Dairy Produce (Price Stabilisation) Bill, 1932—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 179–357 of 357. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 6 of 1932 ›
The difficulty would, then, perhaps be that we would have the whole Bill discussed again on that particular motion when it came before the Dáil. You might have the whole Bill discussed, if you had only £5 to put forward.
Comment on this
Of course, if the amount was small, the Minister need not interfere, but would let it be carried over, but if the amount was big, he could formulate some scheme for disposing of it. His position, then, would be the same as if he wanted some new scheme in the Department of Agriculture and brought forward a Supplementary Estimate for it. These supplementaries are often brought forward and they are generally passed in a very short time.
Comment on this
Our real difficulty in this matter is that we have no idea of what it amounts to. It is the one fund in respect of which we cannot make any close estimate. We can estimate the others very closely but in respect to this one, we cannot. If we thought it was going to amount to a couple of hundred pounds, it could lie there for two or three years. If it amounted to two thousand or three thousand pounds it might be very useful to put into the factory butter account, but if it amounted to £17,000 or £18,000 we might think it too much to put in.
Comment on this
If the Chair would allow me to withdraw amendment No. 51 and move amendment No. 52, I do not think the Minister could have any objection.
Comment on this
And if any difficulty should arise in the way of a protracted debate and embarrass the Minister in any way, let him introduce an amending Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment 53:—
Before Section 42 and in Part IX to insert a new section as follows:—
42. (1) Where the Minister is satisfied that any butter on which a levy under this Act has been paid has been used in the manufacture in Saorstát Eireann of any other article of food which is subsequently exported, the Minister shall pay out of the butter fund to the person who manufactures and exports such article a bounty on such butter and such bounty shall be at the same rate as the bounty for the time being payable under this Act in respect of butter of the same class at time of the manufacture of such article.
(2) The creamery butter account shall be debited with all moneys paid by the Minister under this section in respect of creamery butter, the factory butter account shall be debited with all moneys paid by the Minister under this section in respect of factory butter, and the miscellaneous butter account shall be debited with all moneys paid by the Minister under this section in respect of farm butter.
I have referred to this section already. The aim of it is to compensate manufacturers of certain articles of food, such as biscuits, high-class chocolates, and sweets, who may use butter in the manufacture of such articles.
Comment on this
When going through the Bill after Second Reading, I thought it would be fair for both parties to the contract to give them an opportunity of withdrawing, but on reconsideration I would prefer not to move the amendment, because the producer or supplier who may contract has the option of putting on the 4d. per lb. The other person who is taking the butter or the milk, as the case may be, has the option of breaking the contract. I think it is not necessary to give the supplier the option of breaking the contract, and so I prefer not to move the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment 55:
In Part I, to insert in the appropriate place the words: "Bandon Co-operative Agricultural and Dairy Society, Limited, Bandon, Co. Cork."
This Society was a sort of mutual benefit society up to 1929, when it was compelled to erect a new central creamery at a cost of something like £5,000. At the present time the Society is £1,800 in debt; £1,200 for machinery and £600 on contract. They had to take over the liabilities of other small creameries in the neighbourhood. For Castlelact creamery they owe £450 for milk supply and for Crossbarry they owe £700 to the bank. Along with that, there was a new branch creamery erected at Enniskeane at a cost of £1,600, which had to be borrowed from the bank. With these liabilities, and the position of the dairying industry at present, the Society feels that unless it gets some preference, the same as the other creameries inserted in the Schedule, it will not be able to keep going. I ask the Minister to include it in the Schedule so that it may get the benefit of this levy.
Comment on this
I wish to support the amendment. The facts the Deputy has related are perfectly correct. My only trouble is that there are some others in the same district which are very much in the same condition, such as the Lisavairde creamery, which I cannot leave out. Apparently, we are going to have a long discussion as to the financial condition and prospects of each creamery which it is proposed to insert in the Schedule, and I think it would be better if the Minister gave us his opinion with regard to the Schedule before these amendments would be moved, because he might think we were wasting time if he is not going to accept the amendments. My own idea is that it is very invidious to include all these creameries, and I would be more or less disposed to give the Minister a free hand, so that from time to time, according as circumstances may dictate, he can put on or take off the Schedule certain creameries, after proper examination of the circumstances.
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied that the inclusion of these creameries on the Schedule is not going to be a danger to the ordinary creamery competition? That is a point which many creamery managers have pointed out to me—that with the preference given to them they will be rather dangerous competitors to the other creameries which will have to bear the cost.
Comment on this
I want to ask on what principle can this be defended? I have no feeling about the Bandon or any other creamery, but on the broad general question, if a creamery gets itself into financial difficulties with the bank, why should the State rush in to pull the bank out of the mess? If the bank makes a bad debt, let the bank bankrupt the company and let the company buy back the property at whatever it will realise. If the bank was so imprudent as to advance money on insufficient security, then the bank should carry the baby and not the State. I think this business of the Schedule is hopeless. If the Minister adopts the Schedule proposed, we will all be bombarded with requests to get on to it.
Comment on this
Objection was raised to certain power which I assume in this Bill, but I would not take the powers Deputy O'Neill is offering me of putting on or taking off at my pleasure. I shall deal with the whole of these together. We have a certain number of creameries on. One of the things we are not going to do is to take a creamery on here because it got itself into difficulties with the bank owing to bad management or something like that. But there is a type of creamery on the list started more or less in modern times, which did not get a chance of getting over the initial difficulties before prices fell. These creameries were set up in recent years in districts where creameries were nonexistent before 1927. There was no tradition of the creamery industry in these districts and these creameries may have had a rather hard time to get going. Costs of construction were high, especially when compared with the price of butter for the last couple of years. On account of the high cost of construction, and the subsequent rather quick fall in the price of butter, they were unable to meet the interest on the bank debts, etc., and at the same time pay an economic price to the supplier, with the result that you had in these districts, where there was no tradition of the creamery spirit, people who were only one or two years going to the creamery, and it was quite easy for them to go back to home butter-making, or the rearing of calves, or getting some other way of disposing of their milk.
Comment on this
I do not know. Perhaps it is. What it led to is this: that some of them were true to the co-operative spirit and thought it up to them to stick to the Society, and to go on supplying the milk whatever the price may be. Others, who acted in a more selfish way, perhaps, left the creamery and went back calf rearing, etc., and consequently reduced the supply of milk to the creamery and the creamery, still with the overhead charges, had to reduce the price. Every time the creameries lowered the price the supplies went off, with the result that they got into a hopeless state. The vicious circle went on. The price went down and the more the price went down the more the suppliers went off.
There could be a case, I think, made for a certain number of creameries like that. I think the point of view could be defended that it is better to let them go. That can be defended, but I do not like to take that position. I think that if they were established and as a certain amount of State funds were put into them, as a certain amount of money was put into them by the farmers who were advised and advised fairly strongly by the State and by the co-operative movement to go into the creamery business, it is up to the State to stand by them even to this small extent. We got all the creameries that might be concerned under this heading and we examined them to see what creameries we should put on the scheduled list. Everybody will realise that we must keep the list small. If we put, say, half the creameries on the list there would be no advantage, but, on the other hand, if we put, say, 2 per cent. on the list the advantage would be correspondingly increased. They have, furthermore, to fulfil these conditions:—that they were established in recent years, established since 1927, that they were established in districts where there were no creameries at all, that they have capital liabilities which are excessive in proportion to milk intake, that they are losing their milk supplies as a result of the fall in price, and that they are not in competition with other creameries. That is a condition that rules out many other creameries. There are many creameries down in the amendments proposed, and they should really be on the scheduled list except for the one reason that they are in competition with other creameries, and the other creameries would, naturally, object to their going on the scheduled list.
There is the further condition that they are in this precarious condition and could not continue to operate unless something substantial were done for them, and, finally—this is in reply to what Deputy Dillon said— that they are not in this condition as a result of bad management. We could get many more creameries on this list who are in a very bad financial state, but that state is probably due to bad management.
First of all, there was a list proposed by Deputy O'Leary from the Gaeltacht. There were eighty in all. Some of them as I mentioned last night are amongst the most successful creameries in the country. There are others perhaps which are fairly badly off, but they do not comply with the conditions that I have already given. Some of them were established long before 1927. Some of them are in competition with other creameries and at any rate, not one of these creameries situated in the Gaeltacht has complied with the conditions laid down. The Bandon Co-operative Creamery is also there for a long time. They have capital liabilities.
Comment on this
At any rate, they are not, as far as we can find out, losing the milk supply owing to poor prices. In other words, they are not losing milk supplies any more than ordinary creameries throughout the country, and they do not comply with any of the tests. The next on the list is St. Brigid's Co-operative Creamery, Ballinamore, Co. Leitrim. There we have a creamery which does fulfil the conditions in so far as it is a new creamery and has capital liabilities, but it is in competition with three other creameries in the district. Then we have a list of creameries in Donegal which were put down by Deputy McMenamin. None of them was established in recent years, since 1927. None of them has capital liabilities that are out of proportion to what might be considered normal for creameries and none of them is losing milk supplies as a result of capital liabilities. Then there is the Collooney Creamery, Co. Sligo, which fulfils many of the conditions, but it is not a new creamery. It fulfils the condition of having capital liabilities and as a result of that losing milk supplies, and it is not in competition to any extent with other creameries, but, as I say, it is not a new creamery.
Comment on this
Is the Minister disposing of these amendments without hearing anything in their favour?
Comment on this
I am at the moment offering a few remarks to see if I will be contradicted later. There are three creameries proposed by Deputy Desmond, but they are near the City of Cork. These creameries are new, but they are in a good financial position, comparatively speaking, and they are not losing their milk supplies. They are getting a fairly good supply.
