Resolution No. 7—Customs.
Contributions 217–427 of 647. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
There is an enormous number of articles brought under Reference Number 14. I expect the only way I can deal with them is by putting down amendments hereafter to exclude certain articles. There are certain things which, if they are made in the Free State at the moment, are not made in any quantity. I understand that quite an amount of linen goods are not being made in the country and are not likely to be made for a considerable time. If we get the Tariff Commission Report before the Finance Bill is taken, it will be extremely helpful.
Comment on this
In regard to (5) of Number 14—tarpaulins—I observe there is a preferential rate of 15 per cent. The consumption is very small, but where there is consumption it is very necessary. It could hardly pay anyone to go into the tarpaulin trade. It is difficult to get good tarpaulin because frequently it is exceedingly defective and subject to rot. Very few manufacturers can make tarpaulin. As far as I know they are English.
Comment on this
Is is quite clear we can supply all our requirements in these things? In fact, we have quite a substantial export trade in most, if not all, of these items referred to in (e). Our export trade is larger than our internal trade.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment C2:—
In the Schedule, Ref. No. 15, page 9, in the second column, before the word "Matter" where it first occurs to insert in brackets the letter "a" and after the word "Schedule" to insert in the second, third, and fourth columns the following:—
((b) Books printed in the English language (excluding books chargeable with any other duty)—
(i) books which, in the opinion of the Revenue. Commissioners, are works of fiction; | 15% | 10%
(ii) (other than books included in the next preceding sub-paragraph) printed in Saorstát Eireann and bound (otherwise than in paper covers) outside Saorstát Eireann; | 50% | 33?%
(iii) books (other than books included in either of the preceding sub-paragraphs) bound in leather or any material which is an imitation of leather. | 15% | 10%
Various representations have been made in the matter of books and, after giving careful consideration to them all, it has been decided to amend the duty as set out in the amendment. If the Resolution is amended as we suggest, the duty will apply, in the first place, only to books printed in the English language. In the case of books which are, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, works of fiction, there will be a duty of 15 per cent. with a preferential rate of 10 per cent. That is to a large extent a revenue duty. There is, of course, a very substantial industry in the printing of cheap works of fiction here and, as some Deputies are aware, there is one firm in Dublin with a very substantial export business in these goods.
Comment on this
Quite the contrary; it is calculated that this tariff will assist it in a fairly substantial way. The second paragraph relates to books printed in the Saorstát and bound abroad. Representations have been made by those engaged in the book-binding industry here, particularly on behalf of the Guild of Bookbinders, that a recent development which has taken place in relation to their industry is injurious to their interests, namely, the sending of books printed here to be bound on the Continent, where the binding is done practically for nothing by children and others working in their homes. The loss of employment to book-binders here has been quite considerable.
There are, in fact, a couple of hundred of them, highly skilled workers, without employment in the city at the moment. The imposition of this duty will not restore employment to all of them, but it will go a considerable way to ensure that the practice which has grown up will stop, and that the binding of these books, mainly books of a religious nature, will be done as heretofore in the country. The third duty relates to the 10 per cent. duty on books bound in leather or imitations of leather. Most works of that kind are of a special nature. The binding can be done here and is done here. Irish bookbinders, in fact, have quite a substantial reputation for the skill with which they do that work. We realise that the imposition of a protective duty will not restore the bookbinding trade to anything like its former prosperity, but it will at any rate go some little distance while other methods of putting it on its feet are under consideration.
I might refer here to Amendment 18a. The words in brackets:—"Other than books which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, are works of fiction and other than books chargeable with any other duty" should be deleted; they were inserted there by error. There is the imposition of a duty of 1½d. per copy with a preferential rate of 1d. per copy on books printed outside the Saorstát and bound in paper covers. These are mainly cheap novels.
Comment on this
The intention is that the duty should apply to books printed in the English language only. It may be necessary to have a slight modification of it because of a splitting up of the Resolution. This duty will be leviable upon the cheap covered novels. In the printing of these there is also a substantial industry here. The output last year ran into a considerable number of millions of copies. The imposition of the duty will assist the industry. I went into the matter with very great care and was satisfied that this industry is likely to be assisted in a very substantial way by the imposition of this duty.
Comment on this
The printing of these cheap novels in the country. There are practically only two firms in these islands which are able to compete upon the very keen basis on which these things are done: one firm in the Saorstát and another in the north of England. The Saorstát firm has been able, very successfully, to hold its own in the world's market. Most of the novels sold retail throughout the world by a very well-known firm of chain stores are in fact printed in Dublin. The ability of the firm to hold its own in the market will depend largely upon its being able to keep its costs as low as possible. It will be assisted by the imposition of this duty.
Comment on this
Does the net effect of these various amendments mean that books other than novels which are bound in cloth will be free of duty?
Comment on this
All books other than those in the English language come in free?
Comment on this
Works of fiction printed and bound in paper are subject to the special rate of 1½d. with a preferential rate of a 1d. Bound other than in paper they are subject to the special rate of 15 per cent. with a preferential rate of 10 per cent. All other books are free of duty, except books printed in Ireland and sent abroad to be bound, or books bound in leather or imitations of leather.
Comment on this
I would call the attention of the Minister to the addition to the schedule in Resolution 8: "Books printed outside Saorstát Eireann and bound in paper covers are subject to a duty of 1½d. with a preferential rate of 1d." The Minister is inserting an amendment to make this apply to books in the English language only.
Comment on this
Are we to understand that the distinction between importations in bulk and single copies vanishes altogether now?
Comment on this
Books of fiction imported are now liable to a tariff, that is, books in the English language, whether they are imported singly or in quantities. I take it that single copies as well as bulk quantities are now liable?
Comment on this
As to books bound in leather or in imitations of leather, I presume that is really a tariff on religious books such as prayer books and Missals?
Comment on this
Personally, to me a tax of this nature—the very conception of it—is a complete reversal of values: it suggests that the interested party in a book is the printer and the binder. There used to be the idea that teachers thought that education existed and children existed merely that they would draw their salaries. It seems to me a thoroughly bad thing for this country that there is this implication in this tax, that books exist for the purpose of providing jobs for printers and book-binders. I think that a great many things that will come under the heading of fiction are very necessary towards the general culture of this country. I read the amendments very carefully, and did not get out of them the reading that the Minister now assures us is there. What the Minister has said modifies my objection to the tax very considerably. I do not want to use the word "disgraceful," but at the same time I do think that the implication of this tax is a complete reversal of values. This tax implies that all culture exists for the purpose of providing people with jobs and, in my opinion, the whole conception of it is bad.
Comment on this
Could the Minister give us any figures as to the total value of the books at present being imported into the Free State?
Comment on this
The classifications relate to books and newspapers, but what they except, I cannot, at the moment, say. I have only the figures relating to the first three months of the year, and the value of the importations for the first three months of this year was £146,000.
Comment on this
If the Minister would take the trouble to subtract from that what he knows about newspapers, and what he knows about other printed matter—and he knows more than I do—I think he would be surprised at the smallness of the figure that remains for books, and if he will subtract from that figure again the value of books other than these books of fiction, I think he will be still further surprised at the small sum remaining to which he is applying the tariff. The reason I am asking for this information is, that, with Deputy Fitzgerald, I am convinced that, in regard to this whole tax, he is under a misapprehension, and he is doing something which is a real harm to the people of the country for a very small return. Obviously, what the Minister desires is to restore bookbinding as an industry, but the Minister, in plain language, is up against it. Book-binding is an industry that is dying. Books are going to be bound, and are being bound more and more every day, I am assured, by machinery, and the bookbinders' trade is very rapidly becoming defunct. The Minister is going to do for a very small return something which will be of permanent disservice to the people of the country.
I am convinced that the Minister is doing something which is not worth his while doing. It is not worth his while imposing this tariff on books which has put the country through a period of great confusion, with regard to books generally. It has damaged the booksellers' trade already, by reason of the difficulties they have been under in getting books, and he has encouraged the individual to buy his book direct, rather than from the bookseller, and that is a habit which will grow and increase. I understand from the Minister's answer to my question, a little while ago, that under the modified Resolution, which I admit is a very great improvement on the original Resolution, the purchaser will now have to pay his ten per cent. duty on an English book, whether he gets it direct or through a bookseller?
