Resolution No. 7—Customs.
Contributions 428–647 of 647. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I understand that there are certain types of containers for fruit which come into this country. They are called by the fruit dealers "chips." They come in in large crates, and, as the law stands at present, the Revenue Commissioners say that they are not exempt from duty. There is no possibility of having them made in this country. They are sent out to Balbriggan and Rush and similar places, and the fruit is placed in these containers and sent to the markets here in Dublin. At present the Revenue Commissioners hold that those are not exempt from duty, and I would be obliged if the Minister would look into the matter.
Comment on this
I have received representations in respect of chips and punnets, and it is proposed, subject to an examination showing that there is no possibility of their substitution by anything produced here—which I think is likely—to exempt them.
Comment on this
I would like to suggest to the Minister that he should scrap the term "builder's woodwork and component parts thereof," because I am afraid it is very difficult to understand what is meant by it. Personally, I would have thought that a ladder would have come under the definition. However, it has been ruled that it comes under B. I do not know if the Minister is aware of any source of supply of extension ladders in this country. Is there any manufacturer of extension ladders in this country?
Comment on this
There is no person who engages in the manufacture of extension ladders exclusively, but I am not at all sure that there are not persons engaged in woodworking industries of one kind or another who could not make extension ladders.
Comment on this
I suggest that you will find it difficult to find him. However, that is neither here nor there. I suggest that certain types of things may be brought within this category which it is not intended to bring within it. Take electrical goods. The ordinary switch has a wooden base. I cannot imagine the brass top coming in and being assembled on a wooden base here. I take it that it is not intended that such things as the wooden bases of switches, wooden fuse boxes and things of that kind should come within this category. If they are intended to come within it, they should be specified. There are also covers for fuse boards which I suggest should be specifically exempted, if the Minister can see his way to do so. Personally, I think the broad lines—doors, sashes, stairs, greenhouses, etc.—ought to fill the bill, and the Minister might very well make a start with them instead of giving the Revenue Commissioners a roving commission over every mortal thing that contains wood and that is brought into this country.
Comment on this
Would a bucket with a wooden handle come in under "builder's woodwork," or would a hot water kettle with a wooden handle come in under the same heading?
Comment on this
A hot water kettle with a wooden handle has always been subject to duty as household furniture.
Comment on this
Six years ago, Deputy Blythe succeeded in getting the bucket and the kettles with wooden handles classed as "household furniture," and they have been subject to duty since.
Comment on this
Does the Minister advert to the fact that this will apply to clog soles and that it will also apply to spraying machines on account of their wooden handles?
Comment on this
Is it intended, in the exclusion section, lettered paragraph (d)—scientific and medical instruments—to include under the term "medical""surgical"?
Comment on this
On the general question, I understand that this tax will catch the cheap line of imported wooden toys. Is it intended to catch these?
Comment on this
Will the Minister say how we are to substitute the toys that will be prohibited, because the duty, if this proposal is passed, will in the majority of cases raise the price of these things by almost 100 per cent. In the main, as the Minister, I am sure, understands, these things are made from waste material got from certain timber works. A very specialised industry in these things has been established in certain parts of Germany and in some of the Scandinavian countries. A further article which would not be classed as a toy, but which may be cited as an example of small things caught by this tax which cannot be produced here because they are made from waste wood, is the clothes peg. Clothes pegs are going to be subject to this tax. I would like to know from the Minister what is the likelihood of these being substituted by a home-made article or is it proposed to get some extra bit of revenue by taxation of children's toys and things like clothes pegs?
Comment on this
So far as children's toys and clothes pegs are concerned, I see no reason why they should not be produced here. There was an industry in Galway engaged in the manufacture of wooden toys for a considerable time, and, from time to time, other people have attempted to foster that industry here. It seems to me that there is no reason why the industry should not go ahead. The skill required can be supplied by competent carpenters, and it only needs a little initiative and business ability to build it up.
Comment on this
It is. A large number of types of wooden toys have been made here and sold here, and can be made here.
Comment on this
Does the Minister know that the Galway toy factory went in mainly for the larger type of wooden toy, the wooden horse—a very expensive type of wooden horse—a rather substantially made scooter and a children's toy wheelbarrow? Outside these four main lines, did the Galway factory go in for much else? Did it go in for the type of thing that constitutes a specialised industry in certain portions of Germany, where it is such a tradition that the making of even one fractional part of a penny toy comes down from father to son, and where you see the people collecting at certain times with the specialised parts in a certain town, where the parts are gathered and assembled? These things are then sent out, and after they have paid freight in respect of long journeys over land and sea, they can be sold by the retailer at from 1d. to 3d. These are the things that I am referring to. It is intended to tax these, and the Minister believes that all that is required to produce them here is a little initiative.
Comment on this
The Deputy was talking about children's toys. I said that a large number of children's toys had been made and could be made here.
Comment on this
There may be some wooden toys retailed at 1d. or 2d. which cannot be made here, but there is no reason why the duty should be dropped on that account.
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that there are thousands of youths throughout the country attending woodwork classes, organised and paid for by the State, who are quite competent to do this work in their spare time, and who are hoping to get such work when they complete their course? Is it not a fact that the reports are that there are plenty of boys of genius in these classes capable of undertaking this work, and that the capital required for such enterprises is very small?
Comment on this
Will the Minister say if, for instance, the wood in a spool of thread will be taxed, and if certain classes of indispensable articles of medicine used for cattle, such as Parke Davis's blacklegoids, which come in the wooden containers, will be taxed on the wooden containers? I believe the medicine itself will be taxed under another resolution. Is there, in addition, going to be a tax on the wooden container? That medicine is indispensable for the treatment of blackquarter in cattle. If there is to be a further tax on the wooden container, it will be a very serious matter.
Comment on this
The Minister said he would exempt road and rail carriages. Does the Minister intend to include such things as baby carriages and perambulators?
Comment on this
Could the Minister introduce some amendment that would enable wooden articles of trivial value to be exempt, so that there would be no danger, for instance, of the wood round which the thread is wound in a reel of thread being taxed?
