Dairy Produce (Price Stabilisation) Bill, 1932—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–178 of 357. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 6 of 1932 ›
I move amendment 21:—
In sub-section (2), page 7, to delete at the end of line 15 the words "under this," and in line 16 the word "section."
I move the deletion of those words, as they are a repetition of the words in the sub-section. It is, more or less, a printer's error.
Comment on this
I move amendment 22:—
In page 7 to insert before sub-section (3) a new sub-section as follows:
(3) Any person who on behalf of other persons carries on, whether alone or in conjunction with any other business, the business of selling or arranging for the sale or disposal of farm butter manufactured by other persons shall for the purposes of this section be deemed to have manufactured such butter for sale.
Section 12, as it stands, deals with the case of the unregistered butter factory which is not registered under the Dairy Produce Act, but which purchases butter, and it might possibly, also, deal with the very large farmer of the type who might have 200 or 300 cows, if we had such a farmer in the country. It is proposed under this amendment to bring in another class— the butter factories which sell farmers' butter on commission. We feel that under the Bill as it stands, if we were to attempt to collect a levy on such butter a merchant might hold that he had not purchased the butter, and therefore was not liable to the levy. We feel that if there was such a loophole many of the merchants might avail of it to sell butter on commission to farmers rather than purchase themselves and resell it.
Comment on this
I would like to know what is the present intention of the Minister with regard to farm butter. When he introduced the Financial Resolution he more or less, as I remember, indicated that it was not the intention actually to have any levy on such butter. I gathered from the Minister, perhaps wrongly, that he thought that, although certain powers would be taken in the Bill, he would have to leave farm butter out of the scheme, and with amendments like these coming before us, it looks as if the intention is actually to proceed as far as possible with the levy on farm butter. I would like to know what the intention of the Minister, on reconsideration, is.
Comment on this
I might have been misunderstood, but what I really meant when introducing the Bill was that the butter of the farmer who sells to a consumer, or who sells a small quantity to a retailer in a very small business, would not be subject to the levy, but in a case like this, where a butter merchant or a butter factory was buying a considerable quantity of farm butter, we meant, of course, to bring such a transaction under the provisions of the Bill.
Comment on this
Do I understand the Minister correctly when he says that a shopkeeper who purchases farm butter in the ordinary course of his business from the farmer's wife or daughter is to be levied?
Comment on this
He is not to be levied, unless it is his principal business, or he is in a very big business.
Comment on this
That is far too ambiguous. We had better be clear about it. The shopkeeper takes in eggs and butter from farmers, and exchanges them for goods, and that is undoubtedly the main part of his business. His van goes around the country each day, and collects eggs and butter and hands out groceries in lieu thereof. It is unquestionable that buying butter is the principal part of that business, and it follows, of course, that it is part of his business also to sell that butter and those eggs, because he is not going to let them rot in his yard or store. Does the Minister intend to bring these people under the Bill, because I put a question to him on this point when he introduced the Bill originally, and I definitely understood from him that this would not include farmer's butter in any shape or form, so far as taking it into the shops and selling it is concerned. I intended to move the rejection of this, both in its new and in its old form, and I would like definite information from the Minister as to what he means by it, because it will have to be very precise. Every Deputy in this House, who has any knowledge of business in a country town, knows that buying butter, and, ipso facto, selling it, is the principal part of the trader's business, and if this is allowed to remain in the Bill that trader must be caught.
Comment on this
I should like to know from the Minister what class of people he intends to cover by this. As we know, butter blenders have agents in the different towns and villages buying for them in large quantities. Is that the class that is alluded to?
Comment on this
It appears to me that the section as drafted gives the Minister very wide powers, that he can include within the scope of the section any farmer, whether large or small, making butter in his own home. I should like to know from the Minister if this type of farmer will be included within the ambit of the section—a farmer who keeps ten, twelve or fifteen cows, who makes butter at home and sells it to shopkeepers in neighbouring towns? Is it intended that this section should cover that type of butter manufacture, or what exactly does the Minister mean by the small farmer and the large farmer in relation to this section? Presumably it is the intention of the amendment to cover the large type of farmer; I think the Minister said the farmer with 100 or 200 cows. Where does he draw the line between the large and small farmer?
Comment on this
Various examples have been mentioned. The retailer mentioned by Deputy McMenamin is not concerned in this amendment. As a matter of fact, we have full power already under the definition of a trader as altered by an amendment to Section 2, to deal with the person that Deputy McMenamin has in mind, and this amendment has nothing to do with him. This amendment is aimed more against the factory than the farmer. It is aimed to get at the unregistered factory people who might, in order to evade the Bill, say that they did not intend to buy any more butter, but that in future they would sell farmers' butter on commission. That is what we want to get at. It is not aimed at the retailer or the shopkeeper that Deputy McMenamin mentions. That question has been dealt with already. With regard to the question raised by Deputy Roddy, that has reference to the section as it stands, apart from the amendment, and we can discuss that when the section is put.
Comment on this
I want the Minister to apply his mind to this amendment. (Amendment read.) What does the King's English mean? You have not to be a lawyer to see what this means. Does it not mean that an inspector of the Department can walk into a shopkeeper and say: "You are a butter trader and you are caught by that section?" I am prepared to let the matter stand over until the Report Stage in order to have it put in another form with the words "registered premises" in it, which will include separating stations and other places registered in the Department as such. But it is as clear as anything can be in the English language that a Department inspector can walk into a shopkeeper and say: "You are caught under that amendment and you must pay the levy." What we are concerned with is what this means in law or would be interpreted as in court. It does not matter what is intended, but what we have here in the amendment.
Comment on this
We must take what the section is dealing with. The section is dealing with persons not registered. We have already dealt with anybody who was registered. This is to deal with persons not registered.
Comment on this
Then you catch him. That is your whole argument— that you are catching unregistered people.
Comment on this
The Minister stated that he would reply to my question when discussing the section. It seems to me that you can only deal with the section in conjunction with the amendment. As my question has a particular bearing on the amendment, I would be glad if he would reply to it now, and then probably I can offer some suggestion to him afterwards as to how he might get over the difficulty.
Comment on this
I do not exactly know to whom this would apply. It would not apply to blenders, because blenders are exempt under Section 2 (3). Blended butter does not come under the head of manufactured butter at all. The Minister said a moment ago that anybody buying butter on commission for blending afterwards will come under this heading. I do not know how he can, if blended butter is not manufactured butter.
Comment on this
There is nothing about blending here. The case that Deputy McMenamin has in mind has nothing to do with the amendment. If he reads the amendment he will see it says "or disposal of farm butter manufactured by other persons."
Comment on this
The whole thing depends upon what interpretation you put upon the word "manufactured." It all hinges upon that.
Comment on this
The definition of "manufacture" was quoted here by Deputy McMenamin, "the process of blending or re-working in a butter factory." This amendment says, "any person who, on behalf of other persons, carries on..." Does not that rule out the person Deputy McMenamin has in mind? I understand that the person he has in mind buys butter, or exchanges goods for butter, from the producers and sells it again to somebody else, and therefore does not come under the amendment.
Comment on this
Sells to somebody else. Sells in the village or town without selling to what you might call a factory merchant.
Comment on this
There is no definition here of manufactured butter. Manufactured butter may mean anything. The actual making of butter is manufacturing it in the strict sense of the word. Of course, in the sense meant in this Bill it means purchasing butter from a farmer and putting it through some process. That comes under another category of manufacture. The ordinary definition of "manufacturing butter" is making butter out of cream.
Comment on this
I read this section to mean butter other than butter that passes through a butter factory.
Comment on this
The idea is that this levy be collected on butter that passes through a factory. There may be other butter; for instance, merchants in towns might buy a large amount of butter and export it. That butter never passes through a factory. It is to enable the Minister to charge a levy on that butter that the section is intended.
Comment on this
If Deputy McMenamin will read the definition section he will see that creamery butter means butter manufactured on creamery premises; that factory butter means butter which is manufactured in or brought into a butter factory, and farm butter means butter which is manufactured in the Saorstát and is neither creamery butter nor factory butter.
Comment on this
The definition of manufactured butter is rather vague. One might buy from one man a lot of manufactured butter, and from another man another lot of manufactured butter, but if one blends the two butters it would not be manufactured butter according to the definition here.
Comment on this
It might be wiser to leave this section over for reconsideration on Report Stage. I believe there is a flaw in it, and I am sure the Minister, on re-examination of the section, will observe that there is a flaw. It would be more satisfactory to have the section reconsidered.
Comment on this
I want to know from the Minister if he intends his amendment to cover people who act as agents for the large butter factors in the towns and villages?
Comment on this
Has the Minister considered the advisability of introducing the words "purchased from" instead of "manufactured by"? The amendment would then read: "for the sale or disposal of farm butter purchased from other persons."
Comment on this
The amendment is really intended to cover people who do not purchase butter but who sell butter on commission. That is the whole point. I have no objection to leaving the matter over until the Report Stage.
Comment on this
If the people Deputy McMenamin is speaking for, who buy butter in large quantities by way of trade, sell it to a factory, either they or the factory should pay the levy. If they do not sell it to a factory, do they not have the opportunity of selling the butter on the home market and getting the advanced price without paying any levy—the advanced price provided by the artificial increase which is being charged now to the public?
Comment on this
I now see what the Minister is at, but why should it not be plainly stated in the amendment? All he would have to do would be to put in the words "on commission."
Comment on this
"On behalf of" serves the same purpose. I am not as good a lawyer as the Deputy, but I consider the words in the amendment are sufficient, and the draftsman is of the same opinion. I do not mind leaving over this matter until I have an opportunity of consulting the draftsman.