Comment on this
That is a ten per cent. duty if the book is cloth bound and a penny per book, if it is paper bound. Is that right?
Comment on this
Therefore the disability which has existed against the bookseller will not exist in future, but my contention is that the whole thing is so small, and of such little value, that the Minister would be very well advised to drop it altogether.
Comment on this
I am, of course, postponing this amendment for the Finance Bill, but I would like to know what the Minister's opinion is of the amendment I have tabled, amendment No. 5, because it is an urgent matter, indeed. Until his decision is known, the printing of a certain number of local magazines will be suspended. I think I have explained the matter at length to him already. It is briefly this. A small inset is printed in England and distributed to certain centres in Ireland, where local editions are made, with advertisements and local announcements and news, and the result is a parochial magazine, printed in Cork, Dublin and other centres. A good deal of money is spent in Ireland on the printing, and, in Cork alone, last year, the bill for printing was between £300 and £350.
Comment on this
The Deputy is now on a different point, and I will refer him to amendment 14 on the green sheet. I think that meets the case of the magazine he has in mind.
Comment on this
I will keep my remarks about the tariff in general for the Finance Bill. I agree very largely with the opinions expressed by Deputy Fitzgerald, and by my colleague, Deputy Thrift, as to bookbinding in the city of Dublin. I am a person who has to get a considerable number of books bound each year, and I know the defects of the trade, and there are defects. The finer book-binding in Dublin is splendidly done, but the cost, as it is elsewhere, is pretty prohibitive. The cheaper book-binding is not done at a reasonable cost, in most cases, and is not, I am sorry to say, sometimes done as well as one can get it done elsewhere. It is a very serious item in the ordinary person's expense. I frequently had to pay more for the binding of a book in cheap form than the book itself actually cost, and the price of book-binding in Dublin has gone up. I think it has come down a little now, but it is one of the things that, unfortunately, owing to tariffs the ordinary person will have to economise on this year.
Comment on this
When I was told on the second day of the Budget that this Reference No. 15 included, and was intended to include, books I was very much surprised, but, on consideration of the matter, I was not quite as disturbed as many people were, because I felt that the proposal, as it existed originally, was so outrageous and so ridiculous that the Government could not possibly stand over it, and consequently, I was expecting at least some such amendment as was put before the House to-day. That amendment demonstrates that there was no consideration at all given to the original proposal, and that having given a little consideration to it, the Government has come to the conclusion that it cannot be defended. I think that some further consideration ought to be given to this and that the original proposal should be still further reduced. The Minister was constrained to admit that so far as Item 1 (3) is concerned it is largely a revenue tax. I do not think that the revenue that will be obtained will be considerable at all and I think it is the sort of tax for which there is no real defence.
Remember that in paragraph 1, we are not really dealing with any question of bookbinding, nor with any question of printing or employment either, because I do not believe that a firm printing here will get a single order for printing in consequence of this tariff. The circulation of a single book here, of an ordinary work of fiction, leaving out school books, is so small, that the Free State trade is not going to influence any firm in placing a contract here. The result, so far as the imposition of this duty is concerned, will be only one thing, and that is, to make these particular classes of books dearer. There is no use in taking up any sort of puritanical view about the reading of fiction, or the purchase of books of fiction. I think it would be much better for this country if there was more reading—I do not really care what class of reading it is, but it would, of course, be better if it were a good class—but it would be better if there were more reading and a more extensive purchase of books in this country. There are books of fiction for children which are really of a definitely educational value. They are necessary for children. You cannot expect children to begin to read anything but fiction, and you cannot expect them to acquire the habit of reading unless you provide fiction for them, and I think that the imposition of this ten per cent. tax, while not very heavy, is a definite handicap on the provision of reading matter of a definitely educational value for children and on the provision of matter of undoubted cultural value, and in other cases, matter representing a pastime and a relaxation of a desirable type.
Really, no case remains and the amendment admits that a mistake was made. I think no other construction can be put upon it. It would be better to admit the full extent of the mistake and to wipe the tax out. I can see some point in Number 2 and even in Number 3, but where the question of binding does not come in it would be better to remit the tax altogether. All I have heard about the matter coincides with what Deputy Alton said, that one of the reasons why books are not bound here is that the cost is outrageously high and the work frequently is not up to the standard that can be obtained at lower prices outside the country. The number of books that would be sent out of the country to be bound is not so very high. Only a limited number of people do that, but there are institutions which will be hard enough hit by being obliged to have binding done here. The Minister might be satisfied with that and, perhaps, in view of the difficulties the binding people have experienced here, some attempt would be made to so organise the industry or so change the methods that it will be possible to get the binding cost here brought somewhat more into conformity with competitive prices. Where book-binding is not going to be affected and where printing is not going to be affected, where it is a mere question of revenue, the amount will be so small that it will be of no importance in the total of the Budget. I think that the Minister ought to agree in those cases to remit it altogether. I cannot imagine more than one or two works of fiction, at most, in the year being printed here in consequence of paragraph (1). Perhaps an odd author expecting a local circulation or publishing a class of fiction which would have no sale in England would get it printed here. Even at present, authors get a book of that sort published in this country. So far as books that are likely to have a sale outside the country are concerned, the sale in the Free State would represent such a small proportion of the total that it would not affect the matter at all. The Minister knows very well how extremely small the book-purchasing public is here, how undesirable it is to discourage book-purchase and the actual having of books in houses, apart from the mere borrowing of a book occasionally from a public library. The fact that children and everybody in the house have access to books is a good thing and I think this is a tax that ought to be remitted.
Comment on this
The Minister may have been misled somewhat when he was told that binding is done here very well and that it is not so much dearer than it is in any other place. When we talk of a book being bound, it is very often not bound, technically, at all. A book is really only bound when the stitching of the leaves of the book is actually caught on to the hinge of the book. Most books such as the Official Debates are not really bound at all. I can speak from experience. I have got books bound in France which would have cost me three times as much as the cost of the book itself, plus the binding, if done here. When it comes to what is colloquially called "binding"—when the paper is just caught at the end—there, the Minister will find it is quite different. There is no place here which can really compete in binding in that way. Within the last week or so, I happened to get a book which was printed and bound here—a very expensive book, as the ordinary prices of books go. The first thing that struck me was that the thing was thoroughly badly done. The illustrations fell out. They had not been caught in. That book was thoroughly badly bound and it was an expensive book. For less than half the cost, I think—I could not, perhaps, stand over the statement—that book could have been better bound in England. The Minister talked about certain bookbinders. Very few people can afford to have books bound. Most of them have them caught in cardboards. I think the Minister may have been misled by people talking about bound books in the non-technical sense. If it comes to the production of books in boards, as done in England, I think the Minister will find that neither price nor quality will bear comparison at all.
Religious books are very largely bought in the country and they are bought by the poorest people. The poorest person in the country when a child is receiving First Communion or is being confirmed buys a book for the child—often at a fair cost. It seems to me rather an iniquitous thing to have that poor person who wishes to provide something which is of a very high value to the child, taxed so that binders in this country should be placed in circumstances which will enable them to charge more for doing the same work than is charged in other countries under the same conditions.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputies Thrift and Blythe regarding the duties imposed under this heading. I think, since the Minister brought in these amendments, that he also is of opinion that these duties are not worth while, and that he is trying to patch up his original mistakes by introducing these three amendments. From the point of view of revenue, I can see reactions from this duty on certain firms in this city which the Minister knows. These absurd duties will bring very little revenue and will not bring into employment many bookbinders, while I think that there will be serious reactions from across the Channel on Dublin firms.
Amendments b (ii) and b (iii), I think, require a little explanation. Books printed in Saorstát Eireann and sent outside for binding and returned here are liable to duty of 50 per cent., with a preferential rate of 33? per cent. Books printed outside the Saorstát and bound outside come in at a duty of 15 per cent., with a preferential rate of 10 per cent. I fail to see how that is going to help the book-binding trade in this country. If a book printed in the Saorstát and sent to be bound outside is charged 33? per cent., if bound in the Commonwealth, and 50 per cent. if bound outside it, why should a book printed and bound outside the Saorstát come in at a duty of 10 per cent.? Surely, there is something wrong there. This seems to me to be a hurried attempt to patch up the original mistake of putting a duty on books at all. I ask the Minister to reconsider the whole question. If he does, I am sure he will ultimately come to the conclusion to knock out No. 15 entirely.
