We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Financial Resolution No. 26—General—Report (Resumed).

Contributions 1–214 of 626. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Seán F. Lemass Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

On a point of order, I think there is no definite restriction on Deputies discussing anything, as we are on the General Resolution.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Anything that can possibly come within the scope of Resolution No. 26.

Comment on this

I understood the idea was the discussion would continue while on the General Resolution, taking the items as we went along and passing to the end to-night.

Comment on this

I am agreeable.

Comment on this

When we have finished with one subject we would not go back on it but would progress.

Comment on this

My anxiety is to get some arrangement so that we might finish with the subject. If we take them item by item the danger is that we may spend all the time at one item.

Comment on this

What is the suggestion — that we should go back to some item prior to No. 21? I forgot some of the things that might be said earlier, and I wonder would the Minister object now.

Comment on this

I have no objection to any points arising.

Comment on this

The point that the Minister raised does arise, that there is a tendency to stick at one particular point and to spend all the time on that. We would be anxious to finish the discussion on Resolution No. 7 as early as possible, as there are a certain number of other Resolutions that we would like to have some definite discussion on. I do not know whether it would be possible, in respect of a certain number, to fix a point of time by which we would reach a particular item.

Comment on this

I am not clear as to the other Resolutions that the Deputy wishes to discuss, but an arrangement could be made to finish No. 7 by 7 o'clock or by 7.30.

Comment on this

We might finish No. 7 earlier.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Reference No. 21 — Superphosphates, ground mineral phosphates and compound manures.

Comment on this

I want very briefly to put to the Minister certain things about which I asked for information on the last day and in regard to which I am still in the dark. We are told that the aim of this particular tariff in regard to superphosphates is to prevent 1,000 people being put out of employment. We have asked what is the likelihood of these people losing employment without the tariff and the only statement I have heard was an allusion to imports in the early months of this year. If it is not possible to get the information I want now, I think I might be able to get it by way of Parliamentary Question. I would like to know what were the imports of superphosphates into the Saorstát, year by year, since 1926. I would like a further statement telling me what percentage of each year's total importation does the importation during the first three months represent. If I had that information I would have a proper method of evaluating the significance of the imports during the first three months of 1932.

Deputy Dillon raised certain matters, but his points have not been answered. He adverted to the fact that the lever with which traders have been enabled to keep down prices of the home manufactured material is in danger of being removed, the lever being the Continental manures that have been and are being imported. That is the experience of those who are accustomed to dealing in artificial manures. We are told that another lever is going to be put into the hands of the Government through a certain piece of legislation in connection with price fixing. What is the standard to be taken in relation to the prices rightly to be fixed as the proper prices to be charged to Irish users of the home manufactured article?

I would like to have information either now or later on on the following points: Is it a fact that the home manufacturers at the general meeting of the company held last summer promised a reduction in price for the 1931-32 selling season, the season we have finished, basing it upon foreshadowed reductions in three items which go towards the cost of manufacture of the articles — raw material, freights and the sacks necessary? Was that reduction in price given in the season just past by the home manufacturers to the farmers in this country? If that reduction did not take place, I want the Minister to tell me has he been able to have investigations made as to whether or not the foreshadowed reductions in raw material, freights and sacks did take place and why was it not reflected in reduced prices? I want to know if further decreases have not, in fact, since taken place because the reductions that were foreshadowed would relate to contracts that would have to be made, starting from June last, for delivery of the manufactured material in the early months of this year.

While that material was being purchased at a reduced price, is it not a fact that further reductions have taken place in all three items that go to make up the price here? Is not the consumer entitled to two reductions and will that be the price that will be taken as the standard price when any price-fixing machinery is set up? If not, what is going to be the price that will be taken by the Minister as the standard price when he attempts by legislation to fix the price at which anything is going to be sold? What is going to be the standard when he fixes the price for superphosphates in this country next year?

The matter of dumping has been spoken of, and I think it is rather hard to get the relevancy of the statement — I think it was in that connection reference was made to Britain having gone off the gold standard — about the gold standard and the matter of dumping. I would like to know if we have any figures providing data in the matter of dumping. I would like to know whether or not Continental manures have been railed through Belgium at a price that compares with the sale price here when the freight has been added. Is it not a fact that the raw material in this trade has been for years quoted in sterling and purchased at sterling rates? If that is the fact, what has the matter of Britain going off the gold standard got to do with this business?

The matter of dumping may appear to some people, looking at the thing superficially, to be proved because of the fact that Continental manure is continuing to be sold at a much lower rate here than the home-manufactured article. Can that not be explained by the fact that reductions have taken place in the season 1931-32 and are foreshadowed next season by reason of the reduction in the items I have spoken of? These reductions have not led to a fall in price in the home manufactured articles. If the Minister cannot give me information now, perhaps he will let me have it later. I think it is information that is necessary in the sense that it would enable one to form a proper judgment when one comes to the Committee Stage of the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

The only reason I made any reference to Britain going off the gold standard was that we must take it into account in trying to arrive at an estimate and in coming to the cost of production of the Continental phosphates, bearing in mind the price at which they are sold here.

Comment on this

If the raw material is quoted in sterling what difference does the altered value of the gold standard make?

Comment on this

In estimating the cost of production we must take into account that the Belgian labourers and those engaged in production are not paid in sterling but in Belgian francs and the difference between the two must affect the price at which the producers are selling the material here.

Comment on this

That did not affect the price in 1931-32.

Comment on this

The Deputy asked what is the likelihood of people being put out of employment. I can answer that definitely. I met representatives of the workers in the industry who referred to the fact that a number of them had been put out of employment here in several factories. In a number of factories stocks were not sold; a great part of them were not sold, and in consequence the factories were proposing to close down at an earlier date. Approaches were made to the managers of the factories and in each case we have been able to arrange that hardship will be avoided and there will not be the same diminution in labour as there has been in the past. A certain diminution has taken place and in a number of factories workers were working alternate weeks. If there was not the prospect of an increased market next year the factories would be closed down entirely.

