We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Financial Resolutions—Report Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 124–246 of 246. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The imports of superphosphates.

Comment on this

Has the Minister the figures for previous years to which reference was made?

Comment on this

We have not got them yet for the previous three years.

Comment on this

Yes, they were given already by Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

Has the Minister any figures from the Irish ring as to whether the output has been reduced?

Comment on this

It is a fact that part of the stock that was manufactured has not been disposed of. The factories start manufacturing in September and sell in January, February and March.

Comment on this

Has there been sufficient extra tillage to utilise stocks as a result of the tariff on oats?

Comment on this

There is time enough yet to plough lea land.

Comment on this

Was there an application for this tariff?

Comment on this

If these factories are put out of business and if the thousand men that are disemployed are thrown upon home assistance or the unemployment market, I would like some Deputy to calculate what the cost will be on the country and on the farmers. We are assisting enough at present by home assistance, and out of employment funds, people who have been thrown out of factories, and we do not want to add another thousand to the number to be maintained by the ratepayers or by the taxpayers. If there is undue profiteering we will not hesitate to say to the Irish manufacturers that we are going to withdraw the tariff and, if that is not sufficient, we will not hesitate to throw open the ports again for any manures that may be required. That has been made clear.

Comment on this

What about the working men then?

Comment on this

We cannot help the working men then. At least we will make an attempt to save the working men. Deputy Cosgrave did not make much effort to save the flour mills.

Comment on this

Much more than this Government will do if they were here for a hundred years.

Comment on this

What happened to the flour mills?

Comment on this

I do not think the farmers will be deceived by the talk that is going on. Deputy Bennett and Deputy Gorey and others have become very solicitous for the farmers. I do not believe the farmers are going to be deceived by this talk of a burden of £250,000 or £300,000 a year. I think the farmers are quite prepared to carry this burden if they think it is going to be for the good of the country.

Comment on this

That is quite cheerful news.

Comment on this

Yes, quite cheerful. I do not believe the burden is going to be as heavy as some Deputies have tried to make out. I am quite certain it is not going to amount to £250,000 or £300,000 a year, as Deputy Gorey suggested. I am quite certain an increase in the price of manure as a result of the tariff will not be as heavy as Deputies opposite have prophesied. As I have indicated, and as the Minister for Industry and Commerce has made clear, if we find that manufacturers here are profiteering or charging undue prices as a result of the tariff, we are prepared to throw the ports open for the importation of continental manures.

Deputy Cosgrave asked us if we got an application for the tariff. We have made up our minds that this tariff is going to benefit the country and we have heard nothing which would induce us to change our minds. As Deputies opposite know, there were modifications in some tariffs when we heard sensible suggestions made that the tariffs should be varied in particular ways; but there was no sensible suggestion in regard to this tariff and it will remain. We are not a bit afraid to go on with the matter.

Comment on this

There were sensible suggestions made in regard to this tariff, possibly before the Minister entered to take part in the discussion. There were suggestions that the Government should wipe out this tariff.

Comment on this

I was here quite a long time and there was no sensible suggestion made.

Comment on this

The Minister was absent during a great portion of this debate. Possibly he was not in the House when the Minister for Industry and Commerce spent a considerable amount of time endeavouring to prove that this would mean no burden on the farmers. Now we have the Minister for Agriculture indicating that he is satisfied that the farming community will bear that burden quite willingly. I am interested in this tariff because I think it is an excellent example of the way in which tariffs as a whole have been proposed. I am not going to discuss the rival merits of different manures. There seems to be a conflict of opinion between the Minister for Industry and Commerce and most of those who have personal contact with farming. So far as I am concerned, I prefer to take their view against the Minister. The definite case against this tariff was ignored by the Ministers. It was made, not merely by Deputy Dillon, but by most of the Deputies who spoke on this side. There are two definite grounds of objection to the tariff. The first is the increase in price of this particular commodity and the second is the effect the tariff will have on competitive prices in the State.

We have had the experience of people actually engaged in this business. I suggest that mere categorical statements by the Ministers that certain things will not occur cannot possibly controvert the experience of men like Deputy Dillon or Deputy Davis, who have put forward arguments as to the effect of the importation of this commodity on the home prices. They have given us the results of their practical experience, and I prefer their experience to mere, unsupported statements by Ministers. The experience of those Deputies is that the importation of this commodity from the Continent has led to the reduction of prices here and apparently without any danger of putting the home producer out of the market.

What has been the principal case put forward by the Ministers for this tariff? They say that if we have not this tariff there is the possibility and, according to the Minister for Agriculture, the probability, that in a couple of years this industry that now employs 1,000 people will disappear altogether. Is there the slightest evidence brought forward in support of that statement? The only evidence Ministers brought forward was the figure relating to importation this year and in past years. What evidence is there of the disappearance of the home producer? Not a scrap of evidence has been produced by Ministers except the statement that an additional 5,000 tons were imported during the first three months of this year.

Those who are in immediate touch with the farming community and with the retail trade in this commodity argue that this burden will be put on the farmer. This is a commodity in respect of which there is a production altogether of 200,000 tons. There was in this House a very strong case put up against the tariff by Deputies like Deputy Dillon and Deputy Davis, who deal in this commodity as retailers, and by Deputies who have practical knowledge of farming. Those arguments have never been considered by the Minister. We have plenty of evidence that most of the tariffs in this Schedule are unwise. The Minister has adopted the same practice in regard to this tariff as he has adopted in regard to other tariffs. He has met the manufacturers, asked them what it will cost to produce this article in the country, and then said: "Very good, there is your tariff." He has not considered what will be the effect on the farming community. The conflicting nature of the statements made in the course of the debate are sufficient to indicate that there should be a proper examination of the effects of the tariff before it is imposed. Those best entitled to speak for the farming community, men who have an intimate knowledge, more intimate than I or the Minister for Industry and Commerce could claim, have pointed out the heavy burden this tariff will mean on farmers. I suggest before a burden of that kind is imposed, not merely the manufacturer, but also the farmers, should be heard, together with others who have first-hand knowledge of the subject.

