Resolution No. 7—Customs.
Contributions 1–216 of 647. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I move that the Dáil agree with the Committee in Resolution No. 7.
(1) That there shall be charged, levied, and paid on every of the articles mentioned in the second column of the Schedule to this Resolution imported into Saorstát Eireann on or after the 12th day of May, 1932, a Customs duty of an amount equal to that percentage of the value of the article which is stated in the third column of the said Schedule opposite the mention of the article in the said second column.
(2) That the provisions of Section 8 of the Finance Act, 1919, shall apply to the duty mentioned in this Resolution in respect of any article with the substitution of the expression "Saorstát Eireann" for the expression "Great Britain and Ireland" and,
(a) where a percentage is stated in the fourth column of the Schedule to this Resolution opposite the mention of such article in the second column of the said Schedule, as though such article were included in the Second Schedule to the said Finance Act, 1919, in the list of goods to which two-thirds of the full rate is made applicable as a preferential rate, and
(b) where the word "free" appears in the fourth column of the Schedule to this Resolution opposite the mention of such article in the second column of the said Schedule, as though the said Second Schedule to the Finance Act, 1919, contained a list of goods which were, by way of preferential rate, to be admitted free of duty and such article were included in that list.
(3) That the provisions (if any) set forth in the fifth column of the Schedule to this Resolution opposite the mention in the second column of the said Schedule of any article shall apply and have effect in relation to the duty mentioned in this Resolution in respect of such article.
(4) That, whenever it is shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that the duty mentioned in this Resolution in respect of any article has been duly paid in respect of such article and that such article has not been used in Saorstát Eireann otherwise than for a purpose of manufacture, a drawback equal to the amount of the duty so paid shall be allowed on such article or on any goods in the manufacture or preparation of which such article is shown to have been used if such article or such goods (as the case may be) is or are exported as merchandise, or shipped for use as stores, or deposited in a bonded warehouse for shipment as stores.
(5) That Section 6 of the Customs and Inland Revenue Act, 1879, shall not apply to any article liable to a duty mentioned in this Resolution.
(6) That any article liable to a duty mentioned in this Resolution which is re-imported into Saorstát Eireann after exportation therefrom shall be exempt from such duty if it is shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners either
(a) that such article had not been imported prior to its exportation, or
(b) that such article had been first imported prior to the 12th day of May, 1932, or
(c) that such article had been first imported on or after the 12th day of May, 1932, and was not at the time of such importation liable to any duty of Customs, or
(d) that such article had been first imported on or after the 12th day of May, 1932, and that all duties of Customs to which it was then liable had been duly paid and either no drawback of duty had been allowed on exportation or all drawback so allowed had been repaid to the Revenue Commissioners.
(7) That articles which have been imported and exported by way of transit only shall not be deemed to have been imported or exported for the purposes of the next preceding paragraph of this Resolution.
(8) That where the Revenue Commissioners are satisfied in respect of any article liable to a duty mentioned in this Resolution, that
(a) the importer of such article resides or intends to reside permanently in Saorstát Eireann, and
(b) such article had been previously used by the importer or his family or household or had been previously used by the importer for the purposes of his trade or business, and
(c) such article is being imported into Saorstát Eireann for the use of the importer or his family or household or for the use of the importer for the purposes of his trade or business,
the Revenue Commissioners may, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, permit such article to be imported without payment of any duty mentioned in this Resolution.
(9) That where an article could be regarded as chargeable with two or more of the duties mentioned in this Resolution, such article shall be deemed to be liable only to that one of those duties in respect of which the greatest amount of duty would be payable, and such article shall accordingly be chargeable only with such duty.
(10) That the value of any article for the purposes of this Resolution shall be taken to be the price which an importer would give for the article if the article were delivered, freight and insurance paid, in bond, at the place of importation, and duty shall be paid on that value as fixed by the Revenue Commissioners.
(11) If any person does any act (whether of commission or omission) which is a contravention of any condition prescribed by the Revenue Commissioners under this Resolution or under a provision contained in the fifth column of the Schedule to this Resolution, he shall be guilty of an offence under the Customs Acts and shall for each such offence incur a penalty of fifty pounds, and any article liable to duty in respect of which such offence is committed shall be forfeited.
(12) It is hereby declared that it is expedient in the public interest that this Resolution shall have statutory effect under the provisions of the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act, 1927 (No. 7 of 1927).
SCHEDULE.
Ref. No. | Description of Articles liable to Duty. | Percentage Rate of Duty | Percentage Rate of Preferential Duty | Special Provisions
1 | Monumental, architectural, or building stone which has been dressed, polished, or otherwise worked; excluding stone which has been subjected to no process of working except sawing. | 50% | 33?% | ——
2 | Horseshoes made wholly or mainly of iron or steel. | 50% | 33?% | ——
3 | Hollow-ware of galvanized wrought iron. | 30% | 20% | ——
4 | Manufactured articles of iron or steel for use in building construction (of such types as beams, girders, channels, joists, angles, columns, posts, and tees) which are fabricated for use or otherwise advanced beyond hammering, rolling, or casting. | 50% | 33?% | ——
5 | Metal door frames, metal window frames, metal window sashes, and metal casements. | 50% | 33?% | ——
6 | Bags made wholly or mainly of paper, and imported unfilled. | 50% | 33?% | ——
7 | Blanketing and blankets, whether white or coloured, for whatever purpose intended, and also rugs other than rugs intended to be used as floor coverings. | 30% | 20% | This duty is in lieu of the duty imposed by Section 17 of the Finance Act, 1925 (No. 28 of 1925). Whenever the Revenue Commissioners are satisfied that an article which, but for this provision, would be liable to this duty either—
(a) is of the nature of blanketing or felt and is suitable for and intended solely for use in an industrial process other than the manufacture of blankets, rugs, personal clothing, or wearing apparel, or
(b) is blanketing imported for use by the importer in the manufacture by him in Saorstát Eireann of personal clothing or wearing apparel for exportation under a contract providing for the supply of such blanketing to such importer for use in such manufacture,the Revenue Commissioners may, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think to fit to impose, permit such article to be imported without payment of this duty or repay any such duty paid on such article.
8 | Putty in any form and paints and distempers in liquid form, (excluding white lead either dry or in the form of stiff paste, artists' colours in tubes, and any dry colours) | 30% | 20% | This duty is in addition to any duty chargeable in respect of any spirits contained in or used in the manufacture or preparation of the article, but in lieu of any duty chargeable in respect of any other ingredient contained in or used in the manufacture or preparation of the article.
9 | Filled quilts of any material and unfilled covers of any material intended to be filled with any kind of filling and to be used as quilts. | 37½% | 25% | This duty is in lieu of the duty imposed by Section 1 of the Finance (New Customs Duties) Act, 1930 (No. 4 of 1930).
10 | (a) Toilet (including shaving) soaps, soap powders, and soap substitutes. (b) All other soaps, soap powders, and soap substitutes. | 37½% | 25% | These duties are in lieu of the duties imposed by Section 21 of the Finance Act 1924 (No. 27 of 1924), and Section 22 of the Finance Act, 1925 (No. 28 of 1925), respectively.
(b) All other soaps, soap powders, and soap substitutes. | 22½% | 15% | These duties shall not be charged or levied on any of the following substances when imported otherwise than as a part or ingredient of any article or preparation, that is to say, sodium carbonate, sodium silicate, caustic soda, potassium carbonate, caustic potash, ammonia, borax.