The figures requested by Deputy McGilligan — year by year imports — can be given. They are available in the Library and I think the Deputy will find, if he takes the first three months of this year and makes a comparison with last year and the year before, that the imports this year were considerably larger. Again, we have to bear in mind that it is not so much the quantity of goods imported as the potential quantity of goods that might be imported. Then we have to consider the effect upon industry here. The last Government imposed a tariff on oats. The quantity of oats imported was comparatively small. It was a mere trifle compared with our production. It was the mere fact that oats could be imported in unlimited quantities that mattered because oats might be imported to the point when it would not pay the farmer to produce oats here.

It is not the volume of imports that matters so much. What matters is that once you permit the importation of unlimited quantities, that might tend to make production here an uneconomic proposition. That also raises the point made by Deputy Dillon, a point to which Deputy McGilligan referred. That argument was that if you put a duty upon cheap Continental manures coming in, then you have removed a lever by which the prices of the Irish produced article can be kept down. I am astonished that Deputies opposite who have been using that argument for the past few weeks did not use it previously. Why did they not use that argument when the late Government put a tariff on butter?

Comment on this

There was no occasion.

Comment on this

The price of butter was falling to a price when it did not pay to produce it, and the late Government imposed a tariff on butter for no other reason than to permit an increase in the price of butter to the home consumers to the point which would pay the home producer. Why did not Deputies opposite use that argument then? Why did they not use it when a duty was placed on oats? Why did they not use that argument on every occasion that the late Government put a duty on any article produced at home? Exactly similar circumstances prevailed. If the standard by which we are to judge of our ability to produce any article here is the lowest price at which we can buy that article from any other country in the world, then we can abandon the idea of industrial development, and we can abandon the idea of producing half our present agricultural production, we can reduce our population to 200,000, and concentrate on the production of live cattle, because live cattle are the only commercial product that we can sell cheaper than any other country in the world.

If that is what Deputies want, then they will have the complete wiping out of the towns in the country, the levelling of our hedges and the turning of our country into one large grazing ranch if it is intended to give effect to the policy they have been advocating here. But if we want to secure the survival of this nation, and if our people are to be given work here then we have got to have a different standard, and we have got to decide that the criterion by which we judge the suitability of any industry to this island is the number of workers available, the local climatic and other conditions, the market for the production of the industry, and not the price of the product in some other country where an entirely different standard of living prevails.

Deputy McGilligan asked me a large number of questions relating to the recent changes in prices, and the possible future changes in prices affecting this industry. I am not in a position to supply these figures now, but I will endeavour to get that information for the Deputy. We can then have the matter up again when the Finance Bill comes before the Dáil. In order to obliterate any misunderstanding let me say it is quite clear that we have imposed no duty upon superphosphates or compound manures imported from Great Britain or from the British Dominions. In so far as there are countries engaged in the production of these goods in which the standard of living is similar to our own, we do not intend to interfere with competition in any way.

Comment on this

Why not be honest about it—countries which are in the ring?

Comment on this

If Deputy Gorey has any information about rings it is up to him to give us that information here and now.

Comment on this

Does not the Minister know they are there? Can he not see it himself?

Comment on this

If the price of any article subject to a duty or tariff is artificially shoved up by ring methods we will either remove the duty or take to ourselves the power to burst that ring. We are not going to have that, and Deputy Gorey knows that it is not beyond the wit of man to defeat tactics of that kind. As far as the great part of the artificial manures used by the farmers, and particularly those most popular with the farmers, are concerned, we have not imposed any duty at all; no matter what country they come from there is no duty. We have received applications to extend this duty in order to cover other things, but we declined to do so. This duty was considered in consultation with the experts of the Department of Agriculture, and we fixed it upon this basis, and with the least inconvenience to the farmers. We kept in view the greatest good to the industry. We wanted to preserve employment for the people engaged in this industry, and we succeeded in doing it. Four out of five of the Irish farmers in the past used the products of Irish factories in the way of artificial manures, and we say it is no hardship if five farmers out of five will in the future use these Irish products.

Comment on this

I think the Minister was asked certain items of fact. Will he make inquiries to find out if the Irish manure manufacturers are members of the Fertilisers Manufacturers' Association and tell us if he can find any trace of an agreement amongst these not to ship superphosphate to each other's countries?

Comment on this

The fact that there is a substantial import of superphosphate from Great Britain into this country would seem at first sight to indicate that that is not so.

Comment on this

At first sight!

Comment on this

Will the farmers get these superphosphates at the same price as before the duty was put on?

Comment on this

At a fair price.

Comment on this

Can the Minister not tell us if the farmers will get it at the same price at which they were getting it before the duty was put on?

Comment on this

I have said that it would be at a fair price.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give any indication as to how many farmers this tariff will put out of business as against the number of additional people he expects to see employed?

Comment on this

My answer is none. It will put no farmer out of business.

Comment on this

Then the Minister's knowledge of farming is very little.

Comment on this
Dr. Thomas Hennessy Dr. Hennessy

I wonder does the Minister know that dairy farming is very much dependent on the use of phosphatic manures? If the Minister interferes in dairy farming by putting a tariff on these manures he will certainly increase the production costs of the dairy farmers and he will do this country a great injury. In my opinion this tariff will considerably lessen employment. It does not seem to strike the Minister that dairy farming is one of the greatest sources of employment in this country.

Comment on this

In the matter of Reference No. 23, would the Minister tell us are there any bicycle firms in this country?

Comment on this

There were no bicycle assembling firms when the duty was imposed. A number of firms have since gone into the business. And it is anticipated that the importation of completed bicycles will have ceased by the end of this year, or, at all events, within a very short period.

Comment on this

What is going to happen with regard to the approved roads across the Border and the difficulty the cyclists will be in who have to go in and out across the Border?

Comment on this

A special provision is made in the fifth column which sets out that "the Revenue Commissioners may make regulations providing for the total or partial exemption from this duty for a limited period of articles liable to this duty brought into Saorstát Eireann by persons making only a temporary stay therein." These regulations have been made. Undoubtedly, there will be certain inconveniences.