There are many other tariffs of which the same thing can be said, but this is an outstanding case in which it is apparent that the most important evidence that could be brought forward has not been brought forward. There was no machinery by which it could be brought to the notice of the Minister before the tariff was imposed. It is quite obvious from the speech of the Minister for Agriculture that he is determined to give certain grants to the farmers. He mentioned some of them—the agricultural grant of £250,000 and the butter subsidy, whatever it amounts to. What it will amount to only a prophet would care to determine. Whether it will amount to £100,000, £400,000 or £750,000 will depend upon the amount of butter exported.

That cannot be told unfortunately at the moment. But against these the Minister and other Ministers have put burden after burden on the backs of the farmers. This is only one of them. They have inflicted much more serious injury on the farming community than even the proposed gifts they speak of can compensate the farmers for. It is no answer to the case put up here by those who have a first-hand knowledge of the trade and who are in touch with farming to say that merely because 5,000 tons extra are introduced, merely because, roughly speaking, we are back again to the figure of 1930, that there is a danger. Where is the danger? 5,000 tons in a trade in which the total amount is 200,000 tons. We are asked to answer Deputy Moore's statement. The answer is quite simple—the case does not exist here. There is no danger so far as anyone can see. There is not the slightest ground for the suggestions made by Ministers that there is any danger whatsoever of the disappearance from the market of the home competitor. There is no evidence offered of that that is worthy of a moment's consideration. We were given various reasons why this should be. The gold standard was introduced. The one thing that we should be grateful to the Minister for is that he did not bring in the gold ounces. Then we would have the whole matter perfectly clear.

I was under the impression that one of the charges made against the late Government was that they let this country go off the gold standard, but if this country went off the gold standard as well as England, how that can be brought in as a differentiating factor which would turn aside the importation of this commodity from England to this country, I do not know. What is interesting in this is that it is quite obvious that as in the case of many another tariff no examination was given as to the effect of this tariff on the farming community. The Minister for Agriculture has suggested that they would not listen to any suggestions, but at the same time he has instanced various modifications that have been made in other tariffs, very hastily imposed, such as this was, without any examination. I wonder what was the reason for that? Was it that strong pressure was brought to bear on them? Did the pressure of strongly organised bodies appeal to them? Not merely was there criticism of these tariffs in the House but there was very strong agitation from important bodies in the country. Undoubtedly it is only when the people become alive to the very severe burden inflicted on them by this whole policy of tariffs—this is an outstanding and interesting example of that policy— that the Ministry will begin to mend its hand. No amount of argument will get over the optimism of the Minister for Industry and Commerce that in imposing tariffs he is conferring a benefit on the consumer and is putting no burden on the community. Optimism of that kind, as we have it on the Government Benches, is completely invincible against argument. I put it to the House that there has been an unanswerable case made against this tariff.

Comment on this

I do not know if it is intended to spend the day discussing this duty, or whether we are to go on to discuss the other matters in the Schedule.

Comment on this

There is no question of confining discussion on anything.

Comment on this

I understand that it is intended to complete the discussion of this list by Tuesday evening.

Comment on this

It will have to be done. I know that the Party opposite are trying to wreek the machinery of Government by senseless opposition, but they are not going to get away with it.

Comment on this

A charge has been made against the Opposition. The Opposition yesterday was in the position of being able to obstruct the machinery of Government owing to the failure of the Government to bring in their Resolutions on Tuesday last. They could have done that. Instead of obstructing yesterday, the Opposition met the Government very fairly and gave it the Resolutions last night. There was not the slightest attempt made to obstruct.

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for Defence (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

No, because you were told that you would not be allowed to do it.

Comment on this

We were told nothing of the kind.

Comment on this

There are measures which will be of considerable benefit to the people held up here because of the obstructionist tactics adopted by the Opposition.

Comment on this

Such as?

Comment on this

A number of them have been enumerated.

Comment on this

Such as?

Comment on this

The number of modifications in this duty, for example.

Comment on this

What are the measures that are being talked of?

Comment on this

They have been enumerated.

Comment on this

Have they been introduced?

Comment on this

In speaking on this matter I just wish to say that there is one thing that has been demonstrated during the present session, and that is the hopeless failure of Cumann na nGaedheal as an Opposition. They have been sulking at times, hysterical at other times, and always nagging like a lot of old women. They were a failure as a Government, but their complete collapse as an Opposition has surprised even me.

Comment on this

Optimism overcome.

Comment on this

What has the Opposition overcome? The Deputies sitting opposite were past masters of the art of creating bogies out of their own imaginations and then knocking them down. They have been engaging in that gentle pastime all day to-day, talking about exorbitant increases in the price of certain artificial manures which they know will not and cannot take place. What is the position? There is a 20 per cent. duty imposed on superphosphates and compound manures imported from outside the British Commonwealth. Taking the price as quoted here to-day by Deputy Hassett, Deputy Gorey or Deputy Dillon for any of the Continental products and adding 20 per cent. to it you do not get up to the price at which the Irish products were bought last year.

Comment on this

What is the use of the tariff at all then?

Comment on this

The duty will mean from £1 to £2 a ton extra, and will agriculture in its present depressed condition be able to bear that?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputies should not interrupt. Every Deputy has a right to speak, and can make his own case when the time comes. I do not object to questions, seeking information, being put.

Comment on this

On a point of information. This question is of vital importance to the agricultural community, and when we get up to seek information we are accused by the Minister for Industry and Commerce of obstructing. We are not obstructing. When farmer Deputies on the Minister's side do not get up to make a case against this on behalf of the people affected, we are ready to make one that cannot be answered.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is the type of interruption that I think Deputies should desist from making.

Comment on this

The fact is that if any of the prices quoted here in respect of Continental manures are increased by 20 per cent., then, on the admission of the Deputies opposite, that increased price is less than the price that was given for the Irish products last year. Consequently, even if people are determined to import these manures they can do so and pay duty on them, and have them at a less price than that at which the Irish products have been available. The Irish products are being bought because they are better, as well as for other reasons. Four out of five farmers preferred last year to pay the higher price for the Irish products. These Continental products are produced at in or about 30/- per ton. We cannot produce a similar product here at that price unless we are prepared to adopt a very low standard of living, lower rates of wages, and the very poor working conditions which operate on the Continent in this industry.