Comment on this
I am agreeable to having this particular point left over until the Report Stage. Deputy Roddy raised a matter on Section 12, apart from the amendment. I indicated at the outset that the section covered the big farmer and the butter factory which is not registered under the Dairy Produce Act but is registered under the Food and Drugs Act. These are two definite classes. We exhausted every other class under previous sections and now we are trying to get those two classes in. So far as the big farmer is concerned, we have not anybody in particular in mind at the moment. I do not think any farmer would be brought under the section, but, just as in the case of other Bills that have been before the Dáil, we always have to think of the possibilities of evasion.
We were accused under this Bill of being altogether favourable to the creameries and not at all favourable to the makers of home butter. Here is a section which shows that we were very much afraid we were going to be too favourable to the maker of home butter as compared with the creameries. If the price of creamery butter is put up by fourpence, as it will be under the Bill, the maker of home butter will get a corresponding advantage of fourpence. The creamery must pay twopence, but the maker of home butter will not pay anything. In case there may be too much of an advantage in that respect, and in case some of the big buyers might find it more profitable to go into the making of home butter, we thought it well to have this power in the Bill. We have not anyone in mind at the present time and the section is put there purely because of the possibility that there may be that danger.
Comment on this
Amendment 22 seems to be like Mahomet's coffin. Is the Minister withdrawing it for the purpose of having it redrafted for the Report Stage?
Comment on this
That would be the best course and, in the circumstances, I will withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 23:
In sub-section (2), page 7, line 37 to insert before the word "There" the words "Subject to the provisions of this Act."
It is merely anticipating amendment 25.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 24:
In page 7, to add at the end of sub-section (4) the following words "in respect of butter acquired for use in a butter factory and the miscellaneous butter account shall be credited with all other moneys received by the Minister under this section."
Those registered in the register of non-manufacturing exporters might be dealing with farm butter as opposed to factory butter and sub-section (4) should give power to put the money into the appropriate fund rather than have all the money put into the one fund.
Comment on this
With regard to Section 15, which deals with the refund of levies on farm butter, I would like to know if any refund is to be given to those who sold butter to the buyers since the introduction of the Bill and who were told that as a result of its introduction 2d. per pound was to be deducted from them. Is there any hope of a refund?
Comment on this
That is not what is meant by the section. What is meant is where a merchant buys butter and pays the levy and afterwards sends the butter to the factory and the factory also pays the levy, we want to ensure that the levy is not paid twice.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 25:—
Before Section 16, to insert a new section as follows—
Where any butter manufactured or acquired by the registered proprietor of registered premises during a levy month is placed in cold store in Saorstát Eireann by such registered proprietor before the date on which, but for this section, the levy on such butter would be payable under this Part of this Act, such levy shall not be payable until the 1st day of March next following such date, unless before such 1st day of March such butter is removed from cold store or sold while in cold store, in which event the said levy shall be payable on such removal or sale, whichever first happens.
Sub-section (3) of Section 9 was deleted, and this is to replace it. Under sub-section (3) of Section 9 provision was made for a postponement of the collection of the levy on creamery butter where such butter would be stored for winter use.
The factories felt that they had the grievance that they were not also included, and this amendment is brought in to give the factories the same rights as the creameries in the matter.
Comment on this
Will the rate of levy be that prevailing at the time of production or that at the time it is taken out of cold storage?
Comment on this
I move:
In sub-section (1), page 8, line 56, to delete the words "butter duty" and substitute the words "rate of the butter bounty payable under this Act on factory butter at the time of importation."
The factories in this country sometimes find it necessary to import butter in order to carry on their trade. Hitherto, at least since the tariff was put on, they were exempt from the tariff in case the butter was again exported after being manufactured. If this section were adopted as it was drafted in the beginning, we would, under it, be removing from them the privilege of importing butter free of import taxes, but we had put on them, however, a levy which was equal to the import duty. They would manufacture that butter, having paid fourpence per pound levy, which would be the same as the import duty. They would, as far as we were able to calculate, only get 2½d. per pound on re-export so they would lose 1½d. on every pound imported under that arrangement. That was naturally unfair, and on reconsideration we have changed that so as to allow them to import butter at the rate of the bounty, so that they would at least lose nothing by the transaction.
Comment on this
I move amendment 27, to delete sub-section (5), and amendment 28, to delete sub-section (7).
It seems to me that this Bill should not interfere with the butter trade to a greater extent than the scheme for which it is introduced renders it necessary. It seems to me that it is quite unnecessary that we should have these powers of prohibition. After all, there is now a tariff on butter coming into the country. It is not proposed, as I understand, in this scheme to raise the price of butter in this country more than 4d. above the world price. As there is this tax on butter imported, there is no danger of imports lowering the price below the world price plus 4d. Therefore it seems to me that it is quite unnecessary to have this power of prohibition of import which is taken in the Bill. Pressure of various kinds may be exerted on the Minister to cause him to prohibit the import of butter—possibly in times of scarcity, when the bounty is not really operating in the country, the winter period—and to have the price of butter raised more than 4d. above the world price. As far as I understand the scheme embodied in the Bill, it was to have the price of butter here, both summer and winter, 4d. above the world price. The power of prohibition would mean that in winter it could be raised very considerably more than 4d. above the world price. It could be raised, in fact, by any particular amount. I did not hear in any of the Minister's speeches, any justification given for taking the power to prohibit. He has not offered any explanation, and in default of some reasons I put these amendments down.
The amendments are to remove the operative portions of the section. I am really, in moving the deletion of the sections, opposing altogether the continuance in the Bill of this particular section. As I say, the Minister may have some explanations to offer, but it seems to me that they would need to be very strong. There is power under the anti-dumping Bill to impose special tariffs if the Minister has reason to fear abnormal imports or if something arose that is not covered by the existing tariff of 4d. The Government has power immediately to take steps to reduce any abnormal imports of butter that might be taking place.
It seems to me that it would be much better to rely on that power, and it is entirely wrong to put into the hands of the Minister the power to prohibit, because prohibition is less desirable than prohibitive tariffs for a number of reasons. If you put on a prohibitive tariff at least everybody is affected, whereas if you prohibit imports, if there is a shortage of supply, you may have to give a licence to individuals or groups of individuals to import, and there will be all sorts of jealousies and hardships in the making of selections of individuals who will get a licence to import where others can not. I would suggest to the Minister that he should accept the amendment, or alternatively let the section drop, and rest on the anti-dumping Bill for power to take special steps rather than take steps to prohibit.
Comment on this
Without expressing any opinion on the proposition of Deputy Blythe, I hardly think that reliance on the anti-dumping Bill would be a safe reliance. Surely it could happen that importers would be gradually filling up the cold stores with butter quite unknown to the Government. It does not seem to be the case that the signs that are supposed to indicate to the Government that abnormal importations are taking place would be evident. You could have over several months slightly abnormal importations, and you could reach a point where you would have practically every cold store filled with butter.
Comment on this
At the same time, if there was any desire to avoid recognition of these abnormal importations it could be very easily effected.
Comment on this
The Deputy does not seem to know what the position is. Normally there will not be importations at all, and I suppose the only thing that the Minister can be guarding against is that when the stores are already filled with butter that may be sold out of them during the winter, some sort of abnormal importations will arise. There can be no question of the stores being gradually filled up with imported butter. The position is that the Minister offers this proposal to the Dáil and we have not had a word yet as to why it was proposed in the Bill, or what danger it is supposed to enable us to avert.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy has anticipated more or less what I intended to say. He sees the danger, apparently, from what he said. We are going to give certain benefits to the creameries and to butter producers in general under this Bill. In return for that we are seeking power in another part of the Bill to compel them, if necessary, to store enough butter for our winter supply. What is more, we are going to compel them to store and to sell under a maximum price. If we do that, we think they are entitled, at least, in return, to have the protection of getting practically that maximum price during the winter months, or as near to it as possible, unless they bring it down by internal competition. The 4d. per lb. tariff is not a very good safeguard at the present time. Looking at the price of butter on the British market even now, and considering the fact that, say, next winter, in all probability, colonial butter may be cheaper than it is at the present time, if it comes down by even 5/- or 6/- per cwt. then it can come in here at a price that will practically break our whole scheme as it stands if it comes in during the winter. If our creameries say to us that they can get 126/- at the present time, and that is putting it fairly low, and we say to them "you must store enough for the coming winter"—next August we may say that to them—they may reply, "Well, if we store, and if we take everything into account—bank overdraft, cost of storage and, perhaps, a certain amount of waste and injury to the butter stored—we would want to be assured that we would get 140/- during the winter months." I think we should be able to give them that undertaking. We could not give them that undertaking unless we could prohibit the import of cheap butter.
We do not intend to use this section unduly. As a matter of fact, the imports of butter during the last two winters have been very small. We would like to have this power to be able to assure the creameries that if we compel them to store they may reasonably expect to be able to get a good price for the butter during the winter.
Comment on this
Certainly the introduction of this scheme produces an entirely new situation. A tariff was put on primarily in order to enable the creameries here to get something more in the winter than they could get in the summer, to justify them in keeping a certain amount of butter off the market in the summer and to store it in the winter, and to give them some little profit for keeping it off the market and storing it. At the best, the intention of the tariff was to enable them during the winter months, for as much as was required for the winter supply, to get 4d. above the world price. But now we are taking steps to get them something above the world price, to get 4d. above the world price in the summer. We intend that the consumer shall have to pay 4d. above the world price summer and winter, and there seems to be no particular reason now why we should induce or persuade the creameries to store for the winter at all. There is absolutely no reason why, if they can get 4d. over the world price in the summer that they could not sell that butter and get the 4d., and allow whatever butter is required to meet the shortage during the winter to be imported, paying as it would the fourpenny tax. That would do no damage so far as I can see. In fact, it would allow people in the winter to buy fresh butter instead of cold-stored butter, and that would be some advantage. In that way the sort of situation that the Minister foresees would not arise.