Comment on this

That regulation is all right in regard to people coming in from outside and bringing with them a bicycle which they intend to take out again within a short period. But what regulation does the Minister intend to establish to see that bicycles are not brought in across the Border in large numbers for the purpose of sale? In nearly every country where there is a land frontier authorities have to adopt the system of registration of push bicycles. Is it intended that there should be registration here?

Comment on this

That is a matter for the police and the Revenue Commissioners. I may assure the Deputy that all the resources of the State will be mobilised to see that the law is not evaded.

Comment on this

Has the point been considered?

Comment on this

It has.

Comment on this

And there has been no suggestion of registration for bicycles?

Comment on this

The idea has been considered, but no decison has been taken.

Comment on this

Would there be any disadvantage in compelling the manufacture of bicycle wheels here? Would it not have been a better means of providing labour? So far as I can learn, the labour involved in assembling a bicycle is very small. I know one English concern has only offered 3/6 per bicycle to its agent in Dublin for the assembling of these bicycles. On the other hand, I believe the manufacture of wheels would have been a very good means of giving employment, that it would have given an opportunity to a great number of semi-skilled people throughout the country of showing their skill. Further, it would not have resulted in any increase in the cost of the bicycle. This tax will provide a certain amount of labour, but it is not going to do very much use in the way of providing labour. I believe that the assemblage of a bicycle only takes somewhat less than an hour. I think the Minister might consider whether it could not be extended, so that certain parts might be admitted in and the wheels made here.

Comment on this

It is intended that in due course we shall get a number of parts manufactured here.

Comment on this

As to item 24— photographic prints, has the Minister made up his mind about the amendment I tabled, with reference to those of a scientific, educational, or technical character?

Comment on this

I have discussed the matter from an administrative point of view with the Revenue Commissioners, but I have not yet reached a point when I can say that I have come to a conclusion as to what can be done. It seems to me that we shall be able to get a means by which scientific and technical photographs can be exempted, but the term "educational" would be too wide.

Comment on this

I mean photographs of works of art. It will be a very heavy tax.

Comment on this

The matter has been examined, and I shall go as far as I can to meet the Deputy. The difficulties are merely administrative.

Comment on this

Could it not be met by exempting such prints consigned to educational institutions or the teachers in such institutions?

Comment on this

We shall have that point considered.

Comment on this

That suggestion would not go far enough to meet the point I have in mind. I do not see why we should deny trade of a legitimate type to the distributors of educational photographic prints and sensitised material in this country. If there is going to be an exemption merely for this particular type of photographic print, and the basis as to whether it is educational or not is going to be taken, and whether it is directed to an educational establishment, then clearly we are throwing business into the hands of English distributors and taking it out of the hands of our own.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister if he has considered the question of exhibition prints. I do not propose to deal with whether a photographic print is a work of art, but certainly there are a number of people in this country who send prints for exhibition in England. Would the prints when returned be subject to the duty? Exhibitions of photographic prints are also held in this country from time to time. While there is a definite local section there is also usually an international section, and in that the prints are clearly of an educational character, so far as the photographic trade or art is concerned. I should like to bring to the notice of the Minister this passing and repassing of exhibition prints between the two countries. I should also like to ask him what he means by "printed direct from a photographic film or photographic plate"? Does he mean a contact print?

Comment on this

No, printed upon sensitised material from the negative. We have photographic prints printed from blocks. It is not intended that they should be subject to duty.

Comment on this

This says "printed direct from a photographic film or photographic plate." Do you mean by contact, because the drafting of this Resolution is not very clear? I wish to ask whether you have in mind enlargements, as well as contact prints?

Comment on this

Both contact prints and enlargements?

Comment on this

Will a process such as carbro, where it is transferred, also be covered, because that is certainly contact? It is merely a peculiarity in the drafting which I bring to the attention of the Minister. It is not very clear whether contact enlargements and prints, such as by the carbro process, are included.

Comment on this

What is the reason for the change in the previous measurement of 25 square inches, and the reduction now to 18?

Comment on this

Some firms have proceeded to engage in the production of picture postcards which are actual photographs, and it is desired to give them the protection involved in the reduction of the size.

Comment on this

I think these postcards would come in as cardboard. Technically, a postcard when printed upon will be cardboard.

Comment on this

There is no duty on printed cardboard. Cardboard is not subject to duty.

Comment on this

That is what I mean. When a postcard of sensitised material is printed it would really come in free under the heading of cardboard. Is that not right?

Comment on this

I propose to refer to that under the next photographic item.

Comment on this

The Minister also said that he did not intend to have a block from which photographs would be reproduced tariffed. Is not that block tariffed under another heading?

Comment on this

That is another matter which we can discuss later. Reproductions of photographs from a block will not be subject to duty. It is intended to apply only to what I call real photographs, that is, photographs actually printed from the negative.

Comment on this

Reproductions from a block are subject to a tax under another heading.

Comment on this

The block is included under another heading. It is intended to exclude it.

Comment on this

It is intended to put down an amendment to exclude it?

Comment on this

So far as it is subject to a duty under brass, tin and lead it is intended to exclude it, but not from the wood duty.

Comment on this

As to No. 25, which refers to bedding, I asked if the Minister could tell me what was the difference between a quilt, a counterpane and a bedspread, and I should like to know if he has got the information yet. The reason why I ask it is this: There is a linen tax which includes certain linen goods—Item No. 14 on this—where the tariff is 25 per cent. full rate, with a free rate for a great many of the items, and where the rate is not free it is 15 per cent. When we come to bedding we get a full rate of 37½, with a preferential rate of 25 per cent. I understand that the customs authorities are concluding from the fact that sheets are specifically excluded from the bedding heading that, therefore, bolster cases and pillow cases are necessarily included as bedding, and they are being subjected to the 37½ and 25 per cent. tax. I do not know whether that was meant. I do not know what was the point from which those who drew this up started, in order to make their discriminations. If they started from what a bedding manufacturer produces they will not get any bedding manufacturer to produce bolster cases or pillow cases of linen or cotton. Yet these things are, apparently, being considered as coming within this heading, and charged at the 25 per cent. rate, instead of, where they are linen, being charged at the lower rate. It is a matter that should be looked into. If the point of discrimination is what a bedding manufacturer would make, then these things should be entirely excluded. If they are going to be brought under the linen tariff, although it is not clear from the phraseology that they are, then they will be at the lower rate. It is a point which would want to be looked into.

