocated real economy and bringing our public expenditure into line with our resources.

I believe, rightly or wrongly, that an enormous part of the poverty and unemployment that this country, and almost every country in the world, is struggling with, has been due to Governmental extravagance, and to the fact that money is not left in the hands of the people who earn it. I believe that employment can only be effectively secured by the private citizens throughout the country being in a position to give employment, and to give employment in the most fruitful and useful way. I hope, therefore, that while it is evident that the Fianna Fáil Party is tied to economic nationalism, which, I believe, has also been a failure, they are not tied permanently to the principle that the Government should do as much as possible in the way of collecting money from the private citizen, and spending it, instead of the private citizen spending it.

Comment on this

We have listened to the Minister for Industry and Commerce on this great Budget which has been introduced. We expected to hear great things from the Minister for Industry and Commerce. We expected to hear a rosy picture of the prospects of industry and industrialisation generally throughout the country. I listened carefully to the speech he made, and I noted the kernel of his speech. The three statements that stand out predominantly in that whole speech amounted to little or nothing. The first statement he made was— and it was a most important statement, so far as the new Government is concerned—that they have not yet succeeded in reducing expenditure by two million pounds. The second statement was that there are 130 extra hands in employment in Athlone; and the third statement was that there is a promise of the reassembly of the motor industry in the Saorstát. That is very small fruit for the heavy imposts which the taxpayer of this country is called on to bear in this Budget. For those 130 hands that have been employed—fresh hands, I presume—in Athlone, might I remind the Minister for Finance that, in Dublin alone, in one firm employing 3,000 hands, the employees are working half-time; that is, 1,500 are working one week, and 1,500 the next, so that if we put the gains against the losses, so far as this great policy for the rehabilitation of the country is concerned, the gains look very small. All the 22 hands employed by one firm alone in Abbey Street have been completely disemployed.

The President, when speaking in this House a short time ago, made it perfectly clear that it was his policy to take the greatest care that in endeavouring to solve the problem of unemployment, he would not solve it in such a way as to create fresh unemployment. So far as we can see, the Budget introduced has not created fresh employment, but has really caused an increase in disemployment. If there was one thing for which the Fianna Fáil Party was returned to power in the recent election, it was the distinct and definite promise of economy. It was upon definite and distinct promises of reduction of expenditure. I have here a quotation made by the Minister for Finance as follows:—

If we want money for our social programme, we shall endeavour to secure it by ruthlessly cutting down wasteful and unproductive expenditure. We will rely on economies rather than taxation. Economy before taxation is our watchword. That is a sound principle for the people. The country cannot bear any further increase in the burdens that are already crippling our trade and industry.

Might I ask the Minister for Finance how he has carried out that very definite and precise pledge? What burden will be placed on industry by this Budget beyond the burden that was placed on industry before the Budget was introduced? How has he carried out the gospel of economy he and his Party have preached throughout the country for the past four years? He and his Party told the country, emphatically and distinctly, that the expenditure incurred by the late Government was far in excess of the resources of the country; that the burden of taxation must be reduced, and that taxation must bear a relation to national income. What relation does the burden of taxation imposed in this Budget bear to the national income of the country? We were told:—

There must be a reduction of expenditure. The expenditure of the recent Government was on an Imperial scale. It was beyond the resources of a small country.

The expenditure to which he referred amounted to £21,416,000, and the expenditure that this House is now asked to pass under this Budget amounts to something like £27,000,000 sterling. I want to ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce how he squares those statements of his Party with the policy that is framed in the Budget introduced to this House. Not alone did his Party make those statements, but they went a great deal further. The Minister for Lands and Fisheries stated in 1928 that the taxable capacity of the country, for Twenty-Six Counties, amounted to £12,085,000, and we are asked in this Budget to find some £27,000,000 sterling. How will the country bear it? Can the country bear it? Can the country possibly or humanly survive, under a burden of that nature? An expenditure of £21,416,000 was extravagant when this Party was in office. £27,000,000 is not an extravagant expenditure when the new Government takes up office. We were told, when they were in opposition, that an expenditure of £21,416,000 could only lead to national bankruptcy. What will an expenditure of £27,000,000 lead to? We were told also that the national revenue under an impost of £21,000,000 odd was steadily falling, and this House is now asked to pass a Budget, £6,000,000 in excess of the Budget which the Minister for Finance and his Party told the country could only lead to the national bankruptcy of this State.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce, who has just sat down, also pinned his faith to a somewhat similar doctrine. "If we estimate," said the Minister, "that taxation in England has a fair relationship to the taxable income of this country, then the amount we can afford to spend, on the basis taken by the Minister for Finance, is only £12,000,000." That, said the Minister for Industry and Commerce, is the outside amount that we can afford to spend on the machinery of government. The cost of government is double what it should be, and double, in relation to the taxable capacity of the country, what it actually is in England. What justification, in view of the statements on the records of this House, made by the various members of the new Government, is there for the introduction of a £27,000,000 Budget, and what effect will it have on the economic and national progress of the country? Were these promises made purely for election purposes? Were they made purely to deceive the country? Were they made simply for the sake of getting into office? And is every promise that Fianna Fáil has made in the recent elections, and for the past four years, to be broken, and broken in the flippant way of the Minister for Finance who, in introducing this Budget to the House, looked around, with beaming countenance, from which one would almost imagine that he was conferring a favour on the people of the Irish Free State rather than leading them to where he is undoubtedly leading them, to the bog of bankruptcy?

The Minister for Finance in the late Government put his finger on the kernel of the whole trouble so far as the taxation of any country is concerned. He pointed out to the Minister for Finance that the revenue of the country was drying up. The Minister, in introducing his Budget, referred most emphatically to that fact. In face of the declining revenue, or the drying up of the revenue, of the country, is this a fit and proper time to embark upon an increase of the social services? Where is the money to be found for it? We are told that £5,000,000 is going to be found for housing. Let them first find the £5,000,000 before they talk about having £5,000,000 for the building of houses. £5,000,000 is going to be found for a housing scheme—an uneconomic housing scheme. We were told by the Minister for Finance that it was the intention of the Government to build a cheaper type of house for the artisans of this country.

Nobody would be more in agreement with that plan, if that plan were feasible, than I. We, on this side of the House, particularly myself, being one of the representatives of the City of Dublin, pointed out to the late Government the need for cheaper houses the rent of which the ordinary working man could pay. The people of the country will be asked to find a loan of £5,000,000. For what? For the building of houses the normal rent of which, owing to the cost of building, would be something like 8/- or 12/- and these houses are to be let at 6/- and 4/-. Let us look at the thing purely from the business point of view. Is there any man with any capital in this country prepared to put capital into an uneconomic scheme of housing such as that suggested by the Minister? I fail to see where the loan will mature. I have my doubts whether it will ever mature.

