We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Financial Resolutions—Report Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–123 of 246. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

To my mind, the expression used by the Minister for Industry and Commerce yesterday puts a cloud of mystery about this tariff. He stated last night, with great emphasis, during which he thumped the table, that there was great evidence of dumping in this industry, and that he was prepared to prevent it. He said that 25,000 tons were dumped during the first three months of this year. The Minister also stated, after Deputy Corry confirmed the figure, that 32,000 tons was the normal import for 1930. The Minister did not give the figures for 1931, and did not mention, when dealing with 1930, the months during which these phosphates arrived. What is the mystery about this? When the Minister was asked about this tariff in the first instance, he did not know whether North Africa was inside or outside the Empire. When the matter was brought to his attention he said that these phosphates were tariffed. The Minister put a tariff on an important item for agricultural purposes without knowing anything about the matter. Evidently the Minister does not know anything about it, but Deputy Corry seems to know, judging by the way he was briefing the Minister yesterday.

Everyone who knows anything about this question knows that shipments of these phosphates come here during the winter months only, as they are applied only in the late winter and in the spring. That is the only season during which phosphates come here. These phosphates are largely consigned to co-operative societies. The firms that import them have no stores. The stuff is put on the quays at Dublin, Limerick and Waterford and some other ports of call. I know that cargoes arrive at Limerick and Waterford, because I have taken stuff from the quays there. The consignments are bought by cooperative societies on behalf of their members. The Minister thought it exceptional when 25,000 tons came in three months.

Comment on this

That is not unusual. Everyone knows that consignments do not arrive until the users are prepared to take them away. The other phosphates come from Belgium. We had the spectacle yesterday of Deputy Corry visiting the benches on this side, asking Deputies to put up a case against this tariff, and telling one Deputy that he was going to support him. As soon as the case was made, Deputy Corry made a violent statement in favour of the tariff. What is the mystery? There is a mystery, and Deputies who were here yesterday must recognise that, whatever the mystery, Deputy Corry is the missing link. This is one of the most unjust impositions ever placed on the agricultural community. We had the Minister's figures that 200,000 tons of phosphates are used every year. The highest figure he can give is 32,000 tons to prove that Irish firms have outside competition. What is the comparison between 32,000 and 200,000 tons? Nobody in business would make the case that there is a comparison. There is only competition to keep prices at a reasonable business level.

The proposition here is to take away that competition from the manure ring. Everyone knows there is a manure ring, that it is highly organised, and that the whole idea is to take away the small competition of 32,000 tons, and the 25,000 tons during the late winter and early spring months. I suggest to the Minister that he has not gone into the case at all, and that he has been briefed by someone else. When he was asked about the matter recently he knew nothing about it. All the indications point to that. I would be sorry to think that the Minister had put on the tariff on his own initiative, knowing as little as he seems to know about the matter. I feel very keenly about this. I think it is a most unjust and a most disgraceful tariff, and that it seems to have all the marks of jobbery about it of which the Minister seems to know nothing.

Comment on this

What amazes me is the confidence of the Minister in his own Party discipline. How he hopes or ever hoped to get a tariff of this kind through Dáil Eireann is a source of astonishment to me. If there was one blot on this Budget it is Financial Resolution Number 7, and, if there could be a blot upon a blot, it is the 21st item in the Schedule. Deputy Gorey is an emphatic and an effective speaker, but I do not think it helps our case to suggest that the Government would apply a tariff to super-phosphates without adverting to any of the relevant circumstances, and if they did advert to these they knew nothing about the matter. That is manifestly untrue. I believe that in facing the problem of artificial manures the special position of superphosphates of lime had to be recognised.

It may have been represented to them by Irish and English manufacturers that they were prepared to meet world competion and world prices in the matter of compound manures, and that superphosphates rambled in under the general heading of compound manures. Now there is all the difference in the world between the composition of superphosphates of lime and the composition of compound manures. Most of the Irish and English factories have done the compound manure business, quality for quality, pretty well, but it is the experience of everyone—farmer, cooperative society and manure factor— that unless you have the competition of Continental superphosphates on the market the price of superphosphates will go up in this country by £1 a ton. The day that you stop the introduction of the competition of Continental superphosphates of lime on the Irish market, on that day the price of super-phosphate of lime will increase by £1 a ton. Every farmer on the Fianna Fáil Benches knows that. I am reluctant to quote my personal experience in a debate of this kind, but year after year I myself used the Continental prices for the purpose of securing reductions of from 5/- to 15/- on the prices tendered by Irish and English manufacturers. If the Minister will look into that—there cannot be the slightest doubt about it in the mind of anyone closely associated with this trade—he will discover that year after year the English and the Irish producers bring down their prices from the original quotations the moment the Continental quotation comes on the market.

As to abnormal importations, I do not think that matters very much. I do not know if this was one of the emergency tariffs that was put on, but, of course, the Minister must be aware that superphosphate of lime and these compound manures are only imported into this country during three months of the year practically. There may be a little imported in December, but the vast bulk comes in in January, February and March. The Minister must also be aware that superphosphate of lime is largely the basis of most of the compound manures. I will not press the case of Peruvian guano, but I think that it might have been taken into consideration. To my mind the vital thing in this question of superphosphates is —I want to assure the Minister that if he makes a further examination he will find this to be so—that the imposition of this 20 per cent. tariff on superphosphates of lime means that he is going to increase the price of superphosphates to every farmer in the country by from 12/6 to £1 a ton.

Now, I descibed the tariff on maize as a tariff based on the principle of insanity. I have not the slightest hesitation in saying that to compel the farmers of this country to pay practically £1 per ton more for superphosphates, with the land of this country in the condition that it is in—the Minister for Agriculture said it is starved for phosphates—is absolutely suicidal, because the result of it will be that they will not pay, and you will find large areas of the country where people who used to put out four or six cwt. of superphosphate of lime reducing the four to three and the six to four. The result of that will be grave injury to the quality of the soil of the country and a grave diminution in the output of the soil. If the Minister ever walked a meadow which had been effectively treated with superphosphates and a meadow which had not received an adequate dressing, he would see the loss that would accrue in one year to this country from an inadequate use of phosphates. By this tax he is creating a situation in which that may occur all over the country. Why he should do that, the result of which will mean an enormous additional loss, passes my comprehension.

How the Executive Council can possibly stand over this tax I do not understand. The important thing to remember is that the imperial preference, so far as superphosphate of lime is concerned, does absolutely no good. It is the Continental product that keeps the price down to an economic level, and if you remove the Continental product from the market then it is absolutely certain that you are putting from 10/- to £1 per ton on superphosphates in the coming season. If you do that you will inflict an injury on this country the effects of which will be very serious indeed.