Comment on this
There is an exemption in Column 5 which reads as follows: Where the Revenue Commissioners are satisfied that the quantity of wood contained in any article liable to this duty forms only an inconsiderable portion of the whole of such article, the Revenue Commissioners may, subject to compliance with such conditions as they think fit to impose, permit such article to be imported without payment of this duty or repay any such duty paid on importation.
Comment on this
That will exempt the handle on the kettle or the bucket, but there are a lot of other small wooden article of little value which I think might be exempt. I remember that formerly, by administrative concession rather than by enactment, under the McKenna duties on musical instruments, Jews harps were admitted without duty, on the principle that their value was trivial. I think even these small penny toys could be exempt if some arrangement were made, where the value of the individual wooden article is trivial.
Comment on this
As to No. 19, which deals with disinfectants, insecticides, germicides, etc., I should like to know if the tax is being imposed for revenue purposes or in order to have these things manufactured here. I am not aware that there is sheep dip made here in any quantities. I am not aware that there is a non-poisonous dip made here. It is an absolute necessity for the late autumn dipping. According to this, it will cost us more to kill all kinds of vermin. It puts a tax on cleanliness and sanitation, and on a lot of desirable things, and I should like to know what is the object in introducing it? Jeyes fluid, Condy's fluid, and all the sheep dips, are to be taxed. I should like to know the case that can be made for this before we go any further. Store lambs will be selling about 18th July at anything from 10s. to 15s. Wool is selling as cheap as 3d. and 4d. per lb. In these circumstances, I do not know how the Minister can justify these taxes. Quality is more important even than price. If we cannot get a dip, or a disinfectant, equal in quality to what we have been getting, a very serious situation will arise. I ask the Minister to give us some indication of what he has in his mind with regard to this.
Comment on this
There are some substitutes for the popular disinfectants manufactured here, but I entirely agree with Deputy Gorey that the Minister in this tariff may be doing something, the full significance of which he does not realise, because a large number of the non-poisonous dips that come into this country are the only safe preparations to place in the hands of people. If there is a tariff on an article, a lot of country people will not buy it, and they will try to use substitutes for things like sheep scab and the other ills to which cattle and sheep are heir and as a result very grave danger will arise. If an ineffective sheep dip is used in any particular area the whole administration of the Department of Agriculture may be interfered with. We know the reluctance of people to buy an article on which there is a tariff. The danger is that if you put a tariff on sheep dip, germicides, insecticides, and things of that character, you may do the agricultural community a very serious injury. There is not the slightest doubt that these dips and preparations of that character largely depend on the advertisements, on the grip they have on the people, the confidence the people have in them, and the knowledge they have of how to use them. I suggest to the Minister that he should carefully consider, in consultation with the Department of Agriculture, the desirability of mitigating the rigours of this tax.
Comment on this
I should like to point out that there are sheep dips made in this country which, in fact, are better than the imported dips. One sheep dip made in Cork is recommended by the Department of Agriculture and is used under three-fourths of the county councils and has been proved to be successful. I think this argument is rather nonsensical when there are dips made in this country which are second to none. I see no case for importing foreign dips when they can be made at home and employment given in the making of them.
Comment on this
I am not aware that there is any effective non-poisonous sheep dip available in Ireland. Perhaps the Minister will inform us if there is. There were some disinfectants supposed to be non-poisonous used on various animals which have been proved in use not to be so. If I might refer to domestic animals, a matter which might concern the Minister himself, McDougall's make various washes for dogs, horses and other animals which are absolutely non-poisonous. I do not know if there is any similar preparation made, but certainly it is not in common use if there is. I do not think the Minister would like to see his child poisoned after washing his dog. Deputy Gorey was perhaps a bit modest with regard to that matter. I am not a bit modest in that way. It is well-known that McDougall's provide a non-poisonous disinfectant which has no equal, as far as I know, in the Irish market. If you are going to prevent that coming in you are going to put the owners of dogs in a very serious position. Again, certain people use a non-poisonous sheep dip. If there is any non-poisonous sheep dip from Cork which is effective, it has not been very well advertised. I know that people who are engaged in poultry rearing are very loth to use a poisonous sheep dip, because if they did they would endanger their whole poultry stock. It is a question that the Minister should seriously look into. It may, as Deputy Dillon says, have a disastrous effect on the whole policy of his brother Minister, the Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
I do not think that this discussion should be used to advertise a foreign product, particularly one at the expense of the Cork product. I agree with my colleague on the other side that the Cork sheep dip is able to hold its own with any other. This Schedule, however, includes a lot of other things, such as fungicides and vermicides. I would like to have an assurance that such things are produced in any quantity here, and, if so, that they are equal to the imported articles, particularly the proprietary articles against the importation of which this Schedule is directed, such things as "Catakilla" and "Weedicide."
Comment on this
I would like to know if there are two different classes of sheep dip made in Cork. It is all very well for ignorant people to laugh, but there is an arsenic dip and a non-poisonous dip. A waterproof, non-poisonous dip is quite a different matter to the arsenic dip. I would like if the Minister for Agriculture or somebody with authority would say if both classes of sheep dip are available, and whether they are effective. I have not the remotest hostility to anything from Cork, even if it came from Glounthane, where, I understand, disinfectants, are very largely used. This is an important matter, and I think we might treat it seriously. I did not mention fowl, but it is absolutely essential that the vermicides used in the fowlhouse should not be poisonous, and that it should not be in liquid form. There are times in the year when the fowlhouse should be treated with grey powder. I would be inclined to think in the absence of something convincing from the Minister that he has converted the Executive Council into a society for the propagation of fleas.
Comment on this
There are altogether nine firms engaged in the manufacture of disinfectants, sheep dips and other articles which it is proposed to cover by this item.