Comment on this
I agree entirely with Deputy O'Hanlon, that the amendments which we have in the name of the Minister to-day indicate that the tax upon books must go entirely or, at any rate, that it must go further than it has gone already. Before dealing with that question, I should like to know if the Minister mentioned—I was a few minutes late in coming in—the amount he expects to get from the revised tariff, what the revenue result is supposed to be. I should also like to ask him whether any refund will be given to those who have already paid the duty on books.
When the original proposal was put before us it was made clear that books were taxed. Then we heard that only books coming in in bulk would be taxed and not books coming in singly to individuals. That of course really meant, and I am sure it is the cause of the Minister's change of front, that under the original scheme the Minister was going to encourage people, particularly people buying expensive books, to buy books directly. He was going to prevent Irish booksellers getting any profit. He was going to put people in the position that they could buy from abroad cheaper than in Dublin, thus giving the profits, not to the Minister for Finance nor to the Dublin booksellers, but to foreign booksellers. Also we were told that books coming in to libraries were to be exempt. I take it that has completely gone now. There is no exemption for libraries now.
Altogether, the whole proceeding in this matter indicates that in a gay moment of irresponsibility, the Government said, "What about books?—we will just see what a tax on books will be like". It has been a very serious thing for people who make their living by selling books, and it has been a very serious thing in the past three weeks for people who make their living by using books. The question of a refund is rather important. For example in spite of the Minister for Finance's statement of his intention that books for libraries would not be taxed, I was informed that the Royal Irish Academy Library had to pay duty—it was only a small amount—on books that were certainly not works of fiction, but books from a Dutch Academy. I wonder whether any arrangement has been made for a refund, because a refund is due, seeing that people who have already paid the tax on that kind of a book have paid it because of the Minister's indecent haste in imposing the tax. Tere is another point. As I understand it, the tax is entirely confined to English fiction, and to any book, whether in English or any other language, bound in leather.
Comment on this
English fiction or other books bound in leather. One would like to know whether this tax is looked at from the point of view of revenue, or from the point of view of the amount of assistance it will give to any Irish industry, whether book-binding or printing. I happen to have had an opportunity of knowing, in the course of my official duties in the last ten years, that one firm in Dublin, as the Minister mentioned himself, was able to compete successfully with English firms for the publication of cheap paper-bound novels, and, as the Minister stated, very cheap books sold by a well-known chain store were printed here and even exported to England—printed in millions. I was in these printing works and I was told that on the 31st December some millions of copies were going out to that firm—I remember some enormous figure was mentioned. I should like to stress that that trade was done without a tariff, done by organisation, by ability, and business management of a proper kind; done by Irish people under Irish conditions in Dublin, without assistance from a tariff. I wonder whether a tariff is going to assist these people to do any better. We would like to know whether the Minister has any figures to support the contention that it will.
One thing that strikes one immediately about the fiction question is that it is the cheap fiction which will not be affected. Those who read Edgar Wallace's books or any kind of cheap fiction will have an opportunity now of getting it printed in Ireland. The smaller number of people who read the better type of English fiction, for example, the senior classes in our schools, cannot get what they require here. The Minister possibly has not adverted to this fact: that one of the educational reforms introduced in this country is that, instead of prescribing a book in English for a course in a secondary school, teachers are now allowed to recommend to their class their own favourite authors or the authors who they think would be most suitable. Before that change there was a process by which you prescribed a book for a particular grade. A particular publisher got the book out and made a fair profit. He got it printed here and he was sure of a particular sale. Every boy or girl going for Junior Grade, for example, had to buy a copy of, say, "Treasure Island." That system has been changed. Teachers can now recommend such books as they please to students. The result of this tax is that that kind of book will be taxed, because there is not very much prospect of getting a separate Irish Free State edition printed here of the better class of English fiction. There is a chance of getting other classes, but not the better class.
If you take the series of books published in England, which includes fiction of a very good class, say, at 2/6—there is a new series coming out recently I think at 9d.—there will be no chance in the world of a sufficient market being found in the Free State to make the publisher get an Irish edition printed. I, at any rate, would not imagine there would be. If the Minister has contrary information, I should be glad to hear it. But, from my conversations with printers recently I never gathered that there would be any sufficient Irish market for such a series. The result will be that those who desire to avail of the cheap editions of English classical fiction will have to pay the tax, but the people who want to read the type of fiction which the Minister, in his more national and Christian moments, would like to keep out, will be able to get it free of duty. The changes made now simply illustrate with what precipitancy the matter was first considered. It leaves people who have paid the tax up to the present in a position that they must get a refund from the Minister. Considerable dislocation of the trade of booksellers has occurred, and we are now in the position that those who want to read the better class of English fiction will have to pay extra for it, and, incidentally, those who want to read the cheaper and the worst class of French fiction will not have to pay extra for it at all.
Comment on this
Has the Minister made any provision in his amendment that books coming into public libraries will be exempt from the tax? I do not think the Minister has considered the great traffic that there is in books between this country and Great Britain in the way of exchanging and lending to students; libraries lending books for the purpose of research and study to one another. There is a considerable traffic in that way. We lend books from our libraries here and send them across, and there is reciprocation on the other side. If the Minister is not to put another stone in the way of the poor student's feet I wish he would look into this matter a little more as regards this question of exchange between libraries. A lot of these books are bound here.
Comment on this
With regard to the general policy of which this tax is an illustration, I shall not go into it at present, as we shall have another opportunity of discussing it. I gather from the Minister that No. 1 of these is mainly intended as a revenue tariff. That is what he definitely stated. It may, to some extent, assist local industry. I wonder has he considered that it might have the very opposite effect, that it might very seriously interfere with that particular industry? He has put a tariff on books imported into this country notwithstanding that there is a big export trade. In fact, the particular firm which he refers to would depend largely on that export trade.
This raises the general question of the advisability of putting a tariff on an article in respect of which there is already a big export trade. In this particular connection, we are discussing the effect on a firm whose export trade is more important than its home trade. I think the policy itself has obvious dangers that I need not insist on, but I gathered from the Minister that the main purpose of paragraph B 1 is to impose a revenue tax. That being so, the principal effect undoubtedly will be that which everybody has emphasised, to increase the price of reading literature for the people of this country. The complaint has often been made, and I fear with a certain amount of justification, that we are not a reading public and still less a book-buying public. That has its disadvantages so far as the general outlook of the country is concerned. I fail to see how that will be improved by the imposition of what the Minister has said is a revenue tax. The Minister will surely not contend that a man buys a book which is cheap literature merely because it is printed in Ireland. There are a number of us who buy various materials because they are made in Ireland, but I think people generally buying fiction have an entirely different motive and the fact that it is printed in Ireland will have very little to do with the choice of the actual purchasers. That, of course, will be only bearing out what the Minister has himself acknowledged, that this is a revenue tax so far as paragraph B 1 is concerned.
As regards B 2, it refers only to books printed in the English language. So far as the great bulk of book buyers are concerned the books we buy unbound are books not printed in the English language. The books we want bound are books printed in other languages. Undoubtedly, if he wanted to help the bookbinding trade he would not do what he is actually doing in sub-section (2). So far as the ordinary individual is concerned, he has these books printed in other languages on his shelves and he leaves them—unbound, unfortunately, as most of us know, because the cost of binding is altogether too much. The cost of binding books is excessive. I think, as the Minister himself has admitted by imposing a tax on these books he is imposing a tax on the reading public. That is the main purpose of this as it stands. Deputy Hayes has clearly indicated the various stages through which this tax has gone. Again, I would like to point out that the Government has yielded to pressure from large consolidated interests. In doing so, the Minister was quite right, but that does show the extreme haste with which these taxes were imposed in the first instance. That is an aspect of the matter we can discuss when we are dealing with the tariffs imposed by this Schedule and Schedule 8 as a whole.