Then I understand there is this specific tariff with regard to quilts, filled or unfilled. When one comes to such matters as counterpanes or bedspreads, the customs authorities are deciding that if they can catch them under linen or cotton, by reason of the fabric, well and good they are caught, but if they are not, they are going to catch them under the title of bedding. It is a question whether they were not meant to be excluded. If so, it ought to be made clear.

Comment on this

I will have that point examined.

Comment on this

With regard to Item No. 27 I take it that that is a revenue tax absolutely?

Comment on this

Mainly. There is some hope we will get some of these things made.

Comment on this

Cutlery, and perhaps razor blades.

Comment on this

Is there any prospect of getting safety razors made here? It is necessary I suppose for people to be shaved and to have their faces clean and to make it easier for them to take off their whiskers. The Minister apparently wants to reverse that order because it will cost them more to get their whiskers off. As to knives and forks I do not see any prospect in this country of making these things here. When does the Minister hope to get some advance made in the way of knives and forks and spoons and ordinary razors? At present we know nothing about it except that he demands a tariff. The Minister admitted that this was to be a revenue tariff, but that is not sufficient to justify a tax like this.

Comment on this

It was only a few years ago that there was a cutlery manufactory on the quays in Dublin.

Comment on this

What happened to it?

Comment on this

It went west.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that on Gillette razor blades there is a tax already, owing to the outer cover?

Comment on this

That is the matter of the package tax.

Comment on this

Is the Gillette blade a food, a drink, a medicine or a cosmetic?

Comment on this

They are not subject to duty under the package duty at all.

Comment on this

We went to the trouble some time ago when we were discussing a tax on brushes to introduce an amendment for the purpose of exempting tooth brushes. If we are to be occupied here in this way, I wonder why we went to the trouble of taking out tooth brushes, if we are to raise a revenue on razor blades. I heard Deputy Sir James Craig say he never used a tooth brush in his life.

Comment on this

Surely not.

Comment on this

If we are to tax razor blades here I think he could make a case for transferring the tax from razor blades back to tooth brushes.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will look at the papers he will see that he will get a safety razor blade for a penny.

Comment on this

Has the Minister tried it?

Comment on this

A shave with that would harmonise with hair shirts.

Comment on this

I want to ask the Minister whether he would not introduce an amendment to exclude sensitised materials.

Comment on this

That amendment will be introduced.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister if item 28 is regarded as a revenue producing duty?

Comment on this

Mainly.

Comment on this

It seems to me that you are going to collect a couple of shillings off every camera a tourist brings in——

Comment on this

Are they specially exempted?

Comment on this

No, there is general power exercised by the Revenue Commissioners to exempt articles brought in by tourists for personal use.

Comment on this

I do not see power taken to ensure that in this case.

Comment on this

It is not necessary. It is the same power as that by which the Deputy if he came to Dun Laoghaire with a package of cigarettes would not be asked to pay duty on them.

Comment on this

But if he had more than the amount allowed.

Comment on this

The Revenue Commissioners have power to exclude them up to a certain quantity.

Comment on this

I suggest that the widest publicity should be given to that, because the fear of these things is worse than the actual situation people have to face. The Minister stated this is a revenue producing item, so I do not propose to make any comment upon the possible manufacture of cameras and sensitised materials. At the present moment there are two factories that are catering for developing and printing photographs in the Saorstát. I suppose it is not unnatural that people who are thinking of starting industries here should consider that possibly the same treatment which is meted out here to them would be meted out to other manufacturers who propose starting in this country. These two firms are cut off from the North of Ireland and the Isle of Man. Possibly the Minister may say he does not wish to enter into any negotiations to keep these markets for these people. Possibly it is not the Minister's fault. At the same time it is not the firms' fault which caters for these materials. They are both developing and printing factories and the photographic prints under another heading—the bread and butter stuff— are expressly excluded. I do not know if there is any reason for that. No doubt there is good and sufficient reason. At the same time I suppose the factories concerned look upon that trade with the idea that they ought to have the same advantage as the other people.

Now when you come down to some of the other things they do, one of the factories supplies large photographic prints. If you are going to have Ireland cut off from England as far as sending prints over to the other side for exhibition purposes, it is going to lead to a considerable diminution in the trade carried on by these people. One of the factories has installed machinery and started to produce picture postcards. When you come to look at how they are now situated it is rather interesting. I understand a picture postcard such as I have here—there is no particular virtue in this particular card, it is merely an instance—would come in technically as cardboard duty free. That means that if it is produced on the other side it comes in as cardboard duty free. When our home manufacturer comes to produce these cards in competition with postcards coming in from outside, he is hit with 15 and 10 per cent. more on sensitised material. Am I right in thinking that the Minister is taking that off?

Comment on this

Yes. Is the postcard referred to by the Deputy a photographic print?

Comment on this

When it is printed and comes in it is cardboard. It comes in to him as sensitive paper and is the local manufacturer's raw material. If what is in this Schedule were to be persisted in it would mean that you would be taxing the raw material of the local manufacturer to the extent of 15 per cent. and letting the same material, when printed, in from the other side duty free. However I am glad to hear that the Minister is removing that anomaly at any rate and that the local manufacturer is not going to suffer that handicap in the future. At the same time I would ask the Minister also to consider the question of photographic prints. This is a very large question so far as the factories in this country are concerned.

Comment on this

I am not quite clear as to what the Deputy's point is. Is it that if we are to subject photographic prints to duty at all they should be all subject to duty, including the smaller sizes?