11 | Writing ink in liquid or powder form. | 37½% | 25% | This duty is in addition to any duty chargeable in respect of any spirits contained in or used in the manufacture or preparation of the article, but in lieu of any duty chargeable in respect of any other ingredient contained in or used in the manufacture or preparation of the article.
12 | Adhesive pastes primarily intended for office use. | 37½% | 25% | This duty is in addition to any duty which may be chargeable in respect of any spirits contained in the article.
13 | Polishing preparations primarily intended for use on boots, shoes, and like articles, or on floors, or on furniture, or on vehicles. | 37½% | 25% | This duty is in addition to any duty chargeable in respect of any spirits or saccharin contained in or used in the manufacture or preparation of the article, but in lieu of any duty chargeable in respect of any other ingredient contained in or used in the manufacture or preparation of the article.
14 | (a) Linen piece goods, excluding the following, viz:— | 25% | Free | ——
(1) printed linen piece goods;
(2) power loom damask linen piece goods exceeding one hundred and eighty threads per square inch;
(3) hand loom damask linen piece goods;
(4) painted damask linen piece goods;
(5) turkish and chenille linen towelling piece goods;
(6) all other linen piece goods exceeding one hundred and sixty threads per square inch;
(7) oilcloth.
(b) Union piece goods, that is to say, any piece goods containing any combination of the following fibres, viz:—cotton, linen, hemp, ramie, jute, and hair, excluding turkish and chenille union towelling piece goods, and oilcloth. | 25% | Free. | ——
(c) Cotton tabling in the piece, including oilcloth. | 25% | Free. | ——
(d) Cotton towelling in the piece, excluding turkish and chenille towelling. | 25% | Free. | ——
(e) Woven articles of the following descriptions: | ——
(I) table cloths and napkins, excluding | 25% | 15%
(a) damask table cloths or napkins, if made wholly, in either warp or weft, of silk or artificial silk,
(b) painted damask table cloths and napkins,
(c) power loom damask linen table cloths and napkins exceeding one hundred and eighty threads per square inch,
(d) hand loom damask linen table cloths and napkins, | 25% | 15%
(e) table cloths made of oilcloth.
(2) table mats, tray cloths, teacloths, doyleys and duchesse sets; | 25% | 15%
(3) towels and domestic cloths, lettered or otherwise, excluding turkish and chenille towels, painted towels, and cotton sponge cloths; | 25% | 15%
(4) sheets, excluding linen sheets exceeding one hundred and sixty threads per square inch; | 25% | 15%
(5) tarpaulins of linen, union, or cotton, proofed or unproofed, excluding tarpaulins of jute. | 25% | 15%
15 | Matter printed on paper and imported in bulk quantities, excluding matter printed on paper which at importation is pasted on or otherwise firmly adhering to cardboard and also excluding unbound books, newspapers, periodicals, and articles liable to duty, No. 16 in this Schedule. | 15% | 10% | ——
16 | Stationery of any of the following descriptions, viz.—
(a) envelopes, notepaper, writing pads; | 50% | 33½% | ——
(b) manuscript books, ruled or unruled, with or without headings;
(c) commercial stationery, whether bound or not bound;
(d) labels and tags, imported in bulk quantities;
(e) trade catalogues, imported in bulk quantities;
(f) tickets imported in bulk quantities.
17 | Iron or steel wire, excluding the following articles, viz — barbed wire, wire netting of hexagonal mesh, cables and ropes, pins of all descriptions, nails and tacks of all descriptions. | 22½% | 15% | ——
18 | Articles manufactured wholly or partly of wood or timber (not including planed or dressed wood or timber, mouldings, staves, sleepers, scaffolding poles, telegraph and telephone poles, plywood, and vencer, imported as such), that is to say— | Where the Revenue Commissioners are satisfied that the quantity of wood contained in any article liable to this duty forms only an inconsiderable portion of the whole of such article, the
(a) builder's woodwork and component parts thereof. | 22½% | 15% | Revenue Commissioners may, subject to compliance with
(b) all other manufactures of wood or timber (other than machinery, implements, furniture, articles for use in sport, scientific and medical instruments and apparatus, articles for use in coach and vehicle building, butter boxes, egg boxes, barrels, casks, kegs, and component parts thereof and tools and component parts of such manufactures. | 50% | 33?% | such conditions as they think fit to impose, permit such article to be imported without payment of this duty or repay any such duty paid on importation.
19 | Articles of the nature of disinfectant, insecticide, germicide, verminicide, vermicide or fungicide which pass in commerce under the designation of a proprietary or protected trade name. | 22½% | 15% | ——
20 | Cast iron articles of the following descriptions, viz.— | 22½% | 15%
(a) external water and soil pipes, gutters, and connections; | ——
(b) sash weights;
(c) pig troughts and feeding pans;
(d) desk and seat standards;
(e) manhole covers and frames of all sizes whether galvanized or not galvanized;
(f) hydrant and valve covers;
(g) gulley traps;
(h) cart axle boxes;
(i) pavement light frames, with or without glass;
(j) sky and dead lights;
(k) grids for sewer pipes or traps;
(l) barrow and truck wheels.
21 | Superphosphates, ground mineral phosphates, and compound manures. | 20% | Free
22 | Handcarts and wheelbarrows made wholly or mainly of wood, and component parts (made wholly or mainly of wood) of handcarts and wheelbarrows. | 75% | 50% | The Revenue Commissioners may make regulations providing for the total or partial exemption from this duty for a limited period of articles liable to this duty brought into Saorstát Eireann by persons making only a temporary stay therein.
23 | Complete or substantially assembled bicycles and tricycles (other than mechanically propelled bicycles and tricycles), and wheeled vehicles (not mechanically propelled) ordinarily used for the transport of children. | 37½% | 25% | The Revenue Commissioners may make regulations providing for the total or partial exemption from this duty for a limited period of articles liable to this duty brought into Saorstát Eireann by persons making only a temporary stay therein.
Where the Revenue Com missioners are satisfied that an article liable to this duty is of a type designed for use by invalids or infirm persons they may, subject to compliance with such conditions as they may think fit to impose, permit such article to be imported without payment of this duty or any such duty paid on importation.
24 | Photographic prints of a superficial area of not less than twentyfive square inches and printed direct from a photographic film or photographic plate. | 50% | 33½% | ——
25 | Bedding, including mattresses not otherwise liable to duty, but excluding blankets, blanketing and rugs, sheets, filled quilts and unfilled quilt covers. | 37½% | 25% | ——
26 | Cushions and cushioned seats not otherwise liable to duty, whether fixed or not fixed to any other article at importation, and also cases for such cushions and seats which are not otherwise liable to duty. | 37½% | 25% | ——
27 | Any of the following articles made wholly or partly of steel or iron, that is to say:— | 15% | 10% | ——
(a) knives, knife sharpeners, forks, spoons and tongs of a kind suitable for table use, and component parts thereof.
(b) razors and component parts thereof.