Comment on this
I desire to say only a few words. I object on principle to a tax on books at all, but assuming that there has to be a tax on imported books, I would like to suggest that it should be properly arranged. There is a great deal of rubbish printed that is not fiction. There is a great deal of rubbish printed in languages besides the English language. Instead of discriminating in the way in which it is proposed here, I would suggest that an attempt should be made both on cultural grounds and financial grounds, because I know it would be a method that would produce most revenue, to tax worthless books and to let in classics. In other words, I suggest that a time test might be imposed. If a book has been printed for 50 years and is still being read, it can be assumed to have some value. If you are importing works of art into the United States of America you have to pay a customs duty on them unless they are 100 years or more old. After the lapse of that length of time it is assumed that they are of cultural value to the country. I suggest that English classics and in fact the classics of all countries which have been written for 50 years or more should be allowed in free of duty. In other words, if it is desired to raise revenue in this way and to tax books, books of all countries written less than 50 years, whether in the English language or any other language, should be taxed and books written a longer period should be allowed in free.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister will yield to the opinions which have been so strongly expressed that this book tax is not advisable. If we are unsuccessful in persuading him of that, I hope that we shall be successful in persuading him that he should not try to get a revenue tax out of educational libraries. I am not now referring to the ordinary circulating libraries. I am referring to libraries such as the National Library and the library attached to the institution with which I am connected which is conducted purely for the purposes of education. Whatever the Minister may do with reference to general fiction, I most strongly hope that he will yield on the matter of these educational libraries. I want to point out that there is much more involved in putting a tax on these libraries than the mere payment of the tax. The extra trouble that would be entailed on educational libraries in looking after books in connection with a duty of this kind would mean a very considerable expense in the administration of the library. That is an expense in connection with the library with which I am associated that I simply could not face with equanimity. It would have an extremely bad effect on the manner in which that library carries out the function of providing books which are merely there for educational purposes. I hope that on that point, at any rate, the Minister will yield.
Comment on this
I appeal to the Minister to abandon this tax if he can possibly see his way to do so. In the first place it will not bring in anything like the amount of revenue he imagines. It is also a tax about which there is a good deal of feeling in the country. It is one that is likely to make the Government very unpopular. It is extraordinary that, having survived the Penal laws and the limitation of opportunities for education of the people, a native Government should now come along and put a tariff on the educational and intellectual progress of the people. That is the way in which the matter is being looked upon in the country, and it is likely to have some unpleasant reactions for the Government. If the Minister cannot see his way to abandon the tax altogether I think he should make an exception with regard to circulating libraries. These libraries do not all circulate fiction. Sometimes it is necessary when a person is engaged on some particular work to get a book of reference which he cannot get at home. He is obliged to go to some library such as the Times Book Club, or some other circulating library to get the use of the book for a short time. I think that if the Minister cannot see his way to abandon the tax as a whole, he would be conceding something to feeling in this matter to remove the tariff so far as it affects such circulating libraries as the Times Book Club.
Comment on this
One hesitates to encourage the Minister in any way by referring to the smaller details of this particular imposition, lest one might persuade him that people generally would be prepared in certain circumstances, to tolerate a tax on books. I think that a tax on books will be resisted week in and week out, until it is got rid of. For that reason one hesitates to talk of the smaller aspect of the matter. With that preliminary warning I will turn to one aspect. I would like to extend rather more widely the range of lending libraries that have been called by Deputy Thrift educational lending libraries. Let us take the county libraries generally. With the system adopted in the administration of the libraries, although the control of them is more or less repudiated by the Department of Education on the one side, and cannot be well directed by the Department of Local Government on the other, more and more these libraries are bound to become educational rather than the type of fiction-distributing machinery that they have tended to be for some time.
It is a fact that any serious student in the remotest part of Donegal or West Kerry can get through the county library any book he wants. By means of the machinery through which the county libraries operate through the central book repositories here in Dublin, books can be got from libraries in Scotland and England by the county librarians in the most remote parts of the country. I would like the Minister to consider, if there is any vestige of these books left on the face of the Budget when we are finished with it, what machinery there is for the non-taxing of books coming in in that way, or, if there is a tax, what refund will be given when these books are returned.
Comment on this
Before going into the matter of the books, I want to draw attention to an item which, I think, will be caught by the definition which originally stood alone on the paper and which is now, I understand, lettered par. (a): "Matter printed on paper and imported in bulk quantities," excluding certain things. Certain articles which come into the country at Christmas, such as crackers and Christmas stockings, are likely to be caught under this.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy aware that his Government succeeded in catching them as wearing apparel?
Comment on this
That was never intended and it was discovered with horror at a late point that the Commissioners had decided, under the powers given to them, that crackers ought to be charged because the paper caps contained in them constituted wearing apparel—a most outrageous thing, and a definition that was never meant. Does this particular definition mean to catch Christmas crackers and stockings simply because there might be included in them mottoes and other things which are printed on paper? These and other items of the sort could be described as matter printed on paper and they are certainly imported in bulk quantities. What is the Minister's mind on the subject? Does he want to catch these articles or not? The type of article concerned will not, in my opinion, give very much employment here. There is not even much in the way of revenue to be derived from this tax, because the articles I have referred to come in only at a particular time of the year and they are mainly intended for the benefit and enjoyment of young people.
This book tax, even in the modified form in which it now comes, is likely to draw down upon us the ridicule of most civilised and educated people. It will possibly lead them to think that we are setting out to make this country a notable type of Boeotia. Probably we will soon find ourselves in the position of the young French lady to whom a gentleman was thinking of making a Christmas present. When he intimated his intention of giving her a book he got the reply: "Do not bother; I have one already." We presumably will get ourselves into that position with regard to fiction at any rate.
What is it proposed to exclude under the title of "fiction"? Most of the statements of the Minister for Industry and Commerce with regard to the manufacture of certain articles could be classed as fiction. What is the definition of fiction? Take a very popular edition of classical works, the Loeb Library, which gives the classical text accompanied by an English translation. There are certain books that cannot be classed as fact records. Plays by Aristophanes are not to be classed as records of fact. They must be some type of fiction. Are we to pay tax on the Loeb classical library volumes which come into the country because they contain English translations of the best fiction of a high class type that has ever been produced? Is it intended to catch that type of literature?
We have often heard the comment made that history is nothing but "a fable repeated," a fable that has gained currency. Quite an amount of history as written is alleged to be not definitely of the fact type. There possibly is a certain amount of fiction again. Are we going to have any additions made to the Board of the Revenue Commissioners, men of literary turns of mind, so as to ensure that we shall get a proper definition of what comprises fiction for the purpose of these taxes? One of the best biographical works ever written is published in fiction form. It is probably the best written account of the life of one of the foremost men in the early days of the American nation. I refer to a particular biography of Alexander Hamilton. There are probably from fifteen to twenty first-class biographies of that most notable historical figure.
Undoubtedly, the best description of his life has been thrown into the form of a novel written by an American authoress, Gertrude Atherton. It is reckoned as a first-class work. From the point of view of a student set to study biography, it is much more stimulating than any biography of the ordinary type. Yet the preface to that work includes what amounts to an apology from the authoress that she had to cast such a life into the form of fiction. It classes itself by its preface as fiction. There is certainly no life that would repay reading more than the life of Hamilton, yet we shall have to pay 10 per cent. extra on a book of that type, and if it is printed in America it will be even dearer.
There are numbers of people in this country who get their only touch with the classics from what I might call Kelly's Original Key to the Classics printed in English and dealing, of course, with matters that are not anything except fiction. Are they also to be taxed? If so, there is imposed a tariff, if not on education, certainly on the passage of examinations, which is a somewhat different thing. These, however, are matters that probably will be left to the Revenue Commissioners to decide —"books which in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners are works of fiction." Some of their judgments might pass as fiction, according to what we have heard from disappointed importers. None of the Revenue Commissioners has been chosen with that particular type of discriminatory flair in mind which would enable him to distinguish between one type of work and another. This, I understand, has been declared to be a revenue tax—a tax on reading, even though it be only on fiction.