Comment on this

There are more things in heaven and earth than are dreamt of in the Deputy's philosophy.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I am afraid this scheme will be like some of the schemes for the solution of unemployment that the Minister for Industry and Commerce told us were on the long finger. I am afraid this £5,000,000 loan, about which the Minister talks so glibly, will be very difficult to raise in the circumstances he has forecasted. I cannot understand how the Government have the hardihood, in face of their election promises, to come to the House in the present depressed condition of the important industry of agriculture, and the other industries in the country, and ask this State to bear a burden of £27,000,000. The Minister for Education, dealing with the expenditure of the late Government, stated: "Capable economists have proved that, while the present rate of taxation is going on, there is a steady drain not alone on the capital reserve of the country, which is slowly being eaten up, but also on the subsistence allowance of the Irish people." That statement was made in reference to a £21,000,000 Budget. What is going to happen the capital reserve of the country with a £27,000,000 Budget?

What is going to happen to the subsistence allowance of the people under this £27,000,000 Budget, with its burden of an increased cost of living, its burden on clothing and the necessaries of life, such as tea? Owing to the tariff imposed upon the very shovel which the workman uses in the street it will cost an extra shilling. There is an increase imposed upon almost everything that a workman needs to earn his bread.

I suggest that this Budget means not the conservation, but the annihilation of capital; that it means the complete elimination of the subsistence allowance of the Irish people. That subsistence allowance in these difficult times is small enough, but how will the people manage in the times ahead and especially during the present year? We were told that this was a poor man's Budget. God help the poor man. If this is a poor man's Budget, I do not know what a rich man's Budget is. We were told that £2,150,000 was going to be found for the relief of unemployment. There was a great whirl of trumpets about that. I wonder how much money the late Government spent on the relief of unemployment? Have they not spent ten times that sum and not made all the fuss about it that the Minister for Finance has made in introducing this Budget? How is the £2,150,000 to be found? One of the young men on the back benches of Fianna Fáil had the hardihood to be flippant with one of the most respected members in this House, Deputy Sir James Craig. Deputy Sir James Craig could fitly reply that he had found more employment for people in this country than was found by the combined efforts of the Fianna Fáil Party. The first way this money is going to be found is by a reduction of £250,000 in the salaries of civil servants and other public officials. Does that not mean a reduction of £250,000 in the money in active circulation in this country? Will that not have a repercussion that will produce unemployment and not remove it? I wonder what the Labour Party have to say about that, these people who always stand up for fair rates of wages, and who, I believe, have a motion on the Paper to introduce a fair wages clause in the protected industries. I wonder what the Labour Party have to say to this cut of £250,000 in the salaries of one of the most deserving bodies in this State, a body of which the State might well be proud, and which has rendered good service to the State. What has the Labour Party to say to that reduction? If it is necessary to introduce a fair wages clause for the protected industries, are they going to stand by and see this £250,000 taken off the civil servants? I honestly believe that if there is any body of men who have been disillusioned since the new Government came in, it is the Civil Service. In my opinion, a great many civil servants voted against the late Government and now they are reaping the whirlwind. When we forecast that, we were told: "We could not be much worse under any new Government than we are under the present Government." Facts will speak for themselves.

This poor man's Budget, about which "The Irish Press" had big headlines to-day, imposes a tax of £418,000 upon tea, which every honest man in this House will agree is one of the necessaries of life for the poor.

Comment on this

Was sugar necessary?

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I shall talk about sugar if the Minister wishes. We were told last year that we were endeavouring to impose £267,000 upon sugar, which completely wiped out the sum of £750,000 given by way of an addition to the agricultural grant.

Comment on this

The Deputy's memory is as faulty as his figures.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

My memory is perfectly correct. We were told distinctly that the agricultural grant which the late Government gave to the farmers was wiped out by the imposition of the sugar tax and we are asked under this Budget to impose a tax of £418,000 on tea. We are told by the Minister for Finance that tea is not a necessary of life. If it is not, what is it?

Comment on this

A beverage.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

It is quite evident that the Minister is fonder of drinking beverages than he is of tea.

Comment on this

That accounts for my good humour.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

If there is one thing we cannot do without, it is tea, and the cynical indifference with which this £418,000 is imposed upon the poor— well, I cannot find words to describe it. I wonder what will be left of the £250,000 that the farmers of the country will get when they pay their share of this £418,000 duty on tea. Will they get anything out of the £250,000. I think it is quite reasonable to assume that they will not. In addition, when one takes into consideration that the new Government are putting a tax upon agricultural machinery——

Comment on this

Will the Deputy say what they got out of the sugar tax?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is entitled to make his speech.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

The figure the Minister quoted as the result of the imposition on tea was £418,000. That is a purely speculative figure. On the face of that figure, there is an additional impost of £18,000. There is one thing that I shall tell the Minister. Some of his friends, following Fianna Fáil, who own factories and industries will come well out of the bargain. Some people with shares in the "Irish Press" will come well out of the bargain. Some people who produce agricultural machinery will come well out of the bargain. I think the proper title for the Budget would be the Fianna Fáil Partisan Budget, because it is designed to improve a certain section of the people and not designed for the national upliftment of the masses of the people. We are told that it is a poor man's Budget. There is to be £250,000 reduction in the salaries of the Civil Service. £418,000 is to be imposed as a tax upon tea, which is a general necessary of life, but which the Minister for Finance calls a luxury or a beverage. £60,000 is to be paid under the export of butter—a Bill introduced some weeks ago in order that we may sell our butter at 4d. a pound less to the English consumer than we sell it to the Irish consumer. Is that national economy or national suicide? We are imposing tariffs amounting to something like £910,000 and against whom are we imposing them? We are imposing these tariffs against our best customers. We are imposing them on people for whose trade we are ready to pay this sum of £600,000 in order to keep our Irish butter upon the English market. And while paying this £600,000 to keep Irish butter upon the English market, we are doing everything humanly possible to destroy our export trade with Great Britain. I can only say as an ordinary plain businessman that if we want to carry on our trade with Great Britain, we want to take care of the effect that tariffs are going to have on our export trade. Any man who knows anything about protection knows that it is a two-edged sword. If the Minister for Finance thinks that he is going to recoup his £910,000 mainly at the expense of our best customers, I am afraid he is entering upon a period of sad disillusionment.

There is another item I desire to call attention to. In order to find this £2,150,000 the sum of £650,000 is to be taken from the Hospital Sweepstakes. When our Party was the Government of this country there would not have been much difficulty in finding a sum of £1,000,000 to help the problem of unemployment in this country if we resorted to such measures as that. And the very man who is imposing this £650,000 upon the sweepstakes was one of the men who sneered at the success of the sweepstakes in this country. He belittled their beneficial advantage. Yet now he stoops to the level of taking this £650,000 from the hospitals of Dublin and Cork and other parts of the country. And he comes in here and does this with a smile on his face as if he was a national benefactor. I wonder what effect this will have upon the treatment of the poor? Do Deputies think that £650,000 can be taken away from the hospitals in the cities and the rest of the country without having repercussions upon the poor? And this is the poor man's Budget!