Comment on this
Not more than the ordinary creamery. The next on the list is Woodstock Creamery, Co. Kilkenny. That is in competition with Thomastown and Graiguemanagh and it is not a new creamery. Then we have the Maudabawn Creamery and the Bunnoe Creamery, Co. Cavan. Here we have competition again in both cases, and I think that the trouble in Bunnoe is due to another matter altogether. The Blackwater Valley Creamery in Co. Waterford is competing with other creameries, and compared with other creameries they are not in a bad condition. The Borrisokane Creamery, which is put down by Deputy Morrissey, is not losing its milk supply at all.
Comment on this
I have a letter from the manager which will give evidence indicating that they lost 64,000 gallons on last year's supply.
Comment on this
The highest figure at peak time is 2,000 gallons a day, but it goes down to practically nothing during four or five months in the winter and spring.
Comment on this
It is the one creamery left out that does fulfil all the conditions specified. There is very keen competition there with the private butter makers.
Comment on this
All right. As regards Mahon Bridge separating station in Co. Waterford, that is situated in a creamery district. It is owned by a good society. It does not fulfil any of the conditions mentioned. It is not a new society and it is doing very well. As regards Annagelliffe Creameries, they are competing with other creameries and they are not new. The Magheracloone separating station in County Cavan is one that fulfils many of the conditions, but it is owned by a very strong central creamery, Lough Eagish. The Crettyard separating station in County Kilkenny is owned by an old-established society and it is not new. The premises at Templemartin, Co. Cork, are owned by East Muskerry Co-operative Dairy Society Ltd., an old-established society, and they do not fulfil any of the conditions laid down.
As far as I have been able, I have examined these individual cases that came up for consideration. Many more came up for consideration also by letters from the different societies and creamery managers. They did not have the service of any Deputy who could put in an amendment on their behalf. They wrote asking to be put on the list. We examined every one of them as carefully as possible and we found there was some big objection in each case against putting them on the Schedule. If we were to discuss those particular amendments first and dispose of them, we can then consider the Schedule as it stands and the Dáil will have an opportunity of either approving or rejecting it. I think we should consider the amendments first in order to see whether they should go on the scheduled list. So far as my enquiries in each of these cases have gone, I will have to resist putting any one of them on the Schedule.
Comment on this
I think the case the Minister has made on behalf of the creameries on the scheduled list applies particularly in the case of Bandon. He has made a very good case for Bandon. There is no bad management there. The creamery is excellently conducted. Through no fault on the part of the management they had to build a new central creamery. They took over the Castlelact milk supply and also that of Crossbarry, for both of which they are liable to the extent of £1,000. Enniskeane is a new branch, costing £1,600. Bandon fulfils all the conditions required by the Minister.
Comment on this
As regards Bandon, I will ask the Minister to reconsider his decision. I think he was under the impression that it was not a new company, and it was accordingly disqualified. As Deputy O'Donovan has pointed out, the central creamery was built in 1930. It was built pursuant to a notice served by the Department of Agriculture in December, 1929. They were compelled, through no fault of their own, to expend the large sum of over £4,000. Between this and the Report Stage perhaps the Minister will be good enough to look into the matter. I suggest that the conditions he has referred to, and so fairly put before the House, are one and all complied with in the case of the Bandon creamery.
Comment on this
As far as I can see, Bandon does not fulfil any single condition that I laid down. It is not new.
Comment on this
It has not excessive capital liabilities. It is not losing milk supplies as a result of capital liabilities. It is in competition with many other creameries around and it is not in a precarious condition. There is no reason why it should go on the list.
Comment on this
Will the Minister say if there is any creamery in Co. Cork that fulfils his conditions?
Comment on this
We will have to take the amendments separately, and at the moment we are discussing amendment 55.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I have no objection to having all these amendments discussed together, but there is the possibility that Deputies may want to discuss a certain creamery in particular, and, if the Minister's attitude upon that creamery is not satisfactory, a Deputy may want to get the decision of the House upon it.
Comment on this
I was anxious to allow the Minister to indicate his line towards the entire Schedule, and then I thought it would facilitate the House if each amendment were taken separately. Obviously, there cannot be a great deal said for or against that has not already been said on the main question.
Comment on this
Amendment 55 put.
Do you agree with this result?
On behalf of Deputy Mrs. Reynolds I move amendment 56:
"In Part I to insert in the appropriate place the words: ‘St. Brigids Co-operative Creamery, Ltd., Ballinamore, Co. Leitrim'."
The Minister stated that this creamery fulfilled all the conditions laid down by him except one, namely, that it would be in competition with adjoining creameries for a milk supply. But there is one creamery on the Schedule that will certainly take away a milk supply from an adjoining creamery. If the Minister allowed that creamery to be placed in the Schedule, why is he not prepared to allow this creamery to be placed on the Schedule, seeing it has fulfilled all the conditions he himself laid down except one. I shall give the name of the creamery to which I refer—Dowra Creamery. There is another creamery within five miles of Dowra and, in all probability, Dowra Creamery, enjoying the advantage of being placed on the Schedule, will draw away some of the supplies from the other creamery five miles off. If the Minister made an exception in one case, why not make an exception in this case? I am quite prepared to allow the Minister to consider the position of this creamery between now and the Report Stage. If he is not prepared to do that, I shall have to inflict upon him a very long statement dealing with conditions relating to this creamery.
Comment on this
There is no creamery to which I gave so much attention as St. Brigids Creamery. It is really very close to some other creameries and in competition with them and I am afraid it would not be right to put it in. If it is alleged that Dowra Creamery is in competition with other creameries, I think it would be better for the Deputy to tackle the problem by way of putting in an amendment to have Dowra Creamery removed from the Schedule. I was not aware that Dowra was in competition with other creameries. The question is whether St. Brigid's should be in the Schedule or not. I did examine that case very closely and got all the particulars possible. I think the competition between St. Brigid's and some other creameries is very keen. Certain circumstances about this creamery should be examined, but I do not think they come under this Bill. It is due for consideration on other grounds, but not so far as this Bill is concerned.
Comment on this
Am I to understand that the Minister is prepared to consider the circumstances relating to this creamery under some other scheme at a later stage?
Comment on this
I assume that when the case is examined this creamery will enjoy even greater advantages than inclusion in the Schedule would give it.
Comment on this
I move amendment 57:
In Part I to insert in the appropriate places the following:—
"The Finn Valley Co-operative Agricultural Dairy Society, Ltd;
The Lagan Co-operative Agricultural and Dairy Society, Ltd.;
Ramelton Co-operative Agricultural and Dairy Society, Ltd.;
Drumholme Co-operative Agricultural and Dairy Society, Ltd.;
Inver Co-operative Agricultural and Dairy Society, Ltd.;
Beleek Co-operative Agricultural and Dairy Society, Ltd."
I have examined the conditions the Minister has laid down in regard to the inclusion of these creameries. By those tests, none of the creameries in which I am particularly interested could be included except Inver Creamery. I take it that the Minister has reports of that creamery before him and I wonder if he will include it. It is situate in a very poor district in the Gaeltacht.
According to the accounts, the amount of butter involved last year was only 277 cwts. They lost on the year, according to the balance sheet, £251 10s. 4d. I explained last night the reason for this state of affairs. These small farmers are charged a fairly decent sum for animals for stud purposes. The various districts in the Gaeltacht of Donegal are very seriously affected in this way and the milk supplies to this creamery suffer. For that and other causes, the creamery is in a bad way. I think this is a case for inclusion in the Schedule. So far as the other creameries are concerned, on examination, I could not make a case which would bring them within the conditions fixed by the Minister.
Comment on this
Am I to take it that the Deputy is putting forward his amendments only in respect of Inver?
Comment on this
I do not wish to take up time in reiterating every word that Deputy McMenamin has said. Being familiar with the area in which Inver Agricultural Society operates, I can endorse absolutely all that Deputy McMenamin said relative to it.
Comment on this
I move amendment 58: "In Part 1, to insert in the appropriate place the following: "Collooney Agricultural and Dairy Society, Ltd., Collooney, Co. Sligo." The Minister said that this creamery complied with all the conditions he laid down except one—that it was an old creamery. He is familiar with the circumstances of the creamery at the moment. I took it from the Minister's statement a short time ago that he is considering some scheme for assisting creameries out of their financial difficulties—or, at least, that portion of the scheme would deal with the condition of financially embarrassed creameries. If the Minister has such a scheme under consideration, and if he is prepared to give an undertaking that he will consider the position of this creamery in relation to it, I am prepared to let the matter stand over for the present.
Comment on this
I said that I thought St. Brigid's was deserving of special consideration, but there is no such general scheme being considered at all. I only referred to St. Brigid's, and I was not referring to Collooney. Collooney is an old creamery. It has been there for a good many years, and the present circumstances of Collooney are not due to the fact that the price of butter fell soon after Collooney was built. It has been there for a long time, and I believe it was doing very well for a considerable time in the beginning. Their situation is due to other unfortunate circumstances in regard to management and so on, and the bringing of such a creamery under this Schedule was not contemplated.
Comment on this
I move amendment 59:—
In Part I to insert in the appropriate places the following:—"Carrigaline Co-operative Creamery, Ltd., Co. Cork; Imokelly Co-operative Creamery, Ltd., Co. Cork; Ballinhassig Co-operative Creamery, Ltd., Co. Cork."
I would ask the Minister to consider one of these creameries or two of them or perhaps the three of them. I have not got the facts myself, but I expect the Minister knows all about them. Some of them, I may say, are in very poor circumstances.