Is it considered an undesirable thing to have the lives of the people in the country frightened by the type of reading that they like to indulge in? I do not care how worthless it may be, whether it would pass even the time test to which Deputy MacDermot alluded? If people are oppressed by the boredom of the countryside and find it necessary to take refuge in the works of Charles Garvice or Edgar Wallace, well why should they not? Are they the people from whom it is thought desirable to take the amount of money aggregated here as arising from the different taxes—a sum of £123,000? We have no indication whatever of what this in its modified form is supposed to bring in. Would the Minister venture an opinion on that now? Some tax is going to be put on. It is quite unfair and it cannot be defended on any ground, cultural or any other. Certainly not on cultural grounds; there might have been an attempt to defend it on the basis that all fiction is rubbish, but that particular judgment would not stand any test at all. This tax cannot be defended on cultural, censorship, or any other ground. It is simply put on for revenue. I would rather have extra tariffs on manufactured goods than see a tax on reading material.
There is another difficulty going to arise in the case of books bound in leather. Quite a number of prayer books and missals come in. Missals in general would be printed in Latin, but there is a certain amount of English included in the text at times. Certainly most prayer books, those of the gift type rather than of the purely utilitarian type that come in, are bound in leather and, in the main, are in English. These will fall for the tax. Is that considered to be a proper source of revenue? In the main it is going to be a revenue tax, and it is not going to be possible to get unbound prayer books sent in here to have them bound. I am referring to the type of book which a parent will give to a son or daughter on a particular religious occasion—a prayer book done up in good leather.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry has made an appropriate intervention— on a tax on reading. He is the personification of the unfortunate results of a tax against reading. A useful intervention—I do not think I need say any more.
Comment on this
In this respect I would like to urge on the Minister that he should increase the tax on English newspapers.
Comment on this
As the Deputy is not a member of the Executive Council it is not in order for him to do that.
Comment on this
I would like to point out to the Minister that the "Daily Express" with a huge circulation——
Comment on this
That newspaper, with a huge circulation has dismissed some 33 hands that they had employed in Cork City, and I want it taxed.
Comment on this
I want to refer very briefly to this tax. The Minister, I understand, is not in a position now to form an estimate of what the revised, amended Section 15 to the Schedule will produce by way of revenue. May I ask him has he formed an estimate of what the amended Schedule 15 will produce? What I want to suggest is that the probability of the yield of large revenue is remote. I assume that the amendments do not do away with the right of an individual to purchase an individual book free of duty.
Comment on this
Then that privilege is withdrawn. That makes my task all the easier because I agree with Deputy Mulcahy that this is not a tariff which can be discussed in detail. The Minister must realise that the whole sense of the House is against the principle of raising revenue on literature. I do not think it is necessary to go into the categories of prayer books, fiction and so on, but the whole trend of opinion in civilised countries—I am convinced it is a trend of opinion that Ministers feel a real sympathy with— is against raising revenue from literature or placing obstructions in the way of people having free access to the literature of the world. The result of this inevitably will be to reduce the purchase of books, and as Deputy O'Sullivan said our people have an unenviable reputation for not being a reading people.
All sides will agree that is a most undesirable state of affairs. Whatever revenue is derived from this it cannot be a very large sum. I believe the Minister would do well to forego even a large sum rather than admit the principle that for the purpose of rais- ing revenue or for any purpose, other than that of protecting the public, absolutely free access to the literature of the world should not be made difficult to our people. Once this principle of taxing books or learned literature is admitted, then I fear it opens the way to very grave abuses indeed. It would open the way to a variety of abuses into which it is not necessary to go. It certainly opens the way to the frame of mind of a disinterested Deputy like Deputy Corry who, in regard to some particular publication, feels that some special penalty should be visited on it for some disinterested reason.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, my suggestion was that a tax should be put on an English daily paper coming in here. It has a very large circulation. It was employing 33 hands in Cork City, and has now dismissed them for no reason whatever.
Comment on this
I stand corrected by the Deputy. To admit the principle that it is a legitimate thing for revenue purposes or for any purpose except the protection of the public to interfere with the free access of our people to the literature of the world is to open the gate wide to abuses. I am not prepared to follow some of my colleagues in their cogitations as to the frame of mind Ministers were in when they considered this tariff. I assume they considered it with the same care as the other tariffs. I do say that, having considered the economic aspect of this tariff and the representations that were doubtless made to the Minister by those employed in this particular industry, even now or at a later stage of the Bill the Minister should weigh against the grave responsibility he takes in admitting the undesirable principle of taxing literature, the very questionable advantage that he will secure for the book binding trade. If the Minister makes up his mind that the balance is in favour of literature, then it would be a handsome and a useful gesture on his part if he were to consent to remove this from the Schedule.
Comment on this
I, too, would like to say a word as to the undesirability of this tax. I am quite sure that all the arguments that have been used from all sides of the House, from the Independent Benches and from these benches, will have due effect on the Minister, and will soften his heart, so far as the reading public are concerned. We often hear it mentioned, at the present day, that what we used to call home life is becoming more and more a thing of the past. There are all sorts of amusements to which young people can go. They go to the "talkies" and they go here, there and everywhere. There are still, however, I must say, some homes where reading is carried on, to a great extent, and where the children are encouraged to save their pennies and sixpennies, and to buy books of fiction, and if the Minister imposes this tax on books, it will do a great deal to destroy home life, and to encourage children to spend their savings on something else. I know that younger people read what some people might call a good deal of rubbish, but, still, it gives them a taste for reading. You cannot introduce a boy or girl to the classics all at once, without having some sort of attractive reading beforehand. Such books as "Nan, An Old-Fashioned Girl," while not intrinsically of any great value, so far as improvement of the mind is concerned, are books of fiction—adventures of college girls—and I read them myself at one time. I could name scores and scores of them, and, of course, there are similar books for boys. I am quite sure that the Minister, if he gives the matter further consideration, will take away what will be a very irksome tax. Deputies have pointed out that the revenue from this tax would be very limited. The demand for fiction will be very much less, because, as I say, people will spend their savings on something else, and I would appeal to the Minister to take away this very irksome tax on books.
Comment on this
May I add, to what I said about libraries, something in the way of a little information. I have got before me a short list of some of the libraries that send over books to the Free State. I will just mention the London Library, the Roman Society's Library, the Mathematical Society's Library, the Hellenic Society's Library, the Carnegie Students' Library, connected with about one hundred other libraries, and these are only a few of the libraries that send their books over here. In addition, there is a very large number of foreign societies, which regularly send over their publications, and usually, these publications are bound in leather. Unless the Minister is prepared to meet me, at least on the question of the libraries, these books coming over here will form a very serious source of expense to the libraries that receive them, and it will lead to the breaking of a very valuable link between our societies here, and very many foreign societies, as well as cutting off many of the books that are supplied to this State by these foreign libraries.
Comment on this
A good deal can be said for exception in the case of public libraries, but I do not find myself in agreement at all with Deputy McGilligan, particularly in regard to (b) 3, because, under this heading "books (other than books included in either of the preceding sub-paragraphs) bound in leather or any material which is an imitation of leather" thousands and thousands of prayer books have been and are being imported into this country. I called attention in this House, on more than one occasion, to the fact that the prayer books used in both the Catholic and Protestant churches are mainly printed in Belgium, or some other place. We get the very pious aspiration found on tickets handed out at Sunday schools, for instance, "Suffer little children to come unto Me," printed in Belgium. That is a thing that is quite common, and then again, you have on the prayer books, "Published by Messrs. so-and-so, in Ireland"—Dublin or Cork, perhaps, and then, you have "Printed in Germany" or "Bound in Belgium." A very big traffic has gone on in prayer books in this country for many years, and this paragraph alone would mean a good deal of employment, and I might mention in this connection, that Dublin and Cork firms have been known to take contracts out of English cities. That might, of course, be used as an argument against this section altogether, but I want to show by that that these things can be done just as well in Ireland as abroad. The skill is there, and the most up-to-date and modern machinery is there; efficient management is there, and I do not see any reason at all why it should put even a penny extra on the reading community.