The gold standard comes in at this point. Because of the depreciation of the £ we have got to add to that 30/- per ton—that is the cost of production on the Continent—in or about 10/- when trying to get the figure at which that product could be sold here. If the fall in the value of the £ had not taken place, then these Continental manures should be 10/- cheaper, and, if you add another 10/- for transport charges, it means that, at 50/- per ton, these Continental manures can be delivered at the quay-side here. So that when you add this 20 per cent. duty you still have them at a price less than that at which the Irish farmer in open competition was willing to pay for the Irish product last year. We have no duty upon the British product. In so far as there is competition between England and this country in respect of these items, that competition continues unrestricted. The existing factories here are quite competent to supply the full requirements of the country in these articles. A large range of artificial manures used by farmers are not subject to duty at all. We have only selected the phosphates and compound manures in respect of which there can be no question of the ability of the Irish factories to supply all our requirements, and of a much better quality, too, than we can purchase abroad. That justifies the duty.

Comment on this

I wish to contradict the statement I made here yesterday in regard to the importation of superphosphates by the manufacturers in this country. They import the rock and grind it out and it is used as a basis of manufacture of superphosphates. I was very much amazed to hear the Minister for Agriculture say that this was all they were asking the farmer to pay. I think he must be oblivious of the very much larger number of articles in common use by farmers on which a very heavy tariff has been placed already. He must have overlooked the innumerable taxes that have been put on, increasing the cost of living and which must result in very considerable advance of the cost to the farmer and that at a time when he is least able to bear them. When markets are doubtful and are practically nonexistent, the realisation of the products of the land will be a very serious difficulty in enabling him to bear even the costs that were in existence prior to the tariff. Everyone, particularly the Minister for Agriculture and his Department, will tell you that Irish land is not producing anything like what it should produce under normal and favourable conditions. A large area is not a very big factor in production. It is largely the use that is made of the land that matters. In many cases educated and industrious farmers are able to produce, from smaller areas of land, a volume of production in excess of what would be produced in very much larger areas of land of the same quality simply because of the manner in which the land is used.

Of all the taxes that have been placed on the farmer there is no more serious one owing to the value of manure and the part that it plays, and the assistance it renders to production than this tax. Those of us who have to do co-operative buying and selling know the difficulties they have to encounter. We are well aware that the manure manufacturers in this country have time after time formed rings which have been only broken by the importation of the Continental superphosphate. That is my experience. We have succeeded in reducing almost immediately the prices of manure; they have had to come down £1 a ton under favourable conditions in regard to imports.

I am on seaboard area. Farmers there use up a considerable amount of seaweed for manure. It contains a certain amount of nitrogen and an amount of potash but it is practically useless without the addition of phosphate. It is a tillage area. The farmers there do not go in largely for house-feeding or the keeping of animals which would supply a large amount of farmyard manure. They would be helpless without the aid of artificial manure. I can appreciate the agony of mind of the Minister for Agriculture in trying to make a case for this tariff and the officials of his Department must have informed him of the blow that it will in fact be to Irish farmers if a tax of this description is put upon such a valuable commodity as this commodity is. There is against the various requirements of farmers that have been tariffed this £250,000 which is being made so much of but I say there would be no better way of assisting agriculture than to take that £250,000 and to do something in the line of lessening the price at which manures stand to-day and something further to cheapen them. It is only by cheapening the agricultural requirements of the farmer and preventing further imposts upon him that you can assist production in this country. Production is vital to this country. We are not carrying as large a volume of production as we should. Because of the want of organised markets or organised purchasing, the country is not producing anything like what it could do.

We had undoubtedly a very efficient Department of Agriculture. It has done enormous things for this country and I take off my hat to the Minister and to the officials of the Department of Agriculture for what they have done, but you are nullifying all your efforts in the three items I have mentioned. These taxes are a hindrance to the farmer who has no capital and no market. A great deal of play has been made about the likelihood of the firm of Messrs. Goulding closing down. But they did not close down after the War, when undoubtedly there was a very serious impediment, when continental superphosphates were imported at a very low figure compared with what they were producing. We know the difficulty the ring has placed in the way. We know the advantage offered to the trade. Those who are engaged in buying and selling know what these items are. Deputy Dillon probably is aware of them. These are naturally nullified by importation of the same commodity based on the same analysis, and what particular reason can there be to restrain the farmer from getting what is an enormous advantage to him in carrying on his farm. It is common knowledge to anyone engaged in agriculture that anything that tends to increase the price of the farmer's requirements will make him refrain from getting them. Anyone in contact with farmers knows their attitude on this question. Farmers will not stand for any increase in the price of their requirements, and this tariff is imposed for the purpose of increasing price. There is no question about it that at this time they are not able to bear it, and that while the Land Commission are asking for the prompt payment of their annuities the farmers are not able to meet them. They cannot sell their cattle at the fairs, yet the Government are fixing tariffs upon them that are appalling the farmers in the country, and there is a very loud voiced opposition against them. I appeal to the Minister for Industry and Commerce and to the Minister for Agriculture to use their influence to resist those imposts upon that class which, as I said, cannot possibly bear them.

Comment on this

I want at the beginning to enter a very definite protest against the remarks with which the Minister for Industry and Commerce opened his last contribution to this debate. He spoke of obstruction. Obstruction facing what facts? These, that the Minister for Finance deliberately withheld these Financial Resolutions from discussion in the House until yesterday. They could have been down earlier. Then also he made the plea of necessity, and got his resolution through the House without adequate discussion. There was no obstruction there. Our opposition to this has been dubbed silly, hypocritical and almost nagging. We are told that the opposition to this has been, at times, sulky; at times, hysterical; and, at times, nagging, and that the failure of Cumann na nGaedheal in Opposition has surprised even the Minister for Industry and Commerce. It certainly surprised him into silence, in the main, silence with regard to arguments that were put up, and it certainly surprised the whole Executive Council to the point that, when a particular item was under discussion, they had to walk out of the House, when their deliberate misrepresentations with regard to a special important conference were likely to be shown up. The Minister for Industry and Commerce in talking of this tariff the first day it was introduced, in answer to a remark by Deputy Gorey, indicated his view that North Africa was inside the British Commonwealth. That was where he stood with regard to certain of the small items in connection with this.