Comment on this
In the Saorstát. We have heard two glowing testimonials as to the effect of the Cork sheep dip. We have heard of the manufacture of the non-poisonous and poisonous varieties. The one thing that operates in the mind of the Minister for Industry and Commerce in recommending this tariff is that in 1926 the home production of disinfectants of this description was worth £5,721, and in 1929, £7,930. As against that we import £60,000 worth of these manufactures in the year. Quite frankly, I am not an authority on these matters, but I do not see that there would be any great difficulty in manufacturing them here. Most of them are proprietary articles which have been in the market for a considerable number of years. The chemical composition of virtually every one of them can be ascertained by analysis. I think there is not one of them protected in this country, so that it would be open to any enterprising manufacturer to put on the market here an exactly similar article if it paid him to do so under the tariff, and to supply the needs of home farmers, whatever type of article of this sort they wanted. Apart altogether from that, I do not think that the burden of the tax is going to be very heavy. The rate of preferential duty, which will probably be the effective rate, is only 15 per cent. None of these things costs a great deal of money.
Comment on this
It is not a revenue duty; it is a protective tariff, and the fact that small firms starting here were able inside three years, in a time of falling prices, to increase the value of their output by almost 50 per cent. indicates that small and all as the tariff is going to be, inexpensive as it is going to be, it is going to be an effective tariff, and it is going to enable these industries to develop in this country and to provide what we want here, employment.
Comment on this
Would the Minister undertake to consult with the Department of Agriculture with regard to the question of non-poisonous dips?
Comment on this
Amendment 7a is as follows:
In the Schedule, Ref. No. 20, page 10, in the second column, sub-paragraph (1), to delete the words "barrow and truck" and after the word "wheels" to add the words "except tractor and trailer wheels and wheels which are at importation part of a complete vehicle, machine, or other article."
The purpose of amendment 7b is to extend the list of cast-iron articles to which the protective duty will apply.
Amendment 7b reads:
In the Schedule, Ref. No. 20, page 10, in the second column, to add after sub-paragraph (1) the following sub-paragraphs:
(m) lamp and street standards;
(n) urinals;
(o) storage tanks imported empty;
(p) fire-bars, coal savers, and false bottoms;
(q) columns and posts constructed, designed, and intended for use as gate-posts;
(r) stop-cock boxes;
(s) floor plates;
(t) capstans and bollards;
(u) table standards, including cast-iron tables;
(v) pumps for use otherwise than in industrial undertakings.
At the present moment there are 14 firms engaged in the iron-foundry industry and they afford employment for approximately 350 workers. The industry has been declining here rapidly during the past four or five years and in order to maintain it in the country the Minister for Industry and Commerce considers that a tariff is essential.
Comment on this
With regard to No. 20, we have been told there are so many firms engaged in the foundry business. The Minister for Industry and Commerce thinks these people ought to be protected. What is the extent of the manufacturing, in all? What is the value of the goods produced by these 14 firms in any year? What is the value of the importation which this lengthy list sets out to exclude, except under a tariff? From a collocation of these figures we can get some indication of the increased capital necessary for these firms if they are going to extend to the point when they will capture the business represented by the huge importation that there is. What length of time will elapse before sufficient capital to achieve that is subscribed and what time will elapse before you are in a position to have trained workers? We would like to have some indication of the time that must elapse before home manufacturers will reach the point when they will be able to catch up on the importations.
Comment on this
With regard to (j), sky and dead lights, I think the Minister for Industry and Commerce gave some sort of undertaking that leaded lights would be brought under this heading.
Comment on this
I raise the question from the point of view that some protection might be necessary for the stained glass industry.
Comment on this
In reply to Deputy McGilligan, let me say that the value of the castings of iron and steel produced by native firms in 1926 was £58,227 and in 1929 it had risen to £74,771. With regard to the question of trained and skilled workers, I believe they are all here. The moulders, pattern makers, furnace men and others who are required for manufacturing iron and steel castings are already manufacturing articles of that description. If a person has to make a gully trap or a lamp standard it is only a question of having the appropriate pattern and mould made and then the casting can proceed.
This will involve a considerable increase in employment. The skill is here. Possibly at the present moment some of it is not being utilised. Many of the skilled workers who could be engaged are probably idle. If Deputy McGilligan will walk through Dublin he will see lamp standards and pavement boxes and all sorts of cast articles bearing the imprint of Dublin foundries, some of which, as a matter of fact, have been closed down within the past few years. He will see articles manufactured by Dublin firms which have gone out of business within the past two or three years, and the employees of which must be idle now. I believe this tariff will help to reopen those places and extend existing ones.
Comment on this
I have received no answer to my question. I asked certain questions in order to get a comparison, and so that people might have something on which to form their own opinions, not to be relying on the assurances which the Minister for Industry and Commerce so readily swallows from manufacturers who come to him looking for a tariff and who, of course, will say anything. I asked what was the value of the products in a particular year of the 14 firms upon whom, apparently, we have to rely. I was told the figure was £74,000 odd. I asked what was the value of the imports in this range of articles now being tariffed. I have not got that information. I want to get it in order to make a comparison. We are producing £70,000 worth, and we are importing so much. We would then have some data upon which to found an opinion as to whether or not these articles are going to be made, whether or not the skilled workers are here to make them, what extensions of plant are required, and what is the further capital that has to be involved. I have had no information on the second point. We got from the Minister his view about the skill that is here. I suppose that is derived, too, from the statements of manufacturers who, naturally, have to make the best case they can when looking for a tariff. It is a fact that three years ago there was an importation of not less than £200,000 worth of iron pipes. Put that against £74,000.
Comment on this
I am indicating that in the case of iron pipes alone the value of the imported articles was £200,000. Put that, if you like, against sash weights, pig troughs and feeding pans; desk and seat standards; manhole covers and frames of all sizes; hydrants and valve covers, gully traps and all the rest of the items set out in the list. If the Minister has information, why do we not get it? We must have something upon which to base an opinion of our own and not have to rely on assurances given to Ministers by manufacturers.
Comment on this
Am I to understand that ordinary water-pipes, what are known as the Staunton spun pipe, will come under this?
Comment on this
Would Deputy McGilligan say what particular type of pipe was covered by that figure of £200,000 that he referred to?
Comment on this
Quite. I am looking for information. Surely the people who are putting on tariffs ought to have some idea of the value of the imports that are now being taxed, and the value of the home products? I want to get a comparison between these two items.