Comment on this
As I said in my general statement on these creameries, these three creameries in County Cork do comply with certain conditions inasmuch as they are new, but they are doing very well. They are not losing their milk supplies as a result of bad prices or as a result of overhead charges, and they are preserving their milk supplies reasonably well, as compared with the general body of creameries in the country, and I may say, also, that, financially, they are not anything worse off than many of the old creameries in the country. I think it would be unfair to take anything out of the general pool in order to help them, because they are not, I do not say deserving of it, but they are not dependent on extra help to get on.
Comment on this
Would the Minister extend the same consideration to Deputy Desmond's amendment as he is prepared to extend to Deputy McMenamin's amendment? Perhaps, before the Report Stage is reached, Deputy Desmond will have further information in regard to these creameries. The Bill is one which states in its preamble that it is an Act "to promote the stabilisation of the price of butter and certain other milk products" and the Minister must be aware that, while these creameries are relatively successful, they are, at the same time, worthy of some consideration from his Department. If Deputy Desmond is prepared to withdraw this amendment for the time, will the Minister give further consideration to it before Report Stage, if, and when, further information is forthcoming?
Comment on this
I do not think so. The reason why I promised to look again into the question of the Inver Creamery was because Deputy McMenamin mentioned a fact of which I was not already aware, but in the case of Carrigaline, Imokelly and Ballinhassig, I have got a fair amount of information about each one of them individually, and I know from the information I have got, that they are not in want any more than any ordinary creamery in the country, of special help. They have special advantages. They are supplying, as the Deputy is aware, the Dairy Department in University College, Cork, and they are getting a good price, as good a price as perhaps any of the old established creameries.
Comment on this
Is the Minister prepared to extend some little help to creameries which have proved themselves to be fairly efficient in fairly difficult circumstances? I would suggest that before rejecting this amendment, the Minister should await a further opportunity of, if you like, a little examination. I know from my experience of the Minister that if a good case can be made, he is prepared, at all times, to listen to it and I suggest that he waits until the Report Stage when Deputy Desmond will be able to bring further information before him.
Comment on this
I really could not, because, after all, it would mean that we would have the whole list over again on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment 60:
In Part I to insert in the appropriate place the following:—"Woodstock Co-operative Creamery, Ltd., Co. Kilkenny."
The Minister stated that this creamery was in competition with Thomastown and Graiguenamanagh creameries, but so far as I know the district, I do not think they can be near enough to compete in the collection of milk.
Comment on this
It seems to me that they are too far from that side. The Minister also said it is not new, but from representations which have been made to me I believe that, in certain other aspects, as far as I can gather from the Bill, it is going to suffer from certain other adverse effects, and so far as I can gather from the district, it seems to me that it will probably need to be scheduled just as much as a number of the others in the schedule. As to competition between it and the other creameries, I do not know whether it is competition in selling butter. I do not think it would be an economic area in collecting milk.
Comment on this
The competition, in any case, does not refer to selling. It refers to the collection of milk.
Comment on this
I thought it was a sort of economic area in which a creamery could work more or less mathematically, and that, from my own knowledge of the district, the distance between these creameries means no overlapping of the circumferences of the circles.
Comment on this
The distance is different in different places. In parts of Limerick, where creameries are very thinly studded on the map, the distance would perhaps be only two, or two-and-a-half miles, but, in other places, farmers bring their milk, perhaps, five miles to a creamery, and a distance of six or seven miles, if there is that distance between Thomastown and Inistioge, would mean competition.
Comment on this
Is not the unit based more on the quality of the land and its capacity for feeding cattle? I thought that in a district where there was poor land and where the people could not keep many cows, the area would be big. I did not think it was a matter of the number of creameries, but rather the production of milk that can be obtained in a district.
Comment on this
The Minister will remember, if he knows the district, its peculiar formation. It is right in the centre of a lot of mountains and this Woodstock area is in a pocket. So is Thomastown, practically speaking, and to get to Graiguenamanagh you have to cross over Brandon mountain. The conditions here are altogether different from those you meet anywhere else. There are really two pockets. Thomastown is a pocket, with a mountain separating it, and Graiguenamanagh is even worse still. The Minister must have some knowledge of that particular area.
Comment on this
I have often been there, but, of course, there is also the point that it is not a new creamery.
Comment on this
I move amendment 61:
In Part I to insert in the appropriate places the following:—
"Maudabawn Co-operative Creamery, Ltd., Co. Cavan; Bunnoe Co-operative Creamery, Ltd., Co. Cavan."
And amendment 64:
In Part I to insert in the appropriate places the following:—
"Annagelliffe Creameries, Ltd. (including the following auxiliary stations:—Kill, Carrickallen, Curraghoe, Bogesky, Billis, Poles, Crosskeys, Grousehall, Moynehall, Nahilla and Redhills), Ballyhaise, Co. Cavan."
When I came up here a few days ago, I made a very exhaustive examination of the whole situation, and was prepared to lay a considered case before the Minister, but, from what he has just said, I do not think there is any use in putting any considered case before him, in regard to any of these. I mentioned Maudabawn and said that there could be a good case made for it. I think it is one of those which should really be accepted. The cost of manufacturing butter at a separating station is 17/9 per cwt. In the case of Maudabawn separating station the manufacturing charge at the central was 5/6 for 1931, so that the total cost of manufacture amounts to £1 3s. 3d. per cwt. But, as this separating station was built on borrowed money, and is now paying an annual instalment of £176 to liquidate this debt, the burden is considerable, considering the present depressed prices. On the butter output for 1931, this £176 would represent a cost of 7/- per cwt. which when added to the total manufacturing cost of 23/3, would represent a charge of 30/3 per cwt. The average price received for butter was 118/3, so that the expenses which had to be met exceeded a quarter of the value of the butter produced. As I say there is a fairly good case to be made for that creamery. It is a new creamery set up in an area where it is not competing with any other and where no creamery existed before. If it fails, the people will undoubtedly go back to producing on the farms themselves. A somewhat similar state of affairs exists in the case of the Bunnoe Co-operative Creamery Ltd., so that I think these two particular creameries should get consideration. The Annagelliffe Creamery, like the others is also a new one set up since 1927. It is in a peculiar position, as the various auxiliaries own the creamery and had to take shares to start the business. The liabilities at present amount to £3,817 10s. 9d. It is a new creamery competing with others, and falls short in some respects of the rigid things indicated by the Minister. I suppose, therefore, I cannot press that case, but I would press the case of the Maudabawn and Bunnoe creameries, which I hope the Minister will accept.
Comment on this
In the case of the Annagelliffe Creamery mentioned by Deputy O'Reilly, it is of course competing with other separating stations, and it is not a new creamery as understood in the Schedule. However, the Deputy is not pushing that. Bunnoe is competing with other creameries at Cloverhill and Kells. The trouble is not due to any overhead charges, but to legal troubles which it had, and which I hope it will be able to get over. Apart from that it is getting on fairly well. At any rate it is competing with others. As to Maudabawn, the Deputy holds that it is not competing. As a matter of fact, it is competing so successfully that it has taken milk from an adjoining creamery. The complaint which comes to us is that an adjoining creamery is suffering from the milk being taken from it. If we were to subsidise Maudabawn to a certain extent, to enable it to do a little better than the adjoining creamery, it would probably be complained that we were reducing the milk of the adjoining creamery. It is competing very keenly and I do not think we can accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment 62:
In Part I to insert in the appropriate place the following:—"Blackwater Valley Co-operative Creamery, Cappoquin, Co. Waterford."
This is a creamery that is placed in a peculiar position. The Minister said that the Blackwater creamery was joined with the Ballinamult Co-operative Society. The Blackwater Society is an independent one. It separates the milk in Cappoquin and pays 8/- per cwt. to Ballinamult to manufacture the cream into butter. It also costs the society 10/- per day to convey the cream to Ballinamult, a distance of about nine miles. The creamery is situated in Co. Waterford, practically the outpost of the creamery district, and is within a few miles of the principal buyer in Co. Waterford, at any rate, and one of the principal buyers in the South of Ireland, of farmers' home-made butter. The creamery was erected in 1927 and was built by means of a loan. I suppose it has paid back some of the money—I hope it has. It is not in any way connected with Ballinamult, beyond paying for converting the cream into butter. The supply of milk, even last June when milk was plentiful, was only 1,000 gallons per day. If the Minister would reconsider the case of this creamery I would be satisfied.
Comment on this
The principal point I made against the Blackwater Valley Creamery was that it was in competition with Cappagh and Knockmeal. That is the objection to including it in the Schedule. Apart from that, I believe that the creamery is not really in a precarious position financially, as the others on the list are. That, of course, is a matter of opinion. The Deputy might not agree with us in that. At any rate, the creamery is in direct competition with these other creameries, and that is the reason we have to resist its going on the Schedule.
Comment on this
I move amendment 63:
"In Part I to insert in the appropriate place the following:—
"Borrisokane Co-operative Creamery, Ltd."
I am rather confident that the Minister will accept this amendment in view of the fact that this particular creamery meets all the conditions which he has laid down. In so far as I could follow him in his statement on the various amendments to the Schedule, his only objection to this particular creamery was that it was not losing its supplies any more than any other creamery. I am sure the Minister making that statement was acting on information which has been supplied to him but the information which has been supplied to me by the manager, and by certain members of the Committee of Management of this creamery, is that they have lost very heavily in supplies. This is a new creamery started in an area where as far as I know there was never a creamery before, and it is not in competition with any other creamery. To my own personal knowledge, because this creamery is situated a very short distance from where I live, it is much more deserving of being included in the Schedule than many of the creameries which are included. I would respectfully suggest to the Minister that if he wants to give a chance to a creamery such as this, which was started in a district which in the course would not be looked upon as a dairying industry, even in Tipperary, he should include it in the Schedule. If he does that it will be of assistance to the creamery concerned. If he does not do it I am afraid they will find it difficult to carry on. I should like if the Minister would give his earnest consideration to this matter.