This is one of the simplest of all the tariffs to consider, and you have to start off from a very elementary point with regard to it, an elementary point, which, possibly, the notorious political economist that Deputy Corry is may not have recognised, that prices in anything are like springs—they have a tendency to go upwards and they will go upwards, if not kept down by some dead weight. There are about two good weights that can keep prices down in anything. One is, that the manufacturer must look for biggish sales, dependent on the particular thing he is selling, and he must, therefore, sell within the bounds of what those at whom he is aiming can buy, and, secondly, and by far the biggest weight that would keep prices down, there is competition. Deputy Dillon has made two points here this morning that have not yet been answered, and they are two points that could have been understood, if, before imposing or seeking to impose, this tariff, the Ministry had sought from any trader—not a manufacturer—his experience, and they would have got from nearly any trader, if he gave a statement honestly to them, what Deputy Dillon has said here several times.

In answer to one of the points Deputy Dillon made, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, before the Minister for Agriculture made his appearance, made this point, and made it with great vehemence, that you have got to get into your head one fact—that four out of every five farmers in this country at the moment, who use artificial manures, use Irish manures. That was supposed to be the making of the case, or the foundation for the making of the case, that the Irish farmer was not going to pay more by reason of this. The Minister for Agriculture has apparently thrown that case overboard. He has not got that fact into his head that was so vehemently stressed by his colleague. Instead, he says "of course, we are going to ask the farmer to pay something, but look at what we are giving him." What is going to be the cost to the farmer? Remember that the amount of revenue looked for from this grouped series of articles is not much. It is intended to knock out the continental manures.

Comment on this

Absolutely.

Comment on this

The statement as to the small amount of revenue coming from the group of tariffed articles shows clearly the view of the Ministry on that. This is not intended for revenue to any degree whatever. It is intended to keep out continental manures. Has anybody yet answered Deputy Dillon's point, spoken from his experience of the trade, and the point that can be spoken to by anybody who has any experience of that trade, that the only thing that keeps down the ring price in this country is either the coming in, or the threatened coming in, of continental manures? That point has not been answered. In answer, or in an attempted answer to it, we get the usual compassionate pleas about the thousand people who are employed, and, again, the answer comes to this, what is the probability of these thousand men losing their employment if the tariff be not put on? On that, we get merely a quotation of figures for certain months in this year, but the official documents show that, even if we take the statement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce as to the percentage increase in the first three months of this year, so far as imports are concerned, you are getting back to the 1930 position.

There has been no case made that there is any probability of any of the present employees of this branch of business losing their employment. Supposing the case is going to be made that there is some danger. The Minister for Agriculture attempted to meet another point made by Deputy Dillon with a peculiar phrase. Deputy Dillon pointed out the circumstances of this trade, and pointed out that certain boatloads of manures arrive at certain times, and it is when they arrive that prices begin to shift and it is when these do not arrive and when there is no danger of their arrival, that prices show a tendency to shift the other way. The Minister for Agriculture countered that with the statement "if next January we see that our manufacturers are charging too much, it will not then be impossible to get continental manures in." The time limit is a very narrow one in this, and it is doubtful if that could come about, but supposing it does? Supposing it is within the Minister's power, what about the thousand employees then? Supposing next January, we get to the point where there is a price charged for Irish manures which the Ministry think too much and the Ministry say that they are going to let in continental manures, cannot the same compassionate plea be made then—what about the thousand men? Are you going to throw them out for a mere difference of whatever it will be—even such a thing as 10/- a ton? Are you going to throw out these thousand people for that? Where is the upward limit that has to be reached before compassion ceases and ordinary business instinct gets free play?

We are told further: "if our manufacturers go out, what guarantee have we that the price of foreign manure will not increase"? Supposing home prices go up a bit. Is not that same argument cogent still? You must let them charge the new price—the same argument, if it has cogency now, has got the same cogency, at any rate, hereafter. "Let the price go up." If you do not give a tariff, and even if you do not increase the tariff, the argument can still be used. You dare not let down the home manufacturer because if you do what is going to happen afterwards?—that argument can go on to eternity, with the price rising every year, unless we have, and know, where is the upward limit when that type of argument is not going to prevail, and we are going to have ordinary business methods having their play.

Comment on this

Why does the Deputy think that British competition is of no effect?

Comment on this

There is a ring.

Comment on this

It is part of a ring, too. They are all the one.

Comment on this

This has been spoken of to the point of nausea, but it has not been answered. Does the Deputy know that the only firm really in this business in this country is in the British ring? It has not been denied by the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

A representative of the firm denied it to me, personally.

Comment on this

That is only because he thought the Deputy was simpler than the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The Minister does not deny it, and nobody who knows the business can deny it. Let us reverse that argument about the home manufacturer. What are we doing? We are putting out the continental manufacturer, and let me ask those who are so insistent, what is the future of the country going to be if the foreign manufacturer goes out, and we are left at the mercy of one firm? What is the future going to be if the continental manufacturer, who does bring down prices in this country, on the testimony of people in the business, goes out of operation, and we are left at the mercy of one single firm, and that firm in the ring with the English manufacturers? Is not the danger as great, on the one hand, as it is on the other? It certainly seems as great to everybody but the people who believe that by passing a piece of legislation in this House they can control prices. I only hope we get that price-fixing measure brought forward as quickly as possible and put into operation, so that we may see the futility of it in practice.

The Minister for Agriculture makes the point that supposing you do take the continental stuff, taking into consideration not merely the cost of manufacture abroad, but taking the cost as delivered in this country, and adding 20 per cent., the continental stuff is still able to undersell the Irish manufacture, but the Irish farmer is paying a bit more for the Irish stuff because he considers it the better article. Surely, there is a relation between the price of the continental stuff and the price at which the Irish manufacture is going to be sold. You have the testimony of Deputy Dillon, who is in the business, to which I can add my own testimony, based on the time I was connected with business of the same type, that the one thing which does regulate the price at which home manufactured stuff is sold is the incoming of certain continental manures. If this tax blocks those coming in, as it is intended to do—it is not intended to gather any revenue—the loss to the farmer is not going to be 20 per cent. on the price at which continental manure is at present being sold, but it is going to be the highest price the Irish manufacturer can get out of the farmer, the manufacturer being freed of all competition.