I wonder what repercussions will this £910,000 have upon the cost of living in this country? We are told it will create a new workers' paradise, that we shall have industries springing up like mushrooms in the night. Meantime they have to be paid for. How are these people, many of them living on poor relief, to face up to this increased taxation of £910,000? I know, for instance, that in Dublin £250,000 per annum is spent upon relief. Those poor people have no means of buying a pair of boots or buying a new coat for their backs. Their only income is through relief and how are these people, I ask again, to face up to getting new boots or clothes if this additional £910,000 is placed upon the cost of these articles? We are told that there is going to be a great increase in employment. And the great increase in employment that we were told about by the Minister for Industry and Commerce was 130 hands in the town of Athlone. "You heard of the Widow Malone, ochone; she comes from the town of Athlone." The sum of £910,000 additional taxation is to be imposed mainly upon the people of this country. Their clothing, boots and shoes are going to cost more; they will pay more for their tea and they will pay more for their amusements. Even if you want a gramophone record you will have to pay an extra price for it. This is the great Party that preached the gospel of economy from one end of the country to another. If an unfortunate man, working on a relief scheme, wants to buy a shovel he will have to pay a shilling extra for it.

Comment on this

And then he will get a damned bad shovel.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Yes, a damned bad shovel. The Government are going to provide £5,000,000 for housing. One would think hearing that statement made with a flourish of trumpets that we had actually reached the millennium and that nothing was ever done by the late Government for housing and that no expenditure of money had been made by the late Government to deal with the housing problem. I would remind the Minister of one very important fact: When ex-President Cosgrave took over the Government of this country he was faced with a very different position in the country from that with which the present Government is faced and very different from the position with which the present Minister for Finance is faced. He had to raise in one year something like £38,000,000 but, even at that time, at the peak point, the burden cast upon the people was in no way comparable with the burden cast upon the people by this Budget. £5,000,000 has to be found for housing, we are told. He has to borrow that. You must catch your hare before you cook him—I hope the Minister will catch his hare and then we will cook it. I want to remind the Minister for Finance that the late Government when providing money for housing did not declare, with a great flourish of trumpets, that the unemployment problem was solved. Their first move was to provide £1,000,000 for municipal authorities to build houses, but they did not say that that £1,000,000 was going to solve the unemployment problem. We say emphatically that the £5,000,000 that the Minister hopes to provide, and the £2,000,000 that he hopes to provide in his emergency Budget have not the slightest prospect or hope of solving the unemployment question.

I would like to remind the Minister for Finance when dealing with the subject of housing that the late Government built almost 30,000 houses during their period of office. They spent £2,550,000 in that way by way of State grants without any flourish of trumpets. The unassuming men who were then on the Front Benches did not make any parade of that fact. They did the work and there was no shouting. There is great jubilation on the Fianna Fáil Benches now, but just as with the Civil Service when these things fructify they will have the unemployment problem and will reap the whirlwind. I wondered at the light way in which income tax was raised to 5s. in the £. I wonder would it be an impertinence on my part to ask the Minister for Finance if the increase in income tax affects the Ministry or are they free from income tax? That is a question that I think should be answered in this House before the debate concludes.

Comment on this

It is not a fair question.

Comment on this

Are you free from income tax?

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

When we are considering national economy and when income tax is being increased from 3s. 6d. to 5s. in the £ by the Executive, it puts a very different complexion on this proposal if the members of the Government are exempt. It is all very well to increase income tax from 3s. 6d. to 5s. in the £ if Ministers have not got to pay it. When introducing the Budget the Minister made an important statement. He told us that this was a poor country and that there were very few rich people in it. What reactions will the increase in the income tax have on general employment in this State? If we are a poor country how will an extra tax of 1s. 6d. affect the ordinary people? I heard a Deputy from Mayo flippantly remark that we ought to be proud, being members of the British Commonwealth, to have the income tax here brought up to the level of England. Did anyone ever listen to such nonsense? Is that the way the Fianna Fáil Government is going to face up to national problems? Is that the mood of cynicism in which to treat an important measure of this kind? Is there any Deputy who would suggest that the financial resources of this country bear any comparison with the financial resources of Great Britain, even though Great Britain is at present in a depressed condition?

The ex-Minister for Finance stated here to-day that the Minister for Finance had given no justification for increasing the income tax from 3s. 6d. to 5s. in the £. He pointed out that that could only be done in a country where wealth had been accumulated or which was highly industrialised. Here we are practically an agricultural country. What repercussions will such an increase have or the few remaining industries that are still working successfully in this State? One has got to be very careful when imposing drastic taxation of this kind that the cure will not be worse than the disease. We were told that this poor man's Budget was going to raise one million pounds on the security of the Road Fund. One million pounds to solve the unemployment problem! I wonder did the Minister for Finance forget the amount of money this Party spent on the roads and on the repair of destroyed bridges. He forgot the huge sums that had to be spent in repairing the ravages of the troubled times and how these sums were found without imposing anything like the burden that is imposed on the people in this Budget. We are told that the unemployment problem is going to be solved by £1,000,000. The late Government spent £1,774,588 between 1922 and 1925 on the roads. The Minister was like the hen that laid two eggs when he told the House that one million was going to be spent on the roads. Does the Minister forget that between 1922 and 1931 £7,000,000 was spent on the improvement of roads and on repairs to bridges by the late Government and that the unemployment problem was not solved. The unemployment problem is to be solved by the new Government by the levy of indiscriminate tariffs and by a couple of sops which are mere drops in the ocean. If that is the way the present Government faces up to its responsibilities I hope that at the coming by-elections the country will show what it thinks of their policy and teach them that they cannot play fast and loose with sensible people as they have attempted to do by the introduction of this Budget. Cast-iron tariffs we are told are going to solve the unemployment problem and there is to be decentralisation of industry. That word "decentralisation" has always got on my brain. I often wonder what it means. If you want to set up a successful industry you must set it up upon sound economic lines.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

"Hear, hear," says the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, who wanted to abolish all income tax.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

He is now in a Government that has raised income tax from 3s. 6d. to 5s. in the £. I believe if there is one mortified member in that Party to-day it is the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

You are very wrong.

[An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.]

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I believe if Deputy Flinn had his way this wild-cat scheme of the Minister for Finance would never have been introduced. I have sufficient regard for the common sense of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister to think that he would never have embarked upon these drastic emergency measures which the Minister for Finance has introduced. "Decentralisation of industry!" We have to-day throughout the industrial world an attempt to reduce the cost of production, to reduce overhead charges, to produce at the lowest possible prices and to give the best possible service to secure trade. Will the decentralisation of industry do that? Is there any hope that a country with decentralised industries will ever build up an export trade? What is the great object for levying a tariff to protect any industry? If the Minister for Finance knows anything about tariffs he knows that a protective tariff is first levied to enable an industry to get on its feet and the next thing is to build up an export trade. Can you build up an export trade, for instance, in the agricultural industry with 62 firms operating in this State? Do you think you will have an industry working on sound economic lines with 62 firms operating in a country with a few million inhabitants? Can the raw materials be bought at anything like a reasonable figure with 62 firms operating? Can any one of these firms buy raw materials at the right price? If you want to set up industry in this country you must set it up on sound economic lines. If there is to be decentralisation you are only going to be tinkering with industry for all time. When the Minister for Industry and Commerce was speaking he stated that as long as this Government was in office there was going to be protection for industry. He guaranteed that. He was asked one very important question: "How long will the guarantee last?" That is the first question any business man will ask when putting capital into an industrial venture in any State. Not alone is this decentralised form of industry to be set up, but the Minister for Industry and Commerce tells us that he will only permit some outside firms to come in here and that others he will not permit although they may make industry more efficient. If we had half a dozen efficient industries, they would be worth a thousand decentralised units which can never uplift the country. Why are combines taking place in the chemical and iron industries? They are taking place in order to cheapen production. The Minister for Finance and his Parliamentary Secretary are working along lines that can never be economic.