If there is going to be a fall in winter, then what is going to happen is that in winter we are going to have people paying more than 4d. It amounts to this, that the Minister now anticipates that not only will we have to pay 4d. above the world price in summer, but that we are going to have to pay more than 4d., perhaps 6d., above the world price in winter, and that without any real advantage—in fact, with no advantage at all to the creameries here. I suggest that there has been a failure to adjust our ideas entirely to the new situation that will be brought about by this Bill, that what we ought to do is not to bother any further now about storage for the winter, to give what we say, 4d. all the year round to the butter producers here above world prices, and let the question of imports and exports be regulated by the ordinary conditions of demand and supply. Let the people sell as much as they can advantageously in the summer, and if there is a shortage in the winter, let the people who are importing what is necessary pay the 4d. tariff.
Comment on this
I am afraid Deputy Blythe has forgotten one thing. The key to the whole Bill is the winter storage. Supposing the creameries exported all their butter in the summer, what would they have to get out of the pool? They would have nothing to get. It is the storage in the winter that enables them to get the grant of 2d. they pay in. It is only by the winter storage they can do that.
Comment on this
In connection with the powers that the Minister is taking under this section, I want to put before him the position of creameries in my constituency. There is no cold storage there to any extent nearer than Belfast.
Comment on this
I am opposed to this. It is an attempt in a way to interfere with the creameries in their ordinary routine business. I think it was Deputy Davin who suggested in a recent debate that we should have compulsory powers with a view to bringing about co-operation amongst the creameries. That is resented very strongly by the creameries. This Bill provides them with the means of achieving what they might have achieved by proper co-operation in selling. The Bill, I think, is useful in this way, that it may have the effect of bringing the creameries together eventually in a voluntary manner for their own protection, inasmuch as if they export too much of their butter it will have an effect on their bounty. On the other hand, if they do not export enough it will have another reaction. The Bill itself may eventually lead the creameries and their sellers as a whole to arrange their own business in a proper manner. I think the least Governmental interference there is the better, and for that reason I am rather opposed to this section restricting importation, just as I am to the section restricting exportation.
Comment on this
There is a danger that if this section is enforced it will enable suppliers, more or less, to corner butter and raise the price above what would be the normal price. I think it would be wiser if this section were not enforced. The tariff gives a certain amount of protection and there are, of course, the seasonal imports from countries south of the line. I should be afraid that, if this section were enforced, there would be a likehood of excessive prices.
Comment on this
I suggest that Deputy Brasier should look up the report of the debate when the tariff on butter was at first being imposed. It was asserted from various parts of the House that the price rose from 1/2 per lb. to 1/8 per lb. in consequence of a 4d. tariff.
Comment on this
On the main point, let us assume that butter is sold here and that prices so go down that loss would be entailed to the farmer. In the ordinary way, some information has to come to the Minister to enable him to exercise his powers under Section 19. Would not the same information that would justify him, if the need arose, in issuing a prohibition order under Section 19, enable him to have a proposal made to the Executive Council under the anti-dumping Act, because if you impose an additional tariff you can regulate that additional tariff with reference to the world price of butter? It will affect everybody equally. No difficulties would arise such as would arise under prohibition by giving a particular number of merchants the right to import and refusing others the same right, thus enabling one set of persons to use one class of butter and forcing another set to use another class. Any situation that might arise could be met in a way other than by prohibition. I think prohibition is really the worst way for dealing with each a problem except in very exceptional circumstances. A prohibitive tariff does not raise the type of personal questions which you will have where there is prohibition and licence. Prohibition might carry prices beyond all reason. It might carry them very considerably beyond what is intended when we have the 4d. tariff aiming at 4d. above world prices. I admit that, where butter is stored, circumstances might arise in which you would have to let it get something more than 4d. above the world price. But if we recognise that as a disagreeable necessity, I do not think we should add to it by all the undesirable factors that are connected with prohibition and with the granting of import licences to particular individuals.
Comment on this
Deputy Allen has raised a very important point. If Deputy Bennett were to examine that statement, he would not be against the prohibition of exports and imports. If we were to allow things to take their course, it would probably happen that, instead of exporting 320,000 cwt. of our 640,000 cwts. of creamery butter, we would export 400,000 cwts. and import about 80,000 cwts. during the winter. If we were to allow that to occur, without interfering with exports or imports, the bounty on butter would be three and one-fifth pence instead of fourpence. The finances in this Bill would be altogether different under such free trade. From the financial point of view, we would require to have this power. Whatever we may think about the question of marketing, we should first of all see that our own consumers here are supplied with home butter if they have a preference for it. It is quite evident that they have such a preference. Everybody will have noticed that, during the months of March and April, home consumers bought Irish butter when they could get Danish and New Zealand butter at perhaps 2d. per lb. less. It is evident that our home consumers want Irish butter. If we are to give creameries certain advantages under this Bill, we should see that they supply home consumers with Irish butter during the winter. That means that we must have power of prohibition of exports. If, again, we compel creameries to do that, I think we should be able to assure them that we will not allow dumped or cheap butter in here during the winter, which would put them at a disadvantage regarding their stored butter. I think one of the most necessary things under this Bill is that we should have practically complete control of both exports and imports. If we had not that power, it would be very difficult to work this Bill.
Comment on this
I appreciate the Minis-ter's point and also the point raised by Deputy Allen, that an export of more than half would reduce the advantage to the farmer. But I am opposed to compulsory restrictions on either buying or selling by the creameries. They seem to resent it themselves, and I think the time has not arrived when this House should, even by implication, restrict them. This Bill is built up somewhat on the lines of the suggestions made by the Creamery Managers' Association. They drew up a scheme last year. That scheme was largely on these lines, but they did not in that scheme ask for any restrictions on imports or exports. It seems to me that they do not want such restrictions. Unless we come to the point mentioned by Deputy Davin, when we will have compulsory regulation of the creamery industry, I do not see how we can accept this restriction or the restrictions which occur later in the Bill.
Comment on this
I am opposed to this provision simply because I am opposed to Section 25. I think the discussion on this section must be taken in the light of Section 25 because one section is the counterpart of the other. I am opposing Section 25 because any restriction with regard to the export of butter would be, in my opinion, fatal to the butter trade and fatal to the object of this Bill. If we want to assist creameries to hold the foreign market, we should put them in a position to fulfil their contracts freely and openly. Perhaps the Minister will say, in reply, that he will exercise his power of prohibition of exports with discretion. That is all very well, but if a creamery enters into a contract with a firm in England to supply butter for six or twelve months, it is obvious that it must take into consideration the provisions of this Bill. For that reason, I am opposed also to this section. If there is free importation, there should also be free exportation. If a butter merchant is going to import butter, he will import a cheaper article than is exported. Hence, there is an advantage in importing if, at the same time, we get a higher price for the article we export. These two sections have to be read in connection with one another, because one is the counterpart of the other. I am certainly opposed to giving the Minister any power to prohibit exports, and I think that we should, by some means or another, or by some machinery, provide that our exports of butter are maintained, if possible, during the entire year. I do not mind whether it is cold storage during the winter or otherwise, but some scheme should be adopted by the creameries, whereby they would be in a position to fulfil contracts for export during the entire year, because I feel that it is only by doing that the Irish creameries will ever keep their market.
What kills them at the present moment, to my mind, is that their supply is seasonal, and at the worst time when prices are worst. The proper way would be to put them into the position by a scheme of storage or otherwise, whereby they could fulfil contracts on the export side during the entire year. For that reason, it is necessary that there should be a free passage with regard to imports. If we could import butter cheaper to supply the home demand, and sell our own butter dearer by export, the situation would be helped, and every avenue should be left open and free for the creameries to carry on that business.
Comment on this
Some Deputies want to face both ways at the one time and Deputy McMenamin especially. He wants the Bill and he does not want it.
Comment on this
You either want the machinery necessary for the implementing of this Bill, or you do not want it. The Deputy wants to import butter the full year round and to re-export it again.
Comment on this
I want nothing of the kind. I am not responsible for the Deputy's intelligence. What I said is this——
Comment on this
I want to be clear on what I said. I said that if we were exporting the better article, our own butter, and getting a better price for it, we should do so.
Comment on this
I think that the people of the country will be able to eat our own butter. We were accused, the other day, of giving cheap butter to the British, and now we want to import cheap butter and give the superior butter to the British. Some of the Deputies on the Opposition Benches are trying to face both ways. They remind me of two-headed pennies. It is absolutely necessary to have this machinery in the Bill if it is to be made operative at all. It is quite fair, as the Minister said, that if the creameries are compelled to cold store butter, that cheap butter should not be allowed to come in here and to be sold in winter at a rate under that at which they cold store that butter. That is the position, and that is why it is necessary to have this machinery. Deputy Blythe asked would not the dumping Act be sufficient. It would not, because it might be necessary to break off certain restrictions at a period when it would not be possible to do so under the dumping Act. I understand that if restrictions are put on, they cannot be taken off right away, under the dumping Act, when it might become necessary. The machinery is not as easily used as the machinery asked for here, and I think the Bill would be useless without it.
Comment on this
I think I can understand Deputy Blythe's point. The reason for which he objects to this power is that, in the event of a shortage of home-produced butter in the winter time, it would be possible that the price per lb. here in the Free State would go up to 1/8 or 2/- a lb., whereas the world price of butter on the London market might be only 1/- or 1/2, plus 4d. tariff, making it 1/6, as against, perhaps, 2/- here. I think there is a good deal in his point, and I would like the Minister to consider it. There is also the question to which I alluded when the tariff was imposed, that it was not good policy for the creameries of the Free State to lose contact with the English market. I pointed out on that occasion that if they wanted to compete with foreign competitors, like the Danes and others, it would be necessary to have contact with the British market the whole year round. The advantage of that policy is seen now.