Comment on this

If it was the design, aim and object of the Executive Council to injure the small farmers of the country, and certainly in the West of Ireland, I could hardly imagine any tariff which they could put on which would be more calculated to carry out that design than the tariff we are now discussing. You must bear in mind that super-phosphates—to deal only with phosphates —is the manure which is most largely used in agriculture. In many parts of the country super-phosphate is the only manure used in meadows. It is more necessary than any other manure for all classes of farm crops. Now agriculture is going through a very bad time, and in no part of the country are people suffering more, owing to the agricultural depression, than the smallholders in the West of Ireland. You are, so to speak, putting a tax upon one of the most necessary raw materials for farming. This tax on super-phosphates must have the effect of raising the price of them. The manure trade is almost entirely a cash trade. Certainly, in the West of Ireland if a farmer is going to use manure, as he ought to, he has either got to pay a very heavy rate of interest if he defers his payment for it, or he has to pay, as the majority of them wisely do, cash down. But in present conditions ready money is extremely scarce in the West of Ireland. The fall in the price of cattle and pigs and of farm produce, of every single thing that the small farmer has got to sell has now left him extremely short of ready money.

As Deputy Dillon has pointed out, this is not a tax which will have any immediate effects, but it will have effect next Spring when the manures required are being bought. Judging from everything that we see, the outlook for the small farmer at the moment is very gloomy. If he is going to find the price of super-phosphates put up it will mean that he will have to go in for less intensive cultivation than he is doing at the present time. My view of Irish farming and of small holders is this, that they ought to be encouraged more and more to go in for intensive farming, and to put out more artificial manures than they are putting out at the moment. In my view, the land ought to be made to yield more by an increase in the quantity of manures used, by getting supplies of better seeds and other things of that kind. In other words, the land wants more capital put into it. But instead of encouraging the ordinary tenant farmer and the ordinary small holder to put more money into his farm, as he ought to be encouraged, you are by this tax driving up the prices of most important manures. That will prevent him in the future from putting in the amount of manure which he is putting into the cultivation of his land at the present moment. That is bad for the individual and bad for the farming economy of the small holder everywhere in Ireland. I would like to ask the Minister, passing away from super-phosphates, why is there this tax on ground mineral phosphate. Why is that imposed? I take it that it is imposed on ground Tunisian rock which comes in here and which forms the basis of semsol.

I would like to ask the Minister what is the object of this tax on ground mineral phosphates. These phosphates come in in the raw state and are put in in the raw state undressed. Manures made up in those phosphates are not the best for grass, I grant you. They came in during the war, they are a second grade manure, a cheap manure, and they are a very valuable manure for second class pasture. There seems to be a tendency to think that manures are only used upon meadow land and not for tillage purposes, but everybody who has got rough pasture knows that it pays extremely well to top dress, and basic slag or semsol makes a cheap class of manure. I would like to know what is the object of putting tax upon ground mineral phosphates and I would like to have some explanation of that. In my opinion the crying need for the small holders in Ireland now is to get the things necessary for him if he is going to farm his land at all correctly and to get these things as cheap as possible and nothing should be done to make them dear. Agriculture, as I said, is going through a very bad phase at the present minute and to put this largely unnecessary burden upon the small farmer appears to me to be most unfair to them and appears to be a tariff that will have repercussions upon our agricultural methods in the future. It will have a very bad effect upon our agricultural methods in my opinion.

Comment on this

I should like to ask a question or two in connection with this matter. As a non-agriculturist I was very much interested in the very informative speeches of Deputy Dillon and Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney suggested that it is intended to impose a tariff on ground mineral phosphates and he said that that commodity entered very largely into the manufacture of semsol? Is that so? I am aware that semsol is manufactured in large quantities by a big firm of fertilisers in Cork City who give a very large amount of employment there. I ask those who know something about agriculture this question. If there is a tariff placed on ground mineral phosphates how will that affect such a factory as Goulding's?

Comment on this

It is going to help them very considerably.

Comment on this

What I want to get at, as a non-agriculturist, and I listened with great attention to the speeches of Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney and Deputy Dillon, is: If this ground phosphate which forms a component part of semsol, which is manufactured to a large extent by Goulding's, is to be tariffed will that in any way handicap the industry in Cork City, for if so I shall vote against this Resolution?

Comment on this

The proprietors of that factory were associated with the request that this duty should be imposed.

Comment on this

But what about the consumers of semsol?

Comment on this

The Minister said yesterday that the imports of phosphates last year were somewhat abnormal. So that the Dáil may be in a position to judge of the extent to which they were normal, I would ask the Minister to give the figures relating to the imports of superphosphates for the last two or three years. The Minister will realise that superphosphate is used much more extensively now than some years ago. The use of it is increasing, has increased year by year because the farmers have come to realise that superphosphate is a necessary manure for their purposes, and for that reason they have been using increasing quantities of it year by year. There may be some relation, and there probably is, between the abnormal imports of last year and the increased use of phosphate by farmers in this country. If the Minister had consulted his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, he would have discovered that the inspectors of the Department of Agriculture have been recommending farmers for years past to use phosphates much more extensively, and it is, as a result, to a certain extent at least of the propaganda of the officials of the Department that phosphate is to-day used so extensively by farmers throughout the country. Every one of those inspectors has encouraged, and, as a matter of fact, facilitated, farmers to secure supplies of these phosphates. The Minister for Agriculture could also have informed him that owing to the decrease in the number of dairy cattle in this country there is naturally a decreased supply of farmyard manure available for manurial purposes. Hence it is that the use of artificial manure has increased, and increased enormously, as the Minister will find out if he inquires, by farmers for years past. It will, as Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney pointed out, seriously handicap farming operations in this country if the Minister insists upon imposing this tax. We have been told for many years past in debates in this House that the land of this country is going out of heart. For one reason, on account of the wet seasons, and for certain other reasons the land of the country is decreasing in quality. It is necessary, therefore, that manures of all kinds should be made available to the farmer. This tax will undoubtedly, as Deputy Dillon pointed out, lead inevitably to an increase in price. It is inevitable that manufacturers in this country will put up the price. The one factor that kept down the price in the past was competition from outside. If that factor is removed it is inevitable that the manufacturers in this country will put up the price. If artificial manures are to be kept down to a reasonable price, if the Minister is anxious to make it possible to keep down the price of artificial manures to a normal level, he should allow competition from outside, even if it was limited competition, because it is the only factor that can keep down the price of artificial manures to a normal level in this country.