Comment on this
It would be impossible to get that information. The figures in the trade and shipping statistics relate to all cost-iron goods. We have only taken out particular types of cast-iron goods, and there can be no doubt as to the ability of our manufacturers to supply these. The cast-iron industry here was largely a jobbing industry. In the original duty we included certain types of goods which, to a large extent, were produced more or less by mass production methods. They were produced by semi-skilled labour. We are now adding to that a number of classes of goods which require the labour of the highly skilled cast-iron founders. There are a large number of these in the country. In fact, for a number of years our requirements in relation to these goods were supplied by the Dublin foundries. Recently, because of a variety of reasons, the industry came upon bad times. As Deputy Cosgrave and other Deputies are aware, some of the Dublin foundries in fact closed down. I understand there is some prospect of these foundries now reopening in the new circumstances. In any case, the existing foundries in Dublin, Drogheda, Galway and elsewhere are quite capable of supplying the goods that are now subject to duty.
Comment on this
But still they have only done it for some years past to the extent of £74,000, and in one item which can be segregated from the import list, an item called iron pipes, there was an importation of £200,000 worth in that alone. The Minister for Finance expressed himself as absolutely satisfied as to all the skilled workers there are, and referred to big industrial firms. We have now got a proper description of it as a jobbing business from the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
And, yet, there is no fear in the minds of Ministers that there is going to be any length of time before we get a variety of articles manufactured here.
Comment on this
They can be manufactured straight away. As a matter of fact, a foundry industry in this country could make any casting required under three tons weight except the Staunton spun pipe. It is not intended that this should be included. In regard to all the items mentioned, and to quite a large number that are not included and that normally are manufactured here, the industry is quite capable of supplying any needs that are likely to arise.
Comment on this
I submit to the Minister that the term in the section "external water-pipes" is liable to a misinterpretation. I suggest to him that he should employ the term that is in common use in the trade, namely, eave shoots and down pipes. The term "water-pipes" might refer to water mains, and I understand these are being deliberately excluded from the Resolution.
Comment on this
External rain water and rain pipes, gutters and connections. It includes all that class of goods.
Comment on this
For the sake of clearance, I think it would be better to use the term that is common in the trade, eave shoots and down pipes. Otherwise, it may be thought that water mains are included.
Comment on this
If the Minister desires to see the industry re-started, I do not think this is the best way to do it. In the first place, practically all the people purchasing these goods buy what are called standard goods. They know pretty well what they want, who supplies them and they go to him. Normally, the persons so requiring these goods will pay the 15 per cent. extra and simply add it on to the price of the house, whatever it may be. At the moment and for some time to come, that additional cost is going to go on and it certainly is going to interfere with the cost of building. It must increase the cost of building, and I do not think that is the Minister's intention.
Comment on this
In respect to external water-pipes and down pipes the Deputy is probably aware that these are being made in the country and exported from it?
Comment on this
Certainly, but that is not always the case. Everyone does not buy them. Is the 15 per cent. likely to tilt the scale in favour of the home article and to get a demand for it at once? Personally I do not think it is. I think it is too small, and that it is too much on the other hand for those who have to pay it extra in respect to building —those who will not use the home material. I think the Minister ought to look into that and see whether it is not possible to get a stock of these ready and have it brought home to the builders of the country that they are available. One drawback about this enormous list of tariffs is that people are not in a position to know actually what is tariffed. They know that everything is up, but they are not in a position to know all the goods that are manufactured here and that are available here. It is quite possible that the engine is away from the train.
If it is intended to make a success of this tariff policy a good deal more work than merely having it dealt with here in the Dáil will be necessary. Undertakings from the firms in question as regards continuity of supply, the excellence of the material, the same terms in respect of damaged material that people here are accustomed to get from British manufacturers and so on should be the rule. In addition to that, in respect to quite a number of these items, there ought to be some inspection not of the inquisitorial sort but made rather with a view to ensuring that quality will distinguish the goods they are manufacturing. That is not an unreasonable request, because if people who have a sort of line ball business are going to be placed in a fairly strong position, then the public are certainly entitled to get value for their money. Within a short period there ought to be no addition to the price if they really enter into the proper spirit. I am rather inclined to think that the 15 per cent. is not enough for a business which, as the Minister said, was of a sort of a jobbing character up to now, with perhaps one exception.
Comment on this
As far as housing materials are concerned, in addition to the protection that we are giving here there is a more direct form of protection which we intend to bring in under the Housing Bill, namely, that the grants given will be conditional on the use of certain specified standards of Irish materials. At present we are endeavouring to get into touch with the manufacturers in order to get standards fixed and prices ascertained at which these manufacturers will supply certain standardised materials in quantity. In that way we will be able to get produced, on an economic basis in this country, that range of goods that could not otherwise be produced at all. So far as what the Deputy says, relating to the amount of this duty, is concerned, it is true that those engaged in the industry did press for a larger tariff. They made the case that the competition they were up against, in respect of some of these articles, was particularly severe; in other words, that industries in other countries, because of depressed conditions, and the rest of it, were selling goods at a minimum cost merely to keep production. I went into the matter in some detail, however, and satisfied myself that the protection we are giving is sufficient to tilt the balance in favour of the home foundries, and to insure that orders for these goods will be available to them.
Comment on this
Increased grants have been given in respect of housing. Is the cost of these articles, now that they are going to get the business, if they are going to get it, to be over and above what it has been.
Comment on this
There is a different impression amongst practically all builders and builders' providers as regards the cost. In fact, the impression outside is, and it is the impression of people in the trade, that the increased grants barely compensate for the increased costs.
Comment on this
What we are trying to do is by standardising the materials to bring the cost down to the minimum. There may be some additional increase in cost, and I would like to dispel any false impression on that account, because, in some of the industries affected, the prevailing rates of wages here are somewhat higher than in England and in so far as that is so, the cost may be slightly higher. By standardisation of the type that we have in mind, however, we hope to be able to get down to rock-bottom prices, and to make the materials available to local authorities and to individual builders at prices which will insure that they will be at no disadvantage when they are required to use the products of Irish factories.