Comment on this

He will not be free from competition.

Comment on this

He will be free from the only competition that has counted so far, the only competition that has had the effect of keeping down the price. One point has not yet been met —the very definite statement made by Deputy Dillon, backed by nearly everybody who is in touch with the trade, that there is one lever to force down and to keep down the price of the Irish manufacturer, and that is the impact upon him of the imports of Continental manures.

Comment on this

Dumping.

Comment on this

Now, it is dumping. Let us take that much-abused word. Continental manure is brought in here. Nevertheless, four out of every five farmers use Irish manure. Even if ten per cent. goes on, according to the two Ministers who have made calculations on this matter, the Continental manures will still be sold at a price under the price at the moment for Irish manures. Where does the dumping come in? What does the use of that phrase mean? Dumping to what extent? Dumping increased to what extent? Where is dumping shown? Have prices gone down to the point that the shares of the firm concerned are at a very low figure upon the market? Is the firm likely to be put out of business? Are its employees likely to lose their employment? No case of that kind has been made. A statement has been made about importations in the first three months of this year being 25 per cent. above the figure for that period last year. Even taking that figure, you do not find your imports appreciably higher than they were the year before. That is what is called "dumping."

Let me get back to the main point made. It has to be reiterated again and again because until it is answered a case for this tariff has not been made —that you have a certain amount of Continental manure coming in here and that it keeps the prices low, not merely to the farmer who buys Continental manure solely, if there be such a farmer, but to every four out of five farmers who buy not Continental manure but Irish manure. We are going to take away the lever which operates to keep down the price of the Irish manure and we are doing it on a statement with regard to imports for three months, although the figure of 25 per cent. addition does not mean that the imports are appreciably over those for 1930. That is the case for the tariff.

Comment on this

Could not the same argument be used against every tariff imposed whether by this Government or by the last Government?

Comment on this

It could not.

Comment on this

Apply it to the case of boots.

Comment on this

What was done with regard to boots? The tariff on boots was stated to be a definite experiment. It was stated that it would cost the community about £350,000 and the tea duty was remitted in order to equalise that. It was an attempt to get a home manufacture going at a certain cost to the community, the cost being equalised by remission at another point. This is the case of a tariff that should have been inquired into before it was imposed. The inquiry should have gone beyond the manufacturer. I should like to know from the Minister whether any trader was consulted about this tariff?

Comment on this

We consulted the manufacturer, the workers in the industry and the officials of the Department of Agriculture.

Comment on this

But no trader?

Comment on this

Certainly not. What have they got to do with it?

Comment on this

Did the Minister have any appreciation of what any trader could tell him as to the impact of Continental manures on home prices?

Comment on this

I know that the price of the same manure between one trader and another might vary by 7/6 per ton.

Comment on this

The Minister knows that without having any touch with traders, without having officially approached them to find out, if there was such a difference, why there was such a difference and what were the local conditions that operated. I do not think he would have found any difference like that.

Comment on this

Yes, even between two traders in the same town.

Comment on this

Surely that point could have been inquired into. It would appear to be unnecessary repetition but I do think it is important to stress that the point made at the beginning of this debate by Deputy Dillon has not yet been answered—that the incoming of the foreign manure operates in a particular way; remove that and it is not a question of fixing the farmer with a mere ten per cent. addition on something coming in but it is a question of what the ring can force prices up to in this country while still keeping sales. What is going to be the result? That is what has got to be answered and this calculation of ten per cent. on the very small amount of stuff coming in is not an answer.

Comment on this

I want to ask the Minister for Industry and Commerce a few questions which I hope he will regard as reasonable. He says that this tariff is being brought in to help a declining Irish industry. Is there as much evidence to show that this industry is declining as there is to show that the Irish farming industry is declining? Is there as much danger of this industry collapsing as there is of the Irish farming industry collapsing? Is it as difficult to make a living in this industry as it is in the Irish farming industry? Is there any country in the world with an industry so important to it as farming is to this country which would tax its raw material at this particular time?

I consider that the whole tariff policy of the Government is terribly dangerous to the Irish farmer and I consider that the so-called national policy of the Government is terribly dangerous to the Irish farmer. I cannot expect the Government to agree with me on that but surely it ought to be common ground to all of us that a tax on the raw material of what is admittedly our principal industry at a time like this is absolute madness.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan and Deputy Dillon stated that the one safeguard a farmer had was that he was getting cheap manures by allowing in Continental manures. I have been listening to Deputy McGilligan for four or five years in this House making the same case against every industry that asked for protection. He made the same case as against the coach-building industry. He made the same case against the tariff on boots, against the tariff on clothes, and against every other tariff, even tariffs that the last Government imposed.

Comment on this

I made exactly the opposite case in defence of the tariffs.

Comment on this

He made the very same case against these tariffs, that prices cannot go up so long as imports are allowed. There is no reason why tariffs should be put on if it is necessary to allow in imports to keep down prices. As the Minister for Industry and Commerce said, this tariff was put on in order to ensure that a thousand persons would get employment in future. That is the main reason for it.

Comment on this

At whose expense?