I would ask the Minister to reconsider the question of the imposition of this tax, because there is no doubt whatever that it will inevitably force up the price of manures, and by forcing up the price of manures you are limiting the possiblity of the farmer being able to secure the artificial manure necessary for the improvement of his grass lands. Not only is super-phosphate used, as the Minister probably does not know, for grass lands, but it is also used as a mixture for growing potatoes and root crops generally. I would impress upon the Minister the importance of reviewing the imposition of this tax, and of giving the farmers an opportunity of carrying on their operations on the same scale as heretofore.

Comment on this

I think, as well as I can remember, in the confusion of the Minister for Finance being anxious to bring matters yesterday to a close, that the Minister did state that one of his principal reasons, in fact, his principal reason, for introducing this tariff was that as a result of the imposition of the tariff in England, a lot of the continental phosphates were diverted to this country, and that, I think, in the opening months of this year—or was it the first four months?—there had been an increase of some 25 per cent.

Comment on this

The first three months.

Comment on this

That during the first three months of this year there has been an increase of 25 per cent. It has been pointed out again and again from these benches and, in fact, from every quarter of the House, except the unpaid Parliamentary Secretary to the Executive Council, who has spoken strongly in favour of this tax, that, after the month of May, there is practically no importation of superphosphates into this country, and that, in fact, in certain months there is no importation at all, judging by the returns we have here before us. For instance, in 1931, in the month of June there were only 700 tons; in July, 41 tons; none in August or September; one ton in October; 26 tons in November, and then it goes up again to 800 tons in December. That fully bears out what was said from all over the House. Therefore, do not speak of 25 per cent., but speak of the aggregate number of tons extra that were introduced. And then we are told that the aggregate increase of about, say, 8,000 tons—I should say that would be the very most—say, a 25 per cent. increase, would endanger the employment of 1,000 people working in this industry in this country. The Minister also, I think, said that there was an abnormal increase over last year; but if we take the figure for the year 1931, as given in the trade returns, and compare it with the previous year, it will be found that in the year 1931 there was practically a falling-off of precisely that 25 per cent. from the previous year.

Comment on this

1931? This is 1932.

Comment on this

There was a decrease. In the year 1930 there were brought into the country 42,000 tons——

Comment on this

I am taking the first three months of this year.

Comment on this

I am taking the total year, and it has been pointed out that most of the importations come in in the first three months. There were, in the year 1930, 42,000 tons, and in 1931, there were 32,000 tons. Therefore, there was practically a diminution in 1931 of 20 per cent. to 25 per cent., precisely what it has gone up this year, and he has not proved that they were abnormal, even if there was a 25 per cent. increase. It is absurd to suggest that because there is an increase of 8,000 tons, the whole business of 140,000 tons is in danger. We have heard from everybody interested in the trade, and in farming, here, that this is calculated to do a great deal of damage, and I suggest that the Minister has not made out the slightest case for it, even from the point of view of the statistics his own Department has published, but, of course, he will give us an assurance that this will do no damage to farming. None of the tariffs are going to damage anything. In fact, we were told last night, and, I think, even the simple heart and trusting mind of Deputy Dillon got a shock, that, as a result of the tax on maize meal, its price had fallen in this country, and not as a result of world prices.

Comment on this

That was the implication.

Comment on this

No, that was the direct answer to a question.

Comment on this

I did not say that at all. A Deputy opposite had said prices had gone up following the tariff, and I proved definitely that they had not.

Comment on this

I put the Minister a question: Was the decrease in price due to the tariff? And he answered "Yes," I think, in the hearing of the whole House. In other words, he has left out of account altogether, as he usually will do in these cases, the fact that were it not for the tariff, world prices would have brought the price of maize down still further even than at present. Dealing with a simplicity of mind of that kind I suggest that an assurance that this will not damage agriculture is absurd when we have had from most of the farming Deputies, except Deputy Corry, whose official attitude certainly seems to be against our argument and in favour of the tariff, and from people interested in farming, from whatever Party, whether Independent or those who had a knowledge of dealing with the material itself in the way of selling to the farmers, an assurance that this will mean an increase in price to the farmers of this most important commodity. Of course, if Deputy Dillon thinks that that will have the slightest effect on the optimism of the Minister, I do not know what he is doing in this House, or what he is learning in this House, so far as the attitude of the Government is concerned.

Comment on this

I wish to intervene in order to put some Deputies right, because, apparently their ignorance of this is only equalled by their ignorance of a number of other subjects. Four out of five farmers in this country last year, and in every year, used the product of the Irish factories. That is one fact.

Comment on this

Admitted.

Comment on this

And when we are told about the adverse effect on the farmers, the possibility of their using a smaller quantity of fertilisers and the like, keep that fact in mind. Four out of five farmers use the products of the Irish factories. We are not making it impossible for any farmer to get all the quantity he wants of these products. There is an adequate supply available in the country, and even if the supply in the country runs short, there is no duty on products imported from Great Britain, or any other country in the British Commonwealth. So far as competition is concerned, the suggestion which Deputy Roddy made has been adopted. We have allowed a considerable measure of competition still to prevail, and those engaged in this industry in this country have no objection to meeting competition from any country in which the standard of living and the working conditions in the industry are, in any way, similar to ours.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that the English factories are in a ring?

Comment on this

If there is any indication——

Comment on this

Is there?

Comment on this

If there is any indication that the price of these commodities, or of any other commodity subject to a tariff, is being forced up in consequence of the adoption of ring methods, we propose to introduce a Bill here which will give us power to deal with it, and if we found that such profiteering was taking place, we would, as a last resort, review the duty entirely, but no evidence of undue profit-taking has been offered to us, and no evidence is available.

Comment on this

What is a ring for? Is it not designed to kill home competition?

Comment on this

What is a ring for?

Comment on this

Every year the ring has brought prices down 15/- and 10/- the moment the continental price has come on the market.

Comment on this

Let us consider these continental prices. Continental super-phosphates are being brought in at 50/-. That takes into account 10/- for freight and 10/- in consequence of the depreciation of our currency. These superphosphates are being produced at about 30/- a ton. It is not possible to produce them in this country at that price. Will Deputies say that we should get the benefits of the cheap superphosphates and let the Irish products disappear? Will the farmer be better off? He may be better off for a few months of this year but I think in the long run he is going to be the victim of the consequence of the disappearance of the Irish industry. There are several facts which Deputies appear to be forgetting altogether. First of all, a great number of fertilisers are not subject to duty at all.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Which?