Of course the danger to which Deputy Blythe alludes is somewhat lessened by the power which the Minister has in Section 25, to ensure that there will be a sufficient quantity of butter preserved for the use of the citizens of the State, but there are such things as scares, and there could be such a thing as an artificial scarcity. In that case the price might go up, and I would like to know if the Minister has power to see that the price does not go up unnecessarily above the world price. I am willing to admit that the farmer is entitled to proper remuneration for the work in which he is engaged, but, at the same time, I am out to safeguard the interests of a great many people of this State who will gain no monetary advantage from the provisions of this Bill. For that reason, I think that if the Minister could do something that would secure a price for the farmer, and at the same time ensure that the price of butter does not rise unnecessarily, and especially during the winter months, it would meet the wishes of Deputy Blythe, and the rest of us, who are more or less suspicious of that power.
Again, the question of jealousy would arise. What persons would be entitled to these licences? Who would they be, and what steps would the Minister take to see that, in the event of any scarcity arising here in the winter time, in which it would be necessary to import butter from outside, whatever butter is imported is distributed equally over the whole Twenty-six Counties? There are many points affecting this section, and I think the Minister ought to do something to meet them. I may not be as well acquainted with the dairying industry as many others, but experience has taught me that one thing that must be ensured is constant contact with the British market. That is a matter that has not been accomplished in the past, and it is one which, in my opinion, if the industry is not alone to survive, but to make progress—and I do not see any reason why it should not, in view of the advantages it has— must be attended to to bring about that contact which the industry has not enjoyed in the past, and which alone will enable them to hold their trade.
Comment on this
This is, perhaps, the very worst portion of the Bill. All the machinery of commerce would be held up, and markets that had been made for the export of Irish butter would be lost if there was not continuity of supply. That, perhaps, is one of the secrets of the success of our neighbours, the Danes—that they have been able to maintain supplies right through the year. Was not the aim of the 4d. tariff on butter to bring about winter dairying in this country, and maintain that continuity of supply? I believe more harm will be done to the dairying industry by the inclusion of this particular section than any other part of the Bill, and I feel that very decided injury will be done if it becomes law. Nothing under the sun can do more harm to the men who are exporting butter from this country than to break off their market and their business, which they will never get again once they have refused to supply.
The Minister could not do more injury to these men and to the exports of the country. It is very vital that we should, as far as possible, maintain commercial relations with our principal market. Nothing would certainly take its place. I am absolutely in favour of prohibiting imports as far as we can by the imposition of a tariff and using our own produce, but when it comes to losing the export trade, it is another matter. The Minister has not very much faith in his own Bill when he overlooks the possibility of increasing production here. If there is any merit in the Bill, that is exactly what it will bring about. It was the case in Australia, and certainly I am in hopes that we shall bring about increased production in winter. This is a section which I would ask the Minister not to include in the Bill.
Comment on this
The point which the Minister has not answered is the question of the use of the anti-dumping Act for any emergency that might arise. Deputy Allen spoke about it. I think it is possible to use that Act to meet all the requirements. It is possible under that Act, if it is believed that the duration of the tax should not be long, to make the duration as short as desired. It is possible under it to impose a tax that shall begin as from a certain date and end on a certain date. If the situation still requires it, it will be possible to make a new Order continuing the tax for a further period. In fact, I think it is possible to use that Act in such a way as to have a very flexible means of dealing with the situation—a much more flexible means than is provided in Section 19 of the Bill. Prohibition is a most inflexible thing. It means that you cannot determine effectively how much you are going to let the price go up. If you put a new tariff of 2d. per lb. on to the existing 4d. per lb. you know that the price will not go up more than sixpence beyond the world price. If you prohibit the importation of butter, and this does in fact prohibit it, then you cannot be sure how much it will go up. In order to make any system of prohibition work you would need to have some elaborate machinery, such as does not exist now, for the fair distribution of such butter as you would allow to be imported, because the price will not be very considerable, even allowing for the amount of duty to be paid. You may have the people who are successful in getting an import licence having very substantial advantages over the others who were not selected to get them, and everything as between man and man works out disagreeably.
If you do it by means of a tariff, you do not say that "John O'Donnell" will import butter and "Patrick Smith" will not. You simply put on a tariff to protect the butter in store here to the extent that the situation makes necessary, and you let whoever likes pay the duty and bring in the butter. It is really a much more desirable way. I think what Deputy Allen said about the need for altering the thing within a relatively short period can quite well be overcome by proper drafting of Orders under the anti-dumping Act. It will be easy if the Dáil is sitting, because any Order can be modified by the Dáil and brought up on Report or on a later stage. It can either be increased, reduced or abolished. If the Dáil does not happen to be sitting when the emergency Order is made, then the Order could be drafted so as to operate for a relatively short period, so that if it overran the necessity it could not overrun it very far, and if the necessity outlasted the period of the Order, then a new Order could be introduced. I think the section which says that it shall not be lawful for any person to import into Saorstát Eireann any butter except under licence granted by the Minister is introducing a bad system and, in the circumstances, a quite unnecessary system. We have practically no prohibition of imports now. We deal with the necessity for restricting imports of any particular goods by a tariff, whether high or low, and that is the best way.
Comment on this
I understand that the anti-dumping Act expires in October or November. Suppose the Dáil were to refuse the Minister power to renew this Act for a further period, then you will leave this legislation depending upon whether the House will or will not renew that Act. I think the Minister is right in making provision for this Bill to stand on its own feet. If the Minister is asking the creameries to keep a certain supply of butter for the winter period, it is only fair that he should have the right to see to it that those who keep that supply will be protected. It is altogether wrong to run the risk suggested by Deputy Blythe and others. That power has been taken here on former occasions, and while the power asked for by the Minister may not be necessary to any great extent, I think the Minister is right in asking for it, and that the House is justified in giving it to him.
Comment on this
It seems to me that most of the debate so far has taken place on a later section. I do not want to anticipate that section, but I think the decision on this might reasonably be left over until we discuss the other section, because I think one hinges upon the other to a great extent. I am definitely opposed to the later section. I am not going to discuss it now, although it has been debated extensively on this section. I would, however, like to see the decision on this section postponed until the other one is debated.
Comment on this
This Bill is really an experiment. There are many things in it which some of us do not agree with, but we cannot produce a better alternative. It is going to be experimental for three years, and I think that the control of the butter industry must be kept within the four walls of the measure. You cannot get outside it. I cannot see why the Minister should be in any way restricted with regard to imports or exports. I think the Minister must have control over imports and exports if we are to carry out the idea of the stabilisation of prices for butter. There is another point, which is perhaps more important than any other that I heard so far, and that is, that if the Minister holds control both of imports and exports, absolute control of the whole butter industry which he proposes in the Bill, it is more than likely that those interested in the butter industry, such as the creamery managers and others who cannot agree amongst themselves as to the best method of marketing, with this in the hands of the Minister for a year or two, will awaken to the fact that they will have to do something. Perhaps something will be put up to the Minister after this Bill becomes law which will conduce to the much better marketing of butter, and will inevitably mean the amendment of this Bill or to another Bill being brought in which will be of a much better type. If the results of this measure will be that winter dairying will be taken up—I believe it may result in winter dairying being taken up more generally than it has been in the past—I think it is also necessary that all the powers should be reserved to the Minister in this Bill for the purpose of enabling the people to see exactly where they are in regard to winter dairying and seeing whether it is a feasible thing or not. I do not think it is wise to remove the sub-section which Deputy Blythe has proposed to remove. Neither is it wise to interfere with Section 25. As I said before, the whole control of the butter industry is better within the four walls of this measure than to bring in the anti-dumping Act or anything else to interfere with the first attempt to get real control of one of the most important industries.
Comment on this
Take Section 23 and Section 24 together. Section 24 deals with general exemption licences and Section 23 with special exemption licences. We have discussed at length Section 19, which deals with the prohibition of butter imports. Section 21 practically does the same in regard to dairy produce. Section 22 deals with the penalties to be inflicted in case an order is contravened, and Section 23 deals with the case of licences. Really there are four or five sections dealing with dairy produce for the one dealing with butter, because there are various ways of supplying dairy produce, supplying milk to the creameries, sending cream from a separating station to an auxiliary creamery, and so on. Section 23 deals with special import licences for dairy produce.
Comment on this
I move:—
In sub-section (1), page 11, to insert at the end of the sub-section the words "generally or butter of a specified class."
There has been some discussion on the general provisions of the section with regard to the restriction on the export of butter. I think I have already referred to the two or three occasions on which we may possibly find it necessary to introduce a certain amount of inducement to creameries to store. We may possibly find it necessary to use some compulsion. As the section stands without amendment we would practically have to prohibit exports completely, that is to say, issue a Prohibition of Exports Order applying to creamery butter, factory, and all other butter, while, probably, we would have only one class of butter in mind—creamery butter. We might not have any reason whatever for interfering with the export of factory butter. By inserting this amendment it will be possible to make an Order referring to a particular class of butter.
Comment on this
I am opposed to the section largely for the reasons I gave on Second Reading. I am also opposed to the views expressed by Deputy O'Hanlon a moment ago. Deputy O'Hanlon suggested that we should give the Minister powers within the four walls of the Bill to regulate the control of this industry in toto. If the House is prepared to give the Minister that power which is tantamount to the suggestion of Deputy Davin that we should impose compulsion on creamery managers and proprietors of butter factories as to how to regulate their business, well and good. Creamery managers themselves, however, as a body, are largely opposed to it. The various creameries, as far as I have been able to interpret their wishes, are opposed to any compulsion in the carrying on of their business. Part 5 of the Bill, particularly the first section, which is the key to the whole Bill, gives the Minister power to step in at a very vital part of the dairying industry and to make a break in the continuity of all butter supplies in the British market when, and as often as, the Minister likes with, perhaps, some regard to the convenience of the exporters.