Comment on this
The Minister has been listening to the proceedings here for weeks past and everybody knows that agricultural prices were never as low in the last 15 years as they are at present. People know fairly well that their prices are higher than they have been. For instance, one need only look at the newspapers to find that we are paying 130/- for butter here, which is sold in England for 100/- These costs are all on the main producers of the country. Can they bear any additional cost? If there is going to be accommodation in respect of these matters costs are an essential item, and it is a nice question whether farmers, who will take some of the houses, can afford to pay higher prices for goods here than the prices at which they are capable of being produced in other countries. Tariffs in order to be a success must produce goods at something like world prices and we cannot afford to have here prices in excess of those world prices.
Comment on this
In respect of these tariffs which come into operation almost immediately, and the previous resolutions, the immediate effect has been to bring prices down. The price of soap has gone down, the price of maize meal has gone down, and the price of hosiery produced in Irish factories, has gone down.
Comment on this
What I want the Minister for Industry and Commerce to understand is that prices have toppled everywhere. That is the root cause, or one of the main causes, at least, of the terrible depression there is at present, and here, we engage——
Comment on this
The cost of living index figure reveals a drop of four points between mid-February and mid-May.
Comment on this
That is what I have been saying, but the fact is, notwithstanding that, we are paying 4d. a lb. more for butter than they are paying in England, and we are certainly not as rich.
Comment on this
Might I say in connection with rain water chutes that the Irish article is selling cheaper than the English article. It is used extensively by local authorities and it is just as good, if not better.
Comment on this
There was a question asked by Deputy McGilligan of the Minister, namely, as to the estimate of the amount of these cast-iron goods that are imported, and the Minister refused to give even an estimate. He will remember, however, that, some time ago, we asked him for an estimate of how that £910,000 was made up. In that is included, I see from the type-script paper that was circulated, the item "cast-iron" articles. It is lumped in with the other articles making up that £271,000. Again, I suggest that that was made up by addition of the various items. Would the Minister mind telling us merely as an estimate, of course, what estimate there was, under the separate items, for cast-iron articles. That will, to a certain extent, at all events, give us some idea, and we can go on, then, perhaps, from that.
Comment on this
If the Minister has not got it now, he certainly can supply it as a separate item. He must have got it by having some estimate of the amount of goods imported.
Comment on this
The Minister must have had it in order to reach a total, otherwise the total is worthless.
Comment on this
The Deputy will understand that the yield from the duty will be very greatly influenced by the rate at which development in the industry proceeds. If what we hope happens, the yield will be very low, and if what we do not think is likely to arise, should arise, that imports should continue and that the duty has been fixed too low to tilt the balance in favour of the Irish industry, a slightly larger yield will result. But, in respect of the articles mentioned there, there can be no question that, not merely are the firms capable of producing all our requirements, but they have in fact, been producing the bulk of our requirements over a number of years.
Comment on this
That is not quite the question raised or the question I am nisraig now. To get at this £271,000, the Minister had some estimate. That estimate may be false or not, I grant the Minister, according to whether the tariff is effective or not, but an estimate was formed, and must have been formed, and it can only have been formed on some estimate of the amount of these goods used in the country at present. Could we not have that estimate? Granted that that estimate may not be very accurate—it may be a guess—but some estimate the Minister must have had, if this list is not entirely worthless. I do not ask for his estimate of the yield of the tariff—that may be falsified by events —but an estimate must have been formed of the amount of the goods used in the country, and we should have that estimate, I think.
Comment on this
I do not anticipate that the yield from this tariff will be very substantial at all.
Comment on this
I am not asking for the yield of the tariff. I am asking for an estimate for the amount of goods imported.
Comment on this
In view of the importance, from the Minister's point of view, of housing costs, I will put it to him that he will remember that, when I got an estimate that the tariff on steel windows would increase the cost of an £800 house by £15, he suggested that the use of wooden windows would obviate any necessary rise in the cost of building a house of that particular kind. Taking the cost, however, in respect of the different articles that have been tariffed here, I have got an estimate that the increase in cost on, say, an £800 house would probably run as high as 12 per cent.
Comment on this
There are so many "ifs" in relation to that, that it is impossible to come to a satisfactory conclusion.
Comment on this
There is the danger that the building industry will accept all these "ifs" as very definite burdens falling down on top of them.
Comment on this
It is given as the ordinary £800 house here in Dublin, but I want to point out to the Minister simply the danger he is running at present, if he does not carry out the examination that I suggest he should carry out. Every single possible "if" that a builder can see in front of him is going to be taken into consideration by him, in quoting his building costs, and down on top of a very necessary housing programme that is being planned by the Minister for Local Government and Public Health is going to fall the burden of all these "ifs," if by an examination of the position by the Minister with the machinery at his disposal, all the alternatives are not thoroughly pointed out, and all the "ifs" that can possibly be exorcised and made to vanish are not made to vanish. As I come across opinions amongst the people handling these materials for sale and among builders, the estimate of 12 per cent. is given as the increase in the cost of building, and I think it would be most desirable that the Minister should have the different items that bear on the cost of building examined, with a view to seeing what kind of case can reasonably be made for an increase in the cost of building.
Comment on this
That has been done. The Deputy understands that in relation to tariffs we are bringing in these cast-iron goods, rain-water pipes and down-pipes, and we are bringing in builders' woodwork. The position in regard to builders' woodwork is, so far as local authorities and the organised building trades are concerned, that home-produced woodwork has always been used because the trade unions refuse to handle any other. It only applies really to the unorganised trade, the smaller building people in outlying, unorganised districts. They are now going to be required to use the home-produced doors and window-frames and the like. The local authorities always use the home product, and the larger builders in the organised areas also use the home product. So far as the cast-iron goods are concerned, we are very large exporters at the moment of cast-iron goods. A very large firm in this country is engaged in their production and is supplying them to other countries. We can make cast-iron goods—commercial castings—at a price which compares with that of anything that we can import.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Minister will require to reduce all these general statements to figures.