Comment on this

Basic slag, guano, sulphate of ammonia and a number of other fertilisers in very common use, are not subject to duty. A number of these fertilisers, particularly sulphate of ammonia, is subject to duty on entering Great Britain. The imports of sulphate of ammonia into this country this year increased by over 300 per cent. We have not imposed a duty on that particular commodity because the factories here are not in a position to supply our requirements and for other reasons. The fact is that our farmers, because of the fact that we have not imposed a duty, are in a position to get their supplies at a much lower price than the farmers can get them at in Great Britain. The home factories, as I have said, are at the moment and always have been supplying 75 per cent. of our requirements. Get that fact quite clear because all this talk about hardship being imposed on the farmer is futile nonsense. The fact is, so far as four out of five farmers are concerned, that no hardship is being imposed upon them.

Comment on this

May I ask a question? If four out of five farmers who now use one product continue to use the home product and if they have to buy it at a higher rate are they being penalised?

Comment on this

There is no reason to anticipate that it will be at a higher price.

Comment on this

If they do they will be penalised.

Comment on this

Not necessarily. If the increase in the rate is due to profiteering then undoubtedly they will be penalised and then undoubtedly we will take action, but if the increase in price is due to the increase in price of raw materials it would be justifiable and there would be no question of penalisation. In so far as their chief competitors in the British market are concerned, they are in a more favourable position here. The British imposed a duty and because of that duty there was an increase in the importation of these superphosphates and compound manures into this country. There was an increase of 30 per cent. in March of this year as compared with March of last year. Deputies on the opposite benches are wondering why we do not take the usual course adopted and allow an industry to disappear first before taking steps to protect it.

Comment on this

If dealing with percentages, will the Minister give the actual number of tons for the three months in 1931 and 1932?

Comment on this

I am comparing the 1932 and the 1931 situation which has resulted from the imposition of a duty and the fall in the value of the pound and from the increased competition on the Continent which developed last year.

Comment on this

I am merely asking the Minister for information. Would he mind giving the comparative figures for the three previous years, 1931, 1930 and even 1929?

Comment on this

I will not give them. The Deputy can secure them for himself. If I were to give them they would only create increased confusion in the minds of the Deputies opposite. In the year 1931 the pound went off the gold basis and its value depreciated.

Comment on this

Was it off in 1930?

Comment on this

Last year Britain imposed a duty upon these things coming into England and last year intense competition from the Continent developed. There has been an increase in the first three months, I will admit, of 25 per cent. The imports of super-phosphates have increased 300 per cent. and the imports of sulphate of ammonia also increased. We are not subjecting sulphate of ammonia to any duty. The agricultural industry is being placed under no hardship whatsoever and the livelihood of a thousand people is being preserved. We can, if the Deputies wish, deliberately decide that it is better for us to be in a position in which we can buy these compound manures and fertilisers in the cheapest market in the world and allow another industry to disappear. Do the farmers want that? That is the inevitable consequence of the removal of these duties. You cannot produce these things at 30/- a ton.

Comment on this

You are not asked but you are selling them at £3 12s. 6d.

Comment on this

They are being produced on the Continent at 30/- a ton.

Comment on this

What is that to you? They are not selling them here at that.

Comment on this

I think it is your duty, a Chinn Comhairle, to keep that Deputy in order, if possible. Is that what the Deputies want, that the thousand men engaged in this industry be deprived of their employment and the factories engaged in the production of these things be closed down? If that were done and if the workers were maintained by the farmers out of the home assistance fund, then we would have very severe criticism from the Deputies opposite for not taking action in time to preserve the industry. So far as the farmers are concerned, their position is not being worsened in respect of 25 per cent of their requirements. For these things they have only got to come to the Irish factories instead of to the importers of the continental stuff. In respect of a great range of artificial manures of one kind or another, there is no duty. In respect of the articles which we have brought subject to the duty the greater requirements of the country will be and always have been supplied by our own factories and we want that position to continue.

Comment on this

I do not know if, when considering this tariff, before bringing it in, the Minister took any pains to consult anybody except the manufacturers concerned.

Comment on this

I consulted the officials of the Department of Agriculture and this tariff was prepared in consultation with them.

Comment on this

Did the Minister consult any of the three out of five or four out of five farmers? Did he even consult the representative of the Minister for Agriculture who is here to-day, Deputy Corry? Because in the absence of the Minister for Agriculture he seems to hold the agricultural brief for the Minister. Did the Minister consult Deputy Corry before the introduction of this Resolution? Deputy Corry has been in fear and trembling lest somebody might not get up to oppose this tariff. It seems to-day as if Deputy Corry has transferred his allegiance from the farmers to the manufacturers. Evidently he has. The Minister has spoken of four out of five farmers. He appears to be wrong in his figures because according to the figures he gave me it would work out at 3½ out of 5. Are the four out of five farmers or the three and a half out of five who use this product satisfied with the Minister's explanation? Are not they well aware that the importation of one-third— the Minister said one-fourth—of these commodities has the effect of keeping down the price of the home commodity? The Minister attacks us when we talk about keeping down prices. I do not care one whit. Speaking as a representative of the farmer, if the manufacturers cannot increase their production it must be done at the expense of the farmer. Here we have an industry producing, as the Minister says, 140,000 out of a possible 200,000 tons. They are competing with English and foreign manufacturers and they have expanded their trade so that, as the Minister himself said, they have command of four-fifths of the total. It is, I think, a little less but the home manufacturers have command of a great proportion of the trade. Are we, the farmers of this country, to stand for a proposition which takes away the only possible competition with these merchants and put them in a position to charge anything they like, as they will charge, notwithstanding the legislation which the Minister is to introduce? Deputy Corry, the Assistant Minister for Agriculture, knows as well as I do that that will be the effect. Deputy Corry, who has apparently changed his allegiance from the farmers to the manufacturers, knows as well as I do that if there was necessity for stopping the importation of foreign manures, now, above all times, is a most inappropriate time for such legislation. As Deputy Corry knows, the farmer is now absolutely unable to meet the costs which are pressing upon him. Deputy Dillon said, rightly, that the price of these manures will possibly go up one shilling per cwt. Probably it will. But even if the price only went up one penny per cwt. as a result of this tariff, or 1/8d. a ton, it would be a burden on the farmers greater than the Minister for Industry and Commerce or Deputy Corry can estimate. Deputy Corry knows, if the Minister for Industry and Commerce does not, that many small holders have been able to increase the stock-carrying power of their farms by almost 100 per cent. by the constant application of these manures. Does the Minister, or does Deputy Corry, mean to tell us that even a small addition to the ordinary price of these manures will not be a considerable hardship on the farmers?