Comment on this

What I am pointing out is that if you start with photographic prints, the large sizes, that practically only hits educational and exhibition prints, but when you come to another aspect of the thing you are letting in one duty free and in the other case subjecting the manufacturer to a tax on his raw material.

Comment on this

The postcard size is subject to duty. The extent of the duty was reduced on the Committee Stage.

Comment on this

I had two other amendments down that I want to draw the Minister's attention to. I want to urge exemption in this case for such apparatus as is used in connection with any educational work or in educational institutions generally. The Minister himself has down an amendment "For use in hospitals or surgical work," and I want to add to that "or in any educational institutions," and in my other amendment "excluding scientific, medical and surgical instruments or apparatus." There are a great many of them and I hope the Minister will consider this favourably.

Comment on this

Yes. In so far as they are not covered by the existing exclusion, I will have it considered.

Comment on this

Am I to understand from the Minister if people travelling abroad take photographs with a five by four camera that a duty will have to be paid on the negatives if they are sent in here to be printed, but that if a person takes with him a vest pocket camera the prints of that will be allowed in free?

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

In other words the prints taken by the five by four camera are penalised, while the prints of the vest pocket camera are not. What is behind that policy?

Comment on this

The policy definitely was to make subject to duty certain classes of prints which are used commercially, mainly the cabinet size and the postcard size. It is desired to exempt from duty the ordinary snapshot size photograph because, as Deputies know, it is illegal to send dutiable matter through the letter post and if large numbers of people travelling abroad desire to send back photographic representations of their experiences through the post they would be acting illegally.

Comment on this

Will also a picture postcard be allowed in free?

Comment on this

The photographic print is subject to duty.

Comment on this

Would postcard sized prints from abroad be liable to duty?

Comment on this

This is going to create a very difficult position, and I would ask the Minister to look into it carefully. I take it the position now is that if people travelling abroad on holiday send back prints to have them developed here these prints will be subject to duty. If that position is to be maintained, then people will be practically compelled to have these prints developed outside their own country. That seems a very extraordinary situation. I think the matter is one that the Minister might look into.

Comment on this

In the case of reference No. 29—gas meters—would the Minister say what gas meter firms there are in the country? Are there any?

Comment on this

A couple.

Comment on this

Are they not branches of English firms?

Comment on this

They are.

Comment on this

And they will come under another Act?

Comment on this

Not necessarily.

Comment on this

In connection with reference No. 30—galvanised corrugated iron—would the Minister give the House some explanation of it. So far as this is concerned I do not think that we have here people engaged in the manufacturing or rolling end of it. There may be some interested in it from the scrap-merchants' end. Is this tariff put on to foster a new industry or to maintain an old one? I would like to hear the Minister's explanation before I make any further comments.

Comment on this

I take it that the Minister has no hope of having within the next few years rolling mills here and that the purpose of this resolution is to have flat sheets brought in and galvanised here. Is that the idea?

Comment on this

As the resolution now stands, flat sheets of galvanised corrugated iron or steel are not subject to duty. If they are worked in any way, that is to say, if they have been serrated as well as corrugated, bent or shaped or fabricated in any way for erection they are subject to duty.

Comment on this

Then the idea is that they should be brought in and galvanised here?

Comment on this

A flat sheet of galvanised, corrugated iron is not subject to duty.

Comment on this

I take it the Minister's idea is that he wishes to have the corrugated iron rolled here?

Comment on this

Is the Minister quite clear about this when he talks of flat sheets of corrugated iron? Would he explain exactly what he means?

Comment on this

I am quite clear as to what I mean; a sheet of corrugated iron.

Comment on this

Does the Minister mean galvanised?

Comment on this

Galvanised corrugated iron before you do anything with it: before you shape it, bore holes in it to take rivets, before you cut it for fencing and serrate the ends of it so that there will be spikes on it. All that work can be done here and we are taking steps to see that it will be done here.

Comment on this

That is the object of it.

Comment on this

It is clear then that corrugated galvanised iron can come in duty free, but that if you want to bend it or bore holes in it it is subject to duty?

Comment on this

What is the position with regard to corrugated sheets of iron that are shaped for the purpose of roofing a hay shed?

Comment on this

They are dutiable if shaped.

Comment on this

I just want to ask on the wording of this: is it going to be held that you can have a flat sheet of galvanised corrugated iron?

Comment on this

I suggest that that requires alteration.

Comment on this

I am afraid that this will produce a very peculiar situation, because I understand our policy here is that we are anxious to help the farmer. Under this Resolution, if a farmer gets in a corrugated sheet, even with a slight curve in it to cover a hay shed, it will be subject to duty, but if the corrugated sheet comes in flat, as Deputy Thrift has defined it—it is difficult I may say to conceive of a flat currugated sheet of iron—then it is not subject to duty, but if it is shaped in any way or made suitable for the farmer it is subject to duty. I would point out to the Minister that this is rather an extraordinary situation. We are anxious, as I said, to help our basic industry, agriculture, and here we are penalising agriculture. Where are all our agriculturists?

Comment on this

There are quite a number of idle men and idle firms in this country, quite competent and quite willing to put the bend in corrugated iron that Deputy Good talks of.

Comment on this

How many men will we have operating on the bending of corrugated iron?

Comment on this

I have no idea.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say how much this corrugating, bending or twisting is going to cost the farmer?

Comment on this

It will cost no more to get it done in this country than it costs at present to get it done in England.

Comment on this

Are you sure?

Comment on this

Quite sure.

Comment on this

Why is it not being done?

Comment on this

What evidence can the Minister produce to show that there are firms in Ireland ready to do that work? Have they the machinery to do it? I know that some of them have done a little hand-rolling in local plants, but are they doing it in any quantity? Has the Minister any idea of the hardship that this will inflict on the agricultural community, whose shelter, in many cases for themselves, and certainly for their cattle, is largely corrugated iron? The galvanising does not matter according to the Minister, but apparently the corrugating does.

Comment on this

The bending; not the corrugating.

Comment on this

It is the flat sheet coming in galvanised. Is the sheet to be curved for use as a roof? I know how it is going to be interpreted at the ports, and I think the Minister has not adverted to what the thing means. Are the flat corrugated sheets subject to tax?