28 | Photographic apparatus and component parts and accessories thereof, but excluding apparatus and component parts and accessories of apparatus for use in hospital or surgical work. | 15% | 10% | ——
29 | Gas meters. | 15% | 10% | ——
30 | Galvanized corrugated iron. | 15% | 10% | ——
31 | Pipes made wholly or mainly of wood and designed or intended for use in smoking tobacco or other substances, and also component parts (made wholly or mainly of wood) of such pipes. | 15% | 10% | ——
32 | Roof felting and felting substitutes and other like substances intended for use as roofing material. | 15% | 10% | ——
33 | Floor coverings, including carpets and rugs not otherwise liable to duty, but excluding oilcloth, linoleum, and substances of a nature kindred to oilcloth or linoleum. | 15% | 10% | ——
34 | Manufactured articles which are made wholly or mainly of brass, tin, or lead, or any combination of brass, tin, and lead or any two of them and are not otherwise subject to duty, exclusive of any box or other container which at importation is filled with other goods. | 15% | 10% | This duty shall not be charged or levied on any article which in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners is specially manufactured and designed for use by the proprietors of dairies and creameries in the processes of their business.
35 | Appliances, apparatus, accessories, and requisites for sports, games, gymnastics, and athletics (other than personal clothing and wearing apparel, boots, shoes, slippers, goloshes, sandals and clogs) and component parts of such appliances, apparatus, accessories, and requisities. | 15% | 10% | ——
36 | Cordage, cables, ropes, and twine of hemp or like materials. | 15% | 10% | ——
37 | Knitted fabric of all descriptions imported in the piece, excluding Knitted fabric composed entirely of silk or artificial silk or a mixture of silk and artificial silk. | 45% | 30% | Whenever the Minister for Industry and Commerce is satisfied that knitted fabric liable to this duty is not manufactured in Saorstát Eireann in quantities sufficient for the requirements of manufacturers in Saorstát Eireann of personal clothing or wearing apparel, the said Minister may at his discretion issue to any person a licence to import into Saorstát Eireann knitted fabric of all descriptions or of any specified descriptions or description, either without limit as to time and quantity or either of them or within a specified time or in a specified quantity, subject to the condition that such knitted fabric shall be used in the manufacture in Saorstát Eireann of personal clothing or wearing apparel and to such other conditions as the said Minister shall think proper to specify in such licence.
The Revenue Commissioners shall admit without payment of this duty all knitted fabric which is imported into Saorstát Eireann under and in accordance with a licence issued by the Minister for Industry and Commerce under the foregoing provision.
38 | Mechanical lighters, that is to say, tinder boxes, tinder lighters, and other mechanical and portable contrivances for producing a spark or flame. | 37½% | 25% | ——
Comment on this
I do not know if it is intended that we should discuss Resolution 7 in the way an Estimate is discussed by taking the various reference numbers and going down them?
Comment on this
My intention was to allow discussion in that way but, in view of the difficulty of getting through the business by 10.30, I am not sure whether that course can now be followed. It would undoubtedly be the most satisfactory procedure.
Comment on this
Would it not be possible to allow questions on each paragraph, so as to get the matter clearer for Committee Stage of the Bill?
Comment on this
I am quite prepared not to move the amendments in my name but to raise the points on the section.
Comment on this
In view of the number of amendments, I think it would be necessary to move that the section be re-committed to Committee on Finance.
Comment on this
Is that because the Minister's amendments, instead of being remissions of, are additions to taxation?
Comment on this
The point is that we get shortly before 3 o'clock to-day amendments from the Minister which, instead of being remissions of, are, in fact, additions to the taxation imposed some weeks ago. The Minister requires not only our forbearance to give him all the resolutions to-day but our further forbearance to allow him to impose new taxation to-day.
Comment on this
That is not a matter with which the Chair can deal. The Minister is proposing to recommit Resolution No. 7 for the purpose of dealing with certain amendments.
Comment on this
I am quite prepared to move that the Resolution as a whole be re-committed. I hope that "freedom of discussion" will not mean extension of the discussion.
Comment on this
There is no difficulty about that because the debate has to conclude to-night.
Resolution recommitted.
Comment on this
I should like to ask if artificial stone and marble chippings are included in No. 1 on the Schedule. There is another item which I wish to bring to the attention of the Minister. Under this heading Aberdeen polished granite, black and blueblack, would be included and liable to duty, and from the shop fitting point of view that is very serious. I am not aware that there is any prospect of getting this polished granite worked here, so that it becomes a purely revenue producing tax. That brings me to the fact that that is going to increase the cost of the very best class of shops in the best thoroughfares. I should like to appeal to the Minister from the point of view of the amenities of this city, because it is desirable that shops should have the very best appearance possible. It occurs to me that if the cost of this is going to be run up enormously, you are going to have a class of shop put up that will not redound to the credit of the city.
Comment on this
I should like to support what Deputy Dockrell has said. I have had information supplied to me which leads me to believe that it is impossible to get this polished granite work done in the State, and I would urge the Minister to reconsider the matter. I am convinced that the effect of this tariff will be to cause more unemployment, rather than to bring about employment. Most of the employment that comes from working on the stone comes after the polishing. A great deal of that kind of work, such as lettering, etc., is done on the stone here. I am informed that there is no possibility, certainly at present, of getting the granite itself polished in this State, and that the only effect of this will be that less purchases will be made, and therefore there will be less decorative work to be done, and hands will be actually put out of employment.
I want to add that in the case of marble, for instance, what has happened in similar circumstances has been that a corresponding export duty has been placed on outgoing marble from the country which supplies it, the result being that there is hardly any difference between the cost of the polished marble and the untouched marble, that each can be bought at practically the same price. The effect will be that that will mean a much higher price to the purchaser here, and therefore all the less business will result. There will be less of the final work, such as lettering, to be done, and therefore less employment will be given to workmen engaged on that work. I would ask the Minister to inquire into the matter very carefully because I am convinced that the tariff will actually cause less employment and not more.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister whether he has considered the great hardship that will be inflicted on contractors already engaged in the erection of buildings, for which they have estimated as long as 12 months ago, with regard to getting the dressed stone from round about Newry. The Minister is aware that very large quantities of this stone have been imported into the Free State. It is largely used by certain builders who will suffer a great loss if they are not allowed to have as much of this stone as will enable them to finish the contracts on which they are engaged. I would ask the Minister to consider allowing a sufficient quantity of that stone to be imported under licence to enable these builders to finish the contracts on which they are engaged. Dealing with the question in general, I agree with Deputy Thrift that it would be a wise policy on the part of the Minister to re-investigate the question of the import duty on stone. Take Portland stone. As far as I understand, the cost of the raw material is almost half of the finished article. In that case, it will mean very little additional employment to the stone-cutters in the City of Dublin. The fact of allowing the raw material to come in free of duty means that it is going to have a serious effect on the opening of our native quarries. I wonder has the Minister considered that aspect of the question, that it will mean that no quarries will be opened in the Free State if he allows the raw material to come in duty free. I ask him to give very serious consideration to the question of the import of Newry dressed granite under licence in connection with certain contracts.
Comment on this
As regards the effect of allowing the importation of raw stone in free of duty on the quarrying industry here, of course that industry is in no worse position than it was before the duty was imposed. I agree that there is a case for consideration as to the action which might be taken to develop the quarrying industry and to ensure that stone of one kind or another from Irish quarries would replace the imported stone, where feasible. That question is being examined. As to the point made by the Deputy in relation to contractors who have entered into engagements to import worked stone from over the Border, I am afraid nothing can be done.