The case has been made, and can easily be made that public libraries should be made an exception, especially where there is an interchange of books. I know that that does obtain, because I happen to be a member of a library committee, and I know that we get very many books, by way of exchange, from many libraries here and abroad. It will be a very serious handicap to many of these libraries, if they have to pay an extra penny or twopence duty. Many of these libraries are handicapped from want of finance, due, as has been pointed out here, to the fact that we are not a reading public. There is a fairly decent circulation for all kinds of cheap rubbish, political publications, and all that sort of thing, but there is very little sale indeed for good serious literature in this country. The books which come under the heading of fiction in this amendment will make matters very difficult, and will raise many administrative difficulties at the port. How is the examining revenue officer to distinguish between what is fiction and what is history? A historical novel, while a very attractive way of presenting history, might come under the ban of the revenue officer. I quite see the difficulty in administering (b) 1, but I feel, at the same time, that that difficulty can be got over, because as a general rule, these cheap works of fiction come in in paper covers, and, very frequently, in cheap buckram covers, so that it would not require very much expert knowledge to differentiate between what is fiction and what is not fiction, and what is scientific and what is only pseudoscientific. I intend to support this amendment.
Comment on this
Before the Minister replies, there is a question I would like to ask. As we got the amendment very late, it is difficult to get the exact hang of it, but one point strikes me under paragraph (b) 3—"Books (other than books included in either of the preceding sub-paragraphs) bound in leather." It seems to me that the Minister might reasonably make, in the Finance Bill, a distinction between books imported for use as distinct from books imported for sale that come under that category. I think that Deputy Thrift alluded to that point already. Take the Carnegie Central Students' Library, which is a very valuable asset to students.
It is a very valuable asset to students, teachers and persons who engage in a good type of reading. They will get you any type of book. I saw, for example, in University College, a few days ago, the proceedings of a German medical society, got by the Carnegie Library for the use of one of the medical professors in the College. Its price would be about six guineas, if it could be obtained at all. I had not this amendment in mind, and I took no special notice of the binding, but I am pretty sure that the book was bound in leather or in imitation leather. That book was got for educational use—for the use of a medical professor in the practice of his profession—and it was got free. I think the Minister will agree with me that it would be outside his intention entirely to get revenue from an institution like that or from an individual professor or any individual who obtains a book only for use. He might have it three or four months, but he would be bound to give it back. It would be difficult for a private member to frame an amendment which would cover that kind of case, but if the Minister would favourably consider the suggestion, it would be open to him, with the assistance of the Revenue Commissioners and the Parliamentary draftsman, to provide that such books, imported for use and not for sale—I know that the draftsman has an objection to mentioning any institution like the Carnegie Library—would be exempt from the operation of the paragraph that imposes a tax on books bound in leather. In the case of American and Continental learned societies, you would have books coming in which would cost four guineas and five guincas, and a 50 per cent. duty would be very considerable. It would be taxing a gift and taxing education. I am sure that that is not the intention in inserting this sub-paragraph, and I should like the Minister to give the matter consideration.
Comment on this
I have the greatest objection to putting a tax on anything which will prevent people from reading, but I have a particular objection to the tax referred to by Deputy Hayes—a tax on books sent from these societies. So far as the medical profession is concerned, we get many books from American and other foreign societies, and all these books will be taxed at a heavy rate. To my mind, it is most objectionable that we should have to pay a high tax on these foreign books, which are required almost entirely for reference. If we want to keep up to the standard of other countries, we must know what other countries are doing and we must get the reports of the societies of these other countries. I do not think the Minister would like the country to fall back because of having to pay a heavy tax upon its books. The impost will be very serious, particularly to persons who are teaching medicine in all its branches. As Deputy Hayes mentioned, these books cost from one to five guineas, and a tax would be very considerable.
Comment on this
I have been looking at Item 3. The Minister has, I think, not realised that a great many of the books purchased for our libraries and by our professors are second-hand books. They are invariably bound in leather and are dear books. A 15 percent. duty, with a 10 per cent. preferential rate, will be a very heavy charge in many cases. Our books were supposed to be allowed in free under the legislation of the previous Government, but we had to pay a statistical tax of 6d. I had hoped that this Government, being an enlightened Government, being interested in matters educational, and members of which had joined me in attacks upon the late Minister for Education for not paying sufficient attention to things of this sort, would pay the freight on books in order to help scholars, as they do in Germany. In Germany, they are providing cheap books for educational institutions. Big grants are given in respect of that. Here, they are taxing us. It is incredible. I do not think the Government have thought about it. I do not believe that this is a Fianna Fáil tariff at all. I believe that some barbarian, some vandal, has crept in at night time and jammed this tariff down on their list.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister for a definition of "bound in leather." Does it include half leather or "half calf," as it is known? Few books are bound in full leather. Those that are are luxuries. Most of the books that have leather in their binding are only bound in half leather.
Comment on this
I do not know if it is intended to dispose of this particular duty now. If it is, I would move the various amendments connected with it. There is a consequential one (d2) to delete in the schedule the word "unbound." There is another amendment (4a) which is designed to secure the deletion of "printed music" and "wall paper" from the scope of the general duty upon printed matter.
Comment on this
We only discussed books. Some Deputy was, I think, stopped from going into the question of periodicals.
Comment on this
We will leave 4a. Amendment No. 6 on the green sheet would have the effect of removing the minimum duty upon books imported. We are prepared to accept the principle of amendment No. 5, in the name of Deputy Alton, and an amendment will be introduced on the Finance Bill to meet the point. A strong case has been made for the exemption of books intended for libraries from the scope of the duty, and we will arrange to have an amendment introduced to exempt from the duty books intended for libraries other than proprietary libraries. I think that meets most of the cases made.
Comment on this
How is it proposed to treat books coming from proprietary libraries, like London libraries, to individuals?
Comment on this
It would be practically impossible to exempt them from duty. Virtually, the books are sold. Let us consider the main questiton. I cannot admit that there is any good ground, in principle, for not imposing a duty upon works of fiction if there are good grounds in principle for imposing a duty on sugar or other articles of common consumption. The amount of the duty imposed upon works of fiction is small. It is very difficult to make an estimate of the amount of revenue which will be produced, but some revenue will be produced. It is not unlikely that in respect of quite a large number of books sold here, the duty will be paid by the importer. To a considerable extent, the duty has a protective effect. Under these circumstances, it seems to me that it is completely justified. I do not believe for a moment that because of this tax one person is going to sit idly at home of an evening in the coming year who would otherwise have spent his time reading a book. The amount by which any book would be increased in price in consequence of it is trivial. In fact, even at the moment the duty upon a certain general class of books is being paid, and I believe will continue to be paid, by the importers. The duty has a protective effect. I went into the matter with great care and I was satisfied that not merely would no damage be done to any export trade which we may have in works of fiction, but, on the contrary, that the export trade would be fostered.
A wrong impression is being created by statements made that the industry here is only interested in the very low-grade fiction. The industry here is, in fact, interested and is engaged at present in producing for export as well as home consumption works which are retailed up to 2/6, and even up to 3/6. It is quite possible that we may be able to improve that business considerably. I do not at all accept the statement that the home market for the sixpenny or shilling novel with a cloth cover is a small one. It has not been found to be so. I think it is sufficiently substantial to make it a matter worthy of consideration for any publisher to have the books printed here and thus escape the duty.
The imposition of the duty upon prayer books has also been questioned. There was, and is, a very substantial trade in this country in prayer books. To a very large extent in the past the requirements of the country were met from within the country. Recently that trade has passed abroad. It is noticeable, however, that people who might otherwise be indifferent appear to object strongly to having "Printed in Belgium" or "Printed in England," or anywhere outside Ireland, appearing on their prayer books, and the mere fact that a prayer book is described as "Printed in Ireland" secures a readier sale for it.
Comment on this
The practice grew up of having the prayer books printed in Ireland and described as "Printed in Ireland," but sent abroad to be bound. It is to stop that practice that this is being imposed. The binding can be done here. There are, of course, two kinds of binding, machine binding and hand binding, and both are being done here. In relation to the export trade, it is as a saving in the cost of production in regard to the binding, and more efficient and more effective work here, that the external market is being held. There is no reason, in my opinion, why the requirements of the country in prayer books cannot be supplied from within the country. I am certain it can be done, and the effect of the duties will be to ensure that it will be done.
Comment on this
It will apply to those only bound in leather. That only takes in part of the supply.
Comment on this
Will the Minister give any indication of what was the total invoice value of all the prayer books imported into the Saorstát last year or the year before?
Comment on this
Will the Minister deny that it did not go above £10,000 —the total invoice value of all these prayer books, including those sent to be bound abroad?