Comment on this

The flat sheet of corrugated iron is not subject to tax.

Comment on this

I think if the Minister refers to the corrugated sheet as straight or bent, we will get over the difficulty.

Comment on this

That is the distinction? They make a distinction between straight and bent. I do not believe it, and I would ask the Minister to get further advice, because this is rather important. The Minister has inadvertently given a wrong definition as to the meaning of this. I am certain that it means flat, as well as bent, sheets provided they are corrugated. I want to know if representations have been made by anybody connected with the trade, and what representations, if any, have been made. Have representations been put up by some of our scrap merchants who hold considerable stocks of second-hand corrugated iron? We know that some of them have been busy around this House for the last eight or ten years, and we have seen them recently, and within the last month or two.

Comment on this

I do not even know the people to whom the Deputy is referring.

Comment on this

You are the only one in Dublin who does not know. We see second-hand galvanised sheets advertised in every paper in the Provinces. Every local paper has been boosting these advertisements for the last three or four months—huge stocks of second-hand corrugated iron are in hand, and I would like to know why the Minister took this line. Was it on the advice of a prospective or existing manufacturer? I do not know whether I can use the word "manufacturer," or whether I should say "assembler," but they are something between the two— a "corrugator."

Comment on this

Or a "bender."

Comment on this

Were representations made by any Irish "corrugator" or by the second-hand merchants? Next to the phosphates tariff, this tariff will hit the small farmer most severely, because he is the man who can least afford to put up expensive shedding. It is very seldom used in my county for roofing dwelling-houses, but I was amazed at the number of galvanised-iron roofs I saw in County Kildare during the elections. This would apply to another county as well, but it applies particularly to Co. Kildare. It seemed to me that almost 50 per cent. of the small farmers' and labourers' houses, not built under district council schemes, were all roofed with corrugated iron. There cannot be any getting away from the fact that, after the phosphates tax, this is one of the taxes that are going to lean most heavily on the agricultural community, and I would like to know what the Minister's justification for it is. In the case of the phosphates, it could be said that there was an existing industry, but what case can the Minister put up for this?

Comment on this

I find it scarcely credible that the Minister has deliberately put a duty on curved galvanised iron in order to promote the industry of bending iron in this country. I have viewed the tariff procedure with forbearance, and with what I thought to be a helpful spirit, but, if the Oireachtas of the Irish Free State is to enact legislation in order to promote the business of bending iron in this country, I think it is really carrying things to extremes.

Comment on this

There are more things done with the iron than the actual bending.

Comment on this

What are they?

Comment on this

When corrugated iron is used as a fence, there are spikes cut on the top of it.

Comment on this

That is done here.

Comment on this

Of course, it is.

Comment on this

And it is never imported in that condition.

Comment on this

Indeed, it is.

Comment on this

I think the Minister will agree that to introduce a Financial Resolution for the purpose of promoting the industry of bending and spiking iron is merely something approaching extravagance. I would ask the Minister to consider another aspect of the situation. I do not know whether he is aware of the uses to which this iron is put on agricultural holdings. The old-fashioned type of hayshed was a hayshed erected on wooden beams, with a sloping roof, and a galvanised coping on top, and it was the universal experience of everyone advising the agricultural community that that was not the best form of shed for the purposes for which these sheds are usually used, and that the most effective shed was the shed built of steel girders with a curved roof. It took a great deal of propaganda to prevail on the people to change over to the better method, and there was a great deal of conservative feeling all through the country, or certain parts of the country, in favour of the old hayshed structure. Surely the Minister must realise that for what I cannot describe as anything but the almost absurd proposal of promoting a bending and spiking industry here, he should not seriously jeopardise a work, to which the Department of Agriculture attaches considerable importance.

It might not seem at first glance that the question of the sheds or the structure of the sheds was a matter of any importance, but anyone who has experience of the country knows that by far the most economical and most enduring structure was that in which the curved sheet with the steel framework was employed. I can quite see that as occasion demands certain impositions have to be put on in order to serve useful purposes. There are useful purposes to be served by doing the second best thing if it means a great advantage to another section of the community. I respectfully submit to the Minister however that he cannot possibly persuade himself that any useful purpose is to be served by the industry he proposes to promote in this connection, and that if he consults the Minister for Agriculture I hope he will hear from him a report more favourable to free trade in iron than he heard in regard to free trade in superphosphate of lime.

I quite see the position of the Government in regard to tariffs, but I do think that the Minister for Agriculture might go further than apparently he deems it his duty at present to go in advising the Minister for Industry and Commerce that there are two sections well defined in our community. One is the section primarily devoted to agriculture and the other to industry, and while the agricultural community are prepared to go a long way to help the fortification of the position held by our industrial population, it is only creating ill-will and unnecessary difficulties to lay burdens upon them and to put annoyances and trouble in their way unless some invaluable purpose is to be served. This proposal, and the proposal with regard to compound manures, is creating and will create bitter feeling throughout the agricultural community in this country against the tariffs and, so far as I can see, I believe the feeling of the people with regard to this particular type of tariff is a legitimate feeling and one that I will do everything I possibly can to stir up and mobilise because by the operation of these tariffs they will be unnecessarily harried. I respectfully submit to the Minister for Industry and Commerce that, before he puts it forward to the next stage, he should further consult the Minister for Agriculture and ask him to get in touch with the ordinary farmers in the country and ask them what measure of sacrifices the imposition of these tariffs will require from them, and then let him balance in his mind whether the advantages he envisages are anything to compare with the annoyances and inconvenience which will be caused to the agricultural community.

Comment on this

I think the whole question of this duty on corrugated, galvanised, iron really resolves itself into comparative prices as between what a sheet will cost before this duty is levied and after it is levied. I do not know what that would be exactly, but I do know this, that I have been in receipt of a large volume of correspondence from farmers about this duty and also from an association which is very much interested in the tillage farmers on the same question. Deputy Gorey spoke about the amount of this corrugated iron that is used in Kildare, and I think it is quite patent to anyone passing through the county, particularly the southern part of it, that every farmer uses it for shedding purposes and in many cases for more than shedding. For that reason I would like the Minister to give this very urgent consideration. I know that the iron can be rolled in this country—or bent—I do not know what the correct term is.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Curved.