Comment on this
I know the quarry to which the Deputy is referring and all the circumstances of the case that he has in mind. As it is only a few yards across the Border, it means merely importing the sawn stone across the Border and getting the work of finishing it done in the territory of the Free State, in which case no duty will be payable.
Comment on this
Will the Minister allow the stone already dressed in under licence? I am informed that there is a very considerable quantity of that stone already dressed and ready to be despatched to its destination, and it would be a great hardship not to allow it to be brought in.
Comment on this
Fortunately or unfortunately, there is no power under the law to admit dutiable goods free of duty in a case of that kind. As regards artificial stone, I am afraid I am in some difficulty. Monumental and architectural stone is subject to duty. As to whether artificial stone is subject to duty would depend on the amount of stone and that is a matter I am afraid the Deputy will have to argue with the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
The question of slate is a different matter. I am proposing to amend the Resolution definitely to exclude slate from its scope. There is no need for the imposition of a protective duty on slate. It is intended therefore to make it quite clear that slate is not included in the scope of the duty. Other provisions are under consideration for the development of the slate quarrying industry. It is hoped that these provisions will be quite adequate for some time to come. I am proposing also to amend the Resolution by putting in after the word "sawing" the word "crushing," to ensure that the marble chips which had been referred to will not be covered.
Comment on this
Does the Minister intend to let in slate slabs? Some of these slate slabs are enamelled on the face. Would that make any difference?
Comment on this
This paragraph of the schedule imposes the first duty and I would like to take exception to one thing which the Minister said without going into the details of the paragraph. In dealing with the question of artificial stone, he said that Deputy Dockrell would have to argue the matter out with the Revenue Commissioners. It seems to me that the Minister is under a misapprehension as to the functions of the Revenue Commissioners. When we have passed certain laws here it is undoubtedly the function of the Revenue Commissioners to interpret them but while we are in process of making these laws, it is for us as clearly as may be and as clearly as we can to define these laws. It is quite wrong, I suggest, for the Minister to say to a person "We say it is stone if the Revenue Commissioners think it is, and it is not stone if they say it is not." I suggest to the Minister that it is for this House now to make clear whether it is included in the definition given. It is for the Minister to say what he intends and for us in the House in the process of making the law to make clear to the Revenue Commissioners what we mean the law to be.
Comment on this
This duty is placed on monumental architectural stone. Something has been mentioned which is not stone. If it is not stone, it is not subject to the duty, but if there is any doubt on the matter it is for the Revenue Commissioners to decide.
Comment on this
Again I say that the Minister is completely wrong in his conception of the duty of the Revenue Commissioners. It is a very difficult thing to impose a tariff and be quite clear as to what you mean to cover by the tariff. This Resolution will go down in history as the greatest example of that, but if a particular difficulty is raised, it is for the Minister to consider it on its merits and if he finds it necessary to do so to bring in an amendment to elucidate it. It is not for the Minister to say, "Here is a tariff; if you think that certain articles are not included in it, you can ask the Revenue Commissioners."
Comment on this
What is the Minister's mind in regard to this? Is the duty imposed on anything whatever in stone?
Comment on this
The intention is to tax worked stone, that is, stone intended for monumental, architectural or building work which has been subject to any process except that of crushing or sawing.
Comment on this
We come to another class called artificial stone which is not stone—synthetic stone. Does the Minister want to have that taxed? The Minister says that it depends on the amount of stone. If there is only a certain percentage of stone, is that to be taxed? What is the Minister's mind on the matter? We should not leave it to the Revenue Commissioners to decide the matter.
Comment on this
I suggest that there is no such thing as synthetic stone. Stone is stone or it is not stone. You can argue about that until the cows come home and you get back to the final question as to whether a thing is stone or is not stone.
Comment on this
Some previous speakers have anticipated my difficulty—the definition of what is stone. We are up against a difficulty. I am not asking anything for the purpose of creating difficulties in the Minister's mind, but the question that occurred to my own mind is this, does stone include marble? We can in this country produce black and grey marble, but we do not produce white marble. I want to know is marble included in the word "stone," because the Minister might exclude white marble which is used in ecclesiastical work and which cannot be produced here.
Comment on this
White marble or any marble coming in in an unprepared state is not subject to duty. At the moment we are merely endeavouring to foster the stone-working industry.
Comment on this
What synthetic stone is I do not know. A cement slab might be described as synthetic stone.
Comment on this
Perhaps it would simplify matters to take it down to a small point—will this apply to marbles?
Comment on this
Can we get that as the nearest approach to a definition— that it is really natural stone that is aimed at?
Comment on this
With all respect to the people who are so interested, there is in the Minister's office a slab of what is called synthetic marble. It is crushed marble with certain binding material put into it. It is certainly synthetic, and although it is composed in the main of natural marble, it would not come under the definition from what the Minister has just stated.
Comment on this
I know the material that the Deputy has in mind. That material will not be subject to duty. That is material made of marble crushings bound together by a composition of some kind. It is not intended to make that subject to duty —yet.
Comment on this
The Minister must know that some beautiful specimens of monumental work can be cast in concrete or cement. Will they be subject to duty?
Comment on this
It comes under the name of cast stone or cement, and it may have some effect as regards the evasion of duty.
Comment on this
I have received representations in regard to polished granite and I am having them examined. My whole inclination is against giving any concession in regard to it. It seems to me that if we cannot get polished granite we can get some other material in this country. I do not wish to commit myself definitely in regard to that because it is under examination.
Comment on this
Would the Minister also consider the point about white marble which cannot be got here?
Comment on this
A marble slab will not be subject to duty. If it is imported in the raw for working here there is no duty upon it.
Comment on this
Would the Minister satisfy himself as to the truth or otherwise of the statement I have made that the imposition of a tariff here will be followed by the imposition of an export duty on the marble abroad? That will lead to more unemployment.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment a2:
In the Schedule, Ref. No. 3, page 6, in the second column, before the word "Hollow-ware" to insert the word "Domestic," and after the word "iron" to insert the words "or steel, including galvanized gutters, pipes, and ridgings."
In order to make it clear, I may say that this duty applies only to domestic hollow-ware or galvanized wrought iron or steel and it includes galvanized gutters, pipes and ridgings, but not galvanised tanks or cisterns.
Comment on this
I should like to congratulate the Minister on that definition. I may say that the proposal originally left the trade gasping as to what was meant. As regards galvanised gutters, pipes and ridgings, has the Minister assured himself that there is an adequate source of supply?
Comment on this
I have examined the matter fairly fully and I am satisfied that the existing concerns are quite competent to supply all the requirements of the country in relation to the articles subject to duty.
Comment on this
The Minister has indicated that there is an adequate supply of these commodities in this country. I will refer particularly to galvanised buckets, which are, as we all know, very widely used by the agricultural community. If the Minister imagines that he can put on 30 per cent. on Continental buckets and 20 per cent. on British buckets without increasing the price to the small farmer in the Free State, he is living in a fool's paradise. Unless the Minister takes legislative powers to ascertain the current prices in England and enforce those prices on the manufacturers here, it will mean that the cost of those articles is going to go up and every farmer who feeds cattle and pigs and who utilises these articles for the purpose will have to pay more.
In addition to that, a good many country people use galvanised pig troughs, a very desirable change. I do not know of any place in this country where these articles are effectively made or cheaply made. I know they were at one time manufactured, but from the point of view of price they were almost unpurchasable. It simply means now that if you put 20 per cent. on them every one using those articles will go back to the wooden trough.