Comment on this
There are no statistics relating to that import, and I would not like to estimate it. I believe that in this year, if this duty were not imposed the importation would be very substantially increased. That is due to purely temporary causes. In any case, we are doing something.
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied that this 10 per cent. would put any people in employment in the prayer book business? Is the Minister aware that the prayer book business is a highly specialised one, done not only for Ireland, but for the whole world in one organisation, produced in one factory, in perhaps ten or twelve languages? It is the mass production that enables them to sell cheaply. Even if you put on 50 per cent. on prayer books will you put any person into employment in prayer book printing?
Comment on this
Anyone who wishes to get an Irish-made Prayer Book, can get one without difficulty, no matter what mass production methods are adopted abroad. There is an adequate supply of Irish-made prayer books. The duty is very small. Representations have been made that it is too small. There is something to be said in support of the Deputy's latest contention. It is quite true that the trade is being taken from the workers because of the fact that the imported prayer book is produced under methods which enable it to be sold at a very cheap price. We have to consider that. If a respectable class of skilled workers are to be deprived of employment here, not because the market for their products has disappeared, but because of the low type of industry —the kitchen industry that has developed in Belgium——
Comment on this
In the binding of prayer books by children in the homes which enables them to be sold remarkably cheap. That industry has developed, and it is the importation of these prayer books bound in that way which has upset the industry which formerly existed here, and resulted in disemployment of a very considerable number of people.
Comment on this
A very large number of the prayer books are properly bound. There is a cheaper kind of book which is only glued, and which is imported to a large extent, although even in those there is a considerable home production.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister is deceived when he says that the binding of prayer books is a kitchen industry. It is a very well conducted and excellent industry, highly specialised.
Comment on this
I am not saying that there are not some excellent bookbinding works in Belgium, but that is the production against which we are in competition, and the books coming into this country are produced in the manner I have described.
Comment on this
For the most part. Deputy Hayes mentioned the matter of a refund. Any duty paid which would not have been paid if the tariff as originally imposed had the form it now will have, will be repaid.
Comment on this
I am, for a number of reasons, particularly interested in these industries to which it is intended to give some measure of protection. I am referring not so much to the printing industry as to the publishing and bookbinding industries. Although I realise that we are giving a very small measure of assistance by this duty, I think it should be given, and we can consider and, in fact, are considering, if it is not possible to assist this development in some other way. They are industries in respect of which the output in this country will always be particularly circumscribed and limited, for a variety of reasons. It seems to me that there is no reason, if we tackle it properly, why we might not get even a substantial export trade in home-produced and home-published books of one kind or another. That may seem to be a Utopian dream, but I believe it is possible. What I am anxious to do is to keep some vestige of the industry here until we can consider ways and means to develop it in the manner indicated.
Comment on this
Would the Minister find it possible, before coming to the Final Stage, to have segregated the import list as between books, periodicals and newspapers so that we can get books definitely by themselves? Would it be possible to have a segregation so as to have an estimate made with regard to prayer books?
Comment on this
I doubt very much this statement with regard to the number of prayer books printed in the country. As far as I can understand, the economic unit of production of a certain type of book is not less than 25,000 copies, which could be printed by a good firm in a week. The entire demand for prayer books in the country would not take a firm a month to produce.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister for his concession in regard to the libraries, but I want to ask another favour in connection with it. If we pass this amendment the Government will be free to act, I take it, according to the amendment, and, therefore, it would be likely that another period would elapse in which, without special instructions, books consigned to libraries would be held up. There has been a period of difficulty and perhaps instructions could be given to prevent a further period of difficulty.
Comment on this
I was not here for the whole of the discussion, and perhaps the question I desire to ask has already been put to the Minister. Is he aware that the Revenue Commissioners are interpreting a consignment of more than one book as bulk when it is received by a bookseller and that a private person can receive up to six different ones?
Comment on this
The Minister is not inclined to give any concessions in regard to books sent to an individual bookseller for his own use?
Comment on this
I move amendment (d) 2, which is consequential:—
In the Schedule, ref. No. 15, page 9, in the second column, to delete the word "unbound."
Comment on this
I move amendment 4a.
In the Schedule, ref. No. 15, page 9, in the second column, after the word "periodicals" to insert the words "printed music, wall paper."
This amendment is designed to secure exemption from the scope of duty of printed music and wall paper.
Comment on this
The House can divide on the Resolution as a whole, but there cannot be a division on the fifteenth item. There can, of course, be a division upon any amendment.
Comment on this
With regard to item No. 16, I do not wish to make any comment on (a), (b) or (c). In regard to (e), catalogues imported in bulk quantities, I do not wish to support the proposition that a merchant or manufacturer in this country who gets a trade catalogue printed in England or abroad should be allowed to bring it in without paying duty, but quite apart from that, there is a very large amount of catalogues imported into this country in very small quantities by what I might describe as specialised manufacturers. They are supplied to various merchants and trading firms free, and they distribute those catalogues to their customers. I contend that if you pass this amendment it will result in having those catalogues sent individually to the customers from the manufacturers. I further contend that that would neither be good for the postal revenue nor for the merchant in this country who is competing against other firms in England. He has already paid for the literature under the heading of the goods he buys. Catalogues are supplied in all those cases practically free.
In regard to (d) and (f), namely, labels and tags imported in bulk quantities, and tickets imported in bulk quantities, at the present time the production of labels, tags and tickets is practically a negligible quantity, and it is done on highly specialised machinery. If you persist in putting a tariff on these articles you are really putting a tariff on the printer's raw material. He is competing with imported printed tickets or labels, and I suggest that he will want the full protection that he will get under the preceding paragraph. If you force him to pay an extra price for his raw material, you are only handicapping him when he comes to give the finished article to his customer where he is in competition with the manufacturer on the other side who had bought tickets at the lowest price and paid for them as printed matter. I suggest that that aspect has been entirely overlooked, namely, that the printer wants all the advantage he can get so as to enable him to get the printing, and if you put a tariff on his raw material you are only handicapping him in his business.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Dockrell must be under a very great misapprehension in suggesting that the printing of these labels, tags and tickets is a negligible quantity in this country.
Comment on this
The quantity of these tags circulating and being printed in this country is not negligible.
Comment on this
They do not comprise what is known as printers' raw material. Printers' raw material consists very largely of rollers, leads brass leads and clumps—things of that character, highly technical terms that I do not want to go into now. In the manufacture of tickets, labels and tags much employment will be given in the printing industry. There is no reason to fear that it will add to the cost of production of the finished article—the printed matter. These tags can be made here; the lables can be made here and the printed matter can be put on them. I am fully in sympathy with the proposal.
With regard to the raw material for printers, numbers of commodities have been held up. The materials I have in mind particularly are brasses and leads. These are not made in this country. I am sure the Minister will see that that position is remedied in the future.
Comment on this
With regard to this matter of tags, it is a very small thing. I have it from one of the principal printers in Dublin who does a lot of work in tags that he can pay this 33? per cent., get his tags printed in England and delivered here at a cheaper rate than he could possibly get them done in Ireland.
Comment on this
However, that is only a minor matter. With regard to stationery, I do not think there is going to be any great revenue derived and the net result will be to upset the printing and stationery business. Not alone will these things be held up, but every parcel of stuff that looks like stationery, tags or catalogues will be lying at the North Wall or at other ports and printers will be terribly inconvenienced trying to get stuff through that is not tariffed at all. It is one of these insignificant tariffs that will yield nothing to the revenue. There may be some extra employment in the way of folding notepaper by machinery and there may be other little things scarcely worth talking about.
If there could be three extra hands brought into employment in Dublin I would say "Go ahead with it," but I do not see that there will be any extra employment. There will be inconvenience caused to printers in the country and stationers and people generally in getting stuff through. Surely it is hard enough for people, who have to run on small stocks, when they order paper of some kind to be held up perhaps a month before delivery is made. I think the inconvenience will more than outweigh any little extra employment given.