That would be a very dangerous principle to adopt. Our difficulty in competing with foreigners in the British market has always been that we have never for a good part of the year been able to maintain our supplies. This provision gives the Minister power to make a break in our regular supplies at any time of the year when there is a tendency to export too much butter. As I say, it is a dangerous principle to adopt. I have as much evidence as anybody in the House that the creamery managers are definitely in opposition to it. I said on the Second Reading that a considerable portion of our butter is sold on a semi-contract system. That is, somebody or other arranges with the big English customer to supply him for the greater part of the year with butter. How is he to enter into a contract for the supply of that butter if he is subject to the provisions of this Bill, when the Minister might possibly step in at any time and prohibit his exports? There are, of course, in a subsequent section powers for special licences and for the revocation of special licences if they are granted, and this will be altogether confusing, and it will be impossible for anybody attempting to make a contract.
Outside a contract it is still more dangerous inasmuch as it would break our supplies in the British market at any time, and the breaking of continuity of supply of our creamery produce in the British market will place us in a less advantageous position than that occupied by our competitors there. Unless we accept the principle that we are going to have compulsory control of the creamery industries—and the creameries are against that—I do not see how we can accept this section. I am in opposition to it.
Comment on this
This section is another key to the powers sought in the Bill. In effect it aims at organising the butter industry on a commercial basis. I do not see the slightest danger in giving those powers to the Minister or to the Department. If the butter industry had been properly organised it could have taken these powers to itself long ago. There is less danger with these powers in the Minister's hands—in the hands of any Minister for Agriculture—than in the hands of the butter industry. There would be far more danger, if they were in the hands of the butter industry, if it were highly organised, that all those happenings referred to by Deputy Bennett would come about. The same would apply to other departments of the agricultural industry. In no department has the agricultural community been successful in organising itself on a commercial basis. This is a start, so that one section may be organised.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Allen misses the whole point. A certain power is given to the Minister. Let us assume a creamery has sufficient butter in cold storage or, by means of a fresh supply during the entire year the creamery manager is able to fulfil a contract. What will be the position of that man if he is foolish enough to enter into a contract? He may lay himself open to a law suit. The Minister may say "No; I would not issue an order in that case." Assume all the merchants enter into contracts and the Minister finds it necessary to issue a prohibition order. Against whom is he to issue it? Which of the contractors will he select?
I suppose Deputy Allen will tell me that we should eat our own butter. Of course we should, but this is a business matter, and the idea is to fulfil a contract without any danger to the contracting party. Assume it is necessary to import butter in order to export it for the purpose of annual contracts. I say import it and fulfil your contract and maintain the continuity of supply in the export market if possible. There may, unfortunately, be periods when one would have to import, but it is not likely that any merchant in the Free State is going to export butter at a cheaper price than he would get in the home market. Merchants are not so patriotic as all that. I am opposed to this section.
Comment on this
I would like to ask the Minister if it is not a fact that the percentage of Irish butter exported to the British market is only a fraction over 4 per cent. of British imports of butter and the exports of creamery butter are a fraction under 3 per cent. There is a lot of talk about the continuity of the export trade and this will show the importance of it. I should like further to ask if it is not a fact that this Bill is primarily introduced in an endeavour to help the dairy farmer. The dairy farmer would not find a place in the market if it were not for the artificial assistance which he has got. He would be getting about 7d. a lb. for creamery butter; that is the price he would be getting for his milk. Is it not also a fact that the tendency of all agricultural products is downwards, that the supply is more than the demand can absorb at an economic price to the producer? The discussion in this House concerns petty details and I am of the opinion that that discussion should be curtailed by Deputies themselves. The Minister should be given the opportunity that Deputy O'Hanlon referred to a while ago.
Comment on this
I consider this section is of the utmost importance to the Bill. Having agreed to the section earlier in the Bill giving power to the Minister to prohibit the imports of butter, if we now refuse power to the Minister to ensure that a sufficient supply of butter is retained in the country, what position do we leave the consumers in? I was rather surprised at Deputy Bennett's attitude on this section, seeing that he was in agreement with the earlier section.
Comment on this
I understood the Deputy was. In any case, the House having agreed to the earlier section, I am sure that Deputy Bennett will agree that it is necessary this section should be retained. What does it seek to do? It seeks to ensure a necessary supply of butter in the country for the people. That may be secured without this clause, but on the other hand, it may not. There is nothing to prevent the exporters of butter taking advantage of all the encouragement they are getting on their exports, pocketing the profits and leaving the country at the disadvantage of an insufficient supply. Since no outside butter is to be imported, what position are we going to leave the consumers in?
This section is necessary because it will compel those engaged in the production of butter to ensure that the needs of the people are satisfied. Let them take what action they like, active co-operation or anything of that sort, but it is very necessary to ensure that the interests of the consumers are not exploited by individual creamery concerns interested only in the making of money for their own advantage. Deputy McMenamin says there is a terrible danger that we may lose contact with our markets across the water. Continuity of supply may be a good thing, providing it is profitable to the producer. We have reached a stage now when continuity of supply is no longer a big issue. What is far more important to us is the existence of the industry itself in such a position that it will supply the needs of our own people. It is with the end in view of doing that, of improving the dairying industry of the country, that this Bill was introduced, and I can see no danger arising in that direction. I believe the Bill will result in increased production, sufficient to meet the entire demands of our own people liberally, summer and winter, plus sufficient for an increased export trade. That will ensure continuity of supply on much better terms than the exemption of this clause would, because that would have the effect of placing consumers in this country at the disadvantage of having no butter supply during certain periods of the year.
Comment on this
I do not see that there would be any gain by having the section altered. We never had continuity of export in this country. We lost our contacts with English firms year after year. I think the first duty of the Minister is to see that sufficient butter is kept in the country now that the import of butter is prevented. It is clearly the duty of the Minister to the consumers of this country to see that a sufficient supply of butter is kept in cold storage to meet the winter demand.
In dealing with the question of cold storage, I would appeal to the Minister to use all his power and influence to see that cold storage facilities are available in every part of the country. The position with regard to the Co. Tipperary is that we have to send our butter to Dublin, Cork or Waterford to be cold stored. We have to pay railway carriage on it there, and pay the owners of the cold store for keeping it. We have to pay again when it is being brought back, with the result that our people have to pay a very enhanced price for butter in the spring months. I would ask the Minister to see that the butter, when cold stored, will be kept as near as possible to the consumers. I think it would possibly do no harm, from any angle, to leave the section as it stands. Changing it will not, in my opinion, do any good to the dairy farmer.
Comment on this
I would like to know from the Minister if, in framing the section, he had before him the 1923 Butter Cold Store Order, and if he remembers the evil consequences that resulted from the enforcement of that Order in the butter trade generally?
Comment on this
I think the objection to this section is very largely the objection: that was urged to a previous section: that is, that it is not automatic as between individuals, that it means that the Minister has got to cut in at some time when the export trade seems to him to render it necessary. He is going to be obliged to cut in in a way that will affect different creameries differently. He is going to do something that will probably be injurious to one creamery and quite harmless to another. It would be better, I think, if the Minister feels that any adjustments are necessary either in regard to bounty dates or bounty rates, dates or rates of payment of levy, that he should try and get a system that would secure what he desires automatically; that once he has made an Order he should not have to interfere with the trade of individual creameries or individual exports. There are people who will very definitely be injured if an export Order is suddenly imposed, while there will be other creameries whose trade will be such that they will not have to bear that particular burden at all.
A thing like this would be quite easy to operate if you had some central system of selling. In that case the order would really apply and would be operated through some central body, and the effects of it, whatever they were, would be pooled. But what is proposed here is a system that will allow exports to go on until the Minister feels that the situation is alarming. Then he has to come in with an export order, preventing the export of all creamery butter. The Minister, I think, will be able to see himself how unfairly that might operate in certain circumstances. Presumably that order is going to be inflexible. It is going to mean total prohibition at whatever stage he puts it on. Probably that will mean that too much is kept. In order to get rid of that possibility of excess, provision is made in a later section to give special export licences to particular individuals.
I think this whole system of prohibition and export licences is going to give a tremendous lot of administrative trouble. It is going to cause a great deal of uneasiness and bitterness from time to time in the country. It will be impossible to prevent very strong feelings of injustice arising, and my own belief is that the objects the Minister desires to obtain may be perfectly well obtained by other types of machinery. I think he should be prepared to adopt that other type of machinery so that his Department will not have to be continually making a choice between individuals. The Minister himself can, I think, foresee the terrible difficulties and dangers even that surround one when dealing with the trade of a country along the lines apparently that it is contemplated to deal with it here.
Comment on this
I would like to know if any Deputy has any creamery or exporter in mind who maintains contracts the whole year round? It has been put up to us that the big danger in this is that it is going to mean the breaking of these continuous contracts. I have heard of a few individual creameries that have exported a very small amount of butter last winter, but would any creamery maintain a contract throughout the last two years and sell butter on the British market at, say, 110/- when it could get 150/- here through the tariff system? I have heard of no continuous contracts being maintained during the last two years. Yet we are accused in this Bill of going to break these imaginary contracts.
Then we are faced with a hypothetical poser from Deputy McMenamin: Supposing every one has contracts, how are we going to deal with them; supposing some have contracts to supply the home market and others the foreign market, how are we going to deal with them? Quite obviously we would pick out the people supplying the home market and say to them: "You are supplying the home market, and make sure you are going to supply it the whole year round." If that was not sufficient, we might go to the others and try to deal with them as equitably as possible. I do realise that there will be a certain amount of trouble under this section, but without it the whole scheme would be defective.