Comment on this
I desire to support the amendment moved by Deputy Morrissey. Like Deputy Morrissey I know the district intimately. It was up to 1928 and is yet practically a completely tillage area. It was only when the farmers got completely broken up in that area in regard to the production of barley, potatoes and other crops for which they could not get sale, that they went in for the dairying industry. This creamery was erected in 1928 at a cost of £2,000. As far as I understand from a letter from the manager, it was taking for the last year 64,000 gallons of milk less as compared with the previous year. That, he says, is largely due to the fact that the farmers there are going back to the production of homemade butter.
If you will allow me, a Chinn Comhairle, I will read the manager's letter. It is dated the 14th instant and it will go to show as I am sure the Minister will agree, that the manager at the time could have no idea of the conditions laid down by the Minister himself which would entitle them to special consideration and entitle them to be included in the Schedule. The letter states:—
As we are a new creamery and did our best to discharge our liabilities up to the present we cannot understand why we are not to benefit as well as neighbouring new creameries. We are in the centre of a tillage district and have to employ a fleet of eight lorries to collect our milk and the average supply of each person is about five gallons and we have to collect on a radius of over ten miles. Our cartage rate each year from the society comes to a large sum and the halfpenny per gallon deducted from each supplier for cartage in summer and three-farthings in winter leaves them a very small return. Our milk supply last year shows a reduction of 64,000 gallons and this year gives evidence of a much larger reduction. Our creamery is an independent auxiliary working since May, 1928, and cost £2,000 to erect and equip. Even if Roscrea is the only creamery to benefit in Tipperary we may add that Roscrea and Borrisokane are the only two creameries in the county which are situated in a real tillage area and of the two Borrisokane suffers most on this account where the matter of milk production at its best is only a secondary consideration to the suppliers during the past two years.
Another serious problem which our society has to contend with is the home butter making which is still carried on here very extensively and farmers who were suppliers to this creamery a few years ago have gone back to this system again as they find it pays them better to churn their own milk and sell the butter to private customers. This class of people who are numerous in the district will, of course, be bounty fed by the increased price of butter in the country and with perhaps no levy.
I tried to ascertain for myself, as well as I honestly could, what the facts and figures connected with this creamery were. I went into Plunkett House and I saw the gentleman in charge of the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society with whom I discussed this matter. He was of opinion that this is the one creamery in Tipperary, next to the one which the Minister has scheduled, that should get special treatment under the Act. I know something about creamery work myself, having been secretary of a creamery for something like 20 years, and knowing the conditions under which this creamery is trying to exist, I would strongly impress upon the Minister to include Borrisokane creamery in the Schedule.
Comment on this
It is quite true, as Deputy Morrissey said, that this is a new creamery and that it is not in competition with another creamery, but with regard to the other conditions I stated, it is not losing milk as the result of a fall in prices. I stated also that it is not in a precarious condition financially. They did lose practically 63,000 gallons—62,231 gallons—last year, but they still had 382,000 gallons. They therefore lost 14 per cent., which average loss on the milk supply last year. This creamery also is in a very good position, and is evidently very well managed because they paid an average price last year of 4.72 pence per gallon, or 12.55 pence per lb. of butter fat. That appears to be a very favourable position, taking the majority of creameries. I would say that there is a very small percentage of creameries that could beat that price, so financially Borrisokane cannot be in a bad way. It is really standing on that, that we have excluded them from the list—that they have kept up the supply, and that they have paid as good a price as any creamery could be expected to pay last year.
Comment on this
I think the Minister has strengthened my case. The Minister tells us that it was nothing abnormal for a creamery society started in what was purely a tillage district to lose, roughly, 63,000 gallons of milk in one year. I suggest to the Minister that it is not fair to say that it is only 14 per cent. or roughly about the average. You cannot compare a dairy society in Borrisokane with, say, a dairy society in South Tipperary or Limerick, which is a purely dairying district.
Surely the Minister is not going to hold that because a society is well managed, according to himself, and run in a very efficient way, that this a reason why it should be debarred from the benefits of this measure by being excluded from the Schedule? Surely the Minister is not going to give a bounty for inefficiency? This society was started by farmers in an area which was purely a tillage area three years ago. It was started by farmers who were prepared to put up anything to the extent of £2,000. It has been run upon fairly good lines, being very efficiently managed, and it should receive more serious consideration. Because of the slump, that society lost in one year 62,000 gallons of milk, and surely that society is entitled to the benefits of this measure?
That is the position of the Borrisokane society. That society is away on its own so far as Tipperary is concerned. It is situated in an isolated area; it is not in competition with any other creamery, and it is of immense benefit to the farmers in the area. If the Minister is going to deny that creamery inclusion in the Schedule on the grounds, first of all, that it has been so efficiently and well run that it has not suffered as much financially as other societies, and, secondly, because its supply of milk has not decreased more than 63,000 gallons in one year, I think that his case is a very poor one. I hope the Minister will reconsider the matter.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey forestalled me. The Minister spoke with reference to the management of this society. He said it is well managed and is in a good financial position, or words to that effect. Is it because the creamery is well managed that it is being excluded? Are we to understand that if it was badly managed, if they were in a bad financial position, they would get preferential treatment? Does it mean that we are to subsidise inefficiency?
Comment on this
I would like, again, to point out that, according to the conditions laid down by the Minister, Borrisokane is definitely entitled to be included in the Schedule. First and foremost, the creamery was erected since 1927; as a matter of fact, it was erected in 1928 and that will not be denied. It does not clash with any other creamery, and that is another of the conditions laid down. The third condition is that in order to entitle the creamery to benefit, it should be losing its milk supply as a result of competition with home butter producers. These are three of the conditions laid down by the Minister, and I will stake my reputation on it that Borrisokane complies with those conditions. I would be inclined to press this matter very strongly, because I am fully convinced that this is the one creamery in Tipperary, next to the one in Roscrea, to which you are giving financial benefit, that a very strong case could be made in respect of.
Comment on this
I did mention that Borrisokane was well managed, but I did not say that was the reason why it was not in the Schedule. If I were to pick out all the creameries that are badly managed, and if I were to put them on the list, the Schedule would be fairly long. That was not the test. I said they lost 14 per cent. of their milk supplies and that was the average loss with all the creameries last year. Therefore, their loss was not abnormal.
Comment on this
It is. Taking the purely creamery districts of South Tipperary and Limerick that were mentioned by Deputy Morrissey, where there is no tradition of going back to home butter making, even there they lost 14 per cent. With the usual loss of cows, and with the lower yield owing to the bad year, there was an average loss of 14 per cent. in all creamery districts. If there was only a 14 per cent. loss in Borrisokane we may take it for granted that they did not lose their milk supplies owing to overhead costs, or the poor price they gave for the milk. In support of that I said that they gave as good a price as the majority of creameries. It is not because they have good management there that we are not putting them on the list. Their overhead costs did not prevent them giving the same price for the milk as was given by practically any established creamery. The fact is they do not fulfil the conditions laid down. These are the main reasons.
Comment on this
The Minister has referred to overhead costs in the Borrisokane Creamery. Whilst the Minister has given us comparisons with regard to the loss in milk supplies, he has not given us any figures which would go to show what were the overhead costs in Borrisokane as compared with any other creamery in Limerick or Tipperary. I suggest to the Minister that it is easier to run a creamery, and to get people to supply milk to a creamery in Limerick or in the dairying parts of Tipperary than it is in Borrisokane, which has no dairying tradition behind it, and which has always been a purely tillage area. I suggest that a 14 per cent. reduction in the milk supply in Borrisokane is a much more serious matter to contemplate than a similar reduction in Limerick or South Tipperary.
The Minister has not advanced a single argument against the inclusion of this dairying society in the Schedule. He has attempted to show that this society does not meet with all the conditions he has laid down. The Minister said he did not suggest that it was because this society was efficiently managed that it was being excluded, but the Minister has not suggested any other reason. There is no doubt about the Minister's two points in refusing to include this society in the Schedule —one, that their loss of milk supplies last year was not abnormal, and two, that they had not lost any money, and that they were an efficient and well-managed society.
We are forced to the conclusion that this new society, which was started in a place where there was never a creamery before, that is not in competition with any other creamery, but that has to meet competition from home made butter, is not being fairly treated, The only reason the Minister can advance for refusing to include it in the Schedule is that it has been well managed, and that it has not lost more than 63,000 gallons of milk last year. As one who knows a little about the history of the starting of the creamery in that area, I say it will be a very bad thing for that district and for a very wide radius around the town of Borrisokane if this creamery is not able to continue.
I respectfully ask the Minister, for the sake of the industry itself, and for the sake of the very wide area served by the creamery, to include it in the Schedule. The Minister will find that a much better case can be made for the inclusion of this creamery in the Schedule than can be made for many of the creameries already set out in it.
Comment on this
I have now got something in connection with the capital liabilities of this society. They are not anything abnormal. A considerable proportion of the £2,000 borrowed in 1928 has been paid off. The only capital liabilities that they have got now would be about £500. I said already that they paid 4.72d. per gallon for milk last year. There are many creameries in Tipperary that paid less. If Deputy Morrissey takes that into account, is he prepared to put a burden on the creameries that are paying less, to enable Borrisokane to pay more, because that is what it amounts to?