There is a remarkable silence on the part of the Farmer Deputies on the Government Benches. Deputy Corry alone stepped in where others feared to tread, having changed his allegiance. I defy any farmer Deputy to get up and make any sort of case, good or bad, for the Minister's proposition, or to go back to his constituents and defend the Minister's proposition. The Minister suggested last day that there would be a thousand extra men put into employment. He has corrected that. He said he was trying to preserve in employment the thousand men there at present. Even if we increase the business by one-third, we are not going to have a great many extra men put into employment. And it will be all at the expense of the farmer. Practically every farmer uses, at one time or another, some of the manures specified in this tariff. If allowed to stand, this tariff will be a handicap on farmers, small and large, greater than the Minister or Deputy Corry can estimate, and greater than any of us, without figures as we are at the moment, can estimate. Even if the increase in price be only 1d. per cwt., which is the lowest computation that can be made, the handicap will be very considerable. Is Deputy Corry prepared to go down to Cork and tell the small farmers engaged in tillage or in grazing and helping out the worn-out soil with some of these manures, that he is supporting this tariff because a certain manufacturer in Cork, without this tariff, would not be able to make the profits that, possibly, he made a few years ago? That will be the explanation that Deputy Corry will have to give when he goes down to Cork—not that certain manufacturers are in danger of going out of business, because they are not. Any manufacturers who are in the position of supplying three-fourths of the needs of this country against foreign and Commonwealth competition cannot say that they are in grave danger of being forced out of business. There is not an iota of justification for this tariff. The Minister cannot have taken ordinary care in considering it. He cannot have taken steps to consult any of the people whom it would affect, except the people on the manufacturing side. I notice that the Minister for Agriculture is now beside the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The Minister for Agriculture knows, if nobody else on the Government Bench knows, the effect that this tariff will have on the agricultural community. My appeal to the Minister for Industry and Commerce having failed, I appeal to the Minister for Agriculture to use his influence with his Government to stop this imposition on an already overburdened section of the community.

Comment on this

I fail to follow the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce if he intends it to be a serious contribution to this debate instead of a piece of flamboyant rhetoric. He says that 75 per cent. of the manures used in this country is made in Irish factories. What on earth has that to do with this issue? If 100 per cent. of the manures used by Irish farmers was made in Irish factories it would not influence the matter. The majority of farmers use Irish-manufactured manures. I myself use a considerable amount of artificial manure— all Irish manufacture. I am chairman of a co-operative society which sells a large quantity of manure—all Irish. But we do not want to see the price of any manure go up considerably, to the detriment of the farmers. Under this proposed tax the price must go up. What I would rather expect with the fall in the price of cattle and in the price of all world commodities would be that next year we would have a very considerable fall in the price of manures. I think the price of manures should follow the world tendency, and that it should not be kept up artificially by tariffs to the detriment of the farmer. The Minister for Industry and Commerce is full of woe when he thinks of super-phosphates being put on the Irish market at £2 10s. 0d. per ton. He did not tell us what grade of superphosphate he referred to. So far as I can gather, the Minister considers superphosphates as one whole. He is not aware that there are different grades of superphosphates at different prices. Even XXX superphosphate at £2 10s. 0d. per ton, if it could be got—and I do not see why it should not, with the present fall in world prices—next spring, would be helpful, indeed, to the Irish farmer. I do not see in the least why it should destroy the Irish manure manufacturer.

That is the Minister's case. He says that the Irish manufaturers will have to go out of business. They have 75 per cent. of the business now, and they will have to close down if a tax of this nature is not put on. Either the sale of artificial manure in this country has been going down enormously or the output of the manure manufacturers has been increasing enormously. It must be one or the other. In the year 1930 the importation of rock phosphates was 94,000 tons, and in 1931, 63,000. Of basic slag in 1930 the importation was 38,000 tons; in 1931, 28,000. In 1930 the importation of sulphate of ammonia was 21,000; in 1931, 18,000. In 1930 the importation of superphosphate was 42,000; and in 1931, 31,000. As to compound manures and other fertilisers, in 1930 the importation was 38,000; in 1931, 34,000. In every single one of these items there has been an enormous drop between 1930 and 1931 in the quantity imported. What is the reason of that? Is it that the price of manure has become so high that Irish farmers cannot use it, or is it that the manure manufacturers have captured the market? I do not know which it is. But whichever it is, it is an overwhelming argument against the imposition of this tariff at present that between 1930 and 1931 there should be this enormous drop in the importation of artificial manures.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce seems to think that sulphate of ammonia is a substitute for superphosphate, because he says that you are getting sulphate of ammonia in without any tax. The Irish farmers can carry on practically as well, though not as efficiently as at present, if you stop the importation of sulphate of ammonia altogether, because there are substitutes for it, Sulphate of ammonia is purely a nitrogenous manure, and there are other nitrogenous manures which can take the place of sulphate of ammonia. I do not think any farmer in the House will contradict that proposition. As a matter of fact, sulphate of ammonia is not the most largely used of nitrogenous manures. Though it is more suited for some purposes than the other nitrogenous manures, yet it can in fact be done without, but you cannot do without superphosphates if you are going to use manures at all, because the phosphates are more important than nitrogenous or potash manures.

Now the Minister for Industry and Commerce talked about the gold standard. What has the gold standard to do with it? I cannot see. It seems to me that the Minister was simply trying to beat the air. The gold standard has nothing to do with the number of tons imported. I have given the figures of the number of tons imported. If the Irish farmer is going to be exploited, as seemingly he is going to be exploited, in aid of the manure manufacturers, then it is an extremely bad thing for the agriculture of this country, and it will ultimately be very bad for the manure trade here. They may get a higher price per ton for the manure they sell, but the manure trade will lose on their sales, because you will put it out of the power of the farmer to use necessary manures. The farmer can do without a great deal of manures. Take the manuring of grass land and pasture. That is a very wise thing to do, and very often a paying thing, but it is not necessary. All that will drop away. If you are going to have a rise in the price of other phosphates, you will find that basic slag, which can be got at very much the same price, because it is not manufactured here, and therefore can be imported, will cut out the other phosphate manures for such purposes as basic slag can be used for, such as meadows and turnip growing.