Comment on this

Curved then. I know that it can be done not very far indeed from the town I come from, but the real question is, what is it going to mean to the purchasing power of the farmer and what difference it will make from the point of view of the small amount of employment to be given and as regards the question of prices. I ask the Minister to do as Deputy Dillon has suggested, as the Minister for Agriculture might be able to give him information on it.

Comment on this

Surely it is open to the critics of this tariff to give us a little more information in support of their objections. How many times in a farmer's lifetime does he purchase galvanised iron? He does not erect out-offices or re-roof his dwelling-house every day in the week. Is it not the case that the average small farmer only buys galvanised iron about once or twice in his life?

Comment on this

He need not buy it at all if he has to wear a hair shirt.

Comment on this

He has got to pay a certain theoretical difference between the cost of getting it rolled in another country and the cost of getting it rolled or curved in this country. Nobody has even attempted to estimate what that cost will be. It is not alleged that there will be great inconvenience attached to it.

Comment on this
A Deputy

It is indeed.

Comment on this

I take it that there are people in this country who are prepared to do that curving. There will be no inconveience then attached to the obtaining of this galvanised iron in a curved state. The whole question is one of cost. A man roofs his outhouses once, say, in ten or twelve years and Deputy Dillon tells us that he regards the imposition of this tariff as so serious a matter that he is actually going to mobilise the farmers against all the tariffs.

Comment on this

On a point of correction, sir, I think you will remember that I said nothing of the kind. I said that I would mobilise them against certain of the tariffs, particularly those on compound manures and on this iron. I said no such thing as has been suggested.

Comment on this

Well, without attempting to define what the grievance will be to any farmers either with ten, twenty or fifty acres, Deputy Dillon emphasises again and again how seriously he regards this tariff. Surely the critics of a tariff ought to have more responsibility than that. If they are going to ask for the general support of the House, they ought to give us some little fact to encourage our support. Could not they tell us what the difference will be in getting the galvanised iron curved in Dublin and getting it curved in Birmingham, Liverpool, or anywhere else. Personally, I have no idea what the difference is and I do not think that the fifteen per cent. or ten per cent.—or whatever it is— tariff is going to make such an increase in price as will matter even 10/- to any average farmer in ten years and I ask Deputy Dillon now to give us some facts to disprove that.

Comment on this

Can I ask Deputy Moore to tell us how many will be employed as a result of this tariff? I would like some information as to how many firms in this country are engaged in the work of rolling or curving iron? How many hands are employed by these firms and also how much of the galvanised corrugated iron used in this country is imported first of all in the form of flat sheets? I mean what percentage of the galvanised corrugated iron used by farmers and imported into this country in the form of flat sheets is worked into galvanised corrugated iron here in the country itself?

I quite agree with Deputy Dillon that this tariff will undoubtedly impose additional hardship on farmers and particularly on the small farmers in the west of Ireland. Just take one instance alone. For the last few years quite a big number of haysheds have been erected all over the country. These haysheds are a wonderful convenience to the farmers. They save labour. They help to reduce overhead charges and, incidentally, they make it possible for the farmer to put in his hay whenever it is most convenient for him to do so, and, to a certain extent, regardless of weather conditions.

During the last three years particularly the number of haysheds erected by farmers has increased enormously, and year by year the number of haysheds erected is increasing. Not only is it in connection with the erection of haysheds that this tariff is going to mean an additional imposition on the farmers, but also in regard to the erection of other out-offices. Every farmer, particularly the small tillage farmer, is increasing, every few years at all events, the number of his outhouses. He has got to do that if he is a practical type of farmer at all. This tax again will be an imposition on that type of small farmer. It will be an imposition particularly on the keen, progressive type of small tillage farmer, the man who is farming in an up-to-date way, the man who is endeavouring to make his farm pay, the man who is endeavouring to provide the outhouse accommodation he requires for the purposes of his stock and so on. This tax, taken in conjunction with the other tariffs, the tariff, for instance, on vehicles, the tariff on superphosphates, the tariffs imposed on a number of other articles quite recently by the present Government, will make it almost impossible for any of the small farmers of this country to make any profit whatever out of their business.

I wonder does the Minister realise at what a small margin of profit many farmers are carrying on at the present time. Very few of them are making any profit, and even the most trifling imposition of this kind will add to their burden and will probably wipe out altogether the small margin of profit they are making. If the Government continue to impose tariffs of this description on articles of primary importance, from the farmers' point of view, then I say it is inevitable that the Government instead of helping the farmers will succeed in submerging the farmers and the farming industry in this country altogether.

This tax on galvanised iron will be a definite set-back to the erection of out-offices. It will be a very definite set-back to the erection of haysheds. The erection of haysheds has been encouraged by the Department of Agriculture in years past. In some cases the farmers have been financially assisted by the Department of Agriculture in erecting haysheds. In many cases officials of the Department have actually facilitated farmers in getting supplies of corrugated iron for the erection of haysheds. This tariff will put a stop to operations of that kind and will inflict very serious hardship on farmers, particularly the small farmers.

Comment on this

I am not yet quite clear as to what this particular tariff refers. In the Schedule it is described as galvanised corrugated iron or steel. The Minister says it does not refer to galvanised corrugated iron, but that it applies to certain iron, twisted and bent.

Comment on this

The Schedule does not say that at all.

Comment on this

The Schedule says corrugated iron or steel, excluding unworked flat sheets, but it says galvanised corrugated iron or steel. I do not mind what is excluded. The items that are not excluded are those with which I am concerned. It says that corrugated iron and steel are subject to a 10 per cent. duty. The Minister interprets the Schedule as that it does not mean galvanised corrugated iron or steel, but in my limited capability of interpreting the English language, I prefer to read it as it is printed and it certainly says that galvanised corrugated iron and steel are subject to the tariff. What will be excluded afterwards will depend on this debate, and I hope it will result in excluding galvanised corrugated iron in so far as, it refers to its use by the farmers.