We will probably adopt the suggestion of Deputy Blythe, that is, to vary the bounty to a certain extent, and try to get the creameries, by showing them that the difference between the price they would get by exporting and the price they might expect to get by storing, would be sufficient to induce them to store without any compulsion. We think it necessary to have this power of compulsion, so that if we want it we can use it. I hope myself it will not be necessary to use that power, but I think it is well that we should have it.
Comment on this
Question put: "That Section 25, as amended, stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment 30:
In sub-section (1), page 11, to insert at the end of the sub-section the words "to which such order relates."
This is a consequential amendment on amendment 29.
Comment on this
I do not propose to move them, partly because the matter has been decided on the vote just taken, and also, partly because I am, to a very large extent, satisfied by what the Minister has already said, when he indicated that he was prepared to use other means towards achieving the purpose of amendment 25, before resorting to prohibition and that his policy was to use prohibition as a last resort, and not merely as the first method in the event of the failure of persuasion.
Comment on this
Before moving this, I would like to have your ruling on amendment 36, because I only put down amendment 33 as a second best to be moved, as I understood that there was a danger of amendment 36 being ruled out of order. If it were not ruled out of order, I would not move amendment 33.
Comment on this
Amendment 36 makes mandatory what is left to the option of the Minister in amendment 33, and it seems to me to be out of order, as outside the scope of the Bill, as read a second time. In private discussion with the Deputy, I suggested a compromise which he has embodied in amendment 33, and I am allowing that amendment for the purpose of having the question discussed in the only possible way it can be discussed, consistent with the principles of the Bill. I am ruling amendment No. 36 out of order.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 33 in the hope that, not merely will the Minister accept it, or accept the principle of it, but that he will express to the House his determination, if the amendment is passed, to make use of the powers that this particular amendment would give him. It would be easy, I know, for the Minister to accept the amendment, and to take no further action on it, and although the Bill would have been altered, the position would not really have been altered at all. The purpose of the amendment is to enable the Minister, and to induce the Minister, to take active steps to bring about the establishment of a central marketing organisation here. It might have been argued quite rightly in the past, that the establishment of a central marketing organisation was not really the Minister's business; that while it might be correct for the Minister to argue in favour of such an organisation, it was not his business to take any steps to bring it about; that the creamery industry should organise its own marketing in the way that every other industry organises its marketing, and that the Minister should not try to show them how to do their business, or interfere with the manner in which they were doing it, but the introduction of the Bill seems to me to introduce an entirely new situation, because the Bill asks the consumer to pay a very substantial subsidy for a period, at any rate, to the creamery industry, and if the general consumer is paying that substantial subsidy to the creamery industry, then, the general consumer, acting through the Minister, is entitled to take steps to see that the proper results are got from this large sum which the Minister says will be round about half a million—and I think it would be more.
It would certainly be a terrible thing if the consumer was obliged to pay this very large sum in cash through the extra price of butter, and if, as a result of that, the industry got very little benefit, and that the price cutting, which frequently has damaged Irish butter on the British market, was intensified, so that the price that the consumer in England would pay would be actually lower than it would be if this Bill were not introduced. I believe there would be very grave danger that the introduction of this Bill, if further steps are not taken, would result in some subsidy being given to the British consumer, and would result in price cutting being carried so much further that the English consumer would get his Irish butter some fractional amount cheaper than he would have got it if the Bill had never been introduced. We know that there was an attempt a few years ago at the establishment of a central marketing organisation, and that, in fact, such an organisation was brought into being and operated for a period. So far as anybody outside can gather, it appeared that the reason for that organisation finally collapsing was that it failed to gain the support of the whole of the industry.
When the I.A.C. was being formed and meetings were held, almost all the co-operative creameries attended the meetings and expressed their approval of the principle of an organisation, and expressed their readiness to co-operate in the formation of a central marketing organisation, but, as the work progressed, it was found that a considerable number of these creameries would not actually become members of the I.A.C., and would not sign contracts to sell their butter through it, so that the new organisation started work with only about 80 per cent. of the creameries as members and selling through it, and with only about 60 per cent. of the butter being sold through it.
I believe that during the period that organisation operated it really did confer benefits on the creamery industry. But, if it was able to confer benefits on the creamery industry as a whole, the creameries which remained outside the association were, in many instances, able to get all the benefits that members were able to get, without bearing any of the expense of maintaining the organisation. In certain cases they were able to get greater benefits, because where pooling has to take place, as it has in such a scheme, a particular creamery manager in the organisation is never able to get the advantages of the day-to-day fluctuations. A really good manager outside, when you have an organisation preventing the market being broken, as this organisation would do, can get the advantages of the market being maintained, and can get all sorts of other advantages by pushing English butter in places where the organisation thinks it desirable to keep the supplies as moderate as possible, and by taking advantage of the day-to-day fluctuations. So that I think certain individual creamery managers were able to show better results than their neighbours who were in the organisation, though not better results than they themselves would have obtained if the organisation had not been in being. They were in that happy position outside that they got all the benefits, and they were able to take advantage of any chance opportunities of doing better, and they had not to bear any of the costs.
Naturally, in the establishment of a central marketing organisation, you do come up against the individualism of the creamery manager. You will find large numbers of them who have the instinct for buying and selling and who really prefer to do their own marketing. They will get more satisfaction in taking a trifle less and selling themselves than by getting something more and selling through a central marketing organisation. You had managers who remained outside, and who got the advantage of the work of the Association, boasting of how much better they had done than others who were inside. Consequently, you had from the beginning, as a result of this failure to get the whole of the creameries into the organisation, a widespread propaganda against the central marketing organisation going on. You had new dissatisfaction being created; you had all the unreasonableness that will arise in the working of a new scheme, and you had the failure to recognise difficulties. You had the people wanting all the advantages and refusing to submit to any of the disadvantages. It became apparent, very early in the work of the organisation, even apart from certain losses that arose, as I believe, through a misguided policy, that the organisation was not going to be able to stand the acid criticism from outside. There was nothing to help the organisation. The people who went in had to bear the burdens, and they could get nothing better than those who remained outside.
The Minister, if he accepts this amendment, will have machinery to make it possible to have a new organisation established and to give it support. That will prevent the criticism and individualism which operated in the past from undermining it. I think the Minister should accept the amendment and make up his mind to employ the pressure or offer the inducements that are possible under this amendment in order to ensure that the creameries would come together again and that a new organisation would be established in which all concerned can profit by the lessons of the previous attempt and avoid any of the errors made previously.
It is quite clear, as Deputy Davin said yesterday, that the individualism that characterised the marketing of Irish butter in the past is out of date. I believe it is true that great improvements can be effected by an efficiently-conducted marketing organisation which will be so supported that the energy of the managers and officials will not be taken up fighting enemies in the Saorstát. I do not think I need go into the things that were attempted, and, I believe, to a large extent accomplished, by the organisation that was established. They are apparent. Everybody knows that the practice of undercutting in quotations is rampant; that if a manager wants to sell and hears that the next creamery is selling at a certain price you will find him cutting it by 1/-, quite unnecessarily dropping prices, in a way which would not occur if there were a central organisation. Of course, there is the whole question of getting into districts where Irish butter is not largely sold. There is the question of not having excessive amounts sent out. There is the whole question of organising transport, transit, cooling, chilling and so on, all of which can be undertaken by a central organisation, but which are impossible for an individual creamery. The opportunity is put into the hands of the Minister and the Department by this amendment and without it I think that difficulties of all sorts will be occasioned in the operation of the Bill. We have heard talk about the prohibition of exports and imports. The whole question of supply could be much more satisfactorily arranged if the Minister had one central organisation to deal with. He could enforce his requirements through that organisation in such a way as not to cause hardships to individuals, and not to oblige him to make a choice between individuals in respect of imports or exports.
I believe that the machinery of the Bill, even for the bare purpose of the Bill itself, is incomplete without a central marketing organisation, and that if we have not this organisation we will have, to an undue extent, the operation of the psychological factor which is always present when there is an export bounty. Because of this tendency to competition, we will have people who have the bounty of 4d. on export cutting prices beyond reason or necessity, and we will have, in fact, a loss to the country of a considerable proportion of the large sum which is going to be taken from the private consumer.
The amendment if accepted does not oblige the Minister to take any rash measures, but it does enable him to send, if he chooses, for such representatives of the industry as he likes and to inform them that it is their duty to take steps to organise their marketing centres and to inform them further that he has now a weapon in his hands which he proposes to use in case the industry does not itself act without pressure. I believe he would be justified in the interest of the country from every point of view in using the instrument which this amendment will put in his hands for the purpose of bringing this organisation about. I think that without pressure from the Minister it is hopeless to expect that any steps will be taken in the industry. There may be differences of opinion as to whether the attempt to form the I.A.C. was premature or not but the fact that the attempt was made and that the organisation had to be wound up would make the difficulty of a new start, without support from the Minister, such that no group of people could undertake the labour and the propaganda that would be involved and the criticism and attacks which would certainly follow, as can be clearly seen by the criticisms that have been levelled in the past.
Comment on this
I would urge the Minister to accept this amendment, because it appears to me that the establishment of some kind of selling agency is a natural corollary to the passing of the Bill into law. We heard a great deal, not alone in the Dáil but outside it, about the work of the I.A.C., and I think the Minister himself stated a week or two ago in this Dáil, in reply to Deputy Davin, that the failure of that organisation was due mainly to the opposition of the creamery management. I assume there is still a section of the creamery managers opposed to the establishment of any such organisation at the present time. I know that such opposition does exist and that there was a feeling in the past that the business of selling was a matter entirely for the creameries themselves. I quite agree that if the position were quite normal the business of selling should be left in the hands of the creameries, but the position is not normal and it is getting more abnormal day by day.