Comment on this

Deputy Bennett accused me of changing my allegiance to the farmer. From 1927 onwards, while I was on the benches opposite, trying to help the farming community, I know the assistance we got from Deputies Bennett, Gorey, and the rest. I challenge Deputies on the opposite benches to say that they ever did anything in the farmers' interests in the last five years. I admit that the step was a very short one for some of them from the farmers' interests to the landlords' interests. These Deputies, under the whip of Deputies Good and Thrift, trotted into the Lobby in support of every proposal brought into the Dáil to scourge the hide of the unfortunate farmers. They voted against every Land Bill brought in in the farmers' interests. It is all very well for those people to come along now and shout.

Comment on this

How much have you been paid to shout?

Mr. McGilligan made a remark which was not heard.

Comment on this

What is wrong with the foreign angel with the countenance of Satan?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Remarks such as that should not be made.

Comment on this

The position is that I am faced with a certain condition of affairs in this country. I admit I was against this tariff until I examined the figures.

Comment on this

Were you against it yesterday when you went over to Deputy O'Shaughnessy?

Comment on this

Sit down, you bull. Will somebody ring that bull for me?

Comment on this

Is the language used in the last five minutes at all compatible with any debate here?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not on either side. Deputies must learn to restrain themselves.

Comment on this

The import of superphosphate for the first three months, January to March, of 1929, was 21,000 tons; from January to March, 1930, 22,000 tons; from January to March, 1931, 20,000. That meant that the import was falling until it became 20,000 tons in 1931. In 1932, from January to March, it went up to 25,500 tons, an increase of 5,500 tons. We can examine the position, and we know where we were hit during the last four or five years. We know what happened when we had, I am sure, 100,000 tons of foreign barley thrown into our market and how it affected the market here. We know what happened when the Russian oats were thrown in last year. We know what happened when the foreign butter was thrown in and the effect it had on the market. The then Government had to protect it, even though they were too late. We do not intend to wait until we have 1,000 men thrown on home assistance. Deputy Dillon spoke of £1 per ton increase. Where did he get his figures? I thought a gentleman like him would have some idea of figures. Where did he get the figure of £1 per ton increase? This tariff will, roughly, amount to 12/- per ton. The reduction in imports was from 44,000 tons in 1929 to 32,000 tons last year. In other words, the Irish manufacturers were able to hold their own, and more than hold their own, in the market here.

Comment on this

Until we went off the gold standard.

Comment on this

Until the English people put a tariff on these manures, and then the Belgians dumped every bit of stuff they had here. They dumped it here at an uneconomic price, to get rid of it. On account of that, our manufacturers' stores here were filled up with manures that they could not sell.

Comment on this

25,000 tons.

Comment on this

I suggested something to the Deputy last night and at the rate he is shrugging his shoulders he wants it.

Comment on this

The missing link.

Comment on this

At the rate you are shrugging your shoulders you want a dip of something. I do not know whethere it is arsenic or something else.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies should reserve these exchanges for another arena.

Comment on this

We have to face the position that this import of artificial manure has been driven out of the British market by a tariff and has then been dumped in here just as flour was being dumped in here from Britain. We have to protect our own manufacturers. The total amount of the tariff will be about £18,000, and I say if the Irish farmers have to pay £18,000 on manures coming in here, it is a small price for protecting our manufacturers. We have to bear our end of the stick, and I for one would rather bear it in a tariff than in home assistance of 8/- a week to support a man and his five or six children. When we are accused by Deputies opposite of changing our allegiance we want to know how long ago it is since they changed their allegiance. Where was the late leader of the Farmers' Party when he clapped down on the backs of my constituents £27,000 in the last ten years and walked into the Lobby in defence of his action? I thought that Deputy O'Riordan, from Castletownroche, as the Deputy on one occasion styled himself, or Paddy O'Riordan, when he was caught with the hares, would know all about the manufactures in Cork. He should know about them.

Comment on this

That makes the thing very clear.

Comment on this

It does. The Guards made the thing clear for you. I for one am going to prevent dumping here as far as I can.

Comment on this

At so much.

Comment on this

It is dumping and you cannot call it anything else when the imports of manures had been increased in one three months by 5,500 tons. We have got to look these things in the face. The policy of Deputies opposite, as they absolutely proved while they were on these benches, has been to get our Indian meal and our flour ground by the foreigner, to give everything to the foreigner, and then expect our employers to come in and buy their produce. If that is their idea it is not mine. I would ask the late Minister for Education to consult his legal assessor, Deputy Gorey, on these matters. He is brought down there for consultation. I for one am not surprised at the foolish ideas expressed opposite considering the adviser he has brought down, to advise the late Government on the new policy of opposition.

Comment on this

I should like briefly to intervene in this discussion and I should wish the Minister to say whether it is for revenue purposes or for protection of the manufacturers of artificial manures that he is imposing this tariff. Deputy Corry has stated very candidly and truthfully that the manufacturers of artificial manures are holding their own and more than holding their own. In that I thoroughly agree. I think I am correct in stating that the firm of Goulding, Ltd., controls about seven-eights of the manure factories in this country. If we look at the Stock Exchange and examine the prices of the shares of Goulding and Co., Ltd., and compare them with the prices of any other shares in the market, what shares do we find are best on the market?

Comment on this

Guinness.

Comment on this

Gouldings. They are holding their own and I am very glad to say that in the recent past, more particularly since the introduction of this tariff, they are holding their own still better and a scrutinising public are looking forward with confidence to see the firm of Goulding and Company making more money in future as a result of this tariff.