Comment on this
Galvanised pig troughs are not subject to duty. Ungalvanised pig troughs are subject to another duty.
Comment on this
Then "domestic" excludes pig troughs. Am I to assume that "domestic" includes buckets?
Comment on this
Buckets and pig troughs are on most farms. In my opinion if you put on a tariff of 20 per cent. you will undoubtedly increase the cost to the farmers. How you will differentiate between a bucket and a pig trough, I do not know.
Comment on this
What is the exact extension that the Minister gives to the scope of these words "domestic hollow-ware"? It is not a question of the Minister's ruling; it is a question of what we pass by way of legislation and what will be the interpretation put upon it by the Revenue Commissioners or a Court. "Domestic hollow-ware" will include a bucket but not a pig trough. Is it because the bucket is to be used about the house and the pig trough is not? Will "domestic" apply to articles used mainly in the house?
Comment on this
It is intended to bring in cans and buckets and trays-articles of domestic use. There are some other things that could be made here, but they will not be subject to the duty unless they are domestic hollow-ware. As regards Deputy Dillon's point about prices, I have been assured that the prices which will prevail here will not exceed the English prices. That is a different proposition to saying that the prices prevailing here will be no higher than the prices at which we could buy English galvanised hollow-ware. There has been a consistent price cut on behalf of English firms in order to put Irish firms out of business. They succeeded in putting the major firms here out of business within recent months. That activity has been re-started and under the protection of the duty it is felt that the price cutting which operated before cannot now be successful in preventing the development of the industry. For a long period we could buy English galvanised hollow-ware in this country cheaper than they could buy it in England. That was the confirmed policy of manufacturers and it was designed to clear the market here of competition. It succeeded. The protection afforded by the duty will help to alter the situation that previously existed.
Comment on this
In so far as the price prevailing was uneconomic, was a dumping price designed to destroy Irish industries, there will be an increase up to the economic price, but we will be paying no more than the English people are paying.
Comment on this
Suppose the particular commodities that the Minister has mentioned that are manufactured in galvanized wrought iron are brought in here as ordinary wrought iron and galvanized here, will they be admitted free?
Comment on this
Has the Minister ever yet met any group of manufacturers who did not assure him (a) that they had been beaten down in price because of the deliberate policy of English manufacturers to dump goods and so destroy Irish industry and (b) that there will be no increase in price after the tariff is imposed? Why have we not the cheapest cost of living in the world if everything is being dumped in here in that fashion?
Comment on this
The question has been raised many times as to whether there could be some definition of the word "fabrication" as applied to steel. Some people think that even the cutting of a steel joist is fabrication. Others think that because there are a couple of holes put into steel that it is fabrication. There are different interpretations of what the word actually means in its application to steel. What does it mean when applied to steel work?
Comment on this
Has the Minister considered the case of a contractor who entered into a contract, say to construct some building, before this tax was imposed and who now finds himself faced with very heavy additional cost? I am informed that in one case the extra cost will be approximately £2,000 and in another case the extra cost will be much in excess of that figure. In what way will provision be made in respect of that, if there is any provision made? There are, of course, the two sides to the question. A person enters into a contract for a given sum, say £20,000. This particular impost will make the cost of construction £22,000. It is unfair to the builder who enters into the contract without any information as to a likely increase to be asked to pay the extra amount. On the other hand, the person who gave the order might have hesitated if he were aware that the building was going to cost him £2,000 more than the price he originally agreed to pay. In respect of that particular problem, I would like to see some solution attempted on the part of the Minister. In cases where contracts have been entered into, special provision ought to have been made to allow in the goods free of charge pending the completion of the contract.
There are very few people who normally would be prepared to spend £22,000 on a building which it was calculated last year would cost only £20,000. On the other hand, the Minister might examine the question whether builders' profits would admit of such a contraction as £2,000 on, say, a £20,000 contract. I can get particulars of one case and possibly of another.
Comment on this
Personally I have considerable sympathy with the view that there might be some provision in the law, where a customs duty is imposed, that because of special hardship of the kind referred to there might be a temporary period during which the importation would take place. The situation to which the Deputy referred was effected by the fact that it was largely by accident that the goods became subject to the duty.
Comment on this
That affects the ultimate cost undoubtedly. It does not affect the builder's profits. I think it is correct to say there is a provision in the law by which a builder is entitled to increase his price by the amount of a duty if a duty is imposed that affects the cost of his material.
Comment on this
I am not so sure of that. I am urging the other case, that there are few people who, if they were willing to accept a tender of £20,000, would just as willingly accept a tender of £22,000. A man makes up his mind as to what a thing is going to cost. He is prepared to go that distance, but he is not prepared to go the other distance although he is getting delivery of goods value for the money. The only solution I can think of in connection with such a case is to allow in the goods free of duty in respect of contracts made and in course of construction.
Comment on this
I have sympathy with that point of view and will consider what can be done. At the same time, it seems to me that it is almost impossible to get a provision that would enable anything to be done and at the same time that would not enable abuses to take place. The Minister empowered to do that would have to get very wide powers and, in my opinion, the Dáil should refuse to give them. Only in cases where it was shown that hardship had been inflicted or something of that kind should he admit the importation of goods free of duty. I am afraid the powers required would be so wide that the Dáil would hardly grant them. Of course, if you were to take such powers in respect of any class of goods subject to duty, you would have to take them in respect of almost every class of goods. Every time a duty is imposed you will have cases where somebody has been caught out. The goods may be in course of shipment or actually at the port but not cleared, and in such cases, hardship is inflicted. It is impossible to see how you could do what the Deputy suggests without running great risks. We know that in another country, when the Government proposed to impose duties they gave notice of their intention to do so. As a result there was considerable forestalling, and the rushing in of goods before a particular date. In our case, we could not risk that. It was necessary to follow the method which always operated here, to impose the duty without notice and bring it into effect at once.
Comment on this
While I will admit, with certain reservations, what the Minister has said, I do not say that it is not beyond the bounds of possibility to set up an arbitrator to consider a question of that sort. Practically every contract has a stipulation that, in the event of a dispute, the matter can go before an arbitrator. We do not want in this case to confer a benefit. I suppose we may start out on the assumption that we do not want to impose any disabilities. If there be acceptance of that then it may be possible in the way that I have suggested to have justice done. One of the contracts that I speak of is to last, I understand, for four years. It is inevitable, I think, that contractors in future will hesitate before taking big contracts. If they do not hesitate they will certainly put in a provision to recoup themselves against loss. Obviously no person is going to give a contract in a case of that sort, where he does not know over a period of years what the increase is likely to be. I suggest the desirability of examining the case from the point of view of having an arbitrator appointed in these cases in which contracts have been entered into and are in course of execution so as to ensure that no injustice would occur as a result of the policy which the Government are adopting. I am quite sure that when they were considering their policy on the matter that particular complexity was not before the minds of Ministers. Now that the Minister is in possession of the facts I hope he will see that no serious injustice is done. It may be that as regards some of these contracts the man giving them would not have an extra £2,000 or £3,000. I knew a case in which the Dublin Corporation entered into a contract in which the plant and all that sort of thing came to such a sum—something like £20,000—that though the man was perfectly solvent, it actually put him to the end of his resources and he had to get out of the contract, not having the extra £4,000 or £5,000 that would allow the work to go on.