Comment on this
In answer to the Minister, I am not prepared, and neither I am sure is he, to put a premium on inefficiency. At the same time, I am not going to victimise a particular society or a particular manager because he has been so efficient and his society has been so well run that not only has he succeeded in wiping off heavy capital liabilities, but is also able to pay a better price than others for milk. Perhaps that was due to the fact that it was rather an innovation in that particular district. I would say, in regard to the other points put forward by the Minister, that it, in my opinion, is an added reason why this particular dairy society should be included in the Schedule. I think the Minister will see the fairness of helping a society which, in the Minister's own words, has helped itself and is prepared to do its own part. I am not talking of one society as against another. I suggest that the Minister has not shown to the House that this dairy society does not meet with everything that he has laid down in his speech. Therefore, I do not see why it should not be included in the Schedule.
Comment on this
Is it not the Minister's object to prevent societies, which are in a precarious position, from failing altogether? Here we have Deputy Morrissey telling us about the excellent way this society is managed and of its financial position. In these circumstances he is asking the Minister to give a subsidy to this society, which is in no need of it, at the expense of others.
Comment on this
That is not my case. What Deputy Dowdall is now referring to is the case that was made by the Minister. I did not make that case, but the Minister did.
Comment on this
The fact that the Minister quoted 4.72d. per gallon paid does not give some of us a very clear idea as to what the people actually got. In the course of the letter which I read from the manager, and which has not been contradicted in the smallest iota, the loss to that creamery on last year's supply was about 64,000 gallons. The manager stated further that all the milk is brought to the creamery in lorries. The farmers themselves out of that 4.72d. per gallon, have to pay according to the statement of the manager a ½d. per gallon. That ½d. per gallon has to be deducted from the 4.72d. There has also to be deducted out of that 4.72d. ¾d. per gallon in the winter months. When you have made these two deductions you get near to the actual amount that the suppliers to the creamery are getting.
Comment on this
Amendment put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment 67:
In Part II to insert in the appropriate place the following:—"Crettyard separating station attached to Castlecomer Co-operative Creamery, Co. Kilkenny."
So far as I can see, no matter how one urges the case of these creameries, the Minister is able to come along and say that they do not fulfil the conditions he has defined in his own mind. I think he has stated that this creamery is "thriving." I presume that in this country, as in most other places, one can assume that when a thing is thriving it is being well managed and, on the contrary, that when a thing is not thriving it is evidence that it has been founded in an unsuitable place or is being badly managed. I do not know whether the Minister can assure us that every one of the creameries included in this Schedule do fulfil all his conditions. But it does seem to me a perfectly ridiculous thing that, although the Minister has not stated that his purpose is to subsidise inefficiency, every statement I heard from him seemed to imply that. The Minister has referred to the overhead charges of certain creameries being abnormally high. One of the first duties of an efficient manager or director of a creamery should be to see that the overhead charges are low. In the case of those creameries that are not directly in a creamery area, this Bill may, from the suggestions we have heard, actually have an adverse effect. Apart from that, I should imagine that the statements of the Minister might easily tend to encourage managers to show a little less efficiency in their management. Once they can show that inefficiency, they can be sure of the paternal benevolence of the present Government.
I would like to know if the Minister refuses absolutely to include any creamery which, no matter what difficulties, or what bad circumstances it has to face, is actually, in his own words, thriving.
Comment on this
I did say that this society was thriving. It is an old established society also, of course, and in that way would not be entitled to inclusion in the Schedule. It is old established; they have not got capital liabilities out of proportion to their milk supplies, and they are not losing milk supplies as a result of these capital liabilities. The result of all those things is that it is a thriving society. The same thing might be said of, perhaps, 300 or 400 societies in the country, and I said already that if we were to put creameries that have bad managements on the scheduled list, it would be very big, and if we put thriving, well-managed societies on the list, the Schedule would be much bigger. That was not the test. There were certain tests of being newly established, and so on, and as I said when speaking at the beginning, the type of society on the scheduled list is the society established since 1927, in districts where creameries were not previously established, and where the creamery tradition was not know, and as a result of the fall of prices after a couple of years, the people who had been supplying these creameries went back to the old methods of disposing of their milk. That does not apply to the Crettyard Creamery, which was established long before the fall in prices, and, therefore, it does not come under the Schedule.
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy Vaughan, I move amendment 68:
In Part II to insert in the appropriate place the following:—"Premises at Templemartin, Co. Cork, owned by the East Muskerry Co-operative Dairy Society, Ltd."
I believe that, in this case, I have a branch creamery that will fulfil all the requirements of the Minister. This is a branch held by the East Muskerry Co-operative Dairy Society, and it was established in a purely home butter making area in 1928, and cost upwards of a couple of thousand pounds. I understand that, at that time, the farmers in the district promised to give all their milk supplies to this East Muskerry Society, but since the branch was established the farmers have not carried out their promise, and the result is that in this area, where it cost £2,000 to build this branch, for the first ten days of this month, they had only an average of 600 gallons of milk. There are, I understand, over 360 cows in the area held by farmers who are making their own butter, and I think that when they are in competition with the home producer, this branch of this society should get recognition, and should be included in the Schedule. I think there is a very good case for it. This creamery is outside my area, being situated in North Cork.
I have a letter here from the creamery manager, written to Deputy Vaughan, in which he states that he has written to Messrs. O'Leary and Moylan in regard to this matter. Deputy Vaughan is unable to be here, and Deputy O'Leary, I understand, is away also, but I think Deputy Moylan is in the House, and I believe that when he was looking for votes in the recent election, he made any amount of promises to the people, and I am sorry he is not here to support this amendment. I think the branch fulfils all requirements and I hope the Minister will consider it favourably.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister if it is the intention of this Bill to separate the separating stations from the main creameries. They cannot be divided, because the separating station is a feeder to the main creamery, and if the main creamery is not doing all right, the separating station is not. It is not an independent body and cannot be dealt with by itself. In reference to what Deputy O'Donovan has said, with regard to the 600 gallons of milk received in ten days by the East Muskerry Society's branch, 600 gallons for an auxiliary, in the first ten days of May, is very good.
Comment on this
I am rather amazed to hear Deputy Dowdall say that 600 gallons of milk is very good. I want to support the application of Deputy O'Donovan. Undoubtedly, it is difficult to understand exactly what is the precise point at which the Minister will regard a creamery as being sufficiently efficient to be admitted to the Schedule and sufficiently down-at-heel, if I may use the phrase, to qualify for admission. It is difficult to understand what is the precise point at which the two ends meet. I consider that a very strong case has been put up for the largest number on the Schedule, and I am only surprised at the fact that the Minister has rejected, almost completely, the whole Schedule amendments. I feel that this is a creamery which certainly deserves to be included, and I would ask the Minister to accede to Deputy O'Donovan's request.
Comment on this
There was a similar case to this already discussed—the case of Magheracloone, which is a branch of Lough Egish. The point raised by Deputy Dowdall, of course, disposes of it. You cannot separate the auxiliary from the central premises of the same society, and here Templemartin is part of the East Muskerry Co-operative Society, and we cannot admit one particular part and not take on the whole society. I think that Deputy O'Donovan has more or less admitted that the East Muskerry Co-operative Society is long established, and in a good way, and that the whole society would feel that they had not any claim to get on to the Schedule. I was asked, also, by the last Deputy, where exactly did we draw the line. I have repeated it over and over again—whether the poor price paid for milk was not due to bad management, but to conditions over which a particular society had no control, being established in a non-creamery district, being in competition with home butter makers, losing their supplies owing to big capital liabilities, and having to give a poor price for milk and getting into financial difficulties in that way. That is the type of society that is in the scheduled list. Whatever case may be made for Templemartin, it is part of the East Muskerry Co-operative Society and, therefore, could not be admitted.
Comment on this
It is not definitely in the Bill, but I said that I had already made that point on the question of the Magheracloone society.
Comment on this
The Minister has rejected one in an amendment by Deputy Desmond, the Imokelly Co-operative Creamery in Co. Cork, which is most efficient, newly built, and in a non-creamery district. It is practically a tillage district, and the creamery is carrying on under difficulties, but, at the same time, it is exceedingly well managed. I would be glad to discuss that with the Minister in another place if he will permit me, because I think it is certainly a creamery that answers the description just given by the Minister.
Comment on this
Will the Minister not admit that the East Muskerry Co-operative Dairy Society has a very good claim on behalf of its premises at Templemartin, and that it should be included in the Schedule?
Comment on this
The East Muskerry Society is an old-established society, and in every way I think it would be impossible to take it on to the scheduled list. It has not capital liabilities out of proportion; it is not losing milk supplies, and it is in competition with other societies.
Comment on this
The auxiliaries might have to bear their own capital liability. If the main creamery took them over in full partnership and assumed the liabilities out of proportion, it would be a question for consideration. It depends on the terms under which they were taken into the central creamery. I know from experience that some of them would not be taken in and had to go on as auxiliaries with liabilities hanging over them. I do not know anything of the circumstances in this case.
Comment on this
I suggested to the Minister yesterday that in fact we were voting for these various societies a substantial subsidy and that even if he amends the Bill on Report and prevents the position arising where they might get the full benefit of 1½d. per lb. for three years, some of these societies are going, at the expense of the creamery industry as a whole, to get a very considerable subsidy. The biggest of them might get £2,000 in this year. It might if there is a reduction get two-thirds of that next year and one-third the year after. That is, we might vote that society, by passing the Schedule a sum of £4,000. If instead of taking it out of the Creamery Butter Fund it was being taken out of the Central Fund here, we would have an estimate submitted and details supplied by the Minister giving some justification of that vote of some £4,000 to a particular society. Other societies in this list will obtain as a result of the passage of the Schedule lesser amounts than that, but taking all together the amount that will have to be subscribed by the other creameries is a fairly considerable one. There is, in fact, I think, no very great justification for asking the other creameries to subscribe that amount, even assuming that these societies are all in dire straits and that the circumstances are such that in all cases somebody ought to come to the rescue, even the general taxpayer. Societies that are not on the Schedule and which it was proposed to put on it have been discussed at some length. I think that we should have some details as to each of the societies mentioned in the Schedule. I do not know that the Minister could give them at very great length. It may not be that the case is so bad that we should come to the rescue, or it may be that if the Dáil does not take the money from the other societies and allows these particular institutions to face their own difficulties a way would be found of facing them. Certainly, in the not distant past, it has happened in many cases that a society found it impossible to carry on, and there was not the means of giving it an annual subsidy such as is provided by this Schedule. Shareholders had to lose and guarantors had to pay up, and the general situation had to be liquidated locally. There is a great deal to be said when these difficulties arise, if too widespread a problem is not created, for allowing those concerned with the plan for organising which may have been a bad plan or with the management, which if not bad, may have been of an indifferent character for a period of years and therefore responsible for the plight of the creamery, to face up to their difficulties. In any case before the sum is voted I think we ought to have some details as to the situation of each society.