This tariff is imposed as one of the many blisters that the farmers of this country have got to endure. Many blisters have already been applied. On the one hand the position of the farmer is that everything he has to dispose of to-day is going down in price. Anything that you can refer to to-day that the farmer has to put on the market has gone down in value practically 50 per cent. within the past six months. On the other hand, everything he has to purchase has gone up from 50 to 100 per cent. I wonder, in such circumstances, how is he going to balance his budget as a result of these tariffs? I can visualise the position of the farmer in this country becoming a very unenviable one, and if now or in the past he has found it difficult to make ends meet these tariffs are going to make it not alone difficult to make ends meet but absolutely impossible. We know what position he will find himself in if it goes beyond his reach to purchase artificial manure. We are all aware that, as a result of the use of artificial manures by farmers in this country their position has been vastly improved. If you deprive him of that by the imposition of tariffs of this kind at a time when everything he has to sell is going down in price and everything he has to buy is going up, he will be in a very bad way indeed. I think it is one of the most cruel and harsh attempts to hit him severely and make his position absolutely impossible. I appeal to the Minister to consider the matter with great care, because under ordinary circumstances it would be bad and very bad, but under the present conditions it makes his position impossible. I speak from knowledge of the position of the manufacturers, as one who deals extensively in artificial manures and as a seller and upholder of Irish manufacture. Whenever I can purchase Irish manufacture—and that is at all times—I have purchased and sold nothing else, and sold even at a disadvantage rather than purchase the stuff which is dumped on our market because, to the credit of our manufacturers I must say that they can turn out an article equal, if not superior, to any that I know. I fully realise that artificial manure from Gouldings or anywhere else, is bought on its intrinsic value and that value is arrived at on the basis of its analysis. With regard to the analysis of superphosphate I have heard no one in this debate make any reference to it. I wonder has the Minister for Industry and Commerce been advised by the Minister for Agriculture that it is on analysis that the farmers, or any one else who had a hand in the trade, calculate the price. If we are to get away from that position where do we find ourselves? If the farmer is to go in plainly to the merchant selling manure, one of the things which he is entitled to, if he is a man with any idea of business, is to demand from that merchant a receipt showing the analysis of the manure. He is entitled to that by law established, and that he must be supplied with. That is what guards the farmer against fraud and imposition. Except for certain figures as to the prices of superphosphate we have not heard one word from the other side of the House as to the intrinsic value of that article based on its analysis. I would like the Minister in his reply to this to tell us plainly—and I hope, and am confident, he will be candid on this point—is it for revenue purposes or for the protection of the manufacturer that he is putting on this tariff? There is one thing that stands out and that is that it is going to inflict a grave injury on the farmers of this country.

One thing we have witnessed, and with great pleasure, in years gone by, was that the efforts of the instructors under the Department of Agriculture were not fruitless. They bore fruit in these respects, that they succeeded in dinning into the minds of the farmers of this country the advisability of purchasing and using artificial manures and the great advantages to be derived from their use. If you look back over the past twenty years or so and compare the quantity then used with that at the present time, you will see the very great advance that has been made, and you will admit that that sound result is something to place to the credit of the instructors of the Department of Agriculture. I would appeal to the Minister to reconsider this position. Is this going to be an incentive to the farmer to use artificial manures? Is he going to work his farm to the best advantage if as a result of the tariffs he is going to be driven away from the use of artificial manures? I suggest that if the Minister considered that aspect of the question he would not have committed himself to this policy.

Comment on this

The Minister spoke as if some Deputies had mentioned a 300 per cent. increase. Of course, the use of sulphate of ammonia is practically independent of the superphosphate of lime. He says there is no evidence that the ring operating in this country would advance the prices of superphosphates. If he has not seen that evidence, it has been deliberately withheld from him. The evidence is in existence, and not only is there danger of it, but an attempt has been made every year for the past five years to do it, and on each occasion it was the arrival of Continental superphosphates on the market that broke the ring. The ring held rigid until the arrival of the foreign phosphates. If the Minister would investigate the facts he would see concrete proof of an attempt being made every year for the past five years to raise the price of artificial manures by about 15/- a ton. On each occasion when the Continental stuff came on the market, and the Minister knows the Continental stuff comes in in boat loads, and when it comes in the price is quoted on the market instantly in every case, the Irish and English manufacturers have come down by from 12/- to 15/- a ton, and we are told that those people who are to fall out of business are going to make a profit at a price 15/- a ton less than they were asking. The Minister spoke with some asperity and confusion of mind. I have not the slightest desire to use any but the language of scrupulous courtesy in the discussion, but I do think that I know what the facts are. I know very well that certain interested parties may have withheld information, and all I ask him to do is to look into it, because I know it is there and that he will discover it. I am not so much concerned with compound manures, because to my mind the key to the whole situation is super-phosphates. We will be able to handle the manures by internal competition. In view of the fact that the manure business of this country is in the hands of Gouldings, and they are in a ring with a small group of manufacturers in England, we cannot break that ring except through the Continental producers. No trader in this country can do it. You can give them the compound manures and let them have the advantage of mixing and sacking these compound manures here in Ireland, leaving the superphosphates out of account.

If you leave the superphosphates and lime out of account, as Deputy Davis has said, the analysis is an absolute safeguard for the farmer. If the analysis shows 35 or 37 per cent. that is good superphosphate and lime whether it comes from Belgium, England or anywhere else. I assure the Minister that he need not apprehend any confusion of mind so far as I am concerned with regard to this matter. I believe the Minister for Agriculture will confirm what I say—that if superphosphate is left within the scope of this tariff there is a grave danger of an enormous reduction in the use of superphosphates all over the country and this will operate to the serious deterioration of the land of the country. We are told that it will be 3d. or 6d. a cwt., but I believe it will be at least 9d. or 1/- per cwt. on the farmer. The result will be that the people will not buy superphosphate to the large extent they have been buying it. They will halve their requirements. Buying the same quantity as they have been buying may mean only an entire loss of 5/- but human nature is human nature and they will save in the amount they want to buy and so reduce their requirements.

Deputy Corry does not understand how it is that the tariff might work out at 1/- a cwt. when the tariff is less than that. I will tell the House. If you knock a competitor out of trade, if the foreign competitors are kept out, the price will go up and unless the Continental importers put their stuff on board in good time and make their arrangements in October or November for the disposal of their supplies in the spring you may take it that they are out of the market that season. Gouldings and the other manure manufacturers here can say "When we have the Continental fellows off the market we can jump the prices." They will say nothing now, but in January when the price is quoted the people having made no arrangement with the Continental manufacturers of superphosphates it is quite possible that we will be informed that the cost of raw materials has increased, that the standard of living has risen and, taking everything into consideration they find it necessary to advance the price from £3 10s. to £4 per ton. There will be a circular sent out to the farmer saying: "Do not spare one shilling for it means the improvement of your land," and explaining that at the expense of a half a ton of superphosphates the yield of his stock will be 50 per cent of an increase and that for the sake of the cost it would be a very handsome return and that he should not for the sake of 1/- in the increase of the manure lessen his requirements.

But the increase of 1/- per cwt. means in this country an increase of 33 and 1/3rd per cent. I think the Government should pause before they venture to lay a burden of 33 and 1/3rd per cent. on superphosphate of lime. The result of that will be that the farmers will put out less superphosphates next spring and the yield of the land may decrease by 20 per cent. because of that. In saying that I do not at all exaggerate.

Comment on this

A number of Deputies have asked, when comparing these prices, whether the analysis has been taken into account. Of course, prices have been given on the assumption that the analysis is the same in each case. The import of manures was down in 1931 and attention has been drawn to that by the Deputies on the opposite side. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney does not know whether it was due to the farmers using less manures or whether it was due to the fact that the Irish manufacturers were turning out more manures last year. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney and those with him who lead the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, I am sure, know very well that there were less manures last year because of the fact that there was less tillage in the country. And they ought to know that there is more artificial manure used on tillage than on grass.