Comment on this

At the farmers' expense, according to Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this

And the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

At the farmers' expense, if you like. I shall defend that case. A Bill was brought in last week by the Minister for Agriculture to give certain opportunities to a certain article of agricultural production. The Minister for Agriculture said, and the Government were prepared to stand over it, that the Government were prepared to put an extra price on every section of the community in order that the farmer might be kept in production. They were prepared to put on anything from half a million to three-quarters of a million pounds in the year and tax, to that extent, the farmers themselves and every other section of the community in order that the farmers might be kept in the production of butter. If the Minister came forward to-morrow with proposals to keep the farmers in the proposal duction of barley or oats, Deputy Gorey and the other farmer Deputies on the opposite benches would certainly support that, no matter at whose expense it was. I am not admitting that the farmers will have to pay more, but if there is any suggestion that they may have to pay more for artificial manure we have all the farmers on the opposite benches getting up and making the case that the farmers should not be taxed, or that they should not do anything in order to keep one thousand people in employment. I think the time has come when the farmers, big and small, should realise that they cannot continue to exist without the other sections of the community. They cannot remain independent and exist without leaning in many directions on the other sections of the community. Deputy Gorey ought to be long enough here to realise that. I know what Deputy Gorey's outlook was seven or ten years ago with regard to free trade. He was an absolute free trader. He, for instance, opposed the tariff on boots. I heard him say here that the farmers would have to pay more for their hob-nailed boots if the tariff were put on. It was quite sound to a certain extent, if the farmers could continue to exist on a foreign market. But the time has come now when that foreign market will not give them their cost of production. They are no longer getting their cost of production in a foreign market, and they have to fall back on their own country to keep them in production. Deputy Gorey must realise that. The people who made the statements we listened to to-day are doing an absolute injustice to the farmers. We had Deputy Roddy saying that because dairy cattle were reduced in numbers in this country it was necessary for the farmers to use more artificial manures.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

These are your words.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

That because dairy cattle were reduced in number it was necessary for the farmers to use more artificial manure, and because tillage had gone down it was necessary for farmers to use more artificial manure. Why has it become necessary to use more artificial manure if the cattle population has gone down, if tillage has gone down, and the general output of agriculture has gone down very much in the last three or four years?

Comment on this

I said dairy cattle.

Comment on this

That is what I said. I did not misrepresent the Deputy. Dairy cattle have gone down, and what is the reason? The farmers cannot get a price for their dairy produce. That is the argument Deputy Roddy made, that because the output of agricultural produce had gone down it was necessary to use more artificial manure to grow more grass that would not be used. That is the logical conclusion you must come to. There has been a lot of talk about superphosphates being taxed. There are several other manures upon which there is no tax, such as basic slag, guano and sulphate of ammonia. It is possible for a farmer not to use any superphosphates whatever, and get as good results out of any of these.

Comment on this

What about the thousand men then?

Comment on this

I am putting the other argument. It is possible for them to use basic slag, guano or sulphate of ammonia, and get as good results. Deputy Fitzgerald-Kenney told us that farmers would go in for basic slag, and would not use superphosphates. When that time arrives we can take other measures. All the talk about the price of superphosphates being put up, and the farmers being broken as a result of the tariff, is absolute nonsense, and nobody knows it better than the Deputies who tried to make the case. For how many years have Belgian phosphates been coming in? I do not know. Perhaps Deputy Dillon knows. Is it four or five years?

Comment on this

More. Since the War— about fourteen years.

Comment on this

There was no necessity for them to come in—there was no ring.

Comment on this

Superphosphates were not coming in before the War, and the farmers at that time were able to buy all the superphosphates they needed at an economic price.

Comment on this

How long are they using superphosphates in this country?

Comment on this

I said Belgian superphosphates.

Comment on this

How long are they using any superphosphates?

Comment on this

Longer than you or I remember. Deputy Gorey talked about rings. Have you not rings in everything? What is wrong with the farmers is that they were never able to form themselves into a ring.

Comment on this

God help them when the Dáil joins them in a ring.

Comment on this

A proposal was brought in last week by the Minister for Agriculture to try to form the butter producers, if you like, into a ring, because they were not able to do it themselves. Every group of manufacturers in the country is in a ring—boot manufacturers, clothes manufacturers—every single one of them. The labourers are in a ring, if you like to call it that— they have organisations in industry. The opposition put up to this is unreal.

Comment on this

What about Deputy Corry?

Comment on this

He is not in the Opposition ring.

Comment on this

He is in the manufacturers' ring at so much.

Comment on this

If Deputies opposite only got the inspiration to oppose this tariff from Deputy Corry, well then —

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

If it only came into their heads to oppose this tariff when Deputy Corry spurred them on I do not know what to say. I do not know what is in Deputy Corry's mind. I heard no opposition from him. He did not come to me and ask me to oppose the tariff. I have not been speaking to him but if he wished to oppose it he got all the information from the opposite side of the House. There are several tariffs perhaps that come up here that none of us may like but that we consider will be for the good of the community as a whole. That is the reason we support these tariffs and that is the reason that Deputies opposite find themselves on the Opposition Benches to-day—that they did not take steps in time to see that industries were protected and that every section of the community, farmers and industrialists, were given an opportunity of living in their own country.

Comment on this

Might I ask Deputy Allen this question: Would he propose to tax the raw material of any other industry in the way he is proposing to tax the raw material of the farmers? If the farmers were in a ring would he propose to tax their raw material?

Comment on this

If the raw material could be produced in this country.

Comment on this

At the same price.

Comment on this

As one who cannot be accused of being in the manufacturers' ring and who is only concerned with the workers in that section of the industry, I can say that there have been 44 workers employed in my constituency as a result of this tariff. The Chairman of the Farmers' Party there, a member of a public board, has proposed a resolution appealing to the Government to prohibit the importation of foreign manures, to enable that industry to survive and to keep these men in employment.

Comment on this

Do they sell anything else besides manure?

Comment on this

That man is a large trader and he realises that if the industry was closed down it would be a serious matter and that whatever may be the increased price of manures, it will be compensated for by the fact that these 44 men will not be thrown on home help, which would cost the farmers in my constitutency, taking it at 8/- per man per week, about £1,000 extra. As one who has a knowledge of the workers engaged in the industry I can assure the farmers that there is no fear of any increase taking place in the price as the result of the tariff for the reason that you can increase the output of the factory by 25 per cent. without employing another man. The factory can produce at its full capacity and supply the various counties without any extra cost to the manufacturers or the employment of one extra man. Therefore, it is merely to protect the 44 men who are working in that industry that I am supporting this tariff.

I should prefer that the Minister went even further with the tariff, because these 44 men if they were thrown on the unemployed list would cost much more than what Deputy Gorey expects this tariff will cost the farmer. I think the tariff will cost the farmer nothing. When we, representing the working class, agree to pay 4d. extra per pound for butter to enable the farmer to live and when we are called upon to bear various burdens in the way of tariffs for developing industries, surely we can expect other portions of the community to do something towards assisting the workers? I am sorry the Minister did not prohibit altogether the importation of foreign manures. We want to develop our own industries but we do not want to develop them under the slave conditions that prevail where some of those manures are manufactured. That is the reason it is possible to dump these manures into this country and sell them at less than the cost of production here. The workers here are organised and they will never submit to the slave conditions that prevail in countries where these manures are manufactured.