Comment on this

"Sez you."

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

They will never be able to supply the needs of this country efficiently. The Parliamentary Secretary can say "sez you" to that as long as he likes. What the people want to know is whether this sum imposed upon the consumers—£910,000 —is going to be frittered away or what benefit is going to accrue to the State. Certain followers of the Fianna Fáil Party will do well, but there are other people in the State besides followers of Fianna Fáil. It is in these people that we are interested. I am sorry to see that the Labour Benches have been practically empty during this debate.

Comment on this

Do not be a bit uneasy.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I should like to ask Deputy Davin, if he were here, what he thinks of the £23,000 which is being given to the 'bus industry by way of remission of taxation. Deputy Davin is associated with an industry which gives the largest employment in this country—the railway industry—and not a single penny is being given to help the railways.

Comment on this

What was done for them during the past ten years?

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

During the past ten years we passed many measures to enable the railway companies to face up to the situation created by the new 'bus competition, over which the Government had practically no control. This competition was uneconomic, and some of the companies concerned paid a scandalous rate of wages to their employees. I have heard Labour Deputies say that certain men employed by 'bus companies in the city were paid only 15/- per week. Is there any railwayman working for that wage? Why is this £23,000 being given to the 'bus companies? I wonder is it because some friends of Fianna Fáil have great interest in that industry? I wonder why the Killeen Mills have got a tariff on stationery, why the Urney chocolate factory has got not only a tax on chocolates, but a reduction of the duty on sugar. That chap is going to have it both ways. Under the circumstances that have arisen, it is a great pity that the railway companies did not invest a few thousand pounds in the "Irish Press." It would have been a good, paying proposition. There is no doubt about that. The "Irish Press" investments have paid very well. I see here the name of Pierce. That investment has been extremely profitable.

Comment on this

It is not going to be suppressed after all.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

It will suppress itself in time.

Comment on this

The Deputy will be in eternity before then.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

We are giving £250,000 to the farmers. If there is one industry harder hit than another it is the agricultural industry. The farmers are going to get £250,000 by this Budget in remission of taxation. But the farmers are going to pay more for their clothes, boots, shoes, tea, and agricultural machinery. After the Budget, the farmers will be a great deal worse off than before. When we were trying to do as much as was humanly possible for the farmer, we were looked upon as the greatest enemy the farmer ever had. One of the greatest evils the agricultural industry can possibly suffer is the introduction of this Budget. I am glad the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance is in the House. His Party is allied with the Labour Party. I should have liked to ask Deputy Davin, if he were here, how he can continue in alliance with a Party which entertains for his Party only the most supreme contempt. We must take our hats off to the two Independent Labour Deputies.

Comment on this

We should take our boots off.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I am glad that Deputy Davin has now come into the House.

Comment on this

I was listening to the Deputy from outside the barrier.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I wanted to ask Deputy Davin what the railway industry, of which he is such an able representative, is going to get under this Budget. I wanted to know if Deputy Davin was satisfied that the 'bus owners, who are more or less affiliated with the Government Party, should be given £23,000 by way of remission of taxation when the wages they pay in some cases amounts to about 15s. per week, while the railway industry, which gives more employment than practically any other industry, is getting no concession. I wanted to know in Deputy Davin's absence how he reconciled the alliance with the Government Party which maintains for his Party the most supreme contempt. I venture to quote the words of the new Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance in regard to the Official Labour Party. He said:

I have been challenged by denationalised labour. Broadly speaking, the ignorant uneconomic policy of those who degrade the name of Labour by parading themselves as a Party as such, is that you must get everything done, but that you must not do anything to get it done. "No straw shall be given to you," you say to the industrialists, "but yet ye shall deliver the táille reckoned." I know that the burden upon industry in this country is too high. I know no way of forcing fluid capital into industry.

Comment on this

Where did the Deputy get that?

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I am quoting from the Official Debates. That old dodge of Deputy Davin's did not work. I would like Deputy Davin as champion of the poor and oppressed in this country to indicate what he has got to say about those figures and the imposition of the boot taxes. This fresh taxation on boots will mean anything by way of an additional impost on the taxes of the plain people amounting to £30,000 or £40,000 on men's and women's boots leaving out the boots of boys and girls. In 1926 there was paid by way of salaries and wages £96,822 and the duty was £268,000. I cannot profess to be a correct exponent of the views of Labour but I do say that I have the strongest possible sympathy with Labour and I should like to know what the Labour Party have got to say with regard to that imposition. The leader of the Labour Party in this House speaking on the unemployment debate said that he hoped the new policy of the Government would not be similar to the policy that had been followed in other countries. He referred to the fact that over £2,000,000 had been placed on ordinary consumers by the tax on boots and shoes. We have now in this Budget an extra £40,000 added on to all this and I want to ask the Labour Party are they calmly standing by and taking that lying down or are they going to stand up for the poor whom I believe they really represent in this House.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Claim to represent?

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

They claim to represent them in this House and I believe they are honest. They are a body of men who only want to get a little glimmering of intelligence.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy explain how the Labour Party could be standing up if they are lying down?

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

That would be very difficult. I always heard that an Irishman had leave to open his mouth twice. When one is speaking in this House it is very easy to make a slip. I cannot see for the life of me how the Labour Party can vote for this extra imposition of £40,000 upon boots and shoes which are necessary to life for the greater section of the people we represent. I cannot see how that imposition can be justified in view of the fact that for practical purposes, after enjoying protection for a period of eight to nine years, we are unable or practically unable to turn out boys' and girls' shoes and light footwear for women and men. We are producing, I do grant, at the moment something like one-eighth of the requirements of this country and we are paying for that £268,000 by way of duty per year. We are going to add to that now £40,000. That will be roughly £300,000 which the consumers of this country have got to pay for the setting up of one particular industry in the State.

I want to ask the House, do they think it is a paying proposition? Is it a business job? Can Fianna Fáil ever hope to solve the unemployment problem by a policy of indiscriminate tariffs? When the late Government was in office they handled tariffs very carefully. After being ten years in office there was a sum of £1,350,000 flowing into the National Exchequer, but was there any unreasonable burden on the consumers of this State? Did it press unduly on the people? After being nine weeks in office the Government have imposed tariffs which will put a burden of £910,000 on the consuming public in this country. We want to be careful over these things. The representative from Mayo to whom I have referred in the course of my remarks asked me to point out how the Budget is going injuriously to affect the country. Any man who knows anything about Protection— and the Leader of the Labour Party has referred to this as I have already said in a speech on unemployment— knows this that the imposition of indiscriminate tariffs is not adding to industrial development, but is retarding industrial development and lowering the general standard of the people. I have more than once pointed out to this House that this is not the first time that indiscriminate tariffs have been tried on this world.