Comment on this

Compound manures are used in tillage, and superphosphate is more largely used for grass lands.

Comment on this

I would like any Deputy here to go out and talk to the farmers in the country and say whether there is not more superphosphate used on tillage than on grass lands.

Comment on this

Well, I can say it.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy a farmer?

Comment on this

Take the ordinary farmer with 50 acres of tillage and 50 acres of grass. Would any Deputy here say is not more superphosphate used on the 50 acres of grass than on the 50 acres of tillage?

Comment on this

It is an impossible hypothesis.

Comment on this

Of course it is, to the Deputy.

Comment on this

The Minister ought to be practical.

Comment on this

Certainly it is an impossible hypothesis with Deputies like Deputy Bennett and some others from the grass counties.

Comment on this

It is an impossible hypothesis in Leitrim and North Kerry, where they want to grow wheat.

Comment on this

And they will be allowed to grow wheat in Leitrim and Kerry.

Comment on this

On the bogs.

Comment on this

There are hares on the bogs, and Deputy Gorey can go down there under his name, the name which he used on a former occasion, Mr. O'Riordan from Castletownroche.

Comment on this

Castletownroche is in Cork, and there are no bogs in Castletownroche.

Comment on this

I am referring to the injustice Deputy Gorey did to a Cork man. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney also made another statement that sulphate of ammonia was not the most largely used of nitrogenous manures. I am sure if I were to say anything as wrong as that I would get protests from the other side. There, at least, taking the list of imports into this country, the statement is clearly incorrect. As a matter of fact, sulphate of ammonia was imported last year to the extent of 20,000 tons, and the other imports would not come to more than 5,000 or 6,000 tons, so that the point that the Deputy was making, that sulphate of ammonia would not come to much, that we were not using much of it, and that it would not be much of a burden on the farmers, is valueless. We were accused by others of giving to the farmers more than the other consumers could afford to give them under the Butter Bill. We were told last year by the then Government that we could not afford to give the farmers another £250,000 in relief of the rates.

Comment on this

We, at any rate, are asking the consumers to contribute anything from £450,000 to £800,000 a year on these subsidies on butter according to the calculations made here and we are also voting £250,000 for the relief of the rates. Now because we come along and ask the farmers to contribute something——

Comment on this

And take it all back again.

Comment on this

—to help the people who are working in this industry, we are accused of putting an intolerable burden on the farmers. The consumption of these manures is something less than 200,000 tons a year. Deputy Gorey says that the extra cost on the farmer is going to come to between £250,000 and £300,000 a year. Deputy Bennett says it is going to come to possibly only 1d. per cwt.

Comment on this

I did not say any such thing.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon says it will be £1 per ton. I would like if Deputy Dillon would tell us how he can explain the basis on which he makes out that calculation that it might come to £1 a ton when the tariff is only 20 per cent. I know he gave his reasons for that statement that if we were only going to put on a tariff of 20 per cent. and that if the Irish manufacturers were going to put up their prices only to the extent of 20 per cent. that it would not amount to more than 6s. per ton at the outside over the continental prices, but Deputy Dillon has explained that having put the continental people out of the market, then the Irish manufacturers having got the market to themselves might put up the price to £1 per ton, and the continental people could not come along then because it would be too late to make the necessary arrangements for shipping. I find it very difficult to agree with Deputy Dillon that if, say, next January it was found that the Irish manufacturers were charging too much for manures and they were going to put up their prices because the continental manures would be out of the market, that the continental manufacturers would then find it impossible to send in manures.

Comment on this

Did the Minister say 6s. a ton?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

What is that based on?

Comment on this

On the tariff.

Comment on this

Where does the 30/- come in?

Comment on this

Thirty shillings is what the people must pay to the continental manufacturers for these manures, selling it at the figures they do.

Comment on this

What is the analysis?

Comment on this

There will be ad valorem tax on the c.i.f. price.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

The Minister said that the price of foreign phosphates is 50/- a ton landed here. I know that from my experience of the trade.

Comment on this

Give him a chance. The Government is weak on figures.

Comment on this

We do not reverse the figures though.

Comment on this

The price in my district was £4 10s. a ton for Goulding's and £3 7s. 6d. for Belgian stuff.

Comment on this

The carrier profiteered in your case.

Comment on this

These were the prices in Templemore.

Comment on this

I think this tariff should be withdrawn. There is no case for it.

Comment on this

It is a public scandal, and the two Minister who spoke demonstrated that.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce stated here yesterday that there was what amounted to dumping during the first three months of this year. Whether we call it dumping or not, there was, at any rate, an increase in the imports of artificial manure for the first three months of this year as compared with last year. As a result our manure factories have closed down earlier this year than in previous years. They found it necessary to put the majority of their men out of employment. These factories employ 1,000 men. If that state of affairs continues this year, next year, and the year after what is going to become of our manure factories? They are going to go the way that the flour factories went under the last Government. I would like to ask Deputies opposite the question that Deputy Moore asked them last night: have they any guarantee, if our factories are closed, that a British ring or a continental ring will sell manures cheaper than the Irish factories could sell them? I do not expect Deputies opposite to adopt anything but a shortsighted policy. They never took a long view on anything. They just look at the present—perhaps some of them look nine months ahead, but no further. They have not looked into the question of what is going to become of the workers when the manure factories here are closed. Have they any guarantee, seeing that they asked us for guarantees, from the British or continental rings that in a few years' time, when the factories here are closed, they will sell manures cheaply? I would like to put it to Deputy Dillon that foreigners may come along—whoever they may be—and send out a circular, stating that raw materials have gone up, the cost of labour has gone up, and advising farmers not to mind paying an extra shilling for manures, or suggesting that an extra 2/6 per cwt. on manures would not amount to a great deal. It is quite possible that in two or three years' time we would find ourselves in the position we are in at present with regard to other industries. The Party opposite should remember the mistake that they made when they were in power, when they let the flour mills and other industries go. They should try to have a little sense at this stage, and should see that we are doing the right thing, in order to save the industries we have. I would like to have from Deputies opposite an answer to the question that was put by Deputy Moore last night.

Comment on this

It does not arise.

Comment on this

What guarantee is there that the British or the Belgians will not put up the prices when our factories are gone? If these factories are driven out of production, as they have been threatened, seeing that they had to pay off their men earlier this year than in previous years, and that the imports of manure have been higher for the first three months of this year than in previous years——

Comment on this