Comment on this

We have heard about slave conditions for the first time in this debate. When we hear that there are slave conditions existing on the other side of the English Channel, we begin to speculate as to what is the real attitude and what are the real ideas behind Labour here. What evidence is there that there are slave conditions in Belgium or Holland? Deputy Everett belongs to the same international organisation as the organised workers of Belgium and Holland. He talks about slave conditions in Holland which he must know do not exist, if he is any way well informed in his own organisation. It is only a joke to put up this cant of slavery on the continent.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey has a different opinion of slavery to that which I hold.

Comment on this

The attitude of the Labour Party has always been the attitude of the sheltered trades. They have always been the spokesmen of the sheltered trades, and although they are elected for rural constituencies their policy is to hold on to the rural constituencies while working for the sheltered trades. That has always been their policy and that is the reason that they are where they are to-day. Yet, not one sheltered trade centre will return a Labour Deputy to this House.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce, I think, was very unjust to Deputies on this side and I resent strongly his description of the opposition to the Resolution when he said that it was purely obstruction. It is nothing of the sort and if the Minister paid any attention to the arguments he would see very little trace of obstruction in them. We are able to stand up here and speak with authority from actual knowledge of these matters, and on the tariffs imposed here. I have never stood up here to speak on anything about which I had no knowledge. I speak on this tariff because I have been using artificial manures for many years. I can tell the Minister that this year I have used 26 tons of artificial manure. I can therefore speak with some authority on this matter and I know something about it. It is unworthy of the Minister to say that we have got up for the purpose of obstruction. I never spoke on any subject in which I had not an interest.

One thing emerges from the speech of Deputy Allen, and that is his explanation of why this Party is on this side of the House. He said it is because of our attitude to tariffs, because we did not impose a lot of tariffs. There was nothing about the Oath in it. It is not because of the Oath that we are on this side of the House. That emerges now. The Minister for Agriculture said that we are accusing him of putting a burden on the farmer. We do accuse him of putting a burden on the farmer, and we accuse him of putting it on without any necessity. There is not a shred of necessity for putting this burden on the farmer, and the proof of that is the price at which the shares of the only manufacturing concern engaged in this industry are quoted, and the manner in which they are appreciated on our stock markets. It is one of the most favoured investments in the State. It embraces all the manufacturers in the State and a considerable number of the manufacturers in England. They are joined with the other English manufactures.

The combine or ring is on the two sides of the Channel. Deputy Allen asked how long are phosphates coming in. Belgian phosphates only began to come in, and it was only possible for them to come in at any profit when the trade here perfected itself in one solid ring with all the manufacturers in it. We farmers and users of artificial manures remember it well. The date would be about 14 or 15 years ago. At that time internal competition ceased, and the manufacturers were able to carry on with that, and they thought it good business for themselves to become one company. It was only then that it was possible for the continental stuff to come in.

Comment on this

What will happen when they join the Belgian ring?

Comment on this

We had better join with them and share it.

Comment on this

What will happen then?

Comment on this

The co-operators of this country will have to buy the phosphates themselves in the place where they are to be found. The Minister for Agriculture made a statement that we had evidence of unemployment. He said that the Minister for Industry and Commerce has said that the manure manufacturers had allowed men to go. I did not hear the Minister for Industry and Commerce making that statement himself. The Minister for Agriculture made it on his authority, and I doubt its accuracy. No matter what manufacturers may have said on the subject I doubt it. The system of inquiry into the desirability of a tariff seems to be that a statement by the manufacturer is enough. The Minister said he had an interview with the employees. They will say the same thing. But was there any evidence but word of mouth or hearsay?

Were these people put on the witness table, and were they sworn in the ordinary sense in which evidence is accepted? Not a word about that. I am down in Waterford twice every fortnight, at an important business place. Now, one of the principal branches of the Goulding factory is located in Waterford, and I have not heard a syllable about unemployment in that factory. Waterford is one of the ports where most of the phosphate is landed, and I have not heard a syllable about any unemployment in that factory.

The only thing to make the farmer the abject slave of the manure ring is to compel him to purchase manure whether he wants it or not and whether the price is right or not. What is the position with regard to the use of manures? The farmer is not a fool. He has 30 or 40 years' experience of the use of artificial manures, and he has the assistance of the analysis that our Department of Agriculture thought it wise and necessary to impose. The Department some years ago thought that a very necessary thing to impose for the protection of the users. I want to go very much further than that.

When the Department thought it necessary in the interests of the people and in order to protect the consumer to have an analysis of all manures and to have grass seeds tested in this country, I would like to know what the Dáil is to infer from that? On the basis of these analyses, on the basis of the solubility of the manure, the farmer, when coming to buy his manures in the springtime, will buy them at comparative prices in relation to their manurial value and their suitability to the particular soil. He has no preference one way or the other. He will buy Irish if he can. He is not tied to the continental manures. He does not care two pins. If there is any preference at all he will buy Irish. I always bought Irish, and paid 2/6 a ton more for it. Value for value, we will give a preference to the Irish material.

The Minister says that the price of the continental stuff is going to be raised to the extent of the tariff. Deputy Corry's figure is a joke, 18,000 tons. The facts are that the Irish manufacturer bases his price early in the year on the knowledge that the continental stuff is there to come in. He bases his price accordingly. What would he base it on if he had not the knowledge that the continental stuff was coming in? If he knew that the competition was killed, on what would he base his price?

This is meant to kill competition, and it will kill competition. It will put the foreign manufacturer absolutely out of business and hand that business over to the ring. What would the Irish manufacturer base his price on with the knowledge that the continental supplies were there and would come over? When he has issued his price list, and even when the foreign phosphates arrive at the port here, the Irish manufacturer's price is still further lowered. How much is that price list lowered because of that?