Comment on this
I am opposed to the Schedule. I do not think a great case has been made for any creamery being given a preference over the rest of the creameries. Possibly as good a case could be made out for the creameries on the Schedule as for any other creamery, but a case can also be made for some of the creameries in the established creamery districts. I might have made a case for very many in Limerick and Tipperary—creameries which have very big overhead expenses, and which are mainly in the position of new creameries, inasmuch as they have had in the last few years to take over various concerns bought out with Government assistance. They have had to bear the expense of these, and they are practically in the same position as new creameries. They have got very large overhead expenses and debts. They are forced to pay a contribution for a number of years to pay these debts. They are in a position which is quite as bad as that of any creameries in the Schedule. They are now being asked to subsidise these other creameries. The Minister said that one of the conditions of being placed on the Schedule was that a creamery did not compete with others. Possibly, these scheduled creameries do not compete with others in regard to milk supply, but they do compete very largely with the other creameries in other ways. For instance, if there was a contract for butter to be given by an asylum or some other big institution in Limerick, or some other place, a creamery in Roscrea or Scariff, subsidised to the extent of 1½d. per lb., would be in a position to contract at a lesser price than local creameries, and thus get the contract. They will be in a position to undersell other creameries in the public market if they wish and compete where other creameries could not compete. I do not say they will. There was a good case made here for some other creameries to be put on the Schedule, nearly as good as could be made for those which are included. As I said, I am rather opposed to the whole scheme. It is unfair that creameries, which are themselves struggling and have large overhead expenses should be asked to assist other creameries which, in the main, are not worse off than the creameries which are asked to help them. It is placing the whole of the existing creameries in a very bad position. I do not think the Schedule should be accepted as it is, not to speak of the additions that were proposed to be made to it to-day.
Comment on this
To my knowledge, there are creameries of old standing with very heavy financial commitments. I know one where the figure is £12,000 or £15,000. They are now asked, in addition, to bear their share of the subsidy contained in this Schedule. We have not been given the details which are necessary to know before we can give an intelligent vote on this question. We should know the financial position of the creameries which are included in the Schedule. There is one Wexford creamery included which, a few years ago, was doing an exceptionally good business. As a matter of fact, it was turning out compound meal.
That is all to their credit. I do not know what the position of that creamery is now. I do know the position of creameries nearer home which are in a very serious financial position and which are asked to subsidise these other creameries. I do not think it is fair for the members of the House to be asked to give a vote on this matter without knowing the facts. I suppose the Minister does know the facts. If he does know the facts I think it is right the House should have the figures. If he has not the figures now we can wait until he gets them. There is a big principle involved here because of the financial position of some of the creameries. I am not exaggerating when I say that there is one creamery in my county which is between £12,000 and £15,000 on the wrong side of the ledger.
Comment on this
I join with Deputy Gorey and Deputy Blythe in stating that we would need some information from the Minister in regard to these fourteen creameries. I do not know what their conditions are but I hope the Minister will give us that information before he asks us to come to a decision. I know something about the case of the 33 creameries which were mentioned in the amendments and I think that each Deputy who put forward a case, knowing the circumstances in each case, believed that he had quite as good a case for inclusion in the Schedule as any creamery that is included. I think it is unfair then to find creameries that are supposed to be badly off in the Schedule, while others which are equally badly off are asked to carry them on their shoulders.
Comment on this
I believe there is a better future for new creameries, started under certain conditions, than for old creameries which are in a bad financial position. I see no chance of these latter bettering their position; on the other hand, the position of new creameries offers better possibilities. For instance, an old creamery, which I know and which has been established for fifteen or twenty years has overhead commitments of between £12,000 and £15,000. What prospects are in front of that creamery that it should be asked to give a subsidy to other creameries about which we know nothing? There is no future before certain creameries with large commitments. I would like to know what is the future of the creameries in the Schedule and what are their commitments.
Comment on this
I tried to explain the position of these creameries on two or three occasions to-day. They were established in districts where the creamery tradition did not exist and there was a big risk for the farmers who established them. There is no doubt that their establishment was considered right and good by Government policy at the time. There was a good deal of money spent by the Government in the establishment and organisation of creameries, and farmers were freely advised to go into the creamery business as having the best future. Farmers in some of these districts established these creameries and guaranteed a certain amount of money. I know some of them personally who guaranteed big sums in loans and so on. The fall in prices came on them suddenly and they were not able to pay up their debts, and I do not know whether it is possible even to save them now. Deputy Hogan, the ex-Minister for Agriculture, asked me on the day on which I introduced the Financial Motion what we were going to do for the newly-established creameries. He evidently understood the difficulty they were in. I do not know whether it would be advisable to give to the Dáil the exact financial position of each of these creameries. I think it would not be advisable or fair. I am prepared to give the cost of putting them into the Schedule.
Deputy Blythe, I think, last night raised the question of whether this treatment could be made to last for only one year. I said our intention was to make the advantage less each year for the three years. I thought at the time it could not be put into the Act. I think now it can, and we are asking the draftsman to draft an amendment which would be somewhat on the following lines: that for the present year the levy payable by the scheduled creameries would be not less than one-fourth of the general levy, that next year it would be not less than one-half, and in the third year not less than one-fourth. Assume that there is a levy of 2d. for the whole three years. In that case the levy on the scheduled creameries would be a halfpenny next year, a penny the second year, and three halfpence the next year. Assume again that they have the output of butter for the three years that they had last year. I think perhaps we are assuming a lot there because the supplies are going down. If we take the first two or three months of this year as compared with the first two or three months of last year the supplies are down, but even assuming that they have the same output as last year, the total cost for the whole three years would be £18,000 and £18,000 would be about one per cent. of the whole. I do not think it would be a big burden on the remaining creameries to contribute one per cent., as a subsidy if you like, for these particular creameries to see if we can save them from failure.
Deputy Bennett, who represents Limerick, and the Deputies who represent Tipperary, certainly have a grievance in our asking the established creameries to come to the rescue of the new creameries, but as we are, however, asking consumers to contribute to the pool for the benefit of all creameries, perhaps these creameries would not be so ungenerous as to refuse to contribute under that pool one per cent. of the total towards saving the new creameries. There is no creamery, I think, that would benefit to the extent of £2,000 this year. The highest amount I find here would be £1,593. That is on the basis of 14/- per cwt. on the same output as last year. The contribution this year would be £9,071, next year £6,046, and the third year £3,055, giving the total I have already given of £18,000 odd. I do not know, as I said, whether it would be advisable to lay the full financial position of these particular creameries before the House, but I could consider that question if I am pressed to do so.
Comment on this
The point I wanted to raise does not so much concern the 1 per cent. I do not think that in Tipperary they would be so greedy as to deny 1 per cent. Let us take any one of the creameries in County Limerick that had to be purchased under the recent Act. I am sure my colleagues on the Government Benches, Deputies Crowley and Ryan, know the position very well. These creameries are very heavily burdened. They have overhead charges that none of us can relieve them of. Let us say that they have a market in Dublin, that they are supplying a wholesale house in the city with a large amount of butter. The position is that one of these other creameries might step in and undersell them. A small amount allowed on a large quantity of butter, as every seller knows, is a big inducement to a buyer. It need not be a big amount per cwt. in order to collar a creamery's trade. These assisted creameries will be in a position to undersell here and there.
Comment on this
Can the Minister give us the dates in connection with these creameries and the manufacturing costs?
Comment on this
We could give certain information, perhaps. I have not got that particular information at the moment.
Comment on this
As regards the creamery that is going to get £1,500 in one year, what are its capital commitments?
Comment on this
I think the best thing to do would be to allow this thing to go through, if the House is agreeable, and then some Deputy could put down an amendment on the Report Stage to reject the Schedule. By that time, I could give more information.
Comment on this
Is there a prospect that this amount would enable all or most of these creameries to survive? Even though the amount that may be taken from Deputy Bennett's creamery is only 1 per cent. there is no use in taking that 1 per cent. from that creamery and giving it to one of these creameries. There is no use in taking £9,000 from a number of creameries, all of which have their difficulties, and handing it over to these other creameries unless there is a prospect that, with that assistance, those creameries will be able to get out of their difficulties. If they are so badly situated that they are worse than any case that could be brought forward here this evening, and if the prospects of the butter prices are what the Minister seemed to fear earlier in the day, then the outlook for the creameries is indeed gloomy. We are told by the Minister, and this is the fundamental thing in his selection, that their condition in no case is due to bad management.
Comment on this
Whatever other misfortunes may have happened to them, their management did the best that could be done in the circumstances. Therefore, it looks as if they are creameries that were a mistake from the beginning. That must be the case with regard to some of them. Possibly, they are situated where they ought not to be and if there were better prices and there was some inducement to increase milk supplies they might have done well. But, situated in these areas, and circumstances being as they are, it would look as if they had no prospect at all of improving their position. Therefore, it may look as if it were throwing good money after bad to give them any particular subsidy or to treat them specially in any sort of way.