We have the example which I referred to on more than one occasion, of Australia. Australia proceeded on identically similar lines to the present Government. They set out on a policy of indiscriminate tariffs. They increased the manufactures of the country, they raised the wages of the worker until practically nine-tenths of the industries were uneconomic. They could not produce at an economic price and what was the result? The result was that they had almost to resort to prohibition to keep out the imports that they were unable to pay for. They had something like £15,000,000 per annum interest to pay on national debt. The national debt rose to something like £350,000,000. How long will the national debt of this country be rising if the same effects follow the policy of Fianna Fáil as followed the policy in Australia? These are important considerations. We do not want to discuss these things from the Party angle, good, bad or indifferent. We on this side stand for the industrial development of the country just as much as the men on the other side, but it must be sane development. It must be development on economic lines. If the development is not along economic lines, the cure is worse than the disease.

I would like to ask the Minister for Finance one question in regard to the bachelor tax. I was approached by constituents to-day and asked to put this question to him: Is a widow under this tax considered to be a bachelor?

Comment on this

Make a match for her and see.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Or a widower? I am not asking the question in a flippant or humorous way. Will they have to pay this tax just the same as if they never entered the bonds of matrimony?

Comment on this

Why should they get exemption?

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I suggest it is a great hardship upon this particular man who came to me. This man had four married daughters, every one of them idle. He was the only wage earner in the house and this tax will press upon him with undue severity. At the same time it is a very unfortunate tax for a poor old spinster, a poor old maid who has a few shillings to keep her in her declining years. Goodness knows, the Minister threw the net widely enough to enable him to exempt these particular people. Anybody who has been married once should certainly be exempt from this tax. Will the Minister say——

Comment on this

I would not cast such an aspersion on the ladies of the State.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Will the Minister say whether the tax will be collected from a widow or widower? I am putting the question in perfect seriousness.

Comment on this

The tax will be collected from every person who is not now living in the state of matrimony.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

If there is no hope for the widows and the widowers, it seems to me undoubtedly very harsh treatment for the type of people to whom I have referred.

Comment on this

I do not know whether the Deputy expressed clearly what he had in mind.

Comment on this
A Deputy

You expressed it anyhow.

Comment on this

Is his point that a widower or widow with children will get the allowance in respect of children?

Comment on this
A Deputy

That is not the question.

Comment on this

I think the answer I have given ought to satisfy the Deputy. We will encourage them to remarry.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

I happen to be married myself and I know that anyone that gets out of the net once is not in a hurry to get into it again.

Comment on this

Does that account for the Deputy's melancholy state of mind to-night?

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

The Minister for Finance wants to be personal. Of course I can be personal also. I do not wish to say any more on this Budget than this: that this Budget is one which the country cannot afford. It has been introduced regardless of its ramifications; it has been introduced regardless of the ability of the people to pay and far from curing the unemployment problem, in my opinion, it will only accentuate it.

Comment on this

We have heard a great deal of talk this whole evening from various Deputies on the opposite benches about this Budget. Two ex-Ministers brought us back to the civil war, and they told us that it was a revolution. Well, it is a revolution. It is a revolution from the policy of the late Minister for Local Government— a complete revolution of his policy, the policy of the reduction of the wages of the workers and the increase in the salaries of the officials. It is a complete revolution of the policy of reducing the workers' wages down to £1 9s. 0d. a week and of the policy that insisted upon the local bodies increasing the salaries of their officials from £700 to £1,400. It is a complete revolution of that policy certainly, and I for one welcome that revolution.

We have complaints here because there was going to be a reduction of civil servants' salaries amounting to £250,000. I remember last year being over on the opposite side of the House and pointing out to the late Minister for Finance in connection with the Budget that the amount of the cost-of-living bonus paid on salaries over £400 amounted to £380,000; and I have only one regret, and that is that there was not more than £250,000 demanded of those who are drawing salaries of more than £400 a year in this country. For a man with £400 a year there is no fear of his family starving, and such a man should undoubtedly contribute to the support of those who are in the position to-day of being both workless and hungry.

Then we had complaints about the farmers' position. We had any number of complaints about the farmers' position from different farmer Deputies. Deputy Dillon in fact wanted to know whether the farmers who are here on those benches were going to vote against the Budget. Well, we have got more from this Budget than ever we got from Deputies on the opposite benches when they were in power. We have got an increase of £250,000 in relief of rates. And if those who are now so anxious about the farmers to-day were equally anxious about those farmers twelve months ago when they came into this House and stated that the farmers did not want to get £1,000,000 in relief of rates, if they voted in favour of that £250,000 extra last year, we would not have so many farmers in the country now being hunted about for the payment of land annuities and rates. Deputies closed their eyes absolutely to that aspect of the position.

Then in regard to housing, the late Minister for Local Government definitely set out that the rural population were going to gain no benefit from any housing scheme introduced in this Dáil. He definitely laid it down in this Dáil that the rural population had to subscribe by way of taxes and rates to pay for every scheme of housing, but they were not going to gain any benefit by it. We are now going to get an increased grant for housing, and the rural population and those small farmers in the country will now get a grant towards the reconstruction of their dwelling-houses, a reform which we have been calling for in vain in this House during the last four years. And in addition to that we have a large sum of money of over £1,000,000 to be handed over to the local authorities for the provision of housing schemes for the rural areas and others. That is a big change from the cast-iron system that the late Minister for Local Government adopted towards the rural community. It is a complete change, and I welcome it on behalf of the farming community.

We have also heard talk about the increase in the price of superphosphates. There were 32,000 tons of superphosphates imported last year, and the total amount of extra taxation on that importation would be £10,000. And all the howling is about that £10,000. And it is a decreasing importation. It decreased by 11,000 tons last year. That is there was a decrease of 11,000 tons in the importation in 1931 as compared with 1930. And it is an importation for which in my opinion there is no necessity. There are plenty of manufacturers in this country manufacturing superphosphates so that there is no necessity for importing this material.

We have set out on the right road towards not alone reducing unemployment but abolishing unemployment in this country, and it is high time that we did it. And to those who complain of the position of the farmers to-day I say this much, that if the last Government were to be here on those benches for three years longer there would be no necessity for coming to the relief of the farmers because there would be no farmers there to relieve.

We have been accused here by the baby of the House who spent two hours in telling us about nothing. When he had finished he only impressed us as regards one matter and that is that decentralisation has got into his brain. It must have taken a long time to penetrate into the childish intellect of Deputy J.J. Byrne, but I am glad that it did penetrate it in the end. Deputy Byrne is spokesman for the unemployed. I should like to go to-morrow to the shop of this gentleman who is talking about unemployment. If I did I should find that 80 per cent. of everything that he sells in his shop is imported from foreign countries. This is the gentleman who talks about manufacturers here and of the protection afforded to them. I should like him to remember that and not to be so poisonous because we are putting a duty of 33? per cent. on his importation of Shamrock shovels. He need not be so poisonous over that. There is no occasion for it. It will relieve some of those unemployed who call up to his house looking for bread and looking for work, to whom he can only show the fine Shamrock shovels made in Manchester.