Comment on this
An amount of inconvenience has been caused because of the fact that certain expert knowledge is not availed of by the revenue officers when dealing with printed matter set out in the Schedule. In the case of trade catalogues and other printing mentioned by Deputy O'Hanlon, a practice has grown up here of agents touting for orders, getting orders from good customers and having these orders executed abroad, their clients all the time believing that the matter is manufactured and printed in this country. With regard to trade catalogues, the practice is growing up of Irish manufacturers and others, notably nursery men who trade under Irish names and who ask their patrons to buy the products of Irish gardens, to get their trade catalogues printed across the water and, in order to deprive this State of postage revenue, they get the catalogues posted from Liverpool or elsewhere.
Comment on this
This tariff will do this much, it will bring some of these people to a sense of responsibility. They can get that work done as cheaply and as well in Cork or in Dublin. As Deputy Dillon says, it is to save the extra halfpenny in the postage that they get the stuff printed and posted abroad for their customers in Ireland. It is time to stop that practice.
Comment on this
Indeed it will. If there is a slight difference in the way of price it will stop it.
Comment on this
What are the prospects of getting all these things made in the country soon and at reasonable prices? There are a couple of firms, one in particular, manufacturing rather fine writing paper and ledger paper, but I do not know any that go in for the manufacture of things mentioned in (d), (e) or (f).
Comment on this
Will a book of instructions coming with a machine that is imported be liable to duty under this Resolution?
Comment on this
I am afraid there will be certain anomalies in connection with this tax. For instance, in connection with imported motor cars it is usual for each car to be accompanied by catalogues. I think it is rather a harmless traffic and I think it is very unlikely that this tariff will result in these catalogues being printed here. It will mean that such information as might be available for a retailer or purchaser will not be available. The purchaser will have to take the word of the trader. I particularly want to know whether books of instruction with regard to imported machines will be taxed. It would be anomalous if they were.
Comment on this
There is no difficulty in getting our requirements in labels and tags supplied in the country or in getting our requirements of trade catalogues required by native manufacturers supplied here. The difficulty of exempting from duty the trade catalogues which outside manufacturers send in here is that very frequently these catalogues take the place of catalogues used by the native manufacturer. He gets his name printed on the cover and uses them as his trade catalogue. It would be almost impossible to find a means by which we could admit free of duty catalogues sent in here for information only. A catalogue sent in here for use by a merchant or manufacturer is his trade catalogue among his customers. In our opinion, he should get his catalogues printed in this country. On the Committee Stage of the Finance Bill I propose to move an amendment putting in before the word "tickets" in paragraph (f) the word "printed." Unprinted tickets will be admitted free.
Comment on this
Labels and tags are not labels and tags unless they are printed and prepared as such, and that work can be done here.
Comment on this
Yes. Labels and tags are subject to duty. There is no qualification at all. As far as tickets are concerned, it is proposed to exempt from duty all unprinted tickets. Only one firm is affected in the matter, but we intend to give them that concession.
Comment on this
The Minister said that on the Committee Stage of the Finance Bill he proposes to move to put the word "printed" in front of the word "ticket" in paragraph (f). Quite a number of labels that one can get, luggage labels and others, are quite blank. Some have lines on them and some perforations for tearing off. If there is no printing on them are those not considered to be manufactured, and, therefore, are they free from duty if they come in.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, everybody knows that there is only one firm, and that is situate in England, that is engaged in a really big way in the manufacture of tags. There is no factory in this country for the manufacture of tags nor is there likely to be. I do not think there is the remotest chance of producing tags here.
Comment on this
As I am not in the printing trade I can bear the Minister's decision with resignation, but I would ask him to look into the question of imported catalogues. It is not a question of a person importing catalogues that they ought to get printed in this country, but of getting in free, literature, that they have been given free.
Comment on this
I have explained the administrative difficulties in connection with that. Very frequently merchants here are given large quantities of catalogues produced by manufacturers on the other side. The merchant here sticks his name on the front page of such a catalogue and uses it as his trade catalogue all over the country.
Comment on this
Irrespective of the definitions that are here, I would like to get clear as to what it is intended to include and to exclude. Take the motor trade alone. There are huge numbers of catalogues sent in here for the different makes of cars. They are distributed by the distributing agents here. They never charge a penny for those catalogues. They come in free, and they are distributed free. Is it still intended to have them taxed?
Comment on this
Does the Minister recognise, if these catalogues are excluded, that the volume of trade in connection with them in this country would not justify the cost of their preparation here?
Comment on this
In connection with Reference No. 17, it should read "manufacturers of iron or steel wire."
Comment on this
The amendment to Resolution 7, I think, puts that in. I was intrigued to see this particular amendment. Does it mean now that iron wire itself is not subject to tax?
Comment on this
I see that nails and tacks at the end of Resolution No. 17 are excluded. What about screws?
Comment on this
Would the Minister state what kind of iron wire-work he proposes to protect by this resolution?
Comment on this
Yes. Wide ranges of that class of work are excellently manufactured in this country.
Comment on this
I think there is some kind of wire used in connection with the manufacture of boots. Will it be allowed in?
Comment on this
I also propose to exclude from the scope of the duty coir rope. It is also proposed in respect of this to take the same power to licence, which I mentioned in relation to another duty, in order to exclude certain minor items which are required by manufacturers in the process of manufacture. Where these cannot be supplied within the country, we propose to admit them free under licence.
Comment on this
Ten years ago there was an export trade in wire fencing to South America. Can the Minister say whether that is going on at present?
Comment on this
With regard to Reference No. 18 there is a good deal of apprehension in the minds of shopkeepers, in connection with religious objects, crosses of which portion is timber and various other similar items. If they come under this, I wonder if the Minister has considered the desirability of having them allowed in free. There is no possible chance of their being manufactured in this country, and I am informed that there is occasionally an opportunity of re-exporting considerable quantities of those goods, and with the approach of the Congress, it would be inadvisable to have them held up, as I believe they are being held up, at present at the ports.
Comment on this
This is a very urgent matter. There is, I understand, quite a number of religious objects, in connection with which Church regulations demand that wood should form portion of them, at present held up and they are required very urgently in connection with the Congress. If they are not going to be allowed in, they are not going to be distributed and sold in the ordinary way of business. A certain amount may emerge in Dublin hereafter, and will be on sale here, but the people down the country, who do a trade in these particular articles, at this time of year, are going to lose that trade.
Comment on this
I think arrangements can be made by which they can be allowed in free of duty if an amendment is tabled.
Comment on this
I think there will be general agreement in the House if it were necessary to accept an amendment to do so now, because the time is running short, and by the end of this week, it will be almost too late to have them distributed. The tax on them is pretty considerable. I think some articles which cost a penny bear a duty of a penny or twopence and some articles which cost threepence bear a duty of threepence and sellers say that there is no possible chance of a sale at the enhanced prices.
Comment on this
I would like to have the question of the amendment of the Resolution considered by the Parliamentary draftsman. I cannot see the exact form of wording that might not prove altogether wider, perhaps, than was intended, but I have no doubt in view of the fact that such an amendment, when tabled, and when put to the Dáil, will be obviously acceptable to the Dáil, that we can get an arrangement by which stocks held at the moment can be cleared free of duty or else, subject to a repayment, subsequently.
Comment on this
Perhaps it would save discussion if I gave an indication of an amendment to this which it is my intention to move on the next stage. I propose to exempt from the duty, churns, incubators, component parts of umbrellas, component parts of covers for loose leaf ledgers and musical instruments. Road and rail vehicles are exempt from this duty. I also propose to exempt educational requisites in such a way as to ensure that certain implement and tool handles will be subject to duty— those that can be made here—and that others will not. There is some misunderstanding at present which it is necessary to have cleared up, but I was not able to have the amendment prepared for introduction on this Stage, I will however move it on the next Stage.
It is also proposed in this case to take power to permit the importation free of duty of certain minor items, such as Deputy Fitzgerald mentioned to me yesterday, wooden pegs that are used in boot manufacture which are supplied only by the persons who rent the machines to the manufacturer. He cannot get a supply except from the person from whom he rents the machine, and, consequently, he must import them. Similarly, frames for honey-cases which are made out of a type of wood grown in the U.S.A. and the exportation of which from America is prohibited, and we shall consequently have to allow these frames in free of duty also. There are some minor items of that kind, the difficulties in respect of which we propose to meet by a licence arrangement of the kind we have at the moment in relation to knitted fabric.