Suppose butter conditions had been a little better this Bill presumably would not have been brought in. I do not know whether the Minister would have introduced any special proposals to help those creameries. If he would not, then I do not think that help should be given to them now. I think it is an entirely wrong principle, because we have a Bill that enables help to be given to creameries without the proposal running the gauntlet in the way it would have to run it if a Supplementary Estimate were introduced in the Dáil—it is not right to seize on that opportunity or to allow the people making the claim to avail of that opportunity and to get assistance. To put the matter in a slightly different way, would the Minister, if he had to come to the Dáil with a Supplementary Estimate and ask £18,000 a year—
Comment on this
Then let us say £9,000 for this year. If the Minister had to ask that that sum should be voted for these creameries, would he have asked it? It seems to me that it is extremely doubtful. If the fact is that he would not have done it, then the mere circumstance that the money is not going to come out of the Exchequer but out of another special fund is no reason why these particular societies should be given this special help. If that is the position, then I think the reason for not coming to the Dáil is that the Minister would not feel that he could say this £9,000 would be followed by another £9,000 and that would save the societies and enable them to get on their feet. I presume that would be the reason the Minister would have. If the prospects are not really good, then this help ought not to be given to them. One of the difficulties we have in discussing the matter from this side is that we have practically no information.
Comment on this
Of course, we have information such as the Minister for Agriculture gave me in reply to a question the other day, showing the amount of butter made by the societies mentioned in the first part of the Schedule; but that hardly goes to the root of the matter. We would want to know manufacturing costs, the trend of milk supplies, capital liabilities and how the societies were financed. It may be that in many cases it is simply postponing the bitter end and that it would be much better and more economical to let the end come. There is another possibility and that is that a much larger sum frankly voted to relieve them all at once might put them on their feet and give them a prospect, whereas the dole they will get in this way for a couple of years might simply enable them to hang on. I see that the Minister, perhaps, needs to consider what he would say with regard to each particular creamery.
Could the Minister possibly give us some information without naming the creameries, a sort of sample figures? They would really, of course, have to be taken as sample figures when we had not the names to which they related.
Comment on this
I do not know if the Minister would be in a position to give us figures. Several of us could get up and give figures for other creameries. I am quite certain we could give figures for various creameries that should have the result of placing these creameries on the Schedule. I am quite certain that I could pick out a number of creameries in the County Limerick that are burdened with various costs and that I could make a good case for having them included in the Schedule.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister should give information with regard to the individual position of creameries or that he should furnish names. Whatever chance of success the creameries have by getting relief under the levy, if their names are published and it becomes known their condition is not good, then I think that would prevent them ever getting on their feet.
Comment on this
This is the one thing in connection with the whole Bill to which I have a decided objection. I wish to support the view put forward by Deputy Blythe and Deputy Bennett. Having regard to the conditions under which it is proposed to give this extra bounty it is apparent that it was unwise to bring these creameries into existence. If the Dáil takes up the attitude of subsidising an industry that should not be there at all, then I think it is setting up a very bad precedent for itself.
Comment on this
I happen to be associated with one of the creameries in a scheduled area and to know something about the others as well. Deputy Gorey referred to one creamery that was producing pig meal. That creamery was started, thanks to the energetic work of the Secretary of a co-operative society. The creamery was started in the district with good intentions. All these creameries were going well until the collapse in prices came a couple of years ago. If that collapse had not come they could have carried on. Their suppliers were perfectly satisfied until the collapse came. But when the bad prices came the farmers were not sufficiently versed in the principles of co-operation to stick to their creameries. Some of the suppliers left. I can assure the Dáil and the members who have been rather critical in regard to this matter that the fact of this Bill coming along has had a very steadying effect on creamery suppliers. In connection with the creamery that I am attached to I had a canvass made of all the suppliers who are carrying the liabilities for the loan made available for the setting up of these creameries by the late Government. They are satisfied to come back and continue their supplies. In fact the supplies have increased this year as a result of this Bill being introduced at the right time.
In reply to Deputies who are critical about this I would say to them that this will be money well spent. Even the other creameries that are called co-operative should come in and help their weaker brethren so as to make available for the latter the one per cent. to which the Minister refers, to help them over their difficulties this year, next year and the year after. We hope that things will be better in the future. We hope, too, that there will be real co-operation amongst all the creameries, that this measure will lead to methods being devised for the profitable selling of our produce and that we will all contribute our share towards that desirable end. I attended a conference recently which was representative of a number of these newly established creameries. Everyone of them was anxious to go even to the extent of agreeing to have a compulsory bringing together of all the people connected with co-operative societies for the purpose of selling their butter. Deputy Gorey referred to one society that was producing pig meal. That had nothing at all to do with the other society. It is quite distinct. It is a co-operative society as such that is responsible for the making of the pig meal, and it has nothing at all to do with the running of the creamery at that particular centre.
Comment on this
No, they have no connection whatever. The creamery has to carry its own responsibilities. The responsibility of paying falls on the milk suppliers, on the loyal members of the society who send in the milk. I think in view of the fact that money was made available by the Dáil in recent years for the setting up of new creameries, that now the people connected with them should be encouraged, and I think this money will be well spent I can assure Deputies that the money will be well spent. I have every hope that the creameries will survive and will make good if given help now.
Comment on this
Deputy Blythe did put me a question which I suppose, if I were logical, I would have to admit, that this Schedule should not be here at all. The Deputy asked me if this Butter Bounty Bill had not been necessary would I come to the Dáil and ask for £18,000 to save the creameries? I am afraid I would have felt that I would not be justified in doing so. But when the Bill came along then it looked as if these societies could be saved. We thought, however, that they would want a little more help than this Bill could give them and that is why they are put on the scheduled list. I cannot answer for them all. I have examined them on paper, and it looks as if they can be saved under the Bill with this additional help. I have spoken to about four managers of societies on this list. They believe that they are going to get on their feet again and that they will be able to pay off part of their capital liabilities. I cannot promise further than that and neither could they, because they do not know how prices are going to go.
With regard to what Deputy Bennett said, I do not think there is any danger that a scheduled society will injure an established society in Limerick or elsewhere. As a matter of fact, we are not going to put them on the Schedule either to take a milk supply from an adjoining creamery or to injure established creameries by underselling. If such a complaint were made against any society on the list we have the power immediately to remove it from the list, and it would be done, of course, in that case.
With regard to old creameries and to the new creameries that are in a bad way, the only thing one can say is that the old creameries got their chance when good prices were going, and if they did not make good, well, there are so many of them with capital liabilities that we could hardly deal with them under this Bill. We can say with regard to the new societies that they did not get a chance, even with the best of management. No matter what the management was, the conditions that prevailed were against them, and it was the conditions that beat them. We think as they did not get a chance we ought to give them a chance under this Bill to get on and succeed. The sum that I have mentioned of £18,000 to be spread over three years is not excessive. Still it may be sufficient to tide them over their present difficulties and give them a chance to get on.
Comment on this
Could the Minister say whether the creameries that are scheduled are engaged exclusively in the production of milk products or whether some of them are also engaged in general business?
Comment on this
I am not able to say as regards all of them. There was one mentioned by Deputy Gorey and Deputy Gorry. In that particular case the creamery was set up by the co-operative store that had already been there for some years. But the two concerns are separate so far as finances and banking transactions go.
Comment on this
Might not a co-operative store do a little bit in carrying on its back, during a critical time, a sister society in view of the fact that the operations of the former are, generally speaking, not subject to such catastrophic pressure?
Comment on this
In view of the fact that the Finance Bill is not passed, might I ask the Minister for Agriculture to use his influence with the Minister for Finance? Certain help has been given to these creameries. I do not quarrel with that at all. I approve of help being given by the State. The Minister has made the very frank admission that if he were head of the State he would not vote £18,000 to save them. Many of these creameries are in a very bad way. They are complaining of the prices they are getting and their position is so bad that this Bill had to be introduced to save them. How can the Minister ask them to put up £18,000, which he would not recommend the State to do? Deputy Gorry talked about co-operation, but that is carrying co-operation too far. I accept what has been said about the particular creamery named. It is all to its credit that it branched out in the other directions. But it is not fair to ask the creameries that this Bill was introduced to save—some of which have extraordinary commitments, as I know—to do a thing which the Minister would not ask the State to do. I think it is a preposterous proposition to ask a few creameries to do that, and I think the Minister has not given due consideration to the matter. In view of the £29,000,000 which we are going to spend next year, the Minister should be able to get the Minister for Finance to find £9,000, the portion which would be required this year.
Comment on this
It is extraordinary to hear Deputy Gorey, and other Deputies, criticising this Schedule when, only a few minutes ago, they walked into the Lobby, trying to include other creameries or other societies in the same Schedule——
Comment on this
When they talk like this, do they ever think of their inconsistencies? I know one of the creameries included in the Schedule. As the Minister said at the outset, he proposes to come to the rescue of these societies simply because most of them, if not all of them, were established in recent years.