It appears to me now that if the industry is to survive at all, the State will have to interfere to a larger extent than it has interfered up to the present, and that not alone must it have control to a greater extent over the actual production of butter, but it will have also to interfere in the selling of butter outside the country. Some of the arguments used against the establishment of a central selling agency were that it would not have the effect of altering the international price level because of the very small amount of butter we export from this country. I quite admit, of course, that it would not have the effect of altering the international price level in the slightest, but it would certainly have the effect of stabilising the price of butter exported from the country. It would prevent the possibility of the occurrence of any wide divergences between the price received by one creamery and the price received by another.
At the present time the creameries are entirely at the mercy of the wholesalers on the other side, and, as a matter of fact, opportunities of selling butter on the other side are gradually lessened because of the growth of big combines or the number of big firms. The purchasing in such cases is done through one combine or through one central house. It is quite inevitable in conditions such as these that Irish creamery butter should stand very little chance of commanding a fair competitive price as compared with butter from New Zealand, Australia or Denmark, which butter is sold through highly organised agencies in London. The Minister in this Bill has an opportunity of establishing some form of selling agency. I think the Minister himself does favour the establishment of such an agency. I am quite sure that a big number of creamery managers throughout the country, and certainly quite a number of people very much interested in the development of the creamery industry, are satisfied that it is necessary that such a selling agency should be established. I realise the difficulties in the way of the Minister. I realise that an agency of that kind cannot be established at once. I realise that the Minister will have to overcome certain very big difficulties before he does succeed in getting such an agency actually working, but I do say that the existence of such an agency is absolutely necessary in the interests of the industry itself, that if it is to survive some such selling agency will have to be established. I cannot see any possibility of the establishment of such an agency without the interference of the Minister and without a very large measure of control by the Minister himself. I hope he will avail of the opportunity presented to him by this Bill to see that such a selling agency is established. I hope for that reason he will accept the amendment proposed by Deputy Blythe.
Comment on this
Deputy Blythe gave us to understand that he would have preferred to move amendment No. 33 were it not that the Ceann Comhairle ruled it out of order. That was asking me to bring in a central marketing scheme before June 30th. I must say that the confidence that is shown in my ability to do this is rather embarrassing. I think the ability of my predecessor, Deputy Hogan, was not under-rated by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party and considering that Deputy Hogan made various attempts at this scheme for a number of years, if they have confidence in my ability to establish it in four or five months, I must say I am highly complimented. However, I do not think that I will be able to bring it about in four or five months. I assume that if I were to follow on with the work carried on by Deputy Hogan and his predecessors in getting the creamery business organised properly, it must eventually come to central marketing. I say, however, that under this Bill practically nothing can be done in that way. Take for example, if I were to issue an order stating that I would give a special rate of 4d. to those who would join a central marketing organisation and that to those who did not join I would only give 2d. What would happen? Supposing even 90 per cent. joined the central selling organisation and that only 10 per cent. remained out, would the 10 per cent. not sell all their butter in the home market? They would be no worse off in that way by remaining outside the central selling organisation and we would get nowhere. Therefore under this Bill I see very little hope of doing anything.
I do certainly agree with the principle of central marketing. Looking at it from a detached and general point of view it must be sound. I will go further and say if you want to proceed with co-operation the logical step in co-operation would be combined marketing. If you want to push the idea of the organisation of co-operative creameries to a logical conclusion we must have central marketing in the end. Deputy Blythe referred to the effects of central marketing in this country. It was tried in 1928 and a very large proportion of the creameries, numerically speaking, joined that organisation, but in volume of butter output of course it was not as big. At any rate a large number joined and at the time I think a very good case could be made for the Government compelling those who remained outside to come in if the Government of the time were keen on central marketing. That was not done. As Deputy Blythe says when there is a scheme of central marketing we will always have individuals who remain outside reaping certain benefits that are there because of the central marketing and because they can get these benefits, they are able to turn to their supporters and their admirers and say: "I did better than the central marketing." They are always able to make a case like that; that is only natural. In certain countries, when 75 or 80 per cent. join a central marketing organisation, there is a law to compel the remainder to come in.
There are certain individuals who are good marketers and who, perhaps, have a reputation for having good produce. I am sure we have such in this country. We probably have creamery managers who are very good at marketing, who have a reputation for good produce and are able to get a better price than the general price ruling. They will naturally be opposed to central marketing because they will lose, at least for a while. That loss would possibly be temporary and if central marketing was a success, as it should be if everybody was in it, possibly even the best marketers would benefit by going into it. For a while, anyway, we will find it hard to get certain individuals to come in.
On another occasion it was mentioned that we were losing considerably by not having a central marketing organisation. It was said of our creameries that they were inefficient and not able to get their price because they could not do things as well as Denmark. You will find that is not true. The working expenses of the creameries here are very little higher than in Denmark, about one shilling a cwt. We find that in regard to marketing expenses there is not a big margin of difference. When we come to put up arguments to people in the creamery business we find that the arguments are not as strong as we believed.
I believe there would be an advantage in central marketing, but we cannot do anything under this Bill. There is a considerable amount of distrust and suspicion of central marketing amongst people in the creamery trade, and if we can give them a little time to get over that it will be all to the good. We shall have an Advisory Committee appointed to advise the Minister with regard to the working of this Bill. That Committee will give practically its whole time to marketing. This Bill deals with marketing. The Committee will be representative of the creamery industry, the factory butter industry and others. The Committee will direct its whole attention towards getting the best price for butter. I think they will examine the whole position of central marketing and I think they should get an opportunity of considering that position with a view to finding out what can be done. I am sure they will give it the greatest possible consideration.
Amendment 33, which is proposed here, is more in the nature of a permissive amendment than a compulsory amendment and I do not see any objection whatever to accepting it. To be really on the safe side, I will ask the Deputy to withdraw the amendment until the Report Stage in order to see if it is absolutely right from the drafting point of view.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 37.
In page 12, to add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
"(4) The creamery butter account shall be debited with all moneys paid by the Minister under this section in respect of creamery butter, the factory butter account shall be debited with all moneys paid by the Minister under this section in respect of factory butter, and the miscellaneous butter account shall be debited with all moneys paid by the Minister under this section in respect of farm butter."
In this instance a sub-section has fallen out of its proper place. Sub-section (4) to Section 30 should really be sub-section (4) to Section 29. This amendment makes the necessary change.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 38.
To delete sub-section (4).
I explained the position on the last section.
Comment on this
On Section 31, I would like to point out to the Minister that there is a limited time within which the levy must be paid. There is no obligation on the Minister to pay the bounty within a limited time. He can hold up the bounty as long as he wishes. Would it not be better if there were a definite period within which the minister should be satisfied that the obligation of the Act are complied with and the bounty then paid? The reason I make the suggestion is that there will be a lot of capital held up belonging to creameries and butter exporters. There will be a lot of money out while they are awaiting payment of the bounty.
Comment on this
It will be difficult to amend the Bill so as to compel the Minister to pay the bounty within a certain time. As soon as the Minister is satisfied, the bounty will be paid.
Comment on this
The Minister, I am sure, sees the point I have raised. I am raising it only as a matter of interest.
Comment on this
I do see the point. It is hard to foretell how long it might take before the bounty can be paid. As soon as the regulations are prescribed we will be in a better position to see when it can be paid. Ordinarily, it would be paid immediately the conditions are complied with.
Comment on this
If it be at all possible I would suggest to the Minister that the bounty payments should be made to the creameries about the time of the month they send out the cheques to their ordinary suppliers. If that could be done, it would give great satisfaction. It would be well if the payments could be made about the 14th or the 15th of the month, when the creameries themselves send out their cheques.
Comment on this
I move amendment 39:
At the end of sub-section (1), line 10, to add the words "(e) cheese."
So far as I can see, cheese is the only milk product excluded from the scope of the Bill. There is a good deal of cheese manufactured in the country. The Shandon Dairy Co. of Dungarvan are fairly large makers of cheddar cheese. They have a good export trade. The cheese they make is of excellent quality. I think the manufacture of cheese should be encouraged, especially of the cheddar variety. The cheese made here is much better than some of the imported cheese. The creameries of Killenaule, in the County of Tipperary, and Lissard, in the County of Cork, are also cheese makers. Many of the creameries could get into the manufacture of cheese if some encouragement was given to them under this Bill.
Comment on this
From inquiries we have made, the position with regard to the amount of cheese at present made in the country is that it is not at all equal to the home requirements, even though we do not consume very much cheese compared to other countries. The cheese produced here, I understand, is of only one or two varieties. There are many kinds of cheese coming into the country which would not be produced here. I agree with the Deputy that we should encourage the production of cheese as much as possible. We should encourage any milk product that we can make here, so as to help the milk industry. The Deputy will see that we are taking power in the Bill to include any milk product at any time. We can put cheese on the list at any time that a case is made to us. I want to assure the Deputy that I have every sympathy with his amendment, but I would prefer to leave this to the Advisory Committee that is to be appointed. I feel that if a reasonable case can be made for it the Committee will perhaps include it.
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy Doyle, I move amendment 40a:—
"At the end of sub-section (1), line 10, to add the following new paragraph:
‘(e) any milk product used in the manufacture in Saorstát Eireann of any other article of food which is subsequently exported.'"
The purpose of the amendment is to arrange for a drawback similar to the drawback arranged in respect of any dutiable article which either is reexported or is used in an article which is exported.
Comment on this
Would that amendment require to be elaborated to read: "Where the Minister is satisfied that any butter or any other milk product...."?
Comment on this
There would be very great difficulty in including "other than butter" under manufactured articles exported. We would be able to check the amount of butter going into a biscuit or a chocolate factory, but it would be very difficult to check the amount of cream or whole milk going in. I think it would be impossible to keep a check on"other than butter."