Comment on this
In relation to the other matters, what we are doing is this: we are making out a list of every item which goes into the building of houses, estimating the annual requirements likely to arise in respect of each, ascertaining what the possibility is of standardising it and getting more economic production through standardisation and we are going to the manufacturers and asking them to quote us for producing certain standardised articles in specified quantities. If we find that they can do what we require and that the price is right, well and good. If we find that the price is too high, we have to cut it out for the moment. But the intention is, by standardisation and concentration of orders, to try to get the largest amount of Irish materials put into houses that are to be built.
Comment on this
It might not be amiss to remind the House that we have spent five hours on Resolution No. 7, and that we are not yet finished, while there are 18 resolutions with fifty amendments to be dealt with before 10.30.
Comment on this
I suggest that the House is not responsible for the extraordinary procedure of flinging this large number of amendments at us.
Comment on this
As regards item 21— superphosphates, ground mineral phosphates and compound manures—there is a considerable amount of anxiety amongst the farming community over this tax. Superphosphates are an indispensable commodity on most farms. So far as my inquiries have gone, it is possible that there will be a rise in the price of these articles. If there is, it will be almost disastrous for the working farmers on the poorer lands. The Minister might give us some particulars as to the amount of superphosphates and other manures imported from England and foreign countries. I know that there is only a tax on foreign phosphates, but until we see the amount of superphosphates and other manures imported from foreign countries we will not be able to make any guess at what the probable effects of the prohibitive tariff—it really amounts to prohibition—will be. There is considerable anxiety on the part of farmers on this question. Superphosphates and the other mineral manures mean, perhaps, more to the farmer than even the remission in rates. They mean practically the existence of the small farmer at present. Even the smallest addition to farmers' costs would be lamentable. I should like the Minister to give us an assurance that there will be no increase in the cost of any of these manures. I do not know whether he is in a position to give that or not, but the farming community will expect it from him.
Comment on this
I ask the Minister not to enforce this tariff. Fertilisers are very important to a large section of farmers in my constituency. It is absolutely essential that their land should be fed with fertilisers in order that they may be able to carry on their business. Our great want in County Limerick is lack of sufficient cash to buy artificial manure. I am in a position to tell the Minister what the effects of this tariff will be, because I am the medium through which a large area has been supplied with this superphosphate for a number of years. I bought last spring over 100 tons for the farmers. If this tariff were enforced, I would be only able to buy 80 tons and if I had to buy the home manufactured stuff I would be only able to buy 75 tons. That is the position and it is a very serious position for the farmer. It is a sort of tradition that a Government should attempt to make two blades of grass grow where one grew before. To do that, is to serve the country well. I do not say that the Minister, by this tariff, would stop that growth altogether, but I say that if the tariff is enforced it will prevent the farmer from improving his land to the extent that he wishes to improve it. Deputy Bennett has said that this is more important to the farmers than the agricultural grant given for the relief of local rates. I say that in a large area in my constituency it is more important that this tax should not be put on than is the addition to the agricultural grant and the Butter Bounty Bill. I make this appeal to the Minister in all sincerity and good faith. I hope he will remit the tax. If he does not do so, he will be placing a barrier in the way of many farmers in my constituency which will prevent them carrying on the work they are at present engaged on.
Comment on this
I rise to oppose this tax because I look upon it as a tax upon production. If you have no imports of superphosphate, the price is bound to go up. The manufacturer in this country has to import superphosphate and the handling of it and bagging of it is his only part in the industry. Surely, if there is an increase in the price of superphosphate, it will be a tax on production. The tax will hit the tillage farmer particularly.
He has not much stock to make what is the most valuable adjunct to the farm, and that is farm manure. He must fall back upon the artificial manures which are at his disposal. Probably he will not be able to pay cash for them and may have to pay a little extra simply because he gets credit. How much more will he have to pay when there is an added tax of 20 per cent.? It is the same with compound manures. Every practical farmer knows that the best thing he can do, and what will be of most assistance to him in farm economy, is to mix these manures himself. Every intelligent farmer who has been educated by our agricultural instructors or in our agricultural colleges knows well the proportions in which these manures ought to be mixed. He has not got any information as to what the compound manures are like. There is no section of this industry where there is so much profiteering as in compound manures. An excessive price is charged simply because they are bagged and sold as well-balanced manures. A farmer who has experience and who carries on his farm economy in an up-to-date manner usually makes his own manures in the proportions which his land requires and which his experience considers justified.
This tariff might have a tendency to encourage the production of another commodity which has gone back in this country, and that is the burning of lime. Many farmers regard that as a valuable adjunct to farm economy. I, for one, am very anxious to encourage that side of it, but not by putting a tax upon what must be considered as a most valuable necessity for the tillage farmer in particular, and all other farmers, whether grass farmers or those who carry on mixed farming. Everyone knows that it is only by intensive cultivation of your farm that you can make agriculture pay now; by top-dressing land for meadowing, by highly manuring crops with well-balanced manures. Anyone who taxes an article which the farmer requires is striking a blow at agriculture which will have a more severe effect upon the farmer than any other form of imposition that could possibly be placed upon him.
Recently I was talking to a most intelligent farmer in West Cork, whose rent and rates were not very high. The way he put it was, that a shilling in the cwt. less for meal, and a halfpenny in the pound more for pork would be more to him than either derating or de-renting. He was carrying on production on a very small farm at a rate which showed what can be done with land when intelligence and capital are brought to bear. I happen to know the tillage farmer, and this is the one imposition which the tillage farmer is least able to bear. He may possibly do without a new plough. He may make the old one do, or he may work with deficient implements, but the one commodity he must have an adequate supply of, if he is in any way deficient in farmyard manure, is the artificial manure necessary for proper production. At the present time, that is the position which exists with a large number of farmers in tillage districts. I venture to say that there is very little of the land of the country that is not under-stocked, and that an adequate supply of farmyard manure is not made. No matter how much farmyard manure is made, you must supplement it by adequate mixtures of artificial manures if you are to carry on an expert and adequate farm economy. I have no hesitation in asking the Minister, therefore, not to place this imposition upon the agricultural community, who are already sufficiently burdened, particularly the tillage farmer. We have had recommendations from the Agricultural Department to go in for what is called rotational grazing. Is there anything which will put a stop to all the advantages which agricultural education has placed at our disposal more than the imposition which is about to be placed on it by the Minister? I certainly have no hesitation in opposing it. I believe that injury will be done to the agricultural community, from which they will not recover, by an imposition such as this.