Comment on this
He proposes to give them assistance in this way because they were established in recent years and for other reasons, one of which is that dairying in these areas was not a tradition. I have considerable knowledge of the Dowra case, and I know that dairying was not a tradition in that district. Deputy O'Shaughnessy said that it might have been unwise to start these societies in these areas. But Deputy O'Shaughnessy should remember that a lot of institutions in the State were unwisely established and are a bit cumbersome and that if they were out of the way the taxpayer would be much better off. That they were unwisely established is no reason why we should say that we will not come to their rescue in any shape or form. They were induced to establish these societies and it is not unfair, or unreasonable, to come to their assistance in this way. Deputy Gorey referred to the fact that the Minister would not come to the House directly and ask for a vote for £16,000 or £18,000 for these twelve or thirteen societies. It seems to me that the Party of which Deputy Gorey is a member spent its last four years of office in trying to impose burdens on the taxpayer indirectly. There is very little difference in coming to the assistance of these societies in this way and coming to their assistance directly. This is tantamount to helping them out of taxation and I think the Minister is perfectly justified in choosing this way instead of the other way. I cannot understand the attitude of those Deputies who criticise this Schedule, seeing that they voted for the inclusion of other societies on a much better footing.
Comment on this
My only regret is that they are not in a much better position. Some of them are not in as good a position. To my own knowledge, some of them are in a most unfortunate position. That is why I am speaking on the matter. When I know a society with £12,000 on the wrong side of the ledger, I know they are in a worse position. I have no objection to the State coming to their assistance. I do object to other creameries coming to their assistance. I have no objection to this £18,000 being added to the £29,000,000, but I do object to its being dealt with in this way.
Comment on this
When dealing with an amendment in respect of St. Brigid's Co-operative Society, of Ballinamore, and with Inver Creamery, the Minister suggested that he had in mind a scheme for assisting creameries. I understood that Deputy Roddy withdrew his amendment on a suggestion of that kind from the Minister—that he had a scheme in mind which would render financial assistance to creameries in a difficult position.
Comment on this
I made clear to Deputy Roddy afterwards that there is no other scheme for dealing with creameries in general. There was one circumstance connected with St. Brigid's Creamery which would justify its being dealt with in another way. With regard to Inver Creamery, I asked Deputy McMenamin to mention it again on Report Stage, because I had not sufficient information regarding it.
Comment on this
With reference to the remarks made by Deputy Smith, I should like to point out that, unfortunately, the amendment was considered before the Schedule. We did not know whether the Schedule was to remain, and when the Schedule was there Deputies on this side considered that these creameries had as much right to get on as others which were there. Deputies had a perfect right to vote for their inclusion and to criticise the Schedule afterwards. Those Deputies who voted in that way were quite justified in the circumstances.
Comment on this
Deputy Smith charged us with inconsistency in seeking to have additions made to the Schedule. If there is inconsistency, it is, I think, due to a certain reticence on the part of the Minister. Last night, the Minister seemed disposed to give us information about these creameries. To-day he seems disinclined to give it. He seems to feel that there are reasons sufficiently strong to prevent his doing so. I would not say that there can be no such reasons, but I doubt if there are reasons which would prevent him giving us this information. Deputy Dowdall said that details should not be coupled with the names of creameries because that would destroy any chance these particular societies might have of making good.
I would take leave to say that this is not self evident, by any means. It is not as if there was any doubt at all cast on their position. All of us know that, in the case of a business house, the position sometimes is, that if any doubt at all is passed on its credit, or on its ability to meet its obligations, very serious harm ensues, and you may bring down a business house by casting doubt upon its credit, but I do not think that these creamery societies are in that position at all. Probably their only liabilities are liabilities to the bank, secured by guarantees, and in other ways, or perhaps, liabilities to the Department of Agriculture, and they are not looking for any more credit.
The difficulty presumably in these cases is that every month they continue working, they are adding to their liabilities and eating up any overdraft that might be sanctioned and that they are in danger of coming to a standstill. But unless you had these circumstances I would take leave to submit, subject to the Minister correcting me, that no harm would follow the disclosure of the whole circumstances of these cases. They are not general trading societies —there may be some, but I do not think that there are—they are not people looking for two or three months credit from a wholesale house, or anything of that sort. They are not going to lose milk supplies by any disclosure of their position because the milk suppliers are their members who know how things are.
Therefore, the more I think over it, the less I am disposed to accept what the Minister said about the unwisdom, or the possible unwisdom, of giving the information. I think we would know better where we were if we had it, and I do not see what possible harm it can do them. It is not going to cause the banks to close down on them, because they know already what their position is, or their milk suppliers to go away for fear they would not get their cheque, because the milk suppliers know all about their position, too, and if there is any question that knowledge to the general public might affect them, in any way, then that harm is done by putting them in the Schedule. The mere putting of them into the Schedule is a declaration that their position is almost desperate, and, that being so, I think that, all things considered, it would be better for the Minister to tell us all about them.
Every member of the House then who has a feeling that some creamery, in his particular area, is not getting fair play, by not being put in the same position as these people, will have something on which he can really come to a firm conclusion. All sorts of people can hear the tale of the difficulties of the creameries in their own areas. They can get pressure from their own area to have a particular creamery put in the Schedule, so that it may get any advantages that are going. It is a natural thing that every creamery should seek to get this extra 14/- a cwt., and natural that Deputies, knowing the difficulties of these creameries, should be disposed to add them to the Schedule unless they have information that will convince them that the condition of these creameries in the Schedule is, in some way, more deserving of consideration than others.
It is very hard to say—though this is a factor—that the mere date of starting of a creamery gives it justification. I dare say that a creamery started within the last two years, and started with a good deal of, shall we say, inducement, on the part of the Government, and a loan from the Department of Agriculture, and so on, might have some sort of special claim, but so far as any other creamery is concerned, it is doubtful. In any case, we should know whether this question of the date of starting is the only thing which is putting some creameries on, and keeping others off the scheduled list. I do not know how many of these were started within the last couple of years, or how many were started within the last five or seven years. It is extremely difficult for Deputies to discuss the Schedule or to have discussed properly even these amendments made to the Schedule, when we have not got the information. I think it is information which, if the Minister were coming to the Dáil for a Vote of money, he would be practically obliged to disclose. It is the sort of information, at any rate, that is always disclosed when a Vote is brought forward for the assistance of any institution. It is common in institutions that the accounts may be laid before the Dáil. I was thinking, when the Minister suggested the doubtful propriety of giving these details, of the analogy of a business house, and I was inclined to agree with him, but, as the discussion went on, I must say that my mind came to the view that there was no reason on earth, except that the feelings of some people concerned might be hurt, why he should not give all the story.
Comment on this
I must say that I think Deputy Blythe has done me a wrong in saying that I have become reticent about the information. I was under the impression last night that the only information he asked for was what was going to be the cost of this particular thing. I prepared this table of the cost and I gave the total here, and I said that if information as to an individual creamery was wanted, I could give it. I did not know that the Deputy wanted information from the other point of view and when I was asked about the financial standing of these particular creameries here it was the first time it was put to me and I said that I did not know if it would be proper to give that information in the Dáil but on thinking over it, I also have come to agree with the Deputy, that there is no propriety in it and that it should be given. I have not, however, got it here and could not possibly give it to-night, but I could, say, on next Tuesday, have the date of registration of these creameries on the scheduled list, and I could have their capital liabilities. I do not know if anything else is required.
Comment on this
Yes, I could give a few notes about them, but I think we cannot get any further to-night. I would suggest that the Schedule be allowed to go through, and if Deputies wish they can put down an amendment on report to have it rejected if the information is not satisfactory.
Comment on this
Deputy Smith drew attention to a certain creamery on this Schedule, and I think I pointed out earlier in the afternoon that that creamery would really be in competition, so far as milk supplies were concerned, with a neighbouring creamery. If a creamery of that kind found its way on to the Schedule, it may be that other creameries have found their way there, too, creameries which would be in competition with other creameries. The Minister said on more than one occasion this evening, that that was one of the reasons why he would not allow the creameries referred to in the various amendments to be included. It seems to me that, regardless of distance and regardless even of other considerations, there would be the inducement to the suppliers of milk to neighbouring creameries to send their supplies to the creameries included in the Schedule, and there is also, of course, the other factor, that these creameries which are getting such favoured treatment in this Schedule will offer a certain inducement to milk suppliers to neighbouring creameries to send their supplies to them.
It is doubtful after all if the Minister is really justified in treating the older established creameries in the off-hand way in which he treated them here this evening. After all, the shareholders in nearly all these cases were responsible for contributing the capital on which they were started, and they have secured the money which has enabled the creamery to carry on, particularly during the bad years. They are responsible for securing the money from banks to enable the creameries to carry on for the last four or five years.
It seems to me that creameries of that kind, which now find themselves in a very bad financial position, deserve some special consideration. The Minister enumerated a number of reasons for the position which these creameries find themselves in to-day. Amongst other things he said it was due to bad management, or to the fact that the milk supply had deteriorated, and so on. He omitted one factor, however, which is that the population of dairy cows in some of the areas from which these creameries draw their milk supplies has diminished seriously. Consequently, butter production with them has not been in an economic position for many years. Butter production in some of these cases is costing up to 40s. or 50s. per cwt. In conditions such as these, with a depreciating milk supply, with the cow population deteriorating or diminishing in numbers year by year, it was inevitable that these creameries would get into greater difficulties the longer they continued in existence. Many of these creameries are not getting an economic milk supply. It seems to me that in any scheme the Minister may be considering, not alone in connection with this Bill, but in connection with the rehabilitation of the creamery industry in this country, he should consider the advisability of reorganising the creamery areas in certain counties, so as to secure an economic supply of milk for these creameries. It is quite useless, in a case of that kind, to come to their assistance financially without, at the same time, ensuring or guaranteeing to them an economic milk supply. There are a number of counties in the West and the East where creameries are competing against each other for a supply of milk. In these counties, the areas which serve these creameries, or have served them in the past, are not economic now for various reasons which the Minister understands very well. Some of these creameries could probably be closed up altogether, and the supply of milk they are receiving at present could be diverted to neighbouring creameries. I hope the Minister will consider this matter when he is, at a later stage, considering schemes for the rehabilitation of the industry in the country.