Comment on this
This is a very important question in view of the quantity of butter used by a certain factory, I do not know what the figure would be, but they must use a large quantity of butter annually. Take it that they buy butter at 4d. per lb. extra and that it is used in the biscuits and cakes they export to other countries. These biscuits and cakes will be competing against biscuits and cakes made of butter purchased at the world price. That will necessarily mean that the Irish firm will be placed at a big disadvantage.
Comment on this
I think the Minister's subsequent amendment will cover the matter. I do not know whether he has any means of enquiring whether there would be any substantial quantity of other milk products used in manufactured goods intended for export. I do not know whether the question of cream is of any substantial importance or not. The Minister would probably have the means of finding out, but if it were it would be worthy of consideration.
Comment on this
As far as I can make out, in the good class sweets and chocolates they use butter to a certain extent, and, of course, in biscuits. Other milk products would not be used in the best class manufactures.
Comment on this
I move amendment 41:
In sub-section (1), page 13, line 29, to delete the words "per pound."
This is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment 42, as follows:—
To delete sub-section (2) and substitute the following sub-sections:—
(2) Until regulations are made under this section prescribing the rate at which bounties are to be paid under this Part of this Act in respect of bulk cream, the rate per pound of the butter equivalent of bulk cream shall be twopence.
(3) Until regulations are made under this section prescribing the rate at which bounties are to be paid under this Part of the Act in respect of any milk product (other than bulk cream) the rate per pound of the butter equivalent of such milk product shall be twopence.
This amendment is designed to give us power to make regulations which will deal separately with the items referred to rather than to deal with them all on the same basis.
Comment on this
I oppose the section. Part 7 of the Bill, for some reason, purports to give a bounty of a penny per lb. on cream and 2d. per lb. on other milk products.
Comment on this
I should have explained that. If the Deputy looks at the amendment recently circulated, he will see that the amount is 2d. on everything.
Comment on this
That is not my point. In this part of the Bill, the Minister proposes to pay a bounty on cream and milk products, and there is no provision for a levy. Under Section 35, this is to be charged on the butter bounty. Am I correct in that?
Comment on this
Surely the Minister should make some provision to save himself in that respect. I could not put in an amendment for the simple reason that this is a money matter. I want to know what the Minister proposes to do. Does he propose to amend the Financial Resolution? So far as I can see, this is to be charged on the butter fund without any compensation. If a creamery wants to make money, it will start to export cream and other milk products, because it will not have to pay any levy. Am I correct in that?
Comment on this
Something must be done to protect the creameries who are going to make butter. The Minister must amend his Financial Resolution authorising him to impose the levy or put in another sub-section in this section authorising him to make a levy on these products. If that is not done, the butter trade will be ruined. The creameries will start to export cream or milk products and get the bounty without paying any levy.
Comment on this
I support the suggestion made by Deputy McMenamin. Has the Minister calculated this matter closely? Take the figures for 1930. The suggested bounty on exported cream, condensed milk and dried milk would be £116,000. That would be more than one-fifth of the amount coming from the 4d. per lb. on creamery butter exported during the same year. This bounty will come out of the creamery account, and assuming that exports equal the exports for 1930 how could the creameries exporting only butter get 4d. per lb.? There would not be sufficient money to pay it.
Comment on this
In opposition to that, suppose we were to give no bounty on the export of cream or milk products, is it not quite evident that they would all go into the production of butter, and that the bounty would have to be paid on the butter exported, so that it would come to the same thing? The exporter of cream and whole milk is going to get 2d. and to pay nothing. That is a net 2d. The exporter of butter pays 4d. and gets back 2d. That is a net 2d. They will all have a net 2d. If we did not give anything to exporters of cream or milk products, these would probably be all turned into butter and exported and the money would come out of the same pool. If we saw that people were going into one particular product, and that it was being exported to an extent that was bad for the general trade—if, for instance, everybody went into tinned cream—we could lower the bounty for that particular product and try to regulate the trade. We have that power, but we thought it advisable to start them all off on a level.
Comment on this
You would, if your fund ran out, necessarily have to reduce your bounty on butter. These figures would not permit you to give 4d. per lb. on the butter exported. This is a weakness in the Bill, and I suggest that the Minister should have the matter examined before the Bill is finally passed.
Comment on this
I move amendment 46, as follows:
In sub-section (2) (a), line 49, to insert before the word "direct" the words "on or after the 21st, day of April, 1932 (whether before or after the passing of this Act)."
Under the Bill, as it stands, exporters of cream and milk products would not have the same benefit as exporters of butter, because they would only get the bounty from the time of the passing of the Act or some time afterwards. This puts them back to the 21st April, the same date as that from which the butter bounty will be paid.
Comment on this
I move amendment 47:
In sub-section (2), page 13, to delete paragraph (c) and substitute the following paragraph—
"(c) it is exported by the manufacturer thereof or by the registered proprietor of creamery premises."
We want to see, when we do pay bounty, that the cream is exported by the manufacturer or by the registered proprietor of creamery premises. The cream exporter who buys cream cannot get the bounty as the Bill stands. This will enable us to give the bounty on cream to the manufacturer or to the registered proprietor of creamery premises. Certain creameries make contracts to supply cream to parts of Great Britain. At certain seasons, or even for a few days now and again, they may be short and may have to buy cream from a neighbouring creamery to fulfil their contracts. In such a case, it would be unfair to refuse to give them the bounty because, naturally, they will pass on the good price to the creamery from which they bought. It is necessary to allow them to get the bounty even though they have bought from a neighbouring creamery.
Comment on this
I move amendment 48.
In sub-section (2), page 14, to delete paragraph (d) and substitute the following paragraphs:—
"(d) in case such milk product was or is exported on or after the 21st day of April, 1932, and within twenty-one days next after the date of the passing of this Act, it was or is exported by a person to whom a milk product (export) licence in respect of such milk product has been granted by the Minister under this Part of this Act within the said twenty-one days,
(e) in case such milk product is exported after the expiration of twenty-one days next after the date of the passing of this Act, it is exported by a person who is for the time being the holder of a milk product (export) licence in respect of such milk product granted by the Minister under this Part of this Act and is so exported in accordance with the terms of such licence."
There will be schemes for bounty on milk products for the "preliminary period," as it is called, from 21st April until the Act is passed. That will be payable to those who subsequently get a licence to export. It will be necessary to have a licence to export.
As to the second clause after that— any time within three weeks from the passing of the Act, or subsequently, in the next three years, nobody will be entitled to a bounty on exported milk products unless they have a licence to export—I do not know if there is any further explanation needed. The point is just that we cannot be compelled, whatever the Bill may state, to pay, unless a person had a licence to export.
Comment on this
Is it understood, in connection with that, that everybody at present exporting will be given a licence?
Comment on this
But will the people at present exporting butter automatically be entitled to a licence, or are they to be squeezed out of business?
Comment on this
No, they would not be squeezed out, but I could not say if they would all be given licences. For instance, if there was a charge against an exporter that he was exporting cream below the standard at which it was certified to be——
Comment on this
I move amendment 49:
"Before Section 37, but in Part VII to insert a new section as follows:—
"(1) Every person who claims to be entitled to a bounty under this Part of this Act may apply to the Minister under this section for payment of such bounty.
(2) Every application under this section shall be in the prescribed form and shall contain the prescribed particulars.
(3) If any applicant in any application under this section makes any statement which is false or misleading in any material respect, he shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine of one hundred pounds."
There is a new section to be inserted here. It appears that without this section we could not be legally bound to pay the bounty, or, at least, without the two sections put together.
Comment on this
On Section 37, there is something in it that I think brings out the weakness of the position, to which I referred on Section 34, as to the Minister getting money from the Exchequer to make up deficiencies in the butter fund. Will that be done as a loan?
Comment on this
That shows that you are anticipating the trouble to which I referred as to not having enough money to pay the bounty.
Comment on this
There is no doubt that at one particular time of the year we will be considerably overdrawn.
Comment on this
I have put these amendments on the Paper as alternatives. They are, whichever the Minister chooses, designed to remedy what I think is an oversight in the drafting of this section. The section gives extraordinarily wide powers to the Minister, at present, and, so far as I can see, if there were a surplus in the Miscellaneous Butter Account, he might decide to buy himself a herd of dairy cows, in order to promote the dairy industry. I think, on the whole, that, as the factory butter and the farm butter accounts are so closely related, if the miscellaneous butter account which, I think, is built up from farm butter, should prove to have money to credit, which is not required for any purpose connected with that, it might be transferred to the factory butter account, especially as anything that would tend in the slightest degree to increase the factory bounty would apparently be required. I think, in any case, that some amendment to Section 39 is necessary, and that the absolutely unfettered discretion given to the Minister in it is not a discretion he would ask for on further consideration.
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy. I do not want any great powers under this section at all, but, strange to say, the Cork butter merchants and factories who send up their comments on the Bill, advised that whatever money would be given here would be given towards the improvement and education of the people in the districts where they buy their butter. The suggestion was that we might be able to pay for a few extra dairy instructors, but if the Deputy would be satisfied to put in as an alternative method of disposing of the money——
Comment on this
If the Minister accepts amendment No. 52, instead of amendment No. 51, it simply means that he prepares a scheme to submit to the Dáil. It is much the same as a Supplementary Estimate or something like that.
Comment on this
Might I suggest that amendment 52, if it was only for the Minister's own sake, would relieve him from the barrage to which he would be subjected if there is any balance in this fund. If he has the absolute disposal of it, his life would be made a misery by deputations from every county in Ireland asking for some of the money.
Comment on this
Would it not be better to let any surplus that would remain over at the end of the financial year go forward to the same account next year?
Comment on this
I would not mind accepting amendment No. 52, if I thought it was not going to take a long time to dispose of it in the Dáil.