Then we had Deputy Morrissey complaining about unemployment. Last week here I saw rather an amazing exhibition from Deputy Morrissey. I saw him walking into the Division Lobby against giving increased employment to 500 men. That employment was to be brought about by a tariff on agricultural machinery. We had the Deputy who held up the House here demanding that unemployment be wiped out, demanding to know our immediate remedy for unemployment, walking into that Lobby against the interests of five hundred unemployed. Then Deputy Dillon became very vocal over the tax on maize. There is no tax on maize. There is a tax on maize meal. It is about time there was. We have plenty of idle mills in this country capable of grinding maize and there is no need to pay foreign labourers to grind it for us. We have enough unemployed on our shoulders, and we should not be giving employment to foreign labourers to grind maize while our farmers are looking at men idle around them.

If we were to carry out this policy to its natural conclusion, where would we find ourselves? Where would the policy of the "Shamrock shovel importers" carry us? By that policy we would buy everything foreign because it may be cheaper. What are we going to sell? Are we going to sell anything? The farmer is going to be put out of production because everything can be imported cheaper than the price at which he can grow it. Industrialists are to be put out of production because the foreign combines can clear them out. I have already seen one result of a tariff in my constituency. Last week one manufacturer there got an order for £10,000 worth of stuff. He can increase his employees from 30 to 100 immediately. I would like to see 60 or 70 of my neighbours working in a local factory, even though one might have to pay an extra penny or twopence for the stuff produced there. That is, to my mind, one of the cures for unemployment. It is a successful cure. An idle man can buy nothing no matter how cheap.

The ex-Minister for Local Government trotted out figures about unemployment and he gave us some figures in connection with the Employment Exchanges, stating that unemployment has gone up. Why? Because the unemployed man now knows that he is going to get employment and in that way he is induced to go to the Labour Exchange to register. He knows that one man now is as good as another. He has no longer to walk around for twelve months, wearing his boots looking for work and then finding that a dandy who has just come out of the National Army gets a job before him. These times are past and gone. That is why the figures of the Labour Exchange have gone up. The labourer now, after ten years walking the roads looking for employment, knows that he is at last going to be employed. We had any amount of wails here. I explained for the benefit of Deputy Dillon a while ago that there was no tax on maize. I hope he will remember that fact. There is a tax on maize meal.

Comment on this

You will understand the Budget some time.

Comment on this

The Deputy will after a little time. I would like the Minister for Finance to turn his attention to one matter. I notice that he is giving on certain conditions a remission of 5s. per standard barrel on beer for the first 5,000 barrels. I wonder would he make the conditions a little more stringent. Instead of limiting the malt used in the manufacture of the beer to 80 per cent. of the material used, he might make the remission available only to those who use nothing but Irish grown barley. Practically all the small brewers in this country use home grown barley. It would be a fine gesture on the part of the Minister if the remission were made available only to those who used all Irish barley.

We heard a great deal here about the land annuities. I have a proposition to make to the Deputies opposite and it is a fair proposition. We have heard all about embezzlers, robbers and thieves from Deputies opposite for a number of years. Now remember one thing—both Church and State hold that the receiver is worse than the thief. I suggest to the Deputies opposite who believe that we are indulging in embezzlement in withholding the land annuities that they make out a list of those of their constituents, friends and others who are in favour of paying those land annuities to Britain. Make out that list and let us see how many supporters they have in the country against the retention of those land annuities. Let Deputy Hassett show us how many Tipperarymen think it is embezzlement to retain the land annuities. Then we will see that those gentlemen will not obtain full de-rating or any benefits of the withheld money. I am sure that would be a very enlightening list.

Deputy Morrissey here to-day congratulated me on securing £250,000 extra for de-rating. He need not congratulate me. Every single promise given by Fianna Fáil to the electors is going to be carried out. It is because the people knew we were going to carry out those guarantees that they elected us here. We will carry them out and no doubt about it. Deputies said that we promised full de-rating. We did and we will get it. The less opposition we get from Cumann na nGaedheal Deputies on the question of land annuities the sooner we will get full de-rating. There are several farmer Deputies listening to me who shouted a lot about it being robbery to hold the land annuities. They should have the courage of their convictions and refuse to receive stolen property. They should bring along the list and the more they get to support them the more we will have for those who do not.

I know plenty of our supporters in the country, poor fellows who have been ground down under the heel of the last administration, decent young boys who went out from 1916 to 1923 and fought for Ireland. They found when they came home that they would not get an hour's work. Any employer who had the courage to employ them found they were missing four days every week because they were arrested and rearrested and thrown into jail. We want to look after those young fellows. When we get hold of the land annuities we will be in a position to help industry and give employment to those boys.

Comment on this

I rise to deal with the question of what the farmer is going to get out of this Budget. A lot has been made of the £250,000 grant. That will amount to about 7/1-3d. in the £ in taxation. To the man with £50 valuation, that will mean about 29/2d. in the year. As against a grant of a quarter of a million, it is proposed to take three millions from the farmers as a result of tariffs and the increased prices that are going to obtain. I will not take up many items, but I will deal first of all with superphosphate. A lot has been said here about phosphates. I am given to understand by a man who is an authority on phosphates that there are no phosphate deposits in Europe worth speaking about. The only deposit of importance in Europe is in County Clare. The next source of supply would be in Northern Africa, and then there is an island in the Pacific, in which Australia, New Zealand and Britain have an equal share. The raw phosphates used here have to be got in Clare, or Northern Africa. Some of the Continental phosphates that come here are merely North African phosphates ground in Holland or Belgium.

It has been said that the amount imported is so small that it is not worth talking about. If that is so, what is the reason for putting on a tariff of 20 per cent.? I understand there are certain manufacturers who are anxious to get the raw phosphates without any impost. We all know when the artificial manure ring was perfected, and when it took control. We remember the price at which we could get manure before the ring started operating. As soon as the ring was perfected the price of phosphates immediately went up and continued to remain up until the North African and Continental shipments began to arrive. Then the prices came down, and this year you can buy phosphates for £3 a ton. If we had not the small competition, what would this ring of artificial manure manufacturers be charging? Instead of £3, the price would probably be £5 and perhaps more. The 29/2 that the farmer with a £50 valuation would gain from this £250,000 grant would be more than swept away in the purchase of one ton of phosphates.

I will not deal with clothes, boots, machinery or the tax on shovels and spades. I would like to know from the Minister for Industry and Commerce where in this country are we to get shovels and spades. Is there any firm in this country manufacturing those articles in sufficient quantities to meet requirements, and, if so, where is that firm? We know that Henshaws closed up twelve months ago.

Comment on this

They are going to open again.