Comment on this
I do not know whether the Minister put this tariff on superphosphates deliberately in order that he could withdraw it afterwards. Possibly that was his intention, and so lead the farmers to believe that there was only one thing in this list of tariffs which bore heavily upon them, and that having given that away he was giving a big concession to the farmers. If for no other reason than that it will promote competition, I think the Minister should give way.
Assuming even that the tariff of 20 per cent. would not affect prices, by allowing foreign manures to come in he will keep the home manure manufacturers and the English manure manufacturers within bounds in price. We have had it from experienced farmers, and those who sell manures, that undoubtedly there is from 17/6 to £1 per ton difference between the foreign and the home-manufactured manures. If this tariff goes on, undoubtedly there will be a much greater difference, probably about £2 per ton. In my own county, and also, I heard, in the Midland counties, some farmers this year were so badly-off that they could not use any artificial manure, and the crops had to go in without it, because they had not money to buy it. Here we have an opportunity of maintaining competition in the artificial manure business, and if you do away with that competition you will leave the farmers in a very bad position. I ask the Minister to withdraw this. So far as the yield to the revenue is concerned, I am sure it is not worth considering. If it is in the interests of any particular home manufacturers, I think that the interests of the farming community as a whole are far and away superior to the interests of any small group of manufacturers, who might by this tariff possibly give employment to a few extra men at the expense of the thousands of agriculturists in the country. I appeal to the Minister not to proceed with this.
Comment on this
You would think by the arguments put up here that this was a terrible imposition altogether. Those on the Opposite Benches who pretend to represent the farmers think that they should get foreign workers to grind the maize, foreign millers to mill the flour, but that they should get Irishmen to eat what they produce on the land. The total import last year of these manures was 32,000 tons. The tariff, therefore, would amount to something like £18,000. Deputy O'Shaughnessy said it was more than the agricultural grant—£18,000 as compared with £250,000! It shows the manner in which they make up their accounts.
Comment on this
I did a lot more than the gentleman who gets up here and talks about tillage and who never thinned his turnips.
Comment on this
I know it very well. There are more "buachallans" growing in your farm than you could cut in a month.
Comment on this
There are a thousand people employed in the manufacture of artificial manure in this country. If we let them go west, these people are going to fall on our shoulders in home assistance, and every Deputy knows that as well as I do. I know very well that we have got from the Minister what we were refused last year—£250,000 for the relief of rates. I for one am not going to stand in the way of extra employment in this country for men who are idle in it and in any efforts the Minister makes in that direction I shall help.
Comment on this
I do not want to delay the time of the House in view of the fact that we have got to approve of the Resolution before 10.30 p.m. I just want to say that the speeches we have heard here displayed the most amazing ignorance of the situation in relation to this industry. In all these speeches Deputies assume that the farmers of the country have been depending on foreign sources for the supply of their artificial manures despite the fact that four out of every five farmers never use foreign manure. Out of a total consumption of about 200,000 tons, over 140,000 tons were produced within the country.
Comment on this
I shall tell the Deputy. We are going to put on a tariff for the reason that the British put on a tariff, and because the British put on a tariff, the foreign product, the Continental product, was being dumped into this country. Such a quantity came in here for the first few months of the year or during the winter that the existing factories were unable to dispose of the quantities they produced, and at this moment these factories are closing down and the men are being disemployed.
Comment on this
I say that farmers who have a different outlook to the Deputies who have spoken, four out of every five of them, have been using the home product. Five out of every five will use it as a result of this tariff. They will be placed in no worse position than the British farmer. A duty has been imposed in Britain on the importation of these manures, so that vis-a-vis his English competitor, the Irish farmer will be in no worse position. As a result of this tariff 1,000 men, as Deputy Corry stated, are going to be secured a livelihood in this country. In view of the fact that prices are going to be fixed by competition, and that the existing factories are quite competent to supply the entire requirements of the country, and also that the farmers are in no worse position than their competitors in Britain and Northern Ireland, it seems to me that there can be no reasonable objection to the tariff.
Comment on this
Let us, then, shut down every factory that is not able to produce at an economic price. If that policy is adopted, if we allow into this country everything which we can get at a cheaper price than that at which it can be produced at home, you can shut down every factory, cut down every hedge and level out every fence, and concentrate on the production of live cattle, which is the one commodity in which we can compete with other countries. We can do that and keep a couple of hundred thousand people in this country. We would then have the type of country that the Deputy is endeavouring to create here.
Comment on this
Are Deputy O'Hanlon and Deputy Brasier satisfied that if the factories in the Free State go out of existence prices in the Free State will remain as they are now? Are they quite satisfied that foreign manufacturers, even manufacturers of manures, will still be reasonable and have consideration for the Irish users? Is it not the case that in England there is a proposal by leading politicians to manipulate prices so that profits may be increased? Will that not apply to the manure industry if we are left to the mercy of foreign manufacturers? Are they quite sure that when the manure factories in Wicklow and other towns disappear that the farmer will be all right? It is absolute nonsense. Those who pretend to be farmers should have some consideration.
Comment on this
Might I remind the House there is an arrangement that these Resolutions, with the amendments, should be through the House before 10.30?
Comment on this
This is one of the matters that we wish to concentrate upon. I have not spoken at all to-day except on fleas.
Comment on this
I was looking at the Minister and I could not resist it. Does the Minister say that the total consumption is 200,000 tons?
Comment on this
The Minister has talked about dumping in this country because of the English tariffs. There was no dumping last winter. Only 32,000 tons came over last spring.
Comment on this
The total imports in 1930 amounted to 32,000. The total imports in the first three months of this year were 25,000 tons.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry has gone round to several Deputies asking them to make a case against this tariff.
Comment on this
The most the Minister could say was that 25,000 tons came in in the first three months of the year. That is the only time it would come in, in the month of February and March. The season is over now. We are told by the Minister and by Deputy Corry that the figure is 32,000 tons.