Does the Minister for Industry and Commerce know anything at all about it? The price is lowered as soon as the foreign shipments begin to arrive. The very fact that these shipments are there is responsible for that. We are told the price will be raised only to the extent of 12/- a ton or 15/-, or whatever the figure is that it may be raised by the tariff. It will be more likely to be £2 a ton when competition is killed and the foreigner is out of the business. It is no exaggeration to say that 200,000 tons of these manures are sold in the country every year, and it would be no over-statement to say that these manures will go up by at least 30/- per ton. That would work out on the present normal consumption at the enormous figure of £300,000.

The idea is to kill competition altogether. What was the necessity, first of all, to kill competition in the State? Was it not in order to enable them to charge more? What is the effect of this competition that we have now? Is it not definitely in order to raise prices? The price can be forced up to the point where the consumer will not use these phosphates. I say that that price can be very easily reached now. We have lambs being sold to-day, May lambs, at 30/- to 35/- each. That is actually being called a good price for fat lambs. Milk is being sold at 3½d. per gallon in parts of the country, and corn at a low price. Every other article of agricultural production, and store cattle, are actually unsaleable, practically speaking.

When a man is thinking of buying artificial manure he is thinking of what he is going to get out of it, of how much it will enhance the yield of his crops, how much it will improve his land, and what he is going to get for the finished article turned off his land. Even if the man has money and can afford to spend it, as a business man he would be a fool if he went farther than I have indicated. He will only use manure if it is going to pay him. The probability is that he will not use half as much as he has been using. He will use less of it in any case if the price goes up.

Last year I used 26 tons of artificial manures, and only 6 tons two years ago. The year before last I used 16 tons of artificial manure. It is a question of the value one gets for the money and the prospects one has from applying the manure. We are not all fools. I speak about this matter because I am acquainted with it, and I can speak on it with some authority. There is no justification at all for the suggestion that we are speaking here as obstructionists.

I would be inclined to say, as I see it, that whether they know it or not the Executive Council and the Government have shown themselves to have been the tools of the manufacturers in this country. That is the way I see it. The time, I think, is ripe to preach a holy war against artificial manures in this country in order to bring the Government and the manufacturers to their knees. That can be easily done, and with as much effect as this tariff can if imposed. Years ago we got responses to public appeals, and we will get them again. A thing like this is a public scandal. It is nothing short of perpetrating a scandal on the people of the country whether the Government know it or not.

I asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce, when discussing this at first, to be very careful of what he was doing. Yet when he got up to speak here yesterday he seemed to know less about it than he did on the first day. His whole knowledge was that somebody passed through his office and spent a half an hour there. The Minister did not know whether Northern Africa was in the British Commonwealth or not. He makes a lot of the fact that 25,000 tons came in, in the first two months. 32,000 tons came in last year, and 42,000 tons the year before. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has the figures there before him. Four out of every five of the Irish consumers of phosphates use the Irish products. Of course they do—because they think it is better value for the money and because of freightage and because the attitude in particular of the local trader has a lot to do with it, and if the trader in an inland county stocks only the Irish stuff, the consumer must buy Irish stuff if he is going to use it at all. If you sap the confidence in business competition here in the consumer and the trader, and if you make it impossible for each to use artificial manures, then good-bye to Irish industries, and you will do more harm than good by your protection methods.

Why was it necessary to end competition here? Was it in order to give the manufacturers more money, more value, more dividends? Is it right for any country or State to stand for the encouragement of rings for the purpose of robbing the consumer or extracting more from him? As soon as a State starts to housekeep on these lines they are open to the accusation that they are either stupid or out for jobbery. There is no necessity for a ring here at all except to force up prices, and there is no necessity for forcing out this 32,000 tons of normal competition or 42,000 tons except to kill competition and to hand over the consumer here altogether into the hands of the manufacturer. It would not have been so serious two or three years ago as it is to-day, because the resources of the agricultural community are very much less to-day, and that goes without argument. Everyone will admit it. I do not know whether the Minister still thinks we have stood up for the purpose of obstruction pure and simple. If he still thinks so he is welcome to it. How, if this little small competition that we have from outside —if that ring is broken or if its efficiency is impaired in any way—how is it still the best investment on the market, and for how much are these people prepared to buy legislation of this sort either one way or another? We are long enough in politics to know that there has been an association going round here for the last seven or eight years looking for somebody to do their job, and they did not find them up to lately. I do not know whether they have found them now. If they have, God help the country.

Comment on this

It is very hard to understand all this pother and all this nonsense and tomfoolery from Deputy Gorey. What do they want us to do?

Comment on this

To leave well alone.

Comment on this

What did they ask the Ministers to do? They asked them to adopt the policy that they have been adopting themselves for the last ten years and that has put them in opposition and will keep them in opposition. That is what Deputy Gorey and Deputy McGilligan and the other members of the Opposition in the debate are asking members of Fianna Fáil and of this Government to do. Deputy McGilligan referred to the fact that the Minister for Agriculture had stated that if the home manufacturer did not behave in a proper spirit the Ministry were empowered to admit the foreign manufactured article, and Deputy McGilligan says: "I wonder what will happen then to the thousand men who are employed in this industry?" Deputy Gorey asked, in the event of this tariff what price will be quoted by the Irish manufacturer? We do not know what price the Irish manufacturer will quote, but we do know that a thousand men, as Deputy Allen pointed out, are engaged in this industry, and we think we have the sanction of the majority of the people of this country for believing that this Government is entitled to give the Irish manufacturer this opportunity, and we have the powers, if that manufacturer does not behave in the proper spirit, to allow foreign competition and to allow that competition that members on the other side are shouting for——

Comment on this

You are shutting the stable door when the horse is gone.

Comment on this

You shut the stable door when the industries were gone.

Comment on this

We do not keep industries in a stable. And that is what you have been doing.

Comment on this

We are not going to allow ourselves to be forced into the policy that has driven you out of office. We know what the people of this country want. We know that the foreign market has not been giving the people the cost of production for their butter or their eggs or their beef, and we see, and you must see, and any farmer must see, that the whole economic policy of this country must change if we are to survive at all. We are here to change that policy, and we have got the sanction of the people for it, and we are not going to be induced by any methods of the Opposition to fall into the trap in which they were and are and which will keep them there.

Comment on this