Deputy Moore taunted us with failing to recognise what the cost of the tariff will be. It will cost us 10 or 15 percent. beyond what corrugated iron, twisted or bent or otherwise manipulated according as the Minister thinks, is costing us at the moment. It will cost us 15 per cent. more than the price of that article, which I cannot define, is costing us at the present moment. It will cost the ordinary farmer an addition of that 10 per cent. for that bent, twisted or otherwise deformed corrugated iron, because our experience of tariffs is that not only is the 10 or 15 per cent. imposed by the tariff added to the cost of the article, but there is generally a little bit more added in the retailers' manipulation of the figures. It will certainly cost us that. Deputy Moore taunted us with the fact that we did not use corrugated iron very often. If Deputy Moore likes to take a holiday for five or six months and goes amongst the small farmers in nine or ten counties, he will find that there is scarcely a week in which the farmer does not use this corrugated iron for some purpose or other. If Deputy Moore wishes I will describe the different purposes for which it is used but it would take me rather a long time. It is used in numerous ways besides those already referred to such as the erection of piggeries or houses.

Comment on this

I have spent nearly half my life on a farm and I know all about it.

Comment on this

It is going to raise the cost of this material by 10 or 15 per cent. beyond yea or nay. Notwithstanding what the Minister will explain to us afterwards on the particular form of iron which I cannot define according to the Schedule, some form of corrugated iron, twisted or bent according to the definition of the Revenue Commissioners—and they are very good at defining articles—will bear the tax. They will define corrugated iron, bent or twisted or distorted to any conceivable form, as being subject to a tariff of 10 or 15 per cent. I think that this tariff, in addition to the tariff on phosphates which Deputy Dillon mentioned and all the other tariffs imposed on him, will so twist and bend and galvanise the unfortunate farmer——

Comment on this

And corrugate him.

Comment on this

——that the little sprats thrown to him in the way of the £250,000 for the relief of the rates and the Butter Bill, which does not cost the Government anything, will be of little use to him. He will be so twisted and bent by the various items and the various regulations that he will be one of the number of people who, the Minister said, were necessary casualties if the policy of the Government was to be continued. I am very much afraid that the farmer as a result of this legislation will be one of the first on the casualty list if the Minister does not offer some help, and I hope he will not only offer some help but that he will exempt the farmers from the operation of this Schedule. I leave the industrialists to fight their own battles. Deputy Good stated that we were silent when they were penalised. If the Minister will consent to exclude farmers from this tariff I will let Deputy Good and the other industrialists fight their own battles.

Comment on this

Did Deputy Bennett ever know of a farmer who remembered the price of galvanised iron from one purchase to another?

Comment on this

Indeed, I did.

Comment on this

I would like to know from the Minister the number of people to whom this proposal will give employment?

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I consider this fomented agitation on the part of Deputies opposite rather curious. I was rather amused at the Deputies who spoke. They were responsible for passing the treble annuity system— compensation for tenant rights, compensation for landlord rights and compensation for disturbance. The only thing they were united on was clapping that system on the unfortunate tenants. I was rather amused to hear these Deputies so vocal now. We all know that the position of the farmers is very bad—it is practically desperate. We all know the cause of it. We need not go very far to find a cause; we need only go to the Judicial Commissioners' Court. The reason I am looking for this information is that practically every firm of any repute bends galvanised iron.

Comment on this

If Deputy O'Neill will come with me when he is in Cork I will show him the process being worked. This Resolution will not apply to the houses in County Kildare about which Deputy Gorey spoke. I know a large number of farmers' houses where corrugated iron was put over the thatch. This duty does not apply to such cases at all.

Comment on this

That is a lie.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should withdraw that expression.

Comment on this

I withdraw it. With the best intentions the Minister is wrong: he has misled the House.

Comment on this

I asked Deputy Gorey to read the resolution.

Comment on this

Read it for us. You will interpret it better than the Minister.

Comment on this

The Deputy is very dull.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy—

Comment on this

Sit down, you know nothing about it.

Comment on this

More than you do.

Comment on this

A large number of farmers are using the bent corrugated iron for out-offices and haysheds. They find it a great saving in timber for roofing. They use two wall-plates and put the iron on them. Bent corrugated iron is used three times as much now as it was five or six years ago. I should like to know what extra employment will be given as a result of this proposal, and what quantity of iron is coming in in a bent state. As far as I know every firm of any standing that is selling corrugated iron is bending the iron in its establishment. I invite Deputies to come with me to see the work being done. I consider this agitation to be fomented. I absolve Deputies who were not here before the last election, and who are not responsible for the 37 or 40 blisters that were placed on farmers by previous Acts. Deputy Bennett was silent when the Acts that caused these blisters were put on the farmers, and he walked very kindly into the Lobby after the Parliamentary Secretary for Lands and Fisheries in order that every extra ounce of loot that could be extracted from the unfortunate farmers was extracted from them and handed over to the landlords. The Deputy was very favourable to the Parliamentary Secretary of those days. I consider that this tariff represents very little seeing that practically every firm dealing in a big way in corrugated iron are bending it themselves. I should like if the Minister would state what quantity of corrugated iron comes in in the ordinary state and what quantity in the bent state.

Comment on this

And how much dearer it is.

Comment on this

Fifteen per cent. added

Comment on this

The fifteen per cent. will give extra employment to people who are now in receipt of home assistance. I do not believe in Deputy Gorey's dictum that it is all very well for me to grow crops to sell to unemployed people, and that it is good enough for these labourers to buy my produce out of 8s. weekly home assistance that they get for the support of their wives and children. I believe if we could provide employment for our people by preventing imports we should do so. I am with the Minister in that. I would ask the Minister to let the House know the amount of corrugated iron that comes in in a bent state and to state whether the prevention of such imports will give employment to our people and how many extra hands will be employed.

Comment on this