Comment on this
There was a time when we could buy fertilisers at £2 17s. 0d. a ton. What would we pay if there were no competition, if the 32,000 tons were not coming in? What were we paying before fertilisers were imported and compare that with what we paid after they were allowed in. It is up to the Minister to give us definite information on these matters. What was the position when manufacturers combined themselves into a ring and what was the jump in price as soon as the ring was perfected? Fortunately the North African fertilisers, not to talk of the Belgian or the Dutch, were imported. The North African is a high-grade phosphate. The Minister should give us some indication of what the prices are likely to be when competition is excluded. People got three times as much sulphate of ammonia last year as during the year before and that was because of the war between the two sulphate companies. It cost this year £6 a ton.
I believe this proposal will have the effect of choking off all competition. We will shut out the 32,000 tons of fertilisers that we have been importing. All the people interested in this country are going in procescessions to the Minister anxious to get a job done, and the Minister believes them, regardless of who has to do the paying. The Minister talks about £250,000 in this connection. If the competition is ruled out I believe that it will mean an extra cost of £200,000 or £300,000 on the farmers. I suggest he should take off this tariff.
Comment on this
I would like to ask the Minister if it is not a fact that the merchants submitted that there would be increased tillage as a result of a tariff on oats and is not that to some extent responsible for the increase of 25 per cent. in the importation of artificial manures?
Comment on this
I suggest a good deal of time would be saved if the Minister gave us a little more information of the type asked for a fortnight ago. There is no use in giving us a list of articles like spades and shovels, maize meal and superphosphates and indicating a sum of £56,000. That is absurd. Industrially there is not much connection between the production of these things, however close they may come afterwards. If we had a more detailed schedule it would shorten the business considerably and numerous questions could have been avoided. The Minister must have the information, and I suggest that such information as he has, granted it is only a guess, should be circulated to the House.
Comment on this
As the House is aware, there was an arrangement that all the Resolutions and the Government amendments would be taken before 10.30. Is that agreement going to be observed?
Comment on this
I am not discussing this with Deputy Gorey. I am discussing it with responsible members of the Opposition.
Comment on this
I am suggesting to the occupants of the Front Bench opposite that it is essential the discussion on these Resolutions should terminate at 9.30 and that we should proceed then to complete the financial business.
Comment on this
I would like to ask if the position is that this discussion is to go on to whatever point the Government Party think it should reach, and then we are to pass, without division, all these Resolutions and amendments. Is that the attitude of the Government Party? Is it suggested that we are to take all these Resolutions and do without divisions where normally we would challenge divisions? Normally we would oppose probably nine Resolutions in the Division Lobby.
Comment on this
I understand the arrangement is that anything in these Resolutions that we have not discussed we can discuss to-morrow.
Comment on this
I do not know whether a division is wanted. I suggest it would take up unnecessary time. The House should bear in mind that on the Committee Stage there will be opportunities for further discussion.
Comment on this
We could scarcely be expected to let such an important matter as this pass without a division.
Comment on this
When we decided to take the Resolutions item by item it was for the purpose of information, not for the purpose of debating each item individually.
Comment on this
I suggest we should finish with the Resolutions now and resume the debate to-morrow on matters not now discussed.
Comment on this
It will take ten minutes to conclude these Resolutions and ten minutes for a division, which, I understand, is to be challenged.
Comment on this
I have been informed by a responsible leader of the Opposition that it is intended to challenge a division. There are eighteen resolutions and fifteen amendments, and it is a matter of mathematical calculation to see whether they can all be dealt with under an hour. It is quite possible questions will have to be asked for the purpose of eliciting information.
Comment on this
No questions need be asked so far as Resolution 7 is concerned. We would be quite willing to have the amendments and the Resolutions put now on the understanding that the debate can be resumed to-morrow where it stops short this evening.
Comment on this
If the Government are moving the amendments formally and the Resolutions formally, assuming you are finished with No. 7, surely it will not take ten minutes to finish off the Resolutions and the amendments in that way? If that is the procedure it is a question of estimating what time it will take to do that in respect of Resolution 8 and the remaining Resolutions and amendments.
Comment on this
I think this matter is much too serious to take any risk in respect of it. We must have some margin in hand.
Comment on this
There might be an understanding that we could sit until 11 o'clock, if necessary, in order to finish.
Comment on this
There is no danger unless a division is challenged before 10.30 on a Resolution other than the last. Is not that the position? There is no danger, unless before 10.25 such a division is challenged. I suggest the Chair should start now to put all the amendments, and if any Deputy wants a division let it be taken on a particular Resolution, on the understanding that whatever happens we can go on with the Resolutions. If no division is challenged we can go on to 11 o'clock, if that is considered advisable.
Comment on this
This matter was discussed at the beginning of public business, when certain Deputies took exception to the agreement. Would the Opposition be in a position to bind those Deputies?
Comment on this
If the Ceann Comhairle and the Opposition are on the Minister's side nothing can happen to him.
Comment on this
I move amendment a 8:
In the Schedule Ref. No.24, page 11, in the second column to delete the word "twenty-five" and substitute the word "eighteen."
I may be able to meet Deputy Alton in relation to his proposal. There are difficulties, but I think we will be able to meet him.
Comment on this
I move amendment 10: (a):
In the Schedule, Ref. No. 30, page 11, in the second column, after the word "iron" to add the words "or steel, excluding unworked flat sheets of such iron."
Comment on this
I move amendment 10 (b):
In the Schedule, Ref. No. 33, page 12, in the second column, after the word "carpets" to insert the word "carpeting."
Comment on this
I move that the Dáil agree with the Committee in Financial Resolution Number 7 as amended on recommittal.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
The Opposition have indicated that they are anxious to have divisions on Resolutions Nos. 9 and 14. Will it be possible for me to recommit these Resolutions?
Comment on this
I would suggest that all the motions be taken and that we have divisions on these two, and that we resume then on No. 26, dealing with superphosphates.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy agree to take Resolutions 9 and 14 first and get the divisions over?