Comment on this

And they would need to manufacture an article of better quality than they used to manufacture. They were making an article that nobody would use and that was the reason they had to close up.

Comment on this

Is it a proper thing for a Deputy, under the cover of privilege, to make an attack on a firm which cannot defend itself in this House?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not a proper thing for a Deputy to make an attack upon a firm, especially under the privileges extended here.

Comment on this

The fact is that these people were not able to carry on.

Comment on this

In defence of a reputable firm I would like to say that my experience, which is quite as wide as Deputy Gorey's, is at entire variance with his.

Comment on this

I am speaking of actual experience.

Comment on this

So am I.

Comment on this

I am not a seller but a user of the article.

Comment on this

And so am I.

Comment on this

I worked their article with my hands and feet and it actually bent in my hands and was of no use.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Dáil ought not to be used for the purpose of making an attack on any firm and mentioning the firm's name.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

In the interests of the industry and its likely development, I think the Deputy's remark should be withdrawn.

Comment on this

I will not withdraw it. I made the remark in the best interests of the industry and in the interests of other manufacturers. If we have a little straight talking we will get a better article. I will not withdraw the statement.

Comment on this

I cannot compel you.

Comment on this

I do not think you can.

Comment on this

Not in any shape or form.

Comment on this

There are several charges contained in this Budget on articles other than phosphates which would more than wipe out any benefit the farmer might derive from the grant. I am not in a position to submit actual figures relating to what a tax on maize meal, clothes, boots, spades, shovels and machinery would mean to the farmer. I am not able to make a calculation on that, but I can make a calculation as regards the other items. What I say is that you are giving the farmer a crumb and the loaf to somebody else. The additional taxation contemplated under this Budget—the £5,000,000 or £6,000,000 of a difference —is, some of it at all events, going to be a direct charge on agriculture, while eventually the whole of it is going to come out of the farmers' pockets. One hears a lot of crocodile sympathy expressed here for the position in which agriculturists find themselves. I wonder how much of that is real and how much of it is put on. I urge the Minister for Industry and Commerce to be very careful about the artificial manure manufacturing ring that I have referred to. I am sure the Minister knows as well as anyone else that there is such a ring and that it has been in operation for years. With regard to some of the resolutions that we have read about congratulating the Government on the tariffs they imposed recently we know where some of them came from. We know that these people were on the market for the last seven or eight years and ultimately got their market. I will leave it at that.

I want to refer to the levy imposed by the Budget on the Sweeps or rather on that portion of the Sweep money intended for the hospitals. On behalf of my own county I protest against that levy. My county, like other counties, was expecting a share of the profits on the Sweep, but this imposition will lessen the amount available for it and the other counties. It was only in connection with the last Sweep that we succeeded in getting an Act passed by the Oireachtas giving the counties in the Saorstát an equal claim with the Dublin hospitals to a share of the profits on the Sweeps. The counties were not to get a very high percentage, but still the sum available for them would be considerable. The sum of over £600,000 which the Minister for Finance is now proposing to take out of the profits on the Sweeps will certainly bring down very considerably the percentage available for the county hospitals. It will lessen very considerably what ought to be their fair share of that money. I am not able to quote the exact words of the President, but I feel that he will admit what I am about to say is correct, namely, that twelve months ago he gave it as his opinion that he objected altogether to this method of raising money, even though the money was devoted to hospitals that had to depend for support on charity. The President objected to that. Is not that right? Now, we find him not alone reconciling himself to that position, but in fact taking a share of the money raised in that fashion as revenue for the State. It is one of the most extraordinary things I ever heard of. Twelve months or a year and a half ago the President thought it was immoral and wrong to raise money for private hospitals in that way.

Comment on this

The Deputy had better quote now.

Comment on this

I have not the President's exact words before me, but is the President in a position to deny it?

Comment on this

I think it would be better for the Deputy to quote. It would be safer for him to do so.

Comment on this

It would be safer to quote perhaps, but certainly the statement was made in some form. I am not able to quote the exact words from memory and the President is not able to deny it.

Comment on this

It is going to be put to the purpose now of improving cul-de-sac roads.

Comment on this

It is going to do a much more important thing than that: to keep people out of the hospitals.

Comment on this

In my opinion, this is an attempt to rob the county hospitals and is a degrading method of raising revenue for the State. I do not know that, with the exception of ourselves, you will find any place outside of Monaco where there has been such a thing attempted as this—trying to live on gambling and sweeps. There is no other civilised country that I know of that has attempted such a thing. I do not think that what is proposed is any credit to the State. Some of us in this House thought, and are still of the opinion that not alone should the hospitals be a national charge, but that the expenses in connection with them should be borne by the State, that they should not be left dependent on charity in any form. In this case, we are not only departing from that principle but we are doing what no State should do, making a claim on money intended for hospitals. I also notice that it is proposed to tax mechanical lighters. In other words, anybody carrying a mechanical pipe lighter in future will have to get a licence.

I feel very concerned about an announcement that I read in the Press on Wednesday. It was one of very considerable importance to the people in the county that I belong to. That announcement may not have any weight with the Ministry. Indeed, I suppose it will not. The announcement was to this effect, that one of the biggest employers in the County Kilkenny intimated to his workers that if there was a change in taxation in the direction he referred to he would have to reduce their wages considerably, and perhaps might have to let a number of them go altogether. That is a matter that concerns me very much. The ordinary rate of income-tax is being raised to 5/- in the £. I suppose we have got to bear that, but I do not see any justification for making that increase and at the same time increasing the amount of super-tax chargeable to a gentleman with an income such as this particular employer has. He employs about 200 hands, but I think I would not be far wide of the mark if I said that there are at least 1,000 souls dependent on the employment that he gives. Any curtailment in the wages paid to his employees, or any lessening in the number of people employed would be a matter of grave concern to me. I think there is a good deal in the argument that the people in employment should have as much consideration, should have more consideration I would say, than the people who are out of employment. I think it may be taken as a general principle that the people in employment are the people who want to be in employment, and they are the people who from one cause or another deserve to have employment. I say that you ought not to put people out of employment in order to find work for others. You should do your utmost to keep in employment the people who are in employment, who want to be employed and are constantly trying to get work.

A good deal has been said about the annuities. I do not know if this is the proper time to go into the legal aspect of that question. I have always disputed, and will continue to dispute, the State's claim to collect the annuities except for the purpose for which the annuities are intended. The State has no title at present to collect outside of that particular title. If it wants to get that title legislation must be introduced here making the State the owner of the land.

The State was never the owner of the land of this country. The farmers of this country bought the title—a title extending over seven or eight hundred years—from the only people who had the title. They bought their title, and the State has no title whatever. You have to introduce legislation into this House entitling you to collect, entitling you to put on a land tax and to nationalise the land. The President can laugh, but the President, unless he introduces that particular legislation, will get plenty of tests in the Law Courts. I wish you every luck in keeping the land annuities.

Comment on this
Seán MacEntee Minister for Finance (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

The Deputy ought to keep away from the Law Courts.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance might find himself brought into the Law Courts by the Deputy.