Comment on this
No. It happened many years ago. The point that I wish to put is that it may be that a man may find himself at the end of his capital resources and, in that case, very serious hardship would occur not alone to the builder himself but to whoever had given the contract for the building.
Comment on this
I would like to know if the Minister has been fully advised on the question he referred to, the power of a contractor to increase the price of his contract by the amount of the increase imposed on him as a result of the tariff. I know that a contractor who supplies goods is entitled, under a provision of the customs law, to raise the price of the goods that he supplies. I know one builder at least who has had counsel's opinion, and it was to the effect that the section would not cover him, that he is not a supplier of goods, that he is in a sense, if you like, a manufacturer. He has had counsel's opinion that he is not covered and would not be allowed to increase the price of his contract. It may be that the counsel's opinion which that builder got was not sound, and that the Minister has had other advice. At any rate, there seems to be doubt about it. If the counsel who has been advising my informant is correct, then there is a special hardship applying to one class of trader, if you like, which would call for the giving of some sort of exemption in regard to work already contracted for. I think it should be possible to do that. There may be some difficulty, but if the matter is confined to steel work required for buildings for which the contract has already been taken, and for no others, there should be means at the disposal of the Revenue Commissioners for checking the quantities which seem to be required.
Comment on this
I would advise that builder to pay for a contrary opinion and to produce the two opinions to the Minister.
Comment on this
I will have the matter examined as well as the suggestion made by the Deputy which I think is feasible, because as far as I know there is only one case in which fabricated steel intended for constructional purposes subject to the duty arising out of a contract was brought in.
Comment on this
Having examined the matter, if the Minister finds himself disinclined to introduce a provision to the effect that has been discussed here I would suggest this to him: At the present moment there is considerable unemployment in the building trade, and naturally everyone is anxious to see as much building work done as possible; but there is also uncertainty as to what other additional taxes or other increases may not be put on in the case of building materials. There is a considerable amount of talk with regard to the setting up of the cement factory. Persons anxious to engage on either big building schemes, or the building of any big institution, will, under the present circumstances, either inflate their building cost against possible risks of a rise like that, or they will be caught by any additional tax that may be put on. I think that a clearing up of this aspect of the position of contracts, after increases like this have been put on, would assist those who are running the building industry in making up their minds as to what exactly they are going to do in the constructional line at present.
Comment on this
Am I to understand that the Minister is going to give favourable consideration to the point raised by Deputy Cosgrave in regard to steel girders? If so, and if, as the Minister has said, it is the only case in the country, will he give the same consideration to dressed stones? There is only one firm in Newry involved.
Comment on this
I think there is a special case where the fabricated steel is involved, because the amount of steel which might be imported under one contract might run into many thousands of pounds, and, consequently, the duty payable, if the steel had been ordered and fabricated before importation, might be very considerable indeed. I am afraid there might be a very large number of cases similar to that in which Deputy Coburn is interested.
Comment on this
There is only one, and it affects a big section of the people well known to the Minister at the other side of the Border. There is no difference between the two.
Comment on this
I understood the Minister to say that contractors were protected against these duties imposed after the contract had been entered into. Some of us were under the same impression——
Comment on this
Do not give your case away. I am trying to settle it for you and you are going to put your foot in it again.
Comment on this
We feel much indebted for the assistance we have had from Deputy Cosgrave, but might I point out that it was the intention that contractors and others should have such protection, as far back as 1901. The particular section he refers to, Section 10, is embodied in the Finance Act of 1901, and it is there prescribed that the buyer and seller shall be protected, and it was the intention, I am quite satisfied, when that clause was incorporated, that contractors should be included in the terms, but now it has been found that there is a question about their inclusion, and consequently an unfair and unjust liability will be thrown on them. Under those circumstances, it has been pointed out that it is only fair that such an injustice should not be thrown on them. There is, then, the other aspect of the case as to contracts entered into in the future. Of course, there the burdens would have to be borne by the building owner, but I would point out to the Minister that it is desirable that in all businesses there should be stability. If we are going to have these tariffs dumped on at intervals, it is going to affect all businesses, because supposing we transfer the liability to the building owner, and the building owner feels that if he enters into a contract of some considerable magnitude, he might become liable for additional liabilities of this particular character, he will then say: "Well, until things are much more settled, I will not enter into a contract," and in that way, work is stopped.
It is quite obvious that we want stability in these matters, if we are to get work done, and people to embark on building work. I would urge, except it were a matter of absolute necessity, that disturbance of this character should not be introduced at intervals. If that policy be adopted for the future, we have only to meet the present difficulties, and I think they may be met, if the Minister will inquire into the matter and see if something cannot be done by way of amendment to widen the scope of that particular section, so that it will carry out all that I am quite satisfied it is intended to carry out, that is, that if the words "buyer" and "seller" in that section of the Finance Act were enlarged, say, under a definition in the new Finance Act. I think it would get out of the difficulty in a simple way. I agree, however, with what Deputy Cosgrave, Deputy Blythe, and Deputy Mulcahy have said, that it is an injustice to throw this liability on to an individual who is carrying out a contract, and which he entered into, either six or twelve months previously, without any idea in his mind or without making any provision in his contract against such an emergency. To ask that man to pay a large sum of money in those circumstances, I think, is quite unfair, and I am quite sure it is not the intention of the Minister. If something can be done to get out of that difficulty, it will satisfy those engaged in the industry.
Comment on this
Would the Minister also take into consideration a matter on which I have been in communication with him—a factory which, also, has contracts dependent on the importation of metal casings and which is seriously compromised at present. Would he take into consideration the matter of allowing the completion of their contracts on the same terms as requested by Deputy Cosgrave.
Comment on this
The point raised by Deputy Good is a somewhat different one. My advice is that contractors are safeguarded under the section of the Finance Act of 1901 to which the Deputy referred.
Comment on this
We have had legal advice from two of the most eminent men in the City that we are not protected. That is the difficulty. We do not want to slip down between the two.
Comment on this
The Minister must have got the second opinion that I advised should be got on that point.
Comment on this
Possibly. As regards the question of the metal casings referred to, I would not like to give any promise in that connection, until I got some more information about it. I have given no promise in respect of anything as yet, but I will undertake that when a very large contract has been entered into for fabricated steel——
Comment on this
—fabricated steel, and where the building for which that fabricated steel was designed was in the course of construction when the tariff was imposed, we would consider what could be done to meet the special difficulty there arising. If the Deputy will forward particulars of the case he is interested in, I will see what the situation is.
Comment on this
As regards the point raised by Deputy Good as to the need for stability, I appreciate that, and that is why I am anxious that we should get the position clarified and our intentions known in respect of these things, and to leave the position then as it stands.
Comment on this
This thing divides itself into the question of existing contracts and future contracts. The point about existing contracts again divides itself into the position of the contractor, and the position of the person for whom the building is being erected. I understand that, although no promise has been given, the Minister's attitude is that the contractor is protected under the old clause of the 1901 Act.