Comment on this

I hope not in the same circumstances as the Deputy was brought in.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not a bit ashamed of the circumstances. Some of the Deputies who have spoken have likened the Minister to a bantam in introducing this Budget. Another Deputy likened him to a hen that had laid two eggs, but I can never look at the Minister for Finance, and at the back of an Irish penny, but I see the Minister every time in the representation of a hatching hen. I said that the Executive Council has no claim to collect, but that can be thrashed out later. It is time enough to jump our fences when we meet them, and I promise the President pretty rough travelling over the country.

Comment on this

Will you take your share?

Comment on this

I am paying my share, and nobody will be more delighted than I, if you succeed in repudiating them. As soon as you repudiate them, I will repudiate you. Suppose we are able to repudiate them, what is the position, then? There is a tremendous number of people in this country who own land stock. I know that and the Minister must know it. Anybody who has any knowledge of Irish investments knows that there is a considerable amount of land stock held in this country. Who is going to pay them if we repudiate our engagements to the stock holders? Who is going to make good to the stockholders, and who are we to compel an outside Government to make good to the stock-holders, to the nationals, of this country. I might repeat a last word of warning to the Minister for Industry and Commerce and it is, that he should keep an eye on the artificial manure manufacturers. Let him not allow them to humbug him. There is a much plainer word used in the country, but I do not suppose that I would be in order in using it here.

Comment on this

I want to say a few words in connection with one item in support of the statement made by Deputy Gorey as to superphosphates. I represent here a large county, the land of which needs to be nourished, so much so that I am convinced that, only for the use and aid of fertilisers in recent years, the district would not be able to go on at all. Everybody in this House knows that tillage is expensive and that it has not been profitable in recent years. The owners of this land, in order to meet the needs of the hour, had to convert their land into milk-producing land, and the only possible way to do it was through the medium of fertilisers. In order to achieve the best possible results, and to turn their money to the best advantage, they banded themselves together and bought in bulk, utilising the ports of the South with very great advantage. This tariff of 20 per cent. that has been introduced by the Minister will have the effect this year of putting a levy of anything from 16/- to £1 per ton on that commodity.

The Minister, in his remarks a while ago, said that any reasonable proposition in connection with this Budget, if it were put before him, would have favourable consideration. I say that the owners of land who need fertilisers are the hardest hit section of the community. If there is one thing they suffer from it is lack of sufficient funds to buy a sufficient quantity of fertilisers. The Government say that they will probably have to put on a tax to solve the unemployment problem, and we have it from the President himself that the tax will be put on those best able to bear it. I say that this tax is put on those least able to bear it, and I would ask the Ministers to agree that this tax needs to be reviewed. I ask them to review it, and I hope they will consider my application favourably.

The Government recognises the necessity for relieving agriculture, and they have given a quarter of a million pounds to local authorities for the relief of local rates; but I say that any man who needs fertilisers has to bear a greater burden through these imposts than he will be relieved by the quarter of a million pounds in relief of rates. As Deputy Gorey says, there is a danger, and a great danger, that if this tariff is put on, as is intended, it will have the effect of giving a monopoly with very adverse results to the purchaser. So far as we personally are concerned in the South, we are buying foreign, and we are utilising the ports of the South for distribution, and I say that, even with the tariff, we will have to buy the foreign product, and it will still be cheaper for us. As I have already stated, the impost is put on the section least able to bear it, and I appeal to the Ministry to consider this application I have made, with a view to giving relief to the most distressed section of the community.

Comment on this

Apparently by this Budget, the Minister for Finance believes that he has the unemployment problem solved—solved by 43 tariffs imposed. My opinion of the 43 tariffs imposed is that they will put some people into employment, but they will put a bigger number out of employment. I will take just one industry of which I have some small knowledge. Take the building industry. A fortnight ago I asked the President if he was in a position to give me figures of those unemployed in that industry on 9th March, and he said it was not possible for him. I expected that at a later date I would receive the figures, but so far I have got no information except that given by Deputy Mulcahy relating to Dublin. From what I know of the West, I know that there is much more unemployment at present in that industry than on 9th March. We have now in the Budget a thirty-three and one-third tariff imposed on steel windows. I should like to know from the Minister for Industry and Commerce if it is not to accommodate one firm that that tariff is put on? Am I right in saying that these windows are not made in this country; that they are assembled here, and that the sections are brought over from another country? So that the tariff is put on really to have them assembled here. There is a tariff imposed on practically everything in the building line. On plaster slabs there is a tariff of 4d. per square yard. There are also tariffs on paint, varnishes, cast-iron pipes and fittings. I would like to ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce does he believe that the two firms in this country that supply cast-iron pipes and fittings are able to meet the needs of the country? My information is that they are not able—that it takes them six weeks to carry out orders.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy aware that Messrs. Ford of Cork are engaged in the manufacture of these cast-iron downpipes?

Comment on this
Mr. Brodrick

In a very small way.

Comment on this

Are they going to supply fittings?

Comment on this

That is another detail.

Comment on this

It is a very important one.

Comment on this
Mr. Brodrick

Then we come to galvanized iron. Is galvanized iron manufactured here? If it is not, what is the reason of the ten per cent. tariff? We know that galvanized iron is used by the small farmers to a large extent. In the West it is not alone used on out-offices, but some small farmers use it on dwelling-houses. What is the idea of putting a ten per cent. tariff on it if it is not manufactured here? Coming to the cost of building, you have tariffs on sundry and plumber's brass work. I should like to know if wood mantels come under the tariff? Take the cost of building a house. I have gone into this matter very minutely, and a house which would have cost £700 to build will now cost between £790 and £800 owing to the tariffs. The cost of the £1,000 house will go up to £1,100 or £1,120. We have the Minister for Finance saying that he is going to give £5,000,000 for housing. A sum of £5,000,000 is to be given for the building of houses to be let at half the present rent, which will cost at least one-seventh more than they would cost a few days ago. I should like to know how it is going to be done. I firmly believe that, owing to the tariffs, the building industry is going to be held up. I have information from one Dublin firm that a £2,500 order has been cancelled this morning. I also know that several builders throughout the country are letting men go because they cannot pay for the materials. They expect that they would not be able to get the supplies even if they were able to pay.

Then I come to the Sweepstakes. Last year an Act was passed here under which several hospitals and county homes throughout the country were to get something out of the Sweepstakes. In Galway the ratepayers provided £30,000 to build and equip a hospital. It was hoped that the ratepayers there would be helped by the money they were to get out of the sweepstakes. Now we find that these ratepayers, who spent £30,000 on erecting and equipping a modern hospital, are to be deprived of portion of the sum which they expected to get from the sweepstakes. I think that is most unfair owing to the promises made to these people that they would get this money in order to further equip such hospitals. Ratepayers in counties like Galway are unable to expend any more money on hospitals. I think it is most unfair that this money should be taken from the hospitals and county homes, which served the poor and the infirm, the very people that Fianna Fáil talked such a lot about for the past four years. They are depriving them now of the little help they were to get from the sweepstakes.

Comment on this

I move to report progress.

Comment on this