Comment on this
But there is considerable doubt about that, and would it not be a good thing to clear it up? I take it that the Minister's sympathy, at any rate, is with the contractor, and that he would like to see the provisions of the 1901 Act clarified to make their position clear, beyond shadow of doubt. If that is so, it will mean a very small amendment, and we have had amendments, from time to time, for the purpose of clearing up doubt when it has appeared, but that does not get away from the difficulty that arises in a case of existing contracts—the difficulty of the purchaser or the person for whom the building is being put up. If the contractor can pass on the amount, then the person, say, who has contracted for some building with, say, £20,000 worth of steel work in it, is going to find himself landed with an additional five or six thousand pounds, and the question is one of protecting that person. Clearly, that steelwork was never going to be done here, and, clearly, a person who has entered into a contract cannot get out of it. I am not speaking of the contractor, but of the other party to the contract—a contract entered into in good faith— the person for whom the building is being put up. He may contract, at a certain price, subject to certain contingencies and fluctuations, as is always the case. Suddenly, there is to be put on a building which would have £15,000 to £18,000 worth of steel an addition of one-third. That is a a tremendous hardship and that is not the contractor's case if he can take advantage of the 1901 Act, the cost is going to be passed on. Suppose the contractor has not got protection under the 1901 Act, our sympathies must shift back to him. He has entered into a contract to do a particular piece of work at a particular price and he suddenly finds that one item of his constructional costs has gone up by one-third. Some sympathy should be extended to that person in relation to a duty put on an item in a contract bona fide entered into, not by way of forestalling but as a matter of business. If the Minister desires to clear up the contractor's position, that is easily done, because it only means a clarifying amendment to the 1901 Act setting forth that those terms "purchaser" and "seller" and so on include all that we intend them to include. The other part of the contract must be looked to but we must leave that to see what will come from the Minister on the Committee Stage of the Finance Bill. It is a case for sympathetic consideration, and it is not a case into which any item of forestalling could enter. We are told that to do anything of that nature would give terrific powers. If the Minister is afraid of taking too great powers to himself or to the Executive Council, if he looks at amendment 23, he will see what startling powers are being sought by the Minister for Finance. The powers there will lead to something in the nature of a rival to the Hospital Sweepstakes, because there will be an element of gambling in relation to forestalling that was never thought of before. In future contracts, the great consideration is stability. Nobody is going to enter on the construction of any premises into which steel work enters on the basis of existing prices, because nobody will know what addition to the final price is going to take place. I think that there should be some declaration as to when the Ministry shall have come to the end of their tariff policy in regard to all these matters that enter into building construction so as to give the public security in respect of the building of private houses. It would be well to have some statement from the Minister also as to when he believes steelwork is going to be fabricated, in the more general sense of that word, here and at what price to the consumer, in comparison with the present price, that fabricated steelwork is to be sold.
Comment on this
There is another aspect of that question to which I should like to draw attention. Even assuming the contractor has power under the Act of 1901 to recoup himself for losses sustained as a result of this import duty, it is a well-known fact that contractors, as a rule, do not like to bring their clients to court. In many cases, they would prefer to suffer a loss. That applies, particularly, to certain types of men, and it is another reason why the Minister should give sympathetic consideration to the suggested remission of this duty on building material.
Comment on this
I am afraid I cannot answer that question. I am not clear as to what expanded metal is.
Comment on this
I would require notice of that. If it is steel which has been advanced beyond hammering, rolling or easting, it would be covered.
Comment on this
Then, it is subject to duty. With regard to the points raised by Deputy McGilligan, I am satisfied that all the fabrication of steel that is, or is likely to be, required, can be done by existing firms engaged in the industry here. One firm, if not two firms, is at the moment opening works, or proposing to open works, for the purpose, so that the capacity of the industry to meet the requirements of the country will have been increased in a very short time over what it was when the duty was imposed and at that time the existing firms were capable of supplying our requirements. As regards price, the Deputy is, I think, aware of an arrangement which put constructional firms here at a considerable disadvantage with competing English firms. These English firms get a rebate from English steel manufacturers which is not available to Irish engineering firms. Consequently, it was always possible for the English firms to underquote the Irish firms, particularly in contracts for public buildings, where British steel was always specified. It is intended that this duty will go part of the way towards redressing that position in favour of the Irish firms. The point concerning the position of contractors is being looked into, but it is intended that we shall get done in this country all the fabrication of steel that can be done—and all of it can be done here. The boring of holes and the cutting of bits off the end, to which Deputy Good referred, can be done here. It is our intention that it shall be done here. If it is done elsewhere and the steel is imported, it will be subject to duty.
Comment on this
If a steel oist cannot be cut, I do not know where we will be. If you require a joist six feet long and it is cut out of one twelve feet long, does that mean that it comes here as "fabricated steel?"
Comment on this
The intention is that if steel comes in shaped, cut, bored and all the rest, for erection, it shall be subject to duty. All that shaping, cutting and boring can be done here.
Comment on this
I know what is in the Minister's mind, but we will have to get a definition on Committee Stage. I see a lot of difficulty in the matter.
Comment on this
So far as expanded metal is concerned, cannot adequate substitutes be obtained here?
Comment on this
As regards Item 5—metal door and window frames, etc., the Minister for Local Government and Public Health a few days ago announced increased grants for housing. His proposal in regard to new houses in urban districts is to increase the grants from £40 to £60. That is an increase of £20. I am given to understand that in the case of a house valued at from £800 to £1,000 the increased cost that will arise in respect of a set of metal door and window frames in consequence of the tax will be £15, so that, so far as the erection of new private houses in the city of Dublin and in the towns throughout the country is concerned, bang goes £15 of the £20 increase. I should like to have some information from the Minister as to the expected developments in the manufacture of metal door frames and metal window frames in this country.
Comment on this
One firm has been engaged in the manufacture of these things and another firm is about to engage in it, one in Dublin and the other in Cork. The position is that we can do without metal doors and window sashes, as, generally speaking, wood is used to a much larger extent than metal. Now that a duty is imposed upon builders' woodwork, Irish firms engaged in the production of these doors and sashes and the like, having much larger orders available than would have been available before, are in a position to get down to the point where they can produce supplies for building contractors at prices which are equal to, or almost equal to, those at which the imported material can be supplied. Metal door frames and window sashes and the like are available. The cost at which they are available is slightly higher than that at which they could have been imported. That is due to a variety of causes. It is not due to any excessive profit-taking or anything like that, but to certain higher costs of production involved here. In so far as people do not wish to use this class of material, or to pay the cost involved, there is always the wooden door frame and sash to fall back upon.
Comment on this
I take it what the Deputy was referring to was the cast-iron frame with glass panels in it.
Comment on this
If they are not cast-iron, they are not subject to duty. Sky and dead lights of cast-iron are subject to duty.
Comment on this
The Minister said that the costs of these articles at present were slightly higher than those imported. He means before the imposition of the tariff, I presume.
Comment on this
And the cost of the articles here was slightly higher as a result before the imposition of the tariff. Naturally, he expects they will be much lower as a result of the tariff.
Comment on this
In so far as selling price can be reduced, following increased production, that reduction will take place. There are a few honest men left.
Comment on this
I raised the question because I know that the Minister would be anxious to protect an Irish industry —the Irish stained glass industry. It is at present suffering from fierce foreign competition.
Comment on this
Certain representations which I have received in respect of that industry are at present under consideration, and I would not like to make any promise in respect to it, because there are a number of complications involved.
Comment on this
As to No. 6, I should like to find out what production there is in the country of paper bags.
Comment on this
The total import of paper bags in 1930 was 1,181 tons. The total home production in 1929 was 1,878 tons. The total requirements of the country are roughly about 3,000 tons, of which the home industry has been supplying roughly two-thirds.
Comment on this
Is there any differentiation between the type of bags made at home? I think the only mill which makes one kind imports the light brown paper.
Comment on this
There is a certain type of bag made from paper, manufactured in the country. There are certain bags which are made from imported paper. In so far as common brown paper bags are concerned, practically the whole trade, or very nearly the whole of the trade, is in the hands of Irish firms, both in the production of the paper and the bags. There are other firms engaged in the manufacture of bags for which imported paper is required. There is quite a number of these firms here, and one additional firm has started since the duty was imposed. Between them, they are competent to supply all the requirements of the country.
Comment on this
In all the varieties required if the package tax is kept at its present point? The Minister must know that the packing at present is a very specialised industry. Packages are made with a variety of aims. Some are hygienic. Others are show containers. In the main, paper or cardboard is the foundation of most of these containers. But where some sort of liquid or viscous type of stuff is being put up, the container has to be of a very specialised type in order not to have any deleterious material introduced into the substance being packed. Has the Minister an appreciation of the limited variety of paper that is being turned out, or is likely to be turned out, and the enormous varieties of paper required for these containers?
Comment on this
None of the firms who are engaged, or who are proposing to engage in the package industry has yet produced to us a packet which we were not able to get for them in the country. Some of them may not have come to us for a solution of their difficulties, but any of them who have come to us we were able to put in touch with firms capable of supplying their requirements. I am glad to say that, in the majority of cases, they were capable of supplying the requirements at a lower price than these firms were able to get their requirements made before, in some cases, very much to the astonishment of the individuals concerned.
Comment on this
Could the Minister circulate details, even privately, of the firms to which he refers, and the varieties of paper to which he is referring?
Comment on this
On No. 8, I should like to refer to a question that I asked some days ago as published in the Official Report, column 1589:—
Mr. Dockrell: What I want to find out from the Minister is if paints and distempers in dry form and in paste form are included or excluded?
Mr. Lemass: The duty applies only to paints and distempers in liquid form.
I take it that that is as clear as anything could possibly be that distempers and paints in paste and dry from were not dutiable. I now see an amendment on the paper, after the word "liquid" to insert the words "or paste". Does that mean that the Minister has changed his mind since he answered the question?
Comment on this
No. I move the amendment, C2:
In the Schedule, Ref. No. 8, page 7, in the second column, after the word "liquid" to insert the words "or paste".
The amendment is intended for the purpose of clarification only. It was intended that paint in liquid or in semi-liquid form, or paste form, if we may call it such, should be subject to duty. There is considerable difficulty in determining whether paint is liquid or solid. As a matter of fact when the average paint tin is imported the top is quite liquid and the bottom is quite paste until it is stirred up. It is impossible to distinguish between liquid and paste and it is necessary for the purpose of making everybody know what the duty applies to, that the words "or paste" should be inserted. It will be clear that the only paints excepted from the duty will be those in a completely solid form with one or two exceptions mentioned. It is quite clear that we will have a number of additional concerns engaged in the production of these things in a very short time. There are five or six firms engaged in the manufacture of these paints and colours at the moment and two, at least, of them are undertaking fairly extensive additions to their plant. In addition, some other firms are proposing to engage in this industry, and it seems to me that there need be no fear of any scarcity of supplies. As a matter of fact, the competition will be sufficiently intense to ensure that minimum prices will be charged.
Comment on this
With all due respect, the Minister's reply is anything but satisfactory because there are three distinct classes of paint imported. There is paint or distemper in dried form, and there is this paste form and the liquid form. My precise question was in order to elicit information. I may say that for some days past other people and I have acted on the assumption that it would apply to liquid form only. It is a terrible thing to find that a couple of days, after the Minister has given an answer in a most categorical way——
Comment on this
With all due respect I asked whether paints in dry form or paste form were included and your answer was that only the liquid form was included.
Comment on this
What I wanted to find out from the Minister was whether it applied to distemper or paints in a dry form and the Minister replied that the duty only applied to distemper or paint in a liquid form.
Comment on this
I submit the question was absolutely beyond doubt and the answer I received was beyond doubt. Of course, the Minister, just like everybody else, is entitled to change his mind. There is one other fact which I would like to point out to the Minister. Some of these distempers are composed, as to one-third, of carrageen moss. I do not know whether that makes any difference. It is no wonder that the quays are congested if you get an answer one day and a few days afterwards you find an official amendment different in every way from the reply you got.
Comment on this
The Minister has mentioned putty in any form. What exactly has he in mind? This is one of the things about which the Minister might have made a joke but I do not intend it as a joke. What is putty?
Comment on this
This is a very important thing. There is a powder called putty as well as the paste used for glazing windows.
Comment on this
I do not want an analysis. If you get a definition of putty it may include a lot of things you have not in your head.
Comment on this
I would like to ask the Minister if there is a duty on a certain form of paint that comes in here. It is a mixture of bitumen for treating walls to prevent dampness. If it is subject to a tariff, it is not being manufactured in the country.
Comment on this
I will have that point inquired into. Let me say that it is proposed at a later stage to ask the Dáil for power to admit free, under licence, paints that may be required by manufacturers in the Free State where we are satisfied that such paint is not being made here. There is one item especially in contemplation, a certain form of cellulose paint used by coach-builders and others. It is intended to take power to permit them to procure supplies of that without its being subject to duty. It is not possible to get a definition which will permit of its explicit exclusion as the same definition would cover certain classes of commercial paints which are made here and which there is no desire to admit free. The intention is to ask for powers but we may not discuss that matter now.
Comment on this
When the Minister is considering it will he also consider what is the difference between a quilt filled or unfilled, a counterpane and a bedspread? I understand, according to the description, they are subject to different taxes.
Comment on this
As regards soap substitutes, will it be a substitute which has some item ordinarily connected with soap in it, or which is in some way analogous to soap? It does not mean something that a person could use instead of soap?
Comment on this
This duty has been in force for some years. We are merely increasing the rate. The Revenue Commissioners have definitely established regulations in that connection.
Comment on this
I do not think it is manufactured here, nor is it likely to be. Perhaps the Minister will make enquiries. In any case the importations are small.
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied that the description "primarily intended for office use" will be reasonably interpreted by the Revenue Commissioners?
Comment on this
I think so. It is intended to cover paste made up in handy form and suitable for office use. The Deputy is no doubt aware of the jar of paste, of one kind or another, to which I am referring.
Comment on this
Reference No. 13 relates to polishing preparations. Reference No. 14 deals with linen piece goods.
Comment on this
In connection with the whole of the duties imposed in No. 14, an application was made by persons engaged in this industry to the Tariff Commission and the Tariff Commission reported favourably on the application. The duties imposed herein differ somewhat from those recommended by the Tariff Commission. They are, in fact, slightly less than those recommended. The Report of the Tariff Commission will be published shortly; there is an arrangement to have it printed and circulated.
Comment on this
I notice that if we take the whole run of No. 14, item (7), under (a), oilcloth, is excluded. That is oilcloth which has a basis of linen. If we go on to (b) we see a reference to oilcloth which has a foundation of union and it is also excluded, but when you come to cotton—
Comment on this
There is a misprint there. The word should be "excluding." In the first line of (c) "including" should read "excluding."
Comment on this
That means then that the material commonly called American cloth, with a waterproof top on it, is excluded entirely, no